Latest / Manager Mondays with Fexingo: People Management, Team Leadership, and First-Time Managers / How to Coach an Employee Who Resists Feedback
Transcript
- Lucas: Luna, I want to start with a number. A 2023 study in the Journal of Applied Psychology found that 38 percent of employees react defensively to feedback, even when it's delivered constructively. Luna: That's a huge slice of the workforce — and probably an undercount, because people don't always show it openly. Lucas: Exactly. You might see the eye roll, the crossed arms, the quick 'I know, but...' or the total silent shutdown. And if you're a manager who dreads these moments, you're not alone. Luna: So today we're talking about how to coach someone who resists feedback — not the person who argues aggressively, but the one who subtly deflects or disengages. Lucas: Right. Because that's actually harder to address. Overt pushback is easier to name. But the quiet resistance — the nodding while mentally checking out — that can fester. Luna: I want to ground this in a real example. Can we talk about a specific case? Lucas: Sure. Let's say you have a senior analyst named Priya. She's technically excellent — her models are clean, her forecasts are usually accurate. But in quarterly review meetings, when her manager offers a suggestion — say, to improve her presentation narrative — she immediately says 'yeah, I was going to do that' or 'that's what I meant.' Luna: Right — the classic deflection that makes it seem like she's already on it, but nothing changes. So the manager feels unheard, and Priya doesn't actually grow. Lucas: That's the pattern. And if you leave it unchecked, the manager starts avoiding giving feedback altogether, which hurts Priya's development and the team's performance. Luna: So what's the first thing a manager should do differently? Lucas: The first step is to separate the emotional reaction from the content of the feedback. Most defensive responses are a threat response — the brain interprets criticism as a social threat. Luna: That makes sense. So the manager's job is to lower the threat level before trying to deliver the message. Lucas: Exactly. There's a framework I like — I call it 'the pause, the pivot, and the proof.' Let me walk through it. Luna: Good. Start with the pause. Lucas: The pause means you don't keep talking when you see the defensive response. You stop. You take a breath. You might even say, 'I can see this is landing differently than I intended. Let me step back for a second.' Luna: That's hard to do in the moment. It feels like backing down. Lucas: It does, but it's not backing down — it's recalibrating. You're acknowledging the emotional state without agreeing or disagreeing. It keeps the relationship intact. Luna: So what's the pivot? Lucas: The pivot is shifting from telling to asking. Instead of saying 'You need to add more context to your slides,' you say 'What do you think about the level of context in your slides? Is there anything you'd change?' Luna: That turns it from a critique into a collaborative question. It invites self-assessment. Lucas: Exactly. And often the person will identify the same issue you saw — which means they own it. That's way more powerful than you telling them. Luna: And the proof? Lucas: The proof is following up with a specific, low-stakes ask. 'Could we try adding one sentence of context to the next slide deck and see how it feels?' That's concrete, it's testable, and it's not a judgment of their entire capability. Luna: So it's a small experiment rather than a criticism. Lucas: Right. And if they do it, you celebrate the change. Positive reinforcement is huge for reducing defensiveness over time. Luna: But what about the person who says 'I know' before you even finish the sentence? That's a common one. Lucas: That's a classic. In that case, the pause is even more important. You can say, 'I hear you. What's your take on how it's going so far?' You're not letting them off the hook — you're inviting them to show their understanding. Luna: And if they actually do know, they'll demonstrate it. If they don't, you'll see that gap. Lucas: Exactly. And if they can't articulate it, then you have a clear opening to offer your perspective, but now it's framed as filling a gap they themselves revealed. Luna: That's a much easier conversation than 'You're wrong, let me tell you how.' Lucas: Much easier. And it respects their intelligence. They're not being talked down to. Luna: So the common thread is shifting the dynamic from judge and defendant to two people solving a problem together. Lucas: That's exactly it. And I think that's the mindset shift that separates managers who get defensive reactions from managers who eventually break through. Luna: I want to talk about timing too. Is there a best time to give feedback to someone who's prone to defensiveness? Lucas: Great question. Avoid the 'feedback sandwich' — you know, positive, negative, positive. It's predictable and often feels manipulative. Luna: I think most managers have moved away from that, but it still pops up. Lucas: It does. Better to schedule a dedicated feedback conversation. Say 'I'd like to spend ten minutes in our next one-on-one on your last presentation — I have some thoughts and I'd love to hear yours.' That sets the stage. Luna: So it's not a surprise. And the person has time to prepare emotionally. Lucas: Exactly. Also, avoid end-of-day feedback. People are tired, their defenses are higher. Morning or mid-afternoon is better. Luna: And if the feedback is about a pattern — not a single incident — you might even share the observation in writing first, so they can process it before you discuss. Lucas: That works for some people. But you have to know your employee. For others, seeing it in writing without context can feel like an indictment. Luna: So it's really about knowing the individual. Lucas: That's the core of management, right? There's no one-size-fits-all. But the framework of pause, pivot, proof gives you a starting point that works for most. Luna: Before we go further, I want to mention something that's been on my mind. We put a lot of work into these episodes — researching studies, structuring frameworks, trying to make them genuinely useful. Lucas: Yeah, and we keep the show ad-free because we think that makes for a better listening experience. But it only works if listeners who find value in it occasionally chip in. Luna: Even a couple of dollars a month makes a real difference. If you've gotten something out of Manager Mondays, consider supporting us at buy me a coffee dot com slash fexingo. Lucas: And thank you to those who already do. It keeps the lights on and lets us keep digging into these topics. Now, back to the defensive employee — let's talk about what to do if the defensiveness doesn't subside. Luna: Right. Because sometimes no matter how well you frame it, the person still shuts down. Lucas: At that point, you need to name the pattern itself. But you do it with curiosity, not accusation. You might say 'I've noticed that when I bring up suggestions, you often have a quick response. I'm wondering if there's a way I can deliver feedback that feels more helpful to you.' Luna: That's a meta-conversation — talking about the feedback process itself. Lucas: And it often uncovers something. Maybe they had a previous manager who was overly critical. Maybe they're under a lot of pressure outside work. Maybe they genuinely think they already know the answer. Luna: You're essentially inviting them to co-design the feedback relationship. Lucas: Exactly. And once they have a hand in shaping it, they're more likely to engage. Luna: What about documentation? Should managers keep a log of defensive reactions? Lucas: Only if the pattern persists and you're concerned about performance. But I'd say document the feedback you gave and the response, not the emotional reaction itself. That's for your own reference. Luna: Because if it ever becomes a performance issue, you'll need a record of the conversations. Lucas: Right. But ideally you resolve it before it gets there. The goal is to build trust, not build a case. Luna: So to wrap up, what's the one thing a manager should try this week if they have a defensive employee? Lucas: Pick the next piece of feedback you need to give, and before you deliver it, write down one question you can ask instead of a statement. Then use that question in the conversation. Luna: That's a simple, concrete experiment. And it's low stakes. Lucas: Exactly. One question can change the whole dynamic. Luna: Thanks, Lucas. That's a great note to end on. Lucas: Thanks, Luna. See everyone next week.