Latest / Psychology In Seattle Podcast / Bigot Therapists (2017 Rerun)
Transcript
- 0:00Hey, deserving listeners, It's just me today. I want to tell you
- 0:03something that I learned recently, and I guess I always sort of knew it,
- 0:08but I'd never really heard stories about it until recently. And so I
- 0:13want to tell you something. Did you know that? Right now in America
- 0:18in the United States, there are counselors and therapists and psychologists who refuse to
- 0:25work with gay clients. They refuse to work with LGBTQ clients. Right now
- 0:33in America, there are licensed professionals who refuse to work with lgbt Q clients.
- 0:39There are students in training programs today who are currently refusing to work with
- 0:48gay clients and LGBTQ clients, often because of religion, often because of Christianity.
- 0:56They have a general, I don't know, disdain for the lgbt community,
- 1:03and that's why they won't treat gay people or LGBTQ people. Or they
- 1:08say things like, I can't just do nothing when I see someone living an
- 1:14immoral lifestyle, you know, they'll say stuff like that. They'll just be
- 1:17like, look, if I have a client that is living a moral lifestyle,
- 1:23I can't just sit by and let them live that terrible lifestyle, I
- 1:26have to do something about it. And they are given clients at internships or
- 1:33practicums or other kinds of settings, like they're given a gay teenager who wants
- 1:40to come out to their family or something, or a gay couple wants to
- 1:44improve their relationship and improve their parenting or something, and these, you know,
- 1:49very rare. I just want to say, they're very rare. Counselors
- 1:53and therapists and psychologists and social workers. These are very rare individuals. But
- 1:57they exist and they're not in the closet anymore, or at least they have
- 2:01them in recently. Well, that's what I want to talk about today.
- 2:06I want to talk about these what I'm calling bigoted therapist. I'm just gonna
- 2:09come out and say that I'm going to use strong language in this podcast because
- 2:13it's my podcast and I can say what I want, and I'm going to
- 2:16say what's on my mind, and I have things on my mind, and
- 2:19I'm not gonna sugarcoat it because I don't think it's I don't think it needs
- 2:27to be sugarcoated. It's just to me, it's a very simple issue.
- 2:32To me, there's no debate, there's no ambiguity. There's no well,
- 2:38you know, there's people on both sides. No, there's people on the
- 2:43right side, and then there's people on the other side. And I'm not
- 2:46going to mince words about this today because it's ridiculous. This is the psychology
- 2:52seat of podcast. I'm your host, Doctor Kirkanda. I'm a therapist and
- 2:54I'm also a licensed I'm a licensed therapist and I'm also a professor. As
- 3:01always in any episode, I should say that everything that I say on this
- 3:07podcast, in every episode is only my opinion and doesn't represent anybody else,
- 3:12just me by myself talking. I don't represent my university, I don't represent
- 3:15my profession, I don't represent my race, I don't represent my gender.
- 3:22I'm just me talking. It's just something I just want to say. I
- 3:25think it's fairly obvious. But okay, so we have what I'm going to
- 3:30call a bigoted therapist. Jennifer Keaton. Jennifer Keaton. She is or was
- 3:38a practicum student at Augusta State University in Georgia and in their counselor Education program.
- 3:46It's a master's degree. So Jennifer Keaton, who I will just refer
- 3:51to as Jennifer Jennifer was a student and she was in the program, and
- 3:58she would tell her classmates all about her views about LGBTQ people. She was
- 4:02apparently a Christian, and she voiced now, I just want to say from
- 4:09the onset about Christians that there are many different kinds of Christians, many different
- 4:14kinds of Muslims, and many different kinds of Jewish people. You know,
- 4:16religion is an extremely diverse set of beliefs and people. And when I say
- 4:26that Jennifer Keaton is Christian, that's her you know, identification. But this,
- 4:31this episode is not an indictment on Christianity or Christian people at all.
- 4:36It's not that at all. Atheist people can be terrible, and Christian people
- 4:42can be terrible, and it just so happens that among terrible Christians they happen
- 4:49to be bigoted. That's not a good way to put it. Well,
- 4:53another thing I should say is that there are plenty of Christians who are not
- 4:58only quote unquote tolerant LGBTQ people, but our advocates and allies of LGBTQQ people.
- 5:04There are also many LGBTQ people who are actual Christians. I have LGBTQ
- 5:11clients who are Christians and who attend church every Sunday. So this is again,
- 5:16this is an indictment on Christianity. All right. So we have Jennifer
- 5:19Keaton, a Christian student attending a university in Georgia and a counselor master's degree
- 5:26program, and she would tell all of her classmates about her views on LGBTQ
- 5:30people, and her views were not very sympathetic. She would voice her disagreement
- 5:39in class discussions about the quote unquote LGBTQ or the gay lifestyle. I just
- 5:45love that term, the lifestyle. It's like when I think a lifestyle,
- 5:49I think of I don't know, like I'm living the tennis lifestyle. I
- 5:57play tennis, I like to wear tennis bracelets, I like to talk about
- 6:01tennis. I like to wear tennis shoes, I like to go to tennis
- 6:05clubs I wear I don't know, Tommy hillfigures that that's more sailing, But
- 6:12anyway, I like the tennis lifestyle and I just like how you know,
- 6:17people in I'm just going to call them bigoted, anti LGBTQ people, they
- 6:24will refer to it as the lifestyle. Right now, I don't know the
- 6:29political correctness of what I'm saying right now. Maybe maybe LGBTQ people call it
- 6:32the lifestyle too. I don't think so. But whatever I hear lifestyle,
- 6:36it tends to become from anti LGBTQ people anyway. So this student, Jennifer,
- 6:42would talk in class about her views against the LGBTQ or gay quote unquote
- 6:49lifestyle. She wrote in several assignments that she would submit to her professors that
- 6:56she disagreed with the LGBTQ quote unquote lifetile style. She said she would not
- 7:02work with LGBTQ clients. She said that LGBTQ people were wrong and that she
- 7:11didn't support that lifestyle. She said that LGBTQ people were just going through a
- 7:16quote unquote identity confusion, which is what a lot of Christian bigots will say.
- 7:25Jennifer also would try to convince her classmates to agree with her point of
- 7:31view, and she would also preach to others about conversion therapy. I think
- 7:38I'll do a whole episode on conversion therapy at some point. But that's the
- 7:42therapy where historically was used in our profession, in which therapists would try to
- 7:48convert homosexuals to being heterosexual. So this student. Jennifer is really coming out
- 7:57all guns of blazon right. She's talking about it in class, she's writing
- 8:01about it in assignments, and I'm just trying to figure out why you would
- 8:05do that. She is adamant about not working with lgbt Q client's. She
- 8:09doesn't support it. She says it's identity confusion. She pathologizes it. She's
- 8:15preaching to other people, she's talking about conversion therapy, and I'm just trying
- 8:20to imagine what I would do with a student like this in my program.
- 8:24To be honest, my knee jerk reaction would be to kick him out of
- 8:26the program. I mean honestly, when I when I heard about the student,
- 8:31I'd be like, oh, if a student that was in my program
- 8:33at Antioch, I would be like, You're gone. You are gonna harm
- 8:37people, and I will figure out a way to get rid of you because
- 8:41I do not want you in my profession. But of course, and I'll
- 8:48get into later on why that is not wise, but but that's my that's
- 8:54my knee jerk reaction. And I was at I was actually at a conference
- 8:58yesterday in which we were talking about stuff like this, and that was what
- 9:03was just going on in my head the whole time. It's like, people
- 9:05like this need to go away. I just don't want them around. But
- 9:09you know, I'll get more into what more wise approaches. But you know,
- 9:16my knee jerk reaction is based on my guess and prediction that this point
- 9:22of view is and this, you know, the student just pontificating and preaching
- 9:28about anti LGBTQ sentiments. I'm just guessing it's the tip of the iceberg.
- 9:33Right. There are plenty of people in the profession who are Christians, and
- 9:39there are plenty of people in the in the profession who are also anti LGBTQ
- 9:45people, but they don't make it known. You know, they'll they'll they'll
- 9:48keep it on the sly and for someone which is still not right and it's
- 9:54still discrimination, it's still wrong, very wrong. But but for someone to
- 10:01be so vocal about it, I would just imagine that it's a tip of
- 10:03the iceberg, you know. So I'm just trying to imagine what I would
- 10:07do with a student like this, and how stressful it would be to have
- 10:11a student like this in the program, because I wouldn't I couldn't let this
- 10:16just you know, I couldn't sweep this under the table. If I had
- 10:18a student that was so vocal about it, I would just be like,
- 10:20man, we got to do something, and this is going to get ugly,
- 10:22you know, because it's so politicized. Right, Okay, Well,
- 10:28what did the program do at Augusta State University in Georgia? What did they
- 10:31do? Well? The faculty told her that she she couldn't complete the degree
- 10:37program if she did not complete a remediation plan. So the faculty, I'm
- 10:43just reading between the lines. They probably initially heard little rumblings of an indication
- 10:52of this in her discussions and in writing assignments. Maybe her advisor had a
- 10:56conversation with her. Some professor said, you know, it seems like there
- 11:00was probably a ramp up. I'm guessing the faculty got together. Usually in
- 11:05these programs, my program is very large at antiok and so we have like,
- 11:09I don't know, twenty or thirty full time faculty, but at maybe
- 11:13twenty. But in other programs they typically are smaller and they tend to have
- 11:18like maybe just three full time faculty. And so I'm just guessing here that
- 11:24the three or four faculty members got together and talked about it and said,
- 11:26you know, we got to do something about this Jennifer student. And I'm
- 11:31guessing some people were talking about, well, let's kick her out and what
- 11:33are we doing, and they're like, well, no, let's give her
- 11:35a chance and let's try to help her. Let's try to help her to
- 11:39grow as a professional. And so they said, well, let's lay out
- 11:43a remediation plan. And this is the remediation plan that they laid out for
- 11:50her. They said that she had to attend three workshops on diversity. So
- 11:56let's just look at that one for a second. Three workshops on diversity.
- 12:01Workshops are usually all day, you know, six hours kind of a thing,
- 12:05and it's on diversity, not on LGBTQ people, it's just diversity,
- 12:09so that you know that's notable, right, So three workshops on diversity,
- 12:15so it's probably three days of classes talking about diversity and marginalization and the history
- 12:24of our country and blah blah blah. Okay, number two. The second
- 12:31thing that they said that she had to do, aside from these workshops was
- 12:35to increase her exposure to the gay population. So they's like, look,
- 12:41just expose yourself to gay people. You need to be you need to know
- 12:45gay people. You need to hang out with gay people and you know,
- 12:48humanize them, because I don't think you understand these people very well. And
- 12:54they suggested that she attend the Gay Pride parade, the Gay Pride parade.
- 13:00So you know, that's a pretty easy thing to do. Just go to
- 13:03the Gay Pride parade for an hour and it's just it's just a parade.
- 13:09You know, it's not that big of a deal. It's just watch a
- 13:11parade, or you know, find a find some gay people and say can
- 13:18I talk with you or something. I don't know, just you know,
- 13:22get some exposure to some gay people, and maybe the maybe the program even
- 13:26said, look, we have volunteers who are gay who would be willing to
- 13:31talk to you. Maybe they had I don't know. So number three they
- 13:33also said, you have to read some articles about lgbt Q clients. Okay,
- 13:39that's pretty pretty easy to do. And number four they said you have
- 13:43to write a monthly two page reflection paper on what you've learned during this process.
- 13:52So so attend some workshops, have some exposure to some gay people,
- 13:58and read some articles, and then write a two page reflection paper. And
- 14:03if you're familiar with reflection papers, then you know exactly what I'm talking about.
- 14:07But if you're not familiar with reflection papers, let me explain what they
- 14:11are. They are basically very easy to write because you just you just sort
- 14:18of put your thoughts to the page. You're just like like, she might
- 14:22go, okay, well, this month, I attended this workshop and this
- 14:26is what I learned. I'm still kind of struggling with this because blah blah
- 14:31blah. But I read this other article and it seems to give me some
- 14:35options here, but I'm still I still don't want to work with LGBTQ clients,
- 14:39and here's my reasons and blah blah blah. So that's It's very It
- 14:43can be very formal, but it can also be very informal, and they
- 14:48usually are very informal, so it's not really a big assignment to say,
- 14:52once a month just you know, write a couple of pages about your experience.
- 14:56And this is these are usually double space to by the way, so
- 15:01it's really just like a page of thoughts. So that's the remediation plan.
- 15:07They also had her work on her writing. They needed they as a second
- 15:13as a part of her remediation that was independent from the LGBTQ issue was that
- 15:18they said, you also need to figure out a way to improve your writing,
- 15:20which I just have to say, as a professor and as a former
- 15:24program director, that's something that we're always dealing with. The It's one of
- 15:31the biggest thorns on our side with students is like the occasional students, it's
- 15:35usually like I don't know one in I don't know one and thirty of our
- 15:39students will have significant writing issues that need remediation because in a counseling training program,
- 15:50well our and a lot of counseling training programs, but particularly ours at
- 15:54Antioch University Seattle, we don't have any tests or there's very few tests,
- 16:00so let's put it that way. There's there's the only tests we have are
- 16:03basically related to test prep for the National exam want to get licensed. But
- 16:07all the other classes are all either experiential base or writing base, so you
- 16:11either write a paper or you have to perform something in class, or you
- 16:15know, like a presentation or a demonstration of some kind, and so when
- 16:22students have problems with their writing, everything falls apart, you know. So,
- 16:27so they also said that she needed to work on her writing, which
- 16:30is just sort of a secondary issue to this discussion. But anyway, so
- 16:36when I look at this remediation plan that the faculty laid out for, they're
- 16:37like, look, okay, we got the student that's like extremely vocal about
- 16:41the fact that she won't work with LGBTQ people. This is wrong. It's
- 16:47against the standard of care. It's discriminatory, it is against all the ethical
- 16:52codes. It's you know, it's it indicates some kind of weird thing that
- 17:00she has about particular groups of people. That's just not okay for a clinician
- 17:04to be that way. You know, imagine if a heart surgeon said I
- 17:11don't work with Muslims, or I'm not going to treat redheads, or I'm
- 17:15not going to treat women, or I'm not going to treat black people.
- 17:18Like, no, you can't effing do that. It's not right. It's
- 17:23not American, it's antithetical to Americanism. It's not okay. And so anyway,
- 17:33the faculty, you are looking at the student, Jennifer Keaton, and
- 17:36like, okay, this is you know, she's being discriminatory. What are
- 17:38we going to do, well, what will help her to change? You
- 17:44know? How can we get her to change, because that's that's what we
- 17:45want her to do. We you know that the whole idea with competency based
- 17:51education is that you take someone wherever they're at and you try to make them
- 17:56more competent. You know, you're not looking looking for ways to get rid
- 18:00of someone. You're always looking for ways to help helping them succeed. And
- 18:03so this remediation program addresses that. They're saying, Look, I'm guessing that
- 18:11if this student goes to some workshops, hangs out with some gay people,
- 18:18thinks about this a little bit, maybe read some articles, I'm guessing that
- 18:22she'll loosen up a bit, or at least it'll give her an opportunity to
- 18:25loosen up a bit. And I've seen this happen. I've seen this happen
- 18:29to people where they are quintessentially heterosexist and homophobic and they get a little bit
- 18:37of exposure to some gay people or LGBTQ people they hang out with. Even
- 18:41they actually did, there was this American life about this, I think,
- 18:48in which gay people went door to door and talked to voters who were anti
- 18:53gay people and said, I'm gay. You know, there's like, I'm
- 18:57a gay person. I just want to say that I'd really love it if
- 19:00you voted for this pro gay legislation or something and like it affected people people.
- 19:08I wonder I always wonder what would happen if we just took all the
- 19:12bigots of the world and made them hang out with whoever they're bigoted against.
- 19:18Just make them hang out with that person, like for a couple hours,
- 19:22you know, have a joint together, have a beer together, have a
- 19:26walk together, play chess together, whatever, just do something in a room
- 19:33by yourself. And I just have I've seen it happen so many times.
- 19:37People's bigoted attitudes just wash away. Bigotry breeds within isolation. That's why so
- 19:47many people in America right now hate Mexicans and hate Muslims in communities in which
- 19:53there are no Mexicans and no Muslims. There are people in rural America right
- 19:59now who have extreme views against Muslims and and Mexicans. And it's and it's
- 20:07empirically shown that they've never the community has never seen a Muslim. I've never
- 20:11seen a Mexican immigrant anyway anyway, So that's what they decided to do.
- 20:18They're like, hey, how about you know, we just exposed this girl
- 20:22to some gay people and maybe maybe that will fix it. So so that's
- 20:27what they did. And if now in this moment, so let's put ourselves
- 20:33in Jennifer Keaton's shoes. You're very adamant against LGBTQ people, and your and
- 20:41your program is telling you, look, here's a pretty mild remediation plan,
- 20:47and all you gotta do is do this or else you're going to be kicked
- 20:52out of the program. Now, she probably wasn't thinking, yay, an
- 20:56opportunity to grow, you know, That's probably not what she was thinking.
- 21:00She's probably thinking, God, damn it, this liberal leftist, obamunist program
- 21:07is gonna there, you know, a war on Christmas, war on Christianity.
- 21:17Well, all she's got to do at that point is to be like,
- 21:18you know what, I'm going to go through the motions, I'll say
- 21:21what they want to hear, and then I'll figure something out later. That's
- 21:26all she had to do. And I'm guessing a number of students will will
- 21:30do that about it. They'll just be like, ah, look, this
- 21:33is my religious belief, but it's probably not going to go over well in
- 21:37this program or any program. And so rather than drag myself down and everyone
- 21:45else with me, I'll just go through the motions and then I'll quietly refer
- 21:52LGBTQ clients. And because because that's the thing. If you hate LGBTQ people
- 22:00and there are counselors out there that do, or at least feel very uncomfortable
- 22:03around it, let's just put it that way. All you got to do
- 22:07is quietly refer those people out, and no one will be the wiser that
- 22:11you're a bigot. All you got to do is say like, my practice
- 22:15is full or well, you know, it's not really my expertise this issue
- 22:19that they're presenting. I just don't feel really comfortable, and I'd be doing
- 22:23you a disservice if I treated you. But here's some colleagues that I think
- 22:27are much more suited to what you're talking about and to your presentation. You
- 22:32don't even have to identify the LGBTQ element as the thing that you're referring the
- 22:36person for You could just you could just say an umbrella a statement like,
- 22:41yeah, your overall presentation leads me to believe that I'm not the best person
- 22:45for you, and I'd be doing you a disservice. And there are people
- 22:48who do stuff like that all the time for all sorts of reasons, like
- 22:52if someone doesn't want to work with a domestic violence perpetrator, or someone doesn't
- 22:56want to work with a sexual violence perpetrator, or someone doesn't want to work
- 23:03with an elderly person or someone not because they don't like elderly people, but
- 23:07they just feel like they don't really understand that sort of you know what.
- 23:08There are people who specialize in older adults. There are people who like for
- 23:15me, I don't like working with eating disorder people anymore. I used to,
- 23:21but I don't like to anymore. Not because I don't like people with
- 23:23eating disorders, but because of the extreme eating disordered people that I worked with.
- 23:32They required hours and hours of my time each week that was unpaid,
- 23:37and that's just not the kind of career I want to have. I ended
- 23:42up doing a lot of social work, essentially a lot of casework for those
- 23:47kinds of clients. I was calling the doctor, I was calling the dietician.
- 23:49I was calling the family. I was calling the day treatment center.
- 23:52I was calling her, I was calling the hospital, I was calling her
- 23:57partner. I was calling her friends, like I became a wrap around service
- 24:03coordinator and I'm in private practice and I don't have time for that, and
- 24:07it's not something I want to do. Now. You could easily make an
- 24:11argument that it's discriminatory, but it's just a professional choice that I just make.
- 24:18Another thing is is Throughout my career, I have always referred infants.
- 24:23Very occasionally, someone will refer an infant to me, a two year old,
- 24:26a one year old, a four year old, And in the beginning
- 24:30of my career I did work with infants, but over time I just I
- 24:33figured out for myself that it's not really my thing. I could work with
- 24:38four year olds. I can, I'm capable of it, but I just
- 24:44don't. It's not my thing. There are people who really like working with
- 24:47four year olds and therefore are better suited for that, and obviously over time
- 24:52they gain much more expertise than I have. Plus, I don't have an
- 24:56office that's set up for four year olds. You need an off that has
- 25:00a pretty big play area. You need to have toys that are kids safe.
- 25:04You need to have the corners of your desk need to be rounded off
- 25:10so that falling kids don't brain themselves. There's a lot of So the point
- 25:15is is in our profession, plenty of people will say I prefer not to
- 25:19work with these people. Now, if you in the conference that I went
- 25:26to this there was this lawyer therapist that was talking, and what he was
- 25:30saying was, if I said, I refuse to work with infants, or
- 25:34I refuse to work with people with eating disorders, or I refuse to work
- 25:41with elderly people. Now, I personally love working with elderly people, so
- 25:45it's not my thing. But if someone were to say I refuse to work
- 25:48with people over seventy or eighty years old, and you can't make me,
- 25:53then that can actually potentially be seen as discriminatory, depending on the laws in
- 25:57your area about protected groups of people. But if you say to the person,
- 26:04look, I'm probably not the best person for you, and in Seattle
- 26:08there are thousands of other therapists, many of which are much more suited for
- 26:15you. So here's some referrals. I recommend that you go to these other
- 26:19people. But but if you're going to force me to work with you,
- 26:26then then I will I will work with you. So now most clients in
- 26:30that situation would be like, oh, well, I'm not going to work
- 26:32with you because you're telling me clearly that you're not the best person for me,
- 26:36so I'll find someone else. So that is not discriminatory. You're just
- 26:41highly recommending that they go somewhere else, and you're not refusing them service.
- 26:45You're not saying I'm not going to work with you. You know, it's
- 26:48akin to McDonald's having a policy that you can't eat at their restaurant if you're
- 26:56over seventy years old. Right, it has can't discriminate against people In America
- 27:03and in most states, you can't say you can't refuse service to someone.
- 27:07And so as a therapist, you can't refuse service to somebody. You can't
- 27:11just be like, no because of your identification, because you're gay, or
- 27:15because you're a woman, or because you're black. I refuse to work with
- 27:21you. I'm just and you can't make me and I refuse to get competent
- 27:25in that area. If you say that kind of stuff, then you're discriminatory
- 27:29and you could be sued. But if you say, look, I because
- 27:33I grew up in an all white neighborhood and i've you know, had all
- 27:40white clients. You African American, I'm telling you, like, I'm guessing
- 27:45you have issues that are particular to you that I just have no idea what
- 27:49I'm doing with and I'm probably not going to be the best therapist for you.
- 27:55Now, as I say that out loud, it sounds ridiculous. But
- 28:00but anyway, the way the lawyer said it to me, he was saying
- 28:03that you can say things, but I'll get into more of that after the
- 28:07break. So let's take a break. So what did she do? They
- 28:15give her this remediation plan. Tend some workshops, get some exposure to some
- 28:19gay populations, read some articles, write some reflection papers. What does she
- 28:25do? Well? At first she agreed to it. At first she's like,
- 28:26okay, fine, But then she goes home and then she comes back
- 28:33and she changes her mind. She sends an email She's like, I changed
- 28:34my mind. I'm not going to do this. You're infringing on my First
- 28:37Amendment rights. Blah blah. So I'm reading between the lines here. I'm
- 28:44speculating based on limited information, but I'm guessing what happened as she went home
- 28:49and she told people, maybe even people at her church, and they said,
- 28:56that is discrimination and you have rights and you shouldn't have agreed to that,
- 29:02and let me connect you with some lawyers who can help you out.
- 29:06And then the lawyers routed them to what's called the Alliance Defense Fund, which
- 29:12is headquartered in Scottsdale, Arizona. It's now called the Alliance Defending Freedom.
- 29:17I think it's called, but anyway, Alliance Defense Fund, Alliance Defending Freedom.
- 29:22It's an American conservative Christian organization and they do a number of different quote
- 29:27unquote advocacy, but they also fund lawsuits on these sorts of issues, on
- 29:33what they call religious freedom. And they offered to fund a lawsuit for Jennifer
- 29:38Keaton against Augusta State University. They've actually, incidentally, they've been funding a
- 29:48lot of suits, lawsuits like this, so they have, they've been funding
- 29:53a number. So apparently a number of bigoted trainees are fusing to work with
- 30:00LGBTQ clients and being kicked out of programs or being imposed with sanctions, and
- 30:08they are being routed to this Alliance Defense Fund, and the Alliance Defense Fund
- 30:14is funding all of these lawsuits against these programs. Which I have to say
- 30:18as a former program director of a program of a training program who has been
- 30:23sued before, which I'll get into later. Many times, I mean not
- 30:26many times, but a handful of times. I can tell you that being
- 30:30sued is extremely bothersome. It is not a nice experience to go through.
- 30:34We always win, I just want to cut to the chase. That my
- 30:38program always wins is the ones I've been involved in. But it's not without
- 30:45its stress and without its toll. But anyway, so this Alliance Defense Fund
- 30:52sweeps in Andre like, hey, Jennifer, you are a good case that
- 30:56we want to fund because we want to strike back at the leftist Obamianism in
- 31:02our country. Okay, so she initially again, she initially agreed, but
- 31:07then she withdrew and she said that she was going to sue. So she
- 31:12sued. And the lawyer said that the program, the training program, was
- 31:18requiring her to change her Christian beliefs, and they're saying that's an infringement on
- 31:23her first amendent rights. They're saying, you can't you can't impose this remediation
- 31:27program because you're basically making her change her her religious beliefs around LGBTQ people.
- 31:37Jennifer made a video online and she said, I want to stay in the
- 31:41school counseling program. But I can't honestly complete the remediation program knowing that I
- 31:47would have to alter my beliefs unquote. So now on the side of Jennifer,
- 31:56what the debate would be is that, look, she has her she's
- 32:00a Christian, and she, in her belief in her religion, says that
- 32:06LGBTQ people are sinding their immoral and they need to be changed, and that's
- 32:15her religious belief and you can't and you can't make her change that. You
- 32:20know, it'd be akin to saying to a Muslim that they can't be a
- 32:22Muslim anymore, or to a Jewish person that can't be Jewish, or to
- 32:27a Christian person that they can't believe in God. Can't You can't change someone's
- 32:31religious beliefs, and the program is trying to do that. And also she's
- 32:39not hiding her belief system. She's saying, look, I believe in this,
- 32:44and therefore you shouldn't give me LGBTQ clients. She wasn't saying, let
- 32:50me see all the gay clients because I want to convert them. She was
- 32:52just saying, look, don't give me any gay clients because I believe that
- 32:57it's morally wrong, and if you do give them to me, I might
- 33:00try to convert them. So she's being completely open, she's not hiding anything.
- 33:07And really, when you add up all the potential clients that she would
- 33:10get while she was at her practicum at the university, you know a small
- 33:15percentage of them would have been LGBTQ anyway, and of those they could have
- 33:20been referred. So that's the argument for her. That's what the lawyers are
- 33:23saying. Well, what the school officials and the school lawyers were saying was
- 33:31that, look, we're not trying to change her religious views. We have
- 33:37no interest in changing her religious beliefs, but it's unethical for her to apply
- 33:43her own personal viewpoints to other people. It's unethical for any therapist to impose
- 33:50their religious beliefs on other people. You can't do that. It's also unethical
- 33:53for counselors to refuse to accept particular kinds of clients who have different values than
- 34:02hers. You can't just discriminate against someone because of who they are, you
- 34:08know what their views are. It's unethical and you can't do that. You
- 34:13can have your beliefs, that's fine, but you can't discriminate against people.
- 34:17You know, if your religion says that black people should be killed, that's
- 34:22fine. You can have that belief. It's a ridiculous belief. But if
- 34:24that's your belief, then fine, but you can't go. But that doesn't
- 34:28give you the right to go kill people, right, it doesn't give you
- 34:30the right to kill black people. Well, you can believe that LGBTQ people
- 34:35are going to hell. You can believe that. That's You're totally entitled under
- 34:39the Constitution to have that belief. But you can't discriminate against LGBTQ people.
- 34:45That is not okay, and that is unconstitutional. Also, to be a
- 34:52competent therapist, you have to learn how to work with everybody you have,
- 34:57as every profession in mental health states at this point, according to accreditation standards,
- 35:05according to ethical standards, according to the standards of practice. You need
- 35:08to learn how to work with different groups of people. You can't just say
- 35:13I as a privileged white American, I only am going to work with other
- 35:17privileged, other privileged, dominant groups of people. That's just not okay.
- 35:21You can't do that. Also, you can't arbitrarily decide that a particular group
- 35:29of people's pathological and unworthy of treatment. That's not it's not okay, that's
- 35:34discriminatory, And the program was saying that, look, we're applying this to
- 35:40all students. This isn't just for Jennifer. If any student had something like
- 35:45this, we would apply a remediation plan that was similar to this. This
- 35:49isn't just for Christians, and this isn't just for people who disliked LGBTQ people.
- 35:54This is for anyone who said who would say anything about any group of
- 35:58people. That's that's what our program does. So we're not this is we're
- 36:01applying our rules that we have established to all of our students, including Jennifer.
- 36:07So that's an important legal distinction because if they just attacked her and you
- 36:15know, for this particular belief, then they don't have a fair policy.
- 36:19Right. So they're saying, look, you know, we have a general
- 36:21policy towards any discrimination, and we're applying this policy to her and to all
- 36:29of you. Because I know you're out there, professors of programs, make
- 36:34sure because I've been through this myself as a program director, make sure that
- 36:38in your policies and in your handbooks and in your accreditation self studies that you
- 36:44have language around this sort of thing that specifically lays out your policy, and
- 36:52you tell students about this in the orientation and it's you know in the student
- 36:54handbook that if they discriminate against a particular group of people such as LGBTQ people,
- 37:01then they will be subjected to our mediation plan. And if they do
- 37:06not adhere to their mediation plan or don't fulfill their remediation plan satisfactorily as determined
- 37:12by a committee of professors, then you will be removed from the program.
- 37:17You have to have that explicitly laid out in your policies. You can't just
- 37:22have it in your head. That's one thing as a program director for myself,
- 37:27I have pulled hair out about because before I was program director, God
- 37:31bless him, Paul David, my mentor. He gave me the position of
- 37:36program director, and he was program director of my program for decades, and
- 37:43everything was in his head. And that's kind of the way he liked it.
- 37:45I think he didn't really or let's say, he didn't prefer to write
- 37:50things down. Let's just put it that way. And so when we ran
- 37:52into situations like this, he would just sort of enact how he felt the
- 37:59situation, you know, what the situation needed, and a lot of times
- 38:01it was great. But when we ended up becoming under scrutiny like in a
- 38:07lawsuit, it was hard to justify our actions because we didn't have anything written
- 38:13down. And so I a few years ago just started writing everything down.
- 38:16Actually I started writing things down like ten years ago, but I wreck.
- 38:22And when you go to court and you have these policies, it really helps
- 38:28if you end up getting sued. Plus, it just makes sense that you
- 38:30would publish your policies and have them reviewable by students and faculty anyway. So
- 38:37just make sure you have that kind of stuff. And it seemed that Augusta
- 38:40State University may have had that material available, which helped their case. So
- 38:47the other thing that they look toward is the American Counseling Association because this was
- 38:53a counseling training program within the field of mental health counseling. And so they
- 39:00they're saying, look, all students are taught the fundamentals of the American Counseling
- 39:07Association, including that counselors must support their client's welfare, they must promote client's
- 39:15growth, they must respect client's dignity, they must support client's autonomy, and
- 39:22they must help clients pursue their own goals for counseling. So this is an
- 39:29ethical responsibility. It's also one of the core competencies in the ACA. I'm
- 39:35guessing in my field marriage of family therapy as well. And so the program's
- 39:39saying, look, we're not just arbitrarily imposing this remediation plan on the student
- 39:45because we thought it was okay. We're doing it because we think it's okay.
- 39:50But we also are doing it because our larger umbrella organization, the American
- 39:53Counseling Association, lays this out pretty clearly. Also, they're saying that our
- 40:00curriculum requires that all students be competent to work with all populations. It's clear
- 40:05in our curriculum that you need to learn how to work with all populations.
- 40:08And it's also clear in our curriculum that students don't impose their personal religious values
- 40:14on other clients. They also said that she was completely free to express her
- 40:20disagreement with the curriculum, and she's completely free to disagree with the ethical requirements
- 40:24of the American Counseling Association. So we're not impinging on her freedom of speech
- 40:30and her freedom of religion. She can have her religion, and she can
- 40:32talk about her religion. That is fine, but she can't block our attempts
- 40:37to ensure that she abides by the standard of care and by our ethical standards.
- 40:44If she wants to graduate from our program. She has to learn how
- 40:47to work with all kinds of clients, including lgbt clients. She can continue
- 40:52to believe that LGBTQ people are going to hell, she can completely continue to
- 40:59talk about that point of view, she can say it whatever, but she
- 41:01can't. But she has to learn how to work with these people, and
- 41:05she has to learn how to work ethically and effectively with these people. She
- 41:08can't, you know. So that's what they're saying. Saying it has nothing
- 41:12to do with the First Amendment. This has to do with professional standards and
- 41:15accreditation standards and ethical standards. Okay, so that's the two sides. Now,
- 41:21who won? Remember this is Georgia, right, Just keep that in
- 41:24mind. Who won? Do you think Jennifer won? Or do you think
- 41:27the university one? Well, drum roll da da da da da the school
- 41:31one? Yay. The judge found that the university's rules did not violate her
- 41:37religious rights. The judge said that actually wrote an email to the judge today's
- 41:43thanking him for this, for this judgment, I feel like people like this
- 41:47should be congratulated or honored in some way. The judge said that Jennifer was
- 41:58conflating her personal views with her professional values. Essentially, what the judge was
- 42:02saying was that just because you believe that you're just because you believe that LGBTQ
- 42:08people are immoral, just because you believe that doesn't make that it's doesn't mean
- 42:15that it's true. He was using language he's actually a really good writer,
- 42:20and I'll quote him in a second and you'll realize that his official statement on
- 42:24this case is eloquent, But he basically was saying, Look, just because
- 42:30you believe this to be true doesn't make it true. Just because your religion
- 42:34says that LGBTQ people are a moral doesn't mean that they're actually a moral.
- 42:38It just means that that's your belief system. You know it. You know,
- 42:42just because you believe that the end of the world is coming next year
- 42:45doesn't mean that the end of the world is coming next year. Just because
- 42:49you believe that the Earth is six thousand years old does not make the earth
- 42:52six thousand years old, which I find to be such an interesting thing for
- 42:57a judge to say, you know, okay, this all reminds me of
- 43:01that Built a Spill song where he's like, just because you believe it doesn't
- 43:09make it anyway, all right, So, quoting the judge here, the
- 43:14policies which govern the ethical conduct of counselors, with their focus on client welfare
- 43:20and self determination, make clear that the counselor's professional environs are not intended to
- 43:25be a crucible for counselors to test metaphysical or moral propositions. Just love that
- 43:32language. He's essentially saying that her weird religious belief doesn't preclude her professional responsibility
- 43:39to client welfare and to client self determination. So, just because you believe
- 43:44that LGBTQ people are a moral doesn't doesn't eliminate or preclude your professional responsibility to
- 43:52help people, to help your clients, and to allow clients to choose their
- 43:57own life. That you know, that's you can't make clients engage in conversion
- 44:02therapy just because you think that that's the best thing. It's not. Okay,
- 44:08here's another quote here. One conspicuous and abiding theme of the American story
- 44:15is that individuals like Jennifer Keaton are free to choose their own spiritual path.
- 44:21The Constitution guarantees that the heart may pulse to matters of its own design,
- 44:27death to public cadence. But when affairs of the conscious ripen into action,
- 44:34government is granted leave to regulate in behalf of certain public interests, including education
- 44:39and professional fitness. Unquote. I just again, just great. I just
- 44:44love this stuff. It should be etched in stone. So I just want
- 44:49to say this again. One conspicuous and abiding theme of the American story.
- 44:55I just one conspicuous and abiding theme of the Americans story is that individuals like
- 45:01Jennifer Keaton are free to choose their own spiritual path. You know, it's
- 45:07it's it's an inalienable right for Americans to choose their own religion. But he
- 45:15goes on then, and he goes on. The Constitution guarantees that the heart
- 45:20may pulse to meters to I think he said matters before meters is even better.
- 45:25The Constitution guarantees that the heart may pulse to meters of its own design,
- 45:30death to public cadence. So he brings in this metaphor of music.
- 45:37You know, the Constitution guarantees the heart may pulse to meters of its own
- 45:42design, death to public cadence. So great, But he goes on,
- 45:47But when affairs of the conscience ripen into action, government is granted leave to
- 45:55regulate in behalf of certain public interests, including education and professional fitness. In
- 46:02other words, what he's saying here is you can believe whatever you want.
- 46:07You're free to have whatever religious beliefs you want, but when your beliefs interfere
- 46:10with education and with professional competence, then the government may intervene. Howelujah,
- 46:20okay. So in summary, according to the court, this and according to
- 46:23this court precedent, by the way, because this is what I think,
- 46:25this establishes a president in Georgia that might generalize to the rest of the country.
- 46:32Just because you believe something doesn't make it true. I like that one.
- 46:38Also, the judge implied that there's really no empirical support that LGBTQ people
- 46:45are immoral or wrong. So another thing that this precedent is saying is that
- 46:52people are free to have whatever religious beliefs they want, but they have to
- 46:55put those aside. If those religious beliefs interfere with clients wealth welfare or client
- 47:00self determination, or educational standards or professional standards. So that's a that's a
- 47:07very important fight. It's a very important precedent. You can have whatever belief
- 47:12you want, but if that interferes with the profession and with the educational standards,
- 47:16then then you have to do Then you're you you you are subject to
- 47:22remediation essentially. Also that uh, the press. Another precedent that this sets
- 47:31is that it's reasonable to limit someone's religious freedom in this way. That it's
- 47:39it's it's a reasonable limitation to their freedom of speech and their freedom of religion.
- 47:47So the court isn't saying that it's okay for a university to force someone
- 47:51to change their opinion about something, but they are saying that it's okay for
- 47:54a university to impose remediation to help a student adhere to the standards of the
- 48:00program, as long as the standards are reasonable and standard to the profession.
- 48:06Okay, So what did Jennifer and the Christian organization that was funding her.
- 48:13What do they do? Did they say, well, you win, thank
- 48:15you very much. Nope, they appealed, of course, and guess what
- 48:19they lost again. And I read some of the briefs in some of the
- 48:24opinions of the judges and stuff, and I just have to say one thing.
- 48:29I want to go on a little tangent here. After going through different
- 48:32lawsuits myself, I can tell you that a lot of times what happens in
- 48:37these situations is the defense calls the university program will call upon their accreditation standards
- 48:46as justification for taking actions like this against students, which is what the Augusta
- 48:53State University did. Augusta Augusta, Augusta State University, let me loot gust
- 49:01Us at university. Yeah, so that's what they did, and their their
- 49:07lawyers really pulled from the American Counseling Association accreditation standards as justification for requiring Jennifer
- 49:16to engage in this remediation program. And when I've been in lawsuits myself as
- 49:23a part of the university, that's a big part of our defense. In
- 49:27fact, it's the main defense really is like looking towards our accreditation standards and
- 49:30saying, look, we have to adhere to these accreditation standards and in order
- 49:35to remain accredited, and so therefore it's our hands are tied. We have
- 49:38to do this sort of stuff to our students. And I just have to
- 49:43say that doesn't make a lot of sense to me, because accreditation is great
- 49:49and it's important, but it's not As a program director, former program director,
- 49:53I felt that our program was our program and that the accreditation body accredit,
- 50:00which is great, and by accrediting us, they were signing off that
- 50:05they had checked on us and are saying that we're a legitimate marriage family therapy
- 50:09program that adheres to minimum standards. But those are just minimum standards, you
- 50:15know, they're not these standards. You can become accredited as a counseling program
- 50:20and still be really really shitty. Believe me. You can be accredited and
- 50:24be terrible. So accreditation really has you know, it's an indication, as
- 50:29I've talked about another podcast before, it's an indication of potential quality, but
- 50:36it's not a guarantee by any means. And also, there are programs out
- 50:38there that are not accredited that are very high quality. So accreditation is not
- 50:45as big of a deal as the courts make it out to be. And
- 50:49in my opinion, and really I think just reason should rule right, we
- 50:53shouldn't have to say, look, we are forced to do this by our
- 50:58crediting body, therefore taking easy on us. I don't think we should we
- 51:00should have to say this. What we should be able to say is,
- 51:02look, we have a student here who is refused, who is discriminating against
- 51:07a marginalized group of people, and therefore that's wrong. And we gave her
- 51:13a chance to change her attitude about this and she refused to do it,
- 51:16and that that should stand on its own. We shouldn't have to call upon
- 51:21the American Counseling Association to justify our actions. The actions stand on its own,
- 51:25because it's so obvious. Again, if I changed the group of people
- 51:30and said Jennifer Keaton refused to work with black people, would that doesn't stand.
- 51:37We don't need to look toward our crediting bodies to justify our actions.
- 51:40It just is obvious. That is that that that, of course, a
- 51:45counseling training program would be in the right to impose a mild remediation program on
- 51:52her. And by the way, the remediation program said nothing about changing your
- 51:58attitudes and said nothing about actually change her ability to work with LGBTQ people.
- 52:01You know, the remediation program plan didn't say and at the end you have
- 52:07to work with LGBTQ people. I didn't say that. It just said you
- 52:10just have to expose yourself to gay people. You have to take some workshops,
- 52:14you have to read some articles, and you have to write some reflection
- 52:15papers. That's it. My guess is that the faculty astutely surmised that Jennifer
- 52:23would in the end loosen up, which is what I was saying earlier.
- 52:28So I just want to I just have that little rant that I don't understand
- 52:35this obsession with the accrediting bodies as the main piece of defense. But anyway,
- 52:44so I want to take a break, and after the break IM going
- 52:46to talk about another case that actually went differently. So let's take a break.
- 52:54All right, we're back from the break again. Remember that this episode
- 52:58is brought to you by talk Space. Used the promo code kirk ki RK
- 53:04for a discount and also to signal to talkspace that you are one of my
- 53:07listeners. So if you're looking for a counselor go to talkspace. All right,
- 53:14So that's what I happened with Julie. With Jennifer Keaton is she was
- 53:20very vocal about LGBTQ anti LGBTQ sentiments, and then they imposed a mild remediation
- 53:29plan, and then the Alliance Defending Freedom Fund people came in and funded a
- 53:38lawsuit. They lost, they appealed that they lost again. All right,
- 53:44let's go to another case. This is in Michigan. At Eastern Michigan University,
- 53:50a counseling trainee by the name of Julia Ward. Julia Ward. Julia
- 53:57was at her internship and she received to client file and she has similar,
- 54:04if not identical beliefs to Jennifer, by the way, about LGBTQ people,
- 54:07and she read. So Julia reads in the client file, She's like,
- 54:13Oh, this person, I wonder what's up with them. And she reads
- 54:15that this client he had been counseled before about a sex same sex relation,
- 54:22same sex relationship. So she's like, oh, this guy looks like he
- 54:25might be gay. And so she went to her supervisor at the internship and
- 54:30she said, in accordance with my beliefs, I am not able to counsel
- 54:35this client and I need to refer this client to someone else. Okay.
- 54:40So the university responded by, well, so again, let's pause here for
- 54:46a second and think what, you know, what do we do here?
- 54:51We have an intern that's saying, this client looks gay to me, I'm
- 54:54not going to work with this client. I need I need someone else to
- 54:58see this client. So first, this looks very similar to the Jennifer Keaton
- 55:01situation. Right, we have a bigoted therapist and they're saying that they're not
- 55:08going to work with this person. They're refusing service based on prejudice and discrimination
- 55:14and bigotry, that they're not going to work with that person. Very you
- 55:17know, seems very similar to the Jennifer Keaton case. But is it?
- 55:21So let's look up all right, So university decide, they get together and
- 55:25they determined that she was discriminating against this client and they expelled her. They
- 55:32just there was no remediation. They just kicked her out of the program.
- 55:37So Julia sues and she a similar situation. She claims that she was being
- 55:44singled out for a religious belief. She says that, you know, this
- 55:47is discrimination based on her religion. She says that it's her first amendent right
- 55:52to say whatever she wants to say. So at first, we might think
- 55:58that this, this Julia case is similar to the Jennifer case and she lost.
- 56:04But but again this case is different. There was no remediation plan.
- 56:08There was also no refusal to participate in a remediation plan because there was no
- 56:14there was no remediation plan offered, and there was no expressed interest in conversion
- 56:19therapy. She she just wanted to refer the LGBTQ client. She wasn't saying
- 56:24she was in She wasn't saying I'm gonna engage if you do give me this
- 56:28client, I'm going to engage in an ethical practice. She's just saying,
- 56:31look, I just I just can't work with this person. You need to
- 56:34take You need to send this person to someone else. Also, Julia,
- 56:37from what it seems, was not vocal about her viewpoint. She she just
- 56:43she kept it on the DL and when she was given a gay client that
- 56:46might have been the first time she indicated her preference at all, and she
- 56:50just she just referred. Whereas Jennifer Keaton at the Augusta State University case,
- 56:55Jennifer Keaton, before even bumping up against the remediation plan, had repeatedly talked
- 57:02in class and repeatedly written in assignments, and repeatedly talked with students outside of
- 57:07class about her anti gay attitudes and about her her affinity to conversion therapy.
- 57:15So this is really a different situation. So I believe that they're they're the
- 57:22first hearing. They actually threw it out, they dismissed the lawsuit and cided
- 57:30on the side of Eastern Michigan University, and then I think Julia and her
- 57:37team of people appealed, and as they were heading toward the appeal, Eastern
- 57:45Michigan decided to settle, and they settled for seventy five thousand dollars, which
- 57:51is similar to tuition, which I have to say is a pretty low amount
- 57:57when you consider other kinds of judgments like this, because you can one so
- 58:02one the legal costs for an appeal like this could be hundreds of thousands of
- 58:08dollars for a university. Two, if they lost the case, they could
- 58:14have been they would have they might had they might have had to give up
- 58:16hundreds of thousands, not millions of dollars. So seventy five So settling for
- 58:21seventy five grand is is considered, probably by the university to be a win
- 58:27for the university because they're just like, look, if we can just pay
- 58:30seventy five grand and have this be over and just put this behind us.
- 58:34Then that is money well spent, because we don't have to buy any more
- 58:38lawyers anymore, and we don't have to spend any more time with this.
- 58:40We don't have to risk a terrible judgment by the judgment. But also it
- 58:46appears that the consensus is that Eastern Michigan University didn't have a very good case
- 58:54and was heading into the court proceeding in a lesser position, in a weaker
- 59:01position, and so they settled it. According to some people, their opinion
- 59:08is they settled because they weren't likely to win. And so the difference here
- 59:17is that with Julia, the university expelled her very quickly, right, they
- 59:25didn't. They didn't give her a remediation plan. Also, there was they
- 59:32didn't know really why she was referring. So, again, as I was
- 59:37talking about earlier, people are completely free to refer clients that they don't believe
- 59:44they're going to be very much good with. Right. There are people who,
- 59:49like I say, I refer eating disorder clients, or I refer infants,
- 59:52right, and I refer young children. Now, I used to see
- 59:58infants. I used to see young children. I don't any I don't have
- 1:00:00an office setup for it. I'm sort of out of practice with that kind
- 1:00:02of thing, and so I refer people like that. Is that discrimination?
- 1:00:08Well, it's referring. It's in the best answers of the client that they
- 1:00:15go somewhere else. And there are plenty of other clinicians in Seattle that specialize
- 1:00:20in that sort of thing. Now, at the conference I was at yesterday,
- 1:00:24they were talking about, well, what if you're in a rural context
- 1:00:30and you're the only counselor for one hundred miles around, Well can you refer
- 1:00:35people? And what the lawyer counselor was saying was you actually might have to
- 1:00:40take every client that comes your way if you live in a small community,
- 1:00:44because you can't. You can't refuse service to somebody based on their identification or
- 1:00:51even necessarily their disorder, because that could be considered discrimination. So if you
- 1:00:58live in a very small community, might be kind of screwed when it comes
- 1:01:00to this sort of thing. At least that's what he was saying. But
- 1:01:04anyway, I live in a big city with thousands of therapists, and so
- 1:01:07it's completely it's not harming the client by referring the client somewhere else. But
- 1:01:16again, I'm not saying that I won't work with an infant. I'm not
- 1:01:21saying I won't work with someone with eating disorders. I'm just saying there are
- 1:01:25other people that are probably better for them. And and I'm also saying that
- 1:01:30if they forced me to work with that person, then I'd be fine with
- 1:01:35that, you know, if if they're saying, no, you're the man
- 1:01:37for me, I don't have any other options or blah blah blah, and
- 1:01:40I'd be okay, fine, you know, and I would and I would,
- 1:01:45you know, because I'm just I don't care that much. So so
- 1:01:50that's that. So with with with Jennifer Keaton, what her her problem was
- 1:01:57was she was very she she was very vocal and had written emails and assignments
- 1:02:02and stuff, and there were accounts of her saying that she was adamantly against
- 1:02:07LGBTQ people, whereas Julia Award at Eastern Michigan University, from what I can
- 1:02:14tell, wasn't vocal about anything at all. All she did is say I
- 1:02:17don't want to work with this client for religious reasons, and please refer them
- 1:02:23so that according to the legalese that I've been reading. That's the big difference.
- 1:02:32So you can't just kick a student out or even necessarily create a remediation
- 1:02:37plan. So what Eastern Michigan University should have done is apparently is they should
- 1:02:45have sat Julia down and said, okay, so we heard that you are
- 1:02:51refusing to see this gay client. Can you tell us what's going on there?
- 1:02:55And then they have a conversation with her and she's like, well,
- 1:02:58according to my religion, bah blah, and like, well, so it's
- 1:03:02probably your best interest if you learn how to work with these people, because
- 1:03:07you're going to get other clients like this, and you're also going to get
- 1:03:10other clients that are gonna maybe challenge other religious beliefs of yours, and it
- 1:03:15might it's in your best interest to be able to treat lots of different clients.
- 1:03:19And why don't you give it a try, and and we'll watch you
- 1:03:22and we'll you know, supervise you, and we'll give you consultation and we'll
- 1:03:27see how it goes. What do you say so you have a conversation with
- 1:03:31her. Now at that point, if she's like, no, I'm never
- 1:03:35gonna work with those people, and you're like, well, why ain't gonna
- 1:03:37work these people because it's a moral what they're doing. And I think blah
- 1:03:40blah blah. And then you start hearing the reasons for you're giving her a
- 1:03:46chance to tell her reasons. Now, if a reason is like, well,
- 1:03:51I'm afraid of them because my church tells me that they're terrible people,
- 1:03:54well then you know, then that gives you a direction that you can go
- 1:03:58in in terms of helping her to not be afraid. So so you have
- 1:04:00a conversation so Eastern Michigan University and maybe they did this, I don't know,
- 1:04:03but from the looks of it, they didn't. And you have a
- 1:04:06conversation with her and you try to help her. You try to work with
- 1:04:09her. Give us some time, give us some breathing room, you know,
- 1:04:12give it. Let her off the hook for now. Say okay,
- 1:04:14well, we're for this client for now. But let's let's really get into
- 1:04:16this. We're gonna we're not gonna let you off the hook just yet.
- 1:04:18So let's talk about this. And you have some conversations, you have some
- 1:04:21supervision. You ask her if she would be willing to go to some training
- 1:04:26programs. You ask her if she'd be willing to go to the gay Pride
- 1:04:29parade. You ask her if she'd be willing to talk to some gay colleagues
- 1:04:31of hers or something, and you try to work with her on this,
- 1:04:36and if she doesn't agree to it, then you say, well, if
- 1:04:39you want to see in this program, you're going to have to do these
- 1:04:42things, and then you impose their remediation plan. You give her a chance
- 1:04:45to do that. And then if she refuses to do that, and she
- 1:04:48stated very clearly that the reason why she doesn't want to do it is because
- 1:04:53she believes that LGBTQ people are a moral then you're in a situation like the
- 1:04:57Jennifer Keaton situation at Augusta State University. And then you can kick her out
- 1:05:00of the program because you have enough data and you've given her enough chance.
- 1:05:05So just because someone refuses to work with a particular group of people doesn't apparently
- 1:05:14justify kicking them out of the program. You have to you have to give
- 1:05:16it some some breathing space. You have to give it some time. You
- 1:05:19have to give it, you have to give you have to investigate more and
- 1:05:24and find out what's really going on. Okay, so I want to conclude
- 1:05:30with something here. In response to all this, there was a movement in
- 1:05:35Arizona. So what some of the Christian people were seeing, they were seeing
- 1:05:42the writing on the wall, and they're seeing that lgb that some of their
- 1:05:46Christian brethren and sister and were potentially going to be forced to work with LGBTQ
- 1:05:56clients in a way that with be challenging to their religion. And some I
- 1:06:01don't understand how it challenges their religion, but because as I said earlierre's plenty
- 1:06:08of Christians that are completely fine with LGBTQ people, and there are plenty of
- 1:06:11Christians who are LGBTQ, So I don't understand why it challenges their religion.
- 1:06:15But anyway, they're saying, uh, oh, all these Christian counselors are
- 1:06:20going to be forced to work with LGBTQ people, so we better get ahead
- 1:06:25of this. So in Arizona they passed the law funded by the Alliance Defending
- 1:06:30Freedom people. Those people remember those people again, And incidentally, there are
- 1:06:34similar movements in Michigan and Tennessee and so Arizona, and they got a law
- 1:06:41passed. These people, they got a law passed in the state legislature which
- 1:06:45enacted a law preventing counseling programs from taking actions against students whose religious beliefs run
- 1:06:51counter to serving certain kinds of clients, namely LGBTQ people, as long as
- 1:06:57they consult with supervisors about how to avoid arming those clients. Which I don't
- 1:07:00really understand that last clause. But in other words, if a counseling trainee
- 1:07:04in Arizona says that they don't want to treat a gay person or a trans
- 1:07:09person, or a queer person or a bisexual person, and they don't want
- 1:07:15to treat that person because of their religious beliefs, then the counseling program has
- 1:07:17to give in in Arizona. If you're a training program, you probably already
- 1:07:24know this, if you are a training professional in Arizona that if one you're
- 1:07:29a trainee says, look, according to my religion, I can't work with
- 1:07:31LGBTQ clients. As a training program. You have to be like, okay,
- 1:07:34according to the law, I have to allow you to do that.
- 1:07:39Now. The American Counseling Association wrote the Governor of Arizona urging her to veto
- 1:07:44the bill, and they said that look, multicultural competency is a core,
- 1:07:48core skill in our profession. So by doing this, you're allowing trainees to
- 1:07:56avoid that competency. You can't allow a student to avoid working with a group
- 1:08:00of people that they're prejudiced against. That's just not it's not okay. You're
- 1:08:06you're passing a law that is counter to our ethics. It's actually unethical for
- 1:08:12us to allow a trainee to not work with a particular group of people because
- 1:08:20they want to discriminate against them. It's just not you're putting us in a
- 1:08:24bind here. You're basically asking us to train people in an unethical manner.
- 1:08:30So, and they asked the faculty in some of these training programs in Arizona,
- 1:08:38and the training program people are like, well, we don't like it,
- 1:08:40but will follow the law if we have to. So this is idiotic.
- 1:08:46You know, what are we looking at here? People? We're going
- 1:08:50to allow someone to say that they I don't want to work with LGBTQ people
- 1:08:56and that's because of my religion, and you can't make me, and the
- 1:09:00in Arizona and maybe in Michigan, maybe in Tennessee allow me to do that.
- 1:09:05What are we looking at here? People, McDonald's can say I don't
- 1:09:11want to serve an LGBTQ people person. A dry cleaners can say I don't
- 1:09:15want to wash a dirty black person's clothing. A a government office can say
- 1:09:25I don't like redheads. This is not okay. This is not okay,
- 1:09:30this is not okay. It's un American, it's unconstitutional, it's backward thinking.
- 1:09:36This is counter to everything that our field stands for. It's counter to
- 1:09:42everything that America stands for. It needs to stop. And if you don't
- 1:09:47like it, then you need to get out of the profession. What are
- 1:09:53you doing in our field When you have harmful attitudes like this? You need
- 1:09:58to go away, and you need to just go away and drift into history
- 1:10:03to be forgotten. All of your attitudes will be long gone. In fifty
- 1:10:09years, you will be forgotten. You will be a footnote on this will
- 1:10:13be a footnote in the progression of our society toward a better one. There'll
- 1:10:18be this tiny footnote. Well, in the two thousands or in the early
- 1:10:23twenty first century, there were some minor movements that fizzled out. And again
- 1:10:30I'm not talking about Christians. There are plenty of Christians who would never do
- 1:10:33stuff like this, And there are plenty of Christians who are completely fine with
- 1:10:38LGBTQ people, and there are plenty of LGBTUQ people who are Christians, so
- 1:10:42I'm not talking to them. I'm talking to the bigots who just happen to
- 1:10:45be Christians or some other religion. I'm talking about the bigots who target any
- 1:10:54group of people, naming the LGBTQQ people. I'm also not talking to people
- 1:11:00who agree to engage in a conversation about it. I'm not there are people
- 1:11:04who there are Christians who disagree with the LGBTQ lifestyle who don't want to engage
- 1:11:12in a conversation about it. I'm not talking to those people. I'm only
- 1:11:15talking to people like Jennifer Keaton who just flat out refuse to engage in the
- 1:11:18remediation plan. The program very nicely laid out a very easy remediation plan that
- 1:11:27didn't say that didn't shame her, that didn't say she had to change her
- 1:11:30religious beliefs, that just said, look, we want you to expose yourself
- 1:11:33to more gay people, and our guess is that this will loosen you up,
- 1:11:38but it's up to you. Those are the people I'm talking about.
- 1:11:42Look, if you're that afraid of being exposed to gay people, and if
- 1:11:45you're if your belief system is that fragile that you need to not engage in
- 1:11:53conversations with with LGBTQ people, then how how do you how do you respect
- 1:11:59your own leief system on this Because I have to say, I have a
- 1:12:03belief right and you've heard many of them. Well, if I hung out
- 1:12:08with a bunch of conservative, anti LGBTQ people, I'm pretty positive that I
- 1:12:14wouldn't change my mind. I'm pretty sure that you could make me go to
- 1:12:18a workshop about anti gay sentiment, you could make me read some anti gay
- 1:12:24literature, you could make me hang out with anti gay people, and I
- 1:12:29am one hundred percent sure that my mind will not be changed. Why Because
- 1:12:32I'm right, That's why. Because I am on the right side of this
- 1:12:35issue, as is most of America. By the way, most of America
- 1:12:40is on my side, even Christians. So this needs to stop. You
- 1:12:45need to go away, and you need to change your opinion, or you
- 1:12:47need to start engaging in conversation, or you need to look yourself in the
- 1:12:54mirror and wonder why you're doing this. It just needs to stop. It's
- 1:13:00that simple. I don't understand this. Well, there's two sides to the
- 1:13:06issue, and we want to respect both sides. No, well, sure
- 1:13:11we can respect people, that's fine, But there is no two sides of
- 1:13:15this issue. There's the right side, the moral side, the American side,
- 1:13:20and then there's the bigoted side, the Unamerican side, and the wrong
- 1:13:24side. And history in the future will definitely bear that out if it hasn't
- 1:13:30already. So people in Arizona, if you aren't already, you need to
- 1:13:33change this law. You need to really do something about this law. Citizens
- 1:13:40of Arizona and people of the rest of the world. This nonsense needs to
- 1:13:45stop. And I know a lot of you out there are already doing things,
- 1:13:47and I commend you. We also need to write our politicians, we
- 1:13:51need to write our judges, we need to make blog posts. We need
- 1:13:55to speak up in class. It's not okay to discriminate against any group of
- 1:14:00people, particularly marginalized group of people. I'm tired of people saying that.
- 1:14:06I'm tired of people talking about this. I'm just I'm so tired of this.
- 1:14:10Honestly, it's so obvious what the right answer is and how long is
- 1:14:16it going to take. It's twenty seventeen. Let's wake up again. If
- 1:14:26you're a bigot and you want to be a therapist, either change your attitude
- 1:14:30or get out of the profession. We don't want you and clients are better
- 1:14:33off without you