Latest / CLEs You Actually Want to Hear / Employment Termination and Disability Coverage: A Guide for Attorneys with Stacy Monahan
Transcript
- 0:02Welcome to Employment Termination and Disability
- 0:06Coverage, a Guide for Attorneys. My name is Liza
- 0:09Goldenberg, and I'm a member with the BHBA, and
- 0:12I am delighted to introduce today's speaker,
- 0:15Stacey Monahan -Tucker. Stacey is the founding
- 0:19partner of Monahan -Tucker Law, where she represents
- 0:22insureds in complex disability, life, long -term
- 0:26care and catastrophic property insurance disputes.
- 0:30With a career spanning more than two decades,
- 0:33she is a seasoned trial attorney recognized for
- 0:35her expertise in ERISA and insurance bad faith
- 0:39litigation at the most sophisticated levels.
- 0:42She is also a trusted advocate in high value
- 0:45claims involving significant financial and personal
- 0:48stakes for her clients. And without further ado,
- 0:52let's get started. I'm Stacey, and it's no secret
- 0:59that there have been an enormous amount of layoffs
- 1:03throughout the United States over the past six
- 1:06months. That is the impetus for this topic. I've
- 1:13seen a number of questions both from potential
- 1:16clients and from people working in human resources
- 1:21about how these layoffs affect employees. So
- 1:26we're going to walk through that a little bit.
- 1:29If we can go to the first slide. The first question
- 1:37is what are the disability benefits that people
- 1:40get through their employment and how do they
- 1:43work? Many employers, especially large employers,
- 1:47offer them as part of a package of benefits,
- 1:50people generally focus on their health insurance
- 1:52and don't look at the other benefits until they
- 1:55need them. So we're going to briefly walk through
- 1:58how disability benefits work when you get them
- 2:02through your employment. Most of the time, disability
- 2:06benefits obtained through work are governed by
- 2:09the Employee Retirement Income Security Act of
- 2:121984, which is known as ERISA. That covers probably
- 2:1790 percent of the employers in the United States.
- 2:22Benefits are not governed by ERISA if the employer
- 2:25is a government agency, and that includes local
- 2:29government, state government, or federal government.
- 2:32So we're talking about schools, police, fire
- 2:35departments, state -owned utilities. Interestingly,
- 2:40if teachers don't get their benefits directly
- 2:44from the actual state, but get it from a union
- 2:51that represents them or police or fire, get them
- 2:53from unions. Sometimes that can be subject to
- 2:56ERISA. So interesting aside there, it takes some
- 2:58analysis. Also, if the employer is a religious
- 3:04organization, it's not subject to ERISA. That
- 3:07doesn't just include churches and synagogues
- 3:09and such like, it includes businesses owned by
- 3:12them. In our economy, that most usually occurs
- 3:16with hospitals and health systems. So if you
- 3:19work for a hospital or health system that's owned
- 3:21by the church or affiliated with the church,
- 3:24it is possible that your benefits are not subject
- 3:26to ERISA. The third situation is if the employer
- 3:30self -funds the benefits. Most of the time, employers
- 3:34obtain and provide benefits by contracting with
- 3:37an insurance company. They get a master group
- 3:40policy with an insurance company, and that insurance
- 3:43company accepts premiums from all of the employees,
- 3:48sometimes paid by the employees directly, sometimes
- 3:51paid by the employer directly, sometimes a mix
- 3:54to provide coverage. If the employer decides
- 4:00not to work with an outside insurance company,
- 4:04but to fund the benefits themselves, those are
- 4:07not subject to ERISA. Also, especially with higher
- 4:12salaried senior executives, employers can offer
- 4:17individual disability policies that those employees
- 4:21can choose as well. Depending how those individual
- 4:25disability policies are offered, they are usually
- 4:28not subject to ERISA, but it depends on the facts.
- 4:33So a lot of this, as you can hear, is subject
- 4:37to the usual lawyer response. It depends. For
- 4:42the most part, and for the purposes of this discussion
- 4:45today, we're going to be talking largely about
- 4:47ERISA because most of the benefits that employers
- 4:51are managing and employees are receiving, they
- 4:55receive subject to ERISA. Let's go on to the
- 4:59next slide. So I just explained that they may
- 5:08or may not be subject to ERISA, but The obvious
- 5:11question is why does that matter? Why does anyone
- 5:13care if it's subject to ERISA or not? It matters
- 5:17because ERISA was originally designed to make
- 5:23it easy for employers to offer benefits so that
- 5:29they wouldn't be dealing with massive amounts
- 5:33of lawsuits. They wouldn't be dealing with massive
- 5:35amounts of pushback from employees about not
- 5:40doing it correctly. So ERISA offers a very clear
- 5:44structure for doing this. And if it gets to litigation,
- 5:48the litigation rules around ERISA are very different
- 5:51than traditional litigation. The intent of that
- 5:54was to encourage employers to offer benefits,
- 5:57which employers don't have to offer, right? it's
- 6:01a benefit they offer. And the government realized
- 6:05that more and more employees were relying on
- 6:09work for their welfare related benefits, and
- 6:13they wanted to encourage employers to offer these.
- 6:16So ERISA is part of the way in which the government
- 6:19encourages employers to offer benefits with the
- 6:23intent of making it easy for employers to do
- 6:25so and limiting their exposure. In reality, over
- 6:30the past 50 plus years, employers usually aren't
- 6:35offering the benefits themselves. It's an insurance
- 6:38company that's offering them and the employer
- 6:40contracts with the insurance company. Over the
- 6:43course of time, courts have agreed that the insurance
- 6:46company is usually the proper defendant in any
- 6:50lawsuit. That means that for practical purposes,
- 6:53The insurance companies are the ones benefiting
- 6:55from the limited exposure and streamlined litigation
- 7:00approach related to ERISA. The employers don't
- 7:04get sued related to this or at least. Not usually.
- 7:07Usually these days, it's the insurance company
- 7:10that is sued. And the insurance company benefits
- 7:13tremendously from not having to go through the
- 7:16traditional litigation process and not having
- 7:19to pay all the costs associated with the traditional
- 7:21litigation process and the exposure to additional
- 7:25damages that can occur in traditional litigation.
- 7:30It has resulted in insurance companies having
- 7:34a strong incentive to deny claims because most
- 7:40people don't want to reach out and obtain an
- 7:43attorney and most people don't want to bring
- 7:45suit. So the suits related to these denials,
- 7:52insurance companies have come to accept them
- 7:53as part of the cost of doing business. And here's
- 7:57some of the differences between ERISA and non
- 7:59ERISA and why it matters for how employees are
- 8:03getting these benefits in the first place. There
- 8:06are very strict regulations related to time limits
- 8:09and requirements that affect both the insured
- 8:11and the insurer. ERISA. most of the time preempts
- 8:16state contract law. And there are detailed analyses
- 8:19that go into that. And this is not a seminar
- 8:21on how ERISA works. So we're not gonna delve
- 8:24into that, but most of the time it preempts state
- 8:28contract law. There's no exposure to punitive
- 8:31damages or future benefits. if you are ordered
- 8:35by a court to pay benefits, if you're an insurance
- 8:38company. The most a court can require is that
- 8:41the insurance company pay back benefits and that
- 8:44they reinstate or in -state benefits for so long
- 8:48as the insured remains disabled, according to
- 8:51the insurance company. Most of the time under
- 8:54ERISA, there's no discovery. The cases are limited
- 8:58to the claim file or what's known as the administrative
- 9:02record, which is the documents that the insurance
- 9:04company relied on in making its determination.
- 9:07There are no witnesses. There's also no jury.
- 9:11It's a bench trial decided by a judge with no
- 9:15witnesses, completely reliant on the information
- 9:18in the administrative record. So if it's not
- 9:21in the administrative record, the judge is not
- 9:23supposed to look at it. As we discussed, there's
- 9:27an incentive for insurers to deny claims because
- 9:30there's no penalty for them for doing this. The
- 9:33worst that can happen is that they'll have to
- 9:35pay the benefits that they would have paid anyway.
- 9:38Because ERISA is federal law, the lawsuits must
- 9:42be brought in federal court. It's not based on
- 9:46diversity jurisdiction. It's based on federal
- 9:48law jurisdiction. If the insurance is determined
- 9:52to be non -ERISA, then it's subject to the state
- 9:56contract and tort law of the state in which the
- 9:59lawsuit is brought. It's a traditional litigation.
- 10:03It has discovery and discovery disputes. It has
- 10:06witnesses. It has experts and it has a jury.
- 10:10There is exposure to punitive damages and bad
- 10:13faith damages and Depending on the state you're
- 10:16in if your state allows it judges can order the
- 10:20payment of future benefits as part of punitive
- 10:23damages as a deterrent to insurance companies
- 10:27Go ahead and pull down the next slide Now Under
- 10:39ERISA, just like non -ERISA, the contract language
- 10:42generally controls. But if the contract does
- 10:47not align with ERISA, then ERISA would control.
- 10:52Because of this, generally speaking, insurance
- 10:54companies are well aware of this. ERISA is national
- 10:57law. Most contracts are going to align with ERISA.
- 11:02Under ERISA, an insured has to appeal within
- 11:04180 days of a denial of their claim. They can't
- 11:09bring suit without first appealing. If you try
- 11:12to avoid the appeal and you wait more than six
- 11:18months and you bring suit without appealing,
- 11:21you forfeit your right to bring suit. You have
- 11:24to exhaust your administrative remedies, which
- 11:26is appealing. So it's very important for Anyone
- 11:31who is bringing suit or advising somebody about
- 11:35their claim that's been denied, they have to
- 11:38appeal within six months. An insurance company
- 11:42has to decide a claim within 45 days of receipt
- 11:46of the claim. They are allowed to take extensions,
- 11:49but the insurance company has to notify the insured
- 11:52in writing, explain the reason for the extension,
- 11:54and when they anticipate making a decision. claims
- 12:00denied, the insurer has 45 days to decide an
- 12:04appeal once it's submitted, but they can take
- 12:07an additional 45 days in what ERISA describes
- 12:10as unusual circumstances. If the insurer misses
- 12:14their deadline, the claim is deemed denied under
- 12:17ERISA and the insured can either appeal if they
- 12:20missed their, if the initial deadline for making
- 12:23a claim decision was missed or they can bring
- 12:26suit if the appeal deadline was missed by the
- 12:28insurance company. The insurance company is required
- 12:32to provide a copy of the claim file after a denial
- 12:34and if an appeal is upheld. And that has to include
- 12:40any internal policies and procedures the insurance
- 12:43company relied on. The insurer and the employer
- 12:46are required under ERISA to provide copies of
- 12:49all plan -related documents within 30 days of
- 12:51a request. The employer, not the insurance company,
- 12:55only the employer, is subject to fines of up
- 12:57to $110 a day if it fails to comply. It's important
- 13:01to note that this regulation applies to both
- 13:04current and former employees who request this
- 13:07documentation. I've had a number of situations
- 13:10where clients have informed me that their employer
- 13:13has refused to provide this documentation because
- 13:15they're no longer employed there. That is irrelevant
- 13:18under ERISA. If they are potentially covered
- 13:21by the insurance, which we'll talk about in this
- 13:24presentation, then they are entitled to this
- 13:29documentation. So you have to provide it upon
- 13:32request. Meanwhile, if this is a non -ARISA claim,
- 13:38then the contract language controls subject to
- 13:41state laws such as the notice prejudice doctrine,
- 13:44which we're gonna talk about coming up. And let's
- 13:48go to the next slide. I think this is the same
- 13:59slide. Thanks. We talked a little bit about ERISA
- 14:08litigation. The appropriate defendants according
- 14:12to ERISA are the insurance company and or the
- 14:15plan, which is a separate legal entity under
- 14:18ERISA. The plan is owned by the employer and
- 14:23the employer usually handles the litigation if
- 14:26it's brought against the plan, but the plan is
- 14:28a separate legal entity. Most of the time these
- 14:32days, the insurer is the one who is the defendant.
- 14:37Most group disability contracts grant the insurance
- 14:41company what's called discretion to decide claims.
- 14:44This allows courts or requires courts, I should
- 14:48say. to review the claims under what's called
- 14:51the abuse of discretion standard. That means
- 14:54that the judge has to decide not if the insurer
- 14:57was right or wrong in denying the claim, but
- 15:00if it was manifestly unreasonable. That means
- 15:03they have to give weight to the insurance company's
- 15:09discretion. If there's a reasonable basis that
- 15:14the insurer could have decided to deny a claim,
- 15:16if it could have gone either way, the court under
- 15:19this standard is required to support the insurer's
- 15:22discretion in making that call. In several states
- 15:26around the country, especially in the Ninth Circuit,
- 15:29laws have been passed banning these discretionary
- 15:32clauses. Without the discretionary language,
- 15:35courts apply the de novo standard of review,
- 15:37and that means that the judge reads the claim
- 15:40file, and decides based on that administrative
- 15:42record whether the benefits should be approved
- 15:45or denied. The opinion of the insurance company
- 15:48is irrelevant. It's just based on the facts in
- 15:51the file. In the Ninth Circuit, California passed
- 15:56the California Insurance Code 10110 .6, which
- 16:02bans discretionary clauses. Oregon has it, Washington,
- 16:07Montana, and Hawaii and Alaska have it, but they
- 16:11haven't issued official rules or code changes.
- 16:15They've done it based on their insurance commissioner's
- 16:19interpretation of existing rules that the language
- 16:22is confusing and not straightforward and that
- 16:27it violates the intent of insurance policies.
- 16:31Idaho also has an insurance rule that covers
- 16:34this for obvious reasons. de novo review is better
- 16:39for plaintiffs instead of abuse of discretion,
- 16:42where abuse of discretion gives additional weight
- 16:46to the insurance company's weighing of the evidence
- 16:49compared to the judge's weighing of the evidence.
- 16:52So it's a benefit to insureds, to employees,
- 16:56to plaintiffs to have their claim reviewed under
- 16:59de novo review. And let's go to the next slide.
- 17:10And one of the first questions that I hear from
- 17:14people who call me up with concerns about finding
- 17:17out that they're being terminated while they're
- 17:19on disability, can they be terminated while they're
- 17:22on an active disability claim? The simple answer
- 17:25is yes. Yes, you can be terminated while you're
- 17:27on a disability claim. I am not an employment
- 17:31attorney. So I'm going to cover the basics of
- 17:34this, but If you have concerns that you are being
- 17:39singled out or that a potential client is being
- 17:41singled out based solely on their disability,
- 17:44you will want to talk with an employment attorney
- 17:46about that. In general, you can't single out
- 17:49an employee for termination solely because they
- 17:52filed for disability. First, If you're an employer
- 17:57and you're subject to the Family and Medical
- 18:00Leave Act, then you cannot terminate them during
- 18:03the 12 weeks of protection provided by that act.
- 18:07If you are not subject to it, then that employee
- 18:10doesn't have protection under it, but you still
- 18:13want to be very careful just as a practical matter
- 18:15that you're not immediately terminating somebody
- 18:18because they are disabled. The American with
- 18:22Disabilities Act protects employees who can work
- 18:25with reasonable accommodations. So as an employer,
- 18:28you have to consider reasonable accommodations.
- 18:31They're fact -based. They're determined by the
- 18:33individual employer and the accommodations requested
- 18:35by the employee. For some employees, asking to
- 18:38work from home remotely is a completely reasonable
- 18:40accommodation, depending on the type of work
- 18:42they do. For others, it's completely impossible.
- 18:46It depends on the facts related to the job. And
- 18:49that needs to be considered by any employer that
- 18:53is dealing with an employee who becomes disabled.
- 18:59Let's go to the next slide. So if you are an
- 19:10employee or an employer, and you issue notice
- 19:14of impending layoff or impending termination,
- 19:17that employee, all the employees who receive
- 19:19those are still covered by their group benefits
- 19:21until their last day of work. So they can make
- 19:26a disability claim after receiving notice of
- 19:29termination. Obviously that disability claim
- 19:32can't be ginned up out of thin air. The employee
- 19:39is going to have to demonstrate that they are
- 19:42disabled under the terms of the policy, they'll
- 19:45need physician support, they'll need medical
- 19:47records. But it is completely possible and appropriate
- 19:51under the law for employees to bring disability
- 19:56claims under their policies right up to, and
- 19:59we'll discuss even after they are terminated,
- 20:03so long as that disability began prior to termination
- 20:07while they were. employed by the employer and
- 20:10covered by the policy. If an employee is on disability
- 20:17and a new disability arises, the insurance company
- 20:21is responsible for that new disability as well,
- 20:24kind of the eggshell plaintiff concept. You are
- 20:28responsible for what you get if you have an an
- 20:32insured who is disabled, let's say based on mental
- 20:35health, and then they're hit by a car, the insurance
- 20:37company is responsible for continuing benefits
- 20:40based on that new disability as well. And once
- 20:45an insured is determined to no longer be disabled
- 20:48by the insurer, if the insured has left employment,
- 20:53then they are no longer covered by their benefits.
- 20:57They can't then make a new claim for a different
- 21:00if they're determined to be not disabled, they
- 21:04appeal, the appeals denied, they don't sue, they
- 21:06cannot then get hit by that car six months later
- 21:10and try to make a claim under that same insurance
- 21:12policy. They are not covered by it if they are
- 21:14no longer employed. Go ahead and go to the next
- 21:18slide, please. When employees are terminated
- 21:25or large layoffs occur, severance agreements
- 21:29are usually involved. The severance agreement
- 21:32is going to affect how the employee can access
- 21:38these benefits. The general, very broad language
- 21:44that's included in most severance agreements
- 21:45includes language about waiving their rights
- 21:49under all sorts of potential scenarios. ERISA
- 21:53is generally thrown in there as part of a laundry
- 21:57list. those severance agreements waive the employee's
- 22:04ability to bring suit under ERISA. Depending
- 22:09on how it's worded, it may or may not clearly
- 22:12include the employer's insurance companies and
- 22:16insurers and agents as well. If it doesn't, then
- 22:21there's a lot more question about whether or
- 22:23not an employee's waived their rights under ERISA.
- 22:27an employee who is out on disability or who is
- 22:31in the process of making a claim, who asks to
- 22:34have that carved out, that's a reasonable request
- 22:38because if they waive their right under ERISA,
- 22:40then they're not able to enforce their coverage
- 22:43under the existing policy. I've actually had
- 22:49a case on this before I represented plaintiffs,
- 22:52I represented insurance companies for many years.
- 22:56We had a case, which we're going to talk about,
- 23:00Perez Jones versus Liberty Life Assurance Company
- 23:03back in 2016, where the insured had been on disability
- 23:09for a few years, and she signed a severance agreement
- 23:13in the middle of her disability. out for a couple
- 23:17of years, there was a merger, she got laid off,
- 23:21and she was going to be, she wanted that payout,
- 23:26but she also wanted to stay on her benefits.
- 23:29And let's go to the next slide, because the next
- 23:31slide talks about this a bit more. So Perez Jones
- 23:35was a banker, and her bank was bought in a couple
- 23:39of different mergers, ending up being owned by
- 23:42Wells Fargo. And in 2008, I believe, that merger
- 23:49occurred and she was out on disability at the
- 23:51time. And she'd been out for about two years
- 23:55and her severance that was offered to her was
- 23:58pretty significant. It was over a year of salary
- 24:01and she wanted that. She wanted that severance
- 24:08payment, however. Wells Fargo set it up so that
- 24:11she could only receive the severance payment
- 24:14once she came back from disability leave. She
- 24:17could be on leave as long as she needed, but
- 24:20she wanted to get that money now. In order to
- 24:26get the money now, she had to come back off of
- 24:28leave. Coming back off leave meant she was no
- 24:31longer disabled. She called the insurance company
- 24:34several times, first told her that there might
- 24:36be a severance agreement and wanted to know what
- 24:39that would look like. Insurance companies said,
- 24:42it depends on what the agreement says. Send us
- 24:44a copy and we'll look at it and tell you how
- 24:45it would affect your benefits. She did not do
- 24:47that. Instead, she called back and said, it looks
- 24:50like I'm not going to take the severance agreement.
- 24:52It looks like I might be able to come back to
- 24:54work. Tell me what a successive disability claim
- 24:57looks like. Under a successive claim, you can
- 25:00try to go back to work. And if you're not able
- 25:02to, because your health doesn't allow it, you
- 25:04can go back out on claim again based on the original
- 25:09claim. It's viewed as a continuation of the original
- 25:11claim. So Liberty explained that to Perez Jones,
- 25:16and she told Wells Fargo that she was coming
- 25:21back to work. Her doctor released her to come
- 25:23back to work. She came back for one day. to sign
- 25:27the severance agreement and get the benefits
- 25:30she did not tell liberty life she signed a severance
- 25:33agreement and as soon as the check cleared she
- 25:37made a successive disability claim told liberty
- 25:40she tried to go back to work it didn't work out
- 25:42she couldn't do it and she went back on disability
- 25:45for two more years liberty eventually terminated
- 25:48her benefits and she brought suit saying that
- 25:52her benefits should have continued During the
- 25:54suit, Liberty learned for the first time about
- 25:56the severance agreement and argued that she was
- 26:00not able to seek these benefits because she waived
- 26:03them under ERISA. The court ended up having an
- 26:06entire mini trial in the Arisa case with witnesses
- 26:11and discovery to determine whether or not she
- 26:15had knowingly and willfully signed away her Arisa
- 26:19rights. The court considered the plaintiff's
- 26:21education and business sophistication, the roles
- 26:24of the employer and the employee in negotiating
- 26:27the agreement. how clear the agreement was about
- 26:30the waiver, how much time the plaintiff had to
- 26:32review it, whether the plaintiff had the ability
- 26:35to consult counsel and how much money she was
- 26:38paid for the waiver. The court ultimately decided
- 26:42that she had knowingly and intentionally waived
- 26:44her rights and therefore she could not bring
- 26:48suit and she lost. Her counsel appealed and the
- 26:53Ninth Circuit agreed. But they looked at it a
- 26:56little differently. They said you never needed
- 26:58to get to the question of the severance agreement
- 27:00in this situation. Because when Perez Jones came
- 27:03back to work and accepted her severance and quit,
- 27:08she no longer had coverage under the policy and
- 27:10could not make a recurring disability claim.
- 27:14She wasn't covered anymore. And so therefore,
- 27:17the severance agreement was irrelevant. Once
- 27:19she quit and wasn't working, she could not then
- 27:23claim disability that started after she stopped
- 27:27working. Let's go on to the next slide. So can
- 27:38an employee make a disability claim after learning
- 27:41of your impending termination? Yes. Courts have
- 27:44been very clear about this. Insurance companies
- 27:48like to argue that they're obviously not disabled
- 27:50because they've been working How are you disabled
- 27:53if you're also working? Courts have repeatedly
- 27:55held that there's no logical incompatibility
- 27:58between working full -time and being disabled.
- 28:01Many people, because of economic realities, force
- 28:05themselves to work even though they meet the
- 28:07definition of disability under the governing
- 28:10policy. And the fact that the plaintiff was physically
- 28:13at work doesn't mean that the plaintiff couldn't
- 28:16also be disabled on that date or even earlier.
- 28:20there's no bright line rule that an employee
- 28:23must claim disability before being terminated
- 28:27to receive long -term benefits. So yes, an employee
- 28:31can find out that they're being terminated and
- 28:34then make a disability claim. Employers are often
- 28:38very surprised to hear this, but it's extremely
- 28:41clear under the law. They are allowed to do this.
- 28:43They of course have to demonstrate that they
- 28:46have evidence of this disability. They have physician
- 28:50support of the disability. But oftentimes, one
- 28:53of the reasons people are getting fired or getting
- 28:55included in a layoff is that they weren't working
- 28:57up to their employer's expectations. Oftentimes,
- 29:01that's because their disability didn't enable
- 29:04them to do so. Let's go on to the next slide.
- 29:12Next question. Can a former employee make a retroactive
- 29:16claim for benefits under ERISA or a non -ERISA
- 29:18policy after leaving the company? And the answer
- 29:21again is yes. There are many cases out there
- 29:25that have held this, the most recent of which
- 29:27just came out in May, Dharmasena versus Metropolitan
- 29:31Life. In this case, the plaintiff had muscular
- 29:34dystrophy and kidney disease. He worked despite
- 29:37these issues using a walker and orthotic devices.
- 29:41He loved his job. He wanted to do his job. He
- 29:44put himself in enormous discomfort to do his
- 29:47job. He was included in the layoff and was terminated.
- 29:52After the layoff and after being terminated,
- 29:54he made a claim for disability benefits, stating
- 29:57that he had been disabled while he was employed.
- 30:00The insurer denied it, saying that he obviously
- 30:03had been able to work as demonstrated by the
- 30:05fact that he had been working and that he worked
- 30:07right up until the date of his termination. The
- 30:10court, meanwhile, disagreed. The court reviewed
- 30:13his medical records and noted that yes, he was
- 30:17terminated on February 4th and so stopped working,
- 30:20but he could be disabled while still working.
- 30:24The court held that the last day of work and
- 30:26the date of disability are distinct analyses.
- 30:30And since the insurance company didn't look at
- 30:33it that way, the retroactive claim was permitted.
- 30:36so long as the record evidence supports disability
- 30:40before the last day of work. So that's the issue
- 30:45that has to be reviewed here. Did the disability
- 30:49begin before the last day of employment? Not
- 30:52did you bring the claim by the last day of the
- 30:57employment? Did the disability begin before the
- 31:00last day of employment? That's what the court
- 31:03looks at and that's what anybody making a claim
- 31:06needs to look at. And human resources departments
- 31:09who are asked questions about this by their employees
- 31:14need to understand this as well. Yes, an employee
- 31:18can call back after being terminated, after no
- 31:21longer working there and ask for the information
- 31:26about how to make a claim. And yes, the... the
- 31:29human resources department has to provide that.
- 31:32If the human resources department refuses to
- 31:34provide it, they can be held responsible for
- 31:37that $110 a day fine for the employer not providing
- 31:42the plan documents and plan information. Let's
- 31:46go on to the next slide. So most insurance policies
- 31:57include a time limit by which you have to promptly
- 32:01make a claim. They also include requirements
- 32:06saying that it has to be a claim or litigation
- 32:08has to be brought within X number of years after
- 32:13knowing of the basis for the claim. Insurance
- 32:17companies point to these as a basis for the claim
- 32:21not being able to be brought retroactively, saying
- 32:24that it's too late, you don't have coverage.
- 32:27How that's going to be determined is a state
- 32:31-by -state question. Many states, including in
- 32:36the Ninth Circuit, have adopted what's called
- 32:40the notice prejudice doctrine. It's a state law
- 32:43doctrine that holds that an insurer cannot refuse
- 32:46a late claim just because it's late unless the
- 32:50insurer can demonstrate actual and substantial
- 32:53prejudice because of the late submission. all
- 32:56the states in the ninth circuit except Idaho
- 32:58have adopted this doctrine. That means that all
- 33:02of the states in the ninth circuit except Idaho
- 33:06require their insurance companies to accept and
- 33:10review a late claim. Now, the insurance company
- 33:13can look at this and say, we are actually and
- 33:17substantially prejudiced because we don't have
- 33:20the opportunity to examine you. in real time,
- 33:25at the time you claim your disability began.
- 33:27We don't know what your physical capability actually
- 33:32was two or three years ago when you claimed to
- 33:34have become disabled. We've been prejudiced by
- 33:37having that ability taken away from us. Courts
- 33:41will look at the actual... information in the
- 33:46record in determining whether or not they think
- 33:48that's a reasonable argument for the insurer.
- 33:49It's going to be fact -based depending on the
- 33:52disability and the documentation of it. But that
- 33:56is the kind of actual and substantial prejudice
- 33:58that the insurance company can argue when dealing
- 34:03with these notice prejudice claims. Notice prejudice,
- 34:07by the way, not preempted by ERISA. The US Supreme
- 34:11Court confirmed that back in 1999. So it does
- 34:14apply to ERISA as well as non -ERISA claims.
- 34:18And let's go to the next slide. So when do former
- 34:28employees bring late disability claims? It can
- 34:31happen years after leaving a company. Generally
- 34:35speaking, the typical situation is when an employee
- 34:39is having a hard time getting a diagnosis. When
- 34:42something's wrong, They've been treating for
- 34:45their symptoms for years, often trying to get
- 34:50somebody to figure out what's wrong with them,
- 34:53why they're unwell, why they're exhausted. Oftentimes,
- 34:57it can take years to get the correct diagnosis.
- 35:01Insurance and employees can bring claim for disability
- 35:05without having a diagnosis. Disability is based
- 35:09in the symptoms, not the diagnosis, but most
- 35:13people don't realize this. And most insurance
- 35:16companies push back quite a bit if there's no
- 35:18actual diagnosis, saying that if you don't have
- 35:20a diagnosis, how do you show there's something
- 35:22really wrong with you? So it's a bit of a catch
- 35:24-22 for these employees or insurers who are having
- 35:29symptoms. Nobody's been able to tell them what's
- 35:31wrong with them or how to treat it. One of the
- 35:35requirements under most disability insurance
- 35:37policies is regular treatment by a physician.
- 35:40Being under the ongoing regular treatment of
- 35:42a physician, that can be hard if your physicians
- 35:46don't know what's wrong with you. You tend to
- 35:48bounce back and forth around with different doctors,
- 35:52having different reviews, different opinions,
- 35:56different recommended treatments. So oftentimes,
- 36:01an employee may not realize that they're disabled
- 36:04until years after their symptoms begin. They
- 36:08may not understand that they have a claim. And
- 36:11courts have been very clear the fact that a diagnosis
- 36:15is not made contemporaneously within the time
- 36:19that the claimant's insured. doesn't undercut
- 36:22the viability of a later diagnosis based on medically
- 36:25acceptable techniques. The diagnosis can be properly
- 36:28made several years subsequent to the onset of
- 36:30disability. And in those situations, an insured
- 36:34can indeed bring a late claim and the insurance
- 36:39company has to review it. The employer has to
- 36:44provide the documents allowing them to make the
- 36:47claim. They have to provide the plan information
- 36:50so that the former employee has the correct information.
- 36:54There is a lot of case law out there confirming
- 36:57this and it's important to understand that this
- 37:01is where you have to be. You're opening yourself
- 37:07up to litigation as an employer if you refuse
- 37:09to do this, and you're opening yourself up to
- 37:12litigation as an insurance company if you refuse
- 37:15to review these claims. Most of the litigation
- 37:18around these stems from situations where the
- 37:23employer or the insurer simply refused to consider
- 37:27the claim, said, nope, it's too late, we're not
- 37:29going to look at it. They did not understand
- 37:32the requirements and they have now been spelled
- 37:34out repeatedly in case law that yes, you have
- 37:39to do this. Go ahead and move on to the next
- 37:42slide. So we've talked about the situations in
- 37:50which an employee can make a claim. What does
- 37:54that employer insured need to show regardless
- 37:57of how long it's been? or how recent it's been.
- 38:02You have to demonstrate that you were experiencing
- 38:05your disabling symptoms prior to your last day
- 38:09of work. You need physician support of that disability,
- 38:14physicians that are treating you saying that
- 38:17you became disabled on or prior to your last
- 38:21day of work. And disability is a contract term.
- 38:27it's determined by the language in the insurance
- 38:29policy. Usually that language says something
- 38:33about the inability to perform the material duties
- 38:36of the insured's own occupation or regular occupation
- 38:39for at least the first two years of coverage.
- 38:42If it's short -term disability, oftentimes it's
- 38:45their own job that they have to show that they're
- 38:47disabled from. That means that whatever the requirements
- 38:52of that particular job are, employee can't perform
- 38:58the material duties, then they can't do that
- 39:01job. So if that material, if that one job requires
- 39:06the employee to physically be in the office,
- 39:09and for whatever reason, based on their disability,
- 39:12they can't, then the fact that they could potentially
- 39:16work from home doesn't matter. They're disabled
- 39:18from that job. Occupation. opens it up a little
- 39:23bit more and the insurance companies push hard
- 39:25on this, arguing that the occupation as performed
- 39:30generally in society isn't limited to what a
- 39:32particular employer requires. And they try to
- 39:37broaden that as much as possible saying that
- 39:39just because you can't work for the requirements
- 39:41of this company doesn't mean you couldn't work
- 39:43doing the same occupation for different requirements
- 39:46imposed by a different company. Judges tend to
- 39:50be a little skeptical of this argument. And if
- 39:53the insurer refuses to review the actual job
- 39:57description of the actual employer, it usually
- 40:00goes poorly for them. This is another reason
- 40:03it's important for employers to have job descriptions
- 40:07for their employees and to provide them to the
- 40:09employee upon request, because the employee needs
- 40:11to rely on that in making any claim for disability.
- 40:14They have to be able to point to this. Part of
- 40:19what you need to be able to show when you're
- 40:22disabled testing Like we said physician support
- 40:28medical records a lot of times depending on the
- 40:34Policy there may be a two -year limitation in
- 40:37place for self -reported symptoms. So if the
- 40:41disability is based primarily in what's considered
- 40:45self -reported symptoms like fatigue or pain,
- 40:49then headaches are an excellent example. People
- 40:51disabled by migraines. Insurance companies argue
- 40:55that that's subject to the two -year limitation
- 40:58for self -reported symptoms. Whether or not that
- 41:03actually is correct, courts go back and forth
- 41:06on arguing that many symptoms can be objectively
- 41:10determined with testing. Pain, for example, can
- 41:15be objectively determined by testing. It really
- 41:18depends on the type of disability that the insured
- 41:23has claimed and the type of testing available
- 41:25for it. Let's go on to the next slide. So if
- 41:35you are an insured and you've made your claim,
- 41:39and maybe benefits were paid for a while and
- 41:41denied or maybe they were denied from the get
- 41:43-go and you appeal and your appeal is denied,
- 41:49you then the next step and the only step available
- 41:51to you is bringing suit. So the question is,
- 41:55what does that look like? Under ERISA, venue
- 42:00technically is appropriate anywhere in the country.
- 42:04However, if the insurance company doesn't want
- 42:09to be sued in a particular area, the insurance
- 42:12company can bring a motion to change venue, arguing
- 42:15that the venue is inconvenient. And so that typically
- 42:21happens when the insurance company doesn't want
- 42:24to be sued in what they view as a more beneficial
- 42:28to the plaintiff jurisdiction. So let's say that
- 42:31you are an employee in Massachusetts and you
- 42:37file suit and you want to file suit in California,
- 42:42but your employer is based in Massachusetts.
- 42:45The insurance company is based in North Carolina
- 42:47and you live in Massachusetts. You are likely
- 42:50going to have a hard time bringing suit in California
- 42:53because the insurance company is going to make
- 42:55a motion to change venue, noting that there are
- 42:59no ties to California and it's inconvenient and
- 43:04it doesn't represent justice because California
- 43:08has no vested interest in the claim. But what
- 43:13if you work in Massachusetts and you work for
- 43:15Microsoft in Massachusetts and Microsoft is headquartered
- 43:20in Washington, headquartered in Redmond outside
- 43:23of Seattle? Then can you bring suit in the Ninth
- 43:29Circuit? Can't bring suit in California, but
- 43:31you can bring suit in Washington and file in
- 43:34Washington federal court. and there's no courts
- 43:38have repeatedly held that there's no legitimate
- 43:40basis to overturn that because the plan is based
- 43:45there and the plan is part of the coverage. So
- 43:51venue under ERISA, most courts have held, can
- 43:55be proper where the insured lives, where the
- 43:58insurer is headquartered or incorporated. or
- 44:01where the plan is administered. The plan is almost
- 44:04always administered in the employer's headquarters.
- 44:09It's where human resources is. That's typically
- 44:12considered where the plan is administered, where
- 44:15decisions about the plan are made. So these large
- 44:19layoffs happening by West Coast firms, including
- 44:22Microsoft and Meta and Google and Amazon, Salesforce,
- 44:27Starbucks, all of these that are happening, those
- 44:31employees being laid off all over the country,
- 44:35all of them can file suit in the Ninth Circuit
- 44:37because the disability plans are administered
- 44:40by the employers at their headquarters in the
- 44:42Ninth Circuit. And let's go on to the next slide.
- 44:52What are the benefits to these employees all
- 44:55over the country? for the employees to be able
- 44:58to bring suit in the Ninth Circuit instead of
- 45:00the states in which they live. As we discussed
- 45:03earlier, all of these states for the most part
- 45:06have banned discretionary clauses. That means
- 45:10that their claims are going to be reviewed under
- 45:13de novo review. A judge is going to read the
- 45:16file and the judge is going to decide if the
- 45:19benefits should have been paid or if the insurer
- 45:22got it wrong. the judge doesn't have to give
- 45:26any deference to the insurer's decision. The
- 45:32next obvious question, how do choice of law provisions
- 45:35apply here? Many insurance policies have a choice
- 45:40of law provision in them. That choice of law
- 45:43provision is going to control in terms of what
- 45:48law is going to be applied. The Ninth Circuit
- 45:51just declined to decide just last month whether
- 45:54or not a choice of law provision overrides the
- 45:57state discretionary ban for residents in California.
- 46:01So if you have a California resident who's employed
- 46:07by an employer in Illinois and they work in California,
- 46:14Does the state discretionary ban apply to them
- 46:16if that policy has an Illinois choice of law
- 46:19provision? Ninth Circuit has just avoided the
- 46:23question, so it's still an open question. What
- 46:27if there is a forum selection clause? A forum
- 46:31selection clause is going to control. everything
- 46:35we've just been talking about, about the ability
- 46:37to file where the employer is headquartered,
- 46:42depends on whether or not there's a form selection
- 46:45clause. Most of these policies do not contain
- 46:48form selection clause, but if they do, that is
- 46:54going to control. The language in the policy,
- 46:57unless it's preempted by ERISA, is going to control.
- 47:02Similarly, the notice prejudice doctrine we talked
- 47:05about. That's going to enable all of these employees
- 47:09nationwide to bring late claims in these western
- 47:15states that have adopted the notice prejudice
- 47:17doctrine, regardless of whether or not the state
- 47:20that they live in has adopted it. Plenty of states
- 47:23have not adopted it and do not allow late claims.
- 47:26However, these employees can avoid that if they
- 47:31live in one of those states. by bringing suit
- 47:33where their employer is if that employer is in
- 47:38a state that has the notice prejudice doctrine.
- 47:42So it's important to understand that this is
- 47:48what we are dealing with as lawyers, as human
- 47:54resources professionals, as employers, as insurance
- 47:58companies. Yes. These people are allowed to bring
- 48:03late claims They are allowed to bring claims
- 48:06after they find out that they've been terminated
- 48:08But before they leave they can bring a claim
- 48:11after they've been terminated and after they
- 48:13leave it is one of the benefits provided to them
- 48:17by their employment and So long as they can demonstrate
- 48:21that they were entitled to use that benefit Up
- 48:24to at any time up to the last day of their employment.
- 48:27They are allowed to access it And let's go to
- 48:33the next slide, which I think is the question
- 48:38and answer slide. I am happy to answer questions
- 48:42about this, but I can also dive in a little bit
- 48:45more into the question of venue and how all of
- 48:50this works to answer anything else. Let's see.
- 48:56I do see a question. It's about employment. unemployment,
- 49:01I'm not an unemployment attorney. So I don't,
- 49:05my understanding is the ability to file for unemployment
- 49:08is going to be based on the state law for that
- 49:13state, but it's not related to disability. I
- 49:17will say that if you're applying for unemployment,
- 49:19you usually cannot be on disability because when
- 49:22you're filing for unemployment, you have to continuously
- 49:25confirm that you are actively seeking work and
- 49:28if you're on disability you're taking the position
- 49:30that you cannot work so the two are in conflict
- 49:34so usually an employee usually an employee has
- 49:37to determine if they're going to go for unemployment
- 49:39or if they're going to go for disability they
- 49:41can't do both and I don't think there are any
- 49:49open questions right now. So I'm just going to
- 49:51talk a little bit more about some of the case
- 49:54law on these issues. As I noted, the Supreme
- 49:58Court has determined that, yes, you can bring
- 50:02these late claims. That's not limited to disability
- 50:06insurance, by the way. Notice prejudice applies
- 50:08to all types of insurance. It's particularly
- 50:12interesting for disability because you get your
- 50:15disability through your employment and you may
- 50:18have left the employment years prior, but you
- 50:22can still make that claim. And for venue, there's
- 50:29lots of discussion about choosing venue and making
- 50:34strategic decisions about where to bring claims.
- 50:39The Ninth Circuit is known as being a more plaintiff
- 50:42-friendly venue. Almost not every single court,
- 50:47but most of the courts in the Ninth Circuit are
- 50:48known for being fairly plaintiff -friendly. So
- 50:52if you are looking to bring suit for an insured,
- 50:58there can be tactical advantages to finding a
- 51:01basis to doing so in the Ninth Circuit, depending
- 51:05on where the employer of the insured is located.
- 51:11And human resource employees need to understand
- 51:15these issues as well so that they understand
- 51:18when their prior employees are asking for information,
- 51:23what they have to provide. And that yes, not
- 51:29just the insurance company, although usually
- 51:30the insurance company is the one sued these days,
- 51:33the plan can be sued by someone anywhere in the
- 51:35country as well. And the plan can be sued in
- 51:39the in the state, in the court where the plan
- 51:43is located. So the employer has exposure, the
- 51:47insurance company has exposure, it should be
- 51:52completed there. And I see comments about the
- 51:56proliferation of third party employers. That
- 52:00is a really good question. The plan can have
- 52:07a third party administrator But the third party
- 52:10administrator is not the plan itself. It's a
- 52:14third party. So the plan can hire somebody, but
- 52:17that's not going to change where the plan is
- 52:21located. That third party administrator, they
- 52:24may be, let's say they're in North Dakota, but
- 52:28the plan itself is still located at the headquarters
- 52:31of the employer. I've seen insurance companies
- 52:36try to make this argument. And usually courts
- 52:41have agreed that the plan is administered where
- 52:45the headquarters is. Because there's more to
- 52:48administering the plan than what the third party
- 52:51administrator is doing, right? Somebody had to
- 52:53hire that third party administrator. Somebody's
- 52:55paying that third party administrator. Third
- 52:57party administrator usually cannot make changes
- 53:00to the plan. It's the employer who can make changes
- 53:03to the plan. All of that is part as part of the
- 53:06administration of the plan. And that's still
- 53:08happening where the employer is located. So,
- 53:14no, you're not stuck. If TriNet is in North Dakota
- 53:18and the employer and the employer in California,
- 53:20you're not stuck with what TriNet dictates. If
- 53:24the employer is an employee of TriNet, then yes,
- 53:30they then if their insurance is through TriNet,
- 53:33and Trinet is the plan administrator for its
- 53:38own insurance that it's offering, then yes, the
- 53:41employer is Trinet. So Microsoft, for example,
- 53:45who uses lots of different contractors. You may
- 53:49be doing all of your work for Microsoft. but
- 53:53you're still employed by the contractor that
- 53:56hired you. You're not an employee of Microsoft.
- 53:59So in that situation, yes. If you work for Trynet,
- 54:04then Trynet is where the, wherever Trynet's managing
- 54:09that plan is where the employer would be. However,
- 54:14if you live in California, then you can still
- 54:17bring suit in California because that's one of
- 54:19the places where venue is permitted. If they
- 54:23have a forum selection clause or a choice of
- 54:26law clause that is unrelated to California and
- 54:31it's in the plan, then that's going to control.
- 54:33So if the insurance policy dictates that either
- 54:36the forum selection has to be in North Dakota
- 54:39or the choice of law needs to be in North Dakota,
- 54:42then that would apply. Choice of law, given that
- 54:46it's ERISA, you should still be able to file
- 54:50in California and have Ninth Circuit California
- 54:55law apply. ERISA technically is federal law,
- 54:58which means it's national. The reality of the
- 55:01fact that courts around the country tend to interpret
- 55:03it differently wouldn't be determined by a choice
- 55:09of law selection. So you'd really want the forum
- 55:12to be in California in this situation if you're
- 55:18working for an employer in North Dakota, but
- 55:20you live in California, you could bring suit
- 55:22in California, still have all the benefits related
- 55:25to the Ninth Circuit, and that would hopefully
- 55:30resolve the issue for that. Now, if you worked
- 55:34in Texas and the employer was in North Dakota,
- 55:38you'd have a hard time making an argument that
- 55:39you should be able to file in the Ninth Circuit.
- 55:43any other questions that I can answer. We are
- 55:47almost out of time, but we do still have a few
- 55:49more minutes left. These issues come up more
- 55:55often than you would think. I'd say about half
- 55:59of the cases that I have involve people who were
- 56:05trying to push through with working because either
- 56:08they loved their job or they needed their job
- 56:10and Only make claims when they realize that they're
- 56:13losing their job regardless. So this this is
- 56:16something that comes up a fair amount and understanding
- 56:20how it works, whether it's for your employees,
- 56:24if you are working for a large employer, if you
- 56:29are a wealth management attorney and you find
- 56:33out that one of your clients is getting terminated
- 56:35and they don't know what to do, depending on
- 56:37their health situation, this is an option for
- 56:39them. Obviously, they'd rather be working, but
- 56:4260 % of your salary can be better than nothing
- 56:45while you're focused on your health. ADHD. can
- 56:50be a disability. Sorry, answering a question
- 56:53here. I see a new question just popped up. It
- 56:56depends on the severity of the symptoms and the
- 56:59doctor's support. Executive function and cognitive
- 57:03disabilities are definitely bases for disability.
- 57:08in order to obtain that, you would likely need
- 57:12some kind of neuropsychological testing that
- 57:15would support the inability to do the requirements
- 57:19of that job or occupation. So it can be in reality,
- 57:27it would be for if ADHD were the only issue,
- 57:30it would be difficult to make a claim for that
- 57:33because presumably, the ADHD had existed throughout
- 57:38the course of employment and the insured had
- 57:41been able to do their job the entire time. For
- 57:45mental health, oftentimes depression and anxiety
- 57:49will spike when somebody finds out that they're
- 57:52being terminated. That can be a basis for a disability
- 57:57claim, assuming physician support. Lots of people
- 58:01have ongoing treatment and end up for mental
- 58:05health, but are able to do their jobs. And then
- 58:08something changes. Maybe there's a death in their
- 58:10family. Maybe they're terminated. Something happens
- 58:13that causes that previously manageable disability
- 58:16to no longer become manageable. And those are
- 58:19situations where mental health can change and
- 58:24start to fall under the umbrella of disability
- 58:27when previously the insurer was able to work.
- 58:31And we are just about out of time, but I'm happy
- 58:35to answer any more questions if there are any.
- 58:40Let's see, just saw another question. Can an
- 58:43employee with a disability accept a new job in
- 58:45the company and later file for long -term disability
- 58:48when terminated? Absolutely. If you're still
- 58:54employed, then you are still covered. If you're
- 58:58still employed by that same company, then yes,
- 59:00you're covered. And if you're disabled and you
- 59:03have medical support to demonstrate that disability
- 59:06and your doctors support that disability, then
- 59:08yes, you could absolutely file a claim later
- 59:12down the road. You can also, you can file a claim.
- 59:15You can be out on disability for a period of
- 59:17time. You can come back to work. You can work
- 59:19for a while. If your symptoms increase again,
- 59:22you can go back out on disability. The benefit
- 59:25is there to protect you based on issues with
- 59:28your health. And health, as unfortunately we
- 59:31all know, is never something that you can 100
- 59:33% rely on. people can get better, they can get
- 59:37worse. Most people want to work. Most people
- 59:40like their jobs and like the security of a job
- 59:42and don't want to be on disability. So when they're
- 59:45applying for disability, usually it's because
- 59:48they need it. And it's important, especially
- 59:51for human resources people to remember, the insurance
- 59:54companies deny most claims. That does not mean
- 59:57that your employee is not disabled. Something
- 1:00:01to keep in mind, we hear employers often treat
- 1:00:06employees differently after a claim is denied
- 1:00:08because they think that the employee must be
- 1:00:10making it up. Most insurance claims are denied.
- 1:00:14That is not because the insured is not disabled.
- 1:00:17It's because it's a business model for the insurance
- 1:00:19company, which is important to know. Another
- 1:00:23follow -up question. If the disability doesn't
- 1:00:26affect the new position, could you still file
- 1:00:29for long -term disability? Likely not because
- 1:00:35The definition of disability is going to be that
- 1:00:39based on the ability to perform the duties of
- 1:00:42that job. If you are able to perform the duties
- 1:00:45of a new job, then you're not disabled from that
- 1:00:47new job. But it would depend on the language
- 1:00:49and the policy. So that's really what's going
- 1:00:51to control. It's a contract like anything else.
- 1:00:54The language in the contract is what controls.
- 1:00:59Any other questions? Otherwise, I think we are
- 1:01:02at time. Already, it doesn't look like we have
- 1:01:08any more questions. This concludes today's presentation.
- 1:01:13Once again, I'd like to thank you, Stacey, for
- 1:01:16an excellent program. And I'd also love to thank
- 1:01:19our audience for attending with us today. Have
- 1:01:22a great afternoon, everybody. Thank you.