Latest / Behind the Bastards / It Could Happen Here Weekly 119
Transcript
- 0:01Speaker 1: Al Zone Media.
- 0:03Speaker 2: Hey everybody, Robert Evans here and I wanted to let
- 0:05Speaker 2: you know this is a compilation episode. So every episode
- 0:09Speaker 2: of the week that just happened is here in one
- 0:12Speaker 2: convenient and with somewhat less ads package for you to
- 0:16Speaker 2: listen to in a long stretch if you want. If
- 0:18Speaker 2: you've been listening to the episodes every day this week,
- 0:20Speaker 2: there's going to be nothing new here for you, but
- 0:23Speaker 2: you can make your own decisions.
- 0:26Speaker 3: Welcome to Dick It Up and Here, a podcast about
- 0:28Speaker 3: things falling apart and putting it back together again. I'm
- 0:31Speaker 3: Mia Wong, I'm with Garrison and it is my singular
- 0:36Speaker 3: honor and pleasure to introduce our guest, doctor Julia Serrano.
- 0:39Speaker 3: She is the author of many books, excluded Making Feminist
- 0:44Speaker 3: and queer movements more Inclusive, Sex Stop, How Society Sexualizes us,
- 0:48Speaker 3: and how we can fight back Outspoken, a Decade of
- 0:51Speaker 3: transgender activism and Transfeminism, and most famously Whipping Girl, a
- 0:55Speaker 3: new edition of which is coming out in March. Doctor Serrano,
- 0:58Speaker 3: welcome to the show.
- 1:00Speaker 1: Hi, thanks for having me.
- 1:02Speaker 3: Yeah, I'm really really I'm really happy you can join us. So, okay,
- 1:07Speaker 3: Whipping Girl, I think is really one of quietly the
- 1:13Speaker 3: most influential books of the twenty first century, to the
- 1:16Speaker 3: extent that in kind of classic trans woman fashion, I
- 1:19Speaker 3: don't think. I don't think people realize that the ideas
- 1:22Speaker 3: that it introduced have an origin. So for people who
- 1:25Speaker 3: haven't read the book, and you should, this book is great.
- 1:28Speaker 3: I guarantee you have seen its influence. If you've ever
- 1:31Speaker 3: heard someone like who's not trans referred to as sis, like,
- 1:35Speaker 3: that's that's from this book. The concept of misgendering is
- 1:39Speaker 3: also from this book. The word trans misogyny like also
- 1:43Speaker 3: from this book. And this I think gets at something
- 1:48Speaker 3: from the twenty fifteen second edition preface that you wrote,
- 1:53Speaker 3: which is something I've been wondering about, is what is
- 1:56Speaker 3: it like to sort of experience writing a book and
- 1:59Speaker 3: have it just ripple across society like this.
- 2:03Speaker 1: Yeah, it's uh.
- 2:05Speaker 4: I was very much hoping and you know, as I
- 2:07Speaker 4: was writing it, I was hoping that I thought that
- 2:09Speaker 4: it would resonate with a lot of trans female and
- 2:12Speaker 4: trans feminine people and I hope trans communities more generally,
- 2:17Speaker 4: and the book this is something that a lot of
- 2:19Speaker 4: times people who pick up the book now, in like
- 2:21Speaker 4: the twenty twenties don't necessarily realize is that nobody was
- 2:25Speaker 4: reading anything about trans people outside of feminists and LGBTQ
- 2:30Speaker 4: plus communities, and so I was basically just speaking to
- 2:35Speaker 4: those groups, and I thought it would resonate with some people.
- 2:38Speaker 4: But yeah, definitely, it kind of went out into the
- 2:41Speaker 4: world and did a bunch of stuff that I wasn't
- 2:44Speaker 4: necessarily expecting. And I'm very glad that the book has
- 2:48Speaker 4: kind of touched a lot of people's lives and changed,
- 2:52Speaker 4: you know.
- 2:53Speaker 1: Kind of societal.
- 2:55Speaker 4: Understanding and quote unquote discourses about trans people.
- 2:58Speaker 5: So yeah, it it must be kind of bizarre, like
- 3:03Speaker 5: being twenty years ago writing about you know, caniche term
- 3:06Speaker 5: like cis and now the richest man in the world
- 3:10Speaker 5: thinks it's like the most evil word.
- 3:15Speaker 4: Yeah, it's quite bizarre, and I do want to definitely
- 3:18Speaker 4: kind of clear this up, but I kind of make
- 3:20Speaker 4: this clear in the preface. So I didn't invet like
- 3:23Speaker 4: sis versus trans like a that's like a prefix that
- 3:26Speaker 4: has existed a long time. Yeah, and uh, I've since
- 3:29Speaker 4: seen other people like point out, oh, this person was
- 3:33Speaker 4: using it in nineteen ninety something, or some German writer
- 3:39Speaker 4: like coined cis vestism or something like back a million
- 3:42Speaker 4: years ago. So what I will say is that when
- 3:44Speaker 4: I when I put out the book, I was inspired
- 3:46Speaker 4: by Emi.
- 3:47Speaker 1: Koyama, who was and is an awesome.
- 3:50Speaker 4: Activist intersex activists, who who's written a lot of really
- 3:54Speaker 4: influential trans related essays over the years. And it was
- 3:59Speaker 4: from her blog that was the first time I saw
- 4:02Speaker 4: SIS and trans and the idea of SIS sexism.
- 4:05Speaker 1: And at the time, it was while I was.
- 4:07Speaker 4: Writing the book, and it really I was like, oh
- 4:09Speaker 4: my god, this is kind of the overall idea. I
- 4:12Speaker 4: was talking about all these different facets of basically double
- 4:15Speaker 4: standards between trans and non trans people, and so I
- 4:19Speaker 4: kind of grabbed on to it, and I was really
- 4:21Speaker 4: worried about it actually because nobody, almost nobody was using
- 4:24Speaker 4: those terms. It was very niche at the time, and
- 4:27Speaker 4: so the book popularized that language. And so now it
- 4:30Speaker 4: is kind of funny every once in a while seeing
- 4:34Speaker 4: yes overreactions by SIS people to the idea of SIS
- 4:40Speaker 4: being a slur or whatever. So yeah, and so yeah,
- 4:44Speaker 4: so that's definitely something that is kind of is the
- 4:47Speaker 4: one thing I one thing I did coin in the
- 4:49Speaker 4: book that has kind of also taken a life on
- 4:52Speaker 4: its own is trans misogyny.
- 4:54Speaker 1: So that is something that kind of originated with.
- 4:57Speaker 4: This book and particularly a chap book that I wrote
- 5:00Speaker 4: in two thousand and five that some of.
- 5:02Speaker 1: Those essays became chapters of the book.
- 5:05Speaker 4: And yeah, and so there are other ideas that kind
- 5:06Speaker 4: of are out there, Like I think it was one
- 5:09Speaker 4: of the first I think it was the first book
- 5:11Speaker 4: to talk about like the idea of sis privilege. Misgendering
- 5:14Speaker 4: as an idea was out there, but I kind of
- 5:17Speaker 4: dove into it a little bit deeper. So yeah, so
- 5:21Speaker 4: there are definitely things I was doing at the time
- 5:22Speaker 4: that I didn't know whether they'd be to abstract or
- 5:27Speaker 4: how they'd be taken up.
- 5:28Speaker 1: And so, yes, it's been very interesting.
- 5:31Speaker 3: Yeah, I wanted to talk about misgendering a bit because
- 5:34Speaker 3: I think it's become this word that just means not
- 5:37Speaker 3: saying someone's pronouns correctly. And I think that's at the
- 5:41Speaker 3: very best, like an incredibly reductionist and of simplified version
- 5:46Speaker 3: of the analysis that you were presenting. So I guess
- 5:48Speaker 3: I have two questions here. One, can you briefly sort
- 5:51Speaker 3: of talk about what you were trying to get at
- 5:54Speaker 3: when you sort of did your analysis of the process
- 5:57Speaker 3: of gendering, And two, what do you think about the
- 6:00Speaker 3: way that it's kind of become flattened into this I
- 6:04Speaker 3: don't know, kind of weirdly narrow thing in modern discourse.
- 6:09Speaker 4: Sure, and a lot of the misgendering definitely dovetails with
- 6:14Speaker 4: the idea of passing, and a lot of my kind
- 6:17Speaker 4: of diving into it in a particular way came from
- 6:20Speaker 4: critiques that I had and other trans people had as well,
- 6:23Speaker 4: but I kind of, you know, put them together in
- 6:26Speaker 4: a particularly in the Dismantling I think it's dismantling sexual
- 6:30Speaker 4: Privileged chapter where I kind of go through all these
- 6:33Speaker 4: steps that lead to miss gendering, because I think people
- 6:37Speaker 4: talk about trans people passing and also the people will
- 6:39Speaker 4: talk about other marginalized groups passing is whatever dominant majority group.
- 6:44Speaker 4: The term obviously had long been used with regards to
- 6:49Speaker 4: people of color passing as white and in kind of
- 6:53Speaker 4: white racist you know, us and other societies. So it's
- 6:57Speaker 4: an old term, and a big problem with it is
- 7:00Speaker 4: that it makes it sound like we're doing something active,
- 7:03Speaker 4: that trans people are actively trying to deceive other people.
- 7:06Speaker 1: With huge scare quotes around the word deceive.
- 7:10Speaker 4: And I really wanted to highlight to people that actually
- 7:15Speaker 4: all of us very unconsciously and very compulsively gender every
- 7:20Speaker 4: single person we meet, or at least that's how we're
- 7:23Speaker 4: socialized to be. And you know, you can work towards
- 7:26Speaker 4: getting you know, overcoming that, but I wanted to really
- 7:31Speaker 4: highlight the fact that we see people, we automatically gender them,
- 7:34Speaker 4: and that puts people who do not quite who your
- 7:39Speaker 4: presumptions are wrong about. It puts us in difficult situations.
- 7:44Speaker 4: It's a double bind where do you reveal what you
- 7:47Speaker 4: supposedly really are or do you just allow people to
- 7:51Speaker 4: read you that way? And it works out very differently,
- 7:55Speaker 4: for instance, between trans and say CIS gay people, because
- 7:59Speaker 4: when CIS gay people talk about passing as straight. Their
- 8:02Speaker 4: passing is something that they know that they are not,
- 8:06Speaker 4: Whereas for a lot of trans people, people read me
- 8:08Speaker 4: as a woman and I understand myself to be a woman.
- 8:12Speaker 4: There's it's a very different dynamic because it's not like
- 8:15Speaker 4: I'm not hiding anything, but people are presuming what I'm
- 8:19Speaker 4: really passing as is I'm passing a CIS gender and
- 8:22Speaker 4: people are assuming I'm sis gender when the trans is
- 8:27Speaker 4: the thing that I might need to or feel like
- 8:30Speaker 4: I need to clear up, or other people might put
- 8:32Speaker 4: pressure on me to either tell them that I'm trans
- 8:38Speaker 4: or be accused of deceiving them. So that's a little
- 8:42Speaker 4: bit of kind of how I was approaching it when
- 8:45Speaker 4: I started working on that idea and really stressing the
- 8:48Speaker 4: idea of you can't understand miss gendering unless you understand
- 8:52Speaker 4: that we make assumptions all the time, we gender people
- 8:55Speaker 4: very actively, and you know, so trans people are often
- 9:00Speaker 4: just reacting to that and dealing with that double bind.
- 9:05Speaker 3: Yeah, and this is something that I think is interestingly
- 9:08Speaker 3: discussed in the book about like kind of this this
- 9:14Speaker 3: issue with some with some of the sort of prevailing
- 9:16Speaker 3: gender theories, which thought of which to think about sort
- 9:19Speaker 3: of like femininity and gender is pure performance. But you know,
- 9:25Speaker 3: and this is I think, like the argument that you
- 9:26Speaker 3: were making that I think is really interesting is that
- 9:29Speaker 3: something that I think is is very obvious to trans
- 9:32Speaker 3: people is that so much of gender is how people
- 9:36Speaker 3: perceive you and how you know and stuff that like
- 9:38Speaker 3: you don't have any control over. It's how people sort
- 9:40Speaker 3: of gender you. It's how people like construct a gender
- 9:45Speaker 3: around you in ways that you don't really have control over.
- 9:48Speaker 4: M yeah, and that was a big thing. So in
- 9:54Speaker 4: kind of I was writing the book in the mid
- 9:56Speaker 4: two thousands, and so the nineteen ninety is when Judith
- 10:02Speaker 4: Butler publishes Gender Trouble, which Butler never said all genders
- 10:06Speaker 4: performance are all genders drag, Yeah, but that is, but
- 10:10Speaker 4: that those are like slogans or sound bites that other
- 10:13Speaker 4: people took from their book, right, and they were very
- 10:16Speaker 4: popular at the time. There's also there's a famous sociological
- 10:20Speaker 4: article about doing gender, and so people were very focused
- 10:25Speaker 4: on the way in which we create gender by doing
- 10:31Speaker 4: it particular ways, and a lot of the slogans within
- 10:35Speaker 4: trans communities were sort of like, oh, well, you know,
- 10:39Speaker 4: I just have to do my gender differently, like more transgressively,
- 10:42Speaker 4: and that will like tear down all of gender. And
- 10:45Speaker 4: I felt that there was you know, that is an
- 10:48Speaker 4: aspect of things. And most of us, whether trans or cists,
- 10:52Speaker 4: most of us have had the experience of maybe trying
- 10:57Speaker 4: to perform our genders in a particular way in order
- 10:59Speaker 4: to like, you know, not you know, in order in
- 11:03Speaker 4: order to get by in the world, in order to
- 11:06Speaker 4: not be harassed by other people.
- 11:09Speaker 1: So we've all had that experience. So while that's true, there's.
- 11:13Speaker 4: The other partner of that dance, and that's perception, and
- 11:17Speaker 4: we're all perceiving people very actively, and we're like projecting
- 11:21Speaker 4: our ideas and meanings onto them. And I felt like
- 11:24Speaker 4: that was being under discussed at the time, and that
- 11:26Speaker 4: was not only a huge part of Whipping Girl, but
- 11:32Speaker 4: that's become a part of a lot of my other books,
- 11:34Speaker 4: like including my most recent book, sext Up, How Society
- 11:38Speaker 4: Sexualizes us and how we can fight back. One way
- 11:42Speaker 4: that I would describe that book is it's talking about
- 11:46Speaker 4: sex and sexuality not from what people do, but from
- 11:49Speaker 4: how we perceive and interpret sex and sexuality, because there
- 11:53Speaker 4: are a lot of unconscious ideas, often really horrible ideas,
- 11:58Speaker 4: really hierarchical ideas that are kind of built into the
- 12:01Speaker 4: way we view the world. And interrogating that and so yeah,
- 12:05Speaker 4: that was a very big part of both of The
- 12:07Speaker 4: Been Girl and then my writings since then.
- 12:11Speaker 3: Yeah, I think I think that is something where things
- 12:13Speaker 3: have gotten better in terms of in terms of how
- 12:15Speaker 3: we think about gender, which I don't know, like things
- 12:19Speaker 3: aren't perfect, but it definitely it definitely improved things.
- 12:23Speaker 1: A lot agreed We're going.
- 12:26Speaker 3: To take an ad break, and when we come back,
- 12:28Speaker 3: we're talking trans misogyny. We're back. Yeah. So the other
- 12:44Speaker 3: thing I wanted to sort of talk about was I think,
- 12:47Speaker 3: in like exactly the opposite process that happened to misgendering,
- 12:52Speaker 3: trans misogyny has become a lot more expansive than your
- 12:57Speaker 3: original sort of kind of narrow conception of it. And
- 13:02Speaker 3: I think this has been changing a lot, especially in
- 13:04Speaker 3: the last about half decade or so. So I was
- 13:07Speaker 3: wondering what you think about the way that this concept
- 13:10Speaker 3: has kind of taken on a life of its own
- 13:12Speaker 3: in recent years and what it's been doing since.
- 13:16Speaker 1: Yeah.
- 13:16Speaker 4: So I feel like trans misogyny that there are a
- 13:20Speaker 4: lot of different dialogues and discourses about it coming, like
- 13:25Speaker 4: people coming from different perspectives with it, and some people
- 13:29Speaker 4: feeling like the world is doing things that I never
- 13:34Speaker 4: suggested it was doing. It's kind of hard to know
- 13:37Speaker 4: like where to actually come in on this, But for me,
- 13:41Speaker 4: when I was first writing about it, I was first
- 13:44Speaker 4: just noticing that a lot of the quote unquote transphobia
- 13:47Speaker 4: that I was facing when people know as a trans
- 13:49Speaker 4: woman was actually a lot of it was just misogyny,
- 13:53Speaker 4: and a lot of it targeted like kind of my
- 13:57Speaker 4: femininity rather than my transness, and so I wanted to
- 14:03Speaker 4: write about that, and kind of the way that I
- 14:06Speaker 4: framed it in the book was, which I think is
- 14:11Speaker 4: a really useful kind of model for thinking about it,
- 14:14Speaker 4: is that there most of the types of sexism that
- 14:16Speaker 4: feminists have described over the many years fall into two
- 14:20Speaker 4: sort of camps, one of them being oppositional sexism, which
- 14:24Speaker 4: is the idea that men and women are kind of
- 14:27Speaker 4: perfectly opposite, mutually exclusive sexes that have different interests and
- 14:32Speaker 4: attributes and desires, and so a lot of transphobia and
- 14:36Speaker 4: homophobia are kind of like built into this idea that
- 14:39Speaker 4: men and women are completely distinct. And then the other
- 14:42Speaker 4: one is traditional sexism, which is the idea that femalists
- 14:46Speaker 4: and femininity are less legitimate than malness and masculinity. And
- 14:53Speaker 4: a lot of cis feminists have kind of viewed all
- 14:56Speaker 4: of that as just sexism, right, But when you break
- 14:59Speaker 4: it down like that, it makes it clear that the
- 15:01Speaker 4: double bind that a lot of feminists have talked about
- 15:04Speaker 4: is actually kind of these two different forms of sexism.
- 15:08Speaker 4: So if assis woman acts appropriately femininely so appropriate with
- 15:14Speaker 4: scare quotes. If a SIS woman acts femininely, she'll be
- 15:17Speaker 4: seen as appropriate, but she'll be dismissed because femininity is
- 15:22Speaker 4: dismissed in our culture. So that's the way that she'll
- 15:25Speaker 4: be delegitimized. Whereas if she acts in ways that are
- 15:29Speaker 4: coded as masculine, if she acts assertive or aggressive, then
- 15:33Speaker 4: people will malign her for being kind of a barrant
- 15:37Speaker 4: or deviant. Right, and so oppositional sexism helps keep traditional
- 15:42Speaker 4: sexism in place because you can say that maln is
- 15:45Speaker 4: and masculinity are superior, but that only works if you
- 15:49Speaker 4: can also make a clear distinction between you know, those
- 15:53Speaker 4: people and people are female and feminine. And so I
- 15:56Speaker 4: think this plays out differently. And I want to be
- 15:59Speaker 4: really clear about this because some people have interpreted trans
- 16:02Speaker 4: misogyny to mean that transmeild trans masculine people don't experience misogyny,
- 16:07Speaker 4: which is something I've never said, and obviously the fact
- 16:11Speaker 4: that oppositional sexism is a form of sexism, and obviously
- 16:17Speaker 4: transmeild transmasculine people experience that. But also depending upon how
- 16:21Speaker 4: you're viewed by other people, I feel like the same
- 16:25Speaker 4: double pind that affects this woman affects transmeild trans masculine
- 16:29Speaker 4: people differently, where there's this tendency, like in a lot
- 16:32Speaker 4: of anti trans discourses to dismiss transmasculine, especially transmasculine youth
- 16:39Speaker 4: as being merely girls quote unquote who are like, you know,
- 16:44Speaker 4: misled or seduced by gender ideology, right, And there's a
- 16:49Speaker 4: lot of real anti feminine and anti misogynistic ideas in
- 16:53Speaker 4: there in addition to the fact that it misgenders.
- 16:57Speaker 1: Transmeld transmasculine people.
- 17:00Speaker 4: Then if trans mail trans masculine people, when when they
- 17:05Speaker 4: experience transphobia, there's often you know, like they're scene as
- 17:10Speaker 4: deviant for kind of breaking that role, but often the
- 17:15Speaker 4: maleness or their masculinity themselves are not, you know, denigrated
- 17:21Speaker 4: in the same way because being male, being masculine are
- 17:25Speaker 4: seen as good in our culture. It's just that if
- 17:28Speaker 4: you trans male, trans masculine, it's like, well, you're quote
- 17:31Speaker 4: unquote just a woman, so you can't do it. So
- 17:33Speaker 4: I think it plays out in this very you know,
- 17:35Speaker 4: complex way for a lot of trans mail trans masculine people,
- 17:39Speaker 4: I think for trans female and transfeminine people, because our
- 17:45Speaker 4: crossing of oppositional sexism also involves us kind of moving
- 17:49Speaker 4: towards the female, towards the feminine, that there's kind of
- 17:53Speaker 4: those two forces intersect in a way so that it's
- 17:58Speaker 4: like exacerbated. And some of the ways I talk about
- 18:01Speaker 4: this in Women Girl is that, well, we live in
- 18:03Speaker 4: a world where masculinity is seen as natural and femininity
- 18:06Speaker 4: is seen as artificial, and since trans people are also
- 18:09Speaker 4: seen as artificial compared to sis gender people, a lot
- 18:12Speaker 4: of times we're viewed as doubly artificial. Furthermore, the idea
- 18:17Speaker 4: that women are seen as sex objects whereas men aren't
- 18:22Speaker 4: seen as sex objects often are transitions or gender transgressions
- 18:27Speaker 4: towards a female towards a feminine are presumed to be
- 18:30Speaker 4: driven by sexual motives that can play out in all
- 18:33Speaker 4: sorts of ways. Whether this is the idea that we're
- 18:36Speaker 4: like hypersexual or promiscuous, or that we want to be
- 18:40Speaker 4: sexualized by other people, or you can see it a
- 18:43Speaker 4: lot with the kind of the transgender predator is often
- 18:47Speaker 4: coded as like a man who either has some kind
- 18:51Speaker 4: of fetish or perversion or is just literally deceiving people
- 18:56Speaker 4: to get into women's restrooms to do something horrific. So
- 19:00Speaker 4: those are some of the ways that it plays out.
- 19:03Speaker 4: I feel that sometimes people view it in a cut
- 19:06Speaker 4: or dried way that either they'll assume that trans misogyny
- 19:10Speaker 4: means that trans montal, trans masculine people don't experience misogyny,
- 19:14Speaker 4: which again is not what that's about. Or sometimes people
- 19:17Speaker 4: will like try to make really clear distinctions. There's kind
- 19:22Speaker 4: of language like trans misogyny affected versus trans misogyny exempt.
- 19:28Speaker 1: Are the terms yeah.
- 19:30Speaker 4: TME and TMA, which are not terms I've used and
- 19:33Speaker 4: which or that I didn't coin them.
- 19:36Speaker 1: They're not in the book.
- 19:38Speaker 4: And I think that when I first saw that language,
- 19:41Speaker 4: and I've seen people use it in a way that
- 19:44Speaker 4: appreciates the fact that some people are non binary, so
- 19:47Speaker 4: it's a non identity based a way.
- 19:49Speaker 1: Sometimes this can play out in a really cut or
- 19:52Speaker 1: dried sort of manner that.
- 19:56Speaker 4: You know, sometimes you know, whether it's intended this way
- 20:01Speaker 4: or not, it can make it seem that, like, you know,
- 20:04Speaker 4: just boiling down a really complex experience, people's complex experiences
- 20:09Speaker 4: with different types of sexism into some people are privileged
- 20:12Speaker 4: and some people are marginalized, which I think is a
- 20:16Speaker 4: more general problem that happens kind of throughout all social
- 20:21Speaker 4: justice movements, so yeah.
- 20:23Speaker 5: And trans people are not alien to having complex experiences
- 20:28Speaker 5: be boiled down to three and four letter acronyms, so.
- 20:33Speaker 1: Yeah.
- 20:34Speaker 2: I mean I.
- 20:36Speaker 4: Did this in Twitter form, so it was like a thread,
- 20:40Speaker 4: so like now people can't access threads unless you.
- 20:44Speaker 1: Have an account with Twitter. And it's from a couple
- 20:47Speaker 1: of years ago.
- 20:48Speaker 4: But one of the things that I talked about was
- 20:49Speaker 4: I wrote this essay about ten years ago about how
- 20:53Speaker 4: CIS and trans is kind of a useful Those are
- 20:56Speaker 4: useful terms, but sometimes people fall in between CIS and trans,
- 21:01Speaker 4: and sometimes they can be used in a way to
- 21:04Speaker 4: talk about different double standards, like CIS people are treated
- 21:07Speaker 4: one way, trans people are treated another.
- 21:09Speaker 1: But sometimes it can be used in.
- 21:10Speaker 4: Like a sort of reverse discourse way where it's like,
- 21:14Speaker 4: you know, SIS people of all the privilege, trans people
- 21:16Speaker 4: of none of the privilege, and it can be used
- 21:19Speaker 4: to kind of create this strict dichotomy that ends up
- 21:22Speaker 4: excluding and invisibilizing some people's experiences. And I feel the
- 21:27Speaker 4: same thing as happening with TMME and TMA. So I
- 21:30Speaker 4: don't think that those terms need to necessarily be like,
- 21:34Speaker 4: I don't think there's anything bad about those terms per
- 21:37Speaker 4: se in and of themselves, but I think sometimes they
- 21:40Speaker 4: can be used in ways. And part of why I
- 21:44Speaker 4: reference this the SYS and trans essay that I wrote
- 21:48Speaker 4: many years ago. It appears in my book Outspoken. I
- 21:51Speaker 4: forget the complete title right now, which is but the
- 21:56Speaker 4: reason why I bring that up is so sometimes what
- 21:59Speaker 4: happens is that when people learn about SIS sexism, SIS
- 22:05Speaker 4: people might be like, oh, I face the sexism right.
- 22:08Speaker 4: If I'm a woman and I don't shave my legs,
- 22:10Speaker 4: I'm facing se sexism. And so then trans people say, yeah,
- 22:14Speaker 4: but it kind of plays out differently for us, And
- 22:17Speaker 4: so sometimes in order to stop people from kind of
- 22:21Speaker 4: making those claims, which I think it is true that
- 22:25Speaker 4: you know, a woman not shaving their legs, or if
- 22:27Speaker 4: a man decides to put on a dress one day,
- 22:29Speaker 4: regardless of whether they're SIS or trans, they could experience
- 22:33Speaker 4: sis sexism or transphobia, but it plays out differently for
- 22:37Speaker 4: people who are actually members of that marginalized group. And then
- 22:40Speaker 4: so then the marginalized group makes a distinction even sharper,
- 22:43Speaker 4: and it just kind of becomes this uh, escalating situation
- 22:49Speaker 4: where the language and kind of battles over it become
- 22:52Speaker 4: even more intense in a recent piece, one of the
- 22:56Speaker 4: most recent pieces, if you go to like my medium
- 22:58Speaker 4: site where my essays as we are now is, it
- 23:01Speaker 4: talks about the trans mass versus trans discourse in terms
- 23:07Speaker 4: of what I call the cultural feminist doom loop, where
- 23:11Speaker 4: the doom loop refers to kind of these ideas where
- 23:15Speaker 4: everyone like both sides are trying to talk about the
- 23:19Speaker 4: reason why their experiences are legitimate, and then that seems
- 23:22Speaker 4: as though the other sides are not legitimate, and then
- 23:25Speaker 4: that kind of cascades in a way that ends up
- 23:29Speaker 4: not being very productive but takes up.
- 23:32Speaker 1: A lot of energy on places like Twitter.
- 23:37Speaker 3: Yeah, and I think I think that's something we've still
- 23:40Speaker 3: seen about one trillion times, variety of toxic ways. But
- 23:46Speaker 3: what isn't toxic is the new third edition of Whipping
- 23:48Speaker 3: Girl coming out in March with you can ask your
- 23:51Speaker 3: local bookstore or pre order now. And Yeah join us
- 23:54Speaker 3: tomorrow for our discussion with doctor Serrano of the Anatomy.
- 23:58Speaker 1: Of Moral Panics.
- 23:59Speaker 3: This has been a could happen here. Trans people are great,
- 24:17Speaker 3: welcome to it could happen here. I'm your host, Mia Long.
- 24:19Speaker 3: I am happy to be here once again with Garrison
- 24:22Speaker 3: Davis and doctor Julius Serrano, the author of, among many
- 24:25Speaker 3: other works, a new edition of Whipping Girl coming out
- 24:27Speaker 3: in March, so kind of pivoting a bit. One of
- 24:33Speaker 3: the really bleak aspects of being trans in a hostile
- 24:37Speaker 3: world is that we've we've effectively been forced to become
- 24:41Speaker 3: experts in the architects of our own extermination. And I
- 24:45Speaker 3: think that's a lot of what kind of the new
- 24:47Speaker 3: afterward to the upcoming twenty twenty four to thirty edition
- 24:50Speaker 3: of Whipping Girl is about. So, I guess I wanted
- 24:53Speaker 3: to ask, what do you see as the biggest shifts
- 24:57Speaker 3: in sort of the struggle for transliberation beat between the
- 25:01Speaker 3: end of the sort of Mitchfest like fighting overrom Mitchfest
- 25:04Speaker 3: era that you wrote like Dream, which you sort of
- 25:07Speaker 3: wrote the second the forward, the preface of the second edition,
- 25:11Speaker 3: and then the stuff that's happening now is the sort
- 25:14Speaker 3: of third edition is coming out.
- 25:16Speaker 4: Sure, I think a huge aspect of transactivism from my
- 25:22Speaker 4: perspective of like first coming to trans communities in the nineties,
- 25:25Speaker 4: a lot of nineties and Zero's era transactivism was overcoming
- 25:32Speaker 4: basically people's ignorance, their lack of awareness about trans people
- 25:37Speaker 4: and so and this is one of the things that
- 25:41Speaker 4: you know, Whipping Girl, for example, there are a lot
- 25:43Speaker 4: of bad ideas about trans people that had been circling,
- 25:47Speaker 4: lating for a long time, especially with the culmination of
- 25:50Speaker 4: Janis Raymond's book The Transsexual Empire the late nineteen seventies
- 25:55Speaker 4: nineteen seventy nine, I think, and that influenced a lot
- 25:58Speaker 4: of people that say, places like Mishfest that had trans
- 26:02Speaker 4: women exclusion policies. And I felt like during the nineties
- 26:06Speaker 4: through the Zeros, we were constantly making gains that was
- 26:09Speaker 4: largely due to people learning more about us and then
- 26:12Speaker 4: recognizing basically shared goals, shared things in common. I think
- 26:17Speaker 4: that trans people are marginalized because of you know, mainstream
- 26:22Speaker 4: assumptions about sex, gender sexuality, and those assumptions also hurt
- 26:27Speaker 4: LGBTQIA plus people more broadly, they hurt you know, in
- 26:31Speaker 4: a sexist world, they hurt you know, cis women, you know,
- 26:35Speaker 4: all women, all people who move through the world perceived
- 26:38Speaker 4: as female feminine.
- 26:39Speaker 1: So we all have this kind of shared thing that
- 26:41Speaker 1: we're working.
- 26:42Speaker 4: Towards, and I feel like that was where a lot
- 26:45Speaker 4: of the progress was happening. And I think what really
- 26:48Speaker 4: changed in the mid two thousand tens, especially two year
- 26:54Speaker 4: twenty fifteen, which is literally the year after the so
- 26:58Speaker 4: called tipping point time age declaring the transgender dipping point
- 27:02Speaker 4: was when it was the beginning of what I would
- 27:06Speaker 4: describe as organized anti transactivism, where it wasn't just that
- 27:13Speaker 4: people didn't like us or they detested us, but it
- 27:16Speaker 4: was where there was actual coordination between different groups. In
- 27:22Speaker 4: the afterward, I describe there's the social conservatives and far
- 27:26Speaker 4: right who have always been anti LGBTQ plus who took
- 27:32Speaker 4: an even more intense focus on trans people.
- 27:37Speaker 1: There were groups that at.
- 27:40Speaker 4: The time that I wrote Whipping Girl, the term turf
- 27:43Speaker 4: wasn't around, of the term gender critical wasn't around. Now
- 27:45Speaker 4: we would call them gender critical or trans exclusionary feminists.
- 27:50Speaker 4: They've become kind of a part of that, and both
- 27:52Speaker 4: those groups working together.
- 27:54Speaker 1: In a lot of ways on policies.
- 27:56Speaker 4: I think one of the things that the average person
- 27:59Speaker 4: might not know, if you're not like really in kind
- 28:03Speaker 4: of highly aware of trans communities and issues, is that
- 28:07Speaker 4: probably behind the scenes, the anti transparent movement has probably
- 28:11Speaker 4: made more of an impact than any other group, and
- 28:15Speaker 4: they are very much like the anti vax parent movement,
- 28:20Speaker 4: where it's a lot of people who are from their standpoint,
- 28:26Speaker 4: they're just concerned about their children, they want what's best
- 28:28Speaker 4: for their children, but they actively seek out and often
- 28:33Speaker 4: get involved in you know, websites, social media forums and
- 28:38Speaker 4: sometimes actual activist campaigns that buy into a lot of
- 28:42Speaker 4: ideas that of children being indoctrinated into gender ideology or
- 28:50Speaker 4: being infected by social contagion. And there's all this pseudoscience
- 28:54Speaker 4: that rose out of that. So I would say that
- 28:56Speaker 4: that was the main difference, that there's this organized campaign,
- 29:00Speaker 4: and this campaign has just grown and grown and grown
- 29:02Speaker 4: to the point now where it's just this astoundingly large
- 29:07Speaker 4: moral panic that the types of things that like thirty
- 29:12Speaker 4: percent of people in our country believe about trans people
- 29:15Speaker 4: is abhorrent.
- 29:16Speaker 1: But that's kind of how it played out.
- 29:19Speaker 3: Yeah, I mean, there's there's been a lot of a
- 29:22Speaker 3: lot of very common, weird pseudoscience myths that sort of
- 29:27Speaker 3: came out of that. I wanted to talk a little
- 29:30Speaker 3: bit about quote unquote rapid onset gender dysphoria because that's
- 29:36Speaker 3: been all over the place. Me There's like a New
- 29:37Speaker 3: York Times article talking about it, like two weeks ago,
- 29:41Speaker 3: and it's I don't know, really been a fiasco, especially
- 29:44Speaker 3: given how unbelievably tenuous the stuff they sort of faked
- 29:51Speaker 3: or not as say fake, like unbelievably tenuous to like
- 29:53Speaker 3: quote unquote study they did that got retracted.
- 29:57Speaker 4: Was Yeah, and this is something that I actually saw
- 30:02Speaker 4: developing firsthand and then did research on in twenty nineteen.
- 30:07Speaker 1: So let me frame this.
- 30:09Speaker 4: I'll tell like my personal a short version of my
- 30:12Speaker 4: oral history of this.
- 30:14Speaker 1: So it was around.
- 30:16Speaker 4: Twenty seventeen that I first heard the idea of children,
- 30:20Speaker 4: you know, becoming trans because of social contagion. And it
- 30:24Speaker 4: just seemed to come out of the blue. And it's like, what,
- 30:28Speaker 4: you know, it's gender identity is not contagious. If it was, like,
- 30:32Speaker 4: you know, trans people would have infected way more than
- 30:35Speaker 4: like the less than one percent of us that actually exists.
- 30:39Speaker 5: Not a very effective contagious go yees rising like no,
- 30:46Speaker 5: like yes, yeah, exactly.
- 30:49Speaker 4: It's like, once you start looking at it, it seems
- 30:52Speaker 4: kind of ridiculous. A lot of it was because well,
- 30:55Speaker 4: you know, you know, my kid was hanging around a
- 30:57Speaker 4: transpersoner started watching videos on YouTube, and now they're trans.
- 31:02Speaker 1: It's like, yeah, well, maybe they.
- 31:04Speaker 4: Were hanging out with that trans friend and watching the
- 31:07Speaker 4: YouTube videos because they are trans and they just hadn't
- 31:11Speaker 4: come out yet, or they're just they're still figuring.
- 31:13Speaker 1: It out anyway. So in twenty eighteen.
- 31:16Speaker 4: Is when the Lisa Littmann paper on rapid on set
- 31:19Speaker 4: gender dysphoria came out, and I wrote this essay at
- 31:21Speaker 4: the time talking about all the things wrong with it.
- 31:23Speaker 4: And then in twenty nineteen, I'm like, where did these
- 31:26Speaker 4: ideas come from? And I should say that rap it
- 31:28Speaker 4: onset gender dysphoria is basically transgender social contagion wrapped up
- 31:34Speaker 4: in a medical sounding diagnosis.
- 31:36Speaker 1: Okay, so if you read.
- 31:38Speaker 4: The initial descriptions of transgender social contagion and the description
- 31:43Speaker 4: of rapid onset gender dysphoria, they're basically the same. It's
- 31:47Speaker 4: that kids are infecting one another. But the idea of
- 31:50Speaker 4: rap it on set gender dysphoria was meant to describe
- 31:54Speaker 4: this quick infection of transness that supposedly was happening, and
- 31:59Speaker 4: sowenty nineteen, I basically did a deep dive. I'm not
- 32:03Speaker 4: an investigative reporter, but that's kind of what I did
- 32:06Speaker 4: into like, where the origin of this was, And basically
- 32:09Speaker 4: all of this kind of came down to the website
- 32:13Speaker 4: Fourth Wave Now, which often worked in coordination with two
- 32:16Speaker 4: other anti transparent websites. So Fourth Wave Now is an
- 32:19Speaker 4: anti transparent website, arguably the very first one that came out,
- 32:24Speaker 4: and a parent posted the idea that her child was
- 32:29Speaker 4: like being infected by transgender social contagion, and it's almost
- 32:34Speaker 4: definitely clear. Now I will leave a little caveat even
- 32:38Speaker 4: though I think the evidence is pretty strong that that
- 32:41Speaker 4: was Lisa Marciano, who's anti trans therapist, who's very very
- 32:45Speaker 4: involved in anti transactivism right now, Okay, so and like
- 32:50Speaker 4: all everything points to that being her, and she also
- 32:55Speaker 4: seems to have in some capacity worked with Lisa Littman.
- 33:00Speaker 4: So basically the first paper about rapet on sitt gender
- 33:03Speaker 4: distory that came out was not Lisa Littman's, it was
- 33:05Speaker 4: actually Lisa Marchiano's, which came out twenty seventeen. So it
- 33:09Speaker 4: basically kind of grew from these anti transparent websites it
- 33:13Speaker 4: really quickly within six months. Not only was Lisa Littman
- 33:17Speaker 4: doing her survey, Lisa Littman being someone who has no
- 33:20Speaker 4: experience in trans health ever before then just decides to
- 33:23Speaker 4: go in and only survey parents from an ant from
- 33:26Speaker 4: three anti transparent websites, and it gets taken very seriously
- 33:32Speaker 4: just because the media fan the flames. A lot of
- 33:36Speaker 4: these groups were very excited to have something that seemed
- 33:40Speaker 4: to be a case study on their side. The paper
- 33:43Speaker 4: was heavily critiqued when it came out. There are now
- 33:47Speaker 4: and I described this in an all nine SI have
- 33:50Speaker 4: it's free if you google my name, and all the
- 33:53Speaker 4: evidence against social contagion it's in there. There are now
- 33:56Speaker 4: ten papers that have tested the idea of rap it
- 33:59Speaker 4: on at gender dysphoria and or social contagion and found
- 34:03Speaker 4: evidence that contradicts the hypothesis.
- 34:08Speaker 1: So it's still being.
- 34:09Speaker 4: Talked about that Pamela Paul. It was an alped that
- 34:12Speaker 4: looked like an article in the New York Times. It's
- 34:15Speaker 4: not the first time Pamela Paul and or the New
- 34:17Speaker 4: York Times has done this. They've seemed to have a
- 34:22Speaker 4: particular acts to grind against trans people and putting out
- 34:26Speaker 4: specious articles suggesting that gender firming care, especially for trans youth,
- 34:34Speaker 4: is bad, when actually all the evidence points to the opposite.
- 34:39Speaker 4: So yeah, that's a brief discussion of rapid ons at genders,
- 34:44Speaker 4: for which I think is the most popular of these
- 34:48Speaker 4: kind of pseudoscientific ideas, But there are definitely others that
- 34:52Speaker 4: are like about like four or five others that I
- 34:55Speaker 4: could get into, and I do get into in the
- 34:56Speaker 4: Afterword and in some of my other writings.
- 34:59Speaker 1: But yeah, and.
- 35:02Speaker 4: You know, I don't use the word pseudoscientific lightly. Basically,
- 35:09Speaker 4: there's like science, which is where different research groups try
- 35:13Speaker 4: to answer a particular question and if they all get
- 35:16Speaker 4: similar answers, then that becomes okay, well, that seems to
- 35:19Speaker 4: be established. Now let's work from there and ask more
- 35:22Speaker 4: questions and do more studies. Junk science is when you
- 35:26Speaker 4: do kind of a crappy study that doesn't really interrogate
- 35:32Speaker 4: all the possibilities, that either doesn't use controls or you know,
- 35:37Speaker 4: only looks at you know, a bias sampling size or
- 35:40Speaker 4: a bias sample or small sample sizes, and comes to
- 35:44Speaker 4: a conclusion that.
- 35:45Speaker 1: It wants to come to. That's junk science.
- 35:47Speaker 4: And then pseudoscience is when multiple independent groups all find
- 35:50Speaker 4: something different to what you're saying, but you keep touting
- 35:54Speaker 4: the thing you're saying is science. And that's definitely where
- 35:57Speaker 4: our gd is right now. Same thing with one of
- 36:00Speaker 4: these ideas that I talked about way back early and
- 36:03Speaker 4: Whipping Girl, and I've written other, you know, both academic
- 36:06Speaker 4: papers and online essays about this concept of autoginophilia, which
- 36:11Speaker 4: is this really old theory that just like it's kind
- 36:13Speaker 4: of like this zombie. It doesn't matter how many groups
- 36:16Speaker 4: find evidence to the contrary. It jibes with what basically
- 36:22Speaker 4: certain you know, gender disaffirming practitioners, practitioners and researchers and
- 36:29Speaker 4: anti transactivists. It jobs with what they want to say,
- 36:33Speaker 4: so it just kind of continues to be out there.
- 36:37Speaker 3: So yeah, yeah, I mean something that Garrison we were
- 36:41Speaker 3: talking about before, this is the extent to which the
- 36:44Speaker 3: extent to which the rapid Onset Gender is for you
- 36:46Speaker 3: study is almost exactly the same study as the first
- 36:49Speaker 3: anti vax study like it has it has almost exactly
- 36:52Speaker 3: the same It's the same thing where you find a
- 36:54Speaker 3: group of people who think their kid has autism because
- 36:56Speaker 3: they were got vaccinated, or you find a group of
- 36:57Speaker 3: people who think their kids are trans because social contagion
- 37:02Speaker 3: or something, and then you asked them about it, and
- 37:04Speaker 3: then you report the results of the study and it's like, well,
- 37:06Speaker 3: now and you report the results of you asking the
- 37:08Speaker 3: people the thing that they believe, and now it's a study,
- 37:11Speaker 3: and it's it's I don't know, it drives me insane
- 37:15Speaker 3: the extent to which he is literally exactly the same thing.
- 37:19Speaker 1: Yeah, I mean that was something.
- 37:21Speaker 4: So I didn't know this until h Bomber guy, who's
- 37:24Speaker 4: Auber who does really good investigations and video essays, and
- 37:29Speaker 4: I saw his autism and so this is something that
- 37:32Speaker 4: you know. I remember, I'm old enough to remember the
- 37:34Speaker 4: Wakefield paper being in the news, and then you've heard
- 37:37Speaker 4: lots of people debunking it, and then it's officially retracted
- 37:40Speaker 4: and basically all you know, the scientific field has settled
- 37:45Speaker 4: that it's like vaccines do not cause autism. A lot
- 37:48Speaker 4: of that is just like a coincidence of the time
- 37:51Speaker 4: that you first start noticing that children maybe autistic is
- 37:55Speaker 4: like right around the time after they've had vaccinations. But
- 37:59Speaker 4: but yeah, it wasn't the h Balmber guy video that
- 38:02Speaker 4: he talks about that the Wakefield study is a study
- 38:05Speaker 4: of parents, not the children, a study of the parents,
- 38:09Speaker 4: and the parents already had were already suspicious of the vaccines,
- 38:13Speaker 4: and so they said Oh, well, it happened right after
- 38:16Speaker 4: they had these vaccines, just like rapido ont sat genders
- 38:20Speaker 4: for it happens. Oh, it happened right after. You know,
- 38:23Speaker 4: one of my child's peer, their cheer peers came out
- 38:26Speaker 4: as trans.
- 38:27Speaker 1: It's like, yeah, maybe they're connected. Maybe that's why they're
- 38:29Speaker 1: good friends.
- 38:30Speaker 4: You know, most of my friends, you know, like when
- 38:32Speaker 4: I go out and stuff like that, you know, a
- 38:34Speaker 4: huge chunk of my friends, way higher than the average person,
- 38:38Speaker 4: are trans people. And it's not because any of us
- 38:42Speaker 4: infected each other. It's just that you have that thing
- 38:44Speaker 4: in common. You also, really importantly, when you're part of
- 38:47Speaker 4: a stigmatized group, being around other people who won't stigmatize
- 38:51Speaker 4: you often because they're part of that same group, that
- 38:54Speaker 4: can be really freeing and really supportive.
- 38:57Speaker 3: So yeah, yeah, Sy, we need to take another AD break,
- 39:01Speaker 3: but when we come back there will be more. I
- 39:05Speaker 3: don't know. I'm really kind of blowing the AD pivots
- 39:07Speaker 3: on this one. I'm very sorry, and we are back,
- 39:24Speaker 3: so I guess speaking of moral panics.
- 39:27Speaker 5: Speaking of social contagions.
- 39:32Speaker 4: Yes, moral panics are always very socially contagious.
- 39:36Speaker 3: Yeah, it's really truly, really truly, they have described their
- 39:40Speaker 3: own ideology and they've projected it out to everyone else.
- 39:44Speaker 3: H So, one of the things that you talk about
- 39:48Speaker 3: both in the Afterword and in sext Up is about
- 39:51Speaker 3: the relationship between stigma and contagion and how it's this powerful,
- 39:55Speaker 3: incredibly powerful force for moobilizing moral panics. Can you explain
- 39:59Speaker 3: sort of how that works?
- 40:01Speaker 5: Sure?
- 40:02Speaker 4: Yeah, so, And this was something that when I was
- 40:05Speaker 4: first working on sex Up, it wasn't kind of my idea.
- 40:08Speaker 4: I didn't think I was going to write about the
- 40:10Speaker 4: concept of stigma that much, but it really ended up
- 40:13Speaker 4: being very central the more kind.
- 40:14Speaker 1: Of research I did into it.
- 40:16Speaker 4: And so I think most of us are familiar with
- 40:18Speaker 4: the idea of stigma in terms of like feeling embarrassment
- 40:23Speaker 4: or being made to feel lesser than other people because
- 40:26Speaker 4: of some aspect of your person, right, And there is
- 40:30Speaker 4: that aspect of it that's often called like felt stigma.
- 40:35Speaker 4: But then there's the way that other people view stigma, right,
- 40:39Speaker 4: And so you know, people weren't necessarily stigmatized in that
- 40:42Speaker 4: way themselves, they might view people who are stigmatized in
- 40:46Speaker 4: particular ways. And one aspect of stigma that I learned
- 40:53Speaker 4: a lot of this from psychologists. I think it's Paul Rosen,
- 40:58Speaker 4: I know the last name is Rosin, and also Carol Nemerov,
- 41:04Speaker 4: and they both worked together and they had other colleagues
- 41:06Speaker 4: who worked on this. But a lot of this comes
- 41:08Speaker 4: from this really unconscious idea of contagion that seems to
- 41:13Speaker 4: be it's like pan cultural. It's just kind of a
- 41:16Speaker 4: way that people tend to view the world kind of
- 41:19Speaker 4: like a lot of people and a lot of cultures
- 41:21Speaker 4: have essentialist views. Contagion is sort of along those lines.
- 41:25Speaker 4: It's often described as a type of magical thinking. And
- 41:28Speaker 4: the idea is if something in your mind has this contagion,
- 41:33Speaker 4: if you get too close to it or you interact
- 41:35Speaker 4: with it, it can like permanently corrupt or taint you.
- 41:41Speaker 4: And so it has this kind of contagious like property
- 41:45Speaker 4: in people's minds, and so people often view groups who
- 41:48Speaker 4: are stigmatized, especially groups that are highly stigmatized, as essentially contagious,
- 41:55Speaker 4: where that stigma that they have could rub off on you.
- 41:59Speaker 1: If you get to close to them.
- 42:01Speaker 4: And so this happens like when I was really young,
- 42:04Speaker 4: the idea of like if you were friends with the
- 42:07Speaker 4: trans person. A lot of times people or even someone
- 42:10Speaker 4: who is gay back then people be like, oh, so
- 42:12Speaker 4: what are you? You must be gay too, right, It's
- 42:15Speaker 4: almost as if that stigma would then like kind of
- 42:18Speaker 4: migrate to you. And that's a lot of why stigmatized
- 42:22Speaker 4: groups face a lot of ostracization in society. And so
- 42:27Speaker 4: so this idea of contagion has been around. I think
- 42:30Speaker 4: groups who are lesser stigmatized one of the ways that
- 42:34Speaker 4: that plays out is they're viewed as less contagious. So,
- 42:37Speaker 4: you know, when I was really young, the idea of
- 42:39Speaker 4: if you had a trans person in your life, people
- 42:41Speaker 4: would really question you. Whereas by the time I came out,
- 42:44Speaker 4: you could have a trans friend and that would be fine.
- 42:46Speaker 4: It wouldn't necessarily be contagious, unless, of course, you were
- 42:50Speaker 4: interested in them, and then that stigma would If you
- 42:53Speaker 4: were like attracted to them, then there's that stigma. And
- 42:56Speaker 4: I think that stigma plays a lot into kind of
- 42:59Speaker 4: dynamics of and I write about this and sex stuff
- 43:01Speaker 4: that the whole idea of like fetishes and chasers and
- 43:04Speaker 4: all that. That's basically all the stigma that contagent stuff
- 43:08Speaker 4: playing out in different ways anyway, So I also think
- 43:14Speaker 4: that and I write about and sextup I think people
- 43:17Speaker 4: view sex and stigma as really closely intertwined, such that
- 43:23Speaker 4: I think people view the average person views heterosexual sex
- 43:27Speaker 4: as a stigma contamination act, where the males the corrupting
- 43:30Speaker 4: force and it's the woman who is corrupted by sex,
- 43:36Speaker 4: which is why you know virgins are pure. But then
- 43:39Speaker 4: once a woman has sex, she's like, you know, she's
- 43:42Speaker 4: become contaminated or tainted, and she has a lot of sex,
- 43:46Speaker 4: then people view her as like ruined, right, So that
- 43:50Speaker 4: idea is bell in there, and I think this combination
- 43:54Speaker 4: of viewing sex and stigma is kind of intertwined leads
- 43:58Speaker 4: to this sexual predator, the sexual predator stereotype that we're
- 44:04Speaker 4: seeing play out in really strong ways with trans people
- 44:07Speaker 4: right now. But actually, if you look throughout history, like
- 44:10Speaker 4: a lot of marginalized groups like deal in different ways
- 44:14Speaker 4: with the sexual predator trope.
- 44:16Speaker 5: And so.
- 44:18Speaker 4: I think this really clearly plays out with the kind
- 44:22Speaker 4: of what I call the groomer explosion that started in
- 44:25Speaker 4: twenty twenty two, where you know, people were accusing trans
- 44:29Speaker 4: people being groomors before then, but it really exploded in
- 44:31Speaker 4: twenty twenty two. And if you listen to what people
- 44:34Speaker 4: are saying that they're using the word groomer, which sounds
- 44:38Speaker 4: like a sexual predator thing, Like there's a real thing
- 44:40Speaker 4: of grooming children that sexual abusers do, but they're using
- 44:45Speaker 4: it against trans people in a way that has nothing
- 44:48Speaker 4: to do with that. But what they're talking about is corrupting,
- 44:51Speaker 4: you know, so their children who are presumed to be
- 44:54Speaker 4: sisgender and who often I think this is why a
- 44:59Speaker 4: lot of these anti trans discourses continue to paint like
- 45:04Speaker 4: trans children as being girls, right like, because then it
- 45:07Speaker 4: kind of plays into these feelings of like, you know,
- 45:11Speaker 4: transgender people are the adult men corrupting young girls. It
- 45:15Speaker 4: plays into a lot of people's view like messed up,
- 45:19Speaker 4: messed up heteronormative views of sex and fears of you know,
- 45:26Speaker 4: sexual abuse, child abuse being a very real thing that
- 45:30Speaker 4: people greatly misinterpret it so that the people who are
- 45:35Speaker 4: the usual perpetrators, which are usually you know, by and large,
- 45:41Speaker 4: straight men who are like adults who are close or
- 45:46Speaker 4: sometimes even family members of the child in question. But
- 45:50Speaker 4: like when they say grooming, they just mean corrupting or contaminating.
- 45:53Speaker 4: And I think that both grooming and social contagion, I
- 45:56Speaker 4: think both of these basically play off of this stigma
- 46:00Speaker 4: contamination idea. Right, the kids are pure, but then transgenders
- 46:04Speaker 4: like a type of coudies that if one kid becomes trans,
- 46:08Speaker 4: then they spread it to the other kids. And so yeah,
- 46:10Speaker 4: so I feel like it plays a really big role
- 46:15Speaker 4: not only moral panics, which amosol. Moral panics are there's
- 46:18Speaker 4: some kind of corrupting force that is often attacking otherwise
- 46:23Speaker 4: pure and innocent children. Sometimes it's technology, right, and so
- 46:28Speaker 4: people will be like, oh, we have to ban you know,
- 46:30Speaker 4: social media apps, you know, because it's hurting the children.
- 46:34Speaker 4: Or it could be transgender people who are the things
- 46:36Speaker 4: we need to ban because they're corrupting the children. But
- 46:40Speaker 4: I definitely think that both these ideas of stigma and
- 46:43Speaker 4: contagion play a big role in the way in which
- 46:47Speaker 4: moral panics, why they resonate with a lot of people,
- 46:51Speaker 4: even though they don't make any rational sense if you
- 46:55Speaker 4: just think about them kind of.
- 46:58Speaker 1: From a very realistic, yeah, practical point of view.
- 47:02Speaker 3: And we have to go to ads, but we'll be
- 47:04Speaker 3: back in a second, and we're back.
- 47:18Speaker 5: This is something that you mentioned briefly in the afterward,
- 47:21Speaker 5: and that's something that we've reported on, is how a
- 47:23Speaker 5: lot of this groomer thing that started in twenty twenty two,
- 47:27Speaker 5: and a whole bunch of this kind of modern wave
- 47:29Speaker 5: of transphobia is mirroring a lot of the anti gay
- 47:33Speaker 5: stuff from like the eighties that was pushed forward by
- 47:36Speaker 5: a lot of like evangelicals meant into just like mainstream
- 47:39Speaker 5: conservatism and specifically how it functions as this. Yeah, this
- 47:42Speaker 5: is sort of like moral panic and even social contagion.
- 47:45Speaker 5: The way homosexuality was treated as this thing and this
- 47:50Speaker 5: sort of social contingent aspect is so common now. I mean,
- 47:53Speaker 5: even the way we've already alluded to Musk, even the
- 47:57Speaker 5: way he mentions like the woke mind virus is exactly
- 48:01Speaker 5: this thing and as it really is like moral panics
- 48:03Speaker 5: and stuff. Right, this was kind of predated by the
- 48:06Speaker 5: critical race theory debacle, which then got you know, turned
- 48:10Speaker 5: into the groomer thing, and now exactly and now it's
- 48:15Speaker 5: even changed again. And these moral panics can have like
- 48:19Speaker 5: devastating results in terms of pushing forward legislation that outlasts
- 48:23Speaker 5: the actual moral panic. But the actual things themselves are
- 48:26Speaker 5: very short lived. They don't seem to have very much
- 48:29Speaker 5: like staying power as as as like cultural moments, they
- 48:34Speaker 5: move on so quickly, Like no one talks about critical
- 48:36Speaker 5: race theory anymore. You don't even hear this sort of
- 48:38Speaker 5: groomer rhetoric as often as you did two years ago,
- 48:42Speaker 5: and it's being replaced by new versions. And yeah, like
- 48:44Speaker 5: Mia said, the DEEI thing is the current current thing
- 48:49Speaker 5: that is wrecking American society if you ask about maybe
- 48:53Speaker 5: one third of population. But yeah, how do you feel
- 48:57Speaker 5: about like the life cycle of these morals and how
- 49:00Speaker 5: they relate to like the social contagion aspect.
- 49:03Speaker 4: Yeah, yeah, no, And I agree with what you're also
- 49:05Speaker 4: all the things you're citing that, Like, I think these
- 49:09Speaker 4: are all different variations of kind of the same idea.
- 49:12Speaker 4: And I do really appreciate the idea of the woke
- 49:15Speaker 4: mind virus as being kind of like the perfect like
- 49:19Speaker 4: the exemplar of this and that you know, people were,
- 49:23Speaker 4: you know, people were complaining about, you know, stuff being
- 49:26Speaker 4: woke for a while, and you know it is usually
- 49:29Speaker 4: it's often coded as something that's woke is like anti racist,
- 49:32Speaker 4: or you know, is something like it's very much associated,
- 49:38Speaker 4: you know, infused with like when people complain about wocism,
- 49:41Speaker 4: a lot of times they're like they're racist or there
- 49:46Speaker 4: or at the very least. They have fears about kind
- 49:50Speaker 4: of the corruption of pure whiteness being corrupted by increasing
- 49:55Speaker 4: you know, people of color and and you know, like
- 49:59Speaker 4: making game in society. Right, But the woke mind virus,
- 50:02Speaker 4: because no one could really explain what woke is because
- 50:04Speaker 4: then it keeps shifting and it refers to trans people
- 50:07Speaker 4: or critical race theory, et cetera. Yeah, and the woke
- 50:11Speaker 4: mind virus is like perfect because that's how they think.
- 50:16Speaker 1: It all works, Like it's just this thing that infects people,
- 50:20Speaker 1: specially children.
- 50:22Speaker 4: And the way in which there is a recent thing
- 50:26Speaker 4: just today, I think it was Ackerman, the billionaire has
- 50:29Speaker 4: been involved in a lot of this DII stuff, complaining
- 50:32Speaker 4: about his child being infected in college with Marxism, and
- 50:38Speaker 4: Elon Musk had similar issues with his trans daughter like
- 50:43Speaker 4: becoming pro marx or anti capitalists, and so they just
- 50:46Speaker 4: assume that, like, no, my child was pure, but now
- 50:49Speaker 4: they're infected. It's like, well, maybe there are other ideas
- 50:52Speaker 4: out there that are better than your idea. Yeah, and
- 50:56Speaker 4: maybe that's.
- 50:57Speaker 3: All it is.
- 50:58Speaker 4: But yeah, so I think in all of these cases, yes,
- 51:03Speaker 4: I think that there's this idea of a contagion or corruption.
- 51:07Speaker 4: Often involving children, and it is. Yeah, a lot of
- 51:11Speaker 4: the moral panic, a lot of the literature, like the
- 51:15Speaker 4: social sciences literature, all moral panics. They often describe them
- 51:19Speaker 4: as fleeting. You know, this one, the anti trans one,
- 51:22Speaker 4: isn't fleeting enough right now from my perspective. But people
- 51:28Speaker 4: will tend to kind of move on, like the Satanic
- 51:30Speaker 4: panic of the eighties, you know, like that was a
- 51:34Speaker 4: really big deal and then all of a sudden it
- 51:35Speaker 4: was just gone and no one ever talked about it again.
- 51:38Speaker 4: I think the difference here is that a lot of
- 51:41Speaker 4: these moral panics are really tied together with what's happening
- 51:46Speaker 4: in the country more generally, with anti democratic and authoritative,
- 51:52Speaker 4: you know, views coming from you know, particularly the right
- 51:57Speaker 4: wing of the country. You know, like one of the
- 52:00Speaker 4: to major political parties is really pushing a lot of
- 52:05Speaker 4: just generally across the board. You know, they're against feminism,
- 52:09Speaker 4: they're you know, against people of color, against LGBTQ plus people,
- 52:14Speaker 4: and I think it's all wrapped up into the same thing.
- 52:18Speaker 4: I think that while individual parts of the moral panic
- 52:23Speaker 4: may go away, they may talk about critical race theory
- 52:25Speaker 4: for a bit and then shift to trans people being
- 52:28Speaker 4: groomers then shift to DEI but I think a lot
- 52:31Speaker 4: of this is they're all intertwined. And actually, I think
- 52:34Speaker 4: that's like the last couple of paragraphs of the afterward,
- 52:38Speaker 4: I talk about that as a potentially good thing, because
- 52:41Speaker 4: even though it's been a horring time to be a
- 52:44Speaker 4: trans person, with all the anti trans legislation and all
- 52:48Speaker 4: the anti trans news stories, all the pushes back on
- 52:53Speaker 4: gender firm and care, despite all that, I think the
- 52:56Speaker 4: good thing is that I think there are clear sides here,
- 53:00Speaker 4: and I think, well, this wasn't true early on in
- 53:03Speaker 4: the anti trans backlash in the like late twenty tens.
- 53:08Speaker 4: I think most people realize now that all these things
- 53:12Speaker 4: are tied together from like kind of you know, the
- 53:16Speaker 4: right wing perspective in this country is just against all
- 53:20Speaker 4: these things. You know, they want a white, Christian, straight
- 53:25Speaker 4: minority of people running everything about this country, and so
- 53:30Speaker 4: I think the rest of us really need to recognize
- 53:33Speaker 4: that and work together to defeat that.
- 53:36Speaker 3: Yeah, I mean, I think I think that's a pretty
- 53:39Speaker 3: good place to end on. Do Let's you have anything
- 53:41Speaker 3: else that you wanted to make sure you get in.
- 53:44Speaker 4: No, I mean I feel like we touched we covered
- 53:47Speaker 4: a bunch of the book past, present, and hopefully future
- 53:50Speaker 4: being better than the present right now.
- 53:54Speaker 5: Hopefully hopefully hopefully.
- 53:56Speaker 6: Yes.
- 53:58Speaker 3: So okay, where can people find a the new additional
- 54:03Speaker 3: Whipping Girl and be you and your work on the
- 54:06Speaker 3: internet and or other places?
- 54:09Speaker 1: Sure? Yeah, so the book should be available.
- 54:12Speaker 4: So it's available for pre order right now, so you
- 54:15Speaker 4: can do that through like, you know, online places. I
- 54:18Speaker 4: often suggest people go to the Seal Press, my publisher,
- 54:22Speaker 4: because they give lots.
- 54:23Speaker 1: Of options there.
- 54:24Speaker 4: But you can also go to your local independent bookstore
- 54:27Speaker 4: and say, hey, I'd like the pre order this book
- 54:29Speaker 4: and they will do that for you. So the book
- 54:31Speaker 4: will be available everywhere and should be in stores starting
- 54:34Speaker 4: in March. As for me, my website Juliuserando dot com,
- 54:39Speaker 4: particularly if you go to the writings page there, I
- 54:42Speaker 4: have like literally links to everything I've written online over
- 54:46Speaker 4: the years, so it's kind of a clearinghouse of free
- 54:49Speaker 4: writings of mine. There are also links to my books there,
- 54:52Speaker 4: and then if you're looking for me on social media,
- 54:55Speaker 4: I'm at Julius Serrano on most platforms that I'm at.
- 55:00Speaker 3: I don't know how much stronger I can possibly recommend
- 55:03Speaker 3: reading Whipping Girl. It had I don't know it had
- 55:07Speaker 3: an enormous impact on me when I first read it,
- 55:10Speaker 3: and yeah, it will it will. It will do good
- 55:13Speaker 3: things for you if you read it too.
- 55:16Speaker 5: Yeah, and it's all still incredibly relevant. Like I was
- 55:20Speaker 5: breezing through like fifty pages just to refresh my memory
- 55:24Speaker 5: this morning, and I'm like, oh wow, so many of
- 55:26Speaker 5: the like intercommunity trans discourses that are constantly happening have
- 55:30Speaker 5: already been addressed, like twenty years ago, so many of
- 55:33Speaker 5: like I all the time I spend trying to write
- 55:36Speaker 5: about like trans misogyny of like, oh I I forgot,
- 55:41Speaker 5: this is already like all like written down, Like I
- 55:44Speaker 5: spent so long writing about the Daily Wire movie and like,
- 55:46Speaker 5: oh this is hardly all this work has already been done.
- 55:49Speaker 3: I can just like stop.
- 55:52Speaker 5: Oh man, Yeah, cannot cannot recommend enough.
- 55:57Speaker 3: Yeah, thank you, thank you so much for coming on.
- 56:00Speaker 4: Yeah, thank you all for the kind words. Yeah, thank
- 56:03Speaker 4: you for having me, and uh it was great and
- 56:06Speaker 4: thanks for all you do too.
- 56:08Speaker 3: Oh, thank you.
- 56:23Speaker 7: Welcome back to it could happen here, your favorite podcast
- 56:26Speaker 7: for a daily dose of dystopia. I am once again
- 56:29Speaker 7: you're a guest host, Molly Conger. Today I'm talking to
- 56:32Speaker 7: a good friend of mine in one of the brilliant
- 56:33Speaker 7: minds behind the melting of Charlottesville's Robert E. Lee statue,
- 56:37Speaker 7: Doctor Julane Schmidt, is going to tell us a little
- 56:39Speaker 7: bit about the history of the statue, from its planning
- 56:41Speaker 7: and placement to its current state, melted into ingots in
- 56:45Speaker 7: an undisclosed location. I'm joined today by doctor Julane Schmidt,
- 56:50Speaker 7: a professor of Religious Studies at the University of Virginia,
- 56:52Speaker 7: the director of the Memory Project at the University of
- 56:54Speaker 7: Virginia's Karsh Institute of Democracy, and a steering committee member
- 56:58Speaker 7: at the Swords in da Plowshare's project. As both a
- 57:01Speaker 7: scholar and an activist, doctor Schmidt has been a leading
- 57:03Speaker 7: voice in the Charlottesville community for racial justice and against
- 57:06Speaker 7: the Confederate monuments that once stood here. The Swords into
- 57:09Speaker 7: Plasher's project announced back in October that they had successfully
- 57:12Speaker 7: dismantled and melted down the bronze statue of Robert E.
- 57:15Speaker 7: Lee that once loomed over the Market Street Park and
- 57:17Speaker 7: downtown Charlottesville. Thank you so much for joining me today
- 57:20Speaker 7: to talk about the past, present, and future of that
- 57:22Speaker 7: hunk of bronze.
- 57:25Speaker 6: Thanks for having me Mollie, it's great to great to
- 57:27Speaker 6: talk with you about this.
- 57:29Speaker 7: I don't think i've called you Professor Schmidt since two
- 57:31Speaker 7: thousand and eight, when I took one of your classes.
- 57:33Speaker 6: It's been a while. It's been a while. Yeah, yeah.
- 57:36Speaker 6: Now we just call each other comrades, you know, because
- 57:39Speaker 6: we're out there on the streets and in city council
- 57:42Speaker 6: and you know, doing the things.
- 57:45Speaker 7: So before we get to the final fate of that
- 57:46Speaker 7: melted bronze, I want to ground this in the history
- 57:49Speaker 7: of that particular object. Right, This isn't just any Confederate monument.
- 57:53Speaker 7: This is the statue that made Charlottesville household name, the
- 57:55Speaker 7: statue that brought unite the right here, the statue that
- 57:58Speaker 7: killed someone. It's a statue that had history in that
- 58:01Speaker 7: park for a century before it came down, and before
- 58:04Speaker 7: it was removed. You led some really incredible walking tours
- 58:06Speaker 7: of the downtown parks to try to tell the story
- 58:08Speaker 7: of the way those statues existed in those spaces for generations,
- 58:12Speaker 7: why they were there, what they meant, what impact they
- 58:14Speaker 7: had on the landscape and the people in the community.
- 58:17Speaker 7: I think I went on about a dozen of those
- 58:19Speaker 7: walking tours, and I learned something new every single time.
- 58:21Speaker 7: So can you talk a little bit about the political
- 58:24Speaker 7: atmosphere in nineteen twenty four when that statue first went up.
- 58:28Speaker 6: Yeah, well it should, you know, just kind of to
- 58:30Speaker 6: back up a little bit, like the history of Charlottesville, Virginia.
- 58:34Speaker 6: At around the time of the Civil War, over half
- 58:37Speaker 6: of the population of the local population was enslaved in
- 58:41Speaker 6: Charlottesville and surrounding Albmarle County, and black people were actually
- 58:45Speaker 6: the majority of the population of Charlottesville until about eighteen
- 58:49Speaker 6: ninety and then it has been on this steady decline
- 58:54Speaker 6: you know, since then. So to think about it, if
- 58:57Speaker 6: you look at the history of reconstruction in charlott Pottsville,
- 59:01Speaker 6: black people came out and registered to vote and got
- 59:04Speaker 6: politically organized very quickly in the eighteen sixties already and
- 59:10Speaker 6: were very influential in electing a black delegate from Charlottesville
- 59:14Speaker 6: to go to the Constitutional Convention. This is when in
- 59:18Speaker 6: order to rejoin the Union, all of the former Confederate
- 59:22Speaker 6: states had to get their state constitutions up to snuff,
- 59:26Speaker 6: and so Virginia, as did the other former Confederate states,
- 59:30Speaker 6: you know, had a constitutional convention. In our delegate from
- 59:36Speaker 6: Charlottesville was James T. S.
- 59:38Speaker 1: Taylor.
- 59:38Speaker 6: He was a black man from Charlottesville. He'd been in
- 59:40Speaker 6: the United States Colored Troops, and he had a coalition
- 59:44Speaker 6: had coalesced around him of some progressive whites or savvy whites,
- 59:49Speaker 6: you know that through their lot with him and former
- 59:53Speaker 6: enslaved people and went and you know, and represented us
- 59:57Speaker 6: and put you know, Charlottesville in the mix for starting
- 1:00:00Speaker 6: a new state constitution in Virginia, for finally getting public schools.
- 1:00:05Speaker 6: You know, that's one thing that we can think, you know,
- 1:00:07Speaker 6: all those reconstruction governments around the South, you know, forgetting
- 1:00:11Speaker 6: us those public schools that we wouldn't have otherwise had
- 1:00:13Speaker 6: that we didn't have before.
- 1:00:15Speaker 1: You know.
- 1:00:16Speaker 6: So I say all that backdrop that if you read
- 1:00:19Speaker 6: the historical sources of the time during reconstruction and post
- 1:00:22Speaker 6: reconstruction in Charlottesville, the white elites were quite upset with
- 1:00:28Speaker 6: the state of affairs that had emerged after the Civil
- 1:00:32Speaker 6: War in which formerly enslaved people were in leadership competitian
- 1:00:37Speaker 6: political leadership, you know. And so when you look at
- 1:00:42Speaker 6: the history of you know, then finally as as the
- 1:00:47Speaker 6: new you know, there was a reconstruction era constitution that
- 1:00:52Speaker 6: started all those wonderful things such as you know, public schools,
- 1:00:55Speaker 6: you know, and voting rights for black men, you know.
- 1:00:59Speaker 6: But then as the Neil Confederates or their Confederate sympathizers
- 1:01:03Speaker 6: start to get the upper hand again at the end
- 1:01:05Speaker 6: of reconstruction, and in Virginia that's you know, more or
- 1:01:08Speaker 6: less in the in the eighteen eighties, you know, and
- 1:01:11Speaker 6: then there's this steady imposition of Jim Crow, you know,
- 1:01:14Speaker 6: that's going into you know, in Richmond they put in
- 1:01:17Speaker 6: their giant General Lee statue in eighteen ninety, you know there,
- 1:01:21Speaker 6: and then in nineteen oh two there's finally there was
- 1:01:24Speaker 6: this final push that pushed black people out of political
- 1:01:27Speaker 6: office in Virginia, and in nineteen oh two, a new
- 1:01:31Speaker 6: Jim Crow state Constitution was put into effect in nineteen
- 1:01:35Speaker 6: oh two. And so you have to when you think
- 1:01:37Speaker 6: about all of these statues being installed, we have to
- 1:01:41Speaker 6: see it as this it's really resentment politics, you know,
- 1:01:45Speaker 6: that's come about. That is if you look at these
- 1:01:49Speaker 6: speeches that are delivered at the installation ceremonies of these statues.
- 1:01:54Speaker 6: And this is where I'm getting to our General Lee
- 1:01:57Speaker 6: statue in Charlottesville specifically with this, you go back and
- 1:02:01Speaker 6: look at those at the occasion for the day and
- 1:02:05Speaker 6: these these installation ceremonies, they were a time for the
- 1:02:10Speaker 6: neo Confederate organizations, the hosting organizations in our case, the
- 1:02:15Speaker 6: United Daughters of the Confederacy, the United Confederate Veterans, and
- 1:02:18Speaker 6: the Sons of Confederate Veterans. Okay, we're the hosts you
- 1:02:22Speaker 6: know for this event. And this is a two or
- 1:02:23Speaker 6: three day occasion. So there's like delegations coming in from
- 1:02:28Speaker 6: all over the state, you know, and you know there's
- 1:02:30Speaker 6: this build up you know, in the days ahead, you know,
- 1:02:33Speaker 6: leading up to the installation. This was in May of
- 1:02:37Speaker 6: nineteen twenty four, you know, so you see, oh, this
- 1:02:39Speaker 6: delegation has arrived from Roanoak and now the governor is
- 1:02:42Speaker 6: coming in and now this and now you know, and
- 1:02:44Speaker 6: so you know, the town is just a twitter. You
- 1:02:46Speaker 6: know that this that they are hosting the statewide reunion
- 1:02:52Speaker 6: of the United Confederate Veterans. And there hardly are anymore
- 1:02:56Speaker 6: at this time. They're you know, quite elderly at this point.
- 1:02:59Speaker 6: So there, you know, there's why this you know, uh celebration,
- 1:03:02Speaker 6: and this is also an annual meeting of the Sons
- 1:03:04Speaker 6: of Confederate Veterans. And so the fact that little Charlottesville
- 1:03:07Speaker 6: is hosting a statewide reunion, you know, of the state
- 1:03:12Speaker 6: wide of all the chapters you know, of these neo
- 1:03:14Speaker 6: Confederate veterans is a big deal. And then and then
- 1:03:18Speaker 6: you know they're doing this, you know, and within this
- 1:03:21Speaker 6: context is when the unveiling of this statue is occurring,
- 1:03:25Speaker 6: you see. And so it's this, it's this whole build
- 1:03:29Speaker 6: up of kind of lost cause nostalgia, which which is occurring.
- 1:03:34Speaker 6: And in the speeches at the Lee statue unveiling ceremony,
- 1:03:41Speaker 6: it's very instructive to listen to what is being said.
- 1:03:45Speaker 5: You know.
- 1:03:46Speaker 6: You have, of course, you know, kind of local dignitaries
- 1:03:49Speaker 6: and statewide you know dignitaries are there. The the national
- 1:03:54Speaker 6: Commander of the Sons of Confederate Veterans is there. He
- 1:03:57Speaker 6: gives a speech. He was also a clansman, you know.
- 1:04:01Speaker 6: You know, so this says something there that you know,
- 1:04:03Speaker 6: nineteen twenties Charlottesville, you know, elites were not averse to
- 1:04:07Speaker 6: rubbing shoulders with a known klansman, you know, who had
- 1:04:10Speaker 6: been invited to give a speech. You know, other invited
- 1:04:13Speaker 6: guests one was a minister who was a graduate of
- 1:04:18Speaker 6: the University of Virginia, and it was you know, just
- 1:04:20Speaker 6: kind of revealing, you know what he said in his
- 1:04:24Speaker 6: in his speech, you know, when he was talking about
- 1:04:28Speaker 6: he said that that the days of reconstruction were worse
- 1:04:32Speaker 6: than war.
- 1:04:33Speaker 5: You know.
- 1:04:35Speaker 6: You know, so this right exactly, Yeah, does beg the question,
- 1:04:40Speaker 6: and that yeah, goes without saying, of course, that this
- 1:04:42Speaker 6: is you know, almost exclusively a white audience and you know,
- 1:04:45Speaker 6: the white school kids. School has been canceled for the day,
- 1:04:48Speaker 6: the university as classes you know, canceled for the day,
- 1:04:51Speaker 6: and you know, the businesses are closed. I mean, this
- 1:04:54Speaker 6: is just you know, quite the community event that's going on.
- 1:04:57Speaker 6: So yeah, so reconstruction was worse than or you know,
- 1:05:01Speaker 6: we're celebrating today, you know, the you know, the spirit
- 1:05:04Speaker 6: of lead, the regeneration, you know, of our values, and
- 1:05:08Speaker 6: you know, there's just a lot of of conversation in
- 1:05:12Speaker 6: these in these inaugurations, ceremonies, you know, for the unveiling
- 1:05:16Speaker 6: of these statues that harken to rebirth and regeneration and
- 1:05:21Speaker 6: and you know, and also you know kind of recalling
- 1:05:24Speaker 6: you know, the days of old, you know, and the
- 1:05:26Speaker 6: and the values. You know of our veterans, you know
- 1:05:29Speaker 6: who are now you know of course in dwindling number,
- 1:05:31Speaker 6: you know, these Confederate veterans who are there. And so
- 1:05:34Speaker 6: this and as I said, there's been this whole build
- 1:05:38Speaker 6: up you know, for days and days, you know, I mean,
- 1:05:41Speaker 6: of course for the planning committee, this has been going
- 1:05:43Speaker 6: on for weeks and months, you know, the fundraising and
- 1:05:46Speaker 6: you know, reserving you know blocks you know at the
- 1:05:48Speaker 6: hotels and you know, and all guest houses and all
- 1:05:51Speaker 6: this kind of thing, you know, banquet halls, et cetera.
- 1:05:53Speaker 6: You know. But it's it's also revealing that this installation
- 1:05:59Speaker 6: ceremony for the statue, it is book ended with clan
- 1:06:03Speaker 6: activity and uptick in clan activity before and after the
- 1:06:09Speaker 6: installation ceremony. And why while we don't have well we
- 1:06:15Speaker 6: do know, but you know one one clansman who you know,
- 1:06:18Speaker 6: the the Commander Lee, no relation to the General Lee.
- 1:06:22Speaker 6: But uh but the president and sons sons of the
- 1:06:25Speaker 6: Confederate Veterans, you know. But but to just see all
- 1:06:29Speaker 6: of this uptick in lost cause nostalgia and then these
- 1:06:34Speaker 6: these acts of intimidation of you know, clan rallies, clan
- 1:06:39Speaker 6: posters that were you know, put flyers around town, you know, uh,
- 1:06:43Speaker 6: and this sort of thing. It just it they're the
- 1:06:47Speaker 6: atmosphere of intimidation. You know that this must have been
- 1:06:51Speaker 6: for black residents you know of the time. Uh, you know,
- 1:06:55Speaker 6: it just it really gives you pause, you know, just
- 1:06:58Speaker 6: just seeing how public space was commandeered, you know by
- 1:07:03Speaker 6: these people, these Neil Confederates, you know, to kind of
- 1:07:08Speaker 6: relive what they considered, you know, kind of the glory
- 1:07:10Speaker 6: days you know, of the nation, you know, and the
- 1:07:14Speaker 6: kind of values to which they want to return, you know,
- 1:07:17Speaker 6: and this sort of thing. So yeah, so this is
- 1:07:21Speaker 6: going on, you know in the nineteen twenties, as you know,
- 1:07:24Speaker 6: Charlottesville is you know, locked into Jim Crow by then,
- 1:07:28Speaker 6: you know, and we're twenty two years into that Jim
- 1:07:31Speaker 6: Crow State Constitution. You know, this is the mail u
- 1:07:36Speaker 6: you know, in which in which this is taking place.
- 1:07:38Speaker 5: Now.
- 1:07:38Speaker 6: Of course, Black people have their own institutions, you know
- 1:07:42Speaker 6: that they've founded, namely churches, the Jefferson School, African American
- 1:07:47Speaker 6: what's now the African American Heritage Center, but the Jefferson School,
- 1:07:50Speaker 6: which was a school for black children, and the founding
- 1:07:55Speaker 6: of the High School of a Black High School. So
- 1:07:59Speaker 6: this was you know, the the black community had its
- 1:08:01Speaker 6: own nodes of organizational strength, you know, and goings on
- 1:08:07Speaker 6: that were happening even as you know, there were these
- 1:08:10Speaker 6: pressures going on with the consolidation of Jim Crow. Should
- 1:08:15Speaker 6: also mention that, you know, at this at around the
- 1:08:17Speaker 6: same time in the spring of nineteen twenty four was
- 1:08:22Speaker 6: the passage of the Virginia Racial Integrity Act. And this
- 1:08:28Speaker 6: was the kind of the codification of the so called
- 1:08:32Speaker 6: one Drop Rule, which designated anyone with a perceived ad
- 1:08:38Speaker 6: mixture of African American or Native American ancestry to be
- 1:08:45Speaker 6: designated as colored, you know, and kind of bifurcating the
- 1:08:48Speaker 6: population of Virginia into two categories, white or colored. And
- 1:08:53Speaker 6: so this is also occurring, you know, in nineteen twenty four.
- 1:08:56Speaker 6: There's a very you know, there's very much of a
- 1:08:58Speaker 6: legal you know, kind of strengthening, you know of in
- 1:09:03Speaker 6: terms of the tools that are being used to separate
- 1:09:07Speaker 6: the races quote unquote you know, and what we're seeing
- 1:09:11Speaker 6: then in the parks, you know, in our public spaces
- 1:09:14Speaker 6: were you know, kind of designating what we're well not
- 1:09:20Speaker 6: public spaces, I mean, they were you know, kind of
- 1:09:21Speaker 6: designated you know, almost shrine like you know as white spaces,
- 1:09:26Speaker 6: you know, and that this is it's a kind of
- 1:09:31Speaker 6: broadcasting of who's in charge, is what's going on?
- 1:09:35Speaker 5: Right?
- 1:09:35Speaker 7: I think you know today the sons of Confederate Veterans
- 1:09:38Speaker 7: very much separate themselves from the clan, right, there were
- 1:09:41Speaker 7: a heritage organization. We're not the clan, but you were
- 1:09:44Speaker 7: talking about this sort of clan activity leading up to
- 1:09:47Speaker 7: the unveiling of the statue, and its actually just looking
- 1:09:49Speaker 7: back this morning at some of the archival newspapers from
- 1:09:52Speaker 7: that week. And so when the day the statue was placed,
- 1:09:55Speaker 7: you know, a few weeks before the unveiling, it was
- 1:09:57Speaker 7: still covered, it was shrouded, you know, it's leading up
- 1:09:59Speaker 7: to the big day. So that in the front page
- 1:10:01Speaker 7: of the Daily Progress the day that the statue was
- 1:10:04Speaker 7: put in the park, that little snippet appears in the
- 1:10:07Speaker 7: newspaper right next to a headline about cross burning. These
- 1:10:11Speaker 7: things are happening on at the same time, right, And
- 1:10:13Speaker 7: there was a big clan march through town that week,
- 1:10:16Speaker 7: and I think one of the it's easy to forget
- 1:10:18Speaker 7: that these historical moments were experienced by people whose words
- 1:10:23Speaker 7: that we still have, like people who were living in
- 1:10:25Speaker 7: this moment. I think one of one moment in your
- 1:10:28Speaker 7: historical tour that really has stuck with me all these
- 1:10:29Speaker 7: years is an anecdote about John West, who is for
- 1:10:33Speaker 7: the listener as a man who was born into slavery
- 1:10:36Speaker 7: and this era was one of the largest black landowners
- 1:10:39Speaker 7: in the area, was a successful businessman. And when the
- 1:10:42Speaker 7: clan marched by that week, you know, they're wearing their hoods,
- 1:10:45Speaker 7: you don't know who they are. It's you know, it's mysterious,
- 1:10:46Speaker 7: it's intimidating. But he knew who every single clansman was
- 1:10:50Speaker 7: because he was their barber, and he recognized their shoes.
- 1:10:53Speaker 7: And that just feels so intimate to me, right that
- 1:10:55Speaker 7: he's he's looking at the shoes of these men that
- 1:10:58Speaker 7: he knows, and then tomorrow they're going to come in
- 1:11:00Speaker 7: for a shaven a haircut and he has to say,
- 1:11:01Speaker 7: you know, yes, sir, thank you, sir.
- 1:11:03Speaker 6: That's right, that's right. And so if you can just imagine, like,
- 1:11:06Speaker 6: you know, and here you know John West. You know,
- 1:11:08Speaker 6: so here's one of the most you know, influential Black
- 1:11:13Speaker 6: residents of Charlottesville at that time, and he has to
- 1:11:16Speaker 6: live Yeah, in this you know that there's this this
- 1:11:19Speaker 6: atmosphere of intimidation that you that, yeah, his clients are
- 1:11:22Speaker 6: coming in, you know, they're coming in every ten days
- 1:11:24Speaker 6: or fourteen days to get a get a trim, get
- 1:11:27Speaker 6: a you know, touch up, you know here and there,
- 1:11:29Speaker 6: and yeah, and and he knows that these you know
- 1:11:34Speaker 6: that that these are you know, the folks who are
- 1:11:38Speaker 6: kind of maintaining you know that this this public order,
- 1:11:43Speaker 6: you know that is so uh you know that you know,
- 1:11:47Speaker 6: you better not step out of line. And so just
- 1:11:49Speaker 6: to have one's public space, you know, be demarcated, you know,
- 1:11:54Speaker 6: in such a demonstrative way, you know, in a monumental
- 1:12:00Speaker 6: you know literally yeah exactly is it really illustrates what's
- 1:12:06Speaker 6: going on, you know, and even in you know, relationships
- 1:12:09Speaker 6: like that, you know that are so like you know,
- 1:12:12Speaker 6: intimate a barber and a client, you know, and knowing
- 1:12:16Speaker 6: you know, what your clients are up to, you know,
- 1:12:19Speaker 6: and how you better stay in line.
- 1:12:21Speaker 3: You know.
- 1:12:22Speaker 6: It's scary.
- 1:12:33Speaker 7: That's what that statue was here right for almost a century,
- 1:12:37Speaker 7: So skipping ahead that century right when the statue finally
- 1:12:39Speaker 7: came down in twenty twenty one, so not too long ago, right,
- 1:12:43Speaker 7: So the city solicited proposals for what was to be
- 1:12:46Speaker 7: done with it. Right, A lot of cities put them
- 1:12:48Speaker 7: into storage or moved them to battlefields or museums didn't
- 1:12:52Speaker 7: want them. People say, well, why can't it go to
- 1:12:53Speaker 7: a music museums didn't want it, right.
- 1:12:56Speaker 6: Yeah, So because of my I get pulled in on
- 1:13:01Speaker 6: a lot of different statue statue related consultations, let's put
- 1:13:07Speaker 6: it that way. And I was on the George Rogers
- 1:13:10Speaker 6: Clark Committee at the University of Virginia when the university
- 1:13:14Speaker 6: was trying to decide what to do with a very
- 1:13:16Speaker 6: hideous I called it the Genocide Trophy. It was a
- 1:13:19Speaker 6: statue of the George Rogers Clark, the conqueror of the Northwest.
- 1:13:23Speaker 6: It literally said that on the facade, you know. And
- 1:13:27Speaker 6: so we were in consultation with native tribes. We were
- 1:13:31Speaker 6: contacting the various tribal nations who suffered the onslaught of
- 1:13:37Speaker 6: the so called Northwest Campaign. So these tribes that are
- 1:13:40Speaker 6: in what is now Illinois and Ohio, et cetera, you know,
- 1:13:44Speaker 6: and just asking them, you know, would you like to
- 1:13:46Speaker 6: kind of weigh in, you know, on this, and you know,
- 1:13:49Speaker 6: really sad, genocide is a real thing some folks who
- 1:13:52Speaker 6: are just no longer there, you know, or you know
- 1:13:55Speaker 6: were you know, became such a remnant, you know, as
- 1:13:58Speaker 6: they were so decimated that you know, they kind of
- 1:14:00Speaker 6: you know morphed into you know, other tribes others were
- 1:14:03Speaker 6: you know, went on you know, later on to you know,
- 1:14:06Speaker 6: to uh, Oklahoma or other places. You know, just dispersal,
- 1:14:10Speaker 6: you know, really was you know. You know, so we're
- 1:14:13Speaker 6: in this you know, kind of year long process trying
- 1:14:15Speaker 6: to figure out what to do with UVa's own statue there,
- 1:14:18Speaker 6: you know, also a gift of Paul Goodlow McIntyre, you know,
- 1:14:21Speaker 6: the same donor who gave the least statue to the city,
- 1:14:24Speaker 6: gave this s. George Rogers Clark statue to the university.
- 1:14:28Speaker 6: And so in doing that committee work, we made appointments
- 1:14:34Speaker 6: with all the big players, all the you know, and
- 1:14:36Speaker 6: here we are, We're from the University of Virginia, you know,
- 1:14:39Speaker 6: and we've got this you know, big big monument here,
- 1:14:44Speaker 6: you know, the Smithsonian, the you know, and you know
- 1:14:46Speaker 6: we talked to not about this one, but in another instance,
- 1:14:50Speaker 6: talk to you know, the Civil War Museum's battlefields, you know,
- 1:14:54Speaker 6: I mean, we contacted all the responsible you know, the
- 1:14:58Speaker 6: folks who are going to curate this in a responsible way,
- 1:15:02Speaker 6: you know, because you know that's it is a monumental
- 1:15:05Speaker 6: work of art. You know, it has stood here for
- 1:15:08Speaker 6: a century. It does have historical value of a sort,
- 1:15:12Speaker 6: you know. And I mean and you know, and as
- 1:15:14Speaker 6: someone who has you know, teaches history and research's history,
- 1:15:17Speaker 6: that's my that's my inclination. My initial inclination is, oh, yeah,
- 1:15:21Speaker 6: well we should preserve I mean, that's you know, kind
- 1:15:23Speaker 6: of where I go to. But the problem is it's
- 1:15:26Speaker 6: a very practical one. This is a material object that
- 1:15:30Speaker 6: is taking up space, literal and figurative space in the world.
- 1:15:34Speaker 7: It's six six thousand pounds.
- 1:15:36Speaker 6: Yeah, yeah, the very materiality of it. It is taking
- 1:15:40Speaker 6: up space, and you you have to figure out what
- 1:15:43Speaker 6: space is it going to inhabit. This is a very
- 1:15:47Speaker 6: practical question. If it's not in your park anymore, where's
- 1:15:51Speaker 6: it going to be. We contacted all these museums, you know,
- 1:15:54Speaker 6: and in several you know, different consultations I've been a
- 1:15:57Speaker 6: part of where we've been trying to get rid of statues.
- 1:16:01Speaker 6: Nobody wants them, nobody responsible wants them. And you know,
- 1:16:06Speaker 6: and even if they did have an inclination to want
- 1:16:08Speaker 6: to just the expense of it. You know, who wants
- 1:16:11Speaker 6: to reinforce their floors to put a you know, century old,
- 1:16:15Speaker 6: you know, artistically not exemplary, you know, monument in it,
- 1:16:22Speaker 6: you know, and then care for I mean, museums have
- 1:16:23Speaker 6: very limited budgets. They're nonprofit organizations. Why should they be
- 1:16:27Speaker 6: expending all this energy? I love the My my colleague
- 1:16:33Speaker 6: Aaron Thompson from John Jay College and Cuney, you know,
- 1:16:37Speaker 6: she's an art crime professor, and she said, you know,
- 1:16:40Speaker 6: she talked with somebody at the Smithsonian who said something
- 1:16:43Speaker 6: to the effect that, you know, we're not America's attic
- 1:16:48Speaker 6: for racist art. You know, that's that's not our role.
- 1:16:52Speaker 6: It's like, you know, it kind of does throw back
- 1:16:55Speaker 6: the responsibility to individual communities too. It's like, you know,
- 1:16:58Speaker 6: you have a part to play in this.
- 1:17:00Speaker 3: You know.
- 1:17:00Speaker 6: And so anyway, yeah, so we tried to do the
- 1:17:02Speaker 6: responsible thing. We contacted all the responsible actors out there.
- 1:17:06Speaker 6: They don't want them, and so then the question becomes, Okay,
- 1:17:11Speaker 6: the city also doesn't want it sitting on its back
- 1:17:13Speaker 6: lot for forever in perpetuity. You know, they've got things going,
- 1:17:17Speaker 6: you know, they've got equipment there, They've got things that
- 1:17:19Speaker 6: you know, this shouldn't be sitting there.
- 1:17:21Speaker 2: Where is it going to go?
- 1:17:23Speaker 6: Again? This is the material object that exists in the world.
- 1:17:26Speaker 6: It is a problem, you know, like what physical space
- 1:17:28Speaker 6: is it going to occupy? We're just such brute practicality here,
- 1:17:31Speaker 6: and I don't think people quite get what it means
- 1:17:34Speaker 6: to deal with this. And the only people who want
- 1:17:37Speaker 6: it are the very people who shouldn't have it, you know,
- 1:17:41Speaker 6: who want to take this object that's caused us so
- 1:17:45Speaker 6: much pain and to make a shrine out of it,
- 1:17:49Speaker 6: you know, that would continue to attract bad actors, you know,
- 1:17:54Speaker 6: and that it would you know. And I'm a religious
- 1:17:57Speaker 6: studies scholar, so when I use I don't use the
- 1:17:59Speaker 6: word ran lightly. I know what kinds of activities you know, uh,
- 1:18:04Speaker 6: these engender you know, and the sorts of emotions that
- 1:18:07Speaker 6: are you know evoked, you know, in the ceremonies around
- 1:18:10Speaker 6: you know, objects that are that are held to be sacred.
- 1:18:12Speaker 6: You know that that attract you know, kind of devotees,
- 1:18:14Speaker 6: you know, and so you really have to think about
- 1:18:17Speaker 6: what does it mean to be a responsible ethical actor?
- 1:18:22Speaker 3: You know.
- 1:18:22Speaker 6: It's like now we're we're in grown up world now,
- 1:18:25Speaker 6: it's like, okay, exactly want you know, it's like there
- 1:18:28Speaker 6: is a material object, where are we going to put it?
- 1:18:30Speaker 6: It's like have an adjunct car, what do you do
- 1:18:32Speaker 6: with it? You just let it sit in your driveway
- 1:18:34Speaker 6: and make your neighbors mad at you.
- 1:18:36Speaker 7: Right, And these Confederate statues are sort of the the
- 1:18:38Speaker 7: the junk cars of the Lost Cause, right, because they're
- 1:18:40Speaker 7: not rare, right, like, you know, especially right after Unite
- 1:18:44Speaker 7: the Right, a bunch of cities, all of a sudden,
- 1:18:45Speaker 7: we're like, we got to get rid of these things.
- 1:18:48Speaker 7: And so suddenly the market is flooded with Confederate statues.
- 1:18:51Speaker 7: Where are you going to put them?
- 1:18:53Speaker 6: That's right at that and that is the question. And
- 1:18:57Speaker 6: they are And I've used this this metaphor before, the
- 1:19:00Speaker 6: the metaphor of toxic waste. You know, it's not responsible
- 1:19:05Speaker 6: to say, oh, we want to get rid of our
- 1:19:08Speaker 6: toxic trash here and then ship it down the road
- 1:19:12Speaker 6: to the next town and say, okay, well we're done
- 1:19:14Speaker 6: with that. That's not responsible to make that next town
- 1:19:18Speaker 6: have to deal, you know, or maybe there maybe there
- 1:19:20Speaker 6: were some people in that town that wanted it, you know,
- 1:19:23Speaker 6: but that's not fair to the other people to have
- 1:19:25Speaker 6: to breathe in that air and it brings that water
- 1:19:27Speaker 6: that's that's poisoned by this. That's not that's not being responsible,
- 1:19:31Speaker 6: you know what I mean. So it really is an
- 1:19:34Speaker 6: ethical question, you know, what what space these toxic objects
- 1:19:42Speaker 6: are going to inhabit. And so we were unable to
- 1:19:46Speaker 6: find any responsible actors who would take this on. And
- 1:19:51Speaker 6: so then it kind of it's like, well, I guess
- 1:19:55Speaker 6: it's kind of on us. We have to you know,
- 1:19:59Speaker 6: like the Smithsonian. It's like, we're not the attic for
- 1:20:01Speaker 6: your racist trash.
- 1:20:02Speaker 3: You know.
- 1:20:02Speaker 6: It's like it's really it's it's on us. It's on
- 1:20:05Speaker 6: communities to figure this out, you know. And if there isn't, uh,
- 1:20:10Speaker 6: you know, some sort of organization that can responsibly curate this,
- 1:20:14Speaker 6: you know, and care for it, then you know, we
- 1:20:16Speaker 6: really need to think about it. And in the case
- 1:20:19Speaker 6: of this Lee statue, of Charlottesville's Lee statue, you know,
- 1:20:23Speaker 6: there are about I think there are about sixteen monuments
- 1:20:26Speaker 6: of Lee, like kind of equestrian monuments of this sort,
- 1:20:29Speaker 6: you know, in the country. I can say with confidence
- 1:20:33Speaker 6: that all of the others are of better quality. In Charlottesville.
- 1:20:39Speaker 7: That's it's such an important point, right because this is,
- 1:20:43Speaker 7: you know, an important historical piece of art. And that's
- 1:20:46Speaker 7: true of some of them. Some of them are legitimate
- 1:20:48Speaker 7: pieces of but this one is not.
- 1:20:50Speaker 1: No.
- 1:20:51Speaker 7: I mean, it was like he was smuggling hams in
- 1:20:53Speaker 7: his sleeves.
- 1:20:54Speaker 6: Oh well yeah, so yeah, it's it's terrible. It's really
- 1:20:57Speaker 6: a case The Lee statue from Charlottesville is really a
- 1:21:00Speaker 6: case of too many chefs spoiled the soup. You know,
- 1:21:04Speaker 6: they the guy, you know, they the original sculptor, Schradie,
- 1:21:12Speaker 6: you know, was commissioned to do this, this this work,
- 1:21:16Speaker 6: and he got behind on the commission because he was
- 1:21:18Speaker 6: finishing another another work of his, which is generally regarded
- 1:21:23Speaker 6: as his magnum opus, which is a monument to General Grant.
- 1:21:28Speaker 6: I just love that. It's just sorry you got to
- 1:21:32Speaker 6: wait and working on my best piece.
- 1:21:34Speaker 7: Ready finished a beautiful statue of Grant.
- 1:21:36Speaker 6: And then he died, And then he died. He died,
- 1:21:40Speaker 6: and and supposedly it might be apocryphal. I kind of
- 1:21:43Speaker 6: like this tale that supposedly when he's on his deathbed TRD,
- 1:21:46Speaker 6: he's on his death bending and he's still thinking about
- 1:21:49Speaker 6: that unfinished lead. Probably he's like, oh, mind the you know,
- 1:21:53Speaker 6: mind the cloth, you know, keep.
- 1:21:54Speaker 7: It damp, you know, keeps the plaster wet, right.
- 1:21:56Speaker 6: Yes, keep the plaster. He'd made a maquette, he'd made
- 1:21:59Speaker 6: a model, play model of the Lee statue for Charlottesville
- 1:22:02Speaker 6: for that next commission, the unfinished commission. And he dies
- 1:22:07Speaker 6: and so now it's like, well, you know, this is
- 1:22:09Speaker 6: a problem, you know, for for the philanthropist and the
- 1:22:14Speaker 6: community or the community leaders of Charlesville who wanted this
- 1:22:17Speaker 6: Lee statue. So they find they find a ringer, you know,
- 1:22:21Speaker 6: this young guy, you know, Leolntelly. Interesting, you know, Italian
- 1:22:26Speaker 6: immigrant in the twenties, which is kind of interesting, you
- 1:22:29Speaker 6: know when you think about, you know, all the hate
- 1:22:30Speaker 6: that was being.
- 1:22:31Speaker 7: Whipped before it towns were white, right, that was.
- 1:22:33Speaker 6: Before Italians were white. But he was, yeah, kind of
- 1:22:36Speaker 6: direct from Italy and from a sculpting background. So maybe
- 1:22:38Speaker 6: they made a little exception for him, I don't know. Anyway,
- 1:22:41Speaker 6: so this young guy, you know, Leo Lintell, he takes
- 1:22:44Speaker 6: over and you know, he probably need a little more practice.
- 1:22:50Speaker 1: I don't know.
- 1:22:50Speaker 6: It just didn't turn out well.
- 1:22:52Speaker 7: It went to the Lego tail on traveler like a
- 1:22:54Speaker 7: chunky No.
- 1:22:56Speaker 2: It's just yeah, there was.
- 1:22:57Speaker 6: We had a sculptor from around here who himself works
- 1:23:01Speaker 6: in bronze and dusk monumental work, and he kind of
- 1:23:04Speaker 6: just kind of came and looked at it and he
- 1:23:05Speaker 6: was just you know, just everything's out of proportion. The
- 1:23:09Speaker 6: gauntlets on the glove are too thick, you know, the
- 1:23:14Speaker 6: sword is too long, the tail is too fat, I
- 1:23:17Speaker 6: mean in his head. Yeah, that Lee's head on top
- 1:23:22Speaker 6: of his shoulders. It just looks like, you know, kind
- 1:23:24Speaker 6: of like almost like Transformer toy or something. I mean,
- 1:23:26Speaker 6: it's just really weird, you know, proportions. It's just it
- 1:23:30Speaker 6: just really was not very well executed because apparently the maquette,
- 1:23:33Speaker 6: the model that had been made, just was completely destroyed.
- 1:23:37Speaker 6: The model, the original model by Schrady, was completely turned
- 1:23:40Speaker 6: to dust, and so Lintelly, the successor sculptor, had to
- 1:23:43Speaker 6: work from the drawings that that that remained, you know,
- 1:23:48Speaker 6: and you know, it just didn't didn't really go very well.
- 1:23:51Speaker 6: And here's the thing that even the Boosters at the time,
- 1:23:57Speaker 6: that is, you know, the folks that were planning the
- 1:23:59Speaker 6: in for the installation of the leaf statue in the
- 1:24:01Speaker 6: nineteen twenties themselves did not think it was very well executed.
- 1:24:07Speaker 6: We have diary entries from the Master of Ceremonies of
- 1:24:12Speaker 6: the installation ceremony, RTW Duke's and he says, he writes
- 1:24:16Speaker 6: in it's like day or two before the installation, he says,
- 1:24:20Speaker 6: went on a walk, you know tonight, you know, went
- 1:24:23Speaker 6: by the park, you know, saw the Lea statue.
- 1:24:25Speaker 7: I do not like it me either.
- 1:24:28Speaker 6: This is the guy who's please damn see this unveiling
- 1:24:33Speaker 6: ceremony in you know, the next day or two.
- 1:24:36Speaker 7: How embarrassing.
- 1:24:37Speaker 6: Yeah, and there's op eds even, you know. Also they're
- 1:24:40Speaker 6: saying like wow, you know, that just doesn't look good
- 1:24:44Speaker 6: at all, you know. So and these are the these
- 1:24:48Speaker 6: are the support these are the Neo Confederates, the one
- 1:24:50Speaker 6: it there. And they've they've noticed that too many cooks
- 1:24:54Speaker 6: spoiled the soup, you know. And then apparently the murmurs
- 1:24:58Speaker 6: were sufficient that one of the speakers at the installation ceremony,
- 1:25:04Speaker 6: I can harken back to that, you know, at the
- 1:25:07Speaker 6: Lee installation ceremony, you know, I guess felt compelled to
- 1:25:11Speaker 6: address the complaints that were apparently circulating. And he said,
- 1:25:16Speaker 6: you know, I'm talking about the proportionality problem that I
- 1:25:19Speaker 6: mentioned before, that just so many it's just very disjointed,
- 1:25:21Speaker 6: you know, so many parts of the of the monument
- 1:25:24Speaker 6: are out of proportion to other parts. And so this
- 1:25:26Speaker 6: speaker at the installation ceremony said, you know, there are
- 1:25:29Speaker 6: those who say that the pedestal you know, upon which
- 1:25:35Speaker 6: the Lee statue is, you know, is set, is too small,
- 1:25:41Speaker 6: But I say the world itself is too small a
- 1:25:45Speaker 6: pedestal for general Lee.
- 1:25:49Speaker 2: Just like oh yeah, good say it's it's yeah, yeah, yeah.
- 1:25:54Speaker 7: I mean the whole thing, the plinth was too small,
- 1:25:56Speaker 7: the statue was too large for that tiny park. It
- 1:25:58Speaker 7: just it was never a good spot for him.
- 1:26:01Speaker 6: It was never a good spot. So anyway, all that
- 1:26:03Speaker 6: is to say, it's a very it's a very poor
- 1:26:05Speaker 6: work of art, just just an aesthetic.
- 1:26:09Speaker 1: I mean.
- 1:26:09Speaker 6: And I'm not one that wants to remove, you know,
- 1:26:12Speaker 6: kind of any moral considerations from aesthetic. There are some
- 1:26:14Speaker 6: people philosophers who want to parse that out and this
- 1:26:16Speaker 6: sort of thing. But even if you believe you could
- 1:26:19Speaker 6: do that, which I do not, you know, it's just
- 1:26:22Speaker 6: really a not It's like having a high school art project.
- 1:26:28Speaker 6: A C I give it a c it's a high
- 1:26:30Speaker 6: school art project.
- 1:26:31Speaker 7: That it's not worth saving, right, No, Like even if
- 1:26:35Speaker 7: it had not been this sort of lightning rod in
- 1:26:37Speaker 7: our community, right that, even if this were a you know,
- 1:26:40Speaker 7: a beautiful piece of art that was worth saving, I
- 1:26:42Speaker 7: don't know, I don't know. There's there's two separate concerns, right, Like,
- 1:26:45Speaker 7: it's not beautiful enough to put into a museum regardless,
- 1:26:49Speaker 7: but then also preserving this object in any capacity just
- 1:26:55Speaker 7: allows it to sort of continue to be this lightning rod,
- 1:26:58Speaker 7: like you know, for it's sort of asking about, well,
- 1:27:00Speaker 7: what's the problem with recontextualization. Why can't you just put
- 1:27:04Speaker 7: it somewhere else? And I think that's sort of a
- 1:27:06Speaker 7: broader conversation about these statues in general. But for our statue,
- 1:27:09Speaker 7: for that Robert E. Lee statue, right that it had
- 1:27:12Speaker 7: become sort of a pilgrimage site for vigilanti violence.
- 1:27:17Speaker 6: Oh yeah, And I don't know that like just out
- 1:27:20Speaker 6: for the listeners in radio land, just for folks out
- 1:27:24Speaker 6: there listening that even after the twenty seventeen Unite the
- 1:27:29Speaker 6: Right rally, this statue stood for another four years in
- 1:27:33Speaker 6: our part while we had to wrestle through legal issues
- 1:27:37Speaker 6: legislative and judicial entanglements that prevented Charlottesville from removing that
- 1:27:44Speaker 6: statue even after the Unite the Right rally, and during
- 1:27:47Speaker 6: that time, that four year interim. It's crazy to think
- 1:27:51Speaker 6: about it, Huh. For ye that for four years after
- 1:27:54Speaker 6: Unite the Riot, it was still there.
- 1:27:56Speaker 7: Like this statue made everyone else realize they needed to
- 1:27:58Speaker 7: get rid of theirs. But because of state law and
- 1:28:01Speaker 7: these lawsuits, we were still stuck with ours.
- 1:28:04Speaker 6: Charlottesville was still stuck with it. And there were and
- 1:28:06Speaker 6: these you know, different groups, some of the same constituencies
- 1:28:12Speaker 6: that had attended Unite the Right continued to come and
- 1:28:15Speaker 6: make their pilgrimages to the Lee statue and to antagonize
- 1:28:20Speaker 6: community members by putting up their propaganda near the statues
- 1:28:25Speaker 6: and even uh you know, going to the fourth you know,
- 1:28:29Speaker 6: the the crash site on Fourth Street where a neo
- 1:28:31Speaker 6: Nazi drove his car you know, into a crowd of
- 1:28:35Speaker 6: of Charlottesville counter protesters and killed community member Heather Hire.
- 1:28:40Speaker 6: These these uh fascists you know, who would make their
- 1:28:44Speaker 6: pilgrimage to Charlottesville, would make sure and still do upon occasion,
- 1:28:48Speaker 6: uh go to Fourth Street and put up their propaganda there.
- 1:28:51Speaker 6: As well as if to kind of further antagonize the
- 1:28:55Speaker 6: community out of sight of our trauma, you know, And
- 1:28:59Speaker 6: so it was very clear that this statue would just
- 1:29:02Speaker 6: wherever it would be, it would continue to be a
- 1:29:04Speaker 6: beacon for these people. And so really it was just
- 1:29:07Speaker 6: kind of a question of responsibility. Knowing this, knowing that
- 1:29:12Speaker 6: no responsible historical or artistic institution has the capacity or
- 1:29:19Speaker 6: desire to take it in, what does one do with it?
- 1:29:21Speaker 6: And that it's not an exemplary piece of art. There
- 1:29:25Speaker 6: are fifteen other monuments that are of better quality of lee.
- 1:29:28Speaker 6: We're not going to forget him, you know, if this
- 1:29:31Speaker 6: particular specimen goes missing, and the way we see it,
- 1:29:36Speaker 6: we're doing the art world a favor because as I've said,
- 1:29:38Speaker 6: it was really you know, not a very good, well
- 1:29:41Speaker 6: executed piece of art. So, you know, with in considering
- 1:29:45Speaker 6: all of that, you know, in seeing in prior removals,
- 1:29:51Speaker 6: for instance, the Johnny reb the Courthouse Confederate soldier statue
- 1:29:55Speaker 6: was removed, and there was kind of no plan in
- 1:29:57Speaker 6: place about where it would go, and so it ended up,
- 1:30:01Speaker 6: you know, getting sent to a battlefield that is maintained
- 1:30:05Speaker 6: by a group of Confederate leading folks that seemed to
- 1:30:10Speaker 6: favor kind of lost cause interpretations of the war. So
- 1:30:13Speaker 6: we'd seen that happen already the year before in twenty twenty,
- 1:30:17Speaker 6: that when there isn't a plan, it's one thing to
- 1:30:20Speaker 6: remove it, but then where does it go? Again, this
- 1:30:22Speaker 6: is a physical object that exists in space, in physical space,
- 1:30:25Speaker 6: where is this material object going to go? If you
- 1:30:27Speaker 6: don't have a plan, then bad things can happen.
- 1:30:32Speaker 7: The least resistance the past, the least resistance is just
- 1:30:35Speaker 7: if someone says I will pay to move this, and
- 1:30:38Speaker 7: the city is paying to store it, then that's an
- 1:30:40Speaker 7: easy answer and you can't let that.
- 1:30:41Speaker 6: Many take it, right, And so that that went. So
- 1:30:45Speaker 6: when the County Aldmarle County removed the Johnny reb statue,
- 1:30:49Speaker 6: the Confederate soldier statue from in front of the courthouse,
- 1:30:53Speaker 6: and I think that was September of twenty twenty, and
- 1:30:57Speaker 6: we saw how quickly that got sent to this battle
- 1:31:00Speaker 6: field that is, you know, maintained by these you know,
- 1:31:02Speaker 6: kind of lost cause type folks. That's when Andrea Douglas
- 1:31:08Speaker 6: and I and Andrea Douglas is the director of the
- 1:31:10Speaker 6: Jefferson School African American Heritage Center here in Charlottesville. We said,
- 1:31:16Speaker 6: you know, we still do not have the legal authority
- 1:31:19Speaker 6: to remove Charlottesville's Lee statue, but we anticipated that that perhaps,
- 1:31:27Speaker 6: you know, in the in the coming year, we might
- 1:31:29Speaker 6: I said, we need to start making plans now about
- 1:31:33Speaker 6: what can have, what where the statue should go after
- 1:31:37Speaker 6: its removal, because otherwise, the same thing that happened to
- 1:31:42Speaker 6: this Johnny reb to this Confederate Soldier statue just kind
- 1:31:44Speaker 6: of getting sent down the road, you know, to whatever
- 1:31:47Speaker 6: entity organization that wants it, the same thing's going to happen.
- 1:31:50Speaker 6: And we need to have a plan in place in
- 1:31:54Speaker 6: order to kind of capture that so that so that
- 1:31:57Speaker 6: it doesn't just kind of continue to circulate to do harm.
- 1:32:01Speaker 6: So that was our motivation. So we kind of, you know,
- 1:32:03Speaker 6: in September of twenty twenty, that's when we really you know,
- 1:32:07Speaker 6: put the pedal to the metal on starting the planning
- 1:32:10Speaker 6: of this, you know, and we and mind you, we
- 1:32:13Speaker 6: did not even get permission until I think it was
- 1:32:15Speaker 6: April the first of twenty twenty one, when finally the
- 1:32:18Speaker 6: Virginia Supreme Court ruled in favor of the City of
- 1:32:21Speaker 6: Charlottesville in our efforts to remove the lea statue.
- 1:32:26Speaker 5: You know.
- 1:32:26Speaker 6: So this was you know, six seven months before we
- 1:32:29Speaker 6: even knew if we if we could do this, but
- 1:32:31Speaker 6: we said, let's start making plans. And so we started
- 1:32:34Speaker 6: having these kinds of conversations you know, with battlefields, with museums,
- 1:32:41Speaker 6: with foundries, you know, just you know, just learning, you know,
- 1:32:46Speaker 6: kind of the nuts and bolts, you know, what are
- 1:32:47Speaker 6: the possibilities here? And it turns out it's very complicated.
- 1:33:05Speaker 7: Right, So, I know there'd been sort of jokes around
- 1:33:07Speaker 7: that it was going back over some of the public
- 1:33:09Speaker 7: discourse over the years that we've been sort of joking
- 1:33:11Speaker 7: as a community for years like why don't we just
- 1:33:13Speaker 7: melt it? Why don't we just melt it?
- 1:33:15Speaker 6: Yeah?
- 1:33:15Speaker 7: But when did that become a real idea? Like when
- 1:33:20Speaker 7: did it? When did that sort of coalesce into something
- 1:33:22Speaker 7: that felt possible?
- 1:33:24Speaker 6: I think, you know, in September twenty twenty, I think
- 1:33:27Speaker 6: when the Johnny reb statue was removed and it went on,
- 1:33:30Speaker 6: you know to the Shenandoah Valley Battlefield Foundation, you know,
- 1:33:33Speaker 6: and they have this horrible plaque that they're putting up
- 1:33:36Speaker 6: that talks about how these men died for Virginia, you know,
- 1:33:40Speaker 6: and It's like they died for thirty eight percent of
- 1:33:43Speaker 6: Virginian's were enslaved at that time, So how are you
- 1:33:45Speaker 6: saying that they died for Virginia. Also, this is from
- 1:33:48Speaker 6: Alba Marle County. The majority of people here were enslaved.
- 1:33:51Speaker 6: So did how did the people supposedly represented by this
- 1:33:54Speaker 6: statue die for Virginia fight for Virginia?
- 1:33:57Speaker 3: You know what I mean?
- 1:33:57Speaker 6: So we just like that was so disturbing, you know,
- 1:34:00Speaker 6: in September of twenty twenty, when that happened, that's that's
- 1:34:03Speaker 6: really when I just really started working in Earnest, you know,
- 1:34:08Speaker 6: calling foundries.
- 1:34:09Speaker 7: So the idea was always melting.
- 1:34:11Speaker 6: I mean, it wasn't until then because see this is funny.
- 1:34:14Speaker 6: When this whole controversy started in twenty sixteen, when Ziona
- 1:34:18Speaker 6: Bryant brought up her petition, you know, to consider removing
- 1:34:22Speaker 6: these statues. The position of the activist then was just
- 1:34:26Speaker 6: move the statue. Go back and look right at the
- 1:34:29Speaker 6: signs and at the T shirts and it says hashtag
- 1:34:33Speaker 6: move the statue. We just wanted it move. Just take
- 1:34:36Speaker 6: it from the Central Park and put it out in
- 1:34:39Speaker 6: McIntyre Park where there's more space. Don't have it downtown.
- 1:34:42Speaker 7: I mean that was kind of like that was the edgy,
- 1:34:48Speaker 7: you know, and then they should have taken the opportunity
- 1:34:50Speaker 7: back then.
- 1:34:51Speaker 6: See right, exactly that was the opening bid, and you
- 1:34:55Speaker 6: should have took it.
- 1:34:56Speaker 3: You know.
- 1:34:57Speaker 7: Just these that offers not on the table anymore.
- 1:35:00Speaker 2: Yeah, exactly that that.
- 1:35:01Speaker 6: That would have been good. It would be in Martin
- 1:35:04Speaker 6: mctre part on the outskirts of town. So and so,
- 1:35:08Speaker 6: you know, when the when you know, the city appointed
- 1:35:12Speaker 6: this Blue Ribbon Commission on Race Memorials in Public Spaces
- 1:35:14Speaker 6: to have a series of public meetings to hear from
- 1:35:17Speaker 6: community members what they wanted to have happened with the statues.
- 1:35:20Speaker 6: Should they be removed, should you know, what should happen?
- 1:35:23Speaker 6: And you know, and this Blue Ribbon Commission, you know,
- 1:35:25Speaker 6: hands their final report to city council, you know, and
- 1:35:29Speaker 6: then city council takes a vote, you know, Charlottesville City
- 1:35:32Speaker 6: Council in February of twenty seventeen, and surprising many people,
- 1:35:38Speaker 6: not some of us who were in the know, but
- 1:35:41Speaker 6: one of the council members said, yes, I would like
- 1:35:44Speaker 6: to propose a resolution to remove the lead, not just
- 1:35:48Speaker 6: move it, not just recontextualize it, because that's you know,
- 1:35:52Speaker 6: if you go back and read that report, it's actually
- 1:35:54Speaker 6: fairly there's a couple of different suggests like well you
- 1:35:57Speaker 6: could move it, or you could just do this, and
- 1:36:00Speaker 6: you know, and city council woman, you know, Christian Zaka, said,
- 1:36:05Speaker 6: I would you know, make a motion to have it
- 1:36:07Speaker 6: removed completely, you know. So it's like, whoa, Okay, we're
- 1:36:11Speaker 6: you know, we're making steps, you know. So it was
- 1:36:14Speaker 6: it was about, you know, it was getting from move
- 1:36:16Speaker 6: from move the statue to remove the statue, as in
- 1:36:21Speaker 6: take it away, you know, And then it really wasn't
- 1:36:24Speaker 6: until after all the strife, you know. I mean, I
- 1:36:28Speaker 6: think there were some people all along who's you know,
- 1:36:31Speaker 6: would say tongue and she go, oh, we should just
- 1:36:32Speaker 6: melt it down, you know, or you know, she'd you know,
- 1:36:35Speaker 6: but but the thought it was just so you know,
- 1:36:37Speaker 6: talk about there's much talk of overton windows these days.
- 1:36:40Speaker 2: You know, but they're just they're just.
- 1:36:44Speaker 6: When that was being said, it was always in a
- 1:36:46Speaker 6: kind of jocular manner like oh, of course that could
- 1:36:49Speaker 6: never be but or we should melt it down. It
- 1:36:51Speaker 6: was this kind of offhand right, It wasn't serious because
- 1:36:56Speaker 6: how could that ever be, right, I mean that right,
- 1:37:00Speaker 6: Really that was behind. But what it takes is somebody
- 1:37:02Speaker 6: taking that seriously and like going through the practical steps
- 1:37:06Speaker 6: of what would that look like? And so that's what
- 1:37:08Speaker 6: I started doing in September twenty twenty. It's like, I
- 1:37:11Speaker 6: keep hearing people say that they want it melted down.
- 1:37:13Speaker 1: What would that look like?
- 1:37:15Speaker 7: What do you like physically do that?
- 1:37:17Speaker 6: How would this happen? I'm a humanities person. This was
- 1:37:20Speaker 6: breaking my brain learning about alloys and you know, compositions.
- 1:37:24Speaker 7: Here it becomes an engineering problem.
- 1:37:27Speaker 6: It really did. Yeah, and I did. I consulted with
- 1:37:30Speaker 6: you know, metallurgist engineers, you know, folks at various foundries
- 1:37:36Speaker 6: you know, to to you know, consulting and say, well,
- 1:37:39Speaker 6: you have to do this, you have to you know,
- 1:37:41Speaker 6: consider that. I mean so yeah, it was really in
- 1:37:43Speaker 6: the fall of twenty twenty when you know, kind of
- 1:37:47Speaker 6: in Earnest started having conversations, you know, with with foundrymen
- 1:37:52Speaker 6: and with engineers, with folks that work in bronze casting,
- 1:37:58Speaker 6: you know. But most of the time people didn't want
- 1:38:01Speaker 6: to talk to us. Right when they found out, oh
- 1:38:05Speaker 6: you want to do something with this with the staff,
- 1:38:07Speaker 6: Oh no, they just you know, they were they didn't
- 1:38:10Speaker 6: want to be involved in any controversy, or we would
- 1:38:12Speaker 6: get someone who was on board with it, Yes, we're
- 1:38:15Speaker 6: going to do it. And then for instance, you know,
- 1:38:18Speaker 6: the company got sold and the new owners were like
- 1:38:21Speaker 6: want nothing to do with it, you know, or they
- 1:38:25Speaker 6: won't call us back anymore, or no, or you know,
- 1:38:28Speaker 6: I mean just things just kept coming up. So it
- 1:38:30Speaker 6: was hard to find anyone who would just engage in
- 1:38:34Speaker 6: a serious way about the questions. And then even when
- 1:38:37Speaker 6: you could, it was kind of like, you know, you'd
- 1:38:41Speaker 6: get somebody for a little bit, and then it was like,
- 1:38:43Speaker 6: you know, like the fisher, It's like the fish would
- 1:38:46Speaker 6: swim away, you know, kind of I don't know it
- 1:38:47Speaker 6: just you know, So it was it was a lot
- 1:38:49Speaker 6: of different conversations with a lot of different people, you know,
- 1:38:53Speaker 6: along the way to figure out like what are the
- 1:38:55Speaker 6: you know, literal and figurative nuts and bolts of doing this.
- 1:38:58Speaker 6: You know, I learned a lot, you know about standard
- 1:39:02Speaker 6: width of trailers eight and a half feet did you
- 1:39:05Speaker 6: know that?
- 1:39:06Speaker 2: Yeah?
- 1:39:07Speaker 6: Eight half feet yep, right right, you know, and you
- 1:39:12Speaker 6: know fifty three feet long, and you know, and you know,
- 1:39:15Speaker 6: kind of what kind of what's the hauling capacity, what's
- 1:39:17Speaker 6: the payload? You know, how do you balance the load?
- 1:39:20Speaker 6: You know, what is duneage? I mean you're just like
- 1:39:23Speaker 6: all these things, you know that that just the very
- 1:39:27Speaker 6: practical steps that one has to take to melt a statue.
- 1:39:32Speaker 7: And so it seems like, you know, the conclusion that
- 1:39:34Speaker 7: you reached was this object can't keep existing because the
- 1:39:39Speaker 7: fact that it does exist will always be a problem.
- 1:39:42Speaker 7: So that this is the decision was made that it
- 1:39:44Speaker 7: needed to be destroyed. But what was sort of the
- 1:39:47Speaker 7: process of thinking through what do we do with it now?
- 1:39:51Speaker 2: Right?
- 1:39:51Speaker 7: Like, what is this sort of the vision behind not
- 1:39:54Speaker 7: just yeah, you know, taking the statue down and putting
- 1:39:57Speaker 7: up a different piece of public art, but a different
- 1:39:59Speaker 7: piece of p look art that is physically repurposed. Right
- 1:40:02Speaker 7: that you've you've remediated this material, right right?
- 1:40:06Speaker 6: Yeah, well we we prefer the word transformed, you know,
- 1:40:11Speaker 6: to to destroyed or or I mean it is it is,
- 1:40:14Speaker 6: you know, definitely, it is you know kind of morphing
- 1:40:17Speaker 6: the material is taking the materials, you know, these raw
- 1:40:20Speaker 6: materials and you know, transforming them into kind of usable
- 1:40:28Speaker 6: you know, kind of ingots, brick sized, you know, pieces
- 1:40:31Speaker 6: of bronze. So that they can be made into something new.
- 1:40:35Speaker 6: It's not that we hate art. We want art, right.
- 1:40:39Speaker 7: You know doctor Douglas's her background is in art, right.
- 1:40:42Speaker 6: Yes, doctor Douglas is an art historian, exact. I mean,
- 1:40:45Speaker 6: we are the two most unlikely people to be in
- 1:40:48Speaker 6: charge of such a project. I mean, I'm a religious
- 1:40:50Speaker 6: study scholar. It's like I've spent years of my life,
- 1:40:53Speaker 6: you know, studying you know, how people, you know, make
- 1:40:59Speaker 6: make sacred values, and specifically how they gather around material
- 1:41:03Speaker 6: objects that they regard.
- 1:41:05Speaker 7: I don't think that's unlikely at all, right, that this
- 1:41:07Speaker 7: was an object of veneration for a very harmful cause.
- 1:41:12Speaker 6: I mean I seventeen years, you know, researching a book
- 1:41:16Speaker 6: about a very beloved four hundred year old effigy of
- 1:41:22Speaker 6: the Virgin Mary in Cuba. You can see my book
- 1:41:25Speaker 6: up here. Well, there's a Cuban fly. This right here
- 1:41:28Speaker 6: is my book.
- 1:41:29Speaker 1: I'm going over too far.
- 1:41:30Speaker 7: Yeah, I see the Virgin Mary back there.
- 1:41:32Speaker 6: Yeah. Anyway, so I yeah, so that's that's my book
- 1:41:35Speaker 6: up here. Yeah, right here, this is my book, Kachita's Streets.
- 1:41:40Speaker 6: I mean, if somebody, oh, and you know, and this
- 1:41:43Speaker 6: has happened before. There have been folks, you know iconoclass.
- 1:41:46Speaker 6: If somebody went and destroyed her image there in that
- 1:41:51Speaker 6: shrine in Cuba, I would be obsensed. I would just
- 1:41:57Speaker 6: I would be beside myself. I mean it'd be like
- 1:41:59Speaker 6: somebody killed you know, a family member. I mean, be
- 1:42:04Speaker 6: on the next plane to get you know, you have
- 1:42:06Speaker 6: to console people. I mean a four hundred year old
- 1:42:08Speaker 6: you know, it would just be terrible. You know, it
- 1:42:11Speaker 6: doesn't have all the hate wrapped into it that these
- 1:42:14Speaker 6: you know, statues do in this sort of thing. So
- 1:42:16Speaker 6: what I'm saying is I understand that people have very
- 1:42:18Speaker 6: tender feelings toward these material objects that they have had
- 1:42:22Speaker 6: experiences around them that have bound them together. Religiare you
- 1:42:26Speaker 6: know the binding that's the original you know root Latin
- 1:42:30Speaker 6: root of religion. You know, it is to bind, you know.
- 1:42:33Speaker 6: I get that. And so yeah, I'm not a reflexive iconoclast.
- 1:42:38Speaker 6: You know, I'm a Catholic. I'm a you know, I'm
- 1:42:42Speaker 6: also a you know, participate in these African inspired religious
- 1:42:47Speaker 6: practices and stuff that you know that put a lot
- 1:42:49Speaker 6: of you know, emphasis upon you know, sacred material objects.
- 1:42:53Speaker 6: So I am kind of I mean, it is kind
- 1:42:55Speaker 6: of weird that me I would be involved in this,
- 1:42:57Speaker 6: and that, you know, and doctor Douglas, you know, but
- 1:43:02Speaker 6: it's precisely because we know the power of these things,
- 1:43:06Speaker 6: and the we're eyewitnesses to what happened here. You know
- 1:43:10Speaker 6: that we know the power of it, and so how
- 1:43:12Speaker 6: to be responsible for it, and so to take something
- 1:43:15Speaker 6: like that that was so harmful and to be able
- 1:43:18Speaker 6: to use its materials to transform them and to make
- 1:43:22Speaker 6: something that's meaningful and beautiful and that expresses our community's
- 1:43:27Speaker 6: values and that includes people rather than kind of sets
- 1:43:31Speaker 6: people apart, you know, or kind of you know, symbolizing
- 1:43:34Speaker 6: moments in our history where you know, over half the
- 1:43:39Speaker 6: local population was completely debased, you know. To be able
- 1:43:43Speaker 6: to take the material that that was part of that
- 1:43:47Speaker 6: and transform it into something else, it's just it's just
- 1:43:51Speaker 6: seemed like it just has so much potential, you know.
- 1:43:54Speaker 6: And and and then the name of the project is
- 1:43:56Speaker 6: Swords into Plowshares, which comes from a verse from the
- 1:44:00Speaker 6: off at Isaiah that they shall turn their swords into plowshares,
- 1:44:05Speaker 6: they shall turn their their spears into pruning hooks. So
- 1:44:09Speaker 6: we'll take these implements of destruction and of violence, and
- 1:44:14Speaker 6: we will transform them into instruments of of to cultivate
- 1:44:22Speaker 6: you know, sustenance you know, uh, you know, you know,
- 1:44:27Speaker 6: nutrients you know, for a community. I mean it just
- 1:44:30Speaker 6: you know, to just to just really transform it, you know,
- 1:44:32Speaker 6: from from something so ugly you know, into something beautiful,
- 1:44:36Speaker 6: you know. And we just thought, you know, let's let's
- 1:44:38Speaker 6: take the chance. Let's try and do this. Let's do
- 1:44:41Speaker 6: something that's never been done before, because none of these
- 1:44:44Speaker 6: statues have ever been like I don't think ever completely
- 1:44:47Speaker 6: the Confederate ones anyway, have ever been completely destroyed, you know,
- 1:44:51Speaker 6: like this. Most of them are just in storage somewhere.
- 1:44:54Speaker 6: And we said, let's let's take this chance to transform.
- 1:44:57Speaker 6: Let's be responsible first of all, and not send our
- 1:44:59Speaker 6: talks waist down the road to another community, and let's
- 1:45:02Speaker 6: try to do something transformative, you know, for our community.
- 1:45:06Speaker 6: And maybe this can also move the needle, you know,
- 1:45:09Speaker 6: in a national and international conversation about art and the
- 1:45:14Speaker 6: reparative values you know, potential reparative values of art you know,
- 1:45:20Speaker 6: and community building, you know, and so in our you know,
- 1:45:24Speaker 6: we're the swords into Plowsher's project. We're hoping to put
- 1:45:28Speaker 6: out a request for proposals, you know, to artists this
- 1:45:32Speaker 6: year in twenty twenty four, which is the one hundredth
- 1:45:37Speaker 6: anniversary of when the Least statue was installed. You know, ideally,
- 1:45:41Speaker 6: you know, fingers crossed, if you know, it would be
- 1:45:43Speaker 6: wonderful if we could have a completed statue in twenty
- 1:45:46Speaker 6: twenty seven, which would be the ten year anniversary of
- 1:45:49Speaker 6: the Unite the Right rally, you know, to to you know,
- 1:45:52Speaker 6: to have something else to give back to our community.
- 1:45:55Speaker 6: You know, that's a blasting value that, you know, and
- 1:45:59Speaker 6: for us, it's important that we write our narrative. There
- 1:46:01Speaker 6: were people who attacked us, you know, who tried to
- 1:46:06Speaker 6: kind of imprint on us, you know, some sort of
- 1:46:10Speaker 6: narrative about what we were about. And it also kind
- 1:46:12Speaker 6: of you know, reverberated in a you know, national and
- 1:46:15Speaker 6: international way. And we're really taking control of the narrative here.
- 1:46:20Speaker 6: We're saying, you know, we we are going to say
- 1:46:23Speaker 6: who we are and we're going to express that. You know,
- 1:46:27Speaker 6: and we do value art, you know, we want it
- 1:46:31Speaker 6: to be an art that reflects our values.
- 1:46:34Speaker 2: Right.
- 1:46:34Speaker 7: I think this is a recognition that art does have power.
- 1:46:37Speaker 7: It had the power to harm, It had the power
- 1:46:39Speaker 7: to to bring great harm to this community. But it
- 1:46:42Speaker 7: was you know, that art was harming people just by
- 1:46:45Speaker 7: existing in that space, even before you unite the right.
- 1:46:47Speaker 7: And now those same materials have hopefully the power to
- 1:46:51Speaker 7: bring some repair. Yeah, So it wasn't it wasn't just
- 1:46:55Speaker 7: the practical you know, I think you were saying. It
- 1:46:56Speaker 7: started out a sort of a practical question is what
- 1:46:59Speaker 7: do you do with this large object? And so the
- 1:47:01Speaker 7: practical answer is you reduce its size, you melt it down,
- 1:47:05Speaker 7: You remove it, and you melt it down. But it's
- 1:47:08Speaker 7: not just practical, right, there is there is incredible symbolic
- 1:47:11Speaker 7: value in using that material, that metal, right. I think
- 1:47:15Speaker 7: in some of the articles you all talked about as
- 1:47:18Speaker 7: it was melting there were impurities in the metal. So
- 1:47:20Speaker 7: as this statue is being melted down, the impurities are
- 1:47:24Speaker 7: being extracted from it. It's being purified, and now it
- 1:47:26Speaker 7: can be repurposed. That's really beautiful, Yeah it is.
- 1:47:30Speaker 6: Yeah, the slag getting pulled off the top and just yeah,
- 1:47:33Speaker 6: just it was incredible, you know, to see for sure.
- 1:47:38Speaker 7: And so at this stage you guys are soliciting community input.
- 1:47:41Speaker 7: I think there's a sort of a community survey out
- 1:47:43Speaker 7: about sort of what parks people frequent, how they're using
- 1:47:46Speaker 7: the parks, how they're engaging with the parks, and you
- 1:47:48Speaker 7: said this year there'll be a request for proposals for
- 1:47:50Speaker 7: artists to sort of put forth their vision for this bronze, right.
- 1:47:55Speaker 6: And this is it's nice because this is all coinciding
- 1:47:58Speaker 6: with the city if Charlotteville has for some time wanted
- 1:48:02Speaker 6: to do a renovation of of its downtown park. So
- 1:48:06Speaker 6: this and this has been a long time coming that
- 1:48:08Speaker 6: there are you know, sedated, you know, all of this
- 1:48:10Speaker 6: drama with the with the statues, but it's just really
- 1:48:14Speaker 6: a nice opportunity to just kind of for the community
- 1:48:17Speaker 6: to just kind of take stock. It's like, Okay, we're
- 1:48:20Speaker 6: you know, we're whatever, you know, going on seven years
- 1:48:22Speaker 6: out from Unite the Right. You know, we're eight years
- 1:48:25Speaker 6: out from you know, Zionist initial petition. You know, you
- 1:48:29Speaker 6: know this this statue has been you know taken away,
- 1:48:32Speaker 6: it has been melted, and it just feels like a
- 1:48:34Speaker 6: literal and figurative clearing of the land. You know, it
- 1:48:38Speaker 6: just feels like, you know, people have asked, you know
- 1:48:40Speaker 6: sometimes it's like oh, there's you know, all that empty
- 1:48:43Speaker 6: space at the parks, and I was like, yeah, isn't
- 1:48:44Speaker 6: it nice. It's just kind of like I mean to
- 1:48:48Speaker 6: just kind of I think it's nice to just have
- 1:48:50Speaker 6: just push the pause button for you know, in terms
- 1:48:52Speaker 6: of things that are there for several years, and just
- 1:48:55Speaker 6: kind of allow our our minds to open, you know,
- 1:48:59Speaker 6: just like the the space itself and to just imagine
- 1:49:03Speaker 6: what that space can look like. I think it's really
- 1:49:05Speaker 6: instructive and I wish more communities could have the opportunity
- 1:49:08Speaker 6: to do this. Actually, yes, but you know, for instance,
- 1:49:11Speaker 6: taking that survey you know that that community members in
- 1:49:15Speaker 6: Charlottesville are doing now about you know, yeah, how do
- 1:49:18Speaker 6: you know? Where where do you what parks you go to,
- 1:49:22Speaker 6: what activities do you engage in there? What do you
- 1:49:24Speaker 6: like you know, what would you like to see more of?
- 1:49:26Speaker 1: You know, this sort of thing.
- 1:49:27Speaker 6: It's it's great to you know, to consider this. You
- 1:49:30Speaker 6: know that this is something that has been you know,
- 1:49:34Speaker 6: America's uh uh you know, the United States is uh,
- 1:49:38Speaker 6: you know, public parks has you know, been something that
- 1:49:41Speaker 6: you know, since the nineteenth century. Is something that's that's
- 1:49:44Speaker 6: been a real gem, you know in some of our
- 1:49:47Speaker 6: our public spaces, you know, in some of our cities,
- 1:49:49Speaker 6: and you know, and this is something to you know,
- 1:49:51Speaker 6: to celebrate, and it's it's nice to be able to
- 1:49:54Speaker 6: kind of take stock to really, you know, think about
- 1:49:57Speaker 6: how public spaces can express our professed values, you know.
- 1:50:03Speaker 7: Instead of sort of reacting to hate, like taking a
- 1:50:06Speaker 7: moment to envision not our reaction to or you know,
- 1:50:10Speaker 7: what we don't want, but think about what we do
- 1:50:12Speaker 7: want in that space exactly what would what would serve
- 1:50:15Speaker 7: our community? And I think that's sort of where the
- 1:50:17Speaker 7: project is now, right, just sort of envisioning a positive
- 1:50:20Speaker 7: future rather than trying to remediate a negative past.
- 1:50:24Speaker 6: And it's so nice because I felt like we were fighting, fighting,
- 1:50:27Speaker 6: fighting for so many years. You know, we're in court,
- 1:50:29Speaker 6: or we're protesting, or we're going to lobby at the
- 1:50:33Speaker 6: General Assembly or now we're going to city council. I
- 1:50:35Speaker 6: mean there was just you know all, you know, so fraught,
- 1:50:38Speaker 6: and so now it's just so free to like, oh,
- 1:50:41Speaker 6: to be able to imagine, you know, and to be
- 1:50:43Speaker 6: thinking forward, yeah, and constructively creatively. That's a great feeling.
- 1:50:49Speaker 7: So how can people sort of keep up with sorts
- 1:50:51Speaker 7: into plow Shares, stay up to date on the project
- 1:50:54Speaker 7: and its progress, and more importantly, how can they support
- 1:50:56Speaker 7: sorts into plow Shares.
- 1:50:58Speaker 6: Yeah, so you can visit Sipseville dot com. That's s
- 1:51:03Speaker 6: I P C v I L l E dot com.
- 1:51:08Speaker 6: So sip Cville that's Swords into Plowshires Ceville. And we
- 1:51:11Speaker 6: have occasional updates there with news stories about what we're
- 1:51:15Speaker 6: doing and upcoming meetings which will be happening at the
- 1:51:20Speaker 6: Jefferson School, uh, where we'll be you know, kind of
- 1:51:23Speaker 6: presenting results of of you know, surveys that we've done,
- 1:51:29Speaker 6: you know, and uh and also visiting speakers who will
- 1:51:34Speaker 6: be coming to talk about, you know, what what does
- 1:51:37Speaker 6: art mean in public spaces? You know, So we'll be
- 1:51:40Speaker 6: able to kind of you know, talk with uh, you know,
- 1:51:43Speaker 6: some experts that have come in, you know, to advise
- 1:51:45Speaker 6: us on you know, how to think about about what
- 1:51:48Speaker 6: we want in our in our in our parks going forward.
- 1:51:54Speaker 7: And can people make donations to s I P on
- 1:51:57Speaker 7: the website, Yes, on the website, there is a portal
- 1:51:59Speaker 7: right there on Sipseyville dot com.
- 1:52:02Speaker 6: Definitely welcome that as well.
- 1:52:05Speaker 7: And those donations go towards for the the ultimate creation
- 1:52:07Speaker 7: of this piece of art. Correct, right, It is not
- 1:52:12Speaker 7: cheap to work with that much.
- 1:52:13Speaker 2: More it is not.
- 1:52:14Speaker 6: Yeah, so we're we're you know, putting together you know,
- 1:52:17Speaker 6: fun to pay the artists, you know, for the commissioning
- 1:52:20Speaker 6: the artists.
- 1:52:20Speaker 1: You know.
- 1:52:20Speaker 6: We're also applying for you know, grants from foundations and
- 1:52:24Speaker 6: this sort of thing too. But of course there are
- 1:52:26Speaker 6: other expenses associated with uh, you know, processing materials and
- 1:52:30Speaker 6: yeah and all that.
- 1:52:32Speaker 7: So yeah, so that is s I P C V
- 1:52:36Speaker 7: I L L E dot com slash donate to make
- 1:52:39Speaker 7: sure that that artist gets paid. Absolutely well, Juliane, thank
- 1:52:45Speaker 7: you so much for joining us today and looking forward
- 1:52:48Speaker 7: to seeing our our new beautiful piece of art, hopefully
- 1:52:51Speaker 7: by twenty twenty seven.
- 1:52:52Speaker 6: Yeah, yeah, it's great. Well, thank you for your interest, Mollie,
- 1:52:56Speaker 6: and thank you to all the listeners and supporters out there.
- 1:53:00Speaker 6: Means a lot to us that you know, your interest
- 1:53:02Speaker 6: in us and your support appreciate it.
- 1:53:05Speaker 7: I think we all love those photos of Lee's melting face.
- 1:53:10Speaker 6: It is icon I gotta say, it's iconic, you know.
- 1:53:14Speaker 6: I yeah, we'll always have that, have that memory.
- 1:53:20Speaker 7: Thank you so much.
- 1:53:21Speaker 2: All right, A welcome back to It could Happen Here
- 1:53:38Speaker 2: a podcast where the host Robert Evans, one of the
- 1:53:42Speaker 2: hosts has recently recovered from a terrible, terrible sickness by
- 1:53:47Speaker 2: by engaging in some fascinating experiments with thera flu, largely
- 1:53:52Speaker 2: using a friend's diabetic needles, just shooting it straight into
- 1:53:55Speaker 2: the veins My co host today, Garrison Davis, have you
- 1:53:59Speaker 2: ever ever shot flew medication into your veins?
- 1:54:02Speaker 5: Garrison, No, I've only shot one thing into my veins.
- 1:54:06Speaker 2: Well, speaking of shooting, today's episode of It Could Happen
- 1:54:10Speaker 2: Here is about a shooting. And before you are like,
- 1:54:13Speaker 2: oh man, I don't really have it in me to
- 1:54:15Speaker 2: listen to a horrible story about people dying today, don't worry.
- 1:54:17Speaker 2: Nobody gets shot in this story.
- 1:54:20Speaker 5: Thank God, miraculously no one gets shot, Like against.
- 1:54:24Speaker 2: All odds, it's stunning that nobody got shot. This is
- 1:54:28Speaker 2: the tale of a police officer fucking up, not worse
- 1:54:33Speaker 2: than any cop has ever fucked up, because again he
- 1:54:35Speaker 2: didn't kill anybody, but fucking up in a way that's
- 1:54:37Speaker 2: like more baffling and incompetent than I think I've ever
- 1:54:40Speaker 2: seen before. It's probably the most embarrassing and certainly the
- 1:54:44Speaker 2: most embarrassing, and not even really malevolent, just like outrageously incompetent,
- 1:54:49Speaker 2: but I'm gonna let you take over from here, Garrison.
- 1:54:53Speaker 5: So, yeah, we are going to be talking about in
- 1:54:54Speaker 5: acorn involved shooting today, happened, that happened in Florida.
- 1:55:01Speaker 2: Finally we know what the A and A cab stands for.
- 1:55:05Speaker 2: That's right.
- 1:55:08Speaker 5: So we're gonna we're gonna play some clips here, but
- 1:55:11Speaker 5: I think it's important to set the scene so you
- 1:55:12Speaker 5: kind of understand what you're hearing. So this cop walks
- 1:55:17Speaker 5: up to his patrol car, there is a suspect locked
- 1:55:19Speaker 5: in the back.
- 1:55:20Speaker 2: Sunny day, Houston suburbs, big houses, wide streets.
- 1:55:24Speaker 5: Yeah, now something happens as the cop is about to
- 1:55:27Speaker 5: open up the door. He then dives onto the ground,
- 1:55:31Speaker 5: does two like action roles, double barrel rolls, and then
- 1:55:35Speaker 5: starts shooting at the car and starts yelling to another
- 1:55:39Speaker 5: officer who's in the area. And I think we'll just
- 1:55:41Speaker 5: we'll just play the rest here.
- 1:55:43Speaker 2: Yeah.
- 1:55:44Speaker 5: The first clips about thirty seconds long, and then I
- 1:55:46Speaker 5: just have a few shorter clips kind of that have
- 1:55:48Speaker 5: kind of stitched together that just just to get a
- 1:55:51Speaker 5: sense of like what he's saying and what he's communicating
- 1:55:54Speaker 5: after he opens fire on this patrol vehicle.
- 1:55:57Speaker 2: So here is here? Is that audio far Jeff Jukes,
- 1:56:04Speaker 2: Burt Chuck's burd.
- 1:56:08Speaker 5: You know.
- 1:56:15Speaker 8: Oh, I'm that, I'm here.
- 1:56:21Speaker 2: What I've done? He has the car?
- 1:56:25Speaker 5: Now you shot the car.
- 1:56:28Speaker 9: Oh, I'm I'm good. I'm feel weird, but I'm good.
- 1:56:34Speaker 9: I might have hit my best. Okay, it might hit
- 1:56:45Speaker 9: my best.
- 1:56:45Speaker 1: I don't know.
- 1:56:50Speaker 5: I'm not.
- 1:56:52Speaker 1: Okay, I don't know.
- 1:56:53Speaker 5: I I like it.
- 1:56:57Speaker 8: Jess me, I got you remote to me, Jesse, come back, mark.
- 1:57:08Speaker 3: You right back, dude, my head.
- 1:57:16Speaker 1: Let's get further back, further back to the back.
- 1:57:18Speaker 2: All right.
- 1:57:19Speaker 5: So that was a lot of gunfire. Again, it is
- 1:57:22Speaker 5: shocking that no one died because it's not immediately evident
- 1:57:27Speaker 5: if you just watched the video. But there is somebody
- 1:57:29Speaker 5: who's trapped in the back of that car, and there's
- 1:57:31Speaker 5: multiple officers shooting at the car.
- 1:57:34Speaker 2: And here's the thing, the guy. The distance the guy
- 1:57:36Speaker 2: is shooting from. God from when I watched the video
- 1:57:39Speaker 2: last I would estimate maybe about twenty yards, probably even
- 1:57:42Speaker 2: shorter than that, maybe sure, maybe more like fifteen. It's
- 1:57:45Speaker 2: medium to maybe medium long range for a handgun. For
- 1:57:48Speaker 2: a full size handgun like that, I'd say it's about
- 1:57:50Speaker 2: medium range. So a competent shooter should be able to
- 1:57:54Speaker 2: hit a target about the size of a human torso
- 1:57:57Speaker 2: at that distance with most of the but he is
- 1:58:01Speaker 2: not that. When I say competent, that is somebody who
- 1:58:03Speaker 2: is bracing themselves and who has two hands on the gun.
- 1:58:07Speaker 2: He is shooting like a character in an action movie.
- 1:58:09Speaker 2: And I cannot imagine. So a lot of those rounds
- 1:58:12Speaker 2: did not even hit the truck. I imagine they went
- 1:58:14Speaker 2: flying into a neighborhood where we can hear children playing yes, Yes.
- 1:58:18Speaker 3: So the.
- 1:58:21Speaker 5: Officer who encountered this acorn, which we will get to
- 1:58:24Speaker 5: in a sec was named Deputy Jesse Hernandez. He been
- 1:58:27Speaker 5: a cop for almost two years, and we'll learn more
- 1:58:32Speaker 5: about his background as we as we continue on with
- 1:58:36Speaker 5: this little story. The second officer, well not officer, but
- 1:58:40Speaker 5: a sergeant of this Sheriff's department named Beth Roberts, and
- 1:58:44Speaker 5: she's been a cop since two thousand and eight, so
- 1:58:46Speaker 5: she has a little bit more experience under her belt.
- 1:58:48Speaker 5: So let's kind of explain what happened here. So there
- 1:58:52Speaker 5: was a series of calls that happened earlier in the
- 1:58:54Speaker 5: day about a vehicle who was kind of driving erratically
- 1:58:57Speaker 5: around a nearby neighborhood honking its horn kind of just
- 1:59:00Speaker 5: like making a lot of sounds at like three am.
- 1:59:03Speaker 5: The suspect was described as a black mail in his
- 1:59:04Speaker 5: late twenties. And then a few hours later, a separate
- 1:59:07Speaker 5: call was made by someone talking about how her boyfriend
- 1:59:11Speaker 5: has been refusing to return her vehicle and has been
- 1:59:14Speaker 5: sending her threatening text messages. So this caused police to
- 1:59:18Speaker 5: go to this girlfriend's house. She showed some of these
- 1:59:22Speaker 5: threatening text messages and they were talking with this woman
- 1:59:26Speaker 5: when her boyfriend approached the scene. So the suspect approached
- 1:59:31Speaker 5: the police in front of his girlfriend's house. Deputy Hernandez
- 1:59:33Speaker 5: himself did a pat down to search for weapons and
- 1:59:37Speaker 5: observed a more thorough search once the suspect was handcuffed.
- 1:59:40Speaker 5: The missing car was located a few miles away, and
- 1:59:42Speaker 5: Hernandez was on his way back to the car to
- 1:59:44Speaker 5: do a tertiary search of the suspect, who is currently
- 1:59:47Speaker 5: locked in the backseat with handcuffs. And then as Deputy
- 1:59:50Speaker 5: Hernandez passed the passenger side door in acorn fell onto
- 1:59:55Speaker 5: the roof of his car, which is barely barely audible
- 1:59:59Speaker 5: in it. The bodycam video that we have access to.
- 2:00:02Speaker 2: So you would not notice it were you not listening
- 2:00:05Speaker 2: for it.
- 2:00:06Speaker 7: No, no, So.
- 2:00:07Speaker 5: Three days later, Deputy Hernandez was interviewed by two investigators
- 2:00:11Speaker 5: as a part of the Office of Professional Standards investigation
- 2:00:14Speaker 5: into this incident of discharge gunfire and this this interview
- 2:00:20Speaker 5: in this report is probably one of the most telling
- 2:00:22Speaker 5: things about how police psychology operates.
- 2:00:26Speaker 2: And wow, okay, so.
- 2:00:30Speaker 5: I'm gonna read through a few quotes here from Deputy Hernandez.
- 2:00:35Speaker 5: He talks about how, quote, I'm about to reach for
- 2:00:37Speaker 5: the door handle and simultaneously I hear to at the
- 2:00:40Speaker 5: time what I believe would be a suppressed weapon off
- 2:00:43Speaker 5: to the side. I definitely heard this noise about the
- 2:00:46Speaker 5: same time I felt an impact on my right side,
- 2:00:49Speaker 5: like an upper torso area. I feel the impact. My
- 2:00:52Speaker 5: legs just give out. I don't know where I'm hit.
- 2:00:54Speaker 2: I think I'm hit. I'm struck. I roll back. I
- 2:01:00Speaker 2: rolled to the briving like he's the hard boiled detective
- 2:01:03Speaker 2: and a novel.
- 2:01:04Speaker 5: I rolled to the back of the car. Now I'm
- 2:01:06Speaker 5: stuck in the street, and I knew where the fire,
- 2:01:08Speaker 5: where the shots came from, I or I believed where
- 2:01:11Speaker 5: they came from. It was right there as I'm reaching
- 2:01:14Speaker 5: for that door handle. So I'm laying behind the car.
- 2:01:16Speaker 5: I'm yelling shots fire, shots fired, shots fired. I returned
- 2:01:19Speaker 5: fire once I could get cover behind another vehicle that
- 2:01:21Speaker 5: was parked in the driveway there. So when asked to
- 2:01:24Speaker 5: describe what he felt, because he's not just claiming that
- 2:01:28Speaker 5: he heard a sound, he's claiming he felt like he
- 2:01:31Speaker 5: got hit.
- 2:01:32Speaker 2: Yeah, he felt an impact. He felt an impact and
- 2:01:34Speaker 2: his legs went out from underneath him. Yes, which again
- 2:01:37Speaker 2: in the video, he clearly does a double barrel roll.
- 2:01:40Speaker 2: He doesn't. That is not I have seen people get
- 2:01:43Speaker 2: hit and drop. They did not do double barrel rolls
- 2:01:49Speaker 2: like a little action stow.
- 2:01:50Speaker 5: Yeah, yea, yeah, yeah, he says, quote, it felt like
- 2:01:53Speaker 5: an impact to my upper torso around here, and he
- 2:01:56Speaker 5: motions up to his right shoulder on the right side.
- 2:01:59Speaker 5: It was like a sound impact, like almost that quick.
- 2:02:02Speaker 5: I guess I just loved hit the phrase it was
- 2:02:05Speaker 5: like a sound impact.
- 2:02:07Speaker 2: Yeah, I think he's saying. I think what he's saying
- 2:02:10Speaker 2: from reading it is that like we're missing some of
- 2:02:13Speaker 2: the body language that he was going to It was
- 2:02:14Speaker 2: like sound and then like moving his hands to get
- 2:02:17Speaker 2: sound impact, hearing the sound, and then he got impact.
- 2:02:20Speaker 2: I think he was actually trying to which is not
- 2:02:22Speaker 2: like them, which is actually not in person. Probably very awkward,
- 2:02:25Speaker 2: but yeah, it does. It comes across weird and so
- 2:02:29Speaker 2: more more funny than sound impact. For again, any corn
- 2:02:32Speaker 2: that's falling on a roof, we have quote, my legs
- 2:02:36Speaker 2: weren't working the way I wanted them to be working.
- 2:02:39Speaker 2: I think I yelled at one point to Sergeant Roberts.
- 2:02:41Speaker 2: I think I might have been hitting.
- 2:02:42Speaker 5: The leg or something along those lines, because I was
- 2:02:45Speaker 5: struggling to get cover. I think at one point I
- 2:02:47Speaker 5: reached up to touch my head. I think I still
- 2:02:51Speaker 5: had the sound in my head. I wasn't sure if
- 2:02:54Speaker 5: I had been hidden the head. I was getting a
- 2:02:57Speaker 5: funny tingling around all sides of my body, and I
- 2:03:01Speaker 5: think some of that money just been adrenaline. Putting together
- 2:03:04Speaker 5: the fact that what I just heard and the impact
- 2:03:06Speaker 5: that I felt. I've never been shot before, so I
- 2:03:09Speaker 5: don't know what that's like or you know, unquote great
- 2:03:17Speaker 5: oh man, So he is. He's unsure if you would
- 2:03:21Speaker 5: be able to notice if he got shot in the
- 2:03:22Speaker 5: head or not, which is kind of interesting. I mean,
- 2:03:26Speaker 5: I'm sure he could get grazed, but like, come on, buddy, yeah.
- 2:03:29Speaker 2: Yeah, I mean it's one thing. It is true that
- 2:03:31Speaker 2: like you can be hit like an armor and not
- 2:03:35Speaker 2: be sure if you've gotten a hit because it didn't penetrate.
- 2:03:38Speaker 2: But you would also not mistake a corn shrapnel hitting
- 2:03:42Speaker 2: you reasonably for a bullet Like That's simply not a
- 2:03:46Speaker 2: mistake a reasonable person is going to make.
- 2:03:49Speaker 5: So the investigator asked him, like if there was any
- 2:03:54Speaker 5: other sense that there could have been gunfire, like if
- 2:03:57Speaker 5: you saw any like shattered glass coming from the car,
- 2:04:00Speaker 5: and Hernandez said no. When asked why he decided to
- 2:04:03Speaker 5: stop firing, Hernandez said that he stopped firing once he
- 2:04:05Speaker 5: emptied his clip, moved to cover behind it nearby Tesla
- 2:04:09Speaker 5: end quote, didn't observe any rounds coming back at me.
- 2:04:13Speaker 2: Just just great, because why there's the.
- 2:04:18Speaker 5: Hernandez claim that he was never able to see the
- 2:04:20Speaker 5: suspect while in the patrol car.
- 2:04:22Speaker 2: And Hernandez remained behind.
- 2:04:24Speaker 5: Cover till other deputies arrived and was rushed to a hospital,
- 2:04:27Speaker 5: where only then he was informed that he did not,
- 2:04:30Speaker 5: in fact to get shot.
- 2:04:31Speaker 2: It's amazing he made it all the way to a hospital.
- 2:04:34Speaker 2: So you had a lot of chances. You had a
- 2:04:38Speaker 2: lot of chances to not fuck that up.
- 2:04:39Speaker 3: Man.
- 2:04:40Speaker 5: As soon as the other cops arrive on the seat,
- 2:04:42Speaker 5: he's like, I don't know, I just I just feel
- 2:04:44Speaker 5: so weird.
- 2:04:47Speaker 2: Yeah, buddy, you you had an adrenaline drop because you panicked,
- 2:04:51Speaker 2: Like that is why you feel weird.
- 2:04:53Speaker 5: Like a lot always this like mirrors the police fentanel things,
- 2:04:58Speaker 5: how they can like talk the themselves into feeling into
- 2:05:02Speaker 5: like feeling symptoms.
- 2:05:03Speaker 2: Yes, but all right, So.
- 2:05:08Speaker 5: Hernandoz hadn't been a cop for very long. He had
- 2:05:10Speaker 5: He had no prior law enforcement experience before joining this
- 2:05:13Speaker 5: Florida Sheriff's department, but he did attend to West Point
- 2:05:17Speaker 5: and served as a Special Forces Infantry officers in the
- 2:05:20Speaker 5: Army for ten years. So one could maybe assume that
- 2:05:24Speaker 5: the deputy's outrageous behavior was the result of some kind
- 2:05:28Speaker 5: of PTSD.
- 2:05:29Speaker 2: From serving as Special Forces. But maybe maybe I could
- 2:05:32Speaker 2: kind of explain some of what's going on here. I
- 2:05:34Speaker 2: had multiple people when I posted this on Twitter, be like, oh,
- 2:05:38Speaker 2: this is maybe people with like PTSD shouldn't be.
- 2:05:40Speaker 5: Cops, And I had to be like no, no, no, Well,
- 2:05:44Speaker 5: see the funny thing about that is that he never
- 2:05:47Speaker 5: actually served in combat.
- 2:05:49Speaker 2: No, this guy flew a fucking desk, yeah, which like
- 2:05:52Speaker 2: you need that in a war. But like this, this
- 2:05:54Speaker 2: man did not have any combat trauma that caused him
- 2:05:57Speaker 2: to react this way.
- 2:05:59Speaker 5: You know, like I I've had I've had PTSD. You know,
- 2:06:03Speaker 5: I've certainly gotten like I can get really jumpy with
- 2:06:06Speaker 5: certain sounds.
- 2:06:08Speaker 2: Yeah, that is not that six months Carriod where fireworks
- 2:06:11Speaker 2: made us all very unhappy.
- 2:06:12Speaker 5: Yeah, or like keys dropping was the big one for
- 2:06:15Speaker 5: me because it sounded like a tear guest canister rolling
- 2:06:18Speaker 5: on his bottles.
- 2:06:19Speaker 2: But you know when in the many times that I
- 2:06:21Speaker 2: had bottles fall near me and set me off, or
- 2:06:23Speaker 2: that fireworks went off near me and set me off,
- 2:06:26Speaker 2: I was often carrying a gun and what I never
- 2:06:28Speaker 2: did was empty it vaguely in the direction of a car.
- 2:06:33Speaker 2: So he never saw combat.
- 2:06:35Speaker 5: He did claim that he was aware of what suppressed
- 2:06:38Speaker 5: gunfire sounded like, and he affirmed that the noise he
- 2:06:41Speaker 5: herd reminded him of suppressed gunfire.
- 2:06:45Speaker 2: I'm sorry, bro, what the fuck?
- 2:06:48Speaker 5: Under questioning Herd, Eda said that he did not perceive
- 2:06:51Speaker 5: any other sounds, visuals, or physical indicators. Of gunfire besides
- 2:06:54Speaker 5: the initial tapping sound and his upper torso feeling. In
- 2:06:58Speaker 5: the interview, he was asked why he decided to fall
- 2:07:00Speaker 5: onto the pavement, and he said, I'm not sure if
- 2:07:02Speaker 5: it was adrenaline or just what, but the numbness of
- 2:07:06Speaker 5: my legs and realizing, Okay, I'm going to be on
- 2:07:08Speaker 5: the ground, but also realizing the windows are right there,
- 2:07:10Speaker 5: you know, I'm I need to be on the ground anyway,
- 2:07:13Speaker 5: so I'm not exposed. So yeah, and that that just
- 2:07:15Speaker 5: kind of led to my legs just kind of gave
- 2:07:17Speaker 5: out on me. Fascinating. He then was asked to explain
- 2:07:22Speaker 5: the two action roles he performed on the road, and
- 2:07:25Speaker 5: her dad replied.
- 2:07:27Speaker 2: Uh rnx. At the same time, what was I supposed
- 2:07:31Speaker 2: to do? Pretty much?
- 2:07:32Speaker 5: He said, uh the rolling kind of reaction to what
- 2:07:38Speaker 5: was going on and realizing like, my legs are not
- 2:07:41Speaker 5: working the way I need them to work right now,
- 2:07:44Speaker 5: but I can roll over to the next vehicle. So
- 2:07:47Speaker 5: that's kind of where I was trying to get to
- 2:07:49Speaker 5: unquote sure, okay, okay, bro. So after his little action roles,
- 2:07:55Speaker 5: this is where he started yelling shots fired and he
- 2:07:58Speaker 5: emptied his clip into the car. And told the sergeant
- 2:08:00Speaker 5: that shots were coming from this vehicle, and she began
- 2:08:03Speaker 5: firing in the vehicle as well. At what point Hernandez
- 2:08:05Speaker 5: tried to move off to the side because he was
- 2:08:07Speaker 5: concerned about being shot by the other cop. He says,
- 2:08:11Speaker 5: when I was done engaging the vehicle, I was trying
- 2:08:13Speaker 5: to get off to the side over there because I
- 2:08:15Speaker 5: was worried about possibly having possibly me being in her
- 2:08:18Speaker 5: line of fire.
- 2:08:19Speaker 2: Now sure, this is this is the first reasonable threat
- 2:08:23Speaker 2: that he has expressed. I would also be concerned about
- 2:08:26Speaker 2: them shooting me in that instance.
- 2:08:28Speaker 5: Yes, So, after Hernandez's initial explanation of events, the investigator
- 2:08:32Speaker 5: showed him video stills of an acorn coming into frame
- 2:08:36Speaker 5: and bouncing off the roof of his car. I'm just
- 2:08:40Speaker 5: going to read directly from the from the report, quote,
- 2:08:43Speaker 5: Deputy Hernandez asked acorn. Investigator Hogan answered acorn, I'm quote amazing, amazing,
- 2:08:52Speaker 5: an amazing sentence.
- 2:08:56Speaker 3: This is.
- 2:08:58Speaker 2: This is so perfectly how you would like script it
- 2:09:01Speaker 2: in a really good police procedural comedy, Like if you
- 2:09:04Speaker 2: had some A game writers on the team, and it's
- 2:09:07Speaker 2: it's gonna take some really good you'd need like the
- 2:09:10Speaker 2: wire quality actors to pull those lines off. Bunk and
- 2:09:14Speaker 2: Bunk could have pulled them off right, Like.
- 2:09:16Speaker 5: There's two more lines I want I want to get
- 2:09:18Speaker 5: to before before we take an out of break here.
- 2:09:20Speaker 5: When asked if the sound he heard could have been
- 2:09:22Speaker 5: an acorn instead of suppressed gunfire, the deputy answered, quote,
- 2:09:26Speaker 5: I'm not gonna say no, because I mean, that's but
- 2:09:29Speaker 5: what ten second pause and speaking. What I heard three
- 2:09:33Speaker 5: second pause and speaking sounded almost like twelve second pause
- 2:09:37Speaker 5: and speaking in credit. But I heard sounded what I
- 2:09:39Speaker 5: think would be louder than an acorn hitting the roof
- 2:09:42Speaker 5: of the car. But there's obviously an acorn hitting the
- 2:09:45Speaker 5: roof of a.
- 2:09:45Speaker 2: Car unquote amazing. Uh.
- 2:09:50Speaker 5: The investigator then had to ask her, ed, does if
- 2:09:53Speaker 5: he was in general familiar with the sound of acorns,
- 2:09:57Speaker 5: which must be so embarrassed?
- 2:10:00Speaker 2: That is that is that is a low point in
- 2:10:03Speaker 2: your career, that is Hernetta said that he was.
- 2:10:08Speaker 5: He was then asked if the sound could have been
- 2:10:10Speaker 5: what led him to believe the car theft suspect shot him,
- 2:10:13Speaker 5: to which the deputy answered, it could be seven second
- 2:10:18Speaker 5: pause and speaking, but I don't think so, but it.
- 2:10:21Speaker 2: Could be uncorked.
- 2:10:22Speaker 5: Great so then Hernandez's lawyer said that they could maybe
- 2:10:28Speaker 5: watch the video again and see if see if the
- 2:10:30Speaker 5: acorn striking matches the time that he says that he
- 2:10:34Speaker 5: heard the sound, And then they deliberated for a little bit,
- 2:10:37Speaker 5: and ultimately Hernandez refused to watch the video a s
- 2:10:40Speaker 5: second time once he was told it was an acorn's
- 2:10:45Speaker 5: I mean, yeah, come on, what's there to do?
- 2:10:48Speaker 2: Understandable? No, that's that's that's going to really do some
- 2:10:51Speaker 2: damage to your self esteem right there.
- 2:10:53Speaker 5: Less than a month later, just a few days before
- 2:10:56Speaker 5: a second interview was scheduled, he quit the job.
- 2:11:01Speaker 2: So you know what first decision he's made them, I
- 2:11:03Speaker 2: mean yeah, like, what what else can you do? At
- 2:11:06Speaker 2: this point? This story starts with a bad cop, but
- 2:11:09Speaker 2: it ends with a good one.
- 2:11:10Speaker 5: Like imagine returning to work and everyone's gonna call you
- 2:11:13Speaker 5: like the acorn guy, like you can't, you can't.
- 2:11:17Speaker 2: It's just an anytime there's like a there's like a
- 2:11:19Speaker 2: fucking acorn tree anywhere near you get like you okay, man, okay,
- 2:11:23Speaker 2: do you need to take him?
- 2:11:24Speaker 3: Take it?
- 2:11:26Speaker 5: Did you call this hit.
- 2:11:29Speaker 3: There?
- 2:11:30Speaker 2: Watch Out? Watch Out one hundred, one hundred times a
- 2:11:33Speaker 2: day guys would be getting on his radio being like
- 2:11:35Speaker 2: I just saw an acorn. Dispatch.
- 2:11:38Speaker 5: You can get on a possible acorn, uh negative negative,
- 2:11:42Speaker 5: that is a pine cone.
- 2:11:43Speaker 2: No need for assistance, just some gunfire. We're good, We're good,
- 2:11:47Speaker 2: not an acorn repete. We're safe. See is safe? No
- 2:11:50Speaker 2: acords insight.
- 2:11:53Speaker 5: All right, let's let's take an out of break and
- 2:11:57Speaker 5: we will return to hear about Sergeant Robber recollection of events.
- 2:12:13Speaker 5: Welcome back to Acorn Cop streaming now on the Discovery Channel.
- 2:12:17Speaker 5: Two cops, one acorn. No survive, Actually no, thankfully everyone survived.
- 2:12:22Speaker 5: This would be much less funny.
- 2:12:25Speaker 2: We would not be laughing about this now. There is
- 2:12:27Speaker 2: some permanent psychological damage done to the guy who was
- 2:12:30Speaker 2: shot at but not shot and that is unjust and sad,
- 2:12:33Speaker 2: yet not enough that we are not willing folks. You
- 2:12:37Speaker 2: have a right to laugh at something like this, you know,
- 2:12:39Speaker 2: even if there are some consequences to it. That's just
- 2:12:42Speaker 2: keeping yourself sane in this world.
- 2:12:44Speaker 5: So, Sergeant Roberts was a member of the shaf's department
- 2:12:47Speaker 5: for fifteen years. She has a bachelor's degree in criminology
- 2:12:50Speaker 5: from the Florida State University.
- 2:12:52Speaker 3: So that's cool.
- 2:12:53Speaker 5: She's been teaching at the Criminal Justice Standards and Training
- 2:12:58Speaker 5: Commission for ten years. So I think one thing that
- 2:13:02Speaker 5: led to some of them thinking it could have been
- 2:13:04Speaker 5: suppressed gunfire is that in the threatening messages that the
- 2:13:08Speaker 5: suspect had shown to or had sent to his girlfriend,
- 2:13:12Speaker 5: included was a close up picture of this dark kind
- 2:13:15Speaker 5: of gray cylinder pressed up against the center of the
- 2:13:18Speaker 5: dash in his car. Less than two inches of the
- 2:13:21Speaker 5: cylinder were visible. No parts of a firearm could be seen.
- 2:13:24Speaker 5: But they believed that this was a suppressor, and the
- 2:13:29Speaker 5: victim said that he owned a suppressor. So I think
- 2:13:32Speaker 5: that that is one thing that happened in the interview
- 2:13:35Speaker 5: kind of or in the like exchange leading up to
- 2:13:39Speaker 5: this incident. But no one got any confirmation that he
- 2:13:42Speaker 5: had a gun on him. Again, he was searched two times.
- 2:13:44Speaker 5: There was no gun found on him. It is possible
- 2:13:47Speaker 5: to like hide a gun on you, It is much
- 2:13:50Speaker 5: more difficult to hide a gun with a suppressor like that.
- 2:13:53Speaker 5: Is that is a pretty a pretty big object.
- 2:13:55Speaker 2: They are larger like it. Basically doubles are more than
- 2:13:59Speaker 2: doubles the link of the firearm, and it also does
- 2:14:01Speaker 2: so in such a way that makes it difficult to
- 2:14:05Speaker 2: carry in a concealed fashion.
- 2:14:08Speaker 5: So when Sergeant Roberts was collecting an affidavit about the
- 2:14:11Speaker 5: stolen car, she said that she heard quote some type
- 2:14:14Speaker 5: of noise and shortly thereafter Jesse, who's Hernandez screaming? Shots fired?
- 2:14:20Speaker 2: Quote.
- 2:14:21Speaker 5: It was loud enough that it got my attention and
- 2:14:23Speaker 5: made me think we're about to have a fight with
- 2:14:25Speaker 5: a prisoner or the suspect. Either he's escaped somehow and
- 2:14:28Speaker 5: Jesse's in a tussle with him. I can't tell you
- 2:14:30Speaker 5: exactly what it was, but it made me look and
- 2:14:32Speaker 5: then immediately heard Deputy Hernandez screaming. Shots fired.
- 2:14:37Speaker 2: So Sergeant Roberts ran out into the street. Quote.
- 2:14:40Speaker 5: I saw that Hernandez was down. He had his gun
- 2:14:42Speaker 5: point to the back of his patrol car. I was
- 2:14:44Speaker 5: drawing my pistol and my magazine that was in my
- 2:14:47Speaker 5: meg pouch. Somehow flew out again. Amazing police work.
- 2:14:50Speaker 2: These guys, incredible stuff. That's someone who never practiced.
- 2:14:55Speaker 5: Yeah, at which point I thought there was a malfunk.
- 2:15:01Speaker 5: I thought that I dropped the magazine. Somehow I hit
- 2:15:03Speaker 5: the meg release on my firearm and that that was
- 2:15:05Speaker 5: the magazine that fell out. Turns out it wasn't. It
- 2:15:07Speaker 5: was the one from my meg pouch. Uh huh, at
- 2:15:09Speaker 5: which point I think I fired. So you just have
- 2:15:14Speaker 5: magazines flying you freak out and start pulling your trigger.
- 2:15:17Speaker 2: Yeah, I will say that last part extremely common experience.
- 2:15:21Speaker 2: Police officers are not well trained, and most of them
- 2:15:24Speaker 2: in terms of combat stuff, and most of them do
- 2:15:27Speaker 2: not shoot regularly. When the FBI's done studies of like
- 2:15:31Speaker 2: people who kill police officers, and they nearly always train
- 2:15:35Speaker 2: way more often than the police officers they kill trained.
- 2:15:38Speaker 2: It's very Most cops are not putting one hundred and
- 2:15:40Speaker 2: fifty rounds a month downrange, and like, I fire three
- 2:15:44Speaker 2: hundred rounds a month in training, and I'm not particularly good.
- 2:15:47Speaker 2: That's what I consider like minimum level of competence. And
- 2:15:50Speaker 2: so it is extremely common in police shootings for the
- 2:15:53Speaker 2: officer to say I don't know how many I fired,
- 2:15:55Speaker 2: or I fired two shots and they fired seventeen. That
- 2:15:58Speaker 2: happens fun Oftentimes, even more than that, people will reload
- 2:16:01Speaker 2: and not realize that they reloaded and emptied the second
- 2:16:04Speaker 2: magazine because in an actual violent situation, and it is
- 2:16:08Speaker 2: for that lady, I will say that she just knows
- 2:16:10Speaker 2: that her partner is emptying his firearm. Yeah, so for her,
- 2:16:14Speaker 2: she's this is less unreasonable, right, It is more complicated
- 2:16:18Speaker 2: for Sergeant Roberts. But I think it also points to
- 2:16:21Speaker 2: some of the inherent problems with policing. Oh good god.
- 2:16:26Speaker 5: Yes, and the way police are trained, Like the how
- 2:16:29Speaker 5: quickly it was for her to start firing at a
- 2:16:31Speaker 5: suspect who's locked inside of a patrol car, who she
- 2:16:34Speaker 5: knows has been searched multiple times, and.
- 2:16:36Speaker 2: Who she has not seen shooting.
- 2:16:38Speaker 5: Yeah, she she has not seen any gunfire, she's not
- 2:16:40Speaker 5: seen any evidence of that, she's heard one man screaming.
- 2:16:44Speaker 5: And how quickly they decide to use lethal force is
- 2:16:47Speaker 5: I think very notable.
- 2:16:48Speaker 2: Quote.
- 2:16:49Speaker 5: I fired at the vehicle because I saw Deputy Hernandez
- 2:16:51Speaker 5: down on the ground and he tells me that shots
- 2:16:53Speaker 5: are fired and he's hit, and it scared the hell
- 2:16:55Speaker 5: out of me. I thought I was watching him be killed,
- 2:16:59Speaker 5: which is Yeah, it's to like how they are trained
- 2:17:01Speaker 5: to constantly be in fear for their lives, their fellow officers' lives. Quote,
- 2:17:05Speaker 5: it was the patrol car that was where the threat
- 2:17:07Speaker 5: was coming from. I'm thinking we've we missed the gun
- 2:17:10Speaker 5: in the pack down. Somehow he shot Jesse from the
- 2:17:12Speaker 5: car and Jesse's down shots are being fired. I couldn't
- 2:17:15Speaker 5: tell you exactly where they were coming from, but I
- 2:17:17Speaker 5: fired because of my concern.
- 2:17:19Speaker 2: On grit and you get. This is a thing that
- 2:17:22Speaker 2: does not get represented in fiction. People don't like to
- 2:17:24Speaker 2: talk about it. This happens with soldiers too. I have
- 2:17:27Speaker 2: a friend who was shot in the leg by a
- 2:17:30Speaker 2: fifty cow by one of our fifty cows one of
- 2:17:32Speaker 2: his guy's guns, because they were told anyone from this
- 2:17:36Speaker 2: building over that you see on the thermal scope is
- 2:17:39Speaker 2: an enemy. They saw him on the thermal scope and
- 2:17:42Speaker 2: they lit him up. It was just a series of
- 2:17:44Speaker 2: bad calls being made and nobody checking to confirm. Because
- 2:17:47Speaker 2: you're in an actual chaotic, dangerous situation, checking to confirm
- 2:17:51Speaker 2: is there actually a threat in that area? They're just shooting,
- 2:17:55Speaker 2: you know. It's people panic all the time. It's one
- 2:17:57Speaker 2: of the problems with sending people with gun into neighborhoods
- 2:18:01Speaker 2: like this is part of why the way we do
- 2:18:03Speaker 2: policing is such a bad idea, because there's no way
- 2:18:05Speaker 2: to train out all of this. You can train out
- 2:18:07Speaker 2: acorn guy, maybe maybe, but they didn't. But you cannot
- 2:18:11Speaker 2: train out people panicking and doing things with guns that
- 2:18:15Speaker 2: can never be taken back.
- 2:18:16Speaker 5: Well. And one other aspect is like Hernandez starts firing
- 2:18:20Speaker 5: his gun very shortly after he's yelling shots fired. Like
- 2:18:23Speaker 5: getting that linear cause of events can be tricky because
- 2:18:25Speaker 5: like you are hearing gunfire at the same time you
- 2:18:28Speaker 5: were hearing him yell shots fired because he is shooting.
- 2:18:31Speaker 5: And Roberts said that she wasn't sure if she or
- 2:18:34Speaker 5: Hernandez even shot first, Like all of your memory in
- 2:18:36Speaker 5: these instances can get really kind of blurry, like like
- 2:18:39Speaker 5: all of these like high stress scenarios, it actually can
- 2:18:42Speaker 5: be hard to remember the exact manner of oh, yes, easily, yes,
- 2:18:46Speaker 5: she said quote I'm seeing him on the ground yelling
- 2:18:49Speaker 5: shots fired.
- 2:18:50Speaker 2: I'm hit. I'm hit.
- 2:18:51Speaker 5: I thought I thought I saw a deputy get murdered.
- 2:18:54Speaker 5: I was close enough to see his facial expression that
- 2:18:56Speaker 5: was fear, anxiety, it was it was horrible. I'm seeing
- 2:19:00Speaker 5: him kind of trip fall, stumble something behind the vehicle.
- 2:19:03Speaker 5: At some point he's able to kind of post up,
- 2:19:06Speaker 5: but he was stumbling, crawling on the ground. I don't
- 2:19:08Speaker 5: know how to explain it. He wasn't standing up straight,
- 2:19:11Speaker 5: he was not in a tactical position. He was off
- 2:19:13Speaker 5: as momentum, he was off balance, he was standing behind
- 2:19:16Speaker 5: that car. It did not look like he was in
- 2:19:17Speaker 5: control of himself.
- 2:19:20Speaker 2: Yeah, no, yeah, that's like what she is saying. I'm
- 2:19:24Speaker 2: not going to say this is like a good response,
- 2:19:26Speaker 2: But it makes sense to me that she reacted the
- 2:19:28Speaker 2: way she'd most people would write, which is why most
- 2:19:30Speaker 2: people should not be given firearms and legal immunity to
- 2:19:33Speaker 2: do whatever with them, right, But most people would have
- 2:19:36Speaker 2: reacted in a why broadly similar manner without training, you know,
- 2:19:41Speaker 2: without training and experience.
- 2:19:42Speaker 5: Now, there's one way that she describes his kind of
- 2:19:45Speaker 5: like weird stumbling on the ground quote. The auditory tone
- 2:19:50Speaker 5: in his voice was terror. The best way to describe
- 2:19:53Speaker 5: it was like watching a baby to raft trying to
- 2:19:56Speaker 5: walk for the first time, trying to.
- 2:19:58Speaker 2: Get the out of the road. That is that is
- 2:20:01Speaker 2: going to echo in his mind until the day he dies.
- 2:20:06Speaker 2: So maybe dressed stumbling learning to walk for the first time.
- 2:20:15Speaker 2: Do you know what else is learning to walk? I
- 2:20:19Speaker 2: don't know.
- 2:20:19Speaker 5: That doesn't really now, do you know what else could
- 2:20:24Speaker 5: perceive acorns as a threat to business.
- 2:20:27Speaker 2: Oh yeah, we I mean, the one thing all of
- 2:20:30Speaker 2: our sponsors agree on is that acorns and all trees
- 2:20:34Speaker 2: should be eliminated in the interest of better profit margins.
- 2:20:37Speaker 2: So dangerous kill the natural world, live free. I want
- 2:20:51Speaker 2: to know one other thing as I'm talking about, like
- 2:20:54Speaker 2: why they I'm not surprised they reacted this way, and
- 2:20:57Speaker 2: what it says to me about like how I think.
- 2:20:59Speaker 2: Like I think that a group of moderately competent civilians
- 2:21:04Speaker 2: with concealed firearms would have responded better than both officers
- 2:21:08Speaker 2: in this situation. Large not for the reason that they're
- 2:21:11Speaker 2: more smarter or better trained, because they probably aren't, but
- 2:21:15Speaker 2: because they go through the world carrying a gun knowing
- 2:21:18Speaker 2: that if anything they do with that gun, they're legally
- 2:21:21Speaker 2: accountable for every shot fired they're accountable for, which is
- 2:21:24Speaker 2: a different mind state than what police are trained to do,
- 2:21:28Speaker 2: which is the instant you feel endangered, you should draw
- 2:21:31Speaker 2: and be prepared to shoot or shoot immediately, because nothing
- 2:21:35Speaker 2: matters more than you getting home, and you have qualified
- 2:21:37Speaker 2: immunity on your side, right.
- 2:21:39Speaker 5: Yeah, which allows you to interpret a very quiet tapping
- 2:21:42Speaker 5: sound as a lethal threat to your life. Now, Sergeant
- 2:21:48Speaker 5: Roberts said, that she did observe Hernandez move himself into
- 2:21:52Speaker 5: kind of a kneeling shooting stance on his left knee
- 2:21:54Speaker 5: with his right foot planted in front, but still quote,
- 2:21:58Speaker 5: it seemed like his motor functions were not off running
- 2:22:00Speaker 5: properly from what I saw. He told me again, shots
- 2:22:02Speaker 5: her fire. He's completely out in the open. No one
- 2:22:04Speaker 5: would think that's a good place to take a knee
- 2:22:05Speaker 5: to tactically fire. So he was still trying to respond
- 2:22:09Speaker 5: in some way, but still very very baby draft coated.
- 2:22:12Speaker 2: It seems yeah, yeah, I mean, that seems like a
- 2:22:15Speaker 2: constant thing for this fella.
- 2:22:17Speaker 7: So.
- 2:22:18Speaker 5: Roberts also admitted that she did not ever see the suspect.
- 2:22:21Speaker 5: She could not see inside the patrol car and she
- 2:22:23Speaker 5: couldn't hear anything coming from that area. Quote, if there
- 2:22:27Speaker 5: would have been something going on in that vehicle, I
- 2:22:29Speaker 5: don't know if I necessarily would have heard it. Was
- 2:22:32Speaker 5: I hearing or seeing the windows be blasted out. No,
- 2:22:34Speaker 5: I couldn't see the right side of the vehicle. But
- 2:22:36Speaker 5: based on the circumstances, I'm thinking that somehow he shot
- 2:22:39Speaker 5: Jesse from the back and it had struck him some
- 2:22:41Speaker 5: way somehow. I don't know if the individual's gotten out
- 2:22:44Speaker 5: of the car and it's on the other side, you know,
- 2:22:46Speaker 5: like he's escaped somehow. I couldn't see if the door
- 2:22:48Speaker 5: was wide open. I don't know if he's gotten out
- 2:22:50Speaker 5: and they've had a little tussle. Is he's shooting from
- 2:22:52Speaker 5: the back of the car. All these things are going
- 2:22:54Speaker 5: through my head, but the main thing is that he's
- 2:22:56Speaker 5: in the back of the car. He's got a gun,
- 2:22:57Speaker 5: and we missed it, and somehow he shot Deputy her.
- 2:22:59Speaker 5: Now so she also couldn't remember who shot first, but
- 2:23:05Speaker 5: she denied the notion that she started shooting because she
- 2:23:07Speaker 5: thought Hernandez fired his gun first. She was confident in
- 2:23:11Speaker 5: her her own use of gunfire before before she could
- 2:23:16Speaker 5: tell that Jesse was firing.
- 2:23:18Speaker 2: Yeah, interesting quote.
- 2:23:21Speaker 5: The threat was someone had shot him. We had an
- 2:23:23Speaker 5: armed suspect in the back of the vehicle. Jesse was shot.
- 2:23:25Speaker 5: I'm watching him, you know, fumble on the road. How
- 2:23:27Speaker 5: do I give him more time? How do I draw
- 2:23:29Speaker 5: the attention to me? How do I save him? I
- 2:23:31Speaker 5: thought I was watching him get murdered. The tone in
- 2:23:33Speaker 5: his voice, look on his face, the physical reactions. I'm
- 2:23:35Speaker 5: thinking we missed the gun and this is it. How
- 2:23:37Speaker 5: do I get to Jesse to save him. She she
- 2:23:40Speaker 5: talks about how she quote couldn't let him be shot
- 2:23:42Speaker 5: again again, as all of this is like so confident
- 2:23:45Speaker 5: that that that this has happened, and they're so confident
- 2:23:48Speaker 5: in their own use of force. She was also concerned
- 2:23:50Speaker 5: that if the suspect got away, other people's lives could
- 2:23:54Speaker 5: be in danger, like his girlfriend who was nearby and
- 2:23:56Speaker 5: the friend who was talking to police about their domestic issue. Quote,
- 2:24:00Speaker 5: there was a threat in the back of the patrol car.
- 2:24:02Speaker 5: I had a deputy that was on the ground that
- 2:24:04Speaker 5: was still a threat to Jesse's life. I needed to
- 2:24:05Speaker 5: provide him some sort of cover or bring the attention
- 2:24:07Speaker 5: to me. I'm watching him die. I've got to do something.
- 2:24:10Speaker 5: I've got to do something. There's that just like overall
- 2:24:14Speaker 5: constantly throughout this interview with the Professional Standards Investigation, she's
- 2:24:19Speaker 5: just constantly saying how she thought that this man was
- 2:24:22Speaker 5: gonna die. That's why she responded the way she did.
- 2:24:25Speaker 5: Like she talks about how she can't render aid if
- 2:24:27Speaker 5: there's still a threat, she has to like get regain
- 2:24:30Speaker 5: control the situation.
- 2:24:32Speaker 2: All of those are reasonable things to say, Yeah, all
- 2:24:35Speaker 2: of those are reasonable things to say in a real
- 2:24:37Speaker 2: gun fight.
- 2:24:38Speaker 5: Yes, it's just a little bit less less valid with
- 2:24:42Speaker 5: the en shiting incident. Is an acorn falling on a roof? Yes,
- 2:24:48Speaker 5: and you're shooting directly at a man who's your own
- 2:24:51Speaker 5: big car been searched two times and is wrapped inside,
- 2:24:55Speaker 5: who has handcuffs on.
- 2:24:56Speaker 1: Like.
- 2:24:58Speaker 5: So, Yeah, After both cops spared off this large valley
- 2:25:01Speaker 5: of bullets, they both repositioned behind cover, called in more backup,
- 2:25:05Speaker 5: and Roberts tended to manage the situation and the other
- 2:25:08Speaker 5: individuals in the area and eventually check in on Deputy Hernandez. Quote,
- 2:25:12Speaker 5: the threat was still a threat until we were able
- 2:25:15Speaker 5: to remove him from the car. Again, they're not viewing
- 2:25:18Speaker 5: him as a person, They're viewing him as a threat.
- 2:25:20Speaker 5: Like that is that is like he's no longer like
- 2:25:23Speaker 5: a human being.
- 2:25:23Speaker 2: He is he is a threat. That is what he represents.
- 2:25:26Speaker 5: Now.
- 2:25:27Speaker 2: Yeah, well, and that is that is how they're trained
- 2:25:30Speaker 2: to talk. And that is, by the way, like in
- 2:25:32Speaker 2: a court of law, how you should talk, right, you don't.
- 2:25:35Speaker 2: You would not say, if you were involved in the
- 2:25:37Speaker 2: legal defensive shooting, I shot to kill. You would say
- 2:25:40Speaker 2: I shot to stop the threat. That is like how
- 2:25:42Speaker 2: people are trained, because that's what plays best in the court.
- 2:25:45Speaker 1: Yeah.
- 2:25:45Speaker 5: No, she all of her interview is very polished. She is,
- 2:25:48Speaker 5: she likes very she's she's been a caught for fifteen years,
- 2:25:51Speaker 5: like she is. She knows what she's saying here.
- 2:25:54Speaker 2: Yes, she's been coached before. Yeah, she's she's aware.
- 2:25:57Speaker 5: So after they were able to get to cover, she
- 2:25:59Speaker 5: called in more resources. Quote, that's when we were able
- 2:26:02Speaker 5: to treat it as more of a barricaded armed suspect situation.
- 2:26:06Speaker 5: This poor dude, Yeah, like what do you do?
- 2:26:09Speaker 2: Like you're hanging in the back of the car like everywhere,
- 2:26:11Speaker 2: like like it seems like this guy is guilty of
- 2:26:15Speaker 2: having a little bit of having an emotional breakdown with
- 2:26:18Speaker 2: his partner and doing things he should not have done,
- 2:26:21Speaker 2: none of which the penalty for is getting shot at
- 2:26:24Speaker 2: while strapped into a car.
- 2:26:25Speaker 5: Yeah, he stole his girlfriend's car, He sent her threatening messages.
- 2:26:28Speaker 5: He was described as being abassive in the past. Yeah,
- 2:26:31Speaker 5: there's bad things, but that doesn't mean you can get
- 2:26:33Speaker 5: executed by police because they hurt an a chord Like, No,
- 2:26:37Speaker 5: that is.
- 2:26:38Speaker 2: Not that is not what our society has deemed the
- 2:26:40Speaker 2: punishment for those options for those behaviors should be so.
- 2:26:45Speaker 5: Roberts closed this interview by saying, quote, I don't think
- 2:26:48Speaker 5: there's anything funny about it. It just went from zero
- 2:26:51Speaker 5: to one hundred within the drop of a hat. I
- 2:26:53Speaker 5: know we talk about it all the time, but when
- 2:26:54Speaker 5: it does, it does. And she's talking about how, like
- 2:26:57Speaker 5: how fast the situation escalates, like from a very standard
- 2:27:01Speaker 5: interaction towards you're now multiple people are shooting, like this
- 2:27:05Speaker 5: is it happens so quickly. It went from the zeer
- 2:27:08Speaker 5: to one hundred within the drop of the hat.
- 2:27:10Speaker 2: Yeah, that's that is what happens with shootings.
- 2:27:13Speaker 5: She knew that Hernandez was prior military and when in
- 2:27:16Speaker 5: training Hernandez was training on her shift, she described him
- 2:27:20Speaker 5: as quote a very squared away person, somebody that if
- 2:27:24Speaker 5: they tell you something, you don't question it. I wanted
- 2:27:26Speaker 5: Jesse on my shift. When I observed him in high
- 2:27:29Speaker 5: stressful situations, he reacted appropriately. He wasn't afraid to respond
- 2:27:34Speaker 5: and he's I think that last part is certainly true.
- 2:27:37Speaker 5: He was not afraid to respond well.
- 2:27:38Speaker 2: And this is why, again, when the response for a
- 2:27:42Speaker 2: lot of people when I would talk about this to
- 2:27:43Speaker 2: them is suspecting it had something to do with his
- 2:27:45Speaker 2: military training that he responded this way. Soldiers aren't trained
- 2:27:49Speaker 2: this way. Again, this is soldiers contrained in the field.
- 2:27:53Speaker 2: But soldiers are generally trained to not air on the
- 2:27:56Speaker 2: side of opening fire blindly because war crimes are a
- 2:27:59Speaker 2: thing they're concerned about and they have a sense of
- 2:28:02Speaker 2: professional pride against Again, not to say that they do
- 2:28:05Speaker 2: not kill innocent people. They do all the time, because
- 2:28:07Speaker 2: that's what war is. But this is not the way.
- 2:28:10Speaker 2: So this is police training. This guy's bias towards reacting
- 2:28:14Speaker 2: this way is the result of police training, not special
- 2:28:16Speaker 2: forces training.
- 2:28:18Speaker 5: She kind of reaffirmed her trust in Hernandez as a
- 2:28:20Speaker 5: person who was like reliable, saying when they were on
- 2:28:24Speaker 5: night shift during training, quote, he acted appropriately, He did
- 2:28:26Speaker 5: not lose control of his emotions. I have a lot
- 2:28:28Speaker 5: of respect for him. Actually, when he tells you something,
- 2:28:31Speaker 5: it's not something like are you sure you know he'd
- 2:28:33Speaker 5: tell you something and that's what's happening, or that's what happened.
- 2:28:36Speaker 5: I don't think there's anything malicious about what he did.
- 2:28:39Speaker 2: I'm not mad at him.
- 2:28:40Speaker 5: I'm not upset about it because I truly believe that
- 2:28:42Speaker 5: he thought that's what was happening, unquote, which is again,
- 2:28:46Speaker 5: it just I'd be pissed you almost, Like I don't
- 2:28:50Speaker 5: know if I was tricked into almost killing someone.
- 2:28:53Speaker 2: I don't understand this reaction. Like it's this thin blue
- 2:28:58Speaker 2: line shit, right, Yeah, they have to group together so
- 2:29:01Speaker 2: so hard. Yeah, it's it's and it's like this guy
- 2:29:07Speaker 2: got you into a situation where you could have shot
- 2:29:11Speaker 2: a child, Like I would never forgive someone who put
- 2:29:15Speaker 2: me in that position for no good reason, right, Like,
- 2:29:19Speaker 2: it's why that's such such an insane response to me.
- 2:29:22Speaker 5: So she has to keep affirming that he has like
- 2:29:24Speaker 5: a good judgment, and it's it's so bizarre.
- 2:29:26Speaker 2: No, he doesn't, like he very clearly doesn't. You'll watch
- 2:29:30Speaker 2: the video. It'd be one thing if like they were
- 2:29:33Speaker 2: under fire and he shot and his bullet went wide
- 2:29:36Speaker 2: and hit a civilian and it's no, that's like absolutely,
- 2:29:38Speaker 2: it's just a horrible accident. But like his judgment wasn't bad.
- 2:29:41Speaker 2: It was just a terrible situation. This is so different,
- 2:29:44Speaker 2: like and that she's still going to bat for him,
- 2:29:47Speaker 2: says everything about cop cops, cop brain.
- 2:29:50Speaker 5: Yeah, there's a few lines that I want to read
- 2:29:53Speaker 5: before we close. Out here that are in the conclusion
- 2:29:56Speaker 5: of the of the report can't wait. They describe her
- 2:30:00Speaker 5: and his legs as quote, stopped working correctly. I think
- 2:30:04Speaker 5: it's just a really funny way to phrase it.
- 2:30:06Speaker 2: I would describe his brain that way.
- 2:30:07Speaker 5: But yeah, his legs weren't responding as he intended. But
- 2:30:11Speaker 5: there was no evidence to support anything impacted Deputy Hernandez.
- 2:30:15Speaker 5: No defects are found on his uniform or his blistering
- 2:30:17Speaker 5: vests support the impact Hernandez. It's response was not objectively reasonable,
- 2:30:21Speaker 5: so they they ruled that Hernandez's response was not objectively reasonable,
- 2:30:26Speaker 5: that it was not appropriate.
- 2:30:28Speaker 2: Positively surprised about that, but they.
- 2:30:30Speaker 5: Found Sergeant Roberts's response as being reasonable because she believed
- 2:30:34Speaker 5: Hernandez has been shot because of his tone of voice,
- 2:30:37Speaker 5: his stumbling, attempts to move and stand up, and it's
- 2:30:39Speaker 5: apparent quote lack of control over his body.
- 2:30:43Speaker 2: Yeah, I would not call it. I wouldn't say her
- 2:30:45Speaker 2: response is reasonable. I would say her response is what
- 2:30:47Speaker 2: I would expect most people to do.
- 2:30:49Speaker 5: No, or it is reasonable in terms of how police
- 2:30:53Speaker 5: procedure operates, like she followed the correct protocols for interacting
- 2:30:58Speaker 5: as a police officer.
- 2:30:59Speaker 2: Yeah, I don't believe under the laws she would have
- 2:31:02Speaker 2: been found liable by any court.
- 2:31:04Speaker 5: No, they said, quote Robert's found out Hernandez to be
- 2:31:07Speaker 5: a reliable depity that she could trust. She had no
- 2:31:08Speaker 5: reason to doubt what Hernandez had been telling her. She
- 2:31:11Speaker 5: described the auditory tone of Hernandez's voice as terror, the
- 2:31:14Speaker 5: look on his face as being quote consistent with being
- 2:31:17Speaker 5: in feary. I love that kind of cop speak, consistent
- 2:31:22Speaker 5: with being in fear.
- 2:31:23Speaker 2: Yeah, he looked scared. Yeah, amazing. I I do want
- 2:31:28Speaker 2: to go over one thing before we come out, because
- 2:31:30Speaker 2: this is again something I've been asked by people, and
- 2:31:33Speaker 2: you know, maybe this is actionable. If you ever found
- 2:31:35Speaker 2: yourself handcuffed in the back of a police car and
- 2:31:37Speaker 2: they start shooting at you, you should know how this
- 2:31:40Speaker 2: guy survived because reading the interview with him, he was like,
- 2:31:42Speaker 2: as soon as I realized they were shooting at me,
- 2:31:44Speaker 2: I like flung myself down sideways and laid flat. I
- 2:31:48Speaker 2: think in front of the seat. He might have been
- 2:31:50Speaker 2: on the seat. I would get in front of the
- 2:31:52Speaker 2: seat if you can. But the reason he survived is
- 2:31:57Speaker 2: that handguns number one, police carry hollow points in their handguns.
- 2:32:02Speaker 2: Which is a bullet that has a hole in the
- 2:32:04Speaker 2: slug the thing that goes into somebody. And the reason
- 2:32:07Speaker 2: why you make a hollow point is that a hollow
- 2:32:10Speaker 2: point expands immediately upon impact, so it doesn't penetrate as well.
- 2:32:15Speaker 2: It will not go through armor, and it will not
- 2:32:17Speaker 2: go through objects very well. But when it hits meat,
- 2:32:21Speaker 2: it expands and so instead of going through a body,
- 2:32:26Speaker 2: it stops and it imparts all of the force from
- 2:32:28Speaker 2: the bullet into that body, so it is better at
- 2:32:31Speaker 2: stopping people. But what that means is when someone is
- 2:32:33Speaker 2: shooting at something like a car and shooting into the
- 2:32:35Speaker 2: back of a car and you have that whole reinforced
- 2:32:38Speaker 2: trunk and backseat of a police car to go through
- 2:32:40Speaker 2: those nine millimeters, rounds are unlikely to penetrate very far.
- 2:32:44Speaker 2: So if you are laying down in front of the
- 2:32:47Speaker 2: seat or flat on the seat, your odds of not
- 2:32:50Speaker 2: getting hit are pretty good. Like he had, I'm not
- 2:32:53Speaker 2: surprised he survived having done what he did. You know,
- 2:32:56Speaker 2: if you're sitting up and you've got body parts that
- 2:32:59Speaker 2: are like view of the windows, you're very likely to
- 2:33:02Speaker 2: get hit. But because he did what he did, he
- 2:33:05Speaker 2: essentially saved his own life, is what it's my interpretation
- 2:33:09Speaker 2: of what I've read.
- 2:33:10Speaker 5: Yeah, no, I mean it's it's it is a terrifying
- 2:33:13Speaker 5: scenario that there was. There was an instant recently of
- 2:33:17Speaker 5: this officer who made his first ever arrest. He had
- 2:33:20Speaker 5: two suspects locked in the back and he got distracted
- 2:33:24Speaker 5: about driving. He drove his car off the road into
- 2:33:27Speaker 5: a lake, and both of.
- 2:33:29Speaker 2: The suspects drowned. Jesus fucking Christ.
- 2:33:32Speaker 5: Like this is this is like all these things point
- 2:33:34Speaker 5: towards just inherent problems with the policing system.
- 2:33:38Speaker 2: Cops bad, avoid at all costs.
- 2:33:40Speaker 5: It's terrifying, Like it's it is like these people can
- 2:33:43Speaker 5: just act like this can kidnap, people can do all
- 2:33:45Speaker 5: these things and face basically no repercussions at least turn
- 2:33:49Speaker 5: ind as is no longer a cop, which is good,
- 2:33:52Speaker 5: but like that doesn't fix any of the underlying problems
- 2:33:54Speaker 5: with training that cause people to react like this in
- 2:33:57Speaker 5: the face of a squirrel armed with an AI corn
- 2:34:01Speaker 5: being the most dangerous thing that you can encounter.
- 2:34:04Speaker 2: Yeah, it's very bad police work. Avoid cops.
- 2:34:09Speaker 5: Yeah, yeah, pretty much pretty much. So, Yeah, that is
- 2:34:12Speaker 5: that is what we have to say on the acorn
- 2:34:14Speaker 5: involved shooting.
- 2:34:16Speaker 2: Yeah, great stuff.
- 2:34:17Speaker 5: Watch out for acorns, Watch out for droops. Also dangerous.
- 2:34:20Speaker 5: They can fall off a tree. Yeah, pine cones can
- 2:34:24Speaker 5: sometimes be lethal.
- 2:34:25Speaker 2: Oh they call those the widow makers.
- 2:34:28Speaker 5: Eyes on the sky, folks, You never know.
- 2:34:31Speaker 2: All right, bye, Hey, We'll be back Monday with more
- 2:34:38Speaker 2: episodes every week from now until the heat death of
- 2:34:41Speaker 2: the Universe.
- 2:34:42Speaker 7: It Could Happen Here as a production of cool Zone Media.
- 2:34:44Speaker 1: For more podcasts from cool Zone Media, visit our website
- 2:34:47Speaker 1: cool zonemedia dot com, or check us out on the
- 2:34:49Speaker 1: iHeartRadio app, Apple Podcasts, or wherever you listen to podcasts.
- 2:34:53Speaker 7: You can find sources for It Could Happen Here, updated
- 2:34:55Speaker 7: monthly at cool zonemedia dot com slash sources.
- 2:34:59Speaker 1: Thanks for listening.