Latest / Office Hours with Fexingo: Daily Career Q&A, Workplace Questions, and Professional Advice / How to Ask for a Job Reference When You Dont Know Who to Ask
Transcript
- Lucas: Listener question I want to get to today, and it's one we've never really dug into on the show. Someone writes in and says, 'I need three references for a job I really want, but I've only got one solid person I can ask. My old boss left the company, my other manager and I didn't part on great terms, and I've only been out of school for two years. What do I do?' Luna: Oh, that's a tough spot. And I bet a lot of people feel that way but don't say it out loud. Lucas: Exactly. The term I've heard for this is a 'reference gap' — and it's more common than you'd think. According to a 2025 survey from the Society for Human Resource Management, something like 87 percent of employers still conduct reference checks for final-round candidates. So it's not optional. But the good news is you usually have more options than you think. Luna: Alright, so let's break it down. Who counts as a reference besides your most recent boss? Lucas: First group: former peers who were at your level and saw your work. If you collaborated on a project, they can speak to your contribution, your reliability, your teamwork. Second group: clients or external stakeholders, if your role involved client-facing work. Third group: professors or academic advisors, especially if you're early in your career. And fourth: someone from a volunteer role or a side project that's relevant. Luna: So basically, anyone who can give a specific, credible account of your work — not just a character reference. Lucas: Right. The listener's situation — let's call her Sarah — she works at a mid-sized marketing agency. Her direct boss left six months ago, and the person who replaced her barely knows Sarah. But Sarah led a campaign with a peer named James, and she also worked closely with a vendor contact named Maria. Those two are fair game. Luna: But how does she ask them? Especially if she hasn't talked to them in a while. Lucas: That's the crucial part. You don't just send a one-liner saying 'can you be my reference?' You need to send a 'reference brief' — a short email that reminds them who you are, re-establishes context, and gives them the exact points you'd like them to highlight. Let me give you the template I recommend. Luna: I want to hear this. I've seen people get ghosted because they asked too vaguely. Lucas: So for Sarah emailing James: Subject line — 'Quick favor: reference for at '. Then: 'Hi James, hope you're doing well. I'm applying for a marketing manager role at a new firm, and I was hoping you'd be willing to serve as a reference. You and I worked closely on the Q4 campaign for Client X, and I thought you could speak to how I managed the timeline and coordinated with the creative team. If you're open to it, I'll send a few bullet points to make it easy. Totally understand if you're not comfortable. Thanks either way.' Luna: That's respectful and specific. And you're giving them an out — that's smart. Lucas: Yes. You never want to pressure someone. If they say yes, then you send the bullet points. For Sarah, those bullet points would be: 'Led cross-functional campaign from concept to delivery, met a tight deadline, improved client satisfaction score by 15 percent.' That gives James concrete language to use. The reference call usually lasts 10 minutes, and the person on the other end often just reads from the notes you provided. Luna: So it's almost like you're scripting your reference in advance — but with their permission. Lucas: Exactly. And one more thing: always ask for references that align with the job you're going for. If you're applying for a project management role, don't give a reference who only knows your creative work. Tailor the list. Luna: That makes sense. And what about Sarah's former boss who left? Can she still ask them? Lucas: Absolutely. Former bosses are often the best references, even if they've moved on. Sarah should track down her old boss via LinkedIn or email. The key is to acknowledge the gap. Something like: 'I know it's been a while since we worked together, but I really valued your mentorship and I was hoping you could speak to my work on the X project. I'm happy to fill you in on what I've done since.' Most people are flattered to be asked. Luna: But what if she can't find them? Or they don't respond? Lucas: Then she falls back on the peer and client. And if she still needs a third, she can consider a professor. But here's the thing: many employers will accept two strong references instead of three, especially if the two are stellar. A 2024 LinkedIn survey found that 73 percent of hiring managers would proceed with two references if they were highly relevant and spoke in detail. Luna: That's reassuring. I think a lot of people panic and think they need a perfect list of three former managers. Lucas: Right. And one more strategy: if you're really stuck, you can ask the recruiter or hiring manager if they'd accept a professional reference from a different context — like a client or a vendor. Sometimes they'll say yes, especially if you explain your situation. It shows self-awareness and honesty. Lucas: That's a nightmare scenario. But you can recover. First, you should always check in with your reference after they've been contacted. Send a quick note: 'Just wanted to thank you for taking the call. Everything go okay?' If they admit they weren't comfortable or they fumbled, you can then proactively reach out to the employer and say, 'I understand my reference may not have been the best fit. I'd like to provide an additional reference who can speak more directly to my recent work.' Luna: So you're basically replacing the weak link. I love that — it's not apologetic, it's solution-oriented. Lucas: Exactly. And the key is to do it before the employer decides. Speed matters. If you hear about a bad reference within 24 hours, you can often salvage the opportunity. Luna: That's a great tip. I'm going to remember that. Lucas: You know, Luna, this is exactly the kind of practical career advice we aim to give on this show. And if you find it valuable, there's a simple way to support us. We keep the podcast ad-free and listener-supported, and you can help by buying us a coffee at buy me a coffee dot com slash fexingo. No pressure, just a way for folks who get real use out of the show to keep it going. Luna: Yeah, and we really appreciate that. Every bit helps us keep digging into these exact questions. Lucas: Alright, back to references. One more thing I want to cover: what if the employer calls your current boss without your permission? That happens sometimes, and it can be awkward if your current boss doesn't know you're looking. Luna: Yikes. Is that even legal? Lucas: It's not illegal in most states, but it's against the policy of many companies — and it's definitely bad practice. To protect yourself, you can add a note on your application: 'Please do not contact my current employer without my prior consent.' Most recruiters will honor that. And if they don't, you have grounds to raise a concern. Luna: Good to have a paper trail. What about people who are in the middle of a career change and have no direct experience in the new field? How do they get references? Lucas: That's a tougher one. For career changers, the best reference is someone who can speak to transferable skills. For example, if you're moving from teaching to corporate training, a former principal can talk about your public speaking and curriculum design. If you're moving from retail to sales, a store manager can speak to your customer conversion skills. It's about framing. Luna: So it's not about the job title, it's about the competencies. I like that. Lucas: Exactly. And if you're really early in your career — like a recent grad with only one internship — you can ask the internship supervisor, a professor, and maybe a coach or advisor from a student organization. That gives you three credible voices. Luna: Alright, so to recap: you can use peers, clients, professors, former bosses — anyone who can speak to your skills. You send a reference brief with specific talking points. You tailor your list to the job. And if something goes wrong, you proactively replace the reference. Sound about right? Lucas: That's the nutshell. And I'll add one final thing: always send a thank-you note after the reference is used. A handwritten note or a thoughtful email goes a long way. People remember that, and it keeps the door open for future asks. Luna: Great advice. Thanks, Lucas. And thanks to our listener for the question — hope this helps you land that job. Lucas: Absolutely. That's all for today on Office Hours with Fexingo. We'll be back tomorrow with another question from the inbox.