Latest / Psychology In Seattle Podcast / Colleen Balinger's 2nd Apology and Patron Emails
Transcript
- 0:00Hey is our listeners. A week or two ago, I published a video
- 0:04analyzing the public apology from the public figure named Colleen Balinger. And sometimes when
- 0:13I make a video like this, I think that I should also publish to
- 0:17the audio feed. It doesn't happen very often, but occasionally it does,
- 0:21and so I thought I would do that here. If you don't know who
- 0:24Calleen Balaner is, she is an entertainer on YouTube and for in the live
- 0:33shows like on stage and whatnot, and on social media. She is an
- 0:38entertainer for what seems to be her main audience is young people, like you
- 0:43know, middle school age kids or high school age kids. And she is
- 0:49kind of a clown if you just google her and look up, and I
- 0:53mean clown, and I suppose the positive way where she will dress up in
- 0:58odd clothes. He's kind of like a modern day clown. Like she puts
- 1:02on her her lipstick in this very uneven way. She has very uneven makeup
- 1:10and hair and outfits. Not all the time. Sometimes she just is wearing
- 1:14standard outfits and whatnot. But she is a silly person. But she you
- 1:23know, she's not employed by some production company. It seems she's just a
- 1:26person who decided to become big. You know, in the old days you
- 1:32had people like in Seattle we had JB. Patches, But I guess more
- 1:37broadly, you would have people like Pev Herman or something. And these are
- 1:42figures that we loved, you know, mister Rogers and whatnot. And the
- 1:48thing that is not necessarily the case anymore is back then you would have a
- 1:52whole production team that would be corraling these these performers for better for worse,
- 1:59right, meaning that if Pee Wee Herman, if the actor Paul Rubins,
- 2:07if he decided that he wanted to do something a little beyond the standard,
- 2:14well the standards of entertainment at the time for kids, then the producers,
- 2:21directors and maybe even the FCC the government would actually say, no, you
- 2:25can't publish that, whereas today the vast majority of content providers for children are
- 2:34completely unregulated. And what we're hoping is that YouTube will regulate these folks,
- 2:40but they typically do not. So my impression is that YouTube does not want
- 2:46to get into the business of having to spend billions of dollars monitoring and responding
- 2:53to all these complaints. You know, of course, they have some standard,
- 2:58but I think that they don't want to put the message out there that
- 3:04that is their job. Maybe they're hoping another agency. I don't know,
- 3:07or well, I guess the more cynical view, which is probably the accurate
- 3:12view, is that YouTube makes a lot more money when they're unregulated, so
- 3:15they make money from the content, and there's a lot of advertisers that will
- 3:20put ads in those things anyway. So Colleen Ballinger seemingly, from my understanding,
- 3:24was one of those unregulated content providers that was providing a lot of entertainment
- 3:30that if you just watch like her full catalog, a lot of our entertainment
- 3:36was pretty standard stuff, stuff that you would see on television back in the
- 3:42old days or even today. But because she's unregulated and she's seemingly making content
- 3:49twenty four to seven, you know, the way that these kind of content
- 3:52providers are they well, I'm kind of in that category to some extent.
- 3:57It's weird. A peek behind the curtain is that when you are a content
- 4:01provider like myself, there's never enough time in the day to make all the
- 4:08content that the fans want and are asking for. So there's that also,
- 4:15there's not enough time in the day to or I should say for every minute
- 4:21of content that one provides as a content provider, that makes you money.
- 4:27I mean it's not like, you know, one minute equals x amount of
- 4:30pennies or something. But but the more content you make, the more money
- 4:34you make. And when you have you know that incentive, and you have
- 4:41fans that are asking for more. And you're also self employed, so you
- 4:45never know when the rug's going to be pulled out from underneath you. There's
- 4:48this compulsion to just make content and content and content, and you know,
- 4:53strike while the iron's hot kind of a thing. And then I think calling
- 4:58balancer also has some issues that led to her having some bad judgment making some
- 5:04content that was risking harm to children maybe and seemingly also did harm some minors
- 5:13allegedly. So that's a little background on her if you don't know her.
- 5:18So let's get to that video. And then after the video, I thought
- 5:21I would answer some emails to flesh out this episode and make every minute possible
- 5:29for my content provision service to you. All right, let's listen to that
- 5:35episode. Hey, deserver listeners, A lot of you have been asking me
- 5:39to react to Colleen Ballinger's new apology video. I'm curious what she has to
- 5:45say. If you remember, she had a different apology video from a few
- 5:48months ago where she was playing the ukulele, it didn't go over very well
- 5:53with the public. Let's watch. Hello everybody. Sorry I've been gone for
- 5:58so long. I've really missed this, miss talking to everyone every single day.
- 6:01Obviously, the last view that I posted on here, it's really embarrassing
- 6:09to say the least. I was being accused of some pretty awful things and
- 6:14I just was mad, and I should have handled that situation with maturity and
- 6:18empathy. But instead I just let my ego take over, and I'm really
- 6:21disappointing myself. These apology videos are usually pretty brief, so often I have
- 6:28to almost read into the things that they're saying because they don't elaborate. Let's
- 6:33go phrase by phrase. It's really embarrassing to say the least. I was
- 6:40being accused of some pretty awful things, and I just was mad, and
- 6:45I should have handled that situation with maturity. Okay, So the first thing
- 6:48that I look for is is she sincere? Is their sincerity that's in the
- 6:54eye they beholder, and none of us can read her mind. Contrary to
- 6:58what body language x berts will claim, there is no way to read people's
- 7:01minds or eye movements to detect whether or not someone is telling the truth.
- 7:05So I've been developing this checklist over time because I've watched a lot of public
- 7:11apology videos by this point. So the first thing is what was the transgression
- 7:15exactly? I always or frequently I will go to Reddit and go to the
- 7:19subreddit that is called out of the loop. They say. Colleen Balinger is
- 7:25known for making goofy videos as Miranda Sings. That's the character, and her
- 7:29channel has millions of followers. She has been popular for years, including having
- 7:33a Netflix show and starring on Broadway. She was even Ariana Grande's vocal coach
- 7:40at one point. Wow, that's interesting. And then going on, a
- 7:44fan named Adam McIntyre claimed that Colleen sent him bra and panties. The same
- 7:51person alleged that Colleen brought up sex multiple times in a group chat with other
- 7:58young fans when he was a teen, by asking if he was a virgin
- 8:01and what his favorite position was. Right, So this is what I remember
- 8:05to be the core of the allegation, and I think there's proof of those
- 8:11exchanges. She made a video in response to all this when she was singing
- 8:15you know, the one with the ukulele. Some people called it distasteful and
- 8:20gross. So, in summary, apparently what the allegations were from the public
- 8:26and from individuals that new Colleen is that she, as an adult, was
- 8:31grooming kids. The typical clinical definition of grooming in my field is when a
- 8:37perpetrator is recruiting children or victims so that the perpetrator can abuse them, and
- 8:46it typically involves being nice to them, getting close to them, making everyone
- 8:50feel safe around the perpetrator. So is that the allegation that Colleen Balinger was
- 8:58a perpetrator or is it orbetrator? You know? The general gist of the
- 9:01transgression has to do with calling Balinger on stage and online during live streams,
- 9:09but also in DMS, was communicating in ways with miners that people would consider
- 9:16to be inappropriate or harmful, or exposing children to things that they should be
- 9:22exposed to. Also physically, there were allegations that calling Balinger and there's a
- 9:28video of it, calling Balinger being physically inappropriate with miners on stage, where
- 9:35like there was this one video where one of the kids that she had on.
- 9:37She's a comedian, so the kids are just rolling on the ground laughing.
- 9:43And then she would get volunteers to come up on stage and one of
- 9:46the kids, I don't know how old the kid was, but clearly a
- 9:48kid, and she had him put cheeseballs, like a tin of cheeseballs down
- 9:54his pants or something, or down her pants, and then she told the
- 9:58kid to grab out of the tin. But you know the tin was it
- 10:03wasn't like down down her pants. It was propped within her pants, I
- 10:07guess. But again, any right minded entertainer for children would refrain from that
- 10:13stunt. The fact that she was doing that at the very least is just
- 10:18bad judgment and raises the risk for harm. I think that's the main thing
- 10:22we need to focus on, is harm. The reason why I want to
- 10:24delineate all this is because often in these public apologies, I don't understand why
- 10:31the public is exactly upset. You know, I understand that there's something that
- 10:35was out of the norm, and I hear a lot of people online saying
- 10:39it's inappropriate, or it's wrong, or it's grooming or whatever, and I'm
- 10:43thinking, Okay, what exactly is the harm that happened. Let's really describe
- 10:50it. You know, if the public is up in arms about harm to
- 10:54children, then that makes sense to me. It's really embarrassing, to say
- 10:58the least. I was being accused of some pretty awful things and I just
- 11:05was mad and I should have handled that situation with maturity. Okay. So
- 11:09we hear her saying that she was accused of something, so she's not saying
- 11:13that she did something, and that sounds like she actually is not admitting that
- 11:20she did anything wrong. So far, all she is apologizing for really is
- 11:26the previous apology video that it was embarrassing to her. I should have handled
- 11:33that situation with maturity and empathy, but instead I just let my ego take
- 11:37over and I'm really disappointing myself. Okay, So that's actually pretty good.
- 11:41She's acknowledging I should have been more empathetic. Do you believe that she's being
- 11:46genuine? Hard to know. So here's what I want to say today.
- 11:58Over the last fifteen years years of my career, there have been moments where
- 12:03I was immature and inappropriate with some of my comedy, and there were times
- 12:09when I did not put enough thought into some of my fan interactions. Okay,
- 12:13so that's acknowledging it, depending on what she's referring to. But I
- 12:18think that's pretty solid acknowledgment that she's saying I was inappropriate with my fans.
- 12:24I think she could really drive it home by identifying an example or by saying
- 12:30I was inappropriate with minors. Over the last fifteen years of my career,
- 12:35there have been moments where I was immature and inappropriate. Immature and inappropriate,
- 12:43Yeah, those are good descriptors. Again, I'd love it if she gave
- 12:48us an example. I'm guessing she won't. Some of my comedy and there
- 12:52were times when I did not put enough thought into some of my fan interactions,
- 12:56and because of that behavior, people got hurt. That's good. If
- 13:01you believe her even halfway, then that meets the definition of an apology.
- 13:07You know that she acknowledges the harm that she caused. She's not blaming it
- 13:13on anybody else, at least in this moment. And she's saying I was
- 13:16inappropriate and immature with my fans, and I didn't. She says I didn't
- 13:22give enough thought to my interactions with fans. Yeah, it's certainly not as
- 13:30descriptive or as harsh as the way everyone else puts it. Right, she
- 13:35could say something like, I was an appropriate for example, I sent a
- 13:41pair of bra, a pair of bra. I sent a pair of panties
- 13:46and a bra to a miner who was a fan who was a miner.
- 13:52Now when you hear that to me, it sounds worse than it actually was.
- 13:56It's still bad. But what actually happened. And I remember watching the
- 14:01video. She is doing a live stream and there's a lot of people watching
- 14:07and you know, chatting and chatting, and she was with one of her
- 14:09colleagues and she was unboxing new clothing items and she would take out like ooh,
- 14:16these pants are silly. They look funny, and then she would put
- 14:20them on her head or whatever. And that was part of the charm that
- 14:24people were looking for with her. And within that pile of a lot of
- 14:30different garments, there were unused panties and a bra. On the live stream,
- 14:35she said, okay, who wants because she was sending these items to
- 14:39her fans, and it seemed that to her fans it was this wonderful offering
- 14:43because they would be able to have some connection with her to be sent an
- 14:48actual item from one of the videos. You know, they would frame it
- 14:54or something which you know, I get it. I have my parasocial relationships
- 14:58too. And one of the fans said I want the bron panties, and
- 15:03she joked around and said, okay, I'll send it to you. That's
- 15:05a lot different than the way it sounded at first to me. You know,
- 15:09it's a lot different than she had her own used panties and bra and
- 15:13she as a way of soliciting sex or trying to suggest sex to a biner.
- 15:18She sent her own garments to a fan who was a child. You
- 15:24know, it's a lot different. It's still, as she says, inappropriate.
- 15:26I'm not a huge fan of the word inappropriate because it's not descriptive enough.
- 15:31People use it for all sorts of meanings. You know. The phrase
- 15:35that I would say is that she was doing things that could easily harm children,
- 15:41even though the children wouldn't even necessarily know that they're being harmed or indicate
- 15:46that they're being harmed. This is something that we absolutely understand that when victims
- 15:52are being harmed, particularly when it comes to sexual exploitation or coercion, the
- 15:58victims often don't know that they're being harmed. Sometimes they have a sense of
- 16:03it, but not always. For example, if you have parents who expose
- 16:08their children to pornography, the children might not feel the harm. They might
- 16:14not go, oh that hurts or that was a scary experience, or that
- 16:18damaged me. They probably won't, I mean, depending on the circumstances,
- 16:23know that it's happening. But you will see the harm later on in all
- 16:29likelihoods, particularly if it's a pattern and it involves other kinds of experiences,
- 16:33such that you will see the child start to exhibit all sorts of signs of
- 16:37the harm that had been happening to them, things like being overly sexualized,
- 16:41or being afraid of sex, or believing that they don't deserve sexual boundaries.
- 16:48And you know, there's all sorts of other effects that point to damage that
- 16:53occurred. You know, harm happened to the child. So that's the way
- 16:57I would describe it is that it's not inappropriate. It's not necessarily grooming,
- 17:03because to me, in my clinical circle, we would use grooming in a
- 17:07different context. What I would say is that it's exposing children minors to sexual
- 17:12content that very much risks harming them. That's the way I would describe it.
- 17:18Hence where I was immature and inappropriate with some of my comedy, and
- 17:25there were times when I did not put enough thought into some of my fan
- 17:27interactions, and because of that behavior, people got hurt and I am so
- 17:33sorry. She says the word I am so sorry. That is helpful in
- 17:40an apology, but I want to put the notion out there that saying I
- 17:45am sorry or I apologize does not necessarily mean that someone is apologizing. People
- 17:51walk away only knowing that rule oftentimes, and so they will say that,
- 17:56well, I said I was sorry, so why are you still sat at
- 18:00me? And that's all that they said. You know, they said,
- 18:03I am sorry, I apologize, Let's move on in life. And that's
- 18:07not what an apology is. An apology is it has eleven components. I've
- 18:11already been over all those things in other episodes, but just to go over
- 18:15them again, you need to acknowledge the transgression I did this. You need
- 18:19to acknowledge the harm I caused you harm. You need to take responsibility.
- 18:23It was my fault. You need to sincerely express remorse, meaning that you
- 18:29say something like I feel bad. You need to explain the cause without making
- 18:33excuses things like I have issues with this. Also, you need to provide
- 18:40a plan to address the cause. I will work on those factors that led
- 18:45to that behavior so that I will be less likely to do this in the
- 18:48future. There are other components as well. When I say a component of
- 18:52an effective apology, well, what constitutes an effective apology? Well, the
- 18:56way I define it is that the transgressed upon individual will feel as though the
- 19:03transgressor is genuinely sorry. If I were to hurt my wife's feelings during a
- 19:10conflict or something, and then I apologize, If I apologize such that she
- 19:15actually feels like I'm genuinely remorseful and that I will be trying not to do
- 19:21that again in the future, and I have a plan, I have a
- 19:25logical or a sensible plan about how I can try to reduce that behavior in
- 19:30the future, then I would call that an effective apology. Whereas if I
- 19:34just say I'm sorry or I apologize and that's it, then that's not effective.
- 19:38Plus you notice, when I have the examples here, there's no word
- 19:44sorry or apologize. So with my wife, if I heard of fels,
- 19:47I could say, hey, I just want to say that last night when
- 19:49we had our conflict. I feel bad because I harmed you. I'm guessing
- 19:56I hurt your feelings when I was being mean to you when I said this,
- 20:02this, and this, and I don't really have any excuse. I
- 20:06have a problem with doing that when I get upset. I'm not saying it's
- 20:11an excuse, but I have a tendency to do that sometimes. And my
- 20:15plan is to continue talking about it in therapy and trying to remind myself to
- 20:22remain differentiated, maybe take a break. Blah blah blah. Okay, so
- 20:26you notice, at least I think I never said I apologize or I'm sorry,
- 20:29and that's the thing I really want to get out there. And because
- 20:33of that behavior, people got hurt, and I am so sorry. I
- 20:38never wanted to hurt anybody, but it's clear that I did, and I
- 20:41feel so terrible about that. I also feel like there's probably people who are
- 20:47disappointed or feel abandoned. I always wish that the public figure would elaborate just
- 20:53a little bit. They almost never do. To me. It's like they
- 21:00in their apology provide topic sentences without writing the rest of the paragraph. Because
- 21:04it's possible that there's a lot there, she says seemingly in a genuine way.
- 21:10It could be an act, but it looked genuine. Who knows,
- 21:12but she says, I never wanted to hurt other people. I did hurt
- 21:18people, but I never wanted to hurt other people. I'm going to assume
- 21:21that that's genuine. There's no reason to believe that she lacks empathy, even
- 21:26though the Internet seems to think that half of the world lacks empathy. It's
- 21:30actually a fairly rare condition. You can have empathy that is impaired or eclipsed
- 21:37by defenses or circumstance or culture or something, especially given how much time that
- 21:41she has had to think about it and the consequences that have happened to her.
- 21:45I mean, there was a good couple weeks where seemingly everyone in the
- 21:52English speaking world hated her. That wouldn't feel very good, right, So
- 21:56I think that she probably genuinely feels sorry. He's like, oh, I
- 22:00never wanted to hurt anybody. But where's the rest of the paragraph? Unless
- 22:04she provides it, which I'm guessing she doesn't. I imagine the public just
- 22:07doesn't believe her. But I've heard from professionals who work in PR tell me
- 22:15that your apology should be very brief, and many PR professionals will say you
- 22:22should never apologize, And so I don't understand. Am I the only one
- 22:29that would, you know, even if I'm not a fan of hers,
- 22:32if she were to provide Like with idubs, for example, I did a
- 22:37reaction video to his apology, and I didn't know him. I only knew
- 22:41him because he had guessed he was a guest on other YouTube channels that I
- 22:45watched, So when he was apologizing to the public, he was kind of
- 22:49apologizing to me. And to me, I thought his apology felt genuine.
- 22:53It felt like a repair. It felt like he was truly dedicated to you,
- 23:00trying to make the world a better place, or at the very least,
- 23:02not make the world a worst place through his content, like how he
- 23:06thought he you know, he evaluated that some of his previous content was harmful
- 23:11to other people and putting a bad influence out there into the world for his
- 23:17fans to follow in his footsteps. He's like, I don't stand by those
- 23:21behaviors anymore. And the only reason I think that his apology worked on me
- 23:26was because he elaborated, you know, he provided examples. I also feel
- 23:30like there's probably people who are disappointed or feel abandoned by me because of my
- 23:33silence over the last few months, and I'm so sorry about that as well.
- 23:38I needed to take time to make sure I was listening and learning as
- 23:45much as possible, and I also needed to get the help that I needed
- 23:52to be okay. I'm a mom first and foremost before okay. So she
- 23:57said she got help, What does that mean? Does that mean therapy?
- 24:03And if so, does that mean that she went to a therapist that was
- 24:06conducive to this kind of problem, Because you know, she could go to
- 24:08therapy and just talk about the weather or something. It would be up to
- 24:12her to say, I have a problem, I have a track record,
- 24:17and I need to work on that. Get the help that I needed to
- 24:19be okay. I'm a mom first and foremost before anything else. And then
- 24:26she phrased it, I need the help that I needed to be okay.
- 24:30That seems to imply that she was suffering, which I believe because of the
- 24:34attacks, and she was getting help, meaning support, so that she could
- 24:40get through that time, which is totally fine. I would have recommended that
- 24:44she do that, but in addition, is she actually investigating what it is
- 24:48about her that, over the span of many years led her to exhibiting behavior
- 24:55that harmed other people or at least very much risked harm to minors. And
- 25:02so I'm going to do everything that I can to make sure that I create
- 25:04a positive, kind, inclusive, safe space online with my content. And
- 25:10if you want to be a part of my journey online, I would love
- 25:11to have you, and if not, I completely understand. Okay, So
- 25:15she just offered a topic sentence for another part of my apologies, which is
- 25:23to offer remedy. You know, I'll make it up to you by essentially,
- 25:29and she is saying that she's going to make it up to people.
- 25:33I think that's what she's saying. She's going to make it up to people
- 25:36by providing an inclusive, safe, non harmful place on the internet that her
- 25:41content is going to be I guess more buttoned up or more mature or something.
- 25:45Without elaboration, it's hard to know what she means. Though I expect
- 25:49anyone to welcome me back with open arms. I don't expect to change you
- 25:52one's mind of this video. I just wanted to come on here and say
- 25:56that I'm sorry, and I wanted to to try to show people that it's
- 26:02possible for someone to grow and learn and be better after making mistakes many many
- 26:07years ago. Great. Great, but show us the growth and the change
- 26:14you had a good start. Thank you for listening, and thank you to
- 26:17anyone who supported me in any capacity over the last fifteen years. I've really
- 26:19really appreciated it. Yeah, let's get started with the day and see what
- 26:25happens. I guess I honestly do not know how to transition from this conversation
- 26:29into a vlog, But let's try. Where do I even begin? So
- 26:33much has happened since the last time. Okay, so it was three minutes.
- 26:38I will watch the rest of this, but I probably won't include it
- 26:41in my video. But I'm going to watch the rest of this because maybe
- 26:44there's more apology in here somewhere. Let's try, where do I even begin?
- 26:48So much has happened since the last time I've vlogged. I mean,
- 26:52if I'm being completely honest, the majority of the last few months has just
- 26:55been spent in therapy. But other than that, the twins just turned too,
- 27:00which is okay, So she does say therapy, it's hard to know
- 27:03what that means. I'm guessing at the very least, it means that she
- 27:07was processing a lot of worry and pain and guilt and anger, you know,
- 27:15all the emotions that you imagine someone like this going through. Probably a
- 27:18lot. So the very least, I'm guessing there was that. But in
- 27:22therapy, did she spend sufficient time or will she spend sufficient time investigating the
- 27:27factors that led up to the transgression to begin with, because it could be
- 27:30quite complicated. I think there were some allegations or speculations that her early childhood
- 27:37could have involved experiences and traumas that could cause her or be a factor in
- 27:45her exhibiting the behavior that she seemingly exhibited, i e. The boundary crossings
- 27:52with children regarding sexual content. So that would take a long time to work
- 27:56on. So we don't know. We don't know what she's working on therapy,
- 28:00But at least season therapy. Well, crazy spider and would have finished
- 28:04cleaning and go to bed. He's watching everybody, Hopefully I'll see you soon.
- 28:10All right. So that's that, And let's give her a grade,
- 28:15as I will do so my public apology grading scale. Let's start at the
- 28:22top, So we have a This is more than sufficient. So this is
- 28:26going way beyond the necessary apology to sincerely demonstrate remorse. No B is sufficient
- 28:34so sufficiently met the first seven components of effective apologies. So if we go
- 28:40back up, did she acknowledge the transgression? It was in the ballpark,
- 28:45But it's possible that she didn't, but it looked like she might have if
- 28:49she had elaborated. Number two, did she acknowledge the harm I caused you
- 28:52harm? She acknowledged that she caused harm, but she didn't describe the harm.
- 28:57Number three take your spot onsibility. It's my fault. Yeah, essentially,
- 29:02but again without elaboration, it could have all just been words. Sincerely
- 29:07expressed remorse. I feel bad about I think so. Number five explained the
- 29:11cause without making excuses. Very briefly, she says I was acting mature or
- 29:17I didn't think things through. Number six, provide a plan to address the
- 29:21cause. Again very briefly, she touched on it. And number seven she
- 29:23offered remedy, again very very briefly. So if I were to say sufficiently
- 29:30met, no, not to me C letter grade mostly sufficient somewhat met most
- 29:37of the main components of effective apologies. Somewhat met. It fits that D
- 29:42slightly sufficient. The average public apology is slightly sufficient. That's what I say,
- 29:48minimally met some of the requirements, lacks depth, lacked demonstrated remorse.
- 29:55I think I would give her a C minus or a D plus. That
- 30:03might sound ridiculous to some that I would say CEE minus, But compared to
- 30:08other apologies, she actually is a lot better than a lot of other public
- 30:14apologies. And the typical public apology is a D. And I would say
- 30:18that her apology was better than just slightly better than the typical. So proofs
- 30:26in the pudding. Moving forward, we don't know D plus because it's really
- 30:32hard to know if she actually does recognize the harm, and you think,
- 30:36okay, so here's the thing. If you really did, and to me,
- 30:38if you really recognized and acknowledged the harm that you caused and or risked
- 30:45to all the fans and to the children and other people involved, your employees,
- 30:52if you really acknowledged it and really felt it, and really felt the
- 30:56remorse and the sorrow, that's what sorry me comes from. It comes from
- 31:00feeling sorrow, feeling sad, feeling empathy of like, oh I harmed If
- 31:07you really felt that you think that the apology would be way more elaborate.
- 31:12In fact, research shows that when transgressions are bigger, apologies need to be
- 31:18bigger. Like I always give the example of I'm in the grocery store and
- 31:22I have my cart and I accidentally run into someone. I don't need to
- 31:26apologize for five hours, and I don't even necessarily need to have all the
- 31:32eleven components, right, All I probably need to do is say like,
- 31:34oh my got I didn't see you, I'm so sorry, or are you
- 31:38okay? So that might be all I need to say. Or I might
- 31:41even just be like hmm, I just say a word and look at look
- 31:45at them like, oh, you know, exhibiting like I didn't mean to
- 31:48and I'm sorry, are you okay? Just with my face, I might
- 31:52not even need to say anything. So very small transgressions to the transgressed upon
- 32:00person require very limited apology time and effort and elaboration, whereas the transgression that
- 32:07she caught that committed, Especially when you think about I think millions of people
- 32:13that have been transgressed upon potentially, then you would just imagine that the apology
- 32:19would be a lot more elaborate I can't imagine if I were in her shoes
- 32:23that my conscience would be cleared. So I would say that D plus which
- 32:30is not great, but better than most, which is a sad state of
- 32:37affairs. Okay, So that's the end of the audio version of the video
- 32:44I posted a couple of weeks ago. It's me again from the intro.
- 32:47If that makes any sense to you. Let's take a break, and when
- 32:52we get back, I'll answer some emails. All right back from the break.
- 32:59So this emails from middle Tier Patron. She's anonymous Middle Tier Patrons.
- 33:02She says, Hi, doctor Kirk, you and your mom are such an
- 33:07amazing attachment example. I envy the lovely attachment you have with her. You
- 33:14are teaching me a lot about healthy relationships. My mother was a well meaning
- 33:17caregiver who provided me with food and all the essentials. But I was born
- 33:22a year and a half after triplets, plus there were two kiddos before them,
- 33:28and I didn't nearly get the full attention I needed during my early years.
- 33:34My parents had seven kids within eight years. To this day, I
- 33:37don't feel close to my mom or my dad. They are aging and I
- 33:40want a connection with them, but it's not there. The other siblings have
- 33:45something with them, but I don't seem to have it. Even the baby,
- 33:49even my baby brother who is younger than me, seems to have something
- 33:52with them and he was two years after me. Can you relate this at
- 33:57all to attachment theory? It seems like get fit to me. End of
- 34:00email. Yeah, attachment theory is absolutely involved in this in that it's hard
- 34:07to know, but it's absolutely possible that because your parents already had what seemed
- 34:15they had five kids before you, five young kids. So if I'm understanding
- 34:21the years right, they probably had like when you were born, they had,
- 34:29you know, triplets who were eighteen months old when you were born,
- 34:35and then older than them would have been what maybe like a four year old
- 34:38and a five year old or something like that. So just imagine that you
- 34:43got a five year old, a four year old, and then three eighteen
- 34:47month old children and a new born. So that's going to stretch you pretty
- 34:53thin, right, and absolutely what that can result in is a lack of
- 34:59attuatment, which can result in feeling longing for a connection that doesn't seem to
- 35:05be there. So yeah, that's just right down the middle of attached with
- 35:08theory. But I want to caution you when you draw conclusions about your other
- 35:14siblings and their connection to your parents, it's possible that you have been elected
- 35:19by the family system to actually feel the disconnection that a lot of kids feel.
- 35:25I don't know, it's possible that you just you know, it does
- 35:29stand a reason. I suppose that you experience kind of the worst case scenario
- 35:35because the oldest kid, the oldest two kids, would have had a lot
- 35:39more attention and attunement potentially from the parents. The triplets, probably as a
- 35:49joint effort. The parents could give them a lot of attention, probably less
- 35:53attention than they were able to give the older siblings, but you know,
- 35:57maybe enough. And then you come around and you know, if you have
- 36:01three eighteen month old children that are mobile and starting to get into stuff and
- 36:07starting to demand things and want things and need things and grab for things and
- 36:14fight with each other and da da da, then you could say that you
- 36:19were in the worst position. And then your younger sibling, your baby brother,
- 36:22maybe the parents had overcome some of that stress. You know, the
- 36:29triplets were old enough that they could play quietly by themselves occasionally, such that
- 36:34you were the only one that they had to really kind of focus on and
- 36:38while they were nursing and you know, raising a newborn. So it's stands
- 36:45the reason it's hard to know. There's no research on this configuration specifically,
- 36:50but it's possible. But another possibility is that you actually are in a family
- 36:57with a lot of distance and a lot of feelings about the lack of attunement,
- 37:02and either your siblings don't know or identify with it, or they don't
- 37:07want to talk about it. I've talked with a lot of people, not
- 37:14only clients, but also students, because we run students through a similar discovery
- 37:17process, And what I will hear a lot from a certain percentage of people
- 37:23is that they will have this narrative like everyone else seems to be connected except
- 37:27for me, and then when they actually investigate, they find that no one's
- 37:30connected. In fact, some of those individuals that thought they were the least
- 37:35connected were actually the most connected, so and the others were so much disconnected
- 37:43that they didn't even allow themselves to acknowledge that they were disconnected. So it's
- 37:46hard to know. But if your other siblings do in fact feel that connection,
- 37:52and there is a real connection there greater than yours. It's possible that,
- 37:55yeah, you just got the worst of the Earth order situation. You
- 38:00know that happens sometimes, all right. Six emails from anonymous middle Toier patron.
- 38:05She says, you frequently apologize for your tangents, so just chime me
- 38:09in here. I don't know if I've apologized so much on the audio podcast.
- 38:15I know that I have, But most of the time I'm apologizing in
- 38:19my videos, my reaction videos on YouTube. And it's because sometimes I will
- 38:24be criticized for not going faster through the episodes that I'm watching and reacting to,
- 38:31and people are wanting to get to that story beat and are upset at
- 38:37me for not getting there faster, and so I will apologize because I can.
- 38:45You know, I'm a talker, and so I'm gonna yamer about things
- 38:50for better for worse, and I, you know, to tell you the
- 38:54truth. I often will cut out a lot of my amorings, which you
- 38:59know says something about my yamoring. Since the edited version, there's still a
- 39:04lot of yammerings, right. And I got a particularly good dose of people
- 39:12yelling at me during Love is Blind, the season five that was a couple
- 39:16months ago, I was watching this scene. If you're familiar with what was
- 39:23their names, I've already forgotten their names. It was the firefighter guy who
- 39:30wore all the flags, if you're familiar anyway, And apparently was just about
- 39:38to see a scene between the couple that was particularly infamous, and I was
- 39:45yamoring, which meant that people were watching the episode thinking I was going to
- 39:51get to that story beat, but I didn't, and then they'd have to
- 39:54wait until the next day or maybe even the next day to see me react
- 39:59to it. And there are a lot of people in the comment section that
- 40:02were yelling at me, and and it's one thing to yell at me,
- 40:06but it's the other thing when there's a lot of up votes, which indicates
- 40:07that there's like a whole crowd of people that are yelling at me, you
- 40:10know. And that did not feel good, because, you know, I
- 40:15turn on the microphone, I turn on the camera, and presumably that's my
- 40:20whole thing, is that I talk. And when I get yelled at for
- 40:23talking, it's hurtful. And I also don't like it about myself, don't
- 40:30I don't like to bore anybody like in my personal life I actually don't talk
- 40:37that much because you all get me, give me a chance to get it
- 40:39off my chest here. So I it was hurtful, and so I started
- 40:45probably apologizing more often. And you know, it's a thing I understand,
- 40:51And there's a balance between yammering and being concise, and I'm always trying to
- 40:58ride that line. And it's not as if feedback about my yamoring and tangents
- 41:04are wrong. There's there's a balance, and there's also a bell curve regarding
- 41:08what the audience is looking for. Some people are looking for very concise things,
- 41:12and some people are actually upset that we don't yammer more, have more
- 41:16tangents, or I don't have more content. So you know, I'm trying
- 41:20to please a wide variety of people. But but anyway, so not as
- 41:23military patrons, She says, you frequently apologize for your tangents, and I
- 41:28wanted to remind you that your tangents are actually very useful. Obviously, they
- 41:32often significantly enrich the information that you're presenting and just jamming here. Yeah,
- 41:37when I started to apologize more in reaction to my hurt feelings, there were
- 41:43a lot of really kind comments on YouTube and otherwise, you know, emails
- 41:46saying that you know, they're like, you know, they were, they
- 41:51were basically saying that they've never been critical about my yamoring. They will say
- 41:58that that's exactly why they watch the channel, and if anyone has a problem
- 42:01with the yammering, then they're not true fans or they're not watching the right
- 42:06channel. You know. That's and that's kind of the feeling I got too.
- 42:08I'm like, that's my whole thing is I watch a clip and then
- 42:14I talk about it, and sometimes it's a short thing and sometimes it's a
- 42:17long thing that I say. The other thing I was thinking with this is
- 42:22just my defensiveness, right or wrong. But people are yelling at me,
- 42:24and I'm thinking, well, you saw the scene already, so you're just
- 42:30waiting for me to see this scene and you understand I haven't, you know.
- 42:35And also some people yell at me because I don't know things that have
- 42:39already happened, you know, They'll just be like, how do you possibly
- 42:43have a positive spin on this person when they did this and this and this,
- 42:47And I'm like, well, that happens in the future, so I
- 42:51haven't seen that. Anyway, It's just but like I said, there's you
- 42:54know, like there were criticisms about i'mbard and iammering at the beginning of the
- 43:01deep dive that we did on was the Duggers. I believe there was some
- 43:06tangents that we went to. Oh no, it wasn't the Duggers, it
- 43:09was a more recent one. Anyway, point is is that we had some
- 43:15early tangents that were you know, we didn't. It took us a while
- 43:21to get to the gist of the story is the thing, and and I
- 43:24got that, and I you know, I hear that, and I incorporate
- 43:29that sort of stuff, and some of the feedback was fine, but some
- 43:34of it's hurtful. You know. There's a way to give feedback. You
- 43:37know, if we were in person, I would see that you were bored,
- 43:42and I would adjust as a professor that that would happen. I would
- 43:45notice glazed eyes and people not very engaged, falling asleep, and I'd say,
- 43:52Okay, obviously there's something about what I'm doing right now as not engaging.
- 43:58I don't have that benefit. I'm recording and then putting it out there,
- 44:00so I have to iterate my approach piece by piece. Later, you
- 44:06know what I mean getting back to the email, Obviously, your tangents significantly
- 44:12enrich the information you're presenting, but also personally, I find that the way
- 44:15the so called ir irrelevant tangents are actually helpful in that it slows down the
- 44:22pace, which is actually really useful to me because of the potentially triggering nature
- 44:27of many topics that you discuss. There's lots about the podcast I would miss
- 44:31if you felt like you needed to make it shorter, So the apologies are
- 44:36really unnecessary from my point of view and of email. Well, anonymous middle
- 44:39to your patron, that's very kind of you. Yeah, And a lot
- 44:43of people were saying this's like, that's why we come here, just because
- 44:46we want you to to comment on these things. And I'll also say that
- 44:53I listened to a lot of podcasts. I listened to probably an ap average
- 45:00of I don't know, three four hours of podcasts a day. You know,
- 45:04I'm doing chores, or I'm driving somewhere, or sometimes I'll be playing
- 45:09a video game and I'll just listen to podcasts. So you know, I
- 45:13spend a lot of time listening to podcasts and I and also I watch a
- 45:16lot of YouTube videos long form YouTube videos, and there are times when I
- 45:22will be listening to something or watching something and I'll be thinking there are too
- 45:27many tangents, or they're yammering too much, or they're not getting to the
- 45:29point the point cook enough. And it's always been something that I've been concerned
- 45:35about. I don't know if you all know this. I've talked about this
- 45:37before, but you know my episodes where they're video or audio, I launch
- 45:43it into the topic as soon as i can because I hate podcasts and YouTube
- 45:47videos that have an intro that I'm not interested in, even from content providers
- 45:53that I'm a fan of. You know, it's like when you cook on
- 45:57something, you want to start in on the stuff you know you don't want
- 46:00to have. Like it's like that experience when you sit down to watch a
- 46:05movie on Netflix or something. They have all those introductory graphics like produced by
- 46:10these people in association with these other people, and then you think, Okay,
- 46:16now the movie's gonna start, and then nope, it's not the movie.
- 46:20There's like a bit on on The Simpsons. I think about this,
- 46:22but anyway and stuff like that, it's just like get to I'm a very
- 46:27impatient person. As you can tell. And so I'm always like, get
- 46:29to the point, you know, And so yeah, I've always been very
- 46:34obsessed with trying to be snappy and quick and relevant and engaging and non boring.
- 46:42And I do a lot of editing. I do a lot of thinking.
- 46:45When I work out my outlines. I have every you know, story
- 46:49beat and every Sometimes I have tangents kind of worked in. Sometimes tangents just
- 46:52seem natural. It's a it's a very high priority to you. To me,
- 47:00I was a guest on a podcast a while back, and they did
- 47:06not have that skill or that priority or something. And I was so bored.
- 47:09As I was on the podcast, I was talking with the hosts of
- 47:16this podcast, and I was so bored, and I thought, I can't
- 47:22imagine what it would be like to listen to this episode. I mean,
- 47:24God, bless them. Maybe they have a lot of fans, but to
- 47:27my preferences, I it'll drive me nuts. So I'm thinking about it.
- 47:36If you are one of those people that doesn't like the tangents or wants it
- 47:38to be more concise, I'm doing a lot to get there. It would
- 47:43be much worse if I didn't prioritize that and or I didn't edit stuff out
- 47:47all right, let's take a break back from the break. This emails from
- 47:53Middle to your patron and YouTube member Bob from Minneapolis. She says, since
- 48:00the pandemic and after losing a close family member, Since the pandemic and after
- 48:04losing a close family member, sorry to hear that, I've noticed that I
- 48:07am diving headfirst into an existential crisis, and I'm questioning the meaning of life,
- 48:13and I'm thinking about death myself as well. I'm thirty five and right
- 48:17now my biggest fear is my eventual death. I find myself having panic attacks
- 48:22at the thought of death. I just want to stop time and hold onto
- 48:27every precious moment. I feel like this fear of death might be nagging at
- 48:30society after the pandemic. You have mentioned before that you have that you had
- 48:37come to terms with your mortality. Can you share any advice on how to
- 48:39move through this as a side As a side note, I am a clinician
- 48:44and I have my own therapist. However, my therapist specializes in trauma,
- 48:49not on my own mortality. I'm also an atheist or agnostic, so I
- 48:54cannot rely on spirituality to move through this and to bemal Yeah, I've talked
- 49:00about this a lot before. But briefly is that for those of you who
- 49:07don't relate to this email, God bless you. For those who do,
- 49:10you know exactly what Bob is talking about. What Bob is talking about is
- 49:15right up my alley from Minneapolis. I can absolutely relate to what you're talking
- 49:21about. And it's not just death anxiety. It's not just worries about death.
- 49:25It's worries about annihilation and the abyss. You know, death is one
- 49:31thing, but you know, being erased from existence is a completely different thing,
- 49:37and it is truly terrifying. It can't be any other way. The
- 49:42only way isn't if you don't if you're not terrified of it. Dear listener,
- 49:45again, I wish I was you. Then it typically either you don't
- 49:52really think about it much or you're in denial of it, and those aren't
- 49:55the same thing. You can you can you can acknowledge the reality of death
- 50:00and potential annihilation and also just not really be oriented towards that future. That's
- 50:08not being in denial. But there are people who are existentially terrified of it,
- 50:14but they're in denial of it. And they actively will. I mean,
- 50:16I think that's a big reason why we avoid everything related to death in
- 50:21general in our society. You know, Oh, it's so morbid. Why
- 50:23are you talking about that. I've been told that by many people in my
- 50:27life. They'll just be like, God, that's so morbid. Like I
- 50:30don't know if I said this on the podcast, but Kirk Cousins, a
- 50:34quarterback for the Minnesota Vikings. He was on this documentary kind of thing being
- 50:39interviewed or something, and I actually didn't even watch the episode. I heard
- 50:45about it through someone else, but I heard that Kirk Cousins he has this
- 50:51container with all these rocks. He has a rock for every month that is
- 50:55likely left in his life, you know, given life expectancy, has a
- 51:00bunch of rocks in this vessel, each representing a month of his future life.
- 51:06And then every month he pulls out this rock, and I think he
- 51:08holds onto it for the month, and then at the end of the month
- 51:12he puts it in this other container where he's spent months go. And I
- 51:17like this idea so much because it's completely how I'm oriented normally anyway, and
- 51:22have been since I was a teenager. That I decided to do it.
- 51:25Stacy and I are taking this pottery class, and at first I thought that
- 51:30I wouldn't like pottery, but I'm really getting into it now. Ceramics,
- 51:35I'm terrible, but it's fun to explore and create and stuff and it's a
- 51:40good It's kind of a date for Stacy and I. We do it's a
- 51:44whole production that we do together, and then we go to lunch afterwards and
- 51:47ddity anyway, But I took two bulls that I had made, and I
- 51:55got all these little polished rocks. I always love when I kid, I
- 52:00used to collect paust rocks. It's just so funny because I see kids today
- 52:02who have polish rocks, and they'll have their own tumbler and they will have
- 52:08like just bags and bags of polish rocks. When I was in the early
- 52:14seventies, when I was quote unquote collecting polish rocks, I'm not even joking.
- 52:20I probably had like nine polish rocks total, and no access to any
- 52:25more, and no aspirations or hopes or dreams of acquiring anymore than that.
- 52:30Maybe maybe if we passed by there was this one store that sold polish rocks
- 52:37in the mountains east of Seattle, and I just thought, maybe maybe one
- 52:42day we'll pass by that store and we'll stop in and I'll buy one or
- 52:45two more. But anyway, I now can buy just bags and bags of
- 52:51polish rocks online. And so I body these little they're like they they're about
- 52:55the size of like a jelly bean. And I counted out. You know,
- 53:00my life expectancy is seventy eight given Asian American, and so that was
- 53:07twenty five years actually, because I'm almost fifty three, and well I should
- 53:14be fifty three by the time this episode comes out. Point is is that
- 53:16I counted out twenty five years at which turned out to be I think two
- 53:22hundred if I'm not mistake anyway, some even amount. And I put those
- 53:25in one bowl, and then every month I take I don't carry the rock
- 53:30around with me, but I just take one rock out and I put it
- 53:34in the other bowl. And I think, so far, there's like three
- 53:36months that I've spent I even thought about getting all the polyst rocks for all
- 53:42the months I've actually been alive up until this point. So you could actually
- 53:45see the contrast. For some people that I've told this to, they will
- 53:49say that's morbid, and they're like, why would you want to think about
- 53:53that? It's so depressing, And so I think for some people they go
- 53:57into denial. I think for other people they have religion. Of course,
- 54:00they have the afterlife or some version of it. They're like, well,
- 54:04I don't know if I believe in heaven per se, but you know,
- 54:06there's got to be something after this. There's got to be you know,
- 54:09maybe it's something we can't even comprehend, like we become energy or something.
- 54:14You know, people have those kind of thoughts, and those can be very
- 54:15comforting when you are faced with non existence, right especially with people who have
- 54:21already died. And I'll hold that there are some people who are truly just
- 54:28so enlightened and so much of the Buddha that they are completely okay with the
- 54:35reality of non existence. You know, I can't relate to that personally,
- 54:38but you know, so there's a variety of different, you know, approaches
- 54:44or ways of dealing with this thing that we all have to There's there's two
- 54:47things that are universal and for sure and certain, and that is death and
- 54:52taxes, as they say, and so we're all going to have to face
- 54:54it, and we all know we have to face it, and we all
- 54:58have to have a way of dealing with that facing. And so for me
- 55:04and for you, Bob, and Minneapolis and many others, at least you
- 55:08start off with what you're experiencing, which is this just a panic of so
- 55:19I have limited time. You know, it might be a long time.
- 55:22It might be fifty years. You're thirty five, Maybe you have fifty years
- 55:24left, maybe more. That's a lot of years, but it's finite and
- 55:30it will run out. And as we get older, time goes by faster
- 55:34and faster and faster, and you know, you're halfway to the finish line,
- 55:38is really more like your two thirds of the finish line in terms of
- 55:42how you process time, seemingly, and so it's awful to think that for
- 55:49us and everyone else is just like lights out. You're done, if that's
- 55:52what you believe, And so how do you deal with that? You know,
- 55:55what do you do when the thought occurs to you? It could be
- 55:59de more, it can be terrifying, it can be For me, it's
- 56:04those, but it's also a strange feeling of that I can't even describe.
- 56:08It's like this fundamental emotion or vibe that is preverbal that I'm pretty sure I
- 56:15must have experienced when I was when I was an infant and wasn't able to
- 56:20process things verbally in my head. Yet it's a very unnerving feeling. And
- 56:27yet today I am not an estate of panic like I was before. And
- 56:34you know, I'm just one person. But the way that I've dealt with
- 56:37it is to face it one, to not turn away from it, because
- 56:40that just causes for me more suffering or just kicks it down the road.
- 56:47I've also found that by talking about it it helps and finding other people.
- 56:52There were two noticeable moments for me and this, you know, and this,
- 56:57There were many moments of talking and thinking. Making the podcast is actually
- 57:02a part of that. Uh. I, you know, recognize that I'll
- 57:07be dead and I wanted something to live on. I wanted there to be
- 57:12evidence of my existence. And of course it's narcissistic to think about that,
- 57:19but also it's stupid because and you know, I don't know how many years
- 57:22there won't be podcasts anymore. You know, there won't there won't be ways
- 57:28of accessing this sort of stuff after my death, after you know, for
- 57:31it. So it's not like I'll live forever. But and who knows if
- 57:36anyone will even care, but the but it does. You know, it
- 57:40feels better to feel like, well, you know, I'm there's some meaning
- 57:45here. And if five years after my death someone comes across a random episode
- 57:51of mine and it helps them, then you know that that gives meaning to
- 57:54the time that I was here. So for me, there's been a lot
- 58:00of things, but there were two noticeable moments. There was one episode of
- 58:02this American Life many years ago and Ira Glass, the host if you're familiar,
- 58:08he I believe from my memory, talked about his own death anxiety or
- 58:14existential anxiety regarding non existence. From my memory, he talked about how for
- 58:20him, when his head hit the pillow, that's when all these thoughts would
- 58:23rush into his head, and that was that's the same for me. When
- 58:27my head hits the pillow, that's when all these thoughts start to emerge.
- 58:30And he described it so well, and it really helped me because for the
- 58:36first time I had heard someone describe what I thought was perhaps a unique neurosis
- 58:42of mine. And that's a weird thing for us humans that through suffering together
- 58:46we feel better strangely another and it feels normalizing that kinding. But the biggest
- 58:53moment actually for me was I came across a phenomenalogical psychological study about existential panic.
- 59:02And the reason why I came across it was because when I was working
- 59:09on my own or developing my own research project, I landed on a method
- 59:15called phenomenal phenomenological research, which I won't bore you with the details, but
- 59:20it's a form of how humans discover things and a form of inquiry the few.
- 59:27And I was looking for examples of how to write the report because there
- 59:31weren't a lot of examples out there. I didn't know how it's supposed to
- 59:36format the report after I conduct the research, and so I was looking at
- 59:40various different examples and I came across one My dogs are barking that are on
- 59:46That was on death anxiety or existential dread, and I was reading through it
- 59:53just to get an idea of how these reports are written. But I became
- 59:58completely in roast in the findings and what the participants were saying. And the
- 1:00:05way that you typically will write a phenomenological report is you one you interview a
- 1:00:09small set of people, like ten people typically depending on what you're looking into
- 1:00:15and then you pull quotes in the report as you report themes and what people
- 1:00:21are talking about. There's very different ways looking at it, but it goes
- 1:00:24deep phenomenlogical research. The benefit of it as it goes deep, you know,
- 1:00:28on the opposite end of the spectrum with research is you can do a
- 1:00:30survey where you survey a you know, ten thousand people. You can get
- 1:00:36a lot of you know, mathematical power through doing research studies like that and
- 1:00:43find very small differences between two groups of people, but you're not going very
- 1:00:46deep. You have to ask a fairly simple question like how tall are you?
- 1:00:52Or do you like ice cream? Whereas with phenomenological research, you will
- 1:00:57have say ten participants, but you interview them for hours potentially, and you,
- 1:01:04as the researcher, become extremely familiar with every single word in every interview.
- 1:01:12You know, you conduct the interviews, you record the interviews, you
- 1:01:15transcribe the interviews, you analyze the interviews, you code the interviews, you
- 1:01:19look at the interviews, you process the interviews. You put aside your assumptions
- 1:01:22about what they're saying, and you know, you get really deep into what
- 1:01:25these ten people are saying. And the benefit is that, you know,
- 1:01:30really deep, and so as this report is telling me what the researcher found,
- 1:01:36it was very deep and very rich and very helpful to me because something
- 1:01:43turned in my soul. I remember feeling it almost physically, that something had
- 1:01:49shifted in me from being mostly terrified and occasionally soothed to being very you know,
- 1:01:59very much mostly soothed and just just a little you know, terrified.
- 1:02:06It was weird. And I'm sure that report won't have that effect on many
- 1:02:13others. If not, that report wouldn't affect anyone in the way that it
- 1:02:16affected me. And I've talked about this report before, and people have asked
- 1:02:21me for a copy of it, and I believe me, I have looked.
- 1:02:23It's almost as if if there is a God, that that God sent
- 1:02:29that report just to me to help me. I've looked far and wide,
- 1:02:34and dear listener, if you know how to look for these kinds of things,
- 1:02:37phenomenal loasical research report death anxiety. That's all that I remember. And
- 1:02:45it would have come out I would have read it around twenty twelve ish,
- 1:02:51and so twenty thirteen maybe, so it would have to be a you know,
- 1:02:55a study that was published before that date. But anyway, it that
- 1:03:00report helped me, and I think what it did was it it was an
- 1:03:07in depth look at others who were having the same feeling I was. And
- 1:03:13also the themes that they found were very helpful, Like I don't remember exactly
- 1:03:16the themes, but I think the themes were things like I thought I was
- 1:03:21alone, or I didn't know anyone else had these feelings, or it just
- 1:03:25feels good. Because sometimes when you're interviewing people in these research studies, they
- 1:03:30will find that as they are talking about it, they will tell the researcher
- 1:03:35it actually feels good to talk about this, and some people were as I
- 1:03:39think people. Anyway, The point is that that's for me, And now
- 1:03:45that doesn't tell you all that I have done since I was about fifteen years
- 1:03:49old to wrestle with what I have wrestled with. So it's not as if
- 1:03:54those two things happen and everything was fine. You know, it's a constant
- 1:03:58thing, constant. Another part of it is that when I feel disconnected from
- 1:04:04people, when I'm lonely, I have more existential dread. And it is
- 1:04:10found that for people who were neglected, they generally have a higher likely out
- 1:04:15of having anxiety in general, including death anxiety. So the closer I get
- 1:04:20to other people, the more emotional closeness and attachment vulnerability I have with others,
- 1:04:28generally speaking, the less dread of any kind that I have, including
- 1:04:31as existential dread. Another thing that research has found is that, and I
- 1:04:38can attest to this, is that when people are in the flow of the
- 1:04:41meaning of their life, then they're much less likely to be anxious and much
- 1:04:46less likely to have existential dread. When I have had moments in my life
- 1:04:51where I don't know where I'm headed, or I don't feel like I'm living
- 1:04:57my life's purpose, or I don't even know what my life's purpose is,
- 1:05:00I'm much more prone to that death anxiety. Whereas when I feel like I'm
- 1:05:04in the flow of my life and I'm doing what I want, and I
- 1:05:06feel like I'm you know, satisfying or in the process of satisfying my life's
- 1:05:14mission, whatever that is, and for me, it's trying to make the
- 1:05:16world a better place, trying to have happiness in my life, trying to
- 1:05:20give to others, trying to experience things with other people. Then when I'm
- 1:05:27in that flow, then I don't the death anxiety doesn't have any room to
- 1:05:30creep in. One way to think about it is that existential anxiety is just
- 1:05:36a sign of something else that's happening in our lives. It's not the death
- 1:05:43anxiety that is the problem. It's some other problem that manifests as death anxiety.
- 1:05:49Having said that, I don't want to diminish the existential anxiety. A
- 1:05:54lot of you know you, Bob, you say you're in therapy, but
- 1:05:57your clinician, you're a clinician yourself. But your therapist, although she specializes
- 1:06:02in trauma, which sounds like that's helping you, you say that she doesn't
- 1:06:09specialize in fear of your own mortality. And I found that to be true
- 1:06:14too. When I talk with therapists, my own therapist about this, I've
- 1:06:17had a wide variety of responses, some of which are very dismissive of it.
- 1:06:23They will say, oh, death anxiety, Well, let's work on
- 1:06:26the cognitions or something, and it's just like, no, we're This isn't
- 1:06:29like a phobia. This is a recognition of reality. This is something that
- 1:06:34is going to happen for all of us, and there's no way around it.
- 1:06:40There's the only way with it, I guess, is to be with
- 1:06:44it. And the only way to be with it is to acknowledge it and
- 1:06:46to feel the terror and the disappointment. And I love all the responses I
- 1:06:55get from people. Some of you might have already been emailing me or commenting
- 1:06:58below. You'll have these full I've heard it all. People will say like,
- 1:07:01well, you know, Kirk, there was a time when you didn't
- 1:07:03exist and before you were born, so that wasn't a bad thing. So
- 1:07:10you know, you're just going to return to that newsflash. That doesn't comfort
- 1:07:15me in the least. In fact, that adds another anxiety, because what
- 1:07:20if, you know, in the grand scheme of the universe, however these
- 1:07:24things work, I was never chosen to become conscious. What if I stayed
- 1:07:29in the abyss, so to speak, you know, forever? What if
- 1:07:31I never actually emerged? What if I and what about those quote unquote beings
- 1:07:39that have never come into existence and never will? You know, of course
- 1:07:43they aren't in existence, you know, because they don't exist. But you
- 1:07:45know what I'm saying, like it's and plus that's in the past. Yeah,
- 1:07:50sure, okay, I didn't exist, but I didn't know I didn't.
- 1:07:54Now I know what existence feels like. I don't want to give it
- 1:07:57up. It's doesn't help. Another thing people will say is they'll they'll just
- 1:08:01say like, well, you've got to live life to its fullest and you
- 1:08:05know one day you'll be dead, or or some people will say, well,
- 1:08:11uh, you know, if you die quietly, then it doesn't hurt.
- 1:08:15You know. They think that what I'm afraid of is the pain of
- 1:08:18dying or something, and certainly, you know, it's not super pleasant,
- 1:08:21but but that's you know, that's the fear of that is nothing compared to
- 1:08:28the non existence of myself. Like I'd rather be in an existence and be
- 1:08:35uncomfortable and occasionally in pain then to just no longer exist at all, you
- 1:08:43know, at least I think anyway, it's yeah, it's uh So My
- 1:08:47point is is that if you don't get it, then God bless you.
- 1:08:53You know, I am very very happy for you. There are some people
- 1:08:57that are just content with no longer if they believe, you know, if
- 1:09:00you truly believe that there's no afterlife, then then you know there is that
- 1:09:04that there are some people who are just truly just content and they're cool with
- 1:09:09it, and you know, but don't talk to people like us as if
- 1:09:14we're stupid for acknowledging a thing that an entire branch of philosophy is centered around.
- 1:09:20It's not like all those geniuses in Europe that were you know, Kureker,
- 1:09:25Guard and all those others, It's not like they were stupid and that
- 1:09:29you All they needed to do was talk to your stoner brother who says that
- 1:09:32like life is a circle or something. You know what I mean that it's
- 1:09:35a well understood phenomenon of human struggle is the existence of existential anxiety. An
- 1:09:46entire branch of therapy is based on this notion. So you know, there's
- 1:09:51there's no quick fix to that. So yeah, Bob, I don't know
- 1:09:59if that helps what I'm saying, but that's what I said. And everyone
- 1:10:03out there, please take care of yourself because you deserve it, You really
- 1:10:05really do.