Latest / Deep Values: Value Investing Deep Dives / Buffett's Hero Tom Murphy's 2,000-to-1 Capital Cities Playbook
Transcript
- 0:00I want you to imagine a scenario.
- 0:02It's the mid 1950s, you've got a little bit of savings, maybe
- 0:05$1000, and you decide to bypass the big names, the GES, the Coca
- 0:10Cola's, and you put that money into this small kind of
- 0:15struggling media company A. Bit of a gamble.
- 0:17A huge gamble. You tuck that stock certificate
- 0:19away and you just, you just hold it.
- 0:22You hold it through the 60's, the 70's, the 80s, all the way
- 0:25to 1995. Any idea what that $1000 would
- 0:29be worth? It's a number that's it's almost
- 0:33hard to comprehend. We're talking about a 2000 to
- 0:36one return 2. 1000 to 1. That $1000 would have turned
- 0:39into roughly $2,000,000. Wow.
- 0:41To put that in perspective, that just crushes the S&P 500.
- 0:44It outperforms legendary hedge funds.
- 0:46It is quite arguably one of the greatest compounding records in
- 0:50the history of American business. 2001 that's, that's a
- 0:53tech startup number, you know, not something you expect from a
- 0:55traditional media company in the 20th century.
- 0:58And the really wild part is the man behind this record isn't a
- 1:02household name. He's not Steve Jobs in a
- 1:04turtleneck or, you know, Elon Musk tweeting at all hours.
- 1:07No, he's the ultimate quiet giant.
- 1:11His name was Thomas S Murphy, CEO of Capital Cities, which
- 1:14eventually became Capital Cities ABC.
- 1:17And you're right, he flew under the radar by design.
- 1:19But the people who know, they know.
- 1:21Oh, they definitely know. I mean, Warren Buffett calls
- 1:24Murphy his mental partner. Buffett actually said Murphy is
- 1:28in the same tears Bill Gates. OK.
- 1:30When the Oracle of Omaha puts you on the same shelf as Bill
- 1:32Gates, that's not just a compliment, that's that's a
- 1:34certification. It absolutely is.
- 1:36So our mission for this deep dive is pretty clear.
- 1:40We have to figure out how he did it.
- 1:41We've got a whole stack of sources, biographies, analysis
- 1:44of his partnership with Dan Burke, details on that massive
- 1:48Disney acquisition, and even Buffett's own letters.
- 1:50Right to deconstruct the capital cities playbook.
- 1:53And it really is a playbook, isn't it?
- 1:55It is. This isn't just a biography,
- 1:57it's a master class in rational capital allocation.
- 2:00We're talking extreme decentralization, A roll up
- 2:04strategy, and this fascinating idea that a nice guy, because by
- 2:08all accounts he was a true gentleman, can finish first by
- 2:10just being the most disciplined operator in the room.
- 2:13So let's start at the beginning, because his path wasn't exactly
- 2:17a straight shot to the C-Suite. Not at all.
- 2:20He wasn't born into a media dynasty.
- 2:22He was a Brooklyn native born in 1925.
- 2:25His early career path was incredibly non linear.
- 2:28What was he doing? Well, he served in the Navy
- 2:30during World War 2. Came back, went to Cornell, got
- 2:33a degree in mechanical engineering.
- 2:35An engineer. But, and this is a crucial
- 2:37detail, he didn't actually like engineering.
- 2:40He realized pretty quickly that sitting at a drafting table just
- 2:42wasn't his thing. So he's an engineer who doesn't
- 2:44want to be an engineer? That's a tough spot.
- 2:46Right. So he pivots.
- 2:48He decides business is where it's at.
- 2:51He applies to Harvard Business School and they reject him.
- 2:54I love that the guy who generates a 2000 to one return
- 2:58gets a rejection letter from Harvard.
- 3:00It gives the rest of us hope. It really does.
- 3:03So instead of a classroom, he goes to the school of Hard
- 3:05Knocks. He takes a job as an industrial
- 3:07oil salesman for Texaco. And I think this period is
- 3:10really underrated. In his story, he wasn't in some
- 3:13ivory tower. He was carrying the bag, you
- 3:15know, knocking on doors, facing rejection, trying to sell a
- 3:19commodity. That builds a certain kind of
- 3:20grit, doesn't it? You learn how to read people.
- 3:23Precisely. It grounded him years later when
- 3:26he was a Titan of industry and actually sitting on the board of
- 3:29Texaco. A great full circle moment.
- 3:31He still had that salesman's humility.
- 3:33So he eventually does get into Harvard.
- 3:36He reapplies, gets in, and graduates as a Baker Scholar.
- 3:39Top 5% of his class. But the real education, the
- 3:43thing that forged him, started in 1954.
- 3:46This is the Albany Crucible. Yes, a family friend, Frank
- 3:49Smith, recruits him to run a television station in Albany, NY
- 3:53WROWTV Murphy is 29 years old. He has zero broadcasting
- 3:58experience. And he walks into a disaster.
- 4:00A complete disaster. The station was losing money.
- 4:03It was nearly bankrupt, but the technical problem was even
- 4:06worse. What was that?
- 4:07WRL was a UHF station. You know for anyone who didn't
- 4:11grow up with a rabbit ears on their TV.
- 4:12You have to understand this. Back then the big stations were
- 4:15VHF, very high frequency. Channels 2 through 13.
- 4:19Right where NBCCBSABC lived. The signal was strong.
- 4:23Every TV picked it up. Murphy had a UHF station.
- 4:26Ultra high frequency, the high numbers on the dial.
- 4:29The signal was weaker, it didn't travel as far, but the absolute
- 4:33killer was that standard TV sets didn't even have a tuner for it.
- 4:37So to watch his station, you had to go out and buy a separate
- 4:40converter box. You had to go buy a separate
- 4:42box. It was a marketing nightmare.
- 4:43You're competing against General Electric, who owned the big VHF
- 4:46station, and your pitch is please go buy an expensive piece
- 4:49of hardware so you can watch our snowy, fuzzy picture.
- 4:52That's brutal. Murphy was terrified.
- 4:55He later said he thought he was going to bankrupt the company in
- 4:57his very first executive role, but that pressure cooker forged
- 5:01the entire capital city's philosophy.
- 5:03How? So.
- 5:05He looked at the situation and realized I can't compete on
- 5:08signal strength. I can't compete on money.
- 5:10We're broke, so what's the only lever I have left?
- 5:13Hustle and. Costs bustle and extreme cost
- 5:17control. He had to be the low cost
- 5:18producer. He looked at every single line
- 5:21item. If a dollar didn't help sell an
- 5:23ad or keep the transmitter running, it was cut.
- 5:26No fluff, just survival. And he turned it around.
- 5:29It took three years, but he turned that near bankruptcy into
- 5:32a profitable business. And that trauma, for lack of a
- 5:35better word, it seems like it's stuck with him.
- 5:38It never left him, even when they were billionaires.
- 5:41He ran the company like he was still scared of going broke in
- 5:44Albany. And that leads us directly to
- 5:47the playbook, the. Core Philosophy.
- 5:49Exactly. His core tenet was hire the best
- 5:51people you can and leave them alone.
- 5:53Radical decentralization. And this was totally against the
- 5:56grain at the time. Completely.
- 5:58I mean, look at CBS or NBC back then, they were building these
- 6:01massive centralized bureaucracies in New York City,
- 6:04layers of vice presidents for everything.
- 6:06The. Guy in New York telling the guy
- 6:08in Houston what to do. Exactly.
- 6:10Murphy, look at that and just said that's crazy.
- 6:13I read a stat about their headquarters that I honestly
- 6:15thought was a typo. The 36 number.
- 6:18Yes, even after they bought ABCA massive network with billions in
- 6:23revenue, the capital city's corporate headquarters had only
- 6:2636 employees. That's insane.
- 6:28And that 36 included the secretaries and the
- 6:31receptionist. It's unheard of.
- 6:34Murphy believe the manager of a station in Fresno knew their
- 6:37market better than some suit in Manhattan.
- 6:39So we gave them total autonomy. But with total autonomy, how do
- 6:43you keep everyone rowing in the same direction?
- 6:45Accountability. That's the other side of the
- 6:46coin. He gave them freedom, but they
- 6:49were strictly accountable for the bottom line.
- 6:51Hit your numbers, you're left alone and paid very well.
- 6:55Miss them? You've got a problem.
- 6:57There's that famous story that illustrates his his frugality,
- 7:00the panting, the building story. A classic.
- 7:03SO station manager sends a proposal to Murphy.
- 7:06The station's looking shabby. He wants to repaint the whole
- 7:08thing. He.
- 7:08Seems reasonable, Murphy. Looks at the proposal, pulls out
- 7:11a pen and approves the cost to paint the two sides of the
- 7:14building that face the road. But not the back.
- 7:17He crosses out the cost to paint the back two sides because
- 7:20nobody sees the back. The advertisers driving by only
- 7:24see the front and the side. Painting the back generates 0
- 7:28return on investment. It sounds cheap, but it's not.
- 7:31It's it's rational. That's the word.
- 7:33He was being rational, not cheap.
- 7:35He viewed every dollar as an investment.
- 7:37Does this bring a return? No, they were not spending it.
- 7:41It sends a powerful message to the whole company.
- 7:44We don't spend money on vanity. He was known as the cab man,
- 7:47right? Yes.
- 7:48While other media moguls were in limousines, Murphy was hailing
- 7:52yellow cabs. He had this great train analogy.
- 7:54What was that? He'd say.
- 7:56The goal is not to have the longest train.
- 7:58The goal is to arrive at the station first using the least
- 8:01fuel. That is such a profound
- 8:02distinction. Corporate ego wants the longest
- 8:05train of. Course it does.
- 8:06Look how big my office is. Murphy cared about speed and
- 8:09fuel efficiency, and to keep that engine running, he needed a
- 8:12partner. Daniel B Burke.
- 8:13His operator. He hired Burke in 1961.
- 8:17Murphy was the architect, the deal maker.
- 8:19Burke was the operational disciplinarian.
- 8:21He was the one grinding down on the budgets.
- 8:24A bit of a good cop, bad cop. A little bit, but they built
- 8:27this culture that people loved because it was a meritocracy.
- 8:30It was fair. I heard about the bartender
- 8:33story. Oh, that sums it up perfectly.
- 8:35There's a company retreat afterwards.
- 8:38The bartender working the event went out and bought stock in
- 8:41capital cities. Why?
- 8:43Someone asked him and he said I've worked a lot of corporate
- 8:46parties. This is the only one where I
- 8:49couldn't tell the bosses from the subordinates.
- 8:51No status seeking, no posturing. And that lack of ego let them
- 8:56execute their growth strategy at the roll up.
- 8:59Can you break down how he did that?
- 9:01Sure. The basic idea of a roll up is
- 9:03simple. You buy a company, you fix its
- 9:05operations to boost cash flow. Then you use that cash to pay
- 9:08down the debt you took on to buy it.
- 9:10Then you repeat. Buy, fix, pay down debt, repeat.
- 9:13The problem is most people get addicted to the.
- 9:15Buy exactly they overpay, they take on too much debt.
- 9:19Murphy was incredibly disciplined, but he had a
- 9:21specific hurdle most people don't the FCC.
- 9:24Right, the government had strict ownership limits.
- 9:27The rule of seven You could only own 7 TV stations, so he had to
- 9:31play 3D chess. To buy a bigger, better station
- 9:35in a bigger market, he often had to sell a profitable 1 he
- 9:38already owned. He was constantly trading up,
- 9:39constantly. And the 1971 Triangle
- 9:42Publications deal really highlights this discipline.
- 9:45This was a big one. Pivotal.
- 9:47He gets a chance to buy Walter Annenberg stations, including
- 9:50WPVI in Philadelphia. A massive market, a crown jewel
- 9:54asset that just prints money. But.
- 9:56To get it. To get it and stay legal with
- 9:58the FCC, he had to sell the TV station in Albany.
- 10:02His first station, The one he saved his baby.
- 10:05The very same, and this tells you everything.
- 10:07He viewed assets as fungible capital.
- 10:10Fungible, meaning interchangeable.
- 10:12Meaning he had zero emotional attachment.
- 10:14Most founders would say I can't sell Albany.
- 10:17That's where we started. Remember, if you just look at
- 10:19the spreadsheet, Philadelphia generates a higher return on
- 10:21Capital. Sell Albany, buy Philadelphia.
- 10:24It's cold, rational logic. He never let sentimentality get
- 10:28in the way of compounding. Never.
- 10:30And they moved into newspapers, too, bought the Kansas City
- 10:33Star, and critics of the time were saying, Oh no, these
- 10:36ruthless cost cutters are going to ruin the journalism.
- 10:38But they didn't. The opposite Under Cap Cities,
- 10:42the Kansas City Star won three Pulitzer Prizes.
- 10:45Murphy's argument was that financial discipline protects
- 10:48quality. A profitable newspaper can
- 10:51afford to do investigative journalism.
- 10:53A bankrupt 1 can't. OK, So they're growing, they're
- 10:56trading up, but then comes 1985, the main event.
- 11:00The year the minnow swallowed the whale.
- 11:03They acquired ABC. For 3 1/2 billion dollars.
- 11:06Just to set the scene, how big was capital cities compared to
- 11:09ABC at that point? Cap Cities was about 1/4 of the
- 11:11size of ABC. It was audacious.
- 11:14The Wall Street Journal headline was literally Minnowala's whale.
- 11:17He was betting the entire company and to.
- 11:20Do it. He did a massive amount of cash.
- 11:22And this is where Warren Buffett goes from being a fan to being a
- 11:25partner. How much?
- 11:26Did he need? He needed 517 million in equity,
- 11:30so he sets up a meeting with Buffett.
- 11:32Usually a deal this big takes weeks of due diligence.
- 11:35Lawyers accounts. They met for 15 minutes. 15
- 11:38minutes for half a billion dollars.
- 11:41Buffett said yes. It was the largest investment
- 11:43he'd ever made. At the time.
- 11:45He wasn't betting on media. He was betting on Tom Murphy.
- 11:47He was betting on the jockey, not the horse. 100% he believed
- 11:51Murphy and Burke could manage those assets better than anyone
- 11:54else on earth. So the deal closes the Capital
- 11:56cities guys walk into ABC headquarters in Manhattan.
- 11:59What's the first thing they see? The definition of corporate
- 12:03bloat. A culture of pure excess.
- 12:07ABC had a lavish skyscraper headquarters, a private elevator
- 12:11only for executives and executive dining room with white
- 12:15glove service. It was a Royal Court.
- 12:17And here comes the cab man. Here he comes.
- 12:19Murphy and Burke took one look around and just started swinging
- 12:23the axe. Sold the headquarters for
- 12:24$175,000,000. Moved everyone to cheaper
- 12:27offices. Gone.
- 12:28Shut down the executive dining room.
- 12:30Ripped out the private elevator. I imagine that was a massive
- 12:33culture shock for the ABC execs. A revolution.
- 12:37They cut the staff by 1500 people, which sounds harsh and
- 12:42for those people it was difficult, but the business was
- 12:45suffocating under its own weight.
- 12:47And what was the result? By clearing out the bureaucracy,
- 12:50the operating margins at ABC jumped from the low 30s to over
- 12:5450%. Incredible.
- 12:55It validates that rowboat analogy, that Buffett.
- 12:58Used. Oh, totally.
- 12:59Buffett compared CBS to the Queen Elizabeth to massive
- 13:03resources but impossible to turn.
- 13:05He said CAC Cities was a rowboat, but the robot won
- 13:07because the guys in it were just rowing harder and smarter.
- 13:10They weren't weighing the boot down with gold plating.
- 13:13Exactly. So we've talked cost cutting and
- 13:15acquisitions, but there's another pillar of his capital
- 13:18allocation that Murphy mastered stock buybacks.
- 13:21He was a pioneer here, and it's important to explain why this
- 13:24matters. Right.
- 13:25For anyone listening who isn't CFO, why is buying your own
- 13:28stock a good idea? Think of the company as a pizza
- 13:31with eight slices. You own one slice.
- 13:35If the company takes its cash and buys back two slices from
- 13:38other people, the pizza now only has 6 slices.
- 13:41But I still have my one slice. You still have your slice, but
- 13:44your slice is now a much bigger percentage of the whole pie.
- 13:47You own more of the earnings without spending a dime.
- 13:50It concentrates the value for the people who stay.
- 13:52Exactly. Murphy would aggressively buy
- 13:55back stock whenever he felt it was undervalued.
- 13:58He joked that the employee stock purchase plan was an IQ test.
- 14:01Meaning if you didn't buy it, you were failing the test.
- 14:04The stock was such a clear bargain.
- 14:06Yeah, you're failing the test. I want to touch on the soft side
- 14:09of his management. We've painted a picture of a
- 14:12ruthless cost cutter, but Buffett always praises his
- 14:16emotional intelligence. That's the paradox of Tom
- 14:19Murphy. He was ruthless with costs, but
- 14:22gentle with people. He had a strict rule about
- 14:25anger. He'd say you can always tell
- 14:27someone to go to hell tomorrow. Don't spout off in the moment.
- 14:30Right. Don't act in a moment of anger.
- 14:32Buffett still quotes that as one of the best pieces of advice he
- 14:35ever received. And what about the feedback
- 14:37rule? Praise by name, criticized by
- 14:40category. If John Smith does something
- 14:43great, you praise John Smith at the meeting.
- 14:46If the sales department misses a target, you criticize the sales
- 14:49department. So you address the systemic
- 14:51failure without humiliating the individual.
- 14:54And it builds incredible loyalty.
- 14:56People worked hard for him because they respected him, not
- 14:59just because they were scared of him.
- 15:00So let's go to the Final Act 1995, the Disney sale.
- 15:05The masterpiece? Murphy's at the Allen and Co
- 15:07conference in Sun Valley. He bumps into Michael Eisner,
- 15:10the CEO of Disney. Buffett is there, too.
- 15:12They start talking on the sidewalk, and in three days they
- 15:15hammer out a deal. Disney buys Capital City's ABC
- 15:19for $19 billion. 19 billion from a near bankrupt UHF station in
- 15:25Albany. It's solidified his legacy as
- 15:27one of The Outsiders, a term from William Thorndike's book.
- 15:30These were CE OS who ignored the institutional imperative, the
- 15:34need to just get bigger for ego's sake.
- 15:36He didn't care about being the biggest.
- 15:38He cared about per share value, and that $19 billion check
- 15:42proved he was right. So let's distill this for the
- 15:45person listening. What are the big takeaways they
- 15:48can apply to their own business or career?
- 15:51I think there are three core lessons.
- 15:53First, decentralization requires accountability.
- 15:56You can't just let people loose, they have to own the results.
- 15:59Trust but verify the numbers. Second, frugality is a
- 16:04competitive advantage. It's the big one.
- 16:07If your costs are lower than your competitors, you have more
- 16:09options. You survive downturns.
- 16:12You can buy assets when everyone else is selling.
- 16:14Frugality buys you freedom. And the third.
- 16:17Rationality over emotion. Whether it was selling his first
- 16:20station or not painting the back of a building, Murphy removed
- 16:23his ego from the decision. He looked at the numbers, not
- 16:27the narrative. And maybe there's a fourth
- 16:28lesson, just about the nature of the work itself.
- 16:30Absolutely. When you read about Murphy, one
- 16:33thing stands out. He had fun.
- 16:35He enjoyed the game of business. He wasn't grinding himself into
- 16:38misery. He was energized by the puzzle.
- 16:40He tapped dance to work. It's a compelling blueprint.
- 16:43So here's the question for you to chew on In your own
- 16:46organization or your own career. Are you building a Queen
- 16:50Elizabeth 2? Impressive to look at, lots of
- 16:53bells and whistles, but impossible to turn.
- 16:55Or are you rowing the boat? Because, as Tom Murphy proved,
- 16:58the rowboat usually wins. And remember, don't bother
- 17:02painting the back of the building.
- 17:03Keep rowing everyone, thanks for diving in with us.
- 17:06See you next time.