Latest / The Drake Insights Podcast / Ep 19 - How AI is Reshaping the Digital Landscape with Andrew Miller
Transcript
- 0:00Natasha: This is the Drake insights podcast, your weekly dose of cutting
- 0:04edge senior living marketing insights.
- 0:06Join me, your host, Natasha Drake for bold ideas, proven strategies and inspiring
- 0:11stories straight from the experts.
- 0:13Tune in and let's conquer the senior living marketing landscape together.
- 0:17Hey guys, welcome back to another episode of The Drake Insights Podcast.
- 0:22I am your host Natasha Drake from Drake Strategic.
- 0:25Let's get started.
- 0:26So on today's episode we're gonna dive a little bit into 2025 digital trends.
- 0:32And not really trends because you've heard of most of these, but really what's most
- 0:37important of all the things you've heard, changes, innovations in the digital world.
- 0:42What is most important to take a look at for you to know as you're working
- 0:46with digital agencies and other marketing agencies and changes that are
- 0:49happening with things going on with AI, generative experience, chat GPT, all the
- 0:54things that we'll explain more later.
- 0:57But what is it you have to hone in on really understand and how that
- 1:00can change your search results, your paid search on Google and the results
- 1:06and the conversions you can expect.
- 1:07So I don't know if you saw it, but Workshop Digital has released
- 1:12their Top Trends of 2025.
- 1:14If you haven't seen it, check it out on LinkedIn.
- 1:17And I was really interested to see all the things that they had to talk about.
- 1:20And we're not going to have time to go through all of those trends today.
- 1:24We're going to talk a little bit about them, but really dig into
- 1:27the top SEO and paid search trends and changes that we're seeing like
- 1:31I just mentioned with innovation.
- 1:33And so I brought on our expert from Workshop Digital, a co-founder,
- 1:39Andrew Miller, welcome to the podcast.
- 1:41If you wouldn't mind introducing yourself.
- 1:44Andrew: Yes.
- 1:44Hello.
- 1:45Thank you, Natasha, for the awesome intro.
- 1:47Happy to be here.
- 1:48I'm Andrew, one of the co-founders at Workshop Digital.
- 1:52We're a digital marketing agency based in Richmond, Virginia, but
- 1:55obviously hybrid, gone remote, and now spread out all over the country.
- 1:59We've been around formally since 2015 for about eight years prior
- 2:03to that as separate companies.
- 2:06origin story, but today most people know us as a B2B and lead gen focus
- 2:12agency with really, really smart people doing kick ass work in SEO, paid media.
- 2:18We do a lot of work across a variety of industries have a long history
- 2:21with senior living and have worked with Natasha and your teams in
- 2:25different instances along the journey.
- 2:28It was great to reconnect.
- 2:28Thanks for having me.
- 2:29Natasha: Yeah.
- 2:30I should have mentioned that before.
- 2:31Yeah.
- 2:31We worked together like a little over 10 years ago with some of my
- 2:35biggest clients back in the day.
- 2:37So we've had some great success with Workshop, some
- 2:39great innovative strategies.
- 2:41So I'm really excited to hear what you all are doing and some feedback you have.
- 2:44So thank you again for being on.
- 2:46If you wouldn't mind, can you just kind of delve into some of these top trends,
- 2:50kind of give highlights for the listeners today of what you all mentioned and
- 2:55then we'll dig in further after that.
- 2:57Andrew: Sure.
- 2:57Well, I'm glad we're calling them trends and not predictions, right?
- 3:00Prediction posts are running rampant this time of year.
- 3:03The last thing we need is more predictions.
- 3:05What we like to pay attention to is, is things that are a little bit more
- 3:08established that we can measure.
- 3:09We can, we can actually put some strategic thinking into and take advantage of rather
- 3:14than just crystal ball prognostication.
- 3:17So, for us, the trends that we're paying most attention to are going
- 3:21to be pretty familiar to industry veterans, but if you're not as tuned
- 3:24into the day to day digital marketing environment that we're working in now,
- 3:28these, these might be useful for you.
- 3:30There's always a tradeoff.
- 3:31Right now we're really paying close attention to the tradeoff between
- 3:34personalization and data privacy, right?
- 3:37This is evolving very, very quickly.
- 3:39There's a sweet spot, we believe, between being helpful and being creepy.
- 3:45Technology is advancing a lot faster than consumer adoption and regulation.
- 3:50So, you know, watching where your data privacy practices are falling
- 3:54on that spectrum is going to be super important for brands going forward.
- 3:58Another one that's really interesting now, especially in the evolving world
- 4:02of AI, is voice search optimization.
- 4:05We've been voice search has been around for years, right?
- 4:07We all have devices wearables that we can speak to and little
- 4:12AI agents in our pockets that we can we can chat with sometimes.
- 4:15But it's growing, and it's especially growing on a generational basis.
- 4:20So there are there are younger consumers or budding consumers out there that
- 4:23are have grown up with voice search.
- 4:25My kids are examples.
- 4:26They speak to their phones more than they type to their phones these days
- 4:29when they're trying to find information.
- 4:31I think that's a signal of where things are going and really, what
- 4:35does that mean for us as, as SEOs or digital marketers that's paying
- 4:38attention to the, the way that search behaviors and patterns are changing.
- 4:42Right.
- 4:43So there's there's more natural language based queries being being
- 4:47served or processed now because that's how people are talking.
- 4:50They're personifying their devices and speaking to it almost as a as
- 4:54a copilot rather than a search box.
- 4:57So something to watch out for there.
- 4:59I think maybe the last one I'll touch on is the quick change of pace in
- 5:04analytics, specifically marketing analytics and the integration of AI tools.
- 5:09We can't go a week without hearing updates on new technologies, new platforms, new
- 5:14bots, new agents that are coming along and promising a whole lot of a lot of sizzle.
- 5:20You know, the stake is still the data.
- 5:22There still needs to be a human in the loop in analyzing, interpreting,
- 5:26drawing insights, and informing strategy.
- 5:29But AI is quickly carving out its, you know, its its own value proposition as
- 5:33that copilot for our human analysts.
- 5:36So we still really believe in the, the power of AI plus humans.
- 5:42I don't think we're anywhere near the the replacement phase where
- 5:46they're going to take our jobs.
- 5:47So that's what we're looking at in 2025.
- 5:49These trends are going to continue to evolve.
- 5:51But I think we'll probably be talking about some of them going in next year as
- 5:54Natasha: Yeah, awesome.
- 5:55Thank you for going through that.
- 5:56And I think a lot of these terms are buzzwords that
- 5:59people are hearing a lot about.
- 6:01And I think a lot of the people that I've met with and spoken to
- 6:04maybe don't really understand the full implications of what they mean.
- 6:08And so I wanted to clarify that.
- 6:10It's another reason why what we're going to talk about today is, you know,
- 6:13you hear a lot about AI, Chat GPT.
- 6:15Okay.
- 6:16But how, how is this actually changing the way our SEO works, the
- 6:21search engine works, our paid ads.
- 6:23I think there's just a lot of buzz about, yeah, it's cool.
- 6:26It types in, it comes up with things for you.
- 6:28Right.
- 6:28But not really understanding how on the backend, that's really going to change
- 6:32the way you're doing, and you'll go into this more, but the way you're going,
- 6:35doing your content and the way you're doing search and just like you mentioned,
- 6:38the way that users are searching.
- 6:40When I know what I talk into my phone, is not what I would be
- 6:44typing into a search query, right?
- 6:46So I'm assuming that that's then going to change how the, it pulls
- 6:49content, where it pulls it from.
- 6:50So if you wouldn't mind digging in first a little bit to the, the SEO changes
- 6:54we've talked about in terms of how these technologies are going to affect that.
- 6:58Andrew: Sure.
- 6:59Yeah.
- 6:59And I'll, I'll start with kind of a context that we're all familiar with.
- 7:03Right?
- 7:03If you've, if you've been using Google for a number of years,
- 7:08you've seen the evolution of how they present search results.
- 7:10So what happens after you type that query into a search box?
- 7:14And I'm talking about, of course, Google.com, the web, the web interface
- 7:16that we're most familiar with.
- 7:17So we'll, we'll kind of stick in that frame of reference for now.
- 7:20You know, it used to be 10 blue links and then those 10 blue links and a few ads.
- 7:24And now it's a whole mishmash of different types of search results that
- 7:27have evolved over the years to include, you know, questions that are commonly
- 7:31asked suggested search queries, of course, shopping results and maps and
- 7:36all sorts of, like, rich search results or search features as we call them.
- 7:39AI overviews, which is Google's take on, you know, the AI generated search
- 7:45results that we see at the top of the search results pages now are just really
- 7:48a natural evolution of those those search features that are that Google is
- 7:54betting on answering questions better and faster for their users, right?
- 7:58That's what it comes down to for Google.
- 8:00Google wants to create happy users and ideally keep them on their platform.
- 8:03Keep them searching, making money, generating clicks and revenue, of course,
- 8:06there's always a, you know, a follow the money angle here, but in Google's
- 8:10quest to make an answer engine, they are synthesizing these AI overviews or,
- 8:17or AI generated results that now try to answer questions sometimes hilariously
- 8:23but try to answer questions the same way you might get from a chat GPT chatbot.
- 8:26It's, it's similar technologies.
- 8:28So what does that mean for us as marketers, right?
- 8:30That's the landscape that we use as consumers.
- 8:32As marketers, that means that a lot of the SEO strategies and content
- 8:37strategies that worked for the last 5 to 10 years need to evolve, right?
- 8:42A lot of that top of funnel traffic, the awareness based traffic or
- 8:47search volume that we are used to seeing is now being addressed or
- 8:51answered by those AI overviews to something informational, for example.
- 8:55You know, all you have to do is go to Google and type in, you know, what's
- 8:57the best travel destination and you have to scroll pretty far before
- 9:02you see an actual website, right?
- 9:04You're going to see ads, of course, but above that, you're even going to
- 9:07see their AI overview of, you know, here's, here's our best guess as to
- 9:12what people on the web want to see.
- 9:14So that means for marketers, we're seeing less top of funnel traffic to our
- 9:18websites, less informational traffic.
- 9:21So we have to do a better job creating content that
- 9:23answers more buying questions.
- 9:26You know, Natasha, when we worked together before, we were talking about
- 9:29creating really engaging, useful content for for brands that we partnered on
- 9:36and speaking, you know, to their maybe the history of their organizations,
- 9:39the history of their areas, kind of just trying to localize the content,
- 9:43associate the brand with the community.
- 9:45And that type of content now is largely answered by AI pulling
- 9:49from a variety of sources.
- 9:50So that's an example of types of content that may not be
- 9:53as effective going forward.
- 9:55An example, it's breaking this week.
- 9:57I don't know if you've seen, but all you have to do is go look at HubSpot's
- 10:01search visibility recently is plummeting.
- 10:05HubSpot's great content marketing and has been for years.
- 10:07They define content marketing for a lot of us over the past decade, but
- 10:11Google's new algorithm updates and search features are really hammering HubSpot's
- 10:17visibility and it's declining at an extremely high rate because a lot of
- 10:21their content is overly broad, right?
- 10:23It's, it's keyword based.
- 10:24It's, It's, not nearly as link baity or click baity as BuzzFeeds, for example.
- 10:31But it's it's it's not core to their product and the
- 10:35solution that they're providing.
- 10:36It's it's very general knowledge type stuff.
- 10:38They're very good at producing for a lot of years, drove a lot of traffic.
- 10:41Now that traffic is plummeting because Google is going either to
- 10:44different sources or generating their own results, you know, HubSpot
- 10:47still ranks well for CRM related searches and product related searches.
- 10:51But that's another example of a content producer that's that's
- 10:55suffering right now in a way, but.
- 10:58Where do we go from here?
- 11:00And I'm not going to speak to HubSpot strategy, but where I would go from here,
- 11:03where we're going from here with our clients is leaning into the expertise,
- 11:07the authority that you have, the brand as a subject matter expert, and really
- 11:11focusing in on what your consumers want when they're ready to research and buy
- 11:15you know, there's, that's not unique or proprietary to us, but that's what we're
- 11:19seeing working well now is the middle, the bottom of funnel type content that
- 11:25helps people make a final decision and encourages them to, of course, choose
- 11:28your, your brand or your product or service over a competitor, but it all
- 11:33has to be based on something unique that you're bringing to the party, right?
- 11:36You're experts, your point of view, your perspective you know, your, your
- 11:41trust factors that, that elevates your brand above your competition.
- 11:46It's, it's a very long winded way of saying, you know, quality content still
- 11:50matters and it matters more than ever.
- 11:52And how Google is defining that quality component is evolving to favor
- 11:57more more, more human driven expert level content, not the AI generated
- 12:05mishmash that any of us can create with a few prompts in the chatGPT.
- 12:08Natasha: And you may be talking about this shortly, but what is the biggest change?
- 12:12The biggest change here is we used to write content specifically for keywords.
- 12:16So we would know, okay, you know, in senior living for independent living,
- 12:20whatever, we wanna make sure we plug in these words right into our content.
- 12:24Right.
- 12:24And obviously we know we've talked about a few the past few years
- 12:27that has changed into phrases and then it's answering questions.
- 12:31And so is the, is that something that's, I want to make sure that that's clear.
- 12:36That's a big change of the way you're writing your content.
- 12:39I think it's what you're saying is first of all, knowing your target audience,
- 12:42who, who is searching for you, who do you want to be searching for you?
- 12:46Right.
- 12:46And what are the specific things that they, what are questions
- 12:51they want answered in terms of what your community provides.
- 12:54Am I saying that correctly?
- 12:55And so I'm just trying to think of how this is exactly is, is so different.
- 12:59So for example, if we wanted to attract someone who's looking at a life plan
- 13:03community, we might write a blog or something about specifically about life
- 13:08plan communities, the care they offer.
- 13:10But is that, is, is that still the same or is the way you're writing
- 13:13that content different than maybe you would have written that blog before?
- 13:16I want to make sure I'm clarifying that.
- 13:18Andrew: Sure.
- 13:19Is it still the same?
- 13:20I'll give the traditional SEO answer, kind of yes and no, or it depends.
- 13:24Keywords still matter, right?
- 13:26Searches are still largely keyword based.
- 13:28There's intent there.
- 13:30So we can't ignore keywords, of course.
- 13:31We have to match search intent to the content we're providing.
- 13:34But to your point, the format, the presentation of that
- 13:37content matters more now.
- 13:39Natasha: Okay.
- 13:39Andrew: And not the visuals.
- 13:41I think the harder concept for, for a lot of marketers to understand is it doesn't
- 13:47really matter how you present the content.
- 13:48It's the, it's the depth, the quality of the content that Google is looking for.
- 13:53Natasha: mm, mm,
- 13:55Andrew: I mean think of it this way, if you're Google you can discover thousands
- 13:58of articles about any one particular topic and they're all reasonably,
- 14:02subject matter, you know, they're focused on the right subject matter.
- 14:04They have the right keywords.
- 14:05They have the right content.
- 14:07Rule of thumb is if you can go to ChatGPT and prompt it to write a blog post.
- 14:11Then anybody else can, and they already have, right?
- 14:13There's nothing unique or proprietary in there.
- 14:17So where we're seeing the best results with our clients, and then your example
- 14:21is leaning into the things that are unique and proprietary to your, you
- 14:26know, your community or your brand.
- 14:28That can be your experts, you know, it could be your, your, staff,
- 14:32your, your health care providers.
- 14:34It could be your residents.
- 14:35It could be the community members, right?
- 14:37Each of them has a story to tell.
- 14:39Each of them brings a unique perspective and diverse experience.
- 14:43All of that boosts the, the, one, the uniqueness, the, credibility
- 14:49and a little bit a little bit of the authority component that
- 14:53Google is looking for as well.
- 14:53And I'm throwing around these terms.
- 14:55I'll back up.
- 14:56Google employs thousands of humans around the world to rate their search
- 15:02results as part of this feedback loop to generate better search results.
- 15:05And these human raters are given guidelines to help them clarify, you
- 15:10know, what's, what's a good website.
- 15:12This should be in our search results and or what are good search
- 15:15results that reflect the true intent of the query and what's not.
- 15:19These aren't ranking signals.
- 15:20This isn't the algorithm, but these are guidelines given to humans and
- 15:24the acronym that's in there in black and white that any of us can access.
- 15:28It's on the web.
- 15:28It's not secret.
- 15:29The acronym is EEAT or expertise, experience, authoritativeness
- 15:34and trustworthiness.
- 15:35So that that model is what Google's looking for.
- 15:39And the humans are there evaluating as best they can.
- 15:42You know, who's the expert?
- 15:43Who's the authority?
- 15:43Who has who, who's trustworthy.
- 15:46And there's a variety of suggestions under that under each of those
- 15:49criteria that that I would encourage folks to go find and read through.
- 15:54Some quick examples that we see working well, proprietary research, right?
- 15:59Yes, we can cite public sources, but if you can go do your own
- 16:02qualitative or quantitative research and publish those results.
- 16:05Again, that's unique.
- 16:06That's something you're bringing that Google hasn't seen before.
- 16:08You know that that could play in your favor.
- 16:10You may have been around for 50 years or a hundred years, or
- 16:13maybe you win every industry award or certification under the sun.
- 16:16Or you have raving fans and, and residents or or customers that love to
- 16:21tell their story and share their story.
- 16:22Lean into that, right?
- 16:23Build that that credibility, that trustworthiness using those signals.
- 16:27So every every brand has some differentiation they can they can bring
- 16:31to this equation and that's that's our job is to help tease that out and figure
- 16:34out which of those to emphasize and which ones we need to strengthen a little bit.
- 16:37Natasha: And that's important specifically to for the listeners in the senior
- 16:40living industry specifically because before it was very broad, everyone
- 16:45was writing kind of the same types of topics with those keywords, but you
- 16:50know, put in there to make sure that they're ranking for a specific keyword.
- 16:54But what you're saying and what I want to make sure everyone's hearing
- 16:56is it needs to be very customized.
- 16:58It needs to be unique in depth.
- 17:00Right.
- 17:01Real information that's, that's different maybe specific to that
- 17:04specific area people are searching to not just a broad example.
- 17:08Unique content.
- 17:08And also, if I'm correct me with this is updated often, right?
- 17:13Like it needs to be relevant.
- 17:14It can't be like you're citing stats and data from another article that
- 17:18was written 10, 15 years ago, right?
- 17:20So Google can tell that, that's not a relevant article.
- 17:23That's not the most recent.
- 17:24We want to be updating whatever we're doing content.
- 17:26We have to be constantly updating it because I think that that back
- 17:29five, 10 years ago, we didn't have to do that as much, right?
- 17:31Little changes.
- 17:32And now it's like, no, you have to actually up, you have to actually
- 17:34change and update your content too.
- 17:37So I want to make sure that that's clear for everyone because I think
- 17:39a lot of times what I have heard with some clients is, well, we just
- 17:42got to keep working on our content.
- 17:44Yes, that's true, but it's a little bit different in terms of
- 17:47the way the AI is pulling that.
- 17:48And I wanted to make sure I clarify if I'm saying that all correctly.
- 17:51Andrew: Absolutely.
- 17:52Yep.
- 17:52Freshness matters as well.
- 17:55Right?
- 17:55It's not one of those EEAT acronyms, of course, but it does.
- 17:59It does matter because we all again put.
- 18:01We're all Google users as well.
- 18:04We want the most relevant fresh results, right?
- 18:07And we quickly identify when something's a few years out of date.
- 18:10Natasha: I mean, I can't stand that when I, and this actually happened not too long
- 18:12ago and you're searching for something and you find an article and then you're
- 18:15like, this was written five years ago.
- 18:17Like, well, this is not helping me.
- 18:18Right.
- 18:19I read the article and all of a sudden I saw the date and I'm like, this is, you
- 18:22know, in our industry, that's a, that's a huge change in those amount of years.
- 18:26So.
- 18:26And then in terms of, I don't know if you have any more to add here, but I'm
- 18:29just going to ask in terms of voice search specifically, and I think you
- 18:33mentioned it, touched upon it, but I want to clarify how that's changing the
- 18:37search query because the way people are talking into it and how they're asking,
- 18:40or maybe like the in depth specific question they're asking is different
- 18:45than like, senior living near me.
- 18:47It might be like, Hey, I don't want to say her name because she's in
- 18:51the room, you know, who in terms of technology, you know, I'm talking
- 18:54about you know, find what's the closest assisted living in Washington Crossing
- 19:00Pennsylvania that offers high level dining, whatever, something like that.
- 19:04Right.
- 19:04Where someone most likely wouldn't type that in.
- 19:06But as I'm thinking and talking, I might say a query more specific like that.
- 19:11Is that correct?
- 19:12Andrew: It is.
- 19:13Yeah.
- 19:13You know, that's a good example of like lower funnel, high intent,
- 19:18transactional search query, right.
- 19:21You would expect a different type of search result.
- 19:23For that, whether it's their voice or web search, then you would, if
- 19:26you were just saying, you know, tell me about my parents are getting old.
- 19:32How do I help an aging parent who's having certain types of issues or,
- 19:35like, you know, give me some advice to to help navigate some of these
- 19:39challenges that that, you know, children and adult children are facing.
- 19:43Natasha: Oh, that's a good one.
- 19:44Yeah.
- 19:45Andrew: Like that, that's the kind of conversational that
- 19:48people are starting to use.
- 19:49You know, it's technically grouped under voice search, but where this all
- 19:52ties together to your point, there's a lot more of these responses now
- 19:56that are that are generated for voice search commands are actually those AI
- 20:01generated amalgamations of content.
- 20:03So it's trying to actually answer a question for you without having
- 20:07to click through to a community website for specifics, right?
- 20:12That's the challenge we face as marketers is a lot of these different
- 20:16types of search features now, not just voice search and not just AI
- 20:19overviews, but they're they're grouped under what we call 0 click searches.
- 20:23Natasha: Hmm.
- 20:23Mm
- 20:23Andrew: Where Google or the search engine that you're using.
- 20:25We're using Google, but it's interchangeable with others of course.
- 20:28The search engine presents you the information you're looking for, and
- 20:32you no longer have to click through to a website to get that content
- 20:36or get that information that's dangerous for us risk challenging
- 20:39for us as marketers, I should say.
- 20:41And that's that that's that top of funnel informational type query that we're
- 20:45seeing less volume from these days.
- 20:46Natasha: Right.
- 20:47And correct me if I'm wrong.
- 20:48Sometimes though, and maybe this is not true, but in those generative search on
- 20:54the top, sometimes it does cite, right?
- 20:58Some like it'll cite if there's specific facts or things that are in
- 21:01that it'll cite where it came from.
- 21:04And that's great.
- 21:05Right.
- 21:05If you're, if your site shows up specifically as cited by Google, that
- 21:09is, am I saying that correctly too?
- 21:11Andrew: Yeah, you'll get the citation and you'll get the link.
- 21:13There'll be a little, you know, currently, this could all change,
- 21:16but Right now there's like, a little hoverable tool tip link icon in most
- 21:21of these platforms that would link
- 21:23Natasha: So that would
- 21:23Andrew: you through to the one of the underlying sources.
- 21:26And that's where you want to be as a brand.
- 21:27Natasha: That would be ideal.
- 21:29Yeah.
- 21:29So no, that's helpful.
- 21:30And before we go on to the next question, I do want to make sure I point out that
- 21:34all of this just goes to show how much content you have to have on your site.
- 21:38I talked about this a little bit in my website episode.
- 21:41One of the big hot buttons in senior living is how much to give,
- 21:45how much information to give.
- 21:46Do we list pricing?
- 21:47Do we not list pricing?
- 21:48We're afraid to list that we don't want to give everything away.
- 21:50We want them to come and tour.
- 21:52And it's just something that I'm very passionate about.
- 21:55We have to just get on board with, we have to have the information
- 21:58relevant and on our site because people are searching for it.
- 22:02As you can see, they want all the information.
- 22:04It's more about self selecting and self sales now.
- 22:07So just wanted to throw that in that it's really important to make sure we have
- 22:11as much of that content cause they're going to quickly go somewhere else.
- 22:13If you don't have it listed on your site and if you don't write, what are
- 22:16the averages of prices in your area?
- 22:18And ours is here and they can get that information somewhere else.
- 22:21So make sure they're staying, you know, top of funnel and on your website.
- 22:26Andrew: But maybe it's worth pointing out, too, what complicates this, because
- 22:30everything you said is 100 percent true.
- 22:32We're talking about a funnel or a customer journey, like
- 22:35it's some linear path, right?
- 22:36There's only one line from point A to point B. We all know that's
- 22:39true, so I think we're working on the assumption that the content
- 22:42should surround the customer journey.
- 22:43It's not necessarily that linear path that we all would love it to
- 22:48Natasha: Yeah.
- 22:49Right.
- 22:49Correct.
- 22:50Yeah.
- 22:51I mean, some, and we, and we talked about this in the last episode where
- 22:53someone will could contact a community six times from six different ways
- 22:57at different times of their path.
- 22:59You know, so a lot of times I'll hear, Oh, well, you know, the social
- 23:02media lead wasn't a good lead.
- 23:03Well, that could be their sixth time.
- 23:04They've already been on your website.
- 23:06They already searched you.
- 23:06They already saw your ad. They already saw your direct mail, right?
- 23:09So you don't know where they are on that journey.
- 23:11So let's make sure we have the content for them and what they're looking
- 23:13for, depending on which touch it is they finally landed on your website.
- 23:18Okay.
- 23:18So my next question I'm going to ask is more about paid.
- 23:20So you talked a little bit about that and paid search and this interested me because
- 23:23I wasn't really aware of a lot of this.
- 23:25So, you know, the changes with AI specifically on paid search
- 23:28and how that's changing for listeners to hear about today.
- 23:33Andrew: Yeah, so paid search, Google ads, Microsoft advertising, even even
- 23:37Meta, Facebook and Instagram ads.
- 23:39And every platform now has been using AI behind the scenes for years, right?
- 23:45It's something we've we've co-evolved with on the paid media side.
- 23:49You know, whether whether we realize it or not, AI is taking
- 23:52over more of the mundane day to day tasks, like bidding optimization.
- 23:57In a lot of cases, audience creation or audience selection,
- 24:00creative rotation and testing.
- 24:02Now they're getting into creative generation, ad copywriting, image
- 24:05generation, that type of thing.
- 24:07So it's been a, it's been a longer a longer period that we've had time to
- 24:11get used to this on the paid media side.
- 24:13And it's not without its, you know, pitfalls.
- 24:17There were years where Google was trying to automate more of this
- 24:19stuff, but the, the machine learning, the models weren't there yet.
- 24:23Humans could still dramatically outperform some of these AI driven
- 24:27advancements, if you know what you are doing . Now that's in the last couple
- 24:30of years that tide has shifted back.
- 24:32The machines have have started to win again where, you know, they're,
- 24:36they have so much more data.
- 24:37They can process it so much faster.
- 24:39They can, they can target audiences better.
- 24:41They can build better bidding models, ultimately optimizing for better ROI
- 24:47or return on ad spend than a human can.
- 24:49So where does that leave us?
- 24:51You know, that's, that's always the interesting part of it.
- 24:53What does that mean for us as humans?
- 24:55And I think we're, you know, where this conversation always goes for
- 24:58us is like, okay, well, humans are still better at strategy.
- 25:01Still better at drawing insights and informing strategy and defining,
- 25:05you know, what do we want to test?
- 25:06How do we want to test where, how do we connect all of our different data
- 25:10sources on the back end to feed more information back into the algorithms?
- 25:14To give them the best quality data.
- 25:16And then, of course, QA, QA, QA.
- 25:20You know, AI is not perfect.
- 25:22It's not gonna win 100% of the time, even if its success rate is over a human
- 25:27is 85% of the time, there's 15% of the time where it's gonna go off the rails.
- 25:32And if you don't spot it and stop it and course correct, all of a sudden, you
- 25:37know, we, we look bad because we've taken our eye off off the off the machines.
- 25:41So that's our general philosophy.
- 25:43It's not surprising that a lot of people aren't aware of that
- 25:45or aren't aren't adapting to it.
- 25:48Natasha: Well, and I think there's a lot of, there's a lot that, especially
- 25:52in this industry, people aren't aware of how paid search works.
- 25:54I mean, right.
- 25:55You hire digital agency.
- 25:56Here's the spend.
- 25:57Here's where we're targeting.
- 25:58You kind of see it back.
- 25:59So I think it's important to understand that this is being used a lot on the
- 26:04back end that, you know, we're, we're.
- 26:06That you're now saying that actually AI kind of leading and having a
- 26:10little bit of dependence on it.
- 26:11We kind of need because of how much data they have that we may not have,
- 26:15or you're using their data and our data, but that in terms of the bigger
- 26:18picture, the overall strategy and kind of partnering with AI somewhat.
- 26:23Is that the right way to say it?
- 26:25Like, we're, we're monitoring AI, but we're still using it.
- 26:27And I think we have to kind of get behind that otherwise.
- 26:30And I think what you're saying is because the results that they're able
- 26:33to get with the data they have and the way that AI you know, knows how
- 26:37to target specifically figure out.
- 26:38You have to use that, but we have to be careful and monitor
- 26:41and and be strategic about it.
- 26:44Andrew: That's right.
- 26:45Yeah.
- 26:45You wouldn't let.
- 26:46You, you wouldn't let Alexa babysit your kids, right?
- 26:50You'd want to check in every now and then put, put eyes on it.
- 26:53Here's a tell right for the, for the marketers out there, you know,
- 26:56if you're not in tune with, with paid media and the changes in
- 26:59that over the past several years.
- 27:02If your paid media partner is asking, you know, still talking in terms of keywords
- 27:07and, you know, static ads and that type of thing, you know, chances are that
- 27:14they're still using some outdated tactics, doesn't mean they can't work, right.
- 27:17There's, there's a lot of use cases for that like like we talked about.
- 27:22Where we're finding the most fruitful conversations with our clients and what
- 27:25I, what I would encourage people to look for, you know, is, is partners
- 27:29that are that are digging more into the business side of things.
- 27:32What happens to those conversions once they happen on your site?
- 27:35Where do those leads go?
- 27:36What's what walk me through how the, you know, a sales team
- 27:39might engage with that prospect.
- 27:41What does the journey look like?
- 27:42How many times are they calling you?
- 27:43Where does that information stored?
- 27:45What does the CRM structure look like?
- 27:47Oh, and by the way, can we, like capture and store some ad click
- 27:50information in there and then, you know, close the loop so to speak.
- 27:53Natasha: Yeah.
- 27:54Andrew: That's the section of the customer journey.
- 27:55That's the most important right now is what happens after the click.
- 27:59And so we need to be focusing on and optimizing for those touch points.
- 28:04And a lot of them happen offline still, but there are better and
- 28:07better ways to feed that offline information back into these algorithms.
- 28:10So that's where I push our team and would encourage people to really dig
- 28:14in to see how much of that offline information are we feeding back in.
- 28:17That's your competitive differentiation these days.
- 28:19Natasha: Yeah, and I did talk about that a little bit on the
- 28:21prior paid episode with Matt.
- 28:23You know, we talked a little bit about that Google, you know, match
- 28:25back and using your CRM data.
- 28:27And I, I want to say it again, cause it's, it's really important.
- 28:30Yes.
- 28:30Google has all of their data that you don't have, but they don't have your data.
- 28:35Right.
- 28:35So making sure that we are sharing that information with Google to tell Google,
- 28:41great, everything you've done on the data end that you've brought me this lead, that
- 28:45was a bad lead, or that was a good lead.
- 28:47And telling Google so it knows, okay, those are the types of people, this
- 28:51is the journey that person went on.
- 28:52This is what they clicked on.
- 28:53This is the entire journey they got to you.
- 28:56And now I know what's a, what's in your terms, you know, a good toured or moved
- 29:00in, whatever that, whatever you say that that is, the definition of that.
- 29:03We need to be giving that to Google and AI so that we're working together.
- 29:08It really is like a partnership, which is kind of crazy and scary to say,
- 29:12but that's, that's kind of now how I'm seeing it is it's not them versus us.
- 29:15It's a partnership.
- 29:16And how do we work together on the data they have and the data we have to have
- 29:20higher quality leads, less, not, you don't need to have so many, it's more
- 29:24about quality than a huge quantity, right.
- 29:26For your sales teams to work with.
- 29:27So, yeah that's, that's really interesting to me.
- 29:30So I do want to ask, you know, what is your / Workshop Digital's, you know, point
- 29:36of view, opinion on all of this, like with AI and the growth and how you all, I
- 29:41mean, you've had to make changes, I'm sure in the past five years of how probably
- 29:44every year, every six months, right with some of these Google algorithm changes,
- 29:47like you're constantly having to adapt and change and help educate your clients.
- 29:53And so what is your, what's your opinion or take on all this?
- 29:58Andrew: Wow.
- 29:59Well, I wish we could go six months
- 30:01Natasha: Yeah, I was going to
- 30:02Andrew: major updates.
- 30:03That's a, that's a breath of fresh air.
- 30:06I think we're talking like six days between, you know, little
- 30:10course corrections that we're all making in this industry.
- 30:12Natasha: Right.
- 30:13Andrew: Our, our philosophy is, is born out and has worked for us over
- 30:18the past couple of years as we've been leaning into this is that humans
- 30:21plus technology, humans plus AI are generating better outcomes, of course.
- 30:26We have to equip our humans to think differently with
- 30:29the new tools that we have.
- 30:31Otherwise, we will be obsolete, right?
- 30:32A digital marketing agency that doesn't evolve quickly will be
- 30:37replaced by either other agencies or or platforms that are using more AI.
- 30:43Or we'll just, we'll quickly become so inefficient and ineffective that
- 30:49we lose all of our clients, right, that’s how from an agency perspective
- 30:52if you’re an in-house paid media practitioner same rules apply.
- 30:55Natasha: Right.
- 30:56Andrew: So our, our POV is, of course, like you said, you know,
- 31:00it's, it's a co-pilot for us, right?
- 31:03It's a, sometimes it's a sounding board.
- 31:05It's a way to quickly aggregate and analyze data.
- 31:08But our philosophy is test and learn quickly on different AI tools.
- 31:13Not just chat GPT or not just the ones that are integrated into Google ads
- 31:16these days or Meta ads, but, you know, when we, when we hear about something
- 31:21that's evolving, that might be a good fit we're, we're quickly jumping in
- 31:25and giving it giving it a solid a solid business case and seeing if these AI
- 31:30tools can bring something unique or proprietary to the, to the conversation.
- 31:34And sometimes we have to test and retest because their capabilities change quickly.
- 31:38So lots of testing, lots of validation to make sure they can actually
- 31:42do what they say they can do.
- 31:44And most of them can't.
- 31:45Spoiler alert.
- 31:46You know, there's a lot of AI tools that make big claims,
- 31:48but they can't back it up.
- 31:50And then retraining, reframing our conversations internally with our
- 31:54clients about you, like, updating, modifying workflows and processes now
- 32:00to incorporate more AI, just to speed things up and make it more efficient.
- 32:04The end result of that is we have humans with more time for strategy and
- 32:09strategic conversations and business level conversations and consultation.
- 32:14Less time needed to analyze data, build charts, crunch numbers, and go bid
- 32:20on individual keywords, for example.
- 32:22So
- 32:23Natasha: Yeah.
- 32:23Andrew: It's more fun, it's more engaging for the brain.
- 32:25Natasha: Right.
- 32:26Yeah.
- 32:26I mean, this is and this is one of the reasons why I always recommend
- 32:29and I love partnering with with people like you and always recommend to
- 32:33clients and communities I work with.
- 32:34It's really important that you are working with an expert in this
- 32:37because it's changing, like you said, like maybe I get updates less often
- 32:41than you do, but it, it is, it's changing so frequently and evolving.
- 32:46I shouldn't say changing, evolving and growing and adapting that you need to be
- 32:49partnering with someone who's an expert who can really walk you through these
- 32:52changes and make adjustments and tactics as you go, but partner with you on it.
- 32:56So so grateful for people like you and agencies like you that I get
- 32:59to partner with because it makes my life a lot easier as well.
- 33:02And then before we leave today, thank you so much for being on
- 33:05and, you know, giving us all this valuable digital innovation insight.
- 33:08What are some actionable, you know, key takeaways you want to make sure
- 33:11we talked about a lot of things here.
- 33:13You know, what are some key tips you want to make sure we the
- 33:16listeners remember from today?
- 33:18Andrew: Yeah.
- 33:18Well, number one, stay curious, right?
- 33:22There's, if there's one innate human characteristic that will that will get
- 33:27us through any evolution in technology and AI it's our curiosity, right?
- 33:32We have to know what questions to ask each other and what
- 33:36questions to ask of the data.
- 33:38So staying curious, asking good questions.
- 33:41And then, you know, we, we have to understand.
- 33:44We have an obligation to understand how these technologies actually work, what
- 33:46their capabilities and limitations are.
- 33:48I think point number 2 is, you know, not all AI is created equal.
- 33:52Not all AI is actually AI.
- 33:54So don't take things on face value, right.
- 33:57Spend a little bit of time learning, you know, the great YouTube videos on there,
- 34:02out there, but like, spend a little bit of time learning what AI actually is, and
- 34:05just as importantly, what it isn't and what the inputs and outputs are, right?
- 34:10We all, I think we all intuitively know by now, AI is only as good
- 34:14as the data it's trained on.
- 34:16Natasha: Right.
- 34:16Andrew: Right?
- 34:17You can't ask a language model to do complex math, for example.
- 34:20So just making sure you're using the right tool for the right
- 34:23problem is a big part of it.
- 34:25But that's the, that's one of the biggest things I see people getting wrong.
- 34:27So
- 34:28Natasha: Interesting.
- 34:29Andrew: Level of familiarity is, is key.
- 34:32Natasha: Well, awesome.
- 34:32Thank you so much, Andrew, for being on today and Workshop Digital.
- 34:36If anyone wants further insight into this, please reach out to me or to
- 34:40Andrew Miller at Workshop Digital, happy to help you and walk you through this.
- 34:43And I know it helps me to walk me through it.
- 34:46So thank you again so much for being on today.
- 34:49Thank you everyone for listening to another episode
- 34:51of The Drake Insights Podcast.
- 34:53I look forward to seeing you next time.
- 34:55Bye.