Latest / Surrounded / Naima vs Charlie Kirk, 1 Year Later | Surrounded Follow-Up
Transcript
- 0:00Blacks commit more crimes than whites do.
- 0:02They commit more murders,
- 0:03they commit more arsons,
- 0:04they commit more kidnappings.
- 0:05For example,
- 0:06blacks are 13% of the population and they commit 58% of all the murders.
- 0:10I don't really think Charlie Kirk is interested
- 0:11in achieving equity for the black community.
- 0:13I mean,
- 0:14I.
- 0:15If he was,
- 0:16he wouldn't continue to call us the blacks.
- 0:18He said it maybe like 6 times in that video,
- 0:20which to me is very dehumanizing.
- 0:22Like,
- 0:23I'm not a crayon,
- 0:24you know,
- 0:24we're a group of people.
- 0:25We are black people.
- 0:26We are not the blacks,
- 0:28right?
- 0:29Um,
- 0:29I'm not a lump of coal.
- 0:30We are people.
- 0:33Naima,
- 0:33welcome to the surrounded Follow up.
- 0:35Hello.
- 0:36This is so exciting.
- 0:38Yeah,
- 0:39when I see you appear on the internet,
- 0:41uh,
- 0:43they refer to you often as like Naima from Jubilee.
- 0:46So you're kind of like a Jubilee,
- 0:47uh,
- 0:48ambassador in your own way.
- 0:50I get Jubilee Girl a lot.
- 0:52I get called Jubilee Girl.
- 0:53Yes,
- 0:54I was trying not to make it so,
- 0:55uh,
- 0:56blunt.
- 0:57I prefer it over the girl who talked to Charlie Kirk.
- 1:01I like,
- 1:01I like Jubilee Girl a little more,
- 1:03so,
- 1:03you know,
- 1:03I'll take it.
- 1:05Yeah.
- 1:05Um,
- 1:06well,
- 1:06first off,
- 1:07thank you for appearing in
- 1:09the format so much.
- 1:10You've created a lot of
- 1:13memorable,
- 1:13obviously viral moments with
- 1:16Ben Shapiro.
- 1:17Charlie Kirk was where it started,
- 1:19and we can kind of unpack that since it's much more complex now,
- 1:23um.
- 1:25But yeah,
- 1:25it's,
- 1:26it's been interesting to see the show kind of be a,
- 1:29a launching platform for you as a thinker.
- 1:32Um,
- 1:33from your perspective,
- 1:34has it felt that way or is it just one of many things that,
- 1:37that you feel like you're exploring?
- 1:40Yeah,
- 1:40I mean,
- 1:40so,
- 1:41um,
- 1:41just
- 1:42background about myself.
- 1:43I'm actually a film student.
- 1:44I'm in my last week at USC film school.
- 1:48Um,
- 1:49congratulations.
- 1:49Thank you.
- 1:50And when I first got there,
- 1:52I was like,
- 1:53I'm not going to be an influencer.
- 1:54I don't,
- 1:57you know,
- 1:58I did,
- 1:58I did not see this for myself.
- 2:00I think my main goal was to be a screenwriter and producer,
- 2:04which I still want to do very much so.
- 2:06But,
- 2:07um,
- 2:08Uh,
- 2:08both of my parents are lawyers.
- 2:09My dad is actually a civil rights lawyer.
- 2:11He works a lot with the city of Newark on race,
- 2:13class,
- 2:14and metropolitan equity.
- 2:15So,
- 2:16I've always been like,
- 2:17I like to joke that I've been in law school for 23 years.
- 2:21Um,
- 2:21so I always have really had an interest in these issues and it's kind of been,
- 2:26More of a side thing for me.
- 2:28Like,
- 2:28I never thought I would make a career out of,
- 2:30you know,
- 2:31debating,
- 2:32um,
- 2:32and engaging in thought so much.
- 2:34But when the opportunity presented itself,
- 2:37um,
- 2:38I jumped at it and I was shocked that it was went so viral.
- 2:43I was not anticipating it.
- 2:45I thought it would just be like a fun thing to do on like a weekend.
- 2:49Um,
- 2:50and it really your idea of fun is clearly shaped by growing up with parents.
- 2:54Yes,
- 2:54I was like,
- 2:55it'll be fun to yell at conservatives.
- 2:57Why not,
- 2:57you know,
- 2:58so that
- 2:59just really changed my life and now it's opened me up to the possibility of
- 3:03influencing and how much that,
- 3:05um,
- 3:06my little niche of like political influencing really can affect people
- 3:09and impact people and I found it to be very rewarding.
- 3:12So
- 3:12it's been really awesome.
- 3:15Well,
- 3:15when I,
- 3:16cause I actually pitched this kind of version of Surrounded,
- 3:19it was an idea that
- 3:21different directors had pitched when I worked at Jubilee,
- 3:24um,
- 3:25but when I pitched this version,
- 3:27part of the philosophy was,
- 3:28you know,
- 3:29hey,
- 3:29we wanna test.
- 3:31Thought leaders,
- 3:32you know,
- 3:32who have a lot of influence on political culture online,
- 3:36but
- 3:37there's also gonna be this,
- 3:38you know,
- 3:38organic way of discovering new influencers.
- 3:41And so,
- 3:42when I saw you kind of surface and,
- 3:44and kind of
- 3:45go back through the format.
- 3:46I was like,
- 3:47oh,
- 3:47wow,
- 3:47I,
- 3:48it was,
- 3:48I was actually right.
- 3:49You know,
- 3:49we are discovering voices through the format.
- 3:51So it was cool to see that happen
- 3:54and for you to be kind of one of the first instances of it.
- 3:57Yeah,
- 3:57I mean,
- 3:58I have to thank,
- 3:59um,
- 4:00my friend,
- 4:01shout out to Amanda.
- 4:02She's actually a camera op for Jubilee,
- 4:04and she was the one who originally encouraged me to apply,
- 4:07um,
- 4:08and kind of how I first got into the Jubilee network.
- 4:12Um,
- 4:13so
- 4:14that it's so funny.
- 4:15I always say a joke that me and her are like actually linked now because of this.
- 4:19But yeah,
- 4:20it's,
- 4:21it's been really a joy,
- 4:22um,
- 4:24getting to interact with so many people online,
- 4:25getting to kind of understand this world.
- 4:27I feel like I was kind of thrown into it
- 4:29because I wasn't really planning on being an influencer,
- 4:31you know,
- 4:33like that was
- 4:34not a goal of mine,
- 4:36um.
- 4:37But it's been
- 4:39insane and very cool.
- 4:40Like,
- 4:40I didn't use TikTok and then I woke up one
- 4:42day with like 200,000 followers and I was like,
- 4:44oh my God,
- 4:45what do I do with all these people?
- 4:47What do you say to these people?
- 4:49So it's been a lot of trial and error.
- 4:51It's been a lot of,
- 4:52um,
- 4:52self-discovery through
- 4:54being
- 4:55so present online,
- 4:57but I feel like I've learned a lot about myself,
- 4:59about the world,
- 5:01and I really,
- 5:02I mean,
- 5:02it's cool.
- 5:03It's just sick as fuck,
- 5:04to be quite honest.
- 5:06Nice.
- 5:07I love it.
- 5:08Um,
- 5:08well,
- 5:08yeah,
- 5:08it's very brave of you.
- 5:10Uh,
- 5:10the internet is,
- 5:11uh,
- 5:13it's a different thing now than it was,
- 5:15I think,
- 5:15when I was your age,
- 5:17um.
- 5:18It's,
- 5:18it's not as forgiving.
- 5:20So,
- 5:20no,
- 5:21I grew up on Vine.
- 5:22People just made dumb faces.
- 5:23I'm like what?
- 5:25became famous.
- 5:26Yeah,
- 5:26I,
- 5:26I grew up on Facebook.
- 5:28Like we,
- 5:28we posted our worst behavior and you know,
- 5:32we dumped 200 photos at a time,
- 5:34uh,
- 5:35because the concept of being punished or canceled didn't exist yet.
- 5:39The permanence of it didn't feel as,
- 5:42you know,
- 5:43but.
- 5:44Yeah,
- 5:45you can still somewhere
- 5:47out there,
- 5:47you could probably find like a
- 5:49A box of like Keystone light on my head
- 5:53at a party on a face in in a Facebook photo when I was young.
- 5:57It's embarrassing.
- 5:58I definitely have some photos up floating around in
- 6:01the ether that I hope no one notices.
- 6:04Yeah,
- 6:05I mean,
- 6:06it's probably not the end of the world,
- 6:07but
- 6:08anyway,
- 6:08I,
- 6:09I wanted to bring you on the show,
- 6:10uh,
- 6:11because
- 6:11you've debated,
- 6:12you debated Charlie Kirk probably in one of the most,
- 6:15if not the most viral moment Jubilee's ever had,
- 6:18and we can kinda go through that exchange
- 6:21and,
- 6:22you know,
- 6:22watch it and get your reactions,
- 6:24but you've also debated Candace Owens,
- 6:26Ben Shapiro,
- 6:27and so,
- 6:28are there any,
- 6:29are there any other big ones that I'm missing?
- 6:31Those were the three I wanted to focus on.
- 6:34I don't think so.
- 6:35I think those are the only 3
- 6:37surroundings I've done.
- 6:38Yeah,
- 6:39yeah,
- 6:41I wanna say
- 6:41they all kind of mixed together at a certain point.
- 6:43Yeah,
- 6:44no,
- 6:44I totally get that.
- 6:45So let's start with maybe kind of where it
- 6:47all began was your initial exchange with Charlie Kirk.
- 6:51We'll dig into kind of your stance on the issue and the politics of it,
- 6:53but obviously there's a lot more to talk about.
- 6:55So
- 6:56I'll pull up that clip and then,
- 6:58and we can just see where,
- 6:59where it leads us.
- 7:00OK,
- 7:00can I just ask,
- 7:01um,
- 7:01at how many weeks do you think that a fetus is viable?
- 7:04Well,
- 7:05viability and moral worth are two different things.
- 7:07No,
- 7:07but I'm asking you,
- 7:08at how many weeks do you think at about 20 weeks,
- 7:10a baby can survive outside of utero.
- 7:12So it's actually 24 to 26 weeks,
- 7:1420,
- 7:15the youngest ever in a NICU unit actually happened in San Diego,
- 7:17not far from here,
- 7:18and survived at 20 weeks.
- 7:20OK,
- 7:20so under Roe v.
- 7:21Wade,
- 7:2193% of abortions happened in the 1st 13 weeks of pregnancy.
- 7:26That's 93% of the abortions happened
- 7:29well before a fetus is technically viable as a form of life.
- 7:33Let's go into viability.
- 7:34So what is it about,
- 7:35let's say a 6 week
- 7:37baby that has a heartbeat,
- 7:39its own DNA,
- 7:39fingerprint,
- 7:40brain waves that is less moral worth
- 7:43than an 88-year-old right now with dementia.
- 7:45In a home down the street,
- 7:47that person requires assistance,
- 7:48requires help.
- 7:50Why is it that the six week baby is of less moral worth?
- 7:53Well,
- 7:53first of all,
- 7:53it's not a baby,
- 7:54it's a fetus.
- 7:55What does fetus mean?
- 7:56A fetus
- 7:57is in utero.
- 7:58What does fetus mean in Latin?
- 8:00What the?
- 8:01I'm sorry,
- 8:01is this a language it means little human being.
- 8:05Oh,
- 8:05this smile is very creepy.
- 8:06OK,
- 8:07um,
- 8:07smiling is creepy.
- 8:08No,
- 8:09your smile specifically,
- 8:10it,
- 8:10but let's go back
- 8:12to we're losing track here.
- 8:13No,
- 8:14but,
- 8:14but is it,
- 8:14what,
- 8:14what species is the fetus?
- 8:16The fetus is not a species yet.
- 8:18It's technically classified as a parasite
- 8:21until it is viable.
- 8:22Now,
- 8:22I want to talk to you about something very quick.
- 8:23I can't let you get past that.
- 8:24Are you saying,
- 8:25you're saying a baby is a disease or a tumor?
- 8:27A parasite is not a disease and a tumor.
- 8:29Those are not the same thing.
- 8:30A parasite is defined as something that cannot survive
- 8:33outside of its host.
- 8:35A baby,
- 8:36before it is viable,
- 8:37cannot survive
- 8:39outside
- 8:40of a woman's womb.
- 8:41Got it.
- 8:41So let's let's extrapolate that.
- 8:43It is not a living organism.
- 8:44Are,
- 8:44are old people with Alzheimer's and dementia that are being assisted every day,
- 8:48are they parasites?
- 8:50No,
- 8:50they're not parasites.
- 8:51They're human beings who are on the brink of death.
- 8:53Got it.
- 8:53So my they're not going to be my 4 month old that requires mom's.
- 8:57Breast milk
- 8:57and requires daily changes and feedings cannot survive without its own.
- 9:01Is my 4 month old a parasite?
- 9:03Your baby can breathe on its own.
- 9:05Your baby can drink water from its mouth to its stomach,
- 9:08but,
- 9:08but it can.
- 9:09Your baby can,
- 9:10can it hunt?
- 9:10Can it gather?
- 9:11Can it reason?
- 9:12But that's not
- 9:13what qualifies something as being a living organism.
- 9:16What,
- 9:17what is it like to,
- 9:19to watch that?
- 9:21I've seen it so many times and this is why I'm,
- 9:23it's practically memorized
- 9:26in my head,
- 9:27but I think my favorite line in that is
- 9:31not even mine,
- 9:32but when he goes,
- 9:33can it hunt?
- 9:34Can it gather?
- 9:35Can it erase?
- 9:37That sends me every time because Charlie Kirk,
- 9:40you know your ass can't hunt or gather.
- 9:42I'm
- 9:44Yeah,
- 9:44it just sends me so because we all go to the supermarket.
- 9:47Like what are you talking about?
- 9:50I don't know.
- 9:50I
- 9:52Yeah,
- 9:52it well,
- 9:53it is interesting where,
- 9:55so
- 9:56I don't even know where to start.
- 9:58I guess
- 9:59before we go into the argument,
- 10:00because
- 10:01if,
- 10:01if Charlie was still alive,
- 10:03I still think he would want us to rigorously investigate
- 10:06what you're debating.
- 10:08Um,
- 10:10I guess what does it feel like because I know that you released uh a statement,
- 10:16you know,
- 10:16immediately after he was killed and you were like
- 10:18this is a totally awful thing that happened.
- 10:22What is it like to
- 10:26I don't know,
- 10:27as somebody who's helped make bring the show into existence,
- 10:30myself personally,
- 10:31I have
- 10:32pretty complex feelings
- 10:34seeing him in the video and being like,
- 10:36what part of his own trajectory was this?
- 10:39Do you feel that like sticky.
- 10:43This that I'm describing,
- 10:45um,
- 10:46do you mean like when you him a little bit?
- 10:49No,
- 10:49I,
- 10:50I think I mean more just like emotions like,
- 10:53oh,
- 10:53that was where it was leading,
- 10:55um,
- 10:58you know,
- 10:58to his like untimely and very tragic death.
- 11:00I see what you're saying,
- 11:01um,
- 11:02I,
- 11:02not that there was any responsibility,
- 11:04but just to be a part of that trajectory.
- 11:07You know,
- 11:08I don't necessarily
- 11:10see it as being part of that trajectory because nobody else on Surrounded,
- 11:16um,
- 11:17whether they were in the hot seat or otherwise,
- 11:20has
- 11:21been,
- 11:22you know,
- 11:22assassinated as cruelly as he was as public.
- 11:26Publicly as he was,
- 11:28I think that,
- 11:29you know,
- 11:30I don't blame because I've actually gotten some,
- 11:32especially after he died,
- 11:33I got a lot of DMs like you did this.
- 11:35And I was like,
- 11:36no,
- 11:36I didn't,
- 11:37guys.
- 11:37I was asleep when it happened,
- 11:38first of all.
- 11:39But,
- 11:39um,
- 11:40you know,
- 11:41I think a lot of people see him being in the public eye as being,
- 11:44you know,
- 11:46part of what like why what happened to him happened
- 11:48to him and surrounded being a mechanism of that.
- 11:52But,
- 11:52you know,
- 11:52I disagree with that because I don't.
- 11:54I think that surrounded has had that effect for anyone else.
- 11:58I mean,
- 11:59if this was a pattern of like people
- 12:01going on jubilee,
- 12:02growing their platforms,
- 12:04and then receiving
- 12:06dangerous and violent,
- 12:08you know,
- 12:08threats,
- 12:09hate,
- 12:10um,
- 12:11actual physical violence assaults,
- 12:13then,
- 12:13you know,
- 12:14I would say,
- 12:14OK,
- 12:15maybe there is some kind of correlation here.
- 12:17But I don't think that,
- 12:19you know,
- 12:20Charlie Kirk being.
- 12:21On Jubilee and Jubilee in and of itself was the mechanism of this violence.
- 12:24I think that what happened to him
- 12:26was
- 12:27a direct result of
- 12:29the kind of platform that he created,
- 12:31the rhetoric that he talked about.
- 12:33I also think that he chose to be in college campuses in public and obviously
- 12:39he has every right to debate there.
- 12:41It is his First Amendment right
- 12:43to freedom of speech,
- 12:44freedom of expression,
- 12:45but you know,
- 12:46him doing that.
- 12:47Versus like a Ben Shapiro having his own podcast,
- 12:50a Candace Owens having their own podcast,
- 12:52made it so he was much more
- 12:55vulnerable to public attacks,
- 12:57to physical attacks.
- 12:59So when I see this,
- 13:00I don't think that Jubilee or me or anyone else who
- 13:03debated him really has any responsibility in what happened to him,
- 13:06other than
- 13:08Tyler,
- 13:08really.
- 13:09I don't see us as kind of facilitating what happened to him in any way.
- 13:15So,
- 13:15I don't feel bad about it.
- 13:16Yeah,
- 13:17no,
- 13:17I appreciate you unpacking it.
- 13:19And for me,
- 13:21It's like,
- 13:21it's,
- 13:22it's just like a come,
- 13:23I guess I just didn't anticipate his story would be as tragic as it
- 13:27as it ended up being.
- 13:29Um,
- 13:30and
- 13:31for me,
- 13:33It just,
- 13:33it re-tints
- 13:36every media I see with him in it,
- 13:37um,
- 13:39with a different kind of color,
- 13:40um,
- 13:41and I think it's just strange how that,
- 13:42how that works.
- 13:44But like I said,
- 13:47He would want us to
- 13:49rigorously actually dig into the debate you guys are having,
- 13:53and so.
- 13:55Abortion
- 13:57Let's shift to,
- 13:58let's shift to that.
- 13:59You go towards viability in that clip
- 14:03immediately.
- 14:04Yes,
- 14:05I thought that made a lot of sense.
- 14:07Do you think that is the most important variable when it comes to maybe the,
- 14:12the conservative,
- 14:13more left debate of,
- 14:15um,
- 14:16abortion?
- 14:17You know why,
- 14:19why it should be there,
- 14:20um,
- 14:21since I like debated Charlie Kirk,
- 14:24you know,
- 14:24and I've been unpacking different debate strategies.
- 14:27Like I don't disagree with anything that I said in the clip.
- 14:29I,
- 14:30um,
- 14:31neither did the fact check,
- 14:32but
- 14:36I,
- 14:36you know,
- 14:37I agree with everything that I was saying,
- 14:38and I,
- 14:38I see the argument that I was laying out there in that clip of,
- 14:41you know,
- 14:41something isn't viable,
- 14:42it shouldn't take moral precedent over the being
- 14:44that is keeping it alive and sustaining it.
- 14:47Like,
- 14:47you know,
- 14:48I see that argument that I've created,
- 14:49but it's funny because since the video,
- 14:51people have often told me,
- 14:53you know,
- 14:53don't go towards viability.
- 14:54Don't start your argument at viability,
- 14:56because,
- 14:57um,
- 14:58we can't,
- 15:00there is no scientific consensus on when life begins,
- 15:03right?
- 15:04So
- 15:05it's kind of,
- 15:06you're both arguing on a hypothetical
- 15:08because you can't,
- 15:09neither of you can prove when life begins.
- 15:12And even if life begins at
- 15:14X point.
- 15:16A woman still deserves the right to choose,
- 15:18right?
- 15:18Like you should
- 15:20approach it from a place of like,
- 15:21you don't have to prove that this fetus is viable or not.
- 15:24You have to prove that this woman's
- 15:26right to choose what happens to her body is more important
- 15:30than
- 15:31a fetus's right to
- 15:33hypothetical life,
- 15:34you know.
- 15:36So since that debate,
- 15:37I've definitely like
- 15:38kind of pivoted my strategy to focus more on
- 15:42what happens when women are not given.
- 15:45Access to abortions,
- 15:46how this is affecting those children.
- 15:48I'm sorry,
- 15:48there's a piece of fuzz in the air that's
- 15:51driving me crazy.
- 15:52Um,
- 15:52OK,
- 15:52I think I got it.
- 15:53But yeah,
- 15:54no,
- 15:54since that debate,
- 15:55like,
- 15:55I've definitely been taught to pivot,
- 15:57like instead of focusing on viability and trying to prove viability
- 16:01and how that equates to like the morality of
- 16:04um freedom of choice,
- 16:06I've been taught more to think about
- 16:08how does,
- 16:10how does the right to choose impact women.
- 16:13How are the lives of women and
- 16:16those children drastically impacted by abortion bans?
- 16:20Like thinking about specific instances in which abortion bans have severely
- 16:25hurt women and their children.
- 16:27For example,
- 16:28I think there was a 12 year old,
- 16:29I forget which state who was
- 16:31somebody talked about it in this video,
- 16:33yeah,
- 16:33who was assaulted.
- 16:34There was a 12 year old.
- 16:35That I think
- 16:36would be forced to give birth under,
- 16:38you know,
- 16:38the new,
- 16:39um,
- 16:40abortion bans who had been assaulted by,
- 16:43I think it was her father,
- 16:44her stepfather,
- 16:45so it was like both rape and incest of a minor,
- 16:47and she still was going to have to give birth.
- 16:49Um,
- 16:50and then also since Dobbs now has had a little bit of time since that debate,
- 16:55we've seen the actual number of abortions.
- 16:56Abortions in the US increase,
- 16:59which even with abortion bans,
- 17:01which is a huge point of contention,
- 17:03we've also seen the number of women trying to give themselves abortions increase.
- 17:08We've also seen the number of babies,
- 17:10newborns that have been abandoned
- 17:13in states in which
- 17:14there are incredibly high,
- 17:15incredibly stringent abortion bans increase,
- 17:17right?
- 17:18So
- 17:19the argument now
- 17:21that I would present is less about like when a fetus is viable and more about
- 17:27how do these bands actually impact the women and the children
- 17:32who are subject to them
- 17:35because it's been.
- 17:37That's pretty barely negative,
- 17:39right,
- 17:40right.
- 17:41I think though.
- 17:43This is where I might push back though,
- 17:44because I actually thought the viability argument
- 17:48made the most sense to me as somebody who I think is approaching a lot of these
- 17:52divisive issues,
- 17:53looking for
- 17:54where there could be compromise,
- 17:56and I think like um
- 17:58A constructive resolution.
- 18:00So like I do a lot of the,
- 18:02host a lot of these jubilee debates and
- 18:04so I'm always kind of seeing like,
- 18:06where can we,
- 18:07where might there be something where both people
- 18:10get some of their concern acknowledged.
- 18:13And the point that you made where you said,
- 18:15if we're using viability as
- 18:18kind of a framework,
- 18:19the majority of abortions happen before.
- 18:22Fetuses are considered viable
- 18:25in um recent,
- 18:27you know,
- 18:27data sets.
- 18:28And so,
- 18:30that to me actually seems like a,
- 18:32while I agree with you and,
- 18:34and the people who have,
- 18:35have spoken to you,
- 18:36there's fuzzy science there.
- 18:38The fuzzy,
- 18:39clarifying the fuzzy science and being like,
- 18:41OK,
- 18:41what,
- 18:42what does viability mean and how are we measuring it
- 18:45and like where is that sort of dotted line?
- 18:48That to me is the most tangible thing about abortion.
- 18:51That
- 18:52I can really grasp because where Charlie went after
- 18:55that was kind of this like moral weight argument,
- 18:59which I thought got even fuzzier,
- 19:01where it's like,
- 19:03what makes a human valuable and what does the human need to be able to do and,
- 19:07and it gets
- 19:08It got
- 19:10Like I,
- 19:10I don't,
- 19:12ultimately where that goes is like abortion can never be OK,
- 19:16because
- 19:17emotionally,
- 19:19this potential for a human,
- 19:21um,
- 19:21that's existing in,
- 19:22in
- 19:23mothers expecting.
- 19:26Just should never be
- 19:27extinguished,
- 19:28and if it is,
- 19:29it's the equivalent of murder,
- 19:30and that to me felt like.
- 19:33A path that that was towards too extreme of a resolution.
- 19:37So,
- 19:37I guess I was,
- 19:38I was kind of impressed.
- 19:39I was like,
- 19:39oh,
- 19:39viability does actually seem like the thing.
- 19:43That gets us somewhere.
- 19:44It doesn't get either side exactly what they want,
- 19:47but it gets somewhere.
- 19:49Yeah,
- 19:49I mean,
- 19:50I guess what I would say if like,
- 19:51you know,
- 19:51we've made great advancements in science and like scientifically,
- 19:55if a fetus were to be viable at 10 weeks,
- 19:58like,
- 19:58would we set the ban
- 20:00for you can only get abortions in the 1st 10 weeks?
- 20:04Like,
- 20:04I feel like viability can be a slippery slope sometimes,
- 20:07especially because I'm not.
- 20:10A doctor
- 20:11or a biologist and neither is Charlie Kirk,
- 20:14which I think was one reason why this became so fucking brain rot as a debate,
- 20:19because the whole what does fetus mean a lot.
- 20:21It's like you don't know either.
- 20:22He was wrong.
- 20:23Like,
- 20:24oh,
- 20:24does it not mean little human or tiny
- 20:27I gotta look this up now.
- 20:28I gotta look this up.
- 20:30It doesn't.
- 20:32I forget what it means,
- 20:33but I know it does not mean
- 20:35little human being.
- 20:36Google completed my query before.
- 20:40It means bringing forth,
- 20:42hatching,
- 20:43giving birth.
- 20:43So yeah,
- 20:44it doesn't mean
- 20:46a tiny human.
- 20:49He really thought he got.
- 20:52Yeah,
- 20:53yeah,
- 20:53yeah.
- 20:54So I think that like,
- 20:55I mean,
- 20:55I agree with everything I said about viability.
- 20:57It's something that I do bring up in debates like going forward,
- 21:01I think it is important to note that 93%
- 21:03of abortions happen before a fetus is technically viable,
- 21:07um,
- 21:07to sustain itself,
- 21:09so.
- 21:10It should fully be the mother's right because she is completely sustaining
- 21:15the potential life inside of her,
- 21:17um.
- 21:19So,
- 21:19you know,
- 21:20I think that that is a very strong argument,
- 21:22but I think I've just kind of started to expand
- 21:25on that argument as I've gotten more experience in debating
- 21:30because it can create this kind of
- 21:33Weird like biological stalemate
- 21:36where me,
- 21:38who's not a doctor and somebody else who's not a doctor are
- 21:42debating things that we really don't have a level of expertise in.
- 21:45Like we've researched it,
- 21:46of course,
- 21:47but you know,
- 21:49that would be the time where it's like,
- 21:50OK,
- 21:50now we're gonna bring in a doctor,
- 21:52we're gonna bring in,
- 21:53you know,
- 21:53a study,
- 21:54um,
- 21:55but that being said,
- 21:56uh,
- 21:57with
- 21:59Whether or not that's the right place to,
- 22:01to carve the argument,
- 22:03um,
- 22:03we now live in a post-Roe world,
- 22:06and so
- 22:07you are obviously somebody,
- 22:08do you consider yourself like liberal leftist?
- 22:10What would like the political label be if you had to force the label onto yourself?
- 22:14I mean,
- 22:14I definitely say leftist,
- 22:16progressive left,
- 22:17um,
- 22:17progressive left,
- 22:18yeah,
- 22:18yeah,
- 22:18my political compass was like a socio-anarchist or something,
- 22:22so we don't have to go
- 22:25get it,
- 22:25but you're over my head now.
- 22:28OK,
- 22:29so you're,
- 22:30you know,
- 22:30you're,
- 22:30you're very progressive,
- 22:31you're,
- 22:32you're far left,
- 22:33um,
- 22:33and obviously people like you are wondering what,
- 22:36what's the action,
- 22:37what's the game plan if we want
- 22:40abortion rights
- 22:41back,
- 22:41essentially,
- 22:42um,
- 22:43because we now live in a post-war world.
- 22:45What
- 22:46What do you hear or what do you think is the,
- 22:50the way going forward?
- 22:51Cause it,
- 22:52it,
- 22:52we're not really
- 22:53looking at a,
- 22:54a world where it's like,
- 22:55OK,
- 22:55let's bring it back.
- 22:57There's gotta be kind of a new framework.
- 22:59Yeah,
- 23:00I mean,
- 23:01I think that I've been generally kind of
- 23:05disappointed at how I feel like liberal lawmakers have kind of forgotten about it.
- 23:12Like,
- 23:12dare I say,
- 23:14I really don't hear people,
- 23:17especially in debates,
- 23:19talking a lot about the Dobbs decision,
- 23:22um.
- 23:23And you know,
- 23:24as we've been,
- 23:25I think what's been going on that's been really detrimental to the party is
- 23:30Trump's presidency has thrown
- 23:33so much.
- 23:35So many humanitarian crises like
- 23:39civil rights violations
- 23:42at the left.
- 23:44The muzzle velocity is what they call it.
- 23:46Yes,
- 23:46that it's,
- 23:47it's kind of,
- 23:47I feel like the abortion debate has kind of gotten lost in the shuffle,
- 23:51you know,
- 23:52um,
- 23:53and it's become like,
- 23:55I think immigration,
- 23:57I think trans rights,
- 23:58I think these issues have taken much more of a forefront.
- 24:01Not that they shouldn't,
- 24:02they're very important,
- 24:03you know,
- 24:03not to downplay them,
- 24:05but I think that this is very deliberate on the part of conservatives
- 24:09to use Trump's power and
- 24:12just.
- 24:14willingness to do really anything
- 24:17to push all these insane,
- 24:18you know,
- 24:19the Iran war,
- 24:20attacking Iran,
- 24:20closing the Strait of Hormuz,
- 24:22push all these things all at once.
- 24:25So it would force us to kind of ignore certain
- 24:28issues and they just kind of get automatic dubs,
- 24:31which I think is what's kind of happened
- 24:34with abortion.
- 24:35I think the left is so focused on,
- 24:38um,
- 24:40The just litany and slew of issues that have happened in the last several,
- 24:45I mean,
- 24:46affirmative action being a richard ruled,
- 24:47like everything we've lost progress in
- 24:51everything,
- 24:51but in,
- 24:52in that respect,
- 24:52it's almost like the left can't really focus
- 24:55because the left is still searching for its center.
- 24:58It's like representative center,
- 25:00um,
- 25:01and then what are the issues,
- 25:03what are like,
- 25:03what's the kind of most actionable issues
- 25:06and like you said,
- 25:06you know.
- 25:08Trump's sort of
- 25:09ADD like fast-paced
- 25:12news cycle that he's um
- 25:14masterfully.
- 25:17You know,
- 25:17done throughout his political career,
- 25:19it does have a way of cementing in the changes that he does lock in.
- 25:23Um,
- 25:24and the overturning of Roe is maybe the most,
- 25:26I mean,
- 25:26in,
- 25:26in a lot of respects,
- 25:27it might be
- 25:29one of the most lasting parts of his legacy
- 25:31because legislatively he hasn't really passed a law of legislation.
- 25:34He's not really interested in passing legislation,
- 25:37legislation,
- 25:38neither is Congress underneath him.
- 25:40But
- 25:41getting a,
- 25:41a
- 25:42conservative majority court
- 25:44and to overturn Roe v.
- 25:45Wade is kind of
- 25:46That's one of the most sort of like fleshed out things he's he's brought into
- 25:51legal reality,
- 25:53um.
- 25:54Yeah,
- 25:54so it,
- 25:55it'll be really interesting to see
- 25:57where that goes,
- 25:58um,
- 25:58but before we switch to the next clip,
- 26:01do you have
- 26:01final thoughts on that issue just before we move on?
- 26:04I mean,
- 26:05I,
- 26:06I am so disappointed by it because,
- 26:08you know,
- 26:08it's like my mom and my grandma talk about,
- 26:11you know,
- 26:11protesting for the right to choose,
- 26:14um,
- 26:14and what a,
- 26:16you know,
- 26:16monumentous victory that was for them.
- 26:19And
- 26:20now I feel like me and my children are going
- 26:23to be having this same fight over and over again,
- 26:26and I think that there is kind of a
- 26:29fatigue
- 26:30in having to re-win rights that you already had,
- 26:35you know,
- 26:37um,
- 26:37I think that it's exhausting.
- 26:40To have to
- 26:41keep going 2 steps forward,
- 26:434 steps back,
- 26:442 steps forward,
- 26:444 steps back.
- 26:45I mean,
- 26:46progress is so difficult and challenging and very frustrating,
- 26:49especially when a lot of the people who
- 26:51are destroying this progress are men
- 26:54and are not going to be physically impacted by this legislation.
- 26:58But,
- 26:59um,
- 26:59I hope that
- 27:00those of my friends who are watching this who
- 27:02are
- 27:03pro-choice,
- 27:04don't get tired,
- 27:05don't get frustrated
- 27:07and use this.
- 27:10Setback
- 27:11as inspiration to fight even harder.
- 27:15Because
- 27:16that's what I think they're expecting us to just kind of fold on it
- 27:19because we're exhausted
- 27:21and we can't do that.
- 27:23Mm
- 27:24Yeah,
- 27:25no,
- 27:25I,
- 27:25I,
- 27:25I appreciate those thoughts.
- 27:27I'm,
- 27:27I'm tempted to keep asking more because it is such a complex issue,
- 27:30but I wanna,
- 27:31in this
- 27:32respective time,
- 27:33let's move on and put a pin in that,
- 27:35um,
- 27:36but you and Charlie also talk about race and specifically the black,
- 27:41um,
- 27:41community in America when he invited you back to the center.
- 27:45I was shocked.
- 27:46I did not think he was inviting you.
- 27:49Yeah,
- 27:49no,
- 27:50he clearly
- 27:52was enjoying your,
- 27:53you know,
- 27:53the pushback that,
- 27:54that you are,
- 27:55you are providing,
- 27:56um,
- 27:58no,
- 27:58you know that meme where it's like
- 28:00the kid is pointing,
- 28:03you know what I'm talking about,
- 28:04that's how I felt.
- 28:06Yeah,
- 28:07no,
- 28:07I,
- 28:07I was kind of surprised too,
- 28:09but I mean,
- 28:09I do think
- 28:11uh something that he deserves some credit for is,
- 28:14I think he was interested in where the
- 28:17The true like friction was in an argument and going there,
- 28:20he wasn't interested in just like talking to somebody
- 28:23who was gonna
- 28:24sort of concede.
- 28:25um,
- 28:26I will say in every other debate video I have done
- 28:30since the Charlie Kirk video,
- 28:33everybody else has picked someone who was not really debating them.
- 28:37Yeah,
- 28:37no,
- 28:38I've seen,
- 28:38I've seen the same thing as well,
- 28:40so I was shocked.
- 28:41I did not.
- 28:42I thought that I was like there's no way he's gonna pick me.
- 28:44I was like,
- 28:44Oh,
- 28:44cool,
- 28:44I get to chill for 10 minutes,
- 28:45and then he's like,
- 28:46you,
- 28:46and I was like,
- 28:47All right,
- 28:49do I have like
- 28:51No,
- 28:51that was,
- 28:52um,
- 28:52it was expected.
- 28:53I actually just rewatched it this morning.
- 28:55I was like,
- 28:55oh wow,
- 28:55yeah,
- 28:56that,
- 28:56that was a bold pick.
- 28:57It was a fully unexpected.
- 28:59So I do,
- 28:59I also give him credit for that.
- 29:01It was not what I thought he was gonna do,
- 29:04um,
- 29:05but you know,
- 29:06he was down for it,
- 29:07which is interesting.
- 29:09Yeah,
- 29:10OK,
- 29:10and so this is where it goes,
- 29:11you know,
- 29:12you brought in,
- 29:13um,
- 29:13your own claim,
- 29:14and do you remember what your claim was?
- 29:16I think it'll be up in this.
- 29:17Something about black people,
- 29:18and then I got,
- 29:20I got with slavery ended wrong,
- 29:21which was fucking,
- 29:22I,
- 29:23that's haunted me for the past two years.
- 29:26So your
- 29:27claim was affirmative action is
- 29:29constitutional.
- 29:31Um,
- 29:31oh,
- 29:32right,
- 29:32OK,
- 29:33yeah,
- 29:33so make it for me.
- 29:35You know,
- 29:35it's race adjacent,
- 29:36but it,
- 29:37um,
- 29:38specifically,
- 29:39Charlie and
- 29:41debates you and moves in a direction just specifically around the black community.
- 29:44So,
- 29:45Let's kind of relisten to that and then,
- 29:48and then
- 29:49hear,
- 29:49hear your thoughts.
- 29:50Yeah,
- 29:50so,
- 29:51OK,
- 29:51so I wanna make a quick,
- 29:52you're right,
- 29:53Black Americans are in prison far greater than a percentage of the population.
- 29:56So the black Americans,
- 29:57about 13 to 14% of the population,
- 29:59about half of all prisoners are black.
- 30:01So blacks commit more crimes than whites do.
- 30:03They commit more murders.
- 30:04They commit more arsons,
- 30:05they commit more kidnappings.
- 30:07For example,
- 30:07blacks are 13% of the population,
- 30:09and they commit 58% of all the murders.
- 30:11That's not a war on drugs.
- 30:12It's a culture problem.
- 30:13OK,
- 30:14so let's talk about that culture.
- 30:16Black people
- 30:17have been
- 30:19legislatively subjugated
- 30:21up until
- 30:221965.
- 30:24I'll give it,
- 30:24I mean,
- 30:25honestly,
- 30:25it's later,
- 30:26but let's just say 1965.
- 30:28You do not think
- 30:30that 10
- 30:31generations
- 30:32of legislative subjugation
- 30:34and slavery
- 30:35during that time,
- 30:364000 black men,
- 30:38women,
- 30:39and children are lynched.
- 30:41As a result of race riots in this country,
- 30:44you do not think that these things
- 30:46have a lasting effect.
- 30:47We have had 10 generations of subjugation and 4
- 30:50of legislative freedom they have an impact,
- 30:51but it's more on you to explain why things got worse since the Civil Rights Act,
- 30:55more violent.
- 30:57Less fathers around,
- 30:58poorer.
- 30:59Why is that?
- 31:00Because of mass incarceration and the unfair criminalization of black men.
- 31:04But let's just take murders,
- 31:05for example.
- 31:06Why are,
- 31:07why blacks are 13% of the population and commit 58% of the murders?
- 31:10Why is that?
- 31:11Because
- 31:12people in affluent and Whiter neighborhoods are not being policed at the same rate.
- 31:16There are more police.
- 31:17I'm talking about dead bodies.
- 31:18There's no,
- 31:19like,
- 31:20we're not talking about policing.
- 31:21We're talking about murders.
- 31:22Why are so many blacks committing murders outside of their population?
- 31:26OK,
- 31:26let's take it back to some history.
- 31:28I'm curious for an answer to that question.
- 31:29I'm going to give you one.
- 31:31So let's go to redlining.
- 31:32OK,
- 31:33redlining,
- 31:33redlining is why so many blacks are killing each other.
- 31:36No,
- 31:36let me finish my claim,
- 31:38and then you can respond.
- 31:39Is that OK?
- 31:40OK,
- 31:41so redlining federally mandated or sustained by the FHA,
- 31:45right,
- 31:46separating
- 31:47black Americans
- 31:49to specifically impoverished and relegated areas of the country.
- 31:53We are incapable of buying homes
- 31:56and putting equity
- 31:57into neighborhoods with lower crime rates
- 32:00and better educational systems.
- 32:02We do not have access
- 32:04to things that would uplift and help our community
- 32:07when you are put
- 32:09in.
- 32:10An environment
- 32:12that promotes.
- 32:15And reinforces
- 32:18social
- 32:19and economic inequality.
- 32:22You become desperate and are forced to do things that maybe
- 32:25don't align
- 32:27with
- 32:29I gotta eat that.
- 32:32You're gonna watch yourself back
- 32:34and you're like,
- 32:35oh,
- 32:35please mention this,
- 32:36and then as soon as I said it,
- 32:37I said it.
- 32:38I was like,
- 32:38uh.
- 32:40No,
- 32:40I,
- 32:40I'm glad that you feel that way,
- 32:42um.
- 32:44No,
- 32:45yeah,
- 32:46so you feel,
- 32:47you feel strong about that argument.
- 32:48You still,
- 32:49you stand by that,
- 32:50you probably wouldn't change anything.
- 32:52I mean,
- 32:52I would probably say it quicker.
- 32:54I was a little slow to the punch,
- 32:55but,
- 32:55um,
- 32:56I was kind of like,
- 32:58talk,
- 32:58talk faster,
- 32:59please.
- 33:00But that's just me being
- 33:03overly criticaler than me.
- 33:04Well,
- 33:05this is from New York.
- 33:08Yeah,
- 33:08well,
- 33:09here's something though.
- 33:10So
- 33:11I get what
- 33:12Charlie is,
- 33:14I mean,
- 33:14he's painting a picture of like,
- 33:15hey,
- 33:15there's concerning data
- 33:18about where black Americans are at,
- 33:20you know,
- 33:20there's concerning data and how they are represented in
- 33:23prison statistics,
- 33:24crime
- 33:25statistics,
- 33:26violence statistics.
- 33:28And so like,
- 33:29the starting point actually,
- 33:30I think is shared.
- 33:32It's,
- 33:32there's nothing that you say
- 33:34in your argument that really refutes,
- 33:36yes,
- 33:37that is something to,
- 33:38to be concerned about.
- 33:39There's kind of this um
- 33:41disagreement in sort of how to interpret how we got there.
- 33:45And
- 33:45if I were to say your argument back to you,
- 33:48just to make sure that I understand it.
- 33:51You you're saying how
- 33:53the history of slavery,
- 33:54the history of Jim Crow,
- 33:56the history of discriminate
- 33:58uh discrimination codified into law,
- 34:01has cemented a cultural decline or has cemented.
- 34:05A disadvantage that would obviously be expressed in,
- 34:10you know,
- 34:10negative aspects within our culture,
- 34:12um,
- 34:13a high rate of violence or a high
- 34:16prison population,
- 34:17because
- 34:19The black community is always coming from,
- 34:21uh,
- 34:22inequal footing.
- 34:23Is that sort of a,
- 34:25does that sound like the argument that you were,
- 34:27you were making?
- 34:28Um,
- 34:29not quite,
- 34:29but close.
- 34:30Um,
- 34:31I think where I disagree with that is that I don't
- 34:33think that murder and violence are part of black culture.
- 34:37You know,
- 34:37I don't think we claim that as like an aspect of our culture.
- 34:40I think that that's also part of American culture,
- 34:42to be quite frank.
- 34:44Um,
- 34:45where I think the point that I was trying to
- 34:48make in that video is that where you have poverty,
- 34:51you have more crime.
- 34:52That is a fact regardless of race,
- 34:55like,
- 34:56um,
- 34:56in areas like Appalachia where we see very
- 34:59high levels of poverty among white populations,
- 35:02we see very similar crime rates
- 35:04as to places with high levels of poverty in black populations.
- 35:08Poverty equals desperation,
- 35:09desperation equals crime.
- 35:12When people no longer have the resources to put food on the table,
- 35:16they're not.
- 35:16Going to starve to death.
- 35:18They're going to do something about it.
- 35:20And
- 35:21the more desperate they are,
- 35:22the more willing they are to break laws in order to get what it is that they need
- 35:26because they need it.
- 35:26It's not,
- 35:27you know,
- 35:27a question,
- 35:28like you can't just opt out of drinking water and eating food.
- 35:32Right.
- 35:32And so it's kind of a,
- 35:33it's a matter of material circumstances,
- 35:36really more than anything.
- 35:37So,
- 35:38I think the argument that I'm trying to make,
- 35:39and I do wish that I Brought up that point about white and black
- 35:42people who are in similar levels of poverty do show similar crime rates,
- 35:47but,
- 35:47um,
- 35:48the point that I'm making is that
- 35:51black people have been systematically excluded
- 35:54from,
- 35:55uh,
- 35:56financial economic advancement,
- 35:58economic opportunities.
- 35:59We've been through Jim Crow,
- 36:01we've been kept out of unions,
- 36:03we've through redlining,
- 36:04we've been prevented.
- 36:05from buying homes,
- 36:06putting equity into housing,
- 36:08which is one of the most,
- 36:09like,
- 36:10which is one of the best,
- 36:11most sustainable investments that a family can make,
- 36:14right?
- 36:15You know,
- 36:16generational wealth.
- 36:17Yes,
- 36:17yes,
- 36:18we have been locked out of generational wealth building
- 36:21and then through the loophole in the 13th Amendment allowing free labor
- 36:26so long as it is done as a form of punishment.
- 36:29It's incentivized law enforcement
- 36:32to
- 36:33incarcerate black people at much higher rates in order to use
- 36:36our free labor as we saw with the war on drugs,
- 36:39right?
- 36:40So it's kind of a twofold thing.
- 36:42We've been kept out of economic advancements
- 36:44and we've been demonized for the sake of using our free labor,
- 36:50and both of these things have created.
- 36:54A community
- 36:55that is desperate and poor,
- 36:57quite frankly,
- 36:59and those who are desperate and poor are more inclined to commit crimes
- 37:02or violent crimes in order to get what they need to survive.
- 37:06And so then people like Charlie Kirk,
- 37:09who don't really want to recognize that history
- 37:12of segregation,
- 37:14of exclusion,
- 37:16who don't want to recognize the present condition of exploitation
- 37:20that we are under through mass incarceration.
- 37:23Like,
- 37:24um,
- 37:25You know,
- 37:26stop and frisk was this huge movement in New York
- 37:29that was all about stopping people and just like frisking them.
- 37:33The cops would just check to see if they had any contraband on them.
- 37:35This happened in my lifetime
- 37:38to,
- 37:38was that a response to super predators,
- 37:40that's kind of like the 90s type of thing.
- 37:42Well,
- 37:42it happened in my lifetime and
- 37:44it was disproportionately black and brown men,
- 37:48like way more,
- 37:49even though the population of New York is very diverse,
- 37:53like
- 37:54they had to cops had to fill a quota of people that they were frisking a day.
- 37:58And the majority of people who filled that quota
- 38:01were black people.
- 38:02And then when you add how AI adds to like
- 38:06like recidivism rates and like the racism and AI,
- 38:09there's a whole lot that goes into
- 38:11keeping black people in prison.
- 38:14So
- 38:15when you're like Charlie Kirk and you ignore the past and you ignore the present,
- 38:19it's kind of fair to say,
- 38:21oh,
- 38:21I see this problem and I blame it on these people.
- 38:23They must just be committing crimes more because they
- 38:26have a culture of violence,
- 38:28when in reality,
- 38:29we're reacting the way anyone else would
- 38:32in this situation.
- 38:34Yeah,
- 38:34and,
- 38:35and that
- 38:36argument,
- 38:36I think makes sense to me,
- 38:38especially when it's like grounded in kind of a material
- 38:41um circumstance,
- 38:42like framework,
- 38:43it
- 38:44like the
- 38:46as horrifying as slavery was.
- 38:48If you just think about it as like a a a footing,
- 38:52a foundation of how a group of group of people started
- 38:56in
- 38:57their socio socioeconomic status,
- 38:59it would make
- 39:00complete sense that there would be a disadvantage
- 39:03that endured through several,
- 39:05several generations.
- 39:06And then if it was,
- 39:08if there's discrimination that also endures,
- 39:10you know,
- 39:11it's further suppressing
- 39:13this group of people from
- 39:15Achieving equity or
- 39:16equitable status in whatever country you're talking about.
- 39:20So if I were to put myself in Charlie Kirk's
- 39:23head or,
- 39:23or position in that moment and concede,
- 39:25yes,
- 39:25what you're saying is,
- 39:27is correct,
- 39:28there's,
- 39:28there's a,
- 39:29a history that must be acknowledged.
- 39:32I guess where the question that I have though is,
- 39:35and this is,
- 39:35I think,
- 39:36really
- 39:37tricky,
- 39:38is,
- 39:38OK.
- 39:40The black population is overrepresented in crimes,
- 39:43that might be actually true.
- 39:45Black people are committing more crimes,
- 39:47but because of this
- 39:48legacy and this history that we're talking about,
- 39:51but still then what
- 39:53What are the most exciting or innovative ways to achieve equity,
- 39:57um,
- 39:58for that group of people?
- 40:00That's,
- 40:01that's still kind of an open question.
- 40:02I think
- 40:03there was a lot of ideas that came around,
- 40:06maybe in like
- 40:07Biden years
- 40:09prior to 2016,
- 40:10but it's still sort of an open question.
- 40:12Um,
- 40:13I'm curious what comes to mind for you.
- 40:14Well,
- 40:15firstly,
- 40:15I don't really think Charlie Kirk is interested
- 40:17in achieving equity for the black community.
- 40:19I mean,
- 40:19I,
- 40:21if he was,
- 40:22he wouldn't continue to call us the blacks.
- 40:23He said it maybe like 6 times in that video,
- 40:26which to me is very dehumanizing.
- 40:28Like,
- 40:28I'm not a crayon,
- 40:29you know,
- 40:30we're a group of people.
- 40:31We are black people.
- 40:32We are not the blacks,
- 40:33right?
- 40:34Um,
- 40:35I'm not a lump of coal.
- 40:36We are people.
- 40:37So,
- 40:38um,
- 40:38we're not just a color.
- 40:40So I don't see him as really,
- 40:43Caring about creating equity for the black community because I do believe that
- 40:48him and people who
- 40:49use that argument are blaming us for the situation that we are in now.
- 40:53They'll acknowledge the history,
- 40:54but they won't acknowledge the present discrimination.
- 40:57So,
- 40:57you know,
- 40:57yeah,
- 40:58it was bad before,
- 40:59but
- 40:59right now the shit that you're doing is on you,
- 41:02right?
- 41:03And that's not the case.
- 41:05So I think that.
- 41:07The 3 things that we've seen
- 41:10that create that create economic inequity the most are housing,
- 41:17education,
- 41:17jobs,
- 41:18right?
- 41:19And it's kind of a positive feedback loop between the three things.
- 41:23So,
- 41:23you know,
- 41:24a lot of the public education system is funded by property taxes.
- 41:29So if you're in a neighborhood
- 41:31that
- 41:32is very poor,
- 41:33if you're renting,
- 41:34right,
- 41:34you're not paying a ton of property taxes.
- 41:36So you're,
- 41:37the school system that your children have access to.
- 41:39is going to be worse.
- 41:41It just is.
- 41:42You're gonna see teacher shortages,
- 41:44you're gonna see book shortages,
- 41:45you're gonna see lack of resources.
- 41:47They're not gonna have as many like arts programs,
- 41:49extracurriculars,
- 41:51right?
- 41:51School lunches are going to be worse,
- 41:53like all of these things that hinder a child's
- 41:56ability to learn and grow to the best of their
- 42:00ability
- 42:01are not going to be there.
- 42:03So.
- 42:05Once your housing is kind of garbage,
- 42:06your school is going to be garbage,
- 42:08and if your school is garbage,
- 42:10then the opportunities you have.
- 42:13In terms of,
- 42:14you know,
- 42:14college,
- 42:15and then later on,
- 42:17getting a job are also going to be garbage.
- 42:21So once you now are in a bad job,
- 42:23you can't afford to live anywhere,
- 42:25but the shitty housing you grew up in,
- 42:27and you're back at the start.
- 42:29And now here are your kids going to those shitty schools,
- 42:32getting those same shitty jobs,
- 42:33living in that same shitty housing.
- 42:35So there has to be something
- 42:38that breaks this loop
- 42:40at some point
- 42:42in the loop,
- 42:43right?
- 42:43And,
- 42:44and so this brings us to your claim,
- 42:45you know,
- 42:46affirmative action being
- 42:48kind of the proposed solution,
- 42:49the proposed break in the loop.
- 42:51Exactly,
- 42:51it's one of them.
- 42:52I think that,
- 42:53I mean,
- 42:54I have issues with affirmative action because I don't think it.
- 42:56Does enough.
- 42:57I think that like early childhood education is one of
- 43:00the best places to kind of break that loop.
- 43:03Um,
- 43:03and affirmative action
- 43:04is really only for the kids who are able to kind of do that on their own,
- 43:08right?
- 43:09Because,
- 43:10you know,
- 43:10there's a lot of kids from that neighborhood who
- 43:12were just never going to apply to Harvard,
- 43:13right?
- 43:14They're just not going to.
- 43:16So affirmative action is not going to really help those kids,
- 43:18and we wanted to help all of those children,
- 43:20not just the best and the brightest.
- 43:23But,
- 43:23um,
- 43:25I mean,
- 43:25it's incredibly difficult.
- 43:27It's a really difficult conversation to have both economically and socially.
- 43:32I mean,
- 43:32some people talk about redistricting
- 43:35and allowing students in
- 43:37public in districts where the public schools are garbage
- 43:40to bus into other places.
- 43:42I know Kamala Harris is a big proponent of that,
- 43:44you know,
- 43:44she describes herself as being a bussed in kid.
- 43:47Um,
- 43:48so that's one idea that certain people have had,
- 43:50um,
- 43:51free lunches,
- 43:52like SNAP benefits,
- 43:54things like that at the home are ideas that people have.
- 43:57Um,
- 43:58changing up how schools are funded is a major way to do that.
- 44:05Combating gentrification now there's a lot.
- 44:07There's a lot we can do.
- 44:08I like your idea though.
- 44:10I mean,
- 44:10I think that is kind of a new,
- 44:12it's,
- 44:12it's a fresh,
- 44:13a new way to think about it is like let's move the target further up.
- 44:18Part of the cultural backlash,
- 44:21so we're gonna get into Ben Shapiro because identity.
- 44:23So now we're kind of entering the realm
- 44:24of like identity politics and so like affirmative action
- 44:28could be kind of,
- 44:29uh,
- 44:29classified as like a form of identity politics.
- 44:32We're
- 44:33we're trying to help this,
- 44:34this identity.
- 44:36Uh,
- 44:36achieve equity
- 44:38or more equitable status,
- 44:39and so we're,
- 44:40we're,
- 44:40you know,
- 44:41we're,
- 44:41we're thinking about things on more of like a curve,
- 44:44um,
- 44:45but the thing about college is like,
- 44:48it's so competitive,
- 44:49it's almost like a breeding ground for resentment,
- 44:52like,
- 44:52oh,
- 44:52so and so got in,
- 44:53I didn't get in,
- 44:55and we've kind of lived through this back,
- 44:57this cultural backlash where
- 44:59you're a DEI hire is kind of like a,
- 45:01uh,
- 45:01an insult you can throw at somebody.
- 45:04Um,
- 45:04like you don't,
- 45:05you didn't really earn that,
- 45:06you got that because of your identity.
- 45:08Um,
- 45:09and so we've lived through this backlash,
- 45:11and I kind of like your idea of maybe moving things further up because
- 45:15it might be further away from that sort of like,
- 45:19That competitive nature,
- 45:20like we want all kids to,
- 45:23I don't know,
- 45:23there's something,
- 45:24there's something about that proposition that I think might kind of
- 45:27pull away from the toxicity of like once you're
- 45:29kind of an adult.
- 45:31It everything kind of turns into like,
- 45:32why did this person get it and why didn't I?
- 45:34And we've seen sort of this like.
- 45:38This backlash to it.
- 45:39You would think that,
- 45:40but actually,
- 45:41like a lot of the bussing programs that I
- 45:44was describing have been met with insane amounts of backlash
- 45:48from parents who don't want their kids in school with students who come from
- 45:53with black and brown students who come from.
- 45:56Poorer neighborhoods.
- 45:58It's like,
- 45:59um,
- 46:00including in California,
- 46:02there have been several districts where parents have come out of the woodworks
- 46:07to protest
- 46:08the inclusion
- 46:10of these students who don't have
- 46:12as much financially.
- 46:14Um,
- 46:16so,
- 46:16you know,
- 46:17you would think
- 46:18that it being kids would make people more forgiving and less
- 46:23animus,
- 46:25but no,
- 46:26we've seen a similar response to children.
- 46:29So I think it still has a lot of work to do
- 46:32in terms of like our,
- 46:34our approach to helping others
- 46:37who are less advantaged than us.
- 46:39And
- 46:40the mechanism and the format of the program in and of itself.
- 46:43So you bring up,
- 46:45I think,
- 46:45a really valid point like.
- 46:47Uh,
- 46:47maybe I'm being too optimistic here.
- 46:49Like,
- 46:50even when we talk about trying to
- 46:52achieve better outcomes for less advantaged groups,
- 46:57um,
- 46:58earlier on in their educational journey,
- 47:00there's still tons of tension,
- 47:02there's still tons of
- 47:03resentment,
- 47:04and
- 47:06This kind of brings up,
- 47:07I think,
- 47:08just the question of like,
- 47:10is identity politics as a way of talking about
- 47:15these disadvantages that are baked into our society.
- 47:18Is it a dead end because it uh it
- 47:22evokes these responses?
- 47:24And so you had uh an exchange with Ben Shapiro
- 47:27about kind of just like
- 47:28whether or not we should just think of everybody as an individual
- 47:31or if acknowledging
- 47:34the identities of groups.
- 47:36is a constructive way of achieving equity.
- 47:39So I'm gonna play that clip for you and we can kind of dig into that,
- 47:42but
- 47:42it kind of segues,
- 47:44this,
- 47:44this topic segues into that,
- 47:46I think,
- 47:46really well.
- 47:47So for example,
- 47:47I'm Jewish.
- 47:48I don't think Jews are actually overrepresented in Congress.
- 47:50I don't think that,
- 47:51that we ought to decide exactly
- 47:53how
- 47:53many people in Congress are Jewish based on the Jewish population of the country.
- 47:56I think that's,
- 47:57that's actually a pretty silly way to do representation.
- 47:59Well,
- 47:59we don't have to do it systematically,
- 48:00but fundamentally there is an issue with the
- 48:02The fact that we are not fully represented,
- 48:05like the entire population is not represented.
- 48:07We have never had a black female president.
- 48:09I still have to pay taxes.
- 48:10The whole concept is no taxation without that,
- 48:12but we have had a white male president.
- 48:13We've had like 45 of whether Jews count as white or not
- 48:16has been sort of an object of debate for quite a while.
- 48:19We do.
- 48:19OK.
- 48:20So,
- 48:20I mean,
- 48:21it depends according to whom.
- 48:22And that's a pretty recent development.
- 48:24OK,
- 48:24so basically everyone,
- 48:25it's a religion.
- 48:26It,
- 48:26it's
- 48:27Judaism.
- 48:27Do you not agree that you are a white man?
- 48:29I mean,
- 48:30I think that it depends on,
- 48:30on the context in which you're discussing it.
- 48:32Meaning,
- 48:32what are you,
- 48:33Ben?
- 48:33Are you not a white guy?
- 48:34I mean,
- 48:34I'm,
- 48:35I'm a man of Jewish ethnicity,
- 48:36which is sometimes grouped with white and sometimes not.
- 48:37I mean,
- 48:38that's the more accurate way to put it.
- 48:39But
- 48:39when we're talking about grouped with,
- 48:41with Jews who are ethic,
- 48:42which is an ethnicity,
- 48:43which is an ethnicity,
- 48:45I mean,
- 48:45so you're not white at all.
- 48:46I mean,
- 48:47again,
- 48:47it depends who's doing the grouping and how.
- 48:48I've seen it.
- 48:49I've seen Jews grouped with white and Jews grouped with not white.
- 48:51And
- 48:52are we just pretending that doesn't exist?
- 48:53That that's,
- 48:54that's a reality.
- 48:54However,
- 48:55as far as your generalized point,
- 48:56which is that we are supposed to identify people by group identity,
- 48:59if we don't have a black female president,
- 49:00somehow
- 49:01black females have not been represented.
- 49:02So Barack Obama was in no way representative
- 49:04of black females because he's not a female.
- 49:06No,
- 49:06he was,
- 49:06he was representative,
- 49:07but he's half representative.
- 49:08How do you,
- 49:09how do you do the math on this
- 49:10and why?
- 49:10You shouldn't do the math on it completely statistically,
- 49:12but the fact is you shouldn't do the math on it at all.
- 49:14Clearly treat people as individualpresentative.
- 49:16You should treat people as individuals.
- 49:17Well,
- 49:17if you don't even want Kamala Harris to attempt to create DEI.
- 49:20Initiatives in office,
- 49:21and there isn't even going to be a conversation about it.
- 49:23I mean,
- 49:24I don't think there ought to be a conversation about why
- 49:26we ought to be represented by race or by sex.
- 49:29I think that we are each individual people with individual ideas,
- 49:32and if that person represents my ideas,
- 49:34I don't care what sex,
- 49:35race,
- 49:35or sexual orientation they are.
- 49:36I mean,
- 49:37to an extent,
- 49:38yes,
- 49:39but there is an issue with the lack of empathy in office.
- 49:41We need to be able to empathize and legislate for the people
- 49:45that are living in this country.
- 49:46I was not you not believe that?
- 49:47I was not aware that empathy is,
- 49:49is relegated.
- 49:49To particular race solidarity.
- 49:51No,
- 49:51but I mean,
- 49:52it's easier to be empathetic towards people whose experiences
- 49:55you can fundamentally understand based on your identity.
- 49:57Like,
- 49:58do you not believe that people have an inherent bias?
- 49:59So first of all,
- 50:00based on identity,
- 50:00I mean,
- 50:01we can start with the empathy itself.
- 50:02I'm not sure that empathy is always the best basis for,
- 50:04for actual public policy because when you have
- 50:05group solidarity and empathy based on group solidarity,
- 50:08you're going to attempt to actually benefit
- 50:10the group with whom you have solidarity.
- 50:11So that actually cuts against generalized that's
- 50:12like a fundamental thing that just exists,
- 50:14which is why we need representation in government.
- 50:16OK,
- 50:17so that.
- 50:19That's it.
- 50:19There's interesting tension there.
- 50:21What,
- 50:21what comes to your mind?
- 50:23Well,
- 50:23the first thing that comes to my mind is actually fucking Nick Fuentes.
- 50:26Um,
- 50:27I was thinking of Nick Fuentes too.
- 50:29Why?
- 50:30Well,
- 50:31he reposted that clip.
- 50:33Which
- 50:34was shocking to me and I was like,
- 50:36oh no,
- 50:36no,
- 50:36no,
- 50:37no,
- 50:37Nick Buentes,
- 50:37please don't,
- 50:38no,
- 50:39because Nick,
- 50:40me and Nickuentes have had like weird interactions in the past
- 50:44because he hates Ben Shapiro because he hates all Jewish people.
- 50:48So whenever I debate Ben Shapiro,
- 50:50he gets really excited about it and I'm like,
- 50:52wait,
- 50:52uh,
- 50:53uh,
- 50:53we are,
- 50:53no,
- 50:55that's not the point that I'm making.
- 50:58But he that is interesting because it does.
- 51:01Uh,
- 51:02uh,
- 51:02OK,
- 51:02so if we're talking about
- 51:04purely aesthetics.
- 51:06Um,
- 51:07when you say,
- 51:08do you not consider yourself a white guy,
- 51:10I completely see what you're saying.
- 51:12I'm like,
- 51:13anyone's going to look at Ben Shapiro and be like,
- 51:15that's a white man.
- 51:17But when we're talking about.
- 51:19The more complicated identity politics when
- 51:23we're talking about like Jewish people and Israel
- 51:26and foreign
- 51:27policy and Nick Fuentes,
- 51:29all of a sudden there's kind of like
- 51:32a different calculus going on and Nick Fuentes would never ally himself
- 51:35with Ben Shapiro.
- 51:37But is that a racial thing or
- 51:39it's not really,
- 51:40it's more of like an ideological thing.
- 51:42I mean,
- 51:42it's kind of 3,
- 51:43like it's,
- 51:44it's the intersection of like nationality,
- 51:47ethnicity and race,
- 51:49right?
- 51:50Like,
- 51:51there are people,
- 51:53I think Ben Shapiro's point
- 51:56kind of
- 51:57fucked him a little bit with the whole Nick Fuentes siding with me thing,
- 51:59but,
- 52:00um,
- 52:00and people being like,
- 52:01aha,
- 52:02well,
- 52:02so,
- 52:03The reason why Nick Fuentes reposted it is
- 52:05because Nick Fuentes is a white supremacist,
- 52:08but
- 52:08there is this issue of being a Nazi and a white supremacist at the same time,
- 52:13because there are white Jews.
- 52:15So if you believe that you are a white supremacist
- 52:18and a Jewish person is white,
- 52:20but you also hate them,
- 52:21it kind of creates this weird.
- 52:24Like,
- 52:25well,
- 52:25where do they fit
- 52:26in my framework of white supremacists,
- 52:28of white supremacism.
- 52:30So if this Jewish man is saying,
- 52:31well,
- 52:31I'm actually not white,
- 52:33then Nick Fuentes's worldview is now corroborated
- 52:36because he say he thinks that anyone who is not white sucks,
- 52:40and anyone who is Jewish sucks.
- 52:42So if Jewish people aren't white,
- 52:44then he can maintain his white supremacy and his Nazi.
- 52:48Beliefs without having to deal with
- 52:51where white Jews fit into that because none of
- 52:54them are white allegedly according to Ben Shapiro,
- 52:57but
- 52:58that,
- 52:58so that I think is kind of where Nick is coming from of like,
- 53:02see if you're not white,
- 53:03then you are deeply inferior.
- 53:05I proved it.
- 53:06I did it like
- 53:08you proved it for me,
- 53:09but um
- 53:11to his
- 53:13To
- 53:14Ben's point in the video,
- 53:16I think that he's doing a disservice to black Jews,
- 53:19first of all,
- 53:19like RuPaul Charles is one of my,
- 53:22I don't know if you know him from RuPaul's Drag Race.
- 53:24He is very visibly black and he is also
- 53:27Jewish,
- 53:28right?
- 53:28And so for him,
- 53:31He is going to do,
- 53:32a man who is visibly black and also ethnically and religiously Jewish
- 53:37is going to be dealing with two different types of discrimination,
- 53:40right?
- 53:41Anti-Semitism
- 53:42and racism.
- 53:44Whereas Ben Shapiro is not.
- 53:46Ben Shapiro is just going to be dealing with anti-Semitism.
- 53:50Not that that is at all good
- 53:52or less than,
- 53:53but
- 53:54it doesn't fully accommodate the levels of racism
- 53:58that people are going to experience based on
- 54:01the body that they're in,
- 54:03right?
- 54:04There's no nuance to it.
- 54:06And I think that's what Ben is lacking because he
- 54:09doesn't want to admit that he has white privilege.
- 54:11That's why he's not calling himself white,
- 54:13because he doesn't want to acknowledge
- 54:15white privilege.
- 54:17Because if he does,
- 54:18then it gives points towards my DEI argument,
- 54:21which he doesn't want to give.
- 54:23I think,
- 54:24OK,
- 54:24so,
- 54:25I think I agree
- 54:28with that.
- 54:29There's a lot,
- 54:30you're right,
- 54:30there's a lot of things intersecting here.
- 54:32I don't know if I fully understand why Ben
- 54:37Conceding that he's.
- 54:40Maybe sees himself as more like ethnically
- 54:43Jewish than like quote unquote white supports the Nick Fuentes argument,
- 54:48um,
- 54:49because I don't,
- 54:50I,
- 54:50I don't think Ben or Nick want to really be seen as on each other's teams
- 54:56because they are so
- 54:57ideologically opposed,
- 54:59but I guess.
- 55:01Where my mind goes to if I'm just.
- 55:04This is really complicated.
- 55:05The intersection of all these identities is really complicated,
- 55:08like you're saying with RuPaul.
- 55:10There's
- 55:11a Jewish lens that needs to be acknowledged.
- 55:13There's the ethnic um lens that needs to be
- 55:17uh acknowledged,
- 55:18like racism,
- 55:19anti-Semitism.
- 55:20It,
- 55:20it is all very,
- 55:21very complex.
- 55:23And so that,
- 55:24I actually think does lead me towards understanding what Ben is saying is
- 55:29Identity politics as a basis for legislation
- 55:33maybe is not a good
- 55:35um
- 55:36ground
- 55:36because
- 55:38how can
- 55:40How can we know that
- 55:42whatever group is in power is not going to default towards
- 55:45their preferred group,
- 55:46which is most likely going to be their own identity?
- 55:49Well,
- 55:50that's exactly what I'm saying,
- 55:51right?
- 55:52Because we know sociologically tribalism is a thing.
- 55:56People prefer those who share
- 55:58common ancestry to them,
- 56:00who look like them,
- 56:02who share a history with them,
- 56:04a religion,
- 56:05a race,
- 56:06people.
- 56:06Naturally
- 56:07prefer and favor those people.
- 56:09That's not something that we can necessarily
- 56:13prevent,
- 56:14but that's why it's important to have
- 56:16representation in government that is diverse,
- 56:19so there's no group that's receiving unfair preference because
- 56:23a vast majority of their group is represented in government.
- 56:28Like if everyone in government is white and we know that
- 56:32white people have a tendency to prefer other white
- 56:34people and favor other white people and think about
- 56:37the needs of other white people more and prioritize those needs,
- 56:41then we have to see black people in government.
- 56:43We have to see Asian people
- 56:45and Native American people,
- 56:46you know,
- 56:47and Hispanic people in government
- 56:49because we know that without
- 56:51representation of our race.
- 56:53We can't just rely on other races
- 56:56to make us as much of a priority legislatively because historically
- 57:01and socially we just don't do that as a species.
- 57:04But I guess what Ben,
- 57:06what I think Ben is arguing is how can you
- 57:11create legislation that acknowledges race without,
- 57:14I guess like how do you get there in the form of legislation because
- 57:18Like,
- 57:19is it always the majority,
- 57:20like,
- 57:21is the word majority and minority
- 57:24instead of like white and black,
- 57:26you know,
- 57:26so that it like sort of
- 57:28can scale beyond,
- 57:29let's just fast forward to the future when the majority of American
- 57:33population is,
- 57:34is brown,
- 57:35um,
- 57:35and not white.
- 57:36Like let's just assume
- 57:37far in the future,
- 57:39whites are no longer the majority.
- 57:42What,
- 57:43what kind of laws do we need to design now where the language would apply then?
- 57:48Like the same intention would apply then without being too specific about races.
- 57:53Because if,
- 57:54if we make laws where it's like we need to have
- 57:57a 1 to 1 representation,
- 57:59like if 20% of
- 58:01the population is black,
- 58:02then 20% of
- 58:04lawmakers also need to be black,
- 58:07like is that
- 58:09Are we creating bad incentives in government,
- 58:12where then like later down the road,
- 58:13there's gonna be this sort of um
- 58:16abuse of that logic,
- 58:17um,
- 58:18abuse of that.
- 58:21That style of legislation.
- 58:22Do you see what I'm saying?
- 58:24Well,
- 58:24I think that's kind of like a white replacement theory argument of like,
- 58:28you know,
- 58:30I'm afraid of if we don't,
- 58:31I mean,
- 58:32like,
- 58:32as we've seen historically,
- 58:34like if you look at South Africa as an example,
- 58:36right,
- 58:37South Africa has a vast majority
- 58:40non-white population,
- 58:42yet,
- 58:44Power
- 58:45was concentrated to this white minority,
- 58:49which enabled them to exploit the black majority,
- 58:53right?
- 58:54Um,
- 58:55and to oppress that black majority.
- 58:57So it is all,
- 58:59it's not really about population numbers itself,
- 59:02it's about legislative power
- 59:05and representation in government,
- 59:07because even as a minority,
- 59:09you can still exploit
- 59:11a group that is larger than you,
- 59:14so long as you have a majority where it matters,
- 59:18yes,
- 59:18of power.
- 59:20So,
- 59:21I think that it's a difficult system to quantify and like I said in my debate with Ben,
- 59:27like,
- 59:27I don't think it should be exactly a 1 to 1,
- 59:30and it would take a lot of legislators,
- 59:32a lot of thinkers,
- 59:33a lot of policymakers
- 59:35to come up with a system that was truly fair,
- 59:38equitable,
- 59:39and representative of all races,
- 59:42um,
- 59:43just specifically because,
- 59:44you know,
- 59:44it's not something that I'm just gonna like pitch like,
- 59:47yeah,
- 59:47let's just do a 1 to 1 because I think it's much more complex than that.
- 59:51Um,
- 59:52and I think there's a lot that we have to consider,
- 59:54but I think that it's about,
- 59:56it's about internalizing the belief
- 59:59that people need to be represented in government
- 1:00:02by
- 1:00:03those who share
- 1:00:05their identity.
- 1:00:07Maybe we aren't,
- 1:00:08I'm not
- 1:00:09entirely sure on what policy
- 1:00:11would create that,
- 1:00:12but it's more about so about accepting the ideology and the necessity of that,
- 1:00:17right?
- 1:00:18Our country was founded on that belief of no taxation without representation.
- 1:00:23Meanwhile,
- 1:00:23you know,
- 1:00:24my ancestors weren't even considered people at the time,
- 1:00:27right?
- 1:00:28So
- 1:00:28our country,
- 1:00:30Understands and values the importance of representative government.
- 1:00:33It's like what we've stood on since
- 1:00:361776
- 1:00:39and even before.
- 1:00:41We fought for this,
- 1:00:41we've died for that,
- 1:00:42right?
- 1:00:43But now that this country has expanded to be more diverse,
- 1:00:47we don't really see that same.
- 1:00:50Incentive to represent everyone equitably in government.
- 1:00:55So it's not necessarily that I'm trying to propose legislation,
- 1:00:58it's that I'm trying to propose an idea that I
- 1:01:01think and a value that I think everyone should have.
- 1:01:05We should all value
- 1:01:07seeing ourselves represented in government,
- 1:01:10seeing our identities represented in media,
- 1:01:13because there is power,
- 1:01:15seeing ourselves represented in the private sector and CEOs,
- 1:01:18you know.
- 1:01:20In C-suite executives,
- 1:01:21all of these people should be representative of the
- 1:01:24population because they have so much power over us,
- 1:01:27and,
- 1:01:28If they're priorities,
- 1:01:30because almost all humans prioritize those
- 1:01:33who look like them and share their identity
- 1:01:36and
- 1:01:38share their history.
- 1:01:40If we all do that,
- 1:01:41then we know that it's a necessity,
- 1:01:43which is kind of the point.
- 1:01:45Yeah,
- 1:01:46no,
- 1:01:46and I,
- 1:01:47that
- 1:01:47makes
- 1:01:48perfect sense and I like that idea of it as a value.
- 1:01:50That's like a value we want to instill,
- 1:01:52that's sort of the,
- 1:01:54Ideal,
- 1:01:55pluralistic,
- 1:01:56open society we want to have.
- 1:01:59Yes.
- 1:02:01Something that now that we kind of have Nick Fuentes on the mind,
- 1:02:04when I think of Nick Fuentes though,
- 1:02:06I see him as.
- 1:02:09A manifestation of a white
- 1:02:11identity politics backlash
- 1:02:14to.
- 1:02:16What was a cultural attempt to achieve equity through
- 1:02:19DEI and,
- 1:02:20and,
- 1:02:21um,
- 1:02:22uh,
- 1:02:22a form of
- 1:02:23well-intentioned identity politics.
- 1:02:27That makes me wonder.
- 1:02:29If the better lens that you brought up earlier of class is actually the way to
- 1:02:35prevent
- 1:02:35a,
- 1:02:36a backlash like Nick Fuentes of having sort
- 1:02:38of justified grievances or the appearance of justified grievances
- 1:02:42because
- 1:02:44If the goal is to always make sure that we're,
- 1:02:47we're trying to prevent like power from accumulating just in the wealthiest class.
- 1:02:52Um,
- 1:02:53that
- 1:02:54in the present
- 1:02:55would be a benefit to
- 1:02:58A large portion of brown and black people,
- 1:03:00but it wouldn't be,
- 1:03:01the race wouldn't be like sort of written into the law.
- 1:03:04It would be more of like you're saying,
- 1:03:05this value of like,
- 1:03:07we want to make sure that we're,
- 1:03:08we're not letting
- 1:03:09power concentrate in the people who have the most.
- 1:03:12Um,
- 1:03:13but like class might be the best way to achieve that in an enduring way,
- 1:03:17no matter the
- 1:03:18racial dynamics of,
- 1:03:20of the society.
- 1:03:22You know,
- 1:03:22I have this debate a lot with my communist
- 1:03:25friends because some of them believe that like,
- 1:03:27you know,
- 1:03:28by focusing on the issue of race,
- 1:03:30we're ignoring class consciousness and we're creating
- 1:03:33a divide that doesn't need to exist between
- 1:03:37lower class white people and lower class black people,
- 1:03:40black and brown people.
- 1:03:40I'm sorry,
- 1:03:41I just,
- 1:03:41I laugh because you're like when I debate my communist friends and,
- 1:03:44uh,
- 1:03:45that just is a way to start a sentence.
- 1:03:47It's like maybe chuckle.
- 1:03:48I'm sorry,
- 1:03:50but you have this debate with your friends.
- 1:03:51I have communist friends too.
- 1:03:53It's like a new phenomenon.
- 1:03:54But anyway,
- 1:03:54yes,
- 1:03:55I do what I do meet my communist friends.
- 1:03:57Um,
- 1:03:57you know,
- 1:03:57we have this kind of argument about like whether or not
- 1:04:00it's important to deal with identity politics and class consciousness,
- 1:04:04and I would say I think you kind of have to do both.
- 1:04:06I don't really think that you can forget about racism when it comes to classism.
- 1:04:10I think that if this was a different country.
- 1:04:12Like if this was Sweden,
- 1:04:14then I would say absolutely we should be focused on class,
- 1:04:16you know,
- 1:04:17but this country has a very long history of racism.
- 1:04:21I think that this country is much more racist than people like to give it credit for.
- 1:04:26I mean,
- 1:04:26as we've seen with the attacks on like teaching about
- 1:04:29race theory and the history of racism in schools.
- 1:04:34As we've seen,
- 1:04:35you know,
- 1:04:35attacks on immigrants,
- 1:04:37specifically brown immigrants,
- 1:04:40as they've come to this country,
- 1:04:41even though we've encouraged that immigration
- 1:04:43multiple times throughout our country's history
- 1:04:46and now kind of have backtracked on it and decided to villainize them,
- 1:04:49um,
- 1:04:50despite actually benefiting from their labor.
- 1:04:53Um,
- 1:04:53we see this as mass incarceration today.
- 1:04:55We see this on,
- 1:04:57you know,
- 1:04:57pulling back affirmative action,
- 1:04:59um,
- 1:05:00and that being seen as unconstitutional.
- 1:05:02Like
- 1:05:03we have seen an attack on race
- 1:05:05when you have an openly racist president in office.
- 1:05:08The fact that Trump can be so openly racist
- 1:05:11and still get elected
- 1:05:13means that there are just millions of people in this country
- 1:05:16who don't really care that much about racism
- 1:05:20and how it's impacting.
- 1:05:22Minority communities.
- 1:05:24Um,
- 1:05:24and you can say the same thing honestly about really any issue of identity.
- 1:05:28You could say the same thing about transgenderism and the LGBTQ struggle,
- 1:05:32like all of these groups of people.
- 1:05:35In a way it could be
- 1:05:37used to say like,
- 1:05:38oh,
- 1:05:38they're distracting from the real issues,
- 1:05:40which is classism,
- 1:05:41right?
- 1:05:42And their identities are so enraging to people
- 1:05:46that
- 1:05:47it's
- 1:05:49hurting
- 1:05:50the cause,
- 1:05:51you know.
- 1:05:55This is,
- 1:05:55it's like such a a um,
- 1:05:58OK,
- 1:05:58so,
- 1:05:59but with class,
- 1:06:00I guess what I'm saying is race is baked in.
- 1:06:04Because
- 1:06:04if
- 1:06:05you're addressing the inequities in class,
- 1:06:08you're also addressing the inequities.
- 1:06:11Of that are distributed among race because,
- 1:06:15you know,
- 1:06:15that that's like,
- 1:06:17like class is sort of the outcome of the racism.
- 1:06:21And I guess what I,
- 1:06:22what I'm saying is,
- 1:06:23as a society,
- 1:06:24I wonder if we're.
- 1:06:26Are we perhaps expecting too much?
- 1:06:29Of a large population to be able to,
- 1:06:33like,
- 1:06:33can we really expect
- 1:06:35the,
- 1:06:35the United States to come to a consensus on its history of racism
- 1:06:39in a uniform enough way.
- 1:06:42For like race to be the target through legislation.
- 1:06:46Like I guess I,
- 1:06:47the last 10 years has made me actually really skeptical of that.
- 1:06:50I think
- 1:06:51if you rewind 10 years ago,
- 1:06:52I think I would be more
- 1:06:54on your page and what you're saying now and be like,
- 1:06:56no,
- 1:06:57there needs to be more of a reckoning of our our history with racism and slavery.
- 1:07:01But the last 10 years has made me wonder,
- 1:07:03is that actually possible?
- 1:07:06Um,
- 1:07:07and,
- 1:07:07and is maybe
- 1:07:09focusing on class a way to just get it baked in without,
- 1:07:12without the Nick Fuentes backlash.
- 1:07:14I think that Nick Fuentes would exist regardless,
- 1:07:16um,
- 1:07:17but what I will say is,
- 1:07:19you know,
- 1:07:20it has to be.
- 1:07:22Right?
- 1:07:22It has to be.
- 1:07:23It's not really an option.
- 1:07:24Like,
- 1:07:25so long as black men are being
- 1:07:27torn from their families,
- 1:07:28families are being destroyed over nonviolent offenses,
- 1:07:31so long as black men and women are being killed at the hands
- 1:07:34of the cops without a trial by a jury of their peers,
- 1:07:37like,
- 1:07:37so long as we are afraid to call.
- 1:07:39The police.
- 1:07:40Like,
- 1:07:40I've never called the police in my fucking life,
- 1:07:43and I probably never will.
- 1:07:45Like,
- 1:07:45you know,
- 1:07:46so long as we are afraid to use social services like that,
- 1:07:50so long as we are denied access to loans
- 1:07:54that are fair
- 1:07:55based on our income.
- 1:07:58Solely and specifically on the basis of race,
- 1:08:00preventing us from buying houses,
- 1:08:03like
- 1:08:03the 2008 recession affected the black community
- 1:08:06so much worse
- 1:08:08because we were given these very predatory loans
- 1:08:11because we were black,
- 1:08:13because no one else would loan to us,
- 1:08:14right?
- 1:08:15Because
- 1:08:16we're black.
- 1:08:16And so,
- 1:08:17so long as we have all these tangible negative impacts on my community,
- 1:08:23I cannot
- 1:08:24not try.
- 1:08:25It's not an option for me,
- 1:08:27right?
- 1:08:28Like my father is currently trying to get,
- 1:08:30he needs a kidney transplant and because he is black,
- 1:08:33the level at which his,
- 1:08:36um,
- 1:08:36I think it's called GFR or like his kidney functioning has to
- 1:08:39be at in order for him to be eligible for a transplant.
- 1:08:42Is lower than that of a white person,
- 1:08:45despite the fact that
- 1:08:47physically and medically we are the same,
- 1:08:49right?
- 1:08:50It's like,
- 1:08:51so long,
- 1:08:51like,
- 1:08:51I mean,
- 1:08:52my uncle died because he didn't have access to healthcare.
- 1:08:55He had cancer.
- 1:08:56He refused to go to the doctor
- 1:08:58because he didn't have healthcare through child.
- 1:08:59Like these things have real
- 1:09:02lasting consequences on my community.
- 1:09:04Like this is life or death for a lot of people.
- 1:09:08So,
- 1:09:08you know,
- 1:09:08I understand the desire to.
- 1:09:10Focus on class.
- 1:09:11I see the necessity to do that,
- 1:09:12and I encourage others too,
- 1:09:14especially if that's their niche.
- 1:09:16But for me,
- 1:09:16it's like I'm fighting for the rights of my family who need these rights
- 1:09:21now,
- 1:09:21who needed these rights
- 1:09:23yesterday.
- 1:09:23It's not really a choice for me to just focus on class
- 1:09:27because I'm watching my community suffer
- 1:09:29and I'm watching the people I love
- 1:09:31die,
- 1:09:32literally.
- 1:09:34You know,
- 1:09:35I'm
- 1:09:35obviously that's terrible to hear about with your,
- 1:09:38your dad,
- 1:09:39and um,
- 1:09:40I'm sorry you guys are going through that.
- 1:09:41I'm sorry he's going through that.
- 1:09:42He has great health insurance,
- 1:09:44so he's doing OK,
- 1:09:45and they're figuring it out,
- 1:09:46by the way,
- 1:09:46like he's going to be fine,
- 1:09:48but in no way would I think that that would be acceptable either,
- 1:09:51I guess.
- 1:09:52Like what you're saying is like how can,
- 1:09:53uh,
- 1:09:54a person of one ethnicity have a different
- 1:09:57Qualifying bar
- 1:09:58for coverage versus another identity.
- 1:10:01Like if that's baked into insurance
- 1:10:03insurance
- 1:10:04calculations,
- 1:10:05I,
- 1:10:05I would
- 1:10:06consider that discrimination.
- 1:10:09Yeah,
- 1:10:09well,
- 1:10:09that one is more based into like,
- 1:10:11um,
- 1:10:12medical practices.
- 1:10:13Like a doctor will recommend when you need a
- 1:10:15transplant based on what level your functionality is at,
- 1:10:19and for black people that level has to be lower,
- 1:10:22right?
- 1:10:22And we see also with black women,
- 1:10:25we are,
- 1:10:25I believe,
- 1:10:264 times more likely
- 1:10:28to die during childbirth.
- 1:10:31Like the mortality rates for black women is,
- 1:10:34is terrible.
- 1:10:35Yeah,
- 1:10:37so,
- 1:10:37you know,
- 1:10:37racism is killing us.
- 1:10:39So it's not really like,
- 1:10:41it's not that I don't think we should be focused on class.
- 1:10:44I do believe that there are people who are much more equipped to do that
- 1:10:47and who I encourage to do that.
- 1:10:49Honestly,
- 1:10:50I prefer it when white people do that.
- 1:10:52I don't necessarily enjoy white people always fighting on my behalf because
- 1:10:56sometimes they misspeak for my community and it's not really helpful.
- 1:11:00So,
- 1:11:00you know,
- 1:11:01it got cringy.
- 1:11:02It got really cringy.
- 1:11:05The black screens,
- 1:11:05I was like,
- 1:11:06oh my God,
- 1:11:06guys,
- 1:11:06please stop,
- 1:11:07please stop.
- 1:11:07It's,
- 1:11:08yes,
- 1:11:08the virtue signaling,
- 1:11:09like there are a lot of instances,
- 1:11:12including in this debate actually with some of
- 1:11:14the contestants there who I'm not gonna name,
- 1:11:17but I was like,
- 1:11:17please stop.
- 1:11:20Yeah,
- 1:11:20no,
- 1:11:20but I think that's just like for me it's like I know what I need to do.
- 1:11:24I hope that there are people out there who
- 1:11:26continue to focus on class and creating class consciousness,
- 1:11:29but I have to defend my people
- 1:11:31because they need it now,
- 1:11:33you know.
- 1:11:33I totally get that.
- 1:11:35I think,
- 1:11:35um,
- 1:11:36for me,
- 1:11:36I'm really like marinating in
- 1:11:39the outcomes
- 1:11:40of the last 10 years and,
- 1:11:42and really questioning like what is the tactic
- 1:11:44that actually achieves the outcomes that we want,
- 1:11:47and one of them being
- 1:11:50You know,
- 1:11:51lowering this delta between
- 1:11:54health outcomes,
- 1:11:55financial outcomes
- 1:11:56across
- 1:11:57different races and especially within the black community because
- 1:12:00the black community is just that delta in wealth
- 1:12:03in health
- 1:12:05has existed in this country for so long and so that's exhausted,
- 1:12:08yeah,
- 1:12:08yeah,
- 1:12:10but like you're saying,
- 1:12:11you know,
- 1:12:11the black squares,
- 1:12:13like if race is the forefront,
- 1:12:14like
- 1:12:15I wonder if that incentive actually creates these cringy.
- 1:12:19Like it,
- 1:12:20it turns people into like wanting a virtue signal rather than like
- 1:12:24craft real
- 1:12:26ideas that generate an outcome.
- 1:12:28I guess that that's where my head's at,
- 1:12:30but,
- 1:12:30um,
- 1:12:31I,
- 1:12:31I appreciate your how to prevent on that white people from being cringy.
- 1:12:36That one I can't solve for you.
- 1:12:38But,
- 1:12:39well,
- 1:12:39but that's what I wonder does identity politics generate
- 1:12:42that cringiness because it's a bad social incentive.
- 1:12:45But again,
- 1:12:46that's why we need representation from black people,
- 1:12:49right?
- 1:12:49Because I'm speaking on behalf of like my lived experience.
- 1:12:52It's not cringy when you're sharing your lived experience,
- 1:12:55right?
- 1:12:55So I think.
- 1:12:56What's cringe about white people is that they want to help,
- 1:12:59but because they're the only voices in a space,
- 1:13:02they end up speaking on behalf of us
- 1:13:04and the shit they're saying is wrong and annoying,
- 1:13:07right?
- 1:13:08So that's again why we need to focus on
- 1:13:10creating representation when we're having
- 1:13:12these conversations about identity politics
- 1:13:14and when we're creating legislation that we know is going to impact
- 1:13:19certain communities of color,
- 1:13:21of,
- 1:13:21you know,
- 1:13:23ethnicity of.
- 1:13:24Sexuality,
- 1:13:25right of gender,
- 1:13:26it's important to center those voices
- 1:13:29who are speaking from personal experience
- 1:13:32because otherwise it does come off as cringy.
- 1:13:34It comes off as virtue signaling.
- 1:13:36It comes off as you're doing this.
- 1:13:37Yes,
- 1:13:38you're doing this to satiate your
- 1:13:40need to be a good person,
- 1:13:41right,
- 1:13:41right.
- 1:13:43Yes.
- 1:13:44So yeah,
- 1:13:45just bringing it back of that,
- 1:13:46I think.
- 1:13:47Yes,
- 1:13:48yes,
- 1:13:48we have.
- 1:13:49So just kind of bringing it back to,
- 1:13:50you know,
- 1:13:51my initial debate with Ben.
- 1:13:53That's why we need people to be representative in government.
- 1:13:57That's why we need people to be representative in these conversations,
- 1:14:00because if they're not,
- 1:14:01it's just
- 1:14:02people talking in an echo chamber who don't really know what they're talking about.
- 1:14:06And then eventually they're gonna create legislation,
- 1:14:08and it's like,
- 1:14:09oh God,
- 1:14:09please no,
- 1:14:10please stop,
- 1:14:11you know.
- 1:14:12Well,
- 1:14:12and I think I really agree with what resonates with.
- 1:14:16me a lot from your argument with Ben,
- 1:14:18and I,
- 1:14:19I really wish that debate could have gone on cause I think you,
- 1:14:21I felt like you were both coming to it in good faith,
- 1:14:24even though from very different places.
- 1:14:27Is that lack of acknowledgement,
- 1:14:29wanting to just brush past
- 1:14:31the acknowledgement that yes,
- 1:14:32these disadvantages exist and we need to just like in the conversation,
- 1:14:36voice them.
- 1:14:38I think that's a disadvantage to what Ben is trying to argue
- 1:14:41as well because it's like
- 1:14:43you can't,
- 1:14:44we can't just say,
- 1:14:44oh,
- 1:14:44I only want to focus on the individual and I don't even want to talk about that
- 1:14:49these,
- 1:14:49these
- 1:14:50deltas or these inequities exist,
- 1:14:52um,
- 1:14:53because that in and of itself is like sort of,
- 1:14:56um,
- 1:14:57it's like almost willful,
- 1:14:58willful ignorance so I think,
- 1:14:59I think,
- 1:15:00yeah.
- 1:15:02I think Ben's,
- 1:15:03you know,
- 1:15:03opt optimism is a very white optimism,
- 1:15:06right?
- 1:15:06Like he believes that of course people are going to
- 1:15:08be empathetic towards me in government because they are,
- 1:15:11they are empathetic to him in government,
- 1:15:13you know,
- 1:15:14like he has never really had to
- 1:15:17deal with outside of,
- 1:15:18you know,
- 1:15:19anti-Semitism in government,
- 1:15:20which is not a small issue,
- 1:15:21but outside of that,
- 1:15:22he doesn't really have to deal with
- 1:15:24what it's like to be.
- 1:15:27Kind of forgotten
- 1:15:28or intentionally hurt
- 1:15:31by legislators,
- 1:15:33right?
- 1:15:34That's not his,
- 1:15:36like as a woman,
- 1:15:37I know what that feels like.
- 1:15:39Like when Dobbs hit,
- 1:15:41we were
- 1:15:42devastated.
- 1:15:43It was devastating,
- 1:15:45right?
- 1:15:45Like as a black person,
- 1:15:46I know what that's like.
- 1:15:47When affirmative action was repealed,
- 1:15:49it was
- 1:15:50devastating.
- 1:15:51So I think a lot of his belief is kind of couched in that like,
- 1:15:56I can be optimistic
- 1:15:58because
- 1:15:58I don't know what happens when I'm not represented in government.
- 1:16:02I've never not been represented in government,
- 1:16:05you know.
- 1:16:06So I do think that there is kind of a willful ignorance in the part of his,
- 1:16:10and I don't mean to be so pessimistic,
- 1:16:13but I do think that,
- 1:16:14you know,
- 1:16:15as I've experienced in my life,
- 1:16:18When we are not in government,
- 1:16:20when we are not in positions of power,
- 1:16:23power will be taken from us.
- 1:16:25So,
- 1:16:26you know,
- 1:16:27yeah,
- 1:16:27well,
- 1:16:27I mean that does.
- 1:16:29Track with our history,
- 1:16:31so.
- 1:16:32That,
- 1:16:33that must be acknowledged.
- 1:16:34Um,
- 1:16:35name it,
- 1:16:36thank you so much for going this long with me and,
- 1:16:38and really digging into this.
- 1:16:40I wasn't expecting us to go this long,
- 1:16:41but I'm,
- 1:16:41I'm glad we kind of like really dug into,
- 1:16:44sorry,
- 1:16:44I'm a yapper.
- 1:16:45I have a bad.
- 1:16:47No,
- 1:16:47it's OK.
- 1:16:47I loved it.
- 1:16:48I'm a yapper too,
- 1:16:49and um,
- 1:16:50I wanted to get into Candace Owens,
- 1:16:51but to be honest,
- 1:16:52like
- 1:16:52there was just so much with Charlie and,
- 1:16:54and Ben,
- 1:16:55and
- 1:16:55those all kind of flowed into each other,
- 1:16:57so
- 1:16:57maybe we'll,
- 1:16:58we'll do another one of these.
- 1:17:00Wonderful.
- 1:17:00Yes,
- 1:17:01I'd love to be back.
- 1:17:02Yeah,
- 1:17:02and,
- 1:17:02and like I said,
- 1:17:03it's,
- 1:17:03it's awesome to see you kind of like using Jubilee as a launch pad.
- 1:17:06I,
- 1:17:07I hope it inspires more people to do it
- 1:17:09cause that's sort of the goal of the channel is to just like,
- 1:17:12you know,
- 1:17:12be a platform for,
- 1:17:13for new voices,
- 1:17:14and,
- 1:17:14and you've been a,
- 1:17:15a really dynamic and,
- 1:17:16and impactful one.
- 1:17:17So thank you so much.
- 1:17:19Well,
- 1:17:19thank you for having me.
- 1:17:20I really appreciate it.
- 1:17:21This won't be the last time we chat,
- 1:17:22and,
- 1:17:23and looking forward to seeing you in person on a set,
- 1:17:25IRL sometime.
- 1:17:27Amazing.
- 1:17:28Bye,
- 1:17:28John.
- 1:17:29Bye Naima.
- 1:17:29If you want to see more follow-up episodes of Surrounded,
- 1:17:32be sure to like,
- 1:17:33leave us a positive review,
- 1:17:34comment if you're watching the video on YouTube.
- 1:17:37Uh,
- 1:17:37you can subscribe to Tubbili,
- 1:17:39Jubilee's second channel.
- 1:17:40You can also subscribe to Jubilee to see full
- 1:17:43surrounded episodes.
- 1:17:45But however you want to support us,
- 1:17:46just thank you so much for listening.
- 1:17:48Remember,
- 1:17:48you could be wrong,
- 1:17:50so could I.
- 1:17:50Keep your mind open.
- 1:17:52Until next time.