Latest / Shiny New Object - a Marketing Podcast / Episode 298 / Christiana Courtright / Edelman / Head of Digital Netherlands
Transcript
- 0:00Christiana Courtright: If the data you're looking at has never
- 0:02surprised you, it is likely confirming your bias or your
- 0:06client's bias.
- 0:13Speaker: Are you a fitness loving foodie? Then defy snacks
- 0:16is for you. Defy offers real high quality chocolate you love,
- 0:19combined with functional ingredients, giving you as much
- 0:21as 26 grammes of protein per bag. So you can be both a little
- 0:25bit bad and a little bit good at the same time as a female owned
- 0:28brand, defy dedicates a portion of its profits to other women
- 0:32owned businesses currently sold in the US. You can find us on
- 0:35defy with an eye snacks.com and follow us on social at defy
- 0:39snacks.
- 0:46Tom Ollerton: Hello and welcome to the shiny new object podcast.
- 0:49My name is Tom Ollerton. I'm the founder of Automated Creative,
- 0:53the creative effectiveness ad tech platform, and this is a
- 0:56weekly show about the future of data driven marketing. And I am
- 0:59the lucky guy that gets to go all over the place and meet lots
- 1:02of interesting people and talk about that subject matter,
- 1:05because I love it. I'm obsessed with it, and we've done nearly
- 1:07300 shows, so I can't stop myself. And today is no
- 1:10different. I'm on did you know I do so many of these as a zoom?
- 1:15I've said I'm on a call. I just couldn't stop myself. I'm not.
- 1:17I'm in person in Amsterdam for Christiana Courtright, who is
- 1:21the head of digital for the Netherlands for Edelman. Thank
- 1:25you for inviting me to your lovely, swanky, bougie kind of
- 1:28hotel vibes office. For anyone who doesn't know you and isn't
- 1:31familiar with your work,could you give us a bit of background
- 1:34on how you got to this job and what you do?
- 1:36Christiana Courtright: Absolutely. First of all, welcome to Amsterdam. I have not always been in the advertising industry. I started six years ago, and before that, I was an international journalist in Berlin. So I have in six short years, managed to go from a senior social strategist in digital to the head of digital here in the Netherlands. So it was quite a fast moving career that I've had in the last six years. And what I do now is I run a department of six people, all with different digital talents, and I simultaneously am also in a dual role of being the lead digital of EMEA for Unilever. So I also have that on my plate as well.
- 2:24Tom Ollerton: So what has been the best investment of your own
- 2:29time, energy or money in your own career?
- 2:34Christiana Courtright: This kind of goes back to what I was just
- 2:36saying around how did I in six years go from just joining the
- 2:40industry to the head of a department, I think the best
- 2:44investment I made was in communication. And what I mean
- 2:48by that is twofold. So one, how do I communicate and present? I
- 2:53think we all assume that just because we can talk, we can all
- 2:55communicate, and I don't think that's true. What I would say is
- 2:58that actually communication is an art. So one thing I did was I
- 3:02invested in a business coach who taught me the art of
- 3:05communication, how to talk and present in meetings, how to also
- 3:09set boundaries at work, while still, you know, maintaining a
- 3:11solid reputation. And then the second thing was, I invested in
- 3:15improv comedy, and the improv comedy was again to help my
- 3:19presentation skills and pitches. I once was doing a presentation
- 3:23class at my last job, and my MD pulled me aside and said,
- 3:27Christiana, you're never going to win pitches if you present
- 3:31like that. And it was a really hard moment where I said, Oh,
- 3:34really. And he was like, Yeah, your speaking skills are just
- 3:36not up to par. So I had two choices. I could either cry and
- 3:40give up, or I could do something about it, and I thought the best
- 3:43solution was to do improv comedy, because it means failing
- 3:46fast all the time. Because that was my biggest blocker. It was
- 3:49the embarrassment of, what if I make a mistake in these pitches?
- 3:52Tom Ollerton: Well, as a co leader of a business, I think
- 3:55that's really awful thing to say to someone that's not exactly
- 3:57constructive feedback, is it?
- 3:58Christiana Courtright: It wasn't, and it was definitely
- 4:00some of the hardest feedback I've ever received. What I am
- 4:03grateful for now, in hindsight, is the fact that I found a love
- 4:06for improv comedy. I didn't just do it for, like, a couple
- 4:09months. I ended up doing it for two and a half years. I
- 4:11absolutely loved it, and the presentation skills that it gave
- 4:15me, I credit for the reason I have got to do a TEDx. It's the
- 4:19reason I have been able to stand on stage and been invited. I've
- 4:22never felt more comfortable in front of a stage, and I
- 4:25definitely wouldn't have said that four or five years ago.
- 4:27Tom Ollerton: Well, I can relate. I've also done stand up
- 4:31really badly. That was painful experience for everyone for a
- 4:33couple of years. But part of that sort of smooshed in was,
- 4:36was a lot of improv, and I, my take on that is it allows you,
- 4:41you know, in the you know, in the Matrix that film, everything
- 4:44slows down. Yes, like, that's what improv comedy does to you
- 4:47in a business context, is because you can, because you're
- 4:49thinking on your feet, you're not, yes, you're listening to
- 4:52what the person's saying, but you also have your own narrative
- 4:54in the background, so that the words come out of your your
- 4:58mouth as kind of... additive is the one word. Whereas if you
- 5:04only ever done corporate, you're like, Oh God, I need to read the
- 5:07words on this slide. But I think it gives you a superpower,
- 5:10really, to be able to calm yourself the fuck down and be
- 5:14able to see things happen slower.
- 5:16Christiana Courtright: I think it gives you a much more diverse
- 5:17range of vocabulary than circling back, and let's put a
- 5:20pin in it, you actually find your own way to speak corporate.
- 5:23And I think that's incredibly important, because it really
- 5:26engages people. When you talk like a human and you speak like
- 5:29real, like a real person does not as a corporate human being.
- 5:33Tom Ollerton: Yeah, I always try to pass on the idea of being
- 5:37unprofessionally professional, or is it professionally
- 5:39unprofessional? But either way, it doesn't really matter. It's
- 5:42that you still get the job done, still communicate with people,
- 5:45you're still giving the value and more that you're supposed to
- 5:47deliver, but you're not putting a pin in it, being a human.
- 5:52Well, that's brilliant advice. I'm sorry your boss was mean to
- 5:54you something. It's okay, to be honest, but there you go. Um,
- 5:57you deserve better.
- 6:04Anyway, right? So let's talk about coaching a little bit. So
- 6:08so that would have been expensive, I assume.
- 6:10Christiana Courtright: So yes, but I had a learning and
- 6:11development budget, so that's where I invested my learning and
- 6:14development funds. So it's a...
- 6:17Tom Ollerton: You just carved out of your own budget, or that.
- 6:19Christiana Courtright: So my old office gave me, and so does
- 6:19So lovely, and it's all a bit smooshy and dreamy
- 6:21Edelman. They give us a chunk of money each year, and as long as
- 6:24we're investing it into something that helps us
- 6:26professionally, can be whatever you need it to be. I have team
- 6:29members who also have invested in coaches in my team, and have
- 6:33really benefited from it. I think the other thing to also
- 6:35mention is I think that mentorship is still very hard to
- 6:39come by in advertising, I think we're time poor. I think we have
- 6:43to always be billable. So it kind of puts pressure to put
- 6:46things like mentorship aside. I think investing in mentorship in
- 6:50my team, I have seen like the return on investment so much,
- 6:55the progression, the confidence that my team has had because I
- 6:58spent time investing in myself and then passed on what I
- 7:01learned to them. I think that is probably one of the best things
- 7:04I've done so far in my role as head of.
- 7:13philosophical, but we've got to talk about data driven
- 7:16marketing, right? So give me your best data driven marketing
- 7:19tip. What's that bit of advice that you find yourself passing
- 7:21on to folk?
- 7:23I think that if the data you're looking at has never surprised
- 7:27you, it is likely confirming your bias or your client's bias.
- 7:31I think that the data should often surprise you. It shouldn't
- 7:35just be based on desk research alone. I think speaking to real
- 7:39people is critical to the point where, if you haven't done it, I
- 7:43can't really say then that you're finding anything too rich
- 7:47and interesting, because it's it's the people that offer the
- 7:50complexity, the dynamicism, and also that kind of psychographic
- 7:55intel that you need so that we're not just leaning on those
- 7:58very two dimensional demographics. And that's
- 8:00particularly true for older women or midlife women over 50,
- 8:05because there's such a forgotten demographic in advertising. I
- 8:09mean, we only invest 5% of all of our ads on featuring older
- 8:15women, and so I think that kind of information is important to
- 8:19identify who are your real purchase decision makers? Are
- 8:22you hoping that they're Gen Z, or are they actually Gen Z? Is
- 8:25the persona you've created, even a real person? I mean, I've read
- 8:29so many personas where it's like, Meet Bob. He is a
- 8:32bookstore owner. He also likes to surf on weekends, and he's a
- 8:35graffiti artist. And I'm like, I've never met Bob, and I'm sure
- 8:38many people have not met Bob, and I'm sure he's not even a
- 8:41real person. He's just the person you'd like to advertise
- 8:43to.
- 8:46Tom Ollerton: That's a whole podcast there. But we're gonna
- 8:49move on, so we'll now talk about your shiny new object. Yes,
- 8:55which is ageism? Yes. So I think I know what ageism is but what
- 9:00is ageism in a shiny new object, data driven marketing context?
- 9:06Christiana Courtright: Well, I think one thing to say really
- 9:09plainly is that often people think ageism is just like a
- 9:13misguided attitude, but actually it has been perceived and known
- 9:18to be the last acceptable form of discrimination. So that's an
- 9:22uncomfortable truth onto its own. Because why is it 2025 and
- 9:27we're still leaning on these assumptions that, for example,
- 9:31old age equals weakness and declining health. Because if you
- 9:34think about it, the data doesn't say that, if you speak to real
- 9:39women over 50, the data says this is just another vital life
- 9:42stage. We're enjoying ourselves. We're not all with bladder, you
- 9:45know, weakness and joint pain, but yet, the only ads that seem
- 9:49to be targeted at us are about declining health, incontinence
- 9:52products, anti wrinkle cream, grey hair dye. All of these are
- 9:56saying that the only value you have is to maintain your youth
- 9:59for as long as possible.
- 10:00Tom Ollerton: So the common wisdom that I've been exposed to
- 10:03is that if you get someone into a brand young, then they've got
- 10:06a long term value, right? And no one's gonna argue with that,
- 10:10right? If you hook someone in when they're 18, by the time
- 10:14they're old enough to afford a car or house, a phone or
- 10:17whatever, then that person's great, because you can hold that
- 10:20person for the entire longevity of their life and make loads of
- 10:24money from them, that's the logic, right? However, the
- 10:27tenure of most CMOS is what I don't know. What's the latest
- 10:31figure? A year, year and a half, two, three? It doesn't matter.
- 10:35It's certainly not a lifetime, is it? So it's not like you're
- 10:38going to have these people joining the grad scheme at
- 10:42Unilever at 18 and then working there to, actually Unilever is
- 10:45probably a bad example. Generally speaking, people hop
- 10:49around brands a lot over a 12345, year period, so the idea
- 10:52that they need to kind of get people in at the start and keep
- 10:56them there for whole of their lives. Those two facts don't add
- 10:59up for me. So where's that coming from?
- 11:03Christiana Courtright: It's a great question. I think that a
- 11:07couple of things, and I'll say this more from my own experience
- 11:10of working with brands, is I think that I'm not gonna get
- 11:14into Byron Sharp now and talk all about the science behind
- 11:17marketing, but what I will say is I think that there is an
- 11:20argument for retain and grow, because if you have customers
- 11:25who are, let's just say, more mature, and that is your current
- 11:29customer base and your current purchase decision makers, but
- 11:32you would also like to acquire younger customers so that you
- 11:35know they stay part of, you know, part of your brand or part
- 11:39of Your product for the rest of their lifetime. That is a wiser
- 11:43strategy than only trying to chase the young, which seems to
- 11:46be the predominant strategy of just attract Gen Z and let's
- 11:50just ignore the mid lifers, because there's this assumption
- 11:52that if you feature Gen Z or young, it'll still influence and
- 11:56engage the midlife but that's proven to be incorrect. That is
- 11:59false data, because midlife people want to see people who
- 12:03look like them in advertisements, not young
- 12:04aspirational people. And I think it actually creates more anxiety
- 12:09to see young people than it does actually to inspire them,
- 12:12because it's like, oh, we're irrelevant now, we're invisible
- 12:15now. We don't matter now.
- 12:22Tom Ollerton: This episode of the shiny new object podcast is
- 12:26brought to you in partnership with madfest, whether it's live
- 12:28in London or streamed online to the global marketing community,
- 12:32you can always expect a distinctive and daring blend of
- 12:35fast paced content, startup innovation pitches and
- 12:38unconventional entertainment from madfest events, you'll find
- 12:41me causing trouble on stage, recording live versions of this
- 12:44podcast and sharing a beer with the nicest and most influential
- 12:47people in marketing. Check it out at www.madfestlondon.com
- 12:59So the older generation in certain markets has a massive
- 13:03spending power, right? A massive, huge, disposable...
- 13:07Christiana Courtright: Two generations hold 44.3% of global
- 13:09spending power. So that's Baby Boomers and Gen X.
- 13:11Tom Ollerton: So there's 44% of money on the table.
- 13:14Christiana Courtright: Yeah, that we're leaving off the table
- 13:16by ignoring
- 13:18Tom Ollerton: So that, like, to me, that is like the most
- 13:20whopping business opportunity that even the thickest CEO or
- 13:24CMO would understand. So why is why is it not happening?
- 13:29Christiana Courtright: This is something that I've tried to
- 13:30unpack, because I think it's one of the greatest questions we
- 13:34have. For example, I would say Dove is one of the only
- 13:38companies who, over a decade now, has been combating age
- 13:42bias. They launched real beauty in 2004 they have seen their
- 13:45sales go from 2.5 billion to over 4 billion within the
- 13:48decade. That is the financial proof that any CMO would need,
- 13:51which is it makes money to be age inclusive. And you don't
- 13:55have to do only midlife or only young. You can have just a
- 13:58broad, diverse range of ages for your product. So I think part of
- 14:03the problem is, I think the fact that, first and foremost,
- 14:07between the ages of 45 and 54 in the ad industry, 70% of ad
- 14:12professionals exit the industry, and you are three times more
- 14:16likely in that age group to be forced up by redundancy than to
- 14:19leave due to burnout or to go client side. So I think the
- 14:22first issue is the fact that we don't have midlife people in
- 14:25advertising. So how are we to challenge age bias if there is
- 14:28no one speaking up for the midlife person and being
- 14:31authentic to their experiences? I think it's also the reason why
- 14:34a lot of the advertisements we see play on very tired
- 14:39stereotypes that are almost offensive, like old ladies who
- 14:43have beige tights and woollen cardigans and are driving around
- 14:46in souped up mobility scooters like this kind of comedic,
- 14:50because it's like nothing's funnier, right than a midlife
- 14:52woman trying to be young again, haha, like no one's laughing who
- 14:55is over the age of 50, but yet this ad is still everywhere.
- 15:00Like, start going online and look at recent ads featuring
- 15:02older people, and I can bet you, you will find that stereotype
- 15:05more times than you care to count.
- 15:08Tom Ollerton: So we are obviously a million miles away
- 15:11from true representation in advertising. Yes, I I've been in
- 15:16this industry for 16-17 years, and what's happened in the past,
- 15:20kind of three or four has definitely been a step in that
- 15:23direction. It's part of our vocabulary as an industry. It's
- 15:27something that's talked about from sort of conferences to
- 15:29WhatsApp groups to this people are put in like positions. You
- 15:34know, it's representation. And certainly representation in the
- 15:39UK is definitely going the right direction in terms of race,
- 15:42culture, background, beliefs, all that kind of stuff. I don't
- 15:45see that when it comes to age.
- 15:47Christiana Courtright: No. And I think this is one thing that
- 15:49really frustrates me as an advertiser who's been
- 15:51campaigning against ageism in advertising for the last six
- 15:54years, is how have we been able to talk about so many difficult
- 15:59topics, and yet, when it comes to age, something that we all
- 16:02experience. It isn't just a group of people who age. We all
- 16:06age. We still can't seem to tackle that last piece of
- 16:10discrimination. I don't understand it.
- 16:13Tom Ollerton: So who, who would benefit from tackling it?
- 16:16Where's the money?
- 16:18Christiana Courtright: Well, interestingly, there was a
- 16:21recent study done where a car brand was very sure that men
- 16:27were their purchase decision makers, very sure. And so then
- 16:32they put all of the data, not their ideal persona of males,
- 16:37but just their data of who's been buying their cars recently,
- 16:40the category, and what they discovered was that actually
- 16:43midlife women were the purchase decision makers of cars, not
- 16:47midlife men. And so the AI actually confronted their own
- 16:51bias and said, hey, hey, you've got it wrong. You've got
- 16:54completely the wrong customer. Don't advertise this way. And
- 16:57then they completely redid their advertising towards females, and
- 17:02it increased sales by 50% so I think this is the important
- 17:06thing. Is we have to start using the data and not our bias, in
- 17:12order to identify who real purchase decision makers are.
- 17:15And I recommend any brand who might have a hunch that it's a
- 17:20little bit broader than maybe people 18 to 25 to start
- 17:23inputting data into AI and not and to leave their bias out of
- 17:26it.
- 17:27Tom Ollerton: So I'm gonna have to push you on the AI bit. Yeah,
- 17:29it's incredibly broad. What do you mean specifically by putting
- 17:33it into the AI?
- 17:34Christiana Courtright: Yeah I mean, that is incredibly broad,
- 17:36I think, because I obviously was not part of this case study. All
- 17:41it said in this case study was that they inputted it into
- 17:44artificial intelligence. What I imagine it is, is that it was an
- 17:48app or tool when it was identifying things to do with
- 17:50consumer data and information. What I can say is, though, that
- 17:54I have done this without the use of AI, and I think you could
- 17:57find very similar results without inputting it into an app
- 18:00or tool. For example, we had a brand who was very confident
- 18:04that they needed to target younger people, kind of going
- 18:07back to our earlier conversation, in order to be
- 18:10culturally relevant and in order to drive sales, we did focus
- 18:14groups around the whole of Europe about who are their
- 18:16current buyers and also who are the challengers against this
- 18:19brand. And what we identified was a more mature customer, but
- 18:24also a far more interesting customer than who they thought.
- 18:27They thought the people who currently bought their brand
- 18:30were uneducated, not very interesting, suburban. And
- 18:34actually, we found that these women had complexity and really
- 18:37diverse interests and were dynamic and interesting. And so
- 18:40that became a really interesting moment where we could hold up
- 18:43their own data and say, hey, who you thought was purchasing your
- 18:48product isn't as uninteresting as you think. And this plan to
- 18:53target young in order to attract and be culturally relevant isn't
- 18:56necessary. You can be culturally relevant while still speaking to
- 18:59midlife women. And so we found that way to balance the two.
- 19:02Tom Ollerton: I try not to talk about my own business on this
- 19:10podcast, for this isn't a platform for that, but I think
- 19:14that the... I don't think it's that hard to really experiment
- 19:18with this, right? So in a world of generative AI, which still
- 19:21isn't there, we still know its shortcomings, but at some point
- 19:25you're gonna be able to generate anything for anyone, anywhere,
- 19:27at any time, in any format, right? If you want to a car ride
- 19:32with Brad Pitt sitting in there with a go driving through space,
- 19:35you could probably have that. Not right now, it's a little bit
- 19:37weird. However, if you are a brand that, as you described it,
- 19:43that could sell at different age groups, young through to middle
- 19:45age and beyond then if an AI can generate assets or ads or images
- 19:53of an old person using the product, middle age, young,
- 19:56whatever, and then you can automate production of those ads
- 19:59and then serve them to relevant media groups. So you serve the
- 20:04middle aged people to this age bracket and so on and so forth.
- 20:07You can prove very quickly, very easily, very cheaply, whether
- 20:11the hypothesis that one audience is more valuable than another
- 20:14very quickly. I don't think you even need to put it into AI and
- 20:18go, oh, like, what does the AI think? It doesn't matter. Like,
- 20:23create hypothesis. Is it young, middle, age or old? Create those
- 20:26assets using AI, deploy them to those audiences and see which
- 20:30does has the best return, be that engagement, attention or
- 20:34conversion metric. So I think there's such it's been really
- 20:38inspiring to hear you talk about this stuff. And it's like, I can
- 20:40think, I'm going through all of our brands that we work with,
- 20:42going, oh my gosh, yeah. So it's, it's such an obvious thing
- 20:46to test and so easily done.
- 20:48Christiana Courtright: I think so. But the one caveat I would
- 20:49say around generative AI and to be careful with is, so I've been
- 20:53obviously playing with chatgpt and having fun like generating
- 20:56images there. When I ask it to generate images of women who are
- 20:5950 and 60 and 70. It sometimes gets it right. It sometimes does
- 21:03a very offensive job of making women who are 50 and 60 look
- 21:06more like 80 and 90. So I think we just have to also be mindful
- 21:10that the images it generates are respectful and authentic to
- 21:15actually how these people look, because otherwise we're just
- 21:17perpetuating age bias even further.
- 21:20Tom Ollerton: Well, that's your prompt, isn't it? You know, I
- 21:22think that's the trick that, yeah, anyone who justifies or
- 21:26doesn't justify Chat GPT, so that, look, here's a picture of
- 21:29a car. Oh, that's not very good. Or that is really good, that
- 21:31that's the problem, right? It's that how we were learning the
- 21:34other day about, like, having a sandwich, where you go, like,
- 21:36what is my intention? What do I want to get out of AI? Then you
- 21:39let the AI doing the bit in the middle, and then you own it, and
- 21:42then you re craft it at the other end, which I think is a
- 21:44really nice way of looking at it. So yes, there's definitely
- 21:48going to be ageism built into those algorithms, of course. But
- 21:50with this kind of thought your leadership, it's helping us ask
- 21:54the questions before we get to it, which I think is really
- 21:56powerful. So unfortunately, we've run out of time. I could
- 22:00talk about this all day long. So if someone wants to get in touch
- 22:03with you, where's the best place to do that and what makes a
- 22:06message to you that you'll actually reply to?
- 22:09Christiana Courtright: You can reach me on LinkedIn, and I
- 22:12would be most interested. If you want to talk about ageism and
- 22:14advertising. That's a message that will definitely pique my
- 22:16interest. If you have a hunch that maybe there is a diver,
- 22:21more diverse age group of consumers, and you can't figure
- 22:24out how to identify it. I think that's something I'm very
- 22:26interested in. Mentorship is another thing I'm always
- 22:30interested in, if you want to be mentored, I'm also always
- 22:33available for that. So those would probably be the two things
- 22:36that I would be most engaged in if you reached out to me about.
- 22:38Tom Ollerton: Perfect, thank you so much.
- 22:40Christiana Courtright: Thank you.
- 22:47Tom Ollerton: Hi, just before you go, I'd really appreciate it
- 22:51if you could take the time to write a review of the shiny new
- 22:54object podcast on Apple podcasts, or iTunes, whatever
- 22:57it's called these days, or whichever podcast provider you
- 23:01use. We're at any podcast, so it would go a long way for us. If
- 23:05you could just share the Word and give us a bit of a support
- 23:08on those channels. That'll just be fantastic. If you haven't got
- 23:10time. That's also cool. And yeah, if you could tell your
- 23:13colleagues about the podcast, and also, if possible, don't
- 23:16forget to subscribe. And I'd love to hear your feedback if
- 23:20you'd like to speak on the podcast, I'll be a guest, or you
- 23:23think I'm asking the wrong questions, anything. I'd be
- 23:25super interested to hear what you think. So please email me at
- 23:29Tom at, automated creative.net, that's Tom at, I'm not gonna
- 23:35bother spelling it anyway. You'll work it out. Thanks so
- 23:38much.