Latest / Catalyst: A Podcast of Thought / Flow with Force: Chapter 7 - Conditions for Flow
Transcript
- DrG: There's a particular kind of experience that is difficult to explain while you're in it because you aren't really aware you're experiencing it. You're simply there. For me, it happens when I put on my headphones. I turn on some instrumental music and I begin to write. The world just disappears. There are no people, responsibilities, no judgments, real or imagined. I'm not thinking about whether someone will like what I'm writing. Or whether the sentence I just finished was any good. I'm just thinking about the next word and the next one and another. Somewhere in that process I become completely absorbed in what I'm doing. My attention narrows, but it doesn't become rigid, it just becomes centered. I'm not performing, I'm participating in the act of thinking and putting those thoughts onto a page. Now I've learned that this experience has a name, flow. And what surprised me is that I've apparently been experiencing it for most of my life. I just didn't know it was called that. Welcome to Catalyst, the podcast of thought. I'm Dr. G, and today I'm continuing the exploration of flow with force, with a question that seems deceptively simple. What are the conditions that make flow possible? I'm not interested in turning this into a recipe for getting yourself into flow. Instead, I want to explore what I've noticed in my own experiences. And perhaps invite you to become more curious about your own. When I look back at my childhood I can see experiences of flow all over the place. For example, every summer my best friend and I would buy plastic models and sit at a car table painting the pieces, gluing everything together, trimming them just right and you know, assembling them. We didn't talk that much. We we didn't really need to. Hours would pass while we just worked on our models. I also built little towns for my dad cast cars. Dorky, I know. I still have the cars. I'd use model buildings from train sets, fake grass, sand, roads, whatever I could find, and I build a little world for the cars to move around in. I could go for hours without coming up for air. Wasn't trying to accomplish anything beyond the thing I was doing. I was completely absorbed. Looking back, I recognized those experiences as being in a state of flow. But somewhere between the kids sitting at a car table And the adults sitting at a desk, something changed. A move from trying to do things well to making sure things worked. That wasn't necessarily bad. Growing up brings responsibilities and ambitions. There are things that require intentionality, and there are things that require intensity. Sometimes you have to make yourself do something. Sometimes you have to make something happen. You just can't live in a permanent state of flow and kumbaya your way through life. Even the surfer has to paddle out, they have to learn the fundamentals, they have to develop the strength and skill to stand the board. Eventually, though, there comes a point when the intense preparation has done its job and the surfer has to ride the wave. That's the arc I've experienced intentionality, intensity, performance, participation, and eventually receptivity. I don't think those things are mutually exclusive. In fact, I think they become a Complimentary skill set. I know how to use force. I'm learning how to use flow. The point isn't to choose one and reject the other. The point is to recognize what the moment requires. For me, one condition seems to come before all the others. Curiosity. Curiosity is the spark and the fuel for the fire of flow. It often begins with a simple question. I wonder what's going on here. Curiosity directs attention because you have to look at something to become curious about it. And then it sustains attention because once you notice something interesting, you want to know a little more. I've noticed this in conversations, writing, creative work. Someone will say something that catches my attention. And I'll stick with the thread we're on, but a few minutes later I'll circle back to something they said earlier. Essentially, like Yogi Berra said, when I come to a fork in the road, I take it, right? Both branches of the road in the conversation. I'm not immediately deciding which one is correct. I'm curious about where each one leads. That's when conversations tend to get deeper, broaden. Curiosity keeps that moment alive. But I've also noticed what happens when curiosity disappears. There's a awkward stall. You can feel it in the conversation. Two people are making small talk and suddenly there's this uncomfortable pause. No one knows what to say next, so someone reaches for another question. Hey, have eaten at that new restaurant? Nice weather today, huh? Any plans for the weekend? You know, all those cliched questions and comments. There's nothing wrong with those questions, of course, but there's a difference between a genuine question and a question being used just to keep conversation alive. The curiosity had disappeared, the conversation stalled, and then force enters. We try to make something happen. I think that happens far beyond a simple conversation. When curiosity disappears, movement can stop. Sometimes that becomes disengagement, sometimes apathy, and sometimes we respond by forcing it. That's why curiosity matters so much to flow. It doesn't simply accompany flow, it initiates it and sustains it. Curiosity also changes the quality of attention. When I'm forcing something, my attention becomes scattered. I'm thinking about how I'm being perceived. I'm thinking about my technique in conversation. I'm thinking about whether I'm doing the conversation justice. Am I noticing the people talking in the background, the weather, my own body, the outcome, the last thing I did or said? And more importantly, what am I supposed to do? My attention is everywhere except Where I am and who I'm with. When I'm in flow, my focus becomes narrow, but like I said, not rigid. It's very centered. I'm aware of the world, but I'm not attending to everything in it. I'm attending to the next movement within the conversation or within the passage I'm writing. The next word, the next note, and playing guitar, the next swing in golf, the person in front of me that I'm conversing with. And curiosity keeps asking a simple question. What's next? Not what should happen next. Just what's next? There's another kind of noise that can interfere with our attention. I've come to recognize it as the voices of others. What are they going to think? Am I doing this right? Is this good enough? Should I be doing something differently? These are often people whose opinions matter to me. People I care about, people I want to impress, people whose respect I value. And here's the strange part. They often do respect me, sometimes for things I don't even recognize in myself. So I've started asking myself a question. Could it be that I am my others? I've listened to people I care about, I've considered their advice, I've internalized their standards and expectations, made them my own. Eventually I've done the same thing to their voices. Their voices have become my own, my own internal narrator. If my coach says you should work out, and eventually I hear myself saying, I should work out. Well, that's just internalized obedience to my coach. But if I say I think I should work out because I've considered it and decided for myself, well, that's agency. The behavior might be identical, but the relationship to that voice is different. And I don't necessarily need to silence those voices. I can hear without heeding. I can listen without obeying. But I need to ask: is this still the right voice for me to listen to? Is this still the right time for this voice to exercise its influence? Maybe it is. Maybe it isn't. The important thing is that there is a pause between hearing the voice and acting on it. That pause creates choice. And choice creates room for curiosity. And curiosity also initiates trust. So if curiosity says, I wonder what happens next. Then trust is what allows me to find out. Uncertainty, in contrast, says, I know how this will go. Trust says, I don't know how this will go, but I can stay with it. For me, being in flow requires trusting that my current efforts will produce a satisfactory outcome. And I use the word satisfactory intentionally. I'm not talking about mediocrity. I'm not lowering the bar. I'm not saying excellence doesn't matter. Satisfactory means something more fundamental, all will be well. I might get the birdie, I might get a par, I might even get a bogey or even a double bogey. Whatever the outcome, all will be well. Because I can't be completely focused on the process that creates an outcome while simultaneously attending to the outcome itself. I can care about the outcome, I just can't attend to it while I'm participating in process that creates it. Evaluation comes afterward. I've experienced this in writing. I've experienced in golf and creating these episodes. You get into something and then suddenly you stop to ask, how am I doing? Is this good? Is this working? What does this mean? Now you're no longer entirely in the thing. You're watching yourself do the thing. There's friction there. The flow gets interrupted. The process becomes something you're evaluating rather than something you're participating in. Trust allows attention to stay where it belongs. In the here, in the now, within this moment. Trust, however, doesn't mean I don't prepare. In fact, the more important the outcome, the more preparation matters. I've learned that through writing and production. I've practiced writing, I've practiced editing, I've learned the software and the production process, I've developed the skills outside the actual performative environment. And now when I create something, I can flow more easily. Because I've done the work beforehand. I'm not trying to edit every sentence while I'm writing it. I'm not trying to solve every production problem while I'm creating. I've prepared. Now I can participate fully. That's also where I've learned to distinguish preparation from hypervigilance. So preparation asks, what might happen and what can I do to be ready? Hypervigilance asks, what might happen and how do I prevent it? They can look similar from the outside. Both are attempts to protect ourselves from emotional or social harm, but preparation informs intentional effort. Hypervigilance produces tension. I know what happens when I cross that line. I've over prepared things because I wanted to demonstrate my usefulness, eliminate uncertainty, and make sure nothing was missing. At some point though, preparation becomes force in the in the guise of you know being responsible. The answer isn't to stop preparing. The answer is to know when preparation is finished. At some point, you have to participate. Participate requires timing. I've learned that one the hard way. I was once a program director at a nonprofit. After a conversation with a potential donor, I called one of our longtime volunteers who was also on the call, and essentially I scolded her for the casual way in which she had engaged with the donor. Well I spoke too soon. I hadn't asked her a single question. I had made so many assumptions, and the truth was the issue could have waited a day, a week, a month. It wasn't urgent. I was exercising authority because I was hyper-vigilant about owning the environment in which my program lived. As it turned out, her casualness wasn't a problem at all. It was appropriate. She had known the donor for a decade. Her familiarity made the donor comfortable enough to become our benefactor. I was trying to protect the relationship by managing it. She was actually in a relationship with them. Timing matters. I literally spoke way too soon. Curiosity, had I exercised it, might have changed that. If I had been curious, I might have asked questions instead of I decided I already knew. Curiosity creates room for the possibility that I don't yet have enough information to act. Sometimes the right time is now, sometimes not. It's later. And sometimes the most useful thing I can do is wait long enough for reality to provide another piece of information. Curiosity also changes relationships. If I've already decided what something is, what it should be, or where it needs to go, there's not much left to discover. Force treats situations as objects, something to shape, manage, and direct. Flow treats them as dynamic. Something you're actually participating in. I've learned that in a classroom with a bunch of six-year-olds. I was trying to solve a problem of transitions with adult logic. Line up here, stand there, stop moving, move this way. Just going from one classroom to another part of the school. It wasn't working. Eventually I explained the problem to the kids and asked what they thought. They came up with ideas about timing, groups, gaming it. Where to stand, where to enter the door. And the problem was solved. Not because I found a better way to control the students, but because I stopped assuming they were the problem to be controlled. I created a condition in which they could participate in solving the problem. That's a very different kind of leadership that requires curiosity. What do they see that I don't? What happens if I ask instead of tell? What might emerge if I don't provide the answer first? So curiosity opens relationships. Trust keeps it going. Timing gives it room. Attention allows me to notice what comes back. All these conditions, they're not separate from one another. They're interacting all the time. The more I think about all this, the less interested I am in turning these observations into a formula. Attention, trust, timing relationships aren't four steps. They're not even a checklist. They're not things I can apply and guarantee will put me in some magical state of flow. They're just conditions I've noticed in my own experience. And curiosity seems to initiate and sustain all of them. Curiosity draws my attention and makes trust possible because I'm willing to discover rather than dictate. It affects timing because I'm willing to wait for more information. It creates relationships because I'm interested in what might emerge between me and whatever or whomever I'm engaged with. And when curiosity disappears, I notice something. That stall I mentioned. Then often force. That's useful information because the point isn't to maintain flow. I don't stay in flow. I leave it. I get distracted. I become, you know, self aware. I start anticipating and evaluating and worrying about what someone else might think. I start trying to control something that isn't asked to be controlled, but I'm getting better at noticing. And noticing changes everything. When I realize that the judgment I was anticipating isn't actually happening, I settle myself down and return to reality. I've come to think of that as simply deal with the real. I experience this in golf. I have two or three uncomfortable holes where I get caught up in my swing, my score, what other people might think. What I did wrong, what I need to fix. At some point I get grounded again. Then suddenly I have two or three comfortable swings. Not holes, working on that, but swings. Not because I discovered some new golf technique, because I came back to reality. That's what I began to understand about these conditions for flow. They don't create flow, they just make it more accessible. And accessibility is different from control. Maybe that's why I keep coming back to that kid in the basement. He didn't know anything about flow. He didn't know anything about attention or hypervigilance or false urgency or internalized expectations. He wasn't trying to perform. He wasn't trying to prove his usefulness. He was building stuff. He was curious. So what happens if I put this piece here? What does it look like then? What can I make? And then he followed the next piece and the next hours disappeared. I don't think growing up means losing that kid inside of us. Growing up means acquiring more responsibilities, more skills, awareness, and the capacity to act intentionally. That's good. We need that. Intensity has its place, force has its place. But perhaps maturity also means learning when those tools have done their job, learning when to become receptive, to participate rather than perform. Learning to stop asking what is expected of me and start asking what am I genuinely curious about? That question brings me back to the present. It gives my attention somewhere to go. It gives me something to trust. It gives me reason to wait. Gives me a way to be in a relationship with what is happening, rather than trying to dictate what happens next. Perhaps that's what matters most here. Not a list of conditions for getting yourself into flow, but a reason to become curious about your own experience. You may discover that flow isn't some mysterious state that occasionally visits you. You may discover that you've been there before many times. Maybe you already know more about your own flow than you think you do. You just haven't had been curious enough to notice. I'm beginning to understand that the goal isn't to control flow. It isn't even to stay in the state of flow. It's to recognize the conditions in which I'm most available to it. And to recognize when I've begun working against them. Curiosity helps me notice. Attention keeps me there. Trust allows me to stay. Timing keeps me from rushing. Relationship keeps me connected to what's actually happening. And when I leave that space, I don't have to fix everything. I can simply notice. Pause, come back to it, deal with the real. Perhaps that's the larger lesson here. Flow isn't something we force into existence. It becomes more available when we create the conditions that allow us to participate in what is already happening. In the next episode, we'll move from the conditions that make flow possible to something much more experiential. The feel of flow. What does flow actually feel like when we're inside it? What happens in our attention, our bodies, and our sense of time when we're no longer trying to make the experience happen? I'm doctor G, those are my thoughts. Thanks for listening.