Latest / Surrounded / James Talarico vs 20 Undecided Voters
Transcript
- 0:00Hey listeners,
- 0:00just want to remind you,
- 0:01we have episodes of the pod coming out
- 0:03every Sunday,
- 0:04so please consider subscribing
- 0:06wherever you get your podcasts.
- 0:08Thank you for your support.
- 0:09Honestly,
- 0:10James,
- 0:10I don't think you're gonna do anything.
- 0:12We've heard it before,
- 0:13you know,
- 0:13drain the swamp,
- 0:14eat the rich
- 0:15until they get voted,
- 0:16and then they're just rich people swimming in the swamp.
- 0:19Here's where I agree with you.
- 0:20We need way more investment.
- 0:22In our communities
- 0:23here in America,
- 0:24it's why I fight.
- 0:25It's,
- 0:26it's why I fight for
- 0:28how do we need to invest in those communities.
- 0:30Yeah,
- 0:30uh,
- 0:31Barbara Jordan,
- 0:31a great Texan,
- 0:32she said if you're not at the table,
- 0:34you're on the menu.
- 0:35And so the argument I'm making with this claim is if
- 0:37young people in particular
- 0:38aren't at the table in this election,
- 0:40we will continue to be on the menu
- 0:42in 2027.
- 0:45From Jubilee Media,
- 0:46this is the surrounded podcast where one brave soul faces a room full of disagreers.
- 0:50In the center of this special episode is the Texas senatorial race candidate,
- 0:55James Tallarico.
- 0:56He will be facing 20 undecided Texas voters.
- 0:59James will debate them one on one until
- 1:02they're voted out by their peers and replaced by someone new.
- 1:05Let's get into it.
- 1:08My name is James Tallarico.
- 1:09I'm a Texas state representative,
- 1:11former middle school teacher,
- 1:13and Presbyterian seminarian
- 1:15running for the US Senate
- 1:16to take power back for working people,
- 1:18and I'm surrounded
- 1:19by 25 undecided voters here in the great state of Texas.
- 1:26My first claim is that cuts to healthcare and food assistance hurt all of us.
- 1:39Hi Daniel,
- 1:40it's so nice to meet you as well.
- 1:42My faith teaches me to love my neighbor as myself.
- 1:45In fact,
- 1:46all the major world religions teach something similar,
- 1:48that we should treat others as we want to be treated.
- 1:50The golden rule.
- 1:52I think all of these ancient wisdom traditions
- 1:55are hitting on the same truth,
- 1:56which is that we're interconnected,
- 1:58that what impacts any of us directly
- 2:01impacts all of us indirectly.
- 2:03We are
- 2:04a social species,
- 2:05we rise and fall together,
- 2:07and I think that's particularly true in healthcare.
- 2:09And food assistance
- 2:11because
- 2:12the Republicans in DC
- 2:13are trying to raise premiums on some Americans
- 2:16that will end up raising premiums on all of us.
- 2:19Right now they're
- 2:20cutting food assistance for hungry kids and working parents
- 2:23that's gonna end up
- 2:24raising grocery prices for all of us.
- 2:27And so they may think that they're just attacking some Americans,
- 2:29but in fact they're attacking all Americans.
- 2:31I wanna focus on the religious aspect because I agree,
- 2:34um,
- 2:34I have a very Christian background.
- 2:36But if you look at major religions,
- 2:38including Christianity,
- 2:39it is not a focus on a political system,
- 2:41it's a focus on individual responsibility.
- 2:44And when the political
- 2:44The system takes away the individual responsibility and says,
- 2:47don't worry,
- 2:48the government's gonna take care of you.
- 2:50You are absolutely gonna catch people who need that,
- 2:53and it's a,
- 2:53it's a hand up and it helps them,
- 2:56but you're also going to take away from the individual responsibility,
- 2:59which is needed
- 3:00to get out of those situations.
- 3:02So when you talk about food stamps and healthcare and helping.
- 3:05How do you balance that?
- 3:06Cause I haven't heard a good democratic argument of,
- 3:09great,
- 3:10let's help people,
- 3:10but how are you there are nasty people.
- 3:12There are,
- 3:13there are welfare queens.
- 3:14There are,
- 3:14there are nasty people who take advantage of the system
- 3:17and take away from those who earned it,
- 3:19take away from those who need it.
- 3:21So,
- 3:21how are you gonna take that into account?
- 3:23How are you going to,
- 3:24going to make sure we,
- 3:25we cover that risk as well?
- 3:27The biggest welfare queens in this country
- 3:30are the giant corporations that don't pay a penny
- 3:33in federal taxes.
- 3:34The biggest welfare queens are the CEOs who get a tax deduction
- 3:38for flying on a private jet.
- 3:40It's not
- 3:41hungry kids.
- 3:42It's not working parents who work multiple jobs to provide for their families.
- 3:46I agree with you
- 3:47that we need individual responsibility,
- 3:49and I don't want to create a culture of dependency.
- 3:51I want a hand up and not a handout.
- 3:54You know,
- 3:54I,
- 3:54I believe that you don't give a man a fish,
- 3:56you teach a man to fish.
- 3:57But if you're gonna take your friend out on a boat for the day to teach him how to fish,
- 4:01you wanna make sure he had breakfast that morning.
- 4:03You wanna make sure he's not sick,
- 4:05because that allows him to learn how to fish.
- 4:07Again,
- 4:08I was a public school teacher,
- 4:09so I saw
- 4:10how when kids showed up hungry,
- 4:12they couldn't learn that day.
- 4:13Even my brightest students,
- 4:14even my hardest working students
- 4:16couldn't succeed,
- 4:17couldn't pull themselves up by their bootstraps
- 4:20when they didn't have boots.
- 4:21That's what I'm trying to fix in this country.
- 4:23We don't want dependency,
- 4:24we want to reward hard work.
- 4:26And I think that should apply to those billionaires,
- 4:29not just working people.
- 4:30Uh,
- 4:30I'm gonna push back,
- 4:31so
- 4:32I agree with a lot of what you said,
- 4:34but the issue is.
- 4:36How do you prevent
- 4:37people from taking advantage of the system,
- 4:39because,
- 4:39and I'm not gonna say that like we would agree that
- 4:41in any kind of welfare system or any kind of age,
- 4:43you have a population of people who need it,
- 4:45who use it to better themselves and better those around you.
- 4:47You also have a population of those who abuse it
- 4:50and because it's there,
- 4:52it's harmful to them because they're uninspired to live up to their potential,
- 4:55and it's harmful to everyone else because they're a leech on society.
- 4:58And we could,
- 4:59I think generally we would just.
- 5:00Agreeing on the percentage
- 5:02of how much is this group and how much is that group,
- 5:04that's OK,
- 5:04but how do we prevent
- 5:06this group from taking advantage,
- 5:07not only of
- 5:09those of us who
- 5:10are hardworking and make a good amount of money,
- 5:12but those that really need the aid who get
- 5:13a bad reputation because of these shitheads over here.
- 5:16So
- 5:17this has actually been studied,
- 5:18and
- 5:19the fraud rates for SNAP,
- 5:21the Food Assistance Program,
- 5:23and for Medicaid are shockingly low.
- 5:25And what happens here is the corporate media,
- 5:27they try to pick out
- 5:29some rare case,
- 5:30and they blow it up,
- 5:31they sensationalize it,
- 5:32because they want to discredit these programs,
- 5:35because they don't want
- 5:36tax dollars going to help feed hungry kids.
- 5:38They want tax dollars going to billionaires
- 5:41that own the media,
- 5:42so they can
- 5:43get even more wealth.
- 5:44I,
- 5:44I wanted to go back to something you said because we're both people of faith,
- 5:47both Christians,
- 5:48it sounds like.
- 5:49I,
- 5:49I completely agree with you that
- 5:51everyone has a personal moral responsibility.
- 5:54To,
- 5:54to do right,
- 5:55to do good,
- 5:56to better themselves.
- 5:58But I'll also just say we also have a responsibility to our neighbors,
- 6:01to our community.
- 6:02And in fact,
- 6:04so much of our tradition
- 6:06comes out of the Jewish tradition,
- 6:07which is all about a covenant,
- 6:08a community of people,
- 6:10not singular individuals,
- 6:12but us as a community,
- 6:13us as a covenant.
- 6:15Jesus didn't tell us to love our,
- 6:17our
- 6:18immediate family members.
- 6:20Jesus didn't tell us to love our close friends,
- 6:22those probably would have been easier commandments to follow.
- 6:24He told us to love our neighbors,
- 6:26and then he specifically went further
- 6:28and defined neighbor as someone who's very different from us.
- 6:31And
- 6:32that is an inherently a,
- 6:34a public thing.
- 6:35Loving your neighbors
- 6:37is,
- 6:37is something you do out in public.
- 6:38It's,
- 6:39it's why my,
- 6:40my faith motivates me
- 6:41to do public service,
- 6:42first as a public school teacher,
- 6:44now as a public official.
- 6:46And so I just wanna
- 6:47hold both of those two things together
- 6:49because
- 6:50there's absolutely a,
- 6:51a role for individual responsibility and individual choices,
- 6:54but there's also responsibility to others and to the community.
- 6:57Both those things can be true at the same time.
- 7:00All right,
- 7:00pause.
- 7:01You've been voted out by the majority.
- 7:02Please you did a great job your seat.
- 7:03Yeah,
- 7:03it's so nice to meet you.
- 7:08Hey Stefan,
- 7:09it's so nice to meet you.
- 7:11On its face,
- 7:11where you're saying cuts to healthcare,
- 7:13cuts to
- 7:14fit assistance for so sounds good.
- 7:16But if you look at it,
- 7:17at the inverse,
- 7:19increases to healthcare and increases to food assistance
- 7:22doesn't help all of us.
- 7:24And the reason why is we have a bloated healthcare system
- 7:27where a lot of the money that goes into it gets accrued
- 7:31to the intermediaries,
- 7:32the companies delivering these services,
- 7:34the consultant class,
- 7:36um,
- 7:37a lot of fraud happens.
- 7:38I mean,
- 7:38we have
- 7:39a current member of the Senate,
- 7:41um,
- 7:42and not in Texas,
- 7:43but in the US
- 7:44who
- 7:45defrauded.
- 7:46Millions of people,
- 7:47uh,
- 7:48out of Medicare benefits and,
- 7:49and the like.
- 7:50Um,
- 7:51so,
- 7:52one of the things that I worry about is
- 7:54when we're talking about restoring
- 7:56the,
- 7:56the
- 7:57money that's been cut,
- 7:59is how is it gonna be used effectively.
- 8:01Um,
- 8:02so,
- 8:02I'm,
- 8:02I'm not against
- 8:04having more healthcare
- 8:05to more people.
- 8:06What I'm against is
- 8:08that money being used inappropriately
- 8:10and,
- 8:11you know,
- 8:11you talk about the wealthy,
- 8:12the top versus
- 8:14uh bottom.
- 8:15This is a system that actually makes
- 8:17more people poor and the fewer that are really rich,
- 8:21richer because it gives more opportunities for mine to be sucked out of the system
- 8:25and accrued into fewer hands.
- 8:26So,
- 8:27not necessarily serving more people.
- 8:30So that's why I hesitate to agree that
- 8:33necessarily cutting,
- 8:35uh,
- 8:35healthcare,
- 8:36uh,
- 8:36cutting
- 8:37food assistance is necessarily hurting all of us.
- 8:40Maybe it's
- 8:40probably hurting
- 8:42the rich more than it is hurting
- 8:44most of us.
- 8:44Well,
- 8:45you,
- 8:45you were preaching to the choir.
- 8:46I,
- 8:46I think we've got to
- 8:47transform this healthcare system
- 8:50from
- 8:50the bottom up.
- 8:51Um,
- 8:52most of the countries around the world have figured out
- 8:55how to provide quality health care
- 8:57at lower costs for more people.
- 8:59We're the only rich country that hasn't figured this out
- 9:02because
- 9:03we have
- 9:04giant health insurance companies leaching the life
- 9:08out of our healthcare system.
- 9:09And so I absolutely agree with you.
- 9:11If we're cutting
- 9:12some of those profit margins for these giant healthcare companies,
- 9:15I'm all for it.
- 9:15But that's not what's being
- 9:17being proposed
- 9:18in Washington right now.
- 9:19That big ugly bill is gonna kick millions of Texans off their healthcare.
- 9:22Right now,
- 9:23this government shutdown
- 9:24is all about
- 9:25the Republicans trying to raise premiums
- 9:28on working people.
- 9:29Those folks who can no longer afford
- 9:31to pay those higher premiums,
- 9:33they're gonna
- 9:34drop their health insurance.
- 9:36Those folks are no longer gonna get their screenings.
- 9:38They're no longer gonna get their checkups.
- 9:40They're gonna wait.
- 9:41Things are gonna get worse.
- 9:42They're gonna get sicker,
- 9:43and then where will they go?
- 9:45To the emergency room
- 9:46and who pays for that?
- 9:48Me and you.
- 9:49It's gonna raise our property taxes here in Texas
- 9:51for indigent care at the county level,
- 9:53we all pay for that and it is so much more expensive
- 9:56on the back end
- 9:57than it is on the front end.
- 9:58We end up saving money if we invest in preventative care
- 10:01on the front end
- 10:02and so
- 10:03that's my point with this claim is that.
- 10:05We're all interconnected.
- 10:07What hurts some of us ends up hurting all of us.
- 10:09And when we're all better off,
- 10:10we're all better off.
- 10:12Same with the food assistance cuts.
- 10:14Cutting
- 10:14SNAP benefits for hungry kids and working parents,
- 10:18it disrupts the entire supply chain
- 10:20in our economy,
- 10:21from ranchers and farmers here in Texas,
- 10:24to distributors and truck drivers to grocery stores like HEB.
- 10:27And when supply goes down,
- 10:29prices go up.
- 10:30So,
- 10:31because they,
- 10:32the Republicans in DC are cutting food assistance for poor folks.
- 10:35It's now gonna make grocery store prices even more expensive for everybody.
- 10:40So
- 10:40if we make the decision to invest in our neighbors,
- 10:43to love our neighbors through good public policy,
- 10:45even when we're open to reform
- 10:47and fixing these broken systems,
- 10:49it's actually gonna make us all healthier.
- 10:51It's gonna make us all safer.
- 10:52It's gonna make us all richer.
- 10:54I mean,
- 10:54that sounds really good.
- 10:55Uh,
- 10:56the only thing that I'm
- 10:58sort of,
- 10:58sort of hearing coming from your answer
- 11:00is it's an acceptable cost or benefit to.
- 11:04Uh,
- 11:05you know,
- 11:06give more money to the intermediaries if it's giving more people
- 11:10healthcare,
- 11:11and that's where I continue to
- 11:13sort of hesitate.
- 11:14Let me give you a,
- 11:15a solution that could,
- 11:16that could address this.
- 11:17I'm for a public option.
- 11:19I'm for allowing
- 11:20anyone in the state of Texas,
- 11:22anyone in America
- 11:23to sign up
- 11:23for Medicare,
- 11:24to be able to access high quality,
- 11:26low-cost
- 11:27healthcare.
- 11:28I think when we do that,
- 11:30you're gonna see folks who are
- 11:32in terrible healthcare plans
- 11:34flee
- 11:35and join this public option.
- 11:37It creates competition
- 11:38in the market.
- 11:38It creates choice.
- 11:40It creates uh opportunities for people to decide
- 11:42what's best for themselves and their families.
- 11:44So I'm not satisfied
- 11:46with this healthcare system.
- 11:47Please do not misunderstand me.
- 11:48We need transformational change when it comes to healthcare in this country
- 11:52because I believe healthcare
- 11:53is a human right.
- 11:54And it shouldn't depend on
- 11:56how much money you make or how much money your parents make.
- 11:58We all are entitled to high quality,
- 12:00low cost,
- 12:01affordable healthcare.
- 12:02Why instead of reform,
- 12:04not just completely dismantle and start from scratch,
- 12:06because to me,
- 12:07um,
- 12:08cutting or reforming has not worked in the last 2030,
- 12:1140 years.
- 12:12There's been incremental changes around the corners,
- 12:15and none of that has worked.
- 12:16To me,
- 12:16the solution is a complete reworking of the entire system.
- 12:20So any sort of
- 12:21reform to me does not do the job,
- 12:24does not go far enough.
- 12:25I,
- 12:25I'm completely for
- 12:26holistic reform and reworking of the system.
- 12:29Uh,
- 12:30as a legislator
- 12:31over 4 terms in the state capitol,
- 12:34I've realized how
- 12:35difficult it is to make change.
- 12:37I've got big dreams
- 12:38for this state
- 12:39and for this country,
- 12:41but I'm also very realistic on what I can promise
- 12:44as a candidate for office,
- 12:46and I don't wanna sit here and tell you that I can transform the system overnight.
- 12:48I can't.
- 12:49What I can do
- 12:51is adopt some,
- 12:52some
- 12:53actual reforms that'll help provide more healthcare to more people.
- 12:56And you've said that we haven't seen the system get better.
- 12:58I wanna push back on that
- 13:00because when the Affordable Care Act was passed,
- 13:03we suddenly
- 13:04saw health insurance companies no longer able to deny Americans
- 13:07coverage for pre-existing conditions.
- 13:10We saw that young people could stay on their parents' plan until they're 26.
- 13:14We have seen progress.
- 13:15It's too slow.
- 13:16It's unacceptably slow.
- 13:18The only way that's gonna change is if you
- 13:20and the people around the circle
- 13:21take more ownership of this democratic process,
- 13:24not just voting,
- 13:25but running for office yourselves,
- 13:27supporting candidates,
- 13:27organizing protest.
- 13:29That's how we can
- 13:30speed up the pace of change,
- 13:31which
- 13:32I desperately hope we can do because people are counting on it.
- 13:34All right,
- 13:35pause.
- 13:35You've been voted out by the majority.
- 13:37Great job.
- 13:37Turn to your seat.
- 13:41Hi,
- 13:42Brandon,
- 13:42so nice to meet you.
- 13:43Yeah pleasure.
- 13:45So,
- 13:45um,
- 13:46I,
- 13:46I agree with your sentiment.
- 13:48Um,
- 13:49however,
- 13:50what I've seen
- 13:51over the last
- 13:52two weeks or so,
- 13:54um,
- 13:54I live in East Texas,
- 13:55so
- 13:56when the SNAP benefits were being cut,
- 13:58um,
- 13:59I made a post on a Facebook group
- 14:00out in our,
- 14:01in our area,
- 14:02and it received
- 14:04more love and support than I've seen through,
- 14:07through communities.
- 14:08So I think that.
- 14:09I agree that the benefits being cut is a very,
- 14:12very bad thing that we should definitely be doing everything
- 14:16we can to help the people who are in need,
- 14:18but it's also shown me that the indomitable spirit of the American
- 14:22will come together and rescue,
- 14:24uh,
- 14:25the people that
- 14:26really need the help,
- 14:27you know,
- 14:28at that time.
- 14:28So,
- 14:29um,
- 14:30yeah,
- 14:30I totally agree.
- 14:30And in fact,
- 14:31you know,
- 14:31I'm running for US Senate.
- 14:32We have
- 14:338000 people who have signed up to volunteer for the campaign,
- 14:36which is great.
- 14:37As a politician,
- 14:38you always want to have people volunteering.
- 14:40But when these
- 14:40food assistance programs were cut,
- 14:43we decided to channel
- 14:44all of that
- 14:45volunteer energy away from our campaign
- 14:48and into food banks all over the state of Texas.
- 14:50We had a bunch of
- 14:51Team Tallarico volunteers at the
- 14:53San Antonio and Houston Food Bank
- 14:55helping to make sure that we were taking care of our neighbors.
- 14:57I'm trying to go a little further with this claim
- 14:59and say not only is it the right thing to do,
- 15:01it's also the smart.
- 15:02to do
- 15:03because when we cut these programs that provide
- 15:06a lifeline to our neighbors who are struggling,
- 15:08it ends up
- 15:09allowing them to be more productive.
- 15:11It allows them to give their gift.
- 15:13I believe every person is made in the image of God.
- 15:15Every person has something unique to give this world.
- 15:18And when we make sure that everyone has enough to eat,
- 15:20we make sure everybody is healthy,
- 15:21people are able to give that gift,
- 15:23and that ends up benefiting all of us.
- 15:25I really do believe that
- 15:26the next great business idea
- 15:28is trapped in the mind
- 15:30of a kid in poverty on the west side of San Antonio.
- 15:33I think the,
- 15:33the scary part for me is that what we're witnessing right now
- 15:37is that these,
- 15:38these programs that are designed to help people and designed to
- 15:42help further our communities
- 15:44can be used as weapons,
- 15:45um,
- 15:46as threats that
- 15:48if,
- 15:48if this bill doesn't get passed,
- 15:49we're gonna
- 15:50cut,
- 15:51you know,
- 15:51we're gonna cut healthcare,
- 15:52we're gonna cut,
- 15:53um,
- 15:53you know.
- 15:54Funding for,
- 15:55for food for children.
- 15:56I mean,
- 15:57my,
- 15:57my problem is that there's so much partisanship
- 16:00in politics now where
- 16:01it feels like the,
- 16:02the,
- 16:03the
- 16:03politicians that we have in office right now
- 16:06don't necessarily care what the issue is.
- 16:07They just care about the outcome,
- 16:09which is
- 16:10my party wins,
- 16:11the other team loses.
- 16:12So what would be your plan to work with the other side?
- 16:16I've had to work across the aisle to get stuff done,
- 16:18and I have.
- 16:19So I wanna tell you a story.
- 16:21When I was running for this seat in the state house,
- 16:23I was 28 years old,
- 16:24healthy guy,
- 16:25and I decided to walk the entire length of my district from.
- 16:29Ro und Rock,
- 16:29Texas
- 16:30to Taylor,
- 16:30Texas,
- 16:3025 miles.
- 16:31It was a long walk.
- 16:32It was all in the Texas heat.
- 16:34Halfway through the walk,
- 16:35I started to feel fatigued
- 16:37and nauseous.
- 16:38I actually threw up a couple of times in the last half of the walk.
- 16:41Somehow I finished it.
- 16:42My family got concerned.
- 16:43They took me to the ER.
- 16:45The nurses tested my blood sugar.
- 16:47I,
- 16:47I don't think I'd ever had my blood sugar tested before.
- 16:49They told me that a normal blood sugar is 100 or lower.
- 16:53Mine was 900.
- 16:55I was in a state of diabetic ketoacidosis.
- 16:57They told me that I had type 1 diabetes.
- 16:59I didn't even know what type 1 diabetes was,
- 17:01to be honest with you.
- 17:02I went to Walgreens
- 17:03to pick up my first
- 17:0430-day supply of insulin,
- 17:06this new medicine that I now needed to live,
- 17:08and it cost me $684.
- 17:10It's for a 30-day supply.
- 17:12And
- 17:13I said,
- 17:14if you want to buy that same bottle of insulin for your dog,
- 17:17it's $25.
- 17:18Well,
- 17:18and so here in Texas,
- 17:20after I got elected,
- 17:21I worked with people with diabetes all over the state.
- 17:23I found out.
- 17:24That people were
- 17:25rationing,
- 17:26skipping their doses.
- 17:27Some of them were dying
- 17:28because they couldn't afford it.
- 17:30And I was able to work across the aisle with my Republican colleagues
- 17:32to pass the first ever cap
- 17:34on insulin co-pays in Texas history.
- 17:37So from $684
- 17:38even with insurance,
- 17:40we capped it at $25.
- 17:42So
- 17:43now
- 17:43through public policy,
- 17:45we're gonna make sure that people with diabetes can live a long and healthy life.
- 17:48This system is broken.
- 17:50This healthcare system is broken.
- 17:52Progress is way too slow,
- 17:53but when we come together,
- 17:54when we actually believe progress is possible,
- 17:56we can make people's lives better,
- 17:57and that's the whole purpose of politics.
- 17:59All right,
- 18:00pause.
- 18:00You've been voted out by the majority.
- 18:01Great.
- 18:02Thank you,
- 18:02thank you.
- 18:05Hi Maria,
- 18:06so nice to meet you.
- 18:08OK,
- 18:08so I wanna go back to
- 18:11kind of what you guys were saying.
- 18:13You were saying that um
- 18:14through your faith,
- 18:15charity and giving
- 18:18is part of what makes us all
- 18:20run.
- 18:20And I think that the issue here is that the charity and the love is important
- 18:26but it's not something that is
- 18:28in government.
- 18:29I think it's something that's moral and
- 18:30civic education and that's very much needed.
- 18:33In order for us to live in a just and free society,
- 18:35but government isn't where you put the charity because the thing is I
- 18:39was a former social worker before I became a stay at home mom
- 18:42and I worked with a lot of people,
- 18:44adults and kids,
- 18:45um,
- 18:45and one of the things that I've seen is like when people are on
- 18:49food assistance for too long and I think something like 30% of
- 18:53SNAP benefit.
- 18:54Beneficiaries stay on it long term.
- 18:57It kind of perpetuates
- 18:58and keeps them in poverty
- 19:01rather than helping them out of it.
- 19:03And if we're missing a big middle class,
- 19:06we're saying we're talking about like the
- 19:07poor kids that obviously should have food,
- 19:09but
- 19:10there's a big
- 19:11class outside of that that is struggling
- 19:15and doesn't have the food assistance,
- 19:16so I I I I don't think it's a.
- 19:20I hear you.
- 19:21So I was just talking about
- 19:22a scripture
- 19:23that guides me,
- 19:24and that's Matthew 25,
- 19:25about how we're judged and how we're saved.
- 19:28I forgot to add
- 19:29that that
- 19:29judgment
- 19:30is not just on individuals,
- 19:32it's also on the nations.
- 19:34So it is
- 19:34both us
- 19:35as people,
- 19:36it's also us as communities,
- 19:38and whether or not our communities,
- 19:40our nations,
- 19:40our governments
- 19:41are caring for the poor
- 19:43and the hungry
- 19:44and the widow and the orphan.
- 19:46So,
- 19:47if you look through the entire Bible,
- 19:49particularly the Hebrew scriptures,
- 19:50um,
- 19:51there's so much
- 19:52criticism
- 19:53of
- 19:54kingdoms and empires and governments
- 19:57for not doing right by their people.
- 19:59So many of the Hebrew prophets called out the powerful,
- 20:01the people who are in charge.
- 20:03The difference is today we live in a democracy,
- 20:05we don't live in an empire,
- 20:07and so we are making these decisions together.
- 20:09And when we decide
- 20:11as a country through the consent
- 20:12of the governed,
- 20:13that we want to pitch in to make sure
- 20:16that the most vulnerable people
- 20:17have what they need to succeed and fulfill their potential,
- 20:20I think it's a beautiful thing.
- 20:21I think it's a very Christian thing to do.
- 20:23There's so many
- 20:24politicians who talk about making this a Christian nation
- 20:27until it comes to feeding the hungry,
- 20:29until it comes to caring for the sick.
- 20:31Until it comes to serving the poor,
- 20:33you talked about people being long term
- 20:35on food assistance.
- 20:37I would say the reason for that is because
- 20:38we haven't raised the minimum wage in this country
- 20:41in
- 20:4215 years.
- 20:43Here in Texas,
- 20:44it's still
- 20:44a little over $7 an hour.
- 20:46We allow these giant multinational corporations making record profits
- 20:50to pay people poverty level wages.
- 20:53That is what's keeping people in a cycle.
- 20:55Of dependency.
- 20:55That's what's keeping people in poverty,
- 20:57not because we want to provide some basic healthcare and basic food assistance.
- 21:00There is,
- 21:01I think it's both.
- 21:02I think,
- 21:02I mean,
- 21:03on paper it's $7 but if you go to McDonald's,
- 21:06you,
- 21:06you're making $12 which is not good.
- 21:09It's still not in the great richest country in the world it is,
- 21:11it's,
- 21:11it's more than $7.
- 21:13But I think
- 21:14the,
- 21:15when you're trying to put government into,
- 21:17I mean charity into policy.
- 21:19You're taking away communities,
- 21:21you're taking away the power in communities rather than,
- 21:24and a lot of people
- 21:26if they don't have the education and the statistics,
- 21:29they kind of just go like you said,
- 21:30um,
- 21:31they vote based on the what the billionaires kind of like drift down
- 21:36but
- 21:37what's needed there is the education piece and keeping policies or putting.
- 21:42More money into systems that are keeping people longer into poverty
- 21:46or keeping them there
- 21:48isn't gonna we wanna lift people out of poverty.
- 21:50We,
- 21:50we wanna end poverty,
- 21:52uh,
- 21:52we wanna make sure that everyone
- 21:54can contribute what they have to give to this economy,
- 21:57to this country.
- 21:57That's the goal.
- 21:58And,
- 21:59and I think the way we do that
- 22:01is by unrigging the system because
- 22:03working hard no longer pays.
- 22:05It really doesn't.
- 22:07You can work multiple jobs and still not get into the middle class.
- 22:10That's what we have to fix.
- 22:11And you're right,
- 22:11it's not just government,
- 22:13it's also churches and nonprofits and community groups.
- 22:15It's all the above.
- 22:17All of us have to be working to make sure that every single Texan,
- 22:20every single American,
- 22:21can fulfill their God-given potential.
- 22:23All right,
- 22:24pause,
- 22:26your seat.
- 22:26Hey,
- 22:26good job,
- 22:27everybody.
- 22:29My next claim is that immigrants make America stronger and richer.
- 22:39Hi Jade.
- 22:40Hi.
- 22:40Nice to meet you.
- 22:41Let me just
- 22:42lay out what I mean by this because I know it sounds a little
- 22:45controversial.
- 22:46I'm an
- 22:478th generation
- 22:48Texan.
- 22:48My family's been here since it was Mexico.
- 22:51My mom actually grew up in Laredo,
- 22:53right on the Texas-Mexico border.
- 22:55I feel like we Texans understand immigration
- 22:58more than people outside of Texas because we live with it
- 23:01every day,
- 23:01the benefits and the challenges.
- 23:04The more I traveled the state,
- 23:06the more I've realized that most Texans are in the same spot on this issue.
- 23:10The metaphor I've used is that our southern border should be like our front porch.
- 23:14There should be a giant welcome mat out front
- 23:16and a lock on the door.
- 23:18We can both welcome the stranger,
- 23:20welcome immigrants who want to contribute to this economy,
- 23:23who want to live the American dream,
- 23:24who want to make us stronger and richer,
- 23:26and we can keep people out
- 23:28who mean to do us harm.
- 23:30I will say
- 23:31what I think
- 23:32not enough Democrats have been willing to say.
- 23:35Joe Biden failed us
- 23:37on our southern border.
- 23:38I remember talking to my colleagues in the Texas legislature
- 23:41who represent border communities.
- 23:42They told me about the utter chaos
- 23:44on the border.
- 23:45And that failure by Joe Biden
- 23:48paved the way for Donald Trump to come in
- 23:50with masked men
- 23:51in unmarked vehicles,
- 23:53secret police
- 23:54tearing parents from their children,
- 23:57kidnapping people off the street.
- 23:59I think both parties have failed us
- 24:01on this issue.
- 24:02I think we all should come together
- 24:03and finally pass comprehensive immigration reform,
- 24:06more immigration judges,
- 24:07more border patrol,
- 24:09modernize our ports of entry where most of the fentanyl gets in,
- 24:12reform our asylum system,
- 24:14relieve the visa backlog.
- 24:16We should finally fix this problem
- 24:18instead of grandstanding on it.
- 24:19I completely agree with you on that,
- 24:21um,
- 24:21but I disagree with is the claim that
- 24:24immigrants as a whole.
- 24:25Um,
- 24:26are making America stronger.
- 24:28I think there is a lot of nuance that is not
- 24:31added to that claim.
- 24:32I think that there are a lot of immigrants and immigrants are needed in this country.
- 24:37A lot of these immigrants are the ones that are driving America forward.
- 24:39I also think that there are a lot of immigrants
- 24:41who America is supposed to be a melting pot.
- 24:43America is supposed to
- 24:44have uh people from everywhere come together
- 24:47and there's this.
- 24:49Concept of assimilation where
- 24:51there should be partial assimilation.
- 24:53You don't,
- 24:53uh,
- 24:54no one should be forced to completely assimilate and
- 24:57change who they are and change their beliefs
- 24:59to fit in.
- 25:00But at the same time,
- 25:02whenever we have people coming to this country and then
- 25:05going out on the streets yelling that they hate the country,
- 25:08it's counterintuitive
- 25:09and it really does hurt America as a whole.
- 25:13Do you know any undocumented immigrants?
- 25:15No,
- 25:15I do not.
- 25:16When I was a teacher
- 25:17on the west side of San Antonio,
- 25:19I taught a lot of students who were undocumented,
- 25:23and I don't wanna stereotype,
- 25:24but
- 25:25those students
- 25:26tended to be
- 25:27the most patriotic,
- 25:28the hardest working students
- 25:30that I had in the classroom.
- 25:31They
- 25:32understood something about this country
- 25:34that
- 25:35even I,
- 25:36as a native born American,
- 25:38often take for granted.
- 25:39They believed that this was a land of opportunity,
- 25:42and they were ready to do whatever it took
- 25:44to make it in this country.
- 25:46And that's what generations of Italian
- 25:48and,
- 25:49uh,
- 25:49and Irish immigrants
- 25:51did in this country.
- 25:52And
- 25:52I think if we welcome folks who want to contribute.
- 25:55Who want to be Americans,
- 25:57it's going to make us stronger and richer because it already has.
- 26:00All right,
- 26:00pause.
- 26:01You've been voted out by the majority.
- 26:03So nice to meet you.
- 26:07Hi,
- 26:08how you doing?
- 26:08So,
- 26:09I would argue that as someone who has my dad's side,
- 26:12they come from immigrants and,
- 26:13you know,
- 26:14things like that.
- 26:15I'm originally from Florida,
- 26:16so
- 26:17I'm African and black,
- 26:18however you wanna put it.
- 26:20But
- 26:20I would say I'm I'm in favor of stricter
- 26:23of stricter borders mainly because
- 26:26when we have so many immigrants now that are just coming like as a flock and,
- 26:30you know,
- 26:30from everywhere,
- 26:31from India,
- 26:32from
- 26:33Japan,
- 26:34however you wanna put it.
- 26:35I think the thing,
- 26:36what's happening now is that like,
- 26:38just how
- 26:39um
- 26:39the guy who won for
- 26:42New York,
- 26:43what's his name,
- 26:45um Mandani,
- 26:46um,
- 26:46I think that the people when they when there's too many immigrants coming,
- 26:50they think that they know America better than the
- 26:53originators or people that are born here generationally,
- 26:56and
- 26:57Um,
- 26:57it causes a conflict on government,
- 26:59like,
- 26:59you know,
- 27:00uh,
- 27:01Rama Ramazani,
- 27:02I don't know how to say his name,
- 27:03the Indian guy,
- 27:04who was born here,
- 27:05right?
- 27:06And,
- 27:06um,
- 27:07now he's a part of the government,
- 27:08and I think that kinda plays a part in religion,
- 27:11um.
- 27:12Government,
- 27:13what we believe in because
- 27:15a lot of them
- 27:16may not be Christian,
- 27:17may be Buddhist,
- 27:18and they may just have a different ideology and may not like
- 27:21what you see for us,
- 27:22they may not see for us and they may try to change it.
- 27:24Same way how Indians come over and get
- 27:27HEB
- 27:28um
- 27:29H-1B visas or whatever,
- 27:32and they,
- 27:32you know,
- 27:32bond together,
- 27:34make money together and don't want any other race,
- 27:37culture working
- 27:38with them as a whole.
- 27:40So,
- 27:40that's why I believe overall,
- 27:43stricter borders should be put in place and a stricter um
- 27:47citizenship process
- 27:49because
- 27:49it's not the same as what it used to be.
- 27:51It used to be a lot easier,
- 27:53but now it's getting a lot harder,
- 27:54which is a good thing
- 27:55because,
- 27:55you know,
- 27:56I
- 27:56I agree that we need
- 27:58more secure borders.
- 27:59We're not disagreeing on that.
- 28:00What I am saying is that America as a melting pot is what makes us
- 28:04so special as a country,
- 28:05but it's also what makes us,
- 28:07uh,
- 28:07richer
- 28:08and stronger as a country.
- 28:10Have you
- 28:11ever heard the claim that Social Security is gonna go bankrupt?
- 28:15Maybe once or twice.
- 28:16Yeah.
- 28:16Do you know why Social Security
- 28:18isn't bankrupt today?
- 28:20Because of immigrants.
- 28:20Because of immigrants,
- 28:22undocumented people.
- 28:23Pause.
- 28:23So sorry
- 28:24you've been voted out.
- 28:25Please return to your seat.
- 28:26So nice to see you.
- 28:26Yeah,
- 28:27great job.
- 28:29Hey Malik,
- 28:30so we just got cut off.
- 28:31Um,
- 28:32have you heard the claim that Social Security is gonna go bankrupt?
- 28:36And do you know why Social Security is not bankrupt today?
- 28:39No.
- 28:40So it's immigrants that are keeping Social Security solvent.
- 28:43Undocumented people pay into Social Security through their I-10 numbers,
- 28:47and they don't take
- 28:48any benefits in return.
- 28:49So they
- 28:50single-handedly
- 28:51as a community in the shadows
- 28:52are keeping this
- 28:53system of ours solvent.
- 28:555%
- 28:56of the entire armed forces are immigrants.
- 29:00These are people who can't even vote.
- 29:01But they're willing to lay down their lives
- 29:03for this country,
- 29:05and we have 7 million,
- 29:06we have 7 million jobs
- 29:08that still need to be filled.
- 29:09We have more jobs than there are workers
- 29:11in this country.
- 29:12And so my argument here,
- 29:13this claim that I'm making
- 29:15is that
- 29:15by welcoming immigrants who want to contribute,
- 29:17who want to build
- 29:18their own American dream,
- 29:19they actually
- 29:20help benefit all of us and the entire economy.
- 29:22I would agree with that,
- 29:23but I think this conversation is going in an extremely dangerous direction.
- 29:27100%.
- 29:28And I'll tell you why,
- 29:29so it's really easy to identify a problem,
- 29:31what's the solution?
- 29:32Let's talk about immigration,
- 29:33and I,
- 29:34I would agree,
- 29:35they do make this country better,
- 29:36and I agree that huge
- 29:38welcome doormat and then
- 29:40locking the door.
- 29:41But,
- 29:42OK,
- 29:42what's the process of people actually getting to the door in the first place?
- 29:45What's gonna be deemed fair,
- 29:47what's gonna be deemed unfair?
- 29:49That's where the that's what's gonna cause any politician can say,
- 29:51yes,
- 29:52immigrants,
- 29:53good.
- 29:54Poor people should have money.
- 29:55It's like that.
- 29:55OK,
- 29:55cool,
- 29:56but like what does that process look like?
- 29:58Well,
- 29:58and I,
- 29:59I,
- 29:59I wanna talk about the specific solutions,
- 30:01but I do just want to acknowledge that both parties are
- 30:03not actually talking about welcoming immigrants and securing the border.
- 30:06So I think the problem here is we don't have
- 30:09candidates or elected officials who are speaking
- 30:11to the giant middle ground where most Texans and most Americans are.
- 30:15Most people are pro-immigrant and pro-security.
- 30:17And so am I.
- 30:18To answer your question about
- 30:20what would comprehensive reform look like,
- 30:22a lot of people say immigrants should come here the right way.
- 30:25I agree.
- 30:26The problem is there's not really a right way anymore.
- 30:28There's not even a,
- 30:29a,
- 30:30a line that moves at any real pace.
- 30:32There are people who have applied
- 30:34to be here who have waited 2030 years.
- 30:37Some people have died before they got a response back.
- 30:39That's not a line.
- 30:40If we want a real line,
- 30:42it has to be a fast moving line.
- 30:44We've got to prioritize people
- 30:46who are gonna fill the jobs that need to be filled,
- 30:48and we want to prioritize people who are actually claiming asylum
- 30:52and who need safety.
- 30:53Those are the groups in my mind
- 30:55that need to be prioritized.
- 30:56But we're never gonna be able to process
- 30:57those folks unless we have enough immigration judges,
- 31:00unless we have enough border patrol,
- 31:02unless we modernize the ports of entry.
- 31:0493% of the fentanyl that comes into this country
- 31:07comes through the ports of entry.
- 31:08It doesn't come over the Rio Grande,
- 31:10it comes through the ports.
- 31:11And we don't have the technology or the manpower to detect
- 31:14that fentanyl.
- 31:15And so those are things we have to do.
- 31:17Yeah,
- 31:17please,
- 31:17quickly,
- 31:17because like I said,
- 31:18this,
- 31:18this is where it gets really dangerous because that's what we can blow over.
- 31:22OK,
- 31:23we've identified the problem.
- 31:24The problem is there's not a
- 31:26quote unquote right process,
- 31:28but at the same time,
- 31:30There's,
- 31:31there needs to be some process.
- 31:32So
- 31:33with the line,
- 31:34what does that process look like,
- 31:36knowing that there's not a,
- 31:37a right and a
- 31:39quote unquote right,
- 31:39like what?
- 31:40OK,
- 31:40so what's the line gonna be?
- 31:41And a lot of,
- 31:41and a lot of the problem is manpower,
- 31:43right?
- 31:43We don't have enough
- 31:44folks in the system who are doing this work.
- 31:47The current administration
- 31:48has grown the size of ICE,
- 31:50Immigration and Customs Enforcement,
- 31:52except
- 31:53it's not people doing Immigration and Customs Enforcement.
- 31:55It is a secret police force
- 31:57that
- 31:57is terrorizing communities in North Texas.
- 32:01There was a mom and dad,
- 32:02the Vargases,
- 32:03they own a dry cleaners
- 32:05here in Dallas.
- 32:06They're beloved by their customers,
- 32:08by their neighbors.
- 32:09They were dropping their daughter off at Texas Tech University,
- 32:12one of the best universities
- 32:13in the state of Texas.
- 32:14They were on their way back
- 32:15from dropping her off at school.
- 32:17I stopped them.
- 32:19Detain them.
- 32:19They are still in a detention center.
- 32:21I,
- 32:22I do not want my law enforcement or my immigration enforcement officials
- 32:26focused on the Vargases.
- 32:27I want them focused on murderers and rapists and gang members,
- 32:31people who mean to do us harm.
- 32:33When we devote law enforcement resources to go after the Vargases,
- 32:36it makes us all less safe.
- 32:38So I'm just asking for sanity
- 32:40in the system.
- 32:41I'm
- 32:41pause.
- 32:42You've been voted out by the majority.
- 32:44Great job.
- 32:49Hi Tyler,
- 32:50good to see you.
- 32:50Yeah,
- 32:51alright,
- 32:51OK,
- 32:51so,
- 32:52um,
- 32:53you told a really horrible story that's a very sad story,
- 32:56um,
- 32:57but also
- 32:58they're undocumented,
- 32:59so this isn't just
- 33:01legal people who are here that came from another
- 33:04thing it's a definitely emotional story.
- 33:05It makes me feel horrible for those people that
- 33:07know that I think there needs to be some,
- 33:09some better processes here.
- 33:10Um,
- 33:11but it's,
- 33:12it's,
- 33:12they're,
- 33:13they're still illegal,
- 33:14right?
- 33:14They're not supposed to be here.
- 33:15It's wrong by
- 33:16government standards,
- 33:17right?
- 33:18I think borders are very biblical.
- 33:19We see Nehemiah,
- 33:20the first thing he did for his country when he returned to Israel,
- 33:24he built a wall,
- 33:25right?
- 33:25He built a wall.
- 33:26To keep those that wanted to harm them
- 33:28out,
- 33:28you know,
- 33:28I'm not saying that
- 33:30everyone coming here wants to wants to harm people,
- 33:32but I'm just saying that like biblically this,
- 33:34this reinforces it,
- 33:35um,
- 33:36and so
- 33:37yeah,
- 33:37yeah,
- 33:37I feel like there's I,
- 33:39I believe in borders,
- 33:40um,
- 33:40and I don't believe in amnesty.
- 33:42Um,
- 33:42let's take the Vargases.
- 33:43We were talking about how they are sympathetic,
- 33:45um,
- 33:45hardworking small business owners in our community.
- 33:48They've been here
- 33:48for decades.
- 33:49There needs to be a path to citizenship.
- 33:51That is not the same thing as amnesty
- 33:53because you're right,
- 33:54is there not a path to citizenship?
- 33:55No,
- 33:55and that's the problem.
- 33:56We've got
- 33:57millions of people who are living here in the shadows,
- 33:59and there is no path for them to actually come into compliance,
- 34:03which I want them to do.
- 34:03I,
- 34:04I'm,
- 34:04I'm a law and order Democrat.
- 34:05I believe that laws matter.
- 34:07And there should be consequences for breaking the law.
- 34:09But here's what I will say,
- 34:10Tyler.
- 34:10We do recognize in our legal system
- 34:12that there are different punishments for different kinds of offenses.
- 34:15There are civil offenses like
- 34:16being here without documentation.
- 34:18There are criminal offenses like
- 34:20murdering,
- 34:20raping someone,
- 34:21and those things are treated differently.
- 34:23And so
- 34:24in my mind,
- 34:24and again I'm open to,
- 34:25to negotiating how the details work,
- 34:27but there needs to be in broad strokes,
- 34:29a pathway
- 34:30to citizenship where
- 34:31they pay a fine.
- 34:33For being here without documentation or crossing the border illegally,
- 34:36there should be some penalty
- 34:38for that.
- 34:38I'm not disagreeing.
- 34:39They should also have to pay back taxes.
- 34:41Again,
- 34:41immigrants,
- 34:42undocumented immigrants in,
- 34:43uh,
- 34:44in particular pay
- 34:45a lot of taxes and don't get benefits in return,
- 34:47but
- 34:48they may be missing some of those taxes because they weren't citizens.
- 34:51They need to pay those back taxes,
- 34:52and
- 34:53they need to go through the citizenship process.
- 34:55They gotta take the test.
- 34:56They gotta learn about our government,
- 34:58they gotta learn about our culture.
- 34:59All that is so important.
- 35:00If they do all those things,
- 35:02and they've been here a long time and they've been contributing,
- 35:04I think they should be brought in.
- 35:05You just said they go through the,
- 35:06they need to go through the immigration process,
- 35:08but then you just told me a minute ago that there is no immigration process,
- 35:11that they can't become citizens.
- 35:11I'm talking about creating one.
- 35:12I'm talking about,
- 35:13that's what I mean when I say comprehensive immigration reform.
- 35:15It is building
- 35:17a process to where we can bring
- 35:19these millions of people living in the shadows into
- 35:21compliance because there's not a process right now.
- 35:23And what you're asking is
- 35:25the process.
- 35:25On the front end,
- 35:26how they got in here,
- 35:27and I hear so many people
- 35:29say they should come in the right way.
- 35:31We should create a process where there is a right way,
- 35:33where there's a line and it's a fast moving line.
- 35:35I mean,
- 35:35I think you would agree,
- 35:36Tyler,
- 35:36that someone shouldn't wait
- 35:3820 years
- 35:39to hear back on their application.
- 35:40That's not a process at all.
- 35:42And that encourages,
- 35:43that encourages people to come here
- 35:45the wrong way.
- 35:46So
- 35:46I'm saying this is a systemic problem.
- 35:49You've been voted out.
- 35:50Great job,
- 35:50Tyler,
- 35:50yeah.
- 35:53Hi,
- 35:54Shanice,
- 35:55so nice to meet you.
- 35:56Nice to meet you too.
- 35:57So I hear everything you're saying.
- 35:59I take disagreement with you saying like the Democrats nor the Republicans
- 36:04actually did a good job on border policy,
- 36:06because as an immigration attorney,
- 36:08it started under the
- 36:10Obama administration and continued under the Biden
- 36:13administration where they were deporting people
- 36:15for having crimes of moral turpitude.
- 36:17You would get these notice of deportation.
- 36:20Um,
- 36:20notices in the mail,
- 36:21so this idea or this
- 36:23notion
- 36:24that
- 36:25there was just this open border plan and nothing was being done is like,
- 36:29not true,
- 36:30and in terms of them not hiring people,
- 36:33even the Trump administration had spent a lot of time
- 36:35creating different courts and El Paso
- 36:38and trying to force people to stay out of
- 36:40the border and make Mexico create different courts.
- 36:43And even the Trump administration today is still
- 36:46hiring judges,
- 36:47immigration,
- 36:48immigration judges,
- 36:49and
- 36:50fast tracking
- 36:51people out of the country,
- 36:52so I don't understand.
- 36:55What exactly you're saying in terms and especially when you say public safety,
- 36:59because if we look at what's happening,
- 37:01we're talking about,
- 37:02we have mass shootings that happen because of
- 37:05US citizens,
- 37:06and so this like conflating of
- 37:09illegal immigration and public safety,
- 37:12I just think is like a misinformation.
- 37:14And as a politician,
- 37:16for me,
- 37:17I expect you
- 37:18To come up with an argument that makes sense.
- 37:21Like you said,
- 37:22OK,
- 37:23we wanna create pathways to citizenship.
- 37:25Well,
- 37:25how do you do that for people who are illegal?
- 37:28We had DAPA,
- 37:29we had DACA
- 37:30that created work visas,
- 37:31but that wasn't a way to,
- 37:32a pathway to citizenship,
- 37:34and that's not fair to the people who have H-1B visas.
- 37:37That's not fair to people who have K visas for.
- 37:41Um,
- 37:41their fiance,
- 37:42so I'm just a little confused as to why we would fast track people
- 37:46who are here undocumented
- 37:48and ignore people who have been waiting in the visa process line
- 37:51for a long time.
- 37:52Well,
- 37:53first,
- 37:53thank you for your work on this topic.
- 37:55I want to just clarify a few things.
- 37:56I never said that we had an open border policy.
- 37:58Um,
- 37:59I also
- 38:00don't
- 38:01think we should fast track anybody.
- 38:03What I'm trying to do is create a system that works.
- 38:05And when I speak about the failures
- 38:07of both political parties,
- 38:09including my own,
- 38:10it is the failure to pass comprehensive immigration reform,
- 38:13and that's a failure
- 38:14from George W.
- 38:14Bush
- 38:15to Barack Obama,
- 38:16to Donald Trump the first time,
- 38:18Joe Biden,
- 38:18and Donald Trump the 2nd time.
- 38:20What I'm saying is we should be going after the cartels,
- 38:22not our communities.
- 38:23We should be hunting down human traffickers,
- 38:26not
- 38:27moms and babies.
- 38:28We should be deporting
- 38:29gang members,
- 38:30not,
- 38:30not,
- 38:31not small business owners.
- 38:32We did that.
- 38:33So
- 38:34and I,
- 38:34and I think that was great to have a prioritization
- 38:36in terms of deportation,
- 38:38much better than what we have now.
- 38:39But when you deported.
- 38:41Crime or people that were part of cartels and we were doing that in like the 90s,
- 38:44the early 2000s,
- 38:46you happened to destabilize Central America,
- 38:48which caused an influx of immigration
- 38:51that we've never seen before.
- 38:52So this idea of like,
- 38:53let's knock down doors and
- 38:55do uh come after the cartel,
- 38:57I agree with,
- 38:58but I'm confused,
- 38:59you also said we had to do something
- 39:01about people who had been here undocumented.
- 39:04My question is,
- 39:04what is your actual comprehensive policy look like for those people
- 39:09who have been waiting in line.
- 39:10Yes,
- 39:10because we do have a pathway to citizenship through visas.
- 39:13Yeah,
- 39:14I,
- 39:14I,
- 39:14like I said,
- 39:15I want for those that are living in the shadows,
- 39:17I want them to have a pathway.
- 39:18I'm not saying they should jump in front of anybody else.
- 39:20What I'm saying is we have to bring them out of the shadows because
- 39:23it makes us all safer and it makes us more prosperous.
- 39:26But I would love,
- 39:26I mean,
- 39:27you tell me this is a conversation.
- 39:29You're
- 39:29much more of an expert in immigration law than I am,
- 39:32so tell me what you think that policy should look like.
- 39:34I think
- 39:35if you do what was attempted to do for DACA and DAPA,
- 39:39if you've been.
- 39:39Here for 10 years or you were brought as a child and you were enrolled in school,
- 39:43you should have a pathway to citizenship.
- 39:45I do understand the fundamental policy of not breaking up families,
- 39:49but I don't understand how we
- 39:52allow their children to stay illegally.
- 39:54Like,
- 39:55do you let them stay,
- 39:56get pathways to citizenships,
- 39:58and then turn around,
- 39:59allow their family to do the family visas and
- 40:02make people return back to their original country,
- 40:04because we have to remember if we do that part of it,
- 40:07people go to jail when they go back.
- 40:08We have
- 40:09Like
- 40:09laws in place with different countries,
- 40:12especially in the Caribbean,
- 40:13where if you were in America illegally,
- 40:15you go to jail to come back.
- 40:16So when you go back,
- 40:17so there's no,
- 40:19to me,
- 40:19I don't think we should fast track undocumented workers,
- 40:23or I think we should probably give people work visas,
- 40:26but I don't agree with you necessarily getting citizenship because
- 40:29what other path,
- 40:30why would other people take the better route,
- 40:32which is not to be undocumented and actually apply for a visa.?
- 40:35So tell me,
- 40:35here's where I get hung up.
- 40:37Tell me what we do with kids.
- 40:39Because I,
- 40:39I was telling you how I,
- 40:40as a public school teacher,
- 40:41taught a lot of students who were undocumented.
- 40:43Many of them
- 40:44were saved by DACA.
- 40:45What do we do for those kids who were brought here
- 40:48through no fault of their own,
- 40:49without their consent?
- 40:50They now live here in America.
- 40:51This is the country they know.
- 40:52They know no other country.
- 40:54What are we doing about their parents?
- 40:56And
- 40:57you mentioned DAPA being an opportunity for parents.
- 40:59So if we kept work visas for their family,
- 41:02their parents,
- 41:03and allowed them to stay and they find a pathway to citizenship,
- 41:06if you qualify.
- 41:07the border before you were like 6 and we can prove you were here,
- 41:10then I agree.
- 41:11But I think after that age,
- 41:13it gets too murky
- 41:14with trying to,
- 41:16you know,
- 41:16because people will falsify documents,
- 41:17they'll falsify pictures and so you start,
- 41:19it gets harder and harder to do.
- 41:21I mean,
- 41:21this is the beauty of public policy,
- 41:23right?
- 41:23When we step out of the algorithms and the news networks,
- 41:26people can sit down,
- 41:27even if they may be coming at it from a different point of view.
- 41:30And be able to hammer out a solution that actually
- 41:32works and I always try to listen to the experts,
- 41:34um,
- 41:34because as a
- 41:35politician there's no way you can be an expert in everything.
- 41:38And so I think you and I,
- 41:39some of the solutions we've just talked about,
- 41:41that's exactly what we need to be focused on if we're gonna fix the system.
- 41:44I think secret police is not the answer,
- 41:46and we have got to find a better path forward on immigration.
- 41:49All right,
- 41:49Pa,
- 41:50you've been voted out.
- 41:51Please return to your great job.
- 41:51It's nice to meet you,
- 41:52yeah.
- 41:55Hi
- 41:55Terrence,
- 41:56nice to meet you.
- 41:57I'm,
- 41:57I'm kind of tough.
- 41:58I'm not soft,
- 41:59OK?
- 42:00So the border,
- 42:01I think it,
- 42:02it needs to be like closed for a while.
- 42:04You said that,
- 42:05uh,
- 42:06you know,
- 42:06immigrants are some of the most patriot patriotic
- 42:10in my students,
- 42:11your students,
- 42:12your students.
- 42:13I think that
- 42:14it is black people and foundational black Americans
- 42:17that are the most patriotic in America.
- 42:20Why are we not closing the border and using
- 42:24the
- 42:24drugs that are coming in,
- 42:25the money that's coming in from these drugs?
- 42:27Why are we
- 42:29spending money on private schools and letting
- 42:31these private companies fund these private schools,
- 42:33uh,
- 42:34and not putting money into the black neighborhoods and brown neighborhoods that
- 42:38were here for so long in America and actually built.
- 42:41What a lot of immigrants
- 42:44enjoy today
- 42:45and what are you gonna do
- 42:46to kind of
- 42:47lend a hand in that way?
- 42:49Yeah,
- 42:49I don't think we're disagreeing that we
- 42:51need way more investment in our communities,
- 42:53particularly
- 42:53black neighborhoods all over Texas,
- 42:55um,
- 42:56but I would say that this discussion about immigration also applies.
- 42:59To black people,
- 43:00um,
- 43:00because we have black immigrants,
- 43:02not all immigrants that that come to this country are from,
- 43:04let me,
- 43:05let me start,
- 43:05let's let's let's cut out the black immigrants right now.
- 43:09I'm talking about foundational black Americans
- 43:11and foundational white Americans,
- 43:13so I'm a native of Texas and a descendant of slavery,
- 43:16right?
- 43:17So why are we not focusing on that instead
- 43:20of like closing the border I mean these people,
- 43:22I'm,
- 43:23we're not,
- 43:23it's not America's job,
- 43:25right?
- 43:26To take care of someone's child and mother from another country,
- 43:29that's that country's job,
- 43:30OK?
- 43:31If they wanna
- 43:32put America as a dumping ground and then we have
- 43:35to now spend money to put these immigrants somewhere else,
- 43:38that's unfair to me and other foundational white Americans.
- 43:41So here's where I agree with you,
- 43:42we need way more investment
- 43:44in our communities
- 43:45here in America.
- 43:46That's why I fight.
- 43:48Yeah,
- 43:48it's why I fight for how
- 43:51do we need to invest in those communities.
- 43:52Yeah,
- 43:52it's why I fight for public education in the Texas legislature.
- 43:56Uh,
- 43:56it's why I have fought to lower housing costs and provide more funding
- 44:00for affordable housing.
- 44:01Let's take,
- 44:02uh,
- 44:03education
- 44:03just to drill down.
- 44:04As you know,
- 44:05I was a public school teacher,
- 44:06so I know the system
- 44:07from
- 44:08the inside out.
- 44:09By the time kids show up to kindergarten,
- 44:11in the first grade,
- 44:13kids who
- 44:14grew up in poverty
- 44:15are already behind their peers.
- 44:18The affluent peers who
- 44:19have
- 44:20enrichment opportunities,
- 44:21have summer camps,
- 44:22who hear
- 44:24a lot more words because they have a stay at
- 44:26home parent or a parent who can't stay at home
- 44:28versus kids who grew up in poverty.
- 44:30I think the way to fix that,
- 44:31and this is what I've worked on in the legislature,
- 44:33is high quality,
- 44:35universal.
- 44:36Early childhood education for
- 44:38every child,
- 44:39no matter their zip code,
- 44:40no matter their race,
- 44:41no matter how much money their parents make,
- 44:43because
- 44:44those 1st 1000 days of a child's life,
- 44:46those 1st 3 years are the most important in terms of brain development.
- 44:49And if they aren't
- 44:50catching up in kindergarten,
- 44:52you know that's just gonna get worse
- 44:53the longer they're in the public education system.
- 44:56And so we're setting up these students for failure,
- 44:58and I agree with you.
- 44:59These students are,
- 45:00they're children of promise.
- 45:01Again,
- 45:02they're made in the image of God.
- 45:03They have something to contribute.
- 45:05Our job is to create a system that allows them to do that.
- 45:07I think early childhood education is a key part of it.
- 45:09Are you willing to take away
- 45:11the money that we're putting toward,
- 45:13um,
- 45:14bringing other.
- 45:16Immigrants in
- 45:18because most immigrants take away from the jobs.
- 45:20A lot of people can't find jobs after they graduate college.
- 45:24It takes a long time for them to do that because
- 45:26most of the even the idea
- 45:29has to be sped up
- 45:30in order to get that job because the immigrant can get
- 45:32that job and can get that job for way less.
- 45:34So we've talked about where we agree,
- 45:35which is investment in
- 45:37all kinds of neighborhoods but investment for Americans,
- 45:41um,
- 45:42where we disagree I think
- 45:43is this idea that.
- 45:45Immigrants as a whole
- 45:46are a drain on this country.
- 45:48That's where I strongly disagree,
- 45:51because
- 45:51these immigrants are doing jobs
- 45:53that native born Americans won't do.
- 45:55And here's,
- 45:55and here I'll give you an example.
- 45:56Let me just give you an example.
- 45:57I disagree.
- 45:57How do you,
- 45:58how do you know that?
- 45:59Let me,
- 45:59I'll give you an example.
- 46:00Yeah,
- 46:00let me give you an example.
- 46:01Who did you ask?
- 46:03I actually,
- 46:03I,
- 46:04I talked to an avocado farmer
- 46:06in California who's been running this farm
- 46:08for
- 46:0920 years.
- 46:10He said he has never had
- 46:12a native born American apply to work
- 46:14for one of his jobs.
- 46:15And let me ask you a question.
- 46:17Let me ask you a question real quick,
- 46:18OK.
- 46:18How many black people are in California?
- 46:21In
- 46:21Los Angeles or in California in total.
- 46:23I don't know.
- 46:24I don't know.
- 46:25It's under 7% now.
- 46:26He doesn't have enough people
- 46:29that need jobs in California for you to make that statement toward Texas.
- 46:33Texas,
- 46:34more black people stay in Texas,
- 46:35more foundational white Americans stay in Texas.
- 46:37Let's just talk holistically.
- 46:39There are 7 million jobs.
- 46:40Realistically it doesn't work for everyone.
- 46:41Well,
- 46:42no,
- 46:42but I'm talking
- 46:43globally about the economy.
- 46:44There are 7 million jobs
- 46:46that are unfilled in this country.
- 46:48We have more jobs than we do workers in America right now,
- 46:52and these are,
- 46:53as you know,
- 46:54some of the toughest jobs,
- 46:55right?
- 46:55Picking our fruit,
- 46:56um,
- 46:57taking care of our children and our elders.
- 47:00Um,
- 47:00paving our highways,
- 47:02these are jobs that are difficult,
- 47:04and
- 47:05the research shows that
- 47:06undocumented immigrants
- 47:07are really just competing against
- 47:09other
- 47:10recent immigrants.
- 47:11They're not competing with native born Americans
- 47:13who in many cases,
- 47:14whether it's that avocado farm
- 47:16or
- 47:16whether it's other industries across the country,
- 47:18native born Americans will not sign up to mow our lawns
- 47:21and so.
- 47:22If we go after these immigrants,
- 47:24we're not just hurting them and their families
- 47:26and their ability to
- 47:27live the American dream,
- 47:28we're hurting
- 47:29the entire economy,
- 47:30we're hurting ourselves.
- 47:31And then I'll go one step further.
- 47:33Those immigrants go on oftentimes to create jobs.
- 47:3650% of all Fortune 500 CEOs are immigrants.
- 47:4025% of all entrepreneurs
- 47:42are immigrants.
- 47:43The research shows that
- 47:44immigrants.
- 47:45And their children have a higher economic mobility rate
- 47:48than native born Americans.
- 47:49So these are strivers.
- 47:50They're dreamers,
- 47:51they're doers.
- 47:52Unlike what some politicians say,
- 47:54in the vast majority of cases,
- 47:55these countries are sending their best,
- 47:57and they do make us stronger and richer through their military service
- 48:01and through the doing the jobs that need to be done in this economy.
- 48:03All right,
- 48:03pause.
- 48:04That's time.
- 48:05Please return to your seat.
- 48:06Great job.
- 48:07Nice to meet you.
- 48:10My next claim is that your vote matters
- 48:13in 2026.
- 48:20Hi,
- 48:21what's your name?
- 48:21Michaela,
- 48:22nice to meet you.
- 48:23It's nice to meet you.
- 48:24Since,
- 48:24since this is a new claim,
- 48:25let me just
- 48:26kind of tell you what I'm thinking,
- 48:27and then I would love to open this up.
- 48:29When I first ran for office,
- 48:30I was a 28-year-old
- 48:31public school teacher,
- 48:32and I was running in a Republican district as a Democrat.
- 48:35And so I had to knock on
- 48:36literally every door
- 48:38in order to get elected,
- 48:39and I was trying to talk to my fellow young people.
- 48:41I'm a millennial.
- 48:42I was also trying to talk to Gen Z,
- 48:43and I kept hearing this
- 48:45refrain,
- 48:46I'm not interested in politics.
- 48:48And at some point I was just honest with them.
- 48:49I said,
- 48:50you may not be interested in politics,
- 48:51but politics is interested in you.
- 48:54You may not care about politics,
- 48:55but your boss at work
- 48:57cares about politics.
- 48:58Your landlord
- 49:00cares about politics.
- 49:01Your insurance company
- 49:02cares about politics,
- 49:03and until you care about politics,
- 49:05they're gonna keep using the political system to screw you over.
- 49:08Uh,
- 49:08Barbara Jordan,
- 49:09a great Texan,
- 49:10had this quote where she said,
- 49:11If you're not at the table,
- 49:12you're on the menu.
- 49:13And so the argument I'm making with this claim is if
- 49:16young people in particular
- 49:18aren't at the table in this election,
- 49:19we will continue to be on the menu
- 49:21in 2027.
- 49:22OK,
- 49:23so I agree that the younger generations are essentially our future.
- 49:27Um,
- 49:27I'm completely like undecided.
- 49:29I have no idea
- 49:31which route I want to go specifically because like,
- 49:34I am a younger generation that wasn't necessarily educated on it,
- 49:38you know what I mean?
- 49:38And
- 49:39I don't entirely
- 49:42feel like I strongly just don't
- 49:44feel that like my voice matters,
- 49:45you know,
- 49:46I'm a content creator myself.
- 49:47There on election day,
- 49:49I made a joke like,
- 49:49oh my God,
- 49:50I didn't even realize it was election day.
- 49:52And my whole fan base was like,
- 49:53your vote matters,
- 49:53like you were supposed to use that vote.
- 49:55But for someone who's undecided,
- 49:56if I'm not confident in an answer.
- 49:59Like,
- 49:59why would it,
- 50:00why would my voice,
- 50:01voice matter,
- 50:01you know what I mean?
- 50:02Yeah,
- 50:03I hear that.
- 50:03And
- 50:04your first point about how
- 50:06we don't teach
- 50:07young people
- 50:08about the system of government and,
- 50:09and how to vote and what it means,
- 50:12we're doing them a disservice,
- 50:13and we are actively disenfranchising them by
- 50:15not empowering them with that knowledge.
- 50:17In my first term in legislature,
- 50:19I actually got a bipartisan bill
- 50:21through the state house.
- 50:22It,
- 50:22it ended up dying in the state Senate
- 50:24for comprehensive civics education.
- 50:26It's been a long time since we've had a real civics education in this country
- 50:30that teach young people
- 50:32how to take ownership
- 50:34of.
- 50:34The democratic process
- 50:35and I think that's absolutely necessary if we're gonna give people the tools
- 50:39and the resources
- 50:40to remake this broken political system
- 50:42in their own image because I because
- 50:44politics is corrupt.
- 50:46I will tell you that as someone who's in politics,
- 50:48the system is corrupt from
- 50:50top to bottom.
- 50:51The only way that's gonna change
- 50:53is if people like you,
- 50:54people around the circle,
- 50:55people all over the state.
- 50:57Decide
- 50:58to take that power back
- 51:00and transform
- 51:01this broken system.
- 51:02So I'm not disagreeing that it's rigged.
- 51:04I'm not disagreeing that it's stacked,
- 51:06that's all true.
- 51:07I think where we may be disagreeing
- 51:09is that
- 51:10we're powerless to change it.
- 51:11I don't believe that.
- 51:12I have faith,
- 51:13maybe not evidence,
- 51:15but I have faith
- 51:16that when we come together across all of our
- 51:17divisions that are put in place by billionaires.
- 51:20When we do that,
- 51:21we can change this country for the better.
- 51:23It may not go fast,
- 51:24but it'll happen.
- 51:25You've been voted out.
- 51:26Please return to your seat.
- 51:27Great job.
- 51:27Yeah,
- 51:27thank you.
- 51:30Hey,
- 51:30all right,
- 51:30I'm gonna come at you hard on this.
- 51:323 points.
- 51:33One
- 51:33is it's contradictory to what you said earlier.
- 51:35You said billionaires and billionaires control it.
- 51:37They're all bad guys.
- 51:38We hate them.
- 51:39We know how that happens,
- 51:40right?
- 51:40Advertisements.
- 51:41And so,
- 51:43um,
- 51:43one,
- 51:44that's,
- 51:44that's contradictory.
- 51:45Uh,
- 51:45you're saying it matters.
- 51:46You're also saying it doesn't matter because of millionaires and millionaires.
- 51:49Two,
- 51:49politicians contribute.
- 51:51Politicians are half of the problem.
- 51:53Things like we put R&D
- 51:55on the,
- 51:56uh,
- 51:56voting card.
- 51:57Why?
- 51:58If,
- 51:58if you don't know
- 52:00who you're voting for,
- 52:01why would we put that there?
- 52:02If you're too uneducated and stupid,
- 52:04why are we giving you the worst shortcut ever?
- 52:07And that's a political system.
- 52:09And then we do things like get out and vote.
- 52:10I'll tell you
- 52:11this
- 52:12at a bar
- 52:13and I see this giant sign
- 52:15over the stage in a bar,
- 52:17get out and vote.
- 52:19That's idiotic because the only person that's
- 52:21gonna influence is the person who said,
- 52:23I'm not gonna vote,
- 52:24but you know what?
- 52:24I was at a bar and drinking.
- 52:25I saw a sign.
- 52:26I'm gonna be an informed,
- 52:27educated voter.
- 52:28No,
- 52:28we don't want those people voting.
- 52:30And then lastly,
- 52:31honestly,
- 52:31James,
- 52:32I don't think you're gonna do anything.
- 52:33We've heard it before,
- 52:34you know,
- 52:34drain the swamp,
- 52:35eat the rich
- 52:37until they get voted,
- 52:38and then they're just rich people swimming in the swamp.
- 52:40What,
- 52:41what are you gonna actually do
- 52:42that changes that system that you're talking about?
- 52:45Yeah,
- 52:45well,
- 52:45one,
- 52:46I agree you shouldn't drink and vote.
- 52:48Uh,
- 52:48you gotta keep those two things separate.
- 52:49We'd probably get better voters,
- 52:51honestly.
- 52:52Two,
- 52:53you're not gonna hear me defend
- 52:54this two party system.
- 52:55Um,
- 52:56I actually think it's corrosive in our politics.
- 52:59It's hard to break out of,
- 53:00but I would be very interested
- 53:01in.
- 53:02Supporting policies that allow for multiple parties,
- 53:05um,
- 53:05because a lot of other countries
- 53:06have way more than two parties,
- 53:08and I think it allows for
- 53:10more
- 53:11collaboration,
- 53:11more interest to be
- 53:13represented,
- 53:14more issues to be heard,
- 53:15so
- 53:16I'm,
- 53:16I'm very dissatisfied with the two party system.
- 53:18Big money is powerful,
- 53:19don't get me wrong.
- 53:20But it is nothing
- 53:21compared to people power.
- 53:22We,
- 53:22we may not have the money,
- 53:23but we have the majority.
- 53:25What are you gonna do?
- 53:25How are you?
- 53:26So let's talk about that one.
- 53:27Let me be very honest with you.
- 53:28Specific.
- 53:29I don't want the general.
- 53:29I want a specific.
- 53:30Let me be honest with you.
- 53:31Let me be honest with you.
- 53:33I alone am not gonna change this.
- 53:34I know there are some politicians who say I alone can fix it.
- 53:37I'm not one of them
- 53:38because I don't
- 53:39wanna promise you something I can't deliver.
- 53:41My goal with this campaign
- 53:43is to be a catalyst
- 53:44for
- 53:45people all over the state to come together and organize
- 53:48so that we can start again,
- 53:50not finish,
- 53:50but start
- 53:51our way toward
- 53:53a more representative form of government.
- 53:55So specifically,
- 53:56we talked earlier about
- 53:57comprehensive immigration reform.
- 53:59I think we also need comprehensive political reform.
- 54:02I hope my first vote if I'm elected as US senator
- 54:05would be the for the People Act,
- 54:06which is something that's already been introduced.
- 54:08I'm sure it'll change the details of it.
- 54:10But a few things that it does
- 54:12is it gets big money out of politics,
- 54:13it ends Citizens United,
- 54:15which may be the most disastrous policy
- 54:18for our democracy in modern American history.
- 54:20And then it goes further
- 54:22and it bans things like gerrymandering,
- 54:24because
- 54:25gerrymandering is when politicians redraw
- 54:27political lines to benefit themselves.
- 54:29Democrats do it and Republicans do it.
- 54:31Not always the same amount,
- 54:32but they both do it.
- 54:33Because
- 54:34it's not an issue of party,
- 54:35it's an issue of power.
- 54:36People in power want to stay in power.
- 54:38That's the most
- 54:39predictable thing
- 54:40in history.
- 54:41I've actually been a victim of this.
- 54:43I told you I first ran as a Democrat in a Republican seat.
- 54:47And I won that seat,
- 54:48um,
- 54:49because I brought people together across partisan divides.
- 54:52And then my Republican colleagues in the legislature
- 54:55in 2020 decided to draw me out of that district.
- 54:58They basically
- 54:59broke my district in half,
- 55:00so that they could guarantee the outcome they wanted.
- 55:02Thankfully,
- 55:03I survived because I was able to
- 55:05move a couple of miles down the road and run in the district I grew up in.
- 55:09But I saw firsthand how gerrymandering,
- 55:11how this corrupt redistricting process
- 55:13silences the voices of the people.
- 55:15Again,
- 55:17the deck is I need specifics.
- 55:18Like I,
- 55:18I would love for you,
- 55:19if you don't have the people
- 55:21before you get,
- 55:22before you get my vote,
- 55:23I need a specific plan published on your website and say this is the law.
- 55:26This is how we're covering unintended consequences because.
- 55:30I hope you're right.
- 55:31I've heard it all before,
- 55:32and it's,
- 55:33I feel like I've been hearing it for 20 years.
- 55:34Well,
- 55:35and,
- 55:35and I would say I,
- 55:36I also feel
- 55:38tempted by
- 55:39hopelessness.
- 55:39I really do.
- 55:40There are some days when I'm on the floor of the Texas House
- 55:43and I'm fighting for a policy I believe in on health care,
- 55:46on education,
- 55:47on housing,
- 55:47on
- 55:48stopping fentanyl overdoses.
- 55:50And I lose that fight.
- 55:51I'm not hopeless,
- 55:52I'm disengaged.
- 55:54I'm just telling you how I feel sometimes and it's hopeless,
- 55:56because I'll walk off the floor after that
- 55:58long fight when I've lost.
- 56:00I'll walk out to my truck,
- 56:01I'll drive home,
- 56:02and I'll just feel totally and utterly defeated.
- 56:04And so I can't imagine how someone on the outside
- 56:07must feel when they look at this political system.
- 56:09The only thing I'm trying to convince you of,
- 56:11the only way out of it
- 56:13is through you.
- 56:14And through the people around the circle,
- 56:15not me.
- 56:16It's actually not through politicians.
- 56:17Politicians will not save us.
- 56:19It will be the people of this state and this country that save us
- 56:21because it's the only thing that ever has.
- 56:23All right,
- 56:23pause.
- 56:23You've been voted out.
- 56:24Please return to your seat.
- 56:28Hi,
- 56:29what's your name?
- 56:30Latal,
- 56:30it's nice to meet you.
- 56:31Nice to meet you.
- 56:32So I disagree in the fact that
- 56:36my vote matters because
- 56:39not only things that I've historically seen,
- 56:41but let's just talk about
- 56:43the last,
- 56:43let's just say the 4 years
- 56:45while I was in law school,
- 56:47I had an internship at Capitol Capitol Hill
- 56:50and I actually at the time.
- 56:53You know,
- 56:53Democrat because I was going with my family,
- 56:55how I was raised,
- 56:57but there were a lot of things that I saw.
- 56:59It was actually something that you had touched on earlier
- 57:01about
- 57:02the corporations,
- 57:03their involvement,
- 57:04them paying
- 57:05money to different politicians and it was on both sides
- 57:08and I really.
- 57:08Realize that they all laid in the same bed.
- 57:10There,
- 57:11there is no different.
- 57:12I changed.
- 57:13I went when I got back to Texas,
- 57:15I took that off and I'm like put me down as an undecided or independent
- 57:18voter
- 57:19like you are very charismatic.
- 57:21I like a lot of things that you said,
- 57:23however.
- 57:24I'm still the how
- 57:26and how is it gonna be done.
- 57:27So the gerrymandering,
- 57:28obviously that's been an issue.
- 57:31So if you have politicians involved in that,
- 57:33pretty much you're already saying that my vote doesn't matter,
- 57:36that it's about what the politician wants
- 57:38or the particular party.
- 57:40Also,
- 57:40there's something else that I don't,
- 57:42I don't like that the Democrats do
- 57:44or even really on both sides,
- 57:46you know,
- 57:46make sure that the communities are informed
- 57:49of
- 57:50what you've done or what you're gonna do,
- 57:52even down to us just voting for
- 57:55the propositions.
- 57:56The language was written in a way to where people didn't understand it.
- 58:00Also,
- 58:01again,
- 58:01both parties weren't out there trying.
- 58:02To inform the people
- 58:04to make sure that they understood
- 58:05what each proposition was saying.
- 58:07And so to me it just seems like it's,
- 58:10it's pretty much all controlled
- 58:12and it's not about what I want,
- 58:15it's not about the needs of the people and that it's,
- 58:18it's already a fixed race and it's already decided.
- 58:20So
- 58:21my thing is,
- 58:22what are you gonna do
- 58:23to not only inform the voters.
- 58:25But what are you gonna do to even,
- 58:27because we've talked a lot about the system,
- 58:29you know,
- 58:30but this is 100 years of a system
- 58:32that's not
- 58:33looking like it's gonna be shaken.
- 58:34All right,
- 58:35pause.
- 58:35You've been voted out.
- 58:36Please return to your seat.
- 58:37Thank you.
- 58:39That's so much I wanted to say.
- 58:42How's it going,
- 58:42James?
- 58:43Great name.
- 58:43Yeah,
- 58:43I know,
- 58:43right?
- 58:44Both our parents had good naming conventions,
- 58:46right?
- 58:46Yeah,
- 58:46yeah.
- 58:47Why do I feel like my vote doesn't matter?
- 58:49Because
- 58:51as somebody who is a working class.
- 58:54Uh,
- 58:55attached to the queer community
- 58:57and a non-Christian,
- 58:59there is nobody in our legislature that speaks to the things that I care about.
- 59:03Christian policy,
- 59:05uh,
- 59:05typically
- 59:06works kind of in the same vein of my belief system,
- 59:10but there are certain ways that it doesn't,
- 59:13um,
- 59:14as far as like the queer community,
- 59:16especially here in Texas,
- 59:18who's speaking out for them?
- 59:20Who's talking about them?
- 59:21Besides,
- 59:22you know,
- 59:22trans people are ruining sports,
- 59:24which
- 59:26Not gonna get into that.
- 59:28The final,
- 59:29and to me what feels like the biggest crux of all of this
- 59:32is,
- 59:33no matter how informed I am,
- 59:35no matter how much I research my stuff,
- 59:39all of us in this room research everything,
- 59:42that's 25 of us
- 59:44means 25 people out of,
- 59:46let's say just this block,
- 59:48this,
- 59:48the,
- 59:48where,
- 59:48where we're at right now,
- 59:50there's 500 people in this block,
- 59:5125 people are informed,
- 59:53475
- 59:55probably aren't.
- 59:56And they're more than likely gonna vote with
- 59:59the gerrymandered people who are already in power.
- 1:00:03So when you say that my vote matters,
- 1:00:06All of my stuff plus the fact of that I've been gerrymandered into hell.
- 1:00:11Why?
- 1:00:12So
- 1:00:13based on my personal experience
- 1:00:15when I was running for the legislature 8 years ago,
- 1:00:18I was running in
- 1:00:21A gerrymander district
- 1:00:22that
- 1:00:23was built to vote for Republicans and I was running as a Democrat.
- 1:00:27The deck was stacked against me.
- 1:00:29The deck was stacked against a lot of people in my community,
- 1:00:32but we organized.
- 1:00:33We didn't just vote.
- 1:00:34Voting is the bare minimum in a democracy.
- 1:00:37We organized.
- 1:00:37We went block by block.
- 1:00:39We talked voter to voter,
- 1:00:41and we ended up winning that district with 51% of the vote.
- 1:00:44I say that
- 1:00:44number
- 1:00:45because that means it was just a handful of votes.
- 1:00:48That's right.
- 1:00:48That's right.
- 1:00:49And not every election is gonna be decided by a handful of votes.
- 1:00:51So I wanna be honest about that,
- 1:00:53but some elections that are very consequential will be decided by a handful of votes
- 1:00:57and by getting me elected to that position,
- 1:00:59I have fought
- 1:01:00for LGBTQ people in the state.
- 1:01:03I have fought for their dignity.
- 1:01:04I have fought for their equality,
- 1:01:06and I will always do so,
- 1:01:08and I may not always win every fight,
- 1:01:10but I am there as a voice because
- 1:01:12people believe their votes matter.
- 1:01:14So I,
- 1:01:14I hear that you're.
- 1:01:16Dishheartened,
- 1:01:16believe me,
- 1:01:17it's even more disheartening when you're in the system,
- 1:01:19um,
- 1:01:20but I have seen glimmers of hope,
- 1:01:22and a little bit of hope is a dangerous thing
- 1:01:24because
- 1:01:25Raphael Warnock,
- 1:01:26senator from Georgia,
- 1:01:27has this,
- 1:01:28this thing that he says.
- 1:01:29He says,
- 1:01:30a,
- 1:01:30a vote is like a prayer for a better world.
- 1:01:33You may not always
- 1:01:34see those prayers realized
- 1:01:36in your lifetime,
- 1:01:38but having faith and not necessarily religious faith,
- 1:01:40but faith in.
- 1:01:41In this American experiment,
- 1:01:43that faith means that your hope
- 1:01:46is that your sunset is someone else's dawn for sure.
- 1:01:49Progress is a relay race and we pass it on
- 1:01:51to the next generation plus you've been voted out.
- 1:01:52Please return to your seat for sure.
- 1:01:55Hey,
- 1:01:56how are you?
- 1:01:57Ashton,
- 1:01:57it's nice to meet you.
- 1:01:58I won't y'all to get too long winded so I can
- 1:02:01stay here a little longer,
- 1:02:03um,
- 1:02:04but,
- 1:02:04uh,
- 1:02:04speaking from somebody to kind of walk through this thing,
- 1:02:06and I'll walk through it pretty quick,
- 1:02:07speaking from somebody who
- 1:02:09historically has
- 1:02:10voted Democrat,
- 1:02:11I think the reason why I've transitioned to kind of that undecided space
- 1:02:15is a lot of people have spoken on it today.
- 1:02:17Being as an African American living in this world,
- 1:02:18we've talked about the system in this entire thing.
- 1:02:21We can talk about billionaires and everything,
- 1:02:22but a lot of it is based on white supremacy.
- 1:02:24Um,
- 1:02:25so as an African American man,
- 1:02:26if you think about the history of this
- 1:02:28country and how African Americans have been treated
- 1:02:31as a whole,
- 1:02:32dating back to slavery and Jim Crow and black codes and,
- 1:02:35um,
- 1:02:36the crack epidemic,
- 1:02:37everything.
- 1:02:38You have to understand as to why you can kind of get to a point where you lose hope,
- 1:02:42um,
- 1:02:42because in a sense,
- 1:02:43you have a country who
- 1:02:45continuously
- 1:02:46makes an effort to
- 1:02:48never look,
- 1:02:49never look at us as far as as people,
- 1:02:51um,
- 1:02:51if we're being honest,
- 1:02:52um,
- 1:02:52cause a lot of it is,
- 1:02:53is,
- 1:02:53is based on white supremacy,
- 1:02:54a lot of it is based in
- 1:02:56the aspect of
- 1:02:58we are a marginalized group that they do not even think about.
- 1:03:01So,
- 1:03:01in terms of you being,
- 1:03:03uh,
- 1:03:04a white Christian male and we're living in this white nationalist Christian.
- 1:03:07Nationalist world,
- 1:03:08um,
- 1:03:08currently right now,
- 1:03:10how can someone like you speak to me as African and male
- 1:03:13and an African American just in general and say,
- 1:03:15hey,
- 1:03:15like your vote does matter when historically it never has.
- 1:03:18Here's what I'll tell you,
- 1:03:19they wouldn't be trying so hard
- 1:03:21to stop you from voting and
- 1:03:23stopping young people across the board of all races from voting
- 1:03:26if your vote didn't matter.
- 1:03:27To me,
- 1:03:28voter suppression is proof
- 1:03:30that
- 1:03:30your vote has tremendous power,
- 1:03:32especially when it's joined
- 1:03:33with
- 1:03:34thousands and millions of other people's votes.
- 1:03:37But you're right,
- 1:03:38we are,
- 1:03:38we are working in a system where it is increasingly harder to vote,
- 1:03:42especially here in Texas.
- 1:03:43This is one of the hardest places to vote
- 1:03:44in the entire country.
- 1:03:46All of that is by design.
- 1:03:47It's so that the people who are currently in power can
- 1:03:49stay in power and they'd never have to face accountability.
- 1:03:51I also wanna just.
- 1:03:53Thank you for
- 1:03:55questioning your loyalty to any party.
- 1:03:57Um,
- 1:03:57I'm a proud Democrat,
- 1:03:58but I've said before,
- 1:03:59I already have a religion
- 1:04:01and I already have a sports team.
- 1:04:02Like,
- 1:04:02I have no problem
- 1:04:04sharing hard truths in my party,
- 1:04:06and I don't think you should
- 1:04:07feel that you
- 1:04:08owe loyalty to any party.
- 1:04:10You,
- 1:04:11you have a loyalty to yourself and your community and your family,
- 1:04:14and if one party is not representing you or if one party is taking you for granted.
- 1:04:17Then you have a right to push back against them,
- 1:04:19for sure,
- 1:04:19and I,
- 1:04:20and I think the biggest thing as far as with Democrats specifically
- 1:04:23is,
- 1:04:23I spoke with someone earlier about this,
- 1:04:25I think Republicans kind of put it in your face straight up,
- 1:04:27hey,
- 1:04:27I don't like you and it is what it is.
- 1:04:28Um,
- 1:04:29and I and I think that with Democrats,
- 1:04:31as funny as it is,
- 1:04:32I think with Democrats they kind of speak in a sense of
- 1:04:35Hey,
- 1:04:35if I come to you and say,
- 1:04:36hey,
- 1:04:36you know,
- 1:04:37we are a very marginalized group,
- 1:04:39we are dealing with,
- 1:04:40um,
- 1:04:40over-policing,
- 1:04:41we're dealing with police brutality,
- 1:04:42it's like,
- 1:04:43hey,
- 1:04:43I empathize with you,
- 1:04:45but then they go on about their day.
- 1:04:46Well,
- 1:04:46let me tell you,
- 1:04:47let me give you an example on that.
- 1:04:48I told you I was elected with 51% of the vote,
- 1:04:50so
- 1:04:50black voters were the reason
- 1:04:52that I was able to get elected to the state legislature.
- 1:04:55I had a constituent.
- 1:04:56His name was Javier Ambler.
- 1:04:58He was a father
- 1:04:59who
- 1:05:00was killed by the police
- 1:05:02for not dimming his brights.
- 1:05:04He was pulled over.
- 1:05:05He told them he had a heart condition.
- 1:05:07They tased him so many times that he died right in front of them.
- 1:05:11The whole thing was filmed
- 1:05:12for a reality TV show
- 1:05:14called Live PD.
- 1:05:15It's kind of like Cops.
- 1:05:16The research shows that those reality TV policing programs encourage
- 1:05:20more violent behavior
- 1:05:22from police officers
- 1:05:23toward
- 1:05:24constituents.
- 1:05:25Oftentimes it's black and brown constituents that are getting the most hurt.
- 1:05:28I worked with Javier's family
- 1:05:30to pass Javier Ambler's law,
- 1:05:32which bans
- 1:05:33reality TV policing in the state of Texas.
- 1:05:35It's not enough.
- 1:05:36We have to do so much more,
- 1:05:37but to me that's one example of when you
- 1:05:39elect someone who does have the community's interests at heart
- 1:05:42and you continue to work with them again,
- 1:05:44just voting and walking away,
- 1:05:45it's not gonna do it,
- 1:05:46but if you vote for someone and you hold them accountable,
- 1:05:48which I hope you hold me accountable if I'm elected as your senator,
- 1:05:51progress is possible.
- 1:05:53And I think,
- 1:05:53and I,
- 1:05:53and,
- 1:05:54and to the story of,
- 1:05:55of the police brutality because I had a little brother who passed away,
- 1:05:57uh,
- 1:05:57who was killed by by a police officer,
- 1:05:59um,
- 1:06:00so that is something that I'm also very
- 1:06:01passionate about because it's something that hit.
- 1:06:03Home for me.
- 1:06:04Um,
- 1:06:04so when we speak about things such as defunding the police or,
- 1:06:07um,
- 1:06:07over policing in,
- 1:06:08in our communities,
- 1:06:09um,
- 1:06:10that adds to another piece of why it is,
- 1:06:12is very difficult to
- 1:06:14necessarily,
- 1:06:14if I'm being very frank,
- 1:06:15to believe any,
- 1:06:16any BS that that Democrats are saying because
- 1:06:19I'm living in a,
- 1:06:19in a reality.
- 1:06:20Yeah,
- 1:06:20we can talk about things from a grand scheme,
- 1:06:22from a top level,
- 1:06:23but when you're speaking about as an African American walking everyday life,
- 1:06:26where you're dealing with things that are just based
- 1:06:28in a system that never was meant to.
- 1:06:31Worked for me,
- 1:06:31it's kind of hard to live,
- 1:06:33to,
- 1:06:33to kind of
- 1:06:34see the light at the end of the tunnel.
- 1:06:36I'm a man of faith too,
- 1:06:37and I do believe that there is a belief that you have to,
- 1:06:39you know,
- 1:06:40have hope for something,
- 1:06:41for sure,
- 1:06:41but I think that sometimes,
- 1:06:43you know,
- 1:06:43there is hard to kind of still live in that hope
- 1:06:45when
- 1:06:46the everyday world that's around you does not care about you.
- 1:06:49And Ashton,
- 1:06:49do not believe anything I say,
- 1:06:51believe what I've done for sure.
- 1:06:52And I think that's gonna be the best predictor.
- 1:06:54What was your
- 1:06:55brother's name?
- 1:06:55Uh,
- 1:06:56his name is Isaiah.
- 1:06:57Well,
- 1:06:57I think that
- 1:06:58If we do this right,
- 1:07:00if we have a mass movement
- 1:07:01of working people of all races in this state and across the country,
- 1:07:05I think we can win this next election
- 1:07:08and actually move the country forward
- 1:07:10for Isaiah
- 1:07:11and for
- 1:07:12all the people that we've lost because the system is so thoroughly broken.
- 1:07:15Thank you.
- 1:07:15I appreciate it.
- 1:07:16I appreciate you.
- 1:07:17My final claim
- 1:07:19is that the biggest divide in our politics is not left versus right,
- 1:07:22it's top versus bottom.
- 1:07:28Hi,
- 1:07:29what's your name?
- 1:07:30Krista.
- 1:07:31Spending 8 years in the middle
- 1:07:33of this broken political system,
- 1:07:34I've
- 1:07:35come to realize that the biggest divide is between the billionaires
- 1:07:39who
- 1:07:40run this political system,
- 1:07:41who run this economy,
- 1:07:42who increasingly run this whole country.
- 1:07:44Versus the rest of us,
- 1:07:45whether we're Democrats or Republicans,
- 1:07:47progressives
- 1:07:48or conservatives,
- 1:07:49and I've seen
- 1:07:50how those billionaires pit us against each other with their algorithms,
- 1:07:53with their
- 1:07:54cable news networks.
- 1:07:55They're trying to divide us by party,
- 1:07:57by race,
- 1:07:58by gender,
- 1:07:58by religion,
- 1:08:00so we don't notice that
- 1:08:01they're.
- 1:08:01In our pockets,
- 1:08:02they're closing our schools and
- 1:08:04gutting our healthcare,
- 1:08:05raising taxes on all of us while they cut taxes for themselves.
- 1:08:08So what I'm trying to do is bring us all together
- 1:08:11across all these divisions
- 1:08:12so we can take power away from them
- 1:08:14and bring it back into our communities.
- 1:08:16OK,
- 1:08:16I understand where you're coming from on that.
- 1:08:18Um,
- 1:08:18and I agree that lobbying does play a big role in like some of our representatives,
- 1:08:22you know,
- 1:08:22the more funding they get,
- 1:08:23the more they have to advertise for,
- 1:08:25you know,
- 1:08:26their position that they want,
- 1:08:27um,
- 1:08:28but where I disagree on that
- 1:08:29is I believe that the.
- 1:08:32How can I say this?
- 1:08:33I believe that economics,
- 1:08:35uh,
- 1:08:35like
- 1:08:36the top versus the bottom accounts for economic inequity,
- 1:08:39but I believe ideology is where the polarization comes in.
- 1:08:43So you're a man of faith,
- 1:08:45correct?
- 1:08:46So
- 1:08:46you are definitely.
- 1:08:48So wouldn't you say that your faith
- 1:08:51drives who you are as a person and your beliefs?
- 1:08:53Absolutely,
- 1:08:55and I agree that polarization is a problem.
- 1:08:57What I'm trying to get us to realize is how these systems that we're in,
- 1:09:01um,
- 1:09:01a broken political system,
- 1:09:02a broken media system,
- 1:09:04a broken social media system,
- 1:09:06how that exacerbates
- 1:09:07ideological differences.
- 1:09:08Of course,
- 1:09:09we're all very different people,
- 1:09:10we're gonna have different opinions,
- 1:09:12but these algorithms,
- 1:09:13these cable news networks,
- 1:09:15they fan the flames
- 1:09:16of those disagreements,
- 1:09:17and that's why we have such polarized politics,
- 1:09:19in my opinion.
- 1:09:20So you think it's like an echo chamber like.
- 1:09:22Yeah,
- 1:09:23I,
- 1:09:23I think
- 1:09:24that these billionaires,
- 1:09:25let's,
- 1:09:25you know,
- 1:09:26Jeff Bezos,
- 1:09:27Mark Zuckerberg,
- 1:09:27Elon Musk,
- 1:09:28Rupert Murdoch,
- 1:09:29the people who increasingly own
- 1:09:31traditional media and new social media,
- 1:09:34they have a vested interest
- 1:09:35in all of us being divided
- 1:09:37because if we recognize that we are far more alike than we are
- 1:09:41different,
- 1:09:41if we realize that we have far more in common,
- 1:09:44we're gonna take power back from them and we're.
- 1:09:46Gonna bring it back into our communities.
- 1:09:47So where I would disagree on that is there's so many economic elites.
- 1:09:51So let's just give an example.
- 1:09:52The owners of Ben and Jerry,
- 1:09:54they spend so much time
- 1:09:55on,
- 1:09:56um,
- 1:09:56you know,
- 1:09:57climate change,
- 1:09:57you know,
- 1:09:58trying to draw that back.
- 1:09:59They spend a lot of time on putting their time into charity.
- 1:10:01Let's just say like,
- 1:10:02um,
- 1:10:03you know,
- 1:10:03putting it towards charity for those who are less fortunate,
- 1:10:06but we have the polar opposite,
- 1:10:07right?
- 1:10:07Let's just say the owner of Chick fil A,
- 1:10:09they.
- 1:10:09Spend a lot of their time
- 1:10:10uh donating to more conservative,
- 1:10:12so I would say that
- 1:10:14it's not just the elite.
- 1:10:15I believe it goes back to their
- 1:10:16ideology because we see people who are multi-millionaires
- 1:10:19and they're still donating to the left.
- 1:10:21They're still donating to the right,
- 1:10:22wouldn't you agree?
- 1:10:23I totally agree.
- 1:10:24Um,
- 1:10:24what I'm trying to propose is that we limit
- 1:10:26the influence of those
- 1:10:28very,
- 1:10:29very wealthy people,
- 1:10:30whether they're on the left or the right
- 1:10:31in our political system.
- 1:10:33They can have their own opinions.
- 1:10:35That's,
- 1:10:35there's nothing more American than having your own opinions.
- 1:10:38They shouldn't have an outsized influence on our political system.
- 1:10:41They shouldn't be able to buy
- 1:10:43politicians by the dozen.
- 1:10:44I'll just give you one example.
- 1:10:46Here in Texas,
- 1:10:47there are two billionaires
- 1:10:48in West Texas,
- 1:10:49Tim Dunn
- 1:10:50and Ferris Wilkes.
- 1:10:52They basically run our state government.
- 1:10:54I bet most Texans don't even know their names,
- 1:10:56but
- 1:10:57every member of the state Senate has taken their money.
- 1:11:00A majority of the members of the state house
- 1:11:03have taken their money,
- 1:11:03and for some of these legislators,
- 1:11:05a majority of their
- 1:11:07entire
- 1:11:08campaign contributions
- 1:11:10come from just these two billionaires,
- 1:11:12and they
- 1:11:12use that influence,
- 1:11:13they use their wealth.
- 1:11:15To shift our state into a far right direction,
- 1:11:18the most extreme abortion ban in the country,
- 1:11:20the most insane gun laws in the country,
- 1:11:22all of that is because these two billionaires have
- 1:11:25remade our state government in their own image.
- 1:11:27I'm trying to stop them from doing that.
- 1:11:29They can have their own opinions.
- 1:11:30There's,
- 1:11:30there's nothing wrong with that.
- 1:11:31I'm not trying to stop that.
- 1:11:32I'm trying to prevent the top 1%,
- 1:11:35these billionaire mega donors,
- 1:11:36from being able to dictate
- 1:11:38public policy in this state and in this country.
- 1:11:40So
- 1:11:40when we have the issue of,
- 1:11:42let's just say
- 1:11:43another multi-millionaire in Texas is.
- 1:11:45Using it for policies that you agree with,
- 1:11:47are you gonna do that on both sides,
- 1:11:48or are you gonna just do it on a certain side?
- 1:11:49How are you going to combat that?
- 1:11:50I'm gonna limit the influence of billionaires on both sides of the aisle,
- 1:11:54whether it's a Democratic billionaire or a Republican billionaire.
- 1:11:57I think we've got to ban things like super PACs.
- 1:11:59I think we've got to even further limit campaign contributions.
- 1:12:03I think we've got to prevent
- 1:12:04lawmakers from being able to engage in insider trading and,
- 1:12:07and,
- 1:12:08and buying and selling these stocks.
- 1:12:09I think we need just
- 1:12:10basic ethics reform,
- 1:12:12basic transparency,
- 1:12:14basic accountability.
- 1:12:15Because
- 1:12:15when
- 1:12:16our political system works
- 1:12:17for the uber wealthy,
- 1:12:18it doesn't work for the rest of us.
- 1:12:20In fact,
- 1:12:20it hurts the rest of us.
- 1:12:21It's why
- 1:12:22we can't seem to get ahead no matter how hard we work.
- 1:12:25It's why we can't seem to afford anything,
- 1:12:27whether it's groceries
- 1:12:28or whether it's housing or healthcare or childcare.
- 1:12:31It's because the system is not
- 1:12:32built to work for us,
- 1:12:33it's built to work for those billionaires,
- 1:12:35and it's working very well for them.
- 1:12:37I think the way we fix that
- 1:12:39is by reforming our political system
- 1:12:41so that it can actually be a government of,
- 1:12:43by and for the people again.
- 1:12:44All right,
- 1:12:44pause.
- 1:12:45You've been voted out by the majority.
- 1:12:47Please return to your was great.
- 1:12:48You were great.
- 1:12:48Thanks,
- 1:12:48Krista,
- 1:12:49yeah.
- 1:12:52Biggest thing that I just heard from this debate you
- 1:12:53were just talking about is basically billionaires are the problem.
- 1:12:56I'm curious what,
- 1:12:57um,
- 1:12:58why,
- 1:12:58why you,
- 1:12:58why do you think
- 1:13:00that they are causing the problems?
- 1:13:01So I actually think the system is the problem.
- 1:13:04The system allows for those billionaires to have an outsized influence
- 1:13:07in our
- 1:13:08political conversation,
- 1:13:10in our economy,
- 1:13:11and it
- 1:13:12crowds out the rest of us,
- 1:13:13those who are working class and middle class Texans.
- 1:13:16And I want to try to right that
- 1:13:18imbalance.
- 1:13:19I think what you've seen in this country for the last 50 years
- 1:13:22is an economy that used to work for most people
- 1:13:24transform into one that only works for the uber wealthy.
- 1:13:28The richest 1%
- 1:13:29in this country
- 1:13:30now owns more wealth than the entire middle class.
- 1:13:33Three dudes,
- 1:13:34Elon Musk,
- 1:13:35Mark Zuckerberg,
- 1:13:36and Jeff Bezos now own more wealth than 165 million Americans combined.
- 1:13:41And they're using that wealth
- 1:13:43to corrupt our political system.
- 1:13:44These,
- 1:13:44these are not the rich people of old.
- 1:13:46They're not buying yachts and jets only.
- 1:13:48They're not buying power.
- 1:13:49I,
- 1:13:49I mean,
- 1:13:50think about all the debates
- 1:13:51in our politics.
- 1:13:52Our schools are being defunded
- 1:13:54so those billionaires can get another tax break.
- 1:13:56Our healthcare premiums are about to go up
- 1:13:58because those billionaires
- 1:14:00want another tax break.
- 1:14:01And then our Social Security,
- 1:14:03our Medicare benefits are constantly under threat.
- 1:14:05Because
- 1:14:06those billionaires want yet another tax break,
- 1:14:08so
- 1:14:09I,
- 1:14:09I'm advocating that we
- 1:14:11limit their power
- 1:14:12and we empower working Texans
- 1:14:14to be able to fulfill their own God-given potential.
- 1:14:17Interesting.
- 1:14:17How do you,
- 1:14:18how do you propose that,
- 1:14:19that we go about doing that,
- 1:14:20because I mean the system's been here for a long time.
- 1:14:22And uh I think
- 1:14:23the more important question is
- 1:14:25specifically what,
- 1:14:25what system is it the
- 1:14:27Texas system?
- 1:14:28Is it the federal system?
- 1:14:29Is it the,
- 1:14:30there's there's a lot of systems can be the school system,
- 1:14:33uh,
- 1:14:33the tax system.
- 1:14:34So um,
- 1:14:34what,
- 1:14:35what,
- 1:14:35what specifically are you talking about?
- 1:14:37All the above,
- 1:14:37um,
- 1:14:38so
- 1:14:39you said that we've had it for a long time.
- 1:14:42It has been.
- 1:14:42Long time,
- 1:14:42it's been about 50 years,
- 1:14:44but I just wanna remind you and those watching
- 1:14:46that
- 1:14:47we did have an economic system in this country
- 1:14:49that worked for the middle class in the 1950s,
- 1:14:51the 1960s,
- 1:14:52the richest Americans paid a top marginal tax rate of 90%.
- 1:14:56Now I don't know if we need a tax rate that high for rich folks,
- 1:14:59but it should certainly be higher than what it is now.
- 1:15:00It's about 37%
- 1:15:02now.
- 1:15:03And so I want billionaires to pay their fair share.
- 1:15:06Uh,
- 1:15:07I don't think
- 1:15:08that George Soros
- 1:15:10should
- 1:15:10pay less as a percentage of his income in taxes
- 1:15:13than his secretary,
- 1:15:14and that's what we have now.
- 1:15:16Again,
- 1:15:16billionaires on the left,
- 1:15:17billionaires on the right,
- 1:15:19they're getting away scot-free.
- 1:15:20They are leaching
- 1:15:21the lifeblood out of this country,
- 1:15:23out of all.
- 1:15:23All the systems that you just mentioned,
- 1:15:25I think the only way we're gonna change that is if people like you,
- 1:15:27the people around the circle,
- 1:15:28people around the state
- 1:15:30decide to come together across all of these divides,
- 1:15:33recognize that we have a lot more in common than billionaires want us to think,
- 1:15:36and take power back
- 1:15:38for our communities.
- 1:15:39Interesting.
- 1:15:39So I,
- 1:15:40um,
- 1:15:40I've,
- 1:15:41I did a little research about this,
- 1:15:42and the top 5%.
- 1:15:43percent of earners in America
- 1:15:45make about $260,000 a year.
- 1:15:47Um,
- 1:15:47they make up for about 60%
- 1:15:49of the,
- 1:15:50um,
- 1:15:51of the total federal income tax,
- 1:15:53um,
- 1:15:54so that's,
- 1:15:54that's not billionaires,
- 1:15:56right?
- 1:15:56So that's people who are,
- 1:15:59are getting by they're doing,
- 1:16:00they're they're they're doing pretty good,
- 1:16:01but,
- 1:16:01um,
- 1:16:01my,
- 1:16:02my question is how can you.
- 1:16:03Affect billionaires and also still help
- 1:16:07not hurt those who are
- 1:16:09not billionaires but maybe they have a couple million and they're
- 1:16:12also providing jobs because we have a lot of smaller businesses
- 1:16:14that are within the,
- 1:16:15you know,
- 1:16:155 million totally agree we don't wanna hurt small businesses we
- 1:16:18don't wanna even hurt people who are upper middle class.
- 1:16:20What we wanna do is go after
- 1:16:22that top 1%,
- 1:16:24actually the,
- 1:16:25the top 1% of that 1%,
- 1:16:27those billionaires who run this economy and run this country.
- 1:16:30Uh,
- 1:16:30let's just take an example.
- 1:16:31The big ugly bill that passed a few months ago in Washington,
- 1:16:35it gave $3 trillion in tax cuts to the wealthiest Americans.
- 1:16:40Just guess
- 1:16:41what the average billionaire is gonna get
- 1:16:43in terms of tax cuts from that bill.
- 1:16:46I'm,
- 1:16:46I'm not sure.
- 1:16:47$110,000.
- 1:16:49Again,
- 1:16:50our money,
- 1:16:50our tax dollars are going to those billionaires who don't need it.
- 1:16:54Guess what we're gonna get.
- 1:16:55Regular people,
- 1:16:56what we're gonna get from that bill.
- 1:16:58Not sure.
- 1:16:58A little over $1000.
- 1:17:00OK,
- 1:17:01to me that feels wildly unfair
- 1:17:03and
- 1:17:04It prevents all of us
- 1:17:05from being able to start that new business,
- 1:17:08from being able to grow the economy.
- 1:17:10It keeps us from being able to support our families
- 1:17:12and make sure that our kids are successful in school
- 1:17:15and in college and in the workforce.
- 1:17:17That is how this rigged system
- 1:17:19prevents us from achieving our potential
- 1:17:21as a country.
- 1:17:22All right,
- 1:17:22pause.
- 1:17:23You've been voted out by majority.
- 1:17:24Please return to great job Tyler.
- 1:17:27Hi,
- 1:17:28how are you,
- 1:17:29Tess?
- 1:17:29Good to meet you,
- 1:17:30James.
- 1:17:31So,
- 1:17:32I'm gonna be straightforward,
- 1:17:33honest with you.
- 1:17:34Um,
- 1:17:35I agree with a lot of your stance.
- 1:17:37Um,
- 1:17:37I am also,
- 1:17:39my family,
- 1:17:40our income household,
- 1:17:41we are in that top 3%,
- 1:17:44not 1%.
- 1:17:45That being said,
- 1:17:47I wish,
- 1:17:48I'm
- 1:17:48sure I'm not the only one out there.
- 1:17:50Me and my family,
- 1:17:52we're not opposed to being the people who say,
- 1:17:57you know,
- 1:17:57you tax us more.
- 1:17:59We're,
- 1:17:59we're OK with that
- 1:18:00because everybody around me,
- 1:18:02everybody I know,
- 1:18:03they're going,
- 1:18:05you know,
- 1:18:05paycheck to paycheck,
- 1:18:06single parent.
- 1:18:08There's not many people we know that are
- 1:18:11as blessed as us.
- 1:18:13That said,
- 1:18:15Is it top to bottom that's the problem,
- 1:18:17or is it left to right?
- 1:18:18Because when you look at
- 1:18:20what's going on,
- 1:18:21I do think that there is a
- 1:18:23portion of greed
- 1:18:25that is effective in the billionaires' minds or the top 1%.
- 1:18:29But I think there's a lot of left
- 1:18:31and right
- 1:18:33when it comes into it,
- 1:18:34especially when you look at the industry
- 1:18:36that it plays into,
- 1:18:37whether it's
- 1:18:38oil
- 1:18:38or,
- 1:18:39um,
- 1:18:41Housing or
- 1:18:43whatnot.
- 1:18:43So I,
- 1:18:44I,
- 1:18:44I disagree that it's
- 1:18:47not entirely top bottom.
- 1:18:48I think it's
- 1:18:49a good portion of what plays into the left and right.
- 1:18:52So
- 1:18:52here's what I want to
- 1:18:54point out
- 1:18:54this political discourse in our country,
- 1:18:57it is controlled by those billionaires increasingly,
- 1:19:00these for-profit social media platforms,
- 1:19:02these predatory algorithms,
- 1:19:04they.
- 1:19:05Elevate the most extreme voices on all sides
- 1:19:08to provoke our outrage
- 1:19:10because
- 1:19:11that gets more clicks
- 1:19:12and that makes them more money.
- 1:19:13It's a,
- 1:19:14it's a rage economy.
- 1:19:16Anger
- 1:19:17sells,
- 1:19:17uh,
- 1:19:18fear sells,
- 1:19:19hate
- 1:19:20sells.
- 1:19:21These platforms designed by those billionaires,
- 1:19:24these platforms appeal to our worst demons
- 1:19:27instead of our better angels.
- 1:19:28These billionaires are,
- 1:19:29are engineering our emotions so they can profit off of our pain.
- 1:19:33They are
- 1:19:34selling us conflict and calling it community.
- 1:19:36These platforms don't incentivize us
- 1:19:38doing what we're doing here,
- 1:19:39which is
- 1:19:39listening to each other and finding common ground.
- 1:19:42These platforms want us at each other's throats
- 1:19:45because
- 1:19:46those billionaires benefit.
- 1:19:47Whether you're in the top 3% or whether you're in the bottom 3%,
- 1:19:50we have a lot more in common with each other
- 1:19:52than we do with those billionaires.
- 1:19:54And so they want us focused on how we're different.
- 1:19:57There's definitely
- 1:19:58a progressive.
- 1:19:59Uh,
- 1:20:00conversation,
- 1:20:00a conservative conversation that's been happening since the beginning of time.
- 1:20:03It's healthy.
- 1:20:03It's good.
- 1:20:04I'm worried about how these platforms,
- 1:20:06they divide us further apart
- 1:20:08so that we can't find that common ground anymore and it's corrosive to our politics.
- 1:20:12If you're elected senator,
- 1:20:15what are you going to try and implement and pass in order to make sure
- 1:20:19that this divide is eliminated
- 1:20:22because this divide is kind of tearing.
- 1:20:26It is,
- 1:20:26it is,
- 1:20:27um,
- 1:20:27one,
- 1:20:27I wanna be very honest with you.
- 1:20:29One candidate,
- 1:20:30one senator is not gonna fix this.
- 1:20:32Um,
- 1:20:33this is gonna be fixed by
- 1:20:34you and the people around the circle,
- 1:20:36hopefully
- 1:20:38running and supporting candidates who
- 1:20:40align with this purpose.
- 1:20:42Uh,
- 1:20:42but
- 1:20:43to answer your question directly about what I would want to do if I got in there,
- 1:20:46I've served for 4 terms in the state House.
- 1:20:49I've been fighting these billionaires in the trenches
- 1:20:51of the Texas legislature,
- 1:20:52and I've been bringing together Democrats and Republicans to do that.
- 1:20:56I had a bill
- 1:20:57that I filed a few sessions ago.
- 1:20:59It was actually a Bernie Sanders' idea
- 1:21:01to bring
- 1:21:02cheap prescription drugs from Canada to Texas because Canadians pay
- 1:21:06half of what we pay because
- 1:21:08Big Pharma controls our healthcare system,
- 1:21:10and I didn't think it was gonna pass.
- 1:21:12But a friend of mine in the Freedom Caucus,
- 1:21:14a far-right Republican from Wichita Falls,
- 1:21:17he called me up
- 1:21:18and he was like,
- 1:21:18I really like your bill
- 1:21:20because I believe in free markets
- 1:21:21and Big Pharma distorts the free market.
- 1:21:24So he and I
- 1:21:25got that bill passed through the Texas House,
- 1:21:27through the Texas Senate,
- 1:21:28and we got it signed by the governor.
- 1:21:29It is now law in the state of Texas.
- 1:21:31We're gonna start importing those drugs and saving lives.
- 1:21:34So that's an example of bringing people together
- 1:21:36across a a progressive and a conservative spectrum
- 1:21:39to take power away from Big Pharma
- 1:21:41and help all Texans regardless of your political party,
- 1:21:43regardless of your race,
- 1:21:44regardless of your gender,
- 1:21:45regardless of your religion.
- 1:21:47That's what I'm gonna try to do as a US senator.
- 1:21:49I,
- 1:21:49I wanna focus on prescription drugs.
- 1:21:51I wanna,
- 1:21:52I wanna focus on housing.
- 1:21:53I wanna focus on childcare,
- 1:21:54all things I've worked on here.
- 1:21:56I'll just tell you,
- 1:21:57we're not gonna make progress on any of those issues
- 1:21:59until we get the corruption out of our politics.
- 1:22:02And so I wanna,
- 1:22:03the first bill I wanna file,
- 1:22:04the first bill I hopefully can vote on
- 1:22:06is comprehensive political reform to limit big money,
- 1:22:09to end things like gerrymandering
- 1:22:11so that we can have a government that's.
- 1:22:12Responsive to us and not billionaires.
- 1:22:14But when you say comprehensive government reform,
- 1:22:16specifically,
- 1:22:17yeah,
- 1:22:17banning super PACs,
- 1:22:18this is the,
- 1:22:19the biggest loophole in our campaign finance system.
- 1:22:22I also think we have to lower
- 1:22:24campaign finance contribution limits.
- 1:22:26Uh,
- 1:22:26we do have limits at the state,
- 1:22:27at the federal level.
- 1:22:28We don't have them here in Texas.
- 1:22:29I filed a bill to put them in place here in Texas,
- 1:22:31but
- 1:22:32even those limits at
- 1:22:34the federal level,
- 1:22:34they're way too high,
- 1:22:36and
- 1:22:37they are,
- 1:22:37they are.
- 1:22:38Porous.
- 1:22:39There are so many loopholes,
- 1:22:40so many ways to get around them.
- 1:22:41We've got to tighten up the system so we can actually have
- 1:22:44a political system
- 1:22:46that responds to people and not billionaires.
- 1:22:49Uh,
- 1:22:49and then I want to go further on ethics and transparency.
- 1:22:52I don't think
- 1:22:53lawmakers in our nation's capital should be
- 1:22:55buying and selling stocks,
- 1:22:57especially engaging in the insider trading,
- 1:22:59which we've seen in both political parties.
- 1:23:01We got to end that.
- 1:23:02We got to put an outright ban on that.
- 1:23:03These are just some of my ideas,
- 1:23:04but I'm very open to others.
- 1:23:06pause.
- 1:23:07Oh man,
- 1:23:08sorry,
- 1:23:09I apologize.
- 1:23:10Oh,
- 1:23:10I
- 1:23:12voted out.
- 1:23:13Please return to your seat.
- 1:23:15Hey,
- 1:23:16Malik.
- 1:23:17So,
- 1:23:17uh,
- 1:23:17I do agree with a lot of things that you said earlier as a man of faith.
- 1:23:20I feel like your heart is in the right place as well with a lot of things.
- 1:23:24I would say my only issue
- 1:23:26is we kind of talked about how.
- 1:23:28Using the billion billionaires' money that they're using,
- 1:23:30basically how they're avoiding taxes,
- 1:23:32avoiding paying money for all these things,
- 1:23:33and how people could potentially use that exact same money to start a business.
- 1:23:37My only issue with that is,
- 1:23:39how many people nowadays are getting educated on how to start a business.
- 1:23:43And that's that's a very huge issue.
- 1:23:44So it'll be like,
- 1:23:45OK,
- 1:23:45we can we can also say money is a problem,
- 1:23:46but I don't think that's necessarily what it is.
- 1:23:48And also,
- 1:23:49and
- 1:23:49I would love to be very wrong about this,
- 1:23:51because I am very passionate about about teachers being very underpaid,
- 1:23:56and you are a teacher,
- 1:23:56so I have a lot,
- 1:23:57a lot of respect just
- 1:23:59there in itself,
- 1:24:00but I think you would agree as well that you even taking the step to
- 1:24:04leave that job and to now run for Senate,
- 1:24:06that's also taking a risk.
- 1:24:08And there's people that are.
- 1:24:10Be business owners that are obviously making a lot of money and
- 1:24:13either way,
- 1:24:14they're gonna find a way to avoid those taxes regardless.
- 1:24:17So,
- 1:24:17but wouldn't you agree that you leaving that safe,
- 1:24:19secure job to run for Senate,
- 1:24:21that's taking a risk,
- 1:24:22therefore,
- 1:24:23if you were now successful,
- 1:24:24you kind of deserve
- 1:24:25extra compensation for that.
- 1:24:26Would you agree?
- 1:24:27I'm all for.
- 1:24:28Trying to demonize success,
- 1:24:30um,
- 1:24:31guess what percentage
- 1:24:32of baby boomers made more money than their parents?
- 1:24:35Just take a wild guess,
- 1:24:36a wild guess.
- 1:24:37Oh,
- 1:24:37I don't have a wild guess.
- 1:24:39It was 90%.
- 1:24:4090% of baby boomers made more money than their parents did.
- 1:24:43They lived the American dream.
- 1:24:44It was a reality
- 1:24:45for most people in that generation.
- 1:24:48Guess what that number is for millennials like me.
- 1:24:51No idea 50%.
- 1:24:53It's even lower for Gen Z.
- 1:24:55The American dream is
- 1:24:56out of reach
- 1:24:57increasingly for most people,
- 1:24:59particularly most young people
- 1:25:00in this state and across the country,
- 1:25:02and that is not because millennials or Gen
- 1:25:04Z are more lazy or not interested in succeeding
- 1:25:07or interested in,
- 1:25:08in growing and thriving.
- 1:25:10It's because the system is rigged against us.
- 1:25:12That system over the last 50 years with trickle-down economics
- 1:25:16has just been so heavily weighted
- 1:25:18toward the people at the top,
- 1:25:19the billionaires,
- 1:25:20the mega donors.
- 1:25:22And then they use that wealth to then rig more rules for themselves.
- 1:25:25I'll give you one example.
- 1:25:27In the 1980s,
- 1:25:28they deregulated the banking system.
- 1:25:30And it allowed for these big banks to charge working people,
- 1:25:33the working poor,
- 1:25:35overdraft fees.
- 1:25:36So now,
- 1:25:37you can charge a single mom who's just trying to get by working multiple jobs,
- 1:25:41you can charge her
- 1:25:42multiple overdraft fees a day.
- 1:25:45And they profit
- 1:25:46overwhelmingly
- 1:25:47from those fees.
- 1:25:48So that's an example
- 1:25:49of a,
- 1:25:50a,
- 1:25:50a rule,
- 1:25:52uh,
- 1:25:52or I guess a lack of a rule
- 1:25:53that allows for the wealthy to profit
- 1:25:56off of working people and the working poor.
- 1:25:59These are rules we can change.
- 1:26:00They're man-made.
- 1:26:01We had better rules before trickle-down economics.
- 1:26:03We can get back to that,
- 1:26:05but it's gonna take you and me and all of us coming together.
- 1:26:07Across these divisions
- 1:26:09to take that power back,
- 1:26:10because they're not gonna give it up.
- 1:26:12They,
- 1:26:12they have more money,
- 1:26:13we have more people,
- 1:26:14we have the majority.
- 1:26:15I think my only thing with that is because I,
- 1:26:17I agree with a lot of things that you're saying.
- 1:26:19My only thing is we're talking a lot about money,
- 1:26:21but money's not throwing,
- 1:26:23regardless of
- 1:26:24if people are getting paid more,
- 1:26:25that's not gonna solve the issue.
- 1:26:27The thing is,
- 1:26:27kind of like we were saying earlier,
- 1:26:29people that are making A lot of money,
- 1:26:31maybe not teaching other people how to,
- 1:26:33how to
- 1:26:33basically have the exact same success.
- 1:26:35So maybe it's not a financial issue.
- 1:26:37It's like maybe you have a lack of education on how to start that business,
- 1:26:41how to
- 1:26:42stop being a teacher,
- 1:26:42and now you're
- 1:26:44running for Senate.
- 1:26:44How many people know how to do that that are teachers right now?
- 1:26:46Yeah,
- 1:26:47I think it's both,
- 1:26:47right?
- 1:26:48Right,
- 1:26:48exactly,
- 1:26:48for sure.
- 1:26:49And I,
- 1:26:50uh,
- 1:26:50authored a bill in the state legislature.
- 1:26:52To
- 1:26:54provide financial literacy education for students in Texas,
- 1:26:57because,
- 1:26:57you know,
- 1:26:58in addition to learning the quadratic equation or reading Shakespeare,
- 1:27:02you should also learn how the economy works and learn how to manage your money.
- 1:27:06These are skills that
- 1:27:07maybe will have more of an impact on your life
- 1:27:09than whether or not you read Shakespeare,
- 1:27:11and I,
- 1:27:12I,
- 1:27:12I think our education system
- 1:27:13has to take that into account.
- 1:27:15The problem is here in Texas and across the country.
- 1:27:18We have billionaires like Tim Dunn and Ferris Wilkes
- 1:27:21who are trying to close our public schools.
- 1:27:23We've seen public schools closing
- 1:27:25at an alarming rate all over Texas in all kinds of communities,
- 1:27:28including in my own district.
- 1:27:30Schools are closing because they're being actively defunded
- 1:27:33by those billionaires who don't believe in giving
- 1:27:35all of us an opportunity to succeed.
- 1:27:37So all I'm trying to say is that we've got to recognize that problem
- 1:27:40and we've got to take steps
- 1:27:42as a country,
- 1:27:43working people of all stripes,
- 1:27:44of all beliefs.
- 1:27:46To take power back from those billionaires and bring it into our
- 1:27:49communities for the things that you and I are talking about.
- 1:27:51All right guys,
- 1:27:52that's time.
- 1:27:52You may return to Great job,
- 1:27:53Malik,
- 1:27:54yeah.
- 1:27:57I think they said that I'm the first ever candidate
- 1:27:59to do this show.
- 1:28:00Yeah,
- 1:28:01so cool.
- 1:28:02Yeah,
- 1:28:03maybe we'll,
- 1:28:04maybe we'll make it to where everybody's got to come here and do this.
- 1:28:06Yeah,
- 1:28:06I hope we started trying.
- 1:28:07Yeah,
- 1:28:07yeah,
- 1:28:07yeah.
- 1:28:09James will now choose someone from the circle to come
- 1:28:11back to the center to debate their own claim.
- 1:28:15I'd like to invite Krista back up
- 1:28:17to introduce her claim.
- 1:28:22Thank you,
- 1:28:22good to see you again.
- 1:28:23My claim is no matter how many how much
- 1:28:25gun violence happens within the state of Texas,
- 1:28:27there will never be a gun ban or gun reform.
- 1:28:31Well,
- 1:28:32that claim is pretty gut-wrenching,
- 1:28:34given that we've had 5 of the
- 1:28:36deadliest mass shootings in American history right here
- 1:28:39in Texas.
- 1:28:40One
- 1:28:41still haunts me to this day as a former public school teacher,
- 1:28:43and that's
- 1:28:44the massacre in Uvalde,
- 1:28:46Texas
- 1:28:46in
- 1:28:47Robb Elementary when we lost
- 1:28:4919 babies and 2 teachers.
- 1:28:52Here's where I'll disagree with you on this claim though.
- 1:28:55I saw
- 1:28:56those parents from Uvalde.
- 1:28:58I saw them make the 160 mile drive
- 1:29:01from Uvalde to the state Capitol
- 1:29:03multiple times
- 1:29:04during that legislative session,
- 1:29:06demanding,
- 1:29:06begging
- 1:29:07for basic common sense gun safety.
- 1:29:10They,
- 1:29:11they believed in the Second Amendment just like I do.
- 1:29:13But they knew that there needed to be some kind of regulation
- 1:29:16to keep everyone safe and protect everybody's freedoms,
- 1:29:18including
- 1:29:19the freedom of those 19 babies
- 1:29:21to live and fulfill their potential.
- 1:29:23What I saw them do just over the course of one legislative session
- 1:29:27is move the needle
- 1:29:29on a common sense bill to raise the age to buy those kind of weapons from 18 to 21.
- 1:29:34The
- 1:29:34murderer in Uvalde
- 1:29:36turned 18 the day before he committed that horrific massacre.
- 1:29:40Right.
- 1:29:40There was no Republican support
- 1:29:42for that bill.
- 1:29:43They had all the Democratic support,
- 1:29:45but they worked relentlessly.
- 1:29:46They met with Republican lawmakers,
- 1:29:49and they actually got two Republicans to switch their votes on the committee
- 1:29:52and get it passed out of committee.
- 1:29:54That's the first step in getting something to the floor.
- 1:29:57It didn't ultimately pass,
- 1:29:58hasn't passed yet,
- 1:30:00but there was
- 1:30:01progress
- 1:30:01toward a real solution that could save lives in the future.
- 1:30:05Two of those Republicans,
- 1:30:07um,
- 1:30:08decided to change their votes because of
- 1:30:09those conversations with the families in Uvalde.
- 1:30:12One of them
- 1:30:13sacrificed his seat
- 1:30:14in the next Republican primary to do the right
- 1:30:16thing by those kids and by those families.
- 1:30:18That kind of stuff,
- 1:30:20it makes me believe in humanity again,
- 1:30:22which
- 1:30:22can be really hard when you
- 1:30:24turn on the news or open up your social media timeline.
- 1:30:27But I do think
- 1:30:28that we can get
- 1:30:29common sense gun safety regulations in Texas,
- 1:30:32still honor the Second Amendment,
- 1:30:34and hopefully prevent those kind of massacres from happening in the future.
- 1:30:37So my question is,
- 1:30:38what are you doing?
- 1:30:39I'm,
- 1:30:40I'm following your campaign and I'm not really seeing anything
- 1:30:43on
- 1:30:44what you're doing to prevent gun violence in the future.
- 1:30:46I'm not saying bad guns
- 1:30:48or anything along those lines.
- 1:30:49Of course I want reform.
- 1:30:50I want the legal age.
- 1:30:52Um,
- 1:30:52to be raised from 18 to 21,
- 1:30:54I myself have a 9,
- 1:30:57so I think
- 1:30:57I wanna hear what you're doing.
- 1:30:59Tell me,
- 1:31:00yeah,
- 1:31:00I appreciate that because I,
- 1:31:02when I'm,
- 1:31:02um,
- 1:31:03at these events all over the state,
- 1:31:04this is a question I get asked often,
- 1:31:06and I'm,
- 1:31:07I'm
- 1:31:07talking about gun safety a lot because it's on people's minds.
- 1:31:11And again,
- 1:31:11just like I've said many times in this debate,
- 1:31:13you shouldn't really take
- 1:31:14what I'm saying in this conversation.
- 1:31:16You should take a look at what I've done.
- 1:31:17I have a 100%
- 1:31:20pro gun safety voting record in the state legislature,
- 1:31:23and if I'm elected as US senator,
- 1:31:25I'm gonna fight for things like universal background checks.
- 1:31:27I'm gonna fight
- 1:31:28for red flag laws.
- 1:31:30I'm gonna fight to close the gun show loophole.
- 1:31:32The vast majority of Texans and Americans want
- 1:31:35these common sense gun safety rules put in place so they can save people's lives.
- 1:31:38Why haven't you already started?
- 1:31:39Doing that.
- 1:31:40Oh,
- 1:31:40I have,
- 1:31:41I have,
- 1:31:41I,
- 1:31:41I've introduced a lot of gun safety bills myself.
- 1:31:44I have,
- 1:31:44I have voted for every gun safety
- 1:31:47piece of legislation that came before me.
- 1:31:49Unfortunately there weren't enough
- 1:31:51gun safety advocates serving in the legislature.
- 1:31:53I find it challenging to believe
- 1:31:55that
- 1:31:56there will be any change.
- 1:31:57It's only a matter of time before there's another Uvalde shooting within Texas,
- 1:32:00and it's a matter of.
- 1:32:02I don't want to ban guns at all.
- 1:32:04I don't wanna take away people's rights,
- 1:32:06but it's a matter of
- 1:32:07when are we gonna start putting,
- 1:32:09uh,
- 1:32:09these processes in place,
- 1:32:10you know,
- 1:32:11again,
- 1:32:11background checks,
- 1:32:12again,
- 1:32:13raising the age limit,
- 1:32:14you know,
- 1:32:14your mind isn't even fully developed at 18.
- 1:32:19I would say the biggest obstacle.
- 1:32:20That's preventing us from making progress and saving lives
- 1:32:23is the influence of big money on this issue.
- 1:32:26The NRA
- 1:32:27has a stranglehold
- 1:32:28on too many politicians at the federal level,
- 1:32:31but also at the state and local level,
- 1:32:32and they use that big money
- 1:32:35to
- 1:32:35prevent all of us from passing things that most Texans want,
- 1:32:38that most Americans want.
- 1:32:40The reason we can't is because the NRA has bought
- 1:32:42too many politicians.
- 1:32:44It's why
- 1:32:45I am not taking a dime of corporate PAC money in this campaign.
- 1:32:48It's why I'm not taking money
- 1:32:49from the NRA.
- 1:32:50It's why I'm not taking money from AIPAC.
- 1:32:52I think the
- 1:32:53number of,
- 1:32:54of PACCs that control politicians in this country
- 1:32:58is appalling,
- 1:32:59and it's why
- 1:33:00we can't seem to move forward
- 1:33:01on these issues where most of us agree.
- 1:33:04OK,
- 1:33:04that's interesting.
- 1:33:05I appreciate that perspective.
- 1:33:06Again,
- 1:33:07I think I'm not sure that.
- 1:33:09Yes,
- 1:33:10of course,
- 1:33:10the NRA does play a big role
- 1:33:12with politicians and things like that,
- 1:33:13but I think it goes back to again ideology.
- 1:33:16I value my home.
- 1:33:17I value,
- 1:33:18you know,
- 1:33:19my life.
- 1:33:19That's why I carry a gun with me.
- 1:33:21I don't,
- 1:33:22I live in,
- 1:33:22uh,
- 1:33:23South Dallas,
- 1:33:23and,
- 1:33:23you know,
- 1:33:24it's,
- 1:33:24I can't go on a walk like every day by myself,
- 1:33:27so of course I'm gonna take my 9 with me just in case,
- 1:33:30and I don't think it ties back to.
- 1:33:31NRA,
- 1:33:31I think it ties back to ideology,
- 1:33:33but here's where I'll disagree though.
- 1:33:35It can't be about ideology when
- 1:33:38everybody in the state
- 1:33:39agrees on these common sense policies.
- 1:33:41And maybe there's,
- 1:33:41you know,
- 1:33:42a,
- 1:33:42a handful of folks on the extremes who don't,
- 1:33:45but when you look at the data,
- 1:33:46the vast majority of Texans want these policies in place.
- 1:33:50So to me,
- 1:33:51then I ask the question,
- 1:33:52why can't we get it done?
- 1:33:53If most people are in agreement on the policy,
- 1:33:55then what's preventing us from making progress?
- 1:33:57The only answer I can come back to
- 1:33:59is the influence of big money like the NRA
- 1:34:01in our political system,
- 1:34:03the way they can buy politicians,
- 1:34:04and the way those politicians are then beholden
- 1:34:07to those groups,
- 1:34:08so they're less responsive to our needs and
- 1:34:10more responsive to their billionaire mega donors.
- 1:34:11All right guys,
- 1:34:12that's time.
- 1:34:13Please return to your seat,
- 1:34:14thank you.
- 1:34:18When I sat down with James,
- 1:34:20didn't agree with everything,
- 1:34:21but it was a good,
- 1:34:21healthy reminder of this isn't a bad guy.
- 1:34:24This guy genuinely wants what's good and he thinks this is the best way to go about it.
- 1:34:27And
- 1:34:28I love Surrounded,
- 1:34:29the episodes that accentuate that and remind us of that.
- 1:34:33I mean,
- 1:34:33politicians are good at.
- 1:34:35Saying what you want to hear,
- 1:34:37uh,
- 1:34:37but
- 1:34:38there were some things that
- 1:34:40I like that he's done.
- 1:34:43Voter education
- 1:34:44needs to happen a lot more.
- 1:34:46It needs to be less a form of,
- 1:34:48I don't know how to say this nicely,
- 1:34:49indoctrination through
- 1:34:51through media and social media.
- 1:34:53I think it needs to be more um
- 1:34:54a presenting of the facts.
- 1:34:56Do you think you're absolutely not right?
- 1:34:58100%.
- 1:34:59And it's,
- 1:35:00it's nothing against James.
- 1:35:01It's really not.
- 1:35:02It's just
- 1:35:03two things.
- 1:35:04One,
- 1:35:04I don't see a vision that changes the system fundamentally.
- 1:35:08And two,
- 1:35:08I don't see that much of a difference.
- 1:35:10I really don't.
- 1:35:11I,
- 1:35:12I'm more interested in what I do to control my own life than what the government does.
- 1:35:16And so I think if I'm going to be civilly engaged,
- 1:35:19I'm going to do it in other ways other than voting.
- 1:35:21I'm wasting my time.
- 1:35:22It's one hour to go vote against a bunch of sheep zombies
- 1:35:25who are controlled by
- 1:35:27advertisements and not even good advertisements,
- 1:35:29really shitty non-nuanced arguments.
- 1:35:31Being honest,
- 1:35:32I definitely do see myself voting in a lot of honesty,
- 1:35:34you know,
- 1:35:35hearing James talk,
- 1:35:36there was a lot of things that he said that I thought was great.
- 1:35:38I think on a fundamental level we agree on a lot of things,
- 1:35:40but I think there was a lot of political talk.
- 1:35:43In terms of things that he was saying and the kind of
- 1:35:44dancing around conversations rather than just talking about the root cause of,
- 1:35:48hey,
- 1:35:48this is something that
- 1:35:49I am going to push forward,
- 1:35:51I do understand that he is one person and he is not an entire body.
- 1:35:54It has swayed me in terms of who I'm going to be voting for and
- 1:35:59specific things that I'm going to be looking for as
- 1:36:00far as in politicians when I ask them the question,
- 1:36:03OK,
- 1:36:03what is it that you're going,
- 1:36:04you're gonna be able to do for me?
- 1:36:05And if they can't answer that question and they just dance around it,
- 1:36:08then it is going to sway as far as my decision.
- 1:36:11Don't forget to subscribe to Surrounded wherever you get
- 1:36:13your podcasts so that you don't miss an episode.
- 1:36:16And if you want to watch the video version of Surrounded,
- 1:36:18subscribe to Jubilee on YouTube.