Latest / Future Engineering Bets / Scrapping EV Batteries - Stop! with Michael Hague-Morgan | Future Engineering Bets
Transcript
- Fred Warner: you've got the battery modules that can be replaced, which is a huge saving if you have a nearly new or very recent EV rather than writing off maybe a 10 or 15 K battery pack, you can do a small repair you can put the vehicle back on the road and it should go on to live a fine life. I think some of the BYDs and Teslas, where they build the cells and the modules directly into the vehicle and they make them very difficult to access. They're physically and mechanically glued to Mike Hague-Morgan: Yep. Fred Warner: the car Mike Hague-Morgan: So there's been a big change for the better, led by China from April this year. They've made a new law, legislation, rule number 73. And that says any battery packs that are designed post April, 2026 have to be designed so that you can repair them at a cell or module level. So that is a huge step forward and well done to the Chinese for leading that. Fred Warner: But the bit for people really is The gamble that if a car has a big repair bill, if it's worth much less than £10,000, it's almost an incident write-off for as many people. And that's Mike Hague-Morgan: Correct. Fred Warner: quite a big consideration as they plan a used purchase, which hasn't been considered in any of the legislation currently. Mike Hague-Morgan: what's become absolutely clear got to make sure that you're not prematurely recycling. There's an awful lot of batteries today that go away for recycling for various reasons. but still the vast majority of cells or modules have a really good life left in them. In fact, what we found is almost all of the modules are able to go back into a vehicle. And if you put them back into vehicle, that's the best use of them. So that's the best economic and environmental benefit. Fred Warner: hello everybody and welcome to another episode of Future Engineering Bets where we look at capital allocation and the future of advanced engineering, particularly in the automotive sector. Today I'm very excited to be joined by Michael Hauge-Morgan of the Auto Craft Solutions Group. Michael, welcome to Future Engineering Bets. Mike Hague-Morgan: Thank you, Fred. It's been good to catch up with you. Fred Warner: you're very involved in, as we're going to get into today, the recycling, repair, maintenance of internal combustion engines and, importantly for today's discussion, now EVs and their battery packs as well. And I know you also are a component manufacturer yourself in the supply chain for the OEMs. Do you want to give everyone a quick overview of your group and what you do? Mike Hague-Morgan: Yeah, thank you. So Autograph was established in 1980 as an engine remanufacturer and that today is still our main business where we're the biggest independent engine manufacturer in Europe. But obviously engines, they're not going to be around forever ever in the volumes that we've seen certainly. And we needed to change the business and be relevant. Naturally EV batteries are a replacement power source propulsion mechanism. instead of combustion engines. So I think it was really natural that we tried our hand at see if we could pivot the business, not all of it, but at least half of it into fixing EV batteries in the same way. So it's been a natural transition in many ways, but completely different in others with different skills that the team have had to learn, etc. But we're over a decade into it now. So it's been really good and I'm really excited about the future. Fred Warner: I think we've got a few topics to cover over mostly in the EV space, but we'll also cover off what's happening in the ice and the hybrid space later on and what you're seeing in the markets as being relevant for people that are listening. So number one topic, Mike, the recycling myth versus the actual reality of what's going on. you hear a lot of people in circles that are less informed, shall we say, they'll talk Mike Hague-Morgan: Mm-hmm. Fred Warner: about how EVs will go on forever and then when they're done the battery packs will then go and serve other purposes in life and they all just need plugging in together. Do you want to give people a quick overview of what you know in that space? Mike Hague-Morgan: Yeah, the world is not so standardised as that. So where do start? Well, recycling in general, we're very supportive of. We work with recycling partners. because it's so important that when batteries are truly end of life, that they are recycled in the right way. And we're even starting to get them recycled in a way that we can ensure that the critical minerals, the elements of that battery can then be reused in batteries in the future. That's been a big change in the last 12 months. We've actually got to a point whereby when we're recycling with people, we're actually able to be doing that so that they can actually get some use out of it instead of just blackmast in the road. Okay, so we will see a lot more of that. But what's become absolutely clear in our journey in recent years is that you've got to make sure that you're not prematurely recycling. There's an awful lot of batteries today that go away for recycling for various reasons. but still the vast majority of cells or modules have a really good life left in them. In fact, what we found is almost all of the modules are able to go back into a vehicle. And if you put them back into vehicle, that's the best use of them. You're using them in the way that they were intended. So that's the best economic and environmental benefit. It does also mean that we found that... There's a lot of cells, modules that people are thinking of a second life, but in our experience, there's not actually enough of them in a standardised format, still with a good enough state of health remaining before they hit what we call the knee point to actually make it worth doing second life, battery storage, etc. That's our experience. I know that there'll be some people that disagree with that. Fred Warner: Yeah, it's really interesting insight there, Mike, because not only are we going to delve into, the massive CO2 reduction that you can achieve by not recycling a battery pack early, by replacing one or two modules, because it's one of the things that people don't know is that they often melt the battery packs down to get the raw minerals out. So there's a lot of burn-off. There's a lot of... destruction of the other components in the battery pack in Mike Hague-Morgan: Mm-hmm. Fred Warner: order to get the valuable raw materials out and mostly that's done to retrieve those raw materials. And then the second life piece is an interesting comment that isn't spoken about very much because people are leaning on the fact that there's second lives and you're saying in your experience and granted you're happy to put it that way, you're not thinking that's going to be a viable option for most battery cells when they've reached end of life. Mike Hague-Morgan: Yeah, so we invested in making our own battery storage systems. I've got one at my home here. A couple of the other people within work, we've got them because we got as far as all of the creating the beta versions of them, testing them ourselves and we were gonna launch. We've not launched because actually we don't see a huge market for that anymore. multiple reasons. The price of LFP has really fallen. You can buy LFP so cheap now from China, all in the same format that you want, in the quantity you want. You're not having to go around scrap yards, breakers yards, trying to harvest all of the same module or a similar state of health. And it means that the whole business model, I don't think is there, but probably the best way to... look at the numbers behind it is we've got a white paper that we've published last year. We're only replacing 1.2 modules in a battery pack and everything else goes back into vehicle. And the 1.2 modules that we've got have generally got state of health already less than 60%. So they've reached that knee point where you just get a fast decline. Now, if you're gonna put all the time and effort and money putting them into a battery storage system for second life, you don't wanna be replacing them in 12 or 18 months or even less than that. So when we're making statements about Second Life and why we are not continuing with investing in that and launching battery systems ourselves with used modules, it's because it's based on a data set of over 10,000 batteries that we've repaired and put back into vehicle. And what we find Fred Warner: Yeah, it's. Mike Hague-Morgan: is only 1.2 modules actually need replacing on average on a battery pack. The rest are still at least 80, usually 90 % plus state of health. Fred Warner: And just for the viewers benefit, typical battery module number is in an EV currently. Mike Hague-Morgan: 8 to 36 modules in an EV battery. Fred Warner: Yeah. So fantastic. So there's a few issues that I want to bring up here and ask you about with your, like you say, 10,000 packs later experience. So very, very valid experience if ever there was any. So you've got the battery modules that can be replaced, which is a huge saving if you have a nearly new or very recent EV rather than writing off maybe a 10 or 15 K battery pack, you can do a I suppose a small repair that is a fraction of that in proportionate terms, you can put the vehicle back on the road and it should go on to live a fine life. You've also got the companies and I think some of the BYDs and Teslas, maybe some others where they build the cells and the modules directly into the vehicle and they make them very difficult to access. They're sort of physically and mechanically glued to Mike Hague-Morgan: Yep. Fred Warner: the car if you want for a simpler word. Mike Hague-Morgan: Yep. Fred Warner: How does how does what you do fit around that that do they just form a car that you can't? Mike Hague-Morgan: So there's been a big change for the better, led by China from April this year. They've made a new law, legislation, rule number 73. And that says any battery packs that are designed post April, 2026 have to be designed so that you can repair them at a cell or module level. So what does that mean in practice? That means in practice. We aren't going to have batteries in the future, but we have some of them today, whereby you cannot get the lid off and replace a cell module. So that is a huge step forward and well done to the Chinese for leading that. Fred Warner: Yeah, really good news and I remember seeing that and there's some other implications on where that battery technology can be used in second life that's quite limiting as well as I remember in that whole framework. for the vehicles that are out there, I suppose a lot of people don't realise that the cars they're currently buying, the battery packs can't be repaired or recycled very easily. Mike Hague-Morgan: Some. So some batteries and we are navigating that. So the vast majority you can repair. So batteries in general are very reliable and only small percentages will fail. That does increase with more age and mileage as you would expect, just like a battery in your mobile phone. The older it gets, the more charge cycles you put through it, the more that it will increase the failure rate, okay? But the really good news about it is that the vast majority of them on the road today is kind of a sweet spot where modules can be replaced. You've then got a period of cars at the moment, which there are some which are heavily glued, foamed. resin glue some of the really bad ones and you're right, you can't remove those. So if you get a battery that fails, one of those batteries that fails in your car, you've got a real problem if it's out of warranty. Okay, you've got to go and source another battery somehow or the car is scrap. But the China law 73 means that that should be for a finite period of time. So once batteries have gone through a design cycle, the next design cycle will have batteries that are repairable. So hopefully it's limited to a few makes, brands, models today, and that will end going forward. Fred Warner: news for everybody and recycling. I think one of the challenges with recycling is that it is a business of economics more than it is a business Mike Hague-Morgan: Hmm. Fred Warner: of sustainability and I think often it can be easily overlooked when people assume that all raw materials that can be reused will be taken back out of a unit of any kind, not limited to automotive products in any way, but it's a market of economics. If it's not economically viable, like you say, if the price of a raw material or a mineral drops significantly, then that pushes more material into being disposed of permanently and therefore not being recycled. it's Mike Hague-Morgan: Yeah. Fred Warner: always a bit of a shame one. In terms of this out of warranty piece that you've just touched on there, that is a lot of people's main fear, it? Outside of the corporate fleets, which are fairly straightforward in terms of their warranty, the depreciation has been very heavy on EVs to date. You'd argue it's stabilised in the last six to 12 months. particularly probably with the geopolitical situation in the Iran war. But when you've got an eight-year-old EV, even with the ability to diagnose it, you could still end up with a £3,000 plus bill to repair it, couldn't you, in reality? Mike Hague-Morgan: So there's a genuine concern that people have when buying a used EV, that once their initial battery warranty has expired, they're exposed to a significant cost and risk. The first time I would say is it's not every model that you're really exposed on because most of them are repairable and you are. talking thousands of pounds, not tens of thousands of pounds to get that fixed is where we're going to get to. I say where we're going to get to because there aren't that many garages today that are able to take a vehicle that needs a battery repair, diagnose exactly what's needed and make the repair to the battery. I would encourage anybody buying a used EV to try and find a warranty to cover it Fred Warner: So an average ICE is 14 years. Despite the advances in manufacturing assembly, the raw materials and supply chain, there's a good chance ICE will have a shorter average life. In some cases. But I guess we get to see that in the overall reliability. But the bit for people really is the gamble. The gamble that if a car has a big repair bill, if it's worth much less than £10,000, it's almost an incident write-off for as many people. And that's Mike Hague-Morgan: Correct. Fred Warner: quite a big consideration as they plan a used purchase, which hasn't been considered in any of the legislation currently. It's to how that works going forwards. Mike Hague-Morgan: Yeah, it's a risk that I feel uncomfortable in people having. I don't think there's a need over time to have that. I want people to drive EVs. I want people to be able to have the choice. And I don't want people to have to make a choice that they are then exposed to an unacceptable level of risk. So I said to the team at Autocraft, what we clearly need to do is to be able to offer the same cost and lead time repair on batteries as on engines. So that's their target, is to get to parity. And I think in the next few years, we will get to parity. What we've then got to do is obviously Autocraft is predominantly UK and Arnhem and the Netherlands at the moment. We need to scale that so that we can let more and more people benefit from that once we've achieved it. But I'm pretty confident that for the vast majority of battery failures out of warranty, that by early 2030, 2032, something like that, I think we will be at parity. Fred Warner: Quick question for you on that, because it's a really interesting area. Let's say it's an out of warranty vehicle, so the manufacturer is no longer supporting that vehicle. They come to the garage using potentially even equipment that you've supplied to help them diagnose it. They send it to you for repair. Does that get a full warranty from you for the rest of the pack then? Because you've replaced one module, but there's a whole rest of the pack there. Who provides the warranty? to make it worthwhile taking that cost. Mike Hague-Morgan: Yeah, so when we start in the aftermarket, we are going to offer a warranty for the whole pack. We won't completely be able to cover every single latent defect that was in there from day one. And there'll be a liability for the manufacturer that they will always keep if there are proven to be inbuilt significant issues. But our testing stress tests. So our Optevizer ProScan in particular will stress test a pack and our warranty failures from the 10,000 batteries that we've already had is extremely low. It's fractions of 1%. But we have testing which stress tests the vast majority of the rest of the market. if not all of the rest of the markets will read the BMS and take that value and work their algorithms against it. That isn't stress testing the cells and the modules. So there's a fundamental difference between autocrats testing and our competitors testing where we stand today. Fred Warner: When people are using the BMS, which is insufficient compared to what your knowledge base shows you in terms of the real life, does that mean that you think other people, when they're getting batteries returned, there's still an increased chance of failure because the rest of the battery was never considered in the repair and what the state of the battery was at a cell level? Mike Hague-Morgan: Yeah, I think I've never experienced before a new market like what we're getting into with batteries. I've always been in a relatively mature market where you've got known competitors and you've all got known costs and quality levels that you're fighting against. What I've actually found in EV batteries is our testing is clearly way better than everybody else's. but we would actually like the market in general to be testing better because people are getting a bad experience. We do find that there's OEMs and large garage groups that still believe you can't test. accurately repair successfully to a high quality standard an EV battery and that's not correct. Our data shows it. The big automotive award, the auto mechanic award that we've won, that's a tough panel of judges to convince. That proves that we can do it but... Too many people today are still experiencing testing, which is not what we call dynamic testing. It is reading the BMS when there hasn't been a reasonably applied controlled load on that battery. And then because they diagnose it incorrectly, there are still weak cells remaining and those weak cells fail weeks, days, few months after the battery repair. And we've got to get away from that as an industry. I need, we need consumers to be more confident. Fred Warner: We do it really, really affects everybody. It's a tricky one because I know you've put a lot of time and effort into the competence and capability that you have huge amounts of IP and know-how involved. But the question is, if you don't share it, then everybody else will carry on potentially doing a pretty bad job. Just on that note, as you're looking at the repair, you talked about latent defects in manufacturing. I think that's an interesting point because we know that the OEM is really our vehicle designer and assemblers. not necessarily chemists, so this whole battery piece has not necessarily been thought through from beginning to end. But when you say latent defects, for the layperson, there was an issue when the battery pack was first put together and that cell was always likely going to be the weak one that went. Do want to just talk a bit about what you know there and how it could be improved? Mike Hague-Morgan: Yeah, so you've got a mixture really. Let's try and categorise it to two separate things. You've got an underlying difficulty of defects when the actual battery material is made. So when you've got that separator and you've got your anode and cathode coating processes, there's around about a 20 % defect rate that they discover at the end of the line, but they don't catch everything. Okay, and that's where there's small defects impurities that you'll only find when there's a trace in the chemical change on that cell in that battery. And our testing will pick that up once it's been through a certain number of cycles. So the more cycles it goes in the car, the stronger we can detect that, And that's very unique to Autocraft is my understanding. You've then got... manufacturing assembly issues whereby they are welding tabs, they are folding the sheets, so they are putting them into the cans, so into those circular cells or folding them into a pouch. That process itself has caused problems and it was always going to cause problems because frankly no one's done it at the kind of scale automotive needs before. industry's got a lot better at that. So you've seen some recalls on various cars and I'm not going to speculate on who's been involved, but there are a lot of brands and battery manufacturers that have had recalls. It's generally around that piece of making that cell, making that module where they got much better in recent years. But even if that's fixed, you've still got a level of... minute defect which propagates over time and it's those cells which then will at some point prematurely age and die before the rest of the battery and that's why we've got typically 1.2 modules is all we need to replace in a battery that's failed. Fred Warner: Let's bring in hybrid vehicles as well. I've actually got a Mike Hague-Morgan: Mmm. Fred Warner: 10 year old hybrid in one of our cars and that's got that battery package degrading. And obviously I'm at a point where I don't technically know whether or not it's a single cell if the whole pack's degraded or if one or two cells are getting now to a quite critical point, which they could be. And all of a sudden the car could be really complaining and kicking off. So. Hybrid vehicle owners will be affected as well. So as well as we're supporting neutral technology decisions to say you can carry on with ice and have hybrids, it reduces the amount of raw materials required, special minerals. There's still the ongoing issue for the long term, isn't there, that you have with an EV. Mike Hague-Morgan: Yeah, so we fix batteries which are bev or hybrid. So that 10,000 is a mix to be fair. Doesn't matter to us. The economics are different because it's much more cost effective to repair a bev, which has got hundreds and hundreds of cells in it compared with a hybrid smaller battery pack, which might only have 30, 40 cells, half a dozen modules. So that percentage difference in the economics is clear to see, but the technology of them failing and needing to be repaired is the same. Fred Warner: So your new optevizer product, where Mike Hague-Morgan: That's all right. optevizer Fred Warner: which I know you're very Mike Hague-Morgan: Yeah. Fred Warner: excited about. You've launched it and this is a product that can be purchased by repair centers, OEMs, and they can use it to diagnose cars right there in their unit. Tell us a bit about it and how you've come Mike Hague-Morgan: Yeah. Thank you. Fred Warner: to make that. Mike Hague-Morgan: Well, we've come to make the decision because our testing is very special. We have realised that there is a risk in the market that if people can't more accurately diagnose and repair the batteries to a really good quality standard, that it actually puts a threat on our main business of doing the repair because I've said it damages the reputation of repair and remanufacture of batteries in general. So we've decided we are going to change our business model to be able to offer these two garages so that they can do their repairs, but with the confidence of a world leading testing and repair strategy behind it. It's the first time we've done anything like this. It's really exciting. And I'm hoping that over the next few years, we'll be able to have partners all around Europe, if not the world, using our testing to make a big difference. Fred Warner: It's fantastic story. I'm really pleased that you've developed it, Mike, and to think that you could even be supplying these to your competitors in the future, to be diagnosing batteries, to compete with your repair center business, like for like. So it's a great step. Mike Hague-Morgan: Yeah, this is a multi-billion market. So there's enough space for many, many Autocrafts and other businesses doing testing and repair. So being able to grow faster by allowing people to use our testing will just help everyone. Fred Warner: are you able to talk about price range of your Optivizer? Mike Hague-Morgan: So at the moment, the Optevizer that we've got works if you've got big volume, If you've got the volume going through as we do at our repair centers in the UK and Netherlands, then it really does pay back in a nice time. The issue is a lot of garages are only just seeing the EVs coming through at the moment. So what we need to do is try and help garages pull them regionally together, pull the volume will be one thing to make it more affordable. So a bit of a hub and spoke type of business model. or a soft start package to people so they can start to use our testing and we can start to build the market as the volumes come on. Fred Warner: You know, if people have access to things like Optevizer in the future, imagine a car center where they take in an EV as a trade-in. If they were to put it on the Optevizer, they then might have knowledge that makes them compliant in mis-selling. I suppose to an extent, and this is the difficulty buying a second-hand car because you'd want one that's probably had an Optevizer readout. Mike Hague-Morgan: Mm-hmm. Fred Warner: on it to say this is the true state of this car and with that information the car might be worth a fraction of its current retail value or it would be fine. How do people bridge that gap? Mike Hague-Morgan: We're, think because Optevizer is a very high performance test. It's not economic to do it on every car at the moment. We have some ideas of how we can do that differently in the future, but we have specifically stayed away from the market where they are already got a lot of players there that are able to read the BMS and give a battery state of health report. We're gonna let them carry on with that for the time being. And we're just gonna concentrate on our repairability rather than get dragged into that resale market. It's not something that we will do unless we think we can really bring some real value at a much lower cost than where we're currently at. Fred Warner: Fantastic. So let's talk about Revive and container workshops that you can take around. one of the areas I'm interested in is the warranty liabilities for the OEMs and how this sort of feeds in. Because as you said, you've not got massive failure rates of packs, but when they do fail, writing off the entire pack is significant. How does that work from a, like you say, getting everybody to send cars to you is an expensive business for them. So what's the plan with Revive and is it scalable? Mike Hague-Morgan: Thank you. So we think it is scalable. So we set up Revive Workshop in the Netherlands at Arnhem and that is currently covering all of Europe. So there's some big costs involved with that with transport as you'd expect and it's still profitable and therefore proves it is scalable. The exciting thing is if we were to have multiple workshops like that around Europe, the transport costs would fall and we'd become even more competitive. Okay? So I'm really confident that that business model will work and that it's just a matter of getting the volume together to allow us to do it. But you've also got to be aware that OEMs themselves have set up dealers to do this. So there are OEM tools and OEM dealers set up also doing battery repairs. We are an option for them to outsource everything to us, but they don't have to. Some of our customers, we are just treated like another dealer. So we've got our own way of doing it and our own way of testing, but that doesn't stop them actually doing the repair at one of their own dealer groups, for example. So I think there's a lot more spread and coverage of repairs in the market than most people realize today. Fred Warner: And for the listener on this, the Revive is a mobile workshop that you can take to other places. Mike Hague-Morgan: Yeah, so what we did is we set up, I gave the team a challenge. I said, I want to demonstrate not that just batteries are repairable, remanufacturable to a high standard. I want to demonstrate that the batteries are, that you can do them anywhere. Okay, so really push the boundaries of the technology and the solutions that my team work. So I said, let's see if we can repair them in a supermarket car. And that was the challenge that we gave them. And we got APC, Advanced Propulsion Centre funding here in the UK to part fund that R &D. And we came up with the concept of using an expandable workshop like you have at the Formula One. You see that the Formula One hospitality. But instead of serving drinks and canapes, it actually repairs batteries. So that's what we did. It's proved our technology. That will enable us to set it very quickly in Arnhem. Now we're established and it's a really good profitable place with a fantastic team that we're able to consolidate for. We're putting some fixed workstations. So we're going to double the capacity by putting fixed workstations there because we know we're there for the long term. And then the mobile unit is going to move to one of the other locations. Sweden's probably likely to be the next, but we're also looking at other parts of Eastern Germany, Spain, Italy. So we need to get more coverage so that for the revived workshops, the cost of repair comes down by reducing that transport. Fred Warner: Yeah, a very interesting area to make it fundamentally viable for people to own older vehicles in particular, because the warranty will get resolved one way or another for Mike Hague-Morgan: Yes. Fred Warner: an end user. The OEM may suffer, but the end user really becomes very interested in this out of warranty area and what the options will be in the future. So to see potential mobile workshops and other methods coming together will be really interesting. Now, as we move towards the latter part of this podcast, Mike, talk about where you're seeing the ICE and the EV piece. We talked about it briefly before. Obviously, Mike Hague-Morgan: Mm. Fred Warner: we are in the middle of a ZEV mandate review in the UK Mike Hague-Morgan: Mm-hmm. Fred Warner: currently to end shortly. And I guess we have to wait for the results of that to see if the legislation will shift at all. But we're off track with government legislation whilst the EU is moving. and has moved some legislation already and is a bit out of sync. And interestingly, they've also published yesterday or the day before a potential limit on Chinese vehicle imports, which will potentially limit EV growth as well. What are you seeing in the market? You talk about storms and it's been a tough year. Mike Hague-Morgan: Yeah, yeah, I think we're starting to see things calm a little. I think the review, the mandate review has really helped with that. I suspect that we're going to see a softening. That's what people are kind of saying in the industry that that's the expectation, because achieving this 80 % level at the trajectory that they want is just not happening at the moment. One of your earlier podcasts that talk about that split between the amount of people who are private users against the number of people that are company car. Well, you're not going to get anywhere further unless they can persuade private users to buy more cars. And that seems to be the real struggle. So I think we'll see engines continue for a lot longer than people thought. Not in a pure ICE format, because I don't think that's needed. think we'll see more hybrids. Personally, I'd like to see hybrids whereby you have to plug them in and you've got a much better range on them because most people can then do the majority of their journeys on the electric power knowing that they've got the backup of the engine if they need to without the charge anxiety. And I think there's a sweet spot there which I'm hoping that the ZEV mandate will recognise and they'll change it accordingly. But for a business like us, what does that mean? Well, it means we're not going to have a huge outsourcing of engines to us in the short term because they're not going to close engine plants at the scale that they were leaving us to do the residual volume. And that's the main part of our engine business for the OEMs. But they are going to continue. And I think they're going to continue with both an engine and a battery in them. So for us, it's in a way good news. We're going to be able to service that market in whichever direction and it'll be a stabler market. What was not nice was, and it's been bad for a lot of the supply chain, is when they've invested in EV and EV production lines that EVs haven't sold, they've sunk all that cash. They've got that EV capacity. A lot of them have still got now ice capacity that they were expecting to close. So they're making parts for ice on production lines that aren't full. So for others in the industry, I think it will be more difficult for them to manage. And I think government needs to recognise that the supply chain in particular will have a challenge on doing both simultaneously in a profitable way. Fred Warner: Thank you Mark, it's very interesting. It feels like, particularly in Europe, they've suddenly become quite aware of the risk of actually deindustrialising Europe Mike Hague-Morgan: Yes. Fred Warner: on the path they're on and the consequential potential vast loss of jobs and livelihoods across Europe if we don't look at how we approach things, not just from sustainability but from people's livelihoods and Mike Hague-Morgan: Yes. Fred Warner: economics as well. So Europe is moving in a direction that feels like there's a recognition of it. Making everybody in the UK feel that equally there's a recognition that people can't be forced to buy something they're afraid to buy. And one of the points that I find very interesting, it comes up a lot, particularly in the charging network businesses, particularly. They say that there haven't been any fines for automotive companies. So therefore they've got nothing to moan about really because these, you know, 12 K per car or whatever it would be if they went over the targets. Whereas the reality is they've had some of the biggest capital write downs in history. Honda made their Mike Hague-Morgan: Mm. Fred Warner: first ever loss last year with their capital write downs and they're losing money on all of the EVs. They're heavily discounting to shift to try and hit targets. Mike Hague-Morgan: Yeah, Fred Warner: So the actual net loss to the industry is huge. Mike Hague-Morgan: it's the cost of compliance and the SMMT has been very clear on that. You would never want to pay a fine. You're always better discounting the car. The problem is you're discounting the car to a level that means that they're not making money. and that then puts whole pressure on the car manufacturers right through the supply chain. At the moment it just doesn't seem to be sustainable and that's where this review needs to recognise that they need to find a solution which does decarbonise but decarbonises at a rate that both the government, the consumer and industry can afford. Fred Warner: Well, I think on that note, Mike, that would be a great place to end this podcast and great statement. Where can people find more about Autocraft Solutions? Mike Hague-Morgan: Thank you, Fred. Yeah, so it's autocraftsg.com. There's a lot of videos on there that are particularly useful for people, a lot of information, and you can also follow us on LinkedIn. We put all the updates on there as well. So yeah, engage with us. And over the next few months, hopefully you'll see us actually planning to launch into the aftermarket and start fixing some of these cars so that people don't end up having to write a car off that's only just come out a warranty. Fred Warner: Absolutely, I think that's also the information people will need in the future is that there are options out there and they have to look where to find them. So Mike, thank you so much for joining me on this episode. It's been really great. And to those of you out there, please do like and share, send it to someone you know and follow for future episodes. Future Engineering Bets is about advanced engineering and capital allocation and I'll see you in the future.