Latest / The Sean O'Connell Show / Adam Rittenberg on ESPN's College FB offseason rankings, Where they ranked the Utes, Radical change in offseason philosophy needed for Ut...
Transcript
- 0:15Speaker 1: You're listening to a Sean O'Connell show from the Murdoch
- 0:18Hyundai Studio of ESPN seven hundred and ninety two to
- 0:22one a half am.
- 0:29Speaker 2: The off season in college football now is almost as
- 0:34important as the actual season, because you've got to reorganize
- 0:37your roster, you got to hire the right coaches. It's
- 0:39been a big off season for the University of Utah.
- 0:44ESPN has a really interesting piece out right now evaluating
- 0:47the off seasons of every power for team in college football.
- 0:52Joining us to talk about it, ESPN College Football Insider
- 0:55lead writer Adam Rittenberg, friend of the program, back after
- 1:00it's been a while. Adam, how are you?
- 1:02Speaker 3: I'm good? Oh see how you doing? Man?
- 1:03Speaker 4: Doing all right? Great to have you on.
- 1:05Speaker 2: Appreciate you writing great content that I can then use
- 1:08as material on my show.
- 1:10Speaker 4: It makes my life a whole lot easier. So thank you.
- 1:13Speaker 3: I'm just I'm here for you, brother. That's the inspiration
- 1:16for writing twenty five thousand words in the middle of May.
- 1:19Speaker 4: Yes, I'm always front of mine for you when you're
- 1:22doing your job. I'm sure.
- 1:23Speaker 2: All right, let's talk about how you and your colleagues
- 1:26have evaluated Utah's offseason ranked as the seventh best offseason
- 1:31in the Big Twelve conference, and obviously the key additions,
- 1:35as you haven't listed broken down, Devin dan Pierre starting quarterback,
- 1:39presume started quardingback, I should say is number one there.
- 1:43Let's start with that, a guy who was really exciting
- 1:47at the group of five level for a New Mexico
- 1:50team that it didn't necessarily translate to a bunch of
- 1:52huge wins for them, but a guy that I think
- 1:55has all the tools and the promise and the whatever
- 1:57that when we initially adopted the transfer portal as a thing,
- 2:02it was for this. It was for guys who were
- 2:04a little bit too good to be stuck at Albuquerque
- 2:07to go to a bigger school. Do you think it
- 2:10translates at the Big twelve level for Devin.
- 2:12Speaker 3: Dampier, Yeah, I think it should, and I think it's
- 2:16an exciting time for a Utah program that, let's face it,
- 2:20has been kind of held hostage by injuries and other
- 2:23issues at quarterback the last two seasons. That's the primary
- 2:27reason why Utah hasn't reached the expectations that were placed
- 2:32on it moving into the Big Twelve here at least
- 2:35last year and even in this last year in the
- 2:36PAC twelve. So I think this is a good thing.
- 2:38And you know, there's been a lot of talk nationally
- 2:41about the Ben Arbuckle John Mattier pairing coordinator and quarterback
- 2:46at Oklahoma. I think there's less discussion at least nationally
- 2:51about Jason Beck and Devin dam Pierre, but I think
- 2:54there will be more when the season rolls around, because
- 2:57I think this is a really good move for Utah
- 3:00to address its major issue there at quarterback and create
- 3:04a vision and an outlook that you can really build
- 3:07the rest of your team around, because as you know
- 3:10and your listeners know, you know, defense and special teams
- 3:13usually aren't the problem, and saw like a coordinator, and
- 3:16the offense has been a little bit more of a
- 3:18revolving door under Kyle Whittingham, and I think this gives
- 3:22Utah again a very clear path going forward. And now
- 3:26they have to obviously step up around them, but I
- 3:28think there's certainly some excitement brewing for this year's team.
- 3:33Speaker 2: One of the things, and you reference the revolving door
- 3:37of offensive coordinators, the thing that interrupted that it was
- 3:40with seven coordinators in seven years at one point. The
- 3:43thing that interrupted that was the return of Andy Ludwig,
- 3:46and you know a guy that was, in my opinion,
- 3:50he was the batman to Kyle Whittingham's robin. There was
- 3:53enough respect between them that Kyle Whittingham was like, all right,
- 3:56I trust that you're going to run the offense the
- 3:58right way. And I think he gave a little bit
- 4:01more leash, or at least that there was more cohesive
- 4:03thought on what the offense should be. And we saw
- 4:06Andy Ludwig, you know, spread things out a little bit,
- 4:08and even when they didn't have great wide receiving cors,
- 4:12you got the tight ends involved in all that. But
- 4:14every Utah fan knows and fears that there's this idea
- 4:20with Kyle Whittingham. Short in the game, run the ball
- 4:23three yards in a cloud of dust. And now you've
- 4:25got a new offensive coordinator, you've got a new quarterback.
- 4:29How imperative in your mind is it that it doesn't
- 4:33go back to the old ways, to the conservative approach
- 4:35that has been so heavily criticized for Utah football in
- 4:41recent years and in past years.
- 4:43Speaker 3: Yeah, I think it's critically important that they Kyle, lets
- 4:47Fason and Devin be themselves and feed into ultimately what
- 4:53his strengths are as a quarterback, and you saw that
- 4:56with a healthy Cam Rising and the thing that he
- 4:58was able to do out there when when Utah was
- 5:01winning the Pac twelve, you know, being effective as a runner,
- 5:04playing fearlessly at times. I think that that's what you
- 5:07want if you're a Utah fan out of this particular
- 5:11quarterback because of his skill set. So that's a really
- 5:13important point. Oh see. I think it's something that we're
- 5:15going to watch early in the year, is how much
- 5:18freedom are they truly getting or giving to to Jason
- 5:22Beck And then ultimately for him, I think, you know,
- 5:25if he gets that freedom, we know Devin dan Pier
- 5:27is going to have it because we saw what they
- 5:29were able to do, uh, just last season at New Mexico.
- 5:32And you know, obviously Jason's coming from Syracuse and you
- 5:36know he's obviously been into BYU. He has a really
- 5:38nice talent of experience to bring there to to Utah.
- 5:42But yeah, I think again, if you know, Kyle's done
- 5:45this a long time and I know those criticisms of
- 5:47him are valid, but I think he recognizes for them
- 5:51to take a step forward this season, being overly restrictive,
- 5:56as you know, with the quarterback and the overall philosophy
- 5:59on offense probably isn't the right path to having greater success.
- 6:04Speaker 2: Can you have a great offense if you don't have
- 6:06a great wide receiving corps in modern college football?
- 6:10Speaker 3: Yeah, yeah, it's a great question, and that's a group
- 6:14that I think a lot of us are going to
- 6:15be watching with some question marks with with Utah in particular,
- 6:19is you know, how much can a guy like Devin
- 6:21Dampierre in a system like Jason Beck has improve a
- 6:26group that isn't it decorated to some of the other
- 6:29groups that are returning in the Big twelve. And I
- 6:32know they obviously, you know, made some additions in the portal,
- 6:34but wasn't enough. And they've obviously lost a number of
- 6:37players as well on their offense just because of graduation
- 6:40and some transferring out. So it's it's definitely a group
- 6:44to watch. But I think, you know, if given the
- 6:46choice of strong wide receiving group or potentially elite quarterback,
- 6:51I think you're going to take the quarterback every single
- 6:53time because of what he can do to impact those
- 6:56around him. And that's going to be a key storyline
- 6:59here leading up to the season and certainly through the
- 7:01first few weeks of games.
- 7:03Speaker 2: The story that you helped Wright references this but a
- 7:06lot of love, a lot of conversation, a lot of
- 7:09buzz now about Utah's offensive line and in particular their
- 7:13their bookend tackles, Caleb Lomo on the left side and
- 7:17Spencer Fono on the right side. Both of those guys
- 7:20in a lot of the way too early draft predictions
- 7:22are getting even as high as first round grades for
- 7:25two of them. Now, I've been paying close attention to
- 7:28Utah football for several decades now, I'm quite certain there's
- 7:32never been two first round offensive tackles on the same
- 7:36Utah roster. If they end up playing at that level,
- 7:40what does that look like for Utah in your mind?
- 7:43Speaker 3: Well, it just allows so much some of the other
- 7:46things to happen, whether it's you know, just Dan Peter
- 7:49being able to make plays, you know, guy like Waysound
- 7:52Parker coming in as a as an exciting running back
- 7:55to some of the receivers that we were talking about
- 7:58a little bit, being able to have more time to
- 8:02get open against defenses. And so yeah, I mean for Utah,
- 8:07they've been a program as you know that's been built
- 8:09around the line of scrimmage for many years, maybe a
- 8:12little bit more decorated on the defensive lines at times
- 8:15and the offensive line, but this particular offensive line, I
- 8:18think there's reason to be very very excited and and
- 8:22and I think that if you have that in place,
- 8:25it's almost like everything else will will will kind of
- 8:27find its way.
- 8:29Speaker 5: It's very very hard to build a team the other way,
- 8:31where you have the quarterback, you have the receivers, you
- 8:34have the running back, and you have major questions on
- 8:36the offensive line, and you know that that's just something that's.
- 8:39Speaker 3: Very very difficult to overcome. Whereas Utah can go into
- 8:43the year, sure with some questions at receiver, a little
- 8:46bit at running back, with some new personnel quarterback to
- 8:48a degree, but when you have that foundation of the
- 8:51offensive line, especially the ends of the offensive line, you
- 8:54can feel pretty good about your ability to protect and
- 8:57give your quarterback a chance to do to some of
- 8:59the things that he did in Mexico.
- 9:01Speaker 2: Adam Rehndberg ESPN is our guest here on the Sean
- 9:04O'Connell Show, talking college football. Very fascinating article on espn
- 9:09dot com about the off season rankings for every power
- 9:13for college football team. Adam and his colleagues did a
- 9:16great job breaking it down team by team. Utah's offseason
- 9:20ranked seventh to the Big Twelve BYU, who everyone here
- 9:23plays close attention to, much to their own chagrins. Sometimes
- 9:28you've got them ranked ninth as an offseason squad, and look,
- 9:32they had a great year last year and there's high
- 9:35hopes and their names, that name is appearing on a
- 9:38lot of preseason top twenty fives. What do you think
- 9:41of BYU's upcoming season from a win perspective and obviously
- 9:46through the lens of this article that you just heelp fright.
- 9:50Speaker 3: Right, Yeah, I think this is a team that you
- 9:52certainly should feel excited coming off of last season and
- 9:56the way they finished it with their dominant Bowl win
- 9:59over Colorado, getting to the Big Twelve champions or nearly
- 10:02getting the Big Twelve championship game. But but but being
- 10:04right there, you know, with with Arizona State, now again
- 10:08there's a lot of players that have departed the program
- 10:11and you know, either through your graduation and moving on
- 10:16or or or through or to the portal, and so
- 10:19you know it's going to be a new team and
- 10:21that's just the case in college football these days, is
- 10:23that very rarely are you going to have close to
- 10:25a carbon copy of the group that you had walking
- 10:28off of the field in December or January. And so
- 10:32it's it's about bringing that group together. And it's you know,
- 10:36like we talked with Utah having a new quarterback obviously
- 10:39Jake Retslov coming back to Provo after the season that
- 10:42he had, you know, with with a handful of starters
- 10:45around him, and you know, they added the Bach Meyers
- 10:48laid in the portal and uh see if they can
- 10:50kind of help with from a depth standpoint and play
- 10:52making standpoint. But you know, again it's it's going to
- 10:55be a new look team in some ways with some
- 10:58some really familiar face. Is obviously a quarterback. And I
- 11:02think I think again one part of this so cee
- 11:04that I really focused on was the coaching staffs part
- 11:07of the offseason is you know, in Utah's case, it's
- 11:10bringing in Jason Beck to replace Andy Ludwig, who generally
- 11:13did a great job there. In Dyu's case, they were
- 11:16able to retain, you know, both of their top coordinators
- 11:19who've done really good jobs. In my view, Jay Hill
- 11:22on defense and a Rod obviously on offense. You know,
- 11:24Jay was a guy that I thought was going to
- 11:26get the Utah State job. It didn't happen. Obviously, Bronco
- 11:28ended up getting that one, and Jay's back, and I
- 11:31think that's a really good thing for BYU. Obviously, a
- 11:33Rod has done this for a long time with different quarterbacks.
- 11:36Actually got to see him out here in Chicago earlier
- 11:40this spring. It was great to catch up with him.
- 11:42I know he's excited about some of the personnel that
- 11:45are coming back and others that are emerging on that offense.
- 11:48So yeah, I mean, just because they're ninth in off
- 11:51season rankings doesn't mean they're going to be ninth and
- 11:54in Big twelve, you know, preseason poll or I think
- 11:57that they're absolutely a team that should be on everyone
- 12:00list as a contender to win the conference championship.
- 12:04Speaker 2: So you and I did a bunch of shows together
- 12:06on Serious X Sam, and I know several times we
- 12:09talked about man if Arizona State can just get it
- 12:12figured out, Man, that's a sleeping giant of a program.
- 12:15Everyone who's paid any attention to Arizona State or has
- 12:18been on that campus and knows now what the local
- 12:21high schools are producing. For that matter, we've been kind
- 12:24of waiting for, I guess last year to happen. Is
- 12:28it going to be sustainable for Kenny Dillingham in the
- 12:31Valley of the Sun. Is this Is this the awakening
- 12:34that we long waited for? And now I guess maybe
- 12:36should have feared of Arizona State football.
- 12:40Speaker 3: One of the things I think we talked about, and
- 12:43I know that I've thought about this if we didn't
- 12:44talk about it on our shows, though, see is the
- 12:46fact that Arizona State went so long without a coach
- 12:50who really had roots in that area, and they typically
- 12:53went for, you know, the older, established experience coaches. Nothing
- 12:56wrong with that, but I really thought that they needed
- 12:59somebody who had a stronger connection to the university and
- 13:03ideally to the valley. And clearly Kenny Dillingham is that guy.
- 13:07And yes, he's a young guy, and everyone talks about
- 13:10his age, but if you really look at his experience level,
- 13:13he was someone who essentially began coaching as soon as
- 13:16he got to college, even when he was still in
- 13:17high school a little bit. So he has coached football
- 13:20for a long time and that's why I call him
- 13:22a young old guy, and I think he really understands,
- 13:26you know, different, you know, kind of how to win
- 13:28an Arizona State but also has a national view of
- 13:31the sport, having coached at places like Florida State and
- 13:35Auburn and Memphis and Oregon. He really understands what's going
- 13:38on around the landscape of college football. And I think
- 13:41that served him well as a young head coach, but
- 13:44one who has matured very quickly and obviously won a
- 13:47conference title in year two. And I think the way
- 13:50that he handles the portal is refreshing. You get a
- 13:53lot of hand ringing and complaints about the portal. Kenny
- 13:56just kind of rolls with it. And you know, you
- 13:58look at their offseason. They certainly lost some people, just
- 14:02like everyone does in the portal, but they were able
- 14:04to add and they were able to keep you know,
- 14:06they keep Sam Levitt, they keep Jordan Tyson and some
- 14:09of their other key players from last year. They were
- 14:12also able to retain their primary coordinators and Marcus Royo,
- 14:16who is a former FBS head coach at UNLV and
- 14:20was on the list for some jobs. He's back. He
- 14:22was a Broils Award finalist Brian Ward has done a
- 14:25really nice job on defense. He's back. They really didn't
- 14:28lose a whole lot from the coaching staff, and that's
- 14:30why there'll be a popular pick to repeat. I don't
- 14:32know if it's going to happen. The Big Twelve is
- 14:34really unpredictable, but they have set themselves up for future success,
- 14:38and I really think a big part of that is
- 14:40having a coach who's really devoted to the university and
- 14:44to the area, unlike his predecessors. Nothing against guys like
- 14:48even Herm or Todd Graham or going back to Dennis
- 14:53Ericson and Derk Cutter and some of those guys, but
- 14:55they just weren't connected to that area nearly the way
- 14:58that Kenny is.
- 15:00Speaker 2: I agree with you wholeheartedly, and I I love seeing
- 15:05the success for him.
- 15:06Speaker 4: I like him.
- 15:06Speaker 2: I love seeing, you know, my thoughts about Arizona State
- 15:10be validated. But now I'm like, oh wait, this is
- 15:13a problem for everyone else in the Big twelve to
- 15:15try and get through, and that doesn't necessarily serve Utah.
- 15:18Here on the Home of the Youth, Adam Rittenberg for
- 15:20another minute or two. On the Sean O'Connell show, more
- 15:23of a big picture thing going on right now. But
- 15:25the house settlement, you know, there's been delays. You hear
- 15:28all these proposed potential changes. Is this thing going to
- 15:32be done, dusted, settled, and you know ink dry before
- 15:36the twenty twenty five season at this.
- 15:37Speaker 3: Point, Well, I certainly hope. So I know there's a
- 15:41number of coaches that are anxious for a resolution. You know,
- 15:45it's not surprising in a sense that things are dragging
- 15:49on because that's just what happens, and in anything related
- 15:53to college athletics that nothing comes together very very quickly.
- 15:56But I do know, like talking to coaches, especially at
- 15:59the lower levels fcs and elsewhere, do they want to
- 16:02figure out what their rosters are going to look like?
- 16:05And there is obviously a trickle down effect to the numbers,
- 16:09to the portal to the money that you know just
- 16:12doesn't just impact the Utahs and byus of the world,
- 16:15but but but we're really some of the smaller schools
- 16:17as well. So yeah, I mean we're sitting here on
- 16:20May fourteenth. I know, there was hope to get this
- 16:22thing done about six weeks ago. You know, we're sitting
- 16:25here on July fourteenth in the same position. I would
- 16:28certainly get a little bit worried, but let's hope that
- 16:31there is there is at least to some type of clarity.
- 16:33That's what a lot of people around the sport that
- 16:35I talked to are looking for.
- 16:37Speaker 2: Is twenty twenty five a year of increased parody in
- 16:42college football with maybe this house settlement, you know, redistributing
- 16:46funds a little bit, or or leveling that evening it out,
- 16:49or is it you know, more of what we saw
- 16:51in college basketball and what we saw last year in
- 16:54college football, where ultimately it's you know, the top four
- 16:58pay rolls that end up fighting for it all at
- 17:01the end.
- 17:03Speaker 3: Yeah, you know, I think at the very top it's
- 17:05going to be hard for you know, true Cinderella to
- 17:08get there, a team that isn't spending or winning at
- 17:11that level. But I think there is opportunity for parody.
- 17:14I mean, you look at the Big twelve race last
- 17:16year was very, very compelling, you know, with gosh there
- 17:19was what one, two, three, four or five, six, seven
- 17:22teams that finished either seven or two or six and
- 17:25three in the league. I think that's very, very possible
- 17:28once again in the twenty twenty five season. I think
- 17:32there could be more parody in the SEC. Alabama has
- 17:35kind of come down to earth, you know, Georgia has
- 17:37some questions on offense. Texas is replacing its quarterback, and
- 17:41I lost the first round receiver, and you had had
- 17:44some question marks there. South Carolina returns Laura's Sellers, and
- 17:47there's a number of other quarterbacks that are coming back
- 17:49in the conference. So I think the SEC could have
- 17:52a little bit more parody. I think the Big Ten
- 17:54is still that league, and we saw it last I mean,
- 17:56the Big Ten was set up perfectly to make the
- 17:58playoff because you had fourteen that had really separated themselves
- 18:02record wise from the rest of the league in Oregon,
- 18:05Penn State, Ohio State, in Indiana. I don't know if
- 18:08it'll be exactly that again, but I certainly think you
- 18:11look at teams like Penn State, Oregon, and Ohio State,
- 18:14it would be surprising if they're not in playoff position again.
- 18:17And then maybe there is a fourth team, whether it's
- 18:19Indiana again or Illinois is getting a lot of buzz,
- 18:22or maybe Iowa moves up or USC or someone like that.
- 18:26Maybe that's a fourth team. But I do see kind
- 18:28of a clearer tiers in the Big Ten than maybe
- 18:31some of these other conferences. And then the AEC will
- 18:34be fascinating because Clinton has momentum now they won the conference.
- 18:37They bring back, in my view, the best roster in
- 18:39the conference. But you know Miami has talent. Mario is
- 18:42always going to add players. If you know, SMU brings
- 18:45back Kevin Jennings and know he's taken a lot of
- 18:47hits since that playoff performance against Penn State, still a
- 18:51really good player. I think Louisville's pretty good. So maybe
- 18:53we'll get a little parody in and the ACC, but
- 18:56I don't think it will be as vast as it
- 18:58will be really any league, at least the power for
- 19:01level of the Big Twelve. The Big Twelve is going
- 19:04to be year in and year out the most exciting
- 19:06league race.
- 19:08Speaker 2: Have you ordered any Utah Mammoth NHL gear yet?
- 19:13Speaker 3: No, not yet, although my daughter is getting into hockey,
- 19:16which is here is a very very expensive thing to
- 19:19go down that road, but I'll have to see if
- 19:21she if she wants any Mammoths. The Blackhawks we're rolling
- 19:26here right around the time I started having kids, and
- 19:29they weren't old enough to enjoy it, and then they've
- 19:31kind of got in the tank for seven eight years,
- 19:34so we may become mammoth fans before you know it.
- 19:37Speaker 2: Well, let me know if you need me to pick
- 19:39you up some stuff from the pro shop last thing
- 19:41before I let you go.
- 19:42Speaker 4: It's not a college football question.
- 19:45Speaker 2: Pete Rose eligible now for the Major League Baseball Hall
- 19:47of Fame?
- 19:48Speaker 4: Is he going to get in?
- 19:50Speaker 3: I think he will? And you know, baseball is just
- 19:53such a funny sporto see because of all the retroactive
- 19:57stuff that seems to happen, and and how even the
- 20:00greatest players have to wait before they get into the
- 20:03Hall of Fame, even if they don't have any baggage,
- 20:06and it's unfortunate. I mean, I just I don't see
- 20:08the point of waiting until somebody dies before you are
- 20:11going to honor them. And if they were a great player,
- 20:14they were a great player. I mean, I get the
- 20:16other side of the argument. I respect that viewpoint, but
- 20:20it's just it's just odd how they how they tend
- 20:22to handle these I mean, are we going to see
- 20:24another fial of Dreams movie now that Shoeless Joe can
- 20:27get in from the from the Black Sox. So it's
- 20:29a it's just it's just very interesting how that sport
- 20:32handles its history.
- 20:34Speaker 2: It is very strange. I will co sign that. Thank
- 20:37you so much for your time today. It's great catching
- 20:40up with you, and obviously as the season approaches, we
- 20:42will be bothering you for more of these conversations.
- 20:45Speaker 3: Thanks you bet, thanks for having me.
- 20:48Speaker 2: Adam Brittenberg, ESPN College Football Insider co author on this
- 20:54piece that we were just talking about the off season grades,
- 20:59right King offseason teams in Power for Football