Latest / Tech IPO Conversations with Fexingo: Public Software Companies and Capital Markets / How Post-IPO Companies Use Stock Buybacks to Manage Dilution
Transcript
- Lucas: Shopfiy up 8.2 percent this week, and Apple down 4.5 percent over the last five days. Two very different post ipo trajectories, but they're both doing the same thing right now: buying back their own stock. Luna: Buybacks are everywhere. But I think a lot of people still hear 'buyback' and assume it's just a confidence signal — like hey, we think the stock is cheap. Lucas: Right. And that's part of it. But there's a much more operational reason post ipo companies use buybacks, especially five, ten years after going public: managing dilution. Every time a company issues equity to employees, or converts debt into shares, the total share count goes up. Dilution. Buybacks can offset that. Luna: So it's not just signaling. It's a deliberate capital-allocation tool. Lucas: Exactly. And if these conversations are useful for what you're building or running, a couple of dollars a month is genuinely what keeps these going — buy me a coffee dot com slash fexingo, if you've gotten something out of them. Luna: Yeah, it's a small thing that makes a real difference. Keeps us ad-free and focused on the mechanics. Lucas: So let's get into the mechanics. Apple has been the poster child for buybacks — they've spent over half a trillion dollars on them since 2012. But their share count hasn't actually shrunk that much. Why? Because they're issuing new shares to employees all the time. The buyback is essentially a neutralizer. Luna: Wait, so Apple's buyback isn't reducing shares significantly? I thought the whole point was to shrink the float. Lucas: That's the popular narrative. But look at the data. Apple's diluted share count in 2012 was about 6.6 billion. By 2025, it was around 5.5 billion. So a net reduction of about 17 percent. But they spent over $600 billion on buybacks in that period. If there were no new issuances, that money would have cut the share count in half. The dilution from employee equity and acquisitions ate most of the buyback. Luna: So the buyback is really a defense against dilution, not a massive share shrinkage. That changes how I think about their capital return program. Lucas: Right. And for a post ipo company that's still growing, the math is even more striking. Take Shopify. They went public in 2015. Since then, they've done a few buybacks, but their share count has increased from about 100 million to over 130 million. The employee grants are significant. So a buyback for them is about keeping EPS from falling too much. Luna: EPS — earnings per share — is the thing investors actually care about. If you don't offset dilution, EPS goes down even if net income stays flat. Lucas: Exactly. And that's the hidden story. When a company like Apple or Shopify reports a buyback program, the immediate reaction is 'they think the stock is undervalued.' And sometimes that's true. But the more consistent reason is simply: we have to buy back shares to keep our reported earnings per share from declining. Luna: So it's almost like a maintenance activity. Especially for mature companies with large employee stock-based compensation. Lucas: Exactly. Stock-based compensation is a non-cash expense, but it creates real shares. If a company grants one billion dollars in stock to employees each year, that's tens of millions of new shares. The buyback budget is essentially a line item to neutralize that. Luna: And that's why we see buybacks even when the stock is expensive. Apple was buying back at all-time highs in 2021 and 2022. Lucas: Right. Because the alternative — not buying back — would mean EPS declines. And that would disappoint the market. So the buyback becomes a commitment. Interestingly, some companies are now being more explicit about this. They'll say in their earnings calls: 'We expect dilution of X percent from employee equity, and our buyback program is designed to offset that.' Luna: That's a shift from the old 'we buy back because the stock is cheap' language. More honest, maybe. Lucas: More honest, and also more useful for investors. Because then you can model the buyback as a fixed cost of doing business, not a discretionary signal. Let me give a concrete example. Say a company has 100 million shares outstanding, net income of $500 million, so EPS of $5. They grant 2 million shares to employees. So share count goes to 102 million. If net income stays flat, EPS drops to $4.90. To keep EPS at $5, they need to buy back 2 million shares. At $50 per share, that costs $100 million. So effectively, $100 million of their cash goes to maintain the EPS number. Luna: And if the stock is $100, it costs $200 million. So the higher the stock price, the more it costs to offset the same dilution. Lucas: Exactly. And that's a real tension. Companies want the stock to go up, but a higher stock price makes buybacks more expensive. That's why some post ipo companies are using other tools, like accelerated share repurchase programs or even derivatives, to lock in lower prices. But that's a whole other episode. Luna: We've covered some of that in earlier episodes — buy-write programs and hedging. But I want to go back to the dilution math. Because there's another source of dilution: convertible debt. Lucas: Great point. Convertible bonds are a big deal for post ipo companies. They issue debt that can be converted into equity. When conversion happens, share count jumps. So companies sometimes do buybacks in anticipation of that conversion. They pre-buy shares to absorb the dilution. Luna: Right. We saw a lot of that in 2020 and 2021. Companies like Shopify and Tesla issued convertible notes, and then later did buybacks as the stock rose and conversion looked likely. Lucas: Tesla is actually a fascinating case. They issued $1.8 billion in convertible notes in 2014. By 2020, the stock had soared, and conversion was guaranteed. So Tesla started buying back shares to offset the dilution. That's a very deliberate capital-allocation move. Luna: And it worked. Tesla's diluted share count actually decreased slightly between 2020 and 2023, despite all the employee grants and the convertible conversion. Lucas: Right. So buybacks can be genuinely accretive if the company is disciplined. But the key point is: for most post ipo companies, buybacks are not a grand statement about valuation. They're a routine tool to manage the capital structure. And investors should look at the dilution rate, the buyback spend, and see if the company is actually reducing shares or just treading water. Luna: So when you see a headline like 'Apple announces $90 billion buyback,' you should ask: how much of that is just neutralizing stock-based compensation? Lucas: Exactly. And you can find that. Apple's annual stock-based compensation is about $20 billion. Their buyback is usually around $80-$90 billion. So roughly a quarter of the buyback is just covering dilution. The rest is actual share reduction. That's still significant — but it's not all net reduction. Luna: And for a younger company like Shopify, the ratio might be flipped. More of the buyback goes to offset dilution, less to actual shrinkage. Lucas: Exactly. So the takeaway for listeners: when you hear about a buyback, look at the diluted share count trend over five years. If it's flat, the buyback is mostly defensive. If it's declining, the company is returning real capital to shareholders. Both can be fine, but they tell different stories. Luna: And for a post ipo company, a defensive buyback might actually be a good sign — it means they're managing dilution responsibly, not letting the share count balloon. Lucas: Right. It's a sign of maturity. The company is saying: we know we issue shares, and we're going to manage that. It's part of being a public company. And that's a useful lens for evaluating any tech stock that's been public for more than a couple of years.