Latest / Engineering Influence from ACEC / The Politics of the Moment with Jonathan Martin
Transcript
- 0:00A big thank you to Autodesk, the sponsor of Engineering Influence at this year's convention.
- 0:05Autodesk partners with the AEC industry and its leaders to shape a more connected,
- 0:11data-driven future, empowering engineers to work more intelligently and to make
- 0:16confident decisions to drive meaningful impact.
- 0:19This enables firms to evolve, stay competitive, and deliver stronger business
- 0:23outcomes, all while designing a better world.
- 0:27So thank you again to Autodesk.
- 0:33Welcome to Engineering Influence Podcast, the American Council of Engineering.
- 0:37Company is coming to you from our 2026 Convention and Legislative Summit in
- 0:40Washington, coming off of a great day of programming that was just wrapped up
- 0:47with my guest, Jonathan Martin, Bureau Chief at Politico.
- 0:51Thank you so much for coming onto the stage and talking to former Chairman Schuster
- 0:55and DeFazio about infrastructure.
- 0:57And they got along well. They did. There were no other roles thrown at each other.
- 1:00Uh-huh. It was a very civil conversation. No, it reminded me of what the Congress used to be. Yeah.
- 1:05Where you had this really non-ideological committee that was just dedicated
- 1:09to an issue that was totally unifying and popular because everybody in Congress
- 1:14wants to help their districts or their states.
- 1:17And boy, that was typically the committee where you could do it.
- 1:19And so there was a bit of nostalgia there, I think.
- 1:21Yeah, there was nostalgia and there's that old comedy that you used to see in
- 1:26the committee. Two people have diametrically opposed political perspectives, but we're focused.
- 1:31And largely my experience with the committee is that if you wanted to have a
- 1:34debate, it got very nerdy very quickly.
- 1:36And you were talking about formulas. You were talking about actual policy language.
- 1:39It was never whether or not we should have a highway belt.
- 1:42And that, I don't know. And it was nerdy. It wasn't nasty.
- 1:46No, it was nerdy, but not nasty. That's right. Because it wasn't about abortion
- 1:49or guns or about Donald Trump this or that. It was down in the weeds of this
- 1:56state or district gets X number of dollars.
- 1:58Now, it got scrappy because obviously they're all trying to vie for dollars.
- 2:03But it was a different kind of debate and a different kind of sort of fight
- 2:08that the fights we're having today.
- 2:09Yeah, a lot of it was regional. Total. People wanted to carve up the pie and
- 2:12make sure that their regions were taken care of.
- 2:14We got into the conversation. Cities versus country. Yep.
- 2:17Suburbs versus rural. And that used to be carved up during earmarks,
- 2:20which was a topic of conversation that you had. The Northeast versus everybody else. Yeah, exactly.
- 2:25Remember, donor states, donor states. Yeah, exactly. And then the urban areas
- 2:29versus rural. Of course.
- 2:30And that was really the, it wasn't so much red and blue, it was urban versus rural.
- 2:34And highway versus transit, too. Exactly. That was the other mix that everybody
- 2:38fought over. I mean, from your perch, I mean, you, you talk to a lot of people
- 2:42from all different ranges from the political, uh, uh, uh, you know, spectrum.
- 2:47I mean, where would you gauge it right now? I mean, I, you know,
- 2:51everybody looks back and says, oh, it was so much better back then. Yes.
- 2:55Yes. But was it, I mean, are we just like living in the moment and we're so
- 2:59consumed by headlines? It's a fair question. I look at it this way.
- 3:03We're all products of perspective. So, you know, those of us who remember an
- 3:08earlier generation probably assign them too much stature.
- 3:11Everybody's been putting their pants on the same way in this country for a long
- 3:15time. They were all mortals then, too. And they had the same shortcomings.
- 3:19That said, I don't think it's just perspective. I do think that there was,
- 3:23in the totality, a more seriousness of purpose in an earlier generation.
- 3:30And I think also the issues that animated folks were less the culture wars and
- 3:35were more the bread and butter of how do I take care of my state or district?
- 3:39Because the audience they were catering to, and this is crucial,
- 3:42was between the 40-yard lines of American life.
- 3:45It was the center that animated most of these folks.
- 3:49Now it's the fringes. Yeah, the wings are driving it.
- 3:52The wings are driving it because all the action is now in the primary.
- 3:55One of the most striking parts of the conversation that we had with Schuster
- 3:58and DeFazio was the end, where I said, if you can wave a wand and do anything to change Congress.
- 4:02And both of them said the same thing. One a liberal, one a conservative.
- 4:06They said, stop the gerrymandering. Make these seats come more competitive again
- 4:09so that we can incentivize members to run toward the middle.
- 4:13And that's, you know, I have had this conversation a lot with my wife because
- 4:18we watch when you were on CNN or when you pop on.
- 4:21And we talk about kind of the redistricting fight in Virginia,
- 4:24what's going on in Louisiana with the Voting Rights Act, what happened in Texas.
- 4:28You know, OK, great. It's the whole idea of how do you even get there because
- 4:32you got to two parties because there's no incentive by the parties to make this more competitive.
- 4:36The opposite. You know, they want to make they look at they don't care about
- 4:39the result. They care about the numbers. Max number. Yeah. Plus R,
- 4:43you know, by whatever it is, plus D.
- 4:45You know, I mean, how do you fix that? How do you, how do you get to the point
- 4:48where you can actually get back to a good apportionment that is less...
- 4:53Less, it's inherently political, but less political. Well, here's the good news.
- 4:57You know, back in the day, you talked to an audience about reapportionment.
- 5:01You couldn't even get the word out of your mouth. Folks would fall asleep.
- 5:04I do think nowadays, because of just how extreme this has gotten in this total
- 5:09war mentality of sort of, you know, mid-decade redraw of lines,
- 5:14it's hit the point of absurdity.
- 5:16And I think it's hit the point of the average voter saying, hang on a second,
- 5:19this is too much. This arms race has got to stop. I think we may maybe nearing bottom.
- 5:24And I think when we hit bottom, the voter is going to demand a different way.
- 5:27And what does that look like?
- 5:29I think the short version is you got to have some kind of a national mandate.
- 5:33And I know folks don't like hearing the M-Ward, but you got to have it to ensure
- 5:37that state legislatures do not draw these lines to gerrymander out of one party
- 5:42or the other out of oblivion or rather into oblivion. So I think you have to have a bill.
- 5:47You may even have to have a constitutional amendment. I don't necessarily think
- 5:50you have to, but I think you You at least have to have a bill passed by Congress,
- 5:53signed by a president. Ensuring fair lines. Yeah.
- 5:57Now, it's all being driven by the algorithm, by the rage machine.
- 6:00I think that you've gone from print now to digital. You have the On the Road podcast. Yes.
- 6:05That's a plug. Yeah, of course. I'm going to plug that one. I mean,
- 6:07that's great. Going on the road.
- 6:09Having meals with politicians. Having meals with politicians is kind of a disarming
- 6:13environment. You got it.
- 6:14Yeah. Everybody likes food. Yeah. And politicians love showing off their states and their cities.
- 6:18Yeah. And the best way to do that is go to the local joint where you can get
- 6:22the best barbecue or pizza or seafood or whatever else.
- 6:25And that's the idea of the show. Yeah. It's On the Road with Jonathan Martin.
- 6:28We're traveling the country.
- 6:29You can watch it on YouTube as a video or listen to it as a podcast.
- 6:32And the idea is, yeah, let's find common ground, get off the talking points,
- 6:36and do so over a good meal. And, you know, I think that goes to the larger question
- 6:40of what people are actually looking for.
- 6:42You know, it used to be, you'd see an editorial, you'd see an op-ed,
- 6:46that would get played. Yes. That would be echoed across media.
- 6:50Now, with everybody having instant access to everything, everybody wants,
- 6:54authenticity is going to be the key.
- 6:56If you can get a conversation with an elected official, you're going to be doing
- 6:58Wes Moore pretty soon. Yeah, yeah. If you can get him a little bit off guard. Yeah.
- 7:03And in a more comfortable environment. Have a real conversation.
- 7:05Have a real, like real people.
- 7:07Who is this person? What drives them?
- 7:10What are their anxieties? What are their insecurities? What are their ambitions?
- 7:14And sort of, I think you can do that much easier over an hour-long conversation
- 7:20over a meal than you can in a TV studio for two and a half. Well,
- 7:23everybody's plugged in.
- 7:25If you're doing a remote, you're not even seeing the other person.
- 7:27You're staring a camera, and you're just sticking to talking points in the message.
- 7:30Yeah, I think for, you know, we're in this fascinating moment where the media
- 7:35consumer has become captivated by two art forms.
- 7:40One is, like, the 30-second video clip that all of us see in our daily scrolls across social media.
- 7:46But the other is the long-form podcast. And that it's nice to see that coming
- 7:51back where it's no longer it was like, oh, no, you have to have your message out in 30 seconds.
- 7:55Now it's like, OK, can someone actually sustain a two hour conversation?
- 7:59And I think that the next primary for president, I think both parties.
- 8:04You're going to have to nominate a candidate that's comfortable doing both.
- 8:07Can you break through for 30 seconds in a clip?
- 8:09But also, can you sit down with no staff and talk about arranging issues for an hour?
- 8:14Yeah, because that's where it really breaks through.
- 8:17You actually have to let the guard down, and you have to be a lot more authentic,
- 8:20and you never know what's going on, because a long-form conversation could go
- 8:24a lot of different ways. It can.
- 8:25And you can find the 30 seconds therein that goes viral, right?
- 8:28Exactly. But, you know, people, you know, whether they're driving or they're
- 8:31working out or jogging or walking their dog, they just like having a podcast
- 8:35now to listen to. I've gone from reading the news to now trying to get my podcasts.
- 8:40And, you know, whether it's from Politico or from the time, whatever it is. That's right.
- 8:46It's on demand and it's just self-published information.
- 8:51It's just changing the way that everybody's consuming news and even producing information.
- 8:55And you can dig a little deeper and learn more in a podcast because all of us
- 8:59know the top lines, you know, like the idea of finding out what happened that
- 9:02day by watching the 6.30 PM or 7 PM national news.
- 9:06The thing of the past increasingly, because all of us get our news and information.
- 9:10I don't care if you work in politics or you don't, through social media pings, push alerts.
- 9:16All of us know if there's breaking news during the course of a day, we're going to find out.
- 9:19It's going to find us. And the podcast, I think, gets you a little deeper into
- 9:24the context of what happened.
- 9:26It's kind of like what Time and Newsweek were 30, 40 years ago.
- 9:29It came once a week. It was the story behind the story. That's today's podcast. Yeah.
- 9:33But I mean, not to say that literature still matters. Hey, you do have a book.
- 9:37Hey, got to do the product shot. So you got a new book coming out. There we go.
- 9:41Yeah. This will not pass. This will not pass. So tell me a little bit about
- 9:44the book and the basis for it.
- 9:47Well, thanks for the plug. I appreciate that. So a colleague,
- 9:49Alex Burns and I wrote this book that was an account of what we thought was
- 9:53really a seminal moment in modern American history, which was the year of 2020 and the aftermath,
- 10:00which we thought then And the story can't get any crazier. And obviously it keeps getting crazier.
- 10:06But the title holds up, which is This Will Not Pass.
- 10:09And I think it sort of captures the tumultuous nature of politics today.
- 10:15And a lot of what we've mentioned earlier and just how politics has been transformed
- 10:19into this sort of this almost tribal warfare that is consuming American communities
- 10:26and, frankly, American families.
- 10:27And we try to sort of get at what happened in that fateful 2020 and 2021 period.
- 10:33So I think folks will learn a lot. And our joke is no matter what your politics,
- 10:36if you don't like one chapter, just wait for the next one. Yeah, exactly.
- 10:41If you don't like team red, wait till the next one. Yeah, exactly.
- 10:44I mean, it's, it's something which we have to, everybody takes stock. I mean.
- 10:48John Miescham was here earlier today. Yes, great author. Of course,
- 10:51he has the great historical kind of grand, you know.
- 10:56And it's history is we're living it. And you know what I mentioned?
- 11:01We are. We are. I mentioned to him, it's like, you know, it's,
- 11:03we're still the American experiment.
- 11:05And that's just not a slogan, right? It's like we are actually in it.
- 11:08And we can still determine the path of that experiment, right?
- 11:11There's nothing guaranteed that we're going to keep doing this for 250 more
- 11:16years, let alone 25 more years.
- 11:18It's up to every generation to fulfill the promise of the founders.
- 11:23And obviously, we haven't fully redeemed it yet, but that is still the hope.
- 11:26It's still a young country.
- 11:28You know, I think about members of Congress today and the folks that some of
- 11:32the older ones served with.
- 11:33And, you know, you can go back pretty quickly to an earlier generation.
- 11:37Joe Biden, our last president, he came to the Senate in 1973.
- 11:41He served with folks who were born in the 19th century. And so,
- 11:45you know, you make a really good point. We're not guaranteed this experiment.
- 11:49We've got to keep doing our part. And I think part of that is getting involved
- 11:53and being part of the process, part of the solution.
- 11:55And hats off to what you guys do, getting people involved in their communities,
- 11:59but also in their state government and their federal government to advocate.
- 12:02If you don't do that, you can't plan. Yeah, exactly.
- 12:05So a good way of doing that and staying engaged. So definitely check out the book. There we go.
- 12:10Stay engaged. And Jonathan, thank you for taking the time. Appreciate it.
- 12:13I really appreciate it. Thank you.
- 12:14Yeah, absolutely. And again, this has been Engineering Influence,
- 12:17a podcast from the American Council of Engineering Companies. We'll see you next time.