Latest / Friendship Project: Friendship, community & belonging / The Guilt of Not Being There: Loving a Friend Through Grief | Friendship Project
Transcript
- I spent three years mourning a friendship that never actually existed, and it took me until I was standing in a grocery store aisle crying over avocados to realize I was grieving my own expectations, not her loss. Let’s start with that moment, because it feels so mundane but it changed everything. I’m thirty-two years old, standing in Whole Foods on a Tuesday night, holding two bruised avocados. My husband is in the car waiting for me, and I am just... stopping. The fluorescent lights are humming that low, irritating buzz that only seems to exist after 8 PM. And suddenly, this wave of grief hits me so hard I have to lean against the refrigerated section for support. It wasn’t about the avocados. It wasn’t even really about him. It was about Sarah. Sarah, who I had decided was going to be my soul sister, my ride-or-die, the person who would understand the deepest, darkest corners of my mind without me having to say a word. We hadn’t spoken in six months. Not because we fought, but because life got loud, and I assumed she was busy, and she assumed I was distant, and neither of us reached out because we were both too proud to admit we missed each other. I realized right there, staring at those green fruits, that I wasn’t missing Sarah. I was missing the version of Sarah I had constructed in my head. The one who always knew what to say. The one who was always available. The one who fit perfectly into the narrative of my life like a puzzle piece I had cut myself. We do this all the time, don’t we? We build these elaborate, beautiful architectures in our minds about people we want to be close to. It starts small. Maybe they send you a meme that makes you laugh exactly the way you need to laugh. Or they share a vulnerability that feels eerily similar to yours. And your brain goes, 'Yes! This is the one. This is the connection I’ve been starving for.' And so you start filling in the blanks. You assume they’re as thoughtful as you are. You assume they’re as loyal as you promise to be. You assume they’re as confused by life as you feel inside. But here’s the thing about idealization: it’s lonely work. It’s exhausting to carry around this perfect, polished statue of someone while they’re just walking around being human. Being human means forgetting to text back. Being human means having bad days where you’re short-tempered or quiet or distracted. When we hold onto an idealized version of a friend, we set them up for failure before they’ve even had a chance to show up. And more importantly, we set ourselves up for heartbreak. Because reality will always disappoint the fantasy. Reality is messy. Reality is awkward. Reality shows up late and wears mismatched socks. If we can’t make peace with that, we’ll keep chasing ghosts while the real people right in front of us fade away into the background noise of our lives. I need to tell you something vulnerable, because I think it might help you see your own patterns if you recognize yourself in mine. For years, I was addicted to the 'newness' phase of friendship. You know that feeling? The first few months when everything feels electric and new. You talk for hours until your voice gets hoarse. You share secrets you haven’t told anyone else. It feels like magic. And I loved that feeling. I chased it like a drug. But when the novelty wore off—when the conversations got quieter, when plans got harder to coordinate, when the excitement settled into something steadier—I would panic. I would interpret that normal settling down as a sign that something was wrong. So I would pull away. I would create distance. And then I would find someone new to project my hopes onto. I was essentially dating friends the same way some people date partners, looking for that initial spark and mistaking the absence of it for incompatibility. With Sarah, I had let the relationship go dormant because I thought the magic was gone. I didn’t realize that the magic wasn’t supposed to be constant fireworks. It was supposed to be a warm hearth fire that you tend to, even when you’re not adding fresh logs every single day. I was mourning the spark instead of appreciating the warmth that could still be there if I had just kept the embers alive. So how do we break this cycle? How do we stop falling in love with the idea of someone and start loving the actual person? It starts with accepting disappointment. And I mean that in the gentlest way possible. We have to accept that our friends are flawed. They will hurt you, sometimes unintentionally. They will misunderstand you. They will prioritize their own struggles over your needs, not because they don’t care, but because they are drowning in their own water. Let’s sit with that for a second. Accepting that your best friend is not your therapist, your savior, or your mirror. They are just another person trying to figure out this weird, beautiful, terrifying life alongside you. When I finally called Sarah, I expected her to be cold. I expected her to be distant. I had written her a script in my head where she apologized for disappearing. Instead, she answered the phone and said, 'Rhiannon, I’m so glad you called. I’ve been thinking about you so much, but I didn’t know how to reach out without sounding needy.' And that was it. That was the real her. Not the perfect confidante, but the scared, hopeful, imperfect woman who also needed reassurance. The moment I stopped expecting perfection from her, I could finally connect with her. The tension vanished. The performance ended. And we could just be two women talking, flaws and all. This isn’t about lowering your standards or tolerating abuse. Boundaries are still essential. But there is a huge difference between a boundary and an expectation. A boundary says, 'I will not stay in a conversation where I am disrespected.' An expectation says, 'You must always know how to comfort me.' One protects you; the other controls her. To love the real friend, you have to practice radical presence. You have to show up for the boring parts. You have to listen when they’re talking about their job stress instead of their spiritual awakening. You have to be willing to be the one who initiates the call sometimes, even if you’re tired. You have to forgive the missed texts and the cancelled plans. It requires a kind of courage that feels unglamorous. It’s not the dramatic reconciliation scene in a movie. It’s sending a simple text saying, 'Thinking of you,' with no demand for a reply. It’s showing up to a dinner party knowing you might be bored for an hour, but staying anyway because you value the company. It’s choosing the person over the persona. Tell me more about why that matters to you, because I think many of us are afraid that if we drop the mask, we won’t be enough. But I promise you, the real you is enough. And the real them is enough. You don’t need to fix them. You don’t need to change them. You just need to witness them. Truly see them. Not the highlight reel, but the whole messy, complicated, beautiful film. And while we’re letting go of the idealized versions of others, we have to do the same for ourselves. We often hide our messiness because we’re afraid it will drive people away. We curate our personalities like we curate our social media feeds. But belonging doesn’t happen in the curated spaces. Belonging happens in the cracks. It happens when you admit you’re struggling. When you say, 'I’m not okay today.' When you share your fear instead of your confidence. When I started sharing my own uncertainties with Sarah—admitting that I was lonely, that I was scared about my career, that I felt like I was failing at adulthood—that’s when our friendship truly deepened. She didn’t run. She leaned in. She shared her own fears. And suddenly, we weren’t two performative friends pretending to have it all together. We were two humans, holding space for each other’s broken pieces. It was tender. It was fierce. It was real. So I invite you to look at the friendships in your life right now. Where are you holding onto an image? Where are you disappointed because they aren’t meeting a standard you created in isolation? What would it feel like to drop that standard? To say, 'I see you. I see your flaws. And I choose you anyway.' We’re all just figuring it out as we go. None of us have the manual. None of us are perfect. And there is so much freedom in that. There is so much love waiting for you on the other side of your expectations. Don’t miss it. Thank you for sitting with me here, in the quiet truth of our imperfections. I hope you give yourself permission to love the real people around you today, exactly as they are. Until next time, take care of your heart. It’s doing its best.