Latest / Journey to the Fringe / Fringey Mini: The devil's in the divots
Transcript
- 0:00Now, Chelsea, I don't use this source that often
- 0:03for news, but this is just the first place I
- 0:06saw this article. It's Newsweek. So I just honestly,
- 0:10I know the name, but I couldn't tell you what
- 0:14its kind of reputation is out there. I just know
- 0:17it's a name. I would accept it as news. OK. Yeah.
- 0:21It's got it in the title. So it's got to be.
- 0:23Yeah, exactly. That's how it works. Someone lie.
- 0:28Yeah. Exactly. It could not be news. So this
- 0:32article comes on May 10th, 2025. It was actually
- 0:36updated on May 12th, 2025, written by Holly Silverman
- 0:41and article title is Parkinson's disease linked
- 0:44to living near golf courses. New study. What?
- 0:48Yeah. Okay. I'm intrigued. Researchers found
- 0:52that those living within a mile of golf courses
- 0:54have 126 % higher risk of developing Parkinson's
- 0:58disease than those who live more than six miles
- 1:01away, according to a new study published in the
- 1:04Journal of the American Medical Association,
- 1:06JAMA. JAMA! Newsweek has reached out to Parkinson's
- 1:09Foundation as well as the Dr. Brittany Krizanowski
- 1:12researcher. Oh, okay. Sorry, there's a comma
- 1:16there in this. I was reading as Dr. Brittany
- 1:19Krizanowski, the researcher, which is Dr. Brittany
- 1:23Krizanowski, comma, researcher for the study,
- 1:27comma, or comment. You know, the researcher.
- 1:32Areas that shared drinking water supplies with
- 1:35water used near golf courses were the most greatly
- 1:38impacted, the study shows. Researchers believe
- 1:41this shows that the pesticides used on golf courses
- 1:44could contribute to the amount of Parkinson's
- 1:46cases. Parkinson's disease is a neurodegenerative
- 1:49disease estimated to affect about 10 million
- 1:51people globally. At about 1 .1 million people
- 1:54in the United States, according to the Parkinson's
- 1:56Foundation, there is no cure but treatments are
- 1:58available. Researchers used data of golf course
- 2:01locations throughout the US along with data from
- 2:04the United States Geological Survey on 224 water
- 2:07service areas across 27 counties in Wisconsin
- 2:10and Minnesota. Data from 711 municipal wells
- 2:14provided by the Minnesota Geospatial Information
- 2:17Office was also used to determine the correlation
- 2:19between proximity and prevalences of cases. During
- 2:22the study, 450 incident cases from 1991 to 2015
- 2:26were identified in Olmsted County, Minnesota.
- 2:28Quote, the odds of PD, which I think is Parkinson's
- 2:32disease, were relatively constant within close
- 2:41proximity to a golf course and decreased linearly
- 2:44as distance increased. Individuals living farther
- 2:47from a golf course have reduced odds of PD decreasing
- 2:50relative to the distance from the nearest golf
- 2:53course, end quote the study explained. Previous
- 2:55studies have already linked chemicals found in
- 2:58pesticides including paraquat and rotanone to
- 3:01neo -degeneration according to the study. The
- 3:04disease impacts the nervous system causing symptoms
- 3:06such as tremors, slow movement, and rigid muscles
- 3:09among others according to Mayo Clinic. Parkinson's
- 3:11disease is believed to be caused by a combination
- 3:14of genetics and environmental factors, with men
- 3:161 .25 times more likely to develop the disease.
- 3:20Her symptoms may include little expressions on
- 3:21the face, difficulty walking, and soft or slurred
- 3:24speech. The Parkinson's Foundation says cases
- 3:27have been higher in areas such as the Rust Belt,
- 3:29which includes parts of the Midwest. Cases are
- 3:31also high in Southern California, Southeast Texas,
- 3:34Central Pennsylvania, and Florida, according
- 3:36to the Foundation. Utah saw the highest rate
- 3:38of Parkinson's mortality at 12 .4%, while California
- 3:42saw the highest number of deaths, with 4 ,289
- 3:45according to the U .S. Center for Disease Control
- 3:47and Prevention. National medical advisor for
- 3:50the Parkinson's Foundation, Dr. Michael Okun,
- 3:52posted on Twitter on Saturday, quote, Parkinson's
- 3:55cases are exploding. We now face 11 .8 million
- 3:58cases globally and the numbers are climbing fast.
- 4:00Despite this reality, we still spend just 2 -3
- 4:03% of every Parkinson's dollar on prevention.
- 4:05That has to change. He also added that quote,
- 4:23This isn't about golf, it's about pesticides,
- 4:26environmental exposures and preventable risks
- 4:28hiding in plain sight. If we don't shift from
- 4:31reactive treatment to proactive prevention, the
- 4:34burden will become unmanageable. Who will this
- 4:36affect? Everyone including families, health systems,
- 4:40economies and societies. The science is accumulating.
- 4:43The signals are clear. Now we need the will and
- 4:45a Parkinson's plan." The researchers also said
- 4:48in the study, quote, individuals getting their
- 4:50tap water from groundwater services areas with
- 4:53a golf course had nearly doubled the odds of
- 4:56PD compared to, again, Parkinson's disease. compared
- 4:59with individuals getting tap water from groundwater
- 5:02services areas without golf courses and 49 %
- 5:05greater odds of PD compared with individuals
- 5:08getting drinking water from private wells. Researchers
- 5:11say more information is needed to further study
- 5:14the link between pesticides, golf courses, and
- 5:16the prevalence of Parkinson's disease. The Parkinson's
- 5:18Foundation says an estimated 90 ,000 more people
- 5:21will be diagnosed this year with the number of
- 5:23those suffering expected to be about 1 .2 million
- 5:25by 2030. And that's the end of our article. It's
- 5:28interesting that they go the link between pesticides
- 5:32and golf courses, as if it's the golf course
- 5:36itself, contributing to the Parkinson's, which
- 5:39I don't, or PD, so sorry. Which I don't think
- 5:43is actually a link causing the PD. Golf courses
- 5:49don't cause PD, per se. And they're really making
- 5:53it seem like it is. I would be interesting to
- 5:57see, which they also didn't link in there, is
- 6:00the average age of people who reside next to
- 6:03golf courses. That is true, but you got to remember
- 6:06it's not next to golf courses. It's within one
- 6:09to three miles of a golf course. Which is still,
- 6:12I would probably go out on a limb to say that
- 6:16the average age is going to be higher within
- 6:18one to three miles of a golf course. I mean,
- 6:20yeah, that's fair. We don't exactly know the
- 6:23areas that they were studying. I can't give you
- 6:25that much. I can tell you I'm within one to three
- 6:27miles of a golf course, but also we don't have
- 6:29groundwater that we drink where we are. It all
- 6:32comes from a pretty far away. That's true. I
- 6:34mean, I could definitely see where they're going
- 6:37at, but there's definitely some finer tuning
- 6:39of the wording that they're using. Yeah. Well,
- 6:42and I think that they kind of didn't quite shine
- 6:45a light on this, but I think it's harder to study
- 6:47that it is somewhat of a follow -up on one of
- 6:49the episodes we did a long time ago on the issue
- 6:53of modern day yards and specifically the pesticides
- 6:56we use to keep them looking just grass and that's
- 6:59why it's an interesting link yeah and it's why
- 7:02it looks so prevalent with golf courses because
- 7:04golf courses are such a large area where they
- 7:07need to keep it looking like pristine grass yeah
- 7:10and that's why they use a larger amount of this
- 7:12and why it's easier to study but i would wonder
- 7:14if they could show a very easy link between a
- 7:18house that uses pesticides versus one that doesn't
- 7:21they could have vined to that investigation a
- 7:24little bit further rather than just broadly saying
- 7:28golf course. And they never even brought up the
- 7:30fact that these might be pesticides you're using
- 7:32in your yard and maybe you shouldn't. That's
- 7:34true because also you're not necessarily just
- 7:37going to be having groundwater next to a golf
- 7:40course. You could be having them in other locations,
- 7:42but they didn't even mention that at a golf course
- 7:45you might be using more pesticides. Yeah. So
- 7:48there's work to be done. Was it this week? Technically
- 7:53Newsweek did the article. I'm wondering if it
- 7:56goes more in depth in the actual research paper.
- 7:58I haven't read it. I have only read the article,
- 8:01which I don't know if it shows it well in this
- 8:04article. So it might be worth a read. But yeah,
- 8:08like, like we've done all we're willing to do.
- 8:15It is a mini after all. Other than rant, we will
- 8:18rant some more for you. but the modern yard is
- 8:22just like so wasteful and bad for the environment
- 8:26and this is just like one of those factors that
- 8:28didn't necessarily get fully brought up in that
- 8:30episode but actually that's one that might have
- 8:32been interesting to look at is sod farms where
- 8:35they're growing grass because i guarantee you
- 8:36they're using pesticides there as well i didn't
- 8:38even think about that yeah i wonder if that'd
- 8:40be the next place to study it's gotta be maybe
- 8:43not by newsweek that's for sure not by newsweek
- 8:45they're not doing their research not at all Yeah,
- 8:50that research either. Newsweek, where we only
- 8:54vaguely make connections. Live next to a golf
- 8:59course? Well, you're gonna get PD. Parkinson
- 9:06was too much for him. That's not generally something
- 9:10you would abbreviate, but okay. You got the P
- 9:12- oh man, I make light. It's a horrible disease,
- 9:16but you got the PD. It is, but abbreviating like
- 9:19that I feel like is making light. They shouldn't
- 9:22have said it. Is it? I don't know, I have S gets
- 9:25shortened all the time. But that one's a harder
- 9:27word to say. Is it? Multiple? Yeah, sclerosis,
- 9:31that's harder. Oh, well what about multiple S?
- 9:34Why can't they just go with multiple S? Oh god.
- 9:38But PD, it doesn't need to be a breed. Maybe
- 9:41it's just because it's not normalized, PD. Or
- 9:44is it? I don't know. I don't know either. Anyhow,
- 9:49it's a horrible disease. What's his name? The
- 9:52kid from Back to the Future. Oh, I was just thinking
- 9:54about him. He's still going strong. Somebody
- 9:56tweeted him and see if it's acceptable by him
- 10:00to breed. Or is it a slur? Yeah. It might be.
- 10:03Don't tweet him. At least don't mention us. Yeah.
- 10:08Michael J. Fox, you are on your own. We will
- 10:11not back you up. Anyhow, you guys got 48 hours.
- 10:14Tweet at whom you may without our names involved.
- 10:16Yeah. Bye.