Latest / The World Unexplained / DID JESUS HAVE A BROTHER
Transcript
- 0:02The World Unexplained, a podcast that explores the unusual beliefs, conspiracies, customs,
- 0:12rituals, and traditions from around the world. This is your host,
- 0:17doctor Carlos Go and thank you for joining us. Today we're going to be
- 0:31exploring Jesus, the Dead Sea Scrolls, Jesus have a Brother. All this
- 0:35and more are with Doctor Robert Eisaman is the author of James the Brother of
- 0:40Jesus. He's the author of the Dead Sea Scrolls and the First Christians.
- 0:43He also wrote a book, The Dead Sea Scrolls Uncovered. He is Professor
- 0:47of Middle East Religions and Archaeology and Director of the Institute for the Study of
- 0:51Judeo Christian Origins at California State University, Long Beach, and visiting senior member
- 0:56of Lenaker College in Oxford. He was a senior Fellow at the Oxford Center
- 0:59for host Graduate Hebrew Studies and a US Endowment for the Humanities Fellow in residence
- 1:04at the Albright Institute of Archaeological Research in Jerusalem, where the Dead Sea Scrolls
- 1:08first came in. Let's welcome doctor Isisamon who the circle. Welcome, sir,
- 1:14Thank you, thanks for having me. This is awesome. This is
- 1:15a great It wasn't me a great show. We all lost stuff to talk
- 1:19about. We've had a series a while back on who is Jesus. We
- 1:23had Professor Amy Jolavigne. We have had an emon, We've had a rabbi
- 1:27who is Jesus? Well, I first had to when you told me about
- 1:30who is Jesus. I mean, there's a lot of debate that people may
- 1:34not be aware of, but the debate at the moment is did he exist?
- 1:37It was there a was there a Jesus? I do think there was
- 1:42a Jesus, but I'm not sure that was his name. The point what
- 1:46I'm trying to make is that the name is suspicious. The reason the name
- 1:49is suspicious is because Jesus is a Greek version of Joshua, which in Hebrews
- 1:57Yeshua, which means he who said it's very it's a very strong coincidence that
- 2:04the savior in a religion is also named the Savior. And so the problem
- 2:10being that that we know in the Gospels. In a moment, I can
- 2:15explain that in the Gospels that there were four brothers, James, Simon,
- 2:20Jude, and Josie's Josie j o s e S probably a variation on Joseph
- 2:27or something like that. We heard of Joseph, Yes, Josie's and and
- 2:30and you know the problem, when the Gospels made a supernatural Christ, these
- 2:36four brothers turned into like brothers by another mother or cousins or it's the official
- 2:40Catholic doctrine or what have you. But the point is what seems to have
- 2:46happened is that Jesus, basically, you know, turned into himself. In
- 2:51other words, Josie's was probably who the character was. But when we distance
- 2:57Jesus from the other brother and supernaturalized him, then Josies became his brother.
- 3:06And the same thing. Mary turns out to be an ant in the Gospel
- 3:09of John, and so on and so forth. We've got Mary's sister of
- 3:14Mary in the Gospel of John. That's absurd, that that is ludicrous.
- 3:17That's what happens when you get a doctrine that that that that transforms history.
- 3:23I make it short. What my problem is that what people do, and
- 3:28I know what a downplane was religion of faith, because faith is important and
- 3:31people should have it, they need it, but they should not confuse literature
- 3:38and history. So the thing is that what we have in the Gospels,
- 3:43for instance, is basically literature. It's a Greco Roman literature written in Greek
- 3:49in the Roman Empire, serving a certain purpose for those who were writing it.
- 3:53So they had an agenda, Yes, they had an agenda to pacify
- 3:57the Messianic movement in Palestine. That's the agenda. So the agenda is turn
- 4:01the other chief, which is a lovely doctrine. I'm not you know,
- 4:04you know, return good for evil. You see, if a man slaps
- 4:10you on the one chief, you know, turn the other and so on
- 4:13and so on. Uh and uh, you know. But the Dead Sea
- 4:18Scrolls, which is what I'm somewhat known for to my mind, is the
- 4:25authentic Messianic literature in Palestine. You have to realize that in the Dead Sea
- 4:30Scrolls, as it turns out, there are all the Messianic prophecies that are
- 4:34later incorporated into Christianity and the Gospels and that sort of thing. But it's
- 4:40a completely alien framework. That is, the scrolls are hate the sons of
- 4:46the pit. They don't love their enemies, they hate them. They are
- 4:49preparing and I'm not advocating this, I think, well, that's that is
- 4:56the propaganda that was put out by the scholarly con senses, which gets back
- 5:00to the why we're beginning with the scrolls. And the point is the people
- 5:04who first worked on these scrolls were mostly mostly prelates of one kind or another.
- 5:14Father de Vaux was the head of the Dominican Order in Palestine, and
- 5:17so on and so forth, Father Millic et cetera, et cetera, and
- 5:20all these people, since they were basically Catholican background, and by that time
- 5:26the division of Palestine had occurred, so the scrolls came in under Jordanian auspices,
- 5:34and they set up a basically uten Rhine committee, a uten Rhine committee
- 5:40meaning no Jews on it. So they saw this as a monastery like themselves.
- 5:46So they saw the essenes as peaceful scenes contemplating their navels and so on
- 5:50and so. But they weren't reading the literature. And here we have some
- 5:56of the principal documents of the deadsy scrolls that I translated, the Damascus Document,
- 6:01the Habakuka Commentary, and the Community Rule. And these documents are not
- 6:09peaceful. They are not peaceful whatsoever. There's a war scroll which is outlining
- 6:15the final apocalyptic war against all evil on the earth, and they they they
- 6:23have there. They're somewhat crazy, of course, they think the Messiah is
- 6:27going to come with the heaven the angels, and they're fighting the might of
- 6:31Rome. So they obviously you and I know that a little group like this
- 6:36in the wilderness can't beat Rome. There is the greatest army in the world.
- 6:40But they had a secret weapon, an atomic bomb. Their atomic bomb
- 6:44was the Angelic Host. But they had this idea that in order for the
- 6:48Angelic Host to join their forces. They really believe that it's in the warst
- 6:54goal that the Angelic Coast was going to come into that what they call camps,
- 6:57they had wilderness camps. John the Baptist would been in the wilderness,
- 7:00a type of wilderness camp. He would have been involved, and he probably
- 7:03his doctrines are very similar to the Dead Sea scrolls. But the point he
- 7:08probably was a member or an earlier member of the of the group. But
- 7:11the point is these camps have to be perfectly pure. What does that mean?
- 7:15Why did that have to perfectly pure? No women in the camps,
- 7:19no fornication, no anything like that. If someone, for instance, I
- 7:25don't recruit, but if it has someone had a wet dream had to go
- 7:28and have a bath and purify himself. Why because their doctrine was that the
- 7:33angelic host could not abide human impurity, would not join the camps if there
- 7:39was any impurity, not proper food, this kind of thing in the camps,
- 7:43or anyone was impure because if they came in contact with human impurity,
- 7:46they couldn't go back up to heaven. I don't trus it's Nunny's I'm not
- 7:53advocating this, but that is. They're very original, they're very imaginative.
- 7:57But the point is it's unfamiliar to one who who knows Christianity. No,
- 8:03of course, so these monks basically and brothers and one, they weren't reading
- 8:07the documents. They were just assuming we're dealing with peaceful essenes. But there's
- 8:11something that counter indicates this for your audience, and I'll say it quickly because
- 8:16it's so complicated. There was a Christian writer in the in the around one
- 8:20hundred and fifty called Hippolytus h I P p O L y t u s.
- 8:26And in his works he has a different version of the Jewish historian Josephus,
- 8:30upon which most of our historical knowledge is based. He's the one who
- 8:35tells us about the Essenes. But Josephus tells us something in Hippolytus a different
- 8:39version than the one we received in Greek. So this was probably an earlier
- 8:43Aramaic version. And in that there are four groups of essenes. There are
- 8:48the you know ones that we've heard of, There are marrying essenes, and
- 8:52then there are two others Zelotescenes and sicaries scenes and Sicariae. In Josephus,
- 9:01sicari is supposed to be named after the sikha, the curved dagger, the
- 9:05Roman sword that they used to assassinate their opponents extreme zealots. Yeah, yeah,
- 9:11yeah, he doesn't like them, he hates them, but he tells
- 9:13us who they are. But we don't have to believe Josephus. The point
- 9:18of the matter is that he does make it clear that everyone's heard of Masada,
- 9:20where they committed suicide about thirty kometers south of the Kumrun where the Dead
- 9:28Sea scrolls were found. We did at cal Sate Long Beach a walking survey
- 9:31of the whole area, so it's in in in this book we have all
- 9:35all of the pictures of the walking survey that we did with our students all
- 9:39the way down to Masada and Engetti. Anyway, the point is that that
- 9:48the Sakari, the sakari Is, as he tells us, were the ones
- 9:50at Masada who committed suicide. But we found dead sea scroll documents there.
- 9:54That means that the Sakari we're using dead sea scroll documents. So the point
- 9:58of the matter is hypothesis isn't so far wrong. And he says these these
- 10:03people participated in the war against Rome, to see if it agrees with that.
- 10:07But not only do they participate in the war against Rome, if for
- 10:13instance, he says specifically, they didn't mind dying any kind of death,
- 10:16they were any kind of torture, They would never reveal who any information,
- 10:24and they prefer death to surrender. So they also they also if they heard
- 10:30someone talking about the Law of Moses, he says that they would offer they
- 10:35would offer him circumcision or the sword. And that's what just Acharis. So
- 10:39this so the knife that he's talking about is not probably the assassin's knife,
- 10:46as Josephus you know, wants us to know. In other areas, it's
- 10:48probably the circumciser's knife, and and and and you see that there's it's like
- 10:54Islam Islam or the Sword Islam has a lot in common, fortunately or unfortunate.
- 10:58I don't want to put any judgment on this. With the Dead Sea
- 11:01scrolls, I think some ideas filtered down in the Arabian Peninsula and Muhammad came
- 11:05in touch with that. But I don't want to be making any Muslims angry
- 11:09because for them nothing occurred before Muhammad, and I don't want to gain any
- 11:13of that kind of thing. Let me a quick question. As you mentioned,
- 11:15the wasn't a debate between whether they committed suicide or they were killed.
- 11:20There there had lots of debates of that kind of but I think it's pretty
- 11:22clear they totally commit suicide. The reason is very simple. Why they committed
- 11:26suicide when all hope was lost and the Romans finished using the prisoners to build
- 11:31a ramp and we have a picture of the ramp in here. They wanted
- 11:37to meet they believed in the afterlife, and they wanted to meet their wives
- 11:41and young children in the afterlife. If they surrendered, and the Romans took
- 11:46their women and their children and sold them to the brothels and as slaves,
- 11:50they would be impure. They could not be resurrected. Only the pure were
- 11:56resurrected. In their view, everyone was not resurrected the way we see it.
- 12:00So and they would not see their their their kindred, their wives,
- 12:03their children. Therefore, they prefer to kill their wives and children themselves so
- 12:07they would enjoy the afterlife together. Also, they kill them themselves. They
- 12:11all get together. That's right, that's right. Different, that's exactly what
- 12:15happened. I don't mean, I don't mean to be so assertive, but
- 12:18I know that's what happened. The expert around I know, I know everyone's
- 12:22an expert, but I in your soul you know certain things. I know
- 12:26that that's interesting. Let me ask you this. We're gonna go back to
- 12:28Jesus a little bit. Does these scrolls give a different depiction of Jesus I
- 12:31remember correctly, because there's the Gnostics and all these other different things going on.
- 12:37Is it really different? Well, the scrolls don't have a Jesus.
- 12:43Know. What their scrolls have is a righteous teacher, a teacher of righteousness
- 12:48who's their leader. And and he every time you see teacher of righteousness,
- 12:52which is why this book is so important. Uh in the in the commentaries,
- 12:56like in a backhook or something like that. You know, habakuk,
- 13:03I think it's two four or something like that. The righteous shall live by
- 13:05his faith is the very passage Paul uses in Galatians and Romans and elsewhere to
- 13:11build his foundation of Christianity. They have it here, but they have a
- 13:16different exegesis of it, and it's totally different. The righteous is the righteous
- 13:22teacher, and you will live by your works and faith working together, you
- 13:26know, and so on and so forth. It's a works righteousness ideology which
- 13:31they have. And so anyway, every time the passage righteous One is found
- 13:37in one of these prophets, they interpret it as the righteous teacher. And
- 13:41the righteous one is what Kabbalah, the mystical Jews called the sadik. Most
- 13:48people have heard of the sadik z a d DK. Well, every time
- 13:52Sadik is in the manuscript, it's the righteous teacher. But we know from
- 13:56early Christian texts that James the Just in Latin and Greek, James Justice is
- 14:05James the Tzadik. In Hebrew, James the righteous one. James Justice is
- 14:11a righteous one. James. To my mind, James is the Righteous Teacher
- 14:16of the Dead Sea scrolls. Yes, well that was it. And I
- 14:20got myself mixed up there because I put the Gnostic College. So we do
- 14:24have one of the characters. Now, what I say at the end is
- 14:28that once we found the historical James, we've found the historical Jesus. Because
- 14:33I say, you know, just like Bobby Kennedy didn't differ very much from
- 14:37John Kennedy. You see, the Gospels don't like the brothers, because Paul
- 14:41doesn't like the brothers he hates. In Galatians, he says, he says,
- 14:54the some in Glacious, who some from James, came down and wanted
- 14:58us to stopped keeping table fellowship with Gentiles because they wanted to observe purity laws
- 15:05and and and eat only pure foods. And then Peter and Barnabas copied them
- 15:11in there, Hippocrossia. He calls them hypocrites. He calls he called Pete.
- 15:18Paul calls people don't read the scripture closely. In Galatians to your audience,
- 15:22can go. Paul calls both Barnabas and Peter hypocrites. And I'm here,
- 15:31oh yeah, Well, later on, later on in the History of
- 15:35Christianity. Uh. The famous Christian theologian from North Africa, I forget his
- 15:39name now, wrote Jerome a letter, wrote Jerome a letter in the early
- 15:43four hundreds and said to him, what are we to do about Paul calling
- 15:50Peter a hypocrite? How dare he do that? And Jerome wrote back,
- 15:54there's some things best left unanswered. Augustine, that was always you're right,
- 15:58that's exact I wonder out of this. Yeah, maybe more than your brain
- 16:02is. So Yeah, I love love that answer. Some thing's best left
- 16:06answered, we can answer. They didn't like each other, and he's always
- 16:12heaping abuse on James. Paul is always heaping abuse on James and and his
- 16:18movement. He says, some people are so weak. He says in one
- 16:22of his I think it's it's in one Corinthians. They'll only eat vegetables their
- 16:26consciousness. They have weak consciouces. He means that they conscience for him is
- 16:30a euphemism for observing the law. And he knows that the James Party the
- 16:36some from James. And then they're also called in in in in Ugalatians to
- 16:41the party of the circumcision, and you realize those are the market. Yeah,
- 16:47they're the ones who are coming down, and they are in another language,
- 16:49the siicari essens i assist on circumcision, the party of the Circumcisition POC.
- 16:57Yeah. I don't want to make a big deal, but you know
- 17:00this is not easy stuff for an audience to grasp in one gulp. I
- 17:03will admit that. But that's why this is my most well known book.
- 17:08This isn't a five page book. Here lot of James, the Brother of
- 17:11Jesus, Penguin book. I never in my life, when I was a
- 17:15kid, thought I'd get a thousand page book out in Penguin. And it's
- 17:18still and it's still being marketed, and it started in nineteen ninety seven.
- 17:22It's still on the shelves and a lot of some channels. And remember that
- 17:26this is my most famous book. Though James brother Jesus, no one even
- 17:30talked about him. And I put a thousand pages together, and this is
- 17:33the pages the New Testament code this book. Here are the thousand pages we
- 17:38cut out of this one. So this one, this one was the follow
- 17:44up in two thousand and five. The point when I was telling you earlier
- 17:48that this book was published in ninety seven, ninety eight, both in England
- 17:52and in America by Viking, and a fairly good publisher in England too,
- 17:56and it was reviewed in the Jerusalem Post. In nineteen ninety eight it came
- 18:00out in Penguin and a great review in the Jerusalem Post. And so people
- 18:07in Israel would have suddenly begun to hear about James, the brother of Jesus.
- 18:11Who would have never thought there was such a person, never knew who
- 18:14never They don't know much about Jesus in Israel. And Jesus had a brother,
- 18:18Jacob, the son of Joseph. Long and behold four years later and
- 18:22aushwary appears Jacob the son of Joseph, the brother of Jesus. When I
- 18:29heard that, I just laughed on the brother of Jesus. Yeah, on
- 18:32the atary. Yeah, but in different handwriting, in different handwriting, And
- 18:37no, a person chiseled it in with a different with a different well,
- 18:41it was a different hand it was the it was the I don't want to
- 18:45say. I can't use the word f O R G E R that's forbidden,
- 18:49so I don't do it anyway. Whoever, whoever chiseled it on,
- 18:56I would go any deeper than that. You know it's a different hand.
- 19:00And the point is that it clearly James was so if this was sixty two,
- 19:04when James was supposed to have died. James was so famous in the
- 19:08Jerusalem of his name because he was known as James, the t Sadiq,
- 19:11James, the Just, James, the righteous one. We know that's what
- 19:15he was called. And it's in all the Early Church of literature. And
- 19:19yes, and he is the successor. And Paul admits he's the successor in
- 19:25Galatians too. He said, when the representatives of James came down, then
- 19:30these Peter was under him. Peter had to follow his instructions. And if
- 19:34you read Galatians, and if you read even Acts fifteen sixteen, you'll see
- 19:40that there's a Jerusalem conference that that instructions are sent to the communities overseas.
- 19:45Abstained from. I think it's it's abstained from you know, pork, of
- 19:55course, strangle things, blood, and things sacrificed to and fornication and things
- 20:00sacrificed to idols. Well, Paul doesn't agree with that. Paul doesn't think
- 20:06you should abstain from blood. Paul doesn't think that you should abstained from in
- 20:10any of those twos he said everything in the butcher shop, he says in
- 20:12one Corinthians is clean. So he's totally against the Jerusalem leadership, totally against
- 20:19them. Christianity, we know comes from Paul, and that comes from overseas.
- 20:26So what was the Jerusalem doctrine? The Dead Sea scrolls? So the
- 20:30Jerusalem doctrines here are in are in the Dead Sea Scrolls because the scrolls are
- 20:34the Messianic literature in Palestine, and they're led by a righteous teacher, and
- 20:38that righteous teacher parallels the I would say it was parallels the character of James,
- 20:42the righteous One in early Christianity, who function from the forties to the
- 20:48sixties. So I go back to my initial question. Who would know Jesus
- 20:52better Someone who admits he persecuted him, someone who opposed Christianity and in fact
- 20:57killed the one or two in his early life and then got letters to arrest
- 21:03Christians and suddenly got a vision he claims, on the on the road to
- 21:07to to Damascus, et cetera. Or someone who grew up with him,
- 21:12was born with him, followed him, and so on and so forth.
- 21:15To me, any normal, uh rational person would say the one who grew
- 21:21up with them and knew him. But the whole world says Paul knows Jesus
- 21:26better. That's because Paul created the Jesus we know, which goes back to
- 21:30your original question, Jesus. Yes, there were four brothers, James,
- 21:37Simon, Jude, and Josies and the New The Gospels say as the supernatural
- 21:41Christ developed, they were pushed over to being cousins. I just read an
- 21:45article the other day. Someone said that they're supposed to be, you know,
- 21:52step step brothers by by another mother or something like that. I forget
- 21:57all that stuff. The point of the is that that was the family.
- 22:02It's the supernatural Christ. Mary turns into her own sister Mary, Mary,
- 22:06the sister of Mary, and the Gospel of John and so on and so
- 22:10forth. So James was so famous in the Jerusalem of his day for twenty
- 22:17years. If there was an ashwary, you wouldn't put brother of Jesus because
- 22:22the Gospels hadn't been written yet and no one would have known who Jesus was,
- 22:26and you wouldn't put that. You don't put brother of someone on awards.
- 22:30That's right, because the Gospels were found, you know now, indeed
- 22:33to one hundred and twenty or whatever. So the point is that people in
- 22:37Palistine wouldn't have known who this person was, so you wouldn't put that brother
- 22:41of Jesus on there. James didn't need that. You might have put James
- 22:44the Righteous One or something like that. James the only a modern person would
- 22:48put that. And it's and it's a different handwriting. So I immediately said,
- 22:52that is not an authentic The oshuway is authentic. It's a it's a
- 22:56Jacob, the son of Joseph Aushwary. But they would have been plentiful or
- 23:00been mani ashore. We've found many Oshwaars, you know, with those kinds
- 23:03of things, because they were popular names. I mean, hold on for
- 23:06this. We're gonna take of commercial break. This is unbelievable stuff. I
- 23:08hope you're enjoying it as much as I can. I am surprise. We'll
- 23:12see you back after this message. Hi, welcome to Alante. This is
- 23:27at Alante's Recovery and my name is Vette Cooglan and I'm part of the staff
- 23:34at Alante Recovery Center has helped people dual diagnosis for five years. We accept
- 23:40most PPO insurances and provide luxury accommodations and twenty four hour support to speak with
- 23:45an admissions counselor call one eight eight eight two four two four four five zero.
- 23:53A lot of time we don't even know what's wrong with us, and
- 23:56sometimes we need to get away to figure that out. So if you want
- 24:00to go for a little retreat out in Corona del Mar, which is a
- 24:04confidential location, we're here to help. So we're only from thank you,
- 24:15welcome back here. We are doctor Robert Eisaman once again in the books,
- 24:18but there's too many to point ouple here. The couple of them they are
- 24:21great. The New Testament Code and James the Brother of Jesus. There's one
- 24:25other book you might want to mention to your audience, The Dead Sea scroll
- 24:27Deception by Michael Beaijen and Richard Lee, the people who who wrote Holy Blood
- 24:33and Holy Grail, and they wrote a book about what we were doing.
- 24:36And I was the unacknowledged third author of that that tells the whole dispute over
- 24:41the scrolls. And I had to correct around one hundred errors that they made.
- 24:44So it's a hundred. Yeah. Well, you know, it's a
- 24:48it's a tough subject and so it's it's accurate. The Dead Sea, Scholl
- 24:52Deception, Michael Beaje and Richard Lee. That brings me to the question out
- 24:56of thinking about it, the Da Vinci Code. Did you watch it?
- 25:03I did, yes, recently. That's good. It's a good mystery.
- 25:07It's a good mystery movie. It's nothing to do with anything serious. But
- 25:11I was surprised because I hadn't watched it recently. You know, the major
- 25:15character in the in the Da Vinci Call is at least the negative one or
- 25:21somewhat positive is Lee Tebing. He's the one telling uh, doctor Robert somebody.
- 25:26And I said, oh god, doctor Robert is probably a take off
- 25:30on me, because Lee Tebing is a take off on Beijing and Beijan and
- 25:36Lee. And I'm involved with Beije and Lee telling him all this stuff.
- 25:38And he knows that. And he knows that we went to render the Chateau
- 25:41together, and he knows that we went out in the Dead Seat. Michael
- 25:45Beaigen came out in the Dead Sea together with me, and he knows that
- 25:48they wrote this book the Dead Seas called Deception, so he probably I didn't
- 25:52realize. Probably that Robert character, doctor Professor Robert is a parody of me.
- 26:00It may not be, but Lee Teebing Lee is Richard Lee, and
- 26:03t being is an acronym for pagent. He just changed. He likes to
- 26:07play word games. The man who wrote the Dan Brown, who wrote the
- 26:12Da Vinci Code. The problem is that Pageant Lee were upset about he mentions
- 26:18their book, but upset about not getting some financial remuneration from all the money.
- 26:23Then, yeah, and so they sued him. But I thought that
- 26:26was a very foolish thing to do, because you can't sue a novelist,
- 26:30which is that's just a novel after all, for something. So their lawyers
- 26:33said that he stroll stole the architecture of their work. My wife said,
- 26:37no, they should have sued them for misusing their names, for parenting their
- 26:42names in that way, Lee tebing that would have been that would have been
- 26:47a possible lawsuit, But the other one and so they lost, and they
- 26:49lost everything. They lost all their earnings, and they lost all their royalties
- 26:55and so on because lawsuits and England are very expensive. Lawyers are very expensive.
- 26:59I know they end up suing their own lawyers, and that you know,
- 27:02both of them died not long afterwards. Richard Lee died of a heart
- 27:06attack and Michael Beagent died of a bad liver transplant. Wow, Michael Beijing
- 27:12was my very close friend, my very close friend, and I regretted in
- 27:15mourn his death to this day. I knew Richard. I knew Richard,
- 27:19but I wouldn't consider him a friendly person. I only speaking to those who
- 27:26passed beyond. But you can't say he's my close friend. But he was
- 27:30someone I knew well. I had a thing about him because he took my
- 27:33work and often he would ascribe it to himself. And I have to say,
- 27:38Richard, you have to put a footnote there. You have to put
- 27:41a footnote there. Don't You didn't like that at all. Let me ask
- 27:45a couple of questions. We're going to tackle some of the mysteries here,
- 27:48because you don't get a resident expert all the time in the circle, at
- 27:52least on this topic. And I've been to rend the chateau as well,
- 27:55so we did the radar ground scan there. I was getting ready to ask
- 27:57you, so what is going on over there? Well, the point is
- 28:00that there is a church and people are looking for the grave of Mary Magdalene
- 28:07and that kind of thing. It's all part of the Marry Magdalene cult.
- 28:11I was never that much involved in the Marry Magdalene issue. That's a feminist
- 28:15issue, which is fine, but it really doesn't have much to do with
- 28:18Palestine of the first and second century, because, honestly, that's the point
- 28:22I was trying to make at the beginning. You have to distinguish literature and
- 28:26history. Just like Homer's works are literature. You're not going to take the
- 28:33Odyssey as complete history. You're not going to take the Iliad as complete history.
- 28:37These are literary works. The gospels are likewise literary works. To get
- 28:42the history, you've got to penetrate much, much harsher and much deeper into
- 28:47things. So when you're trying to talk about a wife of Jesus, or
- 28:49a Jesus cave, or a gospel. After a couple of gospels appeared,
- 28:53it turns out there it was a whole you know, cottage industry writing gospels.
- 29:00You know, there's a there's always you know, hundreds and hundreds of
- 29:03hundreds, but literally a hundred or so apocryphal gospels have a beard. They
- 29:08found the Gospel of Philip, the Gospel of Mary Magdalene, the Gospel of
- 29:11Peace. There's all kinds of gospels have suddenly the Gospel of Judas Iscariot,
- 29:17all these gospels have suddenly, you know, appeared. And the ones we
- 29:19know are the ones that Constantine in the fourth century at the Council of Nicea,
- 29:25you know, made made it orthodox to reckon agenda too. Yes,
- 29:33they had it and and agenda, but I don't take those as historical documents.
- 29:38So what I've said, yes, I don't doubt that there was a
- 29:41crucified person. I don't know what his name was, and I know he
- 29:45had a brother called James. And what I'm saying is that since you know,
- 29:48brothers don't really fall very far. Sometimes they do, but rarely do
- 29:52they do that, particularly one who succeeds the other. So I'm saying it's
- 29:56easier to find James because he hasn't been so overwritten. No one's bothered about
- 30:00him. So the material that we have, but James is fairly authentic.
- 30:04Now you take the Book of Acts, where James is mentioned, but there
- 30:08are to jameses, Well, what what I mean to James. There's James
- 30:11the brother of John. Oh, well, that's already rewriting things. Maybe
- 30:17there was a James, brother of John. Maybe there wasn't we know there
- 30:21was a James the brother of Jesus. Now now now very fortunately, James,
- 30:26brother of John evaporates about Acts about twelve or thirteen, setting the stage
- 30:34for the introduction of James the brother of Jesus in chapter fifteen. But the
- 30:40Acts never tells us who James the brother of Jesus was. Suddenly there's a
- 30:42James, and there's Root and there's a Jerusalem conference. But James the brother
- 30:48of John has been killed, crucified or or you know, done to death
- 30:52by the authorities. And they even say, go tell James. That means
- 30:57the other James of You know that I escape Peter at one point in early
- 31:02point of Acts. There's another thing people don't know. The first fifteen chapters
- 31:07of Acts are a third person he they the last chapters of Acts from sixteen
- 31:12fifteen sixteen onwards what we call the We document. I we. That's because
- 31:19the last ten chapters or so of Acts are probably based on a travel document
- 31:26or diary of a person like Luke, who has described the authorship has described
- 31:30to Acts, and the first are more like the Gospels, more literary.
- 31:33The last parts are more reliable, more down to earth. We did this,
- 31:40we went here, we did that, and Acts twenty one twenty one
- 31:44is the key to everything. Paul comes up to Jerusalem and he meets James
- 31:48that actually never tells us who this James is, but he's the leader of
- 31:52the church and he's clearly over Paul. And he comes to see Paul and
- 31:57comes to see James. And then the we document said quotes this James.
- 32:02But you see, Paul, many have heard you've been teaching against the people,
- 32:07against the law, and against the temple all over Asia. Well we
- 32:13know he has been. He teaches against the law and the temple and against
- 32:16the people. And so to show there's no truth to these rumors, we
- 32:21want you to go into the temple and pay for a Nazarite oath on the
- 32:24part of people who are being dedicated for people we have under Nazraite oath which
- 32:30had some expenses attached to it. And Paul is seen as rich because he
- 32:32raises money in all these communities. He's always raising money in his letters.
- 32:37So nothing both, he says sure, and he goes in. And it's
- 32:40at that point an accidenta riot occurs in the temple and the people all shriek.
- 32:45This is the person we've seen all over Asia minor, you know,
- 32:49teaching against et etcetera, etcetera. And they take him and throw him out
- 32:53of the temple and barrow the door behind him. And then the Roman soldiers
- 32:57come down and rescue Paul and make the people listen to him. That's all
- 33:02the later part of us. Now, that to me is pretty authentic stuff.
- 33:07That's pretty authentic stuff. And that's very different character than the early part.
- 33:09So the early part is more literary, the later part is more historical.
- 33:14So the I we document type material is pretty historical, and the letters
- 33:17of Paul are pretty historical. The ones that are considered authentic Galatians, one
- 33:22of two Corinthians, Philippians, and so on. So let me ask you
- 33:25this. How about the authorship that's been in question for recently in the last
- 33:29ten twenty thirty years. I think in seminary they actually have taught it for
- 33:32centre for decades, but the authorship seems to be in question. Did Matthew
- 33:36Mark, Lucan John write it? We don't even know who they are.
- 33:37Those titles came on at some point. But you see, my feeling is
- 33:42there's a huge body of literature that develops in the way literature does develop.
- 33:50It's not necessarily historical literature, you know, if you want to emphasize Mary
- 33:53Magdalene, or if you want to emphasize Judas Iscariot or so on and so
- 34:00forth. So this literature we have three synoptics that are variations on each other
- 34:04from different places. We have John that doesn't even agree with him on many
- 34:07many points, and they're all writing about this quote Jesus, And where is
- 34:12he mentioned in Paul's letters? So I'm not sure. You see, I
- 34:17do think there was a Jesus. A lot of people don't understand, and
- 34:22I don't want to make it too complicated. In the historian Josephus, who's
- 34:27the key year first century Jewish historian died around ninety six, who wrote two
- 34:31books, The Histories and the Antiquities, The Antiquities and the Jewish War.
- 34:39The Jewish War was to praise Titus and Vespasian, who destroyed the Jews and
- 34:45the temple. He went over to them. That's why they gave him their
- 34:47family name. He was the original ben Herr. He's called Flavius Josehas because
- 34:52Flavians were the name of the of the new imperial family, who got that
- 34:58way because of their victories in Palace on. So he totally switched. He
- 35:01was a trader. He even describes in his autobiography, also in his works
- 35:06the Vita which has come down to us, that he goes out under Titus's
- 35:09instructions to speak to the people on the walls of the temple, when they
- 35:14have on the walls of Jerusalem and they have it surrounded, asking them to
- 35:17surrender, and someone has a sling and flings an arrow and hits him on
- 35:23the head, and he falls down. He describes as Josephus, and a
- 35:28huge cheer went up from the ramparts of Jerusalem. He says, because they
- 35:32thought their enemy Josephus was dead. He admits that unabashedly. He knows that
- 35:37the people hate him. You see. So the point is that he dedicates
- 35:43his work to a person called a Paphroditis. If you look at the beginning
- 35:47of Antiquities, he describes who a paphroditis is. You look at Philippians two
- 35:53and four, polls apostle and fellow soldier in Christ is called a Paphriditis,
- 36:01and he sends him to Rome to the household of Caesar. And to my
- 36:07mind, these are the same people. And this is the connection of Josephus
- 36:12to Paul. And why do they want to write these books of Jewish history
- 36:15so they can produce these gospels because they base a lot of the Gospels on
- 36:20what Josephus is writing. So he writes these materials under a Paphroditis's sponsorship.
- 36:27That's a crazy story about Apaphroditis. A Paphroditis is in Nero's household secretary for
- 36:31Greek letters, but somehow he survives into the Flavians. And what happens is
- 36:37when Titus I think it's Titus or is no, No, it's when Nero,
- 36:45who he was in the household previously, commits suicide. Paphroditis is one
- 36:51of his you know, right hand man or you know, in his cabin
- 36:54or whatever. He holds the sword on which Nero runs on to kill himself.
- 37:00Later he held ye four Nero, you know, later on not Vespasian
- 37:07Antitus like a Paphriditis. So he's able to sponsor Josepha's works and so on.
- 37:12But Domitian the third, the third Flavian Titus's younger brother doesn't like them,
- 37:19and he arrests has Paphroditis are arrested and he executes him. And what's
- 37:25the charge raising his hand against an emperor raising his And later on someone assassinates
- 37:36the Domitian And who is it? A woman called Flavia Domatilla. Flavia is
- 37:43the feminine name. We have the Domatilla Catacombs even to this day, in
- 37:47a room on her property. She was an early convert within the within the
- 37:52Flavian family itself, to Christianity. Her servant, Stephen Stefanos assassin it's the
- 38:00mission, and that Stephen is a hero of the Book of Acts, if
- 38:04you recall a peers out of never in the Book of Acts. So what
- 38:07I'm trying to get at here is that you have to try to put these
- 38:09things together in some kind of careful way. But I don't take the Gospels
- 38:14to me, that's later literature. You want to know what Messianism is like
- 38:19in the Palestine itself, not in Rome, not Pauline Roman Messianism, but
- 38:24Palestinian James and Messianism. Go to the Dead Sea scrolls. That's where they're
- 38:30going to tell you how it was over there. That's how that's where you'll
- 38:31find that literature is very different. Because I'm not advocating it, but as
- 38:36I was saying, they have the wilderness camps, the heavenly host is going
- 38:40to join them and have to be absolute purity because the heavenly Hosts can't abide
- 38:45human impurity. They don't believe in turning the other cheek. They don't love
- 38:49their enemies, they hate the sons of the pit. None of this agrees
- 38:52with The's nice. The gospel doctrines are nice. Yes, if you want
- 38:57a peaceful group of people who are under the control of the Roman Empire,
- 39:00fine, but you don't want to rebel. Uh you know crowd who are
- 39:05who are preaching the final apocalyptic war against all evil on the earth, and
- 39:09the epitome of all evil is the Roman Empire. We don't want to be
- 39:15marketing that kind of literature, you see. So this is my problem.
- 39:19And so I say, it's easier to find the historical James. And I
- 39:22say who and whatever James was, So was Jesus. So no one of
- 39:25the questions. Somebody brought one of the scholars. Oh yeah, that's great
- 39:29stuff. It's like somehow you've made the Bible into downtown Abbey here. I
- 39:31don't know you that well. I love this James character. I think he's
- 39:35a marvelous character. And we're not denying the characters in early Christianity. We're
- 39:40just reversing a few of the things that have been reversed. We're reversing them
- 39:44back. And Josepha doesn't really write about Jesus. No, no, he
- 39:47doesn't write about people. I was going to say, there was a Samaritan
- 39:51Taheb, which is a redeemer figure who was executed by Pontius pott in in
- 39:57in a town called that. It's in the Talmud, and it's also in
- 40:00Josephus, and he would have been a Joshua reda vivits because the Samaritans uh
- 40:06followed Joshua, and so their redeemer figure would be a reincarnation of Joshua Jesus.
- 40:12So he would have been a Jesus incarnate, you see. And he
- 40:16was crucified by Pontius Pilot and Joshua. You said, was he was a
- 40:21Greek Jesus. Jesus is Greek for Joshuay. Yes, so I think that
- 40:24that that that that that that time, somehow became incorporated into the gospel presentation
- 40:30of Jesus. Fascinating, fascinating, fascinating stuff. We got about five or
- 40:37six minutes. I want you to wrap up everything. No, just kidding.
- 40:39A couple of things. The shroud. You have it on the cover
- 40:43of your brid right, true, false, nobody. I'm impressed by the
- 40:45shroud, really, but I don't less the pictures of it. I'm impressed
- 40:51by it. I don't think you could forward such a thing, but I'm
- 40:54not sure it's a miraculous thing. We don't have a lot of other bodies
- 41:00in that prayer that were wrapped in something like that, and that the linen
- 41:05was saved. I wouldn't be surprised. It was fairly common from the chemicals
- 41:08and the ointments that they put on the body that you know they ate into
- 41:13the linen materials. So I don't think they're just one such thing of this
- 41:16kind. And also the church denies the authenticity of the shroud because it doesn't
- 41:22the injuries and different things in it don't meet the picture of the gospel of
- 41:28the Gospel Jesus, so they don't. They Actually they called for the carbon
- 41:32testcause they wanted to show it was a forgery the church, but the original
- 41:37people found I thought it was real because it came from the Byzantine Empire.
- 41:40Where did they get it from. They got it from a place called Edessa,
- 41:44which was really Antioch on the Euphrates. It's in southern Turkey now in
- 41:51northern Syria. Now, to my mind, that's the original Antiochy. People
- 41:53don't understand there were four Antiochs in the Empire war. Yeah, because the
- 41:59person who I'm saying it fast, the person who founded the Solucid Empire's father
- 42:04was called Antiochus or Antiochus, and he named every city found it after him.
- 42:08So there's Antioch in Pisidia, there's Antioch on the Errantes, there's Antiocha,
- 42:13or there's Antioch in southern Iraq which is now Bosra. So to my
- 42:17mind, people have the wrong Antioch when they're talking about the Christian antich They
- 42:22think it's the one on the coast. I forget what the what the river
- 42:29there was, But to my mind, it's the one in northern Syria at
- 42:34the headwaters of the Euphrates. That's where Paul was operating. And I go
- 42:37into that in very great detail here to show that that is where things are
- 42:42happening, and that's where the you know, the the wilderness camps are and
- 42:46that's where a lot of things. Queen Helen Eveddiabini who converts to Judaism and
- 42:52gives the golden candelabra to the temple that we have a picture of that in
- 42:55here, the very candelabra that the Romans take, and you see it on
- 42:59the arch of Itis. What they did with that golden candelabra which you had
- 43:01given after she converted, They melted it down and built the Colosseum, the
- 43:07Temple of Death. They took the temple treasure and built this horrible a stadium
- 43:13for blood sports. That's what became of the wonderful temple temple treasure. Because
- 43:19the Flavians understood that people like to be amused, like they like to be
- 43:23amused by sports. Yeah, before we go here, a couple of works
- 43:28we have. We have to have a Laker stadium here. You know what
- 43:30we have to use the people fastball question, but fastball question before the fastball
- 43:38question. Scholars have also said, I don't know if you're included this.
- 43:44I'm just ROBERTI I'm just losing. So you might not. It might be
- 43:49interesting for your folks to know that I am the brother of Peter Eisman,
- 43:52who designed the Holocaust Memorial in Berlin and also the the at Santiago Accompass,
- 44:00which is where the James Pilgrimage goes in Northern Europe. In northern Spain,
- 44:05the visitors center and the center of culture of the province of where Santiago de
- 44:10Compostella is he And to make it short, the Arizona Cardinal Football Stadium because
- 44:15he loved football when he was a kid. And everyone loves the Arizona Cardinal
- 44:19Football Stadium because they roll the the the turf in and out of that place.
- 44:22Oh, that's right. So the question was, there's a lot of
- 44:27Messiahs during those times. There are a lot of people that were going around
- 44:30preaching salvation. There are other Jesuses. Some say there was during the same
- 44:34time as a Jesus and Christianity. There was one gentleman who is very similar,
- 44:38Apollonius Tyana. Yeah, there are a lot of people. I don't
- 44:44think he claimed to be a massagh. Josepha's document Josephus is you have to
- 44:49read through Josephus and you have to like when you have a bad curvature of
- 44:53a lens out in space, you have to make corrections for the for the
- 44:58biases of Josephus and his hatreds, like he hates the Zelots, so he
- 45:01portrays them as horrible, nasty, vicious people, when in fact they were
- 45:06probably righteous anti Roman, you know, sacrifice their lives. So you have
- 45:12to you have to make corrections for the curvature of Josephs's mind. But the
- 45:17data is encyclopedic, so we have a huge and he does talk about several
- 45:23kind of Messianic type pretenders, candidates and so on. And as you say,
- 45:28he doesn't really mention Jesus. People think that's an interpolation, but he
- 45:30does mention the Samaritan Ti Hid and I don't think that's an interpolation, no
- 45:36reason to interpolate that. And so I think that in fact there was and
- 45:40he does mention Jamess. He discussed the death of James the just ninety two
- 45:47sixty two. We wouldn't know the date in his antiquities, and he explains
- 45:52the circumstances and they agree. I want people to know. In this book,
- 45:54we have a document called the Habakuk pressure, the commentary on the prophet
- 45:59Habiku two four, the building block of Christianity Habakuk too for the righteous lived
- 46:04by his faith. They're doing a analysis of that too in the habit in
- 46:10the Habakuk commentary. And to my mind, all the details of a James
- 46:15type figure and death are in the Habaccu commentary. Look at the Tobacco commentary,
- 46:21look at the life of James, and tell me that we're in another
- 46:23world. So what happened? How come the scrolls are so misinterpreted? We
- 46:28started with that because the people who got control of the scrolls at the beginning
- 46:30were a group of prelates who only saw the scrolls through their own prism of
- 46:36their monastic experience and didn't understand this supernatural Holy war ideology which Muhammad, let's
- 46:43say, took a hold of, and so they wouldn't let anyone see the
- 46:47scrolls. They had a small group who saw a small section of the scroll
- 46:52documents, and they give the scrolls out who selected people who saw the scrolls
- 46:57the way they did. And we call this the monopoly and consent. And
- 47:00in the years eighty eight to ninety two, I and one or two others
- 47:05broke the consensus and I got a hold of all the pictures through certain sources,
- 47:09and we published all the pictures and broke their consensus. And the reason
- 47:14we're having even an exhibit up here in Los Angeles now is because we broke
- 47:17that consensus and led a thousand voices sing. And that's what the dientical deception
- 47:23is about. That's how I got someone known, extremely fascinating fastball question.
- 47:27You're ready, sir. By the way, the reason we wanted to break
- 47:30it so that we could get new interpretations, Yeah, go ahead. We
- 47:32asked all Old Testament scholars this tricky question. Genesis six's two, if
- 47:38I remember correctly, the sons of God came down to mate with the women
- 47:42of men. What's wrong with that? Well, that question was who are
- 47:47the sons of God? This is literature. This is literature, that's true.
- 47:52This is not history necessarily old angels. Hey, look, who were
- 47:57the sirens who were Circe in Homer? In Homer's Odyssey. You know,
- 48:02I'm not responsible for what ancient writers put into their literature. The sons of
- 48:10God. I'm sure that they that they were trying to express the old Greek
- 48:15pantheon. But the Canaanites would have had a pantheon, and lots of others
- 48:21had a whole plethora of gods of different guinds. And I think that that's
- 48:24what they're talking about, the the Greco Canaanite type stories of of of of
- 48:32God's mating with with human women. I mean, don't you have what's what's
- 48:37her name who? I think it's Hercules, Hercules' mothers has had a human
- 48:45mother and a god like and Zeus is his father or or Poseionon or This
- 48:51was all the time occurring in the Greco, not just the literature of the
- 48:57East, as far as the Persian Empire world. So this kind of I
- 49:01think that's all that's being alluded to that I don't think it's a great mystery.
- 49:06I don't think that one has to believe in it. Sounds good,
- 49:09Doctor Robert Isaman, thank you so much for being on the circle. Fabulous,
- 49:13I mean, And these books are available. We're leaving some with my
- 49:17good friend Carlos here, so we're bringing leaving that one and we're leaving this
- 49:22one here, which is the story of my travels when I was younger.
- 49:27Thank you very much, sir. And we're also going to Raffle off some
- 49:30of these books, so you don't want to miss out on that. Once
- 49:32again, Doctor Robert Eisman. Here the books right here, the New Testament
- 49:36Code, James the Brother of Jesus, and the New Jerusalem and the New
- 49:40Jerusalem by Robertizem And thank you everyone. Remember our motto is simple, where
- 49:44over the psychology involved, even in the Dead Sea scrolls, We're gonna be
- 49:47there. See you next time, everyone, And also kettro their TV show
- 49:52Circle of Insight on therapycable dot com,