Latest / TheThinkingAtheist / The Exvangelicals: with Sarah McCammon
Transcript
- 0:05The Thinking Atheist. It's not a person, it's a symbol, an idea.
- 0:10The population of atheists this country is going through the rule, rejecting faith,
- 0:15pursuing knowledge, challenging the sacred. If I tell the truth, it's
- 0:20because I tell the truth, not because I put my hand on a book
- 0:24and made a wish and working together for a more rational world. Take the
- 0:29risk of thinking. Feel so much more happiness. Truth, Usian wisdom will
- 0:33come to you that way. Assume nothing, question everything, and start thinking.
- 0:42This is The Thinking Atheist podcast hosted by Seth Andrews. Sarah McCammon is
- 0:58an award winning broadcaster. You may have seen and or heard her on NPR.
- 1:03She's a national political correspondent. She's also co host of the NPR Politics
- 1:10Podcast. She's done a lot of reporting on the country, especially post Row.
- 1:15She's been talking a lot about Christian nationalism, and she's got a new
- 1:19book out called The ex Vangelicals, Loving Living and Leaving the White Evangelical Church.
- 1:26Sarah, thanks for coming, Yeah, thanks for having me. You
- 1:30don't have to answer this, but since I run kind of a heathen channel,
- 1:34are you a religious person anymore? I would say that I am yeah,
- 1:40not in the way that I was raised to be and not the way
- 1:42that I my community would have wanted me to be. But I'm somebody that
- 1:48still thinks pretty much all the time about the kinds of questions that religion I
- 1:53think tries to grapple with those questions, like why we're here, and what
- 1:57we're supposed to be doing while we're here, and how supposed to treat other
- 2:00people and what it's all about. I certainly don't think that religion is the
- 2:05only place to have those conversations or ask those questions. And I understand that
- 2:09many people who are not religious ask them too, But for me, it
- 2:13feels very religious that kind of quest to makes sense of everything, and that
- 2:17still animates me in a huge way, even though I'm no longer an evangelical.
- 2:23Well, it's not a setup. I'm not trying to like I have
- 2:25a lot of believers. I had doctor Kristin Dumay, and I had Robert
- 2:30P. Jones, and I had Andrew Whitehead on the show because we line
- 2:32up in terms of our values, and we can have the discussions about theology
- 2:38at some other time. You know, I'm more interested in what we shared.
- 2:40It's a weird place though you're a professional broadcaster, correspondent, journalist,
- 2:46author, but you share a uniquely personal story, So it's almost a blurring
- 2:51of the line, like are you a professional or are you sharing an anecdote
- 2:54or anecdotes about your own experience? Did you find that was weird writing the
- 2:58book. I don't think it's that unusual. I think there are actually quite
- 3:01a few examples of other journalists that have woven their own stories and their own
- 3:06experiences what they're reporting. And I think it's important to be transparent about who
- 3:12you are and what you're doing. But I think that for many people bringing
- 3:16your own we all bring our own life stories to our reporting. You know,
- 3:20we try to operate by sort of professional standards that make our reporting hopefully
- 3:25as fair and clear and balanced and thorough as possible. But at the same
- 3:30time, somebody who's had an experience like mine is going to see things that
- 3:35somebody who's had a different experience isn't going to see, and vice versa.
- 3:38So define ex vangelical from your vanda. It's like, for me, it
- 3:42means I'm in a post state. But language is stretchy, you know,
- 3:45labels are stretchy. How do you approach the word so expangelical is a word
- 3:52that I ran across when I was reporting on the Trump campaign, and it
- 3:54kind of actually kind of gets to your previous question. You know, I
- 3:58left evangelicalism my early forties. I left in my early twenties. I would
- 4:01say it was sort of a long, slow process that in many ways began
- 4:04in my childhood and still continues. You know, I don't I think it's
- 4:08it's always a journey, But I wouldn't have identified as evangelical within a year
- 4:13or two of graduating from an evangelical college, and I really tried to separate
- 4:17my personal and professional life, like I wanted to be a journalist in large
- 4:20part because I was excited about the opportunity to ask questions, to seek multiple
- 4:26perspectives. That wasn't something I felt free to do. In the evangelical world.
- 4:30We spent a lot of time talking about what we believed and why we
- 4:34believed it, and there was a lot of effort expended trying to produce children
- 4:40and who grew into adults who believed certain things. And so for me,
- 4:45journalism was kind of an escape from that environment that I found to be a
- 4:48very conflicted one for me. So I spent a lot of years, you
- 4:51know, covering things like water quality in Nebraska, and local politics in suburban
- 4:59Chicago, and coastal environmental issues in Georgia, a whole bunch of different other
- 5:03things in various newsrooms. And then I found myself I was recruited to cover
- 5:08the twenty sixteen campaign for NPR. I was assigned to cover the Republican primary,
- 5:12and I found myself covered Donald Trump, and there was this huge conversation
- 5:15happening about evangelicalism, like what it was, would it evangelicals believe? Why
- 5:19were they supporting Trump in such large numbers? Or would they? And kind
- 5:24of gradually, you know, it was an uncomfortable place for me to be
- 5:27in, to be suddenly like face to face with this world that I had
- 5:29come from. But I also realized that I knew something about it and kind
- 5:32of spoke the language and understood the thinking and the theology that undergirded a lot
- 5:38of the political debates that were happening, and in the process of kind of,
- 5:42you know, I became fascinated with it. I'd had a lot of
- 5:44distance from that world, but I knew a lot about it. Became fascinated
- 5:46with it, and so over the course of doing some reporting on those questions,
- 5:50I did one story just before the election about how evangelical women were responding
- 5:56to the Access Hollywood video, and one of the people we interviewed use the
- 6:00word exvangelical and said, for a lot of us, the word evangelical doesn't
- 6:03feel right anymore. We sometimes call ourselves ex evangelicals. And I had never
- 6:08heard this term. It certainly isn't a word I would have used for myself.
- 6:12But I started kind of paying attention to these post evangelical x evangelical spaces
- 6:17where people were using hashtags and making podcasts and making you know, Facebook groups,
- 6:23and going on TikTok and just talking about sorting through all these different aspects
- 6:27of their faith background. And you know, the Trump moment was kind of
- 6:30a catalyst for it, but it wasn't by any means the totality of what
- 6:34was going on. So I think, just to answer your question, and
- 6:38much the same way that evangelical is a very loose broad term that encompasses a
- 6:43lot of people, I think ex evangelical can do the same. And the
- 6:46way I talk about it is essentially somebody who came from that evangelical world and
- 6:51is no longer part of it. It's interesting that we in the non religious
- 6:57sphere just as guilty, right, we speak in the or productive terms.
- 7:00Christians are that Jewish faith is Catholics or Catholicism. You know, the people
- 7:06who practice were billions of people, and we want them to fit in a
- 7:10cookie cutter, you know. And you find that we run the gamut,
- 7:13we run the spectrum. It sounds to me, though, that your upbringing
- 7:16was high control Bible literalist. Is that accurate for sure? And I think
- 7:21that that is. I think that is generally true for most of evangelicalism,
- 7:27at least. I mean, there is a spectrum, for sure, but
- 7:30Biblical literalism is a major theme in evangelicalism. And you know, certainly that's
- 7:35not the same. It's not the same in Europe. I studied abroad in
- 7:38college, and you know, I found that even sort of, you know,
- 7:42within the most most Christians in England, for example, are of course
- 7:45Anglican, but within the Anglican tradition there were many different manifestations and some of
- 7:48them they spanned the spectrum, and some of them that were very evangelical in
- 7:53flavor, you know, and in interacting with Christians there discovered that they had
- 7:57a softer view of you know, for example, biblical literalism, or of
- 8:00things like women in ministry, and certainly some American evangelical churches do today.
- 8:05And I think there's some movement on that, but by and large, you
- 8:09know, if you look at if you look at mainstream evangelical texts, if
- 8:11you look at books from books and magazines for organizations like Focus on the Family,
- 8:16which are hugely influential, they're going to ascribe to a form of Biblical
- 8:20literalism and usually creationism, usually a conservative set of political beliefs, and you
- 8:28know, a very restrictive set of views about human sexuality, including but not
- 8:31limited to the view of gay people. And that was that was how I
- 8:35grew up. It's interesting though that, you know, if you're in a
- 8:37high control fundy faith. I mean, despite the Joyce Myers and the Beth
- 8:43Mores and the Paula Whites and the rare examples, there's not a lot of
- 8:46room for women in those cultures. I don't know, did you fee you're
- 8:50a female growing up in that? Was it restrictive? When it came to
- 8:52your gender. Sure, I mean, and I talk about this in a
- 8:54couple of chapters in the book You Know there was I would say, I
- 8:58got mixed messages about my role. I heard a lot of things growing up,
- 9:03like about how women were supposed to keep the house and women were supposed
- 9:07to, you know, take care of the children. It was almost I
- 9:09grew up in the eighties and nineties, but it was almost kind of like
- 9:11a nineteen fifties model that we were looking back to or trying to hold on
- 9:16to, you know. And I was encouraged to go to college. And
- 9:20now there are some women who grew up in more fundamentalist strains of conservative Christianity
- 9:24that are not encouraged to go to college, but I was. But I
- 9:28also heard things like in case you don't get married, or in case something
- 9:31happens to your husband, I would talk about, you know, I remember
- 9:35feeling sometimes discouraged when I would talk about career aspirations that I had. You
- 9:39know, it wasn't one thing. And I think each of my parents were
- 9:43different. My mom was a bit more traditional. My dad was a bit
- 9:46more career oriented and actually encouraged me in writing and journalism. So I can't
- 9:50you know, I don't want to say that it was just one thing,
- 9:52but most of the women that I grew up around either most of them were
- 9:56stay at home moms. A few had jobs, but they were things like
- 10:00being a teacher at a Christian school, or maybe just working part time,
- 10:05like at a McDonald's to bring in some extra family income, you know,
- 10:07just help supplement the family income. But the emphasis was on the woman as
- 10:13a homemaker, the woman as the support. You know that I was taught
- 10:16that men were the head of the household. First it was God, then
- 10:20it was the man, then it was the woman. And that was hard
- 10:22for me. You know, as a little girl, I wanted very much
- 10:24to have children. I grew up watching my mom. You know, I
- 10:28was the oldest of four, so I grew up watching all the babies be
- 10:31born, watching my mom be pregnant and breastfeed, and I thought all of
- 10:35that was really cool. And I still think all of that is really cool.
- 10:37You know. I think I love being a woman, and I think
- 10:39it's amazing that we get to do these things. And I have two children,
- 10:43and I'm so glad that I do. And so, you know,
- 10:46the emphasis on the family and on motherhood. In many ways, it's really
- 10:50beautiful, but the problem is when it gets restricted to that. And you
- 10:56know, it was harder for me to I didn't see a lot of women
- 10:58who were doing other things outside the home, and I wanted to do things.
- 11:01You know, I've had a whole bunch of ridiculous career aspirations as a
- 11:03kid, like being an archaeologist and you know, like so many kids do.
- 11:07But you know, the paths that were sort of set out for me
- 11:09were pretty limited. And I think, for whatever reason, writing was something
- 11:15that my parents encouraged. My mom liked to write just for fun, and
- 11:18my dad was in the communications field as well, and so I think that
- 11:22was something I had seen modeled for me and felt like I could do,
- 11:24and that's probably why I wound up doing what I'm doing. But there weren't
- 11:28a lot of women I went to school with that became, for example,
- 11:31like doctors or academics. There are some, but it wasn't the norm.
- 11:35It's funny I have mentioned in the past that for the best of reasons,
- 11:41they're the most sincere of reasons. Sometimes that parents will say you can grow
- 11:45up to be whatever you want to be. You can be anything you want
- 11:48to be in this world, and then they commit the whole of their resources
- 11:50to kind of limiting your options. You know, don't be that, don't
- 11:54vote like this, don't marry that person, don't have those friends, don't
- 11:58dress like that, don't get the tattoo, you know, time and again.
- 12:01And I think often they want to protect their children. But in some
- 12:05ways, I think, don't our parents want us to be a reflection of
- 12:07themselves, like a way for them to kind of live on vicariously through us.
- 12:11Oh for sure. I mean I in a way, I like have
- 12:16more sympathy for this now that I have two teenagers. It's easy to judge
- 12:20your own parents when you haven't done it before, and once you've parented,
- 12:22you realize how much how challenging it is. And yes, there's this huge
- 12:24tension between, at least for me, between like wanting to empower them and
- 12:30let them explore their dreams and figure out who they are. But then it's
- 12:33like, well, I'm their parent. I need to give them some parameters
- 12:35and guidelines, you know. I don't want to just throw them out into
- 12:39the world with no direction, because I don't think that tends to work out
- 12:41well. And so you know, again, I think a lot of what
- 12:43evangelical parents were and are trying to do was about protecting kids, about guiding
- 12:48them towards the right path. But there was this very narrow view of what
- 12:52the right path looked like. But yeah, I think it is tricky because
- 12:56you we all, I think, want our kids to and we're happy when
- 13:01our kids look like us, or act like us, or you know,
- 13:03do things that we like. We're not so happy when they maybe pick up
- 13:07parts of us that we're not as big a fans of. And then it's
- 13:09very scary when they go out and do something that's completely that you know,
- 13:13that we haven't thought of, where that's contrary to our values, And you
- 13:16know, I know that's difficult for a lot of the expangelicals. Adults I've
- 13:20talked to have had challenging relationship with their families. I think because they didn't
- 13:24turn out the way that their famili is expected. It's a weird balancing act.
- 13:28They want to teach a child don't touch the hot stove, don't drink
- 13:33the bleach right, don't get in the car with strangers. So much of
- 13:35what they teach children desperately need to be able to navigate the world. But
- 13:41then there is a God and he says this, and your life should look
- 13:46like that. So when does that line blur from one end to the other.
- 13:50You and I walked some of the same steps. I was raised in
- 13:52the same kind of church. You talked in your book about a time you
- 13:56were sitting there and they took some church actor and nailed him across. Kind
- 14:01of freaked you out. For me, it was somebody speaking in tongues.
- 14:03My mother was a Pentecostal, So we're in there and somebody just started screaming
- 14:07at what sounded like Babel, which I think it may have been Babel,
- 14:11and it totally terrified me. And they had up had me on the head
- 14:13and tell me it was going to be okay. Tell me about that moment
- 14:16in church Easter weekend, somebody's being nailed to a cross. Yeah, I
- 14:22mean I was very small, so as I remember, I think there were
- 14:24multiple performances of this Easter pageant, and I just remember, you know,
- 14:30being really confused. I mean, I don't know, I don't know if
- 14:33you're like this. I think some people have really clear memories of themselves as
- 14:35children and other people don't. But I'm the kind of person that, like,
- 14:39I remember what it felt like to be a little kid, and I
- 14:41remember like the confusion of trying to make sense of categories and things I didn't
- 14:45understand. I mean, I have snippets of those memories, and in this
- 14:48case, it was like I just didn't know what was real and I knew
- 14:50it wasn't really Jesus, but I didn't know that the guy wasn't really dying.
- 14:56Like I didn't understand stage makeup and theater and stuff like that. Was
- 15:00there blood and everything? I mean, yeah, I mean I think there
- 15:01was fake blood. But I just remember this like horrible fear that he was
- 15:07going to be killed, that they were like it looked like they were nailing
- 15:09him to this cross, and you know, I knew what that meant,
- 15:11because that is an image that from a young age in an evangelical or fundamentalist
- 15:16household, you're taught is this idea of you know, that Jesus suffered and
- 15:20died and was brutally killed and was nailed to across you know, threw his
- 15:24hands and feet, and I remember hearing very graphic descriptions of it because the
- 15:28idea was we needed to understand it so that we would appreciate what God had
- 15:31done for us and also how sinful we were that had to happen to Jesus.
- 15:35And so yeah, I started I start the book with that story because
- 15:39I think it's a good metaphor for a lot of my life. It's like
- 15:41this very emotional, wrenching, moving stark layered with metaphor and story moment,
- 15:48but also this terrifying moment that forced me to kind of go like, what
- 15:54is happening here? What do I think about this? And what does it
- 15:56mean? Well, do you see the seeds of shame and that it's your
- 16:00fault? Right? He died for your sins because you were born as sinner.
- 16:04I mean that's pounding into the minds of very young children, probably including
- 16:08yourself. Yeah, I know it was. And I mean again, this
- 16:12is like so many things, like I think there's tremendous value in self reflection
- 16:17and humility and in going you know, I am not a perfect person.
- 16:21I mean, I don't have a problem with the idea of sin, but
- 16:23the way that it was or if that's the word you want to use,
- 16:26you know, to talk about the fact that humans are fallible and we're often
- 16:30selfish, and we often do things that serve our own interests but not others,
- 16:32or we don't see how we're harming other people. And I think like
- 16:36it's really important in order to be a decent person to try to self reflect,
- 16:38at least to an extent, about like, how can I be a
- 16:41better person? Who might I be hurting? You know? Am I causing
- 16:45unintended harm in the world or in my relationships? And so that's a really
- 16:48valuable exercise. But when for me, the way that it was presented to
- 16:52me was as a very young child who had not done anything or had the
- 16:56kinds of things that I would do quote unquote wrong, were kinds of things
- 17:00that are normal developmental steps. I mean, And this is a really issue
- 17:03I have with evangelical parenting. You know, children get punished off and very
- 17:07harshly for pushing back, for being angry, for expressing, you know,
- 17:11a temper. And as a parent, I know very well that kids have
- 17:17to be taught and guided. And I don't think that just letting again and
- 17:21just letting children go nuts and behave like little monsters is good either. But
- 17:26you don't have to hit them, you don't have to tell them that God
- 17:29is mad at them, that they're deeply flawed and broken. None of that
- 17:33aligns with the way that I today see human beings much less children. I
- 17:37think you and I line up in terms of our value. I mean,
- 17:40the idea of saying I'm flawed, I make mistakes, I should be better
- 17:44tomorrow than I am today. But that's different. Then I was born so
- 17:48awful that God had to kill himself kind of a thing, you know,
- 17:52there was no one worthy, no not one, which really is kind of
- 17:55a devaluation of human beings. We have to get our value from someone else,
- 18:00and I think that causes trauma and a lot of people. Doctor Marlene
- 18:03wenell Over Journey Free talks a lot about religious trauma syndrome. Do you think
- 18:10religious trauma is a real thing? Some people don't. Sure absolutely, I
- 18:15mean I think I interviewed several experts who have told me that they see this
- 18:19in their practice. You know, religion is not one thing a religion can
- 18:23be. I mean, you may disagree with me, but I actually think
- 18:26religion can be very helpful. I think for people who find meaning from it,
- 18:30for people who are inspired to be better. You know, I look
- 18:33at you know, examples of people who resisted the Nazis or fought against slavery
- 18:37because they were motivated by their religious faith and believed that putting their lives on
- 18:41the line was worthwhile because they believed in something bigger. I think that that
- 18:45is beautiful. I'm also well aware that people who call themselves Christians also were
- 18:51on the wrong side of those things, often in larger numbers than on the
- 18:53right side, And so it's not just one thing. And in the same
- 18:57way, I think, and I'm not export on trauma. I did write
- 19:00a chapter about it, but my sense from the people I've talked to is
- 19:04that religion can provide a sense of meaning and community and a lot of things
- 19:07that are very healthy. It also can inflict trauma, and I think from
- 19:11my research it happens in a couple of different ways. Some of it is
- 19:15directly tied to theological concepts that are presented as fat and as absolute to very
- 19:21young children without any larger context for making a sense of those ideas or understanding
- 19:26that there may be alternative points of view that they could consider. And then
- 19:29some of it is things that would be traumatic in any context. But I
- 19:32think there's a particular and specific kind of trauma that occurs in a church.
- 19:36The classic example would be clergy sex abuse, which we of course became very
- 19:40aware of, you know, twenty twenty five years ago at the Catholic church,
- 19:42but we're increasingly aware of problems with clergy sex abuse in Protestant and Evandelical
- 19:48circles. And so when that happens. Sexual abuse is always traumatic or very
- 19:53often traumatic, I think, probably always by its nature, But when it
- 19:56happens at a church context, there's another layer I think for many people of
- 20:00well, this is happening at the hands of somebody who I'm supposed to trust
- 20:03not only with my physical safety, but my spiritual safety. And you know,
- 20:07I was not a victim of sexual abuse or anything like that. But
- 20:11I think sometimes the fact that some you know, a traumatic experience, a
- 20:15scary experience, a shameful experience, has a layer of religiosity on top of
- 20:18it can really complicate your view of yourself and of whatever you know, whatever
- 20:25you think God is or how God thinks about you. And that's a specific
- 20:27kind of pain. More with Sarah McCammon. Next, I want to talk
- 20:33about entering a Trump rally as a journalist and I want to get into the
- 20:40dominionism of the Christian Bible. We continue next talking here with Sarah McCammon.
- 20:53She is author of the new book called The ex Vangelicals, Loving Living and
- 20:59Leaving the White Evangelical Church. There's a famous orwell line out of nineteen eighty
- 21:03four. Power is in tearing human minds to pieces and putting them together again
- 21:11in new shapes of your own choosing. I can't read that without thinking of
- 21:15today's maga culture. You attended a MAGA rally. Did you go in where
- 21:22you're like wearing your journalism badge? You know, were you sort of under
- 21:26the radar? Tell me about that experience. Oh, I've been to many
- 21:30many Trump rallies. I covered the Trump campaign in twenty sixteen, so generally
- 21:37the experiences, Yeah, as a reporter, so I go in and one
- 21:44of the things I noticed early on in twenty sixteen is that the Trump campaign
- 21:47was quite restrictive about press. You know, a lot of other campaigns would
- 21:51let you sort of mingle with people, but very often there were physical barriers
- 21:56limiting, at least after a certain point in the day, where you could
- 22:00be and whether or not you could be close to people, And I don't
- 22:03want to say that that's unique or exclusive to the Trump campaign, but sometimes
- 22:07access felt very limited, I think more than than other candidates. And you
- 22:12know, from my perspective as a reporter, one of the biggest things I
- 22:17noticed, and I think a lot of people have noticed, is the way
- 22:19that Trump talks about the press. You know, he would talk about those
- 22:25disgusting people in the back of the room, they're the worst people, and
- 22:29you know, blaming the press for all kinds of problems in the country.
- 22:33And this is again not exclusive to Trump. Most candidates for public office at
- 22:38some point tangle with the press, but Trump did it in a particularly I
- 22:42think, vocal and pointed and repetitive and extreme way. And you know that
- 22:48pattern emerged early on and has persisted throughout his versus presidency and then his candidacies
- 22:55for presidents. So I think that you know that was That's not something in
- 23:00experience that only I've had. I mean, many many reporters have had this
- 23:03experience, and it's it's not pleasant, but it is kind of just part
- 23:06of covering a Trump rally. I will say that you know, very often
- 23:08the individuals in the crowd before you talk, before the whole event gets started.
- 23:12Are very friendly and we'll talk and we'll answer questions. You know,
- 23:15some don't want to, but some some were happy to talk with me.
- 23:18But there'd be a real kind of change in the temperature after the rally began,
- 23:22and particularly when Trump started lobbying those attacks at the press. There is
- 23:26a part of your book where you talk about a guy in a MAGA rally.
- 23:30He's got a shirt on and there's three words rope, tree, journalist,
- 23:36and a culture then where reporters fact checkers are made to feel unsafe.
- 23:41Have you felt unsafe? I mean, you don't like to see that.
- 23:45It's obviously and I think I want to be clear, and I was clear
- 23:48in the book. I didn't see that personally. I was at that rally
- 23:52and then later saw coverage of it and realized, oh, that was that
- 23:55that guy was at that. Really I was. You know, you hope
- 23:57that it's just big talk and that it's just kind of blowing off steam.
- 24:02And look, I understand the frustrations with the media. It's increasingly polarized.
- 24:07I'm sure that for an individual trying to sort through all of the information out
- 24:11there, it can be very overwhelming. At times. But I hope that
- 24:15most reasonable people can see how destructive that kind of rhetoric is around the idea
- 24:21of suggesting that journalist should be killed. I mean, that's something that I
- 24:23think we like to think doesn't happen in the United States of America. And
- 24:27no matter how much we disagree, we value robust debate, and we value
- 24:33freedom of the press. It's in our constitution. And so you know,
- 24:37to see that kind of sentiment being expressed openly, proudly, it's concerning and
- 24:44I continue to be concerned about it. Well, I mean this is Orwellian
- 24:47is Trump says what you are seeing and what you are hearing is not what
- 24:49is happening. I want to get theological for just a second, and then
- 24:53we'll come back to the book and put a punctuation mark on it. I
- 24:56know you're being pawt at left and right. One of the challenges I have
- 25:00with the Christian nationalism movement and the resistance to it by people in the faith.
- 25:07Many Christians are saying, well, that's not true Christianity. Jesus is
- 25:11love and light, he would never judge gay people. He doesn't want to
- 25:15send anybody to hell. It's all about the loving embrace of God, which
- 25:21I appreciate. I'll take that Jesus any day of the week, right,
- 25:25I mean, I'm in If that's the Jesus people are going for, I
- 25:27will take that over the more dominionist God of the Bible. I mean,
- 25:33from Adam in the garden being given dominion over the earth. You've got tribal
- 25:37holy wars throughout the Old Testament, whether it's the Amalaki to the Midianites or
- 25:41Jericho. You know, the enemies of God are conquered. The Great commission,
- 25:45go and make disciples in all the nation. There's hell threats for people
- 25:49who are non compliance. So you can see, I think anybody can see.
- 25:52I'm not speaking to you just to here. But if somebody wants to
- 25:56say the country in the world belongs to us and it's holy war, there's
- 26:02a verse or dozens of verses to support that, and that's a real challenge
- 26:07I think for the Christian I don't know what do you want to speak to
- 26:10that at all? Well, I think the question is I think two things
- 26:15about that. One, Christianity is what Christians make it. I mean,
- 26:21religions don't exist, They exist because people exist and try to make sense of
- 26:26the world. So, you know, for there are so many different interpretations
- 26:32of what Christianity is, and what Islam is and what Judaism is. Take
- 26:34any religion, right, there are multiple, many, many, many sets
- 26:40and strains and movements. And so I think the type that you choose to
- 26:45attach yourself to, if you're a religious person, says a lot about you
- 26:49because there are our choices. And I also think that it's incumbent on all
- 26:55of us to speak sort of within the family. If people within our milieu
- 27:02are doing and saying and espousing things that we feel are wrong, that we
- 27:07feel are at odds with the version of our faith that we believe is right
- 27:11or is helpful, it's a coming on us to say so. And you
- 27:18know, I speak from within the Christian family. That's my tradition. I
- 27:25don't think you get to pretend like the Christians who supported slavery or supported the
- 27:32Nazis, to go back to two other examples. I don't think you get
- 27:33to pretend like they're not They weren't Christians. They said they were Christians.
- 27:37Now do they have their hearts right with God? Were they following the teachings
- 27:41of Jesus I mean, I don't think so, but I think we have
- 27:45to look squarely in the face the fact that people do all kinds of terrible
- 27:51things under the banner of religion, claiming and claiming and usually I think often
- 27:55believing that they're doing good. And so I think that should make all all
- 28:00of us hopefully again to go back to something we talked about earlier, self
- 28:03reflect who am I, how am I behaving? What am I doing?
- 28:07And then you know, to your I think your your larger question was just
- 28:11about can you I'm sorry, well I'm speaking about I guess this is kind
- 28:17of where I'm going. And there's especially in Maga culture, there's kind of
- 28:22an Old Testament justice kind of deal. Not just that we want to go
- 28:26and conquer, but we want to punish the wicked. Oh yeah, all
- 28:30right. We're going to punish the people who support ROW. We're going to
- 28:33punish trans people, We're going to punish immigrants. It's alarming. I think
- 28:38what I would just say about that generally is that we, you know,
- 28:44we live in a country that our constitution, intentionally, for reasons the founding
- 28:51Fathers I think thought hard about, sets up a separation between church and the
- 28:55state. And I'm not saying that people can't be wholess, sick people and
- 29:00have their values, including their religious values, in form the way they think
- 29:03about the larger world and even the way that they vote. But I think
- 29:07to say that is different than saying I'm going to impose my view of the
- 29:11world in every detail on other people through the ballot box, or even worse,
- 29:15through anti democratic means. And I think that, you know, one
- 29:21of the real questions that we're grappling with as a country right now is do
- 29:25we believe in the constitution and will we uphold democracy? And democracy as I
- 29:30see it, and I think as I think as our founding fathers saw it
- 29:34is about however imperfectly they saw it at the time, but I think it
- 29:38is about letting people have as much freedom as possible to make decisions about religious
- 29:47matters. Now you know what that looks like on a policy level. I'm
- 29:51not going to comment on because I'm a reporter and I try not to get
- 29:53into that, but you know, I think it's important to remember that this
- 29:57is not a do not live in a theocracy, We do not live in
- 30:02a religious state. This is not a Christian nation. It's a pluralistic country.
- 30:07And yes, Christianity influenced many of the founders. It has influenced this
- 30:12country in significant ways, and some of them, I think in good ways.
- 30:15But this is a country that was set up to be to be non
- 30:22sectarian and to be set up for everyone. And if we, you know,
- 30:26I think we have to ask ourselves do we believe in that or not?
- 30:29And I really believe that if a religious idea isn't compelling enough for people
- 30:33to embrace it on their own, then it's not very compelling. And so,
- 30:36you know, even when I was wasn't evangelical, I was always troubled
- 30:41by the idea that we were supposed to somehow impose Christianity on people who didn't
- 30:47want That seems like such a violation of basic human rights. I'm struck by
- 30:52people who just seem intent on not sharing this world when there's just room,
- 30:56Like there's room for you and there's me, and there's room for us all.
- 31:00You know, I don't need a world that looks just like me.
- 31:03I really feel like there's room for all of us. You and I really
- 31:06are. We have theological discussions here or there, but we're human beings on
- 31:11the same page in terms of values. You know, we could go out
- 31:14and share coffee and have a ball and be from me. I just feel
- 31:15like that this idea that I would other you or you would other me and
- 31:22then declare war. You know, that's the temperature of what's going on.
- 31:26And I guess my final question is this, do you feel like that that
- 31:32type of rigidity, the militarized language, the dogmatism, the othering of people.
- 31:38Do you feel like that's one of the main mechanisms that's driving people out
- 31:44of the formal church. Well, the people that I talked to, it
- 31:47was many of those things. Feeling that either things they were being told in
- 31:53order to sort of keep them in the fold didn't add up, they didn't
- 31:56align with you know, say, scientific fact or that they were exclusive in
- 32:01a way that they didn't want to be. They wanted to include people,
- 32:05They wanted to They wanted to, you know, be able to have relationships
- 32:09with people who weren't just like them and not feel like it was their job
- 32:14to somehow convert them or make them just like them. And I think if
- 32:17you look at you know, and it's if you look at the data around
- 32:21the increasing number of people who identify as nothing at all as religious nuns,
- 32:24you know, an ees, I think we're seeing more and more of that,
- 32:28I mean, and it's it's probably for a variety of reasons, but
- 32:31we do live in a in a society where information is more available than ever,
- 32:37and it's it's more and more difficult to you know, if you want
- 32:40to stay in a bubble where you're not exposed to people who are different than
- 32:45you, it's it's harder to do that. And I think that's a good
- 32:47thing. And so, you know, my feeling is that, you know,
- 32:51as our society moves forward, at some point, people are going to
- 32:54still want the things that religion provides, like the idea of community and meaning.
- 32:58But I think that increasingly people are not wanting to attach themselves to labels
- 33:02and some of the connotations that have often got along with religion. Where that
- 33:07all lands, I really don't know. I mean, I think this sea
- 33:10change we've seen where now religious nuns make up a larger percentage of the population
- 33:15than white evangelicals is really significant and it will be significant for the Republican Party
- 33:19for sure. Exactly how I don't know, but I'm really fascinated to see
- 33:22where that goes. It's really a great book. I mean I'm not just
- 33:27blowing smoke. I mean it's a lovely book. You wrote in three dimensions,
- 33:30you being able to tie your own experience into the shifting of the culture,
- 33:36and so I highly recommend it the Exvangelicals Loving Living and leaving the White
- 33:40Evangelical Church. You've been so kind to chat with me, Sarah McCammon.
- 33:45I will put the link to your work in the book in the description box
- 33:49of this broadcast. All success with it. Be safe out there and let's
- 33:52talk again. Okay, Yeah, thank you, Seth. Good to talk
- 33:54with you. Follow or Thanking Atheist on Facebook and Twitter for a complete archive
- 34:00of podcasts and videos, products like mugs and t shirts featuring the Thinking Atheist
- 34:05logo, links to atheist pages and resources, and details on upcoming free thought
- 34:09events and conventions. Log onto our website, The Thinkingatheist dot com.