Latest / When Killers Get Caught with Brittany Ransom / Katherine Knight: Cannibal? Murderer? Really Bad Girlfriend? YES.
Transcript
- 0:21Hey everybody in Hero Killer country.
- 0:22My name is Brittany Ransom and. My name is Brian Joyner and this
- 0:25is When Killers Get Caught, a podcast of odes, deep dives into
- 0:28the lives and psyches so the killers we love to learn about.
- 0:30Each week Brian and I find a true Crime Story that resonated
- 0:32with us. Then I discuss one well known or
- 0:35lesser known killer and go deep into their childhood lives,
- 0:37methodology, and most importantly how they got caught.
- 0:41And then we get a little spooky and we'll learn something about
- 0:43cryptids or the supernatural. And just before we get in, just
- 0:49to let you know, our Patreon is live.
- 0:51There are 4 tiers from 5 to $50.00 that offer lots of things
- 0:54like being able to listen to us report the podcast, or playing
- 0:58games with us on Twitch, or just getting a free 30 minute podcast
- 1:03about conspiracies. Yes, it's all fun and games over
- 1:07on Patreon. It is fun and games on Patreon.
- 1:10You can support us by going to patreon.com/when killers get
- 1:13caught and you are always open to check out our merch at
- 1:17www.whenkillersgetcaught.com and I am slowly merging it over to
- 1:23the Facebook page which is also searching when killers get
- 1:26caught and the podcast is now available to listen to on
- 1:30Facebook. Look, you getting us everywhere.
- 1:32Yeah. So listen, if you prefer to
- 1:34listen to on Facebook or look at things on Facebook, absolutely
- 1:38they will all be there. That happened this week that I
- 1:42was able to guess Facebook's doing some new changes.
- 1:45Yeah, that's really awesome. Though next it would be freaking
- 1:49Twitter. That'd be great.
- 1:51That would be awesome if everything was all integrated.
- 1:53But so before I start into this week in true crime about what I
- 1:57want to talk about, I want everyone listening to just hear
- 2:01me out. Don't get mad when I say the
- 2:04name of this because I want to talk about missing White Women's
- 2:08Syndrome. That's the specifically in the
- 2:11news right now because of the Gabby Petitto case.
- 2:16And what missing white women's syndrome is, is the American
- 2:21media's propensity to specifically cover with just
- 2:28like a ferocious ferocity. Like the mainstream media in
- 2:31this country absolutely loves to talk about missing white women,
- 2:37and it's to the detriment of missing women of color.
- 2:42There are a disproportionate number of teenage black girls
- 2:46who are being kidnapped across this country, and they are
- 2:48virtually never reported. There are a disproportionate
- 2:51number of indigenous women across North America that have
- 2:55not been reported and it's been such a big deal in Canada that
- 2:58they are now launching like investigations into the coverage
- 3:02and the police, whether they have been doing the right thing.
- 3:06There is an entire highway in Canada that they refer to as the
- 3:10Highway of Tears because there have been so many indigenous
- 3:13women who have gone missing in that in this area and it crosses
- 3:17roughly 75% of the the continent or sorry, that country on our
- 3:22continent. And this is really important
- 3:25because, like I said, so many of the people.
- 3:30Who need to be reported are not being reported just this week
- 3:37alone. It wasn't until Jelani day at
- 3:42his mom spoke on TV about the fact that she had been trying to
- 3:47get coverage of him missing put on mainstream news since he went
- 3:52missing on August 24th. This week he was he was found
- 3:59technically September 4th or September 9th.
- 4:03Yes, and a river in Illinois. But they didn't like.
- 4:09I guess there was no fire behind the Emmy until everyone publicly
- 4:15was like where is he? You found a body?
- 4:18Do the freaking cord or. Like Oh yeah, we found a body,
- 4:22blah blah blah. That's right.
- 4:23And so of course once they do it, like days after this is
- 4:27everywhere on Facebook, TikTok, Twitter, all of a sudden we have
- 4:32a positive ID and it's been 3 almost three weeks since they
- 4:37found the body. I mean their situations.
- 4:41Like Lakia Edelston, Eggleston. She was 8 months pregnant when
- 4:48she disappeared four years ago in Baltimore.
- 4:54There's a young girl named Keisha Unique Jacobs.
- 4:58She's been missing since 2016. She'd be 26 years old.
- 5:02Now. There are a host of families who
- 5:06are asking just for similar coverage of the people who they
- 5:11love. And I have been getting messages
- 5:14in my inbox on TikTok for an A very long time with people
- 5:19asking me to cover missing cases.
- 5:21And so I asked on Facebook, I asked on YouTube, and I asked on
- 5:25TikTok do you want me to cover these cases?
- 5:28And I got to be really honest with you.
- 5:29I don't know if people are prepared for this, but I have
- 5:32absolutely no intention right now of covering whatever the new
- 5:36hot story about the missing white women is, because I feel
- 5:40like there's already enough attention.
- 5:42You got your CNN and every other major news source doing this, so
- 5:46I am going to start covering missing people every Monday.
- 5:49I'm going to try and do more than my normal videos so that I
- 5:53can get a bunch of them up because literally there are at
- 5:56least 50 different people in my inbox at any given time
- 5:59requesting can you talk about my friend, Can you talk about my
- 6:03cousin? Can you talk about my sister
- 6:05like there's so many? And I I got to tell you, I'm
- 6:08going to say that I'm going to start specifically discussing
- 6:12women of color and indigenous women first, because I feel like
- 6:16there is a gap in the reporting. Absolutely.
- 6:20And this is not to say that anybody's missing relative is
- 6:25less important. But until there is fair
- 6:28coverage, those of us who are are talking about things in the
- 6:32media on alternate forms of media have to cover that gap.
- 6:39So I hope I didn't make anybody too mad.
- 6:40People get real angry when you start saying the words white.
- 6:44And women on the Internet. But you know, that's.
- 6:47What we're here for anyway, like you, you and me, that's what we
- 6:50do this podcast for. We we cover that gap of people.
- 6:53It really is true. I have been doing a seminar this
- 6:56past week on marketing and one of the people in my seminar hit
- 7:01me up. He's from the 30 Minute podcast.
- 7:04He actually wanted to know if we wanted to be on his podcast and
- 7:06talk to him. So maybe we might be on another
- 7:10person's podcast. But he specifically said that he
- 7:12was watching a master class and they were discussing the lack of
- 7:17people of color who specifically discussed true crime.
- 7:21And I wasn't aware when we made this podcast that there was a
- 7:25deficit in this. We've gotten a couple emails
- 7:28that were like, yay, you guys are woke.
- 7:30We really appreciate it. But like I said to you the other
- 7:33night when we I called you to tell you about that, I was like,
- 7:35I don't know how to be any other way like.
- 7:37We're black people. We're going to talk about black
- 7:38people stuff. That's what happens.
- 7:41Get 2 black people in the room over the microphones.
- 7:43Come on now, is what? Happens is what we're going to
- 7:45do. So I just, I feel like it's some
- 7:49of that people need to be aware of and think about that the
- 7:53media that we are consuming is being curated by certain people
- 7:58and those certain people care the most apparently about young
- 8:03white women between like the age of like 16 and like 25.
- 8:08They seem to be the ones that get the most attention.
- 8:10And that's unfortunate because I'm sure there's an elderly
- 8:12white woman who's gone missing who could probably use the the
- 8:16media attention, you know, but we don't, we don't care about
- 8:19elderly people in this country. But that's a whole nother
- 8:21conversation. Not going there today, but I'm
- 8:25going to turn it over to you, Brian.
- 8:28What is your story this week? My God, well, thank you for all
- 8:31the information. So Speaking of white people, is
- 8:37this another white? Is this a missing white person?
- 8:39No, no, no, no, no Okay. So this is headlined as
- 8:42teenagers are charged with planning to attack a PA school.
- 8:47Was this the two boys who look like they're about 10 years old?
- 8:50No, no, OK cuz they were that was were mess.
- 8:52So this is a four teenagers. They're trying, they they want
- 8:56to, I guess attack a school, their high school.
- 9:00OK And remembrance of the Columbine, oh Jesus.
- 9:04Which will be turning 25 years old when they were playing the
- 9:08attack. That's ridiculous.
- 9:09Oh my God. So they planned this attack for
- 9:112024. Was this happening in
- 9:13Pennsylvania? Scranton, PA Oh Gee, why is it
- 9:15always Scran? What is going on in?
- 9:18No fucking idea. Scraton's boring sometimes.
- 9:22Maybe that's it. The only thing they got there is
- 9:24the office. And you know, it's just.
- 9:25And it wasn't even filmed there, though I know they literally
- 9:29filmed one like. We have the Electric City, OK?
- 9:33They have the Electric City sign and everything, cuz when I did a
- 9:36story, I did a story about this woman who was taking pictures
- 9:39with dead bodies. She was like a mortician and it
- 9:42was from that region and people were upset.
- 9:47She just thought it was cool. So she was taking pictures of
- 9:49families without their permission.
- 9:52But so these kids. So it was it's four kids.
- 9:57Two of them were 15 year old. They're being charged as adults.
- 10:01The other two were being charged with just juvenile charges.
- 10:07But yeah, it's they were trying to attack Dunmar, Dunmore High
- 10:11School and Scran. I'm guessing that must be their
- 10:13school. Yeah, yeah, yeah.
- 10:16This is. And it says that one of the
- 10:20girl's mothers said that the total police that her daughter
- 10:23was obsessed with Columbine and like as a parent, see, I can't
- 10:32say anything about that because I was like 12 years old reading
- 10:36about serial killers. Okay.
- 10:39Yeah, but what kind of obsession are we talking about?
- 10:41Like are you, are you trying to like, I just want to know
- 10:44everything about them. Yeah, that's the that's when
- 10:47this started this that is now what we have started when I was
- 10:51like 1213 years. Yeah, no, I mean same thing with
- 10:53me and paranormal. But like I also was into the
- 10:56paranormal too. I started reading ghost stuff.
- 10:58But like, come on, like if that's the only thing you're
- 11:01obsessed with Columbine and or shooting and stuff like that.
- 11:04I guess the question is like how do you know that your kid is
- 11:08just like casually interested in something cuz you know, like
- 11:12little kids get into like dinosaurs, they know everything
- 11:14about every dinosaur, right? How do you know that your kids
- 11:17like into murder like that? Or your kid is thinking about
- 11:21doing a murder like I don't know what the.
- 11:24They start mentioning, they start mentioning it a lot.
- 11:27I mean like, OK, for example, how did they know that this was
- 11:32happening? What did they find?
- 11:35So what they found was, hold on, I don't know how they found.
- 11:40I think they found things they were making so they could do
- 11:45this. Oh no.
- 11:47So I I read they found a Molotov cocktail.
- 11:50They they found a bonus for a bomb.
- 11:53Oh, they were trying to do it bigger than Columbine because
- 11:55Columbine did not have explosives.
- 11:57Yeah, they they had plans written down for making bombs
- 12:00and stuff like that. See.
- 12:02And then I'm gonna also tell you that when I was 14, I read the
- 12:04Anarchist Cookbook. Yeah, because I was like, why
- 12:07not? And it was in my high school, my
- 12:09my librarian didn't believe in banning books.
- 12:13She didn't believe that anything was bad to know.
- 12:17But, like, now I feel like I don't know how I feel about
- 12:20that. Yes, I'm.
- 12:21Guessing they they found this stuff in this one in one of the
- 12:24girls rooms, or in in our home or whatever.
- 12:27Thank goodness for a snooping Mama.
- 12:28I know, right? Hey.
- 12:31But goodness gracious, they said.
- 12:34They didn't believe there's like an immediate threat right now.
- 12:38Since when's the anniversary this?
- 12:40Is in 2024, but Jesus, they were planning.
- 12:44Yeah, 2024, That's when they planned the attack.
- 12:47So Lord, yeah, okay, I can understand why the cops were
- 12:50like, well, they're just really stockpiling stuff for three
- 12:54years from now. Wait a second.
- 12:56Two of them wouldn't have even been in high school anymore.
- 12:59They still don't. They still teach this kind of
- 13:01stuff in school, or they learn about this kind of stuff in?
- 13:03No, I just mean that if two of them were sophomores 3 years
- 13:08from now, they would be out of high school, still about to do
- 13:13this attack, and the other two would have been seniors.
- 13:16Or maybe they had planned to. Get held back a year seems like
- 13:20a weird plan. I know, I know.
- 13:22Because everybody. I don't know why.
- 13:24Why would you? This is weird.
- 13:29This is weird and stupid. I guess they had kind of mad
- 13:32about. It Yeah, I guess they had a list
- 13:34of targets that they they wanted people that they wanted to
- 13:37target. People aren't even there
- 13:38anymore. What if the teacher you hate
- 13:39gets transferred? One of them was the principal.
- 13:42Yeah, what if the principal decides to move to Wisconsin Now
- 13:47you can't kill him, your revenge plot foiled.
- 13:49I just. Like.
- 13:52Like, I read it in a like I read the headline.
- 13:54I was like, oh, no, it's really impulsive.
- 13:57So this is very intriguing. Yeah, Because I would understand
- 14:01if they were like, we're going to kill Principal Skinner next
- 14:03week. It's the only one I can think of
- 14:06off the top of my head. Building.
- 14:08But to say we're going to kill Principal Skinner 4 years from
- 14:13now. All right, get ready.
- 14:15Yeah, get ready. You don't even to go see him in
- 14:17the hall. You don't even know, son.
- 14:19My God, you don't know. We got prepared for you.
- 14:22Just wait. Jesus, you better hope it's not
- 14:25a leap year. I'm done, Okay.
- 14:31That's what I got. Kids being kids.
- 14:34And sometimes kids are scary and think of scary things.
- 14:38Kids are absolutely scary. But.
- 14:54Goodness gracious. This week I'm bringing it back
- 14:56to Australia. We are discussing the first
- 14:59woman to get a life sentence without parole.
- 15:02She only killed one person, her partner John Charles Thomas
- 15:06Price. But what she did was so barbaric
- 15:08and disgusting that the government felt compelled to put
- 15:12her in prison for life when the average time a murderer spends
- 15:16is about 25 years in Australia. You and I were both alive when
- 15:21this happened. We were in middle school, and
- 15:24you may recall that it was global news that Catherine
- 15:27Knight scanned her boyfriend and tried to serve him as a dish to
- 15:32his children. Today will probably frustrate
- 15:36you, but not for the normal reasons.
- 15:39Because by the end of this, what I think I'm going to tell you is
- 15:43that misogyny and the confining nature of masculinity are why
- 15:48she was able to get away with abusing every man she ever
- 15:53dated. And had these men had felt the
- 16:03ability to report her, perhaps somebody's life could have been
- 16:10saved. Okay, I feel frustrated already.
- 16:14Let's go. And so let's talk about who she
- 16:17was before she became the cannibal killer of Aberdeen.
- 16:21So Catherine Mary Knight was born October 24th, 1955, to
- 16:24parents who'd gotten themselves into a pretty big scandal.
- 16:27Her mother, Barbara, was married to a man named Jack Ruffin in
- 16:31Hunters Valley in Aberdeen. It's spelled ROUGAN, and I want
- 16:37to say Rogan so bad, but it's wrong.
- 16:41It was in Hunters Valley in Aberdeen, Australia.
- 16:43She was having an affair with a man named Ken Knight, and both
- 16:46Ken and Jack worked for the same slaughterhouse.
- 16:50Oh, isn't that lovely? In fact, Ten was a pretty good
- 16:55guy, except for the whole stealing your girl situation
- 16:58that went down. Boyfriend #2.
- 17:05They all hung out together. Jack and Barbara, along with all
- 17:10the other people. Slaughterhouses in the 1950s in
- 17:12this area were pretty common. It was major unskilled.
- 17:16Well I would say unskilled labor jobs, but non education based
- 17:19jobs. What do you call those?
- 17:25I don't know. When people aren't trade, there
- 17:28you go trade. So what do you mean not
- 17:30education based? So you don't go to college to
- 17:32get this job? Yeah, but you do still need to
- 17:34learn like how to do. Okay, you go to trade school,
- 17:36right? So right.
- 17:36So these are trade based jobs for mining and pretty much
- 17:39manufacturing and working in slaughterhouses.
- 17:42Pretty common back then, but they met in the bar and Ken
- 17:47flirted with her in front of her very drunk husband, but he was
- 17:50too drunk to realize now. Barbara and Jack were high
- 17:54school sweethearts and they had four kids, two teenage boys and
- 17:57two younger children, and she felt trapped in marriage that
- 18:00she entered way too early. She never even considered
- 18:03divorce because it was unheard of back then.
- 18:05But an affair? No problem.
- 18:09People were always having affairs in Aberdeen and Ken was
- 18:12there and he liked her. So one night when they were all
- 18:14drinking, Jack got taken back home because he was wasted.
- 18:18So Barbara went home with Ken instead, and then they ignored
- 18:20each other in public. Just playing it off.
- 18:23Yep. Made sure that they never
- 18:25interacted again in public. But one day she was home and
- 18:30Jack saw a bruise on her thigh that he thought look like a
- 18:32handprint. And he beat the ever loving crap
- 18:35out of Barbara and threw her out of the house and all of her
- 18:37stuff with her. You didn't ask her where it came
- 18:40from. You just assumed within the
- 18:43within a day, the entire town knew.
- 18:45Now, mind you, the town had about 1500 citizens.
- 18:48And so she moved into Jack's very tiny apartment that he got
- 18:52from the job. It was it was bad.
- 18:56Bad enough that like her teen boys would spit at her in the
- 18:59street if they saw her. They sided with their dad
- 19:02wholeheartedly. The two youngest kids were sent
- 19:05to go live with an aunt in Sydney, roughly 200 miles away.
- 19:08And so Ken and Barbara left, and they went to a city called
- 19:13Marine. He got a job at a slaughterhouse
- 19:17there. Barbara got her divorce, and she
- 19:19also lost her friends and her family.
- 19:21And her kids, I mean. That's what happens when you
- 19:23cheat. One week after the divorce was
- 19:26approved, she got married to Ken.
- 19:29She had two boys within the same year, which means those
- 19:32back-to-back pregnancy. Those back-to-back.
- 19:34Oh goodness. And she pretty much walked from
- 19:38a man who didn't really love her into the arms of a man who
- 19:41didn't really love her, but was also a hardcore alcoholic.
- 19:46So you downgraded. She downgraded.
- 19:48Barbara was aware that cheating again meant that she'd lose her
- 19:51children, so she was just gonna try and stick it out for Ken.
- 19:55But Ken was kind of awful to her.
- 19:57Specifically, he was very demanding sexually.
- 20:01And if she would deny him, he'd attempt to beat her into
- 20:03submission. And when that stopped working,
- 20:05he would pretty much chase her around the house and rape her,
- 20:09sometimes 10 times a day. Oh.
- 20:12My God, so when Barbara found out that she was pregnant and it
- 20:17was twin girls, she was so happy.
- 20:21Now she had like some allies in the house.
- 20:28So Catherine and her sister Joy were born in Tannerfield, NSW.
- 20:34Joy was a tomboy who very quickly hung out with the boys
- 20:37in the family. So Catherine ended up being her
- 20:40mother's only friend. She was a pretty normal kid in
- 20:43the midst of a toxic family. Cam was very strict, hyper
- 20:47conservative. The kids were frequently whipped
- 20:49for any bad behavior. But Catherine learned very
- 20:52quickly, and she was never whooped for the same thing
- 20:54twice. She actually learned very early
- 20:57how to deal with her dad's intensity, and she began to
- 21:01idolize him almost. She treated him like a God,
- 21:04which hurt Barbara's feelings because she was like, Dang it,
- 21:08we were supposed to be besties and now you're on his side.
- 21:12Kids always flock to the dead for some reason.
- 21:13I don't know why. Well then Jack died in 1959.
- 21:18Catherine was four years old, so ex-husband dies and the two
- 21:24older boys move in with Barbara and Ken.
- 21:29They very quickly adapt to Ken's intensity and the loathing of
- 21:33their mother. They already viewed her as a
- 21:35whore, and they also viewed all women in this way.
- 21:41They pushed their luck a little bit too many times in town
- 21:44though, and they got blacklisted from pretty much every town
- 21:47event for being creeps. They saw Joy as one of the boys
- 21:51which left Catherine to be sexually groomed by her brothers
- 21:56from roughly the age of 4 to 14. Catherine thought that this was
- 22:00just the way men are because her mother had been telling her
- 22:04stories about being raped by her father since she could remember.
- 22:08Like at one point, Catherine asked her mother.
- 22:10What do you say if you don't want to do those things?
- 22:12Say fucking no, well, her mom responded.
- 22:14Just let them do what they want with you.
- 22:16It's easier that way. You say no.
- 22:18Do you kick them in the balls? Did they try to do anything
- 22:20else? There you go.
- 22:21Listen to Brian. Yes, before Catherine was even a
- 22:24teenager herself. All four of her brothers were
- 22:28molesting her. She started trying to find ways
- 22:31to not be in the house, and she had an uncle named OO was a
- 22:36famous horseman who had a farm where he took care of his
- 22:38rescues and champion horses. Catherine loved it there.
- 22:41She loved learning from him. She would rescue any injured
- 22:44animal she could find and bring it home.
- 22:46This was the one thing that she was willing to fight her father
- 22:49on. She didn't care that she made
- 22:51him mad. She was going to save this bird
- 22:54she found on the side of the road.
- 22:56If she found a bigger injured animal, she took it to Oscar and
- 22:58he would take it to a vet or she would bring him to where it was.
- 23:03Unfortunately, Oscar had his own demons and he took his life when
- 23:06Catherine was 14 years. Old It was just a bit too much
- 23:10for Catherine to take and she was grieving really hard.
- 23:13It just sounds like like the only guy that was yeah, so far
- 23:17the only one who was nice to her is Uncle Oscar.
- 23:19Yeah. Decent guy in her life.
- 23:21Great. OK, well right after he dies,
- 23:24one of her brothers comes into the room to, you know, like, oh,
- 23:27let's hang out so he can like touch her, you know, in that
- 23:30subtle way. And she punched him so hard that
- 23:34she nearly broke his jaw and said if you ever touch me again,
- 23:37I will castrate. Yes.
- 23:40Now the older boys heard about this and they were like, let's
- 23:43go see what Catherine's doing. And the bathroom was pretty sad,
- 23:47but she seemed pretty normal. So they just assumed that like,
- 23:51OK, maybe our younger brother like pushed things too far and
- 23:54that's why she hit him. They all learned their lesson
- 23:56too. One had a black eye for a month,
- 23:59the other got stabbed. The boys told their parents it
- 24:02was just from fighting at school.
- 24:05It's not because we were trying to touch her sister and she
- 24:07fucked us up. No, I love it.
- 24:10Thank you. I're told because that mean they
- 24:13would have to tell on themselves, and they didn't
- 24:15doubt Catherine when she said she'd castrate them because
- 24:18she'd learned how to do it on Uncle Oscar's farm.
- 24:20I love. It so much so.
- 24:23On one hand, things are going pretty good for Catherine.
- 24:25She just learned that if you beat the show of a man, he won't
- 24:27put his hands on you anymore. Yeah, basically.
- 24:30However, after Uncle Oscar died, the family realized that the
- 24:34town of Maury was only putting up with them because Oscar was a
- 24:37celebrity and they didn't really like the very sinful Barbara,
- 24:41and they definitely didn't like her sinful teenage boys who kept
- 24:44touching girls in town. So when Catherine was 15, they
- 24:47moved back to Aberdeen. She entered Muscle Brook High
- 24:53School in 1969. She was the New Girl, and within
- 24:57weeks, within the first week, kids knew that they shouldn't
- 25:00bother her. She was this like sweet, cute
- 25:03redhead, pretty tall. She'd smile and laugh with you
- 25:06until you made her mad, and then she'd just rip into somebody.
- 25:09Just verbally disrespectful. And by chance, if you put your
- 25:13hands on her at all, she would get you back.
- 25:17Like one day on the school bus a girl tripped her, and the next
- 25:20day Catherine cut off her entire ponytail.
- 25:23A boy on the bus talked about her breasts, or lack of thereof,
- 25:27and when she walked by him, she smashed his face into the bus
- 25:31seat in front of him. She was waging war on these bus
- 25:35rides. And then at school, the the kids
- 25:37would report her and the teachers were like, this doesn't
- 25:40make sense, like she's they're saying that they like she beat
- 25:44them up, but she's sitting here just looking chill.
- 25:49And then essentially in these little meetings, the bullies
- 25:51would admit that they had provoked her.
- 25:53And even though her retaliations went from zero to 100, the staff
- 25:56pretty much was like, well, you don't want your teeth knocked
- 25:58out. Leave her alone, I mean.
- 26:01Yeah, pretty much everybody in the school took that position.
- 26:04Her peers respected her. The younger kids feared her.
- 26:07Is a good. Catherine kept a knife in the
- 26:13fold of her skirt at her waist. It was so she could grab it if
- 26:17she needed it. But it was close enough to her
- 26:19body that no male teacher, who were the predominant gender of
- 26:23the teachers at the school, would ever touch her to look for
- 26:26it. And she stabbed a boy at school
- 26:28one day. They couldn't find the knife, so
- 26:32they couldn't prove that it had been done.
- 26:34So they sent home a little behavior letter.
- 26:37This happened a lot. Now Ken would get those letters
- 26:40and he would say, did the boy deserve it?
- 26:43And Catherine would say, yes. As far as Ken was concerned, his
- 26:48daughter was defending her honor from these fresh boys in town,
- 26:52which is kind of funny because he never made the connection
- 26:55that his own sons got rocked by Catherine as well.
- 27:00Just kind of left Catherine and just, you know, get her
- 27:01education and not be bothered. Since she was a farm kid, nobody
- 27:05really expected her to do well in school, but she did all
- 27:08right. She was on the path to having a
- 27:10pretty good life. And then her favorite teacher
- 27:13gave her a failing grade. She sat through his whole class,
- 27:17just Stony silent. And then after the bell rang and
- 27:22the other kids left, he walked over to her and he was just
- 27:25like, what's wrong? And she threw the paper at him
- 27:28and began screaming him. And then she grabbed the knife
- 27:33out of her waistband and stabbed her teacher.
- 27:37She probably would have killed him if he hadn't punched her.
- 27:41And it was the kind of punch that knocks you on your ass.
- 27:46And first there was a moment of silence.
- 27:48And then Catherine just began wailing.
- 27:51Just screaming, sobbing. Now he was a good teacher.
- 27:56And he he didn't mean to punch her like a grown man, but he was
- 28:00in fight or flight mode. So he goes over to her and he
- 28:06leans over her and he's like, Catherine, are you OK?
- 28:08And at that moment, other students arrive.
- 28:11To a crying girl and there's blood everywhere.
- 28:15It's not hers. This is why, well, her teacher
- 28:19was suspended. Catherine played the victim.
- 28:21The school ended up deciding to do an investigation and it was
- 28:24all people who had never met Catherine before.
- 28:27And at the end of the investigation they were just
- 28:29like you've been letting this kid just run around and rule
- 28:33your school. She is the problem here.
- 28:37They reinstated her teacher with all his back pay.
- 28:40They allowed her to school to go back to school if she agreed.
- 28:44No more fighting. Apologize to your teacher and
- 28:46you're on probation. If you get into another like
- 28:49fight or stab somebody else, you're out.
- 28:52She finished the school year avoiding that teacher, and then
- 28:54she never went to school after that ever again.
- 28:59What the hell was the point then?
- 29:00So what she did the next next work day, she decides she wants
- 29:04to go to the Aberdeen slaughterhouse with her dad.
- 29:07She wanted to be like her dad anyway, so she's just like why
- 29:11not do it a couple years sooner? The shift manager saw this
- 29:14skinny little 15 year old and immediately went no, this is not
- 29:17work for you. She kept her cool knowing that
- 29:21her dad was at work and she ended up leaving and going to a
- 29:25fabric factory in town and getting a job there.
- 29:28She was already really good at making her own clothing and so
- 29:32when the job was to cut cloth to size, which you really don't
- 29:37want to mess up on because nobody wants 1 pant leg longer
- 29:40than the other, her employers are pretty happy with her work.
- 29:44She's making enough money. She started, she moved out of
- 29:46her parents house. Now she found the women at the
- 29:50factory boring, so she would go hang out at the bar with the
- 29:54slaughterhouse employees after work.
- 29:56And that shift manager who told her no was completely taken
- 30:00aback to see Catherine in the bar making jokes and threatening
- 30:05to fight grown men in the bar. Now she didn't drink because I
- 30:12think she grew up watching her father be very drunk.
- 30:17They were also all of the men very kind of freaked out by how
- 30:22sexually forward she was. And she kind of made her way
- 30:25through the single men at the slaughterhouse like she was so
- 30:30sexually forward that in some ways it was off putting from the
- 30:33men she was trying to date. Then in 1971 when she was 16,
- 30:39she applies for her dream job again and they accept her giving
- 30:43her pretty much the crappiest job in the place, cutting up
- 30:45meat for dog food. It's generally the scraps from
- 30:49all the other major cuts which she was too good for dog food.
- 30:55The she was too skilled for it. She had watched her dad and her
- 30:59dad is one of the pretty much best people at this place.
- 31:02So within weeks her bosses started testing her and giving
- 31:06her more complex jobs. Once she like proved that she
- 31:09mastered that, they moved her to another station.
- 31:12Over only a few months, she met almost everybody in the factory
- 31:16and they were all in a rude awakening.
- 31:19If you thought you could treat Catherine Knight like she was a
- 31:21stupid. Little girl.
- 31:22If a man in the line raised his voice at her, she would look at
- 31:25him and say, we can always go settle this with our fucking
- 31:28knives. She was ready to.
- 31:31Hurt that nobody ever took her up on her offer, though she
- 31:37eventually did relax enough to stop threatening her coworkers
- 31:40and she would have fun with them cutting meat up, making jokes.
- 31:43She was moved to deboning in 1972, which is one of the most
- 31:46complex jobs in the slaughterhouse, and I had to
- 31:48Google why. The boning is the process where
- 31:51you skin, remove the excess fat, remove the bone and any
- 31:54blemishes to the meat. Your job is to do all of that
- 31:57while trying to preserve as much meat as possible.
- 32:00This was where her father worked and he had earned A reputation
- 32:03of being one of the best people there.
- 32:05She was pretty hype. She was like nice.
- 32:08I get to work with my dad. Ken was a little salty.
- 32:15He had been the top for like decades because he did the job
- 32:19before they'd moved to Maury, and now his own kid was kind of
- 32:23vying for his spot. He they never spoke about it
- 32:26though. It was just it was a silent
- 32:28like. His silent rivalry, but
- 32:32Catherine kind of brought that out of every guy when she worked
- 32:35next to them. They the men couldn't take the
- 32:37hit to their ego that a 16 year old was better at them.
- 32:39So everyone was working their hardest to try and beat her and
- 32:43if she was better than them then they were just trying to like
- 32:47not be ashamed and reach her level.
- 32:50So at least they were on the same level.
- 32:54Because of all this competition. Now in the slaughterhouse, the
- 32:57owners are hype. So much more meats getting cut
- 33:00and it's also much better. So they decided they wanted to
- 33:03show Catherine appreciation but they did not want to give her a
- 33:06raise. So exactly one year from her
- 33:09start date, she was gifted a set of personalized knives and a
- 33:12custom leather bag to carry them in.
- 33:14She took them to work every day at home, she sharpened and
- 33:17displayed them around the house. They were her most prized
- 33:20possession. I think that's even better than
- 33:22a raise. Actually, I I just want to write
- 33:25a little bag that says Catherine.
- 33:27Look, I want one personal set of life that are nice and
- 33:30sharpened. Oh yes.
- 33:31Anyway, the owners didn't actually even need to ask
- 33:36Catherine to show it off. She did it on her own.
- 33:38And on her days off and lunch breaks, she come and hang out
- 33:41with her friends from different departments.
- 33:43Her favorite place to hang out was the pig slaughtering
- 33:46department. Now, unlike the cows who were
- 33:49killed with one blow because they're so slow, you just hit
- 33:53them. It's done.
- 33:54It's over with. Pigs were smaller and kind of
- 33:56wily, and it took more to kill them.
- 33:58Apparently, when you worked at the slaughterhouse, the sound of
- 34:01dying hogs was heard all over the building when the
- 34:05slaughtering moment happened. Lovely, Catherine thought.
- 34:09The job was fascinating. There was an old man who worked
- 34:12there who was kind of a grump, and the only person he liked was
- 34:15Catherine. Some people kind of made jokes
- 34:18that it was like a lecherous relationship, but it seemed to
- 34:21just be a genuine friendship between like, a grandpa and a
- 34:25teen girl. She just wanted to know more
- 34:27about killing pigs, and so he was so happy to have the company
- 34:32on her lunch breaks that he would do stuff he wasn't
- 34:35supposed to, like killing the pigs in front of her.
- 34:40Or he would start killing them in worse ways because it made
- 34:45her happy. Or one time he skinned a pig
- 34:50while it was alive. No.
- 34:52Yep, and that only made Catherine really interested in
- 34:56doing it herself. So he let her slaughter the pigs
- 35:01and sometimes she chased them around and like stabbed at them
- 35:05just to mess with them. Oh my God, we're pigs.
- 35:09So Catherine had gone in just like 3 years from a little girl
- 35:13who couldn't let a squirrel die on the side of the road to a
- 35:16full blown animal torturer, which as we know is one of the
- 35:20signs. Yes, just had to be pigs.
- 35:24Now this was it wasn't like this wasn't known around the
- 35:27facility, and you'd think that men knowing she was into that
- 35:30sort of thing would turn them off.
- 35:32But Nope, she was very consistently asked out.
- 35:36She go from work to the bar and then she fought the night away.
- 35:40By 1972 she was stocky, about 6 feet tall, 17 and she ended up
- 35:48making friends with a man named David Kellet.
- 35:51He was 22. One night out while they were
- 35:53drinking, another man insulted David and David kind of stepped
- 35:57down. He was like, I don't want to
- 35:59fight. Catherine was like I do, and she
- 36:02knocked the guy out and she swung on him until her hands
- 36:07were bloody and his teeth were all over the floor.
- 36:10David and other coworkers had to pull him off of the man.
- 36:14Now everybody else in the bar was like, typical bar fight, but
- 36:17the bartender was like, she's not drunk.
- 36:20And I know she's not drunk because I've been sending her
- 36:23lemonades masqueraded as another drink the whole night.
- 36:26So the bartender was like, this is just Catherine being
- 36:28Catherine, and you need to leave.
- 36:31The only other place that you could go drink in the entire
- 36:34city was a hotel that was literally across the street.
- 36:38So they went there. David was in awe of her.
- 36:42He was just like, I've never had anybody protect me.
- 36:46And the two began dating and David got to see what it was
- 36:50like to date someone like Catherine.
- 36:53She made wonderful home cooked meals.
- 36:55She fixed and improved his clothes.
- 36:57They had a stellar sex life that people at the slaughterhouse
- 37:02when the guys talked could not believe.
- 37:06Apparently she had the similar sexual appetite as her father
- 37:10and David was happy about that, so inevitably she takes him to
- 37:16meet her parents. Now, at this point in time, Ken
- 37:19is heading towards retirement. The family had moved outside of
- 37:22Aberdeen to a small farmhouse. It wasn't to make money though.
- 37:26Most of the property had been parceled out by the bank to pay
- 37:30for a previous owner that had gone bankrupt.
- 37:32So it was just like this old ramshackle farmhouse, but Ken
- 37:36was just like, listen, I'm just trying to rest and chill for the
- 37:39rest of my life. Ken was finally not being
- 37:41terrible to Barbara, not because he wasn't a horrible person, but
- 37:45because he was too old to chase her around the house anymore.
- 37:49Barbara, however, was a mess. She had spent the last decade
- 37:55isolated from nearly everyone, and it was definitely apparent
- 37:59in her behavior. In fact, at one point David went
- 38:03to the kitchen to grab a beer and Barbara corners him and just
- 38:11goes, You don't know this, but Catherine's got to screw loose
- 38:16and he's just like, sure, whatever.
- 38:18And she's like, no, I'm serious, if you if you fuck up, she's
- 38:21going to kill you. And David didn't believe it,
- 38:24though, because he'd only ever seen her beat that one guy, and
- 38:28she'd never been anything but nice to David, yeah.
- 38:31Because you were nice to her, so you didn't fuck up.
- 38:34Won't wait till you fuck up. Well, they got married a couple
- 38:36days after her 18th birthday. It was super cheap ceremony.
- 38:40David was drunk because he was so nervous, but he didn't blow
- 38:42it. They had a party afterward.
- 38:44The folks from the slaughterhouse were there.
- 38:46The Knight family, the Kellet family.
- 38:49They went back to David's company issued apartment to
- 38:51consummate their marriage. They had sex three times and
- 38:54David fell asleep. Catherine was not asleep.
- 38:59She was sitting there thinking about all of this night comments
- 39:02that David's family had made that they thought that she
- 39:05didn't get. But she did get him.
- 39:07She just decided she wasn't gonna beat anybody's ass on her
- 39:09wedding day. Goodness gracious.
- 39:12So she wanted to talk about it with David.
- 39:14So she tried to smack him awake, and when that didn't work, she
- 39:18climbed on top of him and began choking him, which woke him up.
- 39:22And he was very confused. He was just like, why?
- 39:25Why did you choke me? And she's just like, I want to
- 39:28talk to you. He's like, I have scratches.
- 39:30I am now bruised. I don't understand what's going
- 39:32on. And Catherine was showing him
- 39:35who she really was. On the wedding night.
- 39:39Well, So what happens next is that she demands to have sex
- 39:42three more times because her mom had told her that on their
- 39:49wedding night they had had sex five times.
- 39:53And she went to beat her dad's record, which totally turned
- 39:57David off. And he told her he's like,
- 40:00listen, I'm going to go to the bathroom, freshen up, I'll meet
- 40:04you in the bedroom, and she's like, you better be here.
- 40:08He goes in the bathroom, the only door in the entire
- 40:10apartment that locks locks the door, climbs into the tub and
- 40:14goes back to sleep. Passes out while Catherine is
- 40:18banging on the bathroom door. Oh no.
- 40:24After that though, she cooled it.
- 40:27She turned off her crazy, as men are want to say.
- 40:32They went back to work where David would show up, exhausted
- 40:36from Catherine wanting to have sex all night long, and she
- 40:39would show up full of energy, ready to cut.
- 40:42Animals up. She did all of her wifely duties
- 40:45expertly because Barbara was so depressed that she had stopped
- 40:52doing things. So Catherine sort of became very
- 40:54domestic when she was a child. So now that she is an adult,
- 40:59she's cleaning everything, She's fixing all the clothes, she's
- 41:02making him new clothes. She was trying so hard to be
- 41:09perfect and David couldn't really figure out what had
- 41:12happened with the whole choking situation.
- 41:14But since things seemed normal, he was just going to push that
- 41:18to the back and not bring it up anymore.
- 41:22The problem with all this is that Catherine was faking being
- 41:25the perfect wife, and months of doing all this stuff and not
- 41:30really entirely being true to herself was taking a toll.
- 41:34And she started resenting him a little bit and she started like
- 41:38picking at him like if he was late, her big thing.
- 41:44And this is going to be repeated throughout this entire
- 41:46situation. Her big thing is she always says
- 41:51that someone she's dating is cheating on her.
- 41:55Everyone. This went on until 1975, and
- 41:59David got kind of sick of it. He was living in a home where
- 42:02his wife went from enraged to not and then back.
- 42:07It was super stressful. And then Catherine, for a little
- 42:11bit, just stopped bothering him. They gone to visit her parents.
- 42:17And she kind of, I guess, thought about maybe she watched
- 42:22them and she wondered, like, I wonder why they've been married
- 42:24for so long and Dad never stepped out on Mom.
- 42:27And she's like, maybe that's because Barbara didn't bother
- 42:31Ken about all the stuff that he did.
- 42:34So they had a couple of months in 75 of calm until August when
- 42:44she found out she was pregnant and every bit of progress they
- 42:48were making towards this being a normal relationship was over.
- 42:52One night he came home to change his clothes before going to the
- 42:54bar and she was she insisted that he was changing so he could
- 42:59go me another woman. She took all of his clothes,
- 43:02threw them in the tub, covered them in lighter fluid and set
- 43:04them on fire. The Aberdeen Fire Department
- 43:08shows up with her husband in tow, the tub's melted, the house
- 43:12is full of soot, the neighbors are all outside watching.
- 43:15David is mortified and Catherine is just staring them all, just
- 43:19staring at them like I dare you to see what's going on right
- 43:24now. The.
- 43:25Fuck you're looking at. David didn't go to the bar for
- 43:29weeks, mind you. He's not at the bar.
- 43:33He's going home and come. He's going to work and come back
- 43:36home. She's still accusing him of
- 43:38cheating all day, Every day he went back to drinking so he
- 43:41could just get away from her. One night he came home from the
- 43:46bar and she was in one of her rages while ironing his clothes
- 43:50and she hit him in the face with the iron.
- 43:54He ran to the bathroom to get away from her and she screamed
- 43:58and hit the door with the iron until finally she quieted down
- 44:02and begged for forgiveness. David forgave her.
- 44:08The next day he walked into I See Your Face.
- 44:11Brian is shaking his head. No, I would not like.
- 44:15That's OK. Well, I forgive you, but guess
- 44:17what? Leaving the next day, his boss
- 44:21took him to the hospital. No one asked any questions,
- 44:23which is exactly what he wanted. He actually started doing what
- 44:27you do when you're in an abusive relationship.
- 44:29He started bending backward to make Catherine less upset,
- 44:34telling her where he was at every moment of the day, coming
- 44:38home early or exactly on the dot so she wouldn't freak out.
- 44:43One night he was 4 minutes late, and as soon as he walked into
- 44:48the kitchen, she hit him with a cast iron skillet, cracking his.
- 44:52Oh my God. He dragged himself to a
- 44:55neighbor's house to get help. He woke up the next morning at
- 44:58the hospital with Catherine crying next to him.
- 45:01David told the police that his wife was alone and she was
- 45:05pregnant and she said she'd hurt somebody outside and she was so
- 45:08scared and he came home later than usual from drinking and she
- 45:14must have thought that I was an intruder.
- 45:17So you're making excuses now? Yep, great.
- 45:20And the NSW Police Department? We're happy to accept the story
- 45:23because domestic violence is sticky and they didn't want to
- 45:26get involved and David didn't make a formal complaint.
- 45:32Eventually he went home. Catherine showered him with
- 45:34affection. Also very common with abusive
- 45:37relationships. He went back to work and she was
- 45:44actually forced to stay home because she was getting close to
- 45:47her due date. But at home, Catherine obsessed
- 45:52over the fact that David was going to leave her with the
- 45:54baby. A month later, David went to the
- 45:59bar for a tournament and told Catherine he'd be home at 11:00
- 46:02PM. When he didn't come home, she
- 46:04called the bar and she told and he told her he'd be home in an
- 46:07hour. She's like, but you said you'd
- 46:09be home now. And in front of his friends and
- 46:13her friends, he very drunkenly told Catherine, Well, maybe I
- 46:17won't come home at all since you're being annoying.
- 46:21When he got home later, she was ready with the frying pan, but
- 46:25he ducked. Yeah.
- 46:27She swung again and missed and broke a light switch.
- 46:30In the darkness he was able to escape and get back in his car
- 46:34and drive away. God, now.
- 46:37David felt bad because everything Catherine was
- 46:40accusing him of, he was absolutely doing.
- 46:43Ohh what the hell? What?
- 46:45No, no. No, no, no, you can't do that.
- 46:55How dare you? He had been seeing another woman
- 46:58for months. It actually it started after she
- 47:02began accusing him. So it was.
- 47:05It did not start before, but that doesn't matter because he
- 47:08still did it. And right after the frying pan
- 47:11attack he decides he's going to make a plan to be with this New
- 47:15Girl in Queensland. And that New Girl told him that
- 47:18she was pregnant too. David's at this point like I
- 47:23need to get out of town before Catherine kills me.
- 47:27Catherine goes into labor May of 1976, and David is supposed to
- 47:33pack a bag and meet her at the hospital while she goes there
- 47:36with her mom. Instead he got in his car and
- 47:41drove out of Aberdeen. Catherine gave birth to her
- 47:46first child, Melissa Ann, with her only her mother and father
- 47:50and sister by her side. In fact, her sister Joy just
- 47:54went out searching for David and she went back to the house.
- 47:58Everything in his at the house was there that belonged to him,
- 48:01but his car was gone. His friends were like, oh, maybe
- 48:04he had an accident. We should check in the road.
- 48:07Joy's like, I don't think so. And Catherine's like, I
- 48:10definitely don't think so. So this moment that she's
- 48:14supposed to be bonding with her baby, she is just loathing the
- 48:18existence of David. No one really understands this
- 48:24very dark place where Catherine is right now.
- 48:28She goes home with the baby and after several weeks of being
- 48:31alone with Melissa, she starts just walking the streets in a
- 48:35blind rage with a baby and like a stroller.
- 48:38And her neighbors call the police because she is like
- 48:41walking with the stroller, just banging it around, like
- 48:45completely gone. So the police pick her up, they
- 48:50dropped the baby at her parents house, and they take Catherine
- 48:53to Saint Elmo's Hospital in Tamworth.
- 48:56Now, there were some whispers that she might have borderline
- 48:59personality disorder, but ultimately the hospital
- 49:02diagnoses her with postpartum depression.
- 49:05They tried to give her an IQ test, but since she hadn't read
- 49:07any books or had to write anything in the last five years,
- 49:11she was almost illiterate. The test gave an IQ in the 80s,
- 49:15but that didn't line up with the person they were talking to.
- 49:19She was very cognizant of things.
- 49:21In fact, one of her doctors said Catherine Knight is a psychopath
- 49:26and a narcissist and you are being manipulated into getting
- 49:30into releasing her early. She's released seven days later.
- 49:36I'm gonna say that Doctor was absolutely right.
- 49:39He was right. Oh God.
- 49:41So she collects the baby from her parents and it's all calm
- 49:43for a few days. And one day, a man, he's a
- 49:48drifter in town. He just kind of wanders around
- 49:50transient. He's walking train tracks and he
- 49:53hears a baby crying and he's like, oh, well, maybe somebody's
- 49:58out here with their kid. And as he nears the tracks, he
- 50:01sees the baby on the train tracks.
- 50:04This, like the train, is close enough that the everything is
- 50:08vibrating and he runs and scoops Melissa up to take her to town.
- 50:14In town, Catherine is in full blown rage mode, face red.
- 50:20She's so angry that she can barely speak and she's just like
- 50:25growling and grunting. She walks into the town general
- 50:28store. She grabs an axe and just roars
- 50:31and walks back into the street. The police were called at this
- 50:34point and they're just kind of watching her.
- 50:37She's pacing up and down the street, swinging the axe in the
- 50:40air. The other people are coming out
- 50:42of their houses watching her, which is only making her more
- 50:44angry, and she goes to swing the axe at somebody who's watching,
- 50:50and she hears Melissa crying, and it startles her enough
- 50:54because she thought she was sure she killed this baby.
- 50:58They were able to subdue her and they take her back to Saint
- 51:00Elmo's, where she is forcefully medicated, and then it's almost
- 51:05like that crazy beast on the street is gone.
- 51:09They released her again, but this time Ken takes her home and
- 51:12he goes, we're keeping the baby, we'll take care of her until you
- 51:16get better, which is pretty good because Catherine was filled
- 51:20with revenge. And mind you, these situations
- 51:23I'm explaining, are happening weeks apart.
- 51:26So this baby is maybe like two months old at this point.
- 51:30So another night she goes next door and she bangs on her
- 51:36naval's door. These are actually the same
- 51:38neighbors who helped David the Macbeths.
- 51:42And she's like, my baby's sick, I need help.
- 51:45And 16 year old Maggie Mythbeth opens the door and agrees to
- 51:48help her. She's like, I'll drive you to
- 51:49your baby, but I gotta bring my little brother.
- 51:52As soon as they get in the car, Catherine drops the sweet act
- 51:55and she's just like, we have to drive to Queensland.
- 51:59I have to kill David and his whore.
- 52:02Now for the listeners not up on Australian geography.
- 52:05Aberdeen is in the southeastern part of the country.
- 52:07I guess it's about 200 miles away from Sydney, Australia,
- 52:10which is what most of us around the world know.
- 52:13Queensland is located a nice 17 hour drive north northwest about
- 52:191500 kilometers away, which is over 1000 miles for those of us
- 52:23in the godless US who keep using the horrible system of.
- 52:28I'd be like, hey, you got gas money then Sure, 17 hour drive.
- 52:32Wait, is that? Two and from or is it that's
- 52:34two? Oh, hell no.
- 52:36OK, never mind. Well, so Maggie's like I can't
- 52:42drive to Queensland like my my parents, and Catherine actually
- 52:46stabs her. It's a very shallow stab, but
- 52:48it's enough to scare the girl. They end up stopping at a gas
- 52:52station to fill up, and as soon as Maggie gets out of the car,
- 52:58she runs into the gas station. She tells the store clerk.
- 53:03Catherine Knight is going to kill me and my brother.
- 53:05He calls the police and then he's like, you can't go back out
- 53:08there, she's going to hurt you. But Catherine is threatening to
- 53:13kill the little boy. He had tried to run too, and he
- 53:16got. Scooped.
- 53:20So the police arrived and they try and talk her down and that
- 53:25ended with the kids and other civilians safe.
- 53:28But one of the cops arms was slashed from wrist to elbow and
- 53:32he also got stabbed in the ribs while they were forcing her into
- 53:36the back of the cop car and she was just cackling.
- 53:43This time the staff at the hospital realized that David
- 53:46Kellett is in danger. He is the main discussion of
- 53:49every therapy appointment she has.
- 53:52She doesn't care that she permanently traumatized a 16
- 53:56year old girl. It was.
- 53:57I'm going to go to Queensland and torture David's mother until
- 54:00he tells, until she tells me where he is.
- 54:01Then I'm going to go kill David and his girlfriend and anyone
- 54:04who sees me do it. Then I'm going to come back to
- 54:05Aberdeen and kill anyone who helped David leave me, starting
- 54:09with the mechanic who fixed his car.
- 54:10Oh my God. So the police decide to go to
- 54:15Queensland and tell David. Just want to let you know your
- 54:20wife is committed to a hospital and she wants to kill you.
- 54:24I'd say leave the country. I think they thought that like,
- 54:28this would just prep David, but in fact it made him feel guilty.
- 54:33He was like, look at what I did to her.
- 54:36This is all my fault. So he leaves his girlfriend,
- 54:39who's about to have a baby in Queensland, to go back to his
- 54:43wife I. Don't like David?
- 54:44He goes to the hospital, request that she's returned to his care.
- 54:48He'll make sure she takes her meds.
- 54:50He goes, they pick up Melissa. In fact, when they opened the
- 54:54door, he was worried that Ken was gonna be mad at him, but it
- 54:57was actually Barbara who opened the door and immediately attacks
- 55:00him. Like this is your fault.
- 55:02Screaming at him, hitting him and Catherine steps in and like
- 55:05knocks her mom down, protecting her husband.
- 55:10Yeah, I got this, Mom. I'll take care of him later.
- 55:12Don't worry about that. Well, they take their daughter
- 55:14home, but after a couple days it's almost unbearable for both
- 55:17of them, the amount of gossip and people watching them in
- 55:20town. So they moved to Woodbridge,
- 55:22which is a suburb of Brisbane. It was a fresh start.
- 55:26Neither of them had any family there, no one whispered.
- 55:28David's mom comes from Queensland to live with them, to
- 55:31take care of Melissa during the day while both Catherine and
- 55:34David go to work. Catherine takes her medication,
- 55:36which does help. She's a stellar employee gifted
- 55:40with a knife. She would still get people back,
- 55:44like in high school, but it wasn't like before.
- 55:46She was free to be not perfect this time, and they had all this
- 55:51excess money because both of them were working.
- 55:54But the only time that Catherine was really happy was at the meat
- 55:57processing plant and on the very quiet drive back home.
- 56:02This went on for years, Catherine going through the
- 56:04motions, her medication, kind of cutting off that passion that
- 56:08David. She and David had at the
- 56:10beginning. They had a second child, Natasha
- 56:12Marie, on March 6th, 1980. David was there.
- 56:15He held her hand through labor. She did not have the same
- 56:19response. In fact, what happened was that
- 56:22she was bored and she resented David and it started to show.
- 56:28Everything sort of ended the day after Natasha's 4th birthday,
- 56:34March 7th, 1984. She packs up everything.
- 56:37No words, takes the kids, moves back to Aberdeen.
- 56:43It was it was like it was almost like she didn't care.
- 56:47David still loved her, but he was kind of relieved.
- 56:50She filed for divorce and she took the kids to her parents
- 56:53house. Catherine got a small house and
- 56:58Muswellbrook and went back to work at the slaughterhouse.
- 57:01It had been eight years and she acted like absolutely nothing
- 57:04had happened. In 1986, though, she was lifting
- 57:09a hog and she hurt her back. They rushed her to the hospital
- 57:12but this was a career ending injury.
- 57:15She ended up having to file for disability workplace
- 57:18compensation. She gets an apartment from the
- 57:20government through the housing Commission just outside of
- 57:22Aberdeen. She's 31 years old and has no
- 57:25idea what to do with her life. Melissa is 10, and while
- 57:29Catherine did warn Melissa about boys, she did not make the same
- 57:31mistake that Barbara did. But Catherine was lonely, so she
- 57:35started leaving the children at home at night and going to hang
- 57:37out with men where she meets a local minor named David
- 57:42Saunders. He wasn't from Aberdeen, so he
- 57:45gave her a chance. Because what was happening was
- 57:48even if she met a new guy in Aberdeen who worked at the
- 57:50slaughterhouse within a day, other people would be like She's
- 57:54crazy. You should leave her alone so
- 57:57David didn't wasn't in the same circle they moved in.
- 58:01After a couple months, the moods were up and down.
- 58:04She got into little fights with him and he'd go back to his
- 58:06apartment and sconce and sleep there.
- 58:09On their anniversary. He showed up with flowers
- 58:11expecting a nice night. Catherine was in a mood, pacing
- 58:14the kitchen. She walked outside, picked up
- 58:17the family dog that David had bought for the children and slit
- 58:20the dog's throat and said if I ever catch you running around on
- 58:22me, this is what I'm going to do to you.
- 58:26David's like I'm, I'm happy. I would never.
- 58:30But she picks up a pan and she swings it at him and he put his
- 58:34arm up and she broke his arm, hitting him.
- 58:37With a pan, yes. And then as he's like on the
- 58:40ground, she proceeds to beat him with the pan until he is
- 58:43unconscious. For a week he didn't respond to
- 58:47her at all. He stayed at home when the
- 58:50bruises went away. He started doing some works,
- 58:52some shifts at work. His coworkers actually mocked
- 58:55him for being jumpy, and the old men who worked there were like,
- 58:58Nah, Nah, he's dating Catherine Night.
- 59:04He has a reason to be jumpy. Yup, They they exactly.
- 59:07The older men knew. So what happened is that
- 59:11Catherine camped out of his apartment one day and as he's
- 59:15walking home, he expects violence when he sees her.
- 59:17But instead what he gets is Catherine crying and begging for
- 59:20forgiveness. He takes her back.
- 59:25Things are calm for a couple months, and then it goes dark
- 59:28again when David asks her why she's so upset.
- 59:32She's pregnant and she begins obsessing over David leaving
- 59:36her. So David tries to show her that
- 59:39he's serious about her by putting a down payment on the
- 59:41House. June 1988.
- 59:44She has her third daughter, Sarah Saunders now.
- 59:48David was like, after she gives birth, it's going to be great.
- 59:51Nope. Catherine was back in the
- 59:54postpartum state and at the beginning of 1989 they are
- 59:59barely speaking. Catherine got her workers
- 1:00:03compensation. She paid off the rest of the
- 1:00:04house. They started fighting.
- 1:00:07The first big fight was because he came home and the baby was
- 1:00:10still in a dirty diaper. Another time he came home and
- 1:00:14all his work clothes were dirty and he was like, what have you
- 1:00:17been doing all day? She responded by going and get a
- 1:00:20knife. A pair of scissors and cutting
- 1:00:23his shirts in front of him. That's not an answer.
- 1:00:27Then she went to cut his work pants and he was like no, no,
- 1:00:30no, those are my only other pants And he goes to grab them
- 1:00:33and she stabs him in the stomach with the scissors and twists
- 1:00:37them as she pulls. Them.
- 1:00:40Then she went to go get the iron and David hopped it in his car
- 1:00:45and drove away. He didn't speak to her for
- 1:00:50several days. He was like, this is the second
- 1:00:53time this woman's tried to kill me.
- 1:00:55I'm not going to give her a third chance.
- 1:00:56He only went back to Aberdeen to try and see his daughter and
- 1:01:00that's when he learned that Catherine had gone to the police
- 1:01:02and lied to them and got an apprehended violence order,
- 1:01:05which is specifically to keep someone violent away from you.
- 1:01:09What? Excuse me, this order said that
- 1:01:11he could not contact or see Catherine or the kids.
- 1:01:15What does she say that he did to her?
- 1:01:17I don't know fam. Because.
- 1:01:20Oh my God. Like I I would have just went to
- 1:01:22the police station. You see this stab wound in my
- 1:01:25stomach? She stabbed me.
- 1:01:27I didn't do shit for her. Well next guy she dated is his
- 1:01:31name was John Chillingworth and she actually met him the day
- 1:01:34that they came. He came back to Aberdeen.
- 1:01:37They had worked together when she was younger, but he he was
- 1:01:4210 years older than her and he was honestly kind of creeped out
- 1:01:45when she was coming onto him as a 17 year old.
- 1:01:49Now they were roughly 44 and 34 and he was like, yeah, don't
- 1:01:54mind now. John was not like the Davids.
- 1:01:58The first time Catherine swung on him, he ducked and he smacked
- 1:02:02the hell out of her. In fact, she threw him out of
- 1:02:05her house, mainly because she was kind of startled that he
- 1:02:09just hadn't taken the abuse. She begged him to come home the
- 1:02:12next. Day.
- 1:02:15And bless her heart, Melissa. Like, what a lovely child.
- 1:02:18All she heard from her mom was that John hit her.
- 1:02:23So when John comes back, Melissa's like, you hit my mom
- 1:02:27and like gets mad at him and he smacks her too.
- 1:02:29And he's like, sit down little girl.
- 1:02:30Oh my God. Catherine gets pregnant.
- 1:02:34And John was like, maybe we should get married.
- 1:02:37But he realizes that Catherine doesn't care about being
- 1:02:39married, so he's like, bet this is awesome.
- 1:02:43Throughout this pregnancy, all the same accusations, just like
- 1:02:47the first David's. And just like the first David,
- 1:02:51John started sleeping with somebody else.
- 1:02:53You. Dumb ass.
- 1:02:55Her only son, Eric, was born in 1990.
- 1:02:58His father was present and right after he was born, Catherine was
- 1:03:03a domestic queen again. John felt bad about cheating
- 1:03:07because she was just being so awesome.
- 1:03:10So he tells her the truth. She walks into the bathroom,
- 1:03:15punches the glass container holding his like bridge,
- 1:03:19breaking it. Then she walks out and punches
- 1:03:22him square in the jaw, breaking some of his real teeth too.
- 1:03:26That night he went to his company sponsored apartment and
- 1:03:30then came back to the house and picked up his stuff.
- 1:03:32He found Catherine in their bedroom.
- 1:03:34She was overducing on all of the sleeping pills in the house.
- 1:03:39He drove her to the hospital, of course.
- 1:03:42Guilty for driving her to suicide, the captor for
- 1:03:45observation. For a week, things went back to
- 1:03:48normal. But this time Catherine began
- 1:03:51cheating and she planned it. So one night when when Jack came
- 1:03:56home from work, Sean came home from work, he would see it.
- 1:04:00He walked into the house, found her having sex with another man
- 1:04:03in their bed. He's just like, you know what?
- 1:04:05I'm done with this. He leaves the house, never comes
- 1:04:08back. He actually moved away from
- 1:04:09Aberdeen. Quit drinking, ended up becoming
- 1:04:11a drug and alcohol counselor and spent the rest of his life
- 1:04:15helping other addicts. John Chillingham is the only man
- 1:04:18to escape Catherine Knight with no permanent injuries and he's
- 1:04:22the last one to escape alive. The man Catherine was cheating
- 1:04:27with was John Price and the affair had been going on for a
- 1:04:30year before Catherine decided to use him to hurt her ex as their
- 1:04:35affair turn into a real relationship.
- 1:04:36It was pretty good in the beginning.
- 1:04:38Pricey, as he was called in town, brought out a certain
- 1:04:41gentleness in Catherine. He knew about her past.
- 1:04:44He didn't really care. She met his two kids.
- 1:04:46They liked her. Her own children really liked
- 1:04:49him. They were like, this is probably
- 1:04:51the nicest, gentlest person you've ever dated, just like
- 1:04:56normal. After a little bit, she starts
- 1:04:58accusing him of cheating. She yells, She hits him, but he
- 1:05:01is completely smitten with her and anybody who sees can tell
- 1:05:06people in town actually try and warn him, but he decides to take
- 1:05:10Catherine in her word and he's just like, listen, you were just
- 1:05:13protecting yourself from evil man, and those men before you
- 1:05:16were weak before me were weak. They couldn't handle a strong
- 1:05:19woman. In 1993, the infidelity argument
- 1:05:24stops, and now she's mad because Price is not marrying her.
- 1:05:29Now John Price had been married before and he felt like his
- 1:05:33relationship went sour after they got married.
- 1:05:37And he'd asked Catherine about her first marriage and it seemed
- 1:05:40like it was the same thing. They've been happy and then they
- 1:05:43got married and it went to hell. So he's like, why ruin a good
- 1:05:47thing with a wedding in 1995? He tries to make her happy and
- 1:05:53he says move in with me. He's a supervisor at the mine.
- 1:05:57The company gave him a really nice 3 bedroom house.
- 1:06:00She decides to keep her house and move in with him, which was
- 1:06:06great because he didn't exactly like the fact that she had
- 1:06:08animal skins and bones all over her house.
- 1:06:10Anyway, things are great for a year.
- 1:06:14They live like a married couple. She starts asking about getting
- 1:06:17married again. These fights happen daily until
- 1:06:20about 1998, and then as a retaliation for fighting with
- 1:06:29him, one night she takes a video camera that he bought for her
- 1:06:32for Christmas and she videotapes things that John had taken from
- 1:06:37the trash at the mine, mainly old expired Med kits.
- 1:06:41And she mails that tape to his boss and he gets fired after 17
- 1:06:46years. Even after he explained that all
- 1:06:49of those supplies were expired, they wanted nothing to do with
- 1:06:52him or Catherine. He drove home, gathered all of
- 1:06:58Catherine's stuff, and chucked it out the front door.
- 1:07:01When she got home, she discovered all of the locks of
- 1:07:04the house were changed. They stood on the porch
- 1:07:06screaming at each other for about two hours until the
- 1:07:08neighbors threatened to call the police.
- 1:07:10She picked up her stuff, and she went back to McQueen St.
- 1:07:14John was free from Catherine, but he came up against some
- 1:07:19pushback. While he wasn't, like,
- 1:07:21officially blacklisted from the mining companies, other men knew
- 1:07:26about Catherine and they were kind of wary of dealing with any
- 1:07:30man who was dealing with her. She started hanging out with the
- 1:07:35bars again looking for him, and their paths crossed.
- 1:07:39He tried to avoid her, but eventually one night he decides
- 1:07:42to just say hi. They go back to sleeping
- 1:07:45together. The news of the two of them back
- 1:07:47together goes through town in a second, and the next day his
- 1:07:51friends show up at his new job to have an intervention.
- 1:07:56They're just like, listen, we don't want to watch you hurt
- 1:07:58yourself with this woman. Either she goes or we go.
- 1:08:02John's like, listen, it's just sex.
- 1:08:04I'm not going to move back in with her or anything.
- 1:08:07People in Aberdeen actually contacted David Kellett and
- 1:08:11we're like, you need to come talk to this guy.
- 1:08:13So David Kellett meets him at a bar and shows John all of the
- 1:08:18scars that he got from the years he lived with Catherine.
- 1:08:24He even shares the warning that Barbara gave to him before their
- 1:08:27wedding. If you cross her, she'll kill
- 1:08:30you, he says. Do you understand?
- 1:08:32This isn't a joke? She will kill you.
- 1:08:35John sat there, kind of not taking it seriously.
- 1:08:39Dude, you got all these people coming to you saying stay away,
- 1:08:42stay away, you're gonna die. Before John even returned home
- 1:08:48that night, David had already left Aberdeen.
- 1:08:51Just being there was triggering for him, but he had done
- 1:08:56everything he could to save John Price.
- 1:09:00John started allowing Catherine to come by his house for date
- 1:09:02nights. She would cook for him, they'd
- 1:09:05eat, have sex. She'd go home.
- 1:09:08She started pushing for more in the relationship.
- 1:09:12It would escalate to Catherine screaming at him.
- 1:09:14He'd shove her out the front door of the house, lock the
- 1:09:17door. By 2000, the harassment is just
- 1:09:21incessant. They get in a fight and he
- 1:09:24remind her why they're not together.
- 1:09:26And she, of course, is like, well, listen, that's not who I'm
- 1:09:28not that person anymore. I won't do that again.
- 1:09:31And he's like, of course you won't do it again because you
- 1:09:33can't ruin my 17 year career again because I don't have it
- 1:09:36anymore. I'm never letting you live here
- 1:09:39again. This fight happened weekly.
- 1:09:43She'd scream, calm down. They'd make up.
- 1:09:46One night they were together and he told her he would never let
- 1:09:50her hold any power over his life ever again because her temper
- 1:09:55caused her to wreck things and Catherine was offended.
- 1:10:01In fact, she told him, You've never really seen me angry.
- 1:10:06She got up and started hitting him, stabbed him in the chest
- 1:10:09with a knife. He grabbed her, threw her out of
- 1:10:12the house onto the street. The blade was in one of his
- 1:10:16ribs, and it was in such a location that if it'd been about
- 1:10:191/2 an inch, if she'd been 1/2 inch off of her mark, she would
- 1:10:22have stabbed him in the heart in fact.
- 1:10:26And then as he was standing there, he was like, oh crap, the
- 1:10:28back door is open. He rushes to lock the back door.
- 1:10:32She's there banging on the on all of the doors.
- 1:10:35He locks all the first floor windows and eventually she
- 1:10:37leaves. That is February 28th, 2000.
- 1:10:44I can't. I just can't.
- 1:10:46February 29th, he stops at the Scone Magistrate Court on his
- 1:10:50way to work and gets a restraining order against
- 1:10:52Catherine. He tells his coworkers that day
- 1:10:56at work, if I don't come to work, you need to come look for
- 1:10:59me because I think that means that Catherine will have killed
- 1:11:02me. His coworkers beg him not to go
- 1:11:06home. They're like they they at first
- 1:11:08they think that he's just like being a tough guy.
- 1:11:11But in fact, he says, I'm worried that if I show, if I'm
- 1:11:16not there and the children are there, she's going to kill the
- 1:11:20kids. So I have to go back just to
- 1:11:23make sure they're OK. He goes to the house after the
- 1:11:25kids get home from school, he has them pack up, go stay the
- 1:11:29night with their friends and have a sleepover.
- 1:11:32He actually doesn't even. He spends most of the night,
- 1:11:34February 29th, at his friend's house, like across the street,
- 1:11:39just kind of watching, making sure she wasn't there.
- 1:11:43At 11:00 PM. He's confident she's not going
- 1:11:45to come. He goes back to his house.
- 1:11:49Catherine, on the other hand, spent her day differently.
- 1:11:52First thing she does is she goes to his house.
- 1:11:56While he's not there, she films the kids almost as if she's
- 1:12:05making like a will, and she's talking on the camera about,
- 1:12:10like things she's going to give to the children once she's gone.
- 1:12:14Then she went to town, brought new lingerie and waited.
- 1:12:20And after she saw him go into his house, she broke in, watched
- 1:12:25a little TV, took a shower, and then sexually assaulted him.
- 1:12:30She pretty much, like, mounted him while he was sleeping.
- 1:12:34He didn't even realize what was going on, like he was asleep and
- 1:12:39she'd actually hung her bag of knives above his bed.
- 1:12:45When they finished, he was loud, he was awake, and he was like,
- 1:12:48Oh no. And he actually, like, pushes
- 1:12:52her off of him, which makes her angry.
- 1:12:54Yeah. She grabbed one of the knives
- 1:12:57and stabs him between the ribs, collapsing one of his lungs.
- 1:13:01He gets up and tries to run away, but his back is an even
- 1:13:03easier target and she stabs him two more times from behind.
- 1:13:07He fell down and she sits on his chest stabbing him over and over
- 1:13:12again. Somehow I don't know if it was a
- 1:13:16rush of adrenaline. He throws her off of him and
- 1:13:18manages to get outside onto the porch before just the adrenaline
- 1:13:23wears off and he kind of succumbs to his injuries.
- 1:13:26She drags him back inside and stabs him to death.
- 1:13:32Then she cleans herself off, drives into town with his car,
- 1:13:37goes to the ATM and empties his bank account.
- 1:13:40Comes home, skins him, hangs the skin from a meat hook from the
- 1:13:45top of the door in the lounge, decapitates him, cooks part of
- 1:13:49his body with baked potatoes, pumpkin beetroot, zucchini,
- 1:13:52cabbage, yellow squash and gravy.
- 1:13:55Puts 2 servings on the table and then puts those and puts the
- 1:13:58names of his children, Rebecca and John, in like little place
- 1:14:04cards on the table. A third meal is tossed in the
- 1:14:07backyard. She put his hot his head in a
- 1:14:11pot with vegetables and then she took the rest of his skinned
- 1:14:15body and arranged it in his favorite chair with his arms
- 1:14:18slung over an empty soda bottle and his legs crossed.
- 1:14:22She leaves a handwritten note with a piece of his skin on it,
- 1:14:25accusing him of raping one of her daughters and his own
- 1:14:30children. Then she takes all of her psych
- 1:14:34meds that were in the Cabot, climbs into the blood soaked bed
- 1:14:38and just waits to die. Wow.
- 1:14:43So I gotta say one thing. While you were mentioning all
- 1:14:46that, the preparation for the food and stuff, my stomach did
- 1:14:49start growling. Oh no.
- 1:14:53Not because it was advertising to me.
- 1:14:55Just because I'm hungry, OK, some Chinese food.
- 1:14:59I just. It's just it was just a funny
- 1:15:03moment. It happened, well, true to their
- 1:15:07word, when he didn't show up for work, his coworkers were like,
- 1:15:11we need to go check on him. In fact, they showed up at 6:00
- 1:15:14AM. Oh oh, they were ready, the
- 1:15:18coworker was greeted with a bloody hamper on the front door
- 1:15:21and a blood smear on the porch leading back inside the house.
- 1:15:24They called the police. Police break in to find a
- 1:15:27comatose Catherine. The first responders are
- 1:15:31horrified. They didn't even understand what
- 1:15:34they were looking at the entire downstairs.
- 1:15:37The stairwell leading down there is just covered in blood.
- 1:15:41And finally, one of the other police officers goes, that's a
- 1:15:45nose, that's pubic hair, and they realize that they are
- 1:15:49looking at John Price's flesh. Later on, they'll discover that
- 1:15:54she actually stabbed him 37 times in many vital organs.
- 1:15:59Most of the men present that day quit working as cops after
- 1:16:02viewing the scene. There were more than one report
- 1:16:05of suicide, and the few who didn't quit stayed away from
- 1:16:12meat for a little bit. In fact, the police arrived
- 1:16:17quick enough to discover that the pot with his head in it was
- 1:16:21still warm, which means that they got there shortly after she
- 1:16:25finished, which also means she didn't have time to die.
- 1:16:28Oh no. They also deduced that the meal
- 1:16:31in the backyard was from her trying the food and being
- 1:16:34disgusted by it. And the interesting thing was
- 1:16:38that the skinning had been done so expertly that after the
- 1:16:42autopsy, the coroner was able to kind of put him back together.
- 1:16:46Oh no, I don't. Know how I don't like that it's
- 1:16:50an awful image, but like, at least he could sort of have an
- 1:16:53open casket. Yeah, sort of, but not anyway.
- 1:16:57Go ahead, listen, skilled mortician could probably make it
- 1:17:01work. Got to cover that neck wound,
- 1:17:03though. Two days later, Catherine wakes
- 1:17:05up from her coma and the police are like, we're ready to
- 1:17:08interview you. But they kind of forgot about
- 1:17:10her mental health issues. Catherine's like, I don't
- 1:17:13remember anything from the past couple days, and if this was the
- 1:17:18first time that Catherine had hurt a man, they might have been
- 1:17:22willing to accept that. But while the police are kind of
- 1:17:26like, well, we got to wait for her to be in a better headspace,
- 1:17:30hundreds of people show up at the police station and they're
- 1:17:33just like, we want to give a statement about Catherine
- 1:17:36Knight. Everyone in in Aberdeen is
- 1:17:40terrified of what will happen if she is ever like let out.
- 1:17:46So the first time she shows up to court, she tries to plead
- 1:17:49guilty for manslaughter, saying that she remembers nothing, but
- 1:17:53obviously she did it because there's evidence.
- 1:17:56The judge is like, this is the worst crime I've ever seen in my
- 1:17:59entire life. Absolutely.
- 1:18:01There is no such thing. You're not even allowed to bleed
- 1:18:04anything right now. Honestly, unless you are
- 1:18:07pleading to 1st degree murder, I don't want to hear you.
- 1:18:10I plead guilty to everything. She was arraigned on March 2nd,
- 1:18:142001, where she entered A plea of not guilty.
- 1:18:17Her child was originally planned for July 23rd, but it got pushed
- 1:18:21back to October 15th, 2001 because her lawyer actually got
- 1:18:24sick during that time, they decided to have her
- 1:18:27psychologically evaluated. Not to prove that she was insane
- 1:18:31or anything, but I just wanted to prove that she was competent
- 1:18:33enough to enter a plea. And that was when she was
- 1:18:37formally given a borderline personality diagnosis.
- 1:18:41But in fact, some of her old psychiatrists came forward and
- 1:18:44were like no, no, no, no, We disagree.
- 1:18:47Don't do this. I'll explain why they said that
- 1:18:51in a little bit. Trying to find a jury for this
- 1:18:54trial was pretty rough. Almost all of Aberdeen knew
- 1:18:57about the legend of Katherine Knight and Justice Barry O'Keefe
- 1:19:00gave the jurors the the opportunity to back out because
- 1:19:04the the pictures of the crime scene were particularly gruesome
- 1:19:07and about 5 people did remove themselves.
- 1:19:10But of the pool about 60 potential jurors, they did find
- 1:19:13enough people for the trial. So the borderline personality
- 1:19:19situation here is that Catherine pretty much said she frequently
- 1:19:23dissociated and had been this is what she did on the night the
- 1:19:26crime happened. Her lawyer used this diagnosis
- 1:19:30to say that she was not culpable for her actions.
- 1:19:33You know, I have to say this because a lot of people don't.
- 1:19:35This is a I wouldn't say it's a rare diagnosis, but it's not as
- 1:19:39common as some of the other ones we've heard.
- 1:19:41Usually when we talk about killers, we hear schizophrenic.
- 1:19:45It's a very hard mental illness to have.
- 1:19:47It's hard to diagnose. But I feel like I should just
- 1:19:51explain it because a lot of people who have mental illnesses
- 1:19:54really find the way that it is portrayed in court to be very
- 1:19:58disrespectful. Yes, Catherine did have some of
- 1:20:03the symptoms, but dissociation is not.
- 1:20:06You forgetting who and where you are and you just black out for a
- 1:20:09month. Dissociation is your mind
- 1:20:12separating itself from the information and stimulus coming
- 1:20:16in. It can affect your sense of
- 1:20:18identity, your sense of self. It affects your sense of time.
- 1:20:22People dissociating report feeling like they are almost
- 1:20:25outside of themselves, watching them experience the world, They
- 1:20:30don't forget what's happening to them.
- 1:20:32It's not a blackout. You're just kind of watching and
- 1:20:35not feeling what's happening. For you, my friends who have had
- 1:20:41this, have told, who have, who have experienced it, have told
- 1:20:47me that they feel just numb and like they're watching themselves
- 1:20:50in a film, it's really hard to explain.
- 1:20:53It's like you're a third person. You're not the first person,
- 1:20:56right? But because this is such a hard
- 1:20:57thing to explain to people who don't understand, it has this
- 1:21:00aspect of her supposed mental illness, and it was definitely
- 1:21:04on purpose. In fact, one of my best friends
- 1:21:06for the last decade has BPD. And you know who this person is,
- 1:21:10Brian. But I won't say their name on
- 1:21:11air because this diagnosis gets a really bad rap.
- 1:21:16People treat you poorly for having it.
- 1:21:18I have come across dozens upon dozens of articles that just are
- 1:21:22like, This is why you shouldn't date someone with BPD.
- 1:21:26It's a very difficult illness to manage and I've known three
- 1:21:28different people in my life who are managing it and are nothing
- 1:21:32like this. Yeah, I know a few as well,
- 1:21:35Catherine and. Her lawyer put on a.
- 1:21:37Whole show. So at the beginning of the trial
- 1:21:41they. You know, read off all of your
- 1:21:43crimes, Catherine begins begging to.
- 1:21:47Leave the courtroom, she cries, and she begins wailing.
- 1:21:50She has an entire fit when they bring out the photos of the
- 1:21:54crime scene and they. Actually have to sedate her.
- 1:21:58Thankfully, the jury didn't care at all.
- 1:22:00If she remembered committing the crime because her bloody
- 1:22:03fingerprints were all over John's house.
- 1:22:05And she was the only person in town, one of the few people in
- 1:22:09town who could fillet a man with that much skill, and the only
- 1:22:12one with the motive to do it. The judge sentenced her to life
- 1:22:16in prison. And then?
- 1:22:17Added to her file never to be released, she was the first
- 1:22:22woman in Australia to receive. This punishment and I remember
- 1:22:26thinking at the time, all because she killed one man.
- 1:22:30Sure it was gruesome, but I read worse.
- 1:22:32But now, after researching this, Catherine Knight was a menace to
- 1:22:38everyone. In Aberdeen, from 15 years old
- 1:22:41to 46, like I get why nobody in this area wanted her there at
- 1:22:46all. So Catherine has been in the.
- 1:22:49Mulloa. High security prison.
- 1:22:51Ever since, she is escorted by 4 armed guards because even
- 1:22:57medicated, they see her as still dangerous.
- 1:23:01She wakes up at 7:00 AM. She eats breakfast in the same
- 1:23:03room as the other prisoners, but nowhere near them.
- 1:23:06They walk her to her job in the prison.
- 1:23:08They handcuff her to her station, which is out of reach
- 1:23:11of all the other inmates where she assembles small intricate
- 1:23:14earpieces. She is very good at her job,
- 1:23:16actually, so good that it's the the job that pays the most in
- 1:23:20the prison and she got it because she's the best doing it
- 1:23:26and interestingly. Enough the.
- 1:23:27Prisoners call her Nana, and she often handles disputes between.
- 1:23:32The women in prison before guards are called.
- 1:23:35Sometimes when they prisoners get upset with the guards, she
- 1:23:38tells them to knock it off and they do.
- 1:23:41Her word is pretty much the law under the law because people are
- 1:23:45still scared of her even now like 20/21.
- 1:23:48She is a 65 year old woman. When she is at cell times, she.
- 1:23:53She's turned her love of meticulous knife work into
- 1:23:56drawings, paintings, pottery, knitting, intricate pieces.
- 1:24:00Her artwork is so good that the prison put it up in the visitor
- 1:24:03and guard section. Some pieces have been sold to
- 1:24:06help fund programs in the prison, but she doesn't find
- 1:24:09them. She doesn't actually like the
- 1:24:11idea of people buying it because she's the killer.
- 1:24:13There are people who would. Exactly there.
- 1:24:17I'm like there. Are people in the States who are
- 1:24:18like, absolutely. I will sign anything you want
- 1:24:21for some money. In the last 20 years, Catherine
- 1:24:24has never. Been given a cellmate.
- 1:24:26The prison thinks that she's still a risk, and so the only
- 1:24:30way to keep everyone else safe around her is to have these
- 1:24:34guards on her whenever she's around anyone.
- 1:24:37She's not allowed to be alone except in herself.
- 1:24:41Honestly, I agree. Like, this is one of those.
- 1:24:43Situations where I am pretty solid in what the courts did
- 1:24:47normally, we're like mad at the justice.
- 1:24:49But I'm like, no, you guys are good.
- 1:24:52NSW high five, absolutely on. Yeah, now a lot of people.
- 1:24:59Who listen to this podcast often e-mail me asking for more modern
- 1:25:03stories. The problem with modern stories
- 1:25:06is that there are people who are still alive like her four
- 1:25:09children, Melissa and Natasha Kellet, Sarah Saunders and Eric
- 1:25:13Chillingworth. These are real people with who
- 1:25:17are in their 30s and 40s and they are just trying to live
- 1:25:21their lives. And not deal with this None of
- 1:25:24her kids have anything to do with her.
- 1:25:26John Price did have three children total, Rebecca,
- 1:25:28Rosemary and John. Rebecca and John.
- 1:25:34There's no mention of them in any publications.
- 1:25:38The one thing I. Did find was that John's
- 1:25:40daughter Rosemary, who was not there when the crimes happened,
- 1:25:43is not fond of sensationalism about her father's death.
- 1:25:47And I found an article where she spoke about how distasteful it
- 1:25:51was that someone was trying to make a movie about him.
- 1:25:54Yeah, I saw that I was. I was looking up and I was.
- 1:25:57Like, and they were going to name it after his nickname for
- 1:26:01her. He called her The Speckled Hen.
- 1:26:03And I'm like, that's it. Term of Endearment.
- 1:26:06I don't want that movie. Catherine did appeal her.
- 1:26:12Life sentence in June of 2006. She said that it was too severe
- 1:26:17to never give her a chance to rehabilitate.
- 1:26:20Justices Peter McClellan, Michael Adams and Megan Latham
- 1:26:24discussed the appeal in September of 2006, and they
- 1:26:28rejected it primarily because. Catherine has never shown any
- 1:26:32remorse for this murder and Justice McClellan wrote in his
- 1:26:35formal response. This was an appalling crime,
- 1:26:39almost beyond contemplation in civilized society.
- 1:26:42I would say he's right, and there's really no way we could
- 1:26:45ever know if Catherine has been rehabilitated.
- 1:26:48And I wouldn't risk trying. To rehabilitate her and put her
- 1:26:52around other people? No, because he even has a
- 1:26:55grandma. She could still slice and dice
- 1:26:59somebody. My God, hell yeah.
- 1:27:01One of the things that was struck.
- 1:27:02By this week's subject is how misogyny protected Catherine
- 1:27:08Knight. None of the men she ever dated
- 1:27:11ever filed a police. Report against her.
- 1:27:13And a lot of that was from the shame of reporting that they
- 1:27:17were abuse victims. I know some of these
- 1:27:20relationships. Were from decades ago, but this
- 1:27:23is still an issue today. Men are being abused by women
- 1:27:27like Catherine. Knight and we just don't talk
- 1:27:29about it and they get laughed at when they report it or mocked by
- 1:27:32both men and women alike. And I I'm just left wondering
- 1:27:35if, globally, the culture around domestic violence was different
- 1:27:40and less misogynistic, then maybe she would have been put in
- 1:27:43prison long before she murdered John Price, right?
- 1:27:46Yeah, this is one of those few times.
- 1:27:49In the podcast. Where I'm not upset with the
- 1:27:51justice system, I'm more upset with society.
- 1:27:57It is the thing. I just like this.
- 1:27:59Just came up like a day or two ago about men and being, you
- 1:28:04know. In relationships with her being
- 1:28:06abused, I'm like, look, if you need someone to talk to, I will
- 1:28:09not judge you at all. Yeah, it's wrong.
- 1:28:12It's it's it's a thing men do get.
- 1:28:15And it's, yeah, it's rough, it's terrible.
- 1:28:17And The thing is, globally around the world, in the 50s,
- 1:28:21sixties, 70s, it was the same way like.
- 1:28:26You didn't want to show that you weren't masculine.
- 1:28:30And sure, Catherine Knight was 6 feet and she was a very several
- 1:28:36of the books I read described to her as having a sculpted
- 1:28:39physique. It's because she was constantly
- 1:28:41lifting, having things. She was built, but not like
- 1:28:45bodybuilder built. Yeah, she was just.
- 1:28:47Like a toned type, right? She was toned, yeah.
- 1:28:49Yeah, and attractive, but like. Regardless of how tall she was.
- 1:28:58Me, it's one of those weird things, cuz in the beginning we
- 1:28:59were like, yay, rah, rah. She's beating up her brothers
- 1:29:02who are touching her. Yeah.
- 1:29:03And then I'm like now she's just beating up everybody.
- 1:29:06Yeah, I I forever. I love how the stories.
- 1:29:09Like devolve into this. Like, yay, I'm cheering for this
- 1:29:13person because they have a like they had a rough time but now
- 1:29:15they're like overcoming it and then you're then eventually it
- 1:29:19becomes like them being the assaulter or like the Yeah, it's
- 1:29:23just. Well, that's the humanity and
- 1:29:25part of why like doing this podcast, because all of these
- 1:29:29people. Are human, which means there is.
- 1:29:34It's multifaceted. There is.
- 1:29:38Good and bad in everybody. Unfortunately, in this case the
- 1:29:42bad was. Very bad.
- 1:29:43It's usually very bad when we talk about these things, but one
- 1:29:47thing that we we learn is that they come from they experience
- 1:29:51some of the the very human things that a lot of us have.
- 1:29:54Some of these people come from broken homes.
- 1:29:56That's pops up all the time. And our our stories or.
- 1:30:02So that's important to me because I I don't know why.
- 1:30:06This is just one of those things that's really important to me,
- 1:30:08which is just even the worst of. Us are still people, and somehow
- 1:30:15me recognizing that allows me to, kind of.
- 1:30:21Know my place. We all have a capacity.
- 1:30:25For evil, and the thing that makes us different from
- 1:30:29everybody else is the fact that we choose not to do it.
- 1:30:33Exactly. That's how we handle it.
- 1:30:35We do it with it. I don't believe in in.
- 1:30:39Looking at people and treating them like they're boogeyman,
- 1:30:43this is a monster. I'm like, this is a person who
- 1:30:47did a monstrous thing. Make no mistakes.
- 1:30:52I talk about people on the tech talk all the time who kill
- 1:30:57people out of love. For other people.
- 1:31:01So never say never, I guess. Yeah, yeah.
- 1:31:05But what do you have for me today, Brian?
- 1:31:09That was a great story. I hated it.
- 1:31:17Oh dude. Goodness gracious.
- 1:31:22So. This week.
- 1:31:24I was let you know that. I I get.
- 1:31:26Lost easily inside of buildings I'm unfamiliar with.
- 1:31:30Oh, like so for my job. You know, I go to hospitals and
- 1:31:34stuff. Like that, right?
- 1:31:34You have to walk through all the finding hospital hallways.
- 1:31:37Uh huh. The worst one is Hershey.
- 1:31:38That's where it is. But like when I first would.
- 1:31:43Go to a hospital. I'd get lost a couple times.
- 1:31:45But they have signs in the walls.
- 1:31:46I'm like OK. Well, at least I don't get that
- 1:31:48lost. I know which way I should be
- 1:31:49heading, but can you just? Imagine if someone.
- 1:31:55Would just would just drop me off inside of like the
- 1:31:59Winchester Mystery House. I love the Winchester Mystery
- 1:32:02House and like at night and I have no idea where.
- 1:32:06The hell I'm going and all those whining in like trap doors and
- 1:32:09stuff. Listen, if we can go there, I
- 1:32:11would absolutely go there with you like.
- 1:32:17I it would take me like. Forever to find my way out of
- 1:32:20that damn. But I've been saving this story.
- 1:32:26It's been in my back pocket for. I don't know since we started
- 1:32:29the freaking podcast, I think, but this is one of my favorites.
- 1:32:33I decided to talk about it since it's getting.
- 1:32:35Closer and. Closer to freaking October.
- 1:32:38Can you believe that? My God, like I'm planning.
- 1:32:43It's what's, say, 25th. It's almost October.
- 1:32:46This. Friday.
- 1:32:47Oh my God. I gotta get a damn costume.
- 1:32:50I know, so I figured. Why not, you know, break it?
- 1:32:56I'm ready. All right.
- 1:32:58So now before we get into you. Know the spooky home house?
- 1:33:03It's it's only right that we delve into the mind of its
- 1:33:07designer creator. Constructor.
- 1:33:11Yeah, whatever. She doesn't do anything, not.
- 1:33:13She just got the plans and she's hired people?
- 1:33:15Yeah, so we're talking about. I feel bad for her.
- 1:33:20Yeah. We'll talk a little bit about
- 1:33:22Sarah Winchester. Herself, she was born Sarah
- 1:33:29Lockwood Party. The daughter of.
- 1:33:32Leonard Party and Sarah Burns. She grew up pretty well off.
- 1:33:37I mean, she spoke like 4 languages, so she spoke 4
- 1:33:41languages. She went to like good schools.
- 1:33:43She was very beautiful and had a very sparkling personality.
- 1:33:48So I can't remember a picture of her, so I'm gonna say she
- 1:33:53pretty. She grew up pretty.
- 1:33:55By the way, her family is from Connecticut.
- 1:33:59Yeah, that's basically where this all started.
- 1:34:02So Connecticut, I know she didn't move West until later.
- 1:34:07Way later. Yeah.
- 1:34:08Yeah, it's a pretty. Safe visit in the fall.
- 1:34:12You know this time of year if. You wanna go to New England?
- 1:34:15Yeah. New England is beautiful.
- 1:34:17Yeah, absolutely. So I couldn't find where they
- 1:34:22met, but on September 30th, 1862, Sarah married William Wert
- 1:34:28Winchester. I imagine if she was rich and he
- 1:34:32was rich. Well, there.
- 1:34:34Yeah, it was arranged. That was the time, wasn't it?
- 1:34:36Yeah. I just wrote a note.
- 1:34:41There's triple. She took no L's.
- 1:34:44Oh my gosh, he was the son of. Oliver.
- 1:34:49Winchester, the owner of the Winchester Repeating Arms
- 1:34:53Company. The creators of the Winchester
- 1:34:57right the Winchester rifle. It's said to.
- 1:35:00Be the gun that won the West. So they.
- 1:35:06Had one child. Her name was.
- 1:35:08Annie Pardi. She unfortunately died about a
- 1:35:13month after she was born. A lot of mysteries have.
- 1:35:18Tuberculosis in. Yeah.
- 1:35:19I'm not sure why. It's very common.
- 1:35:23So tuberculosis was just that, Rona.
- 1:35:25Yeah, it really was. It was that Rona?
- 1:35:28Yes. It was.
- 1:35:29I'm sorry, I'm sorry. That's a poor joke.
- 1:35:32Oh my God. So of course was the run out of
- 1:35:35the. Yeah, of course.
- 1:35:38It was a comedy of these times. So William wasn't spared from
- 1:35:43the disease and succumbed to it in 1881.
- 1:35:50Not a consolation. For having lost her.
- 1:35:52Husband, but she did inherit 20.5. $1,000,000.
- 1:36:01That's about 500 thirty $600.3 million in today's cash.
- 1:36:10It was the entire for chat. Yeah, she got like, no, she got
- 1:36:14half of. Well, yeah, she got.
- 1:36:15Half of the fortune. No, no, she got the whatever
- 1:36:18she's gonna say, Holy Jesus. Also, she did.
- 1:36:21That's a lot of money. That means that the.
- 1:36:24No. What?
- 1:36:24She got half. The family was worth a billion
- 1:36:26dollars. What she got half of was the
- 1:36:28ownership of the Winchester. Repeating arms company Okay.
- 1:36:31So which came with Excuse me, there it.
- 1:36:34Goes my voice, which came with a nice income of $1000 a day.
- 1:36:40That is $26,852. And $0.29 in today's money.
- 1:36:47I love it. You would have been making more
- 1:36:50than I make in. A year in a day like I'm fucking
- 1:36:52sick when I. Read that I was.
- 1:36:55Like the teacher is a thankless and not paying well job.
- 1:37:00Y'all my God, they make. Like goodness.
- 1:37:05Anyway, so this means our and always were a big business.
- 1:37:11Yeah, so this made her one of the.
- 1:37:15Wealthiest women in the world One of the wealthiest women in
- 1:37:19the world? What year would this have been?
- 1:37:2318. I'm missing 18. 8118 That's when
- 1:37:26he died. So cuz I'm trying to remember
- 1:37:29when Madam CJ Walker was she was born in. 1867 and died in 1919.
- 1:37:37She was also one of the most she was like the first black woman
- 1:37:41millionaire. So and she's considered to be
- 1:37:45one of the most rich women of the time.
- 1:37:48And Sarah Winchester is more wealthy than Madam CJ Walker by
- 1:37:53a lot. Oh my God.
- 1:37:56Freaking crazy. So I imagine there weren't too.
- 1:38:00Many women who had that, yeah. But yeah, not the country she's.
- 1:38:05Richest in the freaking. Yeah, 500 times more wealthy.
- 1:38:09It's crazy. And they live around the same
- 1:38:11time. It is crazy.
- 1:38:13Oh my God, I I was still sick. About it so I that's just I.
- 1:38:20Was like the whole. Round.
- 1:38:22Not flat. That's just doing me in fam,
- 1:38:26that's. So much money.
- 1:38:29Oh my God, it's almost unfathomable.
- 1:38:32It's the way that people talk about Jeff Bezos and like he
- 1:38:34makes 300. Is it $300,000 a day?
- 1:38:38Something crazy? And I'm just like I don't.
- 1:38:41Know what that means? Like you're talking about a
- 1:38:43billion. But I really don't understand a
- 1:38:45billion practically. So for me, a billion and 500
- 1:38:53million, same thing. Yeah, basically, I don't
- 1:38:55understand exactly. Yeah.
- 1:38:57It might as well. It might as well be.
- 1:39:00Monopoly money for me, yeah. Cuz I have no idea what's going
- 1:39:03on. So of course.
- 1:39:05Deeply saddened by the passing of her child and husband.
- 1:39:08They did pass 15 years, 15 years apart still.
- 1:39:12But yeah, still, that's exactly she does.
- 1:39:17When any grieving? Person of that time would do
- 1:39:22uhoh, she goes to see a medium. They were all would be so
- 1:39:28disappointed. They were all the rage back
- 1:39:30then. Side note.
- 1:39:33I'm pretty sure that we had that.
- 1:39:36We had that fortune. Telling law in PA.
- 1:39:40Due to freaking Houdini. You remember when I was telling
- 1:39:42you, Remember when I was telling the story about Houdini and how
- 1:39:46he got, he kind of got fortune telling outlawed, right?
- 1:39:49Yeah. I mean, he was pretty aggressive
- 1:39:51about it. Yeah, pretty much lobbying the
- 1:39:54government. And I just remember that they
- 1:39:57were taking advantage of a very. Public.
- 1:39:59This is true. Very true.
- 1:40:02And I'm not mad at him. For it, Yeah.
- 1:40:04I'm not mad. At Houdini, because I know a
- 1:40:06little bit about the story and I feel like Sarah Winchester was
- 1:40:10taken advantage of. So this medium.
- 1:40:15They tell her that the Winchester family is cursed
- 1:40:19because the guns that they made took so many lives.
- 1:40:24So the spirits that were killed by the guns were seeking vented,
- 1:40:28and in order to kind of save herself from the curse.
- 1:40:32Sarah had to build a home for not only herself, but for the
- 1:40:37spirits as well. Yeah, basically you're making
- 1:40:42money off of our. Desks, like, yeah.
- 1:40:47So the medium tells her that. The home was to.
- 1:40:50Be situated in the West where the sunsets so with her
- 1:40:56belongings and. Inheritance.
- 1:40:59That she just, you know. What was that?
- 1:41:02Money is no gotten games. She didn't want it, though, to
- 1:41:06be honest, she would have. Rather had her.
- 1:41:08Husband, Yeah, absolutely. She moves from New Haven.
- 1:41:11Connecticut to San Jose, CA where she purchased an
- 1:41:16unfurnished 8 room farmhouse, the house used to.
- 1:41:21Be yeah, the house. Used to only have 8:00 rooms,
- 1:41:24only 8 rooms. I'll tell you later how many
- 1:41:28rooms it has, I was thinking. So that that that would be
- 1:41:32enough for anybody. Right, just 8 rooms.
- 1:41:34Maybe in their spirits, the spirits can have a room by
- 1:41:36themselves. And you know, yeah, there you
- 1:41:39go. It's only me.
- 1:41:41Yeah, but I guess if your housing goes, they, you know,
- 1:41:44you gotta. Gotta have some.
- 1:41:46Make some renovations. So she hired carpenters,
- 1:41:50builders and laborers, and they worked basically day and night
- 1:41:56on this house. Now I like I said, I remember
- 1:42:01that I've. I've seen multiple things about
- 1:42:03this. How do you sleep?
- 1:42:07And how's your? Your That's constantly under
- 1:42:09construction. Pretty easily.
- 1:42:11My uncle, my grand uncle, he actually.
- 1:42:13Does like house flipping and stuff like that?
- 1:42:15Well, just cuz like, you know, when there's been construction
- 1:42:18or them working on something out in front of my building, I find
- 1:42:22it very bothersome. I don't know.
- 1:42:24I can sleep like the dead so. I definitely noticed that.
- 1:42:30They are making sounds at like 6:00 AM.
- 1:42:37So they worked and worked on it until it was a.
- 1:42:40Seven Story Mansion. Cool, right?
- 1:42:43I didn't know it was seven stories it.
- 1:42:45Was seven stories. Oh geez.
- 1:42:46Wait, was it was 7? When was it 7 stories?
- 1:42:51Back when they first built it. Interesting, cuz it's not that
- 1:42:54big now, no? There's there's a reason why.
- 1:42:59Well, since Sarah didn't use any type of architect, the house no,
- 1:43:05the house was built pretty haphazardly.
- 1:43:07Wait. Wait.
- 1:43:07Wait. Wait.
- 1:43:08Wait, wait, wait. I've seen pictures of this place
- 1:43:10and it looks. Very beautifully done.
- 1:43:12She just picked some random folks from the 1900s Home Depot.
- 1:43:18Yeah, basically. And wait, here you go.
- 1:43:21Well. Actually, she'd have.
- 1:43:22She had a plan. For like the house in.
- 1:43:25As that plan came from her spirit friends.
- 1:43:28Oh, yes. Yes.
- 1:43:30OK. Because the ghost is a good
- 1:43:32Arctic attack. Yes, yes, yes, yes.
- 1:43:35But based on how the rooms. Were built.
- 1:43:37I'm Pretty Little if you on how or on I'm a little if you on if
- 1:43:44She got all of it from the ghost.
- 1:43:46Right So we're getting that way too.
- 1:43:48It looks beautiful. It is.
- 1:43:50It's a. Wonderful looking house, like I
- 1:43:53love a good Victorian. So that's.
- 1:43:55On top of the whole ghost thing, I would want to look at it just
- 1:43:57because it's pretty. Yeah, I know, right?
- 1:43:59I'll go into the specs of the house a little later.
- 1:44:04Or is it a Victorian? Am I right?
- 1:44:05I think it was. Yeah, yeah, yeah.
- 1:44:08So when it was all. Said and done the.
- 1:44:11Had 161 rooms in it. Sarah was.
- 1:44:17So determined to finish the mansion.
- 1:44:18That she lived almost solitude so.
- 1:44:22No, no one lived with her. She only people that were around
- 1:44:24her were the construction workers or the workers that she
- 1:44:27hired. Well, now one thing that I did
- 1:44:29hear about her is that she stayed in mourning her whole
- 1:44:31life, didn't she? Yeah, yeah.
- 1:44:33Cuz she always wore black. The black veil, she always wore
- 1:44:35black. Yep.
- 1:44:37So you know. That was, I guess, in.
- 1:44:39What honor of her husband, Yeah. Terrible.
- 1:44:43Maybe it was for her. Or maybe for the spirits that
- 1:44:47you know that's true. Out of respect for them, Yeah.
- 1:44:53I mean, I wear black all the time anyway.
- 1:44:55So I'm always in mourning as well, across from you also
- 1:44:58wearing. Mostly black.
- 1:45:01We're both in mourning for what? Who?
- 1:45:04We're mourning. Something, My goodness, okay.
- 1:45:06So that was such a dark thought. Okay, Gen.
- 1:45:09Z, Brian. My God.
- 1:45:14Not. Cracking jokes on y'all I find
- 1:45:16Gen. Z humor to be it's pretty
- 1:45:19wonderful. It's pretty nice whenever one.
- 1:45:20Of my coworkers is just like talking about like I hope I can
- 1:45:26get by a bus. I don't have to come.
- 1:45:27Into work tomorrow. I love it.
- 1:45:29I think it's hilarious. I mean, we're millennials, so we
- 1:45:32kind of we get that. We get that shit.
- 1:45:35It's just super funny. It's just it's just bad that
- 1:45:38y'all a younger generation. Like, it's feeling like that.
- 1:45:40Yeah. Like, why are y'all so
- 1:45:41depressed? I'm sorry, it was like we kind
- 1:45:44of did this to you, but hope for the future.
- 1:45:46No. Fuck that shit.
- 1:45:48Oh my God. Oh goodness.
- 1:45:53September 5th, 1922. Sarah passes away in her sleep
- 1:45:57due to a heart failure. Exactly.
- 1:46:01Yep. She was 83.
- 1:46:02Okay, not that young. No, no So.
- 1:46:05And when she died, all construction on the House.
- 1:46:07Pretty much stopped, right? So now let's get into the.
- 1:46:12House cuz there are some. Things I skipped over.
- 1:46:14So we're going backwards and going into the house and all the
- 1:46:18construction. The only things I know for sure
- 1:46:20is that there's a seance room and it's still there, and that
- 1:46:24it's not as many rooms there now as you said, because they
- 1:46:27recently found like the 101st room like 2 summers ago and they
- 1:46:32didn't know where, like they legitimately were, like, look, a
- 1:46:35new room. And I think that's so weird, cuz
- 1:46:38it's been like a monument for decades.
- 1:46:41Yeah, yeah. Historical site, that's what I
- 1:46:44mean. Not.
- 1:46:45A monument. So it did have 161 rooms.
- 1:46:51And it was seven stories, yeah. And.
- 1:46:53There are pictures from this time I don't.
- 1:46:55Not sure. I think there are.
- 1:46:57I'm pretty sure you have. To you have to dig for them.
- 1:46:59But I know you're wondering just what's all behind those doors
- 1:47:03and those 161 rooms. Well, this 24,000 square foot
- 1:47:09mansion includes 40 bathrooms, 2 ballrooms and 9 kitchens and a
- 1:47:16St. Hunt's room.
- 1:47:18Saint Hunt's room was called the Witch's Cap.
- 1:47:20Which is where you know she would Sarah would go to get her
- 1:47:25plans. It's it's from scrolling.
- 1:47:28It looks like a fancy mansion that a rich person like in
- 1:47:32today's time would own. Yeah, if this is.
- 1:47:37So how many square feet? Again 24,000.
- 1:47:43Again, as we sit in my 400 square foot apt.
- 1:47:46I don't understand what that means in real words.
- 1:47:50In real terms. I don't think I've ever been in
- 1:47:53a house that bad. Wait, I think I've.
- 1:47:57Been something close to that. But that's about it.
- 1:48:00That sounds like the equivalent of like a stadium.
- 1:48:05I maybe have to see how. Fucking Big A.
- 1:48:07Stadium is but like on. Her property?
- 1:48:10She has like, orchards too, yeah.
- 1:48:14So a lot of people go there. They get.
- 1:48:15Married too, I. Went on the website.
- 1:48:16They have wedding stuff there too, and it's like, what?
- 1:48:20There's also a plantation. This is true.
- 1:48:23So true. Oh my God, so.
- 1:48:26There are also 47 fireplaces, over 10,000 panes of glass, 2000
- 1:48:31doors, 52 skylights, 2 basements and three elevators in this
- 1:48:37house. Yeah, yeah, that's there it
- 1:48:40goes. Coal tower.
- 1:48:42There it goes. That's the only one.
- 1:48:44I just wanted to see a picture of.
- 1:48:45What? It looked like in the past and
- 1:48:49as you can. Tell she spared no.
- 1:48:51Calls. No calls to spared.
- 1:48:54Some of the same glass windows were made by Tiffany.
- 1:48:57The Tiffany's are expensive. Yes, yes.
- 1:48:59Talking about $1,000,000 window panes, yes, she was not kidding
- 1:49:03when. They.
- 1:49:04She listen. They spent the money, those told
- 1:49:06me. Build a house.
- 1:49:07But they didn't say it had to be a a crappy house, right?
- 1:49:11I can still be booed. Like I got a living here too.
- 1:49:13Might as well look. Just so sad to think of her
- 1:49:17living in that big place. All along, I know.
- 1:49:19Really terrible. I'm pretty sure she had like,
- 1:49:21you know. Servants, probably servants.
- 1:49:25But still, she didn't have, like, any boyfriend.
- 1:49:29No family, nothing. Yeah, family.
- 1:49:31She. Just lived in a big old
- 1:49:34Victorian dress, but it spray with a black thing over her eyes
- 1:49:38all the time. It's terrible.
- 1:49:39It's so sad. It's terrible.
- 1:49:44So inside this beast. Of a mansion there are.
- 1:49:48Also, stairways that lead to nowhere.
- 1:49:51Yep, right into the roof rooms. You can open the doors too.
- 1:49:57But it just leads you to a brick wall.
- 1:50:00I like the one that's just a straight up drop.
- 1:50:02Yeah, yeah, they're trap doors in.
- 1:50:06Spy holes, of course. Secret passageways in big rooms
- 1:50:11with small rooms inside of them. Okay.
- 1:50:13So what if what if? Oh my gosh, you could have a
- 1:50:16slumber party there. Yes.
- 1:50:22I don't think they let people sleep there because when Shama
- 1:50:26Day and Ryan Bergueira went, they only got to be there at
- 1:50:31night. They didn't sleep there.
- 1:50:34I would. So I don't know if they let you
- 1:50:35sleep there, but I just. Think that would be super fun?
- 1:50:37That would be awesome. I think because of how expensive
- 1:50:39all the chandeliers and stuff are, they wouldn't trust people
- 1:50:42to stay there. I mean, it makes sense normally.
- 1:50:44Like when they let you stay at a place, it's garbage.
- 1:50:47It's very true. Like all the old, you know?
- 1:50:49Yes, sanitariums or trashed. Sure, you can stay here.
- 1:50:54They're overcoming with freaking wilderness.
- 1:50:56Why not? You can stay here all night if
- 1:50:57you want. To fancy houses with Tiffany
- 1:51:00chandeliers and windows. You may not stay here.
- 1:51:02You can do your ghost hunt and get the hell out.
- 1:51:06I'm sorry that. Characterization is me, not the
- 1:51:09Westchester Mystery House. I'm sure they're very nice
- 1:51:14people, so. Like I said this.
- 1:51:18The spirits would. They, you know, they gave Sarah.
- 1:51:19Her plans, Right. And that's she got those from
- 1:51:22her little seances. Yeah, yeah.
- 1:51:24But she would also add in. These little additions like the
- 1:51:31so that. She could.
- 1:51:33You know confuse the spirits that were that was talking her
- 1:51:36and you know they were out for vengeance so you know they and
- 1:51:39that's why it moved around like she would build A room and then
- 1:51:42destroy it. There's just a lot of
- 1:51:45construction going on, Ghost. You thought this was a bathroom
- 1:51:48psych brick wall on your face. Even though ghosts can go
- 1:51:54through. But whatever.
- 1:51:55Yeah, who cares? She.
- 1:51:59Really loved the number 13. Right.
- 1:52:01A lot of the things you see in her in the house.
- 1:52:04There there's a lot of 13 things, right?
- 1:52:07I've heard that during the tour they, like, encourage you to
- 1:52:09count the stuff. Yeah, like the stairs, there are
- 1:52:11a lot of stair of stairways. Or staircases.
- 1:52:14They have 13 stairs. The ones that I've I've seen
- 1:52:17pictures of are like the long stairs, which I find to be
- 1:52:21annoying. Like instead of it being a
- 1:52:23normal step distance, yeah, it's like a foot across or like 2
- 1:52:27feet long. And what is the point So you can
- 1:52:31have more beats, more people walking the stairs?
- 1:52:33What's? The point of a stairwell.
- 1:52:36That's that. Long it just has to be like
- 1:52:39horizontal stairway goodness. Art is also.
- 1:52:45Like, really tight corridors too.
- 1:52:47Yeah, if you're counting. There are also 13 bathrooms.
- 1:52:54See. Yeah, now why is she like was
- 1:52:57her her liking of 13? Cuz she liked it.
- 1:53:00I think it's the same way. Why I like 13 cuz it's just a
- 1:53:02the creepy number. That and it's just a nice.
- 1:53:06It's a lucky number. Too, sometimes it's already,
- 1:53:08Look, it's hard to be lucky. Well, yeah, depending on what
- 1:53:10culture you're in. Absolutely isn't like for an
- 1:53:13unlucky number in like China. Somewhere I actually meant to
- 1:53:16make a tick. Talk about that.
- 1:53:16I forgot all about that. God.
- 1:53:17Damn it. Anyway, so in either 19 oh. 6 or
- 1:53:221904. I got different sources.
- 1:53:25So there's an earthquake in California.
- 1:53:28Yeah, the big earthquake, yeah, which damaged.
- 1:53:31The house causing the top three floors.
- 1:53:33To collapse. And at the end of it, they
- 1:53:38weren't built, They weren't rebuilt.
- 1:53:40So that left the mansion with only four stories.
- 1:53:43That's the seven stories. That's the big.
- 1:53:45That's the San Francisco one that like set San Francisco on
- 1:53:48fire. Yeah, that's that.
- 1:53:49That's that big. I guess it wait, I must add up
- 1:53:51some pretty. Serious reverberations of it.
- 1:53:53Was that that one? Well, that's the one that
- 1:53:55happened in 19. Okay then yes, that's just so I
- 1:53:59was like there. Was a big one in the early 1900s
- 1:54:01that like, racked San Francisco. Like everything fell down.
- 1:54:07That's that one then. OK, wow.
- 1:54:09And. What city is this one in?
- 1:54:11I'm gonna say San Jose. California.
- 1:54:16OK, so San Francisco to San Jose, How far away is that?
- 1:54:24Come on. Google tell me the mile would
- 1:54:28that's 50 miles away. Oh yeah, so.
- 1:54:30Yeah, it definitely that's, yeah.
- 1:54:31I mean, it was like I said it's. One of the worst California
- 1:54:34earthquakes. But to be able to knock down
- 1:54:37buildings 55 miles away, that's intense.
- 1:54:41I mean, remember that we had an earthquake, like, years.
- 1:54:44And years ago, that was in California.
- 1:54:46But we fell all the way in fucking Philadelphia.
- 1:54:48Wait, was that really that? No, it wasn't that one.
- 1:54:51But when was it I was in? School, right?
- 1:54:55I was in school then. Like Colonary Art School and
- 1:55:002010, 2011, I think it was there was an earthquake in California.
- 1:55:06You felt it all wait in Philadelphia and because
- 1:55:10everything was like shaking and we were like, what the hell was?
- 1:55:12That and. Then they ended class early.
- 1:55:13It was like it was an earthquake.
- 1:55:16Apparently it was on one of those fault lines that, you
- 1:55:19know, you could fill it, but I was just really, I googled
- 1:55:22California earthquake felt on East Coast.
- 1:55:25Yeah, and it. Hmm.
- 1:55:31Maybe I got the wrong information.
- 1:55:32Well, no, there was there. Was an earthquake that happened
- 1:55:36on the East Coast. Yeah, because it broke the, the
- 1:55:40giant obelisk in Washington, It's, I think it's called the
- 1:55:43Washington Monument. It's, I know it's an obelisk.
- 1:55:46It's an obelisk. I listen.
- 1:55:48I know certain words. Here I am using 15th grade
- 1:55:53words, but I can't remember the name of the monument.
- 1:55:55Yes. Or is I think my 25?
- 1:55:59Dollar words, but I'm forgetting basic stuff.
- 1:56:01But yeah, it's the Washington Monument.
- 1:56:03It cracked. It's it's been cracked.
- 1:56:04It was like the made. Oh, that's like the. 2012. 2013,
- 1:56:11around the time I remember, because I was on the phone with
- 1:56:14somebody and I was sitting in my bed and the TV started shaking
- 1:56:17and I I literally said to him on the phone, is this an
- 1:56:21earthquake? And then, apparently, everyone
- 1:56:25started. Calling each other and the cell
- 1:56:27phone towers got overloaded and I couldn't talk to anybody for
- 1:56:30like 15 minutes. Yeah, and that was when I lived
- 1:56:33in Philadelphia. So that.
- 1:56:34Sounds like I remember that one. Is that the same one?
- 1:56:37I know this happened in like 2010, 2011 so.
- 1:56:40That's because that's when I was in a Colony art school.
- 1:56:42That's the only reason why. I know we were there two, but we
- 1:56:46in Philadelphia at the same time?
- 1:56:47Probably fun. We didn't know each other.
- 1:56:51Oh my goodness. Anyway.
- 1:56:53Back to the story. I'm so.
- 1:56:55Sorry yo, we are off of rails tonight.
- 1:56:57Goodness, the man is when we start the podcast late.
- 1:57:00This is. True, late in the day, we're all
- 1:57:02wound up. So the mansion was showed.
- 1:57:05Shortly after Sarah's death. Like a couple months after she
- 1:57:09died, the mansion was sold to John and Main Brown.
- 1:57:17Like in five months after her death, John opened the house to
- 1:57:22the public for tours. I thought you were gonna tell me
- 1:57:25that something bad happened to him.
- 1:57:27No, I was ready for it even. Our boy Harry Houdini was there.
- 1:57:33To take it, check it out because he was on his spiritualism tour.
- 1:57:38He was there to prove that there were no ghosts, basically, that
- 1:57:41the mediums were bullshit. Basically, he was, you know, he
- 1:57:45was there to expose. Spiritualism for the fraud it
- 1:57:47was, anyway. He didn't know what to make of
- 1:57:50the house, and like he walked away with like more.
- 1:57:55Questions than answer. Because it was just like a weird
- 1:57:58ass house to him. And he gave it the name.
- 1:58:01The Winchester Mystery House. Really.
- 1:58:04Yeah. Yeah, yeah.
- 1:58:05What did he He gave it that moniker.
- 1:58:08Wow. I never knew sorry.
- 1:58:10And then went with that Harry. Houdini.
- 1:58:14That's for boy, that is. My boy.
- 1:58:17God damn it. That was just a personal joke
- 1:58:23between us and Hams. That's pretty much it so.
- 1:58:28Over the years since. Since the.
- 1:58:30Mansion became an attraction. Visitors and staff have
- 1:58:35reported. Encounters.
- 1:58:38Yes, like footsteps when no one's in there in the room.
- 1:58:42Strange voices, doors banging, strange lights, doorknobs
- 1:58:47turning by themselves just playing creepy stuff.
- 1:58:51The worst part about like a door banging, like here, small
- 1:58:54apartment, The door closes and I'm like, Yup, there you go,
- 1:58:57that's the ghost. You're in that place.
- 1:58:59What door is banging? What direction do I even go
- 1:59:02towards? You just let it go.
- 1:59:03You gotta just let it go. Yeah, imagine it, Echo.
- 1:59:05You just gotta. Let it go.
- 1:59:07I imagine being the. Security guard there would be
- 1:59:10rough, yeah. But you have to have one, yeah.
- 1:59:14True, this is also a great. Place for mediums or psychics to
- 1:59:20come. Goodness gracious, gotcha.
- 1:59:24Yeah, psychics to come and put their two cents in.
- 1:59:27Test it out. Yeah, I'm sure they all
- 1:59:31experience. Sarah Winchester.
- 1:59:32Ohh, I'm sure they do. Everyone talks to Sarah.
- 1:59:36They you know what my hope is. I hope she.
- 1:59:39Passed like I hope she passed on to whatever ohh I got you
- 1:59:44afterlife that there is and she. Really isn't there at her house?
- 1:59:47Just walking around sad. Yeah, 100 years later.
- 1:59:51Goodness. But they have said.
- 1:59:54That there are. Spirits there at the house, and
- 1:59:59one in particular is Sarah Winchester.
- 2:00:02I hope not. The Hall of Fires.
- 2:00:06Is a good spot. To visit if you want to
- 2:00:09experience something paranormal named for all the fireplaces in
- 2:00:13it, right? Okay.
- 2:00:15I have heard of that before, so a man was in the room helping
- 2:00:19with. The renovations or to restore it
- 2:00:21when he feels a tap on his shoulder turns around?
- 2:00:25No one's there. He's like, huh, weird.
- 2:00:28Turns back around to go back to work and he feels this like hand
- 2:00:33on on his back was pushing him like very hard into his back and
- 2:00:38then he's just like, you know what?
- 2:00:42I think they need help in. That other room, so.
- 2:00:45I'm just gonna go down. The hall or.
- 2:00:46I mean, he did exactly what the ghost wanted.
- 2:00:48The ghost was like, get out. There's an old worker there.
- 2:00:55His name is Clyde and he's a ghost.
- 2:00:59And he hangs out in the basement, right?
- 2:01:01That is where Ryan and Shane both did their little solo ghost
- 2:01:07thing. Ooh.
- 2:01:10In the basement, so. This mansion is.
- 2:01:16Open for tours this year. I'm saying yeah, like I could go
- 2:01:22to San. Jose, they have it.
- 2:01:26Deviates a lot. From when it was like just
- 2:01:30giving tours about it, it like nowadays they have axe throwing
- 2:01:34at the at the table. Oh no, listen, axe throwing was
- 2:01:37awesome. There's a freaking Harry Houdini
- 2:01:40escape room theme. Thing going on there.
- 2:01:42So I mean, they gotta make their money.
- 2:01:44Yeah, like it's been like it's become a lot more.
- 2:01:48Than a spooky. Insanely built house.
- 2:01:51It's just like it's actually like an attraction now for
- 2:01:54people to go to and if they wanna do, I just wanna see the
- 2:01:59architecture. Yeah, I just wanna.
- 2:02:01Also, she had a thing for Spider.
- 2:02:02Webs and a lot of if you go there and look, a lot of the
- 2:02:07windows, there's a lot of spider web designs.
- 2:02:10Cool as well. But you have a kindred spirit.
- 2:02:15I know, right? Spiders. #13 Harry Houdini came
- 2:02:19to my house. Not really.
- 2:02:21I wish. But you can.
- 2:02:25Go there and pretend to be Sarah Winchester.
- 2:02:27There you go, Harry. What are you?
- 2:02:30Talking about Ghost, no. Ghost anyway.
- 2:02:33That's what I got today. I like that one.
- 2:02:38Goodness, I love the I I would. Love to visit?
- 2:02:41It's still on my list of places to go.
- 2:02:42Yeah, yeah, absolutely that and even even going to.
- 2:02:45California to visit Mr. Or is it California?
- 2:02:48Is it in Las Vegas? Which?
- 2:02:50What? The mansion?
- 2:02:54Not to Mansion Museum by. Oh, you mean Zach Bagan's
- 2:02:58museum? Yeah, that museum.
- 2:02:59It's in Vegas. OK.
- 2:03:01I go to Vegas one day. You go and visit, I guess.
- 2:03:04Just to see. I don't want to see the dolls
- 2:03:06there and then look at his stupid.
- 2:03:09Stuff and not has like the mirrors and.
- 2:03:11Stuff he has the. Dibic box there too, I thought.
- 2:03:15He only got to wait. I think it's there.
- 2:03:19I'm pretty sure it's there. I know that he got to open the
- 2:03:22dibic box, which you're not supposed to do.
- 2:03:24Why would you do? But I thought the man who owned.
- 2:03:27It keeps it secure like he buries.
- 2:03:31It like he has not taken it out. I'm not sure.
- 2:03:34I think I did hear that. It was either that or something
- 2:03:37that he had there. It might have been like an
- 2:03:40exhibit for a short amount of time, yeah.
- 2:03:44But. I had to look into that.
- 2:03:45Anyway, thank you guys. For listening this week, if you
- 2:03:49wanted to follow this on Socials, you got Britney
- 2:03:53Podcast. I'm on TikTok and I am Creeps
- 2:03:56for Brian. I've been trying to post more
- 2:03:57stuff on there. So yeah, check it out.
- 2:03:59I got more shit, I got what is it?
- 2:04:02What am I doing? Scripted or urban legends in
- 2:04:05your state. So yeah, that's cool.
- 2:04:08And most of our socials you can. Find the links to.
- 2:04:10On our website wentkillersgotcaught.com Yes,
- 2:04:14yes and if you listened this. Whole 2 hours.
- 2:04:17Thank you so much. We do appreciate it.