Latest / Automotive State of The Union / Tariffs Pressure Auto Production, Cybertruck Sales Dive, $8M Super Bowl Ads
Transcript
- 0:00Good morning. It is Monday morning, February 3rd. We got a start to the week at, uh, to the new month on a Saturday, which everyone gets excited about.
- 0:07Today we're gonna talk about tariffs, Cybertrucks, and Super Bowl ad prices. Wanna know, the people really wanna know. Who I is and who I be. Because- Stop the We have Steve Greenfield with us today...
- 0:15smallin' they too me. And if they want no me to be. And I know he just placed- 'Cause shorty be watching TV... his Super Bowl ad placement. What did you decide to run? Yeah, I, I took two of them. I took two of them.
- 0:21Yeah. At 16 mil. In a row? Or- Yeah, yeah, they gave me a discount. They gave me a m- $1 million discount, which is very kind of them. Very much, very much so. [laughs] You took the, took the 60-second spot- Yeah.
- 0:29[laughs]... in the Super Bowl. Basically it's gonna follow up. What was that company that did the QR code? Uh, crypto.com was it? Yeah, yeah. Yeah. Remember?
- 0:36I was like, "That was probably one of the mo- best executions ever." It was just- Yeah... a bouncing QR code and they paid, you know, I don't know, 7 million to do the bouncing- [laughs]... QR code.
- 0:47And when they showed the data on that, it was staggering. Like, the, the actual click-throughs were unbelievable. So, you know. Right. Yeah, yeah. Creativity won the day. Um, we're- Yeah...
- 0:54kind of back, a week, a week back now from NADA. It's funny that, like, all the attention back to New Orleans for the Super Bowl, and we were like, "We were just there."
- 1:03Um, how did, how did the show end up going for you? You had a, a special meetup with a lot of investors, um, which was really nice.
- 1:08And even despite the low attendance to the show, it seemed like you had a lot of people there. Yeah. I mean, it, it was sad that we missed so many folks at, at the last minute were forced not to come. Yeah.
- 1:18But, you know, we, we had a, a reception on Friday night for our investors and our entrepreneurs, which is kind of cool, 'cause only once a year really we get those folks together.
- 1:26And then, um, I was most excited Saturday morning. We had, um, I don't know why I hadn't thought of this before, but we had a reception for non-exhibiting, uh, founders.
- 1:35You know, a lot of founders show up to NADA before they can ever afford to buy a booth- Right... and they're, you know, just trying serendipitously to f- to, to run into a few dealers.
- 1:44So, uh, we're, we're gonna try to do this. I think we're gonna try to bolt this on. We, we should talk about ASOTU CON as well. Yeah.
- 1:49You know, bolting, bolting this on because I think that y- you, you know better than me, a lot of, you know, entrepreneurs show up, uh, to your shows.
- 1:56And, um, if we could have a venue for them just to get together to l- learn, you know, one-on-one time and maybe meet some dealers, you know, in a very informal setting, I think it's, um, it worked out very, very well.
- 2:07So we'll, we'll lean into that and do that, sort of bolt that on to a number of conferences throughout the year.
- 2:12Let's talk about that because we were, we've been talking about, um, what we're going to do the day before ASOTU CON. Okay, good. It's, uh, and if you didn't know, it's a great time to announcement.
- 2:20It's almost like you segued that for us. ASOTU CON tickets are live, by the way. Uh, you can go to asotucon.com, uh, get tickets now. Uh, they are gonna continue to go up in price as we get closer to the event.
- 2:32Um, basically May 13th through 16th, so the week after Mother's Day. Just circle it. Um, we have some, some fairly fun news we're gonna announce. We have, uh, some international folks coming in, making the trip.
- 2:42So the, and especially I think after NADA, um, being a challenging spot, we've had a, a huge uptick in interest. So, um, this one is g- last year was really, really great. It was packed.
- 2:52This year we're opening up more seating, found out a way, uh, we, how we can feed more people. So, uh- Good...
- 2:57there's really gonna be a great collaborative spirit and, and I love the idea of getting the, the non-exhibiting founders in the room, because if you think about what the list of non-exhibiting founders would've been, like, five years ago,
- 3:09it, it would've been pretty amazing, right? We're like- Yep... "Oh, I, I know those guys." I was just, um, I'm, I've been considering my first EV for, like, two years now. And- You gotta pull the trigger, man...
- 3:19I, I know You gotta pull the trigger. I know. And I'm, and I'm there. While you can get a tax incentive. You gotta go now. I know. I know. That's a great point.
- 3:26And so one of the, one of the vehicles that, that I'm looking at, I'm, you know, we, we have some things going on at home and, and I was like, "Maybe a, maybe a pickup truck."
- 3:34I've always wanted a pickup truck, never had one. Mm-hmm. And I never would've thought my first EV might be a pickup truck, but my first EV might be a pickup truck. We'll see. There you go.
- 3:41But I clicked on the little Recurrent. I was browsing on cars.com actually, looking at used inventory across, like, 200 miles, and I clicked on, you know, always click on the little Carfax.
- 3:50I love when they have that available. And I clicked on the little Recurrent button. And I- Nice... I never clicked on the Recurrent button, but I- Ah... you know, we know the guys. Yeah. We know the company.
- 3:59We know the story. And I was like- And you know the investor, us. I do know the- We're the investors... I do know the investor. And I was, like, five seconds into that click and I was like, "This is amazing."
- 4:11Car options.
- 4:11Like, e- the, the, the coolest thing was the li- there's a little map when you click on it, and the map gives you, based on the driving range of the vehicle, how far you can go on a round trip and how far you can go on a one-way.
- 4:23Yep. And, uh, it, it was pretty amazing. So, and all kinds of, like, you know, battery information. I was impressed. This is not a sponsored ad. I was just really impressed. [laughs] Well, there you go.
- 4:31Scott's gonna love you, so I'll report back to Scott Case- Yes. Yeah. [laughs]... and make sure he watches this segment today. [laughs] We'll send a totally unsponsored ad. [laughs] There you go.
- 4:38[laughs] Ann Marie on my team is gonna be like, "You gotta stop saying stuff like that when there's no sponsor." [laughs] Oh, don't worry. We'll get Scott to sponsor something now after this. That's it.
- 4:46[laughs] Don't you worry. Yeah. That's actually our play, aren't we? [laughs] All right, let's get into some news today. Big talk is, uh, the tariffs right now.
- 4:52A fresh round of tariffs signed by President Trump sending shockwaves through North American auto industry with 25% duties on vehicles and parts from both Canada and Mexico, and a 10% levy on Chinese imports.
- 5:04Automakers and suppliers both bracing for rising costs, potential production shutdowns, and some fierce retaliation maybe from some trade partners set to go into effect tomorrow, February 4th.
- 5:15And, and Canada's Prime Mis- Minister, Justin Trudeau, and Mexican's president, Claudia, uh, Sheinbaum, have pledged retaliation which could further escalate the tensions.
- 5:24Automakers could shift production, but they face major supply chain costs and challenges to do so.
- 5:30They're saying, um, you know, vehicles, certain vehicles could increase in price by thousands, like a Chevy Silverado, GMC Sierra, Ram, a lot of trucks built in Mexico.
- 5:40Uh, Toyota RAV4 and Tacoma built in Canada and Mexico. And the Ford Mustang Mach-E, Bronco Sport, and Maverick all built in Mexico.
- 5:48Uh, John Bozzella, we had a chance to meet and sit in person last week at Public Policy Day. It was amazing.
- 5:53President for Alliance for Automotive Innovation says, quote, "We support efforts to strengthen the US auto industry, but across the board tariffs on Canada and Mexico will only increase costs, disrupt sh- supply chains, and put jobs at risk.
- 6:06We want to work on solutions that achieve the president's goals and preserve a healthy, competitive auto industry in America."
- 6:13Steve, you, you, uh, in your, uh, weekly email you had this front and center, so you obviously have some thoughts on it.Yeah, I mean, it's, it's, it's sad because, you know, the consumer is gonna end up paying more for cars, and it's really gonna put pressure in the short term on automakers and, and suppliers, as, as you know.
- 6:30But I mean, there, there isn't enough margin in here, right, for, for, for the, the supply chain to absorb it. The OEMs can s- uh, absorb 25% reduction in margin. Um, the, the s- suppliers definitely can't.
- 6:40They, they run on razor-thin margins as well. And there isn't enough time to, to c- push up MSRP on all the cars.
- 6:47And, you know, could you imagine that if tomorrow you go shopping for that car you're looking for and it's 25% more expensive? Right.
- 6:53Uh, you know, consu- consumers are gonna, like, just not be able to, to stomach this and s- swallow this change as well. So I think that it's great.
- 6:59The, the, the challenge I have with this one is, you know, I, I understand what, what they're, the White House is trying to do. If you, if you read the press release, it's around fentanyl and immigration.
- 7:08But, um, you know, Mexico and Canada aren't gonna have a lot of, like, direct proof that they can reduce fentanyl imports into the US.
- 7:16So even if they wanted to do something about this and show the White House, "Hey, we've, we've changed, you know, we, we, we've done what you wanted, reduce the tariffs," there's no real way to do that in the short term.
- 7:26So I, I don't know how this is gonna play out with- I know... but the, the stock market this morning is gonna, you know, get hammered. Yep.
- 7:31And, uh, I think it's gonna be a, a, a tough day in the markets overall as this gets digested with the uncertainty for how long this will persist. Yeah.
- 7:39You know, I, I do think about the, I was thinking about, like, what the mix of products, 'cause it's just like, it's almost like, it's not quite like gas prices where oil increases and all of a sudden the price at the pump increases, right?
- 7:51Mm-hmm. The gas that's in their tank right now, in their holding tanks, did not cost- Right... the higher amount. It's just an opportunity for them to reap some of the benefit.
- 7:59So automakers, right now everything on the lots, everything in process, everything that's completed and finished is obviously at the price it's at. Right.
- 8:06And depending on which manufacturer, that could be anywhere from a 22-day supply to 120-day supply.
- 8:12And so are we gonna start to see vehicles mixed in where it's, like, two identical vehicles and one is 25% more than the other? It'll be interesting to see how that gets managed.
- 8:21I mean, hopefully, um, you know, the, you know, Trump is a, a, a very shrewd negotiator, and he has, you know, he's, he's a very, um, very much like throw this big idea out there and execute on some of it in order to make everybody move.
- 8:35We've seen a lot of people move in some other immigration issues like Venezuela, Colombia. Um, you know, he, they, they kind of, like, called his bluff for, like, a split second. Right. And then he's like, "Okay," right?
- 8:45And then they're like, "Wait, wait, wait, wait, wait," right? Right, right. And from that point, he's like, "No, I'd like two coats of wax on that car, please." [laughs] Right, right.
- 8:51But, but, like, to your point, like, what is, what is the interim, the interim, like, expression of Canada or Mexico taking increased efforts to, to, you know, like, address immigrati- uh, you know, immigration or address fentanyl?
- 9:05Is that, is that, like, a show of force on the border from the other side? Like, what is it going to take to, to actually do that? And like you said, super unclear right now.
- 9:14Um, I think one of this, things it does for us in the industry is it puts the auto industry in the center of conversation of what's going on in pop culture.
- 9:22So I, as always when that happens, I think we have an opportunity to over-communicate- Mm... and over-empathize with the consumer. Um, you know, and so what, like it or not, here we are. Yeah.
- 9:34I mean, if I, I'm a dealer, and I know a lot of dealers who are tuning in. Think of, yeah, h- how to be opportunistic around this.
- 9:39If you, if you believe that MSR- MSRPs are gonna go up here very shortly, it's a good time to get consumers closed on cars with the fear that they're gonna be paying more in the next month or so. Right, and unknown.
- 9:50And it's tax season, right? Like, there's, there's actually not a better time to try to get people secured in and locked in, give them peace of mind to know, like, "Hey, whatever happens, at least I have this." Right.
- 10:00Agreed. I don't, I think cars aren't getting cheaper. You know what I mean? Like, they're not gonna be, like, substantially cheaper. But they could be substantially more expensive. Agreed. Well put.
- 10:08Speaking of- There's the quote for the day. There's the quote for the day. There you go. Speaking of substantially cheaper- Stop. Segway. Time.
- 10:13There's one truck that is made in the United States that will not be, uh, subject to any tariffs, but can we sell them?
- 10:18The Tesla Cybertruck sales are falling flat, forcing the company to roll out some heavy incentives, including free $6,000 wrap. So they'll wrap the vehicle for free.
- 10:29Um, and they also introduced some new leasing options with demand far below expectations. The questions are mounting whether or not the Cybertruck is turning into Tesla's first major flop.
- 10:38They launched the Cybertruck leases in the US this month starting at $750 a month, which is very reasonable for the truck, uh, a move typically reserved for vehicles with slower demand.
- 10:47Buyers of foundation series Cybertrucks now get a free wrap worth $6,000 as Tesla struggles to clear inventory. So you can choose the color you want and, you know, they're trying to think about what the consumer wants.
- 10:57Sales have been underwhelming despite, uh, one million plus reservations.
- 11:01They've sold fewer than 40,000 units with some analysts estimating that number could drop to 30,000 in 2025, far below its planned 250,000 unit annual capacity.
- 11:12The rear wheel drive version is coming later this year, and new federal tax credit eligibility in 2025 might help, but the impact is unclear. 'Cause now they go, "What's the, what's the $70,000?
- 11:23Is that the, the cutoff for a new one?" Yep. Okay. Yep. So there you go, the Cybertruck. Do you have yours yet? I do not. But you, you, you said just earlier that you were entertaining an EV truck. [laughs] I know.
- 11:32Literally, yes. Yeah, but would you, would, would you, would you s- consider one? See, I was originally on the wait list. I signed up, like, real early. So pretty early on I got the option to get one. Right.
- 11:43And I was thinking about like, "Oh, could I, could I drive it for, like, 1,000 miles and then sell it for a profit or at least to break even?" Right, right. Yeah.
- 11:49I decided to not pull the trigger on it, and the more that I, that I see it around, actually the less I want one. Oh, yikes. It's ju- And the reason- Yeah... th- there's, there's a couple reasons for that.
- 12:00I think the performance of the truck, I've drove one. I was, uh, down at Recharge, at John Foley's Recharge in Virginia. Got to drive one. It was awesome. It feels like you're driving a spaceship. Yep.
- 12:09It was way easier to drive than most people would think with that big truck, um, with the four-wheel steering, with all the, the safety and ca- It was actually so easy to drive and it felt effortless to move that big piece of metal around.
- 12:20Um-You know, I live on a road, and all my neighbors are farmers, right? I'm already the yuppie on the street, right? [laughs] There you go. Like, "What do I do for a living?" "I make videos," right?
- 12:32[laughs] Like, they have, like, combines and tractors. [laughs] Like, their, their, like, eight-year-old kids are throwing bales of hay, like, three stories up into the barn.
- 12:40[laughs] And then I show up in the Cybertruck. I'm like, "Ah, I think I might be, like, maybe an F-150 Lightning a little more [laughs] conducive." There you go. There you go. Get away with it, yeah.
- 12:48There, there's a little bit of peer pressure there, I, I'll have to say. You know, but, I mean, I think $750 a month on a lease, especially with this tariff situation, um, that's pretty attractive. It, it, it is.
- 12:59I mean, the, the challenge is gonna be the residual risk, right?
- 13:01So, uh, Te- Tesla's gone back and forth over the years with a h- high penetration of leasing in the early days with the Model S down to almost no, no penetration of leasing now because they don't wanna take the residual value risk.
- 13:12But remember, you know, three years from now when these Cybertrucks come off lease, no one knows what the value's gonna be. Yeah.
- 13:18And it might encourage more people who otherwise would say, "Ah, I don't wanna take the residual value risk." If, if Tesla's willing to take it on a lease- Yeah...
- 13:25then I may- might be willing to, you know, step up, bu- buy a vehicle at a reasonable price, as you said, per month, and not take the residual value risk. What, what, what is the risk for the consumer?
- 13:34Well, the risk is for Tesla.
- 13:35If this is overwhelmingly positive, they might have all kinds of Tesla Cybertrucks coming back in three years in a market where there's uncertainty about what the value will be for those vehicles.
- 13:44You know, I think one, one thing that Tesla has been very good at doing, um, is making very strategic changes in pricing, and they've shown that they're not afraid to do it very frequently. So I think- Right...
- 13:55I think they, they have, uh, a very firm control of the faucet. Right. So I think they'll offer a $750 lease. Um, you know, they'll see what the response is.
- 14:03If it becomes overwhelming, they'll start to inch that up so it's more reasonable. And before you know it, like, it, it'll feel...
- 14:09So I think that they're very savvy and, and just even knowing, uh, you know, our friend Jimmy Douglas and, you know, his experience at Tesla, he, he has iterated many, many times that they, uh, uh, aside from what popular opinion might think, how they might think decisions are made at Tesla, like Elon walks in a room one day and is like, "Yo, we're gonna do this," and everyone's like, "Okay, we're doing that," it's actually quite different.
- 14:30It, it's very calculated, uh, very grounded in, in business, um, and economic understanding of their business and- Mm-hmm...
- 14:37threads, and they just, they have a pretty tight handle on that, on that little faucet, and I think we've seen that evidenced in all of the pricing changes that seem to happen on a whim. Um, but it's not on a whim.
- 14:47Like- Right... so I, I think that, I think they'll mitigate their risk. I think they just need to show some, some more Cybertrucks on the road. Agreed. Agreed. Oh, here we go. Back to New Orleans. Segway time.
- 14:58[upbeat music] No snow this time. Super Bowl, what-- Ah, you know what? What, what Super Bowl is it? Uh, 50- 59. 59. 59. Super- 59. Oh, it's right there. Super Bowl LIX just around the corner.
- 15:10Advertisers are shelling out a record, a record $8 million for a 30-second spot. Some big names are sitting this one out, including most automakers this year, while AI, snacks, and tech brands are dominating the lineup.
- 15:25At least 10 commercials have sold for $8 million each. That's up half a million dollars from last year, the biggest move and the biggest price hike in Super Bowl history.
- 15:33120 million plus viewers are expected to watch on Fox and Tubi, making it the single largest stage for any advertiser.
- 15:41Traditional big players like Anheuser-Busch, Pepsi, Frito, Taco Bell, and Uber are all in, but the only OEM to rep- appear is going to be Stellantis, Jeep and RAM. Oh, wow. I wouldn't call that. If you- Wow...
- 15:53you said pick one, I wouldn't have picked that one. No, exactly right. Um- Yeah, well, they, they, they need to dig out of the hole, right? They, they've been challenged, so this is their opportunity to shine.
- 16:01A- absolutely. AI-focused ads and pharmaceutical brands are on the rise while movie trailers and streaming services are on the decline. During Super Bowl I in 1967, a 30-second spot cost less than, I don't know.
- 16:17I was trying to compare it to something. Less than a [laughs] I don't know, Chevy Equinox. 37.5. [laughs] 37.5 was the cost at the very first Super Bowl. So- Wow... did you watch the Super Bowl, Steve? I do. I do.
- 16:29And, you know, I watch it more for the commercials. S- sorry, I know you guys are Philly fans, but- That's fine... I watch it more for the commercials. I knew, the Eagles aren't in it. [laughs] Yeah, exactly right.
- 16:37I think, I think this is, th- this is the one thing that resonates with me.
- 16:39So I think back to 2000, Au- Autotrader, and I was at Manheim at the time, so Autotrader was a sister company, spent a million dollars for that Super Bowl ad.
- 16:48If you remember at the time, it was, you know, find me a car, which used the matrix technology- Right. Oh, yeah... um, to, to show. And it really, really the coming out party for Autotrader back then.
- 16:56But people thought they were crazy to spend a million dollars on, on, on a 30-second spot back then, but there isn't one...
- 17:02Well, kudos to the NFL, right, for being so relevant and being, like, sort of in the sort of, like, the zeitgeist of, like, American- Mm-hmm...
- 17:10um, um, uh, um, um, um, uh, you know, um, cur- current, current day, uh, popular, uh, uh, with, with Americans. Yeah.
- 17:17But I, but I think the, the interesting thing is with, with, uh, the NFL and, and the Super Bowl is there isn't one other event, be it the Oscars or whatever- Not even close...
- 17:24that people watch the commercials ahead of time. Yeah. And there's, like, there's commentary on every single news outlet around who, who won, who had the best commercials- Right... et cetera. Right.
- 17:34Th- this doesn't happen, so you, you p- might pay the eight million for the actual spot- Mm-hmm... but then you get so much other impressions, right, before and after the event.
- 17:42Um, if, un- unless you have a dud, but then even if you have a dud- People are talking about it... people will sensationalize that as well. Absolutely.
- 17:47So it, it is amazing, but it just shows you the power of the NFL right now in drawing the audience and how this has become, you know, a badge of honor to, to have a 30-second spot at the Super Bowl. Yeah.
- 17:57Always has been. Absolutely. You know, I think that's super savvy.
- 18:00Like, people release their commercials sometimes ahead of time, and what, what you also see is a lot of, um, like, people who didn't pay the $8 million really just tailwinding off the entire thing, 'cause they'll say, "Oh, this is the Automotive Venture Super Bowl commercial."
- 18:17Right? Right. You- Right... people do that, right? Maybe we'll make a- Right... Soto Super Bowl commercial, right? I mean- You should. You guys should...
- 18:22and it's not actually being aired during the Super Bowl, but when it shows up on YouTube and it, it, it actually can just kind of get wrapped up in that cultural moment.
- 18:30You know, uh, Gary Vaynerchuk, a legendary marketer, kind of like the, the visionary, he still says that Super Bowl commercials, he thinks, are still one of the most underpriced advertising mechanisms- Yeah...
- 18:43in advertising today because of the disproportionate amount of attention they get- Mm-hmm... for the price.
- 18:48Obviously, entry fee, you're gonna $8 million for 30 seconds, and then your, your production budget is probably in the millions as well- Oh, easily... in order- Easily... in order to produce it and celebrity.
- 18:57But, um, you know, this is one of those moments where creativity, like, is the differentiator between who wins and who loses. And, uh, it'll be fun to see.
- 19:05I haven't seen any yet, but this is the week where they all start popping up. Yep. And, uh, we get to have a lot of fun. And so if you're not happy about who's in the Super Bowl, that's fine.
- 19:13Just eat popcorn and pizza and all the other things, and then when the game stops, like, check in and watch the commercials. It's part of the fun. [laughs] Right. Exactly. Exactly. Uh, you can join Steve.
- 19:22We should do live commentary on Super Bowl commercials. Steve, thank you so much for joining us today. Um, look, whatever it is, first week of February, it's 70 degrees in Atlanta, 41 degrees in Syracuse.
- 19:32Whatever it is where you are, go out and help some people. [upbeat music]