Latest / Politics with Paul / Politics with Paul #44: The National Debt—And a Balanced Budget Amendment to the US Constitution?
Transcript
- 0:00Welcome back to the politics with Paul podcast, your home for nonpartisan and nonideological
- 0:05information and analysis.
- 0:07I'm your host, Paul Rader.
- 0:09Today, we're talking about everybody's favorite policy issue, the national debt.
- 0:15Hooray for fiscal irresponsibility.
- 0:17What is the history of the national debt?
- 0:19What makes up our national debt?
- 0:21How is it viewed as a campaign issue?
- 0:23Why is it so difficult to cut spending?
- 0:25And is a balanced budget amendment to The US constitution on the horizon?
- 0:31All this and more is on tap for today's episode.
- 0:33But the national debt crossed $36,000,000,000,000 at the end of twenty twenty
- 0:40four.
- 0:41Yes.
- 0:41With a t, not a b or an m, $36,000,000,000,000.
- 0:46Every time we get around to crafting the budget for the US government, the ballooning national
- 0:51debt becomes one of the most pertinent center stage issues in politics.
- 0:56Despite this, the debt has been climbing for decades and decades, and it has now reached
- 1:01astronomical poor proportions.
- 1:05Now as with any other policy issue, the national debt becomes a highly charged debate.
- 1:10Democrats blame Republicans.
- 1:12Republicans blame Democrats and so on.
- 1:15But as is always the case with this podcast, here we are not concerned with how to dole out
- 1:20blame for this issue.
- 1:22That's not constructive.
- 1:24That's not informative, and politicians are very adept at not taking responsibility for
- 1:29anything anyway.
- 1:30Admittedly, I'm not a policy wonk when it comes to finance.
- 1:34We won't get bogged down too much in the financial jargon.
- 1:38But otherwise, we're diving into the nuts and bolts of the national debt.
- 1:42Yay.
- 1:43Let's go.
- 1:44of all, let's make a clear distinction between what a deficit is and what the debt is.
- 1:50They're very related.
- 1:51They get used interchangeably, but they're not quite the same thing.
- 1:55The budget is the money being spent, also called outlays, over the amount of money
- 2:01collected, also called revenue, over the course of a fiscal year, and that doesn't really
- 2:07follow the calendar year.
- 2:08That's more like in the middle of the year.
- 2:10But the deficit and the surplus refer to single year budgets.
- 2:15Deficit means money spent is higher than money collected that year, and a surplus means money
- 2:23collected is higher than money spent in that year.
- 2:27And we have had surpluses in the past.
- 2:29I know it's hard to believe with how huge the deficit has become, but we did we have had a
- 2:35surplus before, actually several times, most recently in fiscal year two thousand one, and
- 2:40that was part of a four year stretch 1998 to 2001 fiscal year ninety eight to zero one where
- 2:49we had a surplus.
- 2:51Before those years, the last time we had a surplus though was 1969.
- 2:56Since fiscal year nineteen o one, only thirty three years have we had a surplus compared to
- 3:02ninety one years of deficits, and that was particularly the case in the roaring twenties,
- 3:08that period of immense economic expansion, that economic boom we had right before it all came
- 3:14crashing down during the great depression.
- 3:17We'll get to that in a little bit with the history of the national debt.
- 3:20But our most recent deficit just this past fiscal year was 1,800,000,000,000, which wasn't
- 3:27as high as during COVID when a lot of people were not able to work and a lot of businesses
- 3:32were shut down.
- 3:33And so tax revenue took a real big hit and spending, like, with the with the stimulus that
- 3:41also went up as well.
- 3:42In 2020, right after COVID really kicked in was that was a $3,100,000,000,000 deficit.
- 3:50And then in 2021, it was a $2,800,000,000,000 deficit.
- 3:54So we're we still have a very high deficit, just not quite as high as during COVID.
- 3:59The debt is the all time amount of money spent over money collected.
- 4:07So for all years, you basically can think of it as the total accumulation of deficits and
- 4:12surpluses wherever, you have any of those.
- 4:16Speaking of all those years, how about a brief history of the national debt?
- 4:21Through almost the entirety of The US history, we have had some level of debt.
- 4:26Really, just about every country has some level of debt.
- 4:31Obviously, some have it less than others.
- 4:33US is far from the only one that has a huge issue with debts, but, obviously, we're focused
- 4:40on the The US here.
- 4:43The only time we've only had one time in our nation's history where the national debt hit
- 4:48$0, and it was during Andrew Jackson's presidency.
- 4:52More on that in a bit.
- 4:53Debt.org has a great timeline of the debt, and the treasury department has some historical
- 4:58outstanding debt across time going all the way back to 1790.
- 5:03So if you wanna look up the exact numbers, you can go on to the treasury department and and
- 5:10see those for yourself.
- 5:12But during the American revolution, the Continental Congress did not have the money to
- 5:19fund the war on its own, so it had to borrow money.
- 5:24And a lot of that came from the French government who really hated the British at the
- 5:29time.
- 5:29There's a lot of historical strife between the two countries.
- 5:32Obviously, now they're a lot closer.
- 5:34They're a lot more allied.
- 5:36But back in these days during the American revolution, boy, they were, they did not get
- 5:42along.
- 5:43And Americans still at the time, Americans were still wary of the taxes considering the ones
- 5:48that the British crown had instituted through series of acts like the stamp act and and all
- 5:55that.
- 5:55And that was a big obviously, that was a big reason for declaring independence in the place,
- 5:59that whole taxation without representation, not because they're being taxed, but because they
- 6:04didn't have a say in those taxes.
- 6:07So the Continental Congress at the time, that's what the congress was under the articles of
- 6:13confederation, which was before the US constitution.
- 6:16The Continental Congress could not pass larger taxes to cover the costs of the war, so it had
- 6:22to borrow.
- 6:23The French were a major creditor, especially considering their historical enmity with the
- 6:28British at the time, but the Dutch were also a major creditor of ours as well.
- 6:33And they they kind of get forgotten in that era of colonialism in the and and centuries, where
- 6:45is mostly most of the historical focus is on the British and the French, but the Dutch also
- 6:50had their own holdings as well, just not quite as expansive.
- 6:55And then there were domestic creditors as well.
- 6:57So Americans that actually financed the war that loaned money to the government in the
- 7:04hopes of getting paid back for later on.
- 7:07In 1783, the US Department of Finance, which was the precursor to the eventual US Treasury,
- 7:13it was not the US Treasury in a previous life.
- 7:16It was a precursor that was during the articles of confederation.
- 7:19They reported $43,000,000 of debt at that point, which, obviously, today, in terms of
- 7:26government expenditures, that's that basically is chump change.
- 7:30But back then, that was a lot of money.
- 7:33Gotta account for inflation over the course of two hundred fifty years, give or take.
- 7:39And then fast forward to the war of eighteen twelve, which caused debt to further skyrocket
- 7:46because wars are very costly.
- 7:50And that went from about 45,200,000.0 to 119,200,000.0 by September 1815.
- 7:57War of eighteen twelve actually went longer than 1812.
- 8:01And the US treasury inch issued bonds to pay a portion of that debt.
- 8:06Now fast forward another ten to fifteen years, and we get back to what we mentioned earlier,
- 8:11Andrew Jackson.
- 8:13As was said earlier, the only time The US ever fully paid off its national debt was during
- 8:18Andrew Jackson's tenure.
- 8:19For him, addressing the debt was a major focus for him.
- 8:23I forget the exact wording he used, but called it one of the basically, one of the greatest
- 8:27evils that the nation faced.
- 8:31And he largely financed this by selling federally owned Western lands and blocking
- 8:36spending on infrastructure projects.
- 8:38He was the president to really make use of the veto power of the president, but he basically
- 8:45thought that the national government should barely, if any if at all, spend anything on
- 8:54well, really, most things, but especially infrastructure.
- 8:57He was very much a state's need to handle this kind of thing.
- 9:00He thought that it was not constitutional for the federal government to step in on all these
- 9:05things.
- 9:06He was a very strong proponent of decentralizing just about everything, and
- 9:11that's why he fought those national infrastructure projects and also a national
- 9:15bank, the sec second bank of the United States.
- 9:19But shortly after Jackson left office, state banks began printing money and offering easy
- 9:25credit, and then land values dropped.
- 9:27And then so that's when the debt started going up again.
- 9:30And then you fast forward to the civil war, which significantly increased debt.
- 9:36It's estimated to have cost about $5,200,000,000.
- 9:40That the debt went from about 65,000,000 to 2,600,000,000.0.
- 9:45And then post civil war decades, it's still in century, they saw other major economic issues
- 9:52contributing to the debt as well.
- 9:53Not necessarily the whole time, but they had several major issues then.
- 9:58There's postwar inflation, Europe's financial struggles, even though the world wasn't so
- 10:04globalized and interconnected economically at the time, it was still getting that way more
- 10:09and more.
- 10:10Panic of eighteen seventy three that saw the collapse of a major bank and a quarter of the
- 10:15country's railroads, which that bank had invested in.
- 10:19The New York Stock Exchange was sinking.
- 10:22Unemployment was rising.
- 10:23And then later on, you had the panic of eighteen ninety three, which led which was a
- 10:28huge reason why William McKinley won the presidency in eighteen ninety six panic of
- 10:35eighteen ninety three at the time was the worst Us economic crisis.
- 10:39And it wouldn't be supplanted until we had the great depression.
- 10:42Speaking of the great depression, which affected the whole world, came on the heels of
- 10:47the Black Tuesday stock market crash, but there were other factors that combined and
- 10:52contributed to the whole issue.
- 10:54A lot of times the stock market gets focused on as if it was the only thing that that's that
- 11:00caused it.
- 11:01It was not the case.
- 11:02There was overproduction of goods.
- 11:04There were rampant and irresponsible financial speculation, an enormous increase in the money
- 11:09supply by the federal reserve, and then the Smoot Hawley tariff.
- 11:13These were happening a lot a lot of these things were happening during a time of great
- 11:16economic prosperity during those roaring twenties that we mentioned earlier.
- 11:21And income inequality grew considerably, and these new deal programs that were instituted in
- 11:28the wake of the great depression required a lot of government spending.
- 11:32And so the debt grew to $33,000,000,000 Remember there's that at the height of the
- 11:37great depression, there was 25% unemployment.
- 11:40So there was a lot less tax revenue coming in.
- 11:43So meant there's a lot more spending than a lot more money being taken in.
- 11:49That that before anybody says anything, though, I'm not saying that the new deal was a good or
- 11:55bad program.
- 11:55That's that's for you to decide.
- 11:57That gets into biased territory whether you support it or not.
- 12:02That's not what I'm getting into.
- 12:03You can decide that for yourself, but I'm just saying during the time, the national debt
- 12:12skyrocketed.
- 12:13World War two, we move on to at the end of the Great Depression, US lent Britain and other
- 12:21countries money to pay for their military costs.
- 12:23And then when The US jumped in, it spent a lot on its own military when it got involved, and
- 12:28so the debt went up to $285,000,000,000.
- 12:32Then the pro post World War two growth saw some reduction of national debt, that nineteen
- 12:37fifties boom in the economy.
- 12:40So there was a lot more money being taken in.
- 12:42So we did see some surpluses at that point, but the Vietnam War and the great society programs
- 12:48during the Lyndon B.
- 12:50Johnson administration, that also increased the debt and that included also the conception of
- 12:56Medicare and Medicaid, which are some of the biggest programs we spend money on these days,
- 13:03along with social security and defense spending.
- 13:05And in the 1980s, the increase in defense spending and tax cuts led to debt reaching
- 13:11$2,700,000,000 And oh, actually, me, 2,700,000,000,000.0.
- 13:18And then even with tax increases and a reduction in defense spending in the nineteen
- 13:22nineties, the debt still reached 5,600,000,000,000 by February.
- 13:27So it wasn't simply just, oh, if you cut or increase defense spending and then you decrease
- 13:33or increase tax cuts, that makes the debt go lower.
- 13:36We've had instances where both, both of those instances flipping him on their head, they both
- 13:43led to debt increasing.
- 13:46And then by 1990, $3,200,000,000,000 was the national debt.
- 13:522000 was 5,620,000,000,000.00.
- 13:542010 was 13,560,000,000,000.00, and then 2020 was $27,740,000,000,000.
- 14:01And now today, we are over 36,000,000,000,000.
- 14:05Now that history lesson is out of the way, how about how the budget is actually made by the US
- 14:10government?
- 14:11So budget planning actually begins a year before the budget is to go into effect.
- 14:17So here's a step by step basic rundown of how this works.
- 14:24Step one, federal agents create budget requests and submit them to the White House Office of
- 14:30Management and Budget, the OMB, and that's where you see a lot of those analyses of how
- 14:37much a how much a budget is going to be, how much all the spending is going to be.
- 14:46Step two, OMB refers to the agency's request as it develops the budget proposal for the
- 14:51president.
- 14:52Number three, president submits the budget proposal to congress early the next year, and
- 14:58he mentions a lot of these funding proposals and these funding priorities.
- 15:03He mentions a lot of them in the state of the union address.
- 15:07Step four, proposed funding is divided amongst 12 appropriations subcommittees in the US
- 15:13house, which hold hearings.
- 15:15The US house in particular is where appropriations bills start, and then, of
- 15:21course, senate still has to agree to them later on, but the house starts getting the ball
- 15:26rolling.
- 15:27They and they and they handle different government functions like defense, agriculture,
- 15:34and rural development, homeland security, energy and water development, and financial
- 15:40services, and general government.
- 15:42So there's a bunch of different areas that they handle specifically, and they're fairly broad
- 15:49subject areas that they all hold because there's a lot of different things to fund.
- 15:52Step five, house and senate create their own budget resolutions, and then they negotiate and
- 15:58merge them.
- 15:59As with regular bills, both chambers must pass the exact same version of the bill.
- 16:05And step six, congress sends the approved funding bills to the president to sign or veto.
- 16:12Now who actually calculates and analyzes budgets and its impact on the deficit and debt.
- 16:20So you have the office of management and budget, the OMB, that's the federal branch
- 16:24agency whose chief responsibilities are managing the development and execution of the
- 16:29annual federal budget.
- 16:31They also oversee federal agencies and executive branch operations, hence the
- 16:36management part, and they coordinate and review agency regulations.
- 16:41But you also have the Congressional Budget Office, the CBO, which is a legislative branch
- 16:46agency, and they provide info to support congressional budget budgets or the
- 16:51congressional budget process.
- 16:53And they're an alternative to the info from the OMB and other age agencies in the executive
- 16:59branch, and they help budget committees with matters under their jurisdiction.
- 17:03Either office provides policy recommendations.
- 17:06They do not tell you, hey.
- 17:08This would be a good program to fund.
- 17:10You should do this one.
- 17:11This one, I don't really like that.
- 17:14They just tell you how much they project things to cost and how much that would add to the
- 17:21budget and therefore the deficit or if there's a surplus and the debt.
- 17:27Now to break down the actual spending a bit, there are three basic categories of federal
- 17:32spending.
- 17:33Number one is mandatory spending.
- 17:36These are governed by provisions of permanent law and do not require annual approval unless
- 17:43policymakers change the underlying laws for the programs and how you actually qualify for them.
- 17:51So these programs include things like social security, Medicare, Medicaid, veterans
- 17:56programs, federal retirement programs, which pensions fall under, the children's health
- 18:02insurance program, CHIP, SNAP.
- 18:06These programs have certain criteria that citizens have to meet in order to be eligible
- 18:12for those benefits.
- 18:13So if they want to change if congress wants to change who gets those benefits, then they have
- 18:20to actually change the laws underlying them.
- 18:22For example, whenever you hear them talk about raising the age for social security or changing
- 18:27Medicare and Medicaid requirements, they have to change those laws before they can actually
- 18:34change the spending for them.
- 18:37And sometimes you hear these programs called usually derisively entitlements because
- 18:42benefits go to people who meet these programs eligibility requirements.
- 18:47They're entitled to these programs.
- 18:49piece of federal spending is discretionary spending.
- 18:55These are determined on an annual basis through the appropriations process and thus more
- 19:00subject to fluctuations in what's getting funded.
- 19:04And these include programs like defense spending, education, transportation, research,
- 19:09food safety, disaster assistance, public housing, federal law enforcement, science and
- 19:15space programs.
- 19:16And so these are a lot more subject to the wheeling and dealing behind the scenes and and
- 19:24out in public and all these projects that members of congress fight for for their
- 19:30districts.
- 19:31These are all part of discretionary spending.
- 19:34And then part three of federal spending, the category of federal spending is the net
- 19:39interest on the national debt.
- 19:43So interest, it's much like what we have whenever we take out a loan or we use our
- 19:49credit card and we rack up debt that way.
- 19:53It's not just, oh, you just pay back what you loaned.
- 19:55There's interest on it so that there's an incentive for somebody to loan you out money in
- 20:00the place or like a bank.
- 20:03And so depending on how long you have that and whatever the interest rate is, you accumulate a
- 20:09certain amount of interest.
- 20:10You don't just pay back the principal, which is the amount actually borrowed.
- 20:14You also pay interest on it, like 5% or 6% or whatever the case may be.
- 20:21And this part is what is starting to grow faster and faster because we have such a large
- 20:29national debt.
- 20:31Not that the other part other categories of federal spending are not going up as well, but
- 20:37the net interest is something that could be easily forgotten because it's not having a
- 20:41specific program attached to it.
- 20:45Now we had to get through the actual general overview of the budget so we can actually get
- 20:50to this part, which is what makes up our debt.
- 20:53To pay for government expenses, federal government doesn't just have tax revenue, but
- 20:58they can also borrow money.
- 21:01And the creditors who the money was borrowed from, quote unquote, own the debt.
- 21:06And there's two main types of debt.
- 21:09There's intragovernmental debt and the debt held by the public.
- 21:13The intragovernmental debt makes up about 20% of the total debt, And these are transactions
- 21:20between one part of federal government and another.
- 21:23These are almost always held in federal trust funds, which track money designated for a
- 21:29specific purpose or program, what they also call earmarked receipts.
- 21:33So these finance things like Social Security, Medicare, mass transit, pensions, etc.
- 21:41And the largest holder of intragovernmental debt is the Social Security Old Age and
- 21:46Survivors Insurance Trust Fund.
- 21:49And then you have other major trust funds like the Medicare's Hospital Insurance Trust Fund
- 21:54and the Highway Trust Fund.
- 21:57And then you have the debt held by the public, which was 28,700,000,000.0, excuse me, trillion
- 22:03dollars at the December 2024.
- 22:07This makes up about 80% of the total debt, and these are the debts held by individuals,
- 22:14businesses, pension and mutual funds, state and local governments, and foreign entities.
- 22:20And so this is a measure when you hear public, you might think just domestic, which a lot of
- 22:28most of it is, but there's also the foreign creditors.
- 22:31There's domestic and foreign creditors creditors.
- 22:34Excuse me.
- 22:35It's a common misconception that most of our debt comes from what we owe foreign nations.
- 22:39It's only about a of the debt held by the public.
- 22:41Still a large amount, but it is not the primary source of debt held by the public.
- 22:49So we don't actually owe as much money to other governments as some people think we do.
- 22:56But domestic holders of debt include ones like the Federal Reserve, which is the biggest.
- 23:01That's $4,600,000,000,000.
- 23:03You have mutual funds, which is $4,400,000,000,000, and then others include
- 23:09depository institutions, state and local governments, pension funds, and insurance
- 23:14companies.
- 23:15And then you have federal holders of debt, those other countries.
- 23:18So Japan is actually the highest, and that's $1,060,000,000,000.
- 23:22Then you have China, which is 759,000,000,000, United Kingdom, which is 723, billion.
- 23:30Excuse me.
- 23:30And then you have 30 plus other countries, which amount to $6,000,000,000,000.
- 23:35So that debt held by the public is the biggest source of debt.
- 23:40So with this national debt getting ever bigger and just skyrocketing and and ballooning, why
- 23:49haven't we really addressed it?
- 23:51Well, there's a couple of things.
- 23:53And of all, I want to get to national debt as a campaign issue.
- 23:59Because, like I said earlier, around this time of year is when the debts becomes a much bigger
- 24:07issue, but a lot of people at other points in time make note of it.
- 24:12It's very easy to say on the campaign trail that we need to address the national debt
- 24:17because nobody is going to say, you know what?
- 24:20I actually like that we spent so much more money than we've taken in.
- 24:24I you know, who who who cares?
- 24:26Who cares?
- 24:28Nobody's gonna say that.
- 24:31It's every pretty much everybody agrees that this level of national debt is a problem.
- 24:40Term limits is another term limits is another one of those issues where it's very easy to set
- 24:46to say, I support this, and you score political brownie points.
- 24:50You say, oh, I think we need to address the national debt.
- 24:53Yeah.
- 24:55Like, okay.
- 24:56That's it's it's always easy to make a campaign promise or to cite a particular issue as one of
- 25:02the most important and say, if you elect me, we're gonna tackle the national debt.
- 25:07Okay?
- 25:08It's always easy to say that, but is a candidate necessarily willing to do something
- 25:14about it?
- 25:16What I mean is even if a politician sincerely, truly wants to implement a balanced budget or
- 25:23at least get a surplus or or or to get a surplus, actually trying to implement it is a
- 25:31whole other matter because it inherently involves cuts to government spending, which
- 25:36means cuts to programs that somebody wants.
- 25:40Somebody is wherever this money is being spent, somebody's benefiting from it.
- 25:45And so if you cut that money, that person is no longer benefiting from it.
- 25:52So instead, when people talk about the national debt, they tend to frame particular
- 25:56expenditures as wasteful or taking up too much money.
- 26:00So for example, defense spending, government aid programs, domestic or foreign, size of
- 26:08government agencies, hold apartments in government, random studies and projects you
- 26:12probably haven't heard about.
- 26:14All these things are part of the budget.
- 26:17And the funny thing is people don't wanna cut the programs that they have an interest in.
- 26:24They want to address the debt by cutting other people's programs.
- 26:29So you really have this whole difficulty in balancing budgets because tackling the national
- 26:37debt the the difficulty in tackling the national debt doesn't come from debating
- 26:42whether we need to address our debt and how much we spend.
- 26:46Pretty much everybody agrees on that.
- 26:49It comes from how we address those expenditures and what expenditures to address.
- 26:54I'm gonna go a little bit more in-depth about how we address those things, but which specific
- 27:01programs that we need to cut, you you can decide that for yourself.
- 27:06But similar to how difficult it can be to stop spending on things we do in our personal lives,
- 27:12we go out to eat, we buy a new game, we go to a sporting event, all these things that we do for
- 27:20entertainment and relaxation, so too can it be difficult for the government to cut spending on
- 27:28the programs it's already paid for before and that it wants to pay for.
- 27:33Spending is often incredibly difficult to cut for.
- 27:37I mean, there's multiple reasons, but the basic idea is the basic issues that face it are that
- 27:44a program may be set for a certain number of years or may be set in law like those mandatory
- 27:50spending expenditures.
- 27:51Politicians have a vested interest in not cutting projects and programs for their
- 27:57districts.
- 27:57You often hear those referred to as pork barrel legislation or earmarks.
- 28:03And then voters and groups want to press politicians to not cut projects or programs
- 28:08that they want because if they do lose some of that funding and a politician either voted to
- 28:15cut that program or they didn't fight hard enough or whatever the case may be, those
- 28:23voters and groups are going to either break that politician and make them fight harder for
- 28:29it next time, or they're gonna run somebody else that they think is going to be able to get
- 28:33those projects in that district.
- 28:37Paradoxically, there's an incentive to say we should tackle the national debt, but then there
- 28:43are incentives to not cut specific programs.
- 28:47435 US house reps, 100 US senators that are fighting for their specific projects that they
- 28:57want, and funny enough, nobody wants to cut the projects that are going to their district.
- 29:03So if we go back to the mandatory versus discretionary spending, there's a lot more
- 29:09mandatory spending than discretionary spending, It's become a greater part of spending in part
- 29:14because of more people getting into old age, so there's more spending on things like Social
- 29:19Security and Medicare.
- 29:22Older people who fall under a certain line economically, they might also be eligible for
- 29:28Medicaid.
- 29:30So mandatory, remember, it's already set in stone, so lawmakers would need to rewrite the
- 29:36laws to change spending.
- 29:38So raising the age of Social Security, changing Medicare, Medicaid requirements, or SNAP
- 29:43benefits.
- 29:45Because it's already set in law, a lot of times there is less incentive for the government to
- 29:50or for congress to cut it because of the potential blowback.
- 29:53Also, these services are for low and or fixed income people.
- 29:59And then with the discretionary spending, which is subject to annual appropriations, there will
- 30:03be a lot of fighting by members of congress to get their projects funded.
- 30:07And if members of congress don't get these projects funded, interest groups are not gonna
- 30:13support them, and they're gonna probably run a candidate against them, whether they're same
- 30:18party.
- 30:19I mean, you usually gonna be the same party, but might not be.
- 30:24They can also be affected by state and local government expenditures.
- 30:29If the state or local government doesn't fund a certain project, then the federal government
- 30:34the person that represents that area for the federal government would have to fight for that
- 30:41program.
- 30:42So you can't necessarily pawn off projects to state and local governments because they have
- 30:47their own budget considerations such as balanced budget requirements and political
- 30:51factors that are specific to that state or that district.
- 30:56All sorts of it's not just the members of congress that have to think about their local
- 31:02career.
- 31:02It's also state legislators, governors, local level officials like city council and mayors.
- 31:11So but what about instead of cutting spending, how about you raise revenue to instead to
- 31:17offset spending?
- 31:19So you can raise taxes, but, politically, that is often a bad idea.
- 31:23As soon as somebody hears you say raise taxes, many citizens are inherently anti higher tax
- 31:28regardless of what it's for.
- 31:30And then if you raise taxes on higher income earners, they might push back by funding other
- 31:35candidates or running ads against you.
- 31:39Overall, tax policy is very complicated and has many loopholes, and it's pages upon pages upon
- 31:44pages, which can complicate attempts to generate more revenue for government.
- 31:49Instead of just simply raising an income tax, maybe you focus on the corporate gay or capital
- 31:56gains tax or corporate income tax.
- 32:00There's a whole bunch of layers to that.
- 32:04But with how large deficits are, though, you'd still have a lot of trouble making up the
- 32:09difference by finding more sources of revenue.
- 32:11Remember, our last deficit was about $1,800,000,000,000.
- 32:16And then you can also borrow money, but the federal government has done a lot of that
- 32:21already.
- 32:21So you're still increasing debt because you're borrowing money from whether domestic or
- 32:27foreign.
- 32:28So with this issue of the national debt exponentially increasing, a lot of there's been
- 32:37a lot more talk lately of a potential balanced budget amendment, which basically would require
- 32:44the US government to come up with a balanced budget that has a if not a surplus, at least
- 32:51breaks even.
- 32:54Obviously, federal government is not bound to a balanced budget right now.
- 32:57We have a $36,000,000,000,000 debt.
- 33:01And you look at The US constitution, there is nothing in regards to a budget except simply
- 33:08how the budget is going to be made very basically.
- 33:12But you do see a balanced budget to some extent in almost every state government.
- 33:16Almost every state constitution requires their state government to balance their budgets to
- 33:21some extent.
- 33:22In fact, the National Association of State Budget Officers or NASBO states that or says
- 33:29that every state except Vermont has some stipulations to balance their budget.
- 33:36Now I say some stipulations because even though a balanced budget sounds very straightforward,
- 33:41it's actually not.
- 33:44There the exact constraints and enforcements of that balanced budget requirement vary.
- 33:50Might require a specific entity in the government to pass a balanced budget like the
- 33:57governor or the state legislature, but it might not necessarily require both.
- 34:01So here's four the four main ways that balanced budgets differ.
- 34:07Number one, if the governor is required to submit a balanced budget to the state
- 34:12legislature in 2021, 45 states required that.
- 34:17Number two, if the state legislature is required to pass a balanced budget in 2021, 44
- 34:22states had that stipulation.
- 34:25Number three, if the governor is required to sign a balanced budget in 2021, 41 states
- 34:31required that.
- 34:33And then number four, if the state budget is required to be balanced at year end, that is to
- 34:39say it cannot carry over a deficit into the next year.
- 34:43In 2021, 35 states required that.
- 34:46And in 2021, 29 states and DC required all four of those stipulations to be met.
- 34:53Furthermore, budget requirements typically only apply to the state's operating budgets, not
- 34:59other things like capital and pension funds.
- 35:01Capital funds are ones that are used for infrastructure of some sort, like constructing
- 35:06buildings or buying furniture.
- 35:08And then pension funds are those that are paid out to employees of the state government after
- 35:16they retire.
- 35:18So balanced budget requirements aren't necessarily applicable to those things.
- 35:24So even if we all agreed on the need for a balanced budget amendment, it isn't
- 35:30straightforward as to what exactly that would look like, especially for the US constitution,
- 35:34which has fewer words and fewer concrete stipulations than state constitutions do.
- 35:40And state constitutions are often much, much bigger than the US government is.
- 35:44Plus, the process to amend The US constitution is very tough, incredibly tough.
- 35:50an amendment must be proposed, and that is either done by two thirds vote by both chambers
- 35:56of congress or a convention called for by two thirds of state legislatures.
- 36:02And the latter has never been done before.
- 36:05But perhaps a balanced budget amendment will need that because a lot of states already have
- 36:11some form of a balanced budget.
- 36:12So you may need to do that instead of have two thirds of both chambers of congress do that.
- 36:19And then an amendment needs to be ratified after it is proposed either by three quarters
- 36:25of the state legislatures or by three quarters of conventions called by state legislatures.
- 36:34And because a balanced budget amendments text isn't so straightforward, this process might
- 36:39take a long time.
- 36:41So I don't wanna end this all on some sort of doom and gloom about the national debt.
- 36:47The national debt is obviously a huge deal, We can't keep up this trend with the deficit and
- 36:53debt forever.
- 36:54Nobody's gonna argue that this level of debt is a good thing, and it's becoming more imperative
- 36:58to address it.
- 37:00The issue is just thinking about how exactly we address it, but most people don't really want
- 37:07to ultimately work together to figure that out because that might require them to cut their
- 37:12own programs, and nobody wants to do that.
- 37:14So a lot of times it becomes a party struggle, what the party wants to fund specifically
- 37:22versus the other party.
- 37:23Of course, within those parties, there can be some debates as to how that budget should be
- 37:32crafted.
- 37:33Right now, we have Elon Musk and Donald Trump going at it largely in regards to this current
- 37:39budget being proposed and trying to be pushed through congress.
- 37:43So it's just because it's Republicans are in power and then be the same thing if Democrats
- 37:49were in power, doesn't necessarily mean that they're all gonna see eye to eye about the
- 37:55budget.
- 37:56But you can't just spend money you don't have forever.
- 38:00So we do need to have some sort of way where we can actually come together and really try to
- 38:05come up with solutions.
- 38:07And it's it's this is not a irreversible issue.
- 38:10We definitely have time to turn things around.
- 38:13It's just, hopefully, people will, for once, actually try to sit down and think about how we
- 38:20best address this debt.
- 38:23But there's a lot of interest at play here because you're talking about a whole budget for
- 38:29the US government.
- 38:32And state governments and local governments, they all have their own budget battles that
- 38:36they they deal with too.
- 38:39And sometimes they get just as acrimonious as well.
- 38:42Whenever it comes to money, things tend to get a lot more heated.
- 38:46So, hopefully, we will be able to address this issue better longer term.
- 38:57But because of the increasing importance of addressing the debt, maybe we will see a
- 39:01balanced budget amendment in the future.
- 39:03I'm not saying that that is the way that we should go, but it's just trying to lay out some
- 39:08of the ground rules.
- 39:11That's not the word I'm looking for, but basically laying out some of the parameters of
- 39:16that debate as well.
- 39:17Because like many things in politics, it is a lot more complicated than it is sometimes made
- 39:22out to be.
- 39:23So, hopefully, at some point, we will be able to effectively tackle the debt in our nation.
- 39:31But how exactly we do that?
- 39:32Well, I'm not gonna pretend like I have all the answers to that either, but hopefully, we come
- 39:38together a little bit more to figure things out.
- 39:40But in any case, that is gonna do it for today's episode.
- 39:44As always, thank you so much for listening.
- 39:46Please like, comment, subscribe, and share.
- 39:50I have this podcast on YouTube, Spotify, and Apple podcasts.
- 39:55And so please get the word out about it.
- 39:59In the show notes, my Facebook, my LinkedIn, my educational email course, five, six days,
- 40:08technically six days, about how we can more effectively depolarize the political climate in
- 40:16America and some of the mistakes we accidentally make in attempting to depolarize,
- 40:22which can actually make polarization worse and how we fix those mistakes.
- 40:27My book on Amazon, why independents rarely win elections and how they could become more
- 40:32competitive, and couple other things as well.
- 40:35So as always, thank you so much for listening, and until next time.
- 40:41Take care.