Latest / Stage Talks with Bellingcat / "Identifying Explosive Ordnance in Social Media Imagery" with Andro Mathewson
Transcript
- 0:04You're listening to a stage talk titled Identifying
- 0:07Explosive Ordnance in Social Media Imagery. This
- 0:10week, we continued our discussion on weapon identification
- 0:13with Andrew Mathewson, a former Bellingcat Tech
- 0:16fellow and researcher at the Haylor Trust, who
- 0:19is now working for the Center for Information
- 0:21Resilience. He talked us through his guide on
- 0:23verifying EOs. in many different conflict regions.
- 0:27This talk was hosted by me, Charlotte Ma, on
- 0:29Thursday the 27th of March 2025 in the Bella
- 0:32Cat Discord server. We're here with another stage
- 0:54talk. This week we're revisiting a topic we approached
- 0:57last week, well, two weeks ago, identifying weaponry.
- 1:01You can listen back to the talk a fortnight ago
- 1:03on the amazing resource that is the open source
- 1:06munitions portal now on any podcast platform.
- 1:10But today we're here with former Bellingcat Tech
- 1:13Fellow and War Studies student, Andrew Mathewson,
- 1:16to chat about explosive ordnance identification.
- 1:20If you didn't know already, explosive ordnance
- 1:22are munitions that contain explosives and can
- 1:25detonate without warning, killing or injuring
- 1:27civilians long after conflicts have ended. The
- 1:31rise in conflict imagery on social media has
- 1:33both helped and hindered open source research
- 1:36efforts. There is now more footage of EOs than
- 1:38ever before, but within recent conflicts we've
- 1:41seen an uptake in false weapon claims contributing
- 1:43to myths and disinformation. So Andrew here thought
- 1:47he should write up a guide to help verify the
- 1:49most common types of EO. He did just that last
- 1:53year and now is here to talk about it and to
- 1:56dig a little deeper into the types of EO you
- 1:58might find in particular regions. If you'd like
- 2:01to ask a question please so do Do so in the chat.
- 2:04Remember, this is being audio recorded. So if
- 2:07you don't want me to read out your Discord username,
- 2:10please include that within your question. You
- 2:13can find the chat in the corner of your screen
- 2:15on the right -hand side. It's a little speechable.
- 2:20Okay. I'll be back with questions in a bit. Hopefully
- 2:25I can now hand over the mic to Andrew. Thank
- 2:30you all for joining today. I'm a past Bellingcat
- 2:32Tech Fellow and also a PhD student in War Studies
- 2:36at King's College, London. Previously to my studies
- 2:40and my time at Bellingcat, I was a global research
- 2:44officer at the Halo Trust, which is one of the
- 2:46largest humanitarian demining organizations in
- 2:49the world, where I used open source intelligence
- 2:52to map minefields, primarily in Eastern Ukraine,
- 2:54but a few other countries as well. and that was
- 2:57the inspiration behind the beginner's guide to
- 2:59identifying explosive ordnance in social media.
- 3:03A bit more backstory on that. Essentially, I
- 3:06was working in Eastern Ukraine since April 2021,
- 3:10so prior to the full -scale Russian invasion
- 3:12in Eastern Ukraine. However, obviously, when
- 3:15Russia invaded in February 2022, the majority
- 3:19of our team had to leave the country. For the
- 3:21next two or three months, we were really wondering
- 3:24what we can do to support the people of Ukraine,
- 3:26to keep our teams on the ground informed that
- 3:30were remaining in Ukraine, and how we can map
- 3:32any potential minefields that were being laid
- 3:35in the country. And obviously, as probably most
- 3:38of you are aware, with the first few months of
- 3:41the war in Ukraine, the explosion of material
- 3:46that was created online on Twitter, on Telegram,
- 3:49on any other social media platform, really has
- 3:53provided such a wealth of information for any
- 3:55open source intelligence investigations, whether
- 3:58it's mapping minefield, war crimes investigations,
- 4:00human rights abuses, or more just generally conflict
- 4:03mapping. And obviously I think that the conflict
- 4:05in Gaza has sort of solidified the real strength
- 4:08that open source intelligence can play in conflict
- 4:11monitoring and even for justice and accountability,
- 4:13for example. But back to the guide. And so for
- 4:16the first two or three months of since the Russian
- 4:20full scale invasion, All we really could do from
- 4:23sitting abroad in the UK was really look at the
- 4:26imagery that was coming from the conflict and
- 4:28try to identify where mines were being laid,
- 4:31whether that's by the Ukrainians defending or
- 4:35even defensive minefields once Russians had occupied
- 4:38areas in Ukraine. This started out very, very
- 4:42simply. looking at social media imagery, but
- 4:46obviously this developed into a very, very larger
- 4:48scale effort that the Halo Trust continues to
- 4:51use in terms of prioritizing minefield clearance.
- 4:54But obviously, as I'm sure most of you are aware,
- 4:56during the whole, during the conflict and during
- 4:59the war in Gaza, for example, there has been
- 5:00a lot of misinformation and disinformation narratives,
- 5:03including around weapons use. And so that was
- 5:08the primary driving force behind working with
- 5:11Bellingcat. on creating the beginner's guide.
- 5:15I think it's really important because I know
- 5:17one of Bellingcat's central missions is for investigations
- 5:20to be reproducible by anyone with OSINT skills.
- 5:23I think that's really important when talking
- 5:25about munitions identifying too. The reason why
- 5:29it's really called a beginner's guide to identification
- 5:31is because it is somewhat limited in where it
- 5:35focuses only on specifically the types of munitions
- 5:39and not models. those of you who might have a
- 5:45bit more experience with explosive ordnance,
- 5:47there's probably a million different types, specific
- 5:50types and models of ordnance when you really
- 5:53get into the details. But for a lot of the larger
- 5:56scale pictures of investigations and research,
- 5:59the type of munition is generally sufficient.
- 6:03And that's more or less the case for mine clearance
- 6:08at this level where we're at all. to identify
- 6:12whether they're landmines or other types of unexploded
- 6:14ordnance for example. Walking through the guide
- 6:19itself and the whole process, the main aspect
- 6:24of the guide is the identifying features of the
- 6:27different types of munitions. If you're lucky
- 6:31enough to have a very clear image of the explosive
- 6:34ordnance, we're really looking to get as much
- 6:38information as we can at the first instance.
- 6:39So any text on the munitions is really important.
- 6:42Often it might include producer codes, it might
- 6:45even tell you the type of munition exactly it
- 6:47is, the model. Many landmines, for example, have
- 6:50even the production year stamped on them, which
- 6:52can be really interesting information as well.
- 6:55But obviously, talking about social media imagery
- 6:58or munitions that have been in place for many
- 7:01years, often that's very important. possible
- 7:05together, and it's very dependent on the source
- 7:07material, the source image. So if you can't really
- 7:10identify any text, color can be really helpful.
- 7:13One of the more basic things is the color of
- 7:18the munitions, and they can identify, for example,
- 7:21for NATO munitions, blue indicates a training
- 7:24or practice round, so it doesn't have any active
- 7:27explosives in it. Although I wouldn't obviously
- 7:30recommend in person that if you do see a blue
- 7:32munition to pick it up, because nonetheless it
- 7:34can still be dangerous. And last but not least,
- 7:37especially for identifying the models, the shape
- 7:41of the munition is really important. And so for
- 7:50those of you who can see the screen, obviously
- 7:51you can see, for example, one of the the writing
- 7:55on the munition and this is part of a Bellingcat
- 7:57investigation where a fragment of a US -made
- 8:00bomb found in Mali is showing a cage code outlined
- 8:04in green on the screen and also a NATO stock
- 8:06number outlined in red. So this not only allows
- 8:08the exact type of weapon to be identified but
- 8:11actually it's manufacturer as well and so depending
- 8:13on the investigation that you might be conducting
- 8:15that's really really important and really valuable
- 8:17information which you really wouldn't be able
- 8:19to get unless you have that text. visible in
- 8:23the source image. As I said, color can be really
- 8:26important as well. On the screen, you can see
- 8:29a laser guided bomb made in a paveway laser guided
- 8:34bomb. It's very obviously very large and blue
- 8:37in color, the warhead of the bomb specifically,
- 8:40which identifies that it's a training material
- 8:42because it was during a visit by the French defense
- 8:46minister to a military air base. Beyond those
- 8:51two things, obviously, many of the munitions
- 8:52that we might be looking at in social media,
- 8:55it can be degraded. They can be rusted. They
- 9:00can be muddy. If we're talking about large conventional
- 9:03warfare and trench warfare. Really, sometimes
- 9:06all we have to go by is the actual shape of the
- 9:10munition. As I said in the beginning, there's
- 9:15a... a vast, vast amount of exact models of explosive
- 9:19ordnance. In this guide, we're specifically looking
- 9:23just at the type of munitions. I decided to focus
- 9:27on specifically 11 types of explosive ordnance,
- 9:30because those are generally the most commonly
- 9:33used munitions in conventional warfare, such
- 9:37as is the war in Ukraine. That would be artillery,
- 9:42which are projectiles, As you can see on the
- 9:46screen, for example, so there's sort of objects
- 9:48that are normally forced from a gun and follows
- 9:50a trajectory by virtue of kinetic energy. So
- 9:53artillery shells are the most common example.
- 9:56And they're generally not very long. They're
- 9:58quite cylindrical. They've got a point in those,
- 10:01which is the fuse and also a driving band at
- 10:04the end. And almost always they have a very flat
- 10:07base. Afterwards, grenades, obviously very common
- 10:12in conventional warfare, especially in trench
- 10:16warfare and close hand -to -hand fighting. Very
- 10:20small bombs, essentially, but most common items,
- 10:26grenades will have safety pins and fuses, which
- 10:29are very visibly easy to identify. Afterwards,
- 10:34rockets, generally self -propelled, but don't
- 10:39have a necessarily controlled trajectory very
- 10:40often, but they're often very quite long and
- 10:43narrow in shape and have fins at the end for
- 10:46stabilization in flight. Mortars, commonly sort
- 10:50of tight explosive used in conventional warfare,
- 10:53they have quite distinct bodies. They also have
- 10:57fins but spigots at the end where Gas is expelled,
- 11:01so they have quite a distinctive teardrop shell,
- 11:03so they're generally quite easy to identify.
- 11:06Landmines, which is my expertise, given my work
- 11:09at the Halo Trust, while many landmines are flat,
- 11:12such as anti -tank mines or anti -personnel mines,
- 11:15they do come in a lot of shapes and sizes, and
- 11:16that is generally the case for all these munitions
- 11:19covered in the guide as well. So it is more...
- 11:23The guide does focus on the most commonly identifiable
- 11:27items of these different types of munitions.
- 11:30Number six is submunitions. These are known as
- 11:35cluster munitions, so obviously fired normally
- 11:37from larger rockets and then dispersed over a
- 11:39large area. and they're much smaller in size,
- 11:43but almost always they have fins and a fuse at
- 11:46the top of the body. But sometimes they do, for
- 11:47example, come in a ball shape as well. So not
- 11:50always identical in terms of their shape and
- 11:53size as well. I also identified small arms ammunition,
- 11:57which is sometimes difficult to identify in social
- 12:06media imagery because they're quite small in
- 12:08size. And it's very often to also to identify
- 12:11the exact model of small arms ammunition is quite
- 12:14difficult. And then we're moving to fuses, which
- 12:17is essentially not a type of ammunition in itself,
- 12:19but normally part of a munitions payload. And
- 12:23this is the functioning top of a ammunition,
- 12:27so often seen on artillery shells, mortars as
- 12:29well, and grenades in different sizes and shapes.
- 12:32But they're generally the smallest. Item covered
- 12:37by this guide besides small arms ammunitions.
- 12:39Guided weapons. So these normally have a guidance
- 12:42system, so quite complex in their actual internal
- 12:45functioning and generally have an onboard propulsion
- 12:47system as well. Aerial bombs, which are the largest.
- 12:53category in the guide. And so as the name denotes,
- 12:57obviously dropped from aircraft, very large in
- 13:01size, often, for example, used very extensively
- 13:03in the conflict in Gaza right now. And last but
- 13:06not least, IEDs and booby traps. And often these
- 13:08are the most difficult to identify. because they
- 13:12have no uniform shape, and they have no uniform
- 13:15structure. Very often, these might have a power
- 13:17source, such as a battery, and wires, and explosive
- 13:19container. But still, they're not mass produced,
- 13:22except in a very few cases. So they are quite
- 13:25difficult to identify as well. And so those are
- 13:31the key models that I covered in the guide. And
- 13:34one thing I also created for the guide as part
- 13:36of my tech fellowship was a repository of resources.
- 13:40Identifying munitions in social media imagery
- 13:42is almost like working through catalogs of reference
- 13:46material. And I know there's a few that you might
- 13:49be familiar with, such as the open source munitions
- 13:51portal, which is extremely helpful and especially
- 13:53helpful when trying to identify the exact model
- 13:56of explosive ordnance. But out there, and I believe
- 14:00Charlie will be dropping the chat in the link.
- 14:02The link in the chat is the repository of open
- 14:04source reference material where there's both
- 14:08imagery and the sizes and different aspects of
- 14:11a lot of the munitions that you might see in
- 14:13conflicts nowadays. But that's a very brief overview
- 14:16to the guide and the inspiration behind it and
- 14:19some of the things that you might be able to
- 14:21do with the guide as well. So I'll pass back
- 14:23to Charlie now and hopefully we'll have a great
- 14:25discussion if there's any questions from the
- 14:28group. But thank you all for tuning in. Thank
- 14:31you so much, Andrew. Sorry, I turned off my camera
- 14:35for a second there because we were experiencing
- 14:37a little bit of lag on our side. So I just wanted
- 14:40to make sure that that didn't... continue. But
- 14:43thank you so much for talking us through it.
- 14:45I know a couple of the people couldn't see your
- 14:46screen, but the great thing about these audio
- 14:49podcasts is that we describe it in such detail
- 14:53that you don't actually need to be able to see
- 14:55it. So thank you so much. And I know a lot of
- 14:58people were also following along via the guide
- 15:00in the chat which I dropped. I've also shared
- 15:02the Bellingcat Explosive Ordnance Identification
- 15:06Resources sheet that you mentioned within the
- 15:09chat. And Jake from our team has also been sharing
- 15:13some really amazing resources. Jake said, worth
- 15:18following for published investigations on small
- 15:20arms, which is the smallarmssurvey .org. And
- 15:24alternatively for small arms and a lot of investigations
- 15:27on stuff similar to what Andrea is talking about.
- 15:29Conflict armament research is an excellent resource.
- 15:32Who spoke last two weeks ago as part of the open
- 15:36source munitions portal team. Please make sure
- 15:39you're putting your questions within the chat.
- 15:41I'll be reading them out in a second. I wanted
- 15:45to ask because we've just shared quite a lot
- 15:49of different details on identifying munitions
- 15:52and different types of characteristics that you
- 15:57can look out for. Is there some thought to actually
- 16:03thinking about the region that you're looking
- 16:05at specifically and whether there's certain EOs
- 16:09that are more common in different types of conflict.
- 16:12Are there any resources or kind of key factors
- 16:15that you can talk to about that? Yeah, definitely.
- 16:19Thanks, Ro. I mean, I think so that the regionality
- 16:23of the source material is really important. It's
- 16:26one of the contextual clues that can be really
- 16:28helpful in identifying especially the type of
- 16:32munition rather than the model specifically,
- 16:34but different conflict zones will have difference.
- 16:37and suppliers of weaponry very often. And so
- 16:40obviously, for example, in the conflict in Gaza,
- 16:42many of the aerial dropped weapons are, for example,
- 16:45supplied to the Israeli armed forces by the United
- 16:48States. And so it's very likely that if you are
- 16:52seeing any aerial dropped bombs in the conflict
- 16:55in Gaza, those are most likely US made. Obviously,
- 16:58that's not 100 % of them, but many of them will
- 17:01be, as the US is a major arms provider to Israel.
- 17:07the context of the Russian invasion of Ukraine.
- 17:12Obviously in the very early stages of the Russian
- 17:13invasion, back to 2014, 2015, for example, the
- 17:19Ukrainian armed forces weren't receiving almost
- 17:23any support, especially in terms of weaponry
- 17:25from Western countries. So most of the munitions
- 17:28from that time period in far Eastern Ukraine...
- 17:31would have been domestically produced Ukrainian
- 17:34weapons or even legacy Soviet weapons as well.
- 17:39And obviously since then, there have been extremely
- 17:41many different providers of weaponry in Ukraine
- 17:46to both sides in the conflict. And so it has
- 17:50become much more complicated in that region and
- 17:52in that respect as well. But I think One thing
- 17:56that's quite important to note there is this
- 17:59is where timing comes in as well. So beyond obviously
- 18:02the locality of the source image, the timing
- 18:04of the source image can be quite important as
- 18:07well. There are not that many imagery, for example,
- 18:13from the Soviet invasion of Afghanistan. But
- 18:17obviously during that period, for example, if
- 18:18you are looking at any imagery that has munitions,
- 18:20it's most likely to be Soviet imagery. And if
- 18:23we're looking at imagery from the global war
- 18:26on terror, for example, and the US action in
- 18:29Afghanistan, it's much more complex again. So
- 18:32it really depends both on timing and area of
- 18:35the war zone. And that can help you really narrow
- 18:38down. the origin of the weapon at least, which
- 18:42is, you know, any information is helpful when
- 18:43trying to, especially when trying to identify
- 18:45the exact model rather than just the general
- 18:48type. Absolutely. And as you mentioned, there's
- 18:52some conflicts, some regions that aren't as represented
- 18:55as others, and you have to kind of work backwards
- 18:57in terms of who's arming this particular country
- 19:01and this particular conflict. And we mentioned
- 19:03a couple of the regional conflicts that aren't
- 19:06as well represented in social media imagery,
- 19:09at least in the previous talk two weeks ago.
- 19:12So please do listen back for that as well and
- 19:14that discussion. We've got a few people in the
- 19:18chat who are new to the world of exquisite ordinances.
- 19:22I wanted to just ask how you, you mentioned that
- 19:25you were at the HALO Trust, but how did you first
- 19:27really get interested in exploring this particular
- 19:31topic? and looking further and what kind of things
- 19:35helped you at the beginning, kind of really remember
- 19:39the different types of munitions. Yeah, I mean,
- 19:42I think nobody in the world knows every different
- 19:45type of munition, not a model, especially the
- 19:49models, even exposed warrants, disposal technicians
- 19:51with 20 years of experience what know every single
- 19:54model that's out there. And as I said earlier,
- 19:57And there's new types and being developed probably
- 20:00daily, especially with all the conflicts going
- 20:03on. So I think the basics is the most important
- 20:07thing to get straight. And I think this is, again,
- 20:10one of the inspirations behind my guide as well,
- 20:12where I think depending on the level of detail
- 20:17that every investigation is going on or the use
- 20:19of the research that you might be producing.
- 20:23You might not necessarily always need to be as
- 20:25specific as the model. You might not need to
- 20:28know exactly if it's a delay fuse, for example,
- 20:31if it's a time fuse, if it's a magnetic influence
- 20:34fuse. You might just need to know that it's an
- 20:38artillery shell. and maybe like the size of it
- 20:41if you can try and identify that from an imagery
- 20:45as well, although that's sometimes difficult
- 20:47as well. I personally got started in OSINT and
- 20:51munitions research more from an academic perspective.
- 20:54During my undergraduate degree, I was working
- 20:56with a professor as a research assistant on conflict,
- 20:59specifically looking at drones. ISIS in the Middle
- 21:06East was doing a lot of innovations using small
- 21:08drones and drone drop munitions, which is nowadays
- 21:13a common place in conflicts. That really got
- 21:18me interested in about some of the manually manufactured
- 21:22munitions, for example, that insurgency groups
- 21:24have used and we've seen across the world. into
- 21:28an interest in munitions and weaponry more generally
- 21:31speaking. But I think for people who are more
- 21:34new in the space, the basics is really that important.
- 21:37And that's not just the basics of munitions identifying,
- 21:40but the basics of OSINT as well. thinking about
- 21:42verifying an imagery, there's no point in spending
- 21:45a day or two or three going through reference
- 21:47books of munitions to try and identify what it
- 21:50is. If it's a false, if it's a, if it's a, you
- 21:54know, AI generated image, for example, or if
- 21:56it's disinformation, misinformation. So I think,
- 21:59you know, identifying the explosive is just one
- 22:02part of picture as well, in general picture of
- 22:05trying to understand what is the truth and what
- 22:07exactly is being shown on the source material.
- 22:11Your thing about not everybody knowing everything
- 22:14about ordinances really resonated. Someone said,
- 22:17if someone says they know everything about ordinance,
- 22:19they are lying. And a few other people have actually
- 22:22done explosive courses. So somebody said, I studied
- 22:26about explosives in my course with advocacy.
- 22:29Assembly in collaboration with Amnesty International
- 22:31is really helpful. We've got a few questions
- 22:33coming in now. Someone's asked, how would you
- 22:36go about identifying a less known type of munition?
- 22:41For example, in a more remote or less covered
- 22:44conflict. So how would you approach that situation?
- 22:49I think this is where essentially collaboration
- 22:52with people on the ground, if it's possible,
- 22:55is really helpful. Conflict armament research
- 22:57that was mentioned earlier, they have experts
- 23:01who are able to deploy to countries and actually
- 23:02study study munitions in detail and into the
- 23:06physical reality, you know, whether that's the
- 23:08actual munitions as a whole or bits of shrapnel
- 23:10that are remnant. I think the one thing that
- 23:14is really impressive and that's just about, you
- 23:16know, as OSINT as a whole, it's amazing what
- 23:18you can do with very little information. And
- 23:21I think, you know, very often identifying the
- 23:24exact model is impossible, but generally a type
- 23:28or even a larger category of the munition can
- 23:32be identified. I think if we're talking about
- 23:34conflicts or even zones that are not necessarily
- 23:39termed conflicts, thinking about Mexican cartels
- 23:47where there's a lot of booby traps and IDs being
- 23:49used, honestly, it is sometimes impossible to
- 23:52identify exactly what you're looking at and you're
- 23:54not always going to succeed. But if you look
- 23:56at the repository that I think Charlie shared
- 23:57in the chat, there is a striking amount of reference
- 24:00material in there. going as far back as even
- 24:04the US Civil War. So if you're looking at really
- 24:06historical things, I know there's people, for
- 24:09example, that have used those guys to identify
- 24:11munitions that they've found through metal detecting
- 24:13as a hobby. Bullet Picker is one of the guides
- 24:17that is my personal favorite. I think it's something
- 24:21like 800 ,000 entries in there. So it's extremely,
- 24:24extremely in -depth and a really, really great
- 24:28resource. But as I said, unfortunately, sometimes
- 24:32it's not really always possible, especially if
- 24:34you only have one reference image, for example.
- 24:38We've got another question. I noticed cluster
- 24:41munitions are used a lot by both sides in the
- 24:44Ukraine War, and I've read that many of those
- 24:45submunition types do not explode. Does that functionally
- 24:49turn any targeted area as a potential minefield
- 24:52is being used as a remote mining technique? That's
- 24:58a really good question because some munitions
- 25:01have, at least on the Ukrainian side, increasingly
- 25:05proved their tactical utility against infantry.
- 25:09I think one issue with some munitions from a
- 25:13humanitarian mine clearance perspective is they
- 25:15have a very high failure rate, historically speaking.
- 25:20I wouldn't say it necessarily turns it into a
- 25:23minefield because they're not designed to be
- 25:26mines, cluster munitions. They're not designed
- 25:28to go off, for example, from pressure or target,
- 25:30or they're not victim operated essentially, unless,
- 25:34but they are obviously very volatile. So, you
- 25:36know, kicking a submunition or picking it up
- 25:38is something I would never recommend. So it is,
- 25:41in a sense, it is a type of minefield, but they're
- 25:43not necessarily being used as a remote mining
- 25:45technique, because that's not what their intended
- 25:50use really is. However, obviously any area that
- 25:53is littered with subunitions will be very dangerous
- 25:56for both civilians and any military in the area
- 25:58as well. But there are also increasingly a number
- 26:03of mines that can be delivered remotely as well.
- 26:07Both the United States have supplied those to
- 26:09the Ukrainian Armed Forces and the Russians have
- 26:11a few in their kit as well. So remote mining
- 26:16is possible as well, unfortunately. Scary. Yeah,
- 26:23subtle knife has putts. Aren't there more specialized
- 26:26versions of this to deliberately mine a space?
- 26:30I think you've just spoken about that yourself.
- 26:34A lot of people are saying that they are really
- 26:38interested in some of the resources you've shared,
- 26:41particularly talking about Um, ways to follow
- 26:45the Bom Bom in Myanmar as well, using Center
- 26:48for Information Resilience and Open Source Munitions
- 26:51Portal, which we talked about last, uh, two weeks
- 26:53ago as well. Um, the Primal Collective has asked,
- 26:56are there issues with censorship surrounding
- 26:59photos of EO on social media? Um, we haven't
- 27:02really spoken about the actual source that you're
- 27:05using here. Are there issues with those posts
- 27:08being taken down and how do you mitigate that
- 27:11when you're trying to investigate something you've
- 27:13found online? Realistically not. I actually haven't
- 27:18encouraged any issues with censorship. It really
- 27:21depends on the social media. Obviously Telegram
- 27:24has no censorship really. So any imagery with
- 27:30explosive ordinance is quite... easily accessible
- 27:34there. I mean, I think this is a general point
- 27:36about OSIN where archiving source material is
- 27:38really important in case it gets removed or deleted
- 27:41later. So as soon as, you know, there's anything
- 27:43I might be interested in researching immediately.
- 27:46And the Bellingcat auto -archiver is a very useful
- 27:49tool for that as well. So thank you for the Bellingcat
- 27:51team for developing that. But no, generally I
- 27:55haven't really come across any major censorship
- 27:57issues. The caveat being that sometimes if it's
- 28:01in as part of an investigation into something
- 28:06that's a bit more sensitive or gruesome, whether
- 28:10it's a potential war crime or civilian harm incident,
- 28:17then obviously sometimes those can get taken
- 28:18down from social media. But not when it's, for
- 28:21example, just an image of explosive ordinance
- 28:23or explosive ordinance being used. I haven't
- 28:25really come across that more broadly. Often,
- 28:31these images This imagery is just, and there's
- 28:34examples in your guide, actually, if people go
- 28:36and click back on that, they're often, you know,
- 28:39just remnants, metal remnants that people have
- 28:42found buried or thrown under bushes. And they're
- 28:47usually kind of at the corners or away from kind
- 28:52of the scenes of destruction. So yeah, I think
- 28:56it's a really interesting question though. We've
- 28:59had another question back on cluster munitions.
- 29:02Can you touch on the legality regarding cluster
- 29:04munitions? I don't know if you can speak to that,
- 29:07Andrew, or not. Well, cluster munitions and antipersonnel
- 29:12landmines fall under two separate international
- 29:14treaties. So for signatories of those treaties,
- 29:18they are illegal. However, obviously that doesn't...
- 29:23necessarily mean that even those who have signed
- 29:25the treaties are necessarily stick to those promises.
- 29:30And we've also seen countries in Europe, I believe
- 29:33the Baltic States and Poland have either already
- 29:35expressed their desire or already have pulled
- 29:38out of the Ottawa Treaty, for example, that is
- 29:41part of the international campaign to ban landmines,
- 29:43which specifically forbids They use production
- 29:48and stockpile of anti -personnel mines or any
- 29:50victim operating mines. However, that doesn't
- 29:52include anti -tank mines. So yes, in theory,
- 29:58plus munitions are illegal under international
- 30:00humanitarian law. But as I said earlier, the
- 30:04Ukrainians have shown that they do have quite
- 30:07a large tactical utility when used against infantry.
- 30:12However, as I think many of you are probably
- 30:14aware, That's not always been the case, especially
- 30:17by, for example, Russia that has used cluster
- 30:20munitions in heavily urban areas with civilians
- 30:24and caused lots of casualties. I hope that helps
- 30:28clarify that. Thanks for sharing. Keep your questions
- 30:34coming in. We've got about 20 minutes, so please
- 30:38pop them in the chat. I wanted to ask how you,
- 30:42we talked about how you can't be really an absolute
- 30:45expert in this space. You're not going to know
- 30:47every single ordinance that exists. How do you
- 30:51keep your knowledge up to date? How do you make
- 30:55sure that you know as much as you can at this
- 30:58stage? Do you take courses? Do you consistently
- 31:03check archives? How do you keep fresh in this
- 31:07particular subject? I mean, I think Osin more
- 31:12generally is practice makes perfect. I wouldn't
- 31:15say it's a muscle memory task, but the more you
- 31:19stare at munitions, the more you see and the
- 31:23more you know, especially the types off by heart
- 31:26and their different particularities. But I think
- 31:32if we're all monitoring various conflicts, in
- 31:36every other post you'll probably see a munition
- 31:37being used or at least a small arms or a light
- 31:40weapon being used as well. So I think it's really
- 31:43about practice and reading some of the reports
- 31:46that come out from other organizations, conflict
- 31:48arm and research again, ARIs as well, Air Wars,
- 31:54many of these great organizations do fantastic
- 31:57guides about specific munitions, about their
- 31:59use cases. And I think those that have really
- 32:02detailed information about the different components
- 32:05of munitions are fantastic as well, and that's
- 32:08really getting into depth. But otherwise, if
- 32:11there's individuals interested in really gaining
- 32:15in -depth knowledge, there are organizations
- 32:18that can provide explosive ordnance disposal
- 32:20courses. I mean, they are very expensive courses
- 32:23and very long, and obviously it's dangerous.
- 32:26It's blowing up items of explosive ordnance in
- 32:29real life. But a large constituent part of those
- 32:33courses is learning the different munitions,
- 32:36learning the different constituent parts, learning
- 32:39how to work with them safely. So it really depends,
- 32:42I guess, how much people want to learn about
- 32:46this topic. But even Explosive Arms Disposal
- 32:49courses, even if you go on a course and never
- 32:53blow up a munition again in your life, it's still
- 32:55really, really useful knowledge for research
- 32:57or OSINT work as well. Have you yourself had
- 33:03that opportunity? So working with the Halo Trust,
- 33:08I was able to go on an EOD course and so I was
- 33:12spoiled in that sense that I didn't have to pay
- 33:13it for myself. Amazing, amazing. That sounds
- 33:16so interesting. I'm guessing they give you quite
- 33:19the safety talk though. Yeah, there's a lot of
- 33:23safety talks and anybody who has been in the
- 33:26military and probably gone on the EOD course
- 33:28can talk about it as well. Um, but it's a fantastic
- 33:31experience and it's very unique as well. Um,
- 33:34but yeah, I think it really is just practice
- 33:36makes perfect and, and going through the repositories,
- 33:39some of them have, um, you know, a lot of them
- 33:41have reference images or even technical blueprints
- 33:44from any of the missions. So it can be really,
- 33:45really interesting as well. Uh, someone's asked
- 33:48in the chat, which specific courses did you get
- 33:51to go to? Yeah. So In the humanitarian mine clearance
- 33:56world, EOD is set by IMAS standards. So that's
- 34:00the International Mine Action Standards, which
- 34:04is globally recognized for humanitarian mine
- 34:06clearance. I have only done the EOD 1 course,
- 34:09which basically permits me to blow up singular
- 34:11items but not move anything or blow up multiple
- 34:16items at once. But generally, there's EOD 1,
- 34:18EOD 2, EOD 3. And then it can go up to EOD 3
- 34:22plus. and you can also do HIED course, which
- 34:26is humanitarian IED courses, which focuses specifically
- 34:30on IEDs as well. Each different military will
- 34:34have their own different classification, but
- 34:35those are the globally recognized EOD courses
- 34:37for humanitarian mine clearance, at least. Yeah,
- 34:46sorry about my enthusiasm. I mean, it sounds
- 34:48amazing, but I just want to put a PSA there.
- 34:51Please do not approach explosive ordinances just
- 34:54to see if you can blow them up in real life.
- 34:57It requires a very safe setting and people who
- 35:01know what they're doing around you and a formal
- 35:03course. So please, please do not go out and get
- 35:08blown up and then say that you did it because
- 35:09you've listened to the stage talk. Somebody's
- 35:13asked in the chat as well about Bellingcat trainings.
- 35:16We don't offer trainings on EO identification,
- 35:19unfortunately. Maybe that's something we should
- 35:20be doing. But we do offer open source research
- 35:24beginning courses and workshops. Those are announced
- 35:29on our workshops page. And there's some announced
- 35:33pretty much every quarter of the year. So keep
- 35:36your eye on there. That's where they are. Thanks
- 35:39for asking. Keep your questions coming. We've
- 35:41got about 15 minutes left and I would love to
- 35:45know what else you want to know about explosive
- 35:47ordinances. Andrew, while I have you, if you
- 35:51were going to take this guide a step further,
- 35:54obviously you did this as part of your tech fellowship
- 35:56at Bellingcat. What would you do to advance this
- 36:00guide further? What kind of information do you
- 36:04feel? maybe should have been included that wasn't.
- 36:09I mean, I think more broadly, the next step really
- 36:13is automation. And I know a lot of fantastic
- 36:16people at Bellingcat and other organizations
- 36:18are working on automating many aspects of OSINT
- 36:25more broadly. And I think object recognition
- 36:28comes into it, specifically for exposed awareness,
- 36:30object recognition comes into mind immediately.
- 36:36Even if automated tools can't identify the model
- 36:39exactly, because as I said, that's very difficult,
- 36:41I think identifying the type can be relatively
- 36:44easy. And there are fantastic NGOs such as Tech4Tracing,
- 36:47which is funded by the European Union, which
- 36:49is working with Halo actually on doing automated
- 36:52detection of anti -tank mines from drone flights.
- 36:58The focus, if I was to expand the guide, wouldn't
- 37:00really be on the guide per se, but I think on,
- 37:03for example, working on auto recognition tools
- 37:06for social media. Obviously, a lot of the amount
- 37:10of data that comes out of social media research,
- 37:14so telegram channels or even Twitter, and with
- 37:16the ability to scrape those channels now when
- 37:18download images in mass, if you're looking specifically
- 37:21for munitions type, if you could run millions
- 37:24of images that might have munitions through automatic
- 37:29recognition software that can pull out those
- 37:31images and identify the types of munitions in
- 37:35those images. I think that would be amazing,
- 37:38especially if we're talking about large scale
- 37:40conflict monitoring or investigations about munitions
- 37:43use in particular conflict zones as well. Unfortunately,
- 37:46I don't have the coding skills for that, but
- 37:49maybe someone who's listening does and can pick
- 37:52that up as a next project. I have an idea for
- 37:58how to build that. Please get in touch. Great.
- 38:05We had a few interesting questions that I think
- 38:08I can combine. Sarah's asked, what's the weirdest,
- 38:13most unexpected ordinance you've run into? And
- 38:17then we've Easy Bay Covens asked, what's the
- 38:20most interesting ordinance item or development?
- 38:22you've seen. So the most weird is the non -expected
- 38:26one and then the most interesting one and they
- 38:28could be the same thing. Yeah, I think weird
- 38:33is strange, but something I saw in Cambodia was
- 38:37three anti -tank mine, anti -tank mines stacked
- 38:41on top of each other, but buried really, really
- 38:44deep. So most landmines will be buried at about
- 38:4610 to 20 centimeters. Obviously, otherwise the
- 38:48soil will disperse the pressure effect of people
- 38:52or vehicle and then the mine won't work. But
- 38:55in the case in Cambodia, they were buried at
- 38:57about two or three meters and three stacked on
- 38:59top of each other with a wooden stick balanced
- 39:01on top of them and all buried together. And so
- 39:03the stick acting as a pressure mechanism to then
- 39:07pressure on the mines at the bottom. And they
- 39:10were buried that deep, obviously, to avoid detection,
- 39:12although even that depth. would be too deep for
- 39:17any detection, for any minefield. So I think
- 39:19that was really unexpected and strange, especially
- 39:23at that depth. I think most interesting ordinance
- 39:26developed, a lot of the more domestically made
- 39:31stuff, the 3D printed munitions are really interested.
- 39:34I know the Ukrainians are somewhat at the forefront
- 39:36of that. And I think that that presents almost
- 39:40a challenge in itself for the future as well
- 39:41because many of them are not. are not mass produced.
- 39:48And so everyone can a little bit different. I
- 39:51know, for example, during the conflict in Sri
- 39:52Lanka, there were mass produced mines in warehouses
- 39:58that were produced by the Tamil tigers, for example.
- 40:02So each mine has a different amount of explosive
- 40:03in it for it. And the body was made out of different
- 40:06pieces every time. So I think, yeah, I think
- 40:10the IEDs have always been, is probably where
- 40:13all the really interesting ordinances developed.
- 40:16But that's also really complex. But I think in
- 40:19future of more conventional warfare, some of
- 40:21the loitering munitions that are being used in
- 40:22Ukraine are fascinating and scary at the same
- 40:26time. Absolutely. I think 3D printing is going
- 40:32to change a lot of weapon identification munitions.
- 40:36We've got a few more questions coming in and
- 40:38I want to make sure that we can address them
- 40:39before the hour. Alphas asked, upon successfully
- 40:43identifying an EO, how can we begin tracing its
- 40:46origins and how it got to where it is? I think
- 40:50that's really dependent on the source material.
- 40:53And I think I mentioned this in the guide, but
- 40:55after verifying the source material and identifying
- 40:58the type of EO, if we're looking for the exact
- 41:01model, to be able to trace any origins, you kind
- 41:04of really need the exact model. And that will
- 41:06help, for example, if it's a Western produced
- 41:09munitions or ex Soviet Union or Chinese munition,
- 41:11for example. And so I think the first step really
- 41:14is, if possible, narrowing down to the exact
- 41:18model. And this is where some of the reference
- 41:20guides and other platforms such as the OSMP come
- 41:23in really handy. Because, for example, for some
- 41:27of the larger incidents on social media that
- 41:30might have already been done by, for example,
- 41:33the OSMP. I think tracing to how it got where
- 41:38it is is a much more complex investigation. If
- 41:43we're trying to understand, for example, where
- 41:44it was produced, who the manufacturer was, again,
- 41:48as I mentioned earlier, any writing on the munition
- 41:52or on fragments of the munition, that'll be the
- 41:54first go -to to identifying. the producer and
- 41:58manufacturer of the weapon. But unfortunately,
- 42:00just from imagery and social media, sometimes
- 42:02that's very difficult to do. So it's very dependent
- 42:04on the source imagery and if it's in the reference
- 42:09imagery. But yeah, I hope that helps. But basically
- 42:12the first step is to identify the exact model.
- 42:26our channel, Bombs and other killing machines.
- 42:30Sorry, Bombs, Arms, Drones and other killing
- 42:32machines. There's been a lot of discussion on
- 42:35drone use recently. So do you have any experience
- 42:39covering that and could you speak to it? This
- 42:43is blending into my PhD work, which is on essentially
- 42:46exactly this topic, which is remote delivery
- 42:49systems. And so looking at drones as a way of
- 42:53remotely mining areas and remotely delivering
- 42:55munitions. to areas. I think the Ukrainians really
- 42:58are at the forefront of this and have been, and
- 43:01as I said earlier, should have inspired by terrorist
- 43:03groups, ISIS, that were some of the first people
- 43:06to develop these drone drop munitions from conventional
- 43:10store -bought drones, DJI drones. I think the
- 43:14big difference between using those drones rather
- 43:21than larger purpose -built systems is the number.
- 43:23Obviously, many minefields are very large in
- 43:27scale. For example, the minefield on the Cambodian
- 43:30and Thai border is a few hundred kilometers and
- 43:32has many, many different layers of mines. So
- 43:36it really depends on the end goal of the mining.
- 43:40I know the Ukrainians, for example, have been
- 43:42using grenades for targeting specific vehicles,
- 43:49for example, or troops in dugouts or trenches.
- 43:55And FPV drones with attached munitions have been
- 43:58quite effective against armored vehicles. Mines
- 44:02is a bit more difficult. I know the Ukrainians
- 44:04have used them, for example, to mine areas outside
- 44:07of dugouts, for example, during the night. So
- 44:11secretly mining areas and to inflict casualties
- 44:14in the next day. But I guess it's one of the
- 44:17sort of interesting areas of conflict development
- 44:19that we'll see if it becomes standardized or
- 44:22is again more of a more of a one -off thing in
- 44:26this conflict. Probably second to last or last
- 44:32question. Michael has mentioned that they're
- 44:37really interested in learning about the workshops
- 44:40and generally related to war crimes investigations
- 44:43and identifications for that purpose. Are you
- 44:46aware of any groups or resources that are free
- 44:50or offer free or low price training. So is there
- 44:53any training that you're aware of or any resources
- 44:56that you're aware of that we haven't mentioned
- 44:58already that are available for people who are
- 45:01on lower budgets? I think really just going through
- 45:06the repository, I know I've sort of repeated
- 45:08that a few times today, but they're all, almost
- 45:12every single one of them is free. And some of
- 45:15them have really, really detailed and information
- 45:19about the munitions. And so cat UXO, for example,
- 45:22is sort of industry standard for EOD and personnel.
- 45:28And it really depends what you're trying to investigate.
- 45:31So for example, for the war, the Russian invasion
- 45:34of Ukraine, the basic identification of ammunition
- 45:36in Ukraine is a guide by bond text without borders.
- 45:39And they publish new versions every few months.
- 45:42I think they're on version seven now with any
- 45:45new munitions that they've seen. So these are
- 45:47Ukrainian EOD deminers, sappers and foreign volunteers
- 45:51conducting humanitarian demining in Ukraine that
- 45:55are collecting this information. So it's extremely
- 45:57precise. It's extremely detailed and it's from
- 46:00the ground. So it's very accurate. And then as
- 46:04again, the open source munitions portal is fantastic,
- 46:07really detailed and has the imagery as well.
- 46:13And then there is a paper book guide, which is
- 46:15available to purchase. It's called the Practical
- 46:17Military Ordinance Identification. I think it's
- 46:19on its third edition now. So that's almost a
- 46:23full book on how to identify munitions and their
- 46:27types and models. So that would obviously be
- 46:30much cheaper than a full EOD course, for example.
- 46:35But really, I think, like a lot of us, a lot
- 46:38of it can be self -taught. And it really is just
- 46:40spending time looking at the repositories and
- 46:43looking at source images on social media, you
- 46:46know, if you type Twitter, munition on Twitter,
- 46:50you'll get hundreds and hundreds and hundreds
- 46:51of recent things, recent images from the world's
- 46:56war zones that you can sort of use as practice
- 46:59cases and telegrams the same as well. And so
- 47:02I think you can try and I guess practice makes
- 47:05perfect. So you can grab an image from any from
- 47:08even maybe the OSMP, but not read what it is.
- 47:10immediately and then try and identify it yourself
- 47:13and check if you've done it correctly. That's
- 47:15probably a fun task to do. Absolutely. I've just
- 47:20shared the repository again, the Bellingcat one,
- 47:23the one that you made, and also the Chord Search
- 47:28one as well. Those are both within the chat right
- 47:33now, so please check them out. They're also within
- 47:35the guide though, along with many other really
- 47:37useful resources within there. Please do check
- 47:40that out. Sorry, go ahead, Andrew. Yeah, one
- 47:45thing I'd just add is there is also a lot of
- 47:48historical guides that are quite interested.
- 47:50For example, soldiers in the Second World War,
- 47:52many of them were handed out booklets and leaflets
- 47:54about identifying munitions, and those can be
- 47:57found in PDFs online as well. So there's a lot
- 48:01of materials out there as well. So it really,
- 48:04really depends what you're trying to... trying
- 48:06to identify as well. But it's like studying textbooks
- 48:10almost. Yeah, the potato fields just shared the
- 48:14practical military ordinance identification book,
- 48:18which is really useful. Thanks for sharing that
- 48:21in the chat. Last question, because we've spoken
- 48:24about misinformation and disinformation and how
- 48:26that kind of spots the reasoning behind, well,
- 48:29one of the reasons why you thought the beginner's
- 48:31guide was needed. What happens if you... have,
- 48:35think you've identified something, maybe you've
- 48:38used the key, but you've misidentified it. You've
- 48:42seen something that wasn't there and you've maybe
- 48:46posted about it or shared that finding. What
- 48:49do you do then? How do you deal with that kind
- 48:52of situation? I think this is where volunteer
- 48:57communities are just more widely the OSINT community
- 49:00comes in really handy. I mean, like Billing Tats
- 49:02Discord, but more broadly as well. I think a
- 49:05lot of the OSINT community is very open -minded,
- 49:07is very sort of encouraging in terms of learning
- 49:10and corrections. And so I think, you know, double
- 49:13checking with communities like the Bellingcat
- 49:16Discord. Getting a second opinion is always,
- 49:19you know, it never hurts in any case as well,
- 49:21especially before sharing it more broadly as
- 49:23a result of investigation. I think it's always
- 49:27good to get another pair of eyes on that. I'm
- 49:32part of the Bellingcat group as well, so you
- 49:34can always reach me on the Discord, but there's
- 49:36dozens of experts both in Bellingcat and in the
- 49:40group that... I'm sure we'd be more than happy
- 49:42to double check munitions identification as well.
- 49:46So yeah, double checking can never hurt. Hopefully
- 49:50you're not inundated with images of landmines
- 49:53now in the next few hours. Thank you so much,
- 49:58Andro, for this amazing talk. I think a lot of
- 50:01people in the audience really appreciated it.
- 50:04We've gone through a lot of different things.
- 50:06a lot of information all at once. But if you
- 50:10want to recap, you can listen back because this
- 50:12has been already recorded and you can have a
- 50:15read of Andrew's fantastic guide that he wrote
- 50:18a year ago and has come back kindly to chat about
- 50:22today. So thank you so much, Andrew. I will end
- 50:27the recording now and thank you again to everybody
- 50:29who attended at the beginning and had some issues
- 50:33when we had some issues with connection as well.
- 50:38Thank you very much. Thank you all for joining.
- 50:41Please do feel free to reach out if you want
- 50:43any help. Thank you for listening to the stage
- 50:47talk. If you'd like to catch a stage talk live
- 50:50where you can ask the guest questions, join the
- 50:54Bellingcat Discord server by visiting www .discord
- 50:58.gg slash Bellingcat. The music you've heard
- 51:03is titled Dawn by Newer Self. and is courtesy
- 51:06of Artlist.