Latest / Politics with Paul / Politics with Paul #33: Psychology and Viewpoints of Independents w/ Guest Lura Forcum
Transcript
- 0:00Welcome back to the politics with Paul podcast.
- 0:03I'm your host, Paul Raider.
- 0:05Got another special episode on tap because we have a guest.
- 0:10Now whether you're new to this podcast or not, I wanna make note that in my line of work,
- 0:14whether I have a guest or not, I do not take a specific stance to for or against anybody's
- 0:20political views or any political groups they belong to.
- 0:23But that being said, today's guest has some very worthwhile and interesting views to
- 0:28discuss on a topic that's often misunderstood in overall political discourse, those who
- 0:34identify as independent.
- 0:37More specifically, our topic is about the psychology and viewpoints of independence as
- 0:43opposed to aspects like their electoral viability or whether we're gonna see more and
- 0:47more of them win elections soon, though maybe we'll dip our toes a little bit into those
- 0:51points.
- 0:52But here to talk with us more in-depth about the topic, someone who is more ingrained in
- 0:57this independent movement, if you will, is our guest today, Laura Forkham.
- 1:02Laura is the president of the Independent Center, which focuses on info, research, and
- 1:07engagement with independent voters.
- 1:09Previously, she was the director of marketing communications at the State Policy Network and
- 1:14an assistant professor of marketing with Clemson University.
- 1:18And she also holds a PhD in consumer psychology from Indiana University.
- 1:24So without further ado, please welcome to the show, Laura Forkham.
- 1:28Laura, thanks for taking the time to be here today.
- 1:30How are you doing?
- 1:31I'm great, Paul.
- 1:32Thank you for having me on your show.
- 1:34Yeah.
- 1:34Absolutely.
- 1:35Thank you for for being here.
- 1:37So first up, let's just let's talk about more about what you do right now.
- 1:43So what led you to head up the independent center, and what is your goal with the
- 1:48organization?
- 1:50So the independent center, like you said, is primarily doing research and engaging with
- 1:56people who identify as political independents or even just kind of independent minded.
- 2:02And the reason it appeals to me personally is because I really don't have a party.
- 2:09I feel kind of politically homeless, and I have for a long time now.
- 2:14And so I was really eager to do something to engage with other people who also feel like
- 2:20they don't have a political home.
- 2:22And I think that a lot of the research that I did as part of my, doctoral research and as a
- 2:31professor actually gave me insight to how we can talk to people more effectively about
- 2:37public policy.
- 2:39One of the things I'm I think maybe I'm unusual in that I I am excited not by my side of
- 2:46politics winning, but by the idea of people engaging in conversation about public policy.
- 2:53And so I know there aren't a lot of people who feel really excited about talking about public
- 2:57policy, but the way I look at it is we could bring more people into that conversation, and
- 3:03it would be better for the for, you know, individual citizens and for the country as a
- 3:08whole if we could bring people into that conversation.
- 3:11And, actually, marketing research knows a whole lot about how to reach people with ideas and
- 3:17also, like, the practice of marketing.
- 3:19And so it seemed to me like there's this huge opportunity and need for it right now because I
- 3:24think increasingly only partisans and only the bases of the two parties are happy with
- 3:32politics in The United States right now.
- 3:35And so there's so many people who I think have just dropped out, and that's who we at the
- 3:41Independence Center really want to reach and have them feel like, you know, they have an
- 3:47identity.
- 3:48There are other people who see the same things they see, and that their political
- 3:52participation is really important.
- 3:55Yeah.
- 3:55The the idea that what you're talking about with, you know, wanting to discuss public
- 4:00policy, that's that is, I think, something that's, you know, isn't is not a is not a
- 4:05political stance.
- 4:05I mean, it's it's something that we need to do more of, and I think there is a serious issue
- 4:11we have with people thinking that they've already got things figured out about public
- 4:17policy, that there's no reason to have a discussion, and it's it's rather unfortunate.
- 4:22But with your research into independence, I'm sure I'm sure you've you've dealt a lot more
- 4:28into why people identify as independence.
- 4:31And I I talked a little bit about it on a previous episode of my podcast.
- 4:36But since you're more ingrained in the movement, you're obviously gonna know a lot
- 4:40more about it than I am.
- 4:42So what exactly does being an independent mean to you?
- 4:45Because like we just said, different people have different definitions.
- 4:49So what makes an independent an independent in terms of how they affiliate politically, how
- 4:54they think, or how they vote?
- 4:57Yeah.
- 4:57So we we have a lot of research that we've done at the Independence Center, doing polling,
- 5:03doing data work with with AI.
- 5:08And so there are a lot of things that that I could kind of point to.
- 5:12The the one of the main things that we focus on is the fact that voters don't have to vote for
- 5:19a third party to be independent.
- 5:22And we know that independents tend to swing vote.
- 5:26They delivered the last election to Donald Trump, but the previous election went to Joe
- 5:31Biden largely because of independent voters.
- 5:35And so they keep, you know, swinging back and forth, and that actually brings accountability
- 5:39to the system.
- 5:40Right?
- 5:40Because it means you have to court these voters.
- 5:43They're not just baked into the equation.
- 5:46And I think a lot of the conversation among the professional political class is based on the
- 5:53assumption that, like, you have a base, and you only have to speak to those people.
- 5:59But if there's if you can't win an election without independence, which is increasingly the
- 6:04case, then you actually have to deliver something to this group of voters in the middle
- 6:10and make sure they're happy in order to get their votes.
- 6:13So one of the things that we're also kind of assuming when we say independent is that they
- 6:18are people who are pro democracy.
- 6:23They're they fall somewhere, and we can get into how complicated this is, somewhere in the
- 6:29middle of the left right political spectrum, not on the outside.
- 6:34So while I'm sure there are people who consider themselves independent who are communist or
- 6:39socialists or fascists or or whatever, that's not the the group of people we're talking to.
- 6:46We're talking to people who are more in the center of the political spectrum.
- 6:51And so, like I said, these are swing voters.
- 6:53These are also split ticket voters, and we're seeing you know, some states just tend towards
- 6:58split ticket voting.
- 7:00Right?
- 7:00They'll have you know, they they went for Donald Trump in the November elections, but
- 7:06they elected democratic senators or democratic governors or more democratic seats down the
- 7:13ticket.
- 7:13So that's another aspect of independent voting that I think is really important for people to
- 7:18understand.
- 7:19You don't have to vote for a third party to be an independent.
- 7:22Just the fact that you are not bought in and sold, you know, with a single party is is
- 7:27actually, like, really productive for our political conversation and and for the overall
- 7:33dynamic of the country.
- 7:36Yeah.
- 7:37With with the the whole split ticket aspects, that's that's something I want to talk about
- 7:41either with a guest or or just on my own in the podcast just because it the general consensus,
- 7:49I guess, if you will, is that split ticket voting is not quite dead, but it's it's it's at
- 7:55lower levels than we've seen in the past, which may be the case, but you still do see some very
- 7:59noticeable instances in Arizona, Maricopa County.
- 8:05The Democratic US Senate candidate Ruben Gallega won that county, but Donald Trump won
- 8:10it in his president obviously, in his presidential bout.
- 8:14So you've touched a little bit on it with these past couple questions, but let's focus a little
- 8:21bit more about it now.
- 8:22What are some of these common traits that you see from independents, whether just just how
- 8:26they vote in particular or just how how they think in general about politics?
- 8:32So I'll I'll walk you through a few different things that kind of, like, stand out in our
- 8:36research about independents.
- 8:39We see that they tend to be very live and let live socially.
- 8:45So they have you know, they think that people should be allowed to to make decisions about
- 8:51their personal lives without government interference.
- 8:56Right?
- 8:57So they tend to just be very, like, open to other people's choices, especially when those
- 9:04choices don't affect them.
- 9:06They also tend to believe that, like, the financial health of the govern of the country
- 9:12is important, that debt and deficit is a concern.
- 9:18But that's not the same as saying cut everything.
- 9:21Right?
- 9:22Like, they they have, I would say, very balanced views on both economic issues and
- 9:29social issues.
- 9:30Right?
- 9:30They're like, we gotta solve this.
- 9:31It's not one or the other.
- 9:33And I think one of the reasons they're turned off by the parties is because the parties tend
- 9:38to have these really extreme views that that just don't represent the complexities of of
- 9:44modern life.
- 9:47So so we see those types of views on policy.
- 9:52Another thing that's really interesting in our research about independence is that they tend
- 9:58to be younger.
- 9:59And so younger generations, millennials and Gen Z, are more likely to identify as independent,
- 10:07which, you know, people are looking at and trying to understand how that trend will will
- 10:12continue as they grow older.
- 10:14Right?
- 10:14Like, the assumption of a lot of people who are involved in party politics is that they will
- 10:20come home.
- 10:21That's what they say.
- 10:22They'll come home to one of the parties.
- 10:24And we really have our doubts about that because, you know, the for for most of these
- 10:31voters, if they're younger, there is no home.
- 10:34Right?
- 10:34Like, they never identified with a party, so there's not a a a home to return to.
- 10:41And they show some other traits if you are researching them or or talking to them that
- 10:48that sound kind of different from more partisan voters.
- 10:52And so one of the things that we see a lot from these voters when we interview them is they
- 11:00think in trade offs.
- 11:02So they wanna know the pros and cons of a particular policy.
- 11:07And it's interesting because there's not much conversation about pros or cons if you're
- 11:13talking about political conversation about policy.
- 11:16Right?
- 11:16If if you have a republican talking about a republican, bill, they're not saying, here's
- 11:24here's the drawbacks that we're taking into consideration.
- 11:27I can't remember the last time I heard that in a policy debate that was happening among
- 11:32elected officials.
- 11:33Right?
- 11:34They're just saying this is this is a great way to do it.
- 11:36This is the best way to do it.
- 11:38And I think, you know, if if you're being honest at all intellectually, you have to admit
- 11:46that, like, there's no law or policy we can pass that is all side.
- 11:51Right?
- 11:52If it were that simple, we we would just know the answers.
- 11:54We wouldn't need government.
- 11:56Policies have unintended consequences, and they are they exist within really complex systems,
- 12:05complex legal and regulatory systems, complex behavior by citizens and and residents of the
- 12:12country.
- 12:13Right?
- 12:13And so, you know, the idea that there's some policy that exists that's just pure, like, hey.
- 12:19This is a great idea.
- 12:20There are no bad parts of it.
- 12:21That's not true, and independents get that.
- 12:23They know that we're gonna have to weigh these things within a single part policy.
- 12:28Right?
- 12:28So if we wanna have, you know, say, environmental emission standards, well, that
- 12:36needs to be be executed within this complex system, right, that has all these far reaching
- 12:44effects.
- 12:45And so there's not a simple answer to it.
- 12:47So not only do we have complexity in figuring out what is a good policy around emissions,
- 12:54there's further complexity because we need to figure out among all the potential policy areas
- 12:59where we need to pass laws, how does this rank?
- 13:02And so it's an incredibly complicated conversation.
- 13:05I understand why most people don't have time to engage with it.
- 13:10And I think independents are unique and that they really do want to, like, grapple with the
- 13:15details and think about trade offs.
- 13:19Yeah.
- 13:19With the with the details and the nuances, that's the that's a lot of the, I think, the
- 13:24contribution to what we call the ballot information problem when, you know, you've got
- 13:28a research candidates.
- 13:29It's it's because it can be so complicated.
- 13:32It's it's sometimes hard to figure out where to go for research.
- 13:37And in regarding the the pros and cons that you were talking about about trade offs and
- 13:41policies, that's something I'm working on in regards to a TED talk I wanna give later this
- 13:47year is that there's a you know, I I think I mean, just the culture in general, but
- 13:53particularly political culture really incentivizes you to say, there there there
- 13:58there is no set incentive to admit that there's a possibility you might be wrong or that you
- 14:03have some sort of flaw in your your policy views or in in your programs because you're
- 14:10trying to get as much support for what you're trying to pass as as possible, but it it has
- 14:19this unfortunate side effect of just deteriorating political discourse because Mhmm.
- 14:25There's you don't wanna admit that you're possibly wrong about something, and it's it's
- 14:29it's something unfortunate.
- 14:31Think I mean, it's it's also just a general part of human nature that's unfortunate.
- 14:35But
- 14:36Yeah.
- 14:36Well, we know about something from psychology called the fluency effect, which says that
- 14:42ideas that seem fluent seem more likely to be true to us.
- 14:47And things are fluent because they're simple and easy to understand.
- 14:51So if you are running a campaign and your answer about policy is the complex one and your
- 14:59opponent's answer about the policy is is very a simple message, Right?
- 15:04They're gonna win.
- 15:05Their answer will seem more true to people who are not well informed on the issue.
- 15:11And so I don't know how we counter that.
- 15:14It's a really big problem.
- 15:15But one of the reasons I think it's so important to enfranchise independent voters and
- 15:21to bring them into more political discourse and engagement is because these are people who are
- 15:27already inclined to understand that complexity and maybe a little bit less likely to fall for
- 15:33a fluency effect because they would say, well, that's just simplistic.
- 15:36That's not serious.
- 15:38Okay.
- 15:38Interesting.
- 15:39The fluency effect.
- 15:40That kinda sounds like sounds rather like Occam's razor.
- 15:44If Whatever is the simplest thing is is probably the thing that's true.
- 15:48That's that's an interesting viewpoint.
- 15:51But to the next question, we have the typical conception of the partisan spec I I have a
- 15:58feeling I kinda know where you're going with with this, but the typical conception of the
- 16:02partisan spectrum is democrat, lean democrat, independent, lean republican, republican.
- 16:08What is your take on that, and do you find these categories helpful?
- 16:15Well, I mean, sure.
- 16:16If we if we said, well, there's no such thing as a Republican or Democrat, I don't think that
- 16:20would help us have a clearer understanding of of our political process.
- 16:25But I do think what we say and what some other researchers were not you know, this is not our
- 16:31idea.
- 16:31This is an existing idea.
- 16:33Is that instead of a two dimensional or sorry.
- 16:36Instead of a one dimensional spectrum, there's actually a two dimensional spectrum.
- 16:39Right?
- 16:39So then instead of falling into one of two categories or one of five, if you're talking
- 16:46about the the lean, democrat, and independent, then there's actually at least four spaces.
- 16:52Right?
- 16:52Because you have two axes just like an x y axis.
- 16:57Right?
- 16:58And so that you can have people on the off diagonals where you would be, and this is what
- 17:06we find about independence, right, that, like, socially, they tend to be what you would call
- 17:11more liberal.
- 17:12So they they are fine with same sex marriage.
- 17:17They are less restrictive about abortion views on abortion, those types of social policies,
- 17:27more open to, like, DEI and diversity type initiatives.
- 17:31And coupled with expecting government to be effective and expecting us to adhere to fiscal
- 17:40policy that's sensible.
- 17:42So one of the things that we saw in the last election was that independents, if you ask them
- 17:49what their priorities were, affordability and inflation were major concerns.
- 17:56And that was also true of Republican voters.
- 17:59Right?
- 17:59Like, those were top priorities for them.
- 18:02And so it's like, this is you can see why these parties or sorry.
- 18:07You can see why these voters are not represented by a party.
- 18:10Right?
- 18:10Like, they're taking from both sides.
- 18:13And so I think that that that four quadrant space that you get with a two dimensional
- 18:21political diagram this is much easier to talk about if you have a picture, but that, like,
- 18:26that two dimensional way of thinking about politics to me seems more accurate, in
- 18:32representing voter preferences.
- 18:34But, of course, then the question is, you know, is that a third party?
- 18:40Right?
- 18:40And we're really not talking about our work as a party.
- 18:44We're talking about as as a movement of voters.
- 18:49Well, I think that's a that's a good segue into this next question because independence excuse
- 18:55me.
- 18:56Independents are often treated monolithically.
- 18:59And, I mean, I I obviously I generally have a problem with a group being considered
- 19:03monolithic even though we all, at some point, treat a group as monolithic.
- 19:08But much like Democrats and Republicans are sometimes considered to be monolithic even even
- 19:13though they're not as well.
- 19:15But from an outside observer's perspective, it might seem like independents are a less
- 19:21cohesive group.
- 19:22So do you agree with that conclusion, or are independents more cohesive than we often think?
- 19:27Or maybe the better question is, in what ways are independents a cohesive group, and maybe
- 19:32one in other ways are they not so much of a cohesive group in your estimation?
- 19:37Yeah.
- 19:38So we actually have some research measuring cohesion of political views, and we compared
- 19:46the cohesion of independents, Republicans and Democrats and actually found that the
- 19:52independents were most cohesive.
- 19:56And I think part of the reason that's the case is because increasingly, seems like the parties
- 20:03are less reliant on the political philosophy that might have dictated their positions, like,
- 20:10twenty, thirty, forty years ago, and they really seem to form their policy positions just
- 20:16in opposition to the other party.
- 20:18Right?
- 20:18So if if Democrats are concerned with environmental conservation, Republicans are
- 20:25completely opposed.
- 20:26Right?
- 20:26And there's just very it seems like there are few areas in which people, in which both
- 20:33parties agree with each other, but that's actually kind of misleading.
- 20:37If you pull people on their views on a lot of these issues, you'll find that they're closer
- 20:42together than than our national political conversation sounds or than you would hear in
- 20:49the media.
- 20:50So it's it's interesting to me that we have this really divisive rhetoric, but people's
- 20:56beliefs, especially when you pull them in ways that don't rely on, like, the political
- 21:03language that's used to describe the policy, you'll hear something really different than
- 21:08than than what is supposedly the position of people, like, if we're treating them like a
- 21:13monolith like yours.
- 21:16That's an interesting way to put it because I whenever I think about cohesion, often think
- 21:22back to something I learned in grad school.
- 21:24There was a political scientist, the late great Philip Compress, or at least I think he's
- 21:30passed.
- 21:31It was a study he had done back in the nineteen sixties, and he revisited it later.
- 21:34But, basically, it was the idea of what he calls ideological constraint where, basically,
- 21:40if one value shifts, how much do does the rest of your political values shift?
- 21:48And generally speaking, the elites or what we'd call elites, people who are in office, who run
- 21:54for office, they tend to have a lot higher of a an ideological constraint, whereas voters tend
- 22:00to have much less of that where if if one value shifts, the rest of values don't necessarily
- 22:08shift.
- 22:10So it kinda sounds like you're when you talk about the parties, you know, voters are big or
- 22:15the the parties in general are becoming more and more ideologically constrained.
- 22:19But do you see independence do you see independence necessarily doing that as well?
- 22:26That's a really interesting way to frame it.
- 22:30So it's just basically is cohesion the same idea as constraint?
- 22:35Is that how you're thinking of it?
- 22:37Like, if you're very if you have a lot of cohesion, then changing your position on one
- 22:43thing should kind of have ripple effects on the rest of your position.
- 22:46Yeah.
- 22:46I I I guess, you know, what I you know, I guess you could depends on what your, you know,
- 22:51definition of cohesion is.
- 22:53But basically, the idea is like, if you're very committed to the idea of being a conservative
- 22:59or you're very committed to the idea of being a liberal, if one conservative value shifts, then
- 23:06your other conservative value shift.
- 23:08If you become more conservative on abortion, for example, then you might become more
- 23:12conservative on on on gun laws and and and social program spending and and and things like
- 23:21that.
- 23:22Is there necessarily that kind of thing with independence where if, I guess, let's say, they
- 23:29go go more towards the middle on abortion, for example, would they necessarily go more to the
- 23:35middle on gun rights?
- 23:38Or or or I I should say gun laws specifically to try to be gun control to some people and
- 23:44then gun rights to or gun safety to some people, gun rights to other people.
- 23:48Do you see a lot of that movement with with independence, or do they just not even think in
- 23:54those terms?
- 23:55So I I would say what we see from independence is that they want policy that works, and they
- 24:02are not likely to sort of agree with the existing kind of discourse we'll have where
- 24:09it's like, you know, democrats will say, our gun laws are woefully inadequate.
- 24:16We need to do something because there are major safety problems.
- 24:20Right?
- 24:20Like, this is a major problem.
- 24:22And the contrary point from Republicans is, no.
- 24:26It's great just like it is.
- 24:28Right?
- 24:28And so I think they tend to be they want a consensus.
- 24:33Right, which is like, hey.
- 24:34There are some real problems, and we should address them, but but not by, you know, doing
- 24:40what what Republicans have always feared and going door to door and collecting your guns.
- 24:45Right?
- 24:45Like, they want a sensible solution.
- 24:49And and the fact that the two parties seem to be locked in this really absurd conversation of
- 24:56extremes just prevents any kind of solution.
- 24:59Right?
- 24:59Like, they're just gridlock within congress.
- 25:02And and so, like, that's not government being effective.
- 25:07That's not creating policies that make people's lives better.
- 25:11The other way you could look at cohesion so this is, like, this is a fascinating issue.
- 25:15I feel like you could you could do an entire podcast on this.
- 25:19So I'll point out two things.
- 25:21One way to think about cohesion too is instead of the views of an individual being consistent
- 25:27with each other, if you think about cohesion in terms of whether you can predict whether a
- 25:34group of voters behaves the same way, right, whether they all hold the same position, I
- 25:40think is another interesting way to look at it.
- 25:42And so when we talk about cohesion in our research, what we mean is that you can predict
- 25:47the views of independence a lot better than you can Republicans or Democrats because
- 25:54Republicans, for example, differ quite a bit on abortion.
- 25:58The the national viewpoint is actually, on average, most Americans support some degree of
- 26:05access to abortion.
- 26:07Right?
- 26:09But among Republicans, you know, for example, Donald Trump changed the party's position on
- 26:17abortion with his platform in the last election.
- 26:21So you have both voters who are, you know, fully, full stop, completely opposed to
- 26:28abortion within the same party as you have voters who say, well, we need we need some
- 26:33degree of abortion access for women's health.
- 26:37Right?
- 26:38And so that type of cohesion is also something that I think is really important to consider.
- 26:45It's the same on the democrats.
- 26:47Right?
- 26:47There are issues where there's a mix in terms of of people's position.
- 26:52And maybe that's sort of reflecting the complexity of our political environment.
- 26:57Right?
- 26:58And, like, we're we're just stepping away from this idea of, total cohesion within any party,
- 27:06including independents.
- 27:08The other thing that I think is is interesting and notable is the fact that it seems like the
- 27:17parties have kind of stepped away from the underlying philosophy that used to kind of
- 27:22govern what the the platforms and planks that made them up were.
- 27:28And now it tends to be much more driven by an individual.
- 27:31I think it's most obvious on the Republican side, but it's happening on the Democratic side
- 27:36as well.
- 27:37And so I think when you can't say what do we Republicans or what do we mean by being
- 27:43Democrats, then all you're really left with is, like, well, we do whatever the president says.
- 27:50The president is the one setting, right, or the the head of the party is the one setting the
- 27:55positions on different issues.
- 27:57And so that's been an interesting trend to notice because it it suggests to me that it's
- 28:04gonna be more personality driven.
- 28:07Right?
- 28:07Like, you'll instead of having a party with kind of a coalition of people who agree for the
- 28:15most part on values, you'll end up with this kind of, like, monoculture where it's it's
- 28:21really a single or few or individual people whose positions dictate the party positions.
- 28:30Yeah.
- 28:31That the whole you know, we we we tend to look towards a figurehead for some sort of
- 28:37Mhmm.
- 28:38Guidance or or what have you.
- 28:40And and and then I guess you like you're saying, kinda see that a little bit more these
- 28:44days.
- 28:44Just wanna make sure I heard something correct correctly because that that was a really
- 28:49interesting point.
- 28:49You said it's actually easier to predict independence and how they think on a a position
- 28:55versus republicans and democrats?
- 28:57Mhmm.
- 28:57Yep.
- 28:58So, yeah, the like, it will be it's because there's a mix of positions on an issue.
- 29:05Like, you know, it is abortion is a good example, but also things like school choice.
- 29:12Right?
- 29:12You have you'll have a range of degrees of acceptance on it within the same party, And and
- 29:19that's true across multiple issues.
- 29:21Immigration is another example, right, where within the same party, you have, some people
- 29:29who would be more receptive towards, I don't know how you wanna reform of the immigration
- 29:37system and more people who prefer a limiting of immigration.
- 29:42Interesting.
- 29:43Wow.
- 29:44Okay.
- 29:45That's something I I you know, I I I guess you might necessarily think the opposite way.
- 29:50You'd you'd you'd expect the parties to be a little bit more predictable.
- 29:55Now, again, not not to, you know, obviously, I don't wanna trade any group monolithically, but
- 30:00that that isn't really interesting point to make there.
- 30:05But let's move on to shift gears just a little bit.
- 30:09What are one or two of the biggest misconceptions you see about independents in
- 30:15terms of how they think about things or how they vote in general?
- 30:18Whatever the case may be, what are one or two of the biggest misconceptions about
- 30:22independents you see?
- 30:25So, I mean, we touched on this a little bit before, but I think one is this idea that
- 30:29they're gonna come home to a party.
- 30:32And, you know, I think when I think about, like, what are the psychological traits that
- 30:39make up an independent, one of the things I think of is that they are more tolerant of
- 30:46ambiguity and ambivalence.
- 30:49Right?
- 30:49So, you know, another psychological trait we know about humans in general is that, like,
- 30:56ambiguity and ambivalence are cognitively expensive, and we don't like to have things up
- 31:04in the air and unsettled.
- 31:05Right?
- 31:05Like, we just want a ruling.
- 31:06We wanna know is this good or bad?
- 31:09And I think independents have a lot more tolerance for that kind of, you know, there are
- 31:14some good parts.
- 31:15There are some bad thing parts.
- 31:16It's a mix.
- 31:17Right?
- 31:18And so I actually think that means that they're not gonna be inclined to come home to a party.
- 31:24I think that's a a serious misconception.
- 31:27And, you know, as long as people in party leadership and and, like, political advertising
- 31:36and the the sort of political industrial complex, as long as they are able to sort of
- 31:43rely on part partisans to win elections, they don't have any incentive to reach these
- 31:49independents.
- 31:50But the more independents there are, the more they're really gonna be forced to compete for
- 31:54votes.
- 31:55And I think that that is that's the best thing that can happen.
- 32:00You know, I think about it in terms of, like, consumers and marketplaces.
- 32:05Right?
- 32:06Like, where you have a lot of competition for, for consumers for selling them a product, you
- 32:14get higher quality products at lower prices that match what people want more.
- 32:20And so that's not really what we have in politics right now.
- 32:23We have two parties saying, well, this is what we this is what we are.
- 32:26Take it or leave it.
- 32:28And, you know, that they've arrived at this equilibrium where it's like they're both I
- 32:34think they're both very happy with where they are, right, because they don't have to actually
- 32:39listen to voters and court voters and win over voters.
- 32:43They they just talk to their base.
- 32:45Whatever we sell at the Republican store, you can take it or leave it.
- 32:48And or whatever we sell at the Democratic store, you can take it or leave it.
- 32:52You can take it or leave it.
- 32:53Yeah.
- 32:53Yeah.
- 32:54And you fundraise off of this.
- 32:55Right?
- 32:56Like, you fundraise off of the fact that you're stopping the other guys, but you don't have
- 33:01your own vision of what you can offer to voters.
- 33:04And so I understand why it's appealing to the parties, but I also think that it's not serving
- 33:11voters.
- 33:13Yeah.
- 33:14And in a way, it's also not serving their I mean, sometimes they don't realize it, but it
- 33:20doesn't serve their interest eventually anyway.
- 33:22So sometimes it it causes them to lose an election kinda like you're losing business as a
- 33:26store.
- 33:26So that's a really neat analogy that I hadn't really thought about before.
- 33:30But going back a little bit real quick to the ambiguity and the ambivalence, yeah, I think it
- 33:37kinda goes back to that whole culture not wanting to, and we don't wanna admit that we're
- 33:42wrong about something.
- 33:43It's it's it's sort of a threat to not only to whether we you know, how right we think we are,
- 33:49but, like, a threat to our existence.
- 33:50Like, no.
- 33:51No.
- 33:51I've already figured this kind of thing out.
- 33:53I don't I don't need other considerations to kind of kind of think about it in that regard.
- 34:02So to the next question, some political observers and academics would argue that there
- 34:08are relatively few true independents.
- 34:11And I know we've talked a little bit more about this, but I wanted to hear you talk about in
- 34:15regards to this specific question.
- 34:17So personally, I'm a bit skeptical of the whole there are few true independents.
- 34:22I think I think some of the ways that it's been studied have been flawed, and I'm sure you are
- 34:26skeptical of it too.
- 34:27But why do you think some people that study politics think that way?
- 34:33And do you think they the way that they've been studying independents or or specifically more
- 34:39specifically independent voters is flawed in some way.
- 34:44So if they mean independents in the sense that they vote third party, then I would have to
- 34:50agree.
- 34:51Like, in terms of pure third party voters, those are a very small fraction of the
- 34:55electorate, and there's not really any arguing with that.
- 34:59But I think the fact that you have, you know, independents sort of swinging back and forth,
- 35:05and they've been an influential influential block of voters in elections going back to the
- 35:13first Obama administration, first Obama term.
- 35:17So the fact that they are are looking at their two options for presidential election and
- 35:27saying, you know, I'm still thinking about it.
- 35:29Like, to me, that that's a sizable group of voters.
- 35:33I'm sorry.
- 35:33I don't have statistics at hand, to tell you an exact number, but, like, that's a significant
- 35:38proportion of voters.
- 35:40And and I think that is what we need more of.
- 35:43Right?
- 35:43Like, that's what we want to create kind of, a movement of people who feel like they are not
- 35:52alone.
- 35:53There are other voters like them who look at the at the ballot and go, you know, I don't
- 35:59know.
- 36:00I'm still deciding.
- 36:01Tell me what tell me what you're offering.
- 36:04You know, you were talking about how we like this feeling of knowing that we're right.
- 36:09And I think that, you know, when when that goes into your party identity, that can be really
- 36:17problematic.
- 36:18Right?
- 36:18Because you just kind of get together with the people who agree with you and and congratulate
- 36:24yourselves on being right and feel right together.
- 36:26And I know that's appealing.
- 36:27It's a good feeling, and it's important to humans.
- 36:31But the one of the things that I really like about independence is that they are instead of
- 36:38saying we know we're right, when I talk to them and when you study them and listen to them
- 36:43talking, what they're kind of saying is, hey.
- 36:46We're still figuring it out.
- 36:48And they're comfortable with this idea that it still needs to be figured out.
- 36:52And, again, that's the kind of political discourse that I think is really more
- 36:58productive instead of just having these two camps where it's like, well, you know, lump it
- 37:04or leave it.
- 37:05Right?
- 37:05Like, you you can like or whatever.
- 37:07Like it or lump it.
- 37:08This is a republican story.
- 37:09This is a democratic story.
- 37:10You'll you'll have to go somewhere else.
- 37:13Right.
- 37:13Right.
- 37:16And I that kinda speaks to this next question I have.
- 37:19And undoubtedly, we have an issue with polarization in this country now.
- 37:24That's that's a bit a little bit more of a hole of the can of worms as to how polarized we are,
- 37:29but you can look at it from partisan where, the two parties are so polarized ideologically,
- 37:36where conservatives and liberals are highly polarized even and even though partisan and
- 37:41ideological polarization is very well related.
- 37:46It's not the exact same thing.
- 37:48Affective how we feel about each other, issue based polarization.
- 37:53But do you believe polarization is as much of a problem as we make it out to be?
- 38:00Yeah.
- 38:00I mean, I think when we're talking about this, like, affective polarization where it's not
- 38:08that we disagree.
- 38:10It's that we think that the other side are bad people.
- 38:15That's a real problem, and I I think that that absolutely exists.
- 38:19I don't think that that's, exaggerated at all.
- 38:22You you hear this language, right, and and political conversation and campaigns that's
- 38:29incredibly it's polarizing.
- 38:32It's also dehumanizing in a lot of ways.
- 38:35Right?
- 38:35Like, those aren't those aren't fellow citizens that happen to have a different viewpoint.
- 38:41They are they're bad or morally flawed people.
- 38:46Like, something is fundamentally wrong with
- 38:48stupid and evil.
- 38:49Yeah.
- 38:50Yes.
- 38:50Yeah.
- 38:52And so I I think, like, that's incredibly damaging.
- 38:57And I think that independence actually offer a really important counterweight to that because,
- 39:03you know, what actually tends to happen and there's there's research about this that, it's
- 39:09it's research from social networks, but people started studying social networks actually,
- 39:15like, in real life a long time before the advent of social media network.
- 39:21But one of the things we know about groups of people is that when when you end up with these
- 39:30small cohesive groups of people who talk to each other, their viewpoints tend to get more
- 39:36extreme.
- 39:37And so it's like the more polarization we have, the more polarization we'll get because they
- 39:43will keep reinforcing their views, and and the range of acceptable views will get smaller and
- 39:50smaller, and it kind of, like, pulls out towards the edges.
- 39:55And so I think bringing people into political conversation who have a mix of viewpoints or
- 40:02who have you know, who are interested in consensus and who can listen to other
- 40:08viewpoints and sort of put them together into one conversation that's not polarizing.
- 40:15Right?
- 40:15It's not saying, well, you're the bad guys, and we're the good guys.
- 40:17It's saying, you have some points, and you have some points.
- 40:20Let's put them together into a workable solution.
- 40:23That's how you can actually counter polarization.
- 40:26But, you know, there's actually some really interesting work being done by a group called
- 40:31the Dignity Index.
- 40:32And what they do is train people to identify dehumanizing language in political
- 40:38conversation.
- 40:40And it's really interesting because once they I think once you have it pointed out to you that
- 40:45this is actually dehumanizing, you can't unhear it.
- 40:50But to me, that's one of the indications that we're really in in troubling or problematic
- 40:55territory is the fact that we're using this dehumanizing language, and that is often the
- 41:02justification for violence, for threat, for all kinds of things that that have never been part
- 41:08of the American political experiment.
- 41:12So I'm not I'm not saying it's a bad thing for people to disagree on policy.
- 41:17And I think independents are fine with people disagreeing on policy, but the, where you have
- 41:24to draw a line is in saying, we disagree and therefore you're a bad person, or you're not
- 41:29one of us.
- 41:31That's really important to our work at the independence center is like, we want people to
- 41:36know that they are welcome to question whatever policy is being put forward and that policy
- 41:44should match their preferences and their values, not the other way around.
- 41:48Right?
- 41:49Like, you don't need to to make yourself get on board with whatever the policy position is in
- 41:55order to be one of us.
- 41:56And I think the parties do demand that.
- 41:58Right?
- 41:59They say if you don't support this policy, you can't be one of us.
- 42:03If you have questions about this issue, you're not one of us.
- 42:06And, again, that's another hallmark of polarization.
- 42:10Yeah.
- 42:10That specifically goes to you hear people call Democrats call certain other Democrats dinos,
- 42:16and you hear Republicans call certain other Republicans rhinos.
- 42:20And for anybody who who at home who doesn't know, dino just means Democrat in name only.
- 42:25Republican means Republican in name only.
- 42:27It's sort of a no true Scotsman fallacy.
- 42:29Like, oh, that's not a republican.
- 42:30Oh, that's not a real democrat.
- 42:33And I I'm glad you also singled out the effect of polarization, Barton.
- 42:37That's something I am gonna talk about in the in the talk that I'm putting together, and
- 42:41there's an educational email series I have about polarization and and some of the ways we
- 42:47unintentionally increase it and why we why we make those mistakes and how we can correct
- 42:53those mistakes.
- 42:54But a a lot of it goes back to I think the the crux of the issue is not how far the parties
- 43:01are apart or how far the ideologies are or issue camps are.
- 43:07It's the affective part.
- 43:09It's the whole because we hate each other so much, we have to go as far to the other side as
- 43:15possible, and it just really feeds into this Mhmm.
- 43:19Polarization.
- 43:19But at the same time, you know, there are studies that talk about how yeah.
- 43:24We do need to talk about polarization, but at the same time, the way when polarization gets
- 43:33talked about too much, it gets too much attention, basically, people might mute their
- 43:38their polarization on issues, but their affective polarization increases.
- 43:43Their dislike of other people goes up.
- 43:45So it just kind of speaks to that.
- 43:49But a little bit more on the polarization aspects.
- 43:53How exactly do you see there's probably, you know, if you were to sufficiently answer this,
- 43:58it's probably a little bit too long, but just some of the key points you think.
- 44:03How do you see independence helping to close this polarize polarization gap, and how does
- 44:09political independence help the nation become less polarized?
- 44:14So the way I would look at it is that, you know, partisans we can't partisans are gonna
- 44:21make each other more extreme on both sides.
- 44:24Right?
- 44:24And we can't get those extreme voices out of politics.
- 44:28Right?
- 44:28Like, they there's no getting rid of those people.
- 44:31The only thing we can really do is moderate their effect by bringing in voices that are
- 44:37less extreme.
- 44:39And so the opportunity here is to bring in more voices.
- 44:43And I think the the thing that will happen is they if the parties have to compete for their
- 44:51votes, it will actually pull the party positions back toward the center, right, rather
- 44:56than this, like, small extreme body that's just gonna keep getting further and further to the
- 45:03edges.
- 45:04Right?
- 45:04Like, it's the fact that you have to appeal to and win over these voters who are not a done
- 45:10deal for anybody's camp that will actually sort of turn down the temperature on affective
- 45:17polarization.
- 45:18And, you know, another thing that we know in research about interacting with people who
- 45:25disagree with you or who are different from you is that that's a a really powerful force for
- 45:31addressing the affect of polarization because, you know, I'm sure you probably had this
- 45:37experience.
- 45:38I have it.
- 45:38It's like, if you don't have to talk to people who are the other side, right, like, you are
- 45:45free to come up with whatever attributions and conception of them that you want.
- 45:51Right?
- 45:51And you can make all kinds of inferences and assumptions about what drives their behavior
- 45:57and what they're like as people.
- 45:59But if you actually talk to them, right, or you have to go you know, you are part of the town
- 46:05council together.
- 46:06You go to litter cleanup day together.
- 46:08Right?
- 46:08You are forced to confront this kind of messy reality, which is that they are actually a lot
- 46:13more com complex as individuals than whatever you made up in your head about them.
- 46:20Right?
- 46:20And so I think it's this process of actually being connected and in conversation with both
- 46:29sides that makes independence a tremendous force for depolarization and for addressing
- 46:35affective polarization.
- 46:37But, you know, I think I've been thinking about this a lot lately, like, as it relates to my
- 46:44kids and trying to set up play dates, which, you know, if you have kids, everybody works.
- 46:50Everybody has school activities.
- 46:52It's incredibly hard to arrange a play date for kids to hang out and do things.
- 46:56Right?
- 46:57And so I think what happens is you end up hanging out with the people who are most like
- 47:03you.
- 47:04Right?
- 47:05And the kids are gonna do it.
- 47:06They're gonna hang out with if you can only do one plate eight in a week, it's gonna be your
- 47:09favorite friend.
- 47:10Right?
- 47:11And it happens to adults too.
- 47:13We don't have time for socializing.
- 47:14We don't have time for rubbing elbows with our neighbors and and having dinner.
- 47:19And so what you end up doing is spending time with the people who are easiest for you to
- 47:24spend time with, which means it's gonna be the people who are most like you.
- 47:28Because we we know, actually, it's called homophily.
- 47:31People spend time and are close with the people who are most similar to them.
- 47:35And social media algorithms are doing it to us too.
- 47:38So, like, if we go through life spending most of our limited social time interacting with
- 47:45people who are most like us, That's not that's not productive for humans.
- 47:53It's not productive for democracy.
- 47:54Right?
- 47:55Like, that's just not how we were meant to interact with each other.
- 47:58And so, you know, we have a a larger sort of, like, society and and technologically driven
- 48:06problem, which is extreme.
- 48:09Yeah.
- 48:09I guess I would say extreme homogeneity.
- 48:12Right?
- 48:13And and the tendency for that homogeneity is to create polarization.
- 48:18So so to me, what we need is, like, a different way of looking at politics, and I think that
- 48:25that's what independents offer.
- 48:27They're they're here for complexity.
- 48:29They're here for ambiguity.
- 48:30They're here for consensus and talking even though we don't agree.
- 48:36And I think that that is, like, one of the most beneficial things that we could offer to to the
- 48:41political discourse.
- 48:43I guess the cat didn't quite agree with that with that sentiment.
- 48:47Yes.
- 48:47That was
- 48:49That's alright.
- 48:50I love cats, though.
- 48:51But you you what you you just spoke to is that unfortunate predisposition towards echo
- 48:58chambers that we have to unfortunately, we have to work harder than ever to make sure that we
- 49:02don't fall into those.
- 49:03And you I mean, you can even extend that past politics because I I mean, there's even sports
- 49:10figures.
- 49:11I'm I'm I'm a big sports guy, and there's there's sports figures that I I I hated for one
- 49:16reason or not.
- 49:17Not even like they played on a team or coached a team that I hated.
- 49:20I just I just didn't like their attitude about things, but then I actually listened to them.
- 49:23I was like, you know what?
- 49:24This guy's not that bad.
- 49:25So, unfortunately, it it can happen to to anybody, and it it's it's something I think
- 49:31some people think they're a little bit less or a little more immune to, little less given to
- 49:39to those kinds of things, but it's something that you've gotta watch out for because if if
- 49:44you don't, it's it's it's something that can easily happen.
- 49:49Okay.
- 49:50That's technically more the penultimate question regarding independence, but a common
- 49:54theme of human psychology is this whole in group, out group dynamic.
- 49:58My great group is great, wonderful, and pure, and and it's got everything right, and the
- 50:04other groups are dumb, terrible, evil.
- 50:06They get everything wrong.
- 50:09How maybe not necessarily just how do independents, you know, try to break through
- 50:17that mold, but how how in general do we what are some ways that we can try to break
- 50:24ourselves free from that?
- 50:25I know you talked a little bit about it, but maybe go go a little more in-depth.
- 50:28How do we break out of that in group out group dynamic regardless of what our partisan
- 50:33affiliations are?
- 50:35So that's a great question.
- 50:37And in group and out group dynamics are are an area of psychology that I think is actually
- 50:45really helpful to understanding our political environment right now because and and I don't
- 50:51know if this is, you know, common knowledge among people in general, but, like, this is how
- 50:57I think about our political dynamics.
- 51:00So in groups are, like, you know, what would have been your tribe ten thousand years ago,
- 51:08twenty thousand years ago.
- 51:09Right?
- 51:09Like, these are your relatives and close others.
- 51:13And in modern life, it's like, maybe it's our neighborhood.
- 51:17Maybe it's our worker our our colleagues at work.
- 51:20Maybe it is, like, a religious community.
- 51:25And so you can have multiple different in groups.
- 51:28Right?
- 51:28But we don't have as much experience with outgroups.
- 51:31So outgroups in, you know, historical times would have been other warring tribes.
- 51:38And we have a little bit of outgroup dynamics in our normal life, or at least we have over,
- 51:45you know, the past fifty years where, like, you know, the fans of a competing sports team,
- 51:50maybe it feels outgroup y.
- 51:51Or if there's a hostile nation, right, like residents of China or Russia.
- 51:58Right?
- 51:59Like, we would view them as an outgroup to us.
- 52:02The problem is we are now looking at the other political party as an outgroup.
- 52:09And I think, you know, what we're forgetting is that outgroups historically were for warring
- 52:18and fighting and taking from.
- 52:21Right?
- 52:22They were not us.
- 52:23There's the there's we are the in group, and then they are the out group.
- 52:27That's them.
- 52:28They're bad people.
- 52:29They don't need to be treated with the same human dignity and respect.
- 52:33And in some cases, people would agree that they're not even fully human.
- 52:38Right?
- 52:38And so that's what I hear creeping into our political rhetoric.
- 52:42And, you know, that's what explains why you have one set of standards for your own party
- 52:48leadership and a totally different set of standards for the other side.
- 52:53Right?
- 52:53Like, that's why when you look at your party leadership, you would say, like, oh, well, he
- 52:57doesn't really mean that.
- 52:59She's very trustworthy.
- 53:01Right?
- 53:01Like, you make much more positive attributions.
- 53:04You have a lot more trust for the within the in group, and the out group can't be trusted.
- 53:10Right?
- 53:12I don't know if you're familiar with this, but people's we do polling.
- 53:19Everybody does this polling, right, about, like, the direction of the country or your
- 53:23feelings of you know, related to, like, feeling like you have financial resources.
- 53:30Right?
- 53:30People's economic prospects.
- 53:33For, I think, the past eighty or so years, those feelings of of economic security have
- 53:40tracked with whether your party is in power.
- 53:43Right?
- 53:43And so if you if you don't have this in group, out group understanding, then you would be
- 53:47like, well, why should that matter?
- 53:49Right?
- 53:49But the reason it matters is because people actually give preferentially to members of
- 53:55their own in group.
- 53:57Right?
- 53:58So if you have resources that you're giving out, you give more of those resources to the in
- 54:02group, and you give fewer of them to the out group.
- 54:05Even if you're asked to distribute them evenly, people do this without awareness.
- 54:09And so that explains why when the other party is in power, you go, well, like, that's not
- 54:14good.
- 54:15I'm not gonna get the stuff I need.
- 54:16I don't feel very secure, and I don't trust them to govern in my favor.
- 54:21And so that is the dynamic that I wish that more people understood because it's just so
- 54:26damaging and problematic.
- 54:28It doesn't belong in our political conversation.
- 54:31Right?
- 54:32It doesn't matter if somebody is a republican or a democrat or an independent.
- 54:36They're my fellow citizens.
- 54:38And we have to govern and live together, and we can govern and live together even with really,
- 54:43like, deeply ingrained differences of opinion about politics.
- 54:47So I think that we have to we have to, like, understand this inclination and take steps to
- 54:54talk differently about politics.
- 54:56And that's what I like about independence is that, like, they don't have they don't have a
- 55:03strong feeling of, like, hey.
- 55:06You're on my side or you're not on my side.
- 55:08They're just kind of saying, guys, we're gonna have to all figure this out.
- 55:13No.
- 55:14I I I totally get that.
- 55:18And, you know, with with the whole sometimes you get those trying to think of a specific
- 55:23study.
- 55:23My memory memory is hazy on it, but basically how you know, if there is an exception where
- 55:29your in group does something that is not necessarily morally reprehensible, but they do
- 55:36something bad that's not necessarily related to political views.
- 55:39You might say, oh, well, that's just a that's an exception, or they're not really one of us.
- 55:44And then if somebody on the out in the out group does something that you you you respect,
- 55:51like, well, that's that's just an exception.
- 55:52That's that's
- 55:53Exactly.
- 55:54That's the
- 55:54of the good that yeah.
- 55:56Yeah.
- 55:56Exactly.
- 55:57That's the fundamental attribution error is that, you know, for in group or for for you,
- 56:04right, the explanation is, like, what wasn't really that's not really who I am.
- 56:08That's not really my fault.
- 56:09That wasn't my control.
- 56:10It's making these in psychology, they're called motivated attributions or motivated judgments
- 56:18because your motivation is to explain why you and your side is right and the other side is
- 56:24not.
- 56:24And so we do all this discounting.
- 56:26Right?
- 56:27Like, you know, if the Trump administration fixes the American economy and everything is
- 56:34great four years from now, then democrats will say, well, actually, that was that was all
- 56:43because of Joe Biden's infrastructure work.
- 56:46Right?
- 56:46And and if he doesn't, right, republicans will say, well, you know, he Joe Biden left in such
- 56:52bad shape.
- 56:53How what could he have really done?
- 56:55Right?
- 56:55And so we're left with this conversation that is actually not really tethered to reality.
- 57:00Right?
- 57:01It's just in group members defending their own.
- 57:04And so I think the more we can involve independence and enfranchise independence, the
- 57:10less our conversation will be motivated in that way.
- 57:13Right?
- 57:14It'll be like, I don't really care whose side did what.
- 57:19You are an elected official.
- 57:21Your job is to govern effectively in the interests of all citizens of this country, and
- 57:26you're not doing it.
- 57:29Yeah.
- 57:31Yeah.
- 57:31And I remember the first time I really noticed that.
- 57:34I was I was eight when George W.
- 57:37Bush won his first term, so I didn't really quite see it as much with Clinton and Bush, or
- 57:43I wasn't really aware of it.
- 57:44But, I mean, that thing about whether it's Joe Biden or Donald Trump responsible for it kinda
- 57:49makes me think of back when when when from George W.
- 57:52Bush to Barack Obama was kind of the, same way because, again, everybody's gotta be my guy is
- 57:58the one that that was the correct one kinda thing.
- 58:02Before I get to the final final question, which is a nonpolitical thing, any final thoughts
- 58:07you'd like to share about independent voters or candidates or something that you'd like to
- 58:11reiterate?
- 58:13Yeah.
- 58:13So I'll just reiterate that, you know, you can be an independent or an independent minded
- 58:19voter without voting third party.
- 58:21You can split ticket vote.
- 58:22You can swing vote.
- 58:24Right?
- 58:24Like, you can go back and forth.
- 58:27But if you feel like you're not politically homeless, you are not alone.
- 58:31We are doing our best to reach independent voters and sort of create this community of
- 58:37people who feel the same way about politics.
- 58:41And so if you're interested in learning more about that and being connected to other people
- 58:46who also are independent or independent minded, you can visit our website.
- 58:51It's www.independentcenter.org, and we have a newsletter sign up at the top of the page and
- 58:57the bottom of the page.
- 58:59So we send out a weekly newsletter, and what we're hoping to do this coming year is start
- 59:04doing some informal meetups around the country so that people can feel like they are, you
- 59:09know, they're part of something that is politically engaging and, like, fits their
- 59:16values and their needs instead of asking them to fit to a party's.
- 59:20Oh, there you go.
- 59:21Go ahead and and and check out that newsletter.
- 59:23I'll I'll give you a chance at the end too.
- 59:25Also, any other media you wanna share.
- 59:27But first, to end things off, I whenever I have guests and sometimes even when I'm doing it on
- 59:33my own, I like to ask nonpolitical fun questions.
- 59:36No right or wrong answers because you know what?
- 59:39It's not always about politics for us nor should it be, and we we like to be well rounded
- 59:43individuals.
- 59:44So today's random question for you, Laura, is would you rather like to be able to play every
- 59:52instrument in the world or speak every language in the world?
- 59:56Oh, wow.
- 59:57That is a great question.
- 59:59Okay.
- 59:59I would take every language.
- 1:00:03And the reason is because I think it's there's there's some research about this, but I I'm not
- 1:00:11super familiar with it.
- 1:00:12But, you know, the language people use about the world around them, like, colors how they
- 1:00:19see the world.
- 1:00:20And so I think having access to a whole lot of other languages would give you a different view
- 1:00:27of the world and, like, you would move through the world differently with that perspective.
- 1:00:33So my answer is every is every language.
- 1:00:37And if my childhood violin playing is any indication, maybe we're all better off if I
- 1:00:44avoid instruments.
- 1:00:46Well well, I mean, hey.
- 1:00:47If if you chose being able to play every instrument, then you you'd you'd be good at it.
- 1:00:51I'd play them perfectly.
- 1:00:52Okay.
- 1:00:52Yeah.
- 1:00:53I'm still gonna stick with language.
- 1:00:54No.
- 1:00:55No.
- 1:00:55That's fine.
- 1:00:55And, you you know, I'm I'm I'm in agreement.
- 1:00:58I used to be much more in agreement with, like, yeah, the being able to speak every language
- 1:01:01much more utility and it'd be it'd be fun to just speak Spanish and then turn on a dime, go
- 1:01:06to German and then Italian or Swahili or something really esoteric.
- 1:01:10I'm a little less on that side.
- 1:01:12I I still would pick the languages, but I I sometimes think, boy, I'd love to be able to
- 1:01:18shred a guitar or be able to just just go crazy on on on drums if I could play.
- 1:01:24Allison Chains is my favorite band.
- 1:01:26So if I could just play every one of their their songs with every instrument, I that'd
- 1:01:30that'd be so I feel so cool.
- 1:01:33But I I do have to give it to me the languages, though.
- 1:01:37You know, I think I can tell you my my recollection of my grief and unpleasant for
- 1:01:43other people That's fair.
- 1:01:45Stint with violin is that playing music with other people is, like, an incredible experience
- 1:01:51that I don't really get to have anymore, and I kind of miss that.
- 1:01:55And, you know, if we're trying to to make a plug for people getting along better with each
- 1:02:00other, maybe music would be more successful even than being able to speak to other people.
- 1:02:06Like, if if we can just all pick up an instrument.
- 1:02:09Yeah.
- 1:02:10No.
- 1:02:10Absolutely.
- 1:02:11Coordinate ourselves that way.
- 1:02:13Hell, yeah.
- 1:02:14Absolutely.
- 1:02:14So, yeah, it's definitely a much harder question for me to answer these days, but I'll
- 1:02:18I'll still have to give it to language.
- 1:02:19But, in any case, Laura, thank you so much for being on here.
- 1:02:24Any other media that you want to promote?
- 1:02:32I mean, come to our website, independentcenter.org.
- 1:02:36We're also on Facebook, Instagram, and LinkedIn.
- 1:02:42We have a Twitter, but and we we use it, but it's less, you know, conversational.
- 1:02:49So you can follow us on those platforms if that's the way that you like to engage as well
- 1:02:54and, you know, reach out because we are we're we're trying to to build a movement of folks,
- 1:03:00so we wanna hear from people.
- 1:03:03Well, there you go.
- 1:03:03Go ahead and and check out all that stuff.
- 1:03:06And once again, Laura, thank you so much for being on here.
- 1:03:09My media is gonna be in the show notes, the poll writer author and speaker on Facebook, my
- 1:03:15LinkedIn, my my book, why independence rarely win elections, and how they could become more
- 1:03:20competitive sort of talks a little bit about some of the stuff on here.
- 1:03:23But, of course, Lurov's much more ingrained in the movement, but that's on Amazon and ebook
- 1:03:30and paperback format.
- 1:03:31And my educational email course I cited earlier as well.
- 1:03:37But with that all being said, we're gonna wrap things up.
- 1:03:40So thank you so much for tuning in, and until next time.
- 1:03:43Take care.