Latest / No Way Out / Transformative Leadership in Challenging Times with the Honorable Thomas Modly
Transcript
- 0:21Mark McGrath: So, ponch, even though we're not academy grads, we certainly are Navy football fans and you never know who you're going to run into at a Navy football game.
- 0:28Mark McGrath: And I had the honor of being introduced, from one of my mentors and close friends to one of his mentors and close friends that was two years ahead of him at the academy and that's the Honorable Tom Mobley that's joining us and he's got a phenomenal book, as you and I have both read through it, called Vectors, which we highly recommend, and it's an interesting look into a culture that you and I are very familiar with, from a perspective that we're not necessarily familiar with, because this perspective comes right from the top and we want to talk about that and culture and learn from Tom and tell everybody to get this book, because the concepts and the ideas that Tom talks about in the book are so pertinent to any industry, any domain, and there's a lot of great stuff to take out of it.
- 1:16Mark McGrath: Anything you want to add, ponch, as we jump in here, I do want to add something.
- 1:20Ponch Rivera: The timeline for which this book was written, for the most part during this period, lines up well with how we created the flow system.
- 1:28Ponch Rivera: So the CR, the SRR which we may talk about, the USS McCain, uss Fitzgerald, the work that I was doing at the Safety Center, the work we were trying to do on culture, building high-performing teams, all that became what is now known today as the flow system evolution of lean and agile thinking in the age of complexity.
- 1:46Ponch Rivera: You'll see that a lot of things that are written in Tom's book are about complex adaptive systems and that type of thinking.
- 1:52Ponch Rivera: Very fired up to be here.
- 1:54Ponch Rivera: Thanks for being here, tom.
- 1:55Ponch Rivera: Can I call you Tom, by the way?
- 1:56Ponch Rivera: Sure.
- 1:59Mark McGrath: Well, Tom, why don't you start us off by just how did you get to that position in the first place?
- 2:05Thomas Modly: Oh, that's it.
- 2:08Mark McGrath: You're in the Pentagon one day, you're a midshipman at the Academy one day and you're at the Pentagon the next day and you have an amazing career.
- 2:15Mark McGrath: Tell us your story a little bit so we can give the listeners some context.
- 2:21Thomas Modly: Well, first of all, thanks, thanks, guys, for having me on.
- 2:23Thomas Modly: I really enjoy the opportunities to talk about the book and some of the things that I learned, uh, during my time there at the at the Pentagon this recent time.
- 2:30Thomas Modly: But, um, it really wasn't something that like one day I was in one place and the next day I was in the Pentagon.
- 2:37Thomas Modly: So you know, there's about 30 years in between, uh, between that.
- 2:41Thomas Modly: But, um, it's an interesting story because I had sort of had a career that went in between government and private sector.
- 2:50Thomas Modly: I was on active duty in the Navy for seven years and had the advantage of, back in the day, when I was at the Naval Academy, they offered the opportunity for guys and gals who had finished their undergraduate work early to pursue a graduate degree.
- 3:06Thomas Modly: So it's now formally called VJEP, the Volunteer Graduate Education Program.
- 3:11Thomas Modly: But when I was there it was sort of an experimental thing and there were seven of us six or seven of us who finished our undergrad work early, and so they allowed us to drive into DC and take graduate courses and get work on master's degree.
- 3:24Thomas Modly: So there's a reason for me explaining this, because I finished up my my master's right before I started flight school just after graduation from the Naval Academy, in in in politics American politics, international relations, and and so because of that I had the subspecialty coding in Palm Hill affairs that when I rolled out of my first C-Tour it made me eligible for certain P-coded billets.
- 3:52Thomas Modly: One that was open was at the Air Force Academy to teach in their poli-sci department.
- 3:57Thomas Modly: There I was drafted into that job and went out there, sort of drafted into that job, and went out there and left because of that tour, which was really a fantastic tour, because you can't really underestimate the value of standing in front of people five times a day and speaking to them about things and learning as you go, and learning how to talk to people and interact with them and question them and, you know, develop your Socratic methods for teaching.
- 4:25Thomas Modly: But despite that, with respect to my career in the Navy, it put a big limiter on it and I was being told I'd have to transition to a new aircraft which was going to be a one and a half year process, because the helicopter that I flew was being phased out of the Navy.
- 4:40Thomas Modly: You know I did have the opportunity to go to fixed wing, which I flirted with a little bit, but I just didn't really want to take that amount of time and it's interesting when you're young how you think about a year and a half and it seems like such a long time and it really isn't.
- 4:54Thomas Modly: But in that frame of mind it was for me.
- 4:56Thomas Modly: And then they told me I'd be looking at back-to-back-to-back sea tours to get competitive again and I just decided that that's not something that I wanted.
- 5:06Thomas Modly: I really wanted to do and so I decided to get out and go to business school and I got an MBA, which is where I met probably someone we'll talk about later in the podcast, a guy named Don Saul who ended up becoming a professor at MIT.
- 5:18Thomas Modly: Talks a lot about agility and I did corporate strategy in M&A for about 10 years in the DC area.
- 5:25Thomas Modly: Mostly started out in aerospace and defense um, aviation type businesses then moved into high tech and, uh, after nine, 11, um.
- 5:34Thomas Modly: The secretary of defense at the time, secretary Rumsfeld, has put together this thing called the defense business board where he had invited 20 or so senior executive CEOs from around the country to come in and advise him on business transformation in the Pentagon and this was sort of the first big attempt at trying to.
- 5:52Thomas Modly: You know, rumsfeld came out of government, went to business, came back into the Pentagon and said, oh my God, this place is just, you know, arcane with respect to its business processes and its supply chain and financial management.
- 6:04Thomas Modly: You know, we hadn't had an audit.
- 6:06Thomas Modly: We still haven't had an audit.
- 6:07Thomas Modly: We can talk about that too, a successful one anyway.
- 6:10Thomas Modly: And so he wanted to get some advice from private sector CEOs.
- 6:15Thomas Modly: So they didn't have anyone to run that board and they didn't want to have a career civil servant do it.
- 6:19Thomas Modly: They didn't want to have a military person do it.
- 6:21Thomas Modly: So you know, my resume showed up through a connection that I had and I was sort of the nice mix of all those different things, you know academic experience and government, as well as teaching it, as well as active duty, military plus time in business.
- 6:34Thomas Modly: So I was a nice fit for that position and I was there for about a year and a half and then President Bush got reelected and I was asked to step up and become the Deputy Undersecretary of Defense for Financial Management.
- 6:47Thomas Modly: And then I inherited the entire business transformation portfolio between me and a guy in AT&L and we came together and created a new defense agency called the Business Transformation Agency to try and drive that change and it's interesting, we can talk about this a little bit thing.
- 7:04Thomas Modly: We can talk about this a little bit.
- 7:05Thomas Modly: I actually have an op-ed that's coming out in american thinker tomorrow about this thing called doge, which is the concept that elon musk and vivek ramoswamy are trying to create, this department of government efficiency, and I'm advising them not to do that, but but uh, anyway, you can read about that tomorrow, um, or we can talk about a little bit today, but at any rate, um, I left after about five years and then went to thrice waterhouse coopers where I was working.
- 7:28Thomas Modly: I was their um, I was their senior defense uh network leader for the firm, and so I got to work with our defense businesses all around the world as they dealt with smaller defense agencies and it was really.
- 7:40Thomas Modly: That was very enlightening too, because, um, coming from the U S defense department, which is the largest, most complex, you know, industrial organization in the world in my opinion, and then going to these smaller countries with their smaller defenses, I was seeing they were doing a lot of innovative things that we weren't doing um here in the U S because, you know, we were fat with budget and and uh and, uh, there was a war going on and so, um it, it tended to stifle a little bit of innovation on our side.
- 8:09Thomas Modly: So, um, I did that and um, I actually wasn't really seeking an opportunity to serve in the Trump administration was during the election and how everyone was sort of predicting this is going to be this, you know, very horrible four years and so on.
- 8:29Thomas Modly: And I there was a guy that I knew who became the head of the defense transition team in the Pentagon.
- 8:37Thomas Modly: I'd worked with him before when I was there previously, and they were having a really hard time finding qualified people because at that time in the 2016 campaign, there were a lot of very senior and experienced national security people who signed this never Trump letter actually multiple never Trump letters.
- 8:54Thomas Modly: Well, once you got your name on one of those letters, there was no way you were going to get into the Trump administration and, frankly, a lot of those people were the ones that would have been most aggressive to try and get jobs, but they were basically locked out.
- 9:05Thomas Modly: So they were looking for people and I basically and I was pretty candid I said, look, I think I understand a couple of these jobs pretty well and I think I could do them pretty well and I could get the ground running.
- 9:16Thomas Modly: And one of them was Secretary of the Navy or Undersecretary of the Navy, and they'd already selected Richard Spencer for the second half position.
- 9:24Thomas Modly: And they said well, the under is open, are you interested in interviewing with Secretary Mattis for it?
- 9:30Thomas Modly: And I said sure.
- 9:31Thomas Modly: So I went, drove to the Pentagon and this is a very long answer to your question but I went and drove to the Pentagon.
- 9:37Thomas Modly: I was sitting in the Pentagon parking lot and about to go in for my interview and I got this text from a friend of mine saying that another good friend of ours from the academy, an F-18 guy, had just died of some kind of a bacterial or some kind of infection.
- 9:53Thomas Modly: This guy was like one of the healthiest guys I knew once in life.
- 10:00Thomas Modly: And so if I'm offered it, despite all you know the disruptions that it could cause in your life, which is, you know, you know, walking away from a really decent salary and having to rent an extra apartment in DC out of your own pocket, and the long hours and everything else um, it was worth.
- 10:19Thomas Modly: It would be worth it.
- 10:20Thomas Modly: Um, if the country cause, I felt I could do something, you know, if I didn't feel like I could do something, if I didn't feel like I was well equipped or I didn't have some ideas, I wouldn't have done it.
- 10:29Thomas Modly: But so I walked into the interview with secretary Madison.
- 10:31Thomas Modly: I realized that, you know, if they were going to offer the job to me, I was going to accept.
- 10:35Thomas Modly: And, um, it wasn't even an interview.
- 10:38Thomas Modly: He just said when can you start?
- 10:39Thomas Modly: And uh.
- 10:41Thomas Modly: So then it took about six months to get through Senate confirmation, not because I was controversial or anything, it's just that's the process.
- 10:49Thomas Modly: I mean, talk about something that needs a major reform.
- 10:53Thomas Modly: The entire process for getting a nominee through Senate confirmation is just ridiculous, and it basically burns through 25 of an administration, and if you take the back half of the administration off, which is basically a campaign, you really have like two and a half years to try and do anything, and you know, and that's just not acceptable.
- 11:13Thomas Modly: But that is what we, that's what our system has produced.
- 11:16Thomas Modly: Um, so, anyway, I got, I made it through confirmation in november of 2017, and then I was on the job the next week and I went as the under.
- 11:28Thomas Modly: The under is the chief management officer for the department of the Navy, and so I took it very seriously.
- 11:34Thomas Modly: I took over control of the CIO function.
- 11:37Thomas Modly: I said it was going to be mine because I recognized how important that was to the business mission particularly.
- 11:44Thomas Modly: And then I also decided I would chair the audit committee, the financial audit committee, because these functions needed to be elevated so that the organization recognized that it was important to senior leadership and they really hadn't been before.
- 12:02Thomas Modly: And then there was a whole series of other things I did with education and so on that we can talk about in greater detail, so that's how I ended up there.
- 12:09Ponch Rivera: Now I'm familiar with your E4S and a lot of work you've done.
- 12:11Ponch Rivera: I want to hit the juicy stuff first and that is Doge.
- 12:14Ponch Rivera: Um, I want to know uh, you've had plenty of experience trying to create agility, adaptability, innovation inside of the uh department of the Navy.
- 12:22Ponch Rivera: Uh, the Navy and the DOD.
- 12:25Ponch Rivera: You brought in business thinkers.
- 12:26Ponch Rivera: You saw that early with Donald Rumsfeld.
- 12:28Ponch Rivera: In fact, one of the things you brought up in your book was known, knowns and unknown unknowns.
- 12:32Ponch Rivera: We know that was borrowed from Dave Snowden into Admiral Poindexter.
- 12:39Ponch Rivera: That got that into Secretary of Defense Rumsfeld's head, and that was early on in my career as well.
- 12:42Ponch Rivera: So you have a fantastic outsider view on how to change or not to change the government.
- 12:51Ponch Rivera: So can you explain why, or explain your position on Doge?
- 12:54Ponch Rivera: I'm curious about that.
- 12:57Thomas Modly: Well, the title of my article is Elon and Vivek Don't Doze, just do.
- 13:04Thomas Modly: And the the idea of creating a new federal agency to cut waste and efficiency out of the federal government to me is an oxymoron and they shouldn't do it.
- 13:14Thomas Modly: And I think that both of these guys realized that the most effective way to go after these types of things is you got to go after it quickly and you got to have a very small, dedicated team of really smart people who are motivated.
- 13:29Thomas Modly: Um that you can, that you can provide the intellectual guidance to um once it starts getting disseminated.
- 13:36Thomas Modly: And I use an example in there and I know it's a bit of a hyperbolic example, but I open up the.
- 13:41Thomas Modly: I opened it up talking about in 2006, I was in Baghdad at the embassy in the Green Zone, because the agency that I had created in the Department of Defense with Paul Brinkley had taken on a task of trying to help with some of the business processes in Baghdad, contracting things like that that were really really not very efficient, like that that were really really not very efficient.
- 14:05Thomas Modly: And so I was in the embassy green zone and basically this is an old Saddam Hussein palace right in the center of Baghdad.
- 14:14Thomas Modly: And in 2006, the war was going very, very poorly for us.
- 14:17Thomas Modly: There were a lot of service people getting killed every day from IEDs.
- 14:23Thomas Modly: The insurgency was really raging at the time.
- 14:24Thomas Modly: There were civilian aid workers getting killed and kidnapped and beheaded and it was a really, really rough time.
- 14:31Thomas Modly: And I remember walking through the embassy building there which is the old Saddam building, you know big, wide corridors, very, very ornate and walking down the hall and there was a picture, a photograph of somebody you know, official State Department photograph of somebody and I don't remember this person's name and I don't mean to impugn his integrity or anybody's, but it was just symbolic to me.
- 14:51Thomas Modly: The picture was posted on the wall and it said welcome to US Embassy Baghdad, iraq, our new State Department diversity officer.
- 15:00Thomas Modly: And the incongruence between that and what was going on outside the green zone to me was very depressing and enlightening at the same time, because I realized that we may not win this war but we're going to be really successful at planting our bureaucracy right in the center of Baghdad bureaucracy right in the center of Baghdad.
- 15:29Thomas Modly: It just didn't seem right that at that particular time, all these things that were required of a department or a consulate were being put in place that had nothing to do with winning, and so to me it was just an example, and I know it's a bit hyperbolic, but to me the idea of creating a government agency or a new defense department or a new government department, federal department, to create more effective government, to me is just not right.
- 15:56Thomas Modly: This has got to be a very small team and what I say in the article is like, look, it's going to take.
- 16:00Thomas Modly: You know everyone's like, oh, we need somebody to go scrub the numbers.
- 16:03Thomas Modly: I'm like you know it'll take you guys about 24 hours, including coffee breaks, to like figure out where the waste is.
- 16:09Thomas Modly: That is not the hard part.
- 16:11Thomas Modly: The hard part is figuring out how to get it out of there, and that's where I don't know if, um, if, uh, boyd talks about rocks, about you know, but really like the goal of a CEO, the real objective of a CEO, other than setting a vision, in my opinion is getting those big rocks out of the way so that people that work for you are empowered to get stuff done and they don't focus their effort on getting those rocks out of the way.
- 16:40Thomas Modly: This is not going to happen.
- 16:42Thomas Modly: This is not going to happen.
- 16:43Thomas Modly: This is not going to work, because this is not a, this is not a two-year process.
- 16:47Thomas Modly: This is a 10-year evolution to transform something as big as this.
- 16:52Thomas Modly: So if you're going to embark on it, you better be really, really clear about what those rocks are and how you're going to get them out of there.
- 16:59Thomas Modly: That's where you should be spending almost 90 percent of your effort.
- 17:02Thomas Modly: If you're elon musk and vivek ramaswamy, that's what they should be doing.
- 17:06Thomas Modly: And so I talk about in the article.
- 17:08Thomas Modly: I talk about what I think the five biggest rocks are, and they're humongous and they're going to be really, really difficult to overcome.
- 17:19Thomas Modly: So, anyway, that's my opinion on that.
- 17:21Thomas Modly: But, like I say in my book often, and I say it often in other circumstances I don't know if you guys have seen the big lebowski, but there's a great scene in the big lebowski where, uh where, jeff lebowski's in the bowling alley and some guys you know the guy next to him, jesus cantana, who was this very outgoing bowler and he's like screaming and cursing at him about how he's gonna they're gonna wipe them out in their next match.
- 17:45Thomas Modly: Lebowski looks at him and says Well, you know, that's just like your opinion, man.
- 17:50Thomas Modly: So this article, it's just like my opinion.
- 17:53Thomas Modly: It is my opinion, but I've got some scars, having tried to do this before.
- 17:59Thomas Modly: I want this effort to be really successful, so I just hope that they can focus on the right things.
- 18:06Mark McGrath: Well, kudos for quoting, I think, the greatest movie of all time.
- 18:11Thomas Modly: One of them, for sure, yeah.
- 18:14Mark McGrath: I mean, there's so many valuable life lessons in that book.
- 18:17Mark McGrath: Oddly enough, the small sidebar but the congruence of that movie to the theories of John Boyd, specifically with some of the Eastern influence.
- 18:25Mark McGrath: There's a lot of.
- 18:26Mark McGrath: We just have our next episode with you, tom.
- 18:29Thomas Modly: There you go.
- 18:30Mark McGrath: So not long after the Trump administration kicks off and we're moving through 2017, there was a first of.
- 18:38Mark McGrath: It seemed like a series of collisions in the Pacific.
- 18:40Mark McGrath: Like a series of collisions in the Pacific and, from the outsider looking in, that knows enough about the Department of the Navy and what goes on to be dangerous and command and leadership and things like that you started to wonder about what were the reasons, what were the cultural reasons?
- 18:59Mark McGrath: What is the warfighting culture like that?
- 19:02Mark McGrath: We're not building resourceful leaders and people are looking to pass the buck, or are we too over reliance on technology?
- 19:10Mark McGrath: And those sorts of questions emerge when those ships hit.
- 19:14Mark McGrath: But from your vantage point, what was it that you were seeing and the things that you thought about when the Fitzgerald and McCain and others were occurring?
- 19:23Thomas Modly: So those happened within weeks of each other in the summer, while I was waiting for confirmation so I wasn't in the seat yet this sort of landed on Richard Spencer's lap and unfortunately for him he didn't have a full team yet I wasn't there.
- 19:36Thomas Modly: I'm not sure if Fonda Gertz was there yet.
- 19:38Thomas Modly: No, he wasn't, because he got confirmed with me.
- 19:41Thomas Modly: He got confirmed with me, so he didn't have a full team really to sort of help him set a vision, and that stuff hit almost immediately.
- 19:51Thomas Modly: So I think obviously in most of these instances there aren't just one reason why it happened, but there clearly were some cultural issues, I think out there in pack fleet, with the way that decisions were being made and the pace at which people were being required to operate and the lack of an ability to say, you know, to basically call a um, taking on the toughest missions and doing it and sucking it up and going and going and going forward, um.
- 20:30Thomas Modly: But there comes a point where I think that the pace of operations out there became so um, intense, um and so relentless that there was a lot of fatigue involved.
- 20:41Thomas Modly: There was a lot of um also complacency.
- 20:44Thomas Modly: Complacency is one of the villains that I cite in my book.
- 20:48Thomas Modly: Sorry, that's not a person's name, but it's a villain that I cite in my book.
- 20:53Thomas Modly: I think there was a bit of that.
- 20:54Thomas Modly: I think that it's interesting.
- 20:58Thomas Modly: I remember sitting up in Newport and watching.
- 21:01Thomas Modly: You guys may have had the opportunity to do this too, um Ponch, you may have had an opportunity to do this, but we were you were they actually, they re simulated being on the bridge of the Fitzgerald and you could basically watch everything that they were watching at the time.
- 21:16Thomas Modly: And you know, this is like a 45 minute or so evolution, uh, of of the things that happened.
- 21:22Thomas Modly: And I remember and they pointed this out to me that about 45 minutes before the collision, another container ship goes right by the starboard side of the Fitzgerald and no one on the bridge said anything, like there was just like there was no communication.
- 21:41Thomas Modly: No one said anything, the captain wasn't called nothing.
- 21:44Thomas Modly: So I don't know.
- 21:45Thomas Modly: I mean, it's just one of those strange, you know, one of the strange things, but it was an accumulation and clearly there were a lot of different things that were identified that could be corrected, because I believe both of those reports that came out in response to that had well over 110 recommendations.
- 22:01Thomas Modly: Obviously there was overlap between the two but a lot of things that could be done and be fixed and be done differently.
- 22:08Thomas Modly: But there is also, I think and I think this speaks to sort of the some of the stuff that happened at the um, at the at the end of my tenure in my book that I described the, the, the attitude of command and in the military, in the navy, particularly this idea that the captain is the captain of the ship and this and he's out there and he's out there alone and he or she and that's their job and and um, they're ultimately responsible for everything.
- 22:36Thomas Modly: Uh, so there's there's good and bad to that Um.
- 22:39Thomas Modly: I think that served the Navy particularly well in an era when we didn't have instantaneous communications and you sort of had to trust these folks to go out and do the job.
- 22:47Thomas Modly: But that's not the world we live in anymore, and so I think that needs to be rethought quite a bit, me having been in the navy during the cold war for a very short amount of time, leaving and coming back 30 years later, and most of the people that uh were my contemporaries and peers of the naval academy were out now.
- 23:12Thomas Modly: Three and four star admirals in the navy.
- 23:14Thomas Modly: These were all class of 80 to 85 87 type people.
- 23:18Thomas Modly: Um, they grew up in it and there were certain things that I I learned in my time in private sector that it didn't seem that they learned um within the culture of, within the culture of the Navy.
- 24:30Thomas Modly: So, um, I, I I found that, uh, there there weren't.
- 24:35Thomas Modly: I didn't find any nefarious intentions um from any of the people that I had disagreements with or problems with.
- 24:41Thomas Modly: I just didn't think about things the way I did, and so I think that ended up causing some of the issues, particularly at the end.
- 24:52Ponch Rivera: So on the SRR and the CR I can't remember which one it was, but that's how I came back onto active duty was to work on the culture team and kind of like what you did previously, which is bringing that outside perspective back into the military.
- 25:04Ponch Rivera: What we did is we were able to engage with just about any CEO, any academic that we wanted to, and we identified some amazing recommendations, recommendations from things like I hate to say this, but Scrum Not that I'm a proponent of using Scrum everywhere, but understanding that that's borrowed from John Boyd's observable intersite act loop in the Toyota production system.
- 25:25Ponch Rivera: We talked to Toyota executives we looked at I didn't reach out to Don Soule, but we did talk to Steve Spear.
- 25:32Ponch Rivera: I think you're familiar with his work and his work on the USS Ford a little bit later on, and he and I did some work together on naval safety a few years after that.
- 25:40Ponch Rivera: My point behind this is to change the system.
- 25:43Ponch Rivera: You had to go outside to bring the stuff in and here's the key thing that I discovered the very tools and techniques and methods that are working so well in business are actually borrowed from the military, and this includes things like the Kenevan framework which emerged from DARPA.
- 26:00Ponch Rivera: It includes things like red teaming, which comes from UFMCS.
- 26:04Ponch Rivera: We had that school and I believe it's shut down now.
- 26:08Ponch Rivera: If you look at tactical decision making under stress, going back to the USS Vincennes shoot down I believe that was 90, I can't remember the year on that they had task saturation, new technology, a lot of information coming at them and one of the things that they discovered is people need to learn how to work together in teams with technology that didn't survive in the SWO community.
- 26:30Ponch Rivera: That moved on to aviation crew resource management, which you may have been a part of, and I think that started in the early 90s.
- 26:36Ponch Rivera: I believe it did.
- 26:36Ponch Rivera: Yeah, that's when we finally made it.
- 27:04Ponch Rivera: No-transcript phrase psychological safety in here.
- 27:12Ponch Rivera: It just won't work and I'm like well, that's what it's actually called and it came from aviation resource management taught to surgical teams, and Amy Edmondson picked up on this and again, she's not the one that discovered this, but really brought it to the forefront.
- 27:26Ponch Rivera: So what's and I guess my point is, if we're talking about do and doge, there are very good lessons inside the military that can be adopted right now to find efficiency, effectiveness, agility, resilience, safety.
- 27:39Ponch Rivera: In fact, I'll argue that the best lessons in the Navy the US Navy are borrowed from the safety center.
- 27:45Ponch Rivera: If you take those lessons right now and you apply them to innovation, you're absolutely going to destroy everybody.
- 27:51Ponch Rivera: And again, this is my view of the world.
- 27:54Ponch Rivera: This is how we got the flow system.
- 27:55Ponch Rivera: I just want to take that moment to share that with you, because I think what you set up with the you call it E4S is that right.
- 28:03Thomas Modly: Yeah.
- 28:05Ponch Rivera: I believe that was your intent.
- 28:06Ponch Rivera: Right Was to get that gray matter working again.
- 28:09Thomas Modly: Yes, I mean so there were institutional motivations behind that, but also, broadly speaking, it was about creating agile thinkers.
- 28:23Thomas Modly: Creating agile thinkers, the the idea that you can have all the you know agility in the systems that you want with respect to the weapon systems and or the you know great example, like the aircraft carrier, that the um, the move to create electromagnetics there for launching and recovering aircraft, and and uh, I had this you know discussion, heated discussion with President Trump about this, about the value of electromagnetics and what that can do for us with respect to agility and ability to shift to different payloads and more quickly and generate sororities more quickly, and so on and so forth.
- 28:59Thomas Modly: He clearly had somebody in his ear talking about how steam was better and you know I didn't have time, you know, to sort of disabuse him of that idea.
- 29:11Thomas Modly: But, um, it's great if you have all these things that can do that, but it's much more important to have people that are agile minded as well, um, adaptable, because I always said that the most important, the most predictable thing we can say about the future is that it's going to be unpredictable.
- 29:30Thomas Modly: And so how do we bring people into the?
- 29:33Thomas Modly: Or how do we take people into the military and prepare them to handle unpredictable events, because to me, that's what they're going to have to deal with.
- 29:44Thomas Modly: The predictable stuff is easy to be prepared for.
- 29:49Thomas Modly: It's the unpredictable stuff that's not, and it requires agile minds.
- 29:53Thomas Modly: And so what I really wanted to do with E4S was come up with a way to sort of unify the Navy education system so that we could be ensured that we were developing that and it'd been it just like every other thing in the Navy.
- 30:05Thomas Modly: It had become a completely siloed thing.
- 30:07Thomas Modly: You know everything.
- 30:08Thomas Modly: You had the war college over there doing its thing.
- 30:11Thomas Modly: You had the postgraduate school doing something else.
- 30:13Thomas Modly: No real relationship with the Naval Academy, which is sort of our flagship institution, no real coordination with Marine Corps University, and then nothing really for the enlisted people.
- 30:24Thomas Modly: So we created the naval community college, um, just to continue to create this culture of continuous learning, with the purpose of creating people that were more adept at dealing with unpredictability.
- 30:37Thomas Modly: And you know for, for for two and a half years, I talked about unpredictable events, unpredictable events, be prepared for them, and the big unpredictable event happens in the spring of 2020, which is COVID, and some Navy CEOs and organizations and installations performed magnificently and others didn't.
- 31:14Mark McGrath: And I think a lot of that had to do with how prepared they were to be able to deal with something unpredictable like this is training the mind of the individual warfighter first, such that there's a cultural unity across the force where everyone is a Marine first.
- 31:26Mark McGrath: Everyone has very high expectations of how they're going to perform in asymmetric, nonlinear environments, aka chaos.
- 31:38Mark McGrath: But starting from a philosophical standpoint, you know, warfighting is a book for the mind.
- 31:47Mark McGrath: It's not a book about, it's not a how-to manual.
- 31:49Mark McGrath: Why has that never been able to cross-pollinate over to our other side of the department of the Navy, where maybe we'll find it in pockets, we might find it in squadrons, or we might find it in the SEALs, where they have a focus on sort of building the warfighter, if you will.
- 32:05Mark McGrath: Why has that never taken hold in the Navy?
- 32:08Ponch Rivera: Mark, I want to answer that.
- 32:09Ponch Rivera: So my experience was explaining the OODA loop to former fighter pilots.
- 32:13Ponch Rivera: My friends, they have no clue what it is, they think it's just Observe Orient, decide, act right.
- 32:18Ponch Rivera: And then you introduce them back to EM theory, so energy maneuverability theory that John Boyd created to get us the F-16, f-18, a-10, and so forth, and how we use that to understand, you know, rate and radius fights and all that in the cockpit.
- 32:30Ponch Rivera: You make that connection next and they're like wait a minute, he did both of those.
- 32:33Ponch Rivera: Yeah, but the way you use the OODA loop is not the way it was intended.
- 32:39Ponch Rivera: It's.
- 32:39Ponch Rivera: You know there's a lot more behind it than you think, and so I'll argue that I think our military JPME, joint Professional Military Education is pretty phenomenal, and that's because I was able to go through Air Command Staff College and go on and get a JQO call through JPME too as well, and plus I did the Paul Mill stuff with the foreign area officer background.
- 33:00Ponch Rivera: My point behind this is I don't know if people actually listen to what's being taught to them inside of.
- 33:06Ponch Rivera: You know wicked problems understanding wicked problems, exactly what Tom's bringing up there with, with unpredictability in the future.
- 33:13Ponch Rivera: How do we deal with that.
- 33:14Ponch Rivera: We learned a lot about how do you lead like a gardener, leadership in operations, leadership at the tactical level, leadership at the strategic level, understanding the importance of running rock drills, rehearsal of concepts, which I'll argue now.
- 33:28Ponch Rivera: If you take that concept and apply it like a worldly map to an organization, they're going to crush everybody because you're understanding the landscape right.
- 33:34Ponch Rivera: So, again, I'm just sharing my view with you, mark, and that is I thought we were well prepared.
- 33:41Ponch Rivera: However, what people take out of it, what officers take out of it, matters, and I think that's where our military leadership is failing.
- 33:49Ponch Rivera: They're not connecting the dots from what they're being taught in some of our education systems in the military to what they need to do as leaders.
- 33:59Ponch Rivera: So I just want to throw that out there, tom, see if you have any thoughts on that.
- 34:03Thomas Modly: Yeah, I think there's a couple problems there that are inhibiting that.
- 34:06Thomas Modly: One is, I think, that there is a lack of continuity in leadership.
- 34:09Thomas Modly: I think the turnover, the rapid turn, the massive turnover, all the time that you see Someone just wrote an article about this, criticizing the last four CNOs and how they put out strategic guidance that was not really coordinated, it's not continuous, it sort of shifts one or the other.
- 34:29Thomas Modly: And I'll tell you this, when I was there, the CNO's strategic guidance, I was never coordinated on it.
- 34:36Thomas Modly: I mean, no one ever showed it to me as the under or the SECNAF prior to it being published.
- 34:43Thomas Modly: So I mean, who is setting the direction?
- 34:45Thomas Modly: Who's responsible for setting the direction?
- 34:48Thomas Modly: I think the gap, um, this is a bigger question, but I think the gap is that, um, that, uh, I think that the service chiefs, particularly like in the Navy and the Marines, they've taken on the responsibility for determining what the strategy should be for both organizations and that's really Congress's responsibility and the president's, and we don't have that strong sort of leadership from Congress that says this is our maritime strategy, this is what we're going to fund, this is what you guys need to go execute, and then you guys have the title 10, responsibility for man training and equipping and making it happen.
- 35:25Thomas Modly: Um, obviously there should be input, but um, it's, it's otherwise.
- 35:31Thomas Modly: You know, every four years, like it's, it's a sine wave, you know, from one thing to the next, to the next.
- 35:36Thomas Modly: And that's why I talk a lot about this whole 355 ship thing in the book, because it became pretty obvious to me that it was just a meaningless number.
- 35:46Thomas Modly: No one, really, unless you got the money for it.
- 35:49Thomas Modly: It was just a meaningless number.
- 35:52Thomas Modly: And I actually had a four-star, who will remain nameless, who told me yeah, I just tattooed 355 on my forehead every time I go over to Congress, but none of us really believe that can happen.
- 36:01Thomas Modly: So that is to me emblematic of a problem that the higher you get, the more risk averse you are.
- 36:11Thomas Modly: No one's willing to take a risk, no one's willing to throw their stars on the table.
- 36:15Thomas Modly: I mean, look, we haven't had great performance from the military in the last 10 years or so.
- 36:23Thomas Modly: I mean there's been a lot of major failures, particularly Afghanistan.
- 36:26Thomas Modly: No one resigned or no one threw their stars on the table and said I can't support this.
- 36:33Thomas Modly: I think there's just a level of risk aversion now and I think that you know legal there's I talk about that in the book sort of the legal precedents that have been set, um, that make people more and more risk averse and so people are afraid of getting in trouble, um, or afraid of being, uh, scandalized in the media or criticized in the media or whatever.
- 36:58Thomas Modly: Um, you know, so you've got a lot of public affairs people around there running, you know messaging and things like that, and you know they do a fine job.
- 37:06Thomas Modly: But I don't think we had that many public affairs people and lawyers driving decision-making when we were fighting World War II or even the Cold War.
- 37:18Thomas Modly: But there's a lot more of it now and I and I assume you know that's part of living in a media-driven world and you know our elected officials look at that stuff and that's how they they make decisions so well and I, I guess that's a good seg to.
- 37:33Mark McGrath: I mean sort of the, the, the end part of the book about the, uh, the situation on the theater roosevelt during, during, during, during COVID.
- 37:42Mark McGrath: There was a media effect to it, right or wrong.
- 37:44Mark McGrath: It was an effect that had a massive influence on the course of events and we could discuss about how well.
- 37:55Mark McGrath: It had nothing to do with war fighting, I mean your standpoint, it's clear in the book.
- 38:00Mark McGrath: I mean that's your charge as the Secretary of the Navy is to make sure that everything's operational and we're ready to fight our nation's wars at a moment's notice.
- 38:07Mark McGrath: And some of these things you know culturally occur and they slip out of the cracks.
- 38:13Mark McGrath: And the next thing, all the moms, groups on Facebooks of sailors and everything else is going crazy.
- 38:18Mark McGrath: Yet you're trying to keep everybody focused back on the mission.
- 38:22Mark McGrath: That had to have been a.
- 38:24Mark McGrath: You know, tell us about that.
- 38:26Thomas Modly: Well, you know it evolved pretty quickly and, you know, devolved pretty quickly.
- 38:31Thomas Modly: So, yeah, I think that if you look at the vectors and people who haven't read the book, the vectors are the things that I wrote to the fleet every week.
- 38:41Thomas Modly: I wrote a message to everybody you know, a million people in the organization every friday about what was on my mind, what should be on their minds, etc.
- 38:48Thomas Modly: Um and uh, if you look at the two or three weeks leading up to that, I was talking about unpredictability and how this could be the time that is going to define your time in the Navy and how are you going to react?
- 39:02Thomas Modly: And and um, because no one would have ever predicted this, but this is how this is likely going to be the time that defines your time in the Navy, and um, so just to run quickly through the story, that when we found out that the ship had a COVID outbreak on it, the decision was made.
- 39:20Thomas Modly: We thought about Okinawa.
- 39:21Thomas Modly: That wasn't going to work.
- 39:22Thomas Modly: They didn't have enough beds and things like that in case we needed to evacuate a lot of sailors.
- 39:28Thomas Modly: So the decision was made to go to Guam.
- 39:30Thomas Modly: The ship gets into Guam, I believe, on a Friday, and on that Sunday I reached out to my chief of staff, bob Love, and I said, bob, would you please call the captain and tell him that I want to come out, meet with the crew, make sure they're getting all the support they need from the governor of Guam, who I just literally had been in my office like a week before.
- 39:50Thomas Modly: So I had a pretty good relationship with her and she's a former registered nurse and understood a lot of the health challenges and so on and a really good person.
- 39:59Thomas Modly: So I offered to come out there and make sure that they had everything they needed.
- 40:05Thomas Modly: And he waved me off, said no, it would be too much of a distraction.
- 40:08Thomas Modly: And so Bob told me this and he said the only frustration that he had was he wanted to get the sailors off the ship quicker.
- 40:16Thomas Modly: So Bob called the director of the Navy staff, a guy named Andy Heipley who used to be my chief of staff and another great Ohio guy, marine 06.
- 40:28Thomas Modly: And Andy was like yeah, we're all over this and they were getting the hotel rooms.
- 40:35Thomas Modly: They had mobilized 900 people on the island of Guam to get the sailors off, get them meals three times a day.
- 40:41Thomas Modly: They had a whole command center set up.
- 40:43Thomas Modly: I mean it was a pretty remarkable movement that had been done fairly quickly.
- 40:48Thomas Modly: Sometime in the first couple days they told the captain that they could move the sailors off out of their berthing and put them in tents.
- 40:56Thomas Modly: They had a bunch of tents set up and he decided he didn't want to do that.
- 41:00Thomas Modly: He said it would be uncomfortable for the crew to do that.
- 41:03Thomas Modly: So that was his decision.
- 41:04Thomas Modly: He didn't discuss it with the strike group commander, he just said no, um.
- 41:11Thomas Modly: So about two hours after the conversation with or the exchange with, bob, uh, the captain sent out this letter.
- 41:18Thomas Modly: Uh, that was a very much of a hair on fire kind of letter that uh, um, that uh basically was saying that we needed to get the sailors off quickly.
- 41:29Thomas Modly: He didn't feel like he was getting enough help.
- 41:31Thomas Modly: He was reaching out to people to see how they could get um more rooms from different areas and so on and so forth.
- 41:37Thomas Modly: And unfortunately for him, had it been sent over a secure network or directly to me, it wouldn't have been a problem, but somehow or another it got leaked.
- 41:49Thomas Modly: It got leaked to the San Francisco Chronicle.
- 41:51Thomas Modly: They wrote this big article about how this pleas for help from the captain were not being answered, and so on and so forth, and of course that got the interest of the president and the secretary of defense and the media and people in Congress, and so, you know, I started doing my own investigation.
- 42:10Thomas Modly: I had been asking the CNO to reach out to the captain as well and he had just sort of rebuffed me multiple times to do that.
- 42:18Thomas Modly: But what ended up happening was I received a call from Secretary of Defense saying that the president wasn't happy and I said well, he's not the only one, I'm not happy either.
- 42:29Thomas Modly: And so he asked me if he should handle it for me and I said no.
- 42:34Thomas Modly: I said this is a Navy problem and it's kind of my job to keep the president not worried about what's happening in the Navy, so he doesn't need to worry about it, the Navy will handle this.
- 42:45Thomas Modly: So I guess that message got back to him and there were some schemes that were cooked up by the second half I mean SecDef and others to just suspend this guy for the captain for until we did a full investigation.
- 43:00Thomas Modly: And I said I don't really.
- 43:01Thomas Modly: I said I know how investigations work in the Navy.
- 43:04Thomas Modly: They take months and I've got a ship in a crisis right now.
- 43:08Thomas Modly: That's in the spotlight of the media.
- 43:10Thomas Modly: And, frankly, to me this is like the ninth inning when your closer is not, you know, struggling and it's time to you know, go to the bullpen and pull somebody else in.
- 43:19Thomas Modly: And I just felt like I needed to steady your hand on the ship.
- 43:23Thomas Modly: And it was confirmed after talking to the captain himself and I asked him you know how things were going.
- 43:30Thomas Modly: So two days later I said how things are going and he said that.
- 43:34Thomas Modly: He said that things were fine, they were getting the people in the hotel rooms and you know.
- 43:39Thomas Modly: So, on, on and so forth.
- 43:40Thomas Modly: I asked him why did he send out the letter?
- 43:42Thomas Modly: He said that they had just gotten back 50 positive tests and he felt like it was just time to send up a signal there.
- 43:51Thomas Modly: I said, okay, I understand why you did that, but you have to understand what's happening here in response to that.
- 43:58Thomas Modly: But you know, you have to understand what's happening here in response to that.
- 44:02Thomas Modly: And he did.
- 44:02Thomas Modly: And then I talked to the strike group commander the next morning and I asked him what happened.
- 44:08Thomas Modly: And the key to me was that the strike group commander told me that he confronted the captain as well, because he never had a chance to talk to him about this letter, either before it went off the ship and the strike group commander told me.
- 44:18Mark McGrath: And, to clarify, he was the first person in the skipper's chain of command right and he's there co-located on the ship.
- 44:24Thomas Modly: Yeah, they're right next to each other on the ship yeah and so he asked the captain why he didn't talk to him about it before he sent it.
- 44:31Thomas Modly: And the captain and captain kroger actually wrote about this in his book too he made the intentional decision not to talk to him about it because he knew that the strike group commander would not have let him send it.
- 44:44Thomas Modly: And the strike group commander told me that I would have not let him send it.
- 44:47Thomas Modly: There were other ways that we could have gotten the message out, but he did it intentionally because he quote unquote didn't want to be disobeying a direct order if he was told not to do it because he knew he was going to send it anyway.
- 45:01Thomas Modly: He had made the decision he was going to send it, and so it was kind of a manipulation from my view.
- 45:07Thomas Modly: But also it was premeditated, you know, insubordination of his strike group commander, who was an aviator like him.
- 45:14Thomas Modly: I mean, I've learned later that they didn't have the greatest working relationship, but that's on them, you know, that's on them to worry about.
- 45:22Thomas Modly: So I made the decision to relieve him, and it was met with just a flurry of, you know, incredible reaction, both from the Hill, from the media, obviously, mostly from the blue side of Congress.
- 45:40Thomas Modly: I actually reached out and spoke to several senior members on the armed services committees before I formally made the decision, to inform them that this is what I was doing, and most of the Republicans were like, well, sir, it's up to you, it's your call.
- 45:56Thomas Modly: And it was actually a Democratic senator who said I don't get involved in personnel decisions, that's why you're there, and so I appreciated that.
- 46:05Thomas Modly: Several others were, you know, didn't think it was the right thing to do, but, um, but once it became, once the media sort of decided to choose sides in it, um, there was a massive pile on and then that manifested itself in all kinds of online, uh, social media hatred, you know, towards me, towards my family.
- 46:26Thomas Modly: I don't have a very common last name, but people were able to go out on the internet and find my kids and and say nasty things to them and um and so, uh, it became pretty ugly and I decided that I needed to go to Guam and meet with the crew, talk to them, explain to them why I made the decision, because it was obvious he was very popular.
- 46:48Thomas Modly: He'd only been the CO for about four or five months, but still a very popular guy.
- 46:52Thomas Modly: I've said this before.
- 46:53Thomas Modly: I think he's probably a really great guy, but that's not what was working in my calculation at the time.
- 47:01Thomas Modly: I think he was spooked.
- 47:02Thomas Modly: I think the ship's doctors had written this letter as well, which, in my opinion, he should have fired them for that for threatening him, but he didn't.
- 47:12Thomas Modly: But they wrote a letter basically saying that if we didn't evacuate the ship immediately, that 50 people were going to be dead within 10 days.
- 47:20Thomas Modly: 50 sailors would be dead within 10 days of that point in time, which was like the second day into the crisis.
- 47:29Thomas Modly: And you know, obviously, as time has gone on, we've realized that none of that is true or possible.
- 47:35Thomas Modly: I think what I've heard is that the Navy only lost one active duty sailor to COVID.
- 47:39Thomas Modly: What I've heard is that the Navy only lost one active duty sailor to COVID.
- 47:42Thomas Modly: So that's among 335,000 sailors and outbreaks on several different ships.
- 47:47Thomas Modly: But I think they spooked him.
- 47:51Thomas Modly: And the final line of their letter?
- 47:53Thomas Modly: Well, the first line of their letter is telling it basically says that the battle against COVID on the USS Teddy Roosevelt has been lost.
- 48:01Thomas Modly: That was their first thing.
- 48:03Thomas Modly: And then the last line was it is our intention to make all this information available to the public so the world knows what's happening here on Earth, and they said they were going to release it and they all signed it.
- 48:18Thomas Modly: None of these doctors was an epidemiologist or an immunologist or an infectious disease specialist, but they've been reading what was getting promulgated on the Internet about how deadly this virus was and, frankly, it could have been.
- 48:34Thomas Modly: But we were doing the best we can to get the sailors off and make sure that they were free of the virus, clean of the virus and get them back on the ship.
- 48:41Thomas Modly: So we fly to Guam, we pick up the new CEO, who had been the previous CEO for two and a half years, and met him in Hawaii, flew over.
- 48:49Thomas Modly: Of course, that became a new story too, in terms of how much it costs to do that.
- 48:54Thomas Modly: It's funny, the guy who wrote that article I haven't seen him write any other article in the last four years about how much it costs for any government official to do anything um, but that was the topic of the day.
- 49:06Thomas Modly: I know that's a snarky thing to say, but I mean it's just one of those things that that the environment created, um and so, um.
- 49:14Thomas Modly: So, anyway, we, uh, we went over there.
- 49:16Thomas Modly: I got there first thing in the morning.
- 49:18Thomas Modly: Um, I told them, you know, like 2 o'clock in the morning or something, and I stayed up.
- 49:23Thomas Modly: I called my wife.
- 49:26Thomas Modly: I asked her to reach out to the captain's wife in California and talk to her and tell her that we support them as a Navy family.
- 49:33Thomas Modly: And she wouldn't take my wife's call, which I don't blame her, but I thought it was our responsibility to do that at the time.
- 49:44Thomas Modly: And then we went and toured the facilities.
- 49:47Thomas Modly: What was going on?
- 49:48Thomas Modly: I saw the command center.
- 49:49Thomas Modly: I saw all these people and I kept hearing over and over again from the sailors and stuff that were working on the ground that the captain's letter really took the wind out of their sails because they had been working 15, 16-hour days getting this command center up and his letter made it sound like no one was doing anything, which obviously wasn't true.
- 50:07Thomas Modly: And then I met with the governor of Guam who had to reopen her hotels to accommodate the sailors.
- 50:14Thomas Modly: They had sent everybody home from COVID.
- 50:17Thomas Modly: Everything was shut down so they had to bring the hotel workers back and now they're afraid that 3,000 infected sailors are coming into their hotels and they're going to infect the whole island and everyone's going to get sick and die.
- 50:30Thomas Modly: And she told me that the captain's letter cost her about three days and getting the hotels ready because of the panic that set in because of that.
- 50:38Thomas Modly: And she was very strong about you know, look, the Navy's part of our family here and we're going to take care of them, which was a very, very courageous thing to do in the moment.
- 50:48Thomas Modly: But she was upset about how this letter had caused these issues.
- 50:54Thomas Modly: So we go down to, we drive down to the ship and I had told the, I told the team and I only went over there with my chief of staff and and um and my military aid.
- 51:05Thomas Modly: I told the team that I was going on a ship and I was going to talk to the crew and I didn't want to do a speech, I just wanted to go around the ship and talk to them.
- 51:14Thomas Modly: And, uh, sometime in the morning they said, sir, you can't do that, we're response, ncis, protective services and the medical communities said we can't let the secretary of the Navy go on a COVID infected ship.
- 51:27Thomas Modly: You know we're responsible for your safety.
- 51:29Thomas Modly: I said, well, there's 3000 people on there, so I'm going and so you guys have to figure out a way to get me on the ship.
- 51:35Thomas Modly: And so they said, oh, so we'll, we'll work something out.
- 51:38Thomas Modly: And so they decided that they were going to put me in this room on the quarter deck with the one MC and talk to the crew that way.
- 51:45Thomas Modly: And I said that's fine, but submit, have them submit questions so that I can answer all their questions, because I won't have an opportunity to have interaction.
- 51:54Thomas Modly: So, as we're heading down to the pier to meet with the senior officers on the ship, I ship Bob Love.
- 51:59Thomas Modly: My chief of staff says, sir, I got all the questions here, but I don't think you should read them right now.
- 52:06Thomas Modly: And I said, why is that?
- 52:08Thomas Modly: He said, well, you're just not going to like them.
- 52:10Thomas Modly: And so there were about 33 questions.
- 52:14Thomas Modly: They were all typed up.
- 52:15Thomas Modly: Someone had clearly packaged these together and reviewed them all, and some of them were, you know, some of them were very basic, sort of logistic questions how long do you think before we can go back to sea?
- 52:25Thomas Modly: Where will we be staying?
- 52:27Thomas Modly: What's the processes?
- 52:28Thomas Modly: But some of them had more of a tone that were, I would say, a little bit disrespectful.
- 52:33Thomas Modly: One was like sir, how many dead sailors would be acceptable to you before you got us any help?
- 52:38Thomas Modly: Um, we're not at war.
- 52:41Thomas Modly: Why should anyone die?
- 52:42Thomas Modly: You know, those types of things that were had been parroted in the media and and also the captain's letter said some of those types of things, and so I get it.
- 52:51Thomas Modly: They were, you know, they were distressed, they weren't getting good information and and um, so I went down and I met with the senior officers of the ship first and we sat sat down at a picnic table but all of us had masks on and gloves and so it was really hard to gauge people's expressions.
- 53:06Thomas Modly: But I sort of told them what was happening back at home and how the nation was really having a hard time with the virus and they really expected the Navy not to be having a hard time with the virus.
- 53:16Thomas Modly: And it was our responsibility to show that we can work through this, we can fight through this and we can come out the other end and be stronger, and that the captain's letter had created this sense that A the senior leadership wasn't doing anything.
- 53:34Thomas Modly: This was a dire situation for the sailors.
- 53:37Thomas Modly: Here it's spooled up all the family members.
- 53:41Thomas Modly: That's a dynamic I didn't have to deal with when I was on active duty, but all these sailors walk on board with their own phones and their ability to communicate wherever.
- 53:49Thomas Modly: So a lot of that messaging was going back and forth and so I said, look, I'm going to go talk to the crew now.
- 53:56Thomas Modly: Does anyone have anything to say to me in terms of what I should tell them?
- 54:00Thomas Modly: And not a single one of them said anything.
- 54:02Thomas Modly: They just sort of stared at me.
- 54:05Mark McGrath: And just to clarify, these are all the department heads and all the squadron commanders and things like that.
- 54:10Thomas Modly: Yeah, yeah, xo strike group commander was there.
- 54:16Thomas Modly: Xo was sitting right next to me.
- 54:17Thomas Modly: I'll never forget.
- 54:18Thomas Modly: I looked over at him and these poor guys, I mean, they were obviously fatigued, and I I said um, I said uh, exo anything?
- 54:28Thomas Modly: And he just kind of looked at me and shook his head and I was like, okay.
- 54:30Thomas Modly: So you know, that's one of the one of the things I talk about.
- 54:34Thomas Modly: One of my lessons learned in the book is about unmasking yourself, and it's a metaphor, obviously, but um, it's really important, like to unmask yourself when you're talking to people, um, and not don't hide behind your rank or your privilege or whatever, because you don't you, you can't really get to the heart of anything if you're covered um and so, um, that was just a classic sort of metaphorical example of that.
- 54:58Thomas Modly: I mean, I really couldn't sense other than the fact that they were all tired and frustrated with everything and probably not too happy with me, because I think they all like their CEO.
- 55:09Mark McGrath: You had mentioned too in the book that the CEO was basically given a pep rally and exited the ship as a martyred.
- 55:18Thomas Modly: Yeah, I don't think that was his fault.
- 55:20Thomas Modly: Um, he, that was.
- 55:23Thomas Modly: That happened on Friday.
- 55:25Thomas Modly: This, this is what sort of started to escalate all of the vitriol against me, because that Friday, um, he was, he was leaving the ship and somehow they found out he was leaving the ship and they decided to have a big pep rally for him and no one's wearing a mask and everyone's cheering and slapping each other on the back, you know, and that also got leaked to the media, of course, and um, and then later that day we got the word that he had covid also.
- 55:55Thomas Modly: So not only was he, you know, the hero that was taken from command, but now he was sick and you know, it sort of did create this martyr, uh, impression for him of him in the media.
- 56:06Thomas Modly: Um, so that that really helped to drive my decision to go out there.
- 56:12Thomas Modly: I just felt I needed to go and I had been.
- 56:15Thomas Modly: There's a whole series of discussions in the book about my interactions with admiral gilday on this and how I asked him to intervene and call and everything, and he just refused to do it.
- 56:24Thomas Modly: Um, I mean, literally refused to do it.
- 56:28Thomas Modly: Um, and this is sort of the thing.
- 56:30Thomas Modly: You know, this is not how we do things in the Navy type of speech that I got from him.
- 56:34Thomas Modly: Um, and I, I was like you know, you know this is not 1895 anymore.
- 56:44Thomas Modly: You know you can pick up the phone and call this guy and you're you know, if Admiral Aquilino or Admiral Mears out there like have a problem with you jumping the chain of command to talk to this captain who's in a crisis, that's their problem, that's not your problem.
- 56:57Thomas Modly: So, but he just he wouldn't do it so and I think he was.
- 57:04Thomas Modly: You know, that's what, that's not your problem, so, but he just he wouldn't do it so and I think he was.
- 57:05Thomas Modly: You know, that's what I'm saying.
- 57:05Thomas Modly: I think they were just raised in a different culture and they just didn't feel it was a responsibility.
- 57:07Thomas Modly: But I, I can think of you know, I, I checked myself on this because I had a conversation with admiral fogo, who was out here at the time, and I asked him the same question like would you ever hesitate to like pick up the phone and call a CEO of a ship?
- 57:22Thomas Modly: And he goes, no, because I do it all the time, it's just that some guys don't.
- 57:26Thomas Modly: And I said OK, so, so, anyway.
- 57:29Thomas Modly: So I ended up going on the ship and as I'm walking to the ship, the command master chief came up to me and said that you know, he heard what I was saying and that the crew was going to be fine and they were going to get them in line.
- 57:40Thomas Modly: And I had set up I actually set up an email account right when COVID started where anyone could send emails about improvements they think the Navy needs to happen.
- 57:55Thomas Modly: And I think it was called stemdisterncom because we were we were doing a whole stem to stern review and a sailor from the tr had sent me an email early on in the crisis saying sir, don't worry about what's going on here, it's not as bad as they're making it sound, and so on and so forth.
- 58:12Thomas Modly: So anyway, I get up, as I'm walking up the gangplank to to go up to the quarter deck, I just kind of see these sailors on the flight deck, their masks, they're looking down at me and I could tell like I'm like the least popular guy, uh, in that area at that moment.
- 58:29Thomas Modly: Um, but I just kind of kept thinking about Guam and you know there was 25,000 marines who died on Guam to defend it.
- 58:36Thomas Modly: You know, 60, 70 years ago, and I'd met some of them who had been there and, um, I just, you know, I just had this perspective that I'm not sure these guys understand how important it is what they're doing out here, and so I got up on the quarterdeck and I was given a microphone and just started talking extemporaneously and mangled some of my comments and that's totally on me and the media took some of those words and manipulated them to say that I said something that I didn't really say, which is that I called the captain naive and stupid, which I didn't say.
- 59:15Thomas Modly: I said he was either naive or stupid or he did it on purpose, and I knew at that point he did it on purpose.
- 59:21Thomas Modly: So the point was that, by doing it on purpose, he had really violated his chain of command and done something that he shouldn't be doing as a CO.
- 59:31Thomas Modly: So, and then I went on to talk and you know I ended my talk basically quoting a speech that I gave at the Naval Academy graduation in 2018 about what their responsibility was, and their responsibility was not to love their CEO.
- 59:45Thomas Modly: It was to love the people that they're responsible for and the Constitution and the nation they've pledged to defend.
- 59:51Thomas Modly: And let those people worry about themselves.
- 59:55Thomas Modly: Your job is to worry about the people that work for you, and that's sort of how I ended it.
- 1:00:01Thomas Modly: I think I said beat army, and then I walked off and I was kind of like, had this feeling like, well, that's probably the last thing I'm ever going to say is, as the secretary of navy, I just I just didn't have a good feeling and, uh, by the time we got home, um, after it, sort of admonishing them for using the media as part of their chain of command, they had been recording, someone had recorded my remarks, sent it to NBC News and then it was all over the news by the time I got home, and the president, when I landed at Andrews, the president had made a statement that when he was asked about this you know he was very good at solving arguments between people and so he'll just have me and the captain in and we'll solve this argument and I was like I'm not in an argument with anybody, um, and I don't want to put the president in a position to like mediate.
- 1:00:53Thomas Modly: Something that I don't think is is an argument.
- 1:00:56Thomas Modly: Um, it's not really so.
- 1:00:58Thomas Modly: At that moment I realized my job of trying to keep the president focused on big picture stuff and not Navy minutiae.
- 1:01:08Thomas Modly: I kind of failed at that, and so I realized that I really probably couldn't go on effectively, as the second half, the blue side of Congress, would have been, you know, just very, very difficult to overcome and it would have just been investigations, and you know, which is fine.
- 1:01:25Thomas Modly: And the Navy did an investigation of the whole thing, and um found that the captain and both the captain and strike commander had not performed well and had done a bunch of other things that had caused COVID to actually spread more quickly on the ship, and so he was not given his command back, which is unfortunate because, oh, and I left out a very important part.
- 1:01:47Thomas Modly: Before I left Guam, I went up and met with the captain and I sat down with him and I said look, I you know we had to sit across this long table up at Admiral Nimitz's house.
- 1:01:59Thomas Modly: Have you guys been there before on Guam, up on the top of the hill?
- 1:02:02Thomas Modly: No, so he's sitting at one end of the table and I'm on the other.
- 1:02:08Thomas Modly: And I said look, I just want you to know, since I didn't get a chance to talk to you, why I relieved you and he said, sir, you don't have to say another word.
- 1:02:17Thomas Modly: I put you in a tough position as the Secretary of the Navy and if I had been in your shoes I would have relieved me too.
- 1:02:25Thomas Modly: But I did it for the crew and I said that's very noble and I understand, but you have to, and I've already talked to the Naval Air Commander, bullet Miller, in San Diego and he's got a job for you to come back to.
- 1:02:47Thomas Modly: But once you get home and you get healthy and if you want to, if you want to come to Washington and work for me directly, I said this COVID thing is going to go on for at least another year and I've been calling every CEO of every ship and installation in the Navy that has COVID.
- 1:03:00Thomas Modly: But I can't do that every day.
- 1:03:03Thomas Modly: I said, but I need someone to do that every day and I'd like to set up a cell to sort of manage that from the secretariat position.
- 1:03:09Thomas Modly: If you want to come and run that for me, you know I would love to have you and he sort of nodded and, you know, appreciated it.
- 1:03:17Thomas Modly: I think he probably knew that that wasn't something he'd want to do necessarily, but I was serious about it.
- 1:03:25Thomas Modly: I had mentioned it to my staff on the Thursday before we even went to Guam that I wanted to do it.
- 1:03:29Thomas Modly: They all thought it was a horrible idea.
- 1:03:30Thomas Modly: But I didn't think it was a horrible idea.
- 1:03:41Thomas Modly: But when I became Secretary of the Navy I had two artifacts placed in my office.
- 1:03:42Thomas Modly: One was a fitness report of a young ensign from 1917 who had run his ship aground and it's basically sort of a poor fitness report for poor judgment or whatever for judgment whatever.
- 1:04:03Thomas Modly: And then next to that, just a few feet away, I had a massive, probably six by 10 foot oil painting of Admiral Nimitz signing the surrender documents on the deck of the USS Missouri in Tokyo Harbor and the fit rep was his fit rep as an ensign in 1917.
- 1:04:18Thomas Modly: And I had those in my office to just show to people that you know, mistakes happen all the time, people make mistakes all the time, but they can't.
- 1:04:26Thomas Modly: They don't have to be fatal and there's ways to recover from them, and so you just have to be able to learn from them, and I think you become better when you learn from them.
- 1:04:36Thomas Modly: So that was my sense with him is that I really wanted to.
- 1:04:41Thomas Modly: I think this was an unusual circumstance.
- 1:04:42Thomas Modly: I don't think he made the right decision in the moment.
- 1:04:45Thomas Modly: But, more importantly, I just felt like I needed to have the steadier hand at that moment in charge of the ship, and I didn't feel like that.
- 1:04:53Thomas Modly: I felt he could have had an opportunity to continue his career.
- 1:04:56Thomas Modly: I didn't know what the report was going to find and, frankly it's interesting Of all the people in the entire crisis that spoke to Captain Crozier during the crisis from Washington, it was just me and Bob Love, my chief of staff.
- 1:05:11Thomas Modly: Neither one of us were interviewed for that report, for that investigation.
- 1:05:14Thomas Modly: So I don't know what the Navy was thinking about when they did that, but I didn't, you know, I didn't.
- 1:05:22Thomas Modly: People were.
- 1:05:23Thomas Modly: You know.
- 1:05:24Thomas Modly: I got a lot of emails that day like oh, you're vindicated, blah, blah, blah, blah.
- 1:05:27Thomas Modly: And I was like you know what?
- 1:05:28Thomas Modly: If the Navy had decided that the Navy had decided that he should be reinstated, I would have supported that too.
- 1:05:33Thomas Modly: This was a decision I made in the moment, because I needed someone to get that ship back to sea and I just didn't feel like the environment as it had been created by him was right to keep him there.
- 1:05:48Thomas Modly: So that was my decision.
- 1:05:49Thomas Modly: That was my call.
- 1:05:50Thomas Modly: Sorry, that's a long one.
- 1:05:52Ponch Rivera: I have a feeling if you ran that scenario again with different you know, secretary of the Navy and CEO of an aircraft carrier you ran that a hundred times you're going to see this exact result over again, right?
- 1:06:03Ponch Rivera: Just because the novelty of that situation and the information flow and the different orientations that were happening then.
- 1:06:08Ponch Rivera: So thank you for sharing that story.
- 1:06:11Ponch Rivera: It's very, very important that people understand civilian authority, how that works in the military, right?
- 1:06:16Ponch Rivera: I mean, that's you brought that up earlier and you know we are here to support and defend the Constitution of the United States and the civilians that are appointed in those positions that we have to listen up to or we have to.
- 1:06:28Ponch Rivera: You know you are the authority on this.
- 1:06:31Ponch Rivera: That's, that's your position anyway.
- 1:06:33Ponch Rivera: So if those in your command are not doing what you're asking them to do, then maybe we do have a problem in the Navy, right?
- 1:06:40Thomas Modly: Well, the hard thing is Ponch.
- 1:06:41Thomas Modly: I think this is the problem.
- 1:06:43Thomas Modly: A big problem is that I think these guys, they do the best.
- 1:06:47Thomas Modly: The senior officers, they do the best they can.
- 1:06:49Thomas Modly: So, for example, I left in May of 2020.
- 1:06:54Thomas Modly: No, april of 2020.
- 1:06:56Thomas Modly: There have been six people either acting or a secretary of the Navy since then.
- 1:07:00Thomas Modly: So I mean, the lack of continuity in senior leadership makes it very, very difficult to establish that.
- 1:07:07Thomas Modly: And so, for example, richard Spencer came in at second half.
- 1:07:10Thomas Modly: He had John Richardson as his CNO and General Neller as his commandant.
- 1:07:16Thomas Modly: He didn't pick those guys.
- 1:07:17Thomas Modly: Those are people that were picked by the previous administration and so they have to pivot to now a new, different type of leader who's being given orders by a different type of leader and a different type of leader, and that's a very tough thing.
- 1:07:36Thomas Modly: So that's why my view is like these guys should be focused on executing the man, train and equip mission, and I also sort of have this feeling that, because of the time that it takes to impact this type of you know, long-term change whatever that's going to be, that's mandated by the Congress you need a secretary of the Navy or any of the services to be there for almost like an FBI director for like 10 years, so they can build a team of people that they trust and there isn't this turnover based on politics turn.
- 1:08:19Thomas Modly: There isn't this turnover based on politics, um, because otherwise, then then that I think it's that relationship between the military and the civilian leadership becomes a formality and not a reality.
- 1:08:27Thomas Modly: You know what I'm saying.
- 1:08:28Thomas Modly: It's more, it's more formal, it's more like, uh, deferential, but it's not.
- 1:08:34Thomas Modly: It's not.
- 1:08:35Thomas Modly: Yeah, that's my boss and this is what we're doing, because he's got the vision and he's executing the vision.
- 1:08:40Thomas Modly: So I feel sorry, I have some empathy for these senior military guys having to deal with that.
- 1:08:50Thomas Modly: I mean, think about this particular change over the last five years.
- 1:08:53Thomas Modly: Now, right, we're going from a President Trump to a President Biden, to a President Trump again.
- 1:09:01Thomas Modly: The types of people that they're bringing, they will have brought in, are going to be very, very different.
- 1:09:07Thomas Modly: You know, philosophically, managerially, just, you know, experience-wise, it's just going to be so, you know, for Admiral Frank Heddy and General Smith.
- 1:09:21Thomas Modly: I mean, you know I pray for them because it's it's going to be tough dealing with somebody new again.
- 1:09:29Thomas Modly: So we'll see, we'll see.
- 1:09:32Thomas Modly: I think you know they're very skilled.
- 1:09:33Thomas Modly: They're very skilled people, they're smart people.
- 1:09:46Ponch Rivera: But I think the department as a whole, the Department of the Navy as a whole, requires a little bit more continuity at the very, very top.
- 1:09:51Ponch Rivera: Based on your experiences, all your experiences, what lessons could you impart on them about how to transform their organization, as the external landscape is changing so rapidly right now, how can they do that?
- 1:10:04Thomas Modly: Well for those that need to.
- 1:10:05Thomas Modly: I mean a lot of them.
- 1:10:06Thomas Modly: I think a lot of private sector organizations have done an exceptional job at creating all those agile characteristics that I've talked about.
- 1:10:12Thomas Modly: At creating all those agile characteristics that I've talked about.
- 1:10:15Thomas Modly: There's a lot of elements to that, you know, with respect to creating transparent organizations, collaborative, I think I have eight specific elements that I talk about and I would say look at those elements and not just think about how important they are, but figure out a way to measure how your organization is actually doing on those parameters and I think you'll see a difference.
- 1:10:43Thomas Modly: So it's really all about I mean, I'll go to my grave saying this is all about the agile mind, how you create organizations that can learn and can quickly adapt to unpredictability.
- 1:10:55Thomas Modly: That's that's going to be the key to success in everything, including government, government agencies, military, et cetera.
- 1:11:03Thomas Modly: So there's lots of different paths to that.
- 1:11:06Thomas Modly: I know like Dr Saul Don has written extensively on this and has great case examples of how to do that and who's good at and who's not good at it.
- 1:11:17Ponch Rivera: But you know the ones that aren't good at it….
- 1:11:19Ponch Rivera: I want to pause on.
- 1:11:19Ponch Rivera: I want to put a pin in that for a second.
- 1:11:21Ponch Rivera: So on Donald Soule's book, you look at him.
- 1:11:23Ponch Rivera: He references the military, or leadership lessons from the military for surviving in turbulent environments, which is kind of ironic, don't you think?
- 1:11:31Ponch Rivera: I mean, I think it's in his book the Age of Turbulence where he writes about that.
- 1:11:41Thomas Modly: Yeah, I think well, okay, so the military you got to.
- 1:11:42Thomas Modly: I think you sort of have to divorce the military from the bureaucracy that supports the military.
- 1:11:45Thomas Modly: So at the unit level, I think you see a lot of this, I think you see a lot of this innovation and so on.
- 1:11:50Thomas Modly: You know, I know this is maybe anecdotal, but I think it is true the really innovative, innovative folks they get out, they leave at 06 because they see what happens as you get higher up in terms of how that gets stymied.
- 1:12:04Thomas Modly: And yet and they were excited and energized when it was happening at the 0405 level um, down at the, you know, down at those levels and you see it happening there, um, but it gets it.
- 1:12:16Thomas Modly: It gets stymied as you get higher.
- 1:12:17Thomas Modly: So you know that that's one of the things I don't know how you fix.
- 1:12:22Thomas Modly: Fix that problem because, frankly, for a lot of these 06s these are, you know, 05, 06 people who are super talented, the opportunities for them outside of the military are, you know, they're tremendous.
- 1:12:32Thomas Modly: And they're even more tremendous now from a financial reward perspective than they were 70 years ago, you know, in the 60s and 70s, where people were transitioning from the military to private sector.
- 1:12:45Thomas Modly: It was nice, it was a nice bump, but now it's, you know, it can be a significant life, changing generational, changing type of financial reward, changing generational, changing type of financial reward.
- 1:12:59Thomas Modly: And so people get, you know, people get allured by that, and that just doesn't exist in the military.
- 1:13:02Thomas Modly: I mean, I tell people all the time that don't really understand the government, um, that I was running ostensibly a million person organization with a 250 billion dollar a year budget, with billions of dollars of weapons, nuclear plants, nuclear power plants, nuclear weapons, and my salary was 168 000 a year.
- 1:13:29Thomas Modly: And they there are a lot of people like who, donors?
- 1:13:33Thomas Modly: They're like that's, that's impossible, that, what do you mean?
- 1:13:36Thomas Modly: That's it.
- 1:13:37Thomas Modly: That's the top level of the SES scale right now for political appointments.
- 1:13:41Thomas Modly: I'm not saying money is the draw for everybody, but if you're a 40-year-old, 05, 06, and you're looking at taking care of your family, the opportunities outside are just, you know, tremendously different.
- 1:13:56Thomas Modly: Um, and so I can see why, why they may take, take a path, take that, take a path about you know we talk a lot of us did it for duty reasons and for uh, defending our nation.
- 1:14:09Mark McGrath: you give one of your vectors was about bob feller, the uh cleveland indians pitcher that I believe was aboard the USS North Carolina.
- 1:14:19Mark McGrath: I've taken my boys on that ship and there's a birth, like the chief's country or whatever.
- 1:14:26Mark McGrath: There's a monument to him.
- 1:14:27Mark McGrath: But he had no regrets of doing that and he said that's what you do and he could have had a lot more wins than he had and a much more successful career than he had, but he felt duty-bound and obligated to serve.
- 1:14:41Thomas Modly: Well, it's interesting you mentioned that because I'm on the board of the Bob Feller Active Valor Foundation and one of the missions of that foundation is to teach young people that story and stories of other.
- 1:14:53Thomas Modly: There are a lot of major league baseball players who left, uh their their baseball careers to go serve in world war ii.
- 1:15:01Thomas Modly: Uh, yogi barrow is another real famous example of that ted williams.
- 1:15:05Thomas Modly: And so what we're trying to do, the foundation, is get into, particularly into the inner city, in a partnership with boys and girls club to teach these kids these lessons about service and sacrifice and how you create a legacy for yourself and for your country.
- 1:15:19Thomas Modly: They're not getting those lessons taught, they're just not.
- 1:15:24Thomas Modly: And so I think the society and I won't get too much into sort of culture issues, but I think the society has shifted uh significantly towards um image and and money and um celebrity and all those things and these little devices have not helped with that.
- 1:15:49Thomas Modly: You know these things that people carry around with them, and so kids aren't getting exposed to that as much and so um.
- 1:15:57Thomas Modly: But also, I would wonder I, I mean I I can't question bob feller because he's a hero of mine.
- 1:16:02Thomas Modly: I grew up in cleveland, so he's a.
- 1:16:03Thomas Modly: He played for the indians.
- 1:16:05Thomas Modly: Um, these baseball players, back then they were hype.
- 1:16:09Thomas Modly: They were, they were making decent money, but they're not making the kind of money these guys are making.
- 1:16:14Thomas Modly: So would Garrett Cole walk away from $50 million a year to go fight in the Navy?
- 1:16:21Thomas Modly: I kind of doubt it.
- 1:16:22Thomas Modly: So you haven't seen a lot of examples of it, other than the guy for the Cardinals, the Arizona Cardinals, who did that, but not a whole lot of examples of that.
- 1:16:35Mark McGrath: You mentioned everybody having a device.
- 1:16:37Mark McGrath: What was the compounded effect?
- 1:16:39Mark McGrath: Back to the TR issue incident what was the compounded effect of sailors having their own smartphones and access to Twitter and Facebook and everything while they're gone?
- 1:16:49Mark McGrath: And then all the moms' groups or the spouse groups or whatever, amplifying the story through social networking.
- 1:16:56Mark McGrath: What effect did that have on the situation?
- 1:17:01Thomas Modly: It had a significant impact on it because it did the way the stories were being promulgated.
- 1:17:09Thomas Modly: It made it look like we didn't care that the Pentagon wasn't engaged.
- 1:17:13Thomas Modly: The President didn't care.
- 1:17:14Thomas Modly: He was mismanaging the crisis already.
- 1:17:17Thomas Modly: Here's just another example.
- 1:17:19Thomas Modly: So all that stuff just accelerated it.
- 1:17:22Thomas Modly: And you know, there were sailors on the ship who you know it was uncomfortable for the sailors on the ship clearly Because but eventually you know, they all got off.
- 1:17:31Thomas Modly: They had a command center.
- 1:17:33Thomas Modly: They were monitoring, you know, their sailors.
- 1:17:34Thomas Modly: They had an command center, they were monitoring their sailors.
- 1:17:36Thomas Modly: They had an app for the sailors that they were monitoring their temperatures.
- 1:17:39Thomas Modly: They knew exactly when they were given meals.
- 1:17:41Thomas Modly: They had a whole transportation system set up to take them to various places and so on, and it was pretty remarkable, the ship went back to sea within a couple of weeks.
- 1:17:49Thomas Modly: I mean, really that was a really amazing logistics effort.
- 1:17:53Thomas Modly: And those folks on Guam who managed that whole thing, or the Unsung Heroes of the whole thing, I mean they did a phenomenal job and they just sort of no one ever said anything about it.
- 1:18:04Mark McGrath: Doesn't get clicks or likes, except for me, and my book.
- 1:18:06Thomas Modly: They were the heroes in my book but, yeah, they did a phenomenal job.
- 1:18:10Thomas Modly: So, yeah, I think that you know, but that it does accelerate and it becomes dangerous.
- 1:18:14Thomas Modly: I can tell you, you know, we had, we had protection for three months after I left.
- 1:18:18Mark McGrath: Yeah.
- 1:18:19Thomas Modly: Because of the some of the threats that we had and things like that.
- 1:18:22Mark McGrath: Well, we talk a lot about, you know, the medium being the message, and we talk a lot about, you know, asymmetric information environments, and that's something that leaders have to contend with.
- 1:18:30Mark McGrath: That it's not just the balance sheet or the stock price or whatever.
- 1:18:34Mark McGrath: Not just the balance sheet or the stock price or whatever.
- 1:18:36Mark McGrath: There's other elements in the complexity of things, especially the social networking.
- 1:18:42Mark McGrath: The customer gets a vote, but also people that aren't customers get a vote, as long as they're communicating and they're passing information, whether it's accurate or not, via these things.
- 1:18:54Mark McGrath: It's another thing that you had a real first world example there of how a leader has to deal with that, and it's not unusual for our own clients and others to deal with those sorts of things too, and you can't always see that threat as readily as others.
- 1:19:07Thomas Modly: Yeah, I would say that there's no question that I underestimated what the impact of that, but it didn't really.
- 1:19:16Thomas Modly: It wasn't something I really thought about when I made the decision.
- 1:19:19Thomas Modly: It was, you know, my view was I have to make the best decision for the Navy in this moment and that's what I'm going to do.
- 1:19:26Thomas Modly: So but I was a little bit, I can tell you I was taken back by the response.
- 1:19:32Thomas Modly: So it's, you know, it's humbling when it happens, for sure.
- 1:19:40Ponch Rivera: I want to switch gears a little bit and talk about something you brought up in your book and that has to do with suicide.
- 1:19:45Ponch Rivera: You saw increasing numbers of suicide on active duty and we know that estimates are between 22 and 44 veterans take their lives each day.
- 1:19:53Ponch Rivera: I just want to get your thoughts on what you were trying to do when you were secretary of the Navy and under secretary, and what should be happening now.
- 1:20:05Thomas Modly: Boy.
- 1:20:06Thomas Modly: This is a.
- 1:20:06Thomas Modly: This is one of those problems that is a much broader societal problem.
- 1:20:11Thomas Modly: It is exacerbated in the military, I think, and I think the statistics do show that.
- 1:20:18Thomas Modly: But the statistics also skew towards the demographic in the military also, where it's young, you know, largely young males that's, you know that's a high demographic for suicide.
- 1:20:30Thomas Modly: We did a lot, we had a lot of programs, a lot of suicide prevention type programs.
- 1:20:38Thomas Modly: Um, ultimately, what I tried to do and I think I did a whole vector, I did a whole vector on this one week Um, it also ultimately came down, comes down to sailors and Marines looking out for each other and not detaching from each other and really understanding what's going on and talking to people and um, but even then, um, suicide is is a big mystery and you know, I just met a couple the other day who lost a nephew and uh, and there were no signs.
- 1:21:08Thomas Modly: You know they just it's decision that someone makes and then they take it.
- 1:21:13Thomas Modly: So you know we can get philosophical about why that's happening.
- 1:21:17Thomas Modly: Um, I think that there is a lot of, there's a lot of general despair.
- 1:21:22Thomas Modly: I think there's a lot of uh stuff that's exacerbated by social media and uh that drives to depression and um, and I think that you know lack of hope, lack of faith, lack of religion, that all contributes to it as well.
- 1:21:38Thomas Modly: Just the waning influence of those things in the culture are part of it to scare people about things, and so there's um, because that sells, and um, so there's a lot of uh, hysteria, there's a lot of um, doom and gloom talk, and I think people are depressed, get depressed about that and don't see their role, don't see their purpose and um, so they end up taking their lives and it's uh, and you know, I think that's probably the case more often than some of the post-traumatic things that we're seeing from people that were in theater.
- 1:22:20Thomas Modly: It's just sort of the, the despair that people have just in existence, and I think our demographic in the military is sort of right there in the prime spot of of people that are doing this these days.
- 1:22:32Thomas Modly: It's much heavily, it's very heavily skewed towards men, young men, in a certain age bracket, and that's our demographic.
- 1:22:41Mark McGrath: Not long ago we had Tom Wright on, who runs Project Brazen to talk about.
- 1:22:47Mark McGrath: Yeah, I listened to his.
- 1:22:48Thomas Modly: I listened to it you listened to the episode.
- 1:22:49Mark McGrath: Yeah, I wanted to get your thoughts on what we discussed.
- 1:22:52Mark McGrath: We'd be remiss if we didn't ask about the Fat Leonard scandal from your vantage point at the Department of the Navy at the top.
- 1:23:06Thomas Modly: Yeah, boy, that's emblematic of a larger cultural problem I think we had in the PAC fleet and that probably existed even know, even before fat leonard came around, and it's just one of those.
- 1:23:20Thomas Modly: I think it's just one of those.
- 1:23:22Thomas Modly: You know, when you talk about um boyd's definition of, of um, what is it of evil and of corruption?
- 1:23:31Thomas Modly: Evil and corruption, yeah, yeah, I mean there, those are pretty, uh, pretty good, apt descriptions about what happened in those situations.
- 1:23:38Thomas Modly: Um, people just accept things as they are.
- 1:23:41Thomas Modly: Um, there's also, you know, there's also a little bit of that.
- 1:23:45Thomas Modly: You know, this is how we do things in the navy, this is how things are done, this is how we do things in asia, this is how we do things here, and you know, until someone says, well, wait a minute, why is that?
- 1:23:56Thomas Modly: You know, I use that example in my book about I think it's in the last vector, vector 19 um, another great musical movie reference from um, from uh, one of my favorite films um, where, where, um, the uh it's about.
- 1:24:15Thomas Modly: It's a, it's a, it's a.
- 1:24:16Thomas Modly: It's a film about a rock band, a fake rock band spinal tap, spinal tap yeah I'm sorry.
- 1:24:22Thomas Modly: Yeah, it's in your moment.
- 1:24:23Mark McGrath: There it's it's in the vector, I read it.
- 1:24:25Thomas Modly: Yeah, so when he's talking about how his amplifiers go to 11 yeah, and they're like, well, why don't you just make each one louder instead of just taking make one a little louder and two a little louder and two a little louder?
- 1:24:36Thomas Modly: And the guy just looks at him and is like, well, at least go to 11.
- 1:24:40Thomas Modly: You know, that's kind of the answer.
- 1:24:43Thomas Modly: People ask like, well, why are we doing that in the Navy?
- 1:24:45Thomas Modly: You know, this is how we do things.
- 1:24:47Thomas Modly: Well, why are we doing that in the Navy?
- 1:24:48Thomas Modly: And the answer is well, because this is how we do it in the Navy.
- 1:24:52Thomas Modly: You know there's no well, why don't we just do it like this way, which is probably better?
- 1:24:57Thomas Modly: And the answer is well, because this is the way we do it in the Navy, you know.
- 1:25:01Thomas Modly: And so I sort of my my final message to the department was you know, next time someone says that to you, just sort of smile and say these, go to 11.
- 1:25:13Thomas Modly: And then, you know, try and think of a better way to do it than the way they're telling you to do it.
- 1:25:16Thomas Modly: So I don't know, it's culture, it's deep and ingrained in the culture and it's hard to break.
- 1:25:36Thomas Modly: And it's kind of ironic in a way, because I talked before about how the entire senior levels in the military have become very risk-averse averse, I think and very caught up in legalities and things like that, and yet they allowed that somehow to happen at the same time, which is very incongruent for me.
- 1:25:46Thomas Modly: So either they just didn't know, or they looked the other way, or, um, they felt like, well, this is just the kind of way we do things here and it's no one's ever gotten in trouble before and and so there's nothing wrong with it.
- 1:25:57Thomas Modly: So I think that's part of it.
- 1:25:59Thomas Modly: It's just sort of that complacency and acceptance and so on and so forth.
- 1:26:05Ponch Rivera: You know we talk a lot about systems drive behaviors, the way the system is driven and you know complex adaptive systems, things emerge out of that.
- 1:26:12Ponch Rivera: As a young I think it was a Lieutenant JG at the time for squadron ordered up hey, go take these aircraft and go dump gas over the you know whiskey area and come back refuel, go do it.
- 1:26:24Ponch Rivera: I'm like what?
- 1:26:24Ponch Rivera: And it's well, that's how we get money, right, because we have to spend it to get it.
- 1:26:28Ponch Rivera: And that was.
- 1:26:29Ponch Rivera: You know, that's a system driving a behavior.
- 1:26:30Ponch Rivera: Again, To my mind, it's wrong.
- 1:26:33Ponch Rivera: I'm like well, if we don't have to fly, we don't have to fly, but why are we going to dump gas, right?
- 1:26:36Ponch Rivera: So systems are always driving behaviors.
- 1:26:39Ponch Rivera: In my view, of my experience in the Navy the last four years in the Navy which were not that fun, by the way I couldn't wait to get out.
- 1:26:46Ponch Rivera: I snuck out the fastest I could.
- 1:26:47Ponch Rivera: I was like I'm out of here.
- 1:26:48Ponch Rivera: You're telling me that if I have differing extremist, I'm done.
- 1:26:58Ponch Rivera: You know, I'm out of here.
- 1:26:58Ponch Rivera: The system is driving behaviors again.
- 1:26:59Ponch Rivera: So my point behind that is uh, it's not bad people there aren't I mean every.
- 1:27:02Mark McGrath: You might get a few in there, but it's a bad system that's driving these behaviors and and I just want to get your ideas on that, or if that's what you can add one thing to that, because so the the defense fiscal year is October 1 to 930 next year and, as you both know, so our listeners don't know, but I always thought that in the Marine Corps, september was one of the more fun months, because we had to go out and shoot and expend everything we could get our hands on that, everybody, by the way, the 11 months prior to that, hey don't waste ammo, hey don't go so fast.
- 1:27:36Mark McGrath: The 11 months prior to that, hey don't waste ammo, hey don't go so fast.
- 1:27:38Mark McGrath: And then, at the end of the year, you have this stockpile that you had to dump or else you wouldn't get it the next fiscal year.
- 1:27:43Thomas Modly: So to Potts' point, I mean that's yeah, that's the whole.
- 1:27:46Thomas Modly: You know that's one of the issues with the whole budget process I talk about in the book and that no one goes into that budget price process thinking about that.
- 1:27:58Thomas Modly: No one goes into that budget price process thinking about, wow, what shouldn't I do next year that I did this year?
- 1:28:01Thomas Modly: You know it's all about how can I do what I did last year and then do some more stuff next year.
- 1:28:05Thomas Modly: No one goes into it thinking the other way around, and the federal budget doesn't look at it that way either.
- 1:28:12Thomas Modly: So it's, you're right.
- 1:28:15Thomas Modly: I mean, that's the system that's been created and so it does create those behaviors.
- 1:28:18Thomas Modly: And then, unfortunately, some of the financial problems that we have the lack of transparency that our IT systems are unable to provide or unable to provide for us in terms of where's the money and who's spending it and where was it and who spent it on what, like that, and the inability to audit.
- 1:28:40Thomas Modly: That just reinforces the behavior for people to hide.
- 1:28:44Thomas Modly: They hide, they hide money, they hide parts, they hide all kinds of things, um, because there's no incentive otherwise, uh, to do so.
- 1:28:52Thomas Modly: There's never been a, you know, the closest thing I've seen in my time there where a commander at the very, very top of the organization said we're going to get an audit and made it part of we're going to get a clean financial audit and made it part of his objective, and everyone understood was the commandant of the Marine Corpsic smith, and they actually did it this year in the marine corps, the first military service ever to get a clean audit opinion on their financial audit states.
- 1:29:21Thomas Modly: And you know, I, no one else has ever done it and I, frankly, it would be impossible to do it right now, given the systems, environment and that's a whole other discussion we can have, but no one's made it that big a priority.
- 1:29:38Thomas Modly: But what comes with making it that priority is then the system and environment underneath it has to be created to allow that to happen and then that gives you visibility and frankly, that's what people don't want.
- 1:29:51Thomas Modly: They don't want to have that transparency and that visibility because they can't make it.
- 1:29:55Thomas Modly: They don't want.
- 1:29:55Thomas Modly: I don't want to have that transparency, that visibility, because they can't make.
- 1:29:58Thomas Modly: I went through this um when I was trying to get five to seven billion dollars from secretary esper to keep us going on the path towards 355 ships in 2019, early 2020, and he was, like you know where am I going to get the money from?
- 1:30:10Thomas Modly: And I said, well, like you're not really asking me that question because I can tell you how, about taking it from the Army?
- 1:30:17Thomas Modly: Because they wouldn't want to hear that Everyone's got their piece of the pie.
- 1:30:23Thomas Modly: And I said, okay, fine, I'll go back.
- 1:30:26Thomas Modly: I said, if I can find it five to seven, will you give me another five to seven?
- 1:30:30Thomas Modly: He said okay.
- 1:30:31Thomas Modly: So I went back to the Navy and said we're going to find five to $7 billion in our $250 billion a year budget 220 at the time, their budget and it was like I was asking them to kill their firstborn.
- 1:30:47Thomas Modly: There was a writer who writes for Forbes online who called it Secretary Mowdley's St Valentine's Day Massacre.
- 1:30:54Thomas Modly: It was $5 to $7 billion from a $220 billion a year budget.
- 1:30:56Thomas Modly: Uh, secretary modley, saint valentine's day massacre.
- 1:30:56Thomas Modly: It was five to seven billion dollars from a 220 billion dollar year budget.
- 1:31:00Thomas Modly: That that's like less than you know three percent or something like that, and I've been in businesses that cut 30 percent.
- 1:31:07Thomas Modly: Like like that, we, our ability.
- 1:31:11Thomas Modly: I mean it was.
- 1:31:12Thomas Modly: It was like there's no way we can find that.
- 1:31:13Thomas Modly: I said, no, we're gonna find it was like there's no way we're going to find that.
- 1:31:15Thomas Modly: I said no, we're going to find it because it's there.
- 1:31:16Thomas Modly: I guarantee you it's there.
- 1:31:17Thomas Modly: Finding it's not the hard part, it's getting rid of it or shifting it.
- 1:31:21Thomas Modly: That makes it difficult Because there's a constituency tied to every single ballot.
- 1:31:30Mark McGrath: And it makes it really tough to move it around.
- 1:31:31Mark McGrath: There's two interesting things I guess as we wind down I think of as it relates directly to Boyd.
- 1:31:37Mark McGrath: In his biography by Robert Quorum.
- 1:31:38Mark McGrath: There's a story where Pierre Spray, who was instrumental with the A-10 and other things, who was a reformer, came to the office and he heard Boyd shouting on the phone I'm happy to give your boss the brief.
- 1:31:49Mark McGrath: It's six hours.
- 1:31:50Mark McGrath: And he says well, whoever's on the other line said I don't have six hours, I have one.
- 1:31:55Mark McGrath: He goes the brief is six hours.
- 1:31:57Mark McGrath: And then he says hey, since your boss is so pressed on time, I'm going to save him a ton of time.
- 1:32:03Mark McGrath: Zero, you're not getting the brief.
- 1:32:06Mark McGrath: And he hung up and he told Spray.
- 1:32:08Mark McGrath: He goes yeah, that was the exec for the CNO and that's how the Navy never got to hear Boyd or patterns of conflict, at least, not to say that.
- 1:32:21Mark McGrath: That's the reason that a lot of these things that we're talking about, these cultural manifestations, not to say.
- 1:32:25Mark McGrath: But it is interesting how someone like Boyd that offered that kind of an insight of a Reformation idea, a lot of those things could have been avoided if people understood that better.
- 1:32:39Mark McGrath: And I think the other Boyd tie-in is his very famous speech to be or to do that.
- 1:32:44Mark McGrath: Every person, certainly in the military you come to a crossroads and we've kind of hit on a few of these things where you can go one path and you'll be.
- 1:32:52Mark McGrath: You know, you'll get all the stars and have all the club memberships and you're a team player and everybody loves you.
- 1:32:57Mark McGrath: You're not going to rock the boat, you're not going to do anything to upset the apple cart.
- 1:33:01Mark McGrath: On the other side there's the doers, there's the.
- 1:33:04Mark McGrath: We're going to do rather than be, and we're going to be wildly unpopular and we're going to be radical, but we're the ones that are actually going to affect change.
- 1:33:14Mark McGrath: And that was his admonition to young officers was at some point you come to that crossroads and there's no turning back.
- 1:33:20Mark McGrath: You go down the one lane.
- 1:33:21Mark McGrath: You can't reverse yourself and go back on the other lane.
- 1:33:28Thomas Modly: More often than not, yeah, I talk about that a lot in my book too.
- 1:33:32Thomas Modly: Not going to Washington to be something, but go there to do something.
- 1:33:37Mark McGrath: Now the synergies of the book.
- 1:33:38Mark McGrath: For anybody that follows our work and works with us professionally, they definitely want to pick this up, because this is a really phenomenal vantage point of really a side of things that we don't often see.
- 1:33:50Mark McGrath: I mean, most people out there they see the blue angels or they can turn on the news and see when there's a conflict going on or something like that, but what's actually going on behind the system and the decisions that are made that have a pretty profound effect on things?
- 1:34:04Mark McGrath: This is a really great insight.
- 1:34:07Thomas Modly: Well, I appreciate you guys both taking the time to read it.
- 1:34:10Thomas Modly: It's not short, I know, but I tried to make it interesting and I try to make it a little bit different.
- 1:34:16Thomas Modly: And, um, like I said, there's I I do reference a lot of song lyrics at the beginning of the chapters.
- 1:34:23Thomas Modly: And, um, I, my kids, asked me why I did that and I said, well, because I wanted it to be relatable to younger people.
- 1:34:29Thomas Modly: And they said, dad, like these songs are like 35 years old.
- 1:34:33Thomas Modly: So I was like, well, hey, you know, it's my frame of reference.
- 1:34:37Thomas Modly: What can I say?
- 1:34:38Ponch Rivera: Yeah, your Linkin Park reference.
- 1:34:40Ponch Rivera: I'm like I know this song.
- 1:34:43Thomas Modly: Yeah Well, I commend to your listeners if they want to hear, just learn all about Vector as a book.
- 1:34:51Thomas Modly: If they listen to the Vector Songs podcast on Spotify, I go through all 25 songs chronologically in the book and you get a really good sense for what the book's about in terms of why I chose the songs and the tone that they set and like, for example, we were talking about Pieces of the Pie, I use that song by Pink Floyd Money in their discussion of everyone wants their piece of the pie, and that that's the whole chapter about the budget process and so on.
- 1:35:19Thomas Modly: So it's an interesting way to take a sort of a journey through the book without having to pour through 500 pages.
- 1:35:25Thomas Modly: And then I was able to thankfully find an illustrator who had done some work for Marvell comics and he did all the illustrations in the book.
- 1:35:33Thomas Modly: Yeah, they are cool yeah.
- 1:35:36Mark McGrath: I think also to the hero and villain aspect too.
- 1:35:39Mark McGrath: I mean, it's a very readable book.
- 1:35:41Mark McGrath: Tell us the type of things that you're doing these days.
- 1:35:47Thomas Modly: Well, I'm working on another book right now, but it's very different from this one, although thematically I'm hoping it'll be relevant to cultural issues that are going on.
- 1:35:58Thomas Modly: But it's a historical novel about some things that happened in hungary and yugoslavia when my parents were growing up, and so that's that's been kind of a fun little project.
- 1:36:07Thomas Modly: Then I'm I'm also um doing some consulting um and I'm on a couple of boards.
- 1:36:14Thomas Modly: I'm on a board of a small drone manufacturer called Dragonfly that we're hoping will reap the benefits of this pending legislation that's going to keep DGI from selling drones to law enforcement and military and public safety here in the US.
- 1:36:37Thomas Modly: For those who don't know, that's the largest drone manufacturer in the world.
- 1:36:40Thomas Modly: They're chinese-based and they they pretty much dominate the market here in the.
- 1:36:44Thomas Modly: They dominate the global market.
- 1:36:45Thomas Modly: I think they have 70 market share um, but there there was a move to start using them in law enforcement and public safety and I think there's a lot of risks to that and and I think the Congress is recognizing that, so North American manufacturers like Dragonfly.
- 1:37:00Thomas Modly: I think we're going to have a good opportunity to penetrate that market.
- 1:37:05Thomas Modly: Also, doing just some speaking engagements around the book itself, and I'm going to be starting up my own little blog spot as well on Substack, which will probably do a weekly opinion piece type thing, just like my opinion man every week for people who are interested.
- 1:37:25Thomas Modly: But I'll probably hit on a bunch of topics from politics, culture, defense, music you know that type of stuff?
- 1:37:36Mark McGrath: Well, we'll certainly recommend it on our sub stack when uh when it gets, when it gets up and running.
- 1:37:41Ponch Rivera: Yeah, and if you ever want to go live on X with us, we'll start doing that here soon.
- 1:37:45Thomas Modly: I'll be uh, what are you guys going to be doing?
- 1:37:48Ponch Rivera: We have our own X channel.
- 1:37:49Ponch Rivera: We'll be going live on any just about any time we want to.
- 1:37:52Ponch Rivera: So I think the shift from podcast to that near-term engagement or real-time engagement is going to be a real great way to build networks.
- 1:38:04Thomas Modly: Yeah, cool.
- 1:38:05Ponch Rivera: That sounds great.
- 1:38:06Mark McGrath: Yeah, so well, tom, for the purpose of the podcast we're going to say thanks.
- 1:38:10Mark McGrath: We're going to highly recommend that everybody that listens to us pick up a copy of Vectors, uh take a lot of notes.
- 1:38:17Mark McGrath: It's laid out very well.
- 1:38:18Mark McGrath: There's uh great margins on it to take, uh to take notes, as I found as I went through it.
- 1:38:24Thomas Modly: And uh, we appreciate you coming on and uh, can I say one more thing about the book absolutely, um, just so 100 of the proceeds that I make from this book I'm donating, and I have donated to charities that support navy and Marine Corps veterans and their families.
- 1:38:38Thomas Modly: So if your listeners want to help me with that mission, I'd appreciate that.
- 1:38:43Thomas Modly: I'm not making any money on this at all.
- 1:38:45Thomas Modly: I'm losing a lot, but it's a mission for me to use whatever proceeds and so I've been doing that and will continue to do that to use whatever proceeds, and so I've been doing that and we'll continue to do that.
- 1:38:58Mark McGrath: Well, as a Marine in a in a, in a Navy flyer here, I think, as a Marine with two Navy flyers here on this podcast, I think we can all, we can all relate to that.
- 1:39:06Mark McGrath: So Semper Fidelis anchors away and beat army.
- 1:39:10Thomas Modly: Yeah, exactly, it's not looking good this year, but we'll see.
- 1:39:16Mark McGrath: We'll see.
- 1:39:16Thomas Modly: All right, stay with us.
- 1:39:16Thomas Modly: Great to meet you guys and thanks for your time.
- 1:39:18Thomas Modly: Thanks so much.
- 1:39:19Thomas Modly: Okay, see ya.
- 1:39:21Mark McGrath: Bye, okay.