Latest / ZoukNerds • Learn | Build | Belong / Nationality & Pay: Zouk's Ugly Truth (S05 Ep44)
Transcript
- 0:00There are so many leaders and followers out there that are as
- 0:04good and in some cases better than Brazilian born, raised and
- 0:09training teachers. Or because you are Brazilian?
- 0:11We know more than you just by the fact that our passport is
- 0:14from Brazil. You.
- 0:15Know it's absolutely the saddest, the worst thing for
- 0:18anybody to say that a teacher is not as good as them just because
- 0:21they're not Brazilian. A good competitor doesn't mean a
- 0:24good teacher. I want a community that is safe,
- 0:27comfortable, knowledgeable, growing, exclusive, and embraces
- 0:31everybody. What makes a dance teacher truly
- 0:35authentic? Does it matter where they're
- 0:38born, and does that impact how much they get paid?
- 0:43Well, let's find out. Hello.
- 0:45Hello everyone and welcome back to Zook Nerds.
- 0:48In this episode we are tackling a topic often we spread about
- 0:53but rarely discussed publicly. What makes a dance teacher truly
- 0:58authentic? Does a teacher's nationality
- 1:01dictate their status or skill? Is a Brazilian Zook teacher
- 1:05inherently more authentic just for being Brazilian?
- 1:09Let's discuss these perceptions whilst we share insights from
- 1:13our journey and talk about what truly contributes to a teacher's
- 1:17impact in our SO let's go. Hello, hello everyone and
- 1:30welcome back to another episode. My name is Alison Sanji and
- 1:35let's welcome back our beautiful Co host Di Prada.
- 1:38Hello, GI. Hello, guys.
- 1:40Welcome back. Welcome back, Alison.
- 1:43We are here today to talk about something a little bit
- 1:48controversial polemic and that we believe a lot of people talk
- 1:55about this, but maybe not publicly.
- 1:57So we're here to do that. We have received these requests
- 2:01multiple times, especially recently.
- 2:05And I also have heard about this over the years, which is what
- 2:10makes a teacher authentic. Does it matter if somebody is
- 2:17from a country where the dance is from?
- 2:19So let's say, does an Argentinian person automatically
- 2:25gets more status, credibility and payment in Argentine tango?
- 2:31There's a Brazilian dancer gets more status, payment, contracts,
- 2:36fame in Brazilian Zook or somebody got Fiera and all of
- 2:40the other dance styles just for being Brazilian.
- 2:43And you can go on and on and on for all the other dance styles.
- 2:47Is it true? Is it real?
- 2:49Does it really happen in the community?
- 2:52Well, I have a lot to say. I have a lot to say about this
- 2:57and I think Guy and I are in a very special position because
- 3:01both of us have not actually had Brazilian dance partners, which
- 3:07is quite rare for a lot of the teachers that travel around and
- 3:13do this. For as long as we have done, we
- 3:15haven't had Brazil indents partners for whatever reason.
- 3:19For me, it was because my entire career has been outside of
- 3:22Brazil. So, you know, I had local
- 3:25people, local partners that I worked with for guy.
- 3:30I believe the same situation being in the US from the
- 3:33beginning of a like a teaching career.
- 3:36But I want to start just by saying that I don't believe in
- 3:41that because there are so many leaders and followers out there
- 3:46that are as good and in some cases better than Brazilian
- 3:51born, raised and training teachers.
- 3:54But I can see how that can be an issue and how that issue
- 4:00actually exists in terms of payment, credibility,
- 4:04authenticity, and all of those things.
- 4:07What do you think about that guy?
- 4:08Man, it's such a good topic. It's such a tricky one too.
- 4:13Although I didn't have Brazilian partners, I did have Brazilian
- 4:16partners for collaborations. I'd collaborate with Paloma for
- 4:20some time. We'll do it again with Brenda as
- 4:23well. So I, I did have those
- 4:26collaborations. I did not, never had like a full
- 4:30on partner, let alone a Brazilian 1, you know.
- 4:34So yeah, it is an interesting position.
- 4:37It is an interesting topic as always, like to make food
- 4:40analogies about everything that is related to dance and also
- 4:44like language analogies as well. For example, learning Chinese.
- 4:49I looked someone from Taiwan to learn Chinese, to learn Mandarin
- 4:55Chinese. I look from someone from Taiwan
- 4:58that I could learn from that would explain to me from a
- 5:02Taiwanese perspective and the expressions from there and
- 5:05everything else. However, I was watching these
- 5:08videos about language learning and the recommendation sometimes
- 5:12is that you learn from somebody that speaks your language and
- 5:17learn the other one because then they will be able to explain to
- 5:21you the language that he wanted to learn from their perspective
- 5:24of your own. And then my resonate better.
- 5:27And doing my classes with my tutor from Taiwan, I realized
- 5:34there was sometimes several limitations because he had a
- 5:36hard time translating what he wanted to say in English.
- 5:42And then when I had them speak with my, for example, with my
- 5:46friends from Singapore that speak English really well, and
- 5:49then they would like very quickly tell me the equivalence,
- 5:54you know. So I was like, I was going for
- 5:56the authentic stuff. And the authentic stuff was
- 5:59really good because I was learning all the expressions,
- 6:02all the things from Taiwan. But in terms of the structure of
- 6:08the language in a more base basic form, it was actually
- 6:12harder. And then someone who speaks
- 6:14English as well could explain to me this basic structure is
- 6:19better because we are speaking a common language to translate the
- 6:23new language, you know? So in terms of learning how to
- 6:28dance, that's super interesting because in tango, for example, I
- 6:33only had Brazilian teachers for a long time.
- 6:39And I remember when I went to Argentina to learn tango there,
- 6:44I was like, OK, this is cool. But I ran back to my Brazilian
- 6:48teachers because they could translate tango in a way that I
- 6:53could understand. It made sense.
- 6:55And making the connection with somebody.
- 6:57You got Fiera with Bolero, with Foja, with Zook.
- 7:01So there was this common language because the way that
- 7:04the Argentinians would teach was so different.
- 7:08And they had a feeling of the dance.
- 7:11They were already so embodied in the archetype, in the spirit of
- 7:16the dance, that it just exudes from their bodies.
- 7:19And they would say, then you, then you do this.
- 7:23And you're like, do what? So until I could feel the
- 7:28movement, feel that energy, feel that, you know, that if you're
- 7:33an aspect of the dance, I needed someone to translate it to me.
- 7:36And my Brazilian teachers did it really well, you know, But for
- 7:42sure, whenever we would bring an Argentinian teacher in
- 7:46authenticity, authority, all these things, these things are
- 7:50implied. You know, we wouldn't research
- 7:54who this person is just by the fact that he's from Argentina.
- 7:57Authorities implied just by the fact they are Argentinian
- 8:01people, Argentinian dancers that teach tango, double authority,
- 8:06you know, So yes, was more expensive.
- 8:10And yes, we by default would think that they knew more.
- 8:15But then in the class, sometimes we would learn cool things.
- 8:20But in my head it was like, oh, I like my, I like my, my local
- 8:25teachers more. You know, there was more like
- 8:29being exposed to something new, to something truly authentic.
- 8:33They were speaking in Spanish. They were speaking Portuguese,
- 8:37sometimes with a heavy Spanish accents.
- 8:40They moved in a particular way. They had all the little tricks
- 8:46and things that the tan ghettos have, and that was nice to see.
- 8:50But that didn't mean better learning experience necessarily.
- 8:55But in many cases it meant being exposed to how the thing can be
- 9:02when it's in it's like traditional form in its maximum
- 9:08form. So it was 2 experiences was like
- 9:11the learning one and the let's say get inspired one or getting
- 9:17different input one I might say. So I will start there with my
- 9:22experience, like learning Tango for example.
- 9:25And that's exactly how I see it, because I think there's
- 9:29different stages of your dance that one may be better than the
- 9:33other. For example, when people ask me,
- 9:36oh, you know, I want to really get good at Zook and I want to
- 9:40go to Brazil and spend 3 months there.
- 9:42And then they asked me if I think it's a good idea.
- 9:47And that really depends because it depends on the level that you
- 9:52are at the moment. For example, I wouldn't really
- 9:56recommend you to fully go to Japan or Taiwan to learn their
- 10:03local language like Mandarin or Japanese if you didn't quite
- 10:07understand the structure well enough to be able to absorb as
- 10:12much as you can when you're there in person, right?
- 10:15So for example, to Start learning from a teacher from
- 10:21that country made actually not be that beneficial because they
- 10:26cannot relate to you or explain to you in a way that makes sense
- 10:30to you in your local life, in your local habits or even
- 10:35analogies in your own language or country culture and things
- 10:39like that. So I normally say, look, learn
- 10:42as much as you can from the teachers that are local to you,
- 10:45that are available to you for like one or two years.
- 10:49And then once you really have a good understanding and You Can
- 10:54Dance really confidently with a lot of people, then you go and
- 11:00you have that experience. Because a lot of the times the
- 11:04teachers in Brazil were not going to be able to give you
- 11:08that relatable reference or that explanation that is going to
- 11:15make sense to you in your own head because of the language
- 11:20barrier and things like that. But they will be able to give
- 11:23you the feeling or maybe that vibe in the atmosphere.
- 11:28So now we're talking about more like the quality of teaching.
- 11:33I don't think 1 is more quality than the other.
- 11:36So somebody from Argentina or from Brazil or from whatever
- 11:41country, they are not necessarily automatically
- 11:44better. So I don't believe they should
- 11:47automatically get paid more just because of their nationality or
- 11:52because they were trained on that place.
- 11:56But it's more about how well they teach.
- 12:00I've seen so many classes by non Brazilians who I believed were
- 12:06much better for that group and for that type of student.
- 12:11Then classes that I've seen masters of Brazilian dancing
- 12:16teaching to those same people. And I'm talking for example in
- 12:20Australia for like 12 years that I was there.
- 12:24I'll see a lot of the Australian teachers who trained very hard
- 12:28and study like crazy to understand the dance they could
- 12:32to make the students progress better and faster and more
- 12:35consistently than a teacher that would come in and stay there for
- 12:40like a month or so. Because they kind of didn't
- 12:43really understand how to communicate with the students,
- 12:46how to relate to their students. And another thing that I think
- 12:51is mega important and I am very, very passionate about is about
- 12:57learning all their styles for the sake of being able to
- 13:02understand and communicate to people in the language that they
- 13:07are used to. So I always learn as many styles
- 13:10as possible. I learn all of the other dances
- 13:15because I want to help somebody who comes from a different dance
- 13:20style and tell them, see, like when you do this in Kazuma or
- 13:24when you do this in West Coast Swing, you have this feeling you
- 13:27have this type of connection. So it's quite similar, but the
- 13:31difference is we do this instead of like completely erasing and
- 13:36ignoring that previous knowledge that they have and going like,
- 13:39no, no, no, no, no, this is Brazilian Zook.
- 13:41Forget about yourself. So forget about your West Coast
- 13:43wing, forget about your whatever.
- 13:45I don't want you to forget. I want to bridge that gap and I
- 13:49want to make it easier for you to understand that at least to
- 13:52the very, very beginning on how to connect the dots so you feel
- 13:56more confident, so you feel that You Can Dance and learn faster.
- 14:00And eventually as we progress, we go like, so remember when I
- 14:04told you it was similar? Now we need to work on the
- 14:07feeling. Now we need to work on how the
- 14:13body needs to move differently, how the connection needs to be
- 14:19communicated differently, because there is a wall or a
- 14:23ceiling that you're going to hit if you don't start working on
- 14:27those things. So yes, it's very fast for
- 14:31somebody who dance another style to come and learn Brazilian Zook
- 14:33and PPP. OK, yeah, I'm a Zook dancer.
- 14:36I'm going to go to Brazil. Not yet, in my opinion, Not yet
- 14:41because your accent may still be too strong or the structure may
- 14:48not be strong enough for you to absorb what the experience that
- 14:53you're going to have in Brazil can provide you.
- 14:56So yeah, it's a danger zone that I that I ask the students to be
- 15:00a little bit careful with. Interesting.
- 15:03You know, there is, I think, conscious unconscious bias about
- 15:11someone's skill or mastery of something based on where they
- 15:15are from. If they are from the place where
- 15:18the dance is from, I think by default you're going to be like,
- 15:22probably knows really well this thing probably has been dancing
- 15:25for a long time. I remember when my boss at the
- 15:31law firm that I used to work on, she had this like ongoing never
- 15:37ending pains on her neck and her arm that she would wake up
- 15:41locked like this, you know, And she was doing acupuncture for I
- 15:47think maybe 10 years with this guy, with this Brazilian guy.
- 15:52And then she was like, man, I need something more.
- 15:55And then she heard about there was this Chinese guy living in
- 15:59Bottafogo. There was an acupuncturist, but
- 16:02he was way more expensive. You know, like one session with
- 16:07him was like 3 session with a guy.
- 16:09And then it's funny because when I heard she's saying this thing,
- 16:13I said you should totally go. The guy's Chinese.
- 16:17He's probably going to be amazing, you know?
- 16:19So my bias kicked in immediately.
- 16:21Acupuncture, Chinese boom experts.
- 16:26I know nothing just by the fact that he was Chinese and it
- 16:30happened that he wasn't did really good.
- 16:32So she went there and she said with four needles, he did the
- 16:38whole thing. And I remember being with my
- 16:41acupuncturist with 18 and with four needles, and then he put
- 16:45one in my ear. He turned it and I felt a little
- 16:47shocked and then my body unlocked again.
- 16:50So I have this bias too, that sometimes when I want to learn
- 16:55something, I want to go authentic.
- 16:58I want to learn from someone from the place.
- 17:01Because there is this idea that because someone is from the
- 17:04place, he is immersed in the culture, so he'll be able to
- 17:07explain something to me that is beyond technicality.
- 17:12That person will be able to explain to me.
- 17:14Feels make analogies, make these relationships.
- 17:18Because I had this conversation one time with a Brazilian, with
- 17:24a Brazilian couple from Sao Paulo, and they were saying, I
- 17:29think it makes sense that we charge more.
- 17:32And that is it's perceived that we make more because honestly,
- 17:36and I don't know why. Listen, if you know, I don't
- 17:40know how much actually we make versus non Brazilian couples or
- 17:45non Brazilian teachers make, I really don't know numbers like
- 17:49objectively, but I know that based on what organizers say,
- 17:55Miss Moore and they said to me, they told me we practice several
- 18:03hours a day every day. We social dance a lot, we do a
- 18:08lot of courses, we go to the studio almost everyday.
- 18:13So I think by the sheer amount of time that is spent in the
- 18:18craft, the amount of time that is spent social dancing and
- 18:23learning is a way in their minds, to justify making more,
- 18:28you know? And that made a lot of sense to
- 18:31me. The question was also why
- 18:34Brazilian dancers are seen as better, why Brazilian teachers
- 18:39seem as better, not necessarily teachers, dancers.
- 18:42And how come they get so good? How come they get so good so
- 18:45fast? And it's simple.
- 18:48We just do the dance way more. And this was a discussion that I
- 18:52was having with a teacher when we were in Taipei together where
- 18:57he was saying, GI, do you know what is the only difference
- 19:02between these dancers here in Taipei and the dancers in
- 19:05Brazil? And I said, no, he said time
- 19:09with the dance. If we give this dances here the
- 19:13same amount of time with the dance that people in Brazil are
- 19:16able to have, they're going to go far and beyond.
- 19:19The next teachers are going to come from here.
- 19:22They're going to travel from here.
- 19:23They're going to be as good, you know, in terms of technique, but
- 19:28in terms of like the feeling of the dance, like that cultural
- 19:33thing that is really hard to grasp and explain, that is way
- 19:37harder. That's that's when I do
- 19:39recommend that the students go to Brazil, not necessarily to
- 19:44learn the dance, but you feel how social dancing can be,
- 19:48especially for the followers. Especially for the followers,
- 19:53because the leaders in Brazil are different creatures, you
- 19:56know, but when it comes to technique.
- 20:01When it comes to learning the dance like within ginormous
- 20:05quotes properly in this idea of learning the ways, learning the
- 20:09pathways, time with the dance, I think my people is the great
- 20:15differentiating factor, you know?
- 20:18Not the authenticity of your teacher or whatever.
- 20:21It's more, Yeah, exactly. It's all about time, practice,
- 20:26dedication, training. And I agree with you, like why
- 20:31majority of the times you see a Brazilian teacher, you know,
- 20:36headlining an event or getting paid more here or there, it's
- 20:40because of the time invested, not because of the nationality.
- 20:44In my opinion. What I don't agree with and I
- 20:47don't like and I don't support as an organizer or as a member
- 20:51of the community is when either the community or the artists
- 20:56themselves just give themselves that credit without actually
- 21:01earning it. Yes.
- 21:03You know, when I have been in communities where it's sad, but
- 21:08teachers will actually voice it and go like, well, you know, I
- 21:13am from insert country here. So like of course I'm the best
- 21:18teacher here in the city when I know for a fact that they are
- 21:22not. They're just using the fact that
- 21:25they are born in a certain place to impose that authority without
- 21:29having earned and worked hard to get that credit from the people.
- 21:37And, you know, I think it only really works with people and
- 21:42with communities that haven't been exposed enough.
- 21:46And we are very, very lucky and blessed in that case for like
- 21:52online things and social media because nowadays we get access
- 21:57to a lot of information that we can go like on.
- 22:01That's good information, that's solid information.
- 22:04That's information that makes sense to me.
- 22:07And then you can make a better judgement of who is really a
- 22:13good teacher or who is just lying to you, you know, Blank
- 22:17point period. Because I unfortunately, I have
- 22:21seen over the years, especially before social media and online,
- 22:25things were more present people who were using their nationality
- 22:31to just, you know, take advantage of the situation,
- 22:36which I think is one of the negative and dark sides of this
- 22:41that I think it's important to talk about.
- 22:44When somebody like, for example, if we come here to Taipei and we
- 22:48look at the teachers here and we go like, no guys, you are, you
- 22:51are below us because you're not Brazilian.
- 22:53I could never say that. Yeah.
- 22:55Like, it's absolutely the saddest, the worst thing for
- 22:59anybody to say that a teacher is not as good as them just because
- 23:02they're not Brazilian. Like absolutely freaking not.
- 23:06I get, I get really, really annoyed by it and sometimes
- 23:10angry as well because I think it's so it's so unfair because
- 23:14it basically removes and discredits anything that those
- 23:19people may have done to achieve what they have achieved.
- 23:23And I think that's just wrong. Especially in the case of
- 23:26Taipei, know that we have, for example, 2 incredible teachers
- 23:30there, two incredible follower teachers who are not Brazilian.
- 23:33I mean, for that particular dance style name.
- 23:36For example, we have Magda, she's polished as we live in
- 23:40Taiwan for almost 2 decades, teaches Brazilian.
- 23:43Zook teaches really well and made this very intentional
- 23:50effort of travelling to Brazil, understanding how Brazilians
- 23:54dance, understanding this cultural aspect that is harder
- 23:58to grasp. Or she went there to feel a
- 24:00couple times, took classes, understood the thing.
- 24:03How can we, how could we come and say, oh, because we are
- 24:06Brazilian, we know more than you just by the fact that our
- 24:09passport is from Brazil, you know, and.
- 24:12And this happens all over the world.
- 24:14I mean, yeah, not just in Taipei.
- 24:16I'm sorry that we very often mention Taipei and DC and maybe
- 24:20Australia here in this podcast just because we spend so much
- 24:22time in those places. But we do travel to other
- 24:25communities around North America, Europe, Asia,
- 24:29Australia, Brazil that have those same things.
- 24:33Yes, there are examples in Europe as well, you know, like
- 24:37so many, so many. And not in case of Brazilian
- 24:41Zook, but in case of salsa or Cuban salsa or Afro Cuban with
- 24:47Mandy, you know, like I have seen her teaching her Afro
- 24:51Cuban. And she's a Taiwanese woman
- 24:54moving in a way that is so completely different from her
- 24:58culture. But you can see how immersed she
- 25:02is, is like she's an authority on that, on that movement, on
- 25:08that style, on that kind of dance.
- 25:10And she embodies the art form. And she explains the art form.
- 25:14She explains the movement, how they and where they're coming
- 25:17from. So she explained the feeling
- 25:19behind the movements, you know, so she's fully embodied in the
- 25:24art form. So showed completely deserve a
- 25:29pay that is as high as someone from the motherland from where
- 25:35the dance came from. However, in reality, I think if
- 25:39we have someone from there being called and her being called,
- 25:44there is a likely the likelihood of that person being paid more
- 25:49than she does is, is high because, you know, it's the
- 25:54perception of authority. And this is something that was
- 25:56really cool that I learned once that you have like your
- 26:00perception of authority and you have the actual authority, you
- 26:04know, like when you, when you build authority, like you, you
- 26:09earn the authority versus when the authority is perceived
- 26:14already. And then in this sense, just by
- 26:17the fact that the person is coming from the land of the
- 26:19dance, the perception of authority is almost automatic,
- 26:24you know, and that's hard for someone who is not from the
- 26:27motherland to, you know, to work with that because they would
- 26:31need to prove themselves a lot more in order to make
- 26:37themselves, you know, be understood, be seen as someone
- 26:41as a couple or as someone who understood this dance and can
- 26:46convey not only technique, but vibe, feeling and culture.
- 26:51So I think we are dealing with very intense human bias that is
- 26:56hard to, it's really hard to fight rationally.
- 27:01I think it's something that goes through a long period of time.
- 27:06And unfortunately, these couples who are not Brazilian, they do
- 27:11need to prove themselves more. They, they do need to work
- 27:14harder. And I think that the Brazilian
- 27:17Zook universe right now reach a stable point in what comes to
- 27:22new artists coming up. I think we are, we stabilized
- 27:27with the new names, maybe because at some point it was
- 27:30like 4 of them. And I think we are like more
- 27:34stable with what we have. So there might be some space for
- 27:41a new couple to emerge and there might be some space for a new
- 27:44couple or a new artist leader of follow to emerge not from
- 27:49Brazil. I think there is like a a gap
- 27:52there that could be filled. And that's the thing, like most
- 27:56recently, I think in Brazil, the competition has been so strong,
- 28:00yeah, that people are actually training super hard and they are
- 28:04coming out of Brazil monsters, OK?
- 28:07I'm not discrediting that because right now competition in
- 28:11Brazil is very, very, very high. But looking 10 years back or
- 28:17even more, I wouldn't say it was the same.
- 28:19It was very much like, OK, you're good in Brazil.
- 28:23As soon as you step outside, you're God.
- 28:25And that's something that, you know, that's something that
- 28:28doesn't go down with me because I would see back then,
- 28:31especially back then, a lot of people who, as you mentioned,
- 28:35had to work three times as hard and they wouldn't get credit
- 28:41just because they were not coming out of Brazil, you know?
- 28:45And that really hurts me because I'm like, bro, that, that
- 28:48that's, that's just not fair. That's just not fair.
- 28:52OK. Unfortunately, the community
- 28:55didn't have enough, you know, references to make a good
- 28:59judgement. I think now the community also
- 29:02with the references, with the exposure, the community is
- 29:04smart, very, very smart. And they can pick and select who
- 29:08were they once had deserved that credit and who are the ones who
- 29:12are like, you know, just pretending or giving themselves
- 29:18that credit. And I think it's very important
- 29:21to say also that at least from my experience and over this last
- 29:2720 years, every time I spoke to other teachers of Brazilian
- 29:32Zook, like master teachers, very, very credited teachers,
- 29:38what do they think about this topic?
- 29:40They always told me no, Anderson.
- 29:43I don't believe that the nationality matters because I
- 29:46have seen so many people that are just as good and sometimes
- 29:50better than a lot of people trained in Brazil because they
- 29:54train 3510 times harder. So at least from my perspective,
- 30:01these thing that happens or maybe separation and different
- 30:07pay and all of that, to be very honest, it's not something that
- 30:11starts from the artists themselves pushing and
- 30:15separating the non Brazilians. It's more like the perception of
- 30:19the community, the bias of the community going like, well,
- 30:23that's a Brazilian teacher. That's not I'm going to go to
- 30:25that one instead of that Brazilian teacher going like,
- 30:29don't go to that one because they're not Brazilian.
- 30:32That sometimes happens, I know. But I'm just saying like
- 30:35generally speaking from everywhere that I've been in
- 30:39spoken with, most artists are actually extremely, extremely
- 30:43supportive of everybody. And I, to be honest, have a
- 30:49little bit more support and bias for the non Brazilians because I
- 30:55know how hard they work. And I appreciate that, you know,
- 30:59in every event that I organize, everything that I do, I try to
- 31:02do my best to support those who are working hard.
- 31:08And I don't care where your passport nationality is from.
- 31:12I see your work, I see what you do.
- 31:14I see the quality, I see the effort, I see the dream.
- 31:19And to me, that's what matters. Yeah, 'cause they have to
- 31:22compensate for the lacking of opportunities to this that the
- 31:27presidents have. So Brazilians, you know, and I
- 31:31say Brazilians, I say people in the axis, Rio, Sao Paulo, Bello,
- 31:36Rizzo and she, they have more opportunities to social dance.
- 31:40You know, people from other places just don't have as many.
- 31:43So they do need to like, work harder.
- 31:45So bringing them in to teach you are rewarding the effort that
- 31:50was made to bring this dance to this new place, sometimes in the
- 31:56other side of the world. So someone is making like a
- 31:59ginormous efforts to bring the dance to a new place.
- 32:02We're talking about Europe, but there's so many community
- 32:06leaders who are primary followers who are working so
- 32:10much to bring the dance to their communities and to grow the
- 32:14dance and have to find ways to compensate for the lacking of
- 32:20opportunities that they have to social dance.
- 32:23And they make it happen, you know, and they find a way to
- 32:26explain the dance in a way that resonates with those who are
- 32:30around them, that can bring people in that can, you know,
- 32:34explain the dance to a group of people that would not get the
- 32:38dance otherwise. All these things are there is
- 32:41the thing more on who provides the opportunities for people to
- 32:44teach Zook, the local community, the leaders and organizers, you
- 32:49know, and there is a tendency of bringing the Brazilian artists
- 32:54because we want to bring the real thing, right?
- 32:57And then it comes back to my experience at helping organize
- 33:03the Zook track and interfusion where not for Brazilian Zook,
- 33:08but mostly for the other art forms.
- 33:11When the organizer realized, man, I'm bringing these people
- 33:14from abroad to teach this thing, but I have this local teacher
- 33:17here who was really good and we end up teaching beginner stuff
- 33:22like intro contents over and over again.
- 33:25Why am I going to bring this very expensive someone from this
- 33:29other place where I can just give an opportunity for the
- 33:32local person who is working to build the community, You know?
- 33:35And I like that. And I have a fun anecdote.
- 33:38Interesting, ironic to tell there in my first days teaching
- 33:43Brazilians, look here, my first years, the people who told me
- 33:48that I need to put my prices up, none of them were Brazilians.
- 33:52None of them, you know. And to this day, I know there
- 33:57are local from the United States teachers who charge more than I
- 34:02do, you know? So like, I think here in the
- 34:05United States, you might be slightly different in certain
- 34:09cases, in specific cases. But the three times that I
- 34:13heard, oh, you were too cheap, you need to make your prices
- 34:17higher. They were all local teachers,
- 34:21you know. So like, I think that's maybe
- 34:23something that people who are listening would not expect.
- 34:27But it happened to me three times.
- 34:29So the three times I raised my prices, it was because a local
- 34:33teacher told me that I was too cheap.
- 34:35And it's very interesting what you mentioned about within
- 34:39Brazil that happens. Yeah.
- 34:42You know, so it's not about just being Brazilian or not, but
- 34:46like, for example, Brazil is such a huge place that when you
- 34:51go to the north of Brazil in a local community and then you
- 34:54have this teacher coming from Rio, you know, it's red carpet
- 34:58and all of the things because it's like they're coming from
- 35:02where all the stars come from. From the Motherlands with the
- 35:05Motherlands. Exactly.
- 35:07So it even happens within Brazil.
- 35:09So it's just, it's just what it is.
- 35:13What it is, is that it's either the community wanting or the
- 35:19organizers wanting something that comes from a place or
- 35:25somebody really earning that credit and deserving that
- 35:30credit. So when I look at it, I look at
- 35:33it from a place more of like, what do you bring to the
- 35:39community? What do you bring to the
- 35:40students? What do you bring to the event?
- 35:43I don't care where you're from, I'll bring it from wherever.
- 35:47If you bring what I think is worth, I will I will fully
- 35:52support that work. And I have organized a lot of
- 35:57events and I do see that sometimes certain teachers will
- 36:03ask for more, certain teachers will ask for less.
- 36:06Sometimes I see a correlation between nationality or not, but
- 36:13most of the times I see more the relationship between price and I
- 36:19think like time in the dance or time in the in the work, the
- 36:25community. So somebody who's been doing
- 36:27this, travelling, teaching, whatever for like 15 years, it's
- 36:32beyond their nationality at that point.
- 36:35It's more because of their mastery and experience over
- 36:38time, you know, But somebody who's like just came out of
- 36:42Brazil trying to charge as much as like somebody who's been
- 36:45doing this for 15 years, regardless of nationality, I'm
- 36:48not going to take that. I'm not going to take that.
- 36:51I do not accept. I say thank you very much, but
- 36:53this is not something that I can afford or something that I can
- 36:56support because it's not just because you came from Brazil
- 37:00that you can charge as much as the other people who has
- 37:03actually been doing this for a long time.
- 37:06So there has been occasions where I had non Brazilians that
- 37:11were getting more, yeah, were getting paid more than some
- 37:16people that were Brazilians because for me the reward or the
- 37:20price is valid against their time and credit and credibility
- 37:26and basically like the experience that they have and
- 37:30the product that they can bring. So yeah, I see how like what you
- 37:36said before, how sometimes in event organization there is that
- 37:41separation. But for me, I don't make that
- 37:43separation and I recommend people out there who organize
- 37:48events to, you know, have a think about it instead of just
- 37:53giving credit because of nationality or something like
- 37:55that. But actually think about what do
- 37:57they bring regardless where of where they come from.
- 38:00Because maybe your community does not need that couple or
- 38:06that type of teaching. Your community needs a different
- 38:10type of teaching. And maybe that could be a couple
- 38:14that does not come from Brazil or is not born in Brazil but
- 38:19living near you. You could be any other person
- 38:22who is a highly skilled teacher that can give to your students
- 38:26what they need and what they want.
- 38:28Yeah, This topic can go for a very long time because I was
- 38:32having like conversation which you organize it from two
- 38:35different parts of the world when we're talking about the
- 38:38economics of an event. And they are basically saying
- 38:43that although sometimes they know that their community would
- 38:48benefit more from this person here, like maybe a more senior
- 38:52teacher, someone has been around for a longer time being afraid
- 38:57that they will not sell as many tickets or they feel uncertain
- 39:02that they will sell enough tickets for this person.
- 39:05But they know that if they bring this new couple from Brazil,
- 39:09they'll probably sell more tickets.
- 39:11So even though they don't know. And then it gets into this like
- 39:15paradoxical, lightly schizophrenic behavior of the
- 39:20Brazilian zoo community sometimes where you know what
- 39:25you want to bring to your students and you have a desire
- 39:28to bring certain things. But then you bring the thing
- 39:31sometimes that you don't want, but you bring it anyways because
- 39:34you think that's the thing that's going to pay the bill,
- 39:36you know, the thing that's going to make the event happen.
- 39:38So either don't make the event happen or you take the risk of
- 39:44bringing this more senior teacher.
- 39:45But a teacher there is maybe not on a high as he used to be, is
- 39:51less known, you know, and that can be Brazilian, non Brazilian,
- 39:56or you bring the Brazilians who have this perceived authority
- 40:01and will sell more tickets. You know, that's something that
- 40:04I find so fascinating actually, and.
- 40:08Another thing that I have been noticing is some events in Asia,
- 40:13I'm seeing there is a couple there or the teacher who is
- 40:16coming and underneath Max certified.
- 40:21I don't know how many ways in Jack and Jill, you know, so like
- 40:25they are starting to put underneath the name some sort of
- 40:28like certifications that this person is qualified.
- 40:32So like, this person is not Brazilian, so it doesn't have
- 40:36the perceived authority. So you have to show that they
- 40:40have some authority. So what do you say?
- 40:42Oh, they completed Mark. They won Jack and Jill a couple
- 40:46times. And there was recently a case of
- 40:49a Brazilian teacher who lost work opportunities because he
- 40:53didn't place in Jack and Jill. And then he made several posts
- 40:57on Instagram about it, saying that like a good competitor
- 41:01doesn't mean a good teacher and vice versa.
- 41:05You know, So there's like disqualifications that sometimes
- 41:09are required even if you are Brazilian because there are a
- 41:14lot of Brazilian teachers who are like you said, the
- 41:17competition right now is fierce who are scrambling to get an
- 41:21opportunity. And there was this event in
- 41:23Brazil recently called Looking Fauco, who intentionally hired a
- 41:31more, a wider, a more diverse lineup, teachers from all parts
- 41:37of Brazil, teachers from like all walks of life, teachers from
- 41:41all color, all age. So it was a very diverse event.
- 41:45And it was intentionally done this way to also bring
- 41:49opportunity to other people. So it's so complex.
- 41:53There's so many moving parts. We are dealing also with dense
- 41:57economics and the perception of what will sell tickets and what
- 42:02will make the event at least break even.
- 42:05So we are also thinking about these things as organizers.
- 42:11Sometimes it's a balance that is hard to strike, I think.
- 42:15I think when I'm looking at it from an organizer perspective or
- 42:21somebody who is coaching or assisting, somebody who is an
- 42:25organizer, I really try to get them to focus on what is good
- 42:32for the long run, right? So sometimes community leaders,
- 42:37organizers, they're like, oh, I just need to bring a couple
- 42:39every month, you know, to get the energy to get the vibe and
- 42:43blah, blah, blah, blah, blah. And I'm like, how is your weekly
- 42:47classes going? Are people coming like, no, no,
- 42:50no, people, you know, people can't afford the weekenders and
- 42:53the weekly classes. And I'm like, exactly.
- 42:56So you're actually killing the local community.
- 42:59You're killing your local community and people supporting
- 43:02local teachers because you're bringing all of these couples
- 43:05all the time. And there's only so much time
- 43:08and money that people can spend, you know, So actually invest
- 43:11more time in your local community instead of just
- 43:13bringing teachers all the time. All but people want the
- 43:17travelling teachers. Like, yes, that's cool, some
- 43:21people do, but some people are very, to be honest, not some
- 43:24people. A lot of people are very happy
- 43:26with your weekly classes and that's why they're here and
- 43:29that's how you build this community.
- 43:31So trust in yourself that what you're doing is great.
- 43:35And then the weekenders are like an extra thing, maybe once every
- 43:39three months or once every six months.
- 43:41But the real work of growing the community is your daily work
- 43:45with the community, your weekly classes, your communication,
- 43:49your promotion, your networking with everybody and making sure
- 43:53that the community grows. It's not this teacher that
- 43:56travels every now and then and comes here, dumps a bunch of
- 44:00moves and leaves and nobody remembered those moves in the
- 44:04next day. Yes, it's not.
- 44:06They never get the chance of having a homemade meal.
- 44:10They're always going from restaurant to restaurant every
- 44:12weekends, you know, and never get to experience like some
- 44:16stable, comforting homemade meal.
- 44:20And it's the thing, man, that's the thing.
- 44:23You were saying something that annoyed you before.
- 44:26Give me another episode, man. This the thing that annoys me is
- 44:29the most when the organizer says, oh, but that's what they
- 44:32want. And I'm like, that's what you
- 44:34want. That's what you want because how
- 44:39do you know? Have you surveyed everybody?
- 44:42Had you went around and asked if they wanted?
- 44:45Because I know people from communities, they're like more
- 44:49focused on weekenders that they really want regular classes.
- 44:54You know, So it's like sometimes the desire of the organizer is
- 45:00translated as the desire of the community.
- 45:04And then because the organizer has the thing.
- 45:06I used to hear this so many times, like why do you teach
- 45:09these things? Like, oh, because that's what
- 45:11people want to learn. And like no, no, no, no, people
- 45:15will learn whatever you teach. You know, again, you are not
- 45:20cooking homemade meal. You always take them to
- 45:23restaurants from time to time. So they will get spoiled, but
- 45:27not in a good way because you just having them have things
- 45:31they're not everyday, like ordinary stuff that will
- 45:35actually do, you know, like movements that they will
- 45:38actually lead in a social right. So this is something that also
- 45:43man bothers me so much. Yeah, we can always go back to
- 45:47the previous episode. So please make sure you follow
- 45:49and subscribe and check all of our episodes on Spotify,
- 45:52YouTube, Instagram, because we've spoken about this where
- 45:58like the community is a very top down thing, OK?
- 46:02So most of the best of communities that I've worked or
- 46:06seen and the best dancers that I've danced with, they're from
- 46:09communities of teachers that are very focused on what do they
- 46:12want their students to be. Do you want your students to be
- 46:16comfortable dancers, dancers that can dance with anybody?
- 46:21You want your students to know what the dance feels like and
- 46:25how the dance is structure. Focus on that.
- 46:28Focus on that. Give the weekly classes, maybe
- 46:31some weekenders that you can teach all of those things
- 46:35because that's what the community is going to be like.
- 46:37But when you're looking just at the numbers and the money and
- 46:40going like, well, you know, like when I make weekenders,
- 46:43everybody comes so I can afford that, but the weekly classes are
- 46:47very dead. Well, then you're pretty much
- 46:50raising children on fast food. You know, it's not going to be
- 46:54good for the long run. And guess what?
- 46:55The community is actually not going to grow, in my opinion.
- 46:59The community is really strongly based on the people that
- 47:02actually want to show up every week.
- 47:05My priority and my attention always goes to the people that
- 47:09shows up every week. The people that just come to
- 47:12social, the people that just come to Weekenders.
- 47:15I welcome them. I'm always nice to everybody and
- 47:18I'll dance with anybody, but if you ask me who I prioritize,
- 47:23always the people that show up, the people that are helping the
- 47:26community grow. That's the people that if there
- 47:30is any moment that I need to prioritize, I will prioritize.
- 47:35And when I think about my classes, my courses, the prices
- 47:39and everything like that, I have that in mind.
- 47:42I want a community that is safe, comfortable, knowledgeable and
- 47:47growing and inclusive and embraces everybody.
- 47:50That's the community that I want.
- 47:53So if you haven't, go back to some previous episodes and
- 47:56listen to the ones that we talked about.
- 47:58Why do you dance? Why do you organize something?
- 48:02Why do you go to a dance class? That to me is like the ruling
- 48:10king or queen of all the decisions that I make.
- 48:14What do I want for the community?
- 48:17And I'm going to say something that may be controversial to
- 48:20what I'm actually saying, but what I want for the community is
- 48:25not what I want is what I know that the community is asking
- 48:30for. They're asking for comfort,
- 48:33they're asking for safety, they're asking for confidence,
- 48:38they're asking for knowledge. So by listening to the
- 48:43community, I make the decision of like wanting to give that to
- 48:48the community. And as as always, if you're not
- 48:51sure, please connect with us. We would love to help you in any
- 48:56moment that you're going through with your community.
- 48:59Yeah. So I think in the end of the
- 49:01day, when we think about this idea of why Brazilian dancers or
- 49:08Brazilian teachers are more expensive, why they they charge
- 49:12more. All these things we have been
- 49:15talking about play a huge role in it, like demand, perception,
- 49:21the economics of everything, you know, because for example, in
- 49:26this case that somebody runs a local community and wants to
- 49:31bring someone to do a weekend from time to time.
- 49:35So want to bring something special for the students.
- 49:37And then they're going to go study the market and the
- 49:40likelihood that they find that there's a Brazilian couple that
- 49:43is being the famous one on social media is much higher than
- 49:47the likelihood of them finding a couple who's not Brazilian.
- 49:51And then when going talking to them, it's going to be more
- 49:54expensive because there is more demand, you know, so it's like
- 49:59it's it could be like an invitation to research.
- 50:03What are some other teachers that are there around doing
- 50:07great work that could do what you are envisioning for your
- 50:12community? Not Brazilians.
- 50:14So we start a movement where as organizers, we research other
- 50:19couples that could be really good for our community and then
- 50:24go ahead and hire them, you know, just to like bring more
- 50:27variety and see how people who are not from Brazil translate
- 50:31the dance, what they talk about and when they talk about the
- 50:34dance. So you just bring more flavors
- 50:38to the community and offer more opportunities.
- 50:40And then again, recognizing the economics of everything and the
- 50:45risk that might be involved in bringing a couple that people
- 50:49might not know. But guys, to be honest, giving
- 50:53our experience here at District Zook, many times our students
- 50:58don't really know the big names. They don't know.
- 51:02You say a couple is coming from outside to teach and it's the
- 51:07fact that it's a Weekender and it's something special already.
- 51:12Dress is the thing with this aura of special that attracts
- 51:18people, that has enough attraction power.
- 51:21When people Start learning the big names, then they make more
- 51:24specific requests, but at certain stages they really don't
- 51:28know. At least that's our experience
- 51:31here. So you can bring a couple from
- 51:34another country and people come at least again in our
- 51:38experience. So give people the benefit of
- 51:41the doubts. They let them give a chance to
- 51:44this people that they don't know about because they also don't
- 51:48know about anybody else. Sometimes the local Zook teacher
- 51:54is the biggest authority. And if they say this couple is
- 51:58good, people are like, OK, so this couple is good.
- 52:00You know, some people don't even know that even though Brazilian
- 52:04Zook has the name Brazilian in the name, how much it is related
- 52:09to Brazil or how tight it is to Brazil.
- 52:11You know, like people Start learning these things when they
- 52:14go into the dance a little deeper.
- 52:16Yes. And if you're not aware of who
- 52:20those teachers are, please connect with other community
- 52:22leaders and ask around. Please reach out to people who
- 52:26are hiring people that you don't know, for example, some local or
- 52:31Interstate or nearby teachers. But one of the best ways to do
- 52:36this is to actually, when you go to an event festival that has
- 52:40multiple teachers, multiple rooms, go to the classes of
- 52:43those teachers that are close to your community or maybe in your
- 52:48country and take a class from them and realize what they can
- 52:53bring to you. Maybe they're not going to bring
- 52:56the tuiles and counterbalances and spins and crazy stuff, but
- 52:59maybe they are so good at explaining details about
- 53:03something that would be so valuable for your community.
- 53:08And that is great. That's already amazing.
- 53:12So give a chance to everybody, research and bring all the
- 53:16flavors. I think that's how you build the
- 53:19best dancers in the best communities and that's what I
- 53:22have seen from my experience. So hopefully this was helpful
- 53:26for you guys there and either as a student, a teacher, organizer,
- 53:30promoter, supporter, anybody in the community here being with us
- 53:35in Zuknerd Land. And so thank you for being here
- 53:38with us. Please make sure that you
- 53:40subscribe and follow us YouTube, Instagram, Spotify and all of
- 53:44the other platforms and we'll see you on the next episode.
- 53:49Thank you. Thank you.
- 53:50Special specials. Habra Susan, Ciao.
- 53:53Bye. Everybody.