Latest / eMotors: Electric Revolution / Electric Versus Combustion: When to Switch
Transcript
- 0:09Welcome to the Deep Dive. We take your sources, cut
- 0:12through the noise and get straight to the practical
- 0:15takeaways. Today we're tackling, well,
- 0:18probably one of the trickiest decisions out there right now,
- 0:21buying a car. Specifically, how do you balance
- 0:24wanting to go electric with, you know, the hard reality of your
- 0:27budget? It really is a puzzle isn't it?
- 0:30A high stakes one. Our sources layout a pretty
- 0:32structured way to think about it.
- 0:34They start with some, let's call them non negotiable financial
- 0:37rules based on income. Then they dig into the tipping
- 0:40points, like when does switching to electric actually start
- 0:42saving you money and finally breakdown the different ways you
- 0:45can actually pay for the thing. OK, let's unpack all that.
- 0:48Our mission here for you listening is really twofold.
- 0:51First, we need to pull out those hard financial rules, the
- 0:54commandments if you will. That should guide how much you
- 0:56spend. And second, we're zeroing in on
- 0:59the specific, measurable things that tell you, OK, now's the
- 1:02time to actually make the switch from petrol or diesel to
- 1:06electric. So let's dive in.
- 1:07First things first. The foundation, according to the
- 1:10sources, has got to be financial stability.
- 1:13That seems obvious, but let's make it concrete.
- 1:15If someone's starting fresh, what's the absolute core
- 1:18guideline for budgeting for a car?
- 1:20Right. That's what the source is
- 1:21called, a 2030% rule. And honestly it's presented as
- 1:24the gold standard if you want to stay financially sound with car
- 1:27ownership. The rule basically is that your
- 1:29total vehicle spending, and this is key, total shouldn't be more
- 1:32than 20% to 30% of your gross annual income.
- 1:35And total means everything. The purchase price or finance
- 1:37payments, fuel or electricity, insurance, maintenance, taxes,
- 1:41all of it. All of it.
- 1:42That's the critical part. If you forget one of those,
- 1:45you're already kidding yourself about the cost.
- 1:47OK, so this is where it gets interesting, because we can take
- 1:49that rule and see what it actually means in terms of
- 1:52budget. Let's be conservative, say aim
- 1:54for the 20% end of that range. The sources use some well,
- 1:58pretty standard European income levels, and the numbers are
- 2:01stark. They really are.
- 2:03Let's take the lowest tier mentioned someone earning
- 2:06€20,000 a year. So 20% of that is 4000.
- 2:09That's their maximum yearly spend on the car, everything
- 2:11included. Now if you estimate maybe year
- 2:141000 to €1500 for your fixed running cost, insurance, basic
- 2:18upkeep, maybe a bit of fuel or charging, that leaves only what,
- 2:212500 to €3000 a year for the car itself.
- 2:25Like the finance payment or saving up, which translates
- 2:28roughly to a total price tag for the car of maybe 6000 to 8000
- 2:32are assuming you pay it off reasonably quickly.
- 2:34Wow. And at that price, 6000 to 8000,
- 2:37the sources are pretty blunt. Your priority has to be just
- 2:39pure efficiency and reliability. You're basically looking at used
- 2:42city cars, maybe older, very basic used E VS if you can even
- 2:46find them. It's yeah, it's tight.
- 2:48Very tight now. Move up a step someone on
- 2:50€30,000 a year. Their 20% cap is €6000 annually.
- 2:56Take out those running costs again.
- 2:58Maybe their purchase budget allows for a car somewhere in
- 3:00the 9000 to 12,000 range. Here the sources suggest you can
- 3:04start thinking a bit more about comfort, maybe some tech
- 3:07features. We're talking mid range
- 3:08compacts, perhaps some newer hybrids if there's a good deal.
- 3:11OK. And then the top tier mentioned
- 3:13the €40,000 earner budget opens up a bit more, 20% is €8000 a
- 3:18year. So maybe after running costs,
- 3:20they can realistically aim for a car priced over €15,000 and
- 3:24that's where you start seeing, you know, better quality, maybe
- 3:27more performance, latest Genevs or nicer mid segment models.
- 3:31What's really striking, though, is how that 20% rule immediately
- 3:34shows that buying a new electric car, even the cheapest ones, is
- 3:37likely out of reach for those lower income brackets.
- 3:40The upfront cost is just too high to fit.
- 3:42Exactly, even finding a decent used EV in that 6000 to €8000
- 3:46bracket is a big ask when you're sticking to that 20% total cost
- 3:49rule. Honestly, looking at these
- 3:50numbers I think I'll be sticking with my bicycle for a bit
- 3:53longer. Definitely kinder to the budget.
- 3:55Probably a wise financial move, but the critical point for you,
- 3:59the listener, whatever your income is remembering this car
- 4:03budget has to fit into your overall finances.
- 4:05You still got rent or mortgage, food, family costs, and if you
- 4:10finance the car, that monthly payment is a fixed weight you
- 4:13have to carry. It all needs to add up.
- 4:15Right. So, OK, we've dealt with the
- 4:17initial sticker shock and the budget rules.
- 4:19Let's shift gears to the long game.
- 4:21We know EVs cost more upfront. When do those supposed benefits
- 4:25like lower maintenance, cheaper fuel actually start to pay off
- 4:29and make the switch worthwhile? What are the real tipping
- 4:31points? The upsides are definitely
- 4:32there, and they're how you eventually make back that higher
- 4:35initial cost, essentially amortizing it.
- 4:37The biggest one people talk about is maintenance.
- 4:39It's just simpler mechanics. Think about it.
- 4:41No oil changes, no spark plugs, no timing belts, no complex
- 4:44exhaust systems, no transmission fluid.
- 4:47Fewer things to break, basically, which should lead to
- 4:49lower annual upkeep costs. And the environmental angle is
- 4:52huge too, right? The sources mentioned something
- 4:54like a 73% lower life cycle impact compared to a combustion
- 4:57car. That sounds massive.
- 4:59It is a big number, yeah, but it's important to understand the
- 5:01context. That 73% figure is calculated
- 5:05over the entire life of the car, from production to scrapping.
- 5:09And critically, it assumes the electricity grid gets
- 5:12progressively cleaner over time. So yes, making the battery is
- 5:16energy intensive upfront, but the zero tailpipe emissions
- 5:19day-to-day combined with cleaner power generation over the cars
- 5:231015 year life is what delivers that big environmental saving in
- 5:27the long run. OK, but hang on, let me play
- 5:29devil's advocate for a second because the sources bring this
- 5:31up too. What about the argument for just
- 5:33keeping your old petrol or diesel car?
- 5:35Say something 10, maybe 20 years old.
- 5:37By not buying a new car, electric or otherwise, you avoid
- 5:40all the massive environmental impact of manufacturing that new
- 5:43vehicle, digging up lithium for the battery, shipping parts.
- 5:46That's a really important counterpoint, and the sources
- 5:48are clear about when that makes sense.
- 5:50Keeping an old, paid off combustion car can be the better
- 5:53choice both economically and environmentally if, and this is
- 5:57the crucial bit, you don't drive very much.
- 5:59We're talking low annual mileage.
- 6:01If your car uses minimal and the car is still basically reliable,
- 6:05avoiding that huge upfront cost in the manufacturing footprint
- 6:08is arguably the smarter path. OK so we need a clearer line
- 6:11then what signals OK my low mileage doesn't cut it anymore
- 6:15or my old car is becoming a liability?
- 6:18What specific triggers based on the sources tell you the Ev's
- 6:21higher prices now justify? What are those practical tipping
- 6:24points? The sources point to 4 main
- 6:26signals. First and probably most
- 6:28important, high annual mileage. If you're driving over as a
- 6:3310,000 kilometers a year, the savings on fuel, especially if
- 6:36you can charge cheaply at home, start to add up much faster.
- 6:39That helps you pay back the higher purchase price quicker.
- 6:41Below 10,000 kilometers a year, the payback takes a lot longer.
- 6:452nd, signal repair bills. If your current car starts
- 6:48needing frequent or worse expensive repairs.
- 6:51Think engine transmission, major stuff.
- 6:53That's a huge red flag that repair money might be much
- 6:56better put towards a down payment on an EV, avoiding
- 6:59throwing good money after bad. Makes sense, and the other two
- 7:02points are more about logistics, aren't they?
- 7:03Exactly. Third is charging convenience.
- 7:06Do you have easy reliable access to charging, ideally at home
- 7:10overnight which is usually cheapest, or maybe dedicated
- 7:13charging at work? If charging is going to be a
- 7:16constant hassle, finding public chargers waiting around that
- 7:19significantly dampens the EV appeal for many.
- 7:22And 4th is thinking ahead about regulations.
- 7:25We know the EU is phasing out sales of new petrol and diesel
- 7:28cars by 2035. Getting into an EV now means
- 7:31you're ahead of the curve, avoiding potential future
- 7:34restrictions on older cars, especially in city centers, and
- 7:37future proofing your transport. OK, that paints a really clear
- 7:40picture. So the balances keep the old car
- 7:43if you drive very little and it's cheap to run, avoids waste,
- 7:46saves money upfront. But switch to an EV if you drive
- 7:49a lot, have easy charging access, your old car is becoming
- 7:51a money pit. Or you want to get ahead of
- 7:53regulations and maximize that long term environmental benefit,
- 7:56right? We know how much to spend.
- 7:58We know when it might be smart to switch.
- 7:59Now the mechanics of actually buying it, this can be
- 8:02confusing. How do you actually structure
- 8:03the purchase? The sources covered the main
- 8:05ways. Yeah.
- 8:06This is where you trade off having cash now versus the total
- 8:09amount you'll pay overtime. The simplest and cheapest in the
- 8:12long run is obviously a cash purchase pro.
- 8:15No interest, no loan fees gives you strong negotiating power to
- 8:20makes it easier to stay within that 2030% total cost rule over
- 8:23the car's life con. It's a massive hit to your
- 8:26savings all at once. For many people, especially in
- 8:29those lower income brackets we discussed, it's just not
- 8:31feasible. So then you look at financing
- 8:33option one, getting a loan from a bank or another lender.
- 8:37The potential upside here is you might get personalized rates,
- 8:39flexible terms, maybe more transparency, often easier to
- 8:43pay off early without big penalties.
- 8:45Downside, it can involve more paperwork, credit checks.
- 8:48Providing guarantees takes a bit more effort.
- 8:50And what about financing right there at the dealership?
- 8:52That's often pushed quite hard, sometimes called VFG or dealer
- 8:55finance with the final balloon payment.
- 8:57Right dealer financing, sometimes structured as a vendor
- 8:59finance. Guarantee your personal contract
- 9:01purchase PCP with that big balloon payment at the end.
- 9:05The appeal is usually a lower monthly payment, which looks
- 9:07attractive upfront, makes the car seem more affordable month
- 9:10to month. But the big warning flag is the
- 9:12total cost. You're paying interest, often
- 9:15higher rates than a bank loan, plus there can be various fees
- 9:18bundled in. It pushes you closer to that 30%
- 9:21ceiling or even over it. You also tend to have less
- 9:23flexibility and might be tied into dealership servicing, for
- 9:26example. OK.
- 9:27And one last option, which seems like a potential sweet spot for
- 9:30budget buyers wanting electric used EVs.
- 9:34Solves the high initial cost problem right, but adds new
- 9:37risks. Absolutely, used EVs are
- 9:40attractive because they let you get into electric without that
- 9:42huge new car price tag and someone else has already taken
- 9:46the biggest depreciation hit. But, and this is a huge
- 9:50depreciation, but the absolute critical thing is checking the
- 9:53battery's health. It's not like checking the
- 9:55mileage on a petrol car. You need proof like a certified
- 9:59diagnostic report, often called a state of health or SOH check.
- 10:03This tells you how much charge capacity the battery actually
- 10:05still has left compared to when it was new.
- 10:08So you. Really need solid data on the
- 10:10battery. It's like getting a full medical
- 10:12check up for the most expensive part of the car isn't.
- 10:14It precisely if that SOH percentage is low, the car's
- 10:18real world range could be way less than advertised, which
- 10:21undermines the whole point you're running.
- 10:23Cost savings might vanish if the range isn't practical for you.
- 10:26Plus, even though the purchase price is lower, you usually miss
- 10:29out on any government incentives that only apply to new EVs.
- 10:32And of course, it's still a used car, so there's always the
- 10:34standard risk of other parts having more wear and tear.
- 10:37Wow, OK, this has been incredibly helpful I think.
- 10:41Breaking down the rules, the decision points, the ways to
- 10:43pay. Let's try and wrap this up with
- 10:45a clear summary for everyone listening.
- 10:47Sure. Key takeaways.
- 10:48First, be strict with yourself on that 20% to 30% rule for
- 10:52total car cost relative to your annual income.
- 10:55Don't cheat on the total part. Second, use that 10,000
- 10:58kilometers per year mark as a rough guide.
- 11:00Driving more than that makes the EV switch financially viable
- 11:03much faster. Also, watch those repair bills
- 11:05in your old car pill. Big bills are a signal to jump
- 11:08ship. And 3rd, when you're buying,
- 11:10really weigh the upfront pane of cash versus the higher total
- 11:13cost and commitment of financing.
- 11:15Understand the true cost of those lower monthly payments.
- 11:18It really is a complex balancing act, isn't it?
- 11:20Trying to do the right thing for the planet, or at least feel
- 11:23like you are, while also making sure you don't wreck your
- 11:26personal finances. So maybe the final thought to
- 11:29leave you with is this. We know that 2035 date is coming
- 11:33in the EU, the end of new combustion car sales.
- 11:37How can you start planning now to align that future reality
- 11:40with your own financial situation over the next decade?
- 11:43How do you position yourself to make the transition smoothly and
- 11:47save the most money in the process?
- 11:49That's the multi billion euro question, isn't it?
- 11:52A fascinating challenge for everyone.
- 11:53Indeed. Well, thank you so much for
- 11:55walking us through all the complexities of car costs and
- 11:58going electric. It's been really insightful.
- 12:00And for everyone listening, if you found this deep dive useful,
- 12:03please do consider following the channel for more breakdowns like
- 12:06this. We really appreciate you
- 12:07spending your time with us today.
- 12:09Thanks for listening.