Latest / For the Missing: Missing Persons, Families & the Search for Answers / The House That Hid Secrets: H.H. Holmes and the Castle of Lies | For the Missing
Transcript
- Imagine a house that breathed in its victims and exhaled their insurance money. It wasn’t a haunted castle from a storybook, but a three-story building on West 63rd Street in Chicago, built by a man who smiled while he locked the doors. Let’s remember who they were, or at least, who the world thought they were seeing. Herman Webster Mudgett was born on May 16th, 1861, in Gilmanton, New Hampshire. He was the third child of Levi Horton Mudgett and Theodate Page Price. His parents were devout Methodists, descended from the first English settlers in the area. He had two older siblings, Ellen and Arthur, and one younger brother named Henry. But behind that respectable family name was a boy who would become known as Dr. Henry Howard Holmes, or simply H.H. Holmes. He used many aliases—Alexander Bond, Harry Gordon, J.A. Judson, Robert E. Phelps. He was an American con artist and murderer active between 1891 and 1894. By the time he was executed in 1896, his criminal career included insurance fraud, forgery, swindling, three or four bigamous marriages, horse theft, and murder. Known as the Beast of Chicago, the Devil in the White City, or the Torture Doctor, he committed his most notorious crimes in Chicago around the time of the World's Columbian Exposition in 1893. But before we talk about the house, we have to look at the boy. Because the seeds of this darkness were watered long before he ever set foot in Chicago. Holmes attended Phillips Exeter Academy before graduating high school with honors from Gilmanton Academy at just sixteen years old. He was bright, outstanding academically. But his home life was not the picture-perfect Victorian ideal you might expect. His father, Levi, was reportedly a heavy drinker who cruelly beat his children. As an adolescent, Holmes faced bullying by classmates due to his academic capabilities. There is one incident that stands out, a moment that seems to have twisted something inside him. He was forced to stand in front of a human skeleton and put the skeleton's hands on his face in an effort to frighten him. Initially terrified, Holmes later discovered the experience to be intriguing. He claimed that it helped him overcome his worries. This encounter sparked an obsession with death. He began dissecting animals. Hold that thought with me. Think about a child being confronted with mortality in such a visceral way, not as a lesson in biology, but as a tool for torment. And instead of recoiling, he leaned in. He found comfort in the bones. This wasn't just curiosity; it was the beginning of a detachment from the humanity of others. He learned early on that death could be manipulated, studied, and used. And that lesson would follow him into adulthood, shaping every choice he made thereafter. In 1879, Holmes enrolled at the University of Vermont for one year. In 1882, he transferred to the University of Michigan's Department of Medicine and Surgery. Despite mediocre academic performance, he graduated in June 1884. While there, he worked in the anatomy lab under Professor William James Herdman, the chief anatomy instructor. The two were said to have been engaged in facilitating body snatching to supply medical cadavers. Holmes had also apprenticed in New Hampshire under Nahum Wight, a noted advocate of human dissection. Years later, when Holmes was suspected of murder and claimed to be nothing but an insurance fraudster, he admitted to using cadavers to defraud life insurance companies several times in college. This is crucial context. He didn't just kill for thrill; he killed for profit, or rather, he used death as a currency. The ability to obtain bodies, to move them, to hide them, gave him a toolkit that would later make his crimes so difficult to unravel. He understood the system. He knew how medical schools needed specimens. He knew how insurance policies worked. And he saw no moral line crossing those boundaries. To him, people were assets, liabilities, or obstacles. Nothing more. Holmes gave various contradictory accounts of his life. Initially claiming innocence, and later asserting that he was possessed by Satan. His propensity for lying has made it incredibly difficult for researchers to ascertain the truth based on his statements alone. For example, he claimed that Dr. Robert Leacock, a fellow medical school classmate, was one of his first murder victims, killed in 1886 for insurance money. However, Leacock died on October 5th, 1889, in Watford, Ontario, Canada. So, that confession was a lie. It was part of the narrative he constructed to seem like a monster, perhaps to distract from the more mundane reality of his crimes. Much of the lore attached to Holmes concerns the so-called 'Murder Castle,' a three-story building he commissioned on West 63rd Street in Chicago. Details about the building, along with many of his alleged crimes, are considered exaggerated or fabricated for sensationalistic tabloid pieces. Some accounts estimate his body count could be as high as 133. But official findings suggest that the W. 63rd Street property was used for business, and that the irregular architecture was a product of fraud, rather than being designed to fulfill violent fantasies. The myth of the torture chamber often overshadows the reality of the con man. So, if the stories are exaggerated, how did he get caught? It wasn't a dramatic raid on a dungeon filled with screaming victims. It started with a partner who got too close to the fire. Benjamin Pitezel was Holmes’ accomplice in several of his cons. They moved together, planned together. But Holmes’ nature is possessive and paranoid. He believed Pitezel knew too much. Or perhaps Pitezel was getting in his way. It is believed that Holmes killed three of Pitezel's children, as well as three mistresses, the child of one mistress, and the sister of another. These murders were tied to insurance fraud schemes. The turning point in the investigation occurred when a victim's brother noticed a distinctive ring on a skeleton displayed at a medical school. That ring led police to Holmes. Police raided the Chicago hotel in 1894, discovering numerous human remains hidden in the basement and walls of the structure. He was convicted of fraud and later tried for murder, ultimately being found guilty of the deaths of at least two men. Modern forensic analysis and historical research suggest the actual number of his victims may be significantly higher than the two confirmed in court. Holmes was hanged on May 7th, 1896. He confessed to twenty-seven murders during his trial. But remember, we’ve already seen that his confessions were unreliable. He claimed to have killed Dr. Leacock, who was still alive. He claimed motives that didn't align with the evidence. Adam Selzer, author of a book about Holmes, writes: 'Just killing several people isn't necessarily enough for most definitions [of a serial killer]. More often, it has to be a series of similar crimes, committed over a period of time, usually more to satisfy a psychological urge on the killer's part than any more practical motive.' Selzer adds: 'The murders we can connect 'Holmes' to generally had a clear motive: someone knew too much, or was getting in his way, and couldn't be trusted. The murders weren't simply for love of bloodshed but a necessary part of furthering his swindling operation and protecting his lifestyle.' This distinction matters. We often think of serial killers as driven by an uncontrollable impulse. Holmes was different. He was calculated. He was cold. He was a businessman who decided that human lives were expendable overhead costs. That is a terrifying realization. It strips away the romance of the 'madman' and leaves us with something far more banal and dangerous: a man who saw other humans as numbers on a ledger. We don’t know the names of all those who vanished into the shadows of that Chicago building. We don’t know their dreams, their favorite songs, or the sound of their laughter. But we must hold space for them. The search doesn’t end until they’re home, even if 'home' is now just memory. Holmes exploited the chaos of the World's Fair, the influx of strangers, the lack of robust identification systems. He used the very structures of society—medical education, insurance laws, real estate development—to mask his crimes. It reminds us that evil often hides in plain sight, wrapped in professionalism and charm. It hides in the smiles of neighbors, in the trusted professionals, in the quiet corners of our cities. When we look back at history, let’s not just marvel at the complexity of the crime. Let’s honor the resilience of those who sought the truth despite the lies. Let’s honor the families left behind, searching for answers that may never fully come. And let’s remember that while Holmes is gone, the lessons of his life remain. Vigilance. Compassion. And the unwavering belief that every life has value, regardless of what anyone else decides its price. Thank you for spending this time with me. I’m Kimberley Callahan. This story is drawn from public records and widely reported accounts. Our thoughts are with everyone affected. Until next time, keep looking, keep listening, and keep believing in the power of truth. Goodnight.