Latest / Gabriel Ellis, PhD | The Curious Mind Podcast / Being and Becoming a Man in our Society
Transcript
- 0:04Hello everyone. My name is Gabriel Ellis and
- 0:07this is another episode of the Curious.
- 0:09Mind podcasts I have done in the past different couple of things.
- 0:15The last week's I have uploaded episodes of an online therapy
- 0:21that I've done with a client to give you an idea of how if you
- 0:26don't have experience with therapy, how actual therapy
- 0:29might look like and how the development and therapy can look
- 0:32like. And another focus of mine is to
- 0:35try to have interesting conversations with guests.
- 0:39Sometimes about books, sometimes about specific topics and today
- 0:43I have the pleasure to talk to a colleague friend of mine.
- 0:48Your convenient. It is a systemic Gestalt
- 0:52therapist. This is the official title but
- 0:56apart from that he's having interesting views, interesting.
- 1:02Concepts and overall and interesting work with clients.
- 1:06So we know each other from work and so thinking about who else I
- 1:14could talk to interview, your thing, came to my mind and I
- 1:19wanted to take the opportunity to introduce them also and his
- 1:23work to my audience. I do your thing.
- 1:26I got you. Thank you for having me here.
- 1:29It's the first time that we speak English.
- 1:31Finally, usually we converse in German, so you locking is
- 1:37German, native Works internationally as well works
- 1:41with in-person clients but also online.
- 1:46And today, just because I speak to an audience that is mostly
- 1:49International. We switch to English Yes.
- 1:54So what is interesting about you and your work to me is that you
- 2:00seem to have overtime. You have developed perspectives
- 2:06and ideas that I do not come across very often.
- 2:10When I read or talk with colleagues therapist colleagues,
- 2:18your kind of the very basic background of Gestalt and
- 2:22systemic not that unique. These are quite established
- 2:27schools. So what is more interesting is,
- 2:30I think what comes on top of that there are two areas I would
- 2:35like to highlight and then we'll see which we would like to
- 2:40discuss more in our conversation one, is that you are interested
- 2:45in working with men, specifically.
- 2:47And you have created an online community, where a man can
- 2:54exchange and self develop, it's called Brothers of arm Brothers
- 2:59off heart, right? And this is an online community,
- 3:05as far as As I understood is changing, its composition.
- 3:12So it's not a fixed group but people can join and maybe you
- 3:21can start by describing a little bit about the context.
- 3:26How does this work form? Who can participate?
- 3:30And how did you start with this interest?
- 3:33And with the specific kind of Work working online with men.
- 3:40Yeah, this is actually really some special interest for me to
- 3:45work with man and First of all, it was always an interest of
- 3:52mine for my own personal development in the beginning.
- 3:56But then I found also in the work that many times, I believe
- 4:03that men are not really met in Psychotherapy as men many times.
- 4:11My experience is that many times, we tend to believe it
- 4:18seems that the soul does not have a gender so to speak and
- 4:25maybe this is true, I don't know.
- 4:26But what I believe is true, is that every person has a
- 4:33different experience. If this person has a male body
- 4:38or a female body, I believe a person with a female body
- 4:42working through the world has different experiences with the
- 4:47world and B herself, then a person with a male body working
- 4:53in the world walking through the world and having different
- 4:58experiences. and since with that, and I think we many times,
- 5:04don't address that And but this is I believe a crucial topic for
- 5:11many even if it's it might be unconscious, but it has an
- 5:16effect and from this assumption, I started to specialize on
- 5:23working with man and the brothers of heart is our online
- 5:29circles. They are going on four years
- 5:33now, but actually every man can To join just for one cycle that
- 5:39the cycle is about 10 times and it's normally 10 weeks and we
- 5:48need for two hours every week and most of the times there is a
- 5:55topic. For example lately it's the
- 5:59topic of ancestral work, what I call like the the roots of man.
- 6:08What does it mean for a man to have?
- 6:11He's ancestors that he has. So that is one area that I'm
- 6:18specifying on and the chances that the man Can.
- 6:25Relate to the ancestors in a different way that you might
- 6:29have had before and in that he also connects with other man to
- 6:35share experiences and my experiences that it soon as
- 6:41someone is not only working one on one, which is beautiful.
- 6:45But if there is a reflection with other men, it really
- 6:49depends the work. Now it's interesting that you
- 6:55you started your description by saying that often men in a
- 6:59therapeutic or self-development context are not perceived as
- 7:03men. This is quite a symmetrical
- 7:05because I think it's relatively common that women have found a
- 7:10way to address each other in therapeutic goals of development
- 7:15or country contexts for example as women and to develop that.
- 7:23So there is something obvious In that in this asymmetry, I think
- 7:27people are aware that many more possibilities for women to
- 7:33develop themselves as women. Why do you think there is such a
- 7:37lack in possibilities and services for men?
- 7:45well, that's an interesting question and I Wonder do we want
- 7:51to become aware that we are man? Hmm, because many times, and
- 7:59this is what we hear from women, at least.
- 8:01I hear it. It's the way we construct.
- 8:07Our society is that with an underlying assumption that this
- 8:13Society is for men. But this is covered, many times
- 8:22many times we say, oh, this is just a bank, this is just a
- 8:26hotel, this is just a school back to the structure, we are
- 8:30building it with is with the assumption that this is for men
- 8:37from men and maybe their can also some women can show in
- 8:41there. So the work would be to say,
- 8:44okay, let's, let's uncover that See what is actually Our
- 8:49intention here. How do we build that?
- 8:51What our assumptions. But then we as men would need to
- 8:58own that there are lots of privileges we have for example
- 9:03that are covered in this uncovered construction of
- 9:08society and then it's not so not so nice.
- 9:12Sometimes we have to acknowledge that we get more money, man.
- 9:17E x foil for work. They have to acknowledge that
- 9:21it's safe for us to walk the streets at 11 p.m. pm at night.
- 9:27And well, then it would be a little bit uncomfortable, Maybe.
- 9:33and then we many men say we don't want to know about it so
- 9:39much so when it becomes about self-awareness and throughput it
- 9:43work, This needs to be addressed.
- 9:47And I think this is one when you ask this question, why is this?
- 9:51So a symmetric symmetric in our work.
- 9:58I think this is part of it. Do we really want to become
- 10:01aware that we are man and how we look at the world and how we
- 10:06co-construct the world. Yeah, so that's quite
- 10:09interesting because what follows from that is that if we take
- 10:16this approach and we start to reflect with our male clients
- 10:20their experience and the world. It necessarily in very quickly,
- 10:27goes to a societal and social Dimension.
- 10:31So that interestingly, even though we aim at a very private
- 10:37internal reflection, right on, something that touches us as
- 10:44men, every day, every moment. And so on that, it refers
- 10:51automatically to a big picture. Right?
- 10:55And this is again, something that might not be self-evident
- 11:00or normal in therapeutic. Contexts, exactly.
- 11:04And I think it's beautiful how, what you're looking at, and how
- 11:08your point to it, because I believe that many have many men
- 11:13have quite a contrary experience with themselves.
- 11:17I believe many men have an experience of feeling alone in
- 11:23the world. Feeling lonely, feeling
- 11:26disconnected, some are aware of it, some not, but for many, many
- 11:31even if they feel good about themselves, I think there is a
- 11:35sense of I can do it. I can do it alone and there's a
- 11:39beauty in that, but there's also sharing that.
- 11:43So in contrast to this what I said before about the EM covered
- 11:48structure, the individual experience for many men is, oh,
- 11:53I I'm alone with the world and I can make my way through the
- 11:56world. Yes, at this also needs to be
- 12:00uncovered. Why is that?
- 12:02Where is this coming from? Where is this meat coming from
- 12:05to be alone or to feel, or to make it alone?
- 12:10And of course, both the collective and the most personal
- 12:17covered Collective and the covered personal are connected.
- 12:22And when we start to do our work all of a sudden, okay?
- 12:26So then there needs to be an awareness.
- 12:28Oh yeah, I feel like I'm a lone wolf here in the world.
- 12:33Yes, mmm. Where is this coming from?
- 12:36I like to have friends. Why did I not have friends for a
- 12:40long time? Now, for example, so all this
- 12:44needs to, there's a numbness, has a lot of numbness on the
- 12:50personal and the collective level.
- 12:52And all this wants to become aware become alive, and this is
- 12:57a beautiful work, but sometimes it's also painful.
- 13:02Yes. Yes, which leads me to another
- 13:05observation. And question we as therapists we
- 13:10see patterns, right people come individually.
- 13:12They don't know each other. And yet, I think for many of us,
- 13:16our normal experience is that we see certain topics and issues to
- 13:22be be repeating themselves. At the same time, the
- 13:26individuals feel that they are unique and have this specific
- 13:32issue. On their own, a good friend of
- 13:35mine who also appeared on a previous episode.
- 13:39She is working a lot with her not exclusively and she has the
- 13:43same observation. She works with women and women
- 13:46come with their issues in self-identity and body issues,
- 13:51relationship issues, and they perceive themselves as if only,
- 13:56they have this issue. And for us, this contrast is so
- 14:01Stark because You know, I often find myself in a situation that
- 14:05wants to say, don't, you know, that so many people have a very
- 14:10similar issue. So again we have the connection
- 14:12between the individual suffering of a person and what we see is
- 14:18partly a societal level of that. Yeah.
- 14:22And I believe, I think it's true what you say and I believe that
- 14:27this is an unconscious benefit of feeling alone.
- 14:32How is that? Because my assumption is to feel
- 14:38alone or to go long for the world is not so nice.
- 14:43We are social beings to my assumption, my Approach in the
- 14:46work. So how can I even sustain that
- 14:50there must be some benefit in that?
- 14:54And one benefit is I'm unique in my and making myself like kind
- 15:01of covering myself and not connecting so much use me as it
- 15:07maybe as a benefit the feeling. Oh my problems are unique.
- 15:12At least I'm special in that. And when I feel like when I hear
- 15:17oh you have the same problem. Oh, there's also like for the
- 15:20Eco, there's a kind of deflating many times.
- 15:22It's like, okay, I'm not so special with my problem here.
- 15:25It's not but then another experience might kick in because
- 15:31then there is also an connected with you in my trouble in my
- 15:37struggle. And then there is a different
- 15:39way of a different perspective even to the world and then
- 15:44mayumi Candace, maybe doesn't need to come from a unique
- 15:49perspective on suffering, but uniqueness comes more from the
- 15:55creative part from a, from a creative Essence, from a
- 15:59contribution to life. So that's, of course, a totally
- 16:03different pathway. Yes, for we come to a concrete
- 16:08description and maybe you can give us some hints from from the
- 16:11men's Circle that got off, Brothers of heart. the you
- 16:17described before that part of the male experience in our
- 16:23society is a certain numbness and numbness towards how many of
- 16:29the institutions that we have crafted serve maybe a male
- 16:35perspective more than a few other perspective and also I
- 16:39guess it translates at least there's my experience to a
- 16:42certain numbness of Many Men of how they Themselves, how they
- 16:46feel themselves and what you just said, remind me of that,
- 16:51that may be one of the benefits of being alone might be that in
- 16:58spite of the numbness. That I feel I have in this world
- 17:05myself that I still can feel myself in a as unique or at
- 17:09least, I can give myself the title of being unique.
- 17:13Even though I don't feel myself as A unique individual, right?
- 17:17Exactly, that's what I mean. Like this is exactly why we
- 17:21talked about feeling unique. Feeling lonely, of course we we
- 17:24touch the topic of narcissism and and my perspective on that
- 17:32is I don't like so much to use this term because basically I
- 17:36believe the whole society is narcissistic so methods actually
- 17:39even differentiate. Yeah, so so that's a structural
- 17:45Of topic, I believe so. But, but again, what is what if
- 17:49I refuse to stay with this idea of narcissism?
- 17:54What is the benefit of that? And when I feel like when I
- 17:57translate it and when I try to explain it to someone who is not
- 18:01big of a experience of therapy, what is that?
- 18:05Well, for me, gnosis is a way of constructing a facet.
- 18:11And then there's a facet and you you I make you believe that I'm
- 18:16the perfect guy. That's one way of creating it.
- 18:22And then, of course, there is this loneliness inside, but
- 18:27actually in this is exactly what I made and what you want to is,
- 18:31what in this face ate. At least I have the sense of
- 18:35this is me. This is my first date.
- 18:40This is op how I constructed. This is your way.
- 18:44I put it together and the way I am trying to make you leave
- 18:49others that I am. Perfect, for example, is some
- 18:54ways, a lot of creativity in that to be the biggest Sports
- 18:59guy to be the biggest business guy.
- 19:02You know, there's a lot of creativity in that And there's a
- 19:06lot of Shadow involved. But again we need to look at the
- 19:09at the benefits of our patterns. Otherwise we will never get
- 19:18through them or get to any other Pathways I believe because why
- 19:23should we do it if it's so bad to be narcissistic.
- 19:27Yes, yes, it's obviously it serves a very fundamental
- 19:31function, right? Okay, so this is, I think we
- 19:36just scratched the conceptual part of it.
- 19:40It's obviously quite complex. And what is the most
- 19:43fascinating, and what is the most lacking?
- 19:45Maybe nowadays especially, is this connection of something
- 19:49that looks like an intimate individual experience and that
- 19:53that is connected with with a systemic.
- 19:57With a structural with a societal level.
- 20:00And this comes together when we start to reflect on being man,
- 20:05being, a woman, being female. So, how does that translate in?
- 20:10In the circles that you that you moderate, that you guide, we
- 20:16have those fancy Concepts on the one hand, how does it show?
- 20:19How what are some typical things problems?
- 20:24Hesitations questions that man? Who join and maybe the most
- 20:30interesting for me are men who don't have a therapeutic
- 20:33background but come driven through a curiosity and are
- 20:39innocent in that sense. What are you experience is there
- 20:42what are some repeating types or questions that come up?
- 20:47Vote for me, the revolution of creating a circle and online,
- 20:52circle is the circle. That's the revolution already
- 21:01because for many men when they come in for the first time, And
- 21:06even if it's just online and we see all the little tiles on our
- 21:11screens, like there is for many men.
- 21:15There is like There's a they touch all of a sudden something
- 21:22that they might not be aware of in the first place.
- 21:27It is like, oh, how do I feel when I come into a circle of
- 21:30man? It's being patched here.
- 21:34How safe do I feel how much of a man do?
- 21:39I feel with other men? And they're, so there might be
- 21:46so many times for men. They need to kind of relax into
- 21:54The possibility of. Yeah, I am here.
- 21:56I am part of a circle this many times needs a lot of time to
- 22:03become aware of. Okay.
- 22:05I'm actually part of this here. I am.
- 22:11Contributing in my ways. I'm being part of the circle by,
- 22:17and when you ask about, how does it work?
- 22:19Like the basic premise is you are in a circle and you share
- 22:28yourself. Period.
- 22:31Yeah, and that's already very exciting.
- 22:37So we have already a community, the circle and my feelings
- 22:42towards that. And then I am being asked to
- 22:45share. And then we are again.
- 22:47Many men are confronted with this topic of Being a man, these
- 22:56obvious questions of how should I be as a man?
- 23:00Like this is yes. Ongoing question.
- 23:04I believe, I knew it for myself being a boy like, okay.
- 23:09I, at some point, I realized how at some point I should I am
- 23:12supposed to be like, my dad. But how do I get there and how
- 23:18what does it mean? You can it support me in that
- 23:21who can show me what it is to be a man, many men.
- 23:24They have the experience. Nobody shows them.
- 23:28And so there is total insecurity and incoherence in their
- 23:32experience and they try to figure out.
- 23:36Okay. So in this film the main acts
- 23:38like this, oh this seems to be manly.
- 23:40Okay? So let's take this and there's
- 23:42some advertisement, let's take this This.
- 23:45So, we build our concept of being a man, and this needs to
- 23:50be, I believe uncovered, this needs to be deconstructed.
- 23:55Yes. So president do is understand
- 24:00you. There is the system doesn't know
- 24:03exactly how to behave, because it's an unusual environment.
- 24:06So this is relatively normal. I assume what would be a healthy
- 24:13healthy reaction would Be to be aware of that and to allow
- 24:17oneself to sink into this insecurity.
- 24:23Or at least to see myself grasping for hints of
- 24:32performance at would also be healthy because then it's, I can
- 24:37relate to it. I can communicate it.
- 24:38I can address it. Is that a big struggle for the
- 24:45participants? How long does it take for them
- 24:47to break through the shell of performance or the intuition to
- 24:52want to perform? Form, well, it's I feel Joy.
- 24:59When you say that that you say, oh, well would be healthy to
- 25:02fear insecurity to sink into it at, or feel how I am performing
- 25:06now. This leads quite a while and not
- 25:13for all for some and I believe what needs to be established is
- 25:21I know, I start to kind of detach myself for myself.
- 25:29Like many times in the beginning.
- 25:31Well, this is me. What, what are you talkin about?
- 25:35Me is me and then what we do in the work is that we allow more
- 25:41and more voices to come like when I allow myself to voice my
- 25:47fear, Voice it. You, if you have the capacity to
- 25:54to receive me in bed and I get the experience.
- 25:58Oh, my fear can be here in the space.
- 26:00You receive me. And all of a sudden, there's
- 26:04more than fear. There is also you.
- 26:07And with you there, I also become aware of myself having
- 26:11fear. So, all of a sudden there is a
- 26:13process of Detachment, not, because I'm not feeling, I'm
- 26:17not, I'm not going away from the Feeling, but I become aware.
- 26:21There's a kind of process of the Sympathetic witness of myself.
- 26:29I become aware of myself. All of a sudden we have to, I
- 26:36and me. And then it's like, oh now I
- 26:41have a feeling not I am the feeling, this is the beginning,
- 26:45I believe this is an hour and I when we are babies movie A
- 26:49Child, I am the feeling. I am anger, there's nothing
- 26:52else. And then in the development I
- 26:56have anger. That's already Bingo.
- 27:01Then we are already in a different game.
- 27:04Yes how does that translate into a group?
- 27:08MC. So one thing that it would
- 27:10assume is, as long as I'm a caught up in myself, judgment,
- 27:14which is the process that you described, how should I perform?
- 27:17What is a good mean? What is it?
- 27:18Bad me. And so on, as long as I'm in
- 27:21this trap of judgment judging myself, I think it's relatively
- 27:26easy to be stuck also in judging others, which would then lead to
- 27:30a conflict. How do conflicts in this group
- 27:34look like and how do you attempt to dissolve them?
- 27:39Well, again, I would like when you start about like this,
- 27:43judgment, like again, and what do I need a judgment for?
- 27:48That's the benefit. And I believe many men, and
- 27:51maybe also women the benefit of judging is I try to find my
- 27:59place in the world. I judge that you are bad and you
- 28:06are good and I put myself to the good guys, then I have my place
- 28:13and I can relax. Yeah, I think this is the
- 28:16benefit. So but that's of course,
- 28:20allegedly, that's the fantasy right back and relax.
- 28:23If I'm on the go, there's a shadow to it, I have to admit
- 28:26it. So, but to get through that,
- 28:33again, I need to become aware of it as you say.
- 28:37And when I take the needs, when I just take the need, I want to
- 28:43find my place in the world. So then it's when I feel that
- 28:54need Miss it. Okay.
- 28:58And what do I need to fill a place in the world?
- 29:01Then when I really am honest, I might land in the perspective.
- 29:05Oh, I just want to be like and basically, hmm.
- 29:12And we, of course, touch the constructions of being a man.
- 29:17But in this is my core question. When you ask about well, how is
- 29:20it complete? My core question in the work.
- 29:22Sometimes I named it. Sometimes it's an underlying.
- 29:27Question that I'm working with is what is it to be a man for
- 29:33you? And this sometimes it's even
- 29:39though. Oh what are you talking about?
- 29:42But then it's like, okay, so there is an individual.
- 29:48In the whole mess of masculinity.
- 29:53All of a sudden I can be, I just like I can have fear.
- 29:57I can have anger against shame. I can have joy.
- 30:02Well that's interesting. And then we come to a true
- 30:05uniqueness that does not need so much to face a tinny more and
- 30:13yes and this pathway. And you talk about conflict?
- 30:19Leads also, sometimes to come through conflict, of course.
- 30:24And so I have a good example like just last night we had a
- 30:31circle and one man. Would be very critical to say.
- 30:39The least about the corona measurements are having in
- 30:45Germany and he was very critical about it.
- 30:48And he brought this in and also really like this missing for
- 30:59himself to be vaccinated And then it turns out another man.
- 31:05Just has been vaccinated. And how.
- 31:10So that's, that's quite a potential for conflict and we
- 31:13can see it in our society. So, what the invitation for
- 31:19conflict was? Not taken because by what
- 31:26happened the man who was critical was skeptic was
- 31:31dismissing this possibility of vaccination would Express. his
- 31:38feelings about if you would say, I am afraid that this is
- 31:45becoming a tyranny. I am afraid that the structures
- 31:49are overtaking. And this touches an old fear in
- 31:55me, because when I was going into communities School company,
- 32:00whatever I needed to change and move needed, not to be like, I
- 32:04am and this touches the fear, and I'm angry about that, you
- 32:08know? So so that's the invitation to
- 32:13listen. That's the invitation to, okay?
- 32:18This is being touched here through the corona topic, but
- 32:22now you tell me about your fear, you tell me about your anger
- 32:27that is being touched. And then I can be with you
- 32:31regardless, if I'm Rex innate, it or not.
- 32:34Yes. So So we hear the invitation for
- 32:38convict, but there's also a possibility for invitation of
- 32:42meeting each other. And this is the invitation that
- 32:46I'm having and that I'm giving in the circuits, the most
- 32:50important tool is to listen to Listen to myself.
- 32:55To my feelings toward, I am experiencing now, but also to
- 32:59listen to another me. Okay, let me assume a critical
- 33:03position here and ask why That necessary because that starts to
- 33:09sound to me like psychological, you know, stretching when I say,
- 33:15that's a nations are bad. It already implies that I'm
- 33:19somehow uncomfortable about it. Why do I have to say on top of
- 33:23my conviction? That vaccination is bad, that it
- 33:26comes from and uncertainty of fears, a graphical thing, that's
- 33:30all, you know, cycle Babble. But why do I have to Go to this
- 33:37weird level of talking about my feelings and so on, doesn't
- 33:41everybody understand automatically that it comes from
- 33:44such a level? Well, if I look at our
- 33:48conversation in society, it seems not to be so easy to hear
- 33:54the underlying feelings or needs.
- 33:59And I think it's actually that's a crucial part of work and
- 34:05because many times, Times. And this is, I like it that you
- 34:09are critical here because many times, I believe we use topics.
- 34:17It can be the vaccination, it can be anything else we use
- 34:20topics. To, when I take this here and I
- 34:25take it now, 44, you this topic? I have a stick here.
- 34:30I take my stick and then you might say, no or yes, but many
- 34:36times this is an offer to come into a real conversation many
- 34:43times. It's not about that.
- 34:45What I'm offering and many men have learned. you know, my
- 34:51experience in, I love soccer games, I love, you know, but
- 34:56many times when when I see when I experienced group of men
- 35:00there, There needs to be some topic to be able to connect with
- 35:09each other. The topic of football, topic of
- 35:15politics. So something impersonal,
- 35:18impersonal, and on something objective, I have a ba you have
- 35:23a clone post. We need here we meet, we have a
- 35:28beer. Yeah, that's the idea.
- 35:32And what it reveals to me and nothing against be a nothing
- 35:36against soccer, but what it? It shows to me is the need for
- 35:41many men to become objective and to use objects.
- 35:49Why, what's the benefit of that the benefit is this gives me
- 35:53some sense of safety. When we talk about my favorite
- 35:58soccer team, we can talk about the players.
- 36:01We can is better sense of safety.
- 36:03And When we struggle about, why is Cristiano Ronaldo?
- 36:07The biggest guy in the world or not, we can be intimate by
- 36:13fighting. and it's beautiful to talk about it, but then, I can
- 36:21still hide my most personal my most intimate feelings, and I
- 36:28think we need to Open this. We don't need to dismiss it.
- 36:34Can still watch soccer games and we want to be available for
- 36:40something else. I believe.
- 36:43Yes, yes. So that's an interesting aspect
- 36:47of those kind of the topic, talk, right of talking about the
- 36:52world about politics or soccer, all these things.
- 36:55I wonder if there's another level to that, which is when I
- 36:58talk about when I express my conviction, right?
- 37:01Vaccinations are bad, or preconditions are good.
- 37:05A conviction is, is it expression about something in
- 37:10the world, right? And Can be true or false which
- 37:15means that basically, when I say that, I'm looking for
- 37:17confirmation. And when you listen to me, when
- 37:22I address you with my conviction but I'm basically asking you to
- 37:27confirm my view. And that I automatically bring
- 37:32you in the position of confirming or dismissing.
- 37:35What I hold is true. In contrast to that when I talk
- 37:41about my experience that I'm afraid of something, or I'm
- 37:44hesitant, or I'm insecure or happy or whatever it is, there
- 37:50is No debate about that. There is less, we are overly in
- 37:58a psychological, you know, context where we doubt, what is
- 38:01an authentic experience and so on in therapy, but in a normal
- 38:05conversation, right? When I when I add to my
- 38:10statement, that I don't like vaccinations and I add to that
- 38:14because I feel insecure, then I express something that cannot be
- 38:18really doubted. It's people will they will say
- 38:25well, your conclusion is wrong. You have to rethink your
- 38:28conclusion. That vaccinations are good or
- 38:30bad, but I give you that you feel insecure.
- 38:35So, what I kind of the invitation that I give out when
- 38:40I additionally express, my, my unique experience is that of
- 38:46relatability because I express something that cannot be taken
- 38:50away from me. Usually.
- 38:54So for me, this is an additional aspect of Why?
- 38:58There's such a big contrast between just expressing a
- 39:03conviction that I have because it invites confirmation is
- 39:07afraid of dismissal versus to express.
- 39:11A unique experience, an emotional experience or, and
- 39:16otherwise cognitive experience that I have.
- 39:19So, I would very much also emphasize or confirm your
- 39:26experience that It makes a huge difference if people express it.
- 39:33Yeah. And I also want to acknowledge,
- 39:37we need to have these discussions even political
- 39:40discussions. The discussions about Society,
- 39:43how do we want to go about the pandemic?
- 39:47Yeah, How do we? And I believe this is the beauty
- 39:51that we are experiencing in these times.
- 39:53I believe that we are wrestling. How we want to live as a
- 40:02community, as a global Community.
- 40:04How do you want to leave? What's important?
- 40:06Basically, there is a war of values and, but to, and I honor
- 40:14that and I want us to have these discussions but many times in
- 40:21this is also reflecting to what you say.
- 40:24I'm connecting here with what you?
- 40:27What you are expressing because, Many times when I have this
- 40:32strong position against or whatever, we can't have that.
- 40:39But many times there is an emotional, underlying thing
- 40:44creeping in. This makes why I believe this is
- 40:48good or bad. Yeah, and then this is also
- 40:51fine. But when I'm not aware of that,
- 40:55I come from a place that is not mature.
- 41:00And this and I believe our journey of the Soul.
- 41:06This needs to collapse. However, immature positions need
- 41:12to collapse. Why?
- 41:13Because then I land in my truth and say, oh wait a second.
- 41:18There was an old anger here coming in.
- 41:22This is why I had this position. Let me take care of my anger.
- 41:26When I do that, I am in myself in a different place in a more
- 41:31mature, what does it mean mature?
- 41:32I own my feelings. When I do that, then there is a
- 41:38Detachment again from my old feeling and my position, and
- 41:44then I can totally relate to what's happening in the world in
- 41:47a different way. Then, I can still say no to this
- 41:52or to that, but I come from a different place and I will be
- 41:55heard in a way different aspect of many from any other people
- 42:01because we all know, if someone tells us something that is
- 42:05really A worthwhile, listening, we listen.
- 42:10And if someone is coming from a immature place, we say.
- 42:15I hear you. It's not really working.
- 42:18Yes. So to become a really political
- 42:23man or woman, I need to take care of my feelings to be really
- 42:27clear in my message. You described again, things that
- 42:32that would contribute to a maturity in the social
- 42:35discussion, but you experience it in the microcosm of your
- 42:39circle, the the brothers of heart.
- 42:43So you Said that it is a cycle of 10 meetings.
- 42:48Usually what are your experiences of the Dynamics?
- 42:53How many sessions so many settings meetings?
- 42:56Does it take? So that a group of individuals
- 42:59becomes a circle that relates to each other, where the
- 43:04performances go down, where people can address more and more
- 43:08of the emotional undercurrent as you described.
- 43:12So that there is in front of your eyes and guided by topics
- 43:16and guided by moderation, that there is a maturity, amateur
- 43:20ring going on. How would you describe this
- 43:23cycle and the development? I have Willie different
- 43:30experiences. There's a beauty sometimes in
- 43:38when it's one, when the circle in the main are coming from one
- 43:44culture, for example, from Germany because then there is
- 43:47coherence already cultural coherence.
- 43:52And this sometimes and there is of course the language and this
- 43:55sometimes allows men to relax and then it blows the wave of
- 44:02intimacy. Of coming closer or being
- 44:06farther away is kind of a little bit smoother.
- 44:13When we have a mix of ran of international coming from all
- 44:19different places. The beauty there is like there
- 44:24is first of all there might be more of a challenge.
- 44:27Or what does this American man talk about?
- 44:30Because it's for me it's quite clear that the perspectives on
- 44:35masculinity are really different in the u.s. than in Europe.
- 44:40So I need to start to relate and find of feel that but this might
- 44:46really help me to become more aware of my own bubble.
- 44:52So, this might be experienced as a challenge, but then it's also
- 44:55there's a beauty. And this there, the invitation
- 44:57is to feel more. Oh, and what us apart from
- 45:01Collective and cultural perspectives, what is actually
- 45:06connecting us. So that's also a beauty and and
- 45:10then it depends on the man. What's more for him?
- 45:14Like is it more needed to have this cultural?
- 45:18Coherence in the beginning or is it more opening if there are
- 45:23internet? So there's a difference.
- 45:24I believe yes. And yet, there is also a you
- 45:28focused on the individual experience.
- 45:30There is also the level of the group dynamic so just connecting
- 45:34to what you said in the beginning that in when men enter
- 45:37the circle often, they try to find out what is good behavior
- 45:40here. What is bad behavior here?
- 45:43I guess that with time, when I as an individual perceived that
- 45:47more and more More men connect in a certain way to each other
- 45:51and to themselves that it gives me permission to do something
- 45:55similar and make me more courageous to attempt that.
- 45:58So I wonder if, you know those if you have experienced those
- 46:02points where the the atmosphere seems to switch into a different
- 46:06mode when before there was individualism hesitation
- 46:11performance and so on and then it seems to switch into oh, now
- 46:15they get it and now there is a group flow.
- 46:18People who can relate to each other.
- 46:24I start again with the individual but then I hear a
- 46:28question about the group dynamics when one individual has
- 46:35some kind of a rule there, when one individual really becomes
- 46:42vulnerable versus himself in violently from the heart.
- 46:48Many times, this isn't open. And for some men, it's scary.
- 46:58Disgusting and I don't like no. So again there are some kind of
- 47:09There's a sense of Koreans again, that might be applying
- 47:13there, but it's not for all and it's depends really on the
- 47:20circle on the group. if this is happening or not, What I can say
- 47:29as a rule, maybe as an experience.
- 47:35It depends a lot. How I bring myself in, or not
- 47:42you as the moderator as the moderator?
- 47:45Yes, because I'm not only the moderator in.
- 47:50This is a balance for me and the work I see.
- 47:54And because my experience like, you know, when I offer a circle
- 48:00of men and say listen we want to find out what kind of man we
- 48:06are. And if I then would say but you
- 48:10will never know who I am. I'm a white screen here for you.
- 48:17You just share is just worried. Yes, so you as you are feeling
- 48:21as a man in this group meeting this of them.
- 48:24Yes. And I need And this is a
- 48:28balance, it's sometimes delicate.
- 48:32I always want to make sure that it's not about me.
- 48:37The circle is about man. And that, it's that this circle
- 48:44is really working for each man. Also needs me to become part of
- 48:53it. In.
- 48:57Some sense that I need to. I believe the need for many men
- 49:05is, let me feel you. Hey, what kind of man are you?
- 49:10And they want to note from the participants they want to.
- 49:13Also note from me sometimes test me as I say, when I give you
- 49:17this jab, do you sleep still keep standing here or not?
- 49:23There needs to be this kind of. Okay, I need to feel your power.
- 49:27I need to feel your your guts. And that's fine.
- 49:30That's part of the work. It needs to happen.
- 49:33Otherwise it's kind of not really embodied and it's not
- 49:38really lame me. Yes.
- 49:41So that's what I can share from my experience.
- 49:46This is why I when when I find black what is my role?
- 49:52I consider myself. While you could say I'm the
- 49:55facilitator moderator. And so I the fact Oh I express
- 50:01it. Like I'm the guardian and the
- 50:05guardian who needs to see, where is every man.
- 50:11But the man also need to see me. It's both ways.
- 50:16Yes, maybe the last question about this topic you also work
- 50:21with individual clients. How do you integrate this
- 50:25experience on this perspective that you have on men and Society
- 50:28men? And with themselves.
- 50:30How do you integrate it in your individual work?
- 50:41Well, the intricate always is, of course, the individual who
- 50:44comes and what he brings, what I feel is important.
- 50:54Many times is to give a reflection, for example, that
- 51:01this feeling that this man brings, or this experience is,
- 51:05maybe not only his struggle is might be so, at some point, and
- 51:13so my role sometimes is to give a perspective also, I believe.
- 51:22The whole journey of the Soul, strong part of it is to come
- 51:28from separation to differentiation.
- 51:35So many men come from a place of separating feeling separated
- 51:39from their roots from their families, from society from
- 51:43themselves. And then, there needs to be a
- 51:47journey I believe in my part of it is how you're feeling now.
- 51:52Now, yeah, it's very individual, but maybe this is not only your
- 51:56feeling, you have, but maybe you experienced this also from your
- 51:59family and then there is okay. Yeah, yes, maybe true.
- 52:06And then there's also a connection maybe to the
- 52:08collective. And then there is starts to be
- 52:11more of a differentiating. My overwhelm with a feeling is
- 52:18not just me, having that fear, whatever it is anger.
- 52:27But it's also for my dad and this already.
- 52:31Many men, relaxes said, okay, it's not just mine, not my heavy
- 52:37duty only to take that I can leave this to my dad.
- 52:42And I feel myself more being individuated and in that sense
- 52:48differentiated from the parents or the family and this gives
- 52:54more self-awareness in a good sense.
- 52:57This is one way of kind of allowing this in and also I
- 53:03guess it allows a different kind of integration, right?
- 53:05So not just among the community of men today and not just in the
- 53:10society but also an Aggregation into my ancestry ancestral
- 53:17family. Yes, do come aware that.
- 53:21There's a beautiful book about this.
- 53:23You didn't start with you, hmm. And to become aware how it
- 53:27didn't start with me, okay? But it can end with me this
- 53:35intergenerational pattern that might has been contributed to
- 53:40myself in the Yeah, I experienced most personally some
- 53:46for example, emotional violence but it wouldn't start with my
- 53:50dad with my grandfather. Yeah.
- 53:56Can end with me by taking care of it.
- 53:59Yes, I have a last question that is connected that we focused on
- 54:04men in this conversation. I don't know, actually, but I
- 54:09assume that you also work with women and you have such an
- 54:15interesting set of experiences through the men Circle and this
- 54:19general interest in the topic and for decades or Already.
- 54:26It's a widely publicized issue of not understanding each other,
- 54:33right? That men don't understand.
- 54:34Women, women don't understand men, a lot of stand-up comedy is
- 54:37about that topic. It's very repetitive in that
- 54:39sense. It does.
- 54:43It does the opportunity come up if and when you work with women,
- 54:48to let them partake in this experience and to help them to
- 54:54get some inside when it's Out relationship issues or anything
- 54:59concerning men that they can benefit from this.
- 55:04This specific set of interests that you have.
- 55:09Well, there's one, there's two ways actually one way is that I
- 55:14offer also circles on what I call fruits of the roots, about
- 55:19the incest. We work that we notice in the
- 55:22background. So there's this is one part.
- 55:25The other part is, I believe, it's so thank you for the
- 55:28question because it's really crucial for me to include women
- 55:33and The Feminine also and the work with man, first of all,
- 55:37don't want to exclude because um, man circles exclude women,
- 55:42if they don't think this is right, huh?
- 55:45So that's important for me, but your question refers to
- 55:48something else and the women can benefit.
- 55:52When I work with my partner, my partner, Giuliana, we offer
- 55:57together this Workshop, called wide piece and we we had this
- 56:06beautiful workshop for example, in Israel.
- 56:09When we offer a new way of relating she and I offer that.
- 56:16And then we part of it is to work separately with men and
- 56:21women and then to create a new connection and new way of
- 56:25connecting with each other. So that's of course, one way of
- 56:29really letting this work, this is come into this conversation
- 56:36with more nothing. Thank you so much for your time
- 56:42and for this conversation I would be interested to have
- 56:45another conversation. Exactly about that aspect The
- 56:48ancestral work that you do. We focused on the work with men
- 56:53today. Let's see if that comes with to
- 56:55fruition but certainly I will leave some links below both to
- 57:00your side, to the work with your partner.
- 57:04Giuliana and the I guess people will find all the information.
- 57:09Sorry about both brothers of hearts and fruits of the roots
- 57:14and I'm very grateful for the open exchange that we have and
- 57:20additionally to the conversations that we have had
- 57:22in the past where I got some glimpses about your work, I got
- 57:27more complete, not complete but at least more information so
- 57:31that I can I can picture more about the specific work that you
- 57:36do. So thank you for this.
- 57:39Conversation, I really enjoyed it.
- 57:41Thank you. Listen, putting with you.
- 57:39Conversation, I really enjoyed it.
- 57:41Thank you. Listen, putting with you.