Latest / Politics with Paul / Politics with Paul Podcast #16 - 2024 Election Recap (Thus Far)
Transcript
- 0:00Welcome back to the politics with Paul podcast with your host, Paul Raider.
- 0:06The 2024 election is over.
- 0:08Yes.
- 0:08We don't have to see any more of those political ads Regardless of whether the
- 0:13election went the way you wanted to or not, at least we can rejoice and celebrate that part.
- 0:19The dust has mostly settled on the 2024 election results, though we still have some
- 0:25winners of various elections across the country that have not been decided.
- 0:30Couple US house races are still too close to call as of this recording.
- 0:34Full state legislative party memberships have not been fully decided for this upcoming term.
- 0:40The totals for all of these races still need to be made official before we can fully analyze
- 0:45the results such as exact margins of victory, and there will probably be some recounts.
- 0:51So there are still a lot of little nitty gritty details that we can't study with full accuracy
- 0:57yet.
- 0:57Nevertheless, though, there are plenty of takeaways that are already apparent, and those
- 1:03takeaways are what we are going to talk about today.
- 1:06And we've got plenty of key points to talk about with presidential, congressional,
- 1:10gubernatorial, and state legislative results as well as ballot measure results.
- 1:15And we already know some split ticket instances where several individual states voted
- 1:21differently for president than they did for US senate or for one of these states for governor.
- 1:27Actually, 2 of these states for governor.
- 1:30So let's dive in.
- 1:33First up, of course, let's talk about the presidential election.
- 1:36So Donald Trump becomes the 2nd ever president to become president for 2 nonconsecutive terms.
- 1:45The first one of those being Grover Cleveland in the latter 19th century.
- 1:50And Donald Trump, somewhat surprisingly, won all 7 of the battleground states, Arizona,
- 1:56Georgia, Michigan, Nevada, North Carolina, Pennsylvania, and Wisconsin.
- 2:02And in several of those states, there that his victories were in large part powered by major
- 2:07gains in Republican voter registration from 2020 to 2024.
- 2:12And not only that, in some of those cases, the total number of registered Democrats actually
- 2:18decreased.
- 2:19So in Arizona, for example, rep Republicans increased by about 53,000 voters in that 4 year
- 2:27span, about a 3a half percent increase in their based on their 2020 total registration.
- 2:34In Nevada, they increased by about 40,000 voters in that 4 year span, which was about a
- 2:396.1% increase from their 2020 total registration.
- 2:44And in Pennsylvania, Republicans increased from 3,520,000 voters in the 2020 election to about
- 2:503,701,000 in the 2024 election.
- 2:55And also helping out Republicans in those states was a fact that, once again, there was a
- 3:00decrease in total registered Democrats.
- 3:02So very big reasons why Donald Trump was able to win at least those states.
- 3:09You have a larger base to draw on from.
- 3:11It's already an advantage.
- 3:13And your party affiliation is the single biggest indicator of how you're going to vote
- 3:20in an election.
- 3:23Now, of course, as most people know, there is an electoral and a popular vote.
- 3:29So the electoral vote is the one that you actually need to win.
- 3:33Although it's largely based on popular votes, it's if you win popular votes in each
- 3:37individual state, you get that state's electoral votes, generally speaking.
- 3:43312 to 226 is what Donald Trump won by.
- 3:47270 is the majority that you need.
- 3:50And it's the most electoral votes that a presidential candidate, excuse me, has won
- 3:55since 2012, and that was when Barack Obama won 332 in his reelection campaign.
- 4:03The battleground states themselves accounted for 93 electoral votes, which was 34.4% of the
- 4:11majority needed to win, which is, again, 270.
- 4:15And so 93 electoral votes was about 30% of what Donald Trump got of his total electoral votes
- 4:24that he won.
- 4:26And as for the popular vote, this is the first time in 20 years that a Republican presidential
- 4:31candidate has won the popular vote, and make yeah.
- 4:36That included McCain in 2008, Mitt Romney in 2012, and then Donald Trump himself in 2016 and
- 4:442020.
- 4:44Now those vote totals are still being calculated, but it is definite that he has won
- 4:50the popular vote by several million, popular votes.
- 4:55In 2,004, George w Bush won 50.7 percent of the popular vote.
- 5:01So that was the last time that a Republican won the popular vote.
- 5:05We'll see for sure if Donald Trump eclipsed that number.
- 5:11Now do you watch my previews of the 2024 election?
- 5:16You probably heard that I said that Donald Trump probably wouldn't win the popular vote.
- 5:22He lost it by about 2,800,000 votes in 2016 and then about 7,000,000 votes in 2020.
- 5:28So, I guess, 3rd time was the charge.
- 5:32I was wrong.
- 5:34Doesn't happen that often.
- 5:35I can count the number of times I've been wrong in my life on one hand if my hand had thousands
- 5:42of fingers on it.
- 5:43But in any case, sometimes you're wrong, and I was this time.
- 5:48Oh, well.
- 5:50Now there were key places that Kamala Harris underperformed compared to Joe Biden, and those
- 5:55are big reasons why Donald Trump was able to win these battleground states.
- 6:02Now when I say underperforming, I specifically mean Kamala Harris won a smaller vote share of
- 6:08a state or a county or whatever unit area that I'm talking about than Joe Biden did.
- 6:16So, for example, if Joe Biden won x county by 55% in 2020 and then Kamala Harris only won it
- 6:25by 53%, that means that she underperformed relative to Joe Biden.
- 6:30Now underperforming doesn't necessarily mean that Kamala Harris lost that state or county,
- 6:36but she won it by less than Joe Biden did in 2020, just like in that example I talked about.
- 6:43So more concrete actual examples.
- 6:46So in Arizona, Maricopa County, that is the largest county in Arizona.
- 6:51It flipped from Biden in 2020 to Donald Trump in 2024, yet it still voted for Ruben Gallego
- 6:58in the US senate.
- 7:00So an instance of split ticket voting that we're gonna talk about later in this episode.
- 7:07Michigan, democratic strongholds of Wayne and Oakland counties, and Wayne County is where
- 7:13Detroit is.
- 7:14Those both state Democrat, but noticeably lower vote shares in both of them for Kamala Harris
- 7:20in 2024 than Joe Biden had in 2020.
- 7:24In Nevada, Kamala Harris still won Clark County, which has you may have heard of it.
- 7:29It's a city called Las Vegas.
- 7:31And Washoe County, which has Reno, the biggest little city in the world as they call
- 7:36themselves.
- 7:37But, again, lower vote shares in those counties than Joe Biden did in 2020.
- 7:43And then lastly, Pennsylvania, Harris 1, Dolphin County, which has Harrisburg, Lehigh
- 7:49County, which has Allentown, and then Philadelphia County, which obviously has
- 7:53Philadelphia.
- 7:54But, again, lower vote share than Biden had in 2020.
- 7:59And then Trump also flipped Erie and Northampton counties and possibly Bucks and
- 8:04Monroe counties in, in Pennsylvania.
- 8:08So big reasons why Donald Trump was able to win those battleground states in particular.
- 8:16Now moving on to the US senate's election results.
- 8:20So the races that were not expected to be competitive went the way that they were
- 8:24expected to.
- 8:25And Republicans gained the majority, and now they have 53 seats, which was not exactly
- 8:31surprising.
- 8:31They were expected to take the chamber, maybe not necessarily having 53 seats, but they were
- 8:38still expected to take the majority.
- 8:39So even if Kamala Harris had 1, Republicans would have the majority of the US Senate, which
- 8:45means there would not have been a tie breaking vote with Kamala Harris's would be vice
- 8:51president, which in this case would be Tim would have been Tim Waltz.
- 8:5553 state or excuse me.
- 8:5753 seats is the most seats that Republicans have had in the US Senate since the 2018
- 9:03election results, which is 2 years following Donald Trump's win in 2016 1st win, back in
- 9:122016.
- 9:13So Republicans flipped 4 seats, which included defeats of 3 incumbents who first won in 2006,
- 9:20so they were running for their 4th term.
- 9:24And those dates are and, also, democrats didn't flip any seats, but they didn't really have
- 9:30many opportunities to do so.
- 9:31There weren't a whole lot of materially competitive seats that republicans had already
- 9:38had.
- 9:39Most of the competitive ones were ones already held by democrats.
- 9:43So cases where republicans flipped seats that had long time incumbents, we have Montana where
- 9:50Tim Shee defeated incumbent Jon Tester.
- 9:53In Ohio, Bernie Moreno defeated incumbent Sherrod Brown, which was the hottest US Senate
- 10:00race in terms of which one election forecasters thought would be the most competitive.
- 10:05That was Ohio.
- 10:06That was the one that was unanimously considered a toss-up, at least by the election
- 10:11forecasters that we had discussed in the previews.
- 10:16And in the Pennsylvania, Dave McCormack defeated incumbent Bob Casey junior.
- 10:21Now the other state where there wasn't an incumbent was West Virginia.
- 10:26Joe Manchin, former democrat who became an independent, He did not run for reelection.
- 10:31Governor Jim Justice defeated Glenn Elliott in an open seat because, again, vacated by Joe
- 10:37Manchin.
- 10:38So those make up the 4 seats that Republicans flipped.
- 10:42Montana, Ohio, Pennsylvania, and West Virginia.
- 10:47Now Democrats in several states, however, did buck their states voting Donald Trump for
- 10:53president, so cases of split ticket voting.
- 10:57So in Arizona, we had US house representative Ruben Gallego defeated Carrie Lake.
- 11:03You might remember her as a 2022 Arizona gubernatorial candidate.
- 11:07She lost to Katie Hobbs in a very tight election.
- 11:10This one was not a blowout by any means, but it was not nearly as tight as it was, as the 2022
- 11:19Arizona gubernatorial election was.
- 11:22Like we said before, unlike Kamala Harris, Diego actually won Maricopa County, which is
- 11:27the largest county, and it also has Phoenix.
- 11:30And regardless of whether he won or lost a given county, Diego had a larger vote share in
- 11:36each county than Kamala Harris did.
- 11:40So much different results, not just by who won in for president versus US senate, but
- 11:47basically, vote totals had well, not necessarily completely flipped.
- 11:53Donald Trump defeated Kamala Harris by more than Ruben Gallego defeated Carrie Lake by, but
- 11:59it was a noticeably stark contrast between Donald Trump and Carrie Lake.
- 12:05Carrie Lake being very much a pro Trump candidate who made no bones about it.
- 12:12Maybe not as obvious this year compared to 2022, but still, it didn't help her overcome
- 12:21Ruben Gallego in the US senate race even though Donald Trump won the state or president.
- 12:27Over in Michigan, we had US house representative Olisa Slotkin defeating former
- 12:33US house rep Mike Rogers.
- 12:35Slotkin won Muskegon County, which Kamala Harris did not, and the in the Democratic
- 12:42strongholds of places like Ingham County, which has Lansing, Oakland County, and Wayne County,
- 12:48which again has Detroit.
- 12:50Lotkin won a higher vote share in her contest for US senate than Kamala Harris did in her
- 12:56contest for US president.
- 13:00Nevada, incumbent Jackie Rosen defeated Sam Brown.
- 13:05Rosen performed better than Kamala Harris did in Clark County and Washoe County.
- 13:10Again, Clark County has Las Vegas, and Washoe County has Reno.
- 13:14And then Wisconsin, incumbents Tammy Baldwin defeated Eric Hovde, who still unsure if he's
- 13:21gonna ask for a recount because it was a very tight race.
- 13:24He might still argue for a recount, still probably not gonna be enough to overturn the
- 13:30election, but it was a very tight race.
- 13:33Baldwin won Sauk County, which Kamala Harris did it, did not.
- 13:39It Sauk County is not a large county.
- 13:42It's it's actually maybe not quite small, but it's it's not a huge population county.
- 13:50But because the presidential and US senate contest were so tight in that state, every vote
- 13:56matters.
- 13:58And although both Baldwin and Kamala Harris won Dane County, which has Madison, Eau Claire
- 14:04County, which has Eau Claire, and Milwaukee County, which has Milwaukee, Baldwin won a
- 14:11higher vote share in her contest in each of those states or each of those counties, excuse
- 14:17me, for US senate than Kamala Harris did in her run for president.
- 14:23And then neither one of the democrats won Brown County, which has Green Bay, but, Tammy Baldwin
- 14:30still won a higher vote share in her contest than Kamala Harris did in hers.
- 14:36Now onto the US cost race results.
- 14:39This chamber was the one that democrats actually had a fairly decent chance of taking
- 14:47from Republicans.
- 14:48But, nevertheless, Republicans have kept the majority, and they have at least 220 seats.
- 14:54218 is the majority.
- 14:56So they at least have the majority in that chamber, though it'll be fairly tight.
- 15:02Flipped seats, we have at least 8 that flipped from democrat to republican.
- 15:07We have Alaska's at large, which is where Mary Peltola is.
- 15:12She lost to Nick Begich.
- 15:14Colorado's 8th, Michigan's 7th, North Carolina's 6th, 13th, and 14th districts, but
- 15:20in Pennsylvania's 7th and 8th.
- 15:22And those 2, the latter 2 in Pennsylvania were 2 of the tightest, or expected to be the most 2
- 15:31of the most competitive races in the country, at least in terms of US house.
- 15:39And then there are at least 7 republican to democrat lifts.
- 15:42We have Alabama's 2nd, California's 27th, Louisiana's 6th, New York's 4th, 19th, and
- 15:5022nd, and then Oregon's 5th district.
- 15:53So not enough republican to democratic flips to offset the democrats or republican flips unless
- 16:02depending on the last 2, congress or US house races that have not been decided, which are
- 16:09California's 13th 45th districts, especially the 45th district.
- 16:13That's only about a couple 100 votes difference right now.
- 16:18So those could particular could perhaps be republican to democratic flips because those
- 16:25are both republican incumbents, but that's still not enough to deny a republican majority.
- 16:30So we might have 9 republican to democratic flips in the end, and 8 democrat to republican
- 16:37flips have already happened, but, we'll have to see.
- 16:42But in any case, republicans still have the majority in the chamber.
- 16:48And in any case, it seems to be a reversal of a recent trend in presidential elections where
- 16:54actually the winning presidential candidate's party perhaps surprisingly didn't do well in US
- 17:00house elections.
- 17:01Now in midterm elections, the sitting president's party tends to do very poorly,
- 17:08especially in the US house.
- 17:11But it would as surprising as it may be, lately, it hasn't been going well for the
- 17:17winning presidential candidate's party in presidential years either.
- 17:20So in 2016, when Trump won the first time, Republicans lost 6 seats in the chamber.
- 17:25And in 2020, when Biden won, Democrats lost 13 seats in the chamber.
- 17:32Maybe can't quite call 2 elections in a row a trend, but just for the sake of this argument,
- 17:38we're just gonna call it a trend here.
- 17:40And so it seems like there may be a gain of 1 seat for Republicans.
- 17:48Again, we'll have we'll have to see how those last 2 US house races in California shake out.
- 17:54But in any case, it seems to be at least a little bit of a difference compared to the last
- 18:00two presidential elections where the winning presidential candidate's party actually did not
- 18:06do well in the elections and, in fact, actually lost some seats.
- 18:12Gubernatorial elections.
- 18:14So we had 11 races for governor.
- 18:1710 were not expected to be very competitive, and they went the way that they were expected
- 18:22to.
- 18:22The only one that was expected to be competitive was New Hampshire.
- 18:28Now not all of these were necessarily blowouts.
- 18:30Some of them certainly were, but the only one that appears to be within a 10 point margin was
- 18:38that New Hampshire race we talked about, which had Kelly Ayotte, the republican former US
- 18:43senator, going up against democrat Joyce Craig, who was a local politician.
- 18:49But even that seems to be around a 9 point margin.
- 18:52So not by any means a route, but at the same time, not exactly a close election either.
- 19:00Now North Carolina and New Hampshire were the only two states where there were split ticket
- 19:05results between presidential and gubernatorial voting.
- 19:08So in New Hampshire, they voted democrat for president, although that one was pretty tight
- 19:13race, maybe tighter than people expected.
- 19:16Kamala Harris only won by about 2 points, and then it voted Republican for governor again by
- 19:23about 9 points.
- 19:25So roughly an 11 point difference in margins based on how it voted for Democrats and
- 19:32Republicans for president and governor.
- 19:35And then North Carolina is a republican for president and then democrat for governor.
- 19:39And, again, not a particularly close election for governor.
- 19:43Well, this sort sort of close with, with president.
- 19:46Again, we don't know the exact margins of victory until we get certified official
- 19:50results, but presidential voting was sort of close, fairly close in both, states.
- 19:59So not exactly Barnburners, but governor voting showed very clear winners in those states.
- 20:05So certainly not gonna see any sort of recounts or anything for for those states.
- 20:12We'll see a lot more competitive gubernatorial races in the midterms in 2026.
- 20:18And maybe even 1 or 2 in 2025 because there are gonna be at least at least one state is having
- 20:27a gubernatorial election next year.
- 20:29I gotta double check on that, but which is Virginia.
- 20:32But,
- 20:33other than that, though,
- 20:34not a whole lot to to examine in gubernatorial elections in terms of competitiveness because
- 20:42the only one expected to be competitive, New Hampshire wasn't extremely competitive anyways.
- 20:49State legislative results.
- 20:51Now here we're talking specifically about majority partisan control of the state
- 20:56legislative chambers, not individual seats because there's just way too many of those.
- 21:00There's thousands of those.
- 21:01Over 7,000, in fact.
- 21:04But not many changes in partisan majorities here.
- 21:09Republicans did gain the majority in the Michigan state house and at least a tie in the
- 21:14Minnesota State House.
- 21:16They may still win a majority there, but, in any case, they at least have a tie.
- 21:23Democrats did not gain any chambers this election cycle.
- 21:28Now 44 states held elections in at least one state legislative chamber.
- 21:33Most of them held it in both their state house and state senate, but that was not the case for
- 21:37all of them.
- 21:38And several changed supermajority status.
- 21:41Now when we're talking about supermajority, we mean that one party controls enough seats in a
- 21:47state legislature where they can override a governor's veto on a bill without needing
- 21:51members of the other party.
- 21:54And every so often, that can also mean a state legislature being the same party that the
- 22:01governor is.
- 22:02So what that super majority is, it can depend on the state because not every state has the
- 22:08same exact threshold for overriding a governor's veto in terms of do they need 2
- 22:13thirds of each of the of each chamber of a state legislature to override a governor's
- 22:19veto, or do they need a civil majority or 60%.
- 22:23It can vary from state to state because there's a lot of things that vary about how each
- 22:27state's politics and governments work.
- 22:31But in terms of whether there's one party that controls enough seats in the state legislature
- 22:38and, again, can be the same party as the governor or might not be the same party as the
- 22:43governor.
- 22:44For example, Kansas, the state legislature there is very Republican, but there's a
- 22:49Democratic governor in Laura Kelly.
- 22:52So for Democrats, there were 8 state legislatures with supermajorities before the
- 22:572024 election.
- 22:59Now there are 6 that have supermajorities.
- 23:01New York and Vermont both lost their democratic supermajorities, though there's still plenty
- 23:07democratic.
- 23:08So there's no there's no it's not really gonna be terribly competitive.
- 23:15But if they both in New York's case, there's a democratic governor governor Kathy Hochul.
- 23:21So they're probably still not gonna try to override many things that she's gonna do
- 23:26anyways.
- 23:26She's probably not gonna veto a whole lot of things they do, but in the event that there is
- 23:30that interparty squabbling like I was just talking about or rather, I guess, interparty
- 23:35squabbling, that that that could come into play.
- 23:40Vermont's Democratic legislature, but the governor is republican, and he won Phil Scott,
- 23:48he won reelection with flying colors.
- 23:52So, that could become an issue there.
- 23:58But for Republicans, there were 18 state legislatures that had supermajorities before
- 24:03the 2024 election, and now there are 17 that have supermajorities after the 2024 election.
- 24:11South Carolina gained a Republican super majority, but Montana and North Carolina lost
- 24:17their supermajorities.
- 24:18Again, still plenty Republican in those states.
- 24:21And we don't necessarily know for all these states, we don't necessarily know the exact
- 24:26number of Democrats or Republicans and other parties or nonparty members in those,
- 24:34legislatures, but we at least know enough where we can say whether they still have super
- 24:38majority status or not.
- 24:41So Republicans gained 1 super majority, but then lost 2 of them.
- 24:46So, overall, they went from 18 to 17 state legislatures with a super majority.
- 24:51And so there were 18 legislatures of those 44 states.
- 24:55Again, these are all regarding the 44 states that had at least one, chamber that had
- 25:04elections this year.
- 25:05So there's 6 states that are not being included in here.
- 25:08But, there were 18 of these states' legislatures that did not have supermajorities
- 25:12before the 2024 election.
- 25:14Now there are 21 that do not have super majorities after the 2024 election.
- 25:20Those the ones that were added were New York, Vermont, Montana, and North Carolina, and then
- 25:26South Carolina exited that, that category.
- 25:31But, again, to get a full sense of which sit states saw republican or democratic gains,
- 25:36though, we'll have to wait for more results to come in, though.
- 25:39For example, by no means even close losing its super majority status, but Hawaii, which is
- 25:45maybe the most democratic state there is, they actually saw a few more Republicans, gain seats
- 25:55in that state state legislature over in the, state house.
- 25:59And I believe they have one new state senator, but I can't remember for sure.
- 26:05But still plenty of Democratic there, but that state, we at least know what the party
- 26:10membership is going to be in that state legislature.
- 26:13But a lot of states, still have a lot of results left to resolve.
- 26:20Split ticket versus street ticket voting.
- 26:22Again, split ticket voting being a difference in who a a state or a county or a state
- 26:30legislative district, congressional district, presate.
- 26:33There's difference between who they voted for for, for example, president and how they voted
- 26:40for another office such as US Senate.
- 26:43And now split ticket voting has generally been on the decline in recent years.
- 26:47There's been a lot more of a consolidation and partisanship.
- 26:50Republicans voting Republican more and more.
- 26:52Democrats are voting Democrat more and more.
- 26:54But we did see several notable instances in this election where it happened, and we
- 26:59highlighted some of those already.
- 27:00So in Arizona, voted Republican for president, but Democrat for US senator.
- 27:05Michigan voted Republican for president, but Democrat for US senate.
- 27:10Nevada, again, Republican for president, but Democrat for US senate.
- 27:14New Hampshire is a bit of a different story.
- 27:17Democrat for president, but then Republican for governor.
- 27:21North Carolina voted Republican for president, then Democrat for governor, also voted Democrat
- 27:28for attorney general and secretary of state.
- 27:31In Vermont, democrat for president and US senate, though, technically, the latter is
- 27:37independent.
- 27:37That's Bernie Sanders, but he does caucus with the Democratic Party and votes along Democratic
- 27:43Party lines.
- 27:44And the democrats also won the attorney general and secretary of state elections in Vermont,
- 27:50but it voted republican for governor.
- 27:52Again, that's Phil Scott, and he won by an enormous landslide.
- 27:57So very, very stark contrast in that state in particular with how it voted for governor
- 28:04versus the other offices statewide offices at least on that ballot.
- 28:11And some of these counties that we highlighted earlier split their vote for president and US
- 28:17senate, or in New Hampshire's case, there were municipalities that split their vote for
- 28:22president and governor.
- 28:23So in Arizona, Maricopa County, the largest one, voted Republican for president, but
- 28:28Democrat for US senate.
- 28:30In Michigan, Muskegon County, Republican for president, Democrat for US Senate.
- 28:35New Hampshire, a lot of the smaller municipalities voted Democrat for president,
- 28:39but Republican for governor, and there's there's too many of those.
- 28:42But, again, those are a lot of those are very small population municipalities.
- 28:47But Manchester and Nashua, which are 2 of, if not the largest municipal electorates in the
- 28:53state, those both voted democrat for president but Republican for governor.
- 29:00Pennsylvania, Erie County, and possibly Bucks and Monroe Counties, those votes are close
- 29:05enough that those this might change for those 2, but those voted republican for president and
- 29:13democrat for US senate.
- 29:14Erie County certainly did that.
- 29:16We'll see if Bucks and Monroe County after official vote tallies also fall into that camp.
- 29:23And then Wisconsin, South County, SA UK, Republican for president, Democrat for US
- 29:29senate.
- 29:31Interestingly, though, New Hampshire and Vermont were not considered toss ups for
- 29:36president despite these split ticket results.
- 29:39Those 2 were considered to be pretty much in the bag for democratic presidential candidates,
- 29:44in this case, Kamala Harris.
- 29:46But, nevertheless, we saw split ticket votes for them and how they voted for governor.
- 29:51So a lot less, straight up partisanship in those states and how they voted in those cases.
- 30:01However, by and large, straight ticket voting for top of the ticket statewide races.
- 30:06Now besides Vermont, every state that had president, US senate governor, attorney
- 30:11general, and secretary of state elections voted the same party for all of them.
- 30:16Missouri, Montana, and West Virginia voted Republican for all of those, and Washington
- 30:22voted Democrat for all of those.
- 30:25So still plenty of straight ticket voting in these states.
- 30:29And even if there was split ticket voting, most of the elections were went towards one party.
- 30:37And, again, we'll have to wait for some of the more finalized vote totals to see where exactly
- 30:43counties, congressional districts, state legislative districts, and precinct split
- 30:47ticketing occurred, but, nevertheless, we already can see some of these examples in the
- 30:54beneficial vote totals here.
- 30:58So quick recap of the overall balance of tower, across these various results before we move on
- 31:05to the ballot measures and then get to the end of this episode.
- 31:09So Republicans gained the presidency and the US Senate.
- 31:13They also held on to the US House, and this is the first time they held all both chambers of
- 31:19congress and the presidency since the 115th congress, which was the 2017 to 2019 term.
- 31:25That's what followed the 2016 election, which Donald Trump won his first term in.
- 31:32And, again, still a couple US house races uncalled and or heading to a recount, but
- 31:37Republicans have officially kept a majority in that chamber.
- 31:42And with such a thin majority in the US house prior to the 2024 election, democrats had a
- 31:48pretty good opportunity to at least keep control of that chamber while still losing the
- 31:53US senate and the presidency, but they ultimately came up short.
- 31:57And in the case of state governments, the number of governorships per party stayed the
- 32:01same.
- 32:02Republicans have 27, and Democrats have 23.
- 32:05Again, the only really expected to be competitive election there was the New
- 32:10Hampshire one, and that stayed with Republicans.
- 32:13New Hampshire was the only one expected to be competitive.
- 32:16It's held by a Republican.
- 32:17A new Republican won the seat, so now we still have 27 governorships that are Republican and
- 32:2423 that are Democrat.
- 32:26And republicans now have at least 51 state legislative chambers because of the gain of the
- 32:32Michigan state house and potentially the Minnesota state house.
- 32:37So if they gain that, they'll have 52 state legislative chambers.
- 32:41Democrats have control of 31 state legislative chambers, and 2 are still under power sharing
- 32:47agreements, which is Alaska because Alaska politics are very unique.
- 32:52So Republicans since 2010 have had the majority of state legislative chambers in 2010.
- 33:00They gained the majority in a ton of them, and they have kept a majority of them since.
- 33:05Although the number that they've had has ebbed and flowed over the past nearly 15 years now.
- 33:14Ballot measures.
- 33:15So this is just focusing on the 146 measures that were decided on November 5th, 2024, the
- 33:23main election day that, of course, we're talking about where president and all these
- 33:26other major races were decided.
- 33:29Louisiana voters still have 4 to decide on on December 7th, and there were 9 measures that
- 33:34were decided on earlier in 2024.
- 33:37So, again, this is just focusing on the 146 measures that were just decided on a couple
- 33:44weeks ago as of this, bit couple weeks before this recording, so November 5th.
- 33:53And there were bunch of different topics, but the common topics we we saw here were ones
- 33:58relating to abortion, education, marijuana, and in one case, psychedelics, ranks choice voting,
- 34:06citizenship requirements for voting, or at least clarifying citizenship requirements for
- 34:11voting, and wages slash labor.
- 34:14Now ranked choice voting, RCV, and other measures that would change federal and state
- 34:20electoral system electoral systems, they had an abysmal election.
- 34:25And just to recap in case, you're not aware, ranked choice voting is basically where you
- 34:31have all of the candidates on a list, and you rank them based on order of preference.
- 34:37So I want this candidate first most or most first most.
- 34:42I want this candidate most, then I want this candidate second most, this one third most,
- 34:46this one 4th most.
- 34:47Now there's a little bit of difference depending on where you go, how exactly that
- 34:51works, or whether you even have to rank all the candidates.
- 34:54But in any case, ranked choice voting, at least attempts to implement it for federal and state
- 35:01elections, those did not do well at all this election.
- 35:05Five measures to adopt or at least allow adoption of RCV.
- 35:11All all 5 of those failed.
- 35:13Colorado, Idaho, Nevada, and Oregon.
- 35:16Arizona's proposition 1 40 would have allowed for its adoption, though not specifically said,
- 35:22we are adopting it.
- 35:24There's also a measure to repeal the top 4 primary slash ranked choice general election
- 35:30system in Alaska, which was implemented in 2020, but that's race is still way too tight to
- 35:36call us about a couple 100 votes difference there.
- 35:39The no side of it, so the the saying no to repealing that election system is currently
- 35:46ahead, but, again, way too close to call right now.
- 35:49We'll see how that shakes up in the next in the coming weeks, even perhaps even a month.
- 35:56We'll have to see.
- 35:58And then there was a measure in Missouri that would've that would to prohibit RCV, and that
- 36:03passed overwhelmingly.
- 36:05That was about 68.46 percent of the vote.
- 36:09So ranked choice voting and its advocates did not have a good day on November 5th.
- 36:16But RCV measures for local races did better.
- 36:20So these were not statewide ballot measures, but these localities that where the RCV
- 36:27measures would be adopted.
- 36:29Those actually did pretty well.
- 36:30There's 2 initiatives that approved adoption, and then there was one referral that advised
- 36:35the government to adopt it.
- 36:36There are several there are a couple types of ballot measures where you basically tell the
- 36:44government, hey.
- 36:45This is what we want, but it doesn't actually implement said policy.
- 36:49So in this case, they said that there there's municipality.
- 36:53I forget which one it is, but they advised the government to adopt the measure, though it
- 36:58doesn't necessarily outright make it a reality.
- 37:02And then there was one local initiative that would have repealed RCV, and then that one
- 37:07failed.
- 37:09Now one of these other topics we talked about or we highlighted at the beginning, abortion,
- 37:14pro abortionist state constitutional amendments generally did pretty well actually in this
- 37:19election.
- 37:19There are varying degrees of what exactly they provided for, but most would have at least
- 37:23established a constitutional right to abortion, and 7 of 10 of those passed.
- 37:29Now the places where those pro abortion amendments did fail is Florida's amendment 4.
- 37:35Now and that that's my state.
- 37:37Now here in Florida, you might have seen the results.
- 37:4357.16% of voters supported it, but it failed.
- 37:48That's might come as a surprise to you, probably anybody that's not in Florida, but
- 37:53back in, believe it was 2,002, voters passed an amendment where any constitutional amendments
- 38:02moving forward needed 60% of the vote to pass.
- 38:05So that's the highest threshold in the nation.
- 38:08There are a couple states that require 55% approval, but, usually, it's just a straight up
- 38:14majority.
- 38:14You need at least 50% plus 1.
- 38:18But in Florida, you need 60% to pass.
- 38:20And so Florida's amendment 4, even though it had a majority of support, it did not clear the
- 38:26threshold needed to actually pass.
- 38:29So amendment 4 in Florida failed.
- 38:32Nebraska's initiative 439 did not pass either, though Nebraska did have a separate pro
- 38:38abortion amendment that passed, which prohibited well, I guess depending on your
- 38:43point of view, it's it could be pro abortion or pro choice, but it prohibited abortion or it
- 38:49prohibits abortion after the 1st trimester except for or with certain exceptions.
- 38:55So not outright you can't have an abortion whatsoever, but it has to meet certain
- 39:01requirements for you to get an abortion.
- 39:02It has to be after the first trimester.
- 39:06And then South Dakota's amendment g also failed.
- 39:10Now other key ballot measures that did pass in Nebraska, initiatives 437 and 438, which
- 39:18legalized medical marijuana and established the Nebraska Medical Cannabis Commission to
- 39:24regulate it respectively.
- 39:26Those two initiatives passed main question 1, which limits campaign contributions to $5,000
- 39:34to any tax that make independent expenditures.
- 39:37So if you're an individual or an entity and you're donating to PACS that make independent
- 39:43expenditures, independent expenditures, again, that's a lot of times referred to as dark
- 39:47money.
- 39:48Independent expenditures can raise and spend unlimited amounts of money as long as they
- 39:55don't coordinate with the campaigns they support or oppose.
- 39:59I mean, obviously, they're not gonna coordinate with a candidate or campaign that they oppose,
- 40:03but, but, anyways, main question 1 limits those contributions to $5,000 to those packs that
- 40:10engage in independent expenditures, and that one had overwhelming support.
- 40:14That one passed with flying colors.
- 40:17And then other key ballot measures that failed, we had Arizona's proposition 138, which would
- 40:23have allowed for tip tipped workers to be paid 25% less per hour than minimum wage if their
- 40:30total compensation was above a certain threshold.
- 40:33That was overwhelmingly defeated.
- 40:35That one wasn't even remotely close.
- 40:37Florida's 3rd amendment, which would have or sorry.
- 40:40Florida's 3rd amendment, North Dakota's initiated measure 5, and South Dakota's
- 40:44initiated measure 29, all for prorecreational marijuana or would have, legalized recreational
- 40:52marijuana.
- 40:52Those all failed.
- 40:54Again, Florida, 3rd amendment, that one had majority support, but to not have 60% support,
- 41:00so that was not enough for it to be passed.
- 41:03And in Massachusetts, which would have allowed the use of natural psychedelic substances and
- 41:08would have established commission to regulate their lising licensing, That one also failed.
- 41:15Now to end things off before the actual closing of this episode, let's look to the future a
- 41:20little bit.
- 41:21So if you're a Democrat, it's very easy to sit here and be all doom and gloom.
- 41:27And if you're a republican, it's easy to be riding high like you're just gonna start
- 41:31racking up all these wins, and you can't be stopped.
- 41:34But things can change very quickly.
- 41:38And make no mistake.
- 41:39This was overall a very successful election for Republicans, but was it was by no means a wave
- 41:45election.
- 41:45Sometimes people like to say wave election for a party when they're the ones that were pretty
- 41:51successful, but you need to have widespread success and win a ton of seats in congress and
- 41:57state legislatures and all that.
- 41:59It was not a wave election, though it was definitely successful for republicans.
- 42:03But in politics, things can change very quickly.
- 42:06People can get very tired of the Republican and or Democratic parties very quickly when they're
- 42:12the ones running which depending on which one's running the show.
- 42:16And Alan Greenblatt of Governing Magazine notes with the exception of 2012.
- 42:22Over the past 20 years, every federal election has seen one of the parties lose the presidency
- 42:28and or at least one chamber of congress.
- 42:31So voters can get tired of 1 party or the other very quickly, and that has already happened for
- 42:35several past presidents, including Trump's first term.
- 42:40So when you're in the middle of things, it's very easy to depending on who you support to be
- 42:47be high up in the clouds, like you can't be stopped, or to be down in the dumps, like
- 42:52nothing's gonna get better.
- 42:53But things change very quickly in politics.
- 42:57So we'll see what happens in 2025 and 2026.
- 43:02But when you have these election results, you have to be introspective regardless of whether
- 43:06you were successful or not so that you can do better next time.
- 43:11It's really just like in anything else, especially sports.
- 43:14You know?
- 43:14When you when you win, it's very easy to overlook your flaws and to assume that you're
- 43:20just gonna keep winning.
- 43:21And if you lose, always gotta look back at the tape and see what went wrong.
- 43:25So we'll see how it goes in 2025 and 2026, but don't get too comfortable or don't get too
- 43:33uncomfortable because things can change very quickly.
- 43:37With that being said, once again, thank you as always for listening to this podcast.
- 43:43It'll leave you with a random question of the day.
- 43:47The today's random question is, was Pluto's demotion to dwarf planet justified, or should
- 43:54it be granted full planet status again?
- 43:57Now I remember when when it was demoted back in, what was it, 2006?
- 44:02A lot of, lot of I'd I'd say it like a lot of legit maker.
- 44:08I was kinda disappointed, but I wanna say Pluto is my favorite planet, but I did like Pluto.
- 44:14But you know what gets me is the guy who led the charge, Neil deGrasse Tyson, is like this
- 44:22beloved celebrity for a lot of people, beloved celebrity.
- 44:24He's not everybody loves him.
- 44:26I'm not exactly a fan of him.
- 44:29I think he's quite arrogant.
- 44:31But in any case, I just think it's kind of funny that people were very upset about Pluto
- 44:37being demoted, and he was the one who was arguably the biggest or the most prominent
- 44:45person leading the charge to demoted to dwarf planet status.
- 44:51But yet people love him now.
- 44:52But I don't know.
- 44:54Think it's just think it's kind of kind of funny.
- 44:56But in any case, I think it should be upgraded back to planet status.
- 45:01I think it was very rude of people to call it a dwarf planet, but, I mean, I'm not gonna lose
- 45:07sleep over it.
- 45:08Venus is actually my favorite planet, and I answered that in a previous random question.
- 45:12So let me know what you think.
- 45:14Should Pluto have been demoted?
- 45:15Should it be granted planet status again?
- 45:18Maybe you think it shouldn't have been relegated to dwarf planet status, but you don't
- 45:23necessarily think that it should be full planet again.
- 45:26I don't know.
- 45:27Let me know.
- 45:28But in any case, thank you so
- 45:29much for listening.
- 45:31Show notes below.
- 45:33Give you all my my media, like my Facebook, Paul Raider, comma, author and speaker,
- 45:38LinkedIn, my writings on medium, Matchmaker FM, if you wanna have me as a guest on your
- 45:45podcast.
- 45:46Or if you think you wanna be a guest on this podcast, you know, let me know, and you can e
- 45:52also email me at Paul Raider Writes atgmail.com.
- 45:57But and also my book on Amazon, why independence rarely win elections and how they
- 46:02could become more competitive.
- 46:03It's also for sale in ebook and paperbook formats.
- 46:07And, again, all that stuff is in the show notes.
- 46:10So once again, thank you for listening, and until next time.
- 46:15Take care.