Latest / The New Paris Podcast / Episode 3: Innovation and Entrepreneurship in Paris with Rahaf Harfoush
Transcript
- 0:07What are some of the words that come to mind when you think of
- 0:09Paris culture Gastronomy Artistry?
- 0:13Probably romance. Chances are the words progress
- 0:16and Innovation don't make the list which in many ways is
- 0:20strange given its history as a model of modernity in Europe.
- 0:24Its image as a museum city is a veneer masking for many
- 0:27visitors. What is a dynamic and Innovative
- 0:29Capital? Whether it's an entrepreneurship
- 0:32startup culture, or Urban Development, Paris deserves to
- 0:35be part of the global conversation.
- 0:38In this episode of the New Paris podcast, will be talking,
- 0:40Innovation change and an election cycle, that stands to
- 0:44impact both. We're Half her fusha digital
- 0:53Anthropologist a best-selling author, my friend.
- 0:56Which is what I think is her biggest claim to fame and what
- 1:00was really special. During the writing of my book
- 1:03was that I realized that certain points that there would be
- 1:06people, I would be smart to call on to comment on certain areas
- 1:10of change within Paris. And she's the first person.
- 1:13I thought of the first person I wanted to go to when I was
- 1:16writing about changes in business and innovation.
- 1:20And the fact that there are co-working spaces in Paris and a
- 1:24real develops sort of culture. So I have her here with us
- 1:27today. We're about a month and a half
- 1:29from the first round of the French elections.
- 1:31Just so everyone is situated in time and I wanted to get her
- 1:34thoughts on something that she touched on in the book because
- 1:37she did contribute a section things that we didn't weren't
- 1:41able to go into much depth about in the book itself which you
- 1:44will see but wanted her to elaborate a bit more.
- 1:46So we're off you've been here for five years.
- 1:49You are are Canadian, you've lived in Geneva, you've traveled
- 1:54all over the world, you travel all over the world, still to
- 1:57talk about digital Innovation and business and disruptive
- 2:00ideas and big data. So how do you, how would you
- 2:04position Paris in a global scene of progressive ideas?
- 2:09And, and as a culture that is fostering new business.
- 2:17Well, first of all, thank you so much for that.
- 2:19Lovely introduction. Our friendship is definitely my
- 2:25I think that Paris is has always been one of my favorite cities
- 2:29and it has something that is so uniquely special.
- 2:33That I have just never experienced anywhere else, and
- 2:36one might think that, you know, the French have such a
- 2:39reputation abroad for, you know, many good things, some bad
- 2:43things but it was surprising for me to hear.
- 2:46People didn't think the French were quite Innovative and
- 2:49coming. Here, I can say that, you know,
- 2:52their Innovation might look different than other places, but
- 2:56they are an incredibly resilient creative Innovative people.
- 3:00And they are a lot of ways of the city is ahead of a lot of
- 3:04other ecosystems. I think the pace of innovation
- 3:07here, something that has been very fascinating to track over
- 3:10the last couple of years. I live in the section of the
- 3:15city, which is called Old silicone Santi a, which wasn't
- 3:18always silicone Sanjay. It's something that I've had the
- 3:22opportunity to see develop and just as a parenthesis, the Santi
- 3:27has been a textile Hub of the city, but it also happened to be
- 3:31an area where startups started setting up shop.
- 3:35I imagine because of affordable rents or just spacious buildings
- 3:39that they were offices that they could find.
- 3:41So it's something we in conversation.
- 3:44People don't generally call it the Silicon Sante but What?
- 3:46It's known as yes. Now, so to give you guys some
- 3:49context, you know, you would walk down my street and you
- 3:53would just see all of these wholesalers small shops,
- 3:56shuttered, you know, doors Brands, you've never ever heard
- 3:59of. And then, over the past couple
- 4:02of years, what's been awesome is all of a sudden, these
- 4:05wholesalers were being replaced by co-working Spaces by tiny
- 4:09startups, by little workshops. Now, we have one of the biggest
- 4:15and actually long August running incubators and accelerators
- 4:19which is Numa. But across from nuuma, we also
- 4:21have now, Lemme zoned to bitcoin, which is something
- 4:24that, you know, is quite new in the neighborhood, in my own
- 4:28Street. I live in a passage in a
- 4:30pedestrian. Passage way, we have three
- 4:32startups that have come in now and have taken over abandoned
- 4:36spaces, which I think is just great.
- 4:38So, just in the last couple of years that I have been here.
- 4:42I have personally witnessed the pace of innovation in a very
- 4:45real tangible way. In the neighborhoods with the
- 4:48Marais as well as the second. The first, the fourth, the bit
- 4:52we have seen the incredible popularity of co-working spaces.
- 4:56And I think in the radius of my house, I can count at least
- 5:00seven, which is, you know, was unheard of, for five years ago.
- 5:05And now I'm just finding that the conversation around startups
- 5:09is becoming much more accessible to people.
- 5:11You have had huge influential players, like the accelerator
- 5:15and the VC. The Family that came in and they
- 5:17started something called coup d'etat, which was a free
- 5:21available online, video series that taught people.
- 5:25The ins and outs of Entrepreneurship, you started
- 5:27having blogs like rude baguette which just covered exclusively.
- 5:32The French startup scene in English.
- 5:35I think which opened up a lot of the market to people who had a
- 5:38language barrier and you started seeing more big companies
- 5:41actually BNP and IBM, starting to develop their own Own
- 5:46internal startup programs. So even though sometimes on the
- 5:50outside, it might look like things are not changing.
- 5:53When you go down to a granular level of startup level.
- 5:56There's a lot of movement and a lot of excitement and that has
- 5:59change it. It seems to get faster every
- 6:01year. I also read, what?
- 6:04Well, before I get to this one thing I've just learned about.
- 6:08Why do you think this has been a more recent development?
- 6:12I mean, certainly you look at Innovations like the development
- 6:15of they leave. The The bike sharing program.
- 6:17Which yes, that's not a tech Innovation.
- 6:20But certainly all of the models, the bike sharing models, in
- 6:23Chicago, in New York and London were mirrored after the Parisian
- 6:28system. So why do you think we're just
- 6:30starting to see some of these developments in business and
- 6:33Tech in Paris? I think one of the biggest
- 6:37challenges from a global Innovation perspective.
- 6:40Is that whenever people think of innovation or startup hubs, they
- 6:44think of Silicon Valley and silicon.
- 6:46He is an incredibly special place and it, you know, the
- 6:49proximity to venture capital and universities and all of that.
- 6:52But sometimes people assume that it is the global standard for
- 6:56Innovation everywhere, and that became the Benchmark against
- 6:59which other cities are always judged upon.
- 7:02And I don't think that's the right way because Silicon
- 7:04Valley, Silicon Valley, and Paris is Paris.
- 7:06And so when you're starting to compare the Innovative ecosystem
- 7:09between Silicon Valley and Paris, you're like, oh well,
- 7:12Paris is behind on this, there's not as much Capital being
- 7:15raised, there's not as much. Much you know activity, but I
- 7:19don't think that you're going to have the exact same conditions
- 7:22for Innovation. You know, Paris has its own
- 7:24unique set of conditions. We have access to Europe as a
- 7:28whole. We have access to all sorts of
- 7:30different languages, and different cultures, and all
- 7:32sorts of different Innovations. So, the way that Innovation
- 7:34develops, and let's not forget that Silicon Valley is quite
- 7:37new. The u.s. is quite new as a
- 7:39country. The young country.
- 7:41So, you're also dealing with a country that doesn't have the
- 7:43baggage of hundreds of years of revolutions.
- 7:46Aristocracy and this big colorful past.
- 7:50So I think that Paris when you look at it within its historical
- 7:53context is quite Innovative because they have been around
- 7:56for so long that in a way, the French with their revolutions
- 7:59and the Republic have been constantly Reinventing
- 8:01themselves as a constantly innovating since, you know, the
- 8:04beginning of the, the founding of the country.
- 8:06Anyway, so I and this is not just for Paris.
- 8:09This goes for a lot of other cities as well where we need to
- 8:12start looking at Innovation ecosystems based on their own.
- 8:16Text of the culture in the city that they're in.
- 8:18And if you just hold Paris on its own, to the policies that
- 8:22the cities are enacting to the companies that are being founded
- 8:25to the, the excitement to the resources to, you know, you we
- 8:29have the government introducing more competitive visas and
- 8:32startup visas. We have, you know, digital
- 8:35Ministry, we have the French Tech, all of these things are
- 8:39actually, you know, very much considered a strong part and
- 8:42when you rank it Paris ranks, very highly, that's what that
- 8:45was gonna be my next Wait, one of the recent articles I read
- 8:49positioned Paris in the top. Three startup hubs in Europe
- 8:53based on fun recent funding and Capital Growth.
- 8:56So I mean that bodes well for the future of Paris.
- 8:59Are there any companies that you've come into contact with or
- 9:03have observed that you think are sort of a best practice examples
- 9:06for? I mean, I think of blablacar
- 9:09which is the sort of car pooling service that is massively
- 9:14successful and what I think Is interesting is that yes it was
- 9:17created in Paris but the in they instantly thought Global it
- 9:22wasn't limited to a French Market.
- 9:24Are there other examples that you can think of that you think
- 9:27are you know shining stars in this culture culture?
- 9:32Yeah I mean Deezer is a really big one, some of the ones that
- 9:36are sort of up and coming, I like La Bouche gue which I
- 9:40thought was great, also takes advantage of, you know, I feel
- 9:42like the French have a specific relationship with food and it
- 9:46Civic appreciation for food. And so that's like a CSA.
- 9:49Yes. Yeah, I think there's a lot of
- 9:52even there's two places like the family, which have have put a
- 9:55very French spin on venture capital and on building an
- 10:00ecosystem, I think are shining practices and they've sort of
- 10:03managed to expand into London and different parts of Europe.
- 10:07And so, let's not forget like Numa, which is the accelerator
- 10:10has been around for, I think I think almost 10 years it's been
- 10:15around and they have hubs open in Russia and their opening hubs
- 10:18and China trusting. So it's easy to think oh you
- 10:22know, the French are behind but really they're quite
- 10:24competitive. And so this brings me to a more
- 10:42timely topic that links to all of this, the support of business
- 10:46entrepreneurship, Artisan Ray we have a candidate running for
- 10:51president and anyone back home. He's 39 years old, he spent four
- 10:55years working in finance. He was in Nolan's Administration
- 11:00before he resigned to pursue his own activities.
- 11:03He for a lot of people is a breath of fresh air in this
- 11:07election, which Is stricken with its own sorts of scandals.
- 11:14He is someone who we've learned has been quite supportive of the
- 11:20idea of having entrepreneurs create business and, and kick
- 11:23start the economy. What is your impression of him
- 11:26as someone who has seen a figure like Justin?
- 11:29Trudeau and Canada? And we've seen what has happened
- 11:31in the American election. I know you were involved
- 11:34politically with Barack Obama's campaign years and years and
- 11:38years ago. What do you, you know, what are
- 11:40your impressions of this? This very unique character in
- 11:44the French election process. I think what's interesting is
- 11:47when you put what's happening in the French elections within more
- 11:51of a global context, which is we seem to be at a point in history
- 11:56or point in time right now, where institutions that have
- 11:59served a purpose for several decades or no longer doing their
- 12:04job and are failing and people are being left behind.
- 12:06And we've seen that in the US, we've seen it A bit in Canada,
- 12:10we're seeing it in France, where we have done, you know, politics
- 12:13was done in a very specific way that hasn't changed.
- 12:16And what we're starting to see is people rising up and wanting
- 12:20something different than the status quo.
- 12:23The American elections where you saw Bernie Sanders is a very
- 12:26strong candidate. To the left was more about
- 12:30having a similarity with Trump in the sense that they were both
- 12:32considered sort of Outsiders outside, you know,
- 12:35anti-establishment candidates, even Justin Trudeau.
- 12:39Who was elected one of his crew? His critics biggest concern was
- 12:43his lack of experience but I think many Canadians saw that as
- 12:47a breath of fresh air, somebody who isn't necessarily burdened
- 12:50by a lot of the behind the door career, you know, deal-making
- 12:56that kind that goes on. And what's been very interesting
- 12:58about Michael is that he's managed to tap into the
- 13:01sentiment that that many French people feel like the current
- 13:04system isn't working. And what I like to see about
- 13:07candidates like him, is that it Originally in other areas, you
- 13:11know, in the u.s. that manifested itself into very
- 13:14right-wing, sort of isolationist populous type of government, but
- 13:19that and people were thinking, oh, this is inevitable.
- 13:21It's going to happen all over the world but leaders like
- 13:24Trudeau and candidates like Mike Lowell.
- 13:26They also make a good case for the alternative which is we can
- 13:29still have anti-establishment without sacrificing liberal
- 13:33democratic values. And in fact, we should be
- 13:35pursuing any type of innovative thinking that.
- 13:37Take a look at these institutions.
- 13:39And say, can we do it better? Because unfortunately politics
- 13:42is one of those Legacy systems where we do things a certain way
- 13:45for 50 years. Never stop to think, is this
- 13:48still the best way? And he's actually actively
- 13:51encouraging. I mean, this would obviously be
- 13:53taken to the next level. Should he be elected?
- 13:55But he wants people to come back into France and to invest in
- 13:59business and wants to help them along that process.
- 14:03But with regard to anti-establishment candidates
- 14:06Mountain Dew pain could be considered one as well, and Her
- 14:09narrative is very convincing to a certain set of the population
- 14:12who also feel left behind. So, you know, do you think, and
- 14:16I certainly go back and forth on this that the, the French are
- 14:21ready for someone as Progressive as Mac home, because in the end
- 14:25Lupin is not Progressive. She wants to set us back a few
- 14:29hundred years. But he brings something that I
- 14:32think many French people are taken aback by which is he
- 14:35doesn't really follow the rules. He goes about things in his own.
- 14:39Own way, he's very vocal and he has a bit of a tenderness to him
- 14:43that you don't usually see with with politicians.
- 14:46What's interesting about this is that it's less of a political
- 14:49issue and more of a psychological issue.
- 14:51So, because we're in this period of massive disruption, a lot of
- 14:54people are afraid and generally, you see this historically when
- 14:58people are afraid, when there is economic scarcity, or perceived
- 15:01economic scarcity, when Industries are going through
- 15:04periods, where like manufacturing where it's gone
- 15:06from mature industry into, you know, a bit of a Industry.
- 15:10And in many countries know what happens is, people always fall
- 15:14back to the familiar and part of the narrative that they tell
- 15:17themselves is, well, it's not my fault.
- 15:19So then they want to blame it on somebody else.
- 15:21So in this case, the the scapegoat happens to be
- 15:24immigrants or, you know, immigration or open Borders or
- 15:28globalism or you know, capitalism or whatever they want
- 15:31to point fingers. But ultimately, what they want
- 15:33is they want to go back to a different time when they didn't
- 15:36feel. So at risk, when you look at the
- 15:37Americans again, make America. Great again is essentially a
- 15:40Nostalgia cry to go back to 1950s when America was a
- 15:45manufacturing power and the reality is is that's not going
- 15:47to happen. So she I think Le Pen, I think
- 15:51represents the fear response which is what happens when you
- 15:55are scared and what happens when you don't want to change and you
- 15:59don't want to admit that things have changed.
- 16:00You bury your head in the sand and use.
- 16:02I'm just going to blame this person.
- 16:04What I love about Matt Cole, is that he's a bit, no nonsense
- 16:07about it where the other option is to say things, Changing and
- 16:09we need to adapt in order to embrace these changes and create
- 16:13plant the seeds. Now for the future, instead of
- 16:16going backwards to try to make France manufacturing power,
- 16:19let's make France and Innovative power.
- 16:22And when you look at what's being called the fourth
- 16:24Industrial Revolution, which is really how, you know, everything
- 16:27everything is being disrupted and knowledge work, and the
- 16:30exchange of ideas are going to become the most important
- 16:32currency then what he's doing. Now is planting seeds to start
- 16:36planning for the economies that don't even exist yet.
- 16:38That aren't They realized he's creating the foundations for
- 16:40that. However, where the tension
- 16:42becomes is that most people want better economic future, but they
- 16:46don't actually want anything to change.
- 16:48And so they want to have access to new Industries, but they want
- 16:52to hide behind Antiquated labor laws and they want, you know, in
- 16:56America and Canada as well. It's like everyone says, they
- 16:58care about the environment but nobody wants to stop driving
- 17:01their SUV. And so this is where you have
- 17:03this tension where I worry. Sometimes that in a time of
- 17:06fear, people will go towards what they want to hear.
- 17:09Which as you don't have to change.
- 17:10Its not you everything's okay versus somebody who like my call
- 17:14who's telling the truth and saying changes normal, it's
- 17:17going to be a bit painful but if we want to survive or going to
- 17:20have to evolve and in nature, you know, you, if you don't
- 17:23evolve, if you don't adopt you die, what a positive message?
- 17:27No, I think also the, the are Our Hope in this election is
- 17:32that because of macarons young age, if he doesn't go through,
- 17:37this is not the last. We will see of him.
- 17:39Him and I think he is very politically engaged and he is a
- 17:42lot of people engaged around him.
- 17:45So aside from that, however, you know, as someone who regularly
- 17:50speaks on developments and Innovation around the world
- 17:54where do you think Paris in particular?
- 17:57So not speaking about the rest of France now but Paris in
- 18:00particular where do you still see room for change?
- 18:07Where do I see room for change? Okay, well before I answer that
- 18:10I just want to redeem myself a little bit with listening - sort
- 18:13of it wasn't meant to be a negative comment at all.
- 18:14But I just, I think Mike Holmes age and I do want to say this.
- 18:17I think the, I think having younger people in positions of
- 18:20power, is one of the biggest ways that we can have a positive
- 18:24impact because you need the voice of the current, you know,
- 18:28generation to be reflected in policies.
- 18:30And that's why you see these young leaders that are coming
- 18:32up, that are pushing for more Progressive policies.
- 18:35And you know, and then when you look at the United States, it's
- 18:38more like when you look at the things that Donald Trump is
- 18:40proposing. For example, he's proposing,
- 18:43coal and oil and Manufacturing. It's very much reflective of
- 18:48what success looked like when he was in the process of building
- 18:51his business has. That's a generational thing.
- 18:53He's 70 years old. So when you hear Mac home talk
- 18:56when you hear Trudeau talk, they're talking about the
- 18:58environment and about artificial intelligence and about new
- 19:02knowledge economies. Like this is where the future is
- 19:04going. And one of the one areas that I
- 19:06think that I think parisians, or Paris could have some
- 19:11improvement, as I think the cultural attitude towards some
- 19:13of this risk, we tend to be or parisians tend to be very
- 19:16against taking risks and, which is kind of funny to me because
- 19:21as friends as a whole, there's a country with a lot of, it's like
- 19:24a social net, there's a lot of support.
- 19:26So even if you were to take a risk and have that risk, not pan
- 19:29out, we are in a much better place than in many other
- 19:33countries. Where if we do We lose our jobs,
- 19:35then we lose our homes and, you know, it's a complete design.
- 19:38We don't have access to insurance, and medical
- 19:40insurance, and things like that. So, one of the things that I see
- 19:43and I see this a lot when I teach an innovation class at one
- 19:46of the universities here in Seattle, SPO.
- 19:49And when I ask my students, what their goals are and what their
- 19:51aspirations are, a lot of them have ideas for new businesses
- 19:54but they want to do it more as a side business.
- 19:57And we want to work for a big company first because it gives
- 19:59them security. And I'm not sure that's just a
- 20:02French thing as much as it also is a part.
- 20:05Of that cultural response to economic uncertainty, but I do
- 20:08know that we should be creating opportunities for young people
- 20:12to go out whether it's access as my phone was saying to visas or
- 20:15funding, or things like that, like in Singapore.
- 20:18And in Chile, they have these programs where you get paid like
- 20:21a salary to come and bring your start up there.
- 20:23They give you office space to give you a mentorship to in
- 20:25order to go and spend two years developing your ideas.
- 20:28And I know they've talked about stuff like that here, but I
- 20:30think it's not even about bringing people abroad.
- 20:32As it is, empowering the incredibly Smart people that
- 20:35already live here to kind of unleash and do that and part of
- 20:39that requires, you know, reshaping how we see
- 20:42entrepreneurship and reshaping, how we see risk and the attitude
- 20:46that we have around failure, I find that the French are very
- 20:49proud culture and there is a very much about, you know, being
- 20:53respectable and being seen a certain way.
- 20:56And unlike Silicon Valley, which is a bit of a cultural
- 20:58difference, where the Silicon Valley, if you're not failing,
- 21:01you're not seen as experimenting hard enough here.
- 21:04There A bit of a stigma if you're considered a
- 21:06quote-unquote, you know, failure.
- 21:08If your Venture doesn't work versus in other ecosystems, it's
- 21:11just considered par for the course as a part of evolution.
- 21:14So if you can't change the existing culture because that's
- 21:19a mentality, as you said that has existed for long before any
- 21:23of us have been alive, you really need some of that change
- 21:26to come from higher up. You need the political system to
- 21:29be reflective of the attitudes you want to instill in the
- 21:32population where to encourage. Within the population.
- 21:36Hopefully, that will happen. Hopefully, Mac home will make it
- 21:40through or at least be continue to be heavily involved if he
- 21:43doesn't make it through. But I'm glad to hear from
- 21:48someone who has researched this topic heavily and to sort of
- 21:53confirm what my observations were which is that this place is
- 21:56not resistant to to change at all.
- 22:00It may be uncomfortable for them and that has historically been
- 22:03true, but it is a place of Evasion.
- 22:05And obviously, as the book talks about, you can see that in food,
- 22:08you can see that in even on a smaller scale with, in pastry,
- 22:13with Alice, we will talk about whether or not, we see that in
- 22:16fashion and in the retail space, but it is happening.
- 22:19And so I really thank you for bringing that knowledge that you
- 22:22have. And, and talking about this
- 22:25hopefully will have a part to post election and then we can
- 22:29celebrate or or do a deeper analysis.
- 22:32The one thing I just want to say is because I do I do agree that
- 22:35the government's important but I do also want to make people
- 22:38aware of the accountability of the individual piece.
- 22:41As we mentioned, France is a country that has been built on
- 22:43Revolutions of bottom-up you know, uprisings and I do want to
- 22:48say that there are huge influences and people can have a
- 22:52big impact, and it could be something as simple as reaching
- 22:55out to the startups in your area talking to entrepreneurs
- 22:58building mentorship networks. Fostering relationships with
- 23:00some of these very successful, French companies.
- 23:03So those things are also going to have Of a big positive
- 23:06impact. And that's just to say that even
- 23:08if the political election doesn't go the way that you want
- 23:11it to go, that doesn't mean that Innovation will suffer.
- 23:13I think the French have always been very resilient and they
- 23:16always been able to survive and to thrive.
- 23:18And so there's a big component here where the individual were,
- 23:22each of us have an ability, whether you're a pastry shop or
- 23:25you have a small cheese shop or you're a startup we're going out
- 23:30there talking to people forming relationships.
- 23:32Forming communities is what actually ends up driving The
- 23:35Innovation for either, well, let's wait and see.
- 23:40Thanks for listening to this. Episode of the New Paris podcast
- 23:44with me Lindsay trim you de author of The New Paris in
- 23:47stores now, and my co-host Alice Cavanaugh, fashion journalist
- 23:50and author of the latest wallpaper guide to Paris.
- 23:53It was recorded in an 11,000, is small and produced by Lori
- 23:57Martinez. If you've enjoyed the show,
- 23:59please subscribe on iTunes, and share it with a friend.
- 24:02Until next time, feel free to tweet us.
- 24:04Your thoughts and questions at New Paris.
- 24:06Podcast all one word, a bientot.