Latest / Interfaiths / The Capaciousness of the Tradition: Islam, Sexuality, and the Wound of Berlin
Transcript
- 0:00So, um... I want you to try and picture a summer
- 0:03afternoon in Berlin. Okay, setting the scene.
- 0:06Yeah, it's July 26, 2026, and the city is hosting
- 0:10Christopher Street Day, which, if you don't know,
- 0:13is this massive, really vibrant annual celebration
- 0:16honoring the queer community. Right, it's a huge
- 0:19event. Huge! I mean, the weather is warm, there's
- 0:21music echoing off those beautiful historic buildings,
- 0:25and you've got this massive crowd gathered right
- 0:27near the Brandenburg Gate. Just a total festival
- 0:30of joy. Exactly. It is a celebration of human
- 0:33diversity, just people living openly in this
- 0:35modern metropolis. And then, well, then the unthinkable
- 0:38happens. Yeah. A rented van accelerates and just
- 0:41drives directly into that crowd. It is. It's
- 0:45just a devastating, horrific image. And the aftermath
- 0:48is exactly what you would expect from that kind
- 0:50of trauma. Butter chaos. Right. One person is
- 0:52left dead on the street. Twenty nine others are
- 0:54wounded and the whole city is plunged into panic.
- 0:56And the driver, he was eventually shot and killed
- 0:59after a day long manhunt. Right. Yes. He was
- 1:02a 21 year old man. And the really crucial detail
- 1:05here is that he was born right there in Germany.
- 1:08Oh, wow. So not a foreigner. No, not a foreign
- 1:11combatant slipping across some border. He was
- 1:14known to local authorities as being embedded
- 1:16in the city's Islamist milieu. Right. So almost
- 1:20immediately before the dust had even settled,
- 1:22the authorities and the press concluded that
- 1:25this attack was driven by Islamist extremist
- 1:28ideology. And we all know the script that plays
- 1:31out in the media the moment a tragedy like this
- 1:33occurs. I mean, we've seen it, what, a hundred
- 1:35times? At least. On one side, you have these
- 1:37opportunists who use the attacker to condemn
- 1:39an entire global religion. They just flatten
- 1:4214 million people into the actions of, you know,
- 1:45a single man in a rented van. Which is incredibly
- 1:48dangerous. Exactly. But then on the other side,
- 1:50you get this equally reflexive, almost desperate
- 1:53press release response from advocacy groups saying,
- 1:56well, saying this has absolutely nothing to do
- 1:58with Islam. Right. The automatic defense. Yeah.
- 2:00Yeah. Both sides just retreat to their corners.
- 2:02But the sources we're doing a deep dive into
- 2:05today, which include this really profound primary
- 2:08essay supported by a towering stack of historical
- 2:11texts, they refuse both of those easy answers.
- 2:14They do. They really refuse to let us off the
- 2:16hook that easily. Because both of those reflexive
- 2:18answers are, well, they're historically illiterate,
- 2:21right? That's exactly it. The texts we are looking
- 2:23at today ask a much more difficult, much more
- 2:26demanding question of us. which is... How do
- 2:29you reconcile this modern, brutal, puritanical
- 2:33violence with 14 centuries of a civilization
- 2:36that produced some of the world's most sublime
- 2:39love poetry? And the most complex metaphysical
- 2:41philosophy. Right. And this incredibly deep tradition
- 2:44of mystical devotion. Because, you know, when
- 2:47you place the young man in the van next to a
- 2:49figure like Rumi or the great Islamic philosophers
- 2:53of the medieval period, they don't even look
- 2:55like they belong to the same universe. Let alone
- 2:57the same religious tradition. Exactly. So the
- 3:00mission of our deep dive today is to explore
- 3:02this massive, completely paradigm shifting argument.
- 3:06And it really is a paradigm shift. It is. Our
- 3:08sources make the case that this young man in
- 3:10the van wasn't actually defending historical
- 3:12Islam at all. In fact, he was entirely disconnected
- 3:14from it. Which is wild to think about, given
- 3:17his stated motives. Right. The texts argue that
- 3:20he was defending a distinctly modern imported
- 3:22pathology. And here's the kicker. One that was
- 3:25actually engineered in the very West. He thought
- 3:28he was attacking. Yeah, that is the core irony
- 3:31we have to unpack. So to really understand the
- 3:33mechanics of how that happened, how a whole civilization
- 3:37shifts from beautiful poetry to rented vans,
- 3:40we are going to have to unpack some really profound
- 3:43cultural shifts. We have to look at the mechanisms
- 3:46of colonial history. And we have to completely
- 3:48reevaluate our definitions of human identity.
- 3:51Yes. So I want to jump straight into the mindset
- 3:53of this attacker because the primary essay we're
- 3:55working from starts with a sort of diagnosis.
- 3:58Right. A historical diagnosis. Yeah. And to make
- 4:00this diagnosis, the author leans on a historian
- 4:03named Thomas Bauer, specifically his work. It's
- 4:07called A Culture of Ambiguity. A really essential
- 4:09text for this topic. It really is. Now, I've
- 4:13read a lot of history. But Bauer makes a claim
- 4:15about classical Islamic civilization that fundamentally
- 4:18disrupted how I view the past. How so? Well,
- 4:23we are so used to seeing historical religion
- 4:25depicted as this rigid, black and white, highly
- 4:28punitive monolith. But Bauer argues that for
- 4:32the vast majority of its history, Islamic civilization
- 4:34was defined by its extraordinary tolerance for
- 4:38ambiguity. We really need to spend some time
- 4:40on this word ambiguity. Yeah, let's unpack that.
- 4:42Because in modern English, it has a slightly
- 4:44negative connotation. Right, like you're being
- 4:46evasive. Exactly. If I say you're being ambiguous,
- 4:49it implies you're being vague or, you know, you
- 4:51just haven't done the work to find the right
- 4:53answer. But Bauer is talking about something
- 4:55entirely different. What's his definition? He
- 4:57is talking about a structural civilization. comfort
- 5:00with plurality. It's the capacity of a whole
- 5:04society to hold multiple, sometimes totally contradictory
- 5:07truths in suspension without feeling the psychological
- 5:11panic to resolve them into one single dominant
- 5:13role. Okay, let's ground this for you listening
- 5:15because plurality can sound, you know, very abstract.
- 5:19What did this comfort with ambiguity actually
- 5:22look like in the day -to -day operation of classical
- 5:25Islamic society? Well, it manifested at the very
- 5:29highest levels of theology and law. Give me an
- 5:32example. Imagine a society where you have multiple
- 5:35legally valid readings of the exact same Quranic
- 5:39verse. Wait, like different interpretations?
- 5:42Not just different interpretations, but actually
- 5:44different vocalizations of the text that changed
- 5:47the nuance of the meaning. And they all coexisted.
- 5:50Wow. Yeah. You had competing schools of jurisprudence,
- 5:53the Maliki, the Hanafi, the Shafi, the Hanbali,
- 5:57which were entirely different legal traditions
- 5:59with completely different methodologies. And
- 6:02they didn't just tear each other apart. No, they
- 6:03didn't go to war to annihilate each other at
- 6:05all. They explicitly recognized each other's
- 6:07legitimacy. That is wild. Right. And action might
- 6:10be considered totally forbidden in one school
- 6:12and entirely permissible in another. And the
- 6:14society just absorbed that friction without collapsing.
- 6:17I was really trying to visualize how a society
- 6:20functions like that because our modern instinct
- 6:23is that laws have to be uniform. If it's illegal
- 6:26here, it has to be illegal there. We demand consistency.
- 6:30We do. And the image that kept coming to my mind
- 6:34while reading Bauer's work was a massive suspension
- 6:37bridge. Oh, that's a good way to look at it.
- 6:39Yeah. Think about it. If you look at how a suspension
- 6:42bridge is engineered, its genius is that it is
- 6:45explicitly designed. to sway and flex under the
- 6:49weight of different winds, right? Right, and
- 6:51the friction of different traffic. Exactly. The
- 6:53shifts in atmospheric pressure, that flexibility,
- 6:56that structural ambiguity, is exactly why the
- 6:59bridge doesn't break. It absorbs the tension
- 7:01of the environment. It needs that give. Right.
- 7:03But then, as we move into the 19th and 20th centuries,
- 7:06under the immense pressure of colonial modernity,
- 7:09it's as if the engineers of the Islamic world
- 7:12just panicked. They looked at their swaying bridge
- 7:14and got terrified. Yeah. They looked at the rigid
- 7:18steel and stone structures of the European powers
- 7:21that were suddenly dominating them, and they
- 7:23mistook their own flexibility for weakness. And
- 7:27so they decided to encase their entire suspension
- 7:30bridge in solid concrete. That analogy perfectly
- 7:33captures the mechanism of what Bauer calls a
- 7:37civilizational loss of nerve. A loss of nerve.
- 7:40That's a powerful phrase. It is. And this is
- 7:42the critical mechanism we have to understand.
- 7:45The hardening of Islamic thought wasn't some
- 7:48sudden surge in authentic religious piety. Right.
- 7:50It was a symptom of a profound collapse in civilizational
- 7:53confidence. When the Islamic world collided with
- 7:57Western colonial modernity, when they faced the
- 7:59military, economic, and cultural dominance of
- 8:02the British and the French, the trauma was immense.
- 8:05I mean, it must have been world shattering. Completely.
- 8:07Internal reformist movements looked at their
- 8:09own complex swaying traditions and they felt
- 8:11ashamed. Because it didn't look like Europe.
- 8:13Exactly. They felt it looked backward or disorganized
- 8:16compared to the hyper -categorized rigid structures
- 8:18of the Victorian colonizers. So like you said,
- 8:21they poured the concrete. Suddenly. Ambiguity,
- 8:24that beautiful, necessary sway of the bridge
- 8:27came to feel like a mortal threat to their very
- 8:29survival. But pouring concrete over a suspension
- 8:32bridge doesn't actually make it stronger. It
- 8:35just replaces flexibility with certainty. And
- 8:38certainty, when it is that absolute and defensive,
- 8:41is incredibly rigid. And what are the physics
- 8:44of a rigid structure? When it encounters a sudden
- 8:47opposing force. It snaps. It cannot sway. It
- 8:50cannot absorb the impact. It just shatters. Bauer
- 8:53calls this modern condition brittleness. Brittleness?
- 8:56Yes. We have moved from a culture of ambiguity
- 8:59to an ideology of brittleness. It is a mindset
- 9:02that has entirely lost the capacity to hold tension.
- 9:05Which brings us right back to that street in
- 9:07Berlin. It does. If we apply this historical
- 9:09diagnosis to the 21 -year -old attacker in that
- 9:12van, it completely changes how you have to view
- 9:15him. He isn't some ancient warrior of an unyielding
- 9:18faith. Not at all. He is the ultimate manifestation
- 9:20of this modern disease of brittleness. His ideology
- 9:23is so incredibly fragile that it literally shatters
- 9:26upon contact with difference. That's exactly
- 9:28what happened. He looks out through the windshield
- 9:31at a crowd of people at Christopher Street Day.
- 9:34People who are different. who represent a plurality
- 9:37of human existence, who don't fit into his concrete
- 9:40boxes, and his ideology cannot tolerate the tension
- 9:43of their mere existence. The anxiety of that
- 9:46ambiguity is just too much. Right. It's so overwhelming
- 9:49that his only psychological recourse is to try
- 9:52and destroy the source of the tension. And that
- 9:54is the profound tragedy at the center of this
- 9:57narrative. He believes with every fiber of his
- 10:00being that he is acting in the name of a 1400
- 10:03year old tradition. But he's not. No, he is entirely
- 10:07cut off from it. He has inherited the frantic
- 10:09brittleness of the modern era, the trauma of
- 10:12that civilizational loss of nerve, not the capaciousness
- 10:15of the classical Islamic tradition. He has no
- 10:17share in it. None. He has absolutely no share
- 10:20in that older Islam that could hold contradiction
- 10:22as a mode of meaning. He is a modern man. dealing
- 10:26with a modern anxiety using modern violence.
- 10:28Okay, but if classical Islam wasn't this rigid
- 10:32system of concrete laws and punitive certainty,
- 10:35we have to establish what it actually was. Yes,
- 10:37we need to fill in that blank. Because you can't
- 10:39just say, oh, it was ambiguous and leave it there,
- 10:41right? What did that lived reality actually look
- 10:44like for the millions of people who inhabited
- 10:46it? The sources are really adamant that if we
- 10:49only look at the legal rulings, we are completely
- 10:52missing the reality of the civilization. To understand
- 10:56the texture of that lived reality, we have to
- 10:58turn to Shahab Ahmed's monumental work, What
- 11:01Is Islam? Such an incredible book. It really
- 11:04is. Ahmed's core thesis is a direct challenge
- 11:07to how we study religion today. He insists that
- 11:10we cannot reduce Islam merely to fiqh. And fiqh
- 11:13is the legal system, right? Yes, fiqh is the
- 11:15Islamic jurisprudence, the rigid yes and no of
- 11:18the legal scholars. If you only read the law
- 11:21books, you get a highly distorted view of the
- 11:23society. Like judging modern America only by
- 11:26reading the tax code. Exactly. To correct this,
- 11:29he introduces this concept of the Balkans to
- 11:31Bengal complex. When I first read that phrase,
- 11:33the Balkans to Bengal complex, my mind immediately
- 11:36just went to a map. The geography of it is staggering.
- 11:39It covers a massive area. We are talking about
- 11:42a continuous swath of humanity stretching from
- 11:44Eastern Europe down through the Middle East,
- 11:47across Central Asia and deep into the Indian
- 11:49subcontinent. But Ahmed isn't just drawing a
- 11:52map, is he? No, not at all. He's trying to describe
- 11:55an atmosphere. Exactly. He is mapping a vast,
- 11:58interconnected cultural and psychological sphere
- 12:01that existed roughly from the 14th to the 19th
- 12:04centuries. And Ahmed shows that for the vast
- 12:07majority of Muslims across this massive region,
- 12:10Islam was not lived as a strict adherence to
- 12:13a list of rules. What was it then? It was lived
- 12:16as a vast capacious and completely self -contradicting
- 12:20exploration of meaning. The culture was intensely
- 12:23comfortable with holding seemingly opposed ideas
- 12:25in the exact same space. And the sources give
- 12:28us such vivid, almost jarring examples of what
- 12:31this looked like on the ground. We aren't just
- 12:32talking about abstract theological debates in
- 12:34a university somewhere. Right. It was part of
- 12:36daily life. We are talking about societies that
- 12:38actively produced and celebrated wine poetry.
- 12:42Which goes directly against the legal prohibition
- 12:44of alcohol. Exactly. You had deep philosophical
- 12:47traditions that questioned the very nature of
- 12:50revelation. They commissioned stunning figural
- 12:53paintings and miniatures, even though some legalists
- 12:56strictly forbade the depiction of the human form.
- 12:59Yeah, the art is a perfect example of that contradiction.
- 13:02And you had the profound, ecstatic Sufi contemplation
- 13:05of beauty existing right alongside the rigid
- 13:08law. And very often, those two things were in
- 13:11open public tension with one another. And the
- 13:13crucial point on... makes is that to be Muslim
- 13:16in this context was to inhabit that very tension.
- 13:19So it wasn't a flaw in the system. No, it was
- 13:21a system. It wasn't about choosing the law over
- 13:24the poetry or the philosophy over the law. It
- 13:26was about living within the friction between
- 13:28them. That is so hard for us to grasp today.
- 13:30It is. And to understand the emotional depth
- 13:33of this, our sources bring in Anne -Marie Schimmel's
- 13:36classic text, Mystical Dimensions of Islam. A
- 13:39beautiful book. Yes. Schimmel maps out a world
- 13:42where the fundamental orientation of the faith
- 13:44wasn't about avoiding punishment. It was about
- 13:46the path toward union with the divine. This section
- 13:49of the reading completely dismantled my preconceptions,
- 13:52because when we think of the greatest, most universally
- 13:55revered voices of Islamic civilization, the figures
- 13:59who are still quoted today, like Ibn Arabi, the
- 14:01brilliant philosopher mystic. Right. Or Rumi,
- 14:04whose poetry is still a bestseller all over the
- 14:06world today. Or Hafiz or Rabia of Basra. The
- 14:10heavyweights of the tradition. Yeah. These towering
- 14:12figures, the architects of the Islamic imagination.
- 14:14They did not speak the language of rigid punitive.
- 14:18law. No, they didn't. They spoke the language
- 14:20of love. Their entire vocabulary was built on
- 14:24longing, heartbreak, and the absolute annihilation
- 14:27of the self in the presence of God. We have to
- 14:29pause and consider the mechanism of how this
- 14:32changes a society. In this mystical dimension,
- 14:35the human heart's yearning for beauty wasn't
- 14:38seen as a worldly distraction. It wasn't a sin.
- 14:40No, it wasn't a temptation pulling you away from
- 14:42religion. It was the very engine of religion
- 14:45itself. The mysticism provided the emotional
- 14:48vocabulary for the entire civilization I really
- 14:50want to press on this because it runs so completely
- 14:53counter to the puritanical narrative we are fed
- 14:57today. You're saying that the intense human desire,
- 15:00the yearning we feel when we encounter profound
- 15:03beauty, wasn't viewed as a sin that had to be
- 15:05repressed and locked away, but rather as the
- 15:08actual vehicle that drives a person closer to
- 15:11the divine. Yes, exactly. And the mechanics of
- 15:14how they articulated this are fascinating. It
- 15:16is most beautifully illustrated in the Persian
- 15:18poetic tradition through the concept of the Shahid.
- 15:22The word translates to the witness, right? Correct.
- 15:25In this poetic and spiritual tradition, gazing
- 15:28upon a beautiful human face could literally be
- 15:30an act of spiritual contemplation. That is amazing.
- 15:34Yeah. The physical beauty of a human being, the
- 15:36symmetry, the grace, was viewed as a physical
- 15:39trace, a reflection of the ultimate unseeable
- 15:42divine beauty. So by loving the physical, you
- 15:45are witnessing the divine. Exactly. The tradition
- 15:48understood something incredibly profound about
- 15:51human psychology. They recognized that the intense,
- 15:55earthly, erotic longing to be completely undone
- 15:58by love, that feeling of losing your mind and
- 16:01your ego because you were so captivated by another
- 16:03person. Right, that overwhelming feeling. Yes,
- 16:06that feeling is the closest analogy we have as
- 16:08human beings to the soul's longing for God. They
- 16:11did not flinch from the erotics of the soul.
- 16:13They harnessed it. But wait, how does a society
- 16:16organized around that kind of intense poetic
- 16:19vulnerability actually survive? That's the logical
- 16:22modern question. Because modern fundamentalists
- 16:24argue that you need rigid laws to make a civilization
- 16:27strong. The essay seems to argue the exact opposite.
- 16:30It suggests that a civilization organized around
- 16:33love. beauty and the profound longing of the
- 16:36human heart is actually infinitely stronger and
- 16:39more resilient than the brittle ideology of the
- 16:41attacker in the van. And the historical record
- 16:43completely backs that up. This suppleness, this
- 16:46emotional and cultural flexibility is actually
- 16:49the secret mechanism behind how Islam became
- 16:52a global religion. Because it wasn't just conquest.
- 16:54Exactly. There is this pervasive modern myth.
- 16:58often repeated in Western political discourse,
- 17:01that Islam spread primarily at the point of a
- 17:04sword, that it was an endless wave of violent,
- 17:07top -down military conquest. Right, the whole
- 17:10convert or die narrative. Yes. But when you look
- 17:13at the historical texts, the mechanics of its
- 17:16expansion were entirely different. The faith
- 17:19spread along trade routes. It spread through
- 17:21the lodges of the Sufi mystics. The sources bring
- 17:24in Richard Eaton's study of the Bengal frontier
- 17:25as like the perfect case study for this mechanism.
- 17:28When Islam moved into Bengal, it wasn't a conquering
- 17:31army forcing peasants to convert under threat
- 17:33of death. Not at all. Eaton shows how it took
- 17:36root through slow agrarian settlement. You had
- 17:40these mystics known as peers. and holy men who
- 17:43went out into the uncleared forests. They physically
- 17:45wove themselves into the local landscape. They
- 17:47did the hard work. Yeah, they helped clear the
- 17:49land. They established local shrines. They became
- 17:52mediators in local disputes. They integrated
- 17:54Islamic cosmology with the local agrarian cycle.
- 17:57And we see this exact same mechanism replicated
- 18:00across the globe, from the sub -Saharan cultures
- 18:03of West Africa all the way to the island networks
- 18:06of the Indonesian archipelago. Islam moved with
- 18:10merchants and Sufis. And because it was so flexible,
- 18:13right? Yes. Because it was not a brittle, rigid
- 18:16monolith, it had the capacity to adapt. It could
- 18:19absorb local traditions. It translated its core
- 18:22metaphysical truths into a thousand different
- 18:25local idioms. Which a rigid system just can't
- 18:27do. A brittle, rigid ideology cannot do that.
- 18:31If you are rigid, your only tool for expansion
- 18:33is conquest and enforcement. If the local culture
- 18:37doesn't fit your concrete box, you have to smash
- 18:39the culture. But a supple, confident faith can
- 18:42cross the globe by invitation, adaptation and
- 18:45integration. Okay, so this brings us to what
- 18:47the author of the essay openly admits is the
- 18:50hardest part of the conversation. And honestly,
- 18:52it is the most crucial part for you listening
- 18:53right now because it forces us to confront our
- 18:56own deeply held modern assumptions about identity.
- 18:59It's a challenging topic. It is. If this classical
- 19:02Islamic world was so capacious, so comfortable
- 19:05with ambiguity, and so deeply invested in the
- 19:08poetry of human desire, well... How did it actually
- 19:11govern sexuality? Right. Because the modern contrast
- 19:14is so stark. Exactly. Because today, the clash
- 19:17between modern Islamism and LGBTQ identity is
- 19:20presented as absolute, like a war of annihilation.
- 19:23This is the pivot point of the entire deep dive.
- 19:26And we have to tread very carefully here. We
- 19:28must rely strictly on historical facts, resisting
- 19:31both modern progressive attempts to retroactively
- 19:33find pride parades in the 16th century and conservative
- 19:37polemics that project modern homophobia backward
- 19:39in time. We have to look at what was actually
- 19:41there. Exactly. To do this, the essay relies
- 19:44heavily on Khaled al -Ruayhib's essential study
- 19:46before homosexuality in the Arab Islamic world,
- 19:491500 to 1800. Okay. And the central, undeniable,
- 19:53heavily documented premise of his research is
- 19:55this. The modern Western category of homosexuality,
- 19:59and along with it, the demand for a state -recognized
- 20:02sexual identity, did not exist in the classical
- 20:04Islamic world. And the essay is incredibly precise
- 20:07about the mechanics of this absence. This wasn't
- 20:10a case where people were just heavily repressed,
- 20:12hiding in the shadows and afraid to speak its
- 20:14name. No, it wasn't the closet. Right. It wasn't
- 20:17a silence born of fear or the threat of the secret
- 20:19police. It was the literal absence of the conceptual
- 20:23category. The concept simply wasn't there. The
- 20:26idea of the homosexual as a unified, defining
- 20:29psychological identity simply had not been invented.
- 20:32What Elroheb does so brilliantly is unpack the
- 20:35profound differences in how that culture categorized
- 20:39human behavior compared to how we do it today.
- 20:42He shows that pre -modern Arab Islamic culture
- 20:45made very sharp distinctions between behaviors
- 20:48and feelings that our modern world fuses together
- 20:50into a single, inescapable identity. We really
- 20:53need to break down those distinctions because
- 20:55this is where the modern mind really struggles
- 20:57to comprehend the past. We want to put it in
- 20:59our boxes. We do. So what were the different
- 21:01categories they used to map this territory of
- 21:04desire? El -Ruwayhib outlines a tripartite distinction.
- 21:07Okay, three parts. First... there was the passionate
- 21:10often chaste love of a beautiful youth this was
- 21:13not hidden it was celebrated openly often in
- 21:16exquisite poetry by incredibly pious respectable
- 21:20and even married men it was seen as a testament
- 21:23to the refinement of one's soul so having these
- 21:26feelings made you refined not a sinner yes Second,
- 21:30there was the general aesthetic appreciation
- 21:32of male beauty, which we already touched on with
- 21:34the concept of the Shaheed. The culture was obsessed
- 21:36with the aesthetics of the male form. Right.
- 21:38And the third category. The third category was
- 21:41the specific physical sexual act of liwa, which
- 21:45roughly translates as sodomy. And this is the
- 21:47crucial point. The jurists, the legal scholars
- 21:50absolutely did condemn the physical act of liwa.
- 21:53OK, stop right there. I really need to push back
- 21:55on this or at least play devil's advocate because
- 21:56I want to make sure the logic holds up. Go ahead.
- 21:59If the legal scholars strictly condemn the physical
- 22:02act, how did these highly respected, pious, religious
- 22:06scholars get away with publicly writing ardent,
- 22:09passionate love poetry to beautiful boys? It
- 22:12seems like a contradiction to us. Totally. Wouldn't
- 22:14a judge read that poem and say, aha, a confession,
- 22:17throw him in jail? How did a society reconcile
- 22:19the poetry with the law? You are looking at the
- 22:22past through the lens of modern post -Freudian
- 22:25psychology. Okay, explain that. You are assuming...
- 22:27that a poem about desire is proof of an underlying
- 22:31unified sexual identity that inevitably leads
- 22:34to a specific physical act. The classical jurists
- 22:38did not think that way. They didn't connect the
- 22:39two? No. They did not attach the sin to the feeling
- 22:42of love or to the aesthetic appreciation or to
- 22:45the person's soul. The sin... if the jurors were
- 22:48going to invoke it, was attached exclusively
- 22:50to the physical act itself. The act, not the
- 22:53thought. Exactly. And unless four eyewitnesses
- 22:56literally saw the act occurring, which is the
- 22:58impossibly high evidentiary bar set by Islamic
- 23:00law, there was no crime. Wow. So because the
- 23:04law was incredibly narrow and only focused on
- 23:06policing a very specific physical action, it
- 23:09accidentally, or perhaps intentionally, left
- 23:12this massive, unpoliced, imaginative space for
- 23:14the expression of same -sex desire. Precisely.
- 23:18The law's prohibition of a particular physical
- 23:20act simply never colonized the broader imaginative
- 23:23space of the culture. The bridge could still
- 23:26sway. Yes. The poetry, the yearning, the aesthetic
- 23:30appreciation, all of that flourished openly without
- 23:33contradicting a person's religious identity or
- 23:36destroying their social standing. A man could
- 23:39be a revered scholar of Islamic law, a devoted
- 23:41father, and the author of passionate poems to
- 23:44a young man. And his society did not see those
- 23:47things as a contradiction. They did not demand
- 23:49he choose a side. And the texts go even further
- 23:52when it comes to the concept of gender itself,
- 23:54showing that it wasn't just a rigid binary either.
- 23:56Right, which is another modern assumption. The
- 23:58sources cite Everett Rawson's work on the Mukanathun.
- 24:01I had honestly never heard this term before.
- 24:04Who were they and how did they fit into the society?
- 24:07The Mukanathun were gender -liminal figures in
- 24:09early Medina. Meaning they crossed gender boundaries?
- 24:12Yes. These were biological men who lived, dressed,
- 24:16and were socially received as something distinct
- 24:18from the standard masculine norm. They often
- 24:22occupied specific social roles, sometimes as
- 24:24matchmakers, musicians, or entertainers. Okay.
- 24:27And what is most historically significant about
- 24:29Rawson's work is that it proves these figures
- 24:32were present at the very origin of the Islamic
- 24:35community. They lived in Medina during the life
- 24:38of the Prophet Muhammad. So they weren't a later
- 24:40decadent addition, like some corruption of the
- 24:43original faith. They were there at the genesis
- 24:44of the faith. Yes, they were. While their social
- 24:47status was sometimes debated or marginalized
- 24:49by later scholars, the undeniable fact of their
- 24:52visible presence in early Islamic history proves
- 24:55that the conceptualization of gender in early
- 24:57Islam was vastly more capacious, flexible, and
- 25:00complicated than modern polemicists on any side
- 25:04of the political spectrum are willing to admit.
- 25:06So let's look at the board for a second. We have
- 25:09this massive historically documented imaginative
- 25:12space for same -sex desire. We have a culture
- 25:15that completely separates acts from identity.
- 25:18We have gender liminal figures present at the
- 25:20birth of the community. We have revered scholars
- 25:23writing love poems to men. All historical facts.
- 25:26Which begs the million -dollar question. If that
- 25:29was the lived reality for centuries, how on earth
- 25:32did we end up with the rigid, violent, exclusionary
- 25:35Puritanism of the Berlin attacker? Where did
- 25:39this extreme brittleness regarding sexuality
- 25:41actually come from? To answer that, the essay
- 25:44pivots to the historical research of Afsaneh
- 25:47Najmabadi, who studies Iranian modernity, and
- 25:50Drozhievi, who studies the Ottoman Middle East.
- 25:52Two incredible scholars. They both track the
- 25:54mechanism. of a massive historical disruption.
- 25:56They document how that older, fluid, capacious
- 25:59economy of desire was systematically and deliberately
- 26:02heteronormalized. Heteronormalized. Yes. It's
- 26:04forcibly flattened into the rigid modern binary
- 26:07of hetero versus homo. And this flattening happened
- 26:09under the immense crushing pressure of Western
- 26:11modernity during the 19th and 20th centuries.
- 26:14How exactly did that happen? I mean, was it forced
- 26:17on them by colonial armies or did they do it
- 26:19to themselves? It was a complex mixture of both,
- 26:22driven by the internalization of the colonizer's
- 26:25gaze. The colonizer's gaze. Yeah. As European
- 26:28powers began to dominate the Middle East militarily
- 26:30and economically, European travelers, missionaries,
- 26:34and colonial administrators encountered this
- 26:36fluid sexuality and the ubiquitous homoerotic
- 26:39poetry. And the Victorians were horrified. Well,
- 26:43yeah, they were Victorians. Exactly. They labeled
- 26:45the Islamic world as decadent, perverse, and
- 26:49effeminate. They used this supposed moral decay
- 26:52as a primary justification for their colonial
- 26:55rule. They essentially said, you are weak and
- 26:58conquerable because you are sexually deviant.
- 27:00And the tragic part is the reformists within
- 27:02the Islamic world actually believed them. Exactly.
- 27:05When Ottoman and Qajar elites looked for ways
- 27:08to modernize and resist European domination,
- 27:10they didn't just import European telegraphs and
- 27:13military tactics. They imported the culture.
- 27:15They imported European Victorian morality. They
- 27:18rewrote their penal codes based on French and
- 27:20British models. They literally purged their own
- 27:23classical poetry, translating and editing it
- 27:26to erase the male pronouns. Erasing their own
- 27:28history. Yes, frantically trying to hide their
- 27:31own history of same -sex desire just to appear
- 27:34civilized in the eyes of London and Paris. They
- 27:37poured the concrete over their own suspension
- 27:38bridge. This is the ultimate tragic irony of
- 27:42this entire deep dive. It really does. Right.
- 28:07It is a... profound, almost unbearable irony.
- 28:16The men driving these vans, believing they are
- 28:19striking a righteous blow against the corrupting
- 28:21influence of the modern West, are without knowing
- 28:24it, the most thoroughly westernized men in the
- 28:27room. That is just wild to wrap your head around.
- 28:29They aren't defending classical Islam. They are
- 28:32defending the ghost of Victorian Puritanism.
- 28:34They have internalized the moral panic and the
- 28:37rigid binaries of their former colonizers, and
- 28:41they have tragically mistaken those colonial
- 28:43imports for ancient divine law. That is just
- 28:46a staggering realization. They took the concrete
- 28:49that the colonial engineers poured over the suspension
- 28:52bridge, forgot there was ever a bridge underneath
- 28:54it, and convinced themselves the concrete is
- 28:57sacred. That is exactly the mechanism of their
- 28:59radicalization. Now, um... We need to pause here
- 29:01and make something very explicit. Yes. The argument
- 29:04here is incredibly provocative. And whether you
- 29:06agree with it or not, it forces us to look at
- 29:09how Western liberalism operates on a global scale.
- 29:12Now, we are strictly exploring the historical
- 29:15and sociological arguments laid out in our source
- 29:17texts. We aren't taking sides here. Right. We
- 29:20aren't endorsing a political stance, but it is
- 29:23vital to explore this next section impartially
- 29:25because while the sources offer a devastating
- 29:28critique of modern Islamists, they also offer
- 29:31a profound and potentially very uncomfortable
- 29:33critique of the modern Western approach to sexual
- 29:36identity. This brings us to the work of Joseph
- 29:39Massad, specifically his highly debated book
- 29:42Desiring Arabs. A very controversial text. It
- 29:45is. Massad offers a fierce critique of what he
- 29:48provocatively calls the gay international, which
- 29:51is his term for the global, heavily Western -funded
- 29:53campaign to universalize the modern Western framework
- 29:56of gay identity and export it to the rest of
- 29:59the world. Right, because if we just spent the
- 30:01last half hour establishing that the classical
- 30:03Islamic world had a completely different, highly
- 30:05nuanced way of organizing desire and identity,
- 30:08then taking a modern Western template and forcing
- 30:11it onto other societies might not be the universal
- 30:13act of liberation it is often framed as. Exactly.
- 30:16Mossad argues that imposing this Western template
- 30:19onto societies that historically never organized
- 30:21their intimate lives around confessional identities
- 30:23causes real, tangible damage. Let's look at the
- 30:27mechanics of why that is. We have to examine
- 30:29the mechanics of Western liberalism to understand
- 30:31why. The Western demand, the demand that you
- 30:35must name yourself, that you must publicly declare
- 30:37your sexual identity before the state and society
- 30:40to be considered authentic, grows out of a very
- 30:43specific European cultural soil. Right, the Enlightenment.
- 30:47Yes, it centers entirely on the concept of the
- 30:49sovereign individual. It is the post -enlightenment
- 30:52conviction that the self is only truly free when
- 30:56it is publicly categorized, legally recognized
- 30:59by the state and protected by rights. It's the
- 31:01core philosophy behind the concept of coming
- 31:03out, isn't it? The idea that if you don't publicly
- 31:06declare your identity, you are inherently living
- 31:08a lie or suffering under oppression and that
- 31:11public visibility is the only path to true freedom.
- 31:14Exactly. But Mossad points out that this is simply
- 31:16not the axis around which Islamic civilization
- 31:18turned. They had a totally different center.
- 31:21The classical Islamic anthropology, its understanding
- 31:24of what a human being is, was completely different.
- 31:27It did not center the sovereign individual. It
- 31:30centered the ummah, the collective community.
- 31:33In that historical framework, a person's inner
- 31:36life, their private desires, and their intimate
- 31:39actions were strictly a matter between themselves
- 31:41and God. The realm of the private was fiercely
- 31:44protected? It was almost sacred. It was neither
- 31:46the business of the state nor the business of
- 31:48the mosque to interrogate your inner life. God
- 31:51was the only judge of the unseen. So forcing
- 31:53visibility actually changes the system. By introducing
- 31:56the Western demand for public confession and
- 31:59state recognition, Mossad argues that the gay
- 32:01international actually incites a violent backlash.
- 32:05How so? By forcing people to publicly identify
- 32:07with a category that local authorities associate
- 32:09with Western cultural imperialism, it forces
- 32:12the state to police behaviors that, historically,
- 32:15it would have simply ignored under the veil of
- 32:18discretion. So it was a culture of profound discretion.
- 32:21But the expert analysis in our sources points
- 32:23out that this discretion is a double edged sword.
- 32:25Right. It's not exactly a perfect utopia. No,
- 32:28it absolutely cut both ways. And we cannot romanticize
- 32:31the past. Classical Islam was not some progressive
- 32:34liberal utopia that celebrated sexual minorities
- 32:38in the way a modern pride parade does. Right.
- 32:41They weren't marching in the streets. No, it
- 32:43did not celebrate them as a distinct, empowered
- 32:45identity group. but crucially because it never
- 32:49demanded the confessional declaration of sexual
- 32:51identity it also never demanded the modern inquisition
- 32:54into it it did not celebrate but it also did
- 32:58not hunt. Consider what this means for our understanding
- 33:00of the Berlin attacker. It means that his obsession
- 33:03and the obsession of certain strains of contemporary
- 33:06political Islamism with policing, exposing, and
- 33:10violently excluding sexual minorities, none of
- 33:13that is the recovery of an authentic Islamic
- 33:15past. Not at all. The classical scholars wouldn't
- 33:17even recognize his behavior. It is a completely
- 33:19modern pathology dressed up in old clothes. It's
- 33:22that brittle certainty Bauer described forged
- 33:24in the trauma of the 19th century. turned into
- 33:27a deadly weapon in the 21st. The violence is
- 33:30the tragic end result of losing civilization
- 33:33confidence. When a culture loses the confidence
- 33:36to let the inner life remain between the individual
- 33:38and the divine, it panics. It has to control
- 33:41everything. Exactly. It demands conformity, demands
- 33:43to see everything, categorize everything, and
- 33:46violently police everything that doesn't fit
- 33:49the newly imported concrete mold. So hearing
- 33:52all of this history, you know, the immense capaciousness
- 33:54of the early centuries, the poetry, the tragic
- 33:57flattening by colonialism, the modern crisis
- 33:59of identity, it naturally leads to the question
- 34:02of where things stand right now. for believers.
- 34:04Right. Is this beautiful, flexible suspension
- 34:07bridge of a tradition purely historical? Is it
- 34:10trapped in a museum? Or is it alive enough to
- 34:13adapt to the realities of believers living today?
- 34:15The sources emphasize this is not a dead historical
- 34:18artifact. There is a live, rigorous, and often
- 34:22very tense theological debate happening within
- 34:24the tradition right now. And it's happening on
- 34:26the tradition's own terms, right? Exactly. For
- 34:29example, the essay introduces the work of Scott
- 34:32Kugel. In his book, Homosexuality in Islam, Kugel
- 34:36attempts a radical theological recovery. He offers
- 34:39a complete rereading of the story of Lot. The
- 34:41story of Lot, which is shared across the Abrahamic
- 34:44faiths in the Bible and the Quran, is usually
- 34:46the definitive, unassailable text used by clerics
- 34:50to condemn same -sex relations. How does Kugel
- 34:53manage to reread it? What is his mechanism for
- 34:56reinterpretation? Kugel dives deep into the linguistic
- 34:59and historical context of the verses. He argues
- 35:02that the story of Lot is not actually a condemnation
- 35:05of love or consensual same -sex desire or the
- 35:08quest for intimacy. Then what is it about? He
- 35:11argues that the sin of the people of Lot was
- 35:12fundamentally about coercion, sexual violence,
- 35:15and a profound violation of the sacred laws of
- 35:17hospitality. They were attempting to assert power
- 35:20through assault. Okay. Based on this reading
- 35:22and a broader theological framework that emphasizes
- 35:24God's expansive justice, Kugel makes the case
- 35:27that the Koran, when read without the accumulated
- 35:29prejudices of later centuries, can fully embrace
- 35:32gay, lesbian and transgender Muslims. Now, the
- 35:35sources also balance this by bringing in Kesh
- 35:37Ali's book, Sexual Ethics and Islam, because
- 35:41it's important to note that Kugel's view is not
- 35:43the universally accepted standard. It is highly
- 35:46controversial. Yes. Google's reading is intensely
- 35:49disputed by many mainstream jurists who argue
- 35:53he is stretching the text to fit modern sensibilities.
- 35:57Kesha Ali provides a much more measured, academically
- 36:00cautious survey of the landscape. She takes a
- 36:03different approach. She does. She shows how much
- 36:05of what passes for a timeless, unchanging ruling
- 36:09in Islamic law is actually historically contingent.
- 36:12Meaning it was shaped by the politics of the
- 36:14time. Exactly. Meaning it was shaped by the specific
- 36:16political and social anxieties of the time and
- 36:19place it was written. But she also acknowledges
- 36:21how much the classical sources actually settle.
- 36:24And she points out the real methodological challenges
- 36:26in trying to stretch classical jurisprudence
- 36:29to accommodate modern human rights frameworks.
- 36:31But the point the author of our primary essay
- 36:33makes by citing both Kugel and Ali isn't to declare
- 36:36one side the theological winner, right? We aren't
- 36:39here to solve Islamic theology. No, that's not
- 36:41our goal. The point is to prove to you that a
- 36:43serious, rigorous, real debate exists right now
- 36:47conducted by serious believers who And if we
- 36:51connect this back to the overarching theme of
- 36:54ambiguity and brittleness, a confident faith,
- 36:58a civilization that remembers its own capaciousness
- 37:01can hold this debate. It can tolerate the friction.
- 37:04It can tolerate the tension of Kugel and his
- 37:07conservative critics arguing over the texts.
- 37:09It can absorb that friction without collapsing
- 37:12and without resorting to violence. It is only
- 37:14a brittle faith, one terrified of ambiguity and
- 37:17difference, that feels it has lost the argument
- 37:20so thoroughly that it needs a rented van to settle
- 37:23a theological dispute. And the essay brings us
- 37:25all home by tying it back to the core text of
- 37:28Islam itself. It points to a specific verse in
- 37:31the Quran, Surah 30, verse 22. is a verse that
- 37:34explicitly states that the creation of the heavens
- 37:36and the earth and the diversity of human tongues
- 37:38and colors are a sign of God. Think about the
- 37:41absolute devastating contrast there. The attacker
- 37:44in Berlin looked out through the windshield at
- 37:47the vibrant diversity of the Christopher Street
- 37:49Day crowd, and his brittle ideology saw a mortal
- 37:52threat that had to be violently eliminated. He
- 37:54saw something to destroy. But the very text he
- 37:57claims to defend, the text he likely memorized,
- 37:59looks out at the irreducible variety of the human
- 38:02condition. the different ways we love, speak,
- 38:05and exist, and calls it divine. So as we wrap
- 38:09up this deep dive, I want to take you back to
- 38:10where we started. back to that street in Berlin,
- 38:13back to that tragic day in July 2026. The ultimate
- 38:17tragedy of that young man in the van is that
- 38:19the very capaciousness he could not tolerate,
- 38:22the immense, messy, beautiful, swaying diversity
- 38:25of that crowd, is not actually a modern Western
- 38:28gift to Islam. It's really not. As our sources
- 38:30have painstakingly shown, from the poetry of
- 38:33the Shahid to the gender -liminal figures of
- 38:35Medina, that capaciousness is Islam's older gift
- 38:38to itself. The true task ahead. as the essay
- 38:41argues so powerfully, isn't about constantly
- 38:43sharpening a dichotomy between Islam and the
- 38:46modern world as if they are locked in an eternal
- 38:48war of civilizations. We hear that narrative
- 38:50so much. We do, but it's false. The task is the
- 38:54arduous work of recovering a civilizational confidence.
- 38:57A confidence that, for centuries, successfully
- 39:00held the longing, the love, the ambiguity, and
- 39:03the irreducible variety of human beings without
- 39:06shattering. We love things to be clean, binary,
- 39:09and visible. broken or not broken, gay or straight,
- 39:13east or west. But human history, the complexities
- 39:16of human desire and the depths of human faith
- 39:19defy that kind of clinical machinery. The suspension
- 39:22bridge of classical Islam was built to sway with
- 39:25the complexities of the human heart, not to be
- 39:27encased in the concrete of 19th century Victorian
- 39:29morality. And that leads to a final thought I
- 39:31want to leave you with, something to mull over
- 39:33long after this deep dive ends. We've just explored
- 39:35how a 19th century Western idea about sexual
- 39:38order was so... successfully disguised that people
- 39:41today will literally kill to defend it, genuinely
- 39:44believing it to be an ancient sacred truth. It's
- 39:47chilling. It is. It forces us to turn that lens
- 39:50on ourselves. What deeply held traditional beliefs
- 39:53in your own life, your own religion, or your
- 39:55own culture are actually just recent imports.
- 39:58How much of what we confidently call timeless
- 40:00is just a rigidness we invented yesterday to
- 40:03soothe our own modern anxieties.