Latest / Onramp Bitcoin Media / America’s Debt Crisis & Bitcoin’s Institutional Era with Avik Roy
Transcript
- 0:00Let's be clear, Bitcoin is an international asset.
- 0:04We are spending like drunken sailors.
- 0:08Bitcoin is the only economic entity where the supply is
- 0:12unaffected by the demand. If you want to preserve your
- 0:16wealth, you have to convert. That currency into an asset
- 0:20that's scarce, desirable, portable, durable, and
- 0:24maintainable. Welcome back to scarce Assets
- 0:32from on Ramp Institutional. I just sat down with Ovik Roy,
- 0:36Chairman of Free OP, senior advisor to BPI and now on the
- 0:39Board of Strife, to answer a simple question with trillion
- 0:42dollar consequences. What happens to Bitcoin when the
- 0:45US math stops working? We dig into why the fiscal clock
- 0:48likely runs out in the next 10 to 20 years.
- 0:51Why then they fight you is a policy risk phase, not a meme.
- 0:55And the two defenses that actually matter, broad ownership
- 0:58across voters and institutions, and resilient on ramps in
- 1:01custody that cannot be switched off.
- 1:04In the latter part of the conversation, we dug into the
- 1:07ETFs and Bitcoin treasury companies, how he thinks about
- 1:10those versus direct ownership of the asset, and why he's excited
- 1:14about the opportunity to join Strive.
- 1:17At On Ramp Institutional we help serious Bitcoin investors such
- 1:21as family offices, institutions and corporates get it right the
- 1:24first time. Our multi institution custody
- 1:27removes single points of failure with independent key holders in
- 1:30multi jurisdiction coverage, then layers in inheritance
- 1:33planning, insurance and white glove onboarding.
- 1:36So security does not come at the expense of simplicity.
- 1:41If your current exposure is only via spot ETFs and you want a
- 1:44more direct and conservative foundation or you're starting
- 1:47from zero and need an investment committee ready framework, we
- 1:50can help through direct solutions to Bitcoin or through
- 1:52the On Ramp Bitcoin Trust. If your organization is
- 1:56evaluating Bitcoin or ready to scale or reevaluate an
- 1:59allocation, let's talk. You can e-mail me Jackson at on
- 2:02rampbitcoin.com or you can book a consultation on
- 2:05rampbitcoin.com. Welcome back to scarce assets.
- 2:09This week we have ovic Roy Ovic. It's great to have you on the
- 2:12show. Looking forward to this
- 2:13conversation. Just for those who are not
- 2:15familiar with your background, you're the Co founder and
- 2:17chairman at the Foundation for Research on Equal Opportunity or
- 2:21Free OP. You're also a senior advisor at
- 2:23the Bitcoin Policy Institute and more recently a board member at
- 2:27Strive, among many other things. But Ovic, great to have you on
- 2:30the show. How are you doing today?
- 2:33I'm doing great Jax and it's been it's been a lively couple
- 2:36of days here. We're recording this the the day
- 2:39after Strive listed or it's for traded.
- 2:43It had its first trading day as a combined company.
- 2:46So, but it's been exciting times to strive.
- 2:49We're looking forward to building the next Grape Bitcoin
- 2:52Treasure company. Yeah, I'm excited to talk about
- 2:55that and congratulations to you and the team.
- 2:57Thanks. I think a nice place to start
- 2:59just to level set is on the fiscal situation here in the
- 3:02United States. I think listeners of the show
- 3:04are certainly familiar that there are a lot of problems.
- 3:07And as you stated back in 2021, there is a reckoning coming.
- 3:11And then more recently you published a piece in the Satoshi
- 3:14papers titled And then They Fight Us.
- 3:17And really the thesis, I'll, I'll let you let you share more.
- 3:21But the thesis behind that is that we're kind of on a path, it
- 3:25seems to be over the next two decades or so, right, is kind of
- 3:28your analysis. But if we don't get our house in
- 3:30order, we have a pretty dire situation on our hands in the
- 3:33United States in particular, let alone other countries as well,
- 3:36are all kind of facing these mounting levels of sovereign
- 3:39debt. So if you could just paint a
- 3:41picture in terms of when you first started to get concerned
- 3:43or paying more attention to the fiscal situation here in the
- 3:47United States. And I'd be curious before
- 3:49jumping into those reports you've more recently published,
- 3:52just when you first started paying attention, got concerned
- 3:54and you know, over the years how things progressed.
- 3:57Was it kind of in line with your expectations?
- 3:59Was it worse, better than you know, when you initially sort of
- 4:03peeling back layers of the onion here?
- 4:05Well, I've been concerned about the federal debt for, gosh,
- 4:08probably my entire life. I mean, I, I remember in the 80s
- 4:12hearing lectures about how terrible the federal debt was
- 4:15back when it was, you know, like $100 billion or a couple $100
- 4:18billion or something like that. So we're now at 37 trillion or
- 4:22so and it's, things are only getting worse.
- 4:25So I think that that's certainly problematic.
- 4:30And in fact, that my concern about the federal debt is really
- 4:35what has driven a lot of my post Wall Street professional life.
- 4:39So I I was an institutional investor from 2001 to 2012 or so
- 4:45and didn't mean to drop out of that career.
- 4:49I was having a good time in on Wall Street, but I got asked to
- 4:53to be Mitt Romney's healthcare advisor when he ran for
- 4:56president 2012. And that was my first kind of
- 5:01entree into being very actively involved in trying to solve
- 5:05these problems, not just complain about them, but say,
- 5:08OK, like, how would we actually reduce the federal deficit?
- 5:11Well, in the US context, this isn't necessarily true in other
- 5:15countries. But in the US, the big driver of
- 5:17our federal deficit is federal health care spending because we
- 5:22have an extremely poorly designed healthcare system,
- 5:26particularly the government run parts of it, Medicare, Medicaid,
- 5:29Obamacare and the like. And we're just spending more and
- 5:32more on on those programs every year.
- 5:33And we can't seem to fix them because everybody gets mad if
- 5:36you try to do anything to change healthcare.
- 5:38So it's been a hard problem with.
- 5:40So that's what got me into public policy was trying to fix
- 5:42that. It was around the same time that
- 5:44I got into Bitcoin because, you know, at first, actually I
- 5:48looked at Bitcoin as, hey, it's a more efficient form of
- 5:50payment. That's what, you know, intrigued
- 5:52me. But it was very clear to me very
- 5:54quickly that it was, you know, digital gold and something I'd
- 5:58paid attention to from the beginning.
- 6:00I was fortunate that from the launch of the white paper, I had
- 6:03friends who were in the Austrian econ ecosystem who had alerted
- 6:08me to Bitcoin. But I just thought, you know,
- 6:10boy, this is too complicated. I have to code a wallet and I
- 6:13don't have time to deal with any of this stuff.
- 6:15But then Mal Cox blew up and, and there was a, there was an
- 6:18opportunity to get in a low price and I thought, OK, this
- 6:20is, I got to figure this out now.
- 6:22Otherwise shame on me. So that's when I started get
- 6:25involved Bitcoin and the two things kind of went in parallel.
- 6:28I, I got more and more involved in trying to solve the federal
- 6:32deficit at the, at the presidential campaign level and
- 6:36also in terms of working with members of Congress in the White
- 6:39House. And I got more involved in, in
- 6:42Bitcoin as well. And so that that culminated in
- 6:442021. I wrote this paper that you
- 6:46alluded to called Bitcoin in the Fiscal Reckoning, which was
- 6:49published in National affairs, which is a major quarterly
- 6:53policy journalist published in Washington.
- 6:55And I believe it was the first major treatment of Bitcoin in a
- 6:59mainstream public policy journal.
- 7:02And my argument at that time in 2021 was, look, you in
- 7:06Washington who think that Bitcoin is a passing fad.
- 7:09It's not a passing fad For these reasons related to the federal
- 7:13debt getting worse and worse and the the break in 1971 that
- 7:18really freed the dollar from any connection to gold.
- 7:22And on the flip side, I was trying to share with Bitcoiners
- 7:27that actually the government can make your life hard.
- 7:28There was an attitude at the time which may seem, you know,
- 7:32quaint or antiquated now, but at the time the typical Bitcoin
- 7:35would be like, who cares what the government has to say about
- 7:38Bitcoin? They can't touch us.
- 7:39We're a censorship resistant, permissionless network.
- 7:42And that's true. But if you want Bitcoin to be
- 7:46useful to everyone, especially in the context of payments, then
- 7:50actually the government can do a lot to make Bitcoin harder to
- 7:53use because the Bitcoin, the government controls the rails
- 7:56between the US dollar and Bitcoin, Fiat currencies in
- 8:00general in Bitcoin. And so people can't buy Bitcoin
- 8:03with their U.S. dollars if the government shuts that down, for
- 8:06example. And so in that article in 21, I
- 8:10argued that, and this was, I think one of the first arguments
- 8:15around this are proposing a Bitcoin reserve, number one,
- 8:19banning CBDC, central bank digital currencies, which are a
- 8:21way for the government to block that dollar to Bitcoin rail.
- 8:26And then also legalizing exchange traded funds, which at
- 8:29the time were not legal. So we got two out of three.
- 8:32We haven't banned CBDC's, but we have this executive order on the
- 8:36Bitcoin reserve and we've legalized the ETFs And obviously
- 8:40we've seen a lot of growth and demand for Bitcoin as a result
- 8:44of that over the last 12/12/18 months.
- 8:46So that's been great. But the second paper, the
- 8:49Satoshi paper article that you mentioned that that I that's the
- 8:52chapter of this book called then they Fight you.
- 8:55And we also have it as a standalone article on the free
- 8:58OP web page. And the title of that is 3
- 9:01scenarios of how AUS fiscal crisis could harm ordinary
- 9:05Americans. But if you Google free OP, then
- 9:07they fight you if it comes up. And and the point of this
- 9:10article was in a sense to be a sequel to that first one and and
- 9:14it was to think through. OK, so the 2021 article was
- 9:18about seeing around the corner of and trying to get Bitcoiners
- 9:22to understand that actually there are Washington does matter
- 9:25to us If we want Bitcoin to be as useful as we believe it to be
- 9:29and also if we want to make Bitcoin resilient to government
- 9:33intervention in the future. There are a couple things we
- 9:36need to do, and I listed those earlier.
- 9:39This, the second article takes the next step, which is OK.
- 9:42That article is more about the present day, but what about in
- 9:45the future? So we all think federal debts
- 9:49getting worse. I think if you're a typical
- 9:50Bitcoiner, you, you are convinced that this problem is,
- 9:53is going to get worse and worse and not better.
- 9:57And at some point it all comes crashing down.
- 9:58And, and a lot of times Bitcoiners like, hey, this is
- 10:01going to be great. You know, the dollar will
- 10:03collapse and my Bitcoin will be worth millions and you know, of
- 10:06dollars and that, and that's going to be great.
- 10:08I'm going to retire with my umbrella, umbrella cocktail
- 10:12drink, pink cocktail drink on a beach somewhere, and
- 10:14everything's going to be great. And the point I'm trying to make
- 10:17in this article is be careful what you wish for.
- 10:21Because when that fiscal crisis really does happen and there's a
- 10:26failure in the bond market and the US government is flailing
- 10:30around, try to figure out how do we stop the bleeding away from
- 10:35the US dollar? Who do you think they're going
- 10:37to go after? They're going to go after
- 10:39Bitcoin and Bitcoiners specifically.
- 10:43One of the charts I have in the article is that if you look at
- 10:48wealth inequality in Fiat terms, something like, and I'll pull it
- 10:52up so I don't misquote the actual numbers.
- 10:55But if you actually say, OK, what's the distribution of of
- 10:59wealth? You know, like the old Occupy
- 11:01Wall Street people used to say, hey, we are the 99% and we hate
- 11:05the 1%. Well, actually the top 1% of
- 11:10households own about 27% of the US dollar denominated wealth in
- 11:15America, which you know is it's been, it's increased a little
- 11:19bit over the last 10-15 years, but that's pretty much where
- 11:22it's been. Now if you look at Bitcoin, the
- 11:25top 1% of holders own something like 99.9% of all Bitcoin.
- 11:33And so that creates a target for crackdown and democracy.
- 11:38The 99.9% have votes and the 1% of Bitcoiners have votes too,
- 11:42but not very many, right? So what's going to happen in
- 11:46that crackdown? And how do we make Bitcoin
- 11:48resilient to that crackdown in the future?
- 11:50That's the topic of the second. Article, I love it.
- 11:55Thank you for that introduction. That was excellent.
- 11:57If we go back before going forward, you mentioned that
- 12:01really your entire life you've been paying attention to the
- 12:03federal debt and you mentioned at that time a couple $100
- 12:07billion of federal debt compared to 37 trillion today.
- 12:12And so I'm really curious to hear because you said it in your
- 12:15piece, it may be another 20 years or so before this fiscal
- 12:18reckoning happens. And so why do these things tend
- 12:23to play out so much longer than maybe people expect?
- 12:26Because where I'm coming from in this question is post great
- 12:31financial crisis and all the intervention from the Federal
- 12:34Reserve and global central banks, as I understand it, there
- 12:37was a lot of concern about runaway inflation because of all
- 12:39this, the liquidity that was going to be injected.
- 12:42But we saw that NASA price is not the real economy.
- 12:45Then comes COVID and considerable amount of
- 12:48coordination between fiscal and monetary authorities and we've
- 12:51seen a lot of inflation post 2020, but we still haven't
- 12:55really hit that reckoning point yet that you have described.
- 12:58So I'd be curious to hear just over your career, why, what have
- 13:02you learned that informs why this actually takes longer to
- 13:05play out than many expect? And why is it 20 years in terms
- 13:09of your your look forward period?
- 13:12Yeah, it's a really important question, Jackson.
- 13:14And, and this is something that I do talk about in the the first
- 13:18article, the Bitcoin US fiscal reckoning piece, because it's
- 13:21really important. A lot of people have been out
- 13:23there because it would be Cassandra's predicting doom and
- 13:26gloom about the deficit and the debt.
- 13:29And it hasn't exactly happened yet.
- 13:31We haven't seen some complete collapse.
- 13:33And so that means a lot of people, a lot of ordinary
- 13:36Americans and most mainstream economists say, well, is the
- 13:39debt really that big of a deal, especially in a country like the
- 13:43US that can borrow in its own currency?
- 13:45That's the argument you hear from the modern modern monetary
- 13:48theorist, for example. Well, we can borrow in our own
- 13:51currency, and so what's the big deal?
- 13:55And in the article, I, I make several arguments as to why that
- 14:01crisis has not yet occurred. 1 is that the US dollar, as
- 14:09expressed through Treasury securities, is the most liquid
- 14:13securities market in the world. And people like that, people
- 14:17like to hold treasuries because I know that if I buy literally
- 14:22like I could buy a, you know, ten, $10 billion of treasuries
- 14:26and not really move the market because it's such a big market,
- 14:31because there's so much debt. In fact, in the brief period in
- 14:34the late 90s when we had a budget surplus, that was the big
- 14:38concern that, oh gosh, if we're going to retire all this debt,
- 14:42then the treasury markets won't be as liquid.
- 14:43What are we going to do then, right?
- 14:45I wish we had that problem again, but unfortunately we
- 14:48don't. But but that's one, one big
- 14:51thing is that like compared to other countries, like if you
- 14:54want to buy German sovereign debt or French sovereign debt or
- 14:58British sovereign debt, those are relatively much smaller
- 15:01economies. And so there's just not as much
- 15:04of that debt circulating. So if you need to own a cash
- 15:07like instrument, if you're a hedge fund or a bank or some
- 15:10other large institution or a government, Treasuries are a
- 15:12great instrument to hold because they're so liquid.
- 15:14So that creates A bias towards holding if there's an
- 15:17artificially increased demand for U.S.
- 15:20Treasuries because of that, which means the US can borrow
- 15:23more cheaply and the same thing. There's another piece of it
- 15:27which is really important, which is that there are actually
- 15:31international and domestic financial regulations which
- 15:35actually say to banks that if you want us to consider you a
- 15:40less risky bank from regulatory standpoint, the way you're going
- 15:45to convince us that you're less risky is by holding a quote UN
- 15:48quote risk free asset, which is Treasury securities.
- 15:52So a lot of banking regulations are basically designed to say if
- 15:58you own U.S. Treasuries, we'll consider you
- 16:00less risky. If you own other kinds of bonds
- 16:03or particularly if you own equities, we're going to
- 16:06consider you more risky. And so banks say, OK, if I can
- 16:10make 4 or 5% on my treasuries, I'll do that because that's
- 16:14considered a risk free asset, allows me to lend out more of my
- 16:17assets and make more money. So the regulations both again,
- 16:21domestically and internationally, the the most
- 16:24important international banking regulations called the Basel 3
- 16:27Accord. These regulations basically
- 16:31pressure banks, give them an EC powerful economic and incentive
- 16:35to own a lot of treasuries. And there are a bunch of other
- 16:38reasons too, but those are the two most important as to why why
- 16:45institutions own treasuries. The third most important
- 16:48arguably is that just there's this perception.
- 16:50Hey, US is the biggest kid on the block.
- 16:54Treasuries have been a safe investment for decades upon
- 16:57decades and particularly since World War 2.
- 17:00So surely the US will never Welch on its deaths.
- 17:03Surely the US is, you know, the the best country in terms of
- 17:08being the most reliable borrower.
- 17:11But is that going to be true in the future?
- 17:14And that's where a lot of the stuff around the federal debt
- 17:17starts to play out. And one of the one of the charts
- 17:19I have actually, I think it's the first chart in the new
- 17:22paper, Then They Fight you is about this.
- 17:24It's that actually one thing you'll often hear quoted in in
- 17:30commentary in in reports is, well, the Congressional Budget
- 17:35Office predicts that the federal debt will reach such and such
- 17:38percentage of GDP by such and such a year.
- 17:41So those are the official government projections that
- 17:43you'll see most people quote in their in their articles.
- 17:48But what people don't do is they don't dig into those CBO
- 17:51estimates, because if you dig into the CBO estimates, they're
- 17:54actually wildly optimistic. The CBO projects that in in 20
- 18:00years, the debt to GDP ratio will be about 200%, but it'll
- 18:04actually be more likely to be around 600% if you actually just
- 18:09have a more realistic view of how much the debt is going to
- 18:15get worse over time. How much economic growth there
- 18:20will be? So the CBO projects a really
- 18:22robust amount of economic growth forever, 3.6% GDP growth
- 18:26forever, which is basically crazy.
- 18:29That's like 1980s, nineteen 90s level economic growth we have.
- 18:31We don't actually have that now, but they're projecting we'll
- 18:35have that forever. And they also project that we'll
- 18:37be able to borrow money at 4 1/2 to 5% basically forever.
- 18:42And that's not going to happen when the federal debts at 60-70
- 18:45a $100 trillion, we're not going to be able to borrow money at 4
- 18:481/2% and the economy is not going to grow at 3.6%.
- 18:51So if you just say the economy is growing at 3% and you have a
- 18:55more realistic view, a slightly more realistic view on interest
- 18:58rates, the debt to GDP ratio explodes.
- 19:01And so my analysis in this paper is that we have no more than 20
- 19:07years before the the real debt crisis will happen again.
- 19:11And that makes me may make me sound like the Cassandra's of
- 19:14the past, but we are literally running out of other people's
- 19:17money. Well, I do think it makes you
- 19:20sound very balanced and measured, especially when you
- 19:24compare to the number of people who have been kind of in that
- 19:27doom and gloom camp for a number of years now.
- 19:30I feel like going on Twitter or X or many different circles
- 19:34where there's a lot of thought around Bitcoin and just the
- 19:38broader macro fiscal implications of the US economy.
- 19:42There's a lot of people who are telling you are saying that the
- 19:44the crisis is around the corner. So I think by having a horizon
- 19:48of about 20 years, you're probably in the more
- 19:50conservative camp. And I think that's, you know,
- 19:53very reasonable and it's refreshing to hear a perspective
- 19:56that isn't telling, you know, the, the dollar collapses
- 19:59tomorrow, right? Or the dollar collapses in this
- 20:01next cycle, whatever it may be. And I would love to hear, you
- 20:04know, going back into some of the predictions or not even
- 20:08predictions, but prerequisites you, you had mentioned around
- 20:11the Bitcoin or the strategic Bitcoin reserve, the ETFs being
- 20:15approved and we haven't seen yet the CBDC's being banned
- 20:18outright. But on the strategic Bitcoin
- 20:20Reserve, would love to hear your thoughts, particularly this
- 20:23year, the Trump administration, their embrace of Bitcoin and
- 20:26crypto. I think there is.
- 20:28Some positive and some negative, but I would love to hear what
- 20:31your perspective is on the current standing Bitcoin
- 20:36strategic reserve compared to the digital digital asset
- 20:38stockpile. What does that tell us about the
- 20:40administration's view on Bitcoin versus the rest of the space?
- 20:43And then the second part of that question would be if we actually
- 20:46did see the Bitcoin Act passed at some point and we could talk
- 20:51about when that may happen. Does accumulation of Bitcoin by
- 20:54the US government signal strength to the rest of the
- 20:57world, or does it signal desperation and weakness and
- 21:00potentially accelerate the fiscal reckoning that you've
- 21:04mentioned? So first, just on this 20 year
- 21:07point, let me just say that it could be sooner, right?
- 21:11I, I, I, it's, I think we have at most 20 years.
- 21:14It's probably somewhere between 10 and 20.
- 21:18You just never know when, when, when these things are going to
- 21:20happen. It's the old gradually then
- 21:22suddenly added. But the, but the, the likelihood
- 21:27that we get past 20 years is just very, very low because you
- 21:30literally do run out of other people's money.
- 21:32There's about $400 trillion of wealth in the world and only so
- 21:36much of that's going to be parked in Treasury security.
- 21:39So at a certain point, you just literally run out of available
- 21:43money to borrow from the rest of the world.
- 21:45And, and, and 20 years may seem like a long time, but you know,
- 21:49I have young children. You're about to have a kid.
- 21:52You know, let's say, let's take your example like you're about
- 21:54to have a kid. We're talking about your child's
- 21:56entire adult life is going to be the experience of living in a
- 22:01country that's bankrupt. And I don't mean just like
- 22:05technically bankrupt in the sense you could say we're
- 22:06bankrupt today, but I mean in the sense that if people won't
- 22:09lend you money, you really are bankrupt, right?
- 22:13That's going to be your your child's entire adult life, if
- 22:16I'm right. And so that's kind of a
- 22:17terrifying, terrifying thing to think about.
- 22:20And, and it's why I've, I've spent so much of my career
- 22:23trying to trying to solve these problems on the policy level.
- 22:26And it's really hard now to your, to your most more recent
- 22:29question about about the Bitcoin strategic reserve.
- 22:34The reason why I proposed it in 2021 was was not so much because
- 22:42I, I, I wanted that to be a positive engine of Bitcoin
- 22:46demand to drive up the price. I mean, that's obviously it
- 22:49wouldn't hurt, but it was more that it's more the signalling of
- 22:55if, if the government thinks that this is an asset that it
- 22:58can hold to protect its long term balance sheet, then that's
- 23:04a signal to ordinary people that they can feel the same way.
- 23:09It also creates a, a great deal of policy, like it creates an
- 23:12interest for the federal government, right?
- 23:14So like if, if the, if the government owns Bitcoin and that
- 23:19Bitcoin goes up and becomes a, a meaningful part of the, of the
- 23:23government's balance sheet over time.
- 23:25And the government's less likely to blow Bitcoin up because it
- 23:29knows that that would be hurting.
- 23:31It's it would be cutting up its nose to spite its face.
- 23:35And so those were though that was my thought process in 2021.
- 23:40Now what, how does that proposal or that idea square with what's
- 23:46happened since? So what I proposed was actually
- 23:50something I thought I thought was pretty crazy at the time,
- 23:53but also modest, which was what if the US government just took
- 23:5610% of its gold holdings and converted them to Bitcoin?
- 24:00So that way all the people who think Bitcoin is stupid, they
- 24:04wouldn't be offended because the people who think Bitcoin is
- 24:05stupid tend to think gold is stupid too.
- 24:07So, you know, if I'm taking 10% of my gold and turning into
- 24:10Bitcoin, who really cares? It's not that big of a deal.
- 24:13But it starts that ball rolling downhill.
- 24:16What the Trump administration proposed and has tried to
- 24:20execute on was, first of all, let's take the Bitcoin we
- 24:23already hold and stop selling it.
- 24:25And then secondly, let's in a fiscally neutral way, think
- 24:29about ways to acquire more Bitcoin.
- 24:32Now, as your, many of your listeners will know, as, as the
- 24:37US government has tried to figure out how much Bitcoin it
- 24:39actually holds, the number that they've come up with is a lot
- 24:42lower than what people thought it was.
- 24:45And so the government doesn't actually own a lot of Bitcoin.
- 24:47It's, it's great that they're not going to sell it.
- 24:50It's possible that the Biden administration in its last few
- 24:52months dumped a lot of the Bitcoin.
- 24:54There were certainly rumors to that effect, excuse me, in late
- 24:582020 that that's what the Biden administration was doing.
- 25:02So that may be why the US government doesn't hold as much
- 25:06Bitcoin as it it may once have. And in terms of acquiring new
- 25:11Bitcoin, they still haven't figured out exactly how they're
- 25:14going to do that. As far as I know, though there's
- 25:17they're considering various strategies.
- 25:19So we don't really know where where things stand though again,
- 25:22I think it's certainly an amazing encouraging sign that
- 25:27the US government wants to hold Bitcoin.
- 25:29And that certainly drove the big rally in Bitcoin in 2020, the
- 25:35possibility that there would be a Bitcoin strategic reserve in
- 25:39in in 2021 thereafter. So I think it's encouraging.
- 25:43But to go back to what we started with a little bit, I
- 25:46would argue that the rise of Bitcoin treasury companies from
- 25:51a standpoint of the accumulation of Bitcoin is going to be much
- 25:55more significant in the long term, right?
- 25:57The government will own a certain amount of Bitcoin and
- 25:59that's great, but the private sector has a lot more capital to
- 26:03deploy for that purpose. And so if, if Bitcoin treasury
- 26:08companies continue to to proliferate and have some
- 26:13success, then that's going to be the biggest driver of demand for
- 26:17institutional demand for Bitcoin, not governments, though
- 26:20we are seeing again, other governments, not just the US
- 26:24acquire Bitcoin. Yeah.
- 26:27There are a lot of points in there that we could certainly go
- 26:29deeper on. One thing that you rightfully
- 26:32pointed out back in 2021 and you just mentioned in this
- 26:35conversation is it's really at the end of the day for Bitcoin
- 26:39to succeed is ultimately you want the most amount of
- 26:42incentives to be aligned for Bitcoin in favor of Bitcoin for
- 26:45the long term. And So what I think is happening
- 26:49both in the public and private sector is we are seeing a
- 26:52favorability shift toward Bitcoin and ultimately that is a
- 26:56good thing. Not to say we put our guard down
- 26:58as an industry and put ourselves in a very vulnerable position
- 27:01when that reckoning happens. But I do think there are
- 27:04encouraging points, particularly, you know, you
- 27:07mentioned the Bitcoin treasury companies.
- 27:08If you just take a more broader scope on Wall Street and the
- 27:13general interest in Bitcoin and digital assets today versus five
- 27:16years ago, that's incredibly encouraging.
- 27:18And I think there is a recognition, Larry Fink being an
- 27:22obvious one. But when you have the ETF
- 27:24product being live for 18 months and that's the that surpassed
- 27:28their S&P 500 ETF in terms of revenue for the firm, still one
- 27:32product and you know a firm that offers likely thousands of
- 27:35products. But I think you and I both
- 27:37agree, when you look at the success of the Bitcoin ETFs
- 27:41relative to any ETF ever launched, it's undeniable that
- 27:45there's a lot of appetite there from institutional investors
- 27:48like hedge funds to registered investment advisors who, you
- 27:51know, their clients are asking them questions about Bitcoin and
- 27:53they need to be educated on it. Now to then, of course, retail
- 27:56investors that maybe didn't feel comfortable opening a Coinbase
- 27:59or a River account or holding their own keys, but they feel
- 28:02comfortable with, you know, purchasing 1 to 5 to 10% of
- 28:06their portfolio and Bitcoin ETFs.
- 28:08And so I do think what's encouraging is on the private
- 28:10side with the financialization of Bitcoin, you're getting a lot
- 28:14more Bitcoin in people's portfolios and you're getting
- 28:17firms that are well aligned to Bitcoin success because it's
- 28:21increasing the revenue that they're, you know, it's
- 28:23increasing their top of line revenue as a business.
- 28:26On the flip side, in the public public sector, I think as well
- 28:30just by having the Trump administration, of course, the
- 28:33Trump family is very involved in a number of different
- 28:36initiatives within Bitcoin. And I think as that broadens out
- 28:39with policy makers in all different States and, you know,
- 28:44in Congress, I ultimately think that maybe we will be in.
- 28:48I don't want again to put our guard down.
- 28:49But I think we may be in a little bit more of a favorable
- 28:52position in the sense that if we get the hands of Bitcoin into
- 28:55enough people and they have it in their business or they have
- 28:57it in their personal life in some way, they may be less
- 29:00inclined to attack it when that reckoning comes.
- 29:03What are your thoughts there? Completely agree and this is one
- 29:05of the takeaways of of my paper is that we have to do 2 things
- 29:09in order to protect Bitcoin from the potential crackdown to come
- 29:15when the debt crisis really happens in 20 years or whatever
- 29:19that is. The first is ideally as many
- 29:22Americans as possible have to have an economic stake in
- 29:26Bitcoin, whether that's owning Bitcoin directly through self
- 29:28custody, something like on ramp, something like an ETF, something
- 29:33like a Bitcoin treasury company or just in the S&P 500.
- 29:36Having enough of Bitcoin related companies in the S&P 500 or the
- 29:41NASDAQ 100 or whatever index you have in your 401K that cracking
- 29:46down on Bitcoin will will be unpopular.
- 29:50So that's, you know, the most important thing we can do to
- 29:53protect Bitcoin. Also, I suppose the more
- 29:56politicians hold Bitcoin, the more they'll be sensitive to
- 29:59that as well. Hit them where it hurts.
- 30:01Out of self-interest standpoint. That's one bucket.
- 30:04I'd say the other bucket is can we make the exchange of U.S.
- 30:10dollars to Bitcoin resilient from crackdown?
- 30:15Like again right now we depend on government permission rails
- 30:21for U.S. dollars to be exchanged for Bitcoin.
- 30:24What if there was a way to, in a decentralized peer-to-peer way,
- 30:29exchange USD for Bitcoin? There are lots of people working
- 30:32on this, but there is no robust, time tested, proven solution to
- 30:38that problem today. And one of the things I, I
- 30:41really talk about in my piece and certainly have emphasized in
- 30:43my interviews about the piece, is that if you're a Bitcoin
- 30:48technologist, a developer, work on that problem.
- 30:51Because if you can solve the problem of how to exchange U.S.
- 30:54dollars or stable coins for Bitcoin in a decentralized,
- 30:59peer-to-peer censorship resistant way, then the
- 31:03crackdown won't happen because the government will know the
- 31:06crackdown is not possible. If you make the crackdown
- 31:09impossible or infeasible because dollars can flow to Bitcoin
- 31:14online, then the crackdown is unlikely to happen.
- 31:18And the government realize, well, we can't just engage in
- 31:21capital controls Venezuela style to prevent people from fleeing
- 31:25to Bitcoin. We're going to have to get our
- 31:26own house in order. And that is the the policy that
- 31:30will or the the technological advance that will do the most to
- 31:33encourage the US to get its fiscal house in order.
- 31:37That makes a lot of sense. Yeah.
- 31:38That seems to be one of the bigger gaps this industry
- 31:42currently has is there is a lot of depending on the existing
- 31:46financial rails to access the asset, which ultimately the
- 31:50Bitcoin ethos is you don't trust, you verify, it's
- 31:53permissionless. But if we take a pragmatic and
- 31:57realistic view at the industry, pretty much everyone outside of
- 32:00maybe people who you know, get cash and bring it to a Bitcoin
- 32:02ATM and buy non KYC Bitcoin, Everyone is pretty much
- 32:06accessing the legacy there, the traditional financial U.S.
- 32:10dollar based financial system to purchase their Bitcoin.
- 32:13And that's only exacerbated by that there's even more layers of
- 32:17counterparty involvement if you're purchasing a Bitcoin ETF
- 32:20or you're purchasing Bitcoin treasury companies.
- 32:22Not to say there's anything wrong with that.
- 32:24I think that's all great for adoption, but it just kind of
- 32:26there's a gradient here in terms of the level of Bitcoin
- 32:31ownership and also counterparty exposure that you're taking on
- 32:34the other thing too, going back 100 years to Executive Order
- 32:3861-O2, I don't know how I haven't totally validated or
- 32:43verified the number, but I did see something before about 25%
- 32:47of private, privately owned gold was actually confiscated by the
- 32:52US government. So about 3/4 of people were able
- 32:55to protect their gold that they held privately.
- 32:59And the 25% that was confiscated were really kind of already in
- 33:04the coffers of of the government.
- 33:05They were very close to the political apparatus, maybe held
- 33:09in certain banks that were able to easily turn over the asset.
- 33:13Whereas one of the benefits, of course, of Bitcoin is you can
- 33:15manage it yourself in self custody.
- 33:17But there's also to talk about like where I approach this as in
- 33:22our businesses, there's really a spectrum, right?
- 33:25Because you have the people who hold Bitcoin self custody today,
- 33:29but then you have everyone who wants access to Bitcoin.
- 33:31And if you take about 100 people who want access to Bitcoin,
- 33:34probably 99 of them are going to end up in the ETFs and one of
- 33:38them ends up in self custody or some sort of, you know,
- 33:41sovereign way of owning Bitcoin. And so I do think that there's,
- 33:46there's kind of a call in my, a call to action in my mind, if
- 33:49people who want to continue to go down the path of education,
- 33:52just understanding the level of counterparty risk involved.
- 33:55And ultimately Bitcoin ownership is always about assessing
- 33:59trade-offs, right? Because if you, if you ascribe a
- 34:02higher risk or higher likelihood of a 61-O2 attack, then you
- 34:07certainly want to have Bitcoin in self custody.
- 34:09But if you're more worried about your own ability to manage your
- 34:13own keys or your, you passing away and your wife not being
- 34:15able to figure this out for your family, then for in a lot of
- 34:18cases, something like what we do at on Ramp or Bitcoin ETFs
- 34:22really fill that void. I mean, I've heard a number of
- 34:24stories of people who've owned Bitcoin for a decade, they've
- 34:27cashed out part of their position just because they don't
- 34:29want to be subject of physical violence and threats to their
- 34:32family or they don't want to have that risk of an inheritance
- 34:35gap. And so it's easier to cash out
- 34:37part of a position and own an ETF.
- 34:39And so I share this just because I, I 100% agree with you as an
- 34:44industry, there's, there are these different types of risks
- 34:46we need to be thinking about. There's the the dependency in
- 34:50terms of accessing Bitcoin from a a purchasing perspective, but
- 34:53then also from a custodial perspective, thinking through
- 34:56different ways to manage the asset long term that may
- 34:58mitigate some of these risks. Yeah, you know, look there as,
- 35:02as you know, there are purists in the Bitcoin community who
- 35:07would argue that anything short of self custody is is is evil or
- 35:13contrary to the the ethos of Bitcoin.
- 35:16And it's easier for maybe a 27 year old childless guy to say
- 35:23that than somebody with kids, somebody who's getting up there
- 35:27in age, you know, you're like, how am I going to make all this
- 35:31work? And collaborative custody is
- 35:34obviously a great Ave. for addressing some of those
- 35:38concerns because you, you have ways of, of making sure that,
- 35:42you know, if you get hit, if I get hit by a bus or you get hit
- 35:44by a bus, there's somebody who can walk somebody through how
- 35:47to, how to retrieve the Bitcoin. But and, and ETFs and other
- 35:52instruments like Bitcoin treasury companies are another
- 35:55source of in a sense, you know, that those aren't self custody
- 35:59or collaborative custody. Those are full custodial
- 36:02instruments, but they have their use and they have their use,
- 36:06especially in the case of ETF's is a gateway drug, right?
- 36:09It's a gateway drug to say, OK, if I want exposure to Bitcoin,
- 36:13but I want, so I want that exposure in a familiar wrapper
- 36:17that I'm used to dealing with. I'm used to dealing with my
- 36:19Fidelity or my Schwab brokerage account.
- 36:22I, there's a legal infrastructure around those
- 36:25assets to your point where the $5 wrench attack can't take my,
- 36:29my securities away from me. That's helpful.
- 36:33And, and, and to the degree that, as you said, as you
- 36:35rightly noted, that allows people to then get comfortable
- 36:38with the asset of Bitcoin and then iterate from there into
- 36:42these into, into something that's more the raw spot asset,
- 36:48then that's great. I think I think that's really,
- 36:50really important. I think a lot of us did, which
- 36:52is why we, we advocated for the ETFETF legalization in the 1st
- 36:56place. And I think it's been, it's been
- 36:58great. You've seen the efficiencies you
- 37:01compared to the European ETFs which have been around for much
- 37:03longer because ETS were legal in places like Switzerland and
- 37:07Scandinavia much earlier. They were in the US.
- 37:12But the, but the fee structure of the USETS, because it's so
- 37:15robustly competitive has made the cost of those ETFs so low
- 37:20that a lot of the ETF companies or issuers are complaining.
- 37:22They're not making enough money on the ETFs to really to really
- 37:26justify their involvement in it. But they're doing it anyway
- 37:28because they're making it enough, I guess.
- 37:30But but that's been, but that's good for consumers, right?
- 37:33It's good for investors to that these products are so
- 37:36competitive that, that the fees are low.
- 37:39But totally agree that ETFs can be the ETF's can be shut down,
- 37:44they can be D legalized in a crisis.
- 37:47Even a Bitcoin treasury companies could be theoretically
- 37:51blown up in a crisis. They, you know, the government
- 37:53could say we're going to custody your Bitcoin or something like
- 37:56that, right? They there or they could do
- 37:57other things or they could do like what what Roosevelt didn't
- 38:00say. We are going to confiscate your
- 38:02Bitcoin at a certain exchange rate, which is favorable to us
- 38:05and not to you, which is what, you know.
- 38:08When the government confiscated the gold, it wasn't that they
- 38:10confiscated the gold that was the problem.
- 38:13It was that they confiscated the gold and then immediately
- 38:15devalued the relationship between the dollar and gold.
- 38:19And the confiscation was the mechanism for the devaluation.
- 38:23And that's what it would be here as well.
- 38:26And so the more we can create that escape hatch, or you can
- 38:30move your Bitcoin into self custody, or you can move your
- 38:34Bitcoin into offline censorship resistant tools, then the
- 38:38government is less likely to try to confiscate it because they
- 38:42know they won't be able to. Quick break, if you're enjoying
- 38:44the episode, please leave a like and leave a comment if you don't
- 38:48mind. If you haven't done so already,
- 38:50subscribe to our YouTube channel and rate 5 stars on Spotify or
- 38:53Apple. Believe it or not, it takes a
- 38:55lot of time to run podcasts, from booking guests to preparing
- 39:00for episodes, editing them, distributing them and so on.
- 39:03So if you could just take a few seconds as a token of your
- 39:06appreciation. If you're getting value out of
- 39:08this episode out of On Ramp Media, please leave a like and a
- 39:11comment. I really appreciate it.
- 39:13I try to respond to most if not all comments.
- 39:16And so thank you again for your support.
- 39:18I appreciate you being here and hope you enjoy the rest of this
- 39:21episode. Yeah, absolutely.
- 39:23I'd be curious your thoughts before we shift into your recent
- 39:27involvement with Strive and talk more on the institutional space.
- 39:31I'd be curious just to hear your thoughts because at Onramp we're
- 39:34focused on multi institution custody and I'm speaking with
- 39:38investors on a daily basis. And some are more concerned than
- 39:41others about some sort of caesarship of assets by the
- 39:44government. And I think at least right now
- 39:47there's a little bit more comfortability with the Trump
- 39:49administration than there was with the Biden administration
- 39:52and what there would have been if Trump didn't win in the most
- 39:55recent election. And so right now, I think that
- 39:57there's a little bit less of concern about a more immediate
- 40:01type of confiscation of Bitcoin, but not to say that doesn't
- 40:05happen in the future. And So what a lot of people are
- 40:08interested in with our solution is.
- 40:10Out-of-the-box today we have we're using multi sig and three
- 40:14independent businesses are participating in management of
- 40:17the keys and you have two US based companies, our company and
- 40:20then Bitco trust, Bitco's Trust Company in South Dakota and then
- 40:24you have a third company coin cover in the UK.
- 40:27But part of this road map as a company is continuously
- 40:30expanding into other jurisdictions that would
- 40:34provide, let's say more a more neutral exposure to in terms of
- 40:38key management and protecting against maybe the United States
- 40:42or Western countries attacking Bitcoin in a more coordinated
- 40:45manner. So I'd be curious to hear just
- 40:47your thoughts. Definitely don't want to make it
- 40:50about what we do here. But like do you see multi
- 40:53institution as a potential, not to say on ramp only, but I think
- 40:57this is where the industry goes where you have keys distributed
- 41:00in many different jurisdictions to ultimately not allow for any
- 41:03single institution to be coerced by an individual government at
- 41:06any given time. I'm so glad you brought this up,
- 41:10Jackson, because I literally have expressed to every
- 41:14collaborative custody company that, that, that I've spoken
- 41:17with the importance of this very thing that the collaborative
- 41:22custody only becomes truly resilient if you are
- 41:28internationalized, meaning you're not you're, you know,
- 41:32like right now, if your collaborative custody setup is
- 41:35all US entities, then the US government has the jurisdiction
- 41:39to crack down on that and basically call up all the US
- 41:42entities and say, hand over the keys.
- 41:47Now, if you have an international set up, you
- 41:50mentioned the UK, but think of countries like Switzerland or
- 41:53Liechtenstein that have robust privacy and security laws around
- 41:58handing over that data. And there are other countries
- 42:02like that too. The more that collaborative
- 42:05custody can become resilient and hardened on an international
- 42:10basis, then the US government has a lot less ability to say,
- 42:15OK, I'm going to call up, you know, the local domestic
- 42:18custodian and say hand over the keys.
- 42:20They might be able to get that 1/3 of the two of the two out of
- 42:23three set up. But if they can't get the 2, the
- 42:25other two keys or one of the other two keys, then you're OK
- 42:29as a, as the owner of those assets.
- 42:32To me, that's that's what's going to take collaborative
- 42:35custody to the next level is having that international
- 42:38robustness where no single government can can cause
- 42:43problem. Now still in theory, the US
- 42:46could call Switzerland and say, hey, hand it over.
- 42:49But that's a lot harder to do logistically for for the US,
- 42:54especially if Switzerland isn't in the same situation that the
- 42:57US is fiscally and says why should we agree with you?
- 43:00Because that's going to harm our domestic financial sector, and
- 43:04we don't want that. So it won't be in our interest
- 43:06to to agree to whatever the US is doing.
- 43:08And by the way, if the US is collapsing, they're not going to
- 43:11be really in a position to tell anyone else what to do.
- 43:14So I do think that the international piece of it is
- 43:17really, really important. And I'd say it's a product that
- 43:20I'm most anxiously awaiting. Interesting, Yeah.
- 43:25It's exciting because I really think we're in an interesting
- 43:29time as an industry because, but at least for right now we have,
- 43:34we are, we have bought ourselves more time where there's good and
- 43:37bad in terms of policy. A little bit we discussed today,
- 43:40we didn't discuss stable coins. We might not be able to get to
- 43:43it today, but ultimately the industry has some breathing room
- 43:47to be building out solutions that will ultimately protect the
- 43:50end investor. Now what we just talked about, I
- 43:55don't know if I have the conviction to say it strongly,
- 43:59but I think the United States would not allow the ETFs to have
- 44:03keys outside of the United States as part of a multi say
- 44:06quorum. But you have companies like on
- 44:09Ramp or you have other companies that have built around multi sig
- 44:14like Unchained and Casa. Like I ultimately do think even
- 44:17though we're really the firm that's pioneered multi
- 44:19institution custody, I think the industry has to go this way for
- 44:23individuals, for for institutional investors, whether
- 44:27they recognize it or not just yet, and even for corporate
- 44:29treasuries. Because at some point, if
- 44:31Bitcoin does appreciate to the level that we all expect, you
- 44:37can imagine, you're right, you mentioned in that reckoning, you
- 44:39can imagine people going after the individuals who own a lot of
- 44:42Bitcoin. Well, what about the entities
- 44:44that own a lot of Bitcoin? And so I could even see this.
- 44:47Yeah, absolutely. And I could even see this
- 44:48happening, you know, where you're based in Texas.
- 44:52I could see this happening with states as well, where they're
- 44:54going to want to have keys held within their jurisdiction and
- 44:58have a little bit more autonomy, maybe similar to what we kind of
- 45:01saw with COVID where you had states react differently with
- 45:04their their policies around Bitcoin.
- 45:09I, I think the most important point, the thing that we should
- 45:12have all learned from COVID, from the financial crisis, from
- 45:15911, these three big crises we've had in the 21st century is
- 45:20that in every case, things that we never thought were possible
- 45:24from a policy standpoint, that people would never accept from a
- 45:28policy standpoint suddenly became acceptable in terms of
- 45:32restrictions on economic or individual freedom.
- 45:36And we've got to believe based on that history that if there
- 45:41are real debt crisis, the US would not hesitate.
- 45:44They might be temporary measures.
- 45:45They might say, oh, the temporarily we're going to halt
- 45:49the exchange of U.S. dollars for Bitcoin temporarily we're going
- 45:54to confiscate or, or hold the keys or, you know, kind of
- 45:59nationalize a coin base custody or the other big, you know,
- 46:03Bitco or whatever it is, you know, we'll nationalize the
- 46:06domestic custodians temporarily just to make sure that we could
- 46:10secure everything. And of course temporary becomes
- 46:12permanent. That's in fact what happened in
- 46:141971. So when we broke from the peg
- 46:19from the US, the US dollar and gold, which was at that point
- 46:22$35 a Troy oz. Now it's 3500 a Troy oz.
- 46:28When we, when we made that break, the, the, the decision
- 46:31makers in the Nixon administration saw it as a
- 46:33temporary move. They closed the gold window for
- 46:36foreign governments. And so we're just going to do
- 46:38this for a short period of time in hopes that we can kind of not
- 46:43go broke because they were running out of gold literally,
- 46:46and then figure out what to do next later.
- 46:49But they never figured out what to do next later.
- 46:51They just permanently went off the gold bag.
- 46:53And that was the end of that. And we've been living with the
- 46:56consequences for the last 54 years.
- 46:58So crises, we've seen that in crises, the government will do
- 47:03extraordinary things and justify it because it's an emergency
- 47:06situation. And this article, then They
- 47:10Fight You article is really contemplating a lot of what
- 47:13those emergency measures could be.
- 47:18Yeah, everyone should certainly check it out.
- 47:20Just yeah, we we have to think a little bit adversarial adverse
- 47:24seriously as an industry, but I want to be respectful of time.
- 47:28And now we've been recording for about 45 minutes or so.
- 47:32More recently, you joined Strive on the board of directors.
- 47:35I saw your LinkedIn post where you said after a dozen years or
- 47:39so working in the nonprofit sector, you're going back to
- 47:42your original line of work, which is asset management.
- 47:44So could you share a little bit more about your decision to join
- 47:48the Strive team on the board? You know, what excites you about
- 47:51it? And then maybe we can go into a
- 47:53little bit more detail on some of the news more recently and
- 47:56maybe institutional portfolios of the future involving Bitcoin.
- 48:01Well, it's, it's, it's one of those crazy stories.
- 48:03You know, I, I worked on, on Wall Street as a hedge fund
- 48:06investor in biotech and healthcare companies for a dozen
- 48:08years before I got into public policy.
- 48:10And during that phase of my life, which was the 2000s and 20
- 48:15tens, you know, Vivek Ramaswami and I were counterparts.
- 48:19We were biotech investors at, you could say competing funds.
- 48:24So we knew each other through that and, and we're friends.
- 48:28And then obviously we went off on our different tax tracks.
- 48:30He I started a billion dollar company and I went into the
- 48:33nonprofit space, but we stayed in touch over the years.
- 48:36He joined the board of free OP actually, and was a supporter of
- 48:38our work for many years and then ran for president, of course,
- 48:41and, and started strive. And, and so he had had seen that
- 48:46I'd, I'd stepped down as the CEO of a free OP that the think tank
- 48:50that I'd started in 2016. I'm now chairman of the board
- 48:53there, but I'm no longer the CEO.
- 48:57And so he literally called me the next day and was like, Hey,
- 48:59I, I have an idea for how you can spend your free time and,
- 49:03and mentioned what that Strive was pivoting from being that
- 49:06this historically Strive would been founded to be an ETF issuer
- 49:11that was competing against the black rocks the world as a way
- 49:14of saying, hey, if BlackRock is not going to invest in energy
- 49:16companies because of an ESG mandate, we're going to, we're
- 49:21going to have an ETF for energy companies.
- 49:23We'll call it drill and we'll we'll we'll take all the the
- 49:26investors appetite for energy. So started doing that for a
- 49:31while, but then Larry Fink and BlackRock responded in the way
- 49:35that capitalists ought to I suppose, and said, OK, Viveka
- 49:39and his team have identified this gap in the market.
- 49:42We shouldn't let them have that gap because they're getting some
- 49:44traction with it. So let's calm down on our anti
- 49:48or ESG campaign. And, and they started to win
- 49:51back some of that market share that that Strive took.
- 49:54Strive still is doing pretty well.
- 49:55They raised a considerable amount of money, I think it's
- 49:58over 2 billion for their ETS. But it was clear that that was,
- 50:04you know, that the competitors had woken up to what Strive had
- 50:08identified as a gap in the market and the growth trajectory
- 50:11was going to slow going forward. And around this time also, Vivek
- 50:16became a Bitcoiner. He had not been a Bitcoiner, you
- 50:19know, 10 years ago, but he became a Bitcoiner.
- 50:21And the CEO of Strive, Matt Cole, also was a Bitcoiner.
- 50:26And so the two of them got together and said, hey, let's
- 50:29look at what Michael Saylor is doing.
- 50:31We can come up with a, an iteration of that strategy where
- 50:35we can later in our own expertise and our own knowledge.
- 50:38Vivek in the context of being a biotech hedge fund guy and Matt
- 50:42Cole being a guy who ran a $70 billion bond portfolio at
- 50:47CalPERS, the California Public Employee Retirement System
- 50:50pension fund, which is one of the largest investment funds in
- 50:53the world. And the two of them were like,
- 50:55Hey, we, we've got some ideas on how to take the state, the core
- 50:58sailor idea and iterate on it in a way that could build the next
- 51:02great Bitcoin treasury company. And, and so Vivek called, said,
- 51:06Hey, we'd love for you to, to get involved in what we're doing
- 51:09here. And it was, it was, you know, I
- 51:12said, I said, well, you know, I'm busy, but I'd love to, I'd
- 51:15love to be helpful. And the more time I spent with
- 51:18Matt, the more time I spent with Vivek, the more it was clear
- 51:21that this is going to be the most exciting thing that I could
- 51:23possibly do with my time. Is someone who's long thought of
- 51:26how to go full time in Bitcoin, but also had all these efforts
- 51:32in, you know, the public policy world and things like that, that
- 51:36I didn't want to completely abandoned.
- 51:39This turned out to be the perfect way to get more involved
- 51:41how to how to build a great Bitcoin treasury company that
- 51:46that can deliver a lot of value to investors.
- 51:49Now I know that there are in the within, of course, outside the
- 51:54Bitcoin community, there are people who don't like anything
- 51:56about Bitcoin, let alone Bitcoin treasury companies.
- 51:58But even within the Bitcoin committee, there are people who
- 52:00argue, well, these Bitcoin treasury companies, they're
- 52:04they're it's not real Bitcoin. You should just hold your own
- 52:06Bitcoin and self custody or if at worst, hold the ETF and not
- 52:12worry about these additional these kinds of these other
- 52:15strategies. And we can get into that if you
- 52:17want. But, but that's something I,
- 52:18I'm, I'm, I feel very, I feel very comfortable and confident
- 52:23that there are a lot of opportunities to deliver value
- 52:27through a treasury company because there's so many
- 52:30subtleties about the way people can invest in Bitcoin in, in the
- 52:36various, in, in their funds, in their retirement accounts,
- 52:39governments, there's so many mandates and barriers to how
- 52:43institutions can hold Bitcoin that treasury companies being
- 52:48publicly listed equity companies, But you know, being
- 52:51listed in the stock market can create a lot of utility.
- 52:55And compared to an ETF, they can do a lot more to create value to
- 53:00shareholders compared to an ETF. And ETF has the same amount of
- 53:04Bitcoin per share forever in theory, other than the, the fees
- 53:08they charge investors. But the beauty of of a Bitcoin
- 53:11treasury company is that the Bitcoin per share can increase,
- 53:16and that's what makes the Bitcoin treasury company more
- 53:19attractive than ETF if you can get at the right price.
- 53:24I think, well, that's a fascinating story and thanks for
- 53:26sharing that. Just in terms of how you ended
- 53:28up getting involved with Strive, we should certainly talk about
- 53:32that with the remaining time that we have.
- 53:34How do you think personally about owning Bitcoin versus
- 53:38investing in Bitcoin treasury companies or other types of
- 53:42public or private market allocations to Bitcoin adjacent
- 53:45exposure? How do you think about that
- 53:47personally? And then how you mentioned, just
- 53:50like I see this too all the time, it's unrealistic to think
- 53:53that everyone, especially, you know, public companies going to
- 53:56be holding their own keys. And so there needs to be ways
- 54:01that not only just the ETS, but there should be other ways for
- 54:04investors to access Bitcoin, whether it's through the fixed
- 54:07income markets or through the equity market.
- 54:09So can you shed a little bit light how you think about this
- 54:11personally and how that kind of informed, you know, your
- 54:15involvement with Strive and their strategy?
- 54:18Yeah, I mean, it's certainly on a personal level, I mean, I
- 54:21would say a self custody or collaborative custody should be
- 54:24the core of 1's bitcoins holding.
- 54:25Because you know, the whole point of holding Bitcoin is that
- 54:28you want it to be resilient in times of crisis.
- 54:31And so any, you know, listed security is subject to the
- 54:36regulations and the permission of the US government.
- 54:38So to the degree you want to have your savings protected from
- 54:42that, you know, you want that core core of your savings to be
- 54:46in spot Bitcoin self custody or collaborative custody.
- 54:51And again, in a way that's censorship resistant.
- 54:54So I think that's important. I think anyone in a Bitcoin
- 54:56treasury company would tell you the same thing.
- 55:00Having said that, just like when you put money in your bank
- 55:03account, you'd, you'd love to collect kind of an interest
- 55:06payment on your, on your savings instead of it just sitting there
- 55:10collecting dust in it. In case of the US dollar
- 55:12declining in value, real value over time, the same is true with
- 55:16Bitcoin. Ideally we'd like our savings to
- 55:20to increase over time on a Bitcoin denominated basis,
- 55:24right? So if you believe that one BTC
- 55:27equals one BTC, and that the way you should measure the value
- 55:31you've you've saved is in is denominating Bitcoin rather than
- 55:34dollars, well, how do you outperform Bitcoin?
- 55:38And the the simplest way I'd I'd put it is one way to outperform
- 55:43Bitcoin if you believe that the US dollar will decline in value
- 55:46over time is to pair your long Bitcoin position with a short
- 55:52USD position. Short the dollar and long the
- 55:55Bitcoin. And just as an ETF is basically
- 55:59a way of longing Bitcoin because that's all it is, a Bitcoin
- 56:03treasury company can be thought of as an ETF that's short the
- 56:08dollar and long Bitcoin at the same time.
- 56:11And that's what drives the outperformance.
- 56:13The outperformance comes from selling the US dollar in the and
- 56:18what I mean by selling the US dollar is by borrowing in U.S.
- 56:21dollars. That's effectively a way of
- 56:23selling the US dollar as anyone, any institutional investor who's
- 56:26listening knows that's what what it means to sell something short
- 56:29is You're actually borrowing the shares to sell short.
- 56:32So similarly, if you're taking on debt, you're effectively
- 56:35selling that instrument, betting on its value going down and
- 56:40you're taking that dollar that you're selling short and
- 56:44investing in Bitcoin. And there are different ways to
- 56:47do it. And the, and what's going to be
- 56:48really fun about this next 12 to 24 months is you're going to
- 56:52start to see that emergence of different strategies for how to
- 56:57execute on the Bitcoin treasury playbook.
- 57:00So obviously Sailor has been the innovator.
- 57:03He's developed his behemoth and you know, he's experimenting
- 57:07with a lot of different things. He started with secondary
- 57:10offerings at the at the market, the ATM.
- 57:14He also experimented with convertible debt at a time when
- 57:17interest rates were zero. So that was great.
- 57:19Good move, Mike. But now he's shifting to issuing
- 57:23preferred securities so that it's less dilutive to the common
- 57:27shareholders. A really smart idea and he's
- 57:30been iterating on that. So that's all great, but I'd say
- 57:34that, you know, the rest of us can learn from that.
- 57:36What can we learn from that One that that if you want to serve
- 57:40the common shareholders, the way to do that is to really not use
- 57:44convertible debt and use preferred instruments instead,
- 57:48because the preferred instruments don't dilute the
- 57:53common shareholders the way convertible debt does if the
- 57:55converts convert into shares. And so some people have a lot of
- 58:01the Bitcoin treasury companies that have come come around,
- 58:04particularly the US based ones that will last 12 months.
- 58:07They've they've used the convertible debt strategy and,
- 58:11and and I think that could work for some of them.
- 58:13But it's going to be interesting to see.
- 58:15I think one thing that Strive is really emphasized and and you'll
- 58:19see this in our SEC filings that our emphasis at least for the
- 58:24time being is not so much on convertible debt.
- 58:26We are not offering any convertible debt at the moment,
- 58:29but we are planning to issue preferred preferred shares,
- 58:34preferred equity as a way of raising more money, our version
- 58:38of shorting the dollar to invest in big.
- 58:44We actually have no debt on the balance sheet today, zero debt
- 58:47as of today. It's fascinating, yeah.
- 58:49It's great to be able to leverage the learnings from
- 58:51Sailor over the past four or five years and really put
- 58:54together a rock star team and strive between the people
- 58:57involved to the employee basis, but then also on the board of
- 59:00directors. I'm curious if we could just
- 59:03zoom out really quick outside of Strive and the more than less
- 59:08the mechanics and more so portfolio construction.
- 59:11I did a little bit of stocking of your ex profile ahead of
- 59:14recording and I saw that you had reposted something that caught
- 59:17my attention a few weeks back as well with Luke Roman.
- 59:21He posted a really fascinating chart where the S&P 500
- 59:27denominated in dollars and what you know, we all know what that
- 59:29chart looks like up and to the right versus the S&P 500
- 59:32denominated in goal. And so I'd be curious to hear
- 59:36your thoughts just in terms of let's say portfolios of the
- 59:41future, how do you think institutional investors thinking
- 59:44around portfolio construction may evolve over the next decade?
- 59:48Do you think that I think we're still on the fringes by
- 59:51denominating returns in gold, let alone Bitcoin, but do you
- 59:54think that there's going to be more of a focus on real returns
- 59:59and less nominal returns? And before you answer that, I
- 1:00:02just want to tie this into the the reckoning thesis as well,
- 1:00:06because you have, we talked about the federal government,
- 1:00:08but then you also have pension plans, right, as an obvious
- 1:00:11place to point as well. There's a lot of pension plans
- 1:00:13at the state level that are. Very underfunded as well.
- 1:00:17And so I think there are a lot of pools of capital that are
- 1:00:21going to need to reconfigure rejig how they're allocating
- 1:00:23capital. I'm curious how you kind of
- 1:00:26think about this given your background over the past three
- 1:00:29decades. It's a good question.
- 1:00:32I think the way the way I certainly looked at it as an
- 1:00:35institutional investor and when I raised money from other
- 1:00:38institutions, how those institutions looked at it
- 1:00:41typically and I think still look at it today is what's your
- 1:00:45hurdle rate? And you know, commonly you'll
- 1:00:48hear people say their hurdle rate might be, you know, the
- 1:00:51so-called risk free treasury, 10 year treasury or the funds rate
- 1:00:56or something like that. But typically 10 year treasuries
- 1:00:58would be one form of hurdle rate that people would look at.
- 1:01:02Another hurdle rate that you'd hear people look at is the S&P,
- 1:01:05what are the returns of the S&P if the S&P is averaging 8% a
- 1:01:08year? And maybe that's my hurdle rate
- 1:01:10for what I expect if I'm going to invest with you now in the
- 1:01:15Bitcoin era or the gold era, whichever it ends up being the
- 1:01:20hurdle rate, maybe a based on gold or Bitcoin, we'll have to
- 1:01:24see. But I think what this, this, the
- 1:01:27way this may evolve is not so much to, you know, which
- 1:01:31instrument are you picking as your hurdle rate, but the actual
- 1:01:34percentage return that standard may increase.
- 1:01:38And that may all be also be determined by inflation, as you
- 1:01:40said, right? So it could be what's the real
- 1:01:43rate of return for the S&P 500 or the treasuries relative to
- 1:01:49some of these other assets like Bitcoin or or gold.
- 1:01:53And it's going to be a slow, slow process because we're still
- 1:01:57at a point where big companies with a lot of Bitcoin on their
- 1:02:02balance sheet, whether they're specifically Bitcoin treasury
- 1:02:04companies or it's more like a a GameStop or Tesla that has some
- 1:02:08Bitcoin on their balance sheet. But as a portfolio, part of a
- 1:02:11portfolio, you know, it's going to be a really long time before
- 1:02:15Bitcoin is such a mainstream asset that every company in the
- 1:02:19S&P 500 has it in their portfolio the way they might
- 1:02:22have gold or treasury bonds today.
- 1:02:26So we still are a ways from that.
- 1:02:28Again, maybe that's the 10 year time frame or the 20 year time
- 1:02:31frame. But but to me, that's what makes
- 1:02:34me very relaxed about Bitcoins long term trajectory is that no
- 1:02:40matter how much the price has gone up over the last 10 years,
- 1:02:44it's still very, very, very early.
- 1:02:46It's that the real milestone of progress over the last couple of
- 1:02:50years has really been that the government now basically has
- 1:02:54allows us to, to make A to use Bitcoin in, in various ways that
- 1:02:59we didn't have the ability to do before.
- 1:03:01And that's great, but what the government gives up, give us,
- 1:03:04give us it can take it away. And and so the real question is,
- 1:03:08can we get to a point where the adoption is so wide, so broad,
- 1:03:13so deep that it becomes that much harder to take it?
- 1:03:16Well, we were still very far from that.
- 1:03:18But the success, I would argue of the Bitcoin treasury model is
- 1:03:22going to help drive that, right. So if if Bitcoin treasury
- 1:03:25companies are successful at driving value to their
- 1:03:29shareholders, then more and more companies are going to do it.
- 1:03:32And that's what we've seen, right?
- 1:03:33Like Michael Saylor turned what we used to call MicroStrategy
- 1:03:37now strategy from A $1 billion company to $100 billion company,
- 1:03:41literally the best performing stock in the S&P 500.
- 1:03:43It's not even in the S&P 500. And that's what's LED other
- 1:03:48companies to look around and say, hey, let's learn from that
- 1:03:51and let's let's let's do that. And it's often companies that,
- 1:03:56you know, the, a cynic might say are finding that their core
- 1:03:59operating business is not growing like gang investors.
- 1:04:01That's why they're relying on these strategies.
- 1:04:03But that's understandable. Like NVIDIA doesn't have to own
- 1:04:06Bitcoin. They have their core operating
- 1:04:08businesses going so crazy that they can put all their focus on
- 1:04:11that. But if you are a more
- 1:04:13conventional company in terms of your growth, Bitcoin is going to
- 1:04:17be an asset that's going to help drive your growth.
- 1:04:19It's going to beat your hurdle rate.
- 1:04:21And that will be true for more and more companies over time.
- 1:04:24And so I, I, I look at it as the more and more companies, the
- 1:04:28beauty of, of, of Bitcoin. I think the hardest thing for a
- 1:04:31lot of my old friends in the, in that the equities hedge fund
- 1:04:35business or the equity investing business to appreciate is, you
- 1:04:38know, when you buy a stock, you're used to thinking about
- 1:04:42the stock in terms, OK, what's my price target?
- 1:04:46And my price target is based on what I think, you know, at least
- 1:04:51the true fundamental investor would say my price target is
- 1:04:54based on the discounted cash flows or the discounted future
- 1:04:58earnings of the company. If I think over time the company
- 1:05:01will earn this over, you know, a 20 year period, then I'm.
- 1:05:05The stock price should theoretically reflect all those
- 1:05:09future cash flows. And so the, it is the, it is
- 1:05:13possible for a stock to be fully valued, right?
- 1:05:15Like if, if Tesla is at, I don't know, 1500 bucks, it implies
- 1:05:20that Tesla is selling literally every car in the world.
- 1:05:23And that's probably not happening, right?
- 1:05:25So there's a point in which Tesla's stock does become price
- 1:05:30to perfection or even exceeding the price of perfection, right?
- 1:05:33And so you can say, well, at that point I might sell the
- 1:05:35Tesla stock and, and do something else with my money.
- 1:05:40Bitcoin doesn't really have a price target in that same way.
- 1:05:43Because in a, in something that I think I find it's really hard
- 1:05:46for my equity stock friends to, to understand.
- 1:05:52Bitcoin actually becomes more valuable the more people use it.
- 1:05:57The more people are involved in the Bitcoin network, the more
- 1:06:01valuable Bitcoin is. And so there is no real price
- 1:06:05target. We can all say, Oh well, my
- 1:06:07price target is when Bitcoin market cap is equal to gold or
- 1:06:10whatever, but that's not really a price target in the same way.
- 1:06:13And that we all know that Bitcoin is more useful than gold
- 1:06:17because it can be transmitted over the Internet in gigantic
- 1:06:21quantities. I can't take my Brinks truck of
- 1:06:23gold bars and take it with me to Mexico.
- 1:06:27I'll get stopped at the border, but I can send a billion dollars
- 1:06:30of Bitcoin as quickly as I can send an e-mail.
- 1:06:34That's not possible with gold. And so what's your price target
- 1:06:37for Bitcoin, Right. And I think, I think my argument
- 1:06:40is that I'm going to hold Bitcoin as long as as I'm able
- 1:06:45because there is no real price target.
- 1:06:46The value will only increase as the network of people who use
- 1:06:51Bitcoin increases. I know we have to wrap up here
- 1:06:55in just a few minutes. I'd be curious on that same
- 1:06:58thread, are you able to share it all, just reactions from your
- 1:07:03network or even the people in the institutional space that
- 1:07:05used to work with on the equity side?
- 1:07:07I'm sure they've known about your personal involvement in
- 1:07:09Bitcoin for a while. What what do they think about
- 1:07:12your professional involvement now joining Shriver?
- 1:07:14A lot of your peers, are they, have they come around to Bitcoin
- 1:07:18over that time? Are they still very skeptical of
- 1:07:20it as an asset? I think it's a mix.
- 1:07:23I think that a lot of I would say that my friend, the more
- 1:07:27successful my friend has been a particular friend has been, the
- 1:07:31more skeptical they are at Bitcoin.
- 1:07:33I think if you've had a lot of success as an investor investing
- 1:07:37in a more traditional way, you're just more likely to see
- 1:07:41Bitcoin as something I don't need to think about.
- 1:07:43Whereas I think if you are perhaps a more, and I think also
- 1:07:49just people who are focused on stocks and they're just so used
- 1:07:52to looking at, OK, what's the income statement of this
- 1:07:54company? What's the discounted cash
- 1:07:56flows. They just can't get their heads
- 1:07:58around the fact that Bitcoin is not a stock.
- 1:08:00It doesn't have cash flows in the same way that a corporate
- 1:08:05conventional corporation does. So it's really hard for them.
- 1:08:08I think where you see a lot more interest in Bitcoin is among the
- 1:08:12macro investors. So the macro investors who are
- 1:08:14used to thinking about the federal debt, the bond market,
- 1:08:20particularly the sovereign debt market, the Ray Dalio types,
- 1:08:25those are the ones who tend to be much more interested in
- 1:08:29Bitcoin, less hostile to it, more understanding of the thesis
- 1:08:34behind Bitcoin, whether they're directly involved or not.
- 1:08:37A lot of those people tend to be more gold buggy if they're
- 1:08:40particularly if they're older. But but I think that's where
- 1:08:44you're starting to see the real, the real driver of Bitcoin
- 1:08:47adoption institutionally is that sort of more macro oriented
- 1:08:50investor, the more sector specific or stock based
- 1:08:55investors, there's, there's still a bit a bit off,
- 1:08:58especially if they're in a sector where they can make money
- 1:09:01like biotech, you know, it's had its ups and downs over the
- 1:09:04years. It's, it's volatile like Bitcoin
- 1:09:06is, but you can make a lot of money as a biotech investor if
- 1:09:11you if you, if you have a good investment process.
- 1:09:13And so I think the people who are in a sector like that, they
- 1:09:17tend to be the ones who are least interested in thinking
- 1:09:19about something different. Understood.
- 1:09:23Yeah, that makes a lot of sense. Well over now, Yeah, that's
- 1:09:27right for now, right, Because on a long enough time frame, I, I
- 1:09:31think we both believe that all businesses, all individuals will
- 1:09:34likely own Bitcoin or maybe not all, but you know, we'll see.
- 1:09:37I feel confident that majority of people over the next decade
- 1:09:40or two will have some exposure to Bitcoin, whether it's through
- 1:09:42direct ownership, through ETFs, through treasury companies.
- 1:09:46But you know, to your point, it's still very early innings
- 1:09:48with just Bitcoin being a $2 trillion asset among what you
- 1:09:52cited about you said $400 trillion of, of wealth US
- 1:09:55denominated. Is that right?
- 1:09:57Yeah, that that comes from a Credit Suisse report there now
- 1:10:00UBS that comes out every year. They they act, they calculate
- 1:10:04the amount of wealth and willingness, 450 trillion is
- 1:10:06their most recent estimate. There are different estimates
- 1:10:08that are out there, but Bitcoin is obviously it's only 2
- 1:10:12trillion is a very small percentage of that today.
- 1:10:14And look, any investor, any professional investor knows that
- 1:10:19your biggest winners as an investor are the ideas where
- 1:10:22you're both contrarian and right.
- 1:10:25But if if everybody agrees with you, the likelihood that you're
- 1:10:28going to make a lot of money on that trade is a very low.
- 1:10:31It's only when a lot of people disagree with you that you make
- 1:10:34money on a trade or an investment strategy.
- 1:10:37And that's why I'm relaxed about Bitcoin.
- 1:10:39I'm very aware that a lot of people disagree with me about
- 1:10:43and you about about Bitcoins long term trajectory.
- 1:10:47But that's what means that it's going to be successful if we're
- 1:10:50right. That's right.
- 1:10:52Yeah. I, I natively thought that at
- 1:10:54$100,000 per Bitcoin at the end of last year, there would be a
- 1:10:57little bit more interest from the mainstream, but certainly
- 1:11:02haven't seen that on my side. A lot of the conversations we
- 1:11:04have as a business are with the sophisticated individuals that
- 1:11:07already own Bitcoin and are thinking about, you know, one
- 1:11:10step ahead of the risks. And on the institutional side, I
- 1:11:13shared a little bit before we hit record.
- 1:11:15Typically you need to have an internal advocate or champion
- 1:11:19that's really understands Bitcoin very deeply as an
- 1:11:22individual. And they're the ones that are
- 1:11:23pushing for Bitcoin as part of a firm strategy.
- 1:11:26But outside of that, like call it .1% or 1% of fields of the
- 1:11:30United States population, 99% still think we're a little bit
- 1:11:35out there, but maybe that changes over the next decade.
- 1:11:38Yeah. You know, there was a, there was
- 1:11:39a really nice profile over the weekend that we're recording
- 1:11:43this of Mark Casey, who's the portfolio manager at Capital
- 1:11:48Group, one of the largest funds in the world based in the LA
- 1:11:52area. They have, you know, they're the
- 1:11:55largest holder of micro strategy or strategy and it's it's a
- 1:11:58great, it's a great profile because they they talk about
- 1:12:00this contradiction of like, you know, Mark Casey sees himself as
- 1:12:04a Warren Buffett style investor. Capital Group is, you know, one
- 1:12:07of those kind of traditional places that has a traditional
- 1:12:10approach to investing. And here they are doing this
- 1:12:12pretty non consensus thing of loading up on on MSTR and, and
- 1:12:18he walks through, you know, how that how that happened at
- 1:12:22Capital Group and capital groups a bit of an outlier in terms of
- 1:12:25their their stance. It's made them a lot of money.
- 1:12:28I think they made something like 5 or $6 billion from it.
- 1:12:30So congratulations to them. But I think that article really
- 1:12:34describes the process that will have to happen at all these
- 1:12:38other funds to get similar update.
- 1:12:40I'll. Have to check that out.
- 1:12:43Well Ovic, really enjoyed the conversation.
- 1:12:46Appreciative of your time. For anyone who wants to get in
- 1:12:48touch with you or learn more about what you're currently
- 1:12:51focused on. Where should we send them?
- 1:12:53Well, my Twitter X handle is just my first name, AVIK.
- 1:12:57That's the best way to find me. And also check out free op.org,
- 1:13:02FREOP p.org. That's my think tank where we do
- 1:13:05a lot of work on Big Point and some of the stuff we've
- 1:13:07mentioned and of course Strive as well.
- 1:13:10Thanks again over. Thanks, Jackson.
- 1:13:13Thanks for listening to this week's episode of the show.
- 1:13:15If you found the information valuable, please share the
- 1:13:17episode with a friend or leave a rating on your favorite podcast
- 1:13:20app. All the links we discussed in
- 1:13:22today's show will be in the show notes inside your podcast app.
- 1:13:25Before we finish, a quick reminder that Onramp Media is
- 1:13:27for informational and entertainment purposes only, and
- 1:13:30nothing should be construed as investment or legal advice.
- 1:13:33Regardless of where you are on your Bitcoin journey, we'd love
- 1:13:36to hear from you. Visit onrampbitcoin.com contact
- 1:13:39to schedule a consultation with one of our private client
- 1:13:42advisors.