Latest / eMotors: Electric Revolution / The Car Enthusiast and the Electric Vehicle Transition
Transcript
- 0:09OK, so if you spent basically any time on a car for him,
- 0:13right? Or maybe listened in at a Sunday
- 0:16meet up. Oh yeah, at the comment section.
- 0:18You know, the fight it's always screaming about, like piston
- 0:20slap versus the silent instant torque thing?
- 0:23Yeah. Today, we're diving deep into
- 0:25your sources on this. Well, this great automotive
- 0:29culture war internal combustion engine ICE versus the electric
- 0:35vehicle. The EV, the polarization is,
- 0:39it's really incredible, isn't it?
- 0:40It feels very much like an US versus them battle, totally.
- 0:43But the reality, and this is what your sources really bring
- 0:45out. It's just it's far more complex
- 0:47than that, right? So our mission here is to try
- 0:49and filter through some of that noise.
- 0:51We want to understand the legitimate criticisms,
- 0:54technical, environmental, emotional against current EVs.
- 0:59But also maybe uncover something crucial.
- 1:00Exactly that. The people actually building
- 1:02this electric future, well, often they're just as passionate
- 1:05about cars, proper cars, as their loudest critics.
- 1:08Yeah, we've got a really fantastic stack of material
- 1:11here. Stuff from engineers at the, you
- 1:12know, cutting edge EV companies, environmental journalists, even
- 1:16some early EV adopters. It gives a pretty rounded view.
- 1:19A real holistic perspective. So let's maybe unpack this by
- 1:22starting where that emotional argument really kicks off.
- 1:25Yeah, this assumption that if you build an EV, you must
- 1:28somehow hate traditional cars. That's the core myth, isn't it?
- 1:32The one we really need to take apart right at the start.
- 1:34Yeah, because the sources, they really paint that US versus them
- 1:37thing as largely well maybe a myth perhaps perpetuated by
- 1:41Internet arguments. Right, the anonymity effect.
- 1:43Because the very people designing the next wave of
- 1:46electric car, you know, engineers, designers at places
- 1:49like Lucid or Porsche, Yeah, they're often not anti IC at
- 1:53all. Far from it.
- 1:54I found those specific examples really compelling, like we're
- 1:57talking about EV engineers who personally own what was it like
- 2:02Lotus Elise's old BMW M cars? Even a classic Lotus S breed S11
- 2:07source mentioned Wow. So their passion isn't really
- 2:10about the fuel source itself. No.
- 2:13It's tied to engineering, to finding clever solutions to
- 2:16performance, to dynamics. It really connects back to that
- 2:19great quote from the late Ford chief engineer Richard Perry.
- 2:22Jones, the one about the oil age.
- 2:24Yeah, the oil age isn't going to end because we've run out of
- 2:27oil. The oil age will end because we
- 2:29will have found a better solution.
- 2:32It's perfect. It is because that's what drives
- 2:35good engineering, isn't it? The hunt for the better
- 2:37solution, not just sticking to dogma, makes sense.
- 2:40And let's be honest, from a pure engineering standpoint, thermal
- 2:43efficiency, volumetric efficiency, power density, The
- 2:47electric powertrain is just, well, it's miles ahead of what
- 2:51ICE can realistically achieve. OK, deficiency.
- 2:54I get that. Yeah, that excites an engineer.
- 2:56Hugely. But isn't that just looking at
- 2:58the You know the spreadsheet specs aren't enthusiasts, right?
- 3:02When they argue that pure efficiency, however impressive,
- 3:05doesn't always translate into well into soul.
- 3:08No. Yes, the soul argument.
- 3:10When you're driving, don't you want to feel something more than
- 3:13just efficient movement? That really is the absolute
- 3:16heart of the enthusiast grief, isn't it?
- 3:18When car lovers talk about soul, what they're really mourning is
- 3:22that that emotional deficit. They miss the noise, the
- 3:26soundtrack. They miss the vibrations coming
- 3:28through the seat and the steering wheel.
- 3:30The way an engine builds power. Exactly that crescendo as it
- 3:34climbs the Rev range and the actual physical interaction of,
- 3:37you know, changing gear, that whole mechanical dance.
- 3:40That's the essence of ICE appeal for many.
- 3:43It really is. And mechanically, the sources
- 3:45pointed out what they call the uniformity problem, which I
- 3:48thought was interesting. Explain.
- 3:49That a bit. Well, combustion cars are just
- 3:51so wonderfully diverse, aren't they?
- 3:53Think about the difference between like a high revving 4
- 3:56cylinder and a big lazy V8. Or a flat 6 or V12.
- 4:00Yeah, they all feel different, sound different, deliver power
- 4:03differently. Plus you've got gearboxes,
- 4:05manuals, DCTS, punctuation, the whole experience.
- 4:08Exactly, but with almost all current EVs the power delivery
- 4:13is fundamentally the same. Right, that instant jolt.
- 4:16And get that massive instant punch off the line, which is
- 4:19impressive, yes. Then super rapid acceleration.
- 4:23And then it just kind of tails off in terms of drama, doesn't
- 4:26it? Because there are no mechanical
- 4:27stages, no shifts to break it up.
- 4:29So that lack of mechanical complexity, it's a feature for
- 4:33everyday driving maybe? For utility, absolutely smooth,
- 4:37seamless. But for the enthusiast who wants
- 4:39engagement, it feels like a bug. A big one.
- 4:43It can feel like something major is missing, yes.
- 4:45So if you. Take away the inherent drama,
- 4:48the manufacturers then feel like they have to what?
- 4:51Inject it back in artificially. We're seeing that now, aren't
- 4:54we? Oh, absolutely.
- 4:55It's all about the gimmicks. Sometimes, like Hyundai and
- 4:57Toyota, they're experimenting with EVs that try to simulate
- 5:00gear shifts. Really.
- 5:01Even fake engine vibrations. Some are trying that, yes, and
- 5:04sound is huge now. Every performance EV has
- 5:07synthesized noise. Porsche with the TICAN.
- 5:10They actually record the real electric motor noises OK, but
- 5:14then they heavily remix and process them to create this
- 5:17specific signature sound. Which is kind of funny, isn't
- 5:20it? Right?
- 5:21Because an IC car wasn't designed to be noisy and vibey
- 5:24for entertainment, it just was complex and mechanical.
- 5:28He's a byproduct. And now car makers are trying to
- 5:30reverse engineer that accidental entertainment factor.
- 5:33It shows they know, doesn't it? They know that just being a
- 5:36silent, fast appliance isn't quite enough for that
- 5:39performance enthusiast market. Proves the emotional deficit is
- 5:43a real thing they need to address.
- 5:44Definitely. OK, let's shift gears a bit from
- 5:47the emotional stuff to the really pragmatic, practical
- 5:52side, because even, you know, big EV advocates admit there are
- 5:57significant hurdles with the tech right now for sure.
- 5:59And the sources kept coming back to one massive issue.
- 6:02Wait, just sheer weight? Batteries are energy dense, but
- 6:06they're also physically dense. They're heavy, and that
- 6:09dramatically impacts how a car feels and handles.
- 6:12You saw that specific example, the Audi E Tron GT.
- 6:14Right. What did the source say?
- 6:15It weighed something like. 2380 kilograms, which is apparently
- 6:1970 kilos more than Audi even claims for it.
- 6:22Wow. OK.
- 6:23And compare that to, say, a petrol equivalent.
- 6:26Well, it's over 300 kilos heavier than a comparable Audi
- 6:30RS7, which is already a big, heavy car. 300 kilos is
- 6:35significant. And here's the really staggering
- 6:37part. You mentioned it earlier, the
- 6:39battery pack alone. How much did that weigh?
- 6:42Around 700 kilograms. Just the battery. 700, right?
- 6:46So to put that in perspective for you listening, that's
- 6:49roughly the weight of an entire original Lotus Elise.
- 6:52Or like having four big blokes in the car with you all the
- 6:55time. Permanently.
- 6:57And that weight, it has consequences beyond just, you
- 7:00know, handling dynamics. Like what?
- 7:02Well, we always focus on the 0 tailpipe emissions, right?
- 7:05Which is great for a city or quality, no question.
- 7:08But that immense weight combined with the huge wide tires you
- 7:12need to handle the instant torque and the mass.
- 7:15It actually contributes to increased particulate emissions,
- 7:19not from the exhaust, but from the tires wearing down and the
- 7:21brakes working harder. Right, so you solve 1 pollution
- 7:25problem at the tailpipe, but you potentially create more tire
- 7:28dust pollution. Interesting.
- 7:30It's a trade off that needs more attention.
- 7:32OK, then there's the whole charging situation, the great,
- 7:36well, the great variable in every EV discussion.
- 7:39The elephant in the room for many people.
- 7:42Especially if you live in say, an apartment block or terrace
- 7:46house with no driveway if you can't charge at home easily.
- 7:50EV life becomes a real headache. It turns into what one source
- 7:55called the charging lottery. Lottery.
- 7:57How so? Because if you rely purely on
- 8:00public chargers, you just have no guarantee of speed.
- 8:03You might luck out and find a brand new super fast 270
- 8:07kilowatt station which. Would be great.
- 8:09Or you could plug in and find you're getting less than 30
- 8:11kilowatts, which means you're potentially waiting for hours
- 8:14just to get a decent amount of range back.
- 8:16Right, you can't really rely on it for long trips yet, can you?
- 8:19Not with the same confidence as pulling into a petrol station,
- 8:22no. And crucially, it's not always
- 8:24the cheap option anymore, is it? That was a big point in the
- 8:27sources. No, the cost saving argument is
- 8:29getting weaker unless you have cheap overnight electricity at
- 8:32home. Yeah, the sources detailed the
- 8:34cost for that same Audi E Tron GT to fill it up at a typical
- 8:38public rapid charger could easily run you.
- 8:40What about 80 lbs. 80 lbs. And for that, you're getting
- 8:43maybe 250 miles of real world range.
- 8:47Yeah, sometimes less in the cold.
- 8:49Exactly. And suddenly, at that price
- 8:51point, you're in the same ballpark as running a thirsty V8
- 8:54performance car like an Audi RS6.
- 8:56So the cheap running cost argument really only holds if
- 8:59you have that home charging set up.
- 9:01Pretty much for high mileage drivers relying on public
- 9:04networks, it's eroding fast. And we absolutely have to talk
- 9:07about depreciation, especially at the high end of the market,
- 9:10the financial risk seems immense.
- 9:13It is that same Audi GT costing over 120,000 tons new.
- 9:18The source is estimated it could lose something like 70,000 lbs
- 9:22in value. £70,000. In how long?
- 9:25Just the first three years. Wow, 70 grand in three years, If
- 9:28you break that down, that's over £2000 a month just in
- 9:30depreciation, yeah. Just vanishing value.
- 9:33That's, well, that's simply not sustainable for most private
- 9:36buyers, is it? Not really, and it probably
- 9:38explains why so many of these high end luxury EVs you see are
- 9:41company cars where the business can absorb or write off that
- 9:45depreciation. Exactly.
- 9:47It does make you wonder, as one source hinted, are we currently
- 9:51building status symbols 1st and maybe practical consumer
- 9:56transport second? That's a fair question.
- 9:58I think it definitely introduces some necessary skepticism about
- 10:03the current state of play. Agreed.
- 10:04OK, let's pivot again to the bigger environmental picture,
- 10:08because this is where the nuance gets really, really critical,
- 10:11doesn't it? Absolutely, it's not
- 10:13straightforward. We know EVs are 0 emission
- 10:15locally in cities. That's a huge benefit.
- 10:19But what happens when you zoom out?
- 10:20Look at the whole life cycle. Manufacturing, battery
- 10:23production, disposal. This is the really critical
- 10:26counter argument and it's often raised by people who are
- 10:28actually early adopters wanting to be greener.
- 10:31While the tailpipe is clean, you have to look at the
- 10:33manufacturing emissions. The sources cited figures from
- 10:36Volvo suggesting that the greenhouse gases produced during
- 10:39the production of an EV are nearly 70% higher than for
- 10:43making a comparable petrol car. 70% higher just to build the
- 10:47thing. Just to get it off the assembly
- 10:49line. And that difference is almost
- 10:52entirely down to the battery. The energy needed to mine
- 10:55materials, process them, build these massive lithium ion packs.
- 10:59It's hugely energy intensive, which means every new EV starts
- 11:04its life with a pretty significant carbon debt that it
- 11:07needs to pay off through emission free driving compared
- 11:10to an IC car, right? Which takes time and mileage.
- 11:14It does, and this leads to one of the most, well, almost
- 11:16counterintuitive insights from the sources.
- 11:19Which is? But maybe the biggest
- 11:21environmental problem isn't the engine technology itself, but
- 11:24the fast fashion culture of how we buy and sell cars.
- 11:27The constant churn, wanting a new car every three years.
- 11:30Exactly. The sources suggested that if
- 11:32owners simply kept their cars for, say, five years instead of
- 11:36the typical 3. Just two extra years.
- 11:38The CO2 emissions linked to that huge manufacturing footprint
- 11:41would be dramatically reduced, spread over a longer period.
- 11:45So keeping your existing perfectly functional ICR running
- 11:49for longer could actually be an environmental positive, at least
- 11:52compared to scrapping it for a brand new EV with that big
- 11:56manufacturing CO2 hit. It fundamentally shifts the
- 11:59perspective, doesn't it? It suggests longevity is key.
- 12:02Keeping older cars running is an environmental asset, provided we
- 12:05can also find a way to clean up the fuel they burn.
- 12:08And that's the perfect segue, isn't it, to the alternative
- 12:10technologies bubbling up right now, things that go beyond the
- 12:13current slightly imperfect heavy lithium ion batteries?
- 12:17Right, solutions that aim to make that huge existing fleet of
- 12:20IC cars potentially carbon neutral.
- 12:23We're talking synthetic fuels first, E fuels.
- 12:26Yes, E Fuels. Porsche is really pushing this.
- 12:29They're developing a CO2 neutral fuel down in Chile using wind
- 12:32power, water and captured CO2. And the big news is Formula One
- 12:36adopting this stuff. By 2026 that's a massive signal.
- 12:40If E fuels can scale up and become cost effective,
- 12:42theoretically every single existing petrol car could run
- 12:46virtually CO2 neutral. No need to scrap millions of
- 12:49vehicles. Keeps the classics alive too.
- 12:51Absolutely. And there's hydrogen.
- 12:53Toyota's big bet? Toyota is heavily invested in
- 12:56hydrogen fuel cells. The advantage there is they're
- 12:59much lighter than current EV batteries and you can refuel in
- 13:02minutes, just like petrol or diesel.
- 13:04We're also seeing companies like JCB exploring hydrogen for like
- 13:09diggers and trucks. Yeah, using actual hydrogen
- 13:12burning piston engines. Yeah, for heavy industry and
- 13:15haulage where battery weight and charging time are huge issues,
- 13:18it's another Ave. being explored.
- 13:20But the real potential game changer for the EV itself?
- 13:23The next leap seems to be solid-state batteries.
- 13:26That's the technology everyone is watching.
- 13:28It's seen as the otential future because it promises, well,
- 13:32everything we want. Much lighter weight,
- 13:34significantly more range from a smaller pack, and much much
- 13:38faster charging. Lighter, longer range, faster
- 13:40charging sounds perfect. What's the catch?
- 13:42The catch is they're still quite a few years away from being
- 13:45reliable, affordable and mass produced.
- 13:47It's coming, but not tomorrow. Right.
- 13:49So lots of potential futures, but for now, we deal with
- 13:52current tech. OK, So we've hammered the
- 13:54compromises, the issues, the future tech, but we absolutely
- 13:59cannot finish this without acknowledging the upsides of
- 14:03current Ev's because they really do excel in certain areas.
- 14:06Oh, undeniably, they are completely unmatched in some
- 14:08aspects of everyday utility and driving.
- 14:10That instant torque, for example.
- 14:12It's phenomenal the sheer usefulness of having all that
- 14:15grunt available immediately. Think about overtaking a slow
- 14:18truck or merging onto a fast moving motorway.
- 14:20It becomes effortless. Almost 0 planning required.
- 14:23Just squeeze the pedal and you're there.
- 14:24That's where these sometimes times seemingly crazy horsepower
- 14:27figures on modern EVs actually serve a really useful practical
- 14:31purpose. Makes driving less stressful.
- 14:33And the straight line speed can be properly shocking, can it?
- 14:36Absolutely. The sources mentioned
- 14:38acceleration tests where like a Mustang Machi GT and electric
- 14:41SUV was actually faster off the line than a 760 horsepower
- 14:46Shelby GT500 Mustang or the BMW I4M50 being quicker than the
- 14:51legendary M4 Competition. For those traffic light sprints
- 14:54or just feeling quick day-to-day, current EVs often
- 14:56have the edge. And putting aside the raw speed,
- 14:58they're just nail being normal cars, don't they?
- 15:00For the vast majority of driving that most people do most of the
- 15:03time, EVs are just smooth, incredibly quiet, very refined.
- 15:10They can be remarkably relaxing places to spend time.
- 15:13So the good news for the enthusiast who feels caught in
- 15:16the middle is that better performance EVs are on the
- 15:20horizon. Lighter or more engaging ones?
- 15:22It seems so. Porsche is working hard on the
- 15:25electric Cayman and Boxster replacements.
- 15:27Those should hopefully address some of the weight and maybe the
- 15:31uniformity issues with clever engineering.
- 15:33Bring back some feel. We hope so.
- 15:35And then you see these wonderfully bonkers concepts
- 15:37like that Renault 5 Turbo 3E drift machine.
- 15:41Pure fun, 0 practicality. Well done and perhaps most
- 15:45exciting for driving purest of the projects aiming squarely at
- 15:48lightweight electric sports cars like that British startup
- 15:51Longbow. Yeah, what are they aiming for?
- 15:53Targeting A curb weight under 1000 kilograms, which is proper
- 15:56lightweight territory, and aiming for a price around
- 15:59£65,000. OK, that's interesting.
- 16:01Several 1000 kilos changes the game entirely.
- 16:03It proves the goal isn't necessarily to kill driving
- 16:06pleasure, but maybe to redefine it with new tech once they can
- 16:09get the weight down in the engagement.
- 16:12Right. So wrapping this all up then
- 16:13looking across all these sources, right, What's the final
- 16:16verdict? It feels very nuanced.
- 16:19It absolutely is. EVs right now are superior in
- 16:23terms of sheer efficiency and everyday utility, smoothness,
- 16:27quietness. But.
- 16:29But the current generation brings significant compromises.
- 16:33Environmental ones in manufacturing, practical ones
- 16:36with cost and charging, and definitely emotional ones for
- 16:39the driving enthusiast concerned about weight feel.
- 16:42So the solution isn't this cultural war, this US versus
- 16:44them. No, not at all.
- 16:45It's about acknowledging the valid points on both sides.
- 16:48People who love IC cars have legitimate concerns.
- 16:51And the people building EVs aren't the enemy.
- 16:53They're engineers seeking what they see is a better mechanical
- 16:56solution driven by efficiency and performance potential.
- 16:59So the likely path forward for the really committed car
- 17:02enthusiast, anyway. Yeah, it looks increasingly like
- 17:05it might not be choosing one side.
- 17:07It might simply be both might not use a perfectly sensible,
- 17:11reliable, comfortable EV for all the mundane stuff, the commute,
- 17:15the shopping, the school run. Effortless utility.
- 17:19And then? And then you keep that older,
- 17:22beloved, maybe slightly temperamental in tunnel
- 17:25combustion car tucked away in the garage.
- 17:27For the weekend blast. For the pure, unfiltered driving
- 17:30pleasure, when you want the noise, the vibration, the
- 17:33interaction, the Sunday morning drive just for the sake of
- 17:37driving. That feels like a pretty
- 17:38sustainable solution for the soul.
- 17:40Maybe for the planet, too, if we get those E fuels working.
- 17:43It could be. But here's the final thought,
- 17:45The provocative bit? Maybe if the ICE car survives
- 17:48mainly as this weekend emotional toy.
- 17:52How long before regulators decide that even that kind of
- 17:55driving pleasure is frivolous and try to push it entirely onto
- 17:58a simulator screen? That's definitely something to
- 18:01Mull over, isn't it? Where does actual driving fit in
- 18:04the long term? Indeed.
- 18:05Well, thank you for sharing all these fascinating sources and
- 18:08letting us really dive deep into this electric divide today.
- 18:10It's been eye opening. A pleasure, lots to think about.
- 18:13And for everyone listening, if you want more deep dives like
- 18:16this tailored to the information you're interested in, make sure
- 18:19you follow the channel. Thanks for joining us.