Latest / Change My Relationship / When Your Family Won't Talk
Transcript
- 0:00You're listening to an audio recording by Change My Relationship, featuring
- 0:04licensed marriage and family therapist and author Karla Downing.
- 0:08These audios are designed to provide you with practical solutions
- 0:11based on biblical truths for all your relationships.
- 0:21What do you do when your family refuses to talk?
- 0:24This could be your extended family, your parents, your siblings.
- 0:28It could be your family without your with your children and your spouse.
- 0:33Whether the kids are still in the house or they've grown up and they,
- 0:36you know, have gone on and married and have their own families.
- 0:40What do you do when your family refuses to talk about the things
- 0:44that need to be talked about?
- 0:45Well, I got an email from a follower who asked me to address this situation.
- 0:51She had been waiting for two years for her family,
- 0:55her extended family, to talk about the things that she knew
- 0:59that they needed to talk about, and she still had got nothing.
- 1:03In fact, she said the texts had even dropped off.
- 1:07So first of all, dysfunctional families don't talk.
- 1:11That's one of the rules of dysfunctional families.
- 1:14Don't talk. Don't rock the boat.
- 1:15Because if you bring up something that's going to cause problems, then that's,
- 1:19that's called rocking the boat.
- 1:21Everything's okay.
- 1:22The boat is kind of steady.
- 1:24But when one person moves and says, let's talk about this, the boat gets off,
- 1:28kind of tilted sideways, and everybody runs back
- 1:31so that the boat gets back where it's just kind of stabilized.
- 1:35That's called homeostasis.
- 1:37Everybody does what they need to do to keep things the same.
- 1:40Dysfunctional families do not like change.
- 1:43And talking about things that need to be talked about causes change.
- 1:48In fact, it's extremely disruptive.
- 1:51If there's something that your family has avoided for a long time period
- 1:54and you want your family to talk about it, that's going to disrupt things.
- 1:58It's going to definitely disrupt the status quo.
- 2:01Well, there's something called the elephant in the living room.
- 2:04And people's first talked about this with alcoholic families.
- 2:08They said, it's like the family has an elephant in the living room.
- 2:12Everybody knows it's there, but they pretend it's not there.
- 2:16They walk around it, they feed it, they take care of it.
- 2:20They do all these things to make adjustments for this elephant,
- 2:23except saying, why do we have an elephant?
- 2:26This isn't normal.
- 2:28We should not have an elephant in our living room.
- 2:30Let's get rid of this elephant.
- 2:32Well, that's what dysfunctional families do.
- 2:34They literally keep the elephant in the living room and they take care of it.
- 2:40But no one addresses it.
- 2:42So that's because of something called denial.
- 2:46And denial means that you refuse to acknowledge
- 2:49the truth, either to yourself or to other people.
- 2:53You can literally convince yourself that something like that isn't true,
- 2:57that there isn't an elephant in the living room,
- 3:00even though it's right in front of you.
- 3:01So they have what's called shared denial.
- 3:04Everybody opts in to the same reality
- 3:09a reality that is not truthful.
- 3:12And why do families do this?
- 3:13They do this because it's painful.
- 3:16Painful to admit the truth or they're protecting somebody,
- 3:20or they're covering up for somebody, or they all are under the illusion
- 3:24that we're perfect.
- 3:26We don't have any problems or maybe it's because,
- 3:29let's say the person in the family could be an alcoholic.
- 3:33It could be a sex addict, it could be a rageaholic, it could be a workaholic.
- 3:37It could be somebody who's just completely shut down emotionally.
- 3:41It could be mental illness.
- 3:43It could be a secret from the past.
- 3:47It could be the fact that one of the children doesn't talk to the family,
- 3:52and maybe has grown up and moved away and doesn't come around anymore,
- 3:56and everybody in the family knows we don't ask about that person
- 4:00because it's too painful for mom and dad.
- 4:02So nobody brings up that child's name and everyone in the family knows
- 4:07that they are not allowed to say, how come we don't talk about Susie?
- 4:12How come Susie doesn't come home anymore?
- 4:14It could be the fact that they kicked a child out of the home.
- 4:18It could be the fact that somebody died, and it's
- 4:21just too painful for the family to address the death
- 4:24or any other situation that the family cannot face.
- 4:30The family cannot face in a healthy way.
- 4:33So they don't talk about it.
- 4:35They all opt into the shared denial that this isn't true doesn't exist.
- 4:40Not a problem. Don't need to talk about it.
- 4:43So if you are the outsider in your family and you're saying hello, let's talk.
- 4:48Let's talk about this, you are definitely going to be the bad guy.
- 4:53You are going to be the one who's trying to rock the boat,
- 4:56and they're all going to come against you to get you to shut up.
- 5:00They're going to shame you.
- 5:02They're going to accuse you.
- 5:03They're going to punish you.
- 5:05They're going to all come against you.
- 5:07They're going to talk about you.
- 5:09They're going to do all these things for the sole purpose
- 5:12of getting you to shut up and not bring up the elephant in the living room.
- 5:18So why do they deny?
- 5:20They deny?
- 5:21Because denial.
- 5:21Like I said, it's painful to admit the truth.
- 5:24So denials like this. Shock absorber.
- 5:26You hit a bump.
- 5:28The shock absorber accepts the shock.
- 5:31And so you don't have this big jar.
- 5:33Well, the same thing. Denial. Something happens.
- 5:35You fall into denial.
- 5:37Denial protects you from the shock of what happens or from having to face it.
- 5:41And then you go back the same as if it's as if that never happened.
- 5:46So you've got dysfunctional families who are doing this
- 5:50a lot of times not even recognizing why they're doing it.
- 5:54Sometimes it's manipulative.
- 5:56Somebody who knows what's going on and doesn't wanted addressed is going to
- 6:01manipulate and shame people to keep a secret or something from being brought up.
- 6:05That would be in the case of an abuser or a molester
- 6:08who is doing something and knows that if the truth comes out,
- 6:12there's a lot of problems, and so there's going to be threats
- 6:15and there's going to be vendettas
- 6:16and things that are going to be said in order to keep it silence.
- 6:19But when you're talking about just a problem in the family,
- 6:22people don't want to bring up, it is often just because it's
- 6:26just flat out too painful and everybody is opting into it.
- 6:30So what can you do?
- 6:32Well, the truth is, you cannot make anyone change
- 6:37in a way that that person does not want to change.
- 6:40So you can't make a family talk.
- 6:43You can't make a family face truth.
- 6:46You cannot make a family deal with what needs to be dealt with.
- 6:51You have no power to do that.
- 6:52And you probably know that because you've probably tried
- 6:56and found out that it has not worked
- 6:59and made you more miserable in the process.
- 7:02So what can you do?
- 7:04Well, one of the things you can do is try to approach
- 7:07one of your family members, the person that you have really good rapport with,
- 7:12the person that you know is the healthiest out of everyone in the family.
- 7:16Maybe somebody who has said something to you a few times and you know that
- 7:20this person is open to truth or recognizes the dysfunction of the family,
- 7:25or is willing to admit it, you can approach that person
- 7:29and see if you can have the conversation
- 7:31that you want to have, and maybe the two of you can do some type
- 7:35of confrontation or intervention into the family, where you confront
- 7:40the family gently with truth
- 7:43to see if this issue can be discussed.
- 7:46You can be really brave
- 7:49and you can bring this up, say a Thanksgiving dinner,
- 7:53and create a huge reaction and make it a really, really fun Thanksgiving dinner.
- 7:58And I mean that facetiously.
- 8:00It would probably be something that you could make a movie out of.
- 8:03When you watch all the reactions that you get from people for you daring
- 8:07to bring up this, taboo subject and talk about it.
- 8:12And I'm kind of kidding about that. So.
- 8:14But you could do it when everybody's together,
- 8:16when they're sitting on the sofa before they sit down to watch a movie.
- 8:19You you can risk doing that and rock the boat.
- 8:22That's totally up to you.
- 8:23You just be prepared that you're going to get, giant backlash
- 8:28and a lot of shaming and maybe a lot of anger
- 8:31and a lot of people talking about you.
- 8:32And, who knows, you could get, called names.
- 8:35You could get yelled at me.
- 8:36You kind of know how your family works and what the dysfunction does
- 8:40and how they shame people. So be prepared.
- 8:43The other thing that you could do is that you could, address it directly
- 8:48in a more, a less, kind of hitting it right straight from the front.
- 8:53Maybe you could be kind of, soft
- 8:56in the way that you bring it up, or maybe just bring up one little aspect of it.
- 9:00Or maybe you could ask various family members,
- 9:03would you like to talk about our family dynamics?
- 9:06Are you open to that or are you open to talking about
- 9:08the things that aren't healthy about our family?
- 9:12Maybe kind of come in that soft approach and see what kind of answers
- 9:15you get from individual people.
- 9:17And then you can also set boundaries.
- 9:20I mean, I don't know what the issue is that you're thinking about in your family.
- 9:24If it is something like a molestation, you can set boundaries
- 9:28until the family talks about this and we're on the same page.
- 9:32And I feel that it's safe for my child to be around the family.
- 9:36I will not be coming over until the family is willing to talk about,
- 9:41or until my parents are willing to talk about
- 9:45the alcoholism and the fights that happen when the grandkids are over there.
- 9:50I won't be bringing my grandkids over there until we talk about it
- 9:53and come to an agreement.
- 9:55I won't be bringing my kids over.
- 9:57So what that does is it kind of puts a consequence
- 10:00onto the situation and lets them know clearly that
- 10:04this is what you need in order to continue, normally with things
- 10:09or to do a specific thing that is really
- 10:12whatever it is that you're struggling with, whatever concerns you have with
- 10:15whatever is on your heart, you can look at that situation
- 10:18and you can draw that boundary and just say it.
- 10:22You can let each person know.
- 10:25You can let the main people know.
- 10:27So that's an option too.
- 10:28So basically you've got to decide how important it is to you.
- 10:33Is it just something you want to do or is it a vital importance, like it's
- 10:36got to be resolved before you come back over, or you have the people in your home,
- 10:41or you bring your kids over, anything, whatever it is.
- 10:44So it'll be it'll all as always, it will depend
- 10:48on the specific situation that you are dealing with for you
- 10:52to figure out how you want to address
- 10:56your family not talking.
- 10:58Now, being the person that goes behind
- 11:04each person's back and talks about it that way and makes accusations
- 11:09to one person that that person is going to take and tell
- 11:12the rest of the family members is not a wise way to do it,
- 11:15because all that does is stir up trouble and cause you to look like the bad guy.
- 11:19So if you're going to talk to, a person,
- 11:23if there's a person
- 11:24you want to talk to about it, make sure you go directly to that person
- 11:28rather than talk about that person to another family member.
- 11:31Because family members in dysfunctional families are notoriously
- 11:36bad about breaking confidences and going and telling other family members
- 11:41and getting them to react and then aligning against you.
- 11:46So I would highly recommend that any discussion that you do have
- 11:49typically go directly to the person that you really want to talk to.
- 11:54Unless it's a whole family situation
- 11:57and it's like the unhealthy family dynamics, and then you want to go
- 12:01talk to your sister and say, are you willing to help me?
- 12:05bring this up to Mom and Dad together, then that's something
- 12:07that's not talking against or about that person.
- 12:10It's talking about the family dynamic and seeing if she's willing
- 12:15or your brother maybe is willing to come
- 12:18to the family together and say, we need to talk about these things.
- 12:21So I have to tell you that my favorite movies
- 12:26to watch, my favorite sitcoms to watch, are ones about dysfunctional families,
- 12:31because I just find the dynamics and the interaction and the personalities
- 12:35and the things.
- 12:37I'm sorry to say this, but really fun and interesting
- 12:41just because I love to study the different dynamics.
- 12:45And so I, sorry that you're dealing with this.
- 12:48And I would say, the best chance that you have get healthy yourself,
- 12:52get really work on getting healthy for you,
- 12:56getting figuring things out to where
- 12:58you can create as healthy of a life
- 13:01in your own circle, to where you are not dependent
- 13:06on other people doing what you need them to do to be okay.
- 13:12So all right, thank you for watching this video.
- 13:14I hope you will watch others.
- 13:16And also please check out my resources at ChangeMyRelationship.com.
- 13:22Thank you for listening to Change My Relationship.
- 13:25We hope you will subscribe to these podcasts and share them with your friends.
- 13:29Karla would love to hear from you.
- 13:31She welcomes ideas for a future podcast, as well as your feedback
- 13:35on how the podcasts have helped your life and relationships.
- 13:39You can email her at.
- 13:40karla@changemyrelationship.com
- 13:44For more information on Change My Relationship and Karla
- 13:47Downing's ministry, including her books, studies, devotionals, podcasts
- 13:52and YouTube videos visit changemyrelationship.com.