Latest / Success Story with Scott Clary / How US Women’s Soccer Scored Equal Pay, from The Closer
Transcript
- 0:00Everyone's Scott here. Today, you're going to hear something special. It's a preview of the
- 0:03closer podcast from Project Brazen. The closer tells inside stories about the way businesses
- 0:09really work. Landmark deals can alter the course of the economy and transform how we live.
- 0:15The closer asks, who made these deals and why? These are the stories about the way business
- 0:19really works. The drama, the intrigue, high stakes, big personalities. In this episode, you're
- 0:24going to hear about the US Women's National Soccer Team, which is among the most decorated
- 0:29teams in the game, but until recently, was paid a fraction of what the men took home.
- 0:33When the players decided to take up the fight for equal pay, they turned to sports attorney Jeffrey
- 0:38Kessler, who built a career out of representing some of the most high profile athletes in labor
- 0:43disputes and professional leagues. He takes you inside the team's strategy and reveals how they
- 0:48got the deal done. Here comes the preview. If you want to find more episodes at the closer,
- 0:52you can get it wherever you download your podcasts.
- 1:11In all of Women's Soccer, in all of US Soccer, one team dominates.
- 1:16The United States of America are the 2015 World Cup winners.
- 1:22For the fourth time, the United States of America are crowned champions of the world,
- 1:30and for the very first time, they've done it on European soil.
- 1:39The most world cup titles, the most Olympic gold medals,
- 1:43the most number one in the world rankings. And today, perhaps the best known champions of a
- 1:48fight off the field, equal pay. It's a chance now linked forever to the 2019 US Women's Soccer Team.
- 2:01What you're seeing is the women saying, listen, we are your most valuable product and you are not
- 2:06treating us as such. Welcome back to season two of The Closer, a show that covers the inside
- 2:12story of deals that change the world. On this episode, we're talking about the landmark soccer
- 2:18deal that's rewriting the rules of how professional athletes are paid at the highest level,
- 2:23how the winningness team and women's soccer fought for their worth as told by the lawyer who helped
- 2:28build their case. What I think was so appealing about this fight was if these women who were
- 2:35clearly the best in the world and who clearly outperformed the men's team, if they couldn't get equal
- 2:43pay, then who was going to get equal pay, right? So it really sort of highlighted that whole struggle.
- 2:51This is The Closer. I'm Amy Keane. Back in the late 1970s, a young Jeffrey Kessler started his
- 2:59law career at a big New York firm. It was called Wild Gotcha. And I went there to become an
- 3:05anti-trust lawyer. Anti-trust law. This might make you think of things like monopoly power,
- 3:12price fixing, cartels. It refers to the set of laws meant to maintain competition among businesses.
- 3:19The idea is that a competitive and efficient markets keeps prices down and quality up for the
- 3:24benefit of consumers. But matters of anti-trust law and professional sports in the late 70s.
- 3:30There were frankly very few such cases at that time. The business was very, very small economically.
- 3:37It didn't generate that much legal work. And very early in my career, I became involved in
- 3:46utilizing anti-trust law to try to create economic rights and freedoms for athletes.
- 3:55When Jeffrey joined Wild, the firm was in the midst of settling a landmark effort by NBA
- 4:00Hall of Famer Oscar Robertson to bring free agency to the league.
- 4:05Well, I think it's really revolutionizing a game of basketball for it's for being paid.
- 4:09They're absolutely. And for playing like players playing 15 to 20 years now.
- 4:14As professional sports became big business, commissioners of the establishment leagues like the NFL,
- 4:21the NHL and the MLB, they all concentrated power. And kind of like a cartel, these leagues control
- 4:28things that might otherwise be set by the market in other industries. Think of who owns which teams
- 4:34and the salary caps they set. This is where Jeffrey's anti-trust practice comes in.
- 4:40And really everything sort of developed from there. Additional sports clients looking for
- 4:46anti-trust help came to the firm. I became involved in those and it was sort of step by step
- 4:53that my career really developed with sort of two legs.
- 4:58One leg in traditional anti-trust work for big companies in a variety of industries,
- 5:03the other in professional sports. You might be familiar with some of his most high profile cases.
- 5:09He represented Tom Brady when the quarterback and other players challenged the 2011 NFL lockout.
- 5:15Then division one college athletes in their battle with the NCAA for greater compensation.
- 5:20And Tom Brady again in the deflate gate scandal.
- 5:24You know, I've had the good fortune of my career to work on some cases and matters that I think
- 5:28have made a difference in the lives of people. Fast forward to 2016. Jeffrey's co-chairman of another
- 5:36firm Winston and strong and he gets a call from the union representing the US women's national
- 5:41soccer team. They were very unhappy with the deals that they had had in the past.
- 5:47And they were looking to develop ways to better assert their rights and power to get what they
- 5:55would hope would be a fair compensation. Fair compensation from their employer the US soccer
- 6:00Federation. By this point the US women's national soccer team had already racked up just about
- 6:06every win and title they could. Some more than once. They dominated the competition on the field
- 6:13and players were emerging as celebrities in their own right. Alex Morgan, Kristen Press,
- 6:18Carly Lloyd, and then of course Megan Rapinoe.
- 6:22I think now that final game was the most watched game in US soccer history, both male and female.
- 6:33Yeah, and I think that that is just goes to show you how empowering this is.
- 6:43These were the women Jeffrey Kessler was getting ready to work with when the players union called
- 6:48them up. They were really interested in how they could change the economic course of their
- 6:58history not so much for themselves but for the future generation of women who would follow them.
- 7:06The players wanted their paychecks to reflect the value they brought to the field and that started
- 7:11with equal pay. During the bargaining we developed the analysis that showed that they weren't getting
- 7:24equal pay with the men's team. Even though they were better than the men's team in their performance
- 7:32they did the same job as the men's team and they had the same employer. One example of the pay
- 7:39disparity the women found was in their compensation for friendlies or the matches both the men's
- 7:44and women's team played each year beyond the big tournaments. For every friendly the women earned
- 7:49the equivalent of $3,600. If they won they get a bonus of $1,350. Let's talk about women's soccer players.
- 7:58They're the big stars in the states with all the money and the glory of the men well except for
- 8:03the money pots. The men on the other hand they got a bonus as much as nearly $18,000 depending on
- 8:10how their opponent was ranked and whether they tied or won the game and a minimum of $5,000 to play
- 8:17even if they lost $5,000. To be clear about one thing the men and the women were on two
- 8:34different contracts with US Soccer. Many of the women on the national team received a salary
- 8:39as well as some benefits like health insurance and parental leave. The men did not.
- 8:44But there was another big disparity in earning potential for men and women in professional
- 8:48soccer at the time. Most of the women's national team players earned most of their living either
- 8:55from their national team compensation or some of them had big sponsorships but their pro salaries
- 9:01on clubs were quite smaller in most cases. So much less that some players worked other jobs
- 9:08on top of playing soccer. Equal pay for men and women in the same or similar jobs is far
- 9:14from a novel issue and it's played out in the world of sports for years. She's carrying a
- 9:21banner for the women. You like women. A lot of people said you don't like women. This is really
- 9:26more than just. I like a real good in the bedroom, the kitchen and when they bring the slippers in the
- 9:32pipe. Nearly 50 years ago, tennis star Billie Jean King challenged Bobby Riggs to an exhibition
- 9:38after he claimed that women don't play as well as men. I really think the best way to handle the
- 9:43women is to keep them pregnant and this way they don't worry about getting out in the men's world
- 9:51and competing for jobs and trying to get equal money and all that belonging. She famously won
- 9:57in three sets. Sometimes people say to me thanks for what you did for women's tennis. I smile
- 10:03and I say thank you but they would never say that to a male tennis player. They would say thank
- 10:09you for what you did for tennis. The law was settled even earlier than tennis's battle of the sexes.
- 10:15In 1963, the Equal Pay Act amended the Fair Labor Standards Act and it was meant to protect
- 10:21against wage discrimination on the basis of sex and then there's title seven of the Civil Rights
- 10:26Act of 1964. It prohibits employment discrimination based on things like religion, race and sex.
- 10:33So we made it a point. We the women players and their union made it a point to make Equal Pay
- 10:44a fundamental part of their bargaining demands because it's legally required.
- 10:52And during the course of the bargaining, the USS F said no. They said we're not giving you Equal Pay.
- 11:01So Jeffrey the players and the union decided it's time to open up another legal front.
- 11:10And the front we opened up was to file a complaint for five of the women for Equal Pay.
- 11:18Five of the most high profile players announced they are filing an Equal Pay complaint against
- 11:25Carly Lloyd, Hope Solo, Alex Morgan, Becky Sauerbrunn and Megan Rapinoe. These players were
- 11:31taking their argument to the Equal Employment Opportunity Commission, the EEOC, which is the government
- 11:37agency that you have to first go to before you can assert an Equal Pay claim. It's a gatekeeper
- 11:44if you will and they do an investigation. Remember that the players are in the midst of
- 11:51collective bargaining with U.S. soccer on a contract. Then they ratchet things up a notch by
- 11:56filing this complaint. In the complaint, they outlined paid disparities in three of the four
- 12:02types of compensation from the Federation. First, the friendlies, those non-tournament games
- 12:07where men earned higher base and bonus pay. Second, something called other compensation,
- 12:13like sponsorship appearances and per diem to cover meals while on the road. They said men were
- 12:18paid more for both. Third, the World Cup. The most prestigious tournament in soccer,
- 12:24something the U.S. men's team had never won. And according to the complaint, the men earned
- 12:31$9 million for losing. This was in a relatively early round in 2014. But for the women who won
- 12:39the tournament in 2015, a total of just $2 million. The fourth pay category was for attending
- 12:53the Olympics. This was the one situation where U.S. soccer paid both the men's and women's
- 12:58teams equally. Now, the thing to understand about alleging discrimination in the workplace
- 13:04is that sometimes, according to the law, at least, difference in pay is considered justified.
- 13:10Maybe the job isn't actually the same. Maybe one person did more work than another,
- 13:15or one job had different requirements than the other. But if the only difference is gender,
- 13:21if it's based on gender, it's not justified. And this was the claim, Jeffrey, and the five
- 13:28women named in the complaint we're making. That the players on the men's and women's national
- 13:33soccer teams did the same job, but that the women were paid less. Never mind the fact that they
- 13:38had a better record than the men's team, and had drawn the highest U.S. TV ratings for a soccer
- 13:44match in that 2015 World Cup final. Here's Hope Solo in an interview at the time.
- 13:50We continue to be told we should be grateful just to have the opportunity to play professional
- 13:57soccer. And in this day and age, it's about equality. It's about equal rights. It's about equal pay.
- 14:02When the complaint came out, U.S. soccer pushed back on some of the claims.
- 14:06One official called some of the players' figures inaccurate and misleading.
- 14:10The federation also noted the men's and women's teams had negotiated two different sets of contracts.
- 14:16And they also tried to blame FIFA, which is the world body of soccer. This is for the world
- 14:22cup bonuses. They said that, well, FIFA discriminates, which it does, and gave much bigger
- 14:29bonuses to the federation's and the men's tournament than the women's tournament. So they said,
- 14:35well, that's not our fault. It was correct that FIFA was the body that paid bigger bonuses in
- 14:41the men's tournaments than it did in the women's. But the problem with that argument is that FIFA
- 14:47doesn't pay any money to the athletes. FIFA pays the federation's and the federation's like U.S. soccer
- 14:54are the ones who pay the athletes. Here's Carly Lloyd. We've proven our worth over the years,
- 15:00just coming off of a world cup win and the pay disparity between the men and women is just too
- 15:07large and we want to continue to fight. The players were still in the midst of collective
- 15:12bargaining with U.S. soccer. And at this point, getting equal pay with the men's team just wasn't
- 15:17on the table. As Jeffrey tells it, the federation said, even take the best offer we're making now
- 15:24or we're going to shut down the sport. They know employers have the right on the labor laws
- 15:30when you get to the end of an agreement. There's no deal. They can engage in what's called the
- 15:35lockout, shut down the sport. So under that choice, which is not much of a choice, the women
- 15:42decided it was better to take the best deal that was available, which was not an equal pay deal
- 15:50and preserve their legal rights because they were going to continue the equal pay fight
- 15:58in the courts having not been able to achieve it at the collective bargaining table.
- 16:04An elite team of soccer stars kicking off a new fight for equality.
- 16:08The U.S. women's soccer team is taking charge in a major fight off the field,
- 16:13suing for fair pay. This just three. Fest forward a couple years and the team raises the stakes
- 16:18once again. They move on from their complaint with the EEOC to a full on lawsuit.
- 16:24In March 2019, with the green light from the commission, the women's team sues U.S. soccer for
- 16:29institutionalized gender discrimination. The players seek about $67 million in damages
- 16:36and they make it a class action suit, including players from rosters a few years back.
- 16:42That ratcheted things up quite a bit, not just because we edited all the players in a class action
- 16:49and we're going forward in court for a day of reckoning, but also because it allowed us to put
- 16:55together a major public strategy to rally the world around these women in the cause of equal pay.
- 17:03The filing brought on International Women's Day comes three months before the U.S. women
- 17:08tried to defend their World Cup crown. And then in June, the team heads to Paris.
- 17:14Spain works so, so hard, but it is the defending champions who march up. That is it.
- 17:21U.S. advances the French are up.
- 17:24The minutes have been played and the United States are into the 2019 FIFA Women's World Cup
- 17:30final, their third World Cup final in succession.
- 17:35The women went to the World Cup that year in Paris and they won the World Cup.
- 17:40The United States of America are crowned champions of the United States.
- 17:46It becomes the first team in fact to win three women's World Cup titles in the highest scoring
- 17:50final in tournament. The women of the U.S. soccer team are World Champions again, playing in its
- 17:56third straight final. Team USA beat the Netherlands too new in Leo.
- 18:01There's just something about this group that said nothing will ever bring us apart,
- 18:06and I think that that meant that no team will ever be this.
- 18:12Basically, the entire stadium spent that game that was globally televised,
- 18:19chanting equal pay, equal pay, equal pay.
- 18:31It became a global issue. All the teams around the world supported the women.
- 18:38Many sponsors, prominent sponsors of U.S. soccer decided that this was an issue that
- 18:45appealed to their consumers that they wanted to get behind this cause of equal pay.
- 18:51And that compelling story was told. The women spent lots of time appearing on television shows.
- 18:58This was part of that coordinated public strategy to get fans to rally around the player's fight.
- 19:04For comment. Team co-captain Megan Rapinoe and Kristen Press, join us this morning.
- 19:09Ladies, good morning. Thank you for being here.
- 19:11Congratulations.
- 19:12We are so excited to have the rest of the grand prize team,
- 19:16fresh off their historic four World Cup win. Say it again. How many times?
- 19:21Four. That's what I'm talking about.
- 19:22And a celebrated two. Please welcome co-captains of the team,
- 19:25Alex Morgan and Megan Rapinoe.
- 19:29What I think was so appealing about this fight was if these women
- 19:33who were clearly the best in the world and who clearly outperformed the men's team,
- 19:40if they couldn't get equal pay, then who is going to get equal pay, right?
- 19:45So it really sort of highlighted that whole struggle.
- 19:48It's very frustrating for us on the team, you know, for women everywhere.
- 19:53I'm sure to be feeling like they aren't getting paid what they should be.
- 19:58After that big win in France, the women are given a hero's welcome in New York City.
- 20:10The streets of Laura Manhattan are filled with fans and on a stage the team's assembled.
- 20:15Build a blasio, the mayor at the time, he gives the women the keys to the city.
- 20:20Later on in the ceremony, we will honor each player and each coach
- 20:26with the highest honor New York City gives the key to the city and every one of them has earned it.
- 20:32Then Carlos Cordero, the president of US Soccer, gets up to speak.
- 20:36But before he even starts, the crowd erupts in a chant.
- 20:46Cordero acknowledges the team's victory.
- 20:48He talks about the investment US Soccer is making in the game for young girls and for women.
- 20:53And then he talks about the proverbial elephant in the room.
- 20:57In recent months, you have raised your voices for equality.
- 21:01Today on behalf of all of us at US Soccer, I want to say,
- 21:05we hear you, we believe in you, and we're committed to doing right by you.
- 21:13One, the crowd was 100% aware of this issue in support of, but two,
- 21:18Megan Rapino, who was one of the leaders of the women on this, spoke and very diplomatically,
- 21:27but very forcefully, made it clear that from the women's perspective,
- 21:33the US federation needed to put up a shut up.
- 21:38I'm going to stick my neck out there a little bit.
- 21:41I'm going to endorse Carlos.
- 21:43I think he's with us. I think he's on the right side of things.
- 21:45I think he's going to make things right.
- 21:48You could talk about supporting the women and the women's game and that's great.
- 21:53We need equal pay.
- 21:54We look forward to holding those feet to the fire.
- 21:57And so that issue was joined right on that public stage, all of these women,
- 22:05whether it was Pino or Alex Morgan or Kristen Press, so many of these women,
- 22:12they had no hesitance to speak truth to the power.
- 22:15That's what they were entitled to, what all women were entitled to.
- 22:20After the break, the fight for equal pay gets ugly.
- 22:24We'll be right back.
- 22:30The US Women's National Soccer team comes home from the 2019 World Cup Victorious.
- 22:35With another trophy in hand, the players have the support of their fans and sponsors.
- 22:41And there's a sense that the US Soccer Federation might be willing to consider the women's position.
- 22:46We will pay. We will pay.
- 22:49But by the beginning of the next year, 2020, this cordial public dialogue between the players
- 22:55and the Federation takes a turn. And it happens in a court filing.
- 22:59This is a really fascinating, remarkable story here. New court documents reveal why US Soccer says
- 23:04women should not get paid as much as men.
- 23:07In an apparent attempt to dispute any gender discrimination, US Soccer's legal team made a
- 23:12series of claims about supposed differences between the men's and women's teams.
- 23:17It's had the men's team players had more responsibility, and that the men's team required a higher
- 23:23level of skill than the women's team. It even went as far as saying their claim wasn't a sexist
- 23:28stereotype, but rather quote, indisputable science, distinguishing physical ability between the
- 23:34men and the women. Well, needless to say, the world reacted.
- 23:41You're asking me a question about a federation in a 2,600 page legal filing saying that biological
- 23:48science is the reason why men should make more money than the women. You've got to be kidding me.
- 23:53Sponsors reacted, threatened to kill their sponsorships with them. People around the world
- 24:00commentators reacted. There was this gigantic public outcry that you are telling these women,
- 24:07they're not good enough for equal pay, the best women in the world.
- 24:13Another shake up at the top of US Soccer, any surprise that this announcement was made?
- 24:19No, none whatsoever, Zubin, especially when you've got Volkswagen, Coke, and other sponsorships
- 24:25coming out immediately going right after US Soccer in the federation in Carlos Codero.
- 24:30Carlos Codero, the guy who stood up and celebrated the women's team after the World Cup victory,
- 24:35he's in charge at this point. He'd have to take the fall.
- 24:38The president of the US Soccer federation has stepped down from his position.
- 24:42He claimed he didn't know what was going to be in the papers, but that was sort of beside the point.
- 24:48This wasn't made up in their papers. This came from their testimony.
- 24:53I can't believe US Soccer actually put these on papers.
- 24:57That's not made up in the papers.
- 24:59We used it affirmatively to try to show this was their discriminatory intent.
- 25:07They used it offensively to argue, well, it's not discrimination because the games are so different,
- 25:13because women are so different from men, the games are therefore different,
- 25:18so you can't compare them. That was their argument.
- 25:21US Soccer fires their outside counsel,
- 25:24hires different lawyers, and installs a new face at the top of the federation,
- 25:29Cindy Parlo Cone, who had been vice president.
- 25:32She's the first woman to be president in the organization's history,
- 25:35and she's a celebrated former member of the US women's national team,
- 25:39and she quickly disavows the arguments in that filing.
- 25:42So with new leadership at US Soccer, the women's team gets ready for their trial set for May.
- 25:48Now the point of a trial is to look at evidence and listen to testimony to figure out what's true.
- 25:54But presenting evidence in testimony is time consuming and expensive,
- 25:58so each party has the option to file for something called summary judgment.
- 26:02This is where one party says this evidence is so conclusive that even if you think about it
- 26:07from the opposing side's point of view, our argument is in fact clearly what happened,
- 26:12so there's no need for a trial.
- 26:14The women's team did so, arguing that the pay differences between the men and the women
- 26:19had to be a result of nothing other than gender discrimination.
- 26:22Meanwhile, US Soccer did as well, and they argued that not only was there no gender discrimination,
- 26:27the women weren't necessarily paid less.
- 26:30This was the summary judgment filing that got US Soccer in so much trouble with fans and sponsors
- 26:35just a bit earlier. But the ruling on this summary judgment ends up bringing another setback
- 26:40for the women's team. A federal judge has dismissed the unequal pay claim by the members
- 26:46of the US women's national soccer team. What the judge ruled, and of you,
- 26:51incredibly, was that we couldn't show paid discrimination.
- 27:00The judge overseeing the case takes issue with the way the pay discrepancy is presented in the
- 27:04lawsuit. He ruled that in the period covered by the suit, the women actually earned more than
- 27:10the men. Here's how Jeffrey sums up the judge's argument.
- 27:13The women won so many more games than the men, and played in more games than the men,
- 27:21that the total compensation in a year was actually higher than the men.
- 27:29So therefore there was no paid discrimination other than that.
- 27:34So in terms of total compensation, yes, the women's team did earn more than the men during the
- 27:40period of time covered by the lawsuit. But Jeffrey and the women's team had been arguing that the
- 27:45rate of compensation was not the same. Somehow the judge looked and said, no, the man doesn't work,
- 27:51so you don't have paid discrimination. So we were shocked, we were devastated.
- 27:57The team wanted to appeal, but before all of this happened, COVID happened. The world shut down,
- 28:05and we were trying to get our trial, and we kept asking the judge, what are we going to do,
- 28:11because he hadn't ruled on these motions, and the trial was set for May, and the judge wouldn't
- 28:17adjourn the trial. And so we were still thinking we have to prepare, so we were in a mode saying,
- 28:25we have to get ready to try this case, even though we're all remote at the moment,
- 28:30and then this decision comes down that really did shock us.
- 28:36The setbacks on the team's claim of institutional gender discrimination at US soccer.
- 28:42The lawsuit also included a claim against the working conditions, which the two sides end up
- 28:47settling out of court. Then it's time to appeal that summary judgment. And this time around,
- 28:52they have even more support for their argument on the math that the judge had dismissed,
- 28:57and it comes in the form of amicus briefs from academics and equal pay experts,
- 29:02and from the US men's national team.
- 29:06And I think USSF correctly looked at this and said, we're not likely to win this appeal,
- 29:13we're likely to be headed back to trial, the world is against us.
- 29:17You know, maybe we should do something to try to settle this case.
- 29:23Settlement talks go back and forth for a while.
- 29:27This was still during COVID period, so most of the talks were by Zoom or, you know,
- 29:32our phone calls and it was back and forth, the women themselves conducted some of the talks,
- 29:37the lawyers conducted some of these talks, it was sort of a, you know, back and forth.
- 29:42Finally, they came to the posture, yes, we will agree to equal pay.
- 29:52Equal pay on friendlies for appearances and crucially for the World Cup prize money.
- 29:59The US soccer would go back to the table with both the men's and women's teams to negotiate
- 30:04new collective bargaining agreements to reset these terms.
- 30:09It will be equal pay, and we define what that would mean, and basically what it would mean
- 30:16that if the women got the same results in the World Cup as the men got, they would get the
- 30:23same amount of money. When did you get the sense that you and the players were getting close
- 30:28to an agreeable deal with US soccer? Once they said that they would agree to collect the
- 30:35bargaining agreement that would have equal pay for the World Cup, we felt that was the final breakthrough
- 30:42because that had always been this sticking issue. And where in this settlement process did that
- 30:47come through? Late. Very, very late. That really was the last sticking point. It's what we finally
- 30:55got to again about a week before the oral argument was scheduled. So with the loose contours of a deal
- 31:01agreed, now it's time for Jeffrey, the players, US soccer, and all the legal and PR folks to iron out
- 31:07the details. First, there's the damages. They agree on $22 million to be divided up among players
- 31:13in the suit. This was based on a special formula they came up with. And another $2 million that US
- 31:19soccer would put into a fund for player development. All of these negotiations taking place from
- 31:24Jeffrey's home office. I remember doing one of the calls by a granddaughter Olivia who was seven
- 31:31at the time came in and like, in through after the call and like, sound like what's going on?
- 31:37And so I told Olivia, I said, you know, I work for the women's soccer players. They were all this
- 31:43at high Olivia. They all talk guitar. I said, we're fighting because these women who are the best
- 31:49soccer players in the world don't get paid as much as the men. What do you think about that? And
- 31:55Olivia said, I don't even have to think about that for a second. That is wrong. And we said, yes,
- 32:03you are right. And that's why we're having this fight. And of course, all the women were very
- 32:09encouraged. The final step in this landmark deal for equal pay was to go back to the court.
- 32:14Class action settlements have to be approved by a judge. And we didn't actually get this approved
- 32:20until December of 2022. In the meantime, the US women's team and the US men's team reached new
- 32:28collective bargaining agreements with the Federation. So equal pay was achieved. And fittingly,
- 32:33the new collective bargaining agreement was signed after a woman's friendly match in Washington,
- 32:38DC. And there was a fantastic signing ceremony of the collective bargaining agreement that I was
- 32:46able to go witness to attend in Washington at a friendly game that was played.
- 32:53Thanks, Charles. Wow. We got here. We're finally here. What a special day today is. And thank you all
- 33:02for staying. And everyone came out. There was a whole big deal that equal pay was being provided
- 33:07in the collective bargaining agreement. But we didn't. We are here today to sign the contract.
- 33:15And we have finally achieved equal pay for our men's and our women's national teams.
- 33:22Was there anything surprising or anything that you learned in the process of this case, this
- 33:26ongoing case that, I don't know, that just the taught you something, but your line of work?
- 33:32I think what this case taught me more that I never had been as effective in was the combining
- 33:42of the legal fight with the public communications fight. And how important that was to the overall
- 33:53effort. And in fact, I have no doubt that it was the combination of the public fight,
- 34:05all the things the women did to go out there and develop support with sponsors and others,
- 34:10and the legal threat. It needed both to get over this very difficult finish line. And it also taught
- 34:19me something I learned a long time ago is that when you fall down to get right back up,
- 34:25that's where all these women were when we lost that summary judgment. And we were all determined,
- 34:30we're just going to fight harder and we're going to get there. How do you reflect on this deal today?
- 34:37So, I'm obviously proud and humbled to be part of this. You know, I've had the good fortune of my
- 34:44career to work on some cases and matters that I think have made a difference in the lives of people.
- 34:50That's what, you know, what turns me on as a lawyer is I love the advocacy of being a lawyer and
- 34:55being in court and making arguments, but the fact that I've been able to do this for clawing into
- 35:00also made a difference on issues that are important to me. This was one of them. And so I can look
- 35:07back and I feel like what these women were able to achieve was to not just establish equal
- 35:14pay for themselves, but to make an important contribution to the equal pay fight for women in general
- 35:20and the consciousness about that fight. And it seems that consciousness is already spreading.
- 35:26The Canadian Women's National Soccer team recently struck a deal with its federation for equal
- 35:30pay and other national teams are taking action against their working conditions. You know, things are
- 35:36moving the right way on this issue, although no one's naive not to think about their own a lot of
- 35:41struggles. Still there, so to the extent that I was able to play a helpful role in this and be
- 35:46part of this, I am very pleased to be able to play that role or looking back on it.
- 35:57And that's the end of our show, but there's much more for my conversation with Jeffrey Kessler.
- 36:02Just as our interview was wrapping up, I asked him if he had any negotiating advice for the rest
- 36:07of us. And he did. It's advice that I think applies as much to a multi-billion dollar merger
- 36:13as it could to getting your next raise. You're the rest of what he had to say on Breezen Plus on Apple
- 36:18Podcasts. The Closer is a production of Project Breezen in partnership with PRX. Our show is
- 36:30produced by Isabelle Kirby McGowan and Ben Walsh. Marianne Hell Gonzalez is our project manager,
- 36:35Olivia Mead is our researcher and Lucy Woods is head of research. Gold Arthur is our show runner
- 36:41and Bradley Hope and Tom Wright are executive producers. Megan Dean is programming manager
- 36:46and Ryan Ho is design lead. Our marketing consultant is Maggie Taylor and Nora Abdel Latif is our
- 36:52podcast strategist. I'm Amy Keane. Thanks for listening.