Latest / Legally Speaking with Michael Mulligan / Habitat for Humanity Saved, Fitness for Trial and Foreign Buyer Tax
Transcript
- 0:30Michael Mulligan: Yeah, there is a lot going on here, and this is a local story.
- 0:34Michael Mulligan: It's sort of it's the Victoria branch of uh Habitat for Humanity, which is a charity uh intended to try to uh get people into affordable homes, basically.
- 0:44Michael Mulligan: Right?
- 0:44Michael Mulligan: You might have uh uh seen uh Jimmy Carter, former U.S.
- 0:48Michael Mulligan: president who did that for years in the United States, but this is the local branch of that.
- 0:53Michael Mulligan: Uh and so the this litigation, which has made its way all the way to the Court of Appeal, uh could have been, at least in the BC context of that, uh a potential end to how that uh program could operate or if it could operate in British Columbia.
- 1:09Michael Mulligan: Uh and the litigation provides some interesting insight into just how that program or that charity operates, right?
- 1:16Michael Mulligan: Uh and the the basics of it are that with that goal of trying to get people into sort of affordable housing, uh the uh concept would be that uh people would uh who are eligible and apply to uh participate in their program would need to do a few things.
- 1:33Michael Mulligan: One would be to do some volunteer work of a few hundred hours, kind of helping towards building uh the house or other houses.
- 1:41Michael Mulligan: Um and then the concept is that the uh individual or family that's going to get the home uh would need to qualify for a kind of retail mortgage, but for a smaller percentage of what the actual value of the house would be.
- 1:57Michael Mulligan: And the idea is that uh the Habitat for Humanity they would uh subsidize sort of additional funding for the home, get people to volunteer to do work and provide materials to build the home, uh, with the whole idea that a person would be able to get into a home even if they don't have, for example, a down payment, uh, and to make sure they're not having to pay more than 30% of their uh gross income.
- 2:20Michael Mulligan: So that's a good program, good idea, right?
- 2:23Michael Mulligan: Uh and so in this case in Victoria, a woman who's uh it sounds like a single mom with a couple of kids applied for the program uh and she was accepted, and they sent uh a letter out referred to as an acceptance letter of intent.
- 2:38Michael Mulligan: And the letter specified that it was not a contract, just uh specifying that they would, that is to say, Habitat for Humanity Victoria, would make every reasonable effort to provide a new, renovated, or pre-owned home for the person who qualified.
- 2:52Michael Mulligan: So so far so good.
- 2:53Michael Mulligan: Now, the other interesting thing about it is while some of these things are going on.
- 2:57Michael Mulligan: I guess there's like work being done on the home or the person's volunteering to do other things, whatever it might be, uh to qualify for this uh program.
- 3:05Michael Mulligan: Uh they in some cases, as in this case, it allow the person to enter into what they refer to as an early occupancy agreement, and this is where the legal route is going to come, where they uh allow the person to or the family to move into the home uh before they're in a position to uh qualify to buy it.
- 3:27Michael Mulligan: Uh and what they do during that period of time, pursuant to that early occupancy agreement, um, is that the family living or the person living there agrees to pay a what's referred to in that agreement as a monthly occupancy fee.
- 3:41Michael Mulligan: And interestingly, the monthly occupancy fee is set up to be a percentage of the person's income, like no more than 30% of their income.
- 3:49Michael Mulligan: So if your income goes down, what you might have to pay would go down.
- 3:53Michael Mulligan: And the money that you're paying as part of this monthly occupancy fee is collected up, and that amounts to the person's, I guess, down payment eventually, right, when they're in a position to purchase the home.
- 4:05Michael Mulligan: And so indeed, this person moved into the home with uh kids back in 2020, uh, and things marched along.
- 4:12Michael Mulligan: Unfortunately for her, it sounds like she had uh some health problems that caused her to leave employment that she was with, and then she got a couple of other jobs which didn't work out.
- 4:20Michael Mulligan: Uh, and so she didn't, her income went down.
- 4:23Michael Mulligan: And so she went uh wrote to Habitat Humanity on multiple occasions, hey, I lost my job, I don't have any income, can you put off uh accepting this uh these payments?
- 4:32Michael Mulligan: And they agreed to reduce them and suspend them, and they did all kinds of things to try to sort of keep her on track.
- 4:38Michael Mulligan: Um uh and ultimately, unfortunately, they got to the point where they eventually wrote to her and said, Okay, we're ready to sell you your home.
- 4:46Michael Mulligan: Exclamation point in the letter they sent out.
- 4:50Michael Mulligan: Um and at that point, I guess she'd lost uh her employment, and she wrote back protesting, saying she was expecting a much lower price, and eventually they agreed to lower the price.
- 4:59Michael Mulligan: They were saying the house was going to be sold for$720,000.
- 5:03Michael Mulligan: They agreed to lower the price of the house to five hundred and fifty thousand dollars.
- 5:07Michael Mulligan: Now, not a small amount of money, but in the Victoria real estate market, buying a home, uh, you know, that it that is only possible as a result of the charitable efforts here.
- 5:17Michael Mulligan: Now, things went from bad to worse because the uh in order to uh make good on this, you know, we're ready to sell you the home, and having agreed to put off things, reduce the amount of money, and reduce the price, ultimately she just wasn't able to.
- 5:31Michael Mulligan: I guess she just lost her employment and wasn't able to qualify for even the small amount of mortgage that would be required to make the whole program work.
- 5:40Michael Mulligan: Um and so it just fell apart, basically, right?
- 5:43Michael Mulligan: So you have to be able to pay something.
- 5:45Michael Mulligan: Habitat for Humanity doesn't provide free houses for people.
- 5:48Michael Mulligan: Yeah they provide subsidized housing for people that you contribute to.
- 5:51Michael Mulligan: That's the kind of the idea, sweat equity and all that.
- 5:54Michael Mulligan: And so eventually, after much putting off and extensions and this and that, they eventually sent her a letter saying, I'm sorry, you have to vacate uh the home.
- 6:02Michael Mulligan: You're not purchasing it, you're not paying these monthly amounts for it, you're you're gonna have to go.
- 6:07Michael Mulligan: And it resulted in her going to the residential tenancy branch and making an argument that in fact she claimed to at that point be a tenant uh in a rental unit.
- 6:18Michael Mulligan: And so the adjudicator for the residential tenancy branch looked at all this, looked at all the legislation, and disagreed with her ultimately, interpreting how that legislation worked, even though importantly, that resident the residential tenancy legislation in BC, one of its provisions, core provisions, is that you can't contract out of the Residential Tenancy Act, you know, because the Residential Tenancy Act would have terms for like how much rent can go up and when somebody can be invicted and what people have to do.
- 6:47Michael Mulligan: It wouldn't be very effective if you could just have an every tenancy agreement a thing saying the Residential Tenancy Act does not apply, right?
- 6:54Michael Mulligan: It would be immediately circumvented.
- 6:56Michael Mulligan: So that's not allowed.
- 6:57Michael Mulligan: But the adjudicator eventually found this wasn't in the meaning of the act a rental unit, and so that she was not a tenant, and so ordered her, no, you've got to go.
- 7:06Michael Mulligan: You just don't qualify for this, you know, uh program.
- 7:09Michael Mulligan: She took that, she had counsel arguing that interestingly, because I guess there's a fair bit on the line, uh, and she took that to a judicial review in the BC Supreme Court, and she succeeded in the BC Supreme Court.
- 7:22Michael Mulligan: The judge in the BC Supreme Court concluded that uh the adjudicator had made a patently unreasonable decision, um, and so found that she was attendant and this was a rental unit.
- 7:34Michael Mulligan: Uh Habitat for Humanity Victoria, I think probably realizing that would be the end of their capacity to continue to do what they were doing, appealed that to the BC Court of Appeal.
- 7:43Michael Mulligan: And it's that decision which just came out just a few days ago.
- 7:48Michael Mulligan: And I guess unfortunately for the woman, but fortunately for the Habitat for Humanity, and I guess anyone else who might be involved with it, the Court of Appeal overturned the BC Supreme Court decision and found that the adjudicator's interpretation of what was going on, what how this legislation is intended to work was not patently unreasonable, and that the judge reviewing it had applied too high of a threshold and effectively applied their own interpretation of how these things uh should be viewed.
- 8:16Michael Mulligan: And the Court of Appeal pointed out that there is a modern approach to how you know legislation is to be interpreted and it's to be uh you know, sort of assessed in the uh uh a way that ultimately is to sort of get at what is the uh purpose of this legislation, uh, and pointed out, as I talked about, the fact that uh had the uh uh ver had the argument that the woman had been making succeeded, that this uh when you were had an early occupancy agreement and you were doing volunteer work and so on and collecting up money that would amount to your down payment uh based on your income, if that meant you were a tenant and this was a rental unit, uh it would mean effectively that habitats uh for humanity's charitable purpose, having people who need housing be there and trying to subsidize it, it would just all fall apart, basically.
- 9:05Michael Mulligan: Um and so the Court of Appeal found that uh the interpretation implied by the Residential Tenancy Act was not patently unreasonable, um, and that the uh unit was not a rental unit, and this wasn't just some effort to contract out of the Residential Tenancy Act.
- 9:21Michael Mulligan: It was just a fundamentally different thing.
- 9:23Michael Mulligan: You know, it's this agreement that you could sort of live there where while you're doing some work on the place to uh and uh uh the money being paid this monthly occupancy fee wasn't rent.
- 9:35Michael Mulligan: Um and they pointed out things like, for example, it wasn't a fixed amount of money.
- 9:39Michael Mulligan: It was sort of a well, you can pay this amount of money, but it will can go down if your income goes down to eventually in some points when the woman was not working at all, she was paying nothing.
- 9:49Michael Mulligan: Right?
- 9:49Michael Mulligan: And so you'd have to wonder, well, what would that tenancy agreement look like?
- 9:52Michael Mulligan: Could you just be forever unemployed and remain in the home owned by human habitat for humanity?
- 9:56Michael Mulligan: Is that what's been agreed to here?
- 9:58Michael Mulligan: Uh and so that's the latest on it.
- 10:00Michael Mulligan: A very interesting case that it made it all the way to the Court of Appeal uh and a local case, and one uh the outcome of which uh uh has the uh effect uh of uh allowing that uh Habitat for Humanity charity to continue with their work.
- 10:13Michael Mulligan: Uh so that's the latest from the Court of Appeal on who isn't who is not a tenant and uh whether uh that sort of an agreement amounts to a uh rental unit residential tenants yet.
- 10:22Adam Stirling: Michael Mulgan with Mulligan Defense Lawyers legally speaking will continue right after that.
- 10:26Adam Stirling: Uh back on the air here, in fact, it's the legally speaking continues at Michael Mulligan from Mulligan Defense Lawyers.
- 10:33Adam Stirling: Michael, before the break we were talking about Habitat for Humanity, what's next on our agenda?
- 10:38Michael Mulligan: Uh next on the agenda is a case uh recently decided that deals with the issue of whether somebody uh has the capacity to stand trial, whether they're fit to stand trial.
- 10:50Michael Mulligan: Um and uh that's an interesting thing because it's distinct from a issue we've spoken about before, which is the issue of whether somebody might be uh not criminally responsible as a result of a mental disorder, right?
- 11:03Michael Mulligan: And that analysis, whether somebody might be not criminally responsible for a specific criminal allegation, is analyzing what was going on at the time of the event, right?
- 11:13Michael Mulligan: You know, what's did the person have a mental disorder that prevented them from knowing right from wrong or what they were doing, that sort of thing.
- 11:20Michael Mulligan: But this case deals with a separate uh issue, which is the issue of whether a person is unfit to stand trial.
- 11:28Michael Mulligan: Uh now, in that regard, the criminal code first of all provides that there's a presumption that people are fit to stand trial.
- 11:35Michael Mulligan: Uh yeah, and so if uh you uh either party, crown or defense, uh wishes to argue that the accused is unfit to stand trial, they have the burden of proving that on a balance of probabilities.
- 11:48Michael Mulligan: The other interesting thing about this case is this was a woman who was charged with uh reckless discharging of a firearm.
- 11:55Michael Mulligan: That's the offense.
- 11:56Michael Mulligan: And it was not the defense, but rather the crown that was arguing uh that this woman was unfit to stand trial and therefore should not have their trial until she was fit.
- 12:07Michael Mulligan: Uh she had counsel appointed uh by the uh court to assist her, and the position of defense counsel was she is fit to stand trial and wants to proceed to trial.
- 12:17Michael Mulligan: Uh so an interesting juxtaposition there.
- 12:20Michael Mulligan: Uh now the other interesting thing about this case is the nature of the alleged uh mental disorder.
- 12:26Michael Mulligan: Uh, because the whole premise of either of those things, right, the person be arguing they were unfit um or an argument about whether somebody is fit to stand trial, the starting point has to be that the fitness is a result of a mental disorder, right?
- 12:41Michael Mulligan: Like if somebody was unfit because they had taken a bunch of drugs or something, or they're very drunk, right?
- 12:46Michael Mulligan: That's not going to make you uh subject to mental disorder.
- 12:49Michael Mulligan: You're just drunk.
- 12:50Michael Mulligan: We'll wait for you to sober up and we'll carry on, right?
- 12:52Michael Mulligan: So, first of all, it has to be a mental disorder.
- 12:55Michael Mulligan: Now, here, the mental disorder in question was un an unspecified psychosis with religious delusions.
- 13:04Michael Mulligan: Uh and so the in this case, the crown was arguing that her religious delusions made her unfit to stand trial.
- 13:12Michael Mulligan: Um and the crown's argument was that the woman did not recognize the authority of the court, having said things like, Only God has authority over her, and God will be her redeemer.
- 13:22Michael Mulligan: Um and so it's an interesting uh uh allegation of unfitness.
- 13:29Michael Mulligan: Now uh the uh in order to uh pursue this, the there was a uh uh psychiatrist uh who went and conducted uh an assessment of the woman, meeting with her on multiple occasions.
- 13:42Michael Mulligan: Uh unfortunately she seemed to be struggling.
- 13:44Michael Mulligan: She was in uh forensic uh custody, um, and the person doing the psychiatrist described her as a deeply religious and spiritual person who, in that person's opinion, suffered from religious delusions.
- 13:59Michael Mulligan: Uh and the other thing about her in custody there with these religious delusions, uh, she had refused to accept antipsychotic medication, uh, denying that she was delusional or in need of medication.
- 14:11Michael Mulligan: And so the mental health facility she was detained in was had her restrained in bed and was giving her injections of this antipsychotic medication against her will.
- 14:23Michael Mulligan: Uh she was also responding to this treatment uh by refusing to eat or drink, uh, to which the psychiatrist was asking her whether she understood the consequences of not eating or drinking, to which she responded, the eternal body will be with God, the body left behind will decompose.
- 14:41Michael Mulligan: That was her explanation for it.
- 14:43Michael Mulligan: Now, eventually, uh uh happily, she agreed to accept nourishment, uh, but they continued to be an assessment of her beliefs.
- 14:52Michael Mulligan: Um and she uh indicated that she was not suffering from a uh hallucinations, auditory or visual.
- 14:59Michael Mulligan: She did, however, believe that she was uh that Jesus spoke to her and that she was married to God.
- 15:06Michael Mulligan: Now, there was a, as I mentioned, there was a lawyer who was appointed to assist her.
- 15:12Michael Mulligan: Um, and when the uh psychiatrist was asking her about uh the uh case and the trial and so on, uh she pointed to a sticker on the wall of her bed.
- 15:21Michael Mulligan: I guess she's restrained in the bed, that had a name and phone number on it, and she said that was the lawyer who was going to come over and speak to her, and she said she would speak to the lawyer, but that Jesus Christ was going to represent her in court.
- 15:34Michael Mulligan: So it was a little unclear whether she thought actually Jesus Christ was going to show up there or whether she was going to represent herself with uh insights from Jesus Christ, but that's how she expressed it.
- 15:45Michael Mulligan: And so that's the fact pattern before this judge with the crowd arguing that she's unfit to have her trial.
- 15:51Michael Mulligan: Um and the judge went on to start with the uh what the assessment needs to be, and and this is important to know as well.
- 15:59Michael Mulligan: First of all, as I mentioned, you're presumed to be fit to stand trial.
- 16:02Michael Mulligan: Uh and the first question is, do you have a mental disorder?
- 16:06Michael Mulligan: Uh and on that ground, the judge was prepared to conclude that yes, she did have a mental disorder as a result of these religious delusions.
- 16:14Michael Mulligan: Now, the that's not the end of it though.
- 16:17Michael Mulligan: As the judge quite correctly pointed out, somebody who has a mental illness can certainly have a criminal trial, right?
- 16:23Michael Mulligan: Those are not mutually exclusive.
- 16:25Michael Mulligan: And what is required of something isn't that much in terms of what uh you would need to appreciate.
- 16:31Michael Mulligan: So, for example, you would have to, as a result of a mental disorder, be unable to understand the nature of the proceedings, like if somebody didn't appreciate, you know, I'm accused of doing something wrong, uh, or, you know, they think this is some sort of uh, you know, something else, that's not going to do it.
- 16:47Michael Mulligan: But it's got to be an understanding of the nature of the and object of the proceedings.
- 16:51Michael Mulligan: You have to understand the possible consequences of the proceedings, you need to be able to communicate with counsel.
- 16:57Michael Mulligan: Uh, and then there are some other basic things that some of the cases interpreting that referred to.
- 17:02Michael Mulligan: Like you have to have some understanding that that's the judge who's kind of deciding what's going on here, and the prosecutor's not helping me, and you know, this defense lawyer is here to help me.
- 17:12Michael Mulligan: Those kind of base that kind of a basic understanding.
- 17:15Michael Mulligan: Uh and the judge also pointed out that while you do have to have that sort of an understanding, um an accused person is free to make choices even if they're very poor choices, and even if the poor choices are with respect to their defense.
- 17:31Michael Mulligan: Uh saying, you know, for example, you know, it may be that this woman's deciding to represent herself.
- 17:36Michael Mulligan: Maybe that's what she means by Jesus is going to be my lawyer.
- 17:39Michael Mulligan: Maybe she means she's not going to have the other lawyer help and she's going to rely upon religious insights or something to defend herself.
- 17:47Michael Mulligan: But as the judge pointed out, you know, you're allowed to do that, right?
- 17:52Michael Mulligan: You that's not inconsistent with some understanding of the judge and I'm being charged with this and so on.
- 17:58Michael Mulligan: Uh and so uh given that the bird is on the crown, because they're the one raising this, defense wants and she wants to get on with her trial, um, the uh judge was not satisfied, even though they were satisfied, she had a mental disorder, uh, that uh she was uh uh uh unfit to stand trial.
- 18:19Michael Mulligan: And the judge contrasted this with other cases, like there's another BC case that he referred to from a few years ago, where an accused person was having overwhelming auditory hallucinations and delusions, and they thought the prosecutor and defense counsel and the judge were in a conspiracy against them, and so on, right?
- 18:37Michael Mulligan: And in that sort of a circumstance, as the judge points out, that person can't have a trial, right?
- 18:43Michael Mulligan: They don't know what's going on, they can't, they don't appreciate what's happening.
- 18:46Michael Mulligan: Uh, but that's not the case here.
- 18:48Michael Mulligan: Uh, and so the uh net result is the judge uh was not persuaded by the crown that the woman was unfit to stand trial, uh, and uh she will get her wish, and with the assistance of Jesus Christ and God, she will be able to have her trial about whether she was reckless in discharging a firearm.
- 19:05Michael Mulligan: So that's latest on fitness to stand trial in BC and how that relates to uh potential religious delusions.
- 19:11Michael Mulligan: Okay.
- 19:12Adam Stirling: We've got less than 90 seconds road at twelve fifty-nine.
- 19:15Michael Mulligan: Is there anything else we want to say?
- 19:17Adam Stirling: Sure.
- 19:18Michael Mulligan: Sure.
- 19:18Michael Mulligan: Final case just to mention the BC Court of Appeal decision, and it was a case appealing the uh foreign buyer's tax.
- 19:25Michael Mulligan: It was applied to a uh couple that purchased a property in BC, a condo.
- 19:29Michael Mulligan: And the interesting fact pattern is that uh one of the people provided who was the foreign national provided five percent, was put on title for five percent of it, and the other person who was Canadian was put on title for 95%.
- 19:42Michael Mulligan: And they argued that they shouldn't have to pay the foreign buyer's tax on the full price of the condo, they should only have to pay it on the five percent owned by the person who wasn't a Canadian citizen.
- 19:52Michael Mulligan: Uh and uh that issue made it all the way to the BC Court of Appeal, who decided against them, and so the net result there is that uh if You uh purchase a property and one of the people who's purchasing it is not uh you know, would be subject to paying that foreign buyer's tax in British Columbia, you are on the hook for paying the foreign buyer's tax on the complete amount of the property.
- 20:14Michael Mulligan: And the analysis dealt with things like in the legislation, uh it contemplates things like uh a person holding a property in trust for somebody else to avoid that being a way to skirt the tax.
- 20:26Michael Mulligan: Uh and so the uh takeaway there is that uh if you uh wind up uh purchasing a property and one of the people on title uh or beneficial owner is not uh a uh you know Canadian citizen or permanent resident here, uh, you're gonna be on the hook for the uh tax on the entire price of the property.
- 20:43Michael Mulligan: So that's the latest on the foreign buyer's tax from the BC Court of Appeal.
- 20:46Adam Stirling: All right, Michael Mulligan, Mulligan Defense Lawyers, legally speaking, during the second half of our second hour every Thursday.
- 20:51Adam Stirling: Thank you so much.
- 20:52Adam Stirling: Pleasure as always.
- 20:53Adam Stirling: Thanks so much.
- 20:54Adam Stirling: Always great to be here.
- 20:55Adam Stirling: All right, quick break.
- 20:55Adam Stirling: News next.