Latest / The Long for Truth Show / Opening the Floodgates to Prophetic Nonsense
Transcript
- 0:02Welcome to the Long for Truth podcast. I'm Robin Long. Join my husband
- 0:06Dan and I as we explore the roots of the early Pentecostal and Charismatic movements,
- 0:11and we shine a light on false doctrines and false teachers in the modern
- 0:15Church. Let's get started. Prophecy in the New Testament, at least the
- 0:21way it's treated in First Corinthians twelve thirteen fourteen, doesn't appear to have the
- 0:27same scripture quality inherrant inspiration and authority that when in Isaiah, thus seth the
- 0:35Lord. You don't go up to Isaiah and so I'm going to test what
- 0:38you've said now and hold fest wood is good and throw the rest away.
- 0:42But you do that with New Testament prophecy. But someone that steps out in
- 0:48faith and says I believe God is saying this and doesn't get it right,
- 0:54that doesn't make them a false prophet. Got some people some slack. If
- 0:58they're just stepping out beginning, sometimes they're going to make make they're going to
- 1:03mess up, they're going to make mistakes. That doesn't make them a false
- 1:06prophet. Part of the problem we're seeing here is, you know, people
- 1:11really misplaced, They're not really prophets, but somebody prophesied they were prophets.
- 1:15So now they're stepping into a mantle that they don't have any anointing or grace.
- 1:18We're trying to wear armor that doesn't belong to them, and they're prophesying
- 1:22wrongly. So this doesn't make them a false prophet, but they're really not
- 1:25a true prophet either, because they're not a prophet at all. I try
- 1:29to be very careful and listen, y'all. I am not perfect at this,
- 1:30Okay, I'm not, but I try to be very careful when saying
- 1:37this is a word I received from the Holy Spirit. But if the person
- 1:40is a brother or sister, I won't call them a false apostle or a
- 1:42false teacher or a false prophet. Two of the prophetic words that I gave
- 1:48that were predictive came to pass and one of them didn't. So because one
- 1:55of the words was wrong and two of the words were right, mean I'm
- 2:00a false prophet. Yep. Hello, everyone, welcome to Long for Truth.
- 2:05My name is Daniel Long. We are going to be talking about New
- 2:08Testament prophecy today, and we're going to be asking the question his New Testament
- 2:14prophecy and New Testament prophets. Are they judged by the same standard as the
- 2:19Old Testament prophecy and profits In the Old Testament. If a prophet prophesied and
- 2:25that prophecy did not come to pass, he was to be considered a false
- 2:30prophet. If that prophet prophesied and got it right but still led the people
- 2:38into idolatry, he was still considered a false prophet, and under the Old
- 2:44Covenant he was to be he was to be killed. Are New Testament prophets
- 2:49judged by that same standard. Well, those in the modern day prophetic movement
- 2:54would say no. They would say that a true prophet can still prophesy falsely
- 3:02and be considered a genuine prophet. They can also get it partially right and
- 3:08still be considered a true profit. And so we're gonna do that. We're
- 3:12gonna look at scripture, and we're going to look at church history, and
- 3:15I think you're going to see by the end of this video that, yeah,
- 3:19New Testament profits. Profits in the New Testament were judged by the same
- 3:23standards as the profits in the Old Testament, which means that modern day profits
- 3:28that get it wrong they are false prophets. Now, where did this whole
- 3:31idea come from, because it's certainly not in scripture or is it. Well,
- 3:39there is a book that was written write in the late eighties, I
- 3:45believe nineteen eighty eight that kind of open the floodgates to this, and it's
- 3:50this book right here by doctor Wayne grudem The Gift of Prophecy in the New
- 3:54Testament today. This now, this is an older copy that the new book
- 4:01or the cover of the new book looks different, but that book is what
- 4:06opened the floodgates. Grudham actually wrote two in eighty three or eighty two,
- 4:14actually, I think he wrote this one here at the Gift of Prophecy in
- 4:16First Corinthians, which is the basis for the Gift of Prophecy and the New
- 4:21Testament and today. So we are going to take a look at all of
- 4:27that. We're going to look at a video that Wayne Grudham did with Larry
- 4:32Sparks Larry Sparks Yes of Destiny image. So we're going to look at that
- 4:38video where Wayne Grundham is actually talking about this, and we're going to kind
- 4:45of critique that video. I've also got some other clips to show as well.
- 4:47This is going to be a longer video than what most people are used
- 4:51to because we've got a lot to cover here. Before we get into it,
- 4:57though, I do need to give you an update. Most of you
- 5:01that are in the same Facebook groups that I am a part of know the
- 5:08situation with Robin because I've posted there and I've tried to keep keep everyone updated.
- 5:16But I'm going to do an update now because there are people on YouTube
- 5:19that are not part of those groups and have been asking, Hey, where's
- 5:23Robin, what's going on. Robin has been struggling with illness for the past
- 5:29year or so, and she's been having these infections that this or this this
- 5:33infection that would pop up. She'd take anabiotic for it, an antibiotic for
- 5:41it, she would get better and then she'd be okay for a little while,
- 5:44and then it will pop up again. Well, this last time it
- 5:46put her in the hospital. This last time that the infection came it put
- 5:50her in the hospital for four days. They've got it under control. She
- 5:56is home, she is resting, she is on the mend, and hopefully
- 6:00within the next week or two she'll feel strong enough to maybe be a part
- 6:05of another video with me that would be fantastic. So I want to thank
- 6:12you. Robin wanted me to thank everyone for all of the prayers because she
- 6:16does feel much better. The power of prayer is amazing. We believe that
- 6:23God heals, and so with Robin being on the mend, she just needs
- 6:28to get stronger and you'll see her in the videos again soon. Lord Willing,
- 6:32All right, let's jump into this. If you don't know who doctor
- 6:35Wayne Grudam is, this is from his Wikipedia page. Wayne A. Grudam
- 6:43born nineteen forty eight is a New Testament scholar turned theologian, seminary professor and
- 6:48author. Professor of Theology and Biblical Studies of at Phoenix Seminary, Phoenix,
- 6:55Arizona. Grudam holds to non cessationist beliefs, was at one time a qualified
- 7:00supporter of the Vineyard movement. So we're going to be looking at a video.
- 7:06Before we do that, though, I want to talk about another book
- 7:12that I think will be extremely beneficial to you, and it's called The Gift
- 7:15of Prophecy. Is the Gift of Prophecy for today? Why it is urgent
- 7:21that we understand New Testament prophecy. Now, this is what David Farnell says
- 7:28about Wayne Grudam's influence in the modern charismatic movement and especially the modern prophetic movement.
- 7:36He says, the current practice of the prophetic gift has been emphasized,
- 7:42especially by the Vineyard and Signs of Wonders movements. Grudam's hypothesis has also directly
- 7:48contributed to the present turmoil regarding the nature and function of prophecy. His assertions
- 7:56about the prophetic gift are now being used as a primary justification of the current
- 8:00practice of prophecy in these church movements. Let me tell you a little bit
- 8:05about David Farnell. I did not know who David Farnell was until I started
- 8:11doing the research and I came across mention of his book, bought it,
- 8:16and I'm going to tell you he does a phenomenal job refuting Wayne gruten He
- 8:20does a really good job. So I am going to put the link to
- 8:22that. It's on Amazon, the Kendall version. It's only about five I
- 8:26think it's less than five bucks, which is a really super deal. So
- 8:31anyway, this is from David Farnell's Wikipedia page. F David Farnell born nineteen
- 8:37fifty eight is an American New Testament scholar, Christian minister, and as the
- 8:41new pastor of Theological Training at Redeemer Bible Church in Phoenix, Arizona. He
- 8:46was formerly a professor of New Testament Studies at the Master's Seminary. He promotes
- 8:50a conservative approach to New Testament studies. Farnell's works include the book The Jesus
- 8:56Chrisis, The Inroads of Historical Crews into Evangelical Scholarship, and The Jesus Quest
- 9:03The Danger from Within. His writings on Biblical inerrancy have have been endorsed by
- 9:09John MacArthur, Albert Moehler, Page Patterson. He is also the pastor of
- 9:15Grace Bible Church in Oxnard, California. So let's go ahead and get into
- 9:22this first portion of the video, and you're going to hear a redefinition of
- 9:31New Testament prophecy, because that's what Wayne Grunham does. He literally redefines prophecy.
- 9:37Watch Welcome to the Prophetic Life, Larry Sparks Here just a moment.
- 9:43I'm going to bring on my special guests with about thirty minutes today, So
- 9:46I want this to be a content rich time, but I always like to
- 9:50welcome the folks who are watching, you're watching on Facebook or YouTube, welcome
- 9:54and then of course if you're listening to the Prophetic Life podcast, always a
- 9:58joy to bring this content. I really felt stirred of the Holy Spirit to
- 10:03reach out to doctor Wayne Grudem have him on again. I'm going to bring
- 10:07him on in just a moment, because right now I know in our prophetic
- 10:11spirit and powered charismatic whatever they call us these days, in that world,
- 10:15there is a lot of swirl and there's a lot of controversy right now,
- 10:18and there's a lot of taking sides. Well, the side that I think
- 10:22is most beneficial for us to take, if we're going to take a side,
- 10:26is the side of scripture. And that is where I felt led to
- 10:30go today to insert the scriptural New Covenant testimony that the testimony of Jesus is
- 10:37the spirit of prophecy. All right. So one of the things that you
- 10:43are going to notice as you watch this video is that as Larry Sparks here
- 10:52says he wants to really refer to scripture, they don't really do that.
- 10:56Grudom does mention some Bible passages for Scrinthians fourteen, for Theissalonians five twenty.
- 11:03But he doesn't really base his arguments on scripture very much. What he does
- 11:11is he uses his own examples to show what New Testament prophecy looks like.
- 11:22And again you will see a redefinition of prophecy. Now, I say that
- 11:26in saying this in these two books, this this one here, which is
- 11:31the one of one that was really is the one that opened the floodgates,
- 11:35and then this one here. Now I'm going to open this up so you
- 11:39can see if this is a really old book. But I don't know if
- 11:41you can see that or not, but it is really difficult to read.
- 11:46There is a lot of Greek New Testament Greek in it, and he really
- 11:50does try to, you know, bring his point out in scripture, but
- 11:58it is not convincing. It's not it's really not convincing. And I really
- 12:05believe today we are going to get grounded and what the Word of God has
- 12:07to say about the continuation of the New Covenant, New Testament gift of prophecy.
- 12:13So, without further ado, again, welcoming all of you fine folks
- 12:16coming on. Let us know where you're watching from. But right now I
- 12:20am bringing on my special guest, doctor Wayne Grudam. So, doctor Grudam,
- 12:26thank you so much for joining me today. You're welcome, Larry.
- 12:31It's good to be with you. It is good to be with you.
- 12:33I shared this with you briefly, but I'll share it with the fine folks
- 12:35who are watching or listening. One of my first dates with my wife,
- 12:39this is how I got introduced to doctor Wayne Grudham. Very interesting but well
- 12:43over ten years ago. She printed out some material from his classic book,
- 12:48which I'm sure many of you are familiar with, Systematic Theology about election predestination.
- 12:54My wife came from a PCA Presbyterian background. She gave it to me
- 12:56and said, read this. I read it. But what I didn't tell
- 13:01you, doctor Grudem. I started reading through the rest of Systematic Theology,
- 13:05saw some commentaries that you had about John Wimber, and then obviously got your
- 13:09perspective on the gifts in the continuation of the gifts of the Spirit. And
- 13:15here's what I said. I said, Praise God, it's possible to be
- 13:18reformed and charismatic simultaneously. Absolutely so I speak on behalf of many who I
- 13:26know are watching and listening. Systematic Theology has been a game changer we are
- 13:31so grateful for that book. So thank you for that. Thank you,
- 13:33Larry, thank the Lord for enabling me to write it. Oh yes,
- 13:37it's and folks, I know I'm talking about a different book today. If
- 13:41you don't have systematic theology, I recommend it is a staple for every Christian
- 13:46bookshelf, not just a bookshelf to actually read it, all right, diving
- 13:50on in to the New Testament, New Covenant, Gift of prophecy people are
- 13:56familiar with, obviously systematic theology. I actually, doctor grud got a copy
- 14:01of this book. Interestingly enough, at an International House of Prayer one thing
- 14:05conference, Mike Bickl was putting on this book. Oh yes, and I
- 14:11know they are extremely celebratory of you. I got a copy of this book.
- 14:16And yeah, so that video is about three years old, that's well
- 14:20before all of the news about Mike Bickel and his sexual perversions were brought out
- 14:26into the open. But we still have to ask this question, and that's
- 14:30this, why should we believe these guys? Why should we trust these charismatic
- 14:37leaders? Look at their level of discernment. Look who they run with.
- 14:41I mean guys like Wayne Grudem and Sam Storms and the Remnant Radio guys.
- 14:48These are all smart men, and they are promoting people like Mike Bickel.
- 14:54They're promoting people like Heidie Baker. The Remnant Radio guys had Heidie Baker,
- 14:58and they've had Isaiah Saldibar, and they've had other Todd White and others.
- 15:05They've tried to defend. Why should we believe these guys. They've had proven
- 15:09false prophets on their shows, not just the Remnant Radio guys, but any
- 15:15of these guys. No, they don't have a very high level of discernment
- 15:18at all, so we should not believe anything that they say. And I
- 15:24have been indulging it ever since. So I wanted to dive in and talk
- 15:30about some of this. First question to you, what what what does the
- 15:35New Covenant, New Testament gift of prophecy? How does it operate and how
- 15:39does it function? Is it for today? I believe it is for today,
- 15:43Larry, And that's what I wrote that book about. I understand prophecy
- 15:48in the New Testament to be different from the Old Testament, profits where they
- 15:52would proclaim thus says the Lord, and they would speak or write words that
- 15:58were it had authority of scripture. And would be recorded in scripture often.
- 16:03But in the New Testament age after Pentecost, Acts two tells us that sons
- 16:08and daughters will prophesy, old men will dream dreams of young men will see
- 16:12visions, and God will pour out his spirit on all flesh or all people.
- 16:18And so the gift of prophecy is more much more widely distributed in the
- 16:22New Testament age than it was in the Old Covenant or Old Testament. I
- 16:27understand prophecy in the New Testament to be reporting something that God brings to mind,
- 16:34reporting something that God spontaneously brings to mind. Now that isn't That isn't
- 16:42to say that it comes with the authority of scripture, because we're still to
- 16:47be subject to the written words of scripture. But it is to say that
- 16:49God can reveal things to us. Paul says in one Corinthians fourteen, if
- 16:55a revelation is made to another sitting by, let the first be silent,
- 17:00So people would take turns in the church service, or a group of Christians
- 17:04assembled, and one would be giving a prophecy, and then another could give
- 17:08a prophecy. And also has let two or three prophets speak, and the
- 17:15others way what is said, or evaluate what is said. That means that
- 17:19even with their gifts of prophecy, people can make mistakes. So there you
- 17:25have it. Modern day prophets can actually get it wrong. According to wayn
- 17:29Grudem. He uses First Corinthians fourteen twenty eight through thirty three for his argument
- 17:34there. But we'll get to that in a minute. We'll also get to
- 17:41his reading redefinition of prophecy in a minute, But first I want to show
- 17:45you just how far this idea has permeated the charismatic movement. Watch this clip
- 17:52from Remnant Radio. You now, even cessationists should believe that that like God's
- 17:56going to use a preacher or teacher of the Bible to communicate to them.
- 18:00And they'll say, yeah, but it's it's the message of God. But
- 18:03they're not just getting up there and reading the Bible. They're actually exactly the
- 18:07Bible. And God's going to use their gift of teaching to communicate the perfect
- 18:11revelation of God. So God uses the imperfect messenger who might even say a
- 18:18few things imperfectly and almost certainly will, but but he's communicating the written revelation.
- 18:25Well we how much more should we expect it. If somebody's communicating the
- 18:30say, spontaneous revelation of the spirit, like they might get a few things
- 18:33wrong, that doesn't make them a false prophet, just like it doesn't make
- 18:38somebody a false teacher just because they missed a little bit. Like now,
- 18:44if they teach you don't follow Yahweh, don't follow Jesus, that makes them
- 18:48a false teacher. But if they, you know, change their position on
- 18:51Sabbath keeping or you know, something like that, that doesn't mean like,
- 18:53man, you are a false teacher. Now you're a true teacher. Yeah,
- 18:56there's there's a huge difference. There's a huge difference there. First of
- 19:00all, let's talk about pastors for just a second. Because the Bible gives
- 19:04specific qualifications for a pastor. It does not give qualifications for a prophet.
- 19:10It gives qualifications for a pastor, for an elder and a deacon. That
- 19:15pastor needs to know his biblical theology. I did a video with Chris Roseboro.
- 19:22We discussed that it is important for a pastor to be theologically sound.
- 19:26It is important for a pastor to know the original languages Hebrew, Aramaic,
- 19:30and Greek so that he can exegete scripture properly and deliver God's word. God's
- 19:37already final written prophetic word called the scriptures. He can expound that to his
- 19:47people properly, so he needs to know the original languages. And even then
- 19:52he's going to make some mistake because we do have We are sinners, and
- 19:57that's just how we are. But there's a big difference because a false prophecy
- 20:03comes with a warning in scripture. False prophecy incurs the wrath of God.
- 20:10So there is a big difference in a pastor getting something not quite right from
- 20:17the pulpit, then a prophet saying, thus saith the Lord, and then
- 20:22getting that prophecy wrong. There's a warning for that in scripture. All right,
- 20:26let's talk about Wayne Grudam's redefinition of prophecy there, because you heard the
- 20:32remnant guy say something about the Holy Spirit spontaneously bringing something to mind, and
- 20:38that's Grudam's whole definition of prophecy. This is what Grudam's book says about prophecy.
- 20:48Grudham says, although several definitions have been given for the gift of prophecy,
- 20:52a fresh examination of the New Testament teaching on this gift shows that it
- 20:59should be define not as predicting the future, nor as proclaiming a word from
- 21:06the Lord, nor as a powerful preaching, but rather as telling something that
- 21:11God has spontaneously brought to mind. That is not prophecy, that is not
- 21:19New Testament prophecy. So let's talk about New Testament prophecy for a minute.
- 21:25Because New Testament prophets and the apostles gave revelatory, doctrinal information and guidance to
- 21:36the church. New Testament prophets were the found part of the foundation of the
- 21:42church. Let's listen, or let's uh. Look at Ephesians three, verses
- 21:48four through six. This is what Paul says about New Testament prophets. Look
- 21:53at what he says here. When you read this, you can perceive my
- 21:57insight into the mystery of Christ which was not made known to the sons of
- 22:02men and other generations, as it has been now revealed to His Holy apostles
- 22:07and prophets by the Spirit. This mystery is that the gentiles are fellow heirs,
- 22:14members of the same body, and partakers of the promising Christ Jesus through
- 22:18the Gospel. The mystery by the way that Paul speaks about in many of
- 22:22his letters, including First Corinthians. Is the Gospel, the mystery that the
- 22:27gentiles are fellow heirs with the Gospel. And keep that in mind, because
- 22:32that's a very important thing. That is what the prophets were doing. Prophets
- 22:36were proclaiming that mystery. Yes, there was foretelling in with New Testament prophets.
- 22:44You can look at Agabis for example. And we'll discuss Agabis shortly,
- 22:49but you can look at Agabis for example. So there is you know,
- 22:56foretelling among the prophets in the New Testament. But Paul says here that God's
- 23:06God had made known his revelation for a purpose, right. That purpose is
- 23:11to spread the good news of this revelation, this mystery that the gentiles are
- 23:17included in the Gospel. I ask good news, right. And so this
- 23:23is why the prophets are side by side with the apostles, because they were
- 23:30proclaiming that revelation as well. Listen to what Paul says in Ephesians two nineteen
- 23:36and twenty one. So then you are no longer strangers and aliens, but
- 23:41you are fellow citizens with the saints and members of the household of God built
- 23:45on the foundation of the apostles and prophets, Christ Jesus himself being the cornerstone,
- 23:52and whom the whole structure, being joined together, grows into a holy
- 23:56temple in the Lord. Two things to notice here. First of all,
- 24:00notice that the foundation only has apostles and prophets, not teachers, not pastors,
- 24:07not anyone else with the other gifts. And also in Ephesians three through
- 24:11three, four through six, it says that God revealed the mystery of Christ
- 24:17to his holy apostles and prophets. He doesn't add teachers, He doesn't add
- 24:25evangelists or any other person with any other gift in that in that passage.
- 24:32No, it's the apostles and prophets that were the foundation of the church.
- 24:38So here is Ephesians four eleven through fourteen. And he gave the apostles the
- 24:45prophets. Now he mentions the rest the evangelists, the shepherds, and teachers,
- 24:49to equip the saints for the work of ministry, for building up the
- 24:52body of Christ, until we all attain to the unity of the faith and
- 24:56of the knowledge of the Son of God. Too mature manhood to the measure
- 25:00of the statue of the fullness of Christ, so that we may no longer
- 25:03be children tossed to and fro by the waves, and carried about by every
- 25:07wind of doctrine, by human cunning, by craftiness in deceitful scheme. So
- 25:12what is the purpose of a prophet to teach doctrine to keep the church people
- 25:23in the church from falling for every wind of doctrine. So the apostles and
- 25:30the prophets were the first mentioned in that list. They were the first two,
- 25:36and then came the evangelists, then the shepherds, and then the teachers,
- 25:38and all of them are for the purpose of equipping the saints for the
- 25:44work of ministry. So the New Testament prophets had a specific function in the
- 25:52New Testament Church, and that primary function was to give revelatory, doctrinal information
- 25:59and guidance to the church. Yes, there was foretelling. Again we have
- 26:04the example of Agabus, but a big and I would say a major part
- 26:11of the prophet's job was to reveal the mystery of Christ, that the gentiles
- 26:18are included in the Gospel, and the spreading of the Gospel and the teaching
- 26:23of doctrine. That was one of the I think probably the major role of
- 26:30the prophet. They can have They can receive some information from the Lord and
- 26:40supplement it with their own understanding. First Thessalonians five nineteen to twenty two,
- 26:45nineteen to twenty one, twenty two, do not quench the spirit, do
- 26:48not despise prophecies, but test everything, hold fast to what is good.
- 26:52When Paul says do not despise prophecies, but test everything, he is buying
- 27:00that some prophecies are incorrect in the New Testament age, and we have to
- 27:04test them, evaluate them to see whether they're really from the Lord or not.
- 27:11All right, let's uh, let's take a look at first Thessalonians five
- 27:14nineteen through twenty two. Now, keep in mind what when Gridam says this
- 27:19passage is talking about. He is saying that because Paul says do not despise
- 27:25prophecies, but test everything, that that means that some people can be wrong.
- 27:33But that's not what this text says at all. And if you look
- 27:36at this text in context, there are a bunch of different commands that Paul
- 27:41gives for Christians to do. So this is kind of in a list setting,
- 27:48but there's nothing in there that says that when Paul's talking about test everything.
- 27:53He's not talking about profits sitting in the congregation and saying something, and
- 28:00then the whole congresason, wait, wait, wait, let's just see,
- 28:03let's test this. Let's see if this is right. That's not what this
- 28:07passage is talking about at all. Let's look at first Thessalonians. Just the
- 28:11three verses there, first Thesessalonians five nineteen through twenty two, which says,
- 28:15do not quench the spirit, do not despise prophecies, but test everything,
- 28:19hold fast to what is good, abstain from every form of evil. You
- 28:26can't take an unclear text like that and build a doctrine on that, and
- 28:32you can't use one other text. And Paul use or not, Paul Wayne
- 28:37Wayne grudem uses One Corinthians fourteen twenty nine through thirty three to kind of go
- 28:44along with First Thessalonians five. This is what One Corinthians fourteen twenty nine through
- 28:48thirty three says. Let two or three prophets speak, and let the others
- 28:53weigh what is said. If a revelation is made to another sitting there,
- 28:57let the first be silent, for you can all prophesy one by one,
- 29:00so that all may learn and all be encouraged in the spirits of the prophets.
- 29:06Are subject to the prophets or to prophets. For God is not a
- 29:10god of confusion, but of peace. What's happening in the Corinthian Church.
- 29:14We have to take the entire thing in its context, and we have to
- 29:17understand what's going on in Corinth. Corinth was a really messed up church.
- 29:22There were people that were having There were divisions, first of all, among
- 29:29one another. There were some people that were following Paul, some were following
- 29:32a Poulus, some are following Peter. The real spiritual ones were following Christ.
- 29:36They were getting drunk at the Lord's Supper. There was sexual immorality that
- 29:40had run rampant in the church. There was all kinds of issues, and
- 29:45a major issue was how they the Corinthians were using the gifts. They were
- 29:52elevating gifts like tongues, which wasn't nearly as important unless one had an interpret
- 29:59interpreter present. It wasn't nearly as important as prophecy. And that's why Paul
- 30:03says, I wish you all would prophesy because there was disorder, first of
- 30:10all, chaos that was going on in the meeting. And that's why Paul
- 30:12says, you know, if if you know people are speak, if everybody
- 30:18speaking in a tongue and an outsider comes in and he sees all this,
- 30:22he wants to think you're crazy. But yet he says, if prophecy's going
- 30:29on and an outsider walks in, he's going to say, wow, God
- 30:32is really among you. So there was a lot of confusion about spiritual gifts.
- 30:37There was chaos going on in the meetings. And so Paul is this
- 30:41is a corrective letter. This isn't an instructional letter to us to say,
- 30:47Okay, I mean, it does give us instructions of how the gifts are
- 30:51to operate, but it's not primarily for the Corinthians. Paul laying out,
- 30:59okay, this is how tongues work, this is how prophecy work. He's
- 31:03correcting them, he's answering their questions, he's showing them how a proper meeting,
- 31:10a proper church meeting, should be. So when Paul says, here,
- 31:15let two or three prophets speak and let the others, way would have
- 31:17said he's talking about the other prophets. Grudam is saying that others in the
- 31:22church need to way would have said, to sift out the bad from the
- 31:25goods, so to speak. Paul's talking about the other prophets, and I
- 31:30would say, those who have the gift the one who that would be those
- 31:33who would have the gift of discerning spirits, discerning a true discerning whether it
- 31:41is a true word from the Holy Spirit, or whether it is something else,
- 31:47something other, something demonic. Possibly. Let's go back to first Thessalonians
- 31:52for a minute, and I want you to see what certain commentaries say about
- 31:56this passage. I'm going to start with John Calvin. This is what Calvin
- 32:00says by the term prophecy. However, I do not understand the gift of
- 32:07foretelling the future. But look at this as in one Corinthians fourteen three,
- 32:13the science of interpreting scriptures, so that a prophet is an interpreter of the
- 32:19will of God. So Calvin basically says that what's going on and onet Thessalonians
- 32:24five nineteen through twenty two when Paul says, do not despise prophecies, but
- 32:31test everything. He's talking about the prophet expounding doctrine, and he's saying,
- 32:37that's the same thing that's going on in One Corinthians fourteen, when the prophets
- 32:43are speaking and the others are evaluating. The other prophets are evaluating what is
- 32:47said about that doctrine. That is what Calvin says. But I got a
- 32:52few more commentaries here. This is R. H. Lensky, This is
- 32:55what This is his commentary Saint Paul's Epistles to the Colossians to the Thessalonians.
- 33:04Lensky was a confessional Lutheran. This is what he says. Because prophecies are
- 33:09mentioned, some commentators regard this as a reference to the extraordinary charismata. They
- 33:16overlook the fact and I've got some of this text off screen, Sorry about
- 33:20that. They overlook the fact that two gifts of prophecy are clearly distinguished in
- 33:24the Apostolic Church. One was the reception of immediate revelation, the other the
- 33:31acquisition of mediate revelation and the ability to transmit this re acquired revelation to others.
- 33:39Sylvanus and Timothy prophesied by transmitting revelation that had already been given in the
- 33:44word Old Testament and in the Apostolic teaching. And One Corinthians fourteen, all
- 33:50the Corinthians are urged to seek this gift and ability. In Romas twelve seven,
- 33:54this kind of prophecy stands at the head of the list, none of
- 33:59which which are miraculous. So Lensky there is basically saying the same thing.
- 34:06There is another commentary I want us to look at, and this is from
- 34:10the Lutheran commentary series, and this is what that commentator says. The rich
- 34:15use which the early Church, many of whose members had been recently won from
- 34:21Heathenism, made of the Old Testament scriptures, and the skill with which they
- 34:25interpreted them of Christ leads to the conclusion that many of the prophets were inspired
- 34:34to expound these scriptures and apply them. So Erasmus says on this passage,
- 34:38prophecy is the declaration of the secret, hidden meaning of the scriptures. Doubtless,
- 34:44the enthusiastic addresses of the prophets had had a part in begetting the unrest
- 34:51and expectation which had been reported to Paul, in which he had already rebuked
- 34:59in four eleven. Notwithstanding, he does not give his sanction to a contempt
- 35:05for this extraordinary instruction. So again, expounding scriptures. And then this is
- 35:08Leon Morris from the Tendell New Testament commentary series. Morris was an Anglican.
- 35:15The New Testament clearly regards the prophets as important. They are classed with apostles
- 35:19Ephesians two twenty and three five and more formally ranked second to them in One
- 35:23Corinthians twelve twenty eight. If hegis four eleven, prophecy is the gift of
- 35:28God. One Corinthians twelve twenty eight I Phis four eleven. Commentators regularly point
- 35:34out that prophets were fourth tellers rather than four tellers. Their characteristic function seems
- 35:40to have been exhortation Acts fifteen thirty two discussions than that is a discussion on
- 35:47the section of that commentary. Essentially, the prophet was someone who could say,
- 35:53thus saith the Lord. But it should not be overlooked that this might
- 35:58and sometimes did involve for telling the future. And he's mentioning Acts eleven twenty
- 36:02seven there in twenty eight, which is agabus. So we see even from
- 36:08popular commentators that the prophets were more than just foretellers. More than just telling
- 36:17the future, they were proclaiming the Old Testament scriptures, and they were also
- 36:22proclaiming New Testament revelation from the apostles, and they were bringing that to the
- 36:29forefront with the apostles in the New Testament church. So I just wanted to
- 36:35give you that information. Let's carry on with a video. So anyway,
- 36:37I recap that and say, prophecy, I think in the New Testament is
- 36:44reporting something that God suddenly brings to mind. I think that's wonderful. Let
- 36:50me ask you this question before we dive in, because one of the things
- 36:53I really want to talk about today, and it might be something that you
- 36:57and I just grapple with and talk through, is what what does it look
- 37:00like in the twenty first century to judge or test prophecy based on what we
- 37:05see in One Corinthians fourteen. We're going to go there in a minute.
- 37:08But one of the things we often get accused of, and you briefly mentioned
- 37:13this, and I'm glad you did, is in a charismatic or continuationist perspective,
- 37:19people are a bit weary about prophecy because they're thinking we are trying to
- 37:22add to the closed canon of scripture. But prophecy an Old Testament Old Covenant,
- 37:29New Testament New Covenant is very different because, as you said, nobody
- 37:32and well we let's just say it this way. We should not be claiming
- 37:37that New Covenant or New Testament prophecy is adding to the canon of scripture.
- 37:40It is nobody's writing anything. So what you had to answer that question,
- 37:45like, what is the difference between Old Covenant prophetic ministry and New Covenant prophetic
- 37:52ministry? How would you just kind of give a summary of that? All
- 37:55right? So that's not what we're saying. We're not saying that that at
- 38:01least I'm not saying that the modern day prophets are trying to add to scripture.
- 38:08What I and others have said and are saying is that if God is
- 38:15speaking directly to a person, then that person is hearing the voice of God
- 38:27Almighty, and God Almighty's voice is authoritative, and it is as authoritative as
- 38:34scripture. I want you to think for a moment about Jesus calling the book.
- 38:38All right, I would be willing to bet dollars of doughnuts that Larry
- 38:45Sparks and those at Destiny Image and others would have no problem with the book
- 38:51Jesus calling and would actually promote it. How many of you like devotionals?
- 38:55Well, number one, how many of you like to read devotionals. I'm
- 38:58curious to know how many folks out there really enjoy when a book takes some
- 39:01of these principles and breaks it down the more bite sized pieces. I mean,
- 39:06truth be told Jesus always, Jesus calling has done that phenomenally. And
- 39:09yet Sarah Young supposedly heard the voice of Jesus and she's writing down what she
- 39:15hears. If that is the voice of Jesus, then you better believe that
- 39:20it is as authoritative of scripture. Every time God speaks, it's as authoritative
- 39:27as scripture. Well, in the Old Covenant of the Old Testament, the
- 39:32prophets proclaimed, thus says the Lord. And then they wrote or spoke words
- 39:39of words of God which people had to obey. And if they were disobeying
- 39:45the words of the prophet, they were disobeying God himself. Well that's a
- 39:47very serious thing. But in the New Testament, the people who are able
- 39:53to write words of scripture, like Isaiah, Jeremiah, Ezekiel, and the
- 39:59Old test the people who are able to write words of scripture are not called
- 40:04prophets. They're called apostles. All an apostle of Jesus Christ, Peter an
- 40:08apostle. And I think that's because the gift of prophecy was distributed very widely,
- 40:15not just to people who could write scripture, but to Christians generally as
- 40:21a means of showing that God is present and directing the thoughts and prayers and
- 40:28interests of the people immediately involved. So that's why prophecy needs to be evaluated
- 40:37or tested in the New Testament age. I'll give you an example. My
- 40:42wife and I were at a per meeting one time several years ago, and
- 40:46another man at the meeting, after the prayer time had gone on for some
- 40:51time, he got out a piece of paper from his pocket and began to
- 40:54read this is what the Lord showed me, And he said, you're evil
- 40:59with could be pull your plans for moving forward in this church project our evil
- 41:02and I'm not going to bless it. And it just the tone of it
- 41:06just seemed harsh, and it didn't feel like the Holy Spirit, the Holy
- 41:12Spirit's presence was functioning in that prophetic word, that angry word. And I
- 41:19turned to my wife, Margaret and said that do you think that was from
- 41:22the Spirit? That was from the Lord? She went and with both of
- 41:29us in agreement, I just interrupted. I said, thank you, Bill,
- 41:31but I don't think that was from the Lord, and he got mad
- 41:36at me. But after the her time was over, our pastor came up
- 41:39and supported me, so I was happy for that, all right. So,
- 41:45as I said, he gives examples to back up his claims about prophecy
- 41:52and how prophecy functions, which is kind of weird. So that's how he
- 42:00determines whether a word is from God or not. Guy gets up in his
- 42:05congregation. He's kind of angry about what's going on in the church. He's
- 42:07prophesying, saying that people are evil there and that you know, God,
- 42:12that this is not what the way God wants this church to go. And
- 42:16what does Grudom do. He bends over to his wife and he whispers to
- 42:21her and he says, do you think this is from the Lord? And
- 42:22she says no, and he says, I'm sorry, we don't think this
- 42:25is from the Lord. And then his pastor you know, later on,
- 42:30agrees with him. And that is how you judge whether something is from the
- 42:35Lord or not. Well, I would say, no, that wasn't from
- 42:37the Lord what that guy says. But I would also say that if that's
- 42:40how you judge prophecy a prophetic word, man, that's kind of that's kind
- 42:50of weak. So that brings us now to the apostles. He also mentioned
- 42:54the apostles there in the beginning of that clip and in his books. In
- 43:00both of his books, he claims that the New Testament prophets are not held
- 43:07to the same standard, as I said, as the Old Testament prophets,
- 43:10but the apostles are. The apostles themselves are held to the same standard as
- 43:17the Old Testament prophets, because the apostles heard directly from God. The apostles
- 43:23gave new information that they were, they received by direct revelation to the church.
- 43:31The apostles wrote scripture, so all of that coincides with the Old Testament
- 43:37prophets. So he would say that only the apostles, the apostles, and
- 43:42the apostles only are held to the same standard as the Old Testament prophet and
- 43:47profits. And he uses a grammatical rule in you know, within the Greek
- 43:55New Testament to back his claim up in his first book, The Gift of
- 44:02Prophecy in First Corinthians, to make his argument. And what he does is,
- 44:08you remember the passage that we read In Ephesians Chapter two, where the
- 44:13apostle Paul says that the church is built upon the foundation of the apostles and
- 44:21prophets, he basically says that because of that grammatical construction, that the apostles
- 44:30and prophets are not two groups of people, but only one group, the
- 44:35apostle prophets. And he says, because the apostles prophesied that is that is
- 44:42what Paul's referring to. It could be translated, he says, apostle prophets
- 44:47or the apostles who are profits. That's another way he says, it could
- 44:52be translated. But this book that I was telling you about by David Farnell,
- 44:59really talks about it deals with that issue and it goes to show that
- 45:04an error. He says that the problem with Wayne Grudham's view in using that
- 45:08grammatical construction is that the two nouns in that construction have to be singular and
- 45:15not plural. So it if it's said apostle profit, maybe, but when
- 45:22the nouns are plural, that construction doesn't apply. And far Nell SA's many
- 45:30theologians and scholars overlook that point. But anyway, I digress. The point
- 45:37is is that the apostles. That Grudham makes about the apostles is that they
- 45:43are the only ones in scripture that are held to the same standard as the
- 45:50profits in the Old Testament. They're the only ones. So that's what Grudam
- 45:54was talking about there with apostles. And again we don't New Testament prophecy.
- 46:02If somebody gives a word from God, asking your wife and your pastor whether
- 46:07that was from God is not the way you should test whether or not something
- 46:13is coming from God. Well, one of the things that's so important,
- 46:15doctor Grudem is I love the context you put this in. For New Covenant
- 46:21New Testament prophecy, it's very different in the sense that Old Covenant prophets literally
- 46:27number one, they were the ones who were responsible for revealing and speaking the
- 46:32word of God and representing the nature of God to those people. It wasn't
- 46:37like the Holy Spirit was shed abroad on all people like we are living in
- 46:42that age now. But furthermore, going to this idea New Covenant New Testament
- 46:49prophets, I get concerned when a New Covenant or New Testament prophet almost tries
- 46:54to set themselves up as infallible or as somebody who's getting these direct words or
- 47:00direct revelations from God. What you shared was so invaluable. I wrote this
- 47:05down again. The book is gift of prophecy, human word. You described
- 47:08it this way, and I love it, human words that God brings to
- 47:13mind. Can you elaborate on it, because sometimes I think we make the
- 47:17mistake of trying to make New Covenant or New Testament prophecy more divinely inspired maybe
- 47:23than it is. Although Holy Spirit does inspire it, so more divinely inspired
- 47:28than it is. Although Holy Spirit does inspire it. If Holy Spirit inspires
- 47:36it, then it is divine revelation, direct revelation. It is inspired if
- 47:45Holy Spirit inspires it. By the way, just as a side note,
- 47:47I just it drives me insane. It's like running fingers fingernails down to chalkboard.
- 47:53When I hear the charismatic people say Holy Spirit instead of the Holy Spirit.
- 47:59For one thing, it reminds me of the Jehovah's witnesses, because that's
- 48:02what Jehovah's witnesses do. If you look in their translation, they don't put
- 48:07the article in front of the Holy Spirit. They just say, and you
- 48:10will be baptized with Holy Spirit and fire because they believe that the Holy Spirit
- 48:15is God's in God's impersonal active force in the world today. That's just a
- 48:22side note, just irritates me. But if yeah, if God is speaking
- 48:30as I said before, why is it not as authoritative as when the apostles
- 48:38heard it or when the Old Testament prophets heard it. If it's God,
- 48:42it's God. So how does that all work out? Because that is a
- 48:46place I think where a lot of people are getting concerned right now, where
- 48:50certain prophets or prophetic people are trying to set themselves up as infallible, and
- 48:55obviously we are all fallible, right, That's a common mistake that people have
- 49:00made in the history of the church. I think the gift of prophecy is
- 49:04genuine and it functions today. In fact, in many churches where it isn't
- 49:07called the gift of prophecy, there are people who have a sense of God's
- 49:12leading or what God is prompting or encouraging them to do in an individual basis
- 49:19or maybe in a church basis, and they're widely respected for their instinct or
- 49:23what is called their gut sense of what is going on. And it's really
- 49:29that God is bringing things to mind and showing things to them, and they're
- 49:32just not aware that it is God revealing things that would function as the gift
- 49:38of prophecy if they would just speak it in the context of other Christians being
- 49:44present. But again to warn against people who at last too much take to
- 49:50themselves too much authority, I go and go back to first Thessalonians five and
- 49:54nineteen, following where Paul says, do not despise prophecies. Test everything,
- 50:00hold fast to what is good, and that means we need to test and
- 50:05evaluate when someone claims to be speaking for the Lord. I tell you,
- 50:09Larry, if you want to get a bunch of letters on people telling you
- 50:14things that think the Lord is brought to them, publish a book on the
- 50:16gift of prophecy and the letters will come. Which is fine. I mean,
- 50:22people have their own ideas, but I think there's always a problem if
- 50:28people begin to think these should be equal to scripture and authority. They can
- 50:34be wrong, they can be mistakes, and I should I should say in
- 50:42general, we were talking about Old Testament prophets, the writing prophets like Isaiah,
- 50:45Jeremiah, Ezekiel and the others. But there were these bands of prophets
- 50:52prophesying in the time of Samuel and Saul and Elijah, and I think they
- 51:02may have been doing something like the New Testament gift to prophecy. We don't
- 51:07have those words of the bands of prophets recorded in scripture, and so there
- 51:13may be more diversity in the Old Testament than we imagine. I don't know
- 51:17any responsible leader in the charismatic or Pentecostal movements today would say that modern day
- 51:23prophecies are equal to scripture, not one again, why not. It's because
- 51:30of Wayne Grudham's redefinition of prophecy. But even still he's going to say.
- 51:37You'll hear him say in the end that we should qualify. Instead of saying,
- 51:45thus saith the Lord, we should say things like I think God may
- 51:47be saying this, but you're still you're still putting yourself in danger because you
- 51:54are attributing what you're getting ready to communicate to somebody that you think it's from
- 52:00the Lord, because if it's not from the Lord, look, I would
- 52:06so much rather just not say anything, or just say hey, I got
- 52:08some advice I want to give you or whatever, then say hey, I
- 52:14think God wants me to tell you something, but you don't listen. Here's
- 52:16something else too. Wayne Crudem is talking about how you know, how careful
- 52:23you should be. Are the modern day profits careful? Is Chuck Piers careful?
- 52:29Does he do the people in Chuck Pierce's church way? What's being said?
- 52:32Do you see? And now, I'm sure there are churches out there
- 52:36that practice the charismatic gifts that are far more careful than what we see on
- 52:39YouTube and other places and social media. But those on YouTube and other social
- 52:45media platforms, they're still the ones that are the most popular. And you
- 52:52you have a prophets or a dime a dozen, just type in prophecy and
- 52:54YouTube and you've got you've got some some woman they're coming on YouTube given a
- 53:01prophetic word from the Lord. Have you ever played prophecy being going? Watched
- 53:07Kane Ash? I mean, she writes the stuff down. So are the
- 53:13prophets careful? Are people actually sifting through? You know? You have Wayne
- 53:19Grudam say that that's what should be going on, but they don't even do
- 53:22that. I've looked fairly thoroughly, and in a lot of the literature,
- 53:30they're all eager to be faithful to what the Bible says tests everything old fast
- 53:35to what is good. Amen. No, I think that's I think that's
- 53:39very true. I'm thinking as well of those bands of the prophets or schools
- 53:44of the prophets in the Old Covenant, Old Testament era, where there would
- 53:47be kind of this ecstatic prophecy that would come upon them. And it is
- 53:52interesting to compare that to what we see in One Corinthians fourteen. Is this
- 53:57prophetic community, as it were, where people are all sharing one by one
- 54:01decently in an order words that Holy Spirit is bringing to mind. So let
- 54:07me ask this, because goodness, we could do a huge Q and A
- 54:12on the gift of prophecy, and I think we could have many many questions,
- 54:16but I do want to kind of finish up the latter part of our
- 54:21discussion with this, and again for anybody who wants the full enchilada, like
- 54:24all of the material the gift of prophecy. Not only doctor Gruam is the
- 54:29book excellent, but I mean in the back you have all of the I
- 54:31mean you have multiple appendices, I mean covering why Christians can still prophesy.
- 54:39You have what our word of wisdom and word of knowledge. So this is
- 54:45to me and mandatory reading for all people who are involved in the prophetic community.
- 54:51My last question is this, and we can kind of take this where
- 54:54we'd like to in the twenty first century where we are right now obviously we
- 54:59are, or maybe a little bit of a different context that Paul was writing
- 55:01to in One Corinthians fourteen. We have social media, We've got television,
- 55:07we've got video, and people are utilizing those to share or release prophetic words.
- 55:13And I'm not looking necessarily for a definitive answer or revelation on this,
- 55:17but help us, doctor Grum, like, how would you encourage the Body
- 55:23of Christ to judge or test prophecy in the twenty first century as it is
- 55:30being released through all this different media? You know, Larry, I would
- 55:36say, first, we have to be subject to scripture. And if someone
- 55:40prophesies and says Jesus is coming back next Friday, when the Bible says Jesus
- 55:47himself said, you know, neither of the day nor the hour, then
- 55:52we just say it's wrong, it's contrary to scripture. And on the positive
- 55:58side, give an example. I had a former student who had become a
- 56:07pastor of a major church in Africa. I won't mention the city, and
- 56:10he was back in the United States visiting. I brought him to my church
- 56:14that we were attending at the time and introduced him to the pastor. And
- 56:17the pastor, who had prophetic gifts would function from time to time, said
- 56:23to this man the minute he met him, he said, or after a
- 56:27minute or two, he said, I'm going out on a limb here,
- 56:30but I think the Lord wants you to take more leadership in the church that
- 56:32you, pastor. And the African pastor stood there stunned with tears coming down
- 56:39his cheek because another Christian leader had said that to him just before he left
- 56:44his home city, and he'd been convicted of it of himself in times of
- 56:51prayer with the Lord. And now here's a complete stranger out of the blue
- 56:52saying you need to take more leadership in your church that's been entrusted to you.
- 57:00He knew in his heart, a sense in his spirit that this was
- 57:02from the Lord, and it was a confirmation of some other things that the
- 57:06Lord had been showing to him and directing him in. And that's a good
- 57:09example of a prophetic word that really helped helped this man in his ministry.
- 57:16And his leadership. Larry, I've forgotten the question. Is it testing now
- 57:24grew to mention scripture like I said in this video, but he's using examples,
- 57:29personal examples to back up his claims. Now we need to talk about
- 57:34why there was a need for critical evaluation of New Testament profits. Because it
- 57:42was critical that New Testament profits were evaluated, which is why we have passages
- 57:51like First John four to one, which says, beloved, do not believe
- 57:54every spirit, but test the spirits to see whether they are from God.
- 57:59For many false prophets have gone out into the world, and that's because of
- 58:04Jesus warning in Matthew twenty four to eleven, and many false prophets will ARide
- 58:07and lead many astray. Now if that was then, how much more now?
- 58:14How much more now? Is it important to evaluate these prophets? And
- 58:17boy, it is so convenient that you know, their evaluation of New Testament
- 58:25prophecy and prophets are so weak for them. It's convenient for them. I
- 58:30want to read to you a quote from David Farnell's book, and this is
- 58:37what it says, with a larger number of genuine profits, the potential for
- 58:44false prophets and prophecies increased. This expanded sphere of prophetic activity increased the need
- 58:51for care in discerning true profits from false profits. The early Church struggled with
- 58:57a growing wave of false prophecy, especially during the latter half of the first
- 59:00century. Many prophets have gone out into the world. We just read that
- 59:06verse in verse John chapter four, verse one. Such false prophesying with its
- 59:10accompanying false profession, would have created confusion and uncertainty in some areas of the
- 59:17church regarding the truths of Christianity. Eventually, this wave of a false prophecy
- 59:22led in the second century AD to the prophetic crisis of Montanism. And we're
- 59:30going to talk about Montanism in just a moment, because boy, in my
- 59:37study of Motanism, and if you look at Motanism and study it, you're
- 59:40going to see so many parallels to the modern charismatic movement. It's just amazing
- 59:45to me. But let's look at the idea of or let's talk about the
- 59:52idea of false prophets and false prophecies. As Farnell said, as this this
- 1:00:02this dangerous wave of false prophets and false prophecies were making its way into the
- 1:00:09church, there needed to be a critical examination and evaluation of New Testament prophets.
- 1:00:20And yes, there was the gift of discerning spirits, but not everyone
- 1:00:22had that gift. So how were they to evaluate Well, all they had
- 1:00:28was the Old Testament scriptures. Now, Grudem makes an argument in his book
- 1:00:36that you know again that the apostles were the only ones that were you know,
- 1:00:40were held to the same standard. And that's because the word prophet was
- 1:00:45so widely used, the Greek word prophet was so widely used in the early
- 1:00:51Church age among non Christians that it would have confused the Christians to call the
- 1:01:00apostles prophets. And that's why Jesus chose another word, and that was apostle,
- 1:01:06and so they you know, that's why only the apostles were held to
- 1:01:09that standard. But you know, if you have a prophet speaking a word
- 1:01:15of God, a word that they said was from God, and you have
- 1:01:17now you have to sift through all that, how would you evaluate it.
- 1:01:22Well, the point is again New Testament prophets were held to the same standard.
- 1:01:28That's how you you have to evaluate it from scripture. And what they
- 1:01:31had then was the Old Testament scriptures. So they would have gone to passages
- 1:01:36like Deuteronomy eighteen, Deuteronomy thirteen that talks about how to know when a prophet
- 1:01:45is a real prophet or a false prophet, when a person who claims to
- 1:01:47be a prophet is a genuine prophet or a false prophet, they would have
- 1:01:52had to go to scripture there, you know, you don't you don't have
- 1:01:58any other means by which you can test the prophets. And that's what John
- 1:02:02meant when he says, do not believe every spirit, but test the spirits.
- 1:02:07We test the spirits with scripture. Let's talk about the Montanist movement,
- 1:02:13the Montanist movement for a moment. This is far now again on the Montanus.
- 1:02:16He's talking about a in this In this quote, he's going to be
- 1:02:21talking about an anonymous writer that Eusebius mentions in the Church Fathers. This is
- 1:02:27what it says. In the case of Eusebius witness anonymous. The Montanists were
- 1:02:30charged with prophesying in an irrational ecstatic state that was contrary to the custom related
- 1:02:37to the tradition and succession of the Church. From the beginning and describing the
- 1:02:43prophetic state of Priscilla and Maximilia they were two prophetesses that Montanus had with him,
- 1:02:52and describing the prophetic state of Priscilla and Maximilia, he said that they
- 1:02:57spoke in a frenzied manner, unsuited and abnormally. Anonymous appealed to the example
- 1:03:02of the Old Testament prophets, whose state of ecstasy did not resemble that of
- 1:03:07the Montanoust excesses. While true profits were rational, the Montanists, by their
- 1:03:14irrational state, demonstrated that they were false prophets. Thus, the Early Church
- 1:03:19used Old Testament profits and prophecy as a model for New Testament profits and prophecy.
- 1:03:27If New Testament profits did not conform to the pattern of Old Testament profits,
- 1:03:30they were to be rejected as false. Here, the understanding of a
- 1:03:34direct continuity between Old Testament and New Testament profits is seen in the Early Church.
- 1:03:40There is so much correlation between the Montanists and the Charismatic movement, so
- 1:03:50many similarities between the Modernist movement and in the modern day charismatic movement. Maximilia
- 1:03:58and Priscilla were too profits that followed that were a part, major part of
- 1:04:03the Montanist movement, and they prophesied some some really wacky things. They both
- 1:04:11Oh, no, I think it was just Priscilla, maybe both of them,
- 1:04:14but I know I believe it was Priscilla left left her family to join
- 1:04:20Montanous, left her husband. Just now, this is what God wants me
- 1:04:26to do, which is the same thing you see in the early Charismatic movement,
- 1:04:30don't you Mariah Woodworth at her he left her children to go do what
- 1:04:35God told her to do. Amy Simple McPherson. McPherson, McPherson left her
- 1:04:42husband. So you see that kind of thing going on. God told me.
- 1:04:46God spoke to me and said, I have a great destiny for you.
- 1:04:51I have a wonderful job for you. And a husband doesn't go along.
- 1:04:56Well, you know that that's because you know he's the He's not,
- 1:05:00you know, in tune with the spirit. And this is what it says
- 1:05:04in the Nicene and post Nicene Fathers. This is Eusebius, but the false
- 1:05:11prophets. But the false prophet falls into an ecstasy in which he is without
- 1:05:15shame or fear. Beginning with purposed ignorance, he passes on as has been
- 1:05:21stated to involuntary madness of soul. They cannot show that one of the old
- 1:05:28that's the Old Testament prophets, or one of the new that's the New Testament
- 1:05:31prophets, has thus carried away, was thus carried away in spirit. Neither
- 1:05:39can they boast of Agabus or Judas or Silas, or the daughters of Philip
- 1:05:43or Ammia in Philadelphia, or Quadratus or any others not belonging to them.
- 1:05:51So it seems pretty clear to me that the New Testament Church looked at how
- 1:05:58an Old Testament prophet was to act and what an Old Testament profit was like
- 1:06:02in order to evaluate a New Testament profit. I think that's just pretty clear.
- 1:06:08That's all right, how do we in the twenty first century, how
- 1:06:13do we judge or test prophecy? And here's what I'm thinking, because again
- 1:06:16what I love in the book is you go pretty systematically through One Corinthians fourteen
- 1:06:23and you talk about congregationally how they would judge and evaluate the different prophetic words.
- 1:06:29So in that context that totally makes sense. Now it's just interesting because
- 1:06:33we've got prophetic words coming at us left and right, and listen, we
- 1:06:38had Destiny image, we publish prophetic books, we publish profit. I'm you
- 1:06:43know, we're very careful to the best of our ability biblically, integrity wise,
- 1:06:47to make sure we're publishing the right people. But people feel a bombardment
- 1:06:51right now of prophecy, of prophetic words. You know, what are some
- 1:06:56ideas in the twenty first century? How can we evaluate judge these like as
- 1:07:00the congregation of God? You know, because Larry Sparks is so careful.
- 1:07:06He's so careful, especially when he has friends like Jennifer Leclair and Hank Koneman
- 1:07:14and these watch my friend Lana Voser back on. Now we're just talking off
- 1:07:19camera. God has told you basically to really use the media space in this
- 1:07:27season really since COVID. Welcome everyone, Larry Sparks here with one of my
- 1:07:31favorite people in the whole wide world, Emma Stark. When it comes to
- 1:07:38what is the Holy Spirit saying not just for twenty twenty four, but the
- 1:07:41times and seasons ahead, I trust Emma. Hey, everyone, I'm here
- 1:07:45with one of my favorite people, Pastor Bill Johnson. Pastor Bill, thank
- 1:07:49you so much for joining me for this broadcast. You're welcome. That's a
- 1:07:54great privle As always, James, before we were talking, as we were
- 1:07:58talking outside in this here, you shared a word at the global prophetic consultation
- 1:08:04on this beginning of the Great Harvest and the God of Suddenly. So do
- 1:08:11you really think that these people are being careful? Oh? God, is
- 1:08:18God speaking to you? Well, let's really be careful. Let's really look
- 1:08:23and see. Let's test this now, other Destiny images making money. Prophecy
- 1:08:30sells, folks, It really does. So No, Larry Sparks is not
- 1:08:34careful. He's not careful at what he's doing. He's actually he's actually very
- 1:08:41careless with who he has on Destiny image. And again, none of the
- 1:08:45prophets are being careful, at least not the ones that we see in social
- 1:08:51media and and YouTube. They're not being careful. They're just throwing out thus
- 1:08:57saith. The Lord's all over the place now, we're just on social media
- 1:09:00and television and all that kind of stuff. Okay, So it is a
- 1:09:04conformitative scripture. And then does it conform to what we know? Is it
- 1:09:12consistent with what we know about our own life and people around us? And
- 1:09:17then there's this sense of is this from the Lord? There's a sort of
- 1:09:25an impression, an inward sense of our spirit testing or evaluating something. It's
- 1:09:30hard to put into words. Exactly because it's a subjective evaluation. But it
- 1:09:35has to do with sensing the tone and the origin of whether this is from
- 1:09:40the Lord or not. It would help tremendously if people with prophetic gifts today
- 1:09:45some of them do this, but if others would do this, if they
- 1:09:47would say, say their word of prophecy and then say but I might be
- 1:09:50wrong, or even with indicating that some in some phrase like I think the
- 1:09:58Lord is bringing this to my I think this, I think the Learn is
- 1:10:00showing me this, And if it's from God, it will bear witness.
- 1:10:03He will bear witness in the other hearer's hearts. And they'll say, yes,
- 1:10:09that is what Guy's showing us, or it seems that this is what
- 1:10:14God is doing. Can't trust your hearts, folks, can't trust it.
- 1:10:17The Bible says in Jeremiah that at seventeen that the heart is deceitful above all
- 1:10:24things and desperately sick, and that still goes for the converted heart as well.
- 1:10:30Otherwise, there would be no reason for Paul to have to write to
- 1:10:32the Corinthians, or to the Galatians or to the Colossians. There would have
- 1:10:36to be John would not have to talk about the protognostics that had infiltrated the
- 1:10:45church during his time and his letter, you wouldn't have Jesus warning about false
- 1:10:51teachers and false prophets to his church. So, yes, the heart can
- 1:10:55be deceived. We can be deceived even though we have a new part.
- 1:10:58Yes, God says, I will remove the heart of stone and I will
- 1:11:04give them a heart of flesh. But that doesn't mean that that heart of
- 1:11:08flesh can't be deceived because we still have a sinful heart. Paul says,
- 1:11:12old wretched man that I am who will rescue me from this body of death.
- 1:11:17So we can still be deceived. Don't trust your heart. So so
- 1:11:23Griudam at least gives scripture the first, you know, the first in his
- 1:11:29list. But then he talks about, well, we got to look inside,
- 1:11:30we gotta we gotta check and see if you know this, this could
- 1:11:35be from the Lord. You don't. How do you know your heart,
- 1:11:40especially if it's a prophecy about you and it's a good prophecy and you want
- 1:11:45it to be true anyway, Uh Yeah, I just can't trust your heart.
- 1:11:49Were revealing to us, guiding us. If it's from God, we
- 1:11:54won't need to force it or shout about it. The Holy Spirit will empower
- 1:11:59it and convict CONFI vict God's people that it's true and it's right. And
- 1:12:05I think it's also the case that someone with a gift of prophecy could get
- 1:12:10two or three things right and something else wrong. Yep. Yeah. So
- 1:12:16I'm thinking of an instance where we lived in the Chicago, Illinois area for
- 1:12:23twenty years and when we were leaving, friends put together a dinner for us,
- 1:12:26and they were they prayed for us after dinner, and after the prayer
- 1:12:30time, one of the women president, who had frequently had profitic insight,
- 1:12:35said, I think your move to Arizona is more for Wayne than for Margaret,
- 1:12:41which was a complete shock to both of us, because the reason we
- 1:12:45decided to seek another job here in Phoenix in two thousand and one was because
- 1:12:49Margaret had been dealing with some chronic pain issues, and I looked for a
- 1:12:57job here because she felt better in the warm, pot our climate, and
- 1:13:00so our entire process was moving for the sake of Margaret. As it turns
- 1:13:05out, Phoenix Seminary has been very helpful to me and giving me a lighter
- 1:13:11teaching load, and I've been able to write much much more than I could
- 1:13:14have in Chicago. So here I am nineteen and a half years later saying
- 1:13:18that word this is more for Wayne than for Margaret was true, even though
- 1:13:25I didn't realize at the time how it could be true. No, that's
- 1:13:29true. And you know what I loved you said is that there's both content
- 1:13:33and tone. And use the example previously of the guy who was just mad
- 1:13:39and saying all these negative things about the turch and that type of thing,
- 1:13:42and it is interesting. It's interesting. I've even seen where somebody might even
- 1:13:45have a legitimate word content wise, but if they come with a tone that
- 1:13:50is not redemped. Now I'm not trying to candy coat things, but the
- 1:13:55Father Father God does have a tone, and I believe it's constructive. I
- 1:13:59believe it's redemptive. I don't believe people should feel disempoud. I mean the
- 1:14:02gift of prophecy and it's first Corinthians fourteen context is for edification, for consolation
- 1:14:10and then for really for the upbuilding of the saints. So that would be
- 1:14:15my encouragement as well. And I just wanted to highlight what doctor Grudham said
- 1:14:18on that it is both the content I believe also, and the tone of
- 1:14:24the Lord being represented there. So I think that's great. Last question,
- 1:14:30and this is always an interesting one, but I know exactly where you stand
- 1:14:32on this based on the book in that First Corinthians fourteen context, where you
- 1:14:38have multiple profits or prophetic people prophesying and somebody misses it, somebody gets it
- 1:14:43wrong. I don't want to call it a boo boo. I don't want
- 1:14:45to try to make it what it's not. If they get it wrong,
- 1:14:47does that mean somebody is a false prophet? No, false prophet. At
- 1:15:00We'll be denying the gospel of Jesus Christ, We'll be denying the truthfuls of
- 1:15:04scripture, and we're into serious trouble, all right. Yes, somebody who
- 1:15:11preaches a false gospel and claims to be a prophet is a false prophet.
- 1:15:15But so is someone who has a false view of the Trinity. Watch this,
- 1:15:21Jesus and the Holy Spirit are not competings. The Holy Spirit is Jesus.
- 1:15:30Jesus is thought than a flesh, and the Holy Spirit is Jesus,
- 1:15:35and the Father a festered the Spirit. That's modalism, Patrick, that's mordalism.
- 1:15:42Patrick. So Alexander Pregani is teaching modalism, at least in that clip.
- 1:15:47I don't know if he's ever repented from that or tried to straighten that
- 1:15:50out or not, but that's what he's doing there. That is modalism.
- 1:15:55So that makes Alexander Pregani a false prophet. But that's about it with that
- 1:16:00video. From that point forward, we're just gonna hear the same old stuff
- 1:16:03again. The videos probably got about two minutes or so left, and so
- 1:16:06we're gonna we're gonna finish up from there. There. We are going to
- 1:16:10talk about Agabus because there are people like Chris Valatin who says that Agabus got
- 1:16:16it wrong. Watch how do you make sure you're not deceived? Remember we
- 1:16:21just read a story in Acts sixteen about a woman who was telling the truth,
- 1:16:27but it was the wrong spirit lake. I hear a lot of people
- 1:16:30say, well, you can discern a false prophet because they get the prophetic
- 1:16:33word wrong. I'd point out that Agabus got the prophetic word wrong in the
- 1:16:38Book of Acts, and he was a true prophet. I would say Agabus
- 1:16:42did not get it wrong. But let's talk about Agabis because Valatin says Agabus
- 1:16:47got it wrong and Grudom also says that in his book let Me show you
- 1:16:54that this is what he says Acts twenty one ten to eleven. Here Agabus
- 1:16:59prophesied that the Jews at Jerusalem would bind Paul and deliver him into the hands
- 1:17:03of the Gentiles, a prediction that was nearly correct, but not quite.
- 1:17:09The Romans, not the Jews, bound Paul, and the Jews, rather
- 1:17:12than delivering him volunteerily tried to kill him, and he had to be rescued
- 1:17:17by force. The verb used by Agabis in twenty one eleven Paradidomi requires the
- 1:17:24sense of voluntarily consciously delivering, giving over, or handling over something, or
- 1:17:30handling over something to someone else. But that sense is not true with respect
- 1:17:36to the treatment of Paul by the Jews. They did not voluntarily hand Paul
- 1:17:41over to the Romans. This prediction was not far off, but it had
- 1:17:46inaccuracies in detail that would have called into question the validity of any Old Testament
- 1:17:53prophet. First things first, what was the reputation of Agabis? Well,
- 1:17:58his reputation as a prophet is found in Acts eleven. Let's look at what
- 1:18:02it says, Acts eleven twenty seven. Now, in these days, prophets
- 1:18:05came down from Jerusalem to Antioch, and one of them named Agabus, stood
- 1:18:10up and foretold by the spirit that there would be a great famine over all
- 1:18:14the world. This took place in the days of Claudius. So the disciples
- 1:18:17were determined, every one according to his ability, to send relief to the
- 1:18:21brothers living in Judea, and they did so, sending it to the elders
- 1:18:25by the hands of Barnabas and Sault. Now, first of all, note
- 1:18:28his reputation preceded him, because the disciples listened to him, and they sent
- 1:18:34relief by the hands of Barnabas and Saul. Also, the text notes that
- 1:18:40the prophecy was fulfilled. This took place in the days of Claudius. If
- 1:18:45he hadn't already had a reputation as a genuine prophet, would the disciples have
- 1:18:49even listened to him. No, So that's the first thing. Let's go
- 1:18:54ahead and read the second passage, the passage that Grudam and others talk about
- 1:18:59Agabus when he supposedly got everything wrong. This is in Acts twenty one,
- 1:19:02Verses ten to eleven, and it says, while we were staying for many
- 1:19:05days a prophet named Agabus came down from Judea, and coming to us,
- 1:19:10he took Paul's belt and bound his own feet and hands, and said,
- 1:19:13thus says the Holy Spirit, this is how the Jews at Jerusalem will bind
- 1:19:16the man who owns this belt and deliver him into the hands of the Gentiles.
- 1:19:25So did that happen, Well, yeah, it did happen, And
- 1:19:29Paul himself says it happened. Listen to Paul's own words and Acts, Chapter
- 1:19:34twenty eight seventeen, the last chapter of Acts, when he is in Rome,
- 1:19:39he's already taken to Rome. He was taken from Jerusalem. He was
- 1:19:43bound in Jerusalem, and he was held as a prisoner there, and then
- 1:19:45he was sent off to Rome. Acts twenty eight seventeen. Paul says to
- 1:19:50the people that had gathered there in the house that he was being held as
- 1:19:57a prisoner. At After three days, he called to gather the local leaders
- 1:20:00of the Jews, And when they had gathered, he said to them,
- 1:20:02brothers, though I had done nothing against our people or the customs of our
- 1:20:09fathers, yet I was delivered as a prisoner from Jerusalem into the hands of
- 1:20:15the Romans. Right there, Paul says he was delivered into the hands of
- 1:20:23the Romans. Paul makes it clear that he was handed over, that prophecy
- 1:20:29was fulfilled. Now let's take a look at what Agabas said there and acts
- 1:20:34twenty one ten through eleven. Let's look at the fact that Agabas even acted
- 1:20:40like one of the old prophets. First of all, what did he say.
- 1:20:45He says in the beginning of his prophecy, Thus says the Holy Spirit.
- 1:20:50That is equivalent to thus saith the Lord in the Old Testament, So
- 1:20:56he sounds just like an Old Testament prophet. There when he says, thus
- 1:21:00says the Holy Spirit. This is how the Jews at Jerusalem will bind the
- 1:21:03man who owns this belt and deliver him into the hands of the Gentiles.
- 1:21:06And then he binds his hands and feet. I didn't read that part,
- 1:21:10but he binds his hands in his own feet. So he uses imagery just
- 1:21:15like one of the Old Testament prophet. So if New Testament profits only spoke
- 1:21:23spontaneous words that the Holy Spirit brought to mind, as Grudam says, then
- 1:21:27why did Agabus speak like an Old Testament prophet and use graphic symbolism even like
- 1:21:32an Old Testament prophet, for example Isaiah twenty two. Notice the graphic symbolism
- 1:21:38in Isaiah twenty verse two. At that time the Lord spoke by Isaiah,
- 1:21:42the son of Am, saying, go and loose the sackcloth from your waist,
- 1:21:45and take off your sandals from your feet. And he did so walking
- 1:21:48naked and barefoot. Look at Jeremiah thirteen one through two. Thus says the
- 1:21:56Lord to me, go and buy a linen loincloth, and put it around
- 1:22:00your waist, and do not dip it in water. So I brought the
- 1:22:02loincloth according to the word of the Lord, and put it around my waist.
- 1:22:06What did Agabus do? Used that graphic symbolism there and bound his hands
- 1:22:11and feet to show what was going to happen to Paul. And then you
- 1:22:15have Ezekiel doing something similar, although not quite the same. In Ezekiel four
- 1:22:19one through three. And you, son a man, take a brick and
- 1:22:23lay it before you, and engrave on it a city, even Jerusalem,
- 1:22:27and put siege works against it, and build a siege wall against it,
- 1:22:30and cast up a mound against it, set camps also against it, and
- 1:22:33plant battering rams against it all around. And you take an iron griddle and
- 1:22:39place it as an iron wall between you and the city, and set your
- 1:22:42face toward it, and let it be in a state of siege, and
- 1:22:46press the siege against it. This is a sign for the House of Israel.
- 1:22:51Okay, what about the Jews binding Paul. Well, the Jews did
- 1:22:56bind Paul. Their anger and hatred towards Paul's what caught cause the Romans to
- 1:23:00bind him and take him into custody in the first place. So a prophecy
- 1:23:03does not have to have such a literal rigidness to it in order for it
- 1:23:11to be fulfilled. Otherwise you would have an issue with some of the Old
- 1:23:15Testament prophecies like this one in Malachi four to five. Behold, I will
- 1:23:19send you Elijah the prophet before the great and awesome day the Lord of the
- 1:23:24Lord comes. Did Elijah literally come? Well, no, we know who
- 1:23:29Jesus was referring to when he referred back to that prophecy in Malachi, and
- 1:23:34that was John the Baptist. John the Baptist was the fulfillment of that.
- 1:23:40So yes, Agabus got at one hundred percent right. He was an established
- 1:23:44prophet and he wasn't just getting receiving some kind of spontaneous revelation from the Lord.
- 1:23:48Wayne Grudem has opened the floodgates to all of the prophetic non nonsense that
- 1:23:55we see out there with his book The Gift of Prophecy in the New Testament
- 1:24:00and Today, so be warned. I will put a link to the book
- 1:24:06that refutes that does a really good refutation of that of Grudam's book in the
- 1:24:14link. Like I said, it's only about five bucks. It's worth getting
- 1:24:17and it's worth reading. So well. I hope this was a helpful episode
- 1:24:21to you. I hope you were able to kind of at least know why
- 1:24:27now the modern day apostle profits and apostles are actually saying that profits can get
- 1:24:35it wrong. If this has been helpful and you know someone who is caught
- 1:24:39up in this movement, I would really appreciate it if you would share the
- 1:24:42video with them. Anyway, Thanks so much for watching, Lord Willing.
- 1:24:45We'll see you next week.