Latest / Newcomer Pod / Yoni Rechtman Unfiltered on Trump, AI Roll-Ups & Why VCs Backed the Wrong Side
Transcript
- 0:00Is Silicon Valley finally starting to feel embarrassed
- 0:02about their embrace of Trump? Today's guest is Yoni Rachman,
- 0:06venture capitalists as Slow ventures, and one of the
- 0:08spiciest up and coming voices in the tech community.
- 0:11We try to make sense of Silicon Valley's political psychotic
- 0:14break, dig into slow ventures, weird predictions about the
- 0:17future, including why they feel they need to own creators
- 0:20outright and not just their businesses.
- 0:22And finally, we talk about why they're betting that a parking
- 0:26lot company is the next AI juggernaut.
- 0:28This is the newcomer podcast. All right, welcome to the
- 0:38newcomer podcast. You only recommend.
- 0:40Great to have you here. Thank you so much for having me.
- 0:43I feel like but. A long time coming I feel like
- 0:46maybe like 2 years too late frankly.
- 0:49Well, I was looking through it. You have how to work with me and
- 0:52#3 on. It is like give me, give me
- 0:55visibility, give me promotion to be.
- 0:56Clear to be clear #1 on it is courtside tickets to an NBA
- 1:00game. I have been brought to a Nets
- 1:02game yet not yet to a next game #2 on it is bring me cool
- 1:06places. FJ Labs put me on a jet ski,
- 1:09which is great. All right?
- 1:10We've done a lot of business together since then #3 podcast
- 1:13counts for something when the newcomer branded, you know,
- 1:17Suite at the Knicks happens that.
- 1:18Will be the next level. Yeah, yeah, yeah.
- 1:21So a lot to talk about. I mean, you're now you were
- 1:24promoted to be a partner at State Ventures in October 1.
- 1:28I want to have you on because I was honestly thinking to myself
- 1:32like this month, just like who's hustling right now?
- 1:34I'm like who is like, it feels like people aren't like hungry.
- 1:37And I really look at you and you're like, oh, you're really
- 1:39like making it right now. Like I think you're someone
- 1:42who's making moves, thinking about what's happening in
- 1:44venture. So I wanted to talk to you about
- 1:46that and like what's going on, You know, as slow as a firm that
- 1:50almost annoyingly wants to differentiate itself from
- 1:53everybody else. So it's like whatever everybody
- 1:55else thinks, we think the opposite, which, you know, Sam
- 2:00Lesson gets gets some credit for.
- 2:02My my my partner Sam is certainly the spirit animal of
- 2:05the firm. Who you know when I was in the
- 2:06information worked out of his apartment spent some time with
- 2:09him cool. But before we get into all that
- 2:12and like do our classic venture stuff and I think you know
- 2:15everything you guys are in deep in the crater economy.
- 2:18Some of the AI roll up themes figuring out how to invest
- 2:22alongside of the foundation models or with all the funding
- 2:25flowing into the foundation models without that being your
- 2:28investment. We are going to talk politics
- 2:30first, which I don't know, both comes naturally and not so the
- 2:35political moment obviously terrible.
- 2:38I guess we both agree. First the murder of Renee Goode
- 2:43and then a second shooting that sort of broke our brains.
- 2:48You tweeted it, Alex. Freddy, you can say.
- 2:51His name, we can say it was murder.
- 2:53Right, you tweeted. Trump is unleashing brown shirts
- 2:56in our cities in murdering Americans in the streets.
- 3:01The silence, complicity, enthusiasm from our industry is
- 3:04appalling. No tax cut or M&A approval will
- 3:08ever be worth it, and no amount of campus protests or annoying
- 3:12HR meetings could ever equal it. Yeah, well put.
- 3:16I mean, I don't know if there's a question there, but like the
- 3:19reality on the ground feels very self-evident.
- 3:21I've had these conversations with people where they all tell
- 3:24me like, well, like, you know, Alex pretty, he had a gun.
- 3:26He shouldn't have had a gun. He's a left wing agitator.
- 3:28He's in this signal group. He shouldn't have.
- 3:31I, I can actually even accept all of those premises.
- 3:34I, I can accept the like legalistic arguments.
- 3:38I, I don't, but I could accept all of those arguments.
- 3:41The fact of the matter is so many things had to go so
- 3:44terribly wrong for this, like overly militarized, poorly
- 3:52trained, you know, poorly vetted paramilitary group to be
- 3:57conducting operations like that in an American city on a false
- 4:01premise like the the specifics of what happened.
- 4:07I feel like we're being gas lit if we have to argue about it was
- 4:10terrible. Like these are guys wearing
- 4:11masks, pinning him down. They've taken his gun.
- 4:14They shoot him 10 times, many times.
- 4:17I think they they, they fired 10 times and.
- 4:18They hit himself and the guy is an ICU nurse, you know it.
- 4:21Literally a hero among us. So yeah, so I don't think we
- 4:24need to get into the facts of that.
- 4:26It's just I want to talk about, you know, like where we.
- 4:29Want to talk about the venture capital?
- 4:31Of it all exactly exactly how the industry is processing it.
- 4:34I mean, you know, my attitude in the newsletter was, you know,
- 4:40when Trump got re elected was the classic like, you know,
- 4:44leopards are gonna eat your face off sort of situation.
- 4:46I had Parker Conrad at ripling who's sort of another kindred
- 4:49spirit who's like this is terrible.
- 4:51But I, you know, I exist in the tech industry nonetheless being
- 4:55like, man, he said something like, you know, I'm surrounded
- 4:58by a bunch of smart people who think this is gonna be great,
- 5:03but I feels like, no way. It's it's insane.
- 5:08And so then I think, you know, more like left wing members of
- 5:13tech community. Yeah, sort of like chilled out.
- 5:16I mean, my retweets, you know, I would occasionally flare up, but
- 5:20for the most part, we tried to note in the newsletter, you
- 5:23know, crazy moments but not go out.
- 5:25What's been your approach sort of in this sort of like give
- 5:28Trump a year to sort of? See what this is?
- 5:30I didn't give Trump a year. I mean, I remember finding
- 5:33myself at a sort of tech event among some, you know, really
- 5:39cool, fancy, interesting people shortly after the inauguration
- 5:42and got into like a really heated argument about Doge.
- 5:48You know, it's like that was the first thing it was going to be
- 5:49the thing it's, and, and this is how we're going to bring tech
- 5:51into government and we're going to take this like
- 5:53entrepreneurial mindset to government.
- 5:55And, and I, it was very clear to me that this was not a sincere
- 5:59effort, that this was not being undertaken with, you know,
- 6:02seriousness. I I do believe that there are
- 6:04like plenty of the people that volunteered for that effort and
- 6:07that mission, like wanted to contribute to the government in
- 6:11a serious way and like we're civically minded about it.
- 6:16But it was very clear from the onset to me that like all of
- 6:21that, that Trump too is going to be much worse than Trump won any
- 6:24of the, you know, guardrails and constraints and in Trump one
- 6:28were gone. My interest from, you know,
- 6:31shortly after the election was for one, trying to think about
- 6:36what can we do at a more like local level.
- 6:39I believe that, you know, blue cities and states can either be
- 6:46a real like strong point for, you know, Democrats in the
- 6:52midterms and in 2028, or they can be an albatross around our
- 6:55necks. And so like when, you know, New
- 6:57York, California, etcetera, are like run well, thriving
- 7:01Flushing. I think it's a, it's a huge
- 7:03benefit to our argument that like we actually can do this and
- 7:07government can be a force for good in people's lives and.
- 7:11What do you and I want to get into New York?
- 7:13Yeah. What is your read on the
- 7:17political distribution among like the venture capital class?
- 7:21I think that most venture capitalists are at this point
- 7:28amoral financiers. And, and I don't, I don't even
- 7:32mean that in any kind of disparaging way, right?
- 7:34I am, you know, I'm like a very deep believer in property rights
- 7:40and the importance of markets. And there are like a lot of
- 7:44things in the world that I look at with the relatively amoral
- 7:46lens. I think that first and foremost,
- 7:49venture capitalists sell money and they sell money to whoever
- 7:53they can sell money to. And I don't think it's like a
- 7:57necessarily, I think it's a relatively amoral way of moving
- 8:01through the world. And to be clear, I'm saying
- 8:04amoral, not amoral. I don't think there's anything,
- 8:05it's nothing evil, but there's nothing inherently good either.
- 8:09You know, I certainly believe that like entrepreneurial
- 8:13capitalism is, is the best form is the best kind of market
- 8:20system to pair with liberal democracy and to like achieve
- 8:23freedom and broad prosperity. And so in that way, I think it's
- 8:26like ultimately serving some some good purpose.
- 8:28But like most of the people within it are, you know, I went
- 8:32to Stanford, I went to Princeton, I worked at Morgan
- 8:34Stanley, I worked at Meta, You know, I know a bunch of people.
- 8:37I did some Angel investments like, you know, my dad ran the
- 8:41TMT desk at Goldman, like. And so you do think like
- 8:45animating thing they didn't like about Biden.
- 8:47You mentioned your tweet like M&A, like blocking, blocking
- 8:51deals. There was also, you know, the.
- 8:52Crypto angle crypto. Just like make it hard for me to
- 8:56make money. This is really annoying.
- 8:58Gary Gensler and Lena Khan were, I think, legitimately like
- 9:04overzealous in a lot of ways and did a huge amount of like
- 9:08reputational damage pushing tech to the right.
- 9:12And then obviously now like more recently, some of this like
- 9:15cockamamie wealth tax idea in California is doing the same.
- 9:21And so much is, you know, look, my critique about the culture
- 9:26and venture capital is the same about the investing culture as
- 9:30it is about the political culture, which is it's
- 9:32fundamentally like Momo driven. You know, it's like what?
- 9:35Do you? What do you mean?
- 9:36We want to, we, I, I like to be on the winning side.
- 9:39I like to back winners. I like to find winners.
- 9:41And like venture capitalists are always thinking about the world
- 9:44in terms of upside maximization, not looking stupid, job security
- 9:50and, you know, up and like preserving optionality.
- 9:54And so when someone looks like they're winning, most venture
- 9:57capitalists will rush to back the winner.
- 9:59And it's just as true in politics as it is in in their
- 10:03investing. It feels like the momentum is
- 10:06going to turn against Trump. I mean, he's.
- 10:08Yeah, most venture capitalists are quite bad at predicting
- 10:11those wins. But you.
- 10:12Know yeah, it's always worrying, you know, do they think, you
- 10:17know, democracy itself will fail like is it a prediction that.
- 10:21I think a lot of people, I think a lot of people don't take
- 10:24seriously the extent to which our like system of
- 10:29entrepreneurial capitalism rests on strong institutions.
- 10:33And So what Trump is doing in our democracy, he is also doing
- 10:38to our market system. And so, for instance, like, it
- 10:42should be extremely concerning to anyone who calls himself a
- 10:46capitalist to watch him start like nationalizing companies,
- 10:50which is what he has done in the steel industry and in the chips
- 10:53industry to watch him, you know, try and put, I mean, not put
- 10:59pressure criminally prosecute Jerome Powell to like exert
- 11:04control. Like central bank, independence
- 11:06is one of the pillars. And the idea that you could
- 11:09commit fraud and probably if you can pull together a couple
- 11:12$1,000,000, you can you can get it to the Trump administration
- 11:15and then you can get a partner and get out of.
- 11:17It and so like there is no democracy without I I I really
- 11:21believe that there is no like the systems of democracy,
- 11:25capitalism, property rights, institutions, independent
- 11:28judiciary. These are all actually one thing
- 11:31and in countries that have one, they generally tend to have all
- 11:34of them. And in countries where one
- 11:36fails, the rest fail shortly thereafter.
- 11:38Like he's doing third world. You know, it's it's third world
- 11:44style corruption in the US and is, is substantially undermining
- 11:49like the excellence of American institutions and the excellence
- 11:53of American capitalism. And like we are all going to
- 11:55wind up paying for that. So even in the most strictly A
- 11:58moral terms, you don't care about any of the like ideas of
- 12:02about the liberal world order. Like we're going to wind up
- 12:06looking like Turkey or Argentina or Russia where like there is
- 12:11no, you know, sort of free market, there is no meaningfully
- 12:14free market system. There is no central bank
- 12:16independence. There are no strong
- 12:17institutions. There is no.
- 12:20What do you make of these? Things all together that, you
- 12:25know, if you give Trump a golden crown or whatever, he's going to
- 12:29treat you well. And Democrats, if you try and do
- 12:32it, they might say, oh, look, a billionaire, you know, we should
- 12:35tax you more. I I'm not saying Democrats
- 12:38should get more corrupt, but there is this asymmetry where
- 12:41you get more out of cozying up to the Republicans as a business
- 12:44person. Totally, totally.
- 12:46I think the Democrats often really struggle to articulate a
- 12:50positive vision for America and the world.
- 12:54You know, there's this, like, Simpsons meme that people always
- 12:57share that is hysterical. And it's the Republican National
- 13:00Convention. And it says like, you know, you
- 13:03know, like. We're evil.
- 13:04We're we're evil and we know it. And then the Democratic National
- 13:07Convention is like, we hate every, we're like, like we,
- 13:10we're incompetent and we hate ourselves.
- 13:14I think that Democrats really struggle for how much they
- 13:19because of how much they point out problems instead of being
- 13:22able to put forth a like positive vision for America.
- 13:26I think it's really challenging to hold the two conflicting
- 13:29ideas in your head. I am, you know, notwithstanding
- 13:33his like personal proclivities, often very inspired by Bill
- 13:36Clinton and, you know, his line, there's nothing that's wrong
- 13:39with America that can't be fixed with what's right with America.
- 13:42Like, I believe that very deeply.
- 13:43I think the idea of. I still don't.
- 13:46I I agree with everything you're saying.
- 13:47I just don't think it doesn't solve the corruption problem.
- 13:49Part of it is, I think when Democrats are in power, they
- 13:52need to make sure you have severe consequences.
- 13:54Yeah. And if you try to buy off the
- 13:56government, and it has to be, well, you're not allowed to do
- 13:58that. You can't have one party coming
- 14:00to power where you're allowed to sort of be paid to pay, play and
- 14:03corrupt in another party that says we're the principled ones,
- 14:06but we're not. We don't have enough backbone to
- 14:08actually process. No, I mean, Democrats need to be
- 14:10more willing to, like, wield power.
- 14:13I think, you know, Merrick Garland is a coward and an
- 14:16embarrassment and an idiot for not, you know, putting Trump in
- 14:20prison. The What do you tech is built on
- 14:24immigrants. You know, Elon Musk himself is
- 14:28an immigrant. Many of these tech companies,
- 14:30you know, have H1B employees doing a lot of the most
- 14:34important work yet there is. I mean, there's a strain that's
- 14:37like, obviously immigrants are the ones being attacked here.
- 14:40But there's also some of the leader like, you know, XAI has
- 14:43tons of immigrants. Elon is practically, you know, a
- 14:46white nationalist at this point. I don't know.
- 14:48What do you make of the anti immigrant?
- 14:51But they won't go after the good ones.
- 14:53That that's. I think that is, I think it's,
- 14:56that's the cognitive dissonance of like, you know, it's all
- 14:59happening somewhere else over there.
- 15:00It's abstract, you know, won't affect me.
- 15:03It won't affect the people in my life.
- 15:05And frankly, to some extent it might be true.
- 15:08I mean, because of this system of crony capitalism that we're
- 15:11now in and like really third world, third world corruption
- 15:16that Trump has brought to America, it might be true that
- 15:20that the people who cozy up to the administration will get to
- 15:23keep the visas for their. Employment, but they're also not
- 15:24that competent, thankfully, I think.
- 15:26And so, you know, I I don't know, I just saw a tech person
- 15:29the other day who said, you know, they tried to come back
- 15:32from the US on an O1 visa and a cotton like jerked around and
- 15:35they're just like moving to London.
- 15:37You know, it is like we're going to lose.
- 15:39People would be in Silicon Valley, even if, you know,
- 15:42certain firms can get exceptions or special treatment.
- 15:45Yeah. From the administration.
- 15:47It's sort of reminds me there's a, there's a dark, there's a
- 15:52real sort of dark potential here, which is kind of like
- 15:55perestroika, which is, you know, could we be entering a period of
- 16:00like rapid sort of cronyism and privatization that leaves us
- 16:05overall a much poorer country and looking like, looking like
- 16:10Russia with weak institutions, no judicial independence, no
- 16:12central bank independence, but oligarchs who have successfully,
- 16:17you know, seized, seize power based on their proximity to, you
- 16:22know, this like fundamentally illegitimate government.
- 16:24What's your view on how friendly everybody should be with each
- 16:27other on Twitter and in real life?
- 16:29You know, what do we do? It feels like, OK, we're in this
- 16:32moment where both you and I sort of think, OK, we were right.
- 16:35Although like, you know, the sky is falling about Trump really
- 16:38feels true. They are shooting people in the
- 16:41streets. They have a like, Gestapo like
- 16:44force. They have people literally
- 16:46cosplaying as Nazis. You know, it is just, it is a
- 16:50dark moment. Like a lot of the things that,
- 16:53like, if you had predicted that Trump would try to put tariffs
- 16:57on Europe to try and take Greenland from them, you would
- 17:00have been like mocked before the election.
- 17:03So things I think are unambiguously worse than you
- 17:06could have really said without being laughed at before the
- 17:09election. So that's the world we find
- 17:11ourselves in. Yeah.
- 17:13I think we're so fatigued from, whoa, cancel culture era of like
- 17:17booing everybody. Like, where do we, I guess to
- 17:20put a direct question to you, Like, what's your view on this
- 17:23sort of like no compelled speech, right.
- 17:25Like I mocked, I said, I said something snide about Gary Tan
- 17:28because he's always out there talking.
- 17:30Let me he's always out there talking.
- 17:33And I said, you know, he's not saying anything on this.
- 17:35He used to be sort of a principled Democrat.
- 17:38And I said, you know, power corrupts, I guess.
- 17:41And he he's now blocked me on Twitter and people accuse me of
- 17:44trying to compel speech. Like, what's your view on this?
- 17:47I really. Don't think anybody is required
- 17:52to have or share an opinion about anything or everything.
- 17:56I do think that when you have an opinion about everything except
- 18:02for one thing, that's that's a little bit different.
- 18:04Stands out to people. Yeah.
- 18:06So there are a lot of things that go on in the world that I
- 18:10just don't feel like it's necessary for me to express an
- 18:12opinion about, frankly. Like I don't live in California.
- 18:14I don't like want to get too deeply involved in California
- 18:17politics. So I mostly keep my mouth shut
- 18:19because, like, it annoys me when people talk about New York
- 18:22politics and like, you don't have you don't have a stake in
- 18:24this. But like, we're talking about
- 18:25America. We all have a stake in it.
- 18:27And there's a lot of people who I think have put themselves
- 18:31forward as not just business leaders, but moral leaders who
- 18:35then exempt themselves from that responsibility in moments of
- 18:39moral crisis. So I don't think anyone is
- 18:42required to take up a mantle of moral leadership.
- 18:45I don't think anyone is required to, like, be a public
- 18:48intellectual. If you want to be a public
- 18:51intellectual, if you want to, you know, be a philosopher king,
- 18:55then like what? People are going to look to you
- 18:58for leadership and when there are moments of moral crisis and
- 19:01you don't offer anything, people are going to be like, oh, I
- 19:03thought I thought you were a source of wisdom.
- 19:06I I agree with that take 100%. How much do you tell founders to
- 19:12pick their VCs based on their? Morals.
- 19:14Not, not, not really at all. Honestly, I, I think being look,
- 19:19I think it's a lot easier for me to say a lot of this stuff as a
- 19:23venture capitalist, like the job of a founder is just immensely
- 19:29more difficult. And I would love to be able to
- 19:32tell someone like, you know, live your conscience in every
- 19:36way all the time. But like, I heard this once and,
- 19:39and it really stuck with me is that like all money is green and
- 19:41all money is red, you know, like it all spends and it all
- 19:45probably came from something a little bit dirty.
- 19:49And like ultimately at the end of the day, like it's very
- 19:53difficult to like whose money is it really?
- 19:55Frankly, it's like it's sitting in the start-ups bank account,
- 19:57but it was put there by a venture capitalist who received
- 20:00it from some institution who received it from its donors
- 20:03like. Some of these investors end up
- 20:05having leverage over you. I guess that would.
- 20:07Yeah. I think, you know, if it's a
- 20:08minority investor and you're just trying to raise money,
- 20:12yeah. I mean, I tend to be on the sort
- 20:14of when it comes to fundraising, yeah.
- 20:17Pretty tolerant. I mean, you know, I, I try to
- 20:20maintain and quote and especially on deal type stories,
- 20:23talk to right wing members of Silicon Valley.
- 20:26Like it is a funny role that I play where it's like at once I
- 20:29have principles, but you know, they're part of the community
- 20:33and I'm, you know, I want to be sort of a vehicle to keep the
- 20:36community together. And so I would.
- 20:38Piece of it I would much rather be able to believe and I do
- 20:43believe that like the tides will turn than saying I'm going to
- 20:47like cut myself off from anybody who disagrees with me that
- 20:49that's sort of incompatible with a lot of my other values.
- 20:54And like, I have the privilege of being able to like speak
- 20:58about my opinions and like, that is, you know, not everyone has
- 21:02that. I, I'm, I do, but I still do
- 21:06like have a responsibility to like my partners and my founders
- 21:09and our investors to like do the job that they're paying us for.
- 21:14And, you know, I think if I were to just say like, you know, fuck
- 21:18you to everyone I disagree with, that would be like a dereliction
- 21:21of my job. Where?
- 21:23Where do you think things are going?
- 21:25I mean, look, Trump's going to make some noises to moderate
- 21:28ahead of the midterms. He will do that unsuccessfully,
- 21:31but potentially like a credulous national news media will applaud
- 21:34him for, you know, firing Greg Bunvino.
- 21:40And that'll be that. But I think a lot of what's
- 21:43happening right now is, look, Trump was elected basically to
- 21:47do four or five things. America first.
- 21:50Well, he's bailing out foreign governments and getting into,
- 21:54you know, illegal foreign wars, reduce inflation.
- 21:59He's making energy prices go up, home prices go up, not doing
- 22:03that, you know, close the border sent, send them all home while
- 22:07he's just shooting Americans in the head and like rounding up
- 22:10children. And hey, by the way, our
- 22:11deportation numbers are basically flat from Biden and
- 22:15Trump won. And Obama was doing more.
- 22:18Yeah, Obama was doing more. Obama was doing more.
- 22:21Drain the swamp. He's like actively taking bribes
- 22:24and bringing Third World corruption and cronyism to
- 22:29America for the first time. So like.
- 22:31He's literally pardoning. Oh, and there's and there's
- 22:33countries. And then the fifth one is
- 22:35released, the Epstein files, which he is actively.
- 22:39One of the main characters, apparently.
- 22:41One of the main characters in actively subverting that
- 22:43investigation. So if those are the five
- 22:46promises of of Trump too, he is failing on every single one of
- 22:50them in like really substantial and notable ways.
- 22:52I think he's going to get absolutely, like, drubbed in the
- 22:57midterms. I think he is going to make, I
- 23:01think his party's really going to pay for it in 2028.
- 23:04And my hope is that America can then begin the like, long and
- 23:08hard process of rebuilding trust in government and rebuilding the
- 23:11institutions that have been like, really, I mean, profoundly
- 23:14and severely damaged and even just the one first year of his
- 23:17presidency. You, you.
- 23:19You ended up supporting Mom, Donnie.
- 23:20I did. I, I, yeah, I voted for him over
- 23:23Cuomo. I ranked him like 4 probably in
- 23:25the primary. I think I ranked him four or
- 23:26five in the primary. I was.
- 23:27I was like Brad Lander. Brad Lander?
- 23:30Yeah, exactly. Seldner is one or two, you know,
- 23:34I forget which exact. I think Brad because it seemed
- 23:37like he was going to win or he had the more momentum.
- 23:39So not that he was going to win, but and.
- 23:41Brad is also, I mean, you know, I've, I've met him a number of
- 23:45times. I grew up in in Brooklyn, you
- 23:47know, and, and have sort of known him, even if only
- 23:51peripherally for a long time. I think he is a, we're not here
- 23:56to, and this is deeper into New York politics than your audience
- 23:59probably wants to get. But like, I think Brad is like a
- 24:01really, really cool and like kind of beautiful soul.
- 24:04We talked about inside baseball stuff.
- 24:06Yeah, yeah, yeah. And, and if you want to get
- 24:09really, really inside baseball, the like single most personally
- 24:14moving thing to me in Judaism is this idea of like Pitzel and
- 24:16Elohim. We're all made in God's image.
- 24:18We share this kind of divine, like divine spark or, you know,
- 24:22piece of divinity within ourselves.
- 24:23And anyway, something randomly former New York City controller
- 24:28Brad Lander talks about a lot. And he and I have have talked
- 24:31about it and kind of bonded a little bit over that in passing
- 24:34various points. I think he's a really, really
- 24:37special person and I'm excited to see what he does next.
- 24:40But do you think you know if Mom, Donnie and AOC are the
- 24:43future of the Democratic Party? I think they're the future of
- 24:46the Democratic Party in New York.
- 24:47And I think it's really, really important to like, be able to
- 24:51meaningfully distinguish between like, the bluest of blue States
- 24:55and the rest of the country. Like, I don't, you know, John
- 25:02Fetterman is a Democrat, like Tim Kaine is a Democrat.
- 25:06You know, Joe Manchin was a Democrat.
- 25:09Like there are a lot of different flavors of Democrat
- 25:14around the country. I'm not really super convinced
- 25:17that the like the way to win is to like put forth figures like
- 25:25Mandani and AOC on a national stage.
- 25:26I think they do really well in certain corridors.
- 25:29I think they have some good ideas.
- 25:30I think they have some really bad ideas.
- 25:34I don't think that that is the future of the Democratic Party.
- 25:37I I think that there are like honestly on some of the kind of
- 25:41bread and butter issues. I think that the the left does a
- 25:43much the like the left of the Democratic Party just does a
- 25:46much better job of like talking about things and frankly like.
- 25:49Talk like the affordability buzzword.
- 25:52Affordability and like that, you know, then just becomes this
- 25:57question of like do we do we see affordability through a supply
- 26:01side lens, which is more of the kind of like abundance and like
- 26:06YIMBY movement or do we see affordability through more of
- 26:09the demand side lens, which is the historical democratic
- 26:12approach of like subsidized demand and then watches prices
- 26:15spiral out of control. So the emerging Democratic
- 26:19consensus does actually across the sort of range of Democrats
- 26:23does seem to be more supply side or abundance oriented, which is
- 26:27really encouraging. I work in New York with a group
- 26:31called Abundance New York. Who these guys, these guys are
- 26:35great. Shout out, you know, Catherine
- 26:37and and Ryder. And then nationally, I'm, I'm
- 26:40close with the people around the inclusive abundance initiative.
- 26:45I think there's like the whole idea of abundance politics can
- 26:49work really well. I think the language itself is
- 26:52very like elite coded and and and maybe not super transferable
- 26:55works better as affordability. Let's do more things and make
- 26:58things cheaper. But that to me, is like the sort
- 27:01of positive vision of the future that the Democratic Party should
- 27:05be putting. Forward we just in California, I
- 27:07think Matt Mahan is now running for governor.
- 27:09People are clearly going to circle around him.
- 27:12Yeah. I mean, I, I hope the Democrats
- 27:14don't mess it up. You know, I, I think if it's
- 27:17abundance oriented positive mindset like just the California
- 27:22tax while I'm fine with taxing billionaires taxing unrealized
- 27:26gains is such a disaster that then then having these taxes
- 27:31floated even though I know it's sort of like, you know, some
- 27:34union puts on some ballot initiative but it really feels
- 27:37like it could plausibly pass in California.
- 27:39I I that stuff. I don't, I don't think it, you
- 27:42know. I don't think it will pass and I
- 27:43also don't think it would stand up to like a core challenge.
- 27:47But like, yeah, the the like wealth tax idea in that way is
- 27:52really stupid. I think they're like actually
- 27:54right way to do that is get rid of the step up and basis, which
- 27:57is basically like a reintroduction of the estate
- 27:59tax. And then the second thing is
- 28:01like, come up with some. Ideally on a national level so
- 28:04people aren't. State shopping and and and do
- 28:06some approach to taxing the like buy bar or die strategy.
- 28:11Right. And then give people health
- 28:12care. And I, I think if the tax is for
- 28:15something, it's easier to sell sometimes when Democrats are
- 28:19talking about it just as a tax without saying this is the
- 28:22policy we want to pay for. It just feels sort of mean
- 28:25spirited and anti capital. I mean, look, I think what's
- 28:28happened in New York is actually like a really encouraging
- 28:31version of what this could look like, which is New York
- 28:33introduced congestion pricing, which is functionally A
- 28:37consumption tax. Instead of talking about it as a
- 28:40victory of how much revenue we've generated.
- 28:43I think Kathy Hochul in particular like has done a
- 28:46really good job of talking about the outcomes that.
- 28:49It No, I was such a hater. I know.
- 28:51She's so much better than I thought.
- 28:53It's like crazy. Oh yeah.
- 28:54Just wait until after the election like do.
- 28:56It in a much more politically. Palatable way get some seats for
- 28:59Democrats. Like, yeah, she's, she's like,
- 29:01totally. Right.
- 29:02She's a she's a political. It's like, it's like, not my
- 29:05like vibe and aesthetic, but like she's fucking knocking out
- 29:09of the park. And, and part of it is like she
- 29:12is been very, very, she's had a really hardcore message
- 29:15discipline, but not talking about how much money they've
- 29:17raised, but instead talking about the outcomes and what
- 29:20they're spending the money on, which is like, you know,
- 29:22improvements to the subway system.
- 29:24And hey, look at all of the outcomes we're achieving in
- 29:26terms of like shorter commute times and lower air pollution
- 29:30and less noise pollution and you know, more, more shoppers on the
- 29:34street. And yet all of these things are
- 29:36like awesome and real and we have proof of and like it is
- 29:41just that is a positive way of talking about government
- 29:45intervention that is like exciting.
- 29:47And you make a case for how you're going to make people's
- 29:49lives better instead of making a case about how you're going to
- 29:52make their enemies lives worse. All right, so talking about the
- 29:56business of venture capital, talk a little bit.
- 29:59Oh, that, yeah, our job. You know, your job and sort of
- 30:02the main thing I write about. I think, I think probably like
- 30:05all of you know, the rest of my team is.
- 30:07There's this moment. Yeah, fucking God, he's done.
- 30:11We'll have a little link where people can just join us, like,
- 30:14Oh yeah, they're done with politics.
- 30:16Talk about. Tony Eric living out for 20
- 30:18minutes. Give us give us your
- 30:22articulation in classic spicy slow fashion of what slows slow
- 30:26venture philosophy. Is yeah, what look, we are a
- 30:29very decentralized partnership. So it's it's for partners
- 30:32investing the seed fund and and I think we often it's like 80%
- 30:36alignment with the last 20% being language.
- 30:38What I always say is like we need to find really awesome
- 30:42people with weird takes on important stories and it's
- 30:45that's it. The the really awesome people
- 30:47thing is like self-evident. We talk about what awesome
- 30:49people look like, what really, really exceptional people look
- 30:51like. By and large, everyone buys the
- 30:53premise. You need awesome people.
- 30:55I think where most people in venture get wrong is they just
- 30:59look for really cool stories and they forget the second part of
- 31:06it, which is like weird takes they're on.
- 31:08So my belief very deeply is that we need to find things that are
- 31:14are a little bit like off kilter, out of center, non
- 31:17obvious, non consensus. Basically you need things that
- 31:20are like unique inputs to achieve unique end of 1 outputs.
- 31:24And like that's it. That's the entire business.
- 31:26There's nothing else. If you believe in power laws,
- 31:29like don't invest in things that are obvious or same, same.
- 31:35So I am a generalist. I think I can find those kinds
- 31:39of weird takes and and important stories in a lot of different
- 31:43places, But really try and like constrain myself to companies
- 31:48that can sort of be articulated through these like big if true
- 31:50statements or really feel like when you first hear you're like,
- 31:54that's fucking stupid. And then if you think about it
- 31:57for a little while longer, it kind of starts to it grows on
- 32:00you. There's a creeping realization.
- 32:02So how do you invest around AI? Yeah.
- 32:04How are you in foundation models?
- 32:06No. OK, no, we're not in any
- 32:07Foundation models. What?
- 32:09That's a big mistake on some level, all right.
- 32:11Look, on some level, yeah, we probably should have done it.
- 32:14It's a great trade. We should have done it and sold.
- 32:16And you know, we could have whatever we didn't.
- 32:21Sometimes maybe we're a little bit too like honest and
- 32:23principled for our own good. And if we see something we think
- 32:25doesn't make sense, we just don't do it.
- 32:28But I know we're not in any foundation models.
- 32:30So I am at this point much more interested in the like second
- 32:34order effects of AI. So rather than saying like, how
- 32:37do we like Max tokens, what happens after we do?
- 32:41Let's just like accept as a general premise that like, yeah,
- 32:44it's like, this is a real thing. It's going to keep getting
- 32:47better. It's going to wind up in more
- 32:48parts of the economy. Like not without some pain and
- 32:50struggle and strife, but like it's going to wind up in more
- 32:52parts of the economy. What happens then?
- 32:55And I think to my point, I'm like, OK, do you like
- 32:59improvement in deployment of AI is a really important story
- 33:03like, but the most basic version of that is like, well, I'm just
- 33:06going to make the capabilities better.
- 33:08I, I think that's the wrong approach.
- 33:10I think honestly already at this point we're on the wrong side of
- 33:15some scaling laws around this. We're like and, and frankly, a
- 33:19lot of even feels unnecessary. I think that all of the model
- 33:21development could stop tomorrow and we would have like 10 or 15
- 33:25or 25 years of really big important work in front of us.
- 33:28And we have some evidence for that, which is that like, you
- 33:32know, we're still in, we like the whole economy is still in
- 33:37the move to the cloud like 25 years later, you know, so this
- 33:40is not going to happen overnight.
- 33:42But like, what are then the things that only make sense are
- 33:44only possible in that world? What are either the types of
- 33:48problems that AI creates and new businesses will need to solve or
- 33:52the types of opportunities that only become available once once
- 33:57like the capabilities have gotten there?
- 34:00Sure. So I think throughout, like
- 34:05probably the number one feature of like what AI is really good
- 34:08at is inverting any kind of system that relies on like
- 34:14scarce production and abundant attention.
- 34:18So like things like writing phone calls, hiring, coding, all
- 34:24of these are things which previously we had pretty like
- 34:28limited ability to produce. You can only make so many phone
- 34:30calls. You could only write so many
- 34:32lines of code. And we have entire social
- 34:35systems built on the fact that you have like effectively
- 34:38unlimited bandwidth to like review and process those things
- 34:42that have happened, those things that have been produced that is
- 34:44very obviously reversed. So like what are some of the
- 34:47consequences of that? Well, like everything is slopped
- 34:49out. Like, sure, yes.
- 34:50But specifically, like you know, even as the amount of code
- 34:56getting generated is going up in large or in, in, in large
- 34:59organizations, large companies, velocity is going down because
- 35:03now code review has become this unbelievable bottleneck and all
- 35:07of our system of. Every AI hater is just gonna be
- 35:10like they're pumping out tons of words and not valuable.
- 35:15It's creating problems. When it's free to produce code,
- 35:18you produce more code, but it's not free to review that code.
- 35:20So I think, I mean, I think Git is like really, really
- 35:24structurally challenged. And GitHub is, you know, in this
- 35:28weird moment where they're like, basically all the good talent is
- 35:30left and they're in this feature freeze.
- 35:31And Git Lab is like sort of perpetually on the verge.
- 35:34Of a bat in this race of. Course.
- 35:37What is it? Yeah.
- 35:38So, so we backed this business called Atomic, which rather than
- 35:41trying to be like this layer between Git and, you know, the
- 35:46LMS or something like that, which a lot of people are
- 35:48working on, they want to just be an entirely new, you know,
- 35:54replacement, forget so like exist, you know, down here.
- 36:00And we've seen this happen before, used to have centralized
- 36:03version control systems and then sort of the advent of like open
- 36:08source and specifically Linux like broke that open.
- 36:10Like none of those centralized version control systems could
- 36:13manage it. Linus Torvald created Git and we
- 36:15have this like, you know, an unbelievable amount of
- 36:19enterprise value created off of the back of that.
- 36:22Well, that's 20 years ago. It seems unlikely to me that Git
- 36:26is going to really survive like code Gen. and LLM assisted, you
- 36:32know, software development for the next 20 years.
- 36:36One approach that is taken venture capital by storm and I
- 36:41you you guys were early on it but are also passionate is this
- 36:44roll up idea. Take some old world business,
- 36:48give it AI make a bunch of money.
- 36:51What? What is slow doing?
- 36:53Easy 3. Steps.
- 36:55What is the slowest approach and what's your view of sort of
- 36:58venture capital embracing? The so so this is what we
- 37:02internally refer to as a GB O or growth by buy out.
- 37:05We've been doing this for a long time, since well before I joined
- 37:08the firm. So you know, the first kind of
- 37:11canonical example of this that we have is our business
- 37:14Metropolis. Metropolis started off as
- 37:16software for parking lots. They eventually wound up raising
- 37:20$100 million, buying a parking lot operator, installing their
- 37:23software, making that business way more profitable.
- 37:25They then raised another I think billion and a half dollars,
- 37:28bought the biggest public company in their space, took it
- 37:30private, did the same thing. They recently announced that
- 37:32they raised another I think 4. Billion AI for parking lots just
- 37:36underline. That AIAI for parking lots it's.
- 37:41Doing well. Oh, it's, I mean they just
- 37:42raised I think another 4 billion dollars, 456.
- 37:46Who's to say? And the idea is just like
- 37:48computer vision, and the monitoring is much easier, you
- 37:51know? It's it they, they basically run
- 37:53these parking lots now entirely autonomously and they monetize
- 37:56the payments and and. Harder to not pay.
- 37:59Yeah. And so the basic idea in all of
- 38:03this stuff, in our view, is that like there's a lot of markets
- 38:09that are screaming out for like software or AI, but are like
- 38:16fundamentally unsound places to build a business selling it.
- 38:19So rather than trying to like, you know, invest a ton in sales
- 38:25and marketing to bring this product to market that nobody
- 38:28wants to win a very, very small amount of of budget, you know,
- 38:33in, in each one of these customers.
- 38:35Like, why don't you just go, if the if the economics are
- 38:38transformational enough, just go and buy the business, transform
- 38:41it yourself, own all the upside and like be compete on the basis
- 38:46of technology using M&A as a go to market motion.
- 38:50So this is I think where this is very different than private
- 38:52equity, where our view is like is really trying to be laser
- 38:57focused on product, not process. So we meet a lot of people will
- 39:01say like, well, I'm just a really smart, I went to this
- 39:03school, I did this thing like, we're just going to be really
- 39:05good asset owners here. And I think that is an awesome
- 39:08private equity approach that is actually going to perform really
- 39:11well in this moment. We're like we're going to know
- 39:14how to use these tools the best, we're going to integrate them to
- 39:16the best, but it's not necessarily built for scale or
- 39:20built for repeatability or built for defensibility.
- 39:24So we're very interested in these opportunities where we can
- 39:27underwrite like a product team to go and really validate some
- 39:32kind of transformational, economically transformational
- 39:34product in a market that we think will support this kind of
- 39:37motion. But you know, you could envision
- 39:41buying a professional services firm, you know that that has
- 39:46like, you know, call it 10 or 15% EBITDA margins.
- 39:49And if you've built a product that you think transforms that
- 39:52into a, you know, call it 30 or 40% EBITDA business like that is
- 39:58huge value creation for yourself obviously.
- 40:01It also means that you can afford to buy these businesses
- 40:04like much more aggressively, like you're maybe not quite as
- 40:07sensitive on entry price, like maybe you can pay, you know, 11
- 40:11times instead of 10 times or anything, something like that.
- 40:14So you have your pick of the litter on on which business you
- 40:16want to buy. And if you can go and start
- 40:19buying increasingly large businesses over time, as
- 40:22Metropolis has done, you have a chance to, within a relatively
- 40:25short amount of time own this like.
- 40:28Huge. Cash flow generating really,
- 40:31really like unique asset and just like run it forever and
- 40:35take it public. And so we're not interested in
- 40:39these opportunities to say like we're going to go and fix a
- 40:42broken business and like modernize it.
- 40:45And we really want to think about.
- 40:48And this is I think why it really is fundamentally venture
- 40:50is like be very, very focused on the upside that we can create in
- 40:54these businesses rather than thinking about how we can make
- 40:57money through, you know, financial engineering or
- 41:00turnarounds or any of that. It's it is.
- 41:02It's just a different go to market for software instead of
- 41:06some different business model for us.
- 41:09But all the competition for these businesses has got to
- 41:11drive you crazy right now. There's all this money pouring
- 41:14in. So every strategy is going to
- 41:16have all of a sudden if you have a dry cleaning business, all
- 41:20these VCs said, oh, I need that company.
- 41:22We're going to bring AI to it, so.
- 41:26I think the answer just like anything else is it means you
- 41:28have to be willing. Like a few years ago it was
- 41:31unconventional enough to even be thinking about this strategy
- 41:33that like that alone was the off kilter unique kind of end of one
- 41:38approach. I think today we just need to be
- 41:40looking in weirder places. I think we need to be looking at
- 41:43like weirder types of teams. I think we need to be looking at
- 41:46them earlier, different kinds of interventions, different kinds
- 41:49of product approaches, but it's just the, it's the same.
- 41:52It's like. Private equity at least respects
- 41:55expertise in the domain, yeah. Whereas venture capital often
- 41:59scoffs at the people who've been running the dry cleaning
- 42:02business or whatever, and then they they don't understand sort
- 42:06of the particular things that make a business succeed or.
- 42:08So I, I, I don't know if I agree with that premise, honestly.
- 42:12I think that if you're coming in to sell software to that, I
- 42:16mean, look, let's let's use like real examples here.
- 42:19You know, if you're coming in and you're like building toast
- 42:22for, you know, SM BS and restaurants and stuff and you
- 42:25don't have like. Toast the payments processor.
- 42:27Yeah, yeah, Toast, toast, the like, you know, Yeah.
- 42:30And you don't have like a ton of respect for your customers and
- 42:33you're not like really willing to listen to them and understand
- 42:36them and like, they're not going to buy your product.
- 42:39It's not going to work. You're going to build the wrong
- 42:40thing. Like I don't think that it's
- 42:42unique to this instance to say that you need to like if you
- 42:46think about these companies that you're acquiring, if you think
- 42:49about them as your customers and your partners.
- 42:51You're just saying any successful entrepreneur, any
- 42:53success empathetic to there, but it's just easier if you've grown
- 42:56up in the OR it's you know, I'm in media.
- 42:59You watch people get into media sometimes and famous.
- 43:01You're like, you don't know any of.
- 43:03Famously, private equity is extremely respectful when they
- 43:06go in and buy media. Companies, well, they're but
- 43:08those strategies are just like, you know, burn them and take the
- 43:11profits as we can. But whenever somebody says, oh,
- 43:13I really, I'm not from media, but I'm a smart, yeah, I'm gonna
- 43:16like, really? Yeah, reinvent it.
- 43:18It doesn't usually, yeah. Work I I mean this is one of the
- 43:22reasons why we tell people build then buy like don't start the
- 43:28business and immediately. Go to become that thing like.
- 43:30Do a version of. It first, well, what I mean is
- 43:32like go and service them as customers first, build a product
- 43:35that is like really good and transformational to them first.
- 43:39Maybe it's a lot cheaper to build software than it is to go
- 43:42and buy a business, especially today.
- 43:44So you should be able to test and validate that what you've
- 43:47built actually like justifies going and raising a bunch of
- 43:53money to buy these assets. And in the doing, you're going
- 43:56to learn a lot about the the like customers and partners that
- 43:58you're serving. So I just, I just don't, I think
- 44:02it's a different go to market, but I don't think that it is
- 44:05exempt from the same kinds of like basic physics of build
- 44:09business building, which is like, you know, customer
- 44:13centricity and like keep respect and interest in solving problems
- 44:18for them. If you had to bet on one other
- 44:19investment firm doing roll ups, who would it be?
- 44:22I think to some extent it might just be like, look, the whole
- 44:25collection of like kind of what I would call bold bracket
- 44:28venture is doing this well. They're taking a very different
- 44:32approach to this than we are, which usually starts with
- 44:35capital rather than starting with a product.
- 44:38I don't think it's wrong. I think it will trend towards a
- 44:41very different kind of outcome. But like every every one of the
- 44:45like, you know, mega funds, which they increasingly look
- 44:49indistinguishable from the mega private equity funds and even
- 44:52the mega hedge funds, you know, they all have teams now focused
- 44:56on this. I don't think that they will be
- 44:58wrong. I just think they will wind up
- 45:00selecting for different kinds of people and opportunities that we
- 45:03will and they're going to capitalize them very
- 45:05differently. So one of the reasons this whole
- 45:07idea is so attractive to them is because it's an opportunity to
- 45:10go in like deploy mondo dollars from day zero.
- 45:14That's not our approach. Our belief always is that like
- 45:18too much money too fast throttles progress and like, you
- 45:23know, you, you have an overstuffed pig and it dies.
- 45:27It allows a level of, you know, poor discipline and loose
- 45:32thinking. You've you've talked some about,
- 45:35you know, king making. Yeah, in venture capital it can
- 45:38work. I mean if you throw enough, I
- 45:40mean open AI right now is sort of proving well, a too big to
- 45:44fail. Strategy.
- 45:45So yes, I think it's a question of when though, because like
- 45:49Open AI, open AI was so profoundly non consensus from
- 45:54its start. It wasn't even let alone AC
- 45:56Corp, it wasn't a for profit company.
- 45:59So it's all of this stuff looks in it like the present looks
- 46:03inevitable in retrospect. But the number of companies that
- 46:06are like wildly successful today that were deeply, deeply non
- 46:10consensus at the time. You know, Open AI is actually a
- 46:14really good example of this where like, it was not an
- 46:17investable business at its inception.
- 46:20It wasn't an investable business for its first like 5 or 6 years.
- 46:23Enthropic people thought was an insane thing to even attempt at
- 46:28the time. Cognition started as a video
- 46:31conferencing app. Clay wandered in the desert for
- 46:34like, you know, 10 years. There's so many examples of
- 46:38this. And in retrospect, yeah, we all
- 46:40know what the chart looks like. And eventually the chart starts
- 46:43going crazy and it's was always going to happen and it never
- 46:46could have gone any other way. Like each one of those are
- 46:50really really, I mean ramp ramp was like the stupid ever was
- 46:54like, what the hell are they doing?
- 46:56Don't they know about Brex And like it's what for five times
- 46:59Brex now? So like these things always look
- 47:02in like winners always look inevitable in retrospect.
- 47:05I just don't believe in that as as the reality on the ground and
- 47:10I and I think history largely proves me right.
- 47:14What the problem is with this whole sort of like idea of king
- 47:17making is it's not putting this is going to be a, a, a
- 47:22overwrought metaphor. It's not putting a crown on the
- 47:26crown on the head of the Crown Prince upon the death of his
- 47:28father. It's like putting a crown on a
- 47:31baby out of the womb and believing that that the crown
- 47:34itself confers legitimacy instead of the like the
- 47:39legitimacy conferring the crown. And in each one of those
- 47:41examples that I mentioned, those are businesses that now today
- 47:45like have unlimited access to capital and incredible talent
- 47:48and everyone wants to work there, but you're dealing.
- 47:51Rejecting what people? Somebody was calling it like the
- 47:53coconut seed round, you know, saying coconut round, Yeah.
- 47:56Yeah, Mango. Seed or whatever.
- 47:57Yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah. Is that that's where you're sort
- 48:00of pushing back again this sort of we're going to put up so much
- 48:02capital into? Question of scale, I think there
- 48:04are businesses that require a lot of capital upfront and like
- 48:07that's a ton of risk and the power to you if you have the,
- 48:10you know, if you have the Piggy Bank to pull that off and, and,
- 48:13and you know, the balls to do it, like good for you.
- 48:18I think that's different than saying by mere dint of putting a
- 48:22bunch of money into this company.
- 48:24We just know it will work. Like that's not true.
- 48:28I I don't think there's any evidence in history to suggest
- 48:30that that's true. You guys have had a very
- 48:32creative creator economy strategy.
- 48:35I mean, you Sam has been bullish on this idea of like, we need to
- 48:39invest in a person, not just a business, like get our talents
- 48:42into someone who's promising like now and like, watch them
- 48:45go. Is is this when you ask us for
- 48:46money? No.
- 48:47No, they're too far along the. Think about how much further
- 48:51along you could be with a couple $1,000,000 for the newcomer.
- 48:55Yeah. How's that strategy going of
- 48:56investing in individuals? So basically we have in addition
- 49:00to our seed fund and our opportunity fund, we have a
- 49:03third vehicle which is our creator fund, which is a $65
- 49:06million fund. And basically what it does is
- 49:09rather than investing in like consumer media brands or the
- 49:14companies started by creators, we're trying to make these like
- 49:17sort of, you know, 360 deals with creators to just capitalize
- 49:23them for everything that they do.
- 49:24And we own our piece. So that's run by my partner
- 49:29Megan and Sam. Megan, like cap is awesome.
- 49:33She came in to slow at the same time I did to kind of figure out
- 49:37this and like really make it a thing and and it's going really
- 49:40well. The idea is basically that like
- 49:42in a world where, and I would put this under, by the way, like
- 49:45second order effects of AI, in a world in which like all of these
- 49:48kind of performance channels are getting really like clogged up
- 49:54owned access and distribution is like a hugely valuable asset.
- 49:58And so rather than saying, hey, like we want to be media
- 50:01investors, we want to invest in media brands that can go and
- 50:03build really big businesses on top of them.
- 50:06And so there's a lot of like obvious places for this.
- 50:10You know, I think like Glossier honestly is a good example of
- 50:12this. It was started out of Into the
- 50:14Gloss, which was a blog that Emily Weiss started and then
- 50:18like built this really big commerce company on the back of
- 50:20it. So like all of those kinds of
- 50:22consumer opportunities I think are fairly obvious.
- 50:24We backed this guy Jonathan Katz Moses, who's like a woodworking
- 50:27creator on YouTube who's built this really successful like
- 50:31tools business. I think that these opportunities
- 50:34are also to. Bring in the entrepreneur or
- 50:36there's somebody beside them to run the business.
- 50:38Or are they? It it it depends.
- 50:40I mean, in our view, he's the entrepreneur.
- 50:43Like does he like, does he need someone to help him, like to
- 50:48help support him on, you know, maybe it's a president or
- 50:51something to help support him on the operations of the business?
- 50:53Totally. We can maybe help him with that,
- 50:56but it's it's largely on him as ever, Like we're we're money,
- 51:01you know, like we're, we're mine.
- 51:03We're willing to make bets that other people aren't willing to
- 51:04make. It's.
- 51:05Like you run your business? Good luck.
- 51:07Yeah, yeah. It's like, let's find incredible
- 51:10entrepreneurs and it just, we think we've found a whole new
- 51:13category of entrepreneurs that like the market doesn't yet
- 51:16really have a good way of backing.
- 51:18But are we a peak creator yet or where do you think we are in
- 51:21this sort of Arc of? Now, I mean, I think it, it
- 51:24feels very evident to me that that's just what the future of,
- 51:29I don't know, all media is like. I mean, we're seeing more and
- 51:32more companies adopt like mature large companies adopt strategies
- 51:38that look like that because they're finding that their
- 51:40performance channels just like don't work and they need some
- 51:43way to reach people and to talk to people.
- 51:45So this is very clearly like we've looked at any number of BB
- 51:49to B companies doing like some version of this and we're going
- 51:53to look at a lot more over time. I'm really bullish on the idea,
- 51:57healthcare companies, I'm really bullish on the idea that we're
- 52:00going to find these kinds of like creator LED opportunities
- 52:04horizontally, not merely within like, you know, consumer
- 52:09discretionary categories. Yeah, running a newsletter can
- 52:11definitely feel like running a marketing channel without a
- 52:14product. I mean, thankfully our events
- 52:17business has delivered on like that's something that people
- 52:22just don't love paying for content.
- 52:23I know you know, obviously Sam is married to Jessica Lesson,
- 52:27who I work for and really believes in subscription.
- 52:30Even she has expanded the business beyond just
- 52:33subscription. Yeah.
- 52:34But I just think as much as you know, I love our subscribers and
- 52:38think it's a cornerstone of newcomers business.
- 52:40And yet you never say thank you to me.
- 52:44Yeah, I I'd be willing. I'd.
- 52:45I'd be curious to go back. Like where do I, you know, where
- 52:48am I? What number subscriber?
- 52:49I bet you early I. Couldn't be I must be a a triple
- 52:53digit subscriber. I might even be a double digit.
- 52:54Subscriber I can try to check. Paid, I bet.
- 52:58I mean, I just think people don't like paying for media.
- 53:01You know, they, they, they have this feeling that quality
- 53:03content will just get to them. Yeah.
- 53:06And so, yeah, I I think this idea that you use media as the
- 53:11ways to build a relationship with people and then sell them
- 53:14something they're more inclined to pay for, it makes a lot of
- 53:17sense. I mean, I think I should get the
- 53:18chocolate bar business. That's, I think I think it's an
- 53:22interesting exercise that genuinely like sometime when
- 53:26Megan's in New York or you're in the Bay, I think you guys should
- 53:29get up on the whiteboard together and be like, I'm, I'm
- 53:31100% serious. I think you guys should get up
- 53:33on the whiteboard together and like, what are the kinds of
- 53:36products and opportunities? Like, you know, I think what
- 53:38you've done in in conferences, for example, is like fairly
- 53:42directly extensible off of the media off of like it's still is.
- 53:45Part of them. It's still part of within the
- 53:47category I didn't invent. The idea that you pair a
- 53:50newsletter with media with events I.
- 53:53I would bet that if we sat here for 5 minutes, we could come up
- 53:56with like a list of 25 things and some of them would probably
- 54:00require capital for you to do, you know, like it's crazy to me
- 54:03that you don't have a head hunting business.
- 54:05It's. Oh yeah, they're, they're a,
- 54:07their business is similar to mine where they they do.
- 54:09That it's, it's you could make, you could make so much money if
- 54:14you hired a, if you hired A recruiter to work within the
- 54:19newcomer brand. And like that's not hugely
- 54:23capital intensive because that's like, that's like paying a
- 54:25salary and they're probably largely Commission based.
- 54:27So you don't really need it upfront.
- 54:29But if you then told me, like, you know, there's this product I
- 54:32really like Aaron Harris used to be a partner at Y Combinator.
- 54:36He now you've probably interviewed him or met him or
- 54:38something. Yeah, I talked to him.
- 54:40You know, he now has this product called like the Venture
- 54:41Codex, which I use. It's like a really cool like,
- 54:44hey, like who should my company raise from?
- 54:46It's sort of in the overall category, like a pitch book or
- 54:48something, but like. But he doesn't monetize that.
- 54:52He monetizes like an investment for fundraisers.
- 54:55Correct, Correct. But my point is like if you told
- 54:58me that you were going to build some, if you told me like you're
- 55:01going to build a product like that, that's a really
- 55:03interesting product that you have good distribution.
- 55:06For, I've thought about building a data product, but then it's
- 55:08not my expertise. Honestly, my biggest challenge
- 55:12for a lot of these ideas is just like getting a coder excited
- 55:15about. I'm looking for a coder, you
- 55:18know? It's always finding the.
- 55:20Right, haven't you heard? We're all coders now.
- 55:22I know I've tried. I have vibe codes, you know, I,
- 55:25I just feel like. The challenge is in shipping
- 55:27something and it's it's getting it from 70% to 90% and then
- 55:31maintaining it that's. And then my time is not well
- 55:33spent there, you know, it's like I have a lot, a long list.
- 55:36Of things. And so by the way, that would be
- 55:38on the list of things where it's like, well, my time as as like a
- 55:42creator CEO, my time is too constrained.
- 55:45I just like, I don't really have the budget for this.
- 55:47It's kind of like highly exploratory and it's risky.
- 55:50There's maybe a lot of upside to it, but it's hard for me to
- 55:53underwrite with like, you know, a relatively fixed pool Today, I
- 55:57could just basically pay the person out of my own pocket.
- 55:59Like that's the case where we come in with the creator fund
- 56:02and say, like, Hey, show us those 10 experiments that you
- 56:04want to run and we'll give you the money to run all of them.
- 56:06And as and like something will work as long as we're like
- 56:09disciplined about choosing the, you know, choosing and
- 56:11prioritizing those experiments. And we find people who are
- 56:15entrepreneurial and ambitious and, and aspirational enough to
- 56:18actually like do them and have the execution ability to pursue
- 56:22them doggedly. Like that's the business.
- 56:24And have you stuck to this idea that your investment really
- 56:27needs to be in the person rather than the company?
- 56:30Or you're just worried people will run away from the company
- 56:32and or why? It's it's because the whole sort
- 56:37of thesis undergirding it is that the is that the
- 56:40distribution is what differentiates it.
- 56:42And you know, like we want to bet on a person to run all of
- 56:47those experiments. I mean, Mr. Beast is, is a good
- 56:49example of like where this kind of doesn't work, where like
- 56:51beast burgers didn't work. Beast burgers.
- 56:54Like if you would have invested in Beast burgers, you would have
- 56:56lost all your money, even though you totally made the right I,
- 57:00you know, like this, by the way, goes back to like weird take on
- 57:03important story. You're like, hey, I think this
- 57:04influencer is like a huge amount of reach is going to like build
- 57:08this really awesome thing. You'd be completely right on a
- 57:10directional basis and completely wrong about the vector of
- 57:12approach like. He doesn't keep them all within
- 57:15the same He might not. He's the risk, I guess.
- 57:18He now does. There's there's Beastco.
- 57:21I'm running like Jeffrey Hausenbold from SoftBank to be a
- 57:24top executive. If if you say so.
- 57:29I. I would, I would believe it.
- 57:31I mean, look, we have our issues with with Mr. Beast
- 57:34specifically, like we're more focused on kind of like you
- 57:36have. Your issues or?
- 57:37Yeah, I mean, it's like it the the the challenge that we see
- 57:41with Mr. Beast is like how much does he have actually like sort
- 57:44of proprietary owned audience and how much is what he's doing
- 57:47basically like kind of running on a treadmill to like hack an
- 57:50algorithm repeatedly? And like if he stopped doing
- 57:53that, how quickly would? It's media, you know your only
- 57:55because your last story you have to.
- 57:57Yeah, consistently. So.
- 57:59So you know you don't. Feel that way about your
- 58:01woodworker that he still needs to have great woodworking
- 58:04content. He definitely needs good work
- 58:06woodworking content, but we know why people, it's not like for
- 58:09instance, stunt based, it's not celebrity.
- 58:12So the answer is is not like you always need to one up the last
- 58:16thing that you did. That's like a really hard place
- 58:18to get into and like probably burns out over time.
- 58:20Like I don't think you grow up with people that way.
- 58:23And then that means you have like a shorter shelf life.
- 58:26All right, you any last question, who who is hustling
- 58:29right now? Like when you look out, like
- 58:31when you think of who's your short list of like startup
- 58:34founders that you think they are hungry, they want to win right
- 58:38now. Start the of startup.
- 58:40Founders. Yeah, startup founders or other
- 58:41people in venture, but startup founders.
- 58:42Yeah. I mean, look, the startup
- 58:43founders are all of my companies that haven't yet.
- 58:46Haven't yet. Announced rounds, yeah,
- 58:49obviously it's those are the people.
- 58:50That does it feel like it feels like a quieter time for me or I
- 58:53don't know if it's like the foundation models, like looming
- 58:56so large. It just doesn't feel like the
- 58:59new doesn't feel genuinely to me genuinely.
- 59:02And if you spend time with, I think, and this is a challenge
- 59:07for you, I think of being in a media business where you spend
- 59:10time with people who are on one side of the hill.
- 59:13Right, like the people. People wanna read about names
- 59:16that. They've heard for sure, and as a
- 59:18result, they think. They wanna read about people
- 59:19they haven't heard of. And the reality is if you spend
- 59:23time at the earliest stages when companies don't exist yet, when
- 59:28it's just people, when they're in the early phases of building,
- 59:31when they've launched their, the energy right now is
- 59:34unbelievable. Like for all the posturing about
- 59:38like 996 and blah, blah, blah, the real people doing the real
- 59:41work, they just fucking show up and do it.
- 59:43And they're not going to like talk about how hard they're
- 59:46working because they're too busy working the like level of energy
- 59:49and excitement. I mean, we have this company
- 59:51that just announced AC ground in New York a couple weeks ago
- 59:54called Phoebe, which is like a, a basically building like a
- 59:57network of agents for healthcare labor.
- 1:00:01And the, the CEO Justin is like unbelievable.
- 1:00:05And his team is just like the, the energy in the office is
- 1:00:09insane. They're like.
- 1:00:12They're like very technical, very focused, very heads down,
- 1:00:16and they're just like winning every.
- 1:00:17Day they're like, these are the last five years to make wealth
- 1:00:20before they're painted. Underclass yeah.
- 1:00:22Like I think if you honestly, I I would just really encourage
- 1:00:25you to try and spend time around some of the like less polished
- 1:00:29more just like in the thick of it.
- 1:00:32Basically, when people go from being you often meet people when
- 1:00:37they've gone from being founders to being CEOs.
- 1:00:40And I think if you spend more time around people who are just
- 1:00:42founders, you will completely reverse course on this idea that
- 1:00:47like there things are quieter, people aren't hustling or
- 1:00:49there's no energy. Like the amount of energy within
- 1:00:52our early stage portfolio is unbelievable.
- 1:00:55When I'm around New York and the founders that I meet who are
- 1:00:57like, I mean, it's like they're like killing themselves with
- 1:01:01happiness, you know, because they're so excited about what
- 1:01:04they're working on. It's like it's a very, very
- 1:01:06exciting time that feels really different than when I started my
- 1:01:10career and people had a level of like maybe caution of an
- 1:01:16entrepreneurship. And I can't even imagine what
- 1:01:19that felt like compared to 10 years before that.
- 1:01:20But like, no, I, I kind of reject the premise of the
- 1:01:23question. I think there's a lot of people
- 1:01:24in Venture who are lazy for sure, but like.
- 1:01:27Right, Yoda, thank you for staying in principle.
- 1:01:30Thanks for talking politics, playing pundit next time, I
- 1:01:32guess. Courtside, yeah.
- 1:01:33Next time courtside. All right, man.
- 1:01:35Thanks. Thanks so much for listening to
- 1:01:38the Newcomer Podcast. I'm Eric Newcomer.
- 1:01:40Follow us on substack@newcomer.co.
- 1:01:43Hope you enjoyed the episode. See you next week.