Latest / CLEs You Actually Want to Hear / 2025 California Tax Legislation Update: Key Enactments and Conformity Developments
Transcript
- 0:03Welcome to 2025 California tax legislation update,
- 0:07key enactments and conformity developments. I'm
- 0:10Philipp Berend, chair of the BHBA Taxation Law
- 0:12Section. The tax section is sponsored by Hochmann
- 0:15-Solk and Torscher -Porez, B .C. The Hochmann
- 0:19-Solk and Torscher -Porez, B .C. advantage is
- 0:21experience and eye for innovation and genuine
- 0:23dedication to clients, their families and their
- 0:25business. In addition to the national practice
- 0:28on civil tax and criminal tax controversy, and
- 0:31related litigation in federal and state courts.
- 0:34The firm is also active and successful in handling
- 0:37non -tax matters such as business and estate
- 0:39planning for high net worth individuals and closely
- 0:42held businesses together with White Collar Defense.
- 0:45I'm delighted to introduce our speakers for the
- 0:48first panel this year, Colin Grinnell and Hailey
- 0:52Summers. Colin is the chief consultant to the
- 0:56California State Senate Revenue and Taxation
- 0:58Committee. where he oversees policy analysis
- 1:02and legislative strategy on state matters or
- 1:06state tax matters. He previously served as executive
- 1:10staff director for the California State Senate
- 1:13Governance and Finance Committee, providing senior
- 1:16leadership to complex fiscal and local government
- 1:19issues. Haley is a consultant with the California
- 1:23State Senate Revenue and Taxation Committee.
- 1:25where they advise on personal income tax, corporate
- 1:28tax, tax credits, and voluntary contribution
- 1:31funds. They bring a strong background in tax
- 1:34policy, legal research, and public service, informed
- 1:38by their experience in legislative consulting
- 1:41and legal clinics. Haley earned their JD from
- 1:46University of Pacific, McGeorge School of Law.
- 1:52Haley, Colin, please take it from here. Thank
- 1:56you very much, Philip. Thank you for the kind
- 1:58invitation to speak to this group today, as well
- 2:01as the very kind introductions. Once again, my
- 2:04name is Colin Grinnell. I'm joined by my colleague,
- 2:06Haley Summers. We are your staff in the state
- 2:11legislature with regards to tax issues. We have
- 2:15a presentation for you today that will be in
- 2:19four parts. Haley, would you like to start the
- 2:22show? Absolutely. in one moment. All right. Thumbs
- 2:42up from Colin if I'm successfully sharing that
- 2:45presentation. You are. You are. And so in addition
- 2:47to being a very talented tax expert, Haley is
- 2:50also the IT department here at the Senate Revenue
- 2:52and Tax. And so we run a shoestring operation.
- 2:56So I want to go to the next slide. We'll take
- 2:58you through the four parts, first of which we.
- 3:01I had exciting developments last year with regards
- 3:04to state tax conformity. That'll be the first
- 3:07part of the presentation that I will take you
- 3:09through. I will then turn it over to Haley for,
- 3:14actually before I turn it over to Haley, I'll
- 3:17talk a little bit about the revenue overview
- 3:20for California this year and talk about some
- 3:23of the property tax legislation from last year.
- 3:26Then I will turn it over to Haley for other measures
- 3:30of significance. that the committee worked on
- 3:32in 2025. Before we leave, we'll look a little
- 3:36bit ahead into next year, what might be on the
- 3:41legislature's plate in 2026. And then with any
- 3:46time remaining, we'd be happy to take your questions
- 3:49and answer them to the best of our ability. Next
- 3:52slide, please. And so as practitioners, I think
- 4:00a lot of the things here on this slide will be
- 4:02things you probably already know, but I think
- 4:04they kind of set the table for the legislature's
- 4:10effort last year with regards to date change
- 4:12conformity. And so California's income tax system
- 4:18applies to all the resident income, regardless
- 4:22of source, as well as California source income
- 4:25of non -residents. And this personal income tax
- 4:28is the primary source of revenue to fund the
- 4:31state's public services, everything from K through
- 4:3314 education, corrections, health and human services.
- 4:37in the myriad of other kinds of things that the
- 4:40state delivers both directly and through other
- 4:43service providers like counties and nonprofit
- 4:45organizations. You know, these are, you know,
- 4:49you fill out a state tax return, you fill out
- 4:52a federal tax return, they generally do it right
- 4:54around the same time, but these are very different
- 4:58systems in a lot of ways. And so there are key
- 5:01differences between them. The biggest difference
- 5:06between the two systems is that unfortunately
- 5:10here in California, we do not have a money printer
- 5:12in the basement. And so we have a constitutional
- 5:18balanced budget requirement. And so at least
- 5:22in theory, the spending side of the ledger needs
- 5:24to balance with the expenditure side of the ledger.
- 5:28And then also with regards to our tax system,
- 5:34as a state, we are bound by federal case law
- 5:38in ways in which the federal government is not.
- 5:40And so as we start to get into the two systems,
- 5:43keep in mind that the fiscal and legal differences
- 5:47between these two systems. Conformity is the
- 5:55effort by which we try to align the federal and
- 5:58state tax systems to the maximum extent practical,
- 6:02given these limitations and differences. It is
- 6:06the hope that tax filing, tax compliance, tax
- 6:09administration can be as simple and straightforward
- 6:13as possible. I don't have to tell this room that
- 6:15that's not always the case, but to the extent
- 6:18that these systems work in alignment with each
- 6:22other, definitions for the same things are the
- 6:26same, items of income are treated the same way,
- 6:32then this is better for pretty much everybody.
- 6:36With that said, conformity is both a policy and
- 6:39fiscal exercise. And so these administrative
- 6:46equities, these administrative goals can often
- 6:50be subsumed by policy and fiscal issues. And
- 6:58we'll talk about that a little bit more on the
- 7:02next slide. And I don't think it's any mystery
- 7:05that the state of California and the federal
- 7:08government are going to disagree on tax policy
- 7:11issues. They do it all the time, and that is
- 7:16probably as old as the state itself. Next slide,
- 7:21Haley. Thank you. The way our income tax works
- 7:27for the most part is by reference to the Internal
- 7:31Revenue Code. So we try to use the same definitions,
- 7:34rules, and calculations for state purposes as
- 7:40we do for federal purposes. And this is true
- 7:44in pretty much every state that has an income
- 7:46tax. However, there are You can probably put
- 7:51states that have income taxes into three distinct
- 7:54buckets for how they go about these conformity
- 7:56issues. The first of which is rolling or automatic
- 8:01conformity, where whenever the Congress changes
- 8:04the Internal Revenue Code, this is automatically
- 8:07integrated into state tax systems. You may have
- 8:11seen some of these issues popping up in various
- 8:14states with regards to HR1, various provisions
- 8:19that were in that being automatically conformed
- 8:22to in several states. States then can decouple
- 8:27if they want to. That can often be a political
- 8:30process in each state. And given the nature of
- 8:34HR1 or OB3, you have seen states that were, you
- 8:42know, HR1 caused immediate fiscal problems from
- 8:46them that had to be factored into their budgets
- 8:49right away. And then you've seen states then
- 8:53go in to affirmatively decouple from some of
- 8:55those provisions that by virtue of being a rolling
- 8:58conformity state, they automatically conform
- 9:00to. Here in California, we are not an automatic
- 9:04conformity state. There are many reasons for
- 9:06that. There are constitutional restrictions,
- 9:11fiscal policy, and that, as I talked about in
- 9:15the last slide, a little bit of natural push
- 9:16and pull on tax policy between federal and state
- 9:20governments. There will be disagreements. And
- 9:25so the California has always reserved its right
- 9:28to conform to the changes that it wants and discard
- 9:32the ones that it doesn't want. And the mechanism
- 9:34by which we do that is through what we call the
- 9:38conformity date. And so you will see one date
- 9:42in the personal income tax in R &T 17 .024 .5.
- 9:47And there's also corporation tax sections that
- 9:51work directly by reference. And when you look
- 9:53at those sections, they will basically say that
- 9:56the internal revenue code as of a specified date
- 9:59applies in the state of California except as
- 10:02otherwise provided. And then you'll see a whole
- 10:04lot of statute that is the except as otherwise
- 10:07provided part. And so when we move that date
- 10:13forward, We pick up changes in the internal revenue
- 10:18code where the state has already affirmatively
- 10:21conformed to those sections of the internal revenue
- 10:24code. Talk a little bit more about the mechanics
- 10:26of that on the next slide. But I think the long
- 10:30story short is that when that date moves, we
- 10:32pick up things unless we say we don't. And then,
- 10:39of course, there's other states where they don't
- 10:41use date change or automatic conformity. They
- 10:43kind of selectively conform either by section
- 10:46or by public law number. a little bit of history
- 10:51before I get into some of the more technical
- 10:53stuff. So up until 1983, the state had its own
- 10:57kind of standalone personal income tax. We had
- 10:59our own definitions, dates, all kinds of things
- 11:04that operated independently as a legal matter
- 11:07from the Internal Revenue Code. This caused significant
- 11:11friction for taxpayers, for franchise tax board.
- 11:17And so in 1983, there was an effort that sought
- 11:21to reduce or potentially eliminate that standalone
- 11:26nature. And it resulted in basically a repeal
- 11:30of half of the content of our personal income
- 11:33tax with a replacement with references to federal
- 11:37law. The classic example here is instead of having
- 11:43our own definition of what income is or is not,
- 11:46we point to section 61 and then modify it from
- 11:51there to count the things that we want as income
- 11:53and not to count the things that we don't want
- 11:55as income in the state of California. And then
- 11:59we kind of fix that date in the personal income
- 12:04tax and parts of the corporation tax. so that
- 12:09whenever we move that date forward and we conform
- 12:13to something like section 61, we pick all those
- 12:16things up without having to mention them all
- 12:19specifically in the code. And so this is a process
- 12:24that worked pretty well up until the late 90s.
- 12:27Conformity legislation was done pretty much every
- 12:31year. This process then began to slow into the
- 12:342000s. You know, reasons for that, you know,
- 12:41are kind of myriad, increasing political difficulties,
- 12:44fiscal challenges between federal and state governments.
- 12:49And so we kind of slowed down to about an every
- 12:52five year process. The last conformity date we
- 12:57had before last year was January 1st of 2015.
- 13:00So we had gone 10 full years without generally
- 13:05conforming to all of those federal changes. Then
- 13:09assembly member Ting authored AB 154, which represented
- 13:13the last conformity date of January 1, 2015.
- 13:18So in the last 10 years, we had picked up a lot
- 13:21of the the two systems grew apart in all kinds
- 13:26of ways. There were selective conformity efforts.
- 13:32I think when we were doing the list probably
- 13:33between 10 and 12 individually enacted state
- 13:37statutes that conform to individual things, partnership
- 13:42audits. There was a large effort spearheaded
- 13:45by Governor Newsom in 2018 to pick up specific
- 13:49aspects of the Tax Cuts and Jobs Act to fund
- 13:53an enhanced state earned income tax credit and
- 13:56young child tax credit. And then also individual
- 14:00efforts over in the early part of this decade
- 14:06to conform to treatment of some of the COVID
- 14:09assistance programs and the tax treatment of
- 14:13those items. And that is probably about half
- 14:16of the ones that we've done. With that said,
- 14:19we had selective conformity to very specific
- 14:21aspects, but general conformity hadn't been done
- 14:23in 10 years. Next slide. And so how does this
- 14:30process work on a step -by -step basis? And so
- 14:34the first step, of course, is Congress changes
- 14:35the Internal Revenue Code. And so we keep a close
- 14:41eye on Congress. Specifically, the Franchise
- 14:46Tax Board each year publishes a document known
- 14:49as the Summary of Federal Income Tax Changes.
- 14:52For those of you who love acronyms, we call that
- 14:55the CFITC. And so this comes out generally every
- 14:58year that summarizes the changes that Congress
- 15:02made to the Internal Revenue Code in the previous
- 15:04year. So you look at those individual public
- 15:07law changes, and then you look through the revenue
- 15:10and taxation code and look to see, you know,
- 15:13does California either specifically conform to
- 15:15that section or does it do what we colloquially
- 15:18call block conformity? So, you know, specific,
- 15:21you know, chapters, sub -chapters, subtitles
- 15:25of the internal revenue code apply. And so when,
- 15:29you know, when that is the case, then when you
- 15:31move that date change forward, then we automatically
- 15:35conform to those changes. If we do not want to
- 15:39do that, then there has to be individual statute
- 15:41that says, we do not want to do that, or we want
- 15:46to do so in a modified way. And so, over that
- 15:5110 -year period, we had heard from lots of advocates,
- 15:56CLA, CalTax, many others, Franchise Tax Board
- 16:01as an administrative matter, that this nonconformity
- 16:05on a lot of these items was making life harder
- 16:08for practitioners and as an administrative matter.
- 16:12And then tax conformity has not been a high priority
- 16:16for the legislature in the past. And we can get
- 16:20into the reasons for that on the next slide.
- 16:27And so, you know, when we get asked, you know,
- 16:30why hasn't the state conformed to, you know,
- 16:33why is that date all the way stuck in the past
- 16:35back in 2015? Why haven't you conformed to this,
- 16:38that or the other thing? This slide is meant
- 16:40to answer those questions. I think the first
- 16:44and primary, you know, barrier is that unlike
- 16:47usual statutes that can be enacted by the legislature
- 16:51by majority vote and signature of the governor,
- 16:54anything that is tax conformed... is going to
- 16:57trigger a two -thirds vote as a tax increase
- 17:00per the California Constitution. Proposition
- 17:0313 is modified by Proposition 26, which literally
- 17:08says any change in state statute that results
- 17:11in any taxpayer paying a higher tax is a two
- 17:14-thirds vote in each house. So that increases
- 17:18the degree of difficulty in terms of securing
- 17:22the votes on each floor for to secure passage
- 17:27of an omnibus conformity measure. And tax policy,
- 17:31as we all know, is partisan. It is political.
- 17:34And in the last 10 years, we had a lot of federal
- 17:38changes. It will not be a surprise when I say
- 17:42that Democratic members of the legislature did
- 17:45not want to conform to a lot of aspects of the
- 17:47Tax Cuts and Jobs Act. And Republican members
- 17:49of the legislature weren't so keen on adopting
- 17:52a lot of the measures that were in the IRA Consolidated
- 17:55Appropriations Act and the CARES Act as well.
- 17:59The next degree of difficulty is fiscal. As I
- 18:04mentioned previously, the state does not have
- 18:08an ability to print its own currency. And so
- 18:14when conformity is desired, that's a great thing,
- 18:17but it is unlikely to be enacted if it's going
- 18:20to result in general fund revenue losses. Conformity
- 18:24is great, but when you want to cut aid to schools
- 18:29or other kinds of state priorities, it is not
- 18:32nearly as important as those other things in
- 18:34the view of the legislature. On the other side
- 18:37of that coin is that the constituency for tax
- 18:42conformity, for the most part, are taxpayers,
- 18:46large and small, and they're practitioners. And
- 18:49so these groups, they like conformity. It makes
- 18:52life easier for them, at least in theory. However,
- 18:59they are not going to sign on if the goal of
- 19:03the project is to raise revenue for other programs.
- 19:06And so it's a very delicate balance between generating
- 19:09enough revenue that it survives the fiscal process
- 19:12here in the legislature and secures a governor's
- 19:14signature, but doesn't raise too much where it
- 19:16is perceived to be a revenue raising exercise.
- 19:20I don't have to tell this group that tax conformity
- 19:23is a very dense subject matter. It is not easy
- 19:26to lend itself to a quick bill presentation or
- 19:31a press release or a great narrative story about
- 19:34why a bill is going to make the world a better
- 19:36place. And so when speaking to legislators, legislative
- 19:42staff about conformity, you can cover a myriad
- 19:46of very dense and complex tax issues. You know,
- 19:52in the conformity bill that we worked on, there
- 19:55were more than 1 ,000 substantive changes that
- 19:57the state conformed to. And so having an understanding
- 20:02and being able to explain each specific change
- 20:06is not easily done. But that is kind of how omnibus
- 20:11conformity works. And so all these things have
- 20:15to be, you know, are conformed to by virtue of
- 20:18that date change. And so, you know, you have
- 20:23to kind of tackle that, you know, subject denseness,
- 20:27which a lot of legislators, you know, don't want
- 20:31to do because they have other ways they want
- 20:34to spend their time and resources. Next slide,
- 20:37please. And so as Haley and I took on this process
- 20:43of state conformity, we kind of had to come up
- 20:46with some default rules when we went through
- 20:48these more than 1 ,000 substantive changes that
- 20:51the state had not conformed to in the 10 intervening
- 20:54years since AB 154. So we started kind of with
- 20:59the easiest rule that there were. So if we currently
- 21:01conform, we should probably keep conforming.
- 21:04That would make things as practical as they...
- 21:09as they could be and be the least surprising
- 21:12to taxpayers, practitioners, and franchise tax
- 21:16board. If we haven't conformed to it in the past,
- 21:19we probably shouldn't either, because for what
- 21:24I just said, trying to keep the administration
- 21:26as easy as possible. There are exceptions, as
- 21:31there is in most tax laws. I think the most notable
- 21:36one was California has the base research credit.
- 21:41We had conformed to the federal alternative incremental
- 21:44research credit in the past, but we had not conformed
- 21:47to the alternative simplified credit since that
- 21:49had been brought in. There had been efforts in
- 21:54the past by individual legislators. The franchise
- 21:56tax board had sponsored a legislative proposal.
- 21:58This was something that was important to the
- 22:00state's technology companies. So we made the
- 22:03decision to basically enact that proposal to
- 22:06change, to enact the alternative simplified credit
- 22:10as an alternative to the base credit and then
- 22:13repeal the alternative incremental research credit,
- 22:16which didn't apply for federal purposes anyway.
- 22:18And so hopefully that will make compliance and
- 22:23the incentive effect of the research credit better
- 22:27for California taxpayers. The other thing was
- 22:31during the 2018 effort that Governor Newsom spearheaded,
- 22:37the 1031 limitation on real property was not
- 22:41fully conformed to for state purposes. There
- 22:43was an income threshold where if your income
- 22:46was below a certain threshold, you could continue
- 22:50or actually you're still required to make 1031
- 22:54exchanges for property other than real property.
- 22:59Professor Annette Nellon at San Jose State had
- 23:02written very clearly about what a taxpayer compliance
- 23:07and administrative burden failing to fully conform
- 23:11to that 1031 limitation had been. So that was
- 23:14incorporated as well. Kind of the rest of the
- 23:19slide goes into a few more of the rules. trying
- 23:24to have some of the increases from Tax Cuts and
- 23:28Jobs Act generate the revenue by which there
- 23:33were decreases for individual taxpayers. Given
- 23:37the coalition that we had with California Taxpayers
- 23:41Association, they saw, I think, the benefit of
- 23:45conformity outweighing some of those individual
- 23:47business increases. And also legislators were
- 23:51not you know, thrilled to increase individual
- 23:54taxes. And so there's, you know, kind of hardly
- 23:57any provisions of 7 -11 that ended up doing that.
- 24:01We also left out some of the really significant
- 24:03changes TCGA made for individuals, miscellaneous
- 24:08itemized deductions, the increased standard mortgage
- 24:11interest in things. Those were larger policy
- 24:15decisions that the federal government made, that
- 24:17there wasn't a lot of appetite for at the state
- 24:19level. And as a matter of trying to balance together
- 24:24all of these changes and their fiscal implications
- 24:26just became beyond the scope of the project.
- 24:29Other items that would have generated significant
- 24:33opposition, conformity to guilty, now necktie,
- 24:37the minimum book income tax would have resulted
- 24:40in significant opposition from the business community.
- 24:44Also, with the exception of the 1031 limitation
- 24:47where the legislature had previously selectively
- 24:49conformed, we let that be, as well as items where
- 24:53the legislature had considered proposals to conform,
- 24:56most notably with regard to health savings. accounts
- 24:59where we've seen, you know, many proposals over
- 25:01the years that have not been enacted, we let
- 25:04those sleeping dogs lie. And so that kind of
- 25:07goes, you know, kind of summarizes the rules
- 25:09that we applied when we were deciding the contents
- 25:13of SB 711. Next slide, please. And so the legislative
- 25:18strategy was to be as transparent as possible.
- 25:21So we published all of our decisions, all these
- 25:24tentative decisions that were based on the rules
- 25:26that I just previously discussed and on our website.
- 25:29We sent invitations and comment to everybody
- 25:32that we could find. We emphasized that these
- 25:35changes were bipartisan in nature and that H
- 25:40.R .1, which was enacted in the middle of SB
- 25:43711's consideration, none of those items were
- 25:47were included in SB 711 as they were enacted
- 25:50after its revised conformity date of January
- 25:531, 2025. We also had to make specific amendments
- 25:57along the way to address individual opposition,
- 26:01such as the 451B change for credit card companies
- 26:06who argued that they'd already been subject to
- 26:08two state tax increases in as many years and
- 26:11really didn't want a third. We also built a great
- 26:14coalition of groups that really cared about conformity.
- 26:18So as I mentioned before, CalTax, the Society
- 26:21of Enrolled Agents, the Society of CPAs, Spydell
- 26:25Publishing, Silicon Valley Leadership Group,
- 26:28their representatives went and spoke to members
- 26:32and their staff about the importance of conformity.
- 26:35They also sent emails and made phone calls to
- 26:40legislators that weren't really sure what a general
- 26:44conformity bill was and it really helped with
- 26:46the effort. And then Haley and I meeting with
- 26:49anyone and everyone as soon as we could to address
- 26:52any concerns with the proposal. And then we had
- 26:56a great author in Senator Jerry McNerney, the
- 26:59Chair of Senate Revenue and Taxation Committee,
- 27:01and a great principal witness, Gina Rodriguez,
- 27:04not appearing on behalf of her employer, but
- 27:07in her personal capacity as the person, I think
- 27:11maybe the only person who's worked on conformity
- 27:13issues longer than I have around here. And she
- 27:15was able to come to the committee to really,
- 27:17you know, both the Assembly and Senate policy
- 27:20committees to emphasize the importance of conformity
- 27:23from a practitioner point of view. Next slide,
- 27:26please. And so, yeah, this is a little bit of
- 27:30more kind of summarization of what we conformed
- 27:34to and what we didn't. I think I covered most
- 27:39of this, so I think we can kind of go on to the
- 27:42next slide. And so the good news here is that
- 27:49the governor signed SB 711 on October 1st of
- 27:53last year. Our new conformity date is now January
- 27:561 of 2025. There's cleanup legislation that we
- 27:59are currently working on. As a matter of that
- 28:04complexity, there's always going to be a little
- 28:06bit of cleanup on the other side. And so we are
- 28:11currently working on that. But that is basically
- 28:18the story of how legislative conformity came
- 28:21to be in 2025. All right, so we are 28 minutes
- 28:29into our session. And now we're going to shift
- 28:32into a quick look at revenue, revenue overview
- 28:36by the state, and then we'll move into our legislative
- 28:39updates. And we'll have Colin cover the property
- 28:43tax legislative updates. That is his scope of
- 28:46expertise. And then we will, um, lightning round,
- 28:50get into those other legislative tax areas and
- 28:54hopefully have some time for questioning answers
- 28:56at the end. All right, so a little bit of a quick
- 29:03revenue overview. So to finance state government,
- 29:08we have basically three major revenue sources,
- 29:10the corporation tax, personal income tax, and
- 29:12sales and use tax. And you can see here kind
- 29:17of the general revenue composition, at least
- 29:20for the 24 -25 year, as well as the estimates
- 29:22that were built in 2025 -2026. The personal income
- 29:28tax comprises a huge amount of the general fund.
- 29:32It is also highly volatile. And I'm sure an issue
- 29:35that this group is very familiar with, the elective
- 29:38pass -through entity tax. That has shifted revenue
- 29:43from the personal income tax. a bucket where
- 29:46you would have paid when the pass -through made
- 29:51a distribution to its owners and shareholders.
- 29:54That now shows up on the corporation tax side
- 29:57as the entity making the payment on that behalf.
- 30:00And so to the extent we keep elected PTE, which
- 30:03is currently in place, at least for the next
- 30:06few years. and we'll be interested to see how
- 30:10it changes given the higher cap on deductibility
- 30:14under federal law. The sales tax is a little
- 30:18bit different and that is kind of a split revenue
- 30:20effort between the state and about half of it
- 30:24also goes to local governments as well. Local
- 30:28governments can also with voter approval increase
- 30:30the sales tax in their area. The base rate in
- 30:34the state is seven and a quarter, but can get
- 30:36as high as 11 and a quarter based on those voter
- 30:39approved rates. You may have seen some press
- 30:42on this in the last few days, but the Legislative
- 30:45Analyst Office, so kind of the legislature's
- 30:47budget advisor, anticipates the revenues are
- 30:50actually in pretty good shape, despite some of
- 30:52our economic trends. And this is largely due
- 30:55to enthusiasm around artificial intelligence,
- 30:57which has resulted in high stock market valuations,
- 31:01which becomes the basis for compensation for
- 31:05a lot of the state's technology workers. And
- 31:07so somewhat counter -intuitively, revenue is
- 31:10doing above trend. It doesn't mean we don't have
- 31:12a budget problem, but revenue at least is above
- 31:15trend. Our next slide. And so I don't need to
- 31:22remind this group of the devastating fires that
- 31:25occurred in Los Angeles in early January, right
- 31:30around this time last year. When those fires
- 31:34occurred, the legislature sprang into action
- 31:37with three distinct bills. These were all relating
- 31:41on property tax issues. A lot of the income tax
- 31:44treatment is kind of automatic at this point
- 31:47with casualty losses and other kinds of things.
- 31:53There were three measures the legislature advanced
- 31:55that were enacted last year, extending the deadline
- 32:01for reconstruction on the same lot to include,
- 32:05to have kind of a bright line test with regards
- 32:08to valuation to be able to continue having the
- 32:13base year value of the destroyed home. So normally
- 32:16you'd have to do that reconstruction within five
- 32:18years to have that 120 % of value safe harbor
- 32:23to keep the previous base year value. Given the
- 32:27difficulties with reconstructing the legislature
- 32:30respectively or preemptively extended that to
- 32:33eight years. For SB 293, this was mostly as a
- 32:39result of a lot of the families in Altadena that
- 32:42were multi -generational where there might not
- 32:44have been a properly recorded change in ownership.
- 32:47When disasters strike, assessors usually discover
- 32:50those unrecorded changes in ownership. And while
- 32:53they're recording decline in value, they are
- 32:56legally required to then also apply those changes
- 33:00in ownership when the previous owner was deceased
- 33:03retroactively up to eight years back, which can
- 33:07take a family that had lost everything and then
- 33:11send them a huge new property tax bill. And so
- 33:15we were able to fashion a way to extend the current
- 33:18deadline under Prop 19 for intergenerational
- 33:21transfers for eligible taxpayers who were able
- 33:26to then acquire ownership of the property within
- 33:32three years of getting that supplemental assessment.
- 33:34And then SB 663 had a number of different provisions,
- 33:38some identical to AB 245, others with result
- 33:42with regards to the welfare exemption to make
- 33:45sure that welfare exempt entities don't lose
- 33:47their exemption because their properties were
- 33:49destroyed and could no longer be used for their
- 33:53exempt purpose, as well as a few administrative
- 33:56matters. I will stop talking now and turn it
- 33:59over to my colleague Haley to talk about the
- 34:01other things the legislature did in 2025. Awesome.
- 34:04We'll save your voice a little bit. It should
- 34:07give you a chance to recover. Alright, so we
- 34:10have already covered some of the most relevant
- 34:13stuff that we hoped was important to to your
- 34:16practice. We covered the conformity updates already
- 34:19and we covered the property tax. bills that really
- 34:23were important for helping recover in the LA
- 34:27fires. But we've also are going to cover other
- 34:31subject areas of state tax law as we know that
- 34:34you are practicing in many different areas of
- 34:37law. The legislative updates that we are covering
- 34:41will not cover all of the legislative updates
- 34:43that we saw this year. If you do want a more
- 34:47comprehensive list of tax law, notable bills,
- 34:52our committee publishes a greatest hits list
- 34:55on our website. So if you wanted to get a link
- 34:59to explore any of these bills in more depth,
- 35:02please go to our website and find the PDF that
- 35:05links to these. This first slide that we're going
- 35:08to get into here covers the income tax provisions
- 35:12in last year's budget bill. Now the budget bill
- 35:16does not go through the tax policy committee,
- 35:19but there are a number of provisions in the tax
- 35:24budget bill statutes that were enacted that were
- 35:28initially policy bills that were in our committee
- 35:31that we got to to weigh in on. So in this year's
- 35:36budget bill we saw a few notable exclusions enacted.
- 35:40The first one being a gross income exclusion
- 35:43for retirement pay and benefits paid by the DOD
- 35:48to survivors of the spouses for those who have
- 35:56been veterans in the military. There's an AGI
- 36:01cap for this, so it's not for all households.
- 36:05It is up to $20 ,000 for individuals. and is
- 36:10capped at 125K or 250K for those filing jointly.
- 36:16Another exclusion that we saw enacted in the
- 36:18budget bill was related to wildfires. We often
- 36:23see settlement payments be made to victims of
- 36:27wildfires in the state. In the past, we saw one
- 36:29-off bills that would name specific settlements
- 36:32from specific fires. This would be a broader
- 36:37one. This would be for settlements 2021 through
- 36:422030. This does not conform to the similar federal
- 36:48tax income exclusion that we saw, but this is
- 36:53going to eliminate those one -off exclusions
- 36:55that we had seen in years past. A similar type
- 36:59of exclusion is for payments related to the Chautica
- 37:04Canyon elevated temperature landfill. For those
- 37:08of you who may be familiar, there have been individuals
- 37:11who have been suffering nuisance and respiratory
- 37:15illness related to the landfill event. So this
- 37:21is a similar type of exclusion for those who
- 37:23are being affected by a form of disaster. Some
- 37:29of these other bills that were statutes that
- 37:33we're going to cover could be whole CLEs in and
- 37:35of themselves. So I apologize that we're going
- 37:37to have to get through them with brevity. Another
- 37:41notable provision of the budget bill was the
- 37:45extension of the elective pass -through entity
- 37:48tax from 2026 to 2030. There is also provision
- 37:54related to a prepayment election, but that is
- 37:58also a notable provision that we saw in this
- 38:02budget bill. Another significant one is related
- 38:06to the single sales factor apportionment for
- 38:10financial institutions apportioning their California
- 38:14state income. And this would begin January 1,
- 38:182025 or later. Another very big one here is the
- 38:24increase of the film tax credits. huge package
- 38:29of legislation that we saw this year increases
- 38:32the film tax credits from 33 million up to $750
- 38:36million. And this would be for fiscal years 2025
- 38:41through 2030. Many of these bills Colin weighed
- 38:46in on and helped with the details. So please
- 38:50drop an email if you have questions. I know that
- 38:54these are huge pieces of legislation, but we're
- 39:00happy to help answer any questions as you may
- 39:03have them. I only shape the good parts. Hey,
- 39:07that's what matters, right? Piggybacking off
- 39:13of the budget bill was AB 1138. We also saw some
- 39:19related provisions to the expanded film tax credits.
- 39:25Other notable income tax bills that we saw this
- 39:29year pertaining to energy to first one being
- 39:33SB 254. This would allow a 20 % tax credit for
- 39:3910 years. for certain expenditures that a taxpayer
- 39:45incurred related to energy transmission projects.
- 39:50Now, this bill did not come through our committee.
- 39:54It did go through the Energy Utilities and Communications
- 39:57Committee. So this is one of the rare bills that
- 40:03have a substantive tax credit or tax provision
- 40:07that we did not hear in our committee. So we
- 40:10would encourage you to also reach out to our
- 40:13colleagues in the energy committees if you have
- 40:17follow -up questions on this as well. Another
- 40:21notable energy income tax bill was SB 302. This
- 40:26is an income exclusion for payments related to
- 40:30the federal clean energy credits. So this would
- 40:34conform state law to federal law pertaining to
- 40:39energy credits in the IRA. So that is an example
- 40:45of selective conformity as Colin was discussing
- 40:50the different forms of conformity that we use
- 40:55as strategies when conforming state law to federal.
- 41:00Another notable income tax bill pertains to the
- 41:04low income housing tax credits, 8480. This removed
- 41:09the requirement that the developer must elect
- 41:12when they are submitting their application to
- 41:17sell their low income housing tax credits. I
- 41:22think that there were some interesting pros and
- 41:24cons here about why the law required that election
- 41:28to begin with, but this ultimately will help
- 41:34the low income housing development credits better
- 41:37serve the purpose. All right, moving into our
- 41:44state and local taxes, sales and use taxes, excess
- 41:46taxes. Another notable piece of expanded legislation
- 41:52was related to CAITFA. California Alternative
- 41:56Energy and Advanced Transportation Authority.
- 41:59It's a mouthful, but we go by Kate for this.
- 42:04This expanded a sales and use tax exclusion for
- 42:10purchases related to fusion energy used as an
- 42:14alternative energy source. So very exciting.
- 42:21opportunity to increase our state's commitment
- 42:26to clean energy. Other local taxes that we saw
- 42:31enacted this year related to cannabis and the
- 42:35hemp industry. AB 564 would have delayed an increase
- 42:41in the excise tax rate and this delayed it until
- 42:462028 -2029. that became effective in October.
- 42:53Another bill related to excise taxes and cigarette
- 42:57and tobacco product licenses. We saw an increase
- 43:00in the fees for new or renewed licenses for tobacco,
- 43:05for cigarettes and tobacco licensing products.
- 43:07So this went up from 265 to 450 and by regulation
- 43:13up to 600. These increase in fees will help the
- 43:19CDTFA with their enforcement and administration
- 43:23of the cigarette and tobacco regulations, which
- 43:29is the reason why these fees were increased.
- 43:34And we also saw a number of different transaction
- 43:38and use tax cap exemptions. I encourage you to
- 43:43go look at our greatest hits list to see more
- 43:45examples, but a more notable one is the creation
- 43:49of a transit revenue measure district that would
- 43:53cover a specific Bay Area. How many counties?
- 43:59I can't remember exactly how many at the moment.
- 44:02Thank you. It was five out of the eight and one
- 44:05was an option, but they're intended to finance
- 44:09transportation infrastructure. or actually transportation
- 44:13services, mostly by the way of BART and San Francisco
- 44:16of Muni, with some other transportation operations
- 44:20sprinkled in there as well. Perfect. So for those
- 44:25counties, they would be authorized to enact a
- 44:30transaction use tax, which is basically your
- 44:32local sales and use tax, above the 2 % cap. Current
- 44:37law caps cities and counties. in the same jurisdiction
- 44:42from only going up to 2 % of a sales tax. So
- 44:46if a city has one and a half percent, the county
- 44:49can't come in and or any other local government
- 44:52come in and do anything above 5%. So we see these
- 44:55exemption bills come in so that cities and counties
- 44:59don't accidentally lock each other out from the
- 45:04opportunity to impose a local sales and use tax.
- 45:11and rolling into our tax administration bills.
- 45:17This one is kind of actually could have been
- 45:19under our property taxes slide, but AB418 enacted
- 45:26new notice requirements before a property can
- 45:31be sold in a tax sale. This was a bill aimed
- 45:37to provide more transparency and opportunity
- 45:40for property to be sold at a value that compensates
- 45:46the taxpayer for the actual value of their property.
- 45:50So by enacting a new notice requirement, this
- 45:53is going to provide more transparency and opportunity
- 45:57for that tax sale to recover more money when
- 46:02it goes for sale. Another couple tax administration
- 46:10both voluntary contribution funds. I'm not sure
- 46:14that you guys often see these. I know that when
- 46:17you use tax software You don't often get prompted
- 46:20for these, but if you print out the tax forms,
- 46:24you will see an opportunity to check a box to
- 46:28donate your excess tax refunds to a specific
- 46:33fund. We have a number of these. Some of them
- 46:38expire after a period of time and we've had a
- 46:41number of new ones created. This year we had
- 46:44a pediatric cancer research fund added to the
- 46:49tax form for people to donate to, and also one
- 46:52for Parkinson's disease research. Because these
- 46:57are charitable contributions, the taxpayer would
- 47:00receive a deduction in the year in which they
- 47:03made the contribution. So it's an opportunity
- 47:07for people to support specific causes with any
- 47:11tax refund that they may have had. And then another
- 47:17tax administration bill that we had this year
- 47:20was AB 1518. This bill allowed non -resident
- 47:27taxpayers who don't have a social security number
- 47:31or an ITIN to file state returns or be included
- 47:36on a group return. There are certain taxpayers
- 47:41that may have very little business in California.
- 47:47They might not be residents of California or
- 47:52even within the state. They may be foreign residents,
- 47:56but they have business affairs within the United
- 47:58States. Allowing those individuals to file a
- 48:03return allows them to engage in tax compliance.
- 48:07and be good taxpayers. So you see this often
- 48:12happen in the case of group returns. So a preparer
- 48:16will prepare, you know, tax payments and forms
- 48:22for individuals that are in a group and they
- 48:25will be able to participate in filing their taxes
- 48:28on a state level and, you know, be compliant.
- 48:33and in that spirit as well understanding that
- 48:36there are difficulties for these individuals
- 48:39even though they have a desired compliant, there
- 48:41is an authorized exemption for quarterly estimated
- 48:44payments for these non -resident taxpayers if
- 48:49they are included on a group return. They will
- 48:51not be penalized because the person who prepared
- 48:53the group return made a mistake in that filing.
- 49:01All right, and now we are rounding up into our
- 49:05last 10 minutes here. We'll check in with Philip
- 49:12in a couple minutes, but we'll provide you with
- 49:14a couple updates here on a look ahead for this
- 49:17year. And then if we have some interesting questions,
- 49:21we can field those questions. Colin, did you
- 49:27want to discuss our upcoming bill hearing? Yes,
- 49:31happy to. So the way that we kind of kick off
- 49:35the year in January of the even -numbered year
- 49:38is that there are measures that have been introduced
- 49:40in the first year of the two -year legislative
- 49:43session that can be advanced in the second year.
- 49:47We call them two -year bills. But they have to
- 49:49be reported out of the House of Origin by the
- 49:52end of January. And so the committee will be
- 49:54considering those bills next Wednesday. of terrible
- 50:01consequence or significant changes. But we'll
- 50:08hear five or six of those measures next Wednesday
- 50:10the 14th. What will be significant this week
- 50:13is that Governor Newsom will present his final
- 50:16budget of his term at some point this week. I
- 50:19think that's going to be on Thursday. And so
- 50:22that will set the stage for the annual budget
- 50:25process where the state an access budget for
- 50:31the year makes other associated policy changes.
- 50:34At least in committee, I think we're gonna be
- 50:36looking at a good amount of measures to create
- 50:39incentives, either generally for business or
- 50:42a specific kind of businesses or rewards for
- 50:45certain kinds of taxpayers. We may also see some
- 50:49items that would conform to HR1 slash OBBA. That's
- 50:55certainly possible this year as well. As income
- 50:58tax receipts come in over the course of the spring,
- 51:01the governor will then make his May revision
- 51:03sometime in early May that kind of reconciles
- 51:09all the actual revenues with the estimates from
- 51:12the previous year and then makes estimates for
- 51:14the budget year, which would be the 26 -27 fiscal
- 51:17year. The legislature has to approve that by
- 51:20June 15th and the governor must sign it by July
- 51:231st or else state appropriations for the most
- 51:26part are not authorized. With regards to conformity,
- 51:31we do have the personal income tax 163J unintentional
- 51:35conformity, which we're advancing cleanup to
- 51:38decouple from in the coming weeks or month. As
- 51:43I noted, there will also be some individual proposals
- 51:47on selective conformity on HR1 items. And then
- 51:51we're all waiting for that new CFITC to come
- 51:53out of Franchise Tax Board so that we can get
- 51:56our hands dirty with all the various things that
- 52:02were in HR1 slash OPVA. And so I think, yeah,
- 52:09that's what we know currently of what's going
- 52:12to happen in 26. And so we have, I believe, about
- 52:17eight minutes to field any questions that you
- 52:20may have. Thanks again, Philipp, for the invitation.
- 52:22It's been a real pleasure to speak with you today.
- 52:25Thank you so much. It was a great presentation.
- 52:27And yeah, I can just extend to the audience,
- 52:30if you have any questions, please let us know.
- 52:34In the meantime, Are there any tax laws that
- 52:36haven't passed last year that should have passed
- 52:38or? There was one that was really significant,
- 52:42I think, probably for this group, SB 799 by Senator
- 52:47Allen. So the State's False Claims Act has long
- 52:53included a preclusion on cases brought under
- 52:57the Revenue and Taxation Code. It's the same
- 53:01as the case in the same situation as the Federal
- 53:04False Claims Act. We're presuming that the tax
- 53:08enforcement agencies do a good enough of a job
- 53:11where we don't need a key TAM plaintiff mechanism
- 53:18to otherwise enforce tax law. The attorney general
- 53:22Bonta had advanced a bill sponsored, it was SB
- 53:28799 authored by Senator Allen that would have
- 53:31removed that preclusion for under certain circumstances.
- 53:35And so that was probably the most controversial
- 53:37bill the committee dealt with last year. It was
- 53:41double referred first to the Committee on Judiciary
- 53:44and second to the Committee on Revenue and Taxation.
- 53:47When it went to the Committee on Judiciary, which
- 53:50is chaired by Senator Umberg, the measure succeeded
- 53:55in Senate Judiciary despite a lot of business
- 53:58community opposition. that don't want to spend
- 54:03the time to or have the increased risk of defending
- 54:08these false claim statutes. It then came to the
- 54:11Committee on Revenue and Taxation where it failed
- 54:15passage, but was granted reconsideration. And
- 54:20so that measure was then amended to embrace a
- 54:25different subject yesterday and be referred to
- 54:27a different committee. Of course, it could be
- 54:30reintroduced in the second year of the cycle.
- 54:34But I think that was at least of the very consequential
- 54:38measures of interest to this group. That was
- 54:42one that I think that was very significant. Given
- 54:48the elections this year, do you expect a calmer
- 54:52year? I do not expect a calm year. I think a
- 55:02lot depends on the budget situation. I think
- 55:04that's kind of first and foremost. And we'll
- 55:08find out a little bit more about that this week
- 55:10when the governor presents their budget. And
- 55:12then the legislature begins its consideration
- 55:16of the governor's budget. As we like to say around
- 55:18here, the governor proposes, the legislature
- 55:20disposes. And so we will be going through that.
- 55:23you know, subcommittee and budget committee process
- 55:26in the spring. There's also two, at least two
- 55:30very notable initiatives. As legislative staff,
- 55:33there's not a lot we can say about initiatives.
- 55:35But I think, you know, there's what's called
- 55:40colloquially the Taxpayer Protection Act, which
- 55:42is brought by Howard Jarvis Taxpayers Association,
- 55:46California Business Roundtable that would, you
- 55:49know, kind of take those definitions that I previously
- 55:51spoke about in the Constitution that kind of
- 55:56makes the, applies the two thirds legislative
- 55:59vote and voter approval for local taxes and kind
- 56:04of decreases the distringency of those requirements
- 56:07by modifying the definition of what is a tax
- 56:11and what is not a tax. And so I know that that
- 56:14is a proposal that is receiving a lot of attention.
- 56:19And then, of course, you can't kind of go a day
- 56:23following much news without hearing a discussion
- 56:25of the Billionaire Surcharge Act, which is also
- 56:31at the attorney general's office for title and
- 56:33summary. As that measure either receives signatures
- 56:38to secure its place in the ballot or not, we
- 56:41are paying close attention. But I think if that
- 56:45were to qualify, there'd be a heck of a campaign
- 56:48and a rather significant impact if it were to
- 56:53be approved by voters. Can't comment on that,
- 57:00but any legislation falls coming on digital assets.
- 57:03I've seen that last year they passed a number
- 57:06of crypto related laws like unclaimed property,
- 57:10et cetera. Any tax law changes to that regard?
- 57:16Federal government plans some. Haley is our in
- 57:21-house alternative asset guru. So I'll let them
- 57:27answer that question. Thanks, Colin. You know,
- 57:31we do see something in this line over in the
- 57:34assembly side right now, so we'll see where that
- 57:38lands. But the question does come up a lot, right?
- 57:43We've seen it come up in discussions last year.
- 57:48The sales and use tax base in California is still
- 57:53particular to tangible personal property. And
- 57:56we've seen a lot of other states expand their
- 58:00tax base by including software. and other digital
- 58:06goods. And they've done that through a few different
- 58:09ways. Some ways by just adding intangibles to
- 58:13their sales and use tax, and other states by
- 58:17reinterpreting tangible personal property as,
- 58:21you know, digital things being perceivable to
- 58:24the census, which has provided a foundation for
- 58:28expanding sales and use tax to those you know,
- 58:34previously understood as intangible things, but
- 58:36things that are, in fact, perceivable to the
- 58:38census. So, you know, what we will see in terms
- 58:44of the the appetite to explore that form of revenue
- 58:49raising is yet to be seen, but it is undoubtable
- 58:55that when you look at the revenue numbers that
- 58:57the sales and use tax revenues have remained
- 59:00relatively constant despite the increased economic
- 59:06activity in the state and inflationary pressures.
- 59:09So I think that we'll continue to see more significant
- 59:12discussions around that particular topic. And
- 59:19I see you have answered the only question so
- 59:22far about the greatest hits of tax changes. So
- 59:27yeah, I think we are about the hour so I would
- 59:29leave every any parting word to you guys if you
- 59:32want to say anything and then we can close for
- 59:35today. Yeah, happy to. Thanks again, Philip,
- 59:40for the very kind invitation. It's been a pleasure
- 59:42to speak to the group today. As you mentioned
- 59:45before, we are your legislative staff here with
- 59:48regards to tax issues. If we can be of service,
- 59:52our contact information was on the front of the
- 59:54presentation, and I'm sure you can find our emails
- 59:59quite easily. Thanks again for having us, and
- 1:00:04we wish you the best and a happy new year. Thank
- 1:00:07you so much for being here. It was great. Thanks
- 1:00:11a lot. Bye.