Latest / SPEAK LIKE A CEO / 276: Atomic Statements, Apes & Ants, and the New Science of Storytelling. Will Storr
Transcript
- 0:00Welcome back to the show. My guest today is none other than Will's door. Will's books
- 0:04are the signs of storytelling and the status game have had a profound impact on my thinking
- 0:09and have become part of how I try to make sense of the world. And now, he's standing again with his
- 0:13new book, The Story Is A Deal. The book is not a simple ABC recipe for telling better stories to
- 0:19close a deal, although we do talk about that as well. Our conversation goes way deeper and will
- 0:25impacts why narratives are the foundation of human success, what that means for you,
- 0:30and how story can transform the way you communicate, lead, and persuade. Enjoy this world view
- 0:34altering conversation with one of my intellectual heroes, Will's door. Well, thanks for coming on
- 0:40the show. Thanks, Abby Oliver. It's great to be here. I love your new book, I have to say,
- 0:43and in the book you write that humans live in two worlds, Ed Wands. So what are these worlds?
- 0:49So like all animals, we live in a world of survival. We want to have food, oxygen, shelter,
- 0:57procreation. So in that sense, we're no different from any other creature. But humans
- 1:03uniquely live in this other world, which is this story world. And indeed, that's what we
- 1:06send most of our psychological time. We experience our lives as great unfolding narrative,
- 1:12or which we're at the center of. We're on constant quests, which are the plots of our lives. We're
- 1:17surrounded by this cast of characters who are not just other humans, but they're heroes and villains
- 1:21and teachers and allies and all these other things. So it's this story world. This is really
- 1:28the main focus of our conscious lives. Right. I think that's not easy to get your head round,
- 1:33right? Because we assume we live in reality. We think about the world as it is, rather than the
- 1:38story world in our heads. That's right. But every animal has a completely different,
- 1:43they call it an unvelta, you know, perception of what reality is. Like a dog lives in a world of
- 1:47smell and a knifefish lives in a world of electricity and a blood sucking tick lives in a world where
- 1:52they're just sitting on a top of a blade of grass waiting to jump onto something to suck its blood.
- 1:56And all they can do is smell and feel temperature. But humans, you know, are in that story.
- 2:02So we have evolved uniquely to experience the world as this story. And it's the secret of
- 2:08our success. It's that that separates us from the rest of the animals because story is,
- 2:12you know, turns out to be this incredible technology for solving problems.
- 2:18What's the evolution? There are a reason for us to live in a story world.
- 2:22Well, the way that I see it is that there have been three great kind of technological leaps,
- 2:27as it were, in evolutionary history. Now, the first one, if you track our family tree back
- 2:333.8 billion years, so the root of our family tree collectively, there's a single cell bacteria,
- 2:38that's the earliest form of life on earth. And the single cell bacteria is this machine for
- 2:43overcoming obstacles in pursuit of goals. But it's a very simple machine in the sense that it just
- 2:47is like an algorithm. So it can sense what's happening outside it. It can set us up
- 2:52and inside it. And it has these kind of, you know, x, y decisions. If this is the situation,
- 2:58I'm going to do this. So that's, you know, it's very successful in its way. But it's not very good
- 3:03at dealing with unpredictable environments. And of course, what is life on earth if it isn't
- 3:08unpredictable. So then evolution comes up with this brand new technology for overcoming obstacles
- 3:15in pursuit of goals. And that technology is the feeling system. And the feeling system is
- 3:19amazing because it doesn't instruct its owner what to do. It advises. So if you're a mouse and
- 3:24you're hungry and you see some toast crusts over there by the bin, you think I'm going to get
- 3:28the toast crust. But then you see a cat. And so you feel a new feeling, which is fear. And so you
- 3:33can make a rational calculation based on its feelings. Do I go for the crust or do I wait to
- 3:38the cat's gone? So feelings are an incredible, incredible invention for overcoming obstacles
- 3:43in pursuit of goals. And with the most successful technology on earth for millions and millions of
- 3:48years. But then, you know, somewhere around 50 to 100,000 years ago, even as you've got this brand
- 3:53new thing, which was story. And we are the only animal on earth that has this capacity. And story
- 4:00is a fantastic technology for overcoming obstacles in pursuit of goals because it allows us to do it
- 4:03collectively. We can share information about how to do that. We can store it in culture.
- 4:09Story fuses human brains together. So we're all directed on the same obstacles and the same goals.
- 4:15And we're all, we're all, it's a story allows us to behave not like individual apes,
- 4:20which is what we were. But is this kind of collective super organism?
- 4:25That is so fascinating. And does it apply to all of us? Because, you know, I work with engineers,
- 4:31I work with, you know, financially minded CEOs and so on. And I'm sure you do too. So they often
- 4:38push back and say, yeah, most people, but not me. Of course, like all these things, there's a,
- 4:45you know, some of us are more than others. But yeah, absolutely. We all experience our lives as
- 4:50story. I mean, in the lives of those, you know, usually very successful people that you're dealing
- 4:56with, they experience their lives as being absolutely drenched in meaning that the mission of their
- 5:00life, whether it's to build this company or to solve this engineering problem, is of immense
- 5:05importance to them, you know, and that's part of the storytelling brain. It's that, you know,
- 5:09it's that part of us, which says these goals, I mean, no other animal tries to solve problems
- 5:13like this, you know, you know, in this kind of crazy way. And not only is it of immense importance
- 5:18to them, it's also against surrounded by a cast of story characters. There'll be heroes on their
- 5:23team and people at this effect of villains on their team. There are great rivals and other companies
- 5:27that they're trying to compete against. And so it's all story stuff. It's all talking. It's all,
- 5:31you know, it's all it's all the great mission that we're all on to achieve our quests and arrive
- 5:41at our imagined happy endings. I mean, we all have our own stories, of course, but are there
- 5:45archetypes of stories that people tell themselves? Yeah, I mean, I think there are some basic shapes
- 5:51of story. I mean, one of the basic shapes, one of the basic sort of archetypes, which I think
- 5:56is universal, is the underdog. So the underdog is, it is an immensely popular and successful character
- 6:03in story. And the most successful characters in global storytelling are underdogs. I mean,
- 6:09everything from Luke Skywalker back when I was a kid to Squid Game, you know, the character
- 6:15in the central Squid Game is a classic underdog that they spend the first 20 part minutes,
- 6:18half an hour of that show showing you all the ways in which he's this total loser, you know,
- 6:22and it's surrounded by all these problems. And so, so, so, I mean, I think it's part of the
- 6:27story's ending brain that we continually feel like the underdog, even the most successful people
- 6:31in the world feel like the underdog because that's life. Life is immense obstacles and amazing
- 6:38goals and the feeling of struggling a lot, you know, our winds are temporary, they're fleeting,
- 6:42the struggle is eternal. And part of the, you know, the evolutionary purpose of storytelling
- 6:48is to say you can do it, you know, it's an inherent part of the underdog that they're optimistic,
- 6:52despite all their challenges, they still go on and they still push on and they still push on.
- 6:56And it's that, you know, that that's the kind of propaganda role of storytelling to encourage us
- 7:01to make us feel like these underdogs, no matter how bad things get, you've got to keep pushing,
- 7:05and that's a universal. So, in every culture in the world, you find underdog stories.
- 7:09I love that. And yeah, I think it makes a lot of sense that we all see ourselves as sort of
- 7:14the plucky underdog that overcomes obstacles and pursuit of a goal. And it's interesting that
- 7:18you chose the word underdog rather than hero because the hero also starts from a sort of
- 7:23disadvantage position and then has to grow to become the hero, you know, a born hero, you become
- 7:28the hero in the cause of your quest. That's right. Yeah. So, so in archetypal hero stories,
- 7:35the hero is never the hero on page one, in that one, they're an underdog. So,
- 7:40they're struggling, they're low status, and they're often flawed and the way that the protagonist
- 7:46becomes heroic is by overcoming their flaws and by overcoming their flaws, they solve their problems,
- 7:51they achieve their goals. And then when they do in act three, then they're the hero and they're
- 7:55celebrated and they're rewarded with the great social rewards of connection, tribal connection.
- 8:00So, everybody's applauding them and loves them and status. So, they're heroes, they're highly valued
- 8:04in that community. And that's what we all want to assume. That's basic worrying of the storytelling
- 8:09cognition is that we all crave connection and the feeling of being loved and we all crave status,
- 8:14the feeling of being valued. Right. I think that's such a central insight, right? Once our survival
- 8:19is secured, which is not a given obviously in this world, of course. But let's say survival is
- 8:24secured, it's connection and it's status that we're looking for, and connection people like us,
- 8:29or any person. Yeah, I mean, so connection is kind of local. We've evolved to be this highly
- 8:37cooperative collaborative ape. So, we're part ape, part ant essentially. And that's our
- 8:43superman, that's what makes this amazing. But what that means is we're continually looking
- 8:48out into the world for people who are suitable for us to collaborate with. I mean, that's not going
- 8:52to be everybody. This is going to be people who are a bit like us who experience the world in the
- 8:55same way have similar values come from similar backgrounds. So, you know, there's a dark side
- 9:00as a course, which is xenophobia. It can manifest as racism, misogyny, homophobia, all these other
- 9:06things, misandry, whatever it might be. But it's not all bad. I mean, you know, a marriage is an
- 9:13act of people like us. You're looking out into the world for somebody who's like you enough that
- 9:19you can cooperate with them for your life with the, you know, evolutionarily speaking, raising
- 9:24children together. So, you know, instead of friends, you know, friends are very similar. And
- 9:29colleagues are also hopefully very similar in the sense that they're all pushing towards the
- 9:35same goals, though, that they all value the goals of the organization. And they're all trying to
- 9:41cooperate and collaborate with each other to achieve the goals of the organization.
- 9:46That's right. I mean, we can't even pursue a goal without collaborating with other people
- 9:51without connecting. And the most successful people tend to be the ones who have great connections,
- 9:55are great with people as well. But you said something. We're part eight and part and I'd love
- 10:00to double click on that. So, please say more. Yeah. So, so, so, you know, answer, you know, the
- 10:06scientists refer to an ant's nest as a super organism in that it's made up of individual
- 10:11ants, you know, millions of individual ants. But each ant plays their particular role. And so,
- 10:17they're almost like cells in a greater body. And you can see human groups as a super organism too.
- 10:22You know, I mean, ants communicate with pheromones, with smell, we communicate with stories. And so,
- 10:29you know, an organization is a kind of ants nest with everybody's playing their particular role
- 10:36in the super organism in order to achieve the goals of the of the organization. And again,
- 10:41that's our superpower. And what makes that super about work is story. A company tells a story
- 10:48about the world about what our values are, about what our goals are, about what our problems are,
- 10:52about who our rivals are, about the ways we ought to be in order to have a comma obstacles in
- 10:57pursuit of growth or whatever, or, you know, beating our rivals. And it's that story that fuses
- 11:03the brains of all those employees together and gets them all thinking as one, gets them all
- 11:07working as this incredible super organism, which is again, it's our superpower is the thing that
- 11:12is enabled us to take over the world. Yeah, absolutely. Pushback could be bad. Okay, ants don't have
- 11:18free world, don't we have free world, at least free choice? Yeah, we're not literally ants. I mean,
- 11:24answer pure, yeah, answer, answer a kind of pure, pure super organism in that way. And of course,
- 11:31we do have free choice. But I don't think we have as much free choices we might like to think,
- 11:36you know, we're compelled by a very powerful subconscious. And that very powerful subconscious
- 11:41is really what's in control of our behavior and what's in control of our choices. And how the
- 11:45brain works is that we tell stories about our choices. And those stories tend to be, I chose that
- 11:50of my own free will. But often we don't. So I mean, we, they call it confabulation. We tell these
- 11:55stories. I mean, there's a very, very famous study where I'm a very simple study where scientists
- 12:01got these people, these women. And I'm going to, to, to flick through some, I don't know if they're
- 12:07bikinis or, or, you know, underwear or something. And I'm asking to choose their favorite item
- 12:13from the, from the rag. And it's just a known rule that you tend to like the best, the last thing
- 12:19that you've seen. So most of the people just chose the last thing that they'd seen. And when they
- 12:23asked that women, you know, why did you choose this? They come up with all these flowery descriptions
- 12:28and explanations and about why they chose this thing. And when it was suggested to them, well,
- 12:33actually, maybe you chose it just because this is the last thing you'd seen. You know, they said
- 12:35they looked at the experience like they were mad. Like what are you talking about? You're insane.
- 12:39Yeah. And so that's the story setting brain. And it kind of, it kind of shows you, you know,
- 12:43the extent to which we are mostly subconscious. And that subconscious wants these two things. It
- 12:48wants us to be a good member of the super organism. So it wants to seek out and attract us to people
- 12:52like us. So we're constantly looking out for people who are like us. And that's what we spend so
- 12:56much time on our appearance and we're, we fuss about our hair and I've got my books in the background.
- 13:00Everything we do is broadcasting out to the human world. Who am I? What are my values? What are my
- 13:06roles? You know, and it's trying to, it's trying to better attract other people like us to me. So
- 13:11we can work together, but also repel people not like us who are not going to be useful to me.
- 13:15So that's why we spend so much money on clothes. I mean, that's, that's a huge part of the global
- 13:19economy is the money we spend on our identity. The money we spend communicating subconsciously
- 13:24to other people. Who am I? How do I see the world? What are my values? And that's because we're,
- 13:29you know, we're always wanting to be members of the super organism. And the other second thing
- 13:33that we all want is status. So we're constantly fussing about these people like us. Do they value me?
- 13:38Have I pleased them? Am I being useful to them? So that's also a huge subconscious most
- 13:43in human life. Yeah, for sure. And what does that mean for business? Let's start sort of internally
- 13:49within the company. And obviously, let's assume there's a there's leadership and the
- 13:54people who work in the company. How relevant is storytelling within such an organization?
- 13:59Maybe it's super organism. Maybe a big business or big organizations also super organism.
- 14:04Well, it's massively important. It's hugely important. And I think it's important is,
- 14:07it is understated even in today's world where people talk about having to work storytelling for a
- 14:13lot a long time. It's a story that binds the group together. And it's part of a leader's job
- 14:19to communicate that story and even embodied that story. You know, I mean,
- 14:23psychologists talk about good leaders being prototypical. So good leaders don't
- 14:28lead from the top of the mountain, you know, issuing orders and punishments and and
- 14:33bribing with money. I mean, we still have this is kind of industrial revolution mindset that
- 14:36money is how you motivate people. And actually, money motivates you in a short term.
- 14:40We've all had a pay rise before. We're really pleased for about four days. Let me forget about
- 14:44the pay rise. You know, we go, you all I deserved in it. You know, you know, so that's not really
- 14:49what motivates people. What motivates people is this connection and status? Is that feeling that I
- 14:54feel connected to this group? I identify with this mission. What the group wants I personally want.
- 14:59So everything that I'm going to do now is for the group and for our mission. And that's part of me.
- 15:04So when the group wins, I win. When the group says to me, well done, you've done amazing. I feel
- 15:08fantastic. And I go home, feeling that my life has meaning and purpose. And this is true for CEOs
- 15:13and for people who are feeling the toilets. It's true for everybody. So, so that's how important
- 15:19it is. I mean, you know, really an organization can live or die by the power of the storytelling
- 15:26that the organization and the leader communicates down to the organization.
- 15:32Yeah. And I think to me, there's a bit of a crisis and leadership communications that you
- 15:36alluded to. You talked about the industrial revolution mindset. And in a way, we are still a
- 15:41little bit stuck in that, I feel. And when you look at the agents and we do the ages and so on,
- 15:46leaders told stories. That's how they, you know, motivated people to follow them. That's how
- 15:51they organize society, whether it's kings of priests or aristocracy. And then the industrial age came
- 15:58and all became the sort of conveyor belt about the numbers. And we forgot about that a little bit.
- 16:03It's coming back, thanks to people like yourself. But would you agree that there's a bit of a,
- 16:08you know, just a historical dip in the ability and understanding of storytelling?
- 16:12Yeah. And I think that it's because we're in this, you know, post industrial revolution age,
- 16:17where which values money very highly. And there's nothing wrong with that. There's nothing wrong
- 16:20with money. We were all capitalists here. But I guess that's not the thing that fundamentally
- 16:25motivates people. And you know, you push back a little before about saying, we're not like
- 16:29ants, we have free will. And I think one of the ways that we're not one of the mistakes that
- 16:34organizations often make is I think we are like ants. And in the book, as you know, I compare the
- 16:39capitalists of the 20th century and beyond to the communists because they all made the same mistake.
- 16:43They thought we were ants. They thought the communist thought that a good person is somebody that
- 16:49works for the revolution, not for themselves. And that should make them happy. That should be
- 16:52enough for them. Of course, it isn't enough. It isn't enough for people. And also, you know, toxic
- 16:56corporations also think the same. They think, well, I'm paying you away. That should be enough for
- 17:00you. Everything you now do should be for the organization and your, your personal identity should
- 17:05be completely subsumed into the organization. And so there are examples in the, meaning the book
- 17:10from, you know, the great financial firms of Wall Street to more recently, we work, which has
- 17:16been described as the kind of cult like organization. And that's not true either. Like, status is
- 17:21this, we seek status in two different ways. One, yeah, group status is important. We identify with
- 17:26the group. When our football team wins, we feel like we've won. It's a weird thing about humans.
- 17:30It's that group status does impact us. But when we're at work, we also need individual status.
- 17:36We need to feel that our individual contribution to the mission is recognized as seen and is
- 17:42celebrated. So that's also important. And I think, you know, psychologists are just sort of
- 17:49waking up to this idea relatively recently that it's that this individual status is an absolutely
- 17:55crucial thing in terms of motivating people. Yeah. And I think especially now with the introduction
- 18:00of AI systems across organizations, I think there's a huge risk there that people will be treated
- 18:05like ends once again under the headline of digital transformation. Because if you take people's
- 18:11agency away, which could, is it one possible outcome of AI introductions, then they will
- 18:17be demotivated. They will feel about their agency and it's lost that mastery is no longer
- 18:22achievable because they're essentially constant in the machine. Yeah, that's right. And I think,
- 18:27you know, agencies, you know, it's so important in the book. I talk about this idea that I call
- 18:31competent space is that in it's that every employee, no matter what, where they are sitting,
- 18:35the hierarchy, they need to give it, they need to be given space to show their competence.
- 18:40So any job which is this conveyor belt job, where you're told exactly what to do and exactly
- 18:44what time is going to be sold is drawing because you're not given the space to prove your worth,
- 18:48to prove your value individually. So that competent space, I think, is absolutely important for every
- 18:55employee. Yeah, absolutely. Let's talk about customers. So we talked about the organization
- 19:01internally, leadership employees. What about customers? I mean, advertising, social media,
- 19:08all of that is essentially storytelling. And sometimes it works. Sometimes it really doesn't.
- 19:12Yeah, I mean, I think, you know, the most successful advertising appeals to our identity.
- 19:19I mean, you know, it appeals to people like us. It says that we are like you and you are like us.
- 19:24And we have that we have the same values. And that kind of that has a magnetic effect on people.
- 19:29It draws people to, you know, these brands. I mean, the book I tell the story about added
- 19:34ass, who back in the 80s were completely screwed. Like in America, they had a 3% share of the market,
- 19:40being dominated by Reebok, dominated by Nike, who were making all these sponsorship deals with
- 19:47athletes. But then it all changed when run DMC, this pioneering hip hop band, representatives
- 19:54of this new genre of music released this song, Maya Deedas. And you know, the would wave their
- 20:00Adidas in the air at concerts. And so Adidas became this symbol of the hip hop movement. And,
- 20:06you know, to their credit, Adidas is a conservative German company embraced this African-American
- 20:14art form and did a massive deal with run DMC, the first ever sponsorship deal with the musician.
- 20:19And it was enormously successful. Turn their fortunes around. You know, why? Because logically,
- 20:23it doesn't make any sense that that marketing campaign or that marketing exercise was nothing
- 20:29to do with the quality of the shoe. It wasn't to do it. It's comfort, how fast it helped you run
- 20:33or whatever, you know, it's longevity, whatever that might be. It was all about identity. It was
- 20:38like, if you're going to be a fan of hip hop, you have to wear Adidas shoes. And people responded
- 20:42in their millions to that. And so that's the incredible power of these stories having to appeal
- 20:49to identity, which is really the subject of the book. And it's still true, right? Because my
- 20:54neighbor, he grew up in 80s, New York. He's still wears Adidas. He's still in that sort of people
- 21:00like Adidas, right? So one collaboration with the band 40 years ago is still selling shoes today.
- 21:07I mean, that is just incredible. Yeah, that's right. I mean, in the book, as I was writing it,
- 21:12I remembered why I wear box shorts. And that's because back in the 80s, when I was at the beginning
- 21:17of my adolescence, there was the very famous advert for Levi's, Fada Wands, where Nick came and
- 21:23walks in and he's all got all the girls fancily takes his jeans off. And he's got boxers shorts,
- 21:27and that had the weird effect that out of it rocketed sales of Levi's. But it also rocketed sales
- 21:32of boxers shorts. And I'm 50 now. I'm still wearing boxers shorts, because the Adidas saw when I was
- 21:37probably eight years old. I mean, it's extraordinary. Like the idea of wearing pants, like underpants,
- 21:42like, you know, like it's crazy. It's irrational. But so it's still that's part of my identity,
- 21:48you know, even though nobody else knows about this part of my wife in everybody who is my book now,
- 21:52like it's, it feels irrational, but it's not. It's all about this relentless Quester on to, you
- 21:58know, tell stories about who we are in order that we attract other people like us. Yeah. And
- 22:05there's some famous examples as well where companies misjudge their audience, right? And the story
- 22:10what they live in. Yeah, exactly. I mean, you know, the most recent, most catastrophic example with
- 22:14a Bud Light campaign, where, you know, drinkers of Bud Light in America, they're white,
- 22:19often working class dudes. But for some reason, the marketing department of Budweiser felt this
- 22:25somehow sort, you know, solid to them. And they want, so they wanted to, to, to have open a brand
- 22:30new market. And of course, it backfired on them massively, because they, they, they, they, they,
- 22:35almost like sawtap and found a liberty, the opposite people like us to their constituent,
- 22:40their market. And, and, and, and it blew up in their faces. I mean, a similar recent example,
- 22:44a bit of going back a few years was the Gillette ad campaign where they, you know, your, your
- 22:49customers are men and then you do an ad where you basically paint men as bullies and sexual
- 22:55harassers. I mean, these are toxic ideas. No, no man wants to be seen as a bully. And certainly
- 23:01no man wants to be seen as somebody who is a sexual harasser. But that's why it was basically calling
- 23:05its customers these things. So, so, so it's catastrophic. I mean, you can understand that
- 23:09there were good intentions behind these ads. That's the kind of tragedy of them. There were good
- 23:12intentions. They were, they, they wanted to change the world for the better in a sincere way. But,
- 23:17but, but it's the wrong thing to do. You, they were telling stories that remove status, not
- 23:22offer status. But because they were vitrocycling, right? Yeah. And that's also can also be one
- 23:28form of status, but I guess their audience is under different mindset about status. Yeah. And,
- 23:33and I think probably that the, the executives in the marketing departments were, yeah,
- 23:38signaling status to each other to their friends. Look what I'm doing. I'm trying, you know,
- 23:41this Bud Light, these white people, this white men, you know, we're going to get rid of them.
- 23:45And we're going to get some more virtuous people instead. So, I think they were probably forgetting
- 23:50that actually they're supposed to be, I mean, a good market here understands the story world that
- 23:55they're, their audience lives in and experiences and reflects that back to them. It doesn't do the
- 24:02opposite. So, so, yeah, I think that's the trap that people often fall into is that they,
- 24:07they experience their own story world. And I think that's reality. But it's not, it's just their
- 24:11reality. And in order to be a successful market here, you have to understand the story world
- 24:15of your audience. Like, it's a, it's a, it's a non-negotiable. How do you do that, though?
- 24:21We listen to them. You listen to their stories. You listen to their, you observe how they
- 24:26transmit to their clothes and their gestures and their language, especially their language,
- 24:30who they are to each other. You find that who are their heroes? And why? You know, what,
- 24:35what qualities do their heroes have that make them heroic to them? And likewise, who are their
- 24:39villains? Who is it they don't want to be? You know, some successful campaigns that have been
- 24:45successfully in changing behaviour play with that idea of if you don't do this, you're going to
- 24:49be rejected from your group. So, in the, in the book, I tell the very famous story of the,
- 24:54don't mess with Texas anti-littering campaigns, which, which were hugely successful in stopping
- 25:00the, you know, young men throwing their beer cans out of their car windows and
- 25:07littering the freeways by saying, look, you know, you're messing with Texas. This is an
- 25:11unpatriotic anti-Texas act and, you know, it was massively successful. So, so, so, but in order to
- 25:19do that, you know, the guys who came up with that ad campaign, you know, one of them was Texan.
- 25:23He understood the Texas mindset and he understood it deeply. And so he understood
- 25:27instinctively that if you want to stop that, we've got to appeal to the story that Texans tell
- 25:31about themselves and and and say, look, if you do this, you're not really a Texan. You're,
- 25:36you're messing with Texas. The same is true for the Brexit campaign, isn't it, that the
- 25:41leaf campaign listened to focus groups and essentially picked up certain phrases from them
- 25:46that they then used and supposedly played back at them. Yes. Yeah. I mean, in the book, it is so,
- 25:50I've talked about this idea that I call atomic statements, which is just very, very powerful
- 25:54short statements. That were the original form of storytelling, you know, back when the early
- 26:01religions were evolving and spreading around the world, people couldn't read, they had no access
- 26:05to books, you couldn't read the Bible or the collected works of Aristotle. So how did these
- 26:11stories spread? Well, they spread in aphorisms originally. So, you know, Jesus said, no prophet is
- 26:16accepted in his own village, Teneca said in ancient Greece, that sometimes it is an act of bravery
- 26:21even to live, you know, beautiful sentences. So this is kind of like, you know, I argue this is
- 26:28the form of storytelling, a really early form of storytelling because it acts as
- 26:34that very powerful sentence that has exploded meaning on contact with the mind and also serves
- 26:40the fused minds together. Like, we all understand, okay. So, you know, so this is how I need to behave,
- 26:47this is what I need to do in order to be accepted into the world of the, you know, the Greek or the
- 26:52or the ancient, you know, early Christian. Yeah. And so we still use these, you know, atomic
- 26:59statements today, they manifest in the form of memes, tweets, I think we're still calling them
- 27:03tweets, you know, and also kind of, you know, advertising slogans. And I think, you know,
- 27:09when you look at the Brexit campaign, that was part of Dominic Cummings genius. We all know,
- 27:14take back control. And as you say, come out of focus groups, he discovered that people were,
- 27:18the number one thing people were interested in were, it was immigration. And they would constantly
- 27:24come out to the phrase, we need to take back control of our borders, we've lost control of our borders.
- 27:28And number two, that they, they blame the EU for this. So, take back control. What's this dog
- 27:32whistle to people who are worried about immigration and upset about immigration? But it's in atomic
- 27:37statements, incredibly powerful statements. But I think that this kind of under estimators is also
- 27:44the power of the other atomic statement they use, which is project fear, you know, two words.
- 27:48So basically, any sort of fact or data, which the remain campaign you come up with, you can say,
- 27:53look, this is going to be an economic disaster. We're going to be isolated. We're going to be,
- 27:56well, some of the things that actually happened, this, be honest, they could just dismiss it.
- 28:00I said project fear. And that tells a story of a conspiracy of malevolent people, you know,
- 28:07plotting to spread this propaganda that leaving the EU is going to be bad. So I think project fear
- 28:13was at least as powerful. That's very powerful because it suggests that, oh, Dodd listen,
- 28:17I'm there just manipulating to you. No one wants to be manipulated. Yeah. And the left
- 28:22were only as the left always do. They always go back to facts and data.
- 28:27They're just not as good at storytelling. And we saw that recently in the Trump campaign.
- 28:31I mean, one of the things that I thought was interesting was that was was, you know,
- 28:36the atomic statement of the Trump campaign used at the very end of the campaign, which is
- 28:41Kamala Harris's for they then, Trump is for you, which is just incredibly powerful. And you know,
- 28:47an analysis that was written about in New York Times found that that moved, that moved the vote
- 28:522.7%, like, had a massive effect. And it's surprised everybody, even on the Trump campaign,
- 28:56how effective that was. But it shouldn't have done. It's a brilliant atomic statement. It's
- 29:00a perfect atomic statement. It was incredibly powerful for the Trump campaign. And yet again,
- 29:05the left didn't have anything like this, you know, because I just for some reason, the left
- 29:10at its ends so good at storytelling instinctively than the political right. Yeah, I think that's
- 29:17that's very true. And the inside atomic statements or the terminology, I think, is extremely
- 29:23useful. I was thinking recently, I talked to a friend about why certain, let's say, podcast
- 29:28guests or social media personalities cut through when others don't, who may say the same thing,
- 29:34essentially, they have the same sort of background. And we settled on essentially the idea of
- 29:38atomic statement, even though we didn't have the term. So thanks to you. And the new book,
- 29:42you know, that term is out there. But I think this captures it beautifully. I called it
- 29:47aphorisms essentially. Yeah, this person was talking to particularly sort of high profile podcast
- 29:52guests. I said, okay, that person speaks at aphorisms about business. And that's why people
- 29:55remember what he's saying. Yeah, I think that's very true. That's very true. I hadn't thought
- 30:00it actually thought about it in terms of being a podcast guest, but I'm going to just try and cut
- 30:04my answer down. It's. This is perfect. And I was also thinking about, you know,
- 30:11being a host and sometimes a guest, you know, what does it mean in terms of the atomic
- 30:14statements? And I think social media trains you to do that as well. You know, if it's exor,
- 30:18like me on LinkedIn, you only have a few words to ideally convey an atomic statement. But that's
- 30:25beautiful. How do we then tell a story? Right? So I think there's a lot of storytelling advice
- 30:33out there. And, you know, I'm guilty of that as well. I use certain structures, use certain
- 30:36formulas. I like to collect them. And in your book, you point out, let's start maybe there what
- 30:41isn't working. You said, for instance, that muscle of hierarchy of needs and the hero's journey,
- 30:45does that outdated concepts from the 1940s. Maybe let's start there and then work our way
- 30:50towards what is actually working today. Yeah, that's right. So I mean, when I'm consulting and
- 30:55going into talk to organizations, it always fills me with glue that they're still trying to get the
- 30:59hero's journey to work because the hero's journey, I mean, it's amazing. I mean, you know,
- 31:03Joseph Campbell was a genius. But as you said, this was written in the 1940s, this book.
- 31:08The hero's journey in its full form is a 22-step recipe for how to tell a story. Like it's very
- 31:16outdated. It's very unwieldy. And, you know, Joseph Campbell was trying to do this thing of using
- 31:22the latest science and research to understand the secrets of story. And we just know so much more
- 31:26today about human mind and about how it interacts with story. You know, one of the big
- 31:33things that we know is that, you know, we have a huge revolution in evolutionary psychology.
- 31:39So this understanding of actually what we want and actually, you know, what motivates us.
- 31:46And again, this also goes into muscle of hierarchy of needs. It's actually much simpler,
- 31:52you know, we're a tribal animal. And that means that we have evolved to
- 31:59existing cooperative groups. So we want those two things. We want to connect,
- 32:03and we want status, we want connection with other groups, and we want to prove our value to the
- 32:07groups. And actually, when you see stories telling through these much simpler, more recently
- 32:12established forms, it actually makes it, for me, it makes it much simpler. It's much simpler
- 32:17to use that model than Maslow's. I don't forget how many are in a hierarchy of needs, six or seven
- 32:21different needs. And it's actually notes three, survival, connection and status. Those are the
- 32:24three things that humans want. We want to survive, we want to connect, and we want to be valued.
- 32:29And if you think about, you know, what are you thinking about when you wake up in the morning,
- 32:33and last thing you go to bed, assuming you're not sick, yeah, obviously, you're not sick.
- 32:38If you're sick and unwell or somebody that you love is sick and unwell, you're thinking about
- 32:42survival or you're hungry, but assuming you're just living in an ordinary life, western life,
- 32:47you're thinking about connection and status, you're thinking about who loves me, who doesn't love me,
- 32:51you're worrying about a relationship that you've had, or you're thinking about your status, yeah,
- 32:55obstacles, like what went wrong for me today, what went right for me today, what can I do tomorrow
- 33:00in order to push me closer to this goal? So, you know, connection and status dominate our
- 33:05internal monologue. They dominate that. The themes of that little story set in our heads is constantly
- 33:09tripping away. Yeah, and this is no dig towards muscle fabric it needs, or Joseph Campo,
- 33:17you know, geniuses in their own right, but we're just further along, we know. And so,
- 33:22you propose in the book a clear three-act structure that we can follow, and just to clarify,
- 33:27the book is not a methodology of ABC, do this, and you close the dear kind of thing, it's so much
- 33:33more and goes so much deeper, but I appreciate you also giving us a path to telecompaling stories,
- 33:40so could you walk us through the three acts again? Yeah, so this is kind of adapted from, you know,
- 33:46traditional storytelling you talk about, sometimes talk about five acts, but sometimes talk about
- 33:50three acts, which is crisis struggle resolution. So, it's similar to that where the beginning
- 33:56of the story you've got somebody who has a problem, they meet in obstacle, and then they
- 34:02you know, struggle over that obstacle, and then the third act they achieve their goal. And in
- 34:07doing, in overcoming the obstacle and achieving that goal, they learn something, and that thing
- 34:12that you learn is your takeaway message. So, those are the basic building blocks of any story,
- 34:18and I think fundamental to that is the idea of obstacles and goals. I mean, this is even having
- 34:22written a science of storytelling for novelist and screenwriters, I think I, in my mind, underplayed
- 34:27the importance of obstacles and goals. It was only when I worked, when I realized that stories
- 34:32all about getting us to work together to pursue goals and other comments to cause that I realized
- 34:36that that's why that's what storytelling is about. Like, if you don't have an obstacle in the
- 34:41goal and the story, you're confused, you're lost, and often even very experienced storytellers
- 34:45forget this, and you can find so everything, a novel, watching a film, and you're confused,
- 34:50you're bored, and often very often that's because it's not clear who wants what, and what's standing
- 34:56in the way of getting that thing. You know, that's basically what a story has to be. And you know,
- 35:00you see ads that are trying to be stories that aren't actually stories because there's no obstacle
- 35:03and there's no goal. And no transformation. Yeah, no transformation. It may just be an anecdote,
- 35:09or, you know, series of events, but for me, the story, in addition to what you mentioned is,
- 35:14it needs that transformation. Yeah, exactly. Show the growth that has happened as a result of
- 35:19overcoming the obstacle. Yes, and that transformation tells you something, and that's the takeaway message,
- 35:24that that's the important kind of thing that the story's transmitting is, like, look, this person
- 35:29had a problem, and they have a comment, and they changed, and this is what they learned.
- 35:34Yeah. Do we need to distinguish between, let's say, the traditional storytelling we may find
- 35:39in movies and books or, you know, novels and persuasive storytelling we use in business?
- 35:45Is there a structural difference? Well, I mean, in the science of storytelling, when I'm talking to
- 35:51novelists and screenwriters and playwrights, I use a five-act structure there, which is similar,
- 35:57but it's just broken down into more acts. And that really, that five-act structure really
- 36:04emphasizes more the character transformation, because in a story that you're writing for a novel
- 36:10or a film, you're not quite so much interested in the takeaway message, because that's really important
- 36:16for persuaders, is that takeaway message is clear. It's much more about what the characters
- 36:21learning about, what it is to be a human, much more profound lessons, it's not about by this
- 36:25Apple product or by this trainer or vote for this party, it's like, what does it mean to be human?
- 36:29So, you know, what kind of mistakes are we making as people in 2025, and how can we overcome them?
- 36:35You know, it's those kinds of things, but I don't think there's any fundamental difference.
- 36:40I mean, it's stories and accounts of a character or characters overcoming an obstacle,
- 36:46in pursuit of a goal, and learning something. That's fundamentally what all storytelling is,
- 36:50archetypal storytelling is, of course, is modernist versions of story, which played with that.
- 36:56Yeah, that's great advice, and I think you put your finger on something important there,
- 36:59that in business storytelling, there's usually next step, right? I want my team to do something,
- 37:04I want the customer to buy my product. You know, we need to take certain actions, whereas in the,
- 37:09I say, I'm watching a movie, there's no action. I watch the movie, and as soon as as long as I'm
- 37:13entertained, you know, the creators are probably happy that are, you know, paid a few bucks at the,
- 37:17at the box office. That's right, but even in those kinds of films, there's often a subconscious
- 37:22bit of persuasion going on, and when, when psychologists study the effect of storytelling,
- 37:27and when we transported into a film or a movie, our values align with the hero, with the protagonists,
- 37:32and the things that we learn, the things that protagonists learn, we also learn with them,
- 37:35and that's the story doing its evolutionary job of teaching us who to be, and teaching us how to be,
- 37:40and teaching us to be more cooperative, like it's no coincidence that heroes, the end of a story,
- 37:45are more cooperative than they were at the beginning of the story. They're more celebrated,
- 37:49they're, they're, they're, they offer more value to their groups, and that's what, that's the
- 37:52propaganda that stories constantly playing on us. So consciously, it's always wanting us to become
- 37:56a more cooperative member of the group by, by saying, this is what a hero is. This is what a hero
- 38:00does. And in that way, it's no different from a marketing campaign or, you know, a, get out,
- 38:05vote campaign. They're also saying, you know, if you want to be a hero, you've got to vote for Trump,
- 38:09or Kamala Harris, or buy that, buy the shoe, buy the computer. This is what a hero does.
- 38:16Also in a crisis, right? In a crisis situation, storytelling is incredibly important. I often
- 38:20say in trainings that a crisis is an evolving story, and you now have to make sure you're, you're not
- 38:26the villain. That's right. And I think one of the, one of the most fundamental sort of insights
- 38:31that comes from the science of storytelling is the importance of this binary of selfless versus
- 38:35selfish. So when researchers look at morality, what is morality? You know, why are we moral creatures
- 38:42uniquely? We have this moral sense. We know it's part of our storytelling cognition, of course,
- 38:46you know, heroes and villains. It's story stuff. And what storytelling is always trying to do is make
- 38:52us better members of the, of the super organism. So wherever you go in the world, immoral behavior is
- 38:58basically self selfish behavior. And what's selfish behavior is this is like, I'm going to put my
- 39:02own interest before that of the super organism, that of the group. And the opposite is also true.
- 39:07So moral behavior is selfless behavior, whether it's courage or generosity. I'm putting the interest
- 39:11of others before the interests of me. So again, that's the propaganda that stories we're trying to
- 39:14kind of weave on us is, is, is to make us more selfless and less selfish because we're still,
- 39:20you know, underneath these storytelling stuff, we're still animals who have self, you know,
- 39:24often have selfish, interest selfish drives. And so one of the big insights in crisis communication
- 39:30is that you've got to absolutely avoid any sense of selfishness because selfishness is cancer,
- 39:36like it's a toxin. People are highly attuned to it because of our tribal nature. And you know,
- 39:42the classic example of that is the BP Tony Haywood thing where, you know, he billions of billions of
- 39:47dollars, getting up his spill. And he said, you know, nobody wants this over more than I do. I'd
- 39:52like my life bag, which on a human level, it's completely understandable. It's the worst time
- 39:56of his life, you know. But it killed him. You know, he even had President Obama commenting about
- 40:01what an evil villain he was. So that's one of the, one of the takeaways is just to avoid any
- 40:09hint of selfishness and appear selfless at all times. I mean, you studied storytelling probably
- 40:16more than anyone else in the world. And I wonder, do you think that stories are in net benefit
- 40:23to society, to humanity? Well, that's a really good question. I think it's a, I think it's a
- 40:31net benefit in the sense that without storytelling, we would just be another ape and we'd be living
- 40:36in a jungle somewhere. So would be happier. I don't know. But but but but without storytelling,
- 40:41there is no civilization. There are no vaccines. There is no outer space. There is no internet.
- 40:45But also storytelling is incredibly evil, you know, like storytelling isn't good or bad. It's
- 40:50just a technology, like any technology. It has a, it has a variety of outcomes. And you know,
- 40:54without storytelling, you don't get the Nazis. You don't get the communists. You know, you don't get
- 40:58some of these, you know, you don't get genocides. So so so you don't get cancel culture. So, you know,
- 41:03storytelling is sometimes manifest in amazing ways. But storytelling also is, is the worst of us,
- 41:10as well as being the best of us. Yeah. That's so good. Well, thank you so much. Where can people
- 41:16find out more about you and the new book? The new book is called A Story Is A Deal. You can
- 41:22find out more about that on my Twitter at WStore. But probably better on my substack,
- 41:30which is called you are a story. I'm just launching a substack in the next couple of weeks,
- 41:33where I'm going to be sort of digging further into these ideas. And I'll be I'll be printing some
- 41:37sort of extracts from the book in there for free as well. So you can take a look. Yeah. I'll
- 41:41put that in the show notes. Of course. Thank you. And this was my last question. What's your best
- 41:45piece of communications advice? Best piece of communications advice would be just to completely
- 41:52understand the people that you're trying to communicate with and not just understand them,
- 41:57understand the story world. What do they want? Why do they want it? Who are their heroes?
- 42:02Who are their villains? How do they talk? Really in habit? The perception of the story world and
- 42:08you'll be able to appeal to them. Such good advice. Well, sir, thank you so much.
- 42:12Thanks so much, Oliver. Thank you all for listening.