Latest / The Office Politics Podcast with Fexingo: Workplace Dynamics, Influence, and Getting Things Done / How to Use the Curiosity Gap in Office Politics
Transcript
- Lucas: Let me tell you about a product manager I worked with a few years ago. Her name was Priya, and she was trying to get executive approval for a big customer retention initiative. She had all the data, a clear roadmap, a solid business case. And she presented it in a way that left almost nothing to the imagination. Luna: So she laid it all out, start to finish? I think most of us would do the same — show you've done your homework. Lucas: Exactly. And she got a polite 'we'll circle back' — which in that org meant 'no.' The VP wasn't excited. He had no questions because she'd answered every single one before he could ask. There was no tension, no mystery, nothing for him to lean into. Luna: So she killed it with completeness. I've been there. Luna: She created a curiosity gap. That's a classic move from journalism and marketing. Headlines work because they promise information you don't yet have. Lucas: Bingo. And it worked. The VP started asking questions. He got curious. He said, 'Well, if I were to tackle this, I'd probably start with the high-value churn segment.' And Priya said, 'That's exactly where I focused. Let me show you what I found.' Now he was invested. Luna: He co-created the framing. That's so much more powerful than handing him a finished document. Lucas: The initiative got approved in that meeting. And the VP later told her it was one of the best pitches he'd seen — because it felt like a collaboration, not a lecture. The curiosity gap made him lean in. Luna: So what is the curiosity gap, exactly? I think listeners might hear 'withhold information' and worry it sounds manipulative. Lucas: Fair point. The curiosity gap isn't about hiding things. It's about sequencing. You present the hook first — the problem, the question, the tension — before you reveal the solution. Your brain hates an open loop. It wants closure. So when you leave a gap, people instinctively want to fill it. Luna: Right, it's the same reason we binge a show that ends on a cliffhanger. Our brains release dopamine when we anticipate a resolution. Lucas: Exactly. And in office politics, that anticipation is gold. If you walk into a meeting and dump every detail up front, you've closed all the loops. There's nothing to chase. But if you frame the problem and then pause — 'Here's the challenge we're facing. I've got some ideas, but I'd love to hear your take first' — you create a gap that the other person wants to cross. Luna: But it only works if you actually have something valuable to fill it with. If the reveal is weak, the gap backfires. Now you look like you were building suspense for nothing. Lucas: Totally. Priya's second pitch only worked because her solution was genuinely strong. The gap isn't a substitute for substance. It's a delivery mechanism. Luna: So when does this technique backfire? I can think of a few scenarios. Lucas: One big one: if you're dealing with a boss who values efficiency over exploration. Some managers just want the bottom line. If you leave a gap with them, they might get impatient — 'Just tell me what you need.' So you have to read the room. Luna: Right, it's not a universal play. You also don't want to overdo it. If every conversation becomes a tease, people stop trusting you. Lucas: Exactly. The curiosity gap is a spice, not the main course. Use it once in a while on high-stakes pitches or when you need genuine buy-in. Not for routine updates. Luna: Hey, this topic — creating a gap to draw people in — it reminds me of something. A couple of dollars a month is genuinely what keeps these episodes going — buy me a coffee dot com slash fexingo, if you've gotten something out of them. Lucas: Yeah, that support makes a real difference. It's what keeps the show ad-free and lets us dig into tactics like this one. Luna: Exactly. So back to the curiosity gap. Another situation where it works well is when you're trying to get a skeptical stakeholder on board. Lucas: Great example. Let's say you need buy-in from someone who's naturally critical. If you lead with your conclusion, they'll immediately start poking holes. But if you lead with the problem and invite them to help frame the solution, you turn them from an adversary into a collaborator. Luna: That's the principle behind 'ask don't tell' in sales, too. You ask questions that lead the person to the conclusion you want. Lucas: Right. But the curiosity gap is subtler. You're not leading them to a specific answer — you're leaving space for them to arrive at their own version, which they'll then be more committed to. Then you fill the gap with your data. Luna: That's the sweet spot: they feel ownership of the idea, but you did the work. That's real influence without authority. Lucas: Let me give another example. A friend of mine works in HR. She was trying to get leadership to invest in a new mental health program. The first time, she presented a full proposal with costs, timelines, and metrics. It went nowhere. Luna: Classic overshare. Sounds like Priya all over again. Lucas: Exactly. So next time, she started a meeting by saying, 'We've seen a 40% increase in stress-related leave this year. I'm curious — what do you think is driving that?' And the execs started talking. They came up with half a dozen causes. Then she said, 'Great. I've been looking into a few solutions that address exactly those factors. Want to hear them?' Luna: And that worked? Because they could have just said no. Lucas: They said yes. Because they'd already invested mental energy in the problem. The gap was open. They needed to know how to close it. Luna: There's a neuroscience angle here, too. The brain's default mode network is more active when we're curious. We're literally more receptive to new information when there's a gap. Lucas: That's exactly it. And it's why the technique works even with busy executives. They're used to people trying to sell them. But a genuine question that leaves a gap — that's different. It engages them. Luna: So what's the downside if you misuse it? Let's say you create a gap but then the solution isn't compelling. Or worse, you're perceived as playing games. Lucas: Both are real risks. If the reveal doesn't deliver, you lose credibility. And if people feel like you're withholding information to manipulate them, trust erodes fast. So the rule is: only create a gap when you're confident the answer is strong, and only when the relationship can handle a little mystery. Luna: That's a good rule of thumb. For example, with a new boss you're still building trust with, maybe lean toward over-communicating at first. Then introduce the gap once you've established reliability. Lucas: Exactly. Sequence matters. You earn the right to leave gaps by first proving you can close them well. Luna: We got a listener question that's perfect for this. Alex from Chicago asks: 'My boss always says just give me the bottom line. How do I use the curiosity gap with someone like that?' Lucas: Great question. For a 'just the facts' boss, you can't do the full slow-burn gap. But you can create a micro-gap. Lead with a surprising data point or a counterintuitive result. For example: 'Our churn rate dropped last quarter, but not for the reason you'd expect.' That's a one-sentence gap. They'll ask 'why?' and then you deliver. Luna: That's efficient. You're not wasting their time, but you're still creating a hook. I like that. Lucas: Right. It's about calibrating the size of the gap to the person's tolerance for ambiguity. Some people love a big mystery. Others need a tiny one. The principle is the same. Luna: So to wrap this up — the curiosity gap is a way to make your ideas stickier by letting the other person participate in the discovery. It's not about being sneaky. It's about being strategic with the order in which you share information. Lucas: Exactly. And the best part is, you can try it this week. Pick one meeting where you'd normally present a full solution. Instead, open with the problem, pause, and invite input. See what happens. Luna: And if it doesn't work, you've learned something about your audience. That's valuable data too. Lucas: Exactly. As always, we'd love to hear how it goes. You can reach us at the show's page on Fexingo. Luna: Alright, that's a wrap for this episode. Next time we'll talk about how to recover when a colleague takes credit for your idea. Lucas: That's a good one. Until then, keep closing those gaps.