Latest / Automotive State of The Union / July Auto Intel Report w/ Guest Steve Greenfield
Transcript
- 0:00[upbeat music] Yo, it's a very special Wednesday today. I almost said Tuesday because of the holiday. But we got it- [laughs] We got it and I caught myself. I caught myself.
- 0:08Today we have the one and only, you've seen him, you know him, Steve Greenfield, CEO and founder of Automotive Ventures. It's gonna be a good one. Where I go. It's gonna be a good one.
- 0:15People really wanna know who I is and who I be. They stop and stare when they see me. Ah. Like a little slow but still fancy. Get the Wednesday bounce. Ah. It doesn't feel like midweek because of the holiday.
- 0:23I'm all off, man. I know. My wife was like, "Is it Tuesday or Thursday?" And I was like, "Maybe it's Monday. I ha- I didn't... Like yesterday just happened." Yeah, it's, uh, it's crazy, so.
- 0:33I think, I think more dealerships closed this 4th of July than in the history of 4th of Julys because of the inventory issue. We were talking to a dealer yesterday and he was like, "Yeah, we're, we're closed.
- 0:43It's for our families." He's like, "It's not like we're gonna like unload some ground stock," [laughs] you know? [laughs] Yes. Yeah, no.
- 0:51And, and I think also just it's becoming one of those places where dealers can find that additional day to take care of their families. I heard, I heard one friend joke.
- 1:00He was like, "Basically the whole f- the whole country closed except Florida," right? Which is just normal- It's true... for Florida. It's true. Oh, Florida was open, everybody. Oh, yeah.
- 1:08[laughs] Everyone in Florida was open. They were like, "We gotta do this thing. We'll be there." So. Oh, man. I- I'm interested to see what the stats are about that.
- 1:15But either way, um, all right, we were excited because we launched the SoDo Con tickets to the pre-registration list yesterday, and people are buying tickets for like, the first tickets come through.
- 1:24Like you sent the email. You're like, "There are five people on site." Thirty seconds later, it's like, "Tickets purchased," right? [laughs] So- Yeah...
- 1:30it's always fun to, to see go from like concept to synthesis to like people are actually coming now. Like now we're- Yeah...
- 1:36now we're really do- I mean, we were really doing it before, but now that people are coming, it's this new like weight of obligation. Like oh, man, we better have everything just right. Um, but- Exactly...
- 1:45if you're on the pre-reg list, check your inbox, check your spam if you didn't get it, or just shoot us an email at crew@asodu.com. We'll make sure, uh, you have the opportunity to register.
- 1:54Um, but later this week we're gonna make general announcement, launch tickets to everybody, and, um, we are just like battening down the hatches, about to go into our 60 days of content ramp-up into SoDo, uh, SoDo Con.
- 2:07And we're going to have, uh, probably safe to say, hundreds of pieces of content for you, and I'm talking full-length podcasts.
- 2:14We have two new podcasts launching in the next 60 days, um, for a little bit deeper, more textured conversation.
- 2:20You know, The Morning Show is kind of like giving you the news, giving you some thoughts, getting you, uh, on your day with some energy.
- 2:25These, the other two podcasts are gonna be a little deeper, more substantive when it comes to, uh, the length of the conversations.
- 2:31We're gonna have, uh, tons of industry experts, tons of dealers coming at you on social media.
- 2:35If you're not following us on LinkedIn, um, that is kind of the place where that gets, I would say, the majority of the content. I mean, we're also on Instagram- Yeah... and TikTok, right, which is more the lighter fare.
- 2:46But, um, you know, for the, the deep industry substance, LinkedIn is where it's at. So, uh, a lot, Kyle, is kicking off, uh, right now, like from now and through the next 60 days. Literally, Paul.
- 2:57Literally, Paul, right now. Because speaking of really smart people and content in the automotive industry- Segway time. [upbeat music] [laughs] I- we've never introduced somebody- Oh, we're really, really excited...
- 3:10with a segue ever. [laughs] Ah, that was, that was crazy. That was a whole new thing. [laughs] We are really excited to be joined by Steve Greenfield, Automotive Ventures. You see him on the screen if you're hanging out.
- 3:21Uh, Steve, welcome to The Morning Show, to the Automotive Ventures- And I even got some MC Hammer this morning. It was great. Great way to wake up. It's a good day.
- 3:27Well, listen, speaking of getting whatever you get in the morning. Stop. Segway. Time. [upbeat music] [laughs] There we go. I like how in this screen format MC Hammer's like dancing right on Steve's face.
- 3:40[laughs] Right on my head, yes. Exactly.
- 3:42But we were talking before, before the show and before you came into the stream, and we would like to start off the show understanding a little bit more about- Really intense questions... v- very intense.
- 3:52Only the hard-hitting stuff first thing in the morning. What does your morning routine look like? You're someone that gets so much done in a day, and it seems like you're everywhere.
- 4:00And we joke about like having a dozen email addresses that we have to manage. [laughs] What is your morning rou- what is your morning routine? Well, I, I hate to say it, like I'm not a morning person.
- 4:09You know, I'll work until midnight m- or o- one o'clock typically, but mornings are, are, are not my time. And, uh, I also hate to admit, I've got eight cats in the house. All of them are rescue cats. Oh.
- 4:22So I, I literally spend the first like 45 minutes when I wake up, it's cat time. You know?
- 4:27[laughs] It's making sure everyone's fed, everyone has water, cleaning litter, and, uh, you know, it's my time to like g- g- go around the house and see all the cats. So, um- It's literally like- There you go...
- 4:37it's a practice in automotive industry, right? It's like herding cats in the morning- [laughs]... so that you can herd cats the rest of the day. I am herding cat. I'm quite literally herding cats in the morning.
- 4:46That's the first thing I do for the first like 45 minutes. So you say you don't have a morning routine, but that's probably the most unique morning routine I've ever heard- [laughs]... in my life.
- 4:55And I can see it like, you know, like, like a Zen kind of thing. Like it's kind of these- It is... simple tasks, right? You spend your life in, in mental complexity, right? Yeah.
- 5:04[laughs] It's like the cats do the same thing every day. They need the same thing every day. [laughs] Right? Well, that's great. That's amazing.
- 5:11Just, uh, eight cats in the morning is Steve, Steve Greenfield's morning routine. So that wasn't at all what I was expecting at all. There we go. There we go. But I was expecting like 10 pages of something- [laughs]...
- 5:21and like 30 minutes of like you standing in tree pose, you know, [laughs] like on a sauna. Right, right, right, right. Nope. Nope. [laughs] Nope. Taking care of eight cats. It's cat time. All right.
- 5:30Let's talk about like real business for a second. So, uh, your monthly intel report, automotive intel report, is read by thousands and thousands of people across the industry.
- 5:38We wait for it to drop in our inbox, and then we usually start texting each other about it, you know, within an hour of it dropping. Like, "Oh, did you see this?"
- 5:45And, and we saw this month's, and we were like, "We have to see if Steve will come talk about it on the show." It's always great, but this month I think the opening just kind of hit us a little bit harder.
- 5:54So, um, let, let's start by s- you just giving a brief summary about what the report is.
- 5:59Like why you started doing it, why you're keeping doing it, and then we'll get in, uh, we have five things we wanna talk about from it. Well, that's great. Well, thanks, guys.
- 6:05You know, I, I always appreciate the time with you and appreciate, um, m- making time for me to be on the show today. Um-And yeah, the, the, the latest July version I, I did drop, um, uh, at the beginning of this week.
- 6:17So it's available at automotiveventures.com if anybody wants it. And it's free. It'll always be free.
- 6:21So, um, the i- the idea was two years ago that I started publishing this monthly report a- and figuring that I was gonna try to generate content that would be helpful to the entrepreneurs in the space, and help them understand wha- which transactions are taking place, who's buying what, what, what valuations are being paid, et cetera.
- 6:38And then I found very quickly that there was a, a greater appetite than just invest- uh, entrepreneurs. And we have a whole bunch of entrepreneurs that really rely on it for the various frameworks we provide.
- 6:47But, um, you know, a, a lot of car dealerships, uh, were, were starting to subscribe. I was like, "Oh, that's pretty interesting."
- 6:53I think they wanna make sense of, like, the cluttered landscape of all the vendors out there, and stay abreast of, like, new technologies that are coming out, right?
- 6:59They're also interested and intrigued with, like, who's getting exits, et cetera. And it's always fr- I think, frustrating to dealers when they see a big exit from a company that, where they were an earlier adopter.
- 7:08And then, um, the, the, the, the last segment I would say is, like, the investors themselves started to tune in and I started to see more subscribers from, uh, uh, venture capitalists and private equity folks, and even corporate, uh, venture capitalists who, again, are starting to look at the automotive space.
- 7:22And, you know, the good thing we've had over the last couple of years is a lot more people paying attention- Mm-hmm... to automotive and automotive tech. Mm-hmm, yeah.
- 7:29Than in the past, I mean, we were always kind of stigmatized with saying, you know, there wasn't a lot of automotive... uh, a lot of technology being applied to automotive.
- 7:37And I think, uh, q- quite the contrary is true now. Mm-hmm. Um, you know, there, there's definitely some archaic business practices that need to evolve, there's no doubt.
- 7:45But in, in many cases now we're seeing, you know, injections of new technology players that are fetching, you know, billion-dollar valuations. And, uh, it's, it's an exciting time.
- 7:54But I think, um, part of the reason that we have so many subscribers, it's, it's hard to stay abreast of the, the pace of change and the pace of the, the news cycle. Yeah. Yeah. It, it absolutely is. And, and when you...
- 8:06And I love, you know, earlier this year you kind of broke it into dealer tech and, you know, the, the retail automotive kind of stuff. And then, and also now the mobility index, right?
- 8:18And they're running at the same pace at this point. And at some point I think they're going to start to, to, to merge together a little bit more. But right now they're running parallel paces.
- 8:28And so I'm interested to see over the next year how you kind of watch those kind of come into each other, because I think there's gonna be a neat fold.
- 8:36And I think some of the things that we're gonna talk about today, even just the way you're kind of crafting the conversation with a lot of how you lead this within your opening remarks are, are kind of watching, like, that forward-thinking forecasting of how all of these things start to, to lay in as, as the fabric of automotive kinda shifts and changes.
- 8:56Yeah. And it, it, it's, it's a great point.
- 8:58One, one of the hardest questions I have is, you know, when I, when I get put in front of a bunch of dealer owners and they ask me, "What, what does it look like in five years?" Because it's really hard to tell. Geez.
- 9:07Mm-hmm. What we do know is, like, the, the, the pace of change is ha- is accelerating. There's a...
- 9:11As we're gonna get into today, there's a, there's a lot of changes going on that dealers need to stay, uh, highly attuned to.
- 9:16But it's really hard to, like, forecast out and say, "You know, what, what does a franchise dealer model look like in five years? What's the percentage of EV penetration? What are the implications of all this?"
- 9:26You know, the OEM starting to position to sell directly to consumers and just own more of the control of the supply chain.
- 9:33Um, we, we can kind of always work through, like, scenarios that might play out, but it's hard to, like, declare what does the future actually look like. Absolutely. It's impossible.
- 9:40Well, we're gonna try to spend a few minutes on, uh, these five topics that you addressed in your, um, in your letter this week, um, or this month. So number one, dealer valuations and what's driving them.
- 9:51Agency model creep. OEMs controlling lease end volume. Uh, the F&I headwinds that are upon us. And then finally, we're gonna talk about the benefits of scale.
- 10:01And that's kind of in order as the way you've addressed them in the, in the letter. So we'll try to give a little summary. First, dealer valuations have been a topic of conversation for the last...
- 10:09I mean, really elevated over the last 24 months. Um, what is dealer... What is driving dealer valuations right now? And what are the indicators you're seeing that, that might indicate that some change is on the way?
- 10:21Yeah. So I, I would say that, you know, it, it's, it's, it's, it's, it's, um, not too aggressive to say we're, we're in an environment where profits are higher than they've ever been.
- 10:29And mul- valuations are higher than they've ever been for physical stores.
- 10:33So when you multiply those two together, I mean, it's really hard for the average dealer to, to afford, you know, uh, buying dealerships right now.
- 10:40And I think that, uh, the guys that I talk to typically say, "Yeah, but we're, we're looking at underperforming stores." Right. Mm. How many, how many of those are there? Not many. [laughs] Right? So it's like- Yeah...
- 10:50a- and, and everyone is. I mean, Lithia will say the same thing in their, you know, earnings call transcripts.
- 10:54Bryan DeBoer says, you know, "We're typically targeting underperforming stores where we can turn them around," yet they're buying, like, crown jewel stores it seems, and, and I'm sure paying all the money for those stores.
- 11:04But I think that, um, to, to answer your, your, your question, Paul, I think that what's happening is dealers are flush with cash.
- 11:10And, you know, I think dealers, um, kind of innately say, "What am I gonna do with my cash? I'm gonna buy more stores." Mm-hmm. They, they, they, they haven't in the past had the opportunity to diversify very much.
- 11:21And therefore, I think their natural setting is to go and, and buy stores. So that, that's one. Um, and I think that that's supporting valuations.
- 11:28But I think most importantly, as I mentioned Lithia, Lithia's been, like, ravenous to buy more stores.
- 11:34And, you know, clearly been signaling to Wall Street for some time that their intention is to move into the number one slot. Mm-hmm. Which they did in, in Q1. Mm-hmm.
- 11:41They became the, the number one, uh, uh, dealership in, by size at least, in America. And that they're not going back now.
- 11:47And, you know, to get to 500 stores, and then be able to be within, like, 95%, you know, 200-mile delivery radius of 5-- 95% of the US population.
- 11:57So I mean, I-At this pace, and they don't seem to be slowing down at all, um, I think they have another $15 billion in their pipeline of new revenue that they are, are sizing up now according to earnings calls.
- 12:09And, um, you know, I think that, that, that, that single-handedly is supporting valuations.
- 12:15But then you've got, you know, the other dynamic where, where, you know, because there's effectively a, an imbalance between supply and demand, any other dealer that's trying to buy stores, it's just really hard right now because it's, it's just kept valuations very high.
- 12:26So one would think that, you know, with all the uncertainty on the horizon, you know, with, um, sort of interest rates increasing and, and some of the share prices coming down pretty dramatically for the publicly traded groups- Mm-hmm...
- 12:38we'd, we, we'd be seeing a bit of a reset. Doesn't seem like it so far.
- 12:41Everything, all the, the, the, the, um, the, the brokers of these, these, uh, uh, physical dealerships are saying valuations are still as high as ever.
- 12:49And, you know, we know that wa- watching profitability, it's as high as ever. Right.
- 12:54So, uh, my, my question here, and we'll kind of connect to this to the next topic, which is, is this, uh, is this OEM potential shift to the agency model that we're seeing heavily in, uh, heavily in Europe, is with all of this buy/sell activity and with the larger con- you know, publicly traded companies growing market share by purchasing dealerships and profitability, like, what, what is their perception of this, this shift to a potential agency model, and how leveraging purchasing other, you know, brick and mortar rooftops actually sets them up for this potential agency model?
- 13:32'Cause I... Like, my perception is the single one, two, three rooftop groups probably have the most kind of, you know, you know, eyes alert for the agency model. Yeah. Yeah.
- 13:43But it seems like th- there may be something that this has kind of a play to, to make sure that they're hedged against any disruption in the franchise model.
- 13:52And how is, how are those, like, buy/sell ac- uh, how is that buy/sell activity, you know, looking at this future of potential agency model? Yeah. I, g- it's very, very astute observation.
- 14:03I think there, there's naturally a hedge, to use your term, which is a good one. A hedge against the agency model, the bigger that I am.
- 14:10And, uh, if I've got different branded, uh, O- OEM brands within the family, then if one particular OEM gets very aggressive, like a couple have recently, then, um, it, it kind of allows me to diversify away from having too much exposure to one brand.
- 14:26I think that just having, uh, lar- larger dealerships and more volume pumped through those dealerships is more likely to have me have a seat at the table. Mm-hmm. Yeah.
- 14:34You know, OEMs are less, less likely just to push over me, right, and knock, knock me over on the way.
- 14:40I think that, um, the, the, biggest anxiety I see are these, like, these multi-generation groups, um, sometimes only having one or two or three rooftops, where they're like, "Wow, you know, I'm not diversified, and if one of, one or more of my OEMs decides to push for this model, um, it's gonna have a huge effect on me."
- 14:58And, you know, they're, they're hoping to pass this on to the next generations, right? It's not a private equity-backed group that wants to get out, um, in, in five years. They've a much longer time horizon.
- 15:09And, uh, I think that that's where it's creating the, the most angst. But yeah, the, the natural hedge is, um, can be accomplished through scale and having a, a, a bigger potential seat at the table.
- 15:19And, you know, as you're larger... I mean, the OEMs in some cases are, are gonna be like king maker.
- 15:24They're gonna decide the dealerships that they want to invest in the most, and it's likely going to accrue to the, the, the largest dealerships, which happen to be the public groups in most cases.
- 15:34Do you think there's a, there's a benefit to, like, just being a great operator? Like, say, um, you know, a family-owned Ford dealership.
- 15:42Ford obviously is one of the ones being the most aggressive in, um, in the agency model space, or at least talking about that and what we're gonna talk about next as far as lease end volume.
- 15:51How much do you see, like, being just an amazing operator playing into that? If you don't have size, like, does that- Mm... bring a lot of value to the OEM? Yeah, t- tons.
- 16:01I mean, if you're an amazing operator, typically you're gaining market share and getting bigger and bigger, and therefore having more of a seat at the table.
- 16:08It doesn't help anything with the exposure to one particular OEM, and if they decide to make a, a dramatic change towards more of an agency model and control inventory and profitability and such in that channel.
- 16:18But yeah, Paul, I think it's, it's, it's, it's, it's a great point. One of the slides that I, I, um,
- 16:23I, uh, built out for this month's, uh, intel report c- contrasts how the, the average dealer's SG&A, their selling general and administrative costs, versus the public groups.
- 16:33And you can see clearly there, I mean, it's very sort of sta- stark in terms, like, the public groups have a huge advantage from a cost structure. And of course they do. They're centralizing costs on the back end.
- 16:43You know, they've got their own tech teams that look for inefficiencies and ways to automate. They get more, you know, leverage with their vendors to drive down costs.
- 16:52There's a whole slew of ways that bigger groups find costs.
- 16:55But the bigger you are, whether you're one store that grows over time and gets really big or, especially if you're, you know, a larger group, there's definitely, uh, uh, ma- math behind the scenes of finding efficiencies.
- 17:06And then the efficiencies give you... I, I think I call it in the report this, this week, like, dry powder. Mm-hmm. It gives you a, a margin of error, right?
- 17:13So if my costs are less than the guy across the street, then I, I, I could use it to discount cars or I can sit there and say, "I've got more profits every month.
- 17:22I can reinvest those profits into things that are gonna hedge me- Mm-hmm... by either buying more stores or finding more scale or whatever it might be."
- 17:29And, um, I, I, I think it's, it's a, it's a natural kind of hedge to... Scale is a natural kind of hedge because, not the least of which is you take out costs, operating costs, and centralize operating costs.
- 17:39You know, I'm looking at that slide right now. I wish I had a way to throw it on the screen.
- 17:43But it says the NADA average is 71%, and then the s- other six that you list, the highest one is Group One at si- or Penske at 66%, 66.7. But, like, AutoNation is 58.1%, as opposed- Yeah... to the average of 71%.
- 17:59So that's a vast, vast amount of, uh, resources available because of, of the scale and efficiencies of operation.That's pretty amazing. Yeah. And all of that flows through to the bottom line, right?
- 18:09And is, is, th- th- thus, you know, additional profit that they can use for whatever purpose that they want.
- 18:15All right, so as we're talking about that, we kind of touched on a number of things because I think it's an indicator that all of these issues are so intertwined, and we talked about this merging together.
- 18:24Um, let's talk about the OEMs controlling lease end volume. When Ford announced that, um, when you lease through Ford Credit, you can no longer buy the vehicle off lease.
- 18:33Ford is gonna absorb that back into the Ford ecosystem, uh, largely citing battery material concerns. Um, I'd never even thought of or heard of or even thought that anybody would ever do something like this.
- 18:44What's your perspective and take on why it's coming up? Obviously be- the battery materials being one, but, uh, what are the other complexities that you see playing out here?
- 18:53Yeah, so it wasn't lost on me that, like, about two months ago Tesla announced the same thing. Yeah. So, um, you know, I don't think that was cited too much in the press. No, it wasn't.
- 19:00Obviously when Ford, f- when Ford does it, it affects the dealers and we hear about it on, on the front page of Automotive News. But I mean, I think that it's, uh, it's very interesting move, right?
- 19:08And a bit of a head-scratcher for me. Until you, until you start to think about it and you're like, "Okay, well, one is..."
- 19:13And you- sort of ostensibly they said, "We're gonna be able to reclaim the batteries," because there is this worry. I know, I know you've talked to Brian Bensock about this.
- 19:20You know, China controls a lot of the rare earth minerals. You know, we- we're, we're, we're gonna be beholden to international players as, you know, EV penetration increases, driving up the inputs.
- 19:29And they're trying to figure out, how do we get independency from, like, some of these, you know, ba- battery suppliers and, and the, and the raw inputs. Like, that, that's definitely one of the dynamics, no, no doubt.
- 19:39I mean, to, to reclaim all those battery inputs and not have to worry about mining additional materials makes sense to me. But I think there's o- there, there are other things, right?
- 19:47So one is we're gonna see a proliferation of a whole bunch of new EV models. And, you know, we... W- when I was at TrueCar, we owned ALG, which does most of the residual value forecasting.
- 19:58It's really hard with a new, when a new model comes out to forecast what it's gonna be worth in three years, and, and that's what, you know, a lease is predicated on- Yeah... that residual value.
- 20:07And given we're gonna see all these new EVs, they're all not gonna be as hot as an F-150 Lightning or a Hummer. Right. Right.
- 20:13So some of them are gonna be duds, and the, the, the OEMs are gonna have a heck of a time setting residual values on new EVs.
- 20:20And by not letting them come back into the secondary market, they're gonna be able to control for that, and effectively s- um, p- price the, the, uh, the, the, the payment on, on the vehicle wherever they, they want.
- 20:31So that, that's number one. Number two is it's not lost on me that, you know, GM's la- launched CarBravo and, you know, Ford's launched Blue, Blue Advantage, and they're setting up their own secondary, uh, marketplaces.
- 20:43And now they're gonna have, you know, supply that no one else has.
- 20:47There will be unique vehicles that come back that the only place to get them could potentially be on these other competing OEM-owned secondary marketplaces. And, you know, the, the...
- 20:57Who knows if the dealers will have a crack at buying these vehicles at all. Mm-hmm. They may go directly to the consumer from Ford on these third-party marketplaces that are owned by the OEMs.
- 21:06So I think that, that's pretty interesting.
- 21:07And then I think the other thing that I mentioned, it's, um, I think it's frustrating for the OEMs to see this current dynamic where, you know, cars are coming back at five, $7,000 over residual value.
- 21:18And who makes money in that case? Well, the, the consumer, hopefully. If it's an unsuspecting, unaware consumer, the dealer makes a ton of money 'cause they can just wholesale the car right away.
- 21:28But definitely the OEM doesn't have a sort of call option on making that an additional money right now. Mm-hmm. And it's gotta be very frustrating for the OEM.
- 21:37So, um, that can cut both ways, 'cause they could definitely misprice the residual value and be underwater by thousands of dollars. Oh, yeah, we've seen lots of that. There's lots of that in the, in the past.
- 21:47And, and they will be taking that risk if they buy back every car, but I think this gives them a lot more flexibility to, um, control the secondary market.
- 21:56You know what's interesting about this is, is that there have been a lot of people to kind of talk about just the way that...
- 22:02And, and I talk about it a lot, the way that phone technology, phone renting, and the, the way that that service and software and hardware link to, like, a person's mentality on the monthly payment or, like, ownership and how that might shift, uh, the...
- 22:19A similar type of shift might happen in automotive to where we think about cars as two to three-year items that we're never in a purchase mode because technology's moving so fast.
- 22:29And when, when I, like, extrapolate that into this scenario, that's one place that, like, phone providers have actually done well- Mm-hmm...
- 22:40to, to push out the, like, repurchasing and the trade-in, uh, essentially the trade-in valuations on these other providers, whether it be, you know, the, the phone s- you know, the phone platform provider or, you know, the Best Buy or wherever you pur- purchase or trade the phone.
- 22:57And so it's interesting to, to me to see, like, the rest of EV kind of looking s- looking like a phone, and this is the one place that we've been doing it right for a long time, and if we get it, and if we got it right.
- 23:10But now pulling that back to the OEM to manage, I, a- a- as an OEM, it would be the scariest proposition ever, because right now, like, you are, you're taking the bet on all the residuals. Yeah.
- 23:21My- the better play here in my opinion would be to, like, leverage some level of profit sharing potentially on, on that next, on the next turn of the vehicle- Right... if it was, if it was shared over, so. Yeah.
- 23:34But no one's gonna listen to me on that maybe. No, no. I, I, I think it, there's, there's a couple of things in what you said that we should unpack. Because one is, you know, loyalty. Yep.
- 23:42Um, you know, I, I, I'm an iPhone guy, and I l- I love the fact now whether I lose my phone or my phone sort of, like, starts to deteriorate from a battery standpoint, they can literally, like, real-time port over my entire experience with a new phone.
- 23:54Yeah. And I, I don't miss a beat. Yeah. And you can imagine that a consumer who gets all their car customized.
- 24:00I, I buy, you know, a, a, a, a Mach-E, like a Mustang, and then I, I wanna get into the newest Mustang, and they can port all my-All my preferences over. Yes And it's like totally seamless.
- 24:11It may drive a lot more loyalty and people li- less likely to, to defect. And then the second thing is you, you look at how much of Apple's revenue is through the App Store- Yes...
- 24:20and collecting that thir- thir- 30% of, you know, app revenue. Anybody who wants to play in their, like, walled garden ecosystem. And I, I would think that, um, it's, it's to be determined. Totally other issue.
- 24:30But, you know, as the OEMs offer up subscription services post-sale, what the revenue split will be between the OEM and the dealer. And that'll get negotiated on a, on a, on a OEM-by-OEM basis.
- 24:41But I mean, th- this, this... That, that should all be very high margin, uh, revenue that can be split between the OEM and the dealer.
- 24:48So whereas e- there's a lot of uncertainty in the market, there's a lot of hope as well that there will be brand-new revenue streams available to dealers and OEMs that haven't existed.
- 24:57And I think we should- There you go... continue to use the analog, as you are, of the, of the phone because it's like I don't really think about too much about who my carrier is. I'm loyal to- Right...
- 25:07I'm very loyal to the, the manufacturer. But it's more about the services than it is the hardware. The hardware is secondary. It's like, like, to use the term of a vehicle.
- 25:15It is a vehicle to, to get me the, the high value stuff, which is all the apps that are running on the vehicle itself. Everywhere you're trying to go. Right. All the rest of the experience, right? Right.
- 25:25And that's, that's, that's ev- Like, the dealership should be thinking about that. The OEM should be thinking about that, both separately in how they can leverage that technology and jointly for revenue streams.
- 25:35Because that is. That's... Like, you know, e- e- everyone's losing their mind about, you know, invoice matches retail price, right? And I think, yes, there's, there's something to be said about that.
- 25:46But we lost money on new cars for years and years. This is the first time where we even cared that invoice and MSRP were the same thing, right? Right, right.
- 25:53And so, you know, to, to, like, go back to 2018 and remember when you were losing net money. [laughs] You know, before, before house money.
- 26:00And think about, like, if you had additional revenue streams at, in 2018 to, to put on top of that as a subscription service.
- 26:09Whether that be F&I products or experience products or anything like that, that you either did solely as a dealer, developed your own. Or partner with the OEM to create revenue streams.
- 26:19It's so much more lucrative because it's, it's, it be- you become a SaaS company as opposed to a transaction company. And that's a totally different model.
- 26:27And actually, it's more attractive to outside perspectives looking at the revenue streams of, like, w- I mean, you deal in venture capitalism all the time. Like- Sure... you know, you go from...
- 26:39You, you move into SaaS model to, to fintech and, like, everything moves.
- 26:44And so if we can, if we can look at dealerships in that same way, the multiples actually might increase with money from outside of auto looking to get at some of these, some of these mid to large sized groups.
- 26:55That's a great point. Oh, in my opinion, that is so important. That's a great point. You know- Yeah, great point...
- 26:58Kyle and I, something we, we say quite a bit and have been saying it, find ourselves saying it more and more, whether we're in front of people or on the show, is that the entire industry right now should be focused on, and the savviest players are, solving the customer experience and not all of these little lanes that run within that highway of customer experience.
- 27:18Like, jumping to the end and saying, "How can we make that great?" Because we know that there's money to be made, and there's value to be had, and there's loyalty to be had when we're solving for the customer experience.
- 27:28So, like, all of this... And I know some people might be listening and be like, "All right. You're flying way up in the clouds right now." [laughs] I can...
- 27:33It's kinda, it's kind of the nature of, like, focusing on future and technology, right? Like, we get to say, "Well, you know, in five years..."
- 27:40Not, not so much like a politician will be like, "You know, by the year 2040, we're gonna do this. Who's with me?" Right? Right. I'll be retired or dead, right, by then.
- 27:46[laughs] [laughs] It's, it's a little different than that. Um, the last thing I think we have time to cover before we go. Uh, you mentioned F&I headwinds. Um, or I call them headwinds.
- 27:55Um, things that are happening in F&I, whether it's regulation or OEM control, online selling, that are going to change the game and are changing the game, that has been a, a very staple of the profit center, especially of used car departments, but new car departments as well.
- 28:09Uh, what do you see shifting and going on right there? And what would your advice be to, like, the F&I manager today? You know, I wanna bring it back down to the ground for a minute. Yeah, yeah, sure.
- 28:18So I mean, pay attention to, you know, this news around the, the Federal Trade Commission, the FTC, and what they announced last week, right?
- 28:24So there, there was a lot in that and I think, you know, we, we need more smart industry people to kinda unpack it and opine. Because the document itself is very heavy and very long.
- 28:33But at a high level, you know, we saw with, with, with Trump coming into power, you know, the CFPB, which up until that point was kind of warning, "Hey."
- 28:40They're, they were gonna, like, cap dealers' ability to make profit off finance and they might start looking at F&I products, et cetera.
- 28:47Um, you know, u- u- under the, the previous Republican, um, um, government, uh, in the White House, I mean, it was really defanged, right?
- 28:54The CFPB wasn't dissolved but, I mean, a lot of the power was taken away and there wasn't a lot of emphasis. Well, it seems like, you know, we've reenergized this now through the FTC.
- 29:02And the FTC is looking at not only F&I products and disclosures and, you know, what they s- what they're, they're calling, um, low value or junk fees, in their terms, right?
- 29:11That are providing no value to consumers, F&I products. But also there, there, there's a lot in there on advertising products too, and truth in advertising.
- 29:19And, you know, there, there, there's language in there that a dealer may have to keep, um, a track record of all their advertising for the last two years.
- 29:26Which is, as you guys know, is gonna be very hard in a, in a digital medium to keep track of every single impression that you've had, every single advertising unit that you've, you've served up.
- 29:35So I mean, we'll have to keep an eye on this.
- 29:36But at a, at a high level it's concerning because, you know, it seems like the, the government is looking at potentially getting into, into the F&I department and starting to scrutinize, you know, the, the lower value or, in their words, no value F&I products that are being sold.
- 29:52And then ensuring that, you know, the consumer is presented at the time of purchase-Clear indication of what the car would be, the price would be without and with these F&I products, right?
- 30:02So no more moving shells around and trying to confuse the consumer. Um, and you, you know, we, we could see a, a wave of new sort of, um, regulation coming in as a result.
- 30:12So I, I don't know if we're up to, to your p- point or your question, Paul, there's anything to do right now.
- 30:16But, um, if I'm an F&I manager, I need to stay abreast of this because downstream there's gonna be implications. Um, I think that, you know, there, there's gonna be a 60-day comment period, and it'll be very interesting.
- 30:27And, and I'll do my best to stay on top of, like, as much as they disclose whatever public comments are out there. But there is gonna be change coming, it seems, to the F&I department.
- 30:36And probably not, not a lot of it positive net net for the profitability of that function within the dealership. Kyle- Yeah... any, any closing words as we wrap?
- 30:44I know we've gone a little longer than we usually do, but well, well worth it. Any, any last- Yeah. Well, I-... questions, final words before I wrap us? Look, here's the thing.
- 30:52It, one, if you're listening to w- w- this and you're not subscribed to the Automotive Ventures Intel report, at that minimum get that.
- 30:59Because this was something that back two years ago when I first subscribed, it really just, like, opened my eyes to thinking bigger, uh, when I was at the dealership and then now outside of the stores.
- 31:13It, it really gives you a, a clear perspective. Um, but, but also, uh, recognize that, that everything that has a horizon also has a now.
- 31:24And l- like Steve just said, like, there are things that you can- Did you get that quote, Paul? Paul, get that quote. Every... [laughs] Oh, we got it all. That's a, that's a good one. Everything on the horizon- Yeah...
- 31:32also has a now. Yeah. So the idea is, like, you can look out on the horizon and pull it back to what you m- what you have to be doing now to start thinking about the horizon and, and activating your business mentality.
- 31:45Because car dealers, software providers are great business operators. We're not th- we're not discounting that fact.
- 31:52And so approach new business mentalities, new horizons with that same great, like, energy and momentum that you have always as dealers and industry partners. And that will keep us sustaining.
- 32:05And not just sustaining, but thriving in this industry. Steve, parting word from you.
- 32:10We're just, we're just dropping gems, so I'm just keeping- Well, I, I, you know, Kyle, I don't know that I could actually add anything.
- 32:15I think that, you know, uh, dealers need to be on their best game and stay, stay c- highly attuned to what's going on. Th- this pace of the news cycle is crazy right now. And like- Yeah...
- 32:24literally every new, every, every week we're getting new, new news out there that could potentially have really big impacts on the dealer body.
- 32:30So, you know, um, you know, I think what you guys are doing for the good of the industry, kudos to you. And I think that dealers that aren't, uh, tuning in need to be tuning in and s- and paying attention.
- 32:40Well, thank you very much. [upbeat music] Ladies and gentlemen, Steve Greenfield, automotiveventures.com to get the report. Follow the man on LinkedIn because he's got 28,000 followers. Because there's a reason.
- 32:50They're not just doing it for their health. You know what I'm saying? We'll see you tomorrow. [upbeat music]