Latest / Braver New Worlds / Shared Equity, Collective Power, and Rethinking Who Owns Housing with Josh Newton
Transcript
- Nathan Young: Hello, welcome to another episode of Braver New Worlds, a podcast about the stories we need to tell for the future we want to see. My name is Nathan Young. I am your host. And today's guest is Josh Newton. He is a researcher and a lecturer at UC San Diego and co-founder of the San Diego Community Wealth Building Coalition. Josh studies something most of us have never really been taught to think about before, and that is what would it look like if housing wasn't something you buy and sell for profit? Or thought of as like an asset, but something a community collectively owns and governs together. Crazy idea, right? And I think in America we're very attuned to thinking of housing as being a vehicle for individual wealth building and security and not thinking about it as a collective resource or collective wealth building opportunities and you know, even you know, housing. shares some important reframes around how to think about this. And so we get into some of the economic models that that can be used towards community wealth building and resource sharing. one of them is a collective land trust. Or community land trust. Another is a limited equity partnership, even though that limited equity might seem like a little bit of a misnomer. also housing cooperatives, business cooperatives, just different formations of ownership that step outside of the individual or the family wealth and the patriarchal wealth and puts it into more of a collective framing of ownership. And we get into like, you know, what what this means, and what is the possibility that this creates for our future to start thinking about home and property ownership in the context of models like this. And it extends beyond that too. Businesses, community building, all these things. So you've ever thought or felt like the housing conversation is stuck between like build more. And like nothing will ever change because that sort of seems like the those the only two options for how to manage housing in our s in our growing populations. Then this is gonna be a good opportunity to explore A set of third options you probably haven't heard much about. So let's get into it. Josh Newton, welcome to the podcast. Josh Newton: Yeah, thanks for having me. Nathan Young: Cool. Well, as I start off all these, just introduce yourself real quick to the the people listening at home. Josh Newton: Sure. Hey everybody, I'm Josh Newton. I'm a researcher and a lecturer in the Department of Urban Studies and Planning at the University of California, San Diego. And I have a PhD in urban planning and public policy from the University of Texas at Arlington. Much of my research is around different forms of housing and community development research, a lot on different forms of housing precarity, but also different types of solutions to our housing issues. Nathan Young: Cool. And yeah, those solutions to our housing issues was really what I was excited to talk to you about here today. And especially there's terms for this like community wealth building and community land trusts and and all of those things. And so maybe a good place to start would be if you could just give us a couple of these different models that have been really They're like popular or effective or attainable, however however the best way to think about it might be. Josh Newton: Yeah, definitely. So community wealth building is kind of a broad designation for a lot of things, but it's typically used to describe things that promote community ownership, but also community decision-making. And so for instance, community land trusts and limited equity housing cooperatives are two forms of community wealth building that are done in housing. Community land trusts are really more of a model for collective ownership of land. But in the United States, 90 something percent of the time it's used to produce affordable housing. And so basically the community land trust model just creates a system where the ownership of land is separated from the ownership of whatever is on top of it. That land is then owned by a nonprofit organization that has a board that's made up of community members, residents of housing, and typically some different types of experts as well, maybe lawyers, developers, real estate interests, or planners, people that kind of know how to move these things along. Limited Equity Housing Cooperative is very similar, but it's for a particular structure. So it's tenants of housing that own the structure that they live in. And so it has that same sort of board system for the decision making purposes, but it's completely made up of tenants. So tenants have a direct say over what's happening in their housing. Nathan Young: Okay, interesting. And so and what was the name of that second one again? It was called the what was that? Josh Newton: It's a limited equity housing cooperative. But for sure, you know, we could just say housing cooperatives. It's just, there's a lot of different types of housing cooperatives. That one is considered a form of community wealth building because it limits the equity that somebody can make whenever their housing is sold. to some degree, that's what ensures that housing stays affordable forever. Nathan Young: Mm, okay. Well yeah. So I I wonder if you can sort of spell this out for us a little bit too about like how does this benefit average folks that that might be involved in one of these? Like what comes back to them or how does it maintain, you know, pricing that works better for average folks these days? Josh Newton: Yeah, I think most people are going to think of the benefits of both of these models in probably at least three different ways. So the first is going to be the way that it not only creates deep affordability of housing, much deeper than we can do currently with any other sort of housing policy, it's also going to create stability for residents. And I'll talk about how that happens. And then again, that piece about the community decision making is really important as well. It gets people involved in land use decisions, decisions around their housing that they typically aren't able to have any kind of power in, right? Typically, like I've been a renter my whole life. When I rent housing, I have no say over what happens in this housing. My landlord gets to decide what the quality of my housing looks like, what the pricing of my housing looks like. And even like the timing and the level of maintenance that's going to occur Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. Josh Newton: in that housing, right? When you in a limited equity housing cooperative, when tenants collectively own the structure, they then have much more of an incentive to make sure that that housing stays quality, right? So there's Nathan Young: mm-hmm. Josh Newton: no question around, should we, make these fixes to our units? The Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. Josh Newton: answer is always going to be yes, because we live in the units, right? The same thing with a community land trust. You know, the really important piece of that collective ownership is that oftentimes, and we see this in San Diego a lot, right? That in neighborhoods, there's, people have felt like they've been left out of development decisions happening in their neighborhoods, right? A perfect example of this historically is probably by a Logan where there's been so many historical harms done to that neighborhood. mean, first, building the five and the Coronado Bridge through that neighborhood, divided it in half to where now we have body of Logan and Logan Heights. Many homes, many businesses were destroyed in that process. Now that neighborhood is facing massive gentrification because of how close it is to downtown area, right? For decades, really, for Nathan Young: Yeah. Mm-hmm. Josh Newton: decades, people have been being pushed out of their neighborhood. Not really having a say over what's developed in their neighborhood. And so the community land trust puts direct resident decision making into those processes. So the community as a whole decides what are we going to build on top of land? The community Nathan Young: Mm. Josh Newton: as a whole decides if we're going to build housing, what is that housing going to look like? Is it going to be single family homes? Is it going to be multifamily structures? Is it going to be condos and duplexes? So there's a lot more decision making that happens that directly contributes to the stability of residents as well. So when you have collective ownership of housing, of land, the decision-making is usually going to prioritize making sure that people can stay in place, right? Oftentimes, for instance, there's a community land trust in Barrio Logan right now called Tierra Indígenas. You can find them on Instagram. And I think they might be working on a website. You know, a lot of the reason that they started that community land trust is because of all those historical harms that I mentioned. So they were tired of not having a say over what happens in their neighborhood. They were tired of not being able to stay in place, not just residents, businesses that have been there long-term. The arts and cultural community that's so strong in Body of Logan has been displaced as well. so these things are able to create much more stability because of the communal form of decision-making that happens. And then I think the affordability piece is, well, I guess I should say real quickly that with a limited equity housing cooperative, if people are collectively owning their building together, there's much less of a likelihood that for instance, you're gonna get evicted for different reasons. Nathan Young: Mm-hmm, Josh Newton: Typically you've come together as a group and decided we all like each other, we wanna live together, Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. Josh Newton: but we wanna own our building. And so that's not to say that there aren't conflicts within the building. There's Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. Josh Newton: just more democratic processes to decide if someone's going to move on or not, you know, and that process would look much better for the person that would be moving on afterwards. They would try to make sure that it's done in a very fair way. But I think, for most people, the affordability piece of these things is maybe the most important because I mean, You know, we all know that San Diego in particular is facing a massive housing crisis. And we keep being told by our electeds, by developers, by the real Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. Josh Newton: estate industry, that if we just build more and more housing, eventually we'll see rents and mortgages go down. Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. Josh Newton: Except the problem with that, as an academic, I can tell you, there's very, very little evidence for that. And even Nathan Young: Mm. Josh Newton: the evidence there is, the kind of gains in the rent and mortgage prices, is so minimal that it really doesn't make an actual effect in somebody's life, right? So this idea that if we just build more housing, there's so many things wrong with that idea. I could go into that if you want me to, but it's... Nathan Young: Well yeah, is a basic thing that just like you build more housing then more people just show up, more people move here and then it keeps the prices up, or is it that, you know, the or landlords or the powers that be don't necessarily lower prices or all the above or? Josh Newton: It's kind of more that like that idea is based on two very flawed theories. So the first is very basic, like supply and demand theory that we probably all heard of in some way, right? So like, if the supply of something is low, then that means the demand for it is going to be higher. And so Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. Josh Newton: that means that the price can be higher. if multiple people are competing to buy the same house, then it makes sense that the person selling it could sell it for more. The problem with that theory in real life is that it doesn't really work out that way. There's a lot of assumptions that go into that theory that we don't often think about. So for instance, one assumption is that, you know, there's this idea of like the consumer would have perfect knowledge. So Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. Josh Newton: I, as somebody buying a home, I would have all knowledge of every single home and every single place being sold in San Diego. And so I could make the best choice about, this is the cheapest one. I'm going to choose that. Nathan Young: Mm-hmm, mm-hmm. Josh Newton: I don't know about you. I don't know that kind of knowledge, right? Nathan Young: Yeah. Yeah, yeah. Josh Newton: Even, you know, even with the advent of the internet, we don't have that kind of access to information. And in fact, oftentimes, particularly in cases where we have corporations owning a lot of our housing, even here in San Diego, they almost always have much more knowledge than we have because they have the money to gain more knowledge than we do. Another example is like there's an assumption in that theory that there's no kind of externalities. So Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. Josh Newton: there's nothing outside of the housing itself that's having an effect on the price of that housing. Nathan Young: Hmm. Josh Newton: We know from urban planning that there's so many externalities. know, Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. Josh Newton: if I... If my housing is located next to industrial areas, it's going to be much cheaper. If my housing is located next to a transit stop, it's going to be much more expensive. there's many, many assumptions to this theory that just makes it to where like there's very little examples in real life where that theory actually works. Nathan Young: Yeah, okay. Josh Newton: The other theory is it's called filtering often. So Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. Josh Newton: It's kind of like if you've heard of trickle-down economics, it's basically that in housing. So it's like Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. Okay. Josh Newton: when a new housing unit is built, somebody that's living in old housing will sell that housing and then go buy that new housing. Nathan Young: Mm. Josh Newton: And then that'll open up a more affordable spot for someone else to come by. The problem Nathan Young: So Josh Newton: is there's so many things that happens in those two transactions. Nathan Young: Yeah. Josh Newton: That means that that house doesn't stay affordable. And even if we're thinking about housing justice, even if that theory did work out, that means that we're building our whole housing system on low income people should get the least quality housing in our cities. And that has a lot of bad justice implications. Nathan Young: Yeah, yeah, yeah. Yeah. Well, so wait, I want to go back to these two models here 'cause I just want to make sure that I understand them here and like you know, how I understand so when you we talked about community land trusts, and one of the things you said that stuck out to me was that like you own the land underneath, but you don't necessarily own the building. So like would there have to be like a limited equity housing cooperative on top of the community land trust to own the building, or how does that work? Mm-hmm. Josh Newton: It could be. mean, it could the beauty of the community land trust model is it's basically just collective ownership over land. And so just like individual owning land, you can do anything you want on top of that land. So really a community land trust, its land could be used for non-housing purposes. But like I said, because of the housing crisis, Nathan Young: Mm. Josh Newton: it's almost always used for housing. And so basically, that nonprofit organization, which is the Community Land Trust and is run by community members and whoever Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. Josh Newton: else is involved owns just the land. They Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. Josh Newton: might also do the development on top of the land, but Community Land Trusts for housing have been used for every housing type you can think of, single family homes, for multi-family structures, for townhomes, condos, duplexes. Nathan Young: Mm. Josh Newton: But yeah, you could put a cooperative on top of it as well. So then you would have the community owning the land and Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. Josh Newton: the tenants of housing owning the housing on top of it. And so Nathan Young: Okay. Josh Newton: you'd have two different levels of democratic decision-making happening there. Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. Josh Newton: And the important piece is that like that relationship between those two entities is mediated by a lease agreement. so oftentimes with CLTs that lease will be very, very affordable. More established CLTs that have good financials, often will lease the land to whoever owns whatever's on top of it for a dollar a year. Nathan Young: Mm. Mm. Josh Newton: And that's what makes the housing on top of it so affordable. Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. Josh Newton: You know, in California, when we build housing, oftentimes 60, almost 70 % of the cost of the housing can be just the land itself. So if you're taking that price out of the picture, all of sudden you have much more affordable housing, right? Maybe an easier way for most people to typically think about this is like, if I live in single family home, when I go to get a mortgage for that home, my mortgage has both the cost of the land and the cost of the housing in that mortgage, right? Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. Josh Newton: So I'm paying for both of those things. If the CLT owns the land, I'm just getting a mortgage for the housing on top of that land, which Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. Josh Newton: is usually cheaper than the land itself. And so my mortgage is going to be less expensive, right? So it makes my housing affordable. Nathan Young: Yeah, it'd just be like you have to buy the materials and the construction and stuff essentially, right? Yeah, interesting. Josh Newton: Yeah, exactly. Nathan Young: Okay. I'm curious to know this sort of practical methodology of like how this comes together. I mean, like and you've you've talked about community land trusts happening in the context of yeah, a lot of times like a organization or a nonprofit will they'll own the land and maybe they've they had some access to land prior to and they built affordable housing on top of it. Is that kinda how it usually goes or Josh Newton: It could, I mean, it can go almost anywhere. There's Nathan Young: Okay. Josh Newton: so many different, like every model of a CLT is different than the other one. Nathan Young: Mm. Josh Newton: for instance, we have, I mentioned Tierra Indígenas and Barrio Logan. That was a bunch of activists and artists from the neighborhood that came together and said, we have to do something about being displaced. Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. Yeah. Josh Newton: So they worked with the Environmental Health Coalition, which is this nonprofit. in San Diego and the San Diego Foundation to apply for this big state level grant that was for, I think, 30 something million dollars. Nathan Young: Hmm. Josh Newton: So a piece of that went to establishing a community land trust and ultimately to them purchasing their first property, which was already developed. So they Nathan Young: Mm. Josh Newton: bought a property that already had a structure on top of it, already had people living in the top level of that structure. So they were able to keep those people in place, which many people purchasing that property might not have done. And they're redeveloping the lower part of the structure to have space for a midwife clinic, for artists space. And they're going to have a like outdoor area for like events and maybe even build some ADUs in the future as well. There's another one in San Ysidro called the Avanzando San Ysidro CLT. Nathan Young: Mm. Josh Newton: that was started by Casa Familiar, which is this long standing, started as a community based organization. Now it's kind of more of a community developer in Santa Cedro. So they've been building affordable housing in Santa Cedro for a long time. And we're looking for something that creates more long-term affordable housing. Like you had mentioned before, during the recession, they kind of had some good foreknowledge and bought up some properties I think they were like being foreclosed on and stuff. And so Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. Josh Newton: they kind of banked that land. And then eventually when they started the Community Land Trust, donated that land to the Community Land Trust. There's examples of like, different cities and counties giving public Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. Josh Newton: land to CLTs to use to develop housing. You could have like, just an individual who has land. and wants to donate it to a community to Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. Josh Newton: use for affordable housing, that could happen as well. So, you know, it can be any mix of ways of getting that land. It can be development of new housing or redevelopment of old housing. It can use multiple different funding structures to do all of that kind of stuff. Nathan Young: Okay. And so then it could be the type of thing where like, me and a group of friends were like, All right, we want to start a community land trust and like, suppose we're all neighbors, could we just be like, Yeah, our property is now our community land trust. Could just formulate it that way? That's like one possibility or Josh Newton: You could, you know, there would need to be some like intentionality there around why that's Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. Yeah. Josh Newton: being done. like, but you could technically take like a whole block of houses and put it in a community land trust. Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. Josh Newton: There's some community land trusts that have worked on, and I think the Thierry Sandinus wants to do this in the future of like talking to people already living in the neighborhood Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. Josh Newton: and being like, hey, you can sell your land to us. Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. Josh Newton: refinance your housing just for the housing piece and it'll make your mortgage much more affordable, right? Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. Mm-hmm. Josh Newton: And then the land gets to be used for the community's purposes in perpetuity. And so you know in Nathan Young: Hm. Josh Newton: the future that it won't be some big developers coming in and deciding what happens to this neighborhood, Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. Josh Newton: but rather that the community decides what's going to happen there. Nathan Young: Okay. And then like with that person that sells into that, would they they wouldn't necessarily have like a share of the land trust then? It'd be the land trust would be operated by like a non profit that's got some agreed upon bylaws for how they manage the land. Is that is that right? Josh Newton: Yeah, community land trusts are almost always membership organizations. So Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. Josh Newton: the nonprofit is the community land trust. They're, usually in the bylaws of that nonprofit, it'll say what the restrictions are on membership. I can't think of any community land trust that wouldn't let the people living in housing be in the membership. But usually it's geographically defined. like Nathan Young: Mm. Josh Newton: with Avanza, Ndosana, Cedro, CLT, If you live in San Ysidro, you can be a member of the Community Land Trust. That gives you a vote in who's going to be the board members of that Community Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. Josh Newton: Land Trust and kind of do the like day-to-day operations of that. Nathan Young: Mm-hmm, Josh Newton: But for instance, Barrio Logan, because their whole thing is like anti-displacement, they Nathan Young: Mm. Josh Newton: have very restrictive membership. So you have to have lived, worked, or served in Barrio Logan for at least five years if you want to be a member. Nathan Young: Mm. Josh Newton: They also want like 50 % plus one member to be low income people so that they ensure that like the people that are living in that neighborhood are the ones controlling that community land trust. Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. Okay. All right. and again, I just want to make sure I understand this sort of like the the the management option. It is like, yeah, so there is a sort of like vote share control within that board or that structure, but it's not necessarily tied to, you know, what you put into the land trust as far as like adding property or something, the way that like maybe that might just be more in the terms of like a traditional corporation partnership type thing where where it it's done that way where like you have shares of control. Is that right? Josh Newton: So with the Community Land Trust, you might sometimes they'll have like a price for membership. Nathan Young: Okay. Josh Newton: It's usually very cheap because they're trying to like make sure the whole community has access to being a member of this. And that membership gives you a vote in the board elections. Also sometimes in the bylaws, it'll make it to where the board has to bring like really important decisions back to the membership. Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. Mm-hmm. Josh Newton: So you'd have a vote in any of those things. I think with the limited equity housing cooperative, that's a bit more like, you know, the way we would typically think of a corporation where like, for instance, when I am a part of a limited equity housing cooperative, I don't technically own a unit of housing. I own a share in the cooperative corporation that owns the housing. So that's kind of like the means through which the collective ownership happens. Nathan Young: So it's almost like you own the share of the housing and then you are renting from the housing too. It's almost like two separate transactions. Josh Newton: Yeah, so there'll be a lease with the cooperative for that unit of housing. The difference between a corporation, a typical corporation and a cooperative is in a cooperative, one share equals one vote. And you can't own, let's say five shares and have five units of the housing. You can only get one share, one vote. So it's a completely democratic process. In a corporation, Nathan, you could have a hundred shares and I could have one share. You have a hundred percent more power than me, right? So the corporation, the traditional corporation isn't actually very democratic. It's more about whoever has the most money has the most say. In the cooperative, it's everybody has the exact same say. So it's much more democratic. Nathan Young: Okay, so yeah, even if you and you know, this is gonna be reductive. I'm gonna talk about like money as being a f a thing of a democracy. But it does tell at some level it would make sense to me that like if you put in more money towards making it happen that you should have like a little bit more say, but that's just not how it's supposed to be set up and that's not what the people going into that would want for it. Is that essentially what you're saying? Josh Newton: Well, yeah, and I think, you know, maybe we could think about it in terms of like what's happening today where like we have money in politics now in a way that most nations around the world do not, right? And so we have a situation where corporations have much more control over our democratic process than individuals do. And Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. Mm-hmm. Josh Newton: I think most people would agree that that's not the way that the United States was originally meant to kind Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. Josh Newton: of operate, right? I mean, you know, there's lots of critiques of the way that the United States was founded in terms of, you know, only white male landowners originally Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. Josh Newton: having a say in our political processes. But we've done a lot to try to overcome a lot of those inconsistencies in like the kind of spirit of what democracy was supposed to be in the United States. And so, you know, now we have a situation where that's been undone, because we have said that corporations are people and that they can have a say in what happens in our politics. And so now we have lots of things happening where like, and directly related to housing, where corporations can buy housing. And then if we, people decide that's not really something that we want in our city because it's creating that affordability, they can come in and put a lot of money into the politics and make sure that it doesn't get overturned, right? Nathan Young: Mm-hmm, Josh Newton: We saw that recently here in San Diego, actually. where we were trying to pass a vacancy tax to where Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. Josh Newton: if corporations were keeping housing vacant in San Diego, they would get taxed and that money would go back into a fund to create more affordable housing. And Airbnb paid a lot of people from LA and bus them down here to have a say in our political process in San Diego. you Nathan Young: Mm. Josh Newton: know, on the one hand, it's incredibly corrupt that Airbnb can just toss a lot of money Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. Josh Newton: at our politics and have a, you know, overthrow what people in San Diego want. But on top of that, what are people from LA doing, having a say in San Diego's politics, right? So that kind of shows you the way that politics can corrupt our democratic processes, especially when we have representative democracy and those representatives Nathan Young: Mm. Josh Newton: can be paid off by these corporations and, and lobbying groups and all these things, right? And so I think most people that get into a cooperative probably don't want to see that kind of stuff happening in their housing or you Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. Josh Newton: know, I haven't mentioned but like community wealth building is also about like worker cooperatives, Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. Josh Newton: grocery cooperatives, agricultural cooperatives, like people choosing to be a part of these models are typically wanting to see a much more democratic process than we've had Nathan Young: Yeah. Josh Newton: in the past. Nathan Young: what would it look like to have just more of this going on? You know? Like if if there was more community land trust going on, like if every neighborhood had a certain amount of land trust. 'Cause actually let me back up. So like the the one that you talked about in Barrio Logan, the tiendas was I'm sorry, what was it called? The Josh Newton: T.R.S. Indigenous. Nathan Young: D S and D Tieras and D S my Spanish accent's terrible. Josh Newton: It's cool. Nathan Young: So the property that they picked up, it was just, you know, there was maybe some houses or a building or apartment building or a for a a a retail building and like maybe was it just sort of a was it one plot or was it a collection of plots or do we know or? Josh Newton: Right now they just have one plot, but they're working on getting more. Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. Josh Newton: And so a community land trust, think one of the kind of misconceptions of them is people think that community land trusts have to own a bunch of land that's right next to each other. Nathan Young: Yeah. Mm-hmm. Josh Newton: could, know, oftentimes their only restriction is the geography that they've set for themselves. So like with Tierra Indígenas, they've said that there, I think theirs is actually based on a zip code. But it's basically Barrio Logan and so they would, they could buy any lot in Barrio Logan. Nathan Young: Hm. Josh Newton: So you could, for instance, Avanzando San Ysidro CLT down in San Ysidro has two lots at the moment and they're separate from each other. They're kind of close but they're in different parts of San Ysidro. So yeah, it could be one lot. Most start out with one lot because of money. But it could be multiple lots. I there's some really huge, long-standing community land trusts in the United States, like Champagne Housing Authority or Housing Trust, I think, in Vermont was started by Bernie Sanders in the 1980s. And now it's the largest community land trust in the United States. So these things can grow really, really large. Nathan Young: Yeah. Okay, interesting. And is that like sort of an affordable housing situation there or like is that how Josh Newton: Yeah, and actually, you know, I think the more, lands that they come to own and the more housing that they own, the easier it is to produce affordability because then it's much easier to lease out that land for very cheaply. And then, you know, we haven't had these really long enough or really seen them spread enough to know if this is true. But there's a pretty good working theory that like, if you can get enough of this, that it's gonna push the private market down as well. Nathan Young: Mm. Josh Newton: Because let's say, you know, just theoretically, if Tierra Indígena owns, let's say like half the lots in Barrio Logan, and Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. Josh Newton: all of those lots have deeply affordable housing on it, all of a sudden, the private sector is gonna have to compete with that, right? Nathan Young: Mm-hmm, mm-hmm. Josh Newton: So, you know, and I think there's there's really good like evidence to kind of back this theory too, because really when we think about like the mechanism through which community land trusts and limited equity housing cooperatives are creating affordability, it's really just decommodification. So it's taking land, taking housing and saying, this isn't important because I can make money off of it. Nathan Young: Mm. Josh Newton: It's important because people can use that land or people can live in that housing, right? So for instance, with the housing cooperative, if everybody collectively owns it, all of a sudden you've cut landlord profit out of the picture, right? Because if you all are landlords of yourself, Nathan Young: Yeah. Josh Newton: you don't want to overcharge yourself for housing, right? Nathan Young: Mm-mm, yeah, yeah, yeah. Josh Newton: So, you know, there's multiple forms of decommodified housing though. For instance, public housing owned by the government is also another form of decommodified housing because usually the government is producing housing for the people. not Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. Josh Newton: trying to make money off of it. They're just trying to make enough money to keep it running or and keep it maintained, you know, so Nathan Young: Yeah. Yeah. Josh Newton: there's other places in the world like the most famous right now is Vienna in Austria. They've created a very vibrant decommodified housing sector using housing cooperatives and public housing. They now have up to 180 % area median income living in affordable housing. Nathan Young: Mm. Josh Newton: So again, like if you can do this on a massive scale, even if it's just other types of decommodified housing, some public housing here, some community land trust housing there, some cooperatives there, Nathan Young: Mm. Mm. Josh Newton: it's gonna force the private market to come down. Nathan Young: Okay. Interesting. So so I'm trying to think like like to really make this happen at scale though, it's gonna require like buying lots of land. Okay. And that that's a ch Yeah, well sorry, or what? Okay. Josh Newton: Yeah. Or getting it donated. Or getting it donated. Nathan Young: And that that is the challenge here, at least in, you know, San Diego, is is this land being being affordable. and it does also 'cause you hit on something that that I was sort of sitting on. I couldn't quite articulate what it was. But yeah, I think, you know, in American society so many of us are ingrained with the idea that like you build wealth by building equity and it sort of like doesn't basically that's kind of not like is there is there an equity building com component to this for you know both the trust or the individual at all? Like does the individual sort of build equity with anything while they're involved with it or is it just that like, you know, their housing is cheaper 'cause the the overhead they're paying is just for the maintenance of it and not for, you know, the landlord living living large too. So Josh Newton: Yeah. So there is equity building. just looks, or there's, should say there's both equity and wealth building. It just looks different. So with limited equity housing cooperatives, it's kind of in the name, like your equity at the end, when you sell your share of the cooperative is limited. So they Nathan Young: Mm. Mm. Josh Newton: usually put that at a certain percentage per year Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. Josh Newton: plus whatever kind of maintenance you put into the unit. And there's You know, the bylaws usually kind of lay out all these different aspects of how your equity is going to be determined. Some people have said that like, that's actually not a really good name for it because one, sounds negative. It sounds like my equity is being limited. Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. Josh Newton: In reality, what's happening is the equity is being shared. So Nathan Young: Mm. Josh Newton: when that structure, and this is both in community land trust housing and limited equity housing co-ops, when you're property value when your structure value goes up. Typically, if you're an individual and you own that, you gain all that equity. Instead, Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. Josh Newton: what's happening here is the person living in the housing is gaining whatever that limited amount is. And really the community land trust or the cooperative is keeping the rest of it. But I also say that it's different in terms of the way that wealth is built. So that's one, you do get some equity. It's not as much as we see in like private ownership of a single family home or whatever it might be. The other part of this is that in both community land trust housing and housing cooperative housing, your rent or your mortgage is so affordable that you're actually gaining your wealth every month instead of just trying to cash in at the end. Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. Josh Newton: And so one, that's good because That's why to some degree we call it community wealth building because Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. Josh Newton: if people have more affordable housing, they have more money each month, they're Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. Josh Newton: typically going to spend that in the local economy. So Nathan Young: Yeah. Josh Newton: it's not only that we're like building wealth community through like collective ownership. It's also because it's contributing to the broader community. There's also a lot less risk in that. like if I'm trying to make all of my wealth off of just selling my home at the, you Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. Josh Newton: know, maybe when I retire. or I don't need a big house anymore or whatever it might be, I have to hope that the market is going to be good when that time comes, right? So it's a little bit of a gamble, but even in that, it's a structural flaw of our system. And I'm not saying this to like discredit anyone that owns their own home and is trying to make wealth at end of their life. Nathan Young: Yeah. Mm-hmm. Josh Newton: I mean, to some degree, it's the only outlet that people have to make wealth because Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. Josh Newton: we don't have good social welfare systems in the United States. Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. Josh Newton: We don't have good, I mean, social security is falling apart. Nathan Young: Mm-hmm mm, yeah. Josh Newton: So rightfully so, people are afraid of like what's going to happen at the end of life. And this is one of the only good ways in which to make sure that you're taken care of at the end of your life. So I completely understand that. But it's also a structural flaw in our system because, at the very like, just very simply, like if for instance, I have a home. Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. Josh Newton: And I need to make wealth off of that for whatever reason. So that I can retire, so I can send my kids to college, whatever it might be. When I sell my home, I need to make sure that I make as much money off of that as possible, right? So that already means I'm selling it for the absolute highest price that I can get. Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. Josh Newton: If I'm selling it to you, Nathan, that means that all of a sudden your house is much less affordable. Nathan Young: Mm. Josh Newton: So our very system of building wealth off of the housing market, Nathan Young: Mm. Mm-hmm. Josh Newton: is creating the unaffordability problem that we have, right? Nathan Young: Yeah. Because every sell it just like the the price keeps going up and it's not like yeah. Yeah yeah yeah. Josh Newton: Yeah. So these models undo that, right? So you limit Nathan Young: So Josh Newton: the equity that's made. So the next person gets an affordable home, just like you got an affordable home. But also you're making wealth slowly month by month. And so it might not look like the big payout at the end of the process. But it's a much more sustainable way of making wealth, right? I mean, Nathan Young: Yeah, yeah. Josh Newton: even when we make investments in real life, right? Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. Josh Newton: We want to invest in like stocks or whatever it might be. Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. Josh Newton: that are consistent, they're gonna actually make you money, right? You might have the ability to take those real big risks and invest in something that might pay off, but really you probably wanna avoid that if you're trying to like collect for your retirement, right? So Nathan Young: Yeah, yeah, yeah. Josh Newton: same idea with these models really in terms of housing. Nathan: As much as I love doing this podcast, sad truth of it all is that doesn't pay the bills. It actually cost me money to make this podcast. That's okay, I love doing it, so we're doing it. So what does pay the bills for me is I help individuals and organizations leverage the power of storytelling for leadership and persuasion. This is the work I do and I want to tell you about it real quick here. For organizations, a lot of times the work is very much focused on fundraising for nonprofits or developing a narrative strategy for the important messages that they want to get out in their campaigns. can also be about developing leadership and communication skills amongst a team that you've already got working within your organization. For individuals, a lot of my work revolves around helping develop a narrative-based communication approach for those high-leverage career moments that come up from time to time, like giving a public talk, interviewing for a new position, integrating into a new role at a new company, or making the leap for yourself to jump into entrepreneurship and how you talk about the work that you do with external audiences there too. These are very much the moments that can have a huge impact on your career. And by utilizing storytelling and narrative, you can not only communicate a more resonant message about what it is you're doing, but also what is going to stick. So if this is intriguing to you and you wanna know more, you can check out my website, storycultureconsulting.com. I'll have a free tool on there that's available for download, or you can check out the show notes too. I'll have the same tool down there that you can grab too. Once again, that's story culture consulting.com and now back to the show. Nathan Young: So I kind of want to ask like some utopian kind of questions here. And and and like just like on like at a different scales, because I'd be curious, what is the most potentially amazing thing that could happen here? And I'm guessing it here's maybe a hypothetical I want to propose. And feel free to like, you know, suggest an adjustment. But I wanna like, okay, if somebody came to you and was like Josh, here's five million dollars. run with this. Do the most amazing thing you can within the context of these models with that five million dollars. Like, where would you go? What would you do? Josh Newton: $5 million, sadly, in the housing market in San Diego. Not going to get too very far, but. Nathan Young: That doesn't get far. Yeah, yeah. Well, yeah, don't don't limit yourself to San Diego. Like b I don't know, maybe you're going out to twenty nine palms or maybe you're going out to Nebraska. Like what you know, what like r run with it. Kind of where where could you go with that? Josh Newton: But I will say this, like in the most, mean San Diego's probably one of the most expensive markets in the United States right now. I believe what Tierra Sendijenas got from that 30 something million dollar grant is four million dollars, I think. With that, they purchased a property that already had some development on top of it. They're gonna redevelop that and make sure that that property is actually quality, something that... typically landlords are not doing right now. I've lived in a lot of apartments and typically what they do is put a new coat of paint on the outside of the apartment and then raise the price of the rent, right? So they're doing that. Yeah, yeah. Nathan Young: Yeah. Yeah. Maybe some new tile, you know. Yeah. Josh Newton: So they're doing that. They already bought a property and like I said, they made sure that 10 long-term residents of Barrio Logan didn't get displaced by somebody that would have bought the property and probably... redeveloped it into a new structure that would have displaced them, right? They're going to be creating things that the community needs. Their artists are being displaced as well, they're artist space. People don't have access to the healthcare they need, so they're creating a midwife clinic. I think either the first black and indigenous-owned midwife clinic in San Diego, or maybe it's... it will be the only one that's remaining now or something along those lines. And creating community space that people need, right? So they're taking what before was land that was just used for housing purposes and creating a lot more purposes that the community needs, but also creating long-term affordable housing as well, Eventually, with the success of that, they'll probably be able to get more funding. they'll be able to buy more land and eventually this just kind of exponentially grows, right? So I think that's a really good example of what can be done with $5 million. mean, with the housing cooperative, same thing. You could create tenant ownership of one building, which we desperately need in San Diego. Limited equity housing cooperatives are huge in places like Washington, DC, New Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. Josh Newton: York, the Bay Area even. We have none in the city of San Diego. We have three in the county of San Diego. And so most people don't know that this is an option. They, you know, even like for people living in San Diego, they're unlikely to go see the ones in Escondido. So Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. Josh Newton: they don't have a concrete example of what this could look like. So taking $5 million and starting the first cooperative in the city of San Diego, symbolically could be huge for that model Nathan Young: Mm. Yeah. Josh Newton: to like show people. This can actually be done, this can work. Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. And like, yeah, if you're gonna do that, like if you know, say I was like a tenant in a building, like if I want to like rally the other tenants to to buy the building off our landlord, is that like something that we could do and then we could create a limited equity housing cooperative? Is that like a possibility or theoretically? Okay. Josh Newton: Absolutely. Absolutely. mean, and in fact, it kind of has to be in that way, because if you're going to have collective ownership over housing, everybody has to be on board. So Nathan Young: Yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah. Josh Newton: there's a lot of organizing that has to happen for that. I think the best model of like kind of scaling up limited equity housing cooperatives has been Washington, DC. Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. Josh Newton: created, there's this policy called Tenant Opportunity to Purchase Act. So basically it gives tenants the first right of refusal to purchase their building. So if tenants want to buy their building, doesn't matter if a corporation wants to buy, it doesn't matter if whoever else wants to, tenants have the first right. Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. Josh Newton: Alongside that, they put legal assistance, they put funding assistance, and they did a lot of organizing to create tenants councils that could then turn into cooperatives, right? And Nathan Young: wow. Yeah. Mm-hmm. Josh Newton: so there's all those pieces that need to happen. But you can have, if you have a city that supports those things, you can make them happen. think from the 1980s to like the early 2000s, Washington Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. Josh Newton: DC created over 4,000 limited equity housing cooperative units and started many more tenants unions that could eventually become housing cooperatives. Nathan Young: Okay. It it strikes me that one of the other challenges too is like, you know, it's hard to get people to work together sometimes. Is that part of the deal? Josh Newton: I think so. But you know, like, I always tell people, like, I don't think it's any different than living in any other kind of housing, right? Like, I've lived in apartments my whole life. You have to learn to live with your neighbors. You're gonna hear stuff coming from the other house. You're going to run into each other. For a lot of people, it typically looks like trying to stay out of each other's way. Nathan Young: Yeah. Josh Newton: This is a bit more intentional about like, let's actually learn how to live together. Let's learn how to like own this thing together for our Nathan Young: Yeah. Josh Newton: collective good. But you still Nathan Young: Even more like just gathering the money together and getting the agreement like we're gonna do this, right? Josh Newton: The other good thing is typically a limited equity housing cooperative purchases the property through what's called a blanket mortgage. So if there's, let's say there's like 10 units in the housing, whatever those units look like, instead of each individual person bringing their assets, their income, all of that, to get their own mortgages, to purchase their own unit. The cooperative itself is taking out a mortgage for all of those units. So that's good for at least two reasons. One, it displaces the risk onto the cooperative corporation. Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. Josh Newton: for instance, and as far as I know, this has never happened, but if a cooperative isn't able to pay off its mortgage, it's the cooperative that goes under and loses the housing. Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. Josh Newton: So the individuals don't, for instance, get a foreclosure on their record. The other thing is because it's this blanket mortgage, it's much easier to get low income people into home ownership, Nathan Young: Mm. Mm-hmm. Josh Newton: even if it's a non-traditional form of ownership, because all of a sudden low income people that are typically like not able to be financed through our housing system, it doesn't matter because the cooperative is getting the mortgage, not the individual person, right? Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. Josh Newton: So, you know, it's just as hard as, I mean, for a lot of people like my generation right now, It's hard for us to get mortgages, even those that are making decent money, to pay for housing because housing is so expensive. So, Nathan Young: Yeah, yeah. Josh Newton: know, a cooperative is going to face the same thing. You have to find a way to pay for that structure, Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. Josh Newton: right? So that is the biggest blocks are like education, people knowing about these models, organizing, people being organized already to be able to purchase Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. Yeah. Josh Newton: the housing. And then, you know, the funding part, where is the money going to come from? Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. Yeah. Well yeah, I'm curious, like the examples do you know, like to what degree were they already sort of like connected and working together in order to to take advantage of this opportunity as they saw it or as it emerged. Josh Newton: I think almost always with the housing cooperatives, it's going to have started through some sort of like tenants union or tenants council. Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. Josh Newton: There are example, I mean, some of the ones in Escondido, it was a housing developer that started them. Community housing works. Some listeners might've heard of them. They're a decently well-known affordable housing developer in San Diego. And it was back in the mid 1990s, the CEO at the time, Sue Reynolds had come from New York and had seen cooperatives work there and wanted to figure out how to make those happen in San Diego. And so the problem they faced was tenants were not already organized to be a part of a cooperative. So they set up what's called a leasehold cooperative, which is basically like, They were able to use tax credits to pay for the development of these buildings. And then the cooperative as a cooperative leased from Community Housing Works. And the idea was that eventually the cooperative would be organized enough to understand what a cooperative is, how it runs and be able to do it. And they would buy the structure off of Community Housing Works. As far as I know, that never happened. Maybe it's a possibility in the future, but... So there are other ways of getting these things started. I think for the long-term sustainability of the individual models, it's usually better if people are already organized so that they know what they're getting into, Nathan Young: Mm-hmm, Josh Newton: how to run it, or at least what resources they need to make it happen and all those sorts of Nathan Young: Yeah yeah. Okay. Well yeah, 'cause that brings up a question for me too of like so that's an example of somebody that or an organization, Community Housing Works, which is a nonprofit, right? Like they they have the capital and is there what advantages, if any, are there for somebody or some entity or organization that has the capital to build housing to build it in this model, or is it very much like limited as far as like advantages from that point of view and it's more like a bottom up set of advantages? Josh Newton: I think most of the advantages are going to be bottom up, but I think, you know, there's different types of organizations that this might be attractive to that have a lot of capital. So, I mean, right off the top of my head, I'm just thinking about philanthropic foundations, right? Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. Yeah, Josh Newton: Especially community foundations that Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. Josh Newton: are like rooted in the community. Most times they have some sense of like, kind of just, You know, they're philanthropic. They're trying to do Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. Josh Newton: good for the places in which they're working. And so they have kind of a, a kind of social advantage almost, I think, incentive from this that like, if you're creating housing that is actually affordable and Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. Josh Newton: permanently affordable for people, it's only going to look good for you. And also like, I actually, have a background in studying foundations and their community development work. Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. Josh Newton: There's also a level to this for them that like foundations are often trying to like kind of show themselves to be really innovative and on the cutting Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. Josh Newton: edge of ideas. And so investing in these types of models and kind of moving them forward is a really good thing for them in terms of their name and like they're kind of like altruistic persona, I guess. Nathan Young: Mm-hmm, mm-hmm. Josh Newton: But for developers, you know, there are developers out there that are like nonprofit affordable housing Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. Josh Newton: developers that are like you know, really rooted in the communities in which they're working in. so like, this is a way of, know, oftentimes those developers are trying to show that they do much more like community work and community service alongside that housing development. Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. Josh Newton: So it's attractive in kind of like showing that, this is something that we do and we're creating these kind of like innovative models, I think. But I think for the most part, it's going to be best for the people that are actually living in the housing. Nathan Young: Yeah, yeah. Okay. Who's had a question that sort of slipped away from here. Well I guess okay, okay. The other thing I wanted to ask is getting back to that kind of utopian ideal here. Like, all right, suppose somewhere, again, hypothetical here, there's some small city through some sort of you know, economic magic, all all the property switches over to this this community-based model. This now, like small city has control, the population has control, and they've put you in charge of or they've asked you to come in as a consultant to help them manage this and and manage this that transition. I mean what would you tell them like what could be possible for for a small city in that context? Josh Newton: I think a couple, if I'm going to think, in a utopian sense, Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. Josh Newton: well, one for the city would be great because, one of the biggest things that we struggle with here in San Diego is the affordability. and on top of that, it's going to be great for the city because like I mentioned, when you have more affordable housing, you're more likely to spend in the economy. Creating actually affordable housing is actually a form of economic development as well, Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. Josh Newton: right? On top of that, people are more likely to spend like in their immediately local economy. A lot of cities around the US and really just around the world are struggling with this issue of like their development contributing to the wealth of somebody somewhere else, right? Nathan Young: Mm-hmm, mm-hmm. Josh Newton: If we have a corporation from, you know, wherever, I don't know, New York City that Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. Josh Newton: owns 25 % of the housing in San Diego, Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. Josh Newton: all of that money is flowing out of San Diego. That's a problem for cities. Nathan Young: Mm. Josh Newton: It's so like, especially when we get a lot of revenue from property taxes and these sorts of things. But so you're creating not only deeply affordable housing where everybody can live. Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. Josh Newton: which is usually something that most electeds are trying to accomplish. You're also Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. Josh Newton: creating a local economy that can sustain itself and be resilient. But utopian wise, I think I'll point to two things. One, the United States or the United Nations Declaration of Human Rights says that every person in the world has a right to quality housing. Nathan Young: Mm. Josh Newton: That's something that we don't live up to anywhere in the world. And it's kind of sad to think that we can't live up to that here in the United States. Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. Josh Newton: A nation that we typically talk about as probably the most wealthy nation that has ever existed, right? In the most wealthy nation that's ever existed, we have people that have very low quality housing or as we know in San Diego, don't even have housing, right? Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. Josh Newton: That's a massively huge equity and justice problem. I think at their very like ideological root, these models are turning that around saying housing is not something that should be bought and sold. It's something that should be there for people to have shelter. So in a utopian sense, you're creating the, I guess, avenues through which we can actually live up to that declaration of human rights, right? Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. Josh Newton: I think in another sense, like in urban planning, we typically look at, I don't know if you've ever heard of Jane Jacobs. She's kind of like known as the mother of urban planning. she was this journalist from New York who did a lot of like advocating for her community and, kind of stopped one of the biggest, highway construction projects from going through Greenwich village in New York. so should we, we kind of look to her because she wrote this great book called the death and life of great American cities. Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. Josh Newton: If the listeners haven't read this book, go and read this book. It's amazing. Like you'll be reading this book and thinking, why don't we have cities like that? And also like, you'll see so much of the critique that she has of the way that our cities that are developed that Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. Josh Newton: is true to this day. She wrote it in the sixties. It still happens this way today. So Nathan Young: Well. Josh Newton: anyway, one of the things that she kind of talked about, she talked about how to create these like vibrant neighborhoods Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. Josh Newton: and all of this. But one thing she talked about was governance. And one of the like, We typically look at this as a utopian and it could never happen. Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. Josh Newton: But I would say these models could actually make this happen is that she said in an ideal city, the governance should go from the bottom to the top. Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. Josh Newton: So you should have these neighborhood councils that ultimately vote to have these regional councils that ultimately vote for the council that runs the whole city, right? These could actually make that happen. I mean, the community land trust itself is already kind of a model of that, right? It's people in a neighborhood coming together and collectively deciding what happens to the land in that neighborhood. And so ultimately we could create that utopian form of governance where people have an actual say in what happens in their neighborhoods, Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. Josh Newton: in a collection of neighborhoods and their broader city through that kind of governance process of going from the bottom to the top instead of the top to the bottom. Nathan Young: Yeah. Okay. It it strikes me too, is that like, you know, if if yeah, like a whole city did sort of have control over all the property in their city that way, in a more collective way, yeah, as certain like needs emerged, you know, They'd have some say as far as like, okay, we can open up whatever sort of factory or service or business we need here for the sustainability of this community. And there wouldn't be as much of the overhead challenges that come up as far as like buying the property and Yeah, and like yeah, the money left in the community could go to different services that are needed in the community. Yeah, okay. It's interesting. Josh Newton: And you know, there's actually another utopian vision from urban planning that we usually point to called the garden cities, which was an idea in like the early 20th century. It was kind of a response to industrial, like the industrialization of our cities. Nathan Young: Mm-hmm, mm-hmm. Josh Newton: The guy Ebenezer Howard in the UK was really concerned with the way that like all of these industries were kind of taking over our city, making Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. Josh Newton: them less healthy. making them look ugly, making Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. Josh Newton: them dirty, something that we could probably point to as happening today as well. And he thought one way to like kind of overcome this is create these little communities outside of the inner city that were connected by transit that ultimately would have all of this green space around it, would have businesses that would create these little local economies. Something we typically leave out of the history of that is he also saw those as being collectively owned. So Nathan Young: Mm. Josh Newton: he thought some philanthropists would kind of fund the creation of these little communities. Nathan Young: Mm. Josh Newton: And ultimately through the work that the people provided in those communities, they would be able to purchase that and collectively own it. So again, this is kind of like a forebearer of like these, this idea of the community land trusts. And even like we talk about transit oriented development today, right? these little walkable communities around transit stops that have everything that you need. So, you know, that again is like this utopian vision that we could actually make come to fruition. It's just we need more education around it. We need Nathan Young: Yeah. Josh Newton: more policies to support it. We need more funding going into these models. Nathan Young: Yeah. Well, that's I mean, we'll have to have another conversation about those things. I think this is Josh Newton: Yeah. Nathan Young: probably a good good place to stop here. But yeah, this is all just fascinating to me, because yeah, again, like there's just it does seem like there's such a possibility and it would be so interesting to get more people to be thinking this way. And like I'm sure there's it takes a while to like, you know, it starts with like, okay, like thinking this is possible, this is a thing, and then Josh Newton: Yeah. Nathan Young: being able to recognize the opportunities when and if they emerge and take advantage Josh Newton: Mm-hmm. Nathan Young: of it. And that just takes some like knowledge and understanding of the existence of the possibility, right? Josh Newton: Yeah. And I would just say that like, it just takes one model to show people that it can work. Right. Nathan Young: Yeah. Josh Newton: At one point we had zero community land trusts in San Diego. Now we have two and I know of at least three more that are starting. like, you know, once people see it's possible, they realize this can be done. and it's much easier to scale it up after that. I think it's just a matter of like finding the resources to make it work. Nathan Young: Yeah, yeah. Which that's kind of the rub, right? Yeah. Josh Newton: Yeah. But that's also the problem with affordable housing right now, right? They're saying Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. Josh Newton: we can't build affordable housing because it's so expensive to build it. So we got that problem no matter what. Like let's invest in these innovative models. Nathan Young: Mm. Mm-hmm. Mm-hmm. Yeah, yeah. Well exactly. Yeah, yeah, yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Totally. Totally. Cool. Well, duh, thank you for coming on here and sharing all this stuff. Cause I think this is like really interesting to talk about and you know, like yeah, there's I could probably ask you questions all day about this. So that we'll we'll we'll Josh Newton: Yeah. Nathan Young: we'll save some for later. so anybody that really liked what you're saying here, they want to get in touch with you, they want to hear more, like where where can they find you? Josh Newton: They can contact me by email JDNewton at UCSD.edu. I also have a LinkedIn you can find me on there. And also I have a coalition that's pushing these models called the San Diego Community Wealth Building Coalition. We have an Instagram where we post all of our events. Right now most of our events are around like educating people on these models. So if you want to learn more, come to one Nathan Young: Yeah. Josh Newton: of our events. Nathan Young: Yeah, cool, cool. All right. Sadio Community Wealth Building Coalition and is that right? Did I say that right? Yeah. Josh Newton: Yeah, that's it. Nathan Young: Alright, we'll put links in the in the show notes and everything too. So okay, well Josh Dune, thank you so much for coming on here and sharing all this and really appreciate having you. Josh Newton: Yeah, thanks for having me, Nathan. It was awesome. Nathan Young: All right. That was our conversation with Josh Newton. thanks so much for coming on the show and sharing all these economic models and these possibilities and and things to think about with us, I really appreciate how we walked us through like how these models worked. And even though these aren't the kind of things that like you ever encounter or think about much, and you probably heard me trying to ask all the like really dumb questions because I I know nothing about this stuff prior to having this conversation. And since, you know, the the time since having this conversation and recording this little intro, I've been digging into all kinds of things around this. So I'm super intrigued. I think there's lot here worth exploring. And I think, yeah, it does bring up ideas for me. I think towards the end that we started talking about you know, what retirement is going to be looking like for us and thinking of housing as assets and what that's going to mean for a lot of us too as we get into old age and we depend on like the wealth that's in these properties for those of us that have them to to see us through those years. And I don't know, maybe that might be unrealistic to think about and there's got to be a sort of consideration of a different model. And also thinking about, you know, just the the stories that we tell ourselves about housing and how there's basically, yeah, like either no housing or, you know, we have to build more housing. And and it doesn't sound like any of those options are really helpful or or even feasible or like are gonna happen. So I appreciate that Josh gave us a sort of third way of thinking about how we can be doing housing in the future. especially given that like like Josh was saying here too, these economic models, it just sort of like the there's it's it's built into them to just make housing more and more and more expensive. Because every time a home sells, they gotta sell it for a higher price. Anyways, if this sparks something for you, share it with someone who cares about their city or their community and might get something out of this conversation, check the show notes for ways to connect with Josh, learn more about community land trusts near you. We also put that group Tieras and Dihinas. We put that group's links in the show notes there too. I'm gonna look them up and see if I could talk to them one of these days also. So if you haven't already, subscribe to the channel and we'll catch you next time on Braver New Worlds.