Latest / Her Journey: Women, identity, culture & modern life / Birthdays Alone: Finding Joy When Your Best Friends Are Miles Away | Her Journey
Transcript
- There is a specific, heavy kind of guilt that settles in your chest when you’re happy and the person you love most is falling apart. It feels less like an emotion and more like a physical weight, pressing down on your lungs until even your joy feels like a betrayal. Let’s sit with that for a second. We grow up believing that friendship is a shared burden, that if one of us is drowning, the other must be ready to dive in and struggle alongside her. We think that loving someone means mirroring their pain, absorbing it until our own emotional state matches theirs perfectly. But what happens when life hands you a gift while they are still fighting for air? What happens when you get the promotion, or meet someone new, or finally find a peace you’ve been chasing for years, and your best friend is still in the thick of it? The silence between those two realities can feel deafening. You might catch yourself checking your phone, hesitating to send that text about your good news because you know it will land poorly. You might dim your light so she doesn’t have to squint against it. And isn’t that exhausting? To feel like you have to shrink yourself just to make space for someone else’s grief or confusion. I remember sitting across from my own best friend once, watching her cry over a breakup that had lasted three years, while I was secretly planning my trip to Italy. I wanted to scream, I wanted to dance, I wanted to tell her how beautiful the world felt that morning. Instead, I sat there, nodding, holding her hand, feeling this sharp, jagged rock of guilt lodged right behind my sternum. I thought I was being a good friend by hiding my happiness. But looking back, I realize I was actually doing something much more complicated. I was trying to manage her emotions for her. I was trying to ensure that our bond remained equal in suffering, as if equality in pain is the only proof of loyalty. It’s complicated, isn’t it? Because underneath that guilt, there is often another feeling we rarely admit to out loud: envy. Not the malicious kind, but the raw, human ache of wanting what she doesn’t have yet. Maybe it’s stability. Maybe it’s clarity. Maybe it’s just the simple ability to sleep through the night without dread. When you see your friend stuck in a loop you’ve already escaped, or a pattern you’re currently breaking, it can trigger a deep sense of shame. You start to wonder if your escape was lucky, or if it was earned, and if it was luck, do you deserve it? And if it was earned, why hasn’t she figured it out too? This comparison is dangerous ground. It makes us feel superior, which is terrible, but it also makes us feel responsible, which is even worse. We begin to view our thriving not as a personal victory, but as a personal failure of empathy. I used to believe that if I couldn’t relate to her pain, I didn’t truly understand her. So I would force myself to focus on the negative aspects of my own life, digging for flaws just to create common ground. If she was anxious about money, I’d complain about my bills, even if I was financially secure. If she was lonely, I’d highlight the times I felt isolated, ignoring the vibrant social life I actually had. It was a performance of solidarity. And let me tell you, it is a terrible way to live. It drains you. It creates resentment, slowly and quietly, like mold growing in the walls of a house you can’t see. You start to resent her for needing you to be sad, and you start to resent yourself for being able to be happy. That dynamic poisons the well. It turns friendship into a competition of who can suffer more gracefully, rather than a sanctuary where both people can heal. We need to talk about the zero-sum game of happiness. Our culture loves to tell us that joy is finite, that if one person takes up all the light, there is none left for the rest of us. But that is simply not true. Your happiness does not subtract from her potential healing. In fact, your thriving can be a beacon. Think about it. When you are struggling, who do you want to see around you? Do you want everyone mirroring your despair, sitting in the dark with you, validating that the darkness is permanent? Or do you want someone who remembers what the sun feels like? Someone who can say, 'I know it’s hard now, but look at me. I made it. I am here. It gets better.' Your recovery is not a betrayal of her struggle; it is evidence that her struggle is survivable. I learned this the hard way. There was a period where my best friend was battling severe depression, and I was going through a messy divorce. For months, we were a pair of wounded animals, huddled together in the cold. We bonded over our misery. But eventually, I started to stabilize. I went to therapy. I set boundaries. I found routines that worked. And every time I mentioned my progress, I saw her eyes glaze over. She would change the subject. She would sigh. I interpreted that as rejection. I thought, 'She doesn’t care about my growth.' But later, she told me something that changed everything. She said, 'When you talk about getting better, it reminds me that I’m broken. It makes me feel like I’m failing.' Ah. There it is. The mirror effect. Your success holds up a mirror to her stagnation, and that hurts. But the solution isn’t to turn off the light. The solution is to handle the reflection with gentleness. It’s about acknowledging that her pain is valid, and your joy is valid, and they can exist in the same room without canceling each other out. It requires a level of emotional maturity that most of us haven’t practiced. It asks us to hold two truths at once: I am hurting, and you are healing. Both are real. Both matter. So how do we navigate this without abandoning the person we love? How do we thrive without becoming selfish? It starts with radical honesty about our capacity. We cannot pour from an empty cup, but we also cannot keep others drowning while we stay dry on the shore. The key is presence, not proximity. You don’t have to be in the trenches with her to support her. Sometimes, the most supportive thing you can do is stand on solid ground and offer her a rope. But you have to stop apologizing for standing on that ground. I used to apologize for having a good day. 'Sorry I’m so cheerful,' I’d say, as if happiness were a rude interruption. Now, I frame it differently. I say, 'I had a really good moment today, and I wanted to share it with you because you’re my person.' I leave space for her to respond however she needs to. If she’s too tired to celebrate, that’s okay. If she’s angry, that’s okay. But I don’t preemptively shrink myself to accommodate her mood. This shift changes the dynamic entirely. It moves the relationship from codependent enmeshment to interdependent connection. You are two whole people choosing to walk together, not two halves trying to complete each other through shared trauma. It allows for nuance. You can be excited about your life while still being deeply committed to her healing. You can laugh loudly in one conversation and sit in silence during the next. You don’t have to be consistent in your suffering; you only have to be consistent in your love. And love, real love, doesn’t demand that you lower your wings so she doesn’t have to fly. It waits for her to be ready. It trusts that she will rise when the time is right. Your job is not to pull her up; your job is to be a reminder that upward movement is possible. Where does that live in you? That fear that your joy is theft? That question has haunted me for years. I realized recently that it comes from a place of unworthiness, not unkindness. I didn’t believe I deserved happiness while others were in pain. I believed I had to earn it, or that it was too risky to claim it fully. But listening to you, reading your letter, I hear that same hesitation. You’re afraid that if you move forward, you’ll leave her behind. You’re afraid that your evolution will create distance. Let me tell you something true: distance is not always abandonment. Sometimes, distance is growth. And growth is scary. It requires us to trust that the bond is strong enough to withstand change. It requires us to believe that love is resilient enough to survive inequality in circumstance. You don’t have to fix her. You don’t have to carry her. You just have to stay. Stay present. Stay curious. Stay kind. But also, stay yourself. Your authenticity is the greatest gift you can offer her. A fake, dimmed-down version of you offers no hope. Only the real, vibrant, messy, thriving you can show her that life is worth living. So take up space. Celebrate your wins. Grieve your losses. Be exactly who you are, even if it’s uncomfortable for her to watch. Because one day, she will look up, and she will see you. And she will see that it’s safe to try again. Until then, breathe. You are allowed to be happy. You are allowed to be free. And you are allowed to love her without losing yourself. Thank you for trusting me with your heart today. I’m Quinn Cuffe. Remember, you don’t have to dim your light to help someone else find their way. Take care of yourselves, and each other.