Latest / The Sperrins: Mining, Power & Community in Northern Ireland / #No.44🎙️ Public Inquiry Late Evidence Accepted -Day 2
Transcript
- 0:04Today was warm, grey, cloudy and wet all day,
- 0:06not the brilliant sunshine we'd had the day before.
- 0:11One might say the mood was similar at the PI
- 0:14walking back in there, not knowing if it was going to be
- 0:17adjourned. Yesterday, wrapped up with the planning appeals
- 0:22commission holding off on decision until this morning
- 0:27on whether Northern Ireland
- 0:29environmental agencies new information would be accepted.
- 0:34The decision was to accept it on the basis that, in their view,
- 0:39the commissioner's questions were grounded in the statement
- 0:41of case and rebuttals, not in the new material. I thought to
- 0:47myself, what would we have written differently in our
- 0:51statement of case and rebuttals if we had access to this
- 0:55information earlier this morning, looking around the
- 1:00stage on which all of this is
- 1:02playing out, I noticed for
- 1:04the first time the number of suits in the room,
- 1:09some beautifully cut,
- 1:11quality style, broad at the shoulder, narrow at the hip,
- 1:16designed for power and influence, as someone said, As
- 1:19if they all drank in the same club, masculine energy is
- 1:23definitely to the forefront. Later, I couldn't help but
- 1:29notice an unconscious bias towards the same power in the
- 1:33room, especially when third party members were speaking, who
- 1:37sometimes had long waits with their hands in the air to answer
- 1:40a question whilst the DFI and dalradian barristers, sitting
- 1:45strategically close to the commissioner, could engage in
- 1:48intimate conversation without even asking permission to speak.
- 1:54The state of affairs continued for some time, creating
- 1:56frustration and anger with third party people, by the way, that's
- 2:00us
- 2:02being forbidden to laugh or clap the day
- 2:04before we dutifully followed the instructions, making the
- 2:08preposterous presumptions that same law would apply equally to
- 2:12all parties. Sadly, this was not the case. It seems that some of
- 2:17the suits patently thought they were above the law, laughing and
- 2:20showing contempt a number of times over the last few days.
- 2:24Moving on, it was good to see the commission pushing dalradian
- 2:27today for Worst case scenario figures instead of
- 2:30approximations and to properly detail where these figures were
- 2:35in the application. Yesterday was noticeable that questions
- 2:40like these were not directly answered instead being kicked up
- 2:43the road like the proverbial tin can, a large part of discussion
- 2:49in the morning served to highlight big gaps in basic
- 2:53details, not inconsequential elements, such As chemicals
- 2:59tonnage and the mystery of the disappearing 15,000 tonnes of
- 3:04soil, words such as flocculence, been bandied about when I looked
- 3:10it up. It comes from an early 19th century English and it
- 3:13means tuft of wool. Apparently, this is used in processing the
- 3:17ore. It's a highly corrosive product. Contact with eyes or
- 3:22skin can cause burns, and ingestion or inhalation can
- 3:26cause internal damage. The casual way these strange terms
- 3:31were being bandied about would almost make you believe they
- 3:34were harmless, like warm and cuddly or something
- 3:39instead, a delraydian
- 3:40expert witness compared the concentrate, that is to say, the
- 3:45stuff that comes out after flotation, conditioning,
- 3:49processing with reagents and flocculence, to a glass of
- 3:53orange juice. I almost choked. I imagined him drinking it as I
- 3:59listened to the staff comparison with growing incredulity, there
- 4:03were conversations about whether the DFI have the jurisdictional
- 4:07remit to actually make a
- 4:09decision about the application,
- 4:11as the lack of management
- 4:13agreements between Northern Ireland and the Republic of
- 4:15Ireland leaves the locks agency powerless to discharge many of
- 4:19its functions if this project was given the go ahead, we
- 4:24wonder who would regulate it. Ah, but that's nothing to worry
- 4:28about. Sure, it's going to be a shared responsibility, isn't it?
- 4:33Finally, the spectre
- 4:35of cyanide raises its ugly head once more. The Commission asked
- 4:40DFI to confirm if Cyanide is removed from the process,
- 4:44because apparently it still appears in documents such as
- 4:47Appendix G part one, mine waste plan not hidden well enough.
- 4:53Comes to my mind,
- 4:55there had been several requests to remove it from all
- 4:58documentation over the last year. It, and yet, here it is
- 5:01again, like a bad smell. Assurances were given, but it
- 5:06appears not to be formally ruled out. This uncertainty is
- 5:10creating real and growing concern for third parties that
- 5:15it could be used somewhere else in the process, and is deeply
- 5:18worrying. Mr. Bill Donnelly, respected objector against the
- 5:24Kavanagh call mine, over many years, reminded the commission
- 5:28that the mine at Kavanagh call has planning permission for the
- 5:31use of cyanide, that it simply had to apply to the nie a to
- 5:37instal a cyanide reactor to process its ore, and it will be
- 5:41rubber stamped through that was never included in the habitats
- 5:45regulation statements, and that it cannot be ruled out that
- 5:48dalradian could process their ore in Kavanaugh call instead of
- 5:52Nova Scotia as outlined in their application. I think the day
- 5:57ended with the conversation about Project splitting, as
- 6:00raised by third parties in the statement of case. As there are
- 6:05eight different planning applications, ranging from power
- 6:07to water to road abandonment, I would have thought it was pretty
- 6:12obvious to the dogs in the street that was project
- 6:15splitting in an effort to avoid an environmental impact
- 6:18assessment. Usual standard mining practice, as outlined in
- 6:23the mining handbook. Get one bit through, and the rest will
- 6:27follow. That's all I have for you this evening, onwards and
- 6:32upwards. See you tomorrow. You.