Latest / Beyond The Horizon / Brad Edwards And His Affidavit In Support Of Epstein Related Transparency By The DOJ (Part 7)
Transcript
- 0:00Speaker 1: What's up everyone, and welcome to another episode of the
- 0:02Epstein Chronicles. In this episode, we're going to pick up
- 0:06where we left off with Brad Edwards and the CVRA
- 0:09Affid David. With regard to factor three, the degree to
- 0:13which governmental self evaluation and consequent program improvement will be
- 0:18chilled by disclosure, this is a lawsuit to force the
- 0:21compliance by the government with its CVRA obligation. Accordingly, the
- 0:26government's program of providing victims rights will be directly improved
- 0:30if the victims are able to enforce their rights in
- 0:32this lawsuit. With regard to factor four, whether the information
- 0:37sought as factual data or a summary, many of the
- 0:40items that the victims seek are factual summaries. An example
- 0:43of this is found at page eighteen of the first
- 0:46Privilege log with regard to box number three P zero
- 0:51one one seven seven eight to P zero one one
- 0:54seven eight eight. The entry reads file folder entitled six
- 0:57twelve oh nine Victim Notificationation Log containing chart with victim
- 1:02contact information and attorney notes regarding dates and types of contacts.
- 1:07This would include, for example, dates of contacts with Jane
- 1:10Do number one and Jane Do number two, which would
- 1:13be purely factual information. With regard to factor five, whether
- 1:17the party seeking the discovery is an actual or potential
- 1:20defendant in any criminal proceeding, either pending or reasonably likely
- 1:24to follow from the incident. In the question, Jane one
- 1:28and Jane do two are plainly victims of a crime,
- 1:30not criminal defendants. Indeed, as the court is aware, it's
- 1:34the criminal defendant, Jeffrey Epstein who has undertaken several limited
- 1:38intervention efforts to try and block disclosure of information to
- 1:42the victims. With regard to the factor six, whether the
- 1:46police investigation has been completed, the investigation at Epstein was
- 1:50completed years ago, and the government has not produced in
- 1:53its privileged log any information indicating recent investigative activity. With
- 1:59regard to factor whether any inter department disciplinary proceedings have
- 2:04arisen or may arise from the investigation, it appears that
- 2:07OPR investigation has arisen as a direct result of the
- 2:11victim's efforts in the case. However, it does not appear
- 2:15that release of any information to the victims would hamper
- 2:18any disciplinary proceedings, indeed, to the extent that the victims
- 2:22are able to obtain information about the case and find
- 2:25information about misconduct, they can provide the information to the
- 2:29government and other disciplinary entities as appropriate. With regard to
- 2:34factor eight, whether the plaintiff suit is non frivolous and
- 2:37broaden good faith, it should be clear at this juncture
- 2:41of a five year long case that the victims have
- 2:43substantial claim that has brought in good faith. With regard
- 2:47to factor nine, whether the information sought is available through
- 2:50other discovery or from other sources. As recounted throughout this AffA, David,
- 2:55the victims have no other way to obtain the information
- 2:58at issue in this privileged debate, as it involves information
- 3:01internal to the Justice Department. With regard to factor ten,
- 3:06the importance of information sought to the plaintiff's case, the
- 3:10information that the victims are seeking is highly important to
- 3:13their case. Indeed, without adequate proof, the court is indicated
- 3:17that it may have to deny the victim's petition. Throughout
- 3:20this Avid David I have provided numerous examples and explanations
- 3:24of why the victims need the information that they're requesting.
- 3:28The documents to which the government is asserting investigative privilege,
- 3:31for example, bear directly on the government's alleged estoppel defense,
- 3:36which victims need to complete evidentiary record to dispute work
- 3:40product doctrine. A work product claim can be defeated by
- 3:44showing of substantial need and undue hardship to obtain the
- 3:47material in other ways. In this Avid, David, I have
- 3:51tried to articulate the specific and compelling need for all
- 3:54the materials that victims are seeking. I will not repeat
- 3:57all of those assertions here, but simply note that I
- 4:00stand ready to provide any additional information that the court
- 4:03may require to determine the compelling need that the victims
- 4:07have for the materials they have requested, as well as
- 4:10the undue hardship, if not actual impossibility of obtaining the materials.
- 4:14In other ways, any balancing of considerations tips decisively in
- 4:19the victim's favor. As one example, the victims have a
- 4:23compelling need for the materials that OPR collected as part
- 4:26of its investigation. Because Justice Department attorneys are generally required
- 4:32to talk to OPR investigators, OPR was apparently able to
- 4:36investigate the claim of misconduct related to the Epstein case
- 4:39by getting statements from the attorneys involved. These interviews appear
- 4:43to be recorded in materials found at page fourteen of
- 4:47the Supplemental Privilege log D two sixteen one with regard
- 4:51to Supplemental box number three p DASH zero one three
- 4:54nine five six two p DASH zero one three eight
- 4:58four six a total of fourteen pages. Judging from the entry,
- 5:04these notes would be factual statements from Justice Department prosecutors
- 5:08about how the Epstein case was handled and whether any
- 5:11misconduct occurred during the handling of the case. Those are
- 5:15central issues in the case. There's no other way for
- 5:18the victims to obtain information about these subjects because the
- 5:21Justice Department has declined to provide information on the subject.
- 5:27The victims have established a substantial need for the material
- 5:30there are requesting in the previous paragraphs of this Avid
- 5:33David that review requests by request their document Production Request
- 5:37numbers one through twenty five and Supplemental Request number one
- 5:42as Another example of why the victims have established a
- 5:45compelling need for the materials is the fact that the
- 5:48Court has indicated that it will be considering an estoppel
- 5:51argument raised by the government as a defense in the case.
- 5:55The Court has noted that this argument implicates a fact
- 5:58sensitive equitable defense which must be considered in the historical
- 6:02factual context of the entire interface between EPSTEIN, the relevant
- 6:06prosecutorial authorities, and the federal offense victims, including an assessment
- 6:12of the allegation of a deliberate conspiracy between EPSTEIN and
- 6:16federal prosecutors to keep the victims in the dark on
- 6:18the pendency of negotiation between EPSTEIN and federal authorities until
- 6:23after the fact and presentation of the non prosecution agreement.
- 6:28The materials to which the government is asserting work product
- 6:31protection go directly to that interface between the victims, the government,
- 6:35and EPSTEIN. The victims have no other way of showing
- 6:39what that interface is. The government will not be harmed
- 6:42if the materials are provided to the victims grand jury information.
- 6:46The victims legal pleading has explained why the government has
- 6:49not properly asserted any grand jury secrecy to the documents
- 6:53at issue. In addition, many of the government's grand jury
- 6:56privilege assertions appear to broadly cover both grand jury and
- 7:00non grand jury information. Even if the court allows the
- 7:04government to assert some form of grand jury privilege, it
- 7:06should require the government to sever grand jury material from
- 7:10non grand jury material. An illustration of this problem comes
- 7:14from page twelve of the first privilege log with regard
- 7:17to box number two p DASH zero zero eight six
- 7:21one six to p DASH zero zero eight six eighty six.
- 7:25The entry reads file folder entitled FBI Summary Charts containing
- 7:29chart prepared at direction of AUSA, containing victim names, identifying information,
- 7:35summary of activity, and other information relevant to the indictment.
- 7:39This does not appear to be a document that was
- 7:42ever presented to the grand jury or that directly discloses
- 7:45grand jury preceding. Moreover, to the extent that it involves
- 7:49some kind of limited disclosure of grand jury proceedings, that
- 7:53limited disclosure could be redacted, and the other information provided
- 7:56to the victims, it does not appear that any of
- 7:59the all edge grand jury materials that the government is
- 8:02asserting privilege involve ongoing grand jury issues. Moreover, it does
- 8:06not appear that disclosing any of the materials would tip
- 8:10off a potential target to a government investigation. Of course,
- 8:14Jeffrey Epstein and his associates are well aware of the
- 8:17government's investigation into their crimes against young girls for sexual purposes.
- 8:23The government has not explained any harm that would come
- 8:26from releasing the documents to the victims. If the government
- 8:29raises any such harm, I respectfully request an opportunity to
- 8:32provide additional information on that alleged harm privacy rights of
- 8:37other victims. Chaine Do number one and Jaine No. Number
- 8:41two do not seek confidential or identifying information about any
- 8:45other victim. To clarify that fact, on July thirty first,
- 8:49twenty thirteen, I sent a letter to the government stating
- 8:52in part that to avoid any interference with any privacy
- 8:56rights of victims who are not parties to this litigation,
- 8:59Chaine don'tumbs uber one and Jane Do number two are
- 9:02not seeking any identifying information about other victims in any
- 9:07of the documents that Jane Do number one or Jane
- 9:09Do number two have requested from the government that they produce.
- 9:13The government should not produce the names of other victims
- 9:16or other identifying information, eg. Address or a telephone number,
- 9:20but should instead redact that information. I declare, under penalty
- 9:25of perjury pursuant to US Code twenty eight, Section seventeen
- 9:29forty six, that the foregoing is true and correct to
- 9:33the best of my knowledge and belief. Executed this sixteenth
- 9:37day of August twenty thirteen, and this document was signed
- 9:41by Brad Edwards All right, So that finishes up the
- 9:45affid David of Brad Edwards when it comes to the CVRA.
- 9:49And now with this new dump, we have a lot
- 9:51of court records to dive into and the grand jury material,
- 9:54especially because we've never seen that, right, so I want
- 9:58to make sure that we get a handle on that
- 9:59as well. So over the next couple of days, we're
- 10:02going to be diving deep into that grand jury material,
- 10:05and that way everybody gets to see for themselves what
- 10:08we've been saying for all these years that the fix
- 10:10was in and this has been a cover up since
- 10:13the start. All of the information that goes with this
- 10:16episode can be found in the description box.