Latest / CLEs You Actually Want to Hear / Habitability Issues for Landlords: Minimizing Risk, Responding to Habitability Claims, and Insurance Coverage
Transcript
- 0:01Welcome to Habitability issues for landlords
- 0:06minimizing risk. responding to habitability claims
- 0:10and insurance coverage. I'm Elizabeth Dryden,
- 0:13a partner of Glazer Weill and co -chair of Beverly
- 0:15Hills Bar Association's real estate section.
- 0:18Before I turn to our program, a few housekeeping
- 0:20items. If you have any questions for our speakers,
- 0:25please put them in the Q &A box. Our speakers
- 0:28will then turn to those questions at the end
- 0:30of their program. We also have some other programs
- 0:34coming up on November Fifth, we have a practical
- 0:41analysis of SB 79, Abundant and Affordable Homes
- 0:45Near Transit Act. This will be presented by Sherry
- 0:49Bondstel of Greenberg -Lusker, Trevor Damian
- 0:53of Commercial Lending Solutions, and moderated
- 0:56by Joseph Cobert of Cobert Law. Then in January,
- 1:01we'll have a legal ethics program. Legal ethics
- 1:04when advising on documenting and resolving real
- 1:07estate matters, presented by Jennifer Felton
- 1:11of RE Law. Now, I am delighted to introduce our
- 1:15speakers, Dan Fine and Stephen Rauscher. Dan
- 1:19is with Alchemy Insurance Services, where he
- 1:21provides solutions for all forms of property
- 1:23and casualty coverage lines. but has a specialization
- 1:27in coverage and risk management review. Dan has
- 1:30worked on the brokerage side of the industry
- 1:32for over 20 years. His connection is on procuring
- 1:36the appropriate coverage for entities while providing
- 1:39the most competitive pricing. Dan obtained the
- 1:42designations of certified insurance counselor
- 1:44and certified risk manager. Stephen Rauscher
- 1:48is a litigator at Rubin, Rauscher & Blum, where
- 1:51his practice centers on general business litigation,
- 1:55including real estate and contract disputes.
- 1:58He has a strong track record helping clients
- 2:00resolve insurance coverage issues and has tried
- 2:03and arbitrated numerous cases to decision with
- 2:07extensive experience at the appellate level as
- 2:10well. Mr. Rauscher has long been active in the
- 2:14legal community. He served as president of the
- 2:17Beverly Hills Bar Association in 2010, 2011,
- 2:20and he currently chairs the association's amicus
- 2:23committee, where he advocates in the appellate
- 2:26courts on matters of public interest. He has
- 2:28been recognized as a super lawyer in Los Angeles
- 2:31magazines every year since 2009. All right, guys,
- 2:35take it away. Thank you, Elizabeth. That was
- 2:38very kind. Let me start by saying a little bit
- 2:44more about Dan Fine. He's the non -lawyer here
- 2:48today. And so he brings a little bit of a different
- 2:51perspective to some of these issues, which I
- 2:53think, and I hope that everyone will find valuable.
- 2:56And I've known Dan for at least 10 years, and
- 3:01I deal with a lot of insurance brokers in my
- 3:03practice. Many of them, if not most of them,
- 3:07are really just salesmen. That's not the case
- 3:10with Dan. He really knows his stuff. He knows
- 3:13the actual issues that his clients are facing
- 3:16when it comes to insurance coverage, habitability
- 3:19included. So I'm really glad he's here today
- 3:23and values input. have invited him to sort of
- 3:27chime in as I'm going along here with some of
- 3:30the legal stuff. And then about halfway through
- 3:32the program, we'll get to some sort of more pure
- 3:35insurance market kinds of questions. So, but
- 3:39thanks again, Dan, for being here. You bet. Can
- 3:43we go to the next slide, please? So just as a
- 3:47little bit of an overview, these are the topics
- 3:49that we're going to go over today. And as Elizabeth
- 3:54mentioned, please do submit your questions in
- 3:57the Q &A, and I hope that we will have some time
- 4:00at the end of the program to go through some
- 4:03of them. But I want to start just by posing a
- 4:09rhetorical question, and that is, what is the
- 4:12biggest single liability that landlords, especially
- 4:18in the city of Los Angeles and California, generally
- 4:21face? And I would submit that the biggest liability
- 4:26is habitability claims by their tenants. Then
- 4:34the question is, well, are you insured for those
- 4:37kinds of claims? What happens when those claims
- 4:39come in? And a big topic of our discussion here
- 4:44today is going to be habitability exclusions
- 4:46that appear in commercial general liabilities
- 4:50policies more and more frequently. And what I
- 4:53tell my clients is when they come to me with
- 4:58a habitability claim, I said, if you are buying
- 5:02commercial general liability, CGL insurance that
- 5:06contains a habitability exclusion, you almost
- 5:10might as well not be buying the insurance. You're
- 5:13wasting your money. Maybe that's a little bit
- 5:18extreme because there are such things as slip
- 5:20and fall claims and other kinds of claims that
- 5:22can happen. but the biggest single exposure is
- 5:26for habitability claims and the insurance companies
- 5:29know that and that's why they're putting in these
- 5:34habitability exclusions. Oftentimes without the
- 5:39client, the insured understanding really what's
- 5:42in these policies. So we can go to the next slide
- 5:46please. I wanna start with a couple background
- 5:50areas. that are important to understanding how
- 5:55these habitability claims interact with the insurance
- 5:59issues that come up. And the first question is
- 6:01what do we mean by habitability claim? And it's
- 6:07fairly simple. It's a bodily injury or property
- 6:12damage claim that is arising as a result of substandard
- 6:17living conditions at someone's property, typically
- 6:21a residential. property. The types of habitability
- 6:25issues that can arise come in a lot of different
- 6:28forms, and the form that they come in can be
- 6:31important for coverage purposes as well. As the
- 6:35list indicates, it can be mold. It often is,
- 6:38almost always is, includes mold. Insects, bed
- 6:44bugs, rodents, you get into more property issues
- 6:48like peeling paint, some quality of life issues
- 6:52like excessive trash or homeless problem that
- 6:56can sometimes overflow into the apartment building
- 6:59itself, causing quality of life issues for people
- 7:03and in some cases, health issues for people.
- 7:07Another type that comes up quite frequently,
- 7:10which is often tied to the mold claim, but not
- 7:14necessarily the same as the mold claim, is there
- 7:17can be water, there's water intrusion. So you
- 7:21can imagine that a tenant might complain of water
- 7:24intrusion issues that are damaging their property,
- 7:27but not necessarily creating mold. That becomes
- 7:31important for coverage purposes. I just want
- 7:34to throw out another one that's not on my list
- 7:36here because it's come up recently in a habitability
- 7:41case for me, and that's dust mites. The plaintiff
- 7:45in that case was claiming that dust mites were
- 7:49connected to water intrusion issues. And that
- 7:54plaintiff had not tested positive for mold exposure,
- 7:59but the argument was that the water generated
- 8:03dust mites were creating health issues and not
- 8:07dissimilar from mold. So that's another one that
- 8:11can come up. And as a practical matter, most
- 8:15cases, uh that are filed include multiple examples
- 8:21of these of habitability issues um almost in
- 8:27a laundry list fashion and there's a lot of the
- 8:31plaintiffs council in this area are repeat uh
- 8:35filers of these kinds of cases so they have a
- 8:37whole list of things and the smarter ones tend
- 8:40to try to plead that into coverage as opposed
- 8:42to pleading things that they know are very likely
- 8:44going to be excluded Next slide, please. So in
- 8:53terms of the factual basis, the things that I
- 8:56was just talking about are the factual predicates
- 9:00for habitability claim. But in terms of the legal
- 9:04basis, the causes of action that are alleged,
- 9:09they can come in several different forms and
- 9:12oftentimes do come in multiple different forms
- 9:15in the same complaint. And of course, the one
- 9:18that we're most familiar with is garden variety
- 9:21negligence. But there's also for residential
- 9:27tenancies, an implied warranty of habitability.
- 9:30So oftentimes there's an allegation of breach
- 9:32of the warranty of habitability. There's also
- 9:35an implied covenant of quiet enjoyment. And depending
- 9:39on the nature of the habitability issue, the
- 9:44issue can... affect quiet enjoyment or may may
- 9:47cause someone to have to move out of their unit
- 9:50because of mold or something to that effect.
- 9:53They also sometimes allege private nuisance or
- 9:57constructive eviction on a similar theory to
- 10:00the implied covenant of quiet enjoyment. We also
- 10:04see other theories popping up in some of these
- 10:07complaints in the city of Los Angeles. There's
- 10:10a tenant harassment or anti harassment ordinance
- 10:13and sometimes the tenant will plead that, hey,
- 10:17I complained about a habitability issue and now
- 10:21I am being discriminated against because of that
- 10:23or I'm being, there's been some kind of negative
- 10:26action taken against me. So that can form a basis
- 10:29for a separate cause of action with a separate
- 10:32types of damages, including statutory damages
- 10:35and penalties that can be assessed. Sometimes
- 10:38these claims whether related directly to the
- 10:42habitability issues or not include a wrongful
- 10:45entry claim that the landlord was coming into
- 10:49the unit without proper notice or inappropriately
- 10:53and similar to that invasion of the right to
- 10:57private occupancy. So I'm not going to say a
- 11:00ton more about the legal bases or even the damages
- 11:06for these kinds of cases, but I am going to recommend
- 11:10If you're interested in that aspect of this area
- 11:14a little bit more, there was a program put on
- 11:17by our real estate section back in July with
- 11:20Andrew Wesley, who's a mediator with Signature
- 11:23Resolution called Mediating Tenant Landlord Habitability
- 11:27Cases. And that one didn't go too much into coverage
- 11:30issues, but did go into quite a bit of depth
- 11:33into the issues that come up in these kinds of
- 11:35cases. So that's kind of the background for the
- 11:40kinds of claims that we're talking about. Now
- 11:43let's talk a little bit about some background
- 11:45for the insurance issues that come up. Then we
- 11:48can go to the next slide. So as I mentioned earlier,
- 11:55the type of insurance policy that is most often
- 11:58going to respond to habitability claims is the
- 12:04commercial general liability. policy. There are
- 12:07some exceptions to that, and Dan and I will talk
- 12:10about those a little bit later, but that's what
- 12:15pretty much every landlord has, that type of
- 12:18policy. And as you might expect if you know anything
- 12:23about what those policies cover, these kinds
- 12:27of claims are typically under the bodily injury
- 12:30and or the property damage coverages that are
- 12:33in every CGL policy. Most CGL policies, not all,
- 12:41although in some cases you have to pay extra
- 12:43if you also want personal and advertising injury
- 12:46coverage. So most of them also have that kind
- 12:50of coverage. And I think most people think of
- 12:54those as covering things like defamation and
- 12:58malicious prosecution and things like that, which
- 13:01are referenced here in the typical definition
- 13:03of personal and advertising injury. But that
- 13:07coverage can also become relevant to a habitability
- 13:11claim too, because of item C there in the definition,
- 13:15wrongful eviction or wrongful entry, invasion
- 13:20of the right of private occupancy. That can sometimes
- 13:26come into play when we have these complaints,
- 13:30depending on what the causes of action are and
- 13:33depending on what the facts are that are alleged.
- 13:39Go to the next slide, please. So when we're talking
- 13:44about insurance, it's important to keep in mind
- 13:48the two duties that arise under a third -party
- 13:53liability policy like a CGL policy, and that
- 13:56is the duty to defend and the duty to indemnify.
- 14:01I'm sure everyone pretty much understands the
- 14:04distinction, but What that means is that if there
- 14:07is a claim alleged that falls under the policy
- 14:10or potentially falls under the policy, the insurance
- 14:13company has a duty to pay a lawyer to defend
- 14:16you at the landlord in the lawsuit. The duty
- 14:19to indemnify refers to whether or not the insurance
- 14:22company has to pay the judgment that ultimately
- 14:25is entered at the end of the lawsuit or more
- 14:29often settlement that's reached of the claim.
- 14:32And a key element or foundational element of
- 14:37insurance law is that the duty to defend is greater
- 14:41than the duty to indemnify. So just because the
- 14:45judgment at the end may not be payable by the
- 14:50insurance company doesn't mean that they don't
- 14:52need to provide a defense along the way. And
- 14:55the name of the game, to be frank, is to get
- 15:01the insurance company on the hook. for the duty
- 15:04to defend. Because once you have the insurance
- 15:07company in the lawsuit, they are going to be
- 15:12incurring significant legal fees and expert costs
- 15:17to defend the lawsuit. They are potentially going
- 15:21to be subject to bad faith liability when policy
- 15:25limits demands come in and so forth. And so if
- 15:29you can get them on the hook just for that, the
- 15:33chances go up a lot that you're gonna be able
- 15:36to get them to pay to settle the case, or as
- 15:39we'll talk about later, pay the lion's share
- 15:42of settlement of the case, even if there are
- 15:44significant coverage issues. Couple other concepts
- 15:48to keep in mind. When insurer defends a complaint,
- 15:55it has to defend the whole complaint, even when
- 15:58there are causes of action for which there's
- 16:00no potential for coverage. and the Seminole California
- 16:05Supreme Court case on this is bus versus superior
- 16:09court that mentions that the insurance company
- 16:12can't parse claims. So even if one claim out
- 16:17of 10 is potentially covered, the insurance company
- 16:20has to defend the entire lawsuit. My favorite
- 16:23example of this from my practice was we had a
- 16:27client who was hit with an employment lawsuit
- 16:30with about 10 different employment torts, sexual
- 16:34harassment and so forth. But also the boss in
- 16:39the parking lot one day backed up into her car
- 16:42and caused, I don't know, five, $10 ,000 worth
- 16:47of property damage. And that claim was included
- 16:49in the lawsuit as well. And as a result of the
- 16:52inclusion of that claim, the commercial general
- 16:55liability carrier had to defend. and not only
- 16:59that, but defend through independent counsel,
- 17:01as we'll talk about in a minute. Now, something
- 17:04to keep in mind is that when you have these mixed
- 17:07causes of action under the bus case, the insurance
- 17:11company, in theory, has the right to come back
- 17:14after the insured for an allocation of the defense
- 17:20costs and seek those from the insured in a subsequent
- 17:25lawsuit. So it's not a perfect situation for
- 17:30the insured, but as a practical matter, the insurance
- 17:33companies generally don't do that. And also if
- 17:36you reach a settlement that involves some contribution
- 17:39by the policy holder as part of the settlement,
- 17:43then those claims go away as part of that settlement.
- 17:47Again, we'll talk about that in a few minutes.
- 17:49Let's go to the next slide. Something else to
- 17:53keep in mind, if you are representing a landlord,
- 17:58and tendering an insurance claim. One additional
- 18:03question is whether or not the insured may be
- 18:07entitled to independent counsel or cumus counsel
- 18:10as we call it in California based on a fairly
- 18:15old case that established the principle that
- 18:18was subsequently codified in the civil code.
- 18:22And the situation here is that when the insurance
- 18:25company designate someone to defend the landlord,
- 18:31they're going to designate what we call panel
- 18:33counsel from someone who works for them over
- 18:37and over again, usually on these particular kinds
- 18:40of cases at a pretty low rate. And those people,
- 18:48their clients are technically both the insurance
- 18:50company and the policyholder. Although we know
- 18:54who the repeat client is. So where their actual
- 18:58loyalties lie can be called into question. Because
- 19:03of that, for certain kinds of lawsuits, certain
- 19:07kinds of complaints that plead covered and uncovered
- 19:11claims, there can be a conflict of interest that
- 19:14arises with those lawyers. And in those situations
- 19:19where the way the case is litigated, can be determinative
- 19:28of whether there is coverage going forward, the
- 19:31courts have recognized and the legislature has
- 19:33recognized that the policy holder has a right
- 19:37to their own independent counsel paid for by
- 19:40the insurance company. Now, there's a little
- 19:43bit of a hitch to that, which is that the insurance
- 19:46company is only required to pay the rates that
- 19:49it normally pays its own panel counsel. And that's
- 19:53oftentimes, I suspect, less than the rates of
- 19:56many of the people on this Zoom. But that's negotiable
- 20:01with the insurance company and or sometimes you
- 20:04negotiate with your client to pay the differential
- 20:07or some of the differential. What I would say
- 20:10is that if you find yourself or your client finds
- 20:15itself in a situation where there's a habitability
- 20:19claim and there is the potential for or the obligation
- 20:23to provide independent counsel, the policyholders
- 20:27should avail themselves of that right. Because
- 20:33the insurance companies, generally speaking,
- 20:37treat those cases where there's independent counsel
- 20:40a little differently than they do where it's
- 20:42just panel counsel. Insurance companies generally
- 20:45do not like having to provide independent counsel
- 20:49because even though they're theoretically paying
- 20:52the same rates, the fees that are charged by
- 20:57independent counsel almost always are gonna be
- 21:00more than what would be charged by panel counsel
- 21:02for a variety of reasons. And also the independent
- 21:09council, one of the reasons they are there, they're
- 21:11kind of there to make sure to keep the insurance
- 21:14company honest, if you will, to honor its duty
- 21:18to defend the policyholder and the duty to settle
- 21:22if settlement is indicated. And so the independent
- 21:25council is there to make sure that settlement
- 21:30opportunities are not missed and to put pressure
- 21:34on the insurance company to put as much money
- 21:36on the table to settle as possible. Okay, so
- 21:41let's go to the next slide. So your client calls
- 21:48you and says, I just got served with a habitability
- 21:52complaint. What do I do? Well, the first order
- 21:57of business is to tender the claim to the insurance
- 22:00company, of course. But what insurance company?
- 22:04Which policy? And so to understand that, you
- 22:07have to gather all the policies that are potentially
- 22:10going to be on the hook for this particular claim.
- 22:14These commercial general liability policies are
- 22:16occurrence -based policies. So if there was a
- 22:19water intrusion in 2025, the policy that was
- 22:22on the risk for that year is going to apply.
- 22:25But if there was also a water intrusion issue
- 22:28that happened in 2024, that could be a different
- 22:31carrier and a different policy. And so that one
- 22:34is also going to potentially apply. So you have
- 22:38to look at the policies. You have to gather the
- 22:43policies. Your client has to get you the actual
- 22:48policies, not just the collection of declarations
- 22:52pages, which is something that I repeatedly run
- 22:55into. Even when I tell the client to go back
- 22:59to their insurance agent and ask for a copy of
- 23:02the full policy, they're often told, well, you
- 23:04have it. You have two pages of declarations and
- 23:08three pages of privacy disclosures and three
- 23:12pages of nuclear energy exclusions and maybe
- 23:17three or four other things. You don't actually
- 23:19have the full set of endorsements. And one of
- 23:22the things that happens is the full policy is
- 23:26oftentimes provided the first policy here, but
- 23:29during subsequent renewals, they oftentimes don't
- 23:32provide it again. So in order to evaluate, if
- 23:35for example, there's a habitability exclusion
- 23:37or whatever, you need to be able to see the whole
- 23:38policy. So gather the actual policies, talk to
- 23:42the client about the length of tenancy, because
- 23:46as I said, if the person has been there for several
- 23:50years, you may end up going back several years.
- 23:54And that can be very important because maybe
- 23:56they just got a habitability exclusion slapped
- 23:58on their policy last year, but they didn't have
- 24:01it in the prior years. That becomes even more
- 24:03of an issue if some of the plaintiffs are minors.
- 24:09And I love it from a policyholder's perspective
- 24:12when there are minor plaintiffs because the statute
- 24:16of limitations for minors is told until they
- 24:19turn 18. And so if this family has lived in this
- 24:22unit, which happens a lot, for 10 or more years
- 24:26or whatever, and the child is 12, well, you get
- 24:29to go back 10 years for insurance policies. And
- 24:35again, the further back you go, the less likely
- 24:38there will be a habitability exclusion. Of course,
- 24:41as we move forward in time, that becomes more
- 24:45and more of a problem. But for now, if there
- 24:49are claims by miners, you got to go way back,
- 24:51way back beyond two or three years. One other
- 24:55point to keep in mind is most of these CGL policies
- 25:00have what's called anti -stacking provisions,
- 25:03which means that if there were three, say you
- 25:05renewed with the same carrier three years in
- 25:08a row at a million dollar per occurrence limit,
- 25:13You might think, oh, I'm going to have plenty
- 25:14of insurance to take care of this problem. I'm
- 25:16going to have $3 million of insurance to take
- 25:18care of this problem. But most of the policies
- 25:21have these provisions which say, if we issued
- 25:24multiple policies to the same insured over the
- 25:28course of more than one policy period, you only
- 25:31get one year worth of policy limits. So you only
- 25:35have $1 million in coverage, not $3 million in
- 25:38coverage for the same claim. OK. So next slide,
- 25:43please. So we've talked or hinted at habitability
- 25:49exclusions a lot. Now let's get to the meat of
- 25:53what is a habitability exclusion. So a few years
- 25:58ago, when I would get these cases, there would
- 26:02sometimes be habitability exclusions in policies,
- 26:05but they often had holes in them. And, you know,
- 26:10As I said before, all we need is the potential
- 26:12for coverage and we can get a defense and getting
- 26:16a defense is the name of the game. So we're gonna
- 26:20go through a couple sort of the evolution of
- 26:23the habitability exclusion from versions that
- 26:27had holes to versions that are pretty much airtight.
- 26:31And so this first one is an example from a policy
- 26:35taken from my own practice. from several years
- 26:39ago. And you can see that this exclusion is aimed
- 26:45at alleged or actual violations of the following
- 26:49as they pertain to habitability. And then it
- 26:51goes on to cite code sections, not specific code
- 26:55sections, but types of code sections, civil code,
- 26:59health and safety code, rent stabilization ordinances,
- 27:04section eight programs, rules and regulations.
- 27:08actual or constructive wrongful eviction arising
- 27:12from the above. And habitability in this case
- 27:16is defined and it refers, as you might expect,
- 27:19to safe living environment and or fit for occupancy
- 27:23by human beings. So this might strike you as
- 27:28a pretty tight habitability exclusion, but it
- 27:35doesn't mention some of the other types of claims
- 27:39that I've talked about that sometimes come up
- 27:41in these cases like What if there was a wrongful
- 27:45entry not based on habitability issues, but based
- 27:48on something else or Well, what if there's a
- 27:53generalized negligence claim, but they're not
- 27:56specifically referencing these code sections
- 28:00Or they are referencing some code sections, but
- 28:03it's including but not limited to those things
- 28:06In those cases, you could in the past oftentimes
- 28:10get the insurance company to provide a defense.
- 28:17So let's go to the next claim. I mean, the next
- 28:20slide. But you would probably get a denial letter
- 28:24if you had that habitability exclusion. And so,
- 28:28you know, one of the things that I'm here to
- 28:30say is don't necessarily take the denial letter
- 28:32as the end of the story. because for all the
- 28:36reasons that I was just talking about, all you
- 28:39need is one claim or aspect of a claim that's
- 28:44potentially covered and you can get the duty
- 28:46to defend invoked. So in this particular case,
- 28:50if I got a denial letter with that habitability
- 28:53exclusion, I would say, let's push back. Let's
- 28:56go on to the next slide. So this sort of net,
- 29:06Version two, I guess, of the habitability exclusion
- 29:12added language to make it even broader, not just
- 29:18limiting the exclusion to the code sections and
- 29:21so forth, but to including simply failure to
- 29:25maintain premises in a safe, sanitary condition.
- 29:29So that tends to take away the argument that
- 29:33the claim must be tied in its totality to statutory
- 29:38violations and not be based on a generalized
- 29:41negligent claim. But again, under this exclusion,
- 29:44there could still be other non -habitability
- 29:47related claims that could trigger coverage. And
- 29:56then the last sentence here, the company shall
- 29:58have no duty to defend any claims, proceedings
- 30:01or suits in any way arising from allegations
- 30:04of the above. That could potentially be read
- 30:07to say, well, even if there are some covered
- 30:10claims, this exclusion is still going to exclude
- 30:14coverage. However, the courts have generally
- 30:16read that kind of language as not going so far
- 30:20as to take away. the policyholders rights under
- 30:24the bus case. Now let's go to the next slide.
- 30:30And I think this is the state of the art in terms
- 30:32of the latest version of habitability exclusion.
- 30:39So I didn't quote the entirety of the text, but
- 30:43the key language here is that first you have
- 30:47to have a claim arising out of the habitability
- 30:52rules and regulations and laws. but also in subsection
- 30:57two, they then go on to say, and excluded our
- 31:03causes of action alleged in any claim or suit
- 31:05that also alleges any violation or breach of
- 31:11wrongful eviction entry or invasion, et cetera,
- 31:16as set forth above. So it's that also language
- 31:19that is the problem. And that language was interpreted
- 31:27in a bad way for policyholders in a case called
- 31:3024th and Hoffman and we can go to the next slide.
- 31:35It's a key case in this area of habitability
- 31:38exclusions and it's in the materials. But what
- 31:42happened in that case was the insurance company
- 31:46issued a CGL policy to the owners of an apartment
- 31:49complex. And the owners of the complex started
- 31:54renovations. And I think that the plaintiffs
- 31:56in this case were the only two tenants who didn't
- 31:58move out. They refused to be bought out and refused
- 32:01to move out. And so during the course of the
- 32:04renovations, there were all kinds of problems,
- 32:07dust, debris, vermin, et cetera. And they filed
- 32:11a complaint about all those things. But they
- 32:14also alleged two claims that were really unrelated
- 32:19to the habitability issues, conversion and trespass
- 32:23to chattels. based on somebody, potentially the
- 32:30landlord, stealing personal property out of a
- 32:32locker in the complex, which fell under property
- 32:36damage coverage. Go on to the next slide. So
- 32:42Northfield had the exclusion that I was just
- 32:45talking about, and they refused to defend the
- 32:48case. And so the landlord had to settle the case
- 32:51and defend the case with their own money and
- 32:53then sued Northfield. The trial court found that
- 32:58Northfield had breached its duty to defend because
- 33:01you had these other non -habitability claims,
- 33:04but the Court of Appeal reversed, finding that
- 33:10the insurance company had essentially contracted
- 33:13out of the requirements of BUS by including clear
- 33:19language in its exclusion. That's the also language.
- 33:24claims alleged in a suit that also included habitability
- 33:28claims. You can go on to the next slide. And
- 33:33the court acknowledged that, well, it's kind
- 33:35of an odd situation where the insurance contract
- 33:40covers certain claims if they are in their own
- 33:43lawsuit. If the lawsuit had only been for the
- 33:46conversion of the personal property, then there
- 33:50would have been a duty to defend. But because
- 33:52they were included in a claim that also had habitability
- 33:57claims, the court said, no, in that case, no
- 34:02defense, no indemnity. Notwithstanding the fact
- 34:06that it recognized the oddity of the situation
- 34:10and the policies that had been expressed in bus,
- 34:14it ruled in favor of the insurance company because
- 34:17the language it felt was just too clear. And
- 34:21the policyholder petition for review to the California
- 34:24Supreme Court, but review was denied. So that
- 34:27is the state of law in California when it comes
- 34:31to habitability exclusions. And you can bet that
- 34:38the insurance companies, for the most part, have
- 34:40updated their habitability exclusions to follow
- 34:44what was in the Northfield case. So let's go
- 34:48on to the next slide. And I'm going to turn it
- 34:52over a little bit here to Dan, although I might
- 34:54have my pipe in too. But for Dan to talk about,
- 34:59well, what is it really like out there in the
- 35:02insurance market for residential landlords? Dan?
- 35:07So ever since the fires have occurred, obviously
- 35:12the property market has been hardening, as the
- 35:16term is in insurance, more restrictive underwriting.
- 35:22regarding multifamily inhabitation risk, it's
- 35:27become more difficult for property owners. Prices
- 35:34have gone up and truly the issue is the underwriting
- 35:42appetite, the restrictions that the insurance
- 35:45carriers put on a submitted risk, a multifamily
- 35:51submitted risk is more restrictive. And they
- 35:56do that in certain aspects where if a building
- 36:00is too old and it falls outside their underwriting
- 36:05parameters, they decline the risk. And as a result,
- 36:12I'm speaking to admitted and standard markets
- 36:16which have habitability coverage within their
- 36:21language. So where you get the exclusion is what's
- 36:26called surplus lines, non -admitted paper. That
- 36:31is the majority of where that exclusion is found.
- 36:36And that appetite restriction can either occur,
- 36:41as I said, the age of the building, the lack
- 36:45of updates, the capacity, the size of the building,
- 36:50and there's a litany of things that insurance
- 36:52carers do That they restricted their underwriting
- 36:56appetite to not accept that building for acceptable
- 37:01underwriting so You know how prevalent prevalent
- 37:10it is is based on the actual individual risk
- 37:13and that's kind of the problem and it's unfortunate
- 37:18that the age of a building is almost irrelevant
- 37:22to a general liability claim because if a property
- 37:27owner keeps his building in good standing and
- 37:34is actively involved and it's well managed. It's
- 37:38unfortunate that that owner is not allowed to
- 37:44get into an admitted market just based on the
- 37:47age of the building. It's unfortunate. So the
- 37:52question is how much more premium? What's interesting
- 37:55today is Normally, in the past, admitted markets,
- 38:01standard markets, and I'm referring to your Mercuries,
- 38:05your Amtruss, your CIGs, your habitational markets,
- 38:10historically have been less expensive. But there
- 38:14has been a trend with the amount of habitability
- 38:19claims that have come in where a surplus line
- 38:24premium can actually be less money than an admitted
- 38:31premium because that admitted premium has a habitability,
- 38:37the lack of habitability exclusion. So the market
- 38:42is flipping a little bit. Historically, you would
- 38:46get your Mercuries or you would get your CIGs
- 38:50or you get your Amtrust or your guards, insurance
- 38:55carriers and You would not have that exclusion
- 38:59and it will also be less in premium and that's
- 39:03still the case But what they're doing is the
- 39:07the underwriting appetite is more restrictive.
- 39:09So you really have to have a product that fits
- 39:13their underwriting requirement So, you know as
- 39:18with any insurance carrier when you have a what
- 39:21happens when you have a habitability claim that
- 39:25goes your loss runs and there is a certain view
- 39:30on a certain carrier. If it's either not mitigated,
- 39:33not taken care of, or the carrier looks at it,
- 39:37what the habitability claim was, it could be
- 39:40mismanaged or the host of things that Stephen
- 39:43pointed out. They might either not renew or when
- 39:47you go to market, they won't accept that risk.
- 39:51So, you know, they do say today that the property
- 39:55market is softening, you have that. But in reality,
- 39:58it might be softening on price a little bit,
- 40:00but it's not softening on underwriting requirement.
- 40:05So to that last point, why a building may be
- 40:08forced to obtain coverage without habitability
- 40:10is to all those points. The age of the building,
- 40:15lack of updates, potential claim that occurred.
- 40:20So those are the main things that will have a
- 40:26property not have the ability to obtain a standard
- 40:30market or admitted carrier. Next slide, please.
- 40:36Let me just jump in here, Dan, before you talk
- 40:38a little bit more about the property manager
- 40:40coverage issues. One question that I asked myself
- 40:48as we were preparing this program was, okay,
- 40:50well, what if you have the habitability exclusion?
- 40:53Are you out of luck or are there any other? sources
- 40:58for you to be able to bring insurance to the
- 41:02table. And so that raises the question about
- 41:06what if you have a property manager, don't they
- 41:09have their own CGL coverage and what happens
- 41:12in that case? So with that backdrop, go ahead,
- 41:15Dan. So if you are a landlord and you retain
- 41:23a property management company for their services,
- 41:28you really want to read they're hold harmless.
- 41:32The property management's out. A lot of times
- 41:36they have language that makes the owner of the
- 41:41building fully responsible for that claim. Unless
- 41:45they are found, you know, they're too negligent
- 41:49in the way they manage it, and as a result, there
- 41:51was a habitability claim, then obviously the
- 41:56owner of the building can file a claim for...
- 42:00have you know they have a reason to have put
- 42:02towards the general liability of the property
- 42:07management company and as a result you should
- 42:10also make sure that a property management company
- 42:12carries their own general liability because what
- 42:15happens is a lot of property management companies
- 42:17just look to the landlord for their general liability
- 42:22and their name as additional insured or real
- 42:25estate manage ISO form their name automatically
- 42:28as additional insured so they don't buy their
- 42:30own general liability. So if you're going to
- 42:33retain a general property management company,
- 42:36make sure that they have their own general liability
- 42:39along with errors and emissions. Steve? Yeah.
- 42:43So before we go to the next slide, I'll just
- 42:45add to that that the property manager or as it's
- 42:53called real estate manager in the standard CGL
- 42:57policy is an additional insured or maybe more
- 43:01properly named insured, entitled to insurance
- 43:06under the landlord's own policy. And so that's
- 43:09why the property managers can sometimes get away
- 43:13with outsourcing the habitability liability to
- 43:19their clients because they know that they're
- 43:21going to be insured. And they may also be an
- 43:23additional insured under different theories too,
- 43:27if they have written indemnity obligation in
- 43:30their contract, for example. One other thing
- 43:35to keep in mind is that most good responsible
- 43:39property managers will have errors in emissions
- 43:42coverage. And it's not ideal if the property
- 43:46manager and the landlord have both been sued
- 43:48for a habitability case for the property manager
- 43:50to be cross complaining against. or for the landlord
- 43:55to be cross complaining against the property
- 43:57manager for an errors and emissions claim. But
- 44:00sometimes if it's a big case, some of these cases
- 44:03can be 100 different plaintiffs with a big exposure.
- 44:08If you need insurance to come to the table, it
- 44:12may be advisable for the landlord to sue the
- 44:17property manager and trigger that ENO claim.
- 44:19Let's go to the next slide. So this is some fairly
- 44:27standard indemnity language that Dan sent me.
- 44:32And the key takeaway, as Dan was saying, is that
- 44:36in the first part here, it's the owner who's
- 44:39agreeing to defend and indemnify the property
- 44:41manager for pretty much everything other than
- 44:45gross negligence or willful misconduct. So simple
- 44:49negligence flows back to the owner. So therefore,
- 44:55suing the property manager doesn't really get
- 44:59you that far if we're talking about simple negligence,
- 45:03because then it just flows back to the owner
- 45:06under the indemnity clause, which is one reason
- 45:10why the CGL policy, if it is defending, will
- 45:13typically defend both the owner and the property
- 45:16manager and not be concerned about which of the
- 45:19two of them was at fault. Of course, the owners
- 45:21generally on the hook for anything that the manager
- 45:24did as its agent, at least if it's something
- 45:28negligent. And if it's something grossly negligent
- 45:31or certainly willful, then that's not going to
- 45:33be insured anyway. And then you can see that
- 45:37this standard language actually had some exculpatory
- 45:41language or an agreement to waive claims against
- 45:44the manager. So if you're a landlord, you should
- 45:47look carefully at at what insurance your property
- 45:52manager has, as well as what's in the indemnification
- 45:56language. Not that there's necessarily that much
- 45:59you can do about it as a landlord, but at least
- 46:01you know and it may impact just how important,
- 46:05how much additional premium you're willing to
- 46:07pay to get rid of that habitability exclusion,
- 46:10if that's a possibility. Dan, let me ask you
- 46:12a question about that. Let's say you get a quote,
- 46:16with a habitability exclusion, Is it generally
- 46:22the case that if you're willing to pay enough
- 46:24money to get rid of the habitability exclusion,
- 46:26you can? No. What I have seen, I mean, not normally
- 46:36the case because you would actually go to markets.
- 46:38What I have seen is today's market has surplus
- 46:41lines as habitability sublimits. So they'll give
- 46:46you, they might throw in 150 ,000 for a sublimit.
- 46:51and there are carriers out there which we have
- 46:55access to that will give you what's in the surplus
- 46:59lines market will give you up to $500 ,000 sub
- 47:03limit for habitability coverage and they will
- 47:07go back as far as as possible and not to have
- 47:12an age restriction for underwriting so it's a
- 47:16potential win but obviously the other underwriting
- 47:20parameters have to fall within their appetite.
- 47:23And when they give you those sublimits, if you
- 47:25know, are those typically burning limits or defense
- 47:28outside of limits? Normally, they're burning
- 47:32limits. OK. Those are sublimits. OK. Well, so
- 47:36and so for the audience, burning limits means
- 47:39normally in a normal CGL claim when you have
- 47:41a million dollars in coverage, most of the time,
- 47:45the defense costs do not eat away at that million
- 47:48dollars. But if the defense costs do eat away,
- 47:51at the limits, that's called burning limits.
- 47:54And obviously, you know, the longer the case
- 47:57goes on and more expensive it is, the less limits
- 48:00there are to settle. So there's some pluses to
- 48:03that, but there's also a lot of minuses in terms
- 48:06of the exposure if you burning through the limits,
- 48:09especially if it's only 150 ,000. But boy, that's
- 48:12a lot better than nothing, even if it just covers
- 48:14the defense costs. That's a significant exposure.
- 48:18Okay, so let's go to the next slide. So Dan brought
- 48:22to my attention something I really have not seen
- 48:26yet. I don't know how new it is, but it is that
- 48:30I've been aware of you can buy a separate policy
- 48:34that covers housing discrimination or tenant
- 48:36discrimination claims that are excluded under
- 48:39the CGL policy. But Dan tells me that there may
- 48:44be some ability to get some coverage for habitability
- 48:47under these kinds of policies too. You wanna
- 48:49talk a little bit about that? Dan? Sure. So what
- 48:54we've been doing lately is when a risk or portfolio
- 49:02of buildings that are older fall out of the admitted
- 49:06or standard market underwriting requirement and
- 49:09they're buying surplus lines with the habitability
- 49:11coverage, we are purchasing an errors and emissions
- 49:15professional liability policy for coverage. So
- 49:18if we go to the next slide. So basically what
- 49:24this is happening is this is a, and I just highlighted
- 49:30what's important. It's a million dollar policy
- 49:34for a professional liability policy. We have
- 49:38the sub limits within that. And the way they
- 49:45look at it is you will receive an application
- 49:49based on what you're doing. You're a syndicate.
- 49:54you're self -managing, you're in partnership,
- 49:58however you own it, you'll check a certain box,
- 50:00and as a result, you'll get a professional liability
- 50:06policy that, and I make sure it's enhanced, that
- 50:10will provide certain things, which actually sometimes
- 50:12is even better than a CGL policy. And that being
- 50:17the case, so we have, the main things to look
- 50:20at is the third party discrimination, We have
- 50:26a bodily injury property damage of 250 and failure
- 50:31to disclose 500 ,000. And as we get to that,
- 50:37we have a third party discrimination policy as
- 50:41with any professional liability policy where
- 50:45it's duties that you performed or in the course
- 50:49of owning and managing the property. or if a
- 50:53wrongful act occurs, this policy will respond
- 50:56as a professional liability policy will do. And
- 51:01we have the enhancement of the landlord tenant
- 51:06ordinance violations sublimit, which is down
- 51:08to the bottom, which is really what are the exclusions
- 51:14for the claims for alleged violations of landlord
- 51:18tenant ordinance act statute law. rule regulations
- 51:22including any civil fines or penalties provided
- 51:27the claim is made against you and you will be
- 51:30defined as the owner of the property for professional
- 51:33services and So what we've been doing is we've
- 51:37been selling these and putting these in place
- 51:40for owners of buildings that can't get habitational
- 51:45coverage I'm circling back back to this last
- 51:49because we have a we have a failure to disclose
- 51:55pollutant claim. And it's really for, you know,
- 52:01the mold and the things that trigger a pollution
- 52:05claim. It may not specifically defend against
- 52:12a mold claim if that is singularly the claim,
- 52:16but most of the time a claim will occur as this
- 52:19failure to disclose sub limit of $500 ,000, failure
- 52:23to disclose that you as a property owner didn't
- 52:28know that that pollution or hence mold was in
- 52:33place. And nine times out of 10, the claimant
- 52:39attorney will put that into the claim. And Steve,
- 52:43have you seen the failure to disclose on a mold
- 52:46claim? No, I haven't really seen that. Although
- 52:51maybe I need to look a little more carefully
- 52:54at what they say in their complaint, whether
- 52:56it's just complaining about mold or the failure
- 52:57to disclose mold. But I'll say in general, most
- 53:01landlord clients that I have seen, and they tend
- 53:05to be on the smaller business side, don't have
- 53:09this kind of insurance at all. you know, including
- 53:12the housing discrimination insurance, which is
- 53:15also another significant liability, obviously,
- 53:17that tenants can face. So I think a lot of landlords
- 53:21view this as an expensive luxury that they're
- 53:24not willing to pay for, but that they should
- 53:26probably reevaluate that. And I'm sure the first
- 53:31question is, is how much does this cost? These
- 53:33are actually not that expensive policies. So
- 53:36these range based on obviously your retention.
- 53:39These range from Three to five thousand obviously
- 53:43if you have a portfolio of buildings, it's going
- 53:46to be rated To that risk but for a standalone
- 53:50building that is That can't get habitation and
- 53:58they need For $3 ,000 on say $25 ,000 I'm speaking
- 54:05in specifics premium that they may be paying
- 54:07in surplus lines. This might be worth it or the
- 54:12$3 ,000 might be worth it in general just for
- 54:15the safekeeping of having that coverage. Okay,
- 54:18well great. I think that's really valuable information.
- 54:22Let's go to the next slide because I want to
- 54:23run through a couple last items before we see
- 54:27if we have time to address some questions. There
- 54:29are, aside from the habitability exclusion, there
- 54:32are any number of exclusions that can find their
- 54:35way into these CGL policies that can create coverage
- 54:38headaches. The big one, that I've alluded to
- 54:41being the mold exclusion. And there is no CGL
- 54:45policy that does not have a mold exclusion. Or
- 54:49if they have any coverage, it's $5 ,000 or something
- 54:52like that. So that's always going to be there,
- 54:55which is one reason why smart plaintiffs' lawyers
- 54:59try to plead things other than mold, if they
- 55:02want to try to trigger insurance coverage. But
- 55:05the fact that there's mold at least until they
- 55:08redraft this thing to be like the habitability
- 55:11exclusion, the fact that there's mold, a mold
- 55:15claim as part of the claim does not operate as
- 55:18a complete bar to coverage or to a defense. So
- 55:21that's the good news. Let's go on to the next
- 55:24one. There's a whole cottage industry, or at
- 55:27least there was, I don't know if it's still going
- 55:29strong, but bed bug claims. And so sometimes
- 55:35you'll find bed bugs exclusions, That's not usually,
- 55:38unless it was a claim against a hotel or something
- 55:40like that, that's not usually going to be the
- 55:43only basis of the claim, but that can be there.
- 55:47Next slide. There's sometimes a vermin exclusion.
- 55:54Some of these exclusions are broader. than other
- 55:58exclusions. This is one of the broader ones that
- 56:01I've seen that includes not only bed bugs, but
- 56:05flies, lice, mites. I mentioned dust mites earlier.
- 56:09Ants, beetles, roaches, termites, gnats. And
- 56:14my favorite at the end there, moles. So I don't
- 56:18know how big of a problem that is in Southern
- 56:20California, the moles, although we have had gophers.
- 56:25They're there too, just to be safe. So let's
- 56:30go on to the next slide. The next slide is just
- 56:33another example of a vermin exclusion, which
- 56:37is pretty broad. So you have to be on the lookout
- 56:41for that. The next slide, another thing to keep
- 56:44in mind is that, let's go on to the next one,
- 56:49that. In a lot of these cases, under the civil
- 56:52code, the plaintiff can have a right to attorney's
- 56:55fees. And in all, as in all litigation, when
- 56:57that occurs, then it complicates settlement of
- 57:01the case. And the longer the case goes on, the
- 57:05higher the exposure gets. But the typical CGL
- 57:10policy for many years has said that they will
- 57:13not pay for the plaintiff's attorney's fees.
- 57:17So that becomes important. Let's go to the next
- 57:21slide. I'm going to come back to this one. Let's
- 57:26go to the last one. So when it comes time to
- 57:30settle these cases, this is often where it becomes
- 57:33very important to have personal counsel involved,
- 57:37the non -panel counsel, even if there was no
- 57:39independent counsel, right? Because these mediations
- 57:42that happen for settlement of habitability claims
- 57:46of course, involve a negotiation between the
- 57:49plaintiff and the defendant, but they oftentimes
- 57:51also involve some negotiation between the policyholder
- 57:55and the insurance company. If the claim is primarily
- 57:58a mold claim, then they are going to say, well,
- 58:02we need you, Mr. Policyholder, to contribute
- 58:05to make this settlement happen. Or, you know,
- 58:08if a big chunk of the plaintiff's claim is the
- 58:10attorney's fees that have been incurred. Or sometimes,
- 58:15I mentioned multiple policy years. Sometimes
- 58:18a particular year will have a policy with a habitability
- 58:21exclusion, and other years will not have a habitability
- 58:25exclusion. So the carriers that are defending
- 58:29are going to say, well, a quarter of your damages
- 58:32or whatever percentage were in the year where
- 58:35there was a habitability exclusion, and that
- 58:37wasn't us. So you have to contribute to that.
- 58:41The good news is that in my experience, most
- 58:45insurance companies that are defending, they
- 58:47want and maybe need for their file some contribution
- 58:51by the policyholder, but they're not generally
- 58:54looking for huge contributions. They recognize
- 58:58that sometimes that's not possible. you know,
- 59:01or they recognize that, well, the duty to defend
- 59:04is on them. So if they don't put up money, they're
- 59:06going to incur more defense costs. So it's oftentimes
- 59:09possible to get a relatively modest contribution
- 59:13or percentage contribution. But it is often necessary
- 59:16to settle these cases. Let's go back to the prior
- 59:20slide just before we end. And I will take some
- 59:24of the questions, see if we can run through them
- 59:27quickly. I mentioned no coverage for mold, but
- 59:31there is a product out there that's oftentimes
- 59:34called a pollution policy, but it also will cover
- 59:39mold claims that you can pay, you know, it's
- 59:42a separate policy that you can buy. It's not
- 59:45an occurrence based policy. It's a claims made
- 59:47policy, which means that it's going to respond
- 59:49to less claims. And it oftentimes has a pretty
- 59:54high deductible and burning limits, but depending
- 59:59on your risk appetite and what's going on at
- 1:00:01your property, it is an option that you might
- 1:00:03consider. Dan, do you have any comments about
- 1:00:05this type of policy? No, I mean, normally these
- 1:00:08are put in place for commercial risk that have
- 1:00:13exposure to that. They're great policies to put
- 1:00:17in place, but multifamily, I've not seen a lot
- 1:00:19of multifamily with pollution policy in place.
- 1:00:22Okay. Yeah, I have seen at least one client buy
- 1:00:25one because they got burned by so many mold claims
- 1:00:28that they decided that it was worth it to do
- 1:00:31that and burned by the exclusions that had been
- 1:00:34put on their policy. Okay, so that's it for the
- 1:00:37PowerPoint. Let me see if I can get through some
- 1:00:41of these questions. Someone says, I've been noticing
- 1:00:46more surplus lines policies, disclaiming coverage
- 1:00:49on nearly all habitability related claims after
- 1:00:53many primary carriers had left the market. How
- 1:00:55likely do you expect surplus line policies to
- 1:00:59become the predominant coverage for small and
- 1:01:01large buildings? And do you believe that will
- 1:01:03change the habitability landscape? That is the
- 1:01:09space that we're in today. I mean, I always say
- 1:01:12it's... Insurance carriers are capitalistic.
- 1:01:17So the pendulum swings and then obviously there
- 1:01:19was a little bit of a Shock with the fires, but
- 1:01:24there are habitability Endorsements now on surplus
- 1:01:28lines Courage and I as I want I noted I've just
- 1:01:32wrote one the other day that 500 ,000 in in a
- 1:01:36sub limit so but yes, that is that is the issue
- 1:01:41and but you can ask to see if we can get a general
- 1:01:46liability with at least a minimum sublimit. Okay.
- 1:01:52Next question. In addition to claims by miners,
- 1:01:55what about going back under a continuing tort
- 1:01:57theory? So pushing the statute of limitations
- 1:01:59back. My experience for this type of tort, the
- 1:02:06cutoff is generally going to be for property
- 1:02:09damage three years prior. Sometimes there's breach
- 1:02:12of contract claims that go back four years, but
- 1:02:15if it was a continuous leak or something like
- 1:02:17that, I don't think that you can just go back
- 1:02:21forever. There are certain kinds of claims where
- 1:02:25you can go back further, but I don't think this
- 1:02:28is one of them. Next one, can you comment on
- 1:02:32claims for attorney's fees and the conflicts
- 1:02:34that can arise if fees are not covered? I think
- 1:02:37that's what I was just talking. I think they're
- 1:02:38asking about sort of what I was just talking
- 1:02:40about. So hopefully I answered that question.
- 1:02:45Does indemnifying your property manager void
- 1:02:48your insurance coverage? The answer to that is
- 1:02:51no. As I mentioned, the real estate manager,
- 1:02:57property manager is typically automatically uninsured.
- 1:02:59And I think that's partially in recognition of
- 1:03:01the fact that there are often these indemnity
- 1:03:03obligations. There's also something called insured
- 1:03:06contract coverage under most policies, which
- 1:03:09is when you've agreed to indemnify someone. So
- 1:03:11short answer is no, you're okay. But it might
- 1:03:15cut off other avenues for you to bring in other
- 1:03:19insurance to the table when you get to that settlement
- 1:03:22conference or mediation. And how does a plaintiff
- 1:03:27attorney get fees? Well, if they pursue the case
- 1:03:35to its conclusion and they prevail on certain
- 1:03:38claims about habitability, then they have a right
- 1:03:41to make a motion for attorney's fees. And, you
- 1:03:43know, it's the tenant, I mean, the landlord,
- 1:03:48the defendants who are on the hook for that.
- 1:03:51Most of these cases, almost all of these cases
- 1:03:53are as practical as an actual matter are on contingency
- 1:03:56basis. So when they settle, they typically get
- 1:04:00paid out of that settlement. Hopefully that answers
- 1:04:02that question. I think that answers pretty much
- 1:04:07the questions that I can answer here today. So
- 1:04:12we're a couple of minutes over time. So I want
- 1:04:14to say thank you to Dan again. Thank you to the
- 1:04:16Becquiel's Bar, and hope everybody got some value
- 1:04:20out of this presentation. Thanks, everybody.
- 1:04:22Have a good day. Thank you, Steve.