Latest / The President's Daily Brief / The PDB Situation Report | November 14th, 2026: Spy Scandal at Nvidia Rocks America’s AI Industry & Russia-Ukraine Peace Talks
Transcript
- 0:07Welcome to the PDB Situation Report.
- 0:10I'm Mike Baker,
- 0:10your eyes and ears on the world stage.
- 0:13All right.
- 0:14Let's get briefed.
- 0:15First up,
- 0:16an espionage scandal,
- 0:17Rock Nvidia.
- 0:18Perhaps you've heard about it,
- 0:20forcing out its longtime CEO
- 0:22and raising concerns about China's access
- 0:25to America's most sensitive AI technology.
- 0:28We'll be joined by Max Meisli of the Foundation
- 0:30for Defense of Democracies for more on that.
- 0:33Later in the show,
- 0:34Russia and Ukraine
- 0:36have returned to the negotiating table in Abu Dhabi,
- 0:40making some limited progress,
- 0:41but failing to resolve the biggest obstacles to ending the war.
- 0:45Former US ambassador to Ukraine John Herbst will stop by to give his insight.
- 0:50But first,
- 0:51today's Situation Report Spotlight.
- 0:54Well,
- 0:54it's been an interesting few weeks for the world's leading AI chip maker Nvidia.
- 0:59That's an understatement.
- 1:00Its longtime CEO Jensen Huang has resigned following revelations
- 1:05of an affair with a businesswoman suspected by US intelligence
- 1:08of spying for China.
- 1:10That would be among other affairs.
- 1:12I believe the scoreboard is at 3 so far.
- 1:15Nvidia has launched an independent investigation.
- 1:18Well,
- 1:18that's nice,
- 1:19while lawmakers are demanding answers about potential espionage,
- 1:22sensitive technology,
- 1:23and China's access to advanced American chips.
- 1:27Frankly,
- 1:27it's a very good thing
- 1:28if Congress spends more time focusing on China's shenanigans.
- 1:33The company maintains it has no evidence the national security was compromised.
- 1:37None.
- 1:37Oh,
- 1:38but the scandal has renewed questions about
- 1:40China's efforts to obtain American technology.
- 1:43As a pro tip,
- 1:44they are
- 1:45constantly trying to obtain American technology
- 1:48and Washington's attempts to stop it.
- 1:50Joining me now for more on this is Max Misli.
- 1:53She's the deputy director of the Foundation for Defense of Democracy's
- 1:56Center on Economic and Financial Power.
- 1:59Max,
- 2:00well,
- 2:00there you are,
- 2:01first time guest on the PDB Situation Report.
- 2:03Thank you very much for joining us today.
- 2:06Happy to be with you.
- 2:09Uh,
- 2:10well,
- 2:11let's see,
- 2:11before we get started on this,
- 2:12um,
- 2:14according to the,
- 2:16um,
- 2:17Jensen Huang
- 2:18side action scoreboard.
- 2:21So far,
- 2:21the tally is 3.
- 2:22It looks like,
- 2:23uh,
- 2:231
- 2:24alleged Chinese intel asset and 2 Nvidia employees.
- 2:28Are you surprised that he resigned?
- 2:32No,
- 2:32I think there are a lot of pressures for him to resign,
- 2:35um,
- 2:36what's in the board,
- 2:37um,
- 2:38look,
- 2:38he's gonna be facing a lot of scrutiny,
- 2:40um,
- 2:40at the individual level,
- 2:42there's gonna be additional scrutiny,
- 2:44well,
- 2:44on Nvidia at the corporate level looking at matters of US national security.
- 2:48I think honestly the most interesting thing here is that
- 2:51Uh,
- 2:51as much as we've already known about issues related to export control,
- 2:54evasion and diversion of these high-end chips,
- 2:57uh,
- 2:58somehow what it took for people to have a renewed interest in this
- 3:01important matter of national security was the CEO having an alleged affair with,
- 3:05uh,
- 3:05or an affair with an alleged Chinese intelligence asset.
- 3:08So
- 3:09I think that actually should just give us a little
- 3:10bit of pause that this is the basis for why
- 3:12folks are all of a sudden having a renewed interest in the issue.
- 3:17I'm gonna take that one step further,
- 3:19Max.
- 3:19I'm gonna say that
- 3:21it wasn't so much
- 3:23the
- 3:23intimate relationship that he admitted to with the alleged,
- 3:27we keep saying alleged,
- 3:28uh,
- 3:29Chinese intel asset.
- 3:31Um,
- 3:32because,
- 3:32um,
- 3:33a lot of folks in Silicon Valley and others just rallied around him.
- 3:36They were like,
- 3:36it,
- 3:36it was almost like they were saying,
- 3:38well,
- 3:38yeah,
- 3:38OK,
- 3:38that's bad,
- 3:39but getting rid of Jensen would be worse.
- 3:41What,
- 3:41what apparently was a bridge too far
- 3:44was then his affairs with people who worked for him.
- 3:47And that's,
- 3:48I think,
- 3:49Um,
- 3:50very interesting in the sense that it wasn't,
- 3:52it wasn't the threats to national security on
- 3:55the large basis that you're talking about.
- 3:56It wasn't
- 3:57the,
- 3:58the actual sleeping
- 4:00with an alleged Chinese intel asset.
- 4:02It was then,
- 4:03oh my God,
- 4:03he's,
- 4:04he hadn't.
- 4:04Affair with an employee who was working for him.
- 4:06Well,
- 4:06that's,
- 4:07that's a bridge too far.
- 4:09So,
- 4:10I think that was the
- 4:11that was in part,
- 4:12I,
- 4:12I know I'm oversimplifying this,
- 4:13but that was the part that
- 4:15that I that struck me as,
- 4:17as,
- 4:17uh,
- 4:18I don't know what to call it,
- 4:19interesting.
- 4:20Uh,
- 4:20let me ask you this,
- 4:22Max,
- 4:22do you think,
- 4:24do you think Jensen Huang
- 4:25is indispensable?
- 4:29Look,
- 4:29I'm not an expert on on chip design,
- 4:32um,
- 4:32or you know,
- 4:33the business side of semiconductors and building out this industry.
- 4:36I understand that he's
- 4:38been indispensable for the growth of of AI and for the underlying technology
- 4:43that actually is the backing for the entirety of the AI industry,
- 4:46um,
- 4:47so in a way he's been
- 4:49An incredibly important person for the growth of this industry,
- 4:52for the growth of
- 4:53uh the US dominance in the AI sector
- 4:57in many respects,
- 4:58um,
- 4:58but look,
- 4:59it would be a bad thing if the fate of a company is
- 5:02going to be tied to the person who's led it for 33 years.
- 5:05I,
- 5:05I do have concern though,
- 5:06I mean,
- 5:07just as a matter of the general reporting on,
- 5:09you know,
- 5:09the board structure and the business lines within Nvidia,
- 5:12it seems like
- 5:13You know,
- 5:14things ran,
- 5:14uh,
- 5:15uh,
- 5:15relatively flat with,
- 5:17uh,
- 5:17Jensen talking about having how he had 60 direct reports.
- 5:21Um,
- 5:21so it seems like this is going to be a
- 5:22difficult thing for whoever comes in his place to fill,
- 5:25um,
- 5:26but it really doesn't address,
- 5:27I think,
- 5:27the most important part here,
- 5:28which is the underlying national security concerns
- 5:30and the export control and diversion matters,
- 5:33um,
- 5:33that
- 5:34impacts not only Nvidia but every other
- 5:36similarly situated firm involved in this ecosystem.
- 5:40Yeah,
- 5:41no,
- 5:41I,
- 5:41I,
- 5:42I get your point and I agree with you.
- 5:44Um,
- 5:45it was
- 5:46William Shakespeare.
- 5:47Everybody attributes things to,
- 5:48apparently,
- 5:48the only people who were making quotes
- 5:50were Winston Churchill or William Shakespeare,
- 5:51but I think he wrote
- 5:53that the graveyards are full of indispensable men.
- 5:56Um,
- 5:57again,
- 5:58just as an aside,
- 5:59this isn't the,
- 5:59the key point to any of these developments,
- 6:01or,
- 6:01or the story,
- 6:02but
- 6:03it is interesting how people rallied around him in,
- 6:05in the face of this.
- 6:07national security issue,
- 6:09you know,
- 6:09saying,
- 6:09well,
- 6:10even Elon Musk was like,
- 6:11well,
- 6:11you know,
- 6:11he's,
- 6:12he,
- 6:12he actually is indispensable.
- 6:13He can't be,
- 6:14I,
- 6:14I,
- 6:14I think that's,
- 6:15you know,
- 6:16what do I know?
- 6:16I'm,
- 6:17I'm the last person you should talk to about
- 6:18ship development and,
- 6:20and,
- 6:20and,
- 6:20and technology,
- 6:21but
- 6:22I
- 6:23have been around for a long time.
- 6:24I don't believe anybody's indispensable.
- 6:27Um,
- 6:28So,
- 6:28talk to me if you could about
- 6:31the
- 6:33Look,
- 6:34the,
- 6:34the,
- 6:34the fact that Jensen Huang
- 6:36was an advocate for opening up the market,
- 6:40right?
- 6:40For,
- 6:40for pushing
- 6:41for,
- 6:42um,
- 6:44Uh,
- 6:44you know,
- 6:44fewer restrictions
- 6:46on processor on chip sales
- 6:48to China.
- 6:52Talk to me about where that stands right now.
- 6:54I mean,
- 6:55I think it's,
- 6:55it's,
- 6:56it's somewhat confusing because we can,
- 6:58we can allow the transfer of,
- 7:00of certain chips,
- 7:01not others,
- 7:03um,
- 7:03but talk to me about where we are right now in that process and
- 7:07also if you could then kind of move into the idea of,
- 7:09well,
- 7:10how good are we at policing that?
- 7:14Right,
- 7:14so there's um,
- 7:16you know,
- 7:16long standing export controls as it relates to uh semiconductors and these
- 7:22advanced chips and then the servers that ultimately house uh the chips.
- 7:27Um,
- 7:28there are some loopholes that have existed for quite some time where,
- 7:32uh,
- 7:32these servers and the chips can be exported to other countries that then
- 7:38uh provide remote access for firms in other countries like China
- 7:42that shouldn't otherwise be able to access them.
- 7:44This is something that's developed a significant amount of bipartisan interest
- 7:48in closing that loophole since this whole saga has begun.
- 7:53In the last
- 7:54several days involving uh Cheni Wong and and and Alice Wong,
- 7:58um,
- 7:59there's there's other matters though that require greater attention that I think,
- 8:03you know,
- 8:04few are actually talking about,
- 8:06um,
- 8:06and so this relates to the financial institutions
- 8:08and their responsibility and policing against this threat.
- 8:11Um,
- 8:12so we think a lot about,
- 8:13you know,
- 8:13the companies that are directly involved,
- 8:15right?
- 8:15So Nvidia and its understanding of its customers downstream and then from there,
- 8:20who they're then providing services to or providing
- 8:23indirect transfer of the controlled chips to,
- 8:26uh,
- 8:26that's all worthwhile and there's a lot that can be done legislatively,
- 8:30uh,
- 8:30to create a more aggressive enforcement posture so that,
- 8:33uh,
- 8:33goods can't be more easily transferred to end users in China.
- 8:38Um,
- 8:38but to my point about the financial institutions,
- 8:41Yeah
- 8:43No,
- 8:43no,
- 8:43no,
- 8:43go ahead.
- 8:44I'm sorry,
- 8:44go ahead.
- 8:45To my point about the financial institutions,
- 8:47uh,
- 8:48you know,
- 8:48the,
- 8:48the Commerce Department put out guidance just a couple of years ago,
- 8:51highlighting that financial institutions and any other entity,
- 8:54uh,
- 8:55no matter where they're located,
- 8:56so not just US persons,
- 8:58have an obligation,
- 8:59uh,
- 8:59because they're prohibited from providing services or financing for
- 9:03deals that relate to these export controlled goods.
- 9:06And so we're talking about billions of dollars of these export controlled
- 9:11chips moving to China,
- 9:13uh through cutouts like Alice Wong's
- 9:16Megaspeed and other similarly situated entities.
- 9:19Now,
- 9:20there's been reporting in recent days about the financing that's been provided,
- 9:24where there was collateral provided,
- 9:26uh,
- 9:26and so firms are providing
- 9:28big
- 9:29money,
- 9:30right,
- 9:30billions of dollars to to provide for the sale and flow of these chips.
- 9:35Uh,
- 9:36they have an obligation under US law to not do so,
- 9:39uh,
- 9:39if they have an indication that doing so could actually be in violation of the law.
- 9:44And then
- 9:44we think about the Treasury authority impression was.
- 9:49I'm,
- 9:50I'm sorry,
- 9:50we have a bit of a delay,
- 9:52um,
- 9:52in,
- 9:52in the system,
- 9:53uh,
- 9:53for some reason this morning,
- 9:55Max,
- 9:55but,
- 9:56uh,
- 9:56my impression was,
- 9:58That Nvidia is one of those
- 10:00companies
- 10:01that is providing
- 10:03support,
- 10:03providing money,
- 10:04providing whatever you want to call them,
- 10:06subsidies,
- 10:07uh,
- 10:07to grow the business,
- 10:08right?
- 10:10Well,
- 10:10so Nvidia has its customer base,
- 10:12right,
- 10:12and so they're selling directly to uh suppliers
- 10:16uh who are then providing the uh semiconductors downstream
- 10:20to other customers that Nvidia might not have direct insight into who they are,
- 10:24right?
- 10:25So there's questions.
- 10:26about the extent to which Nvidia
- 10:27should have an additional obligation to understand
- 10:30downstream who ultimately those end users are of the chips.
- 10:33This is why closing up this loophole that allows
- 10:36for remote access from servers in Southeast Asia,
- 10:39um,
- 10:39would be uh warranted.
- 10:41But let me just put forward this theory of
- 10:44how the US could investigate further utilizing financial institutions.
- 10:48And at the end of the day,
- 10:49when we're moving billions of dollars,
- 10:51there's significant amounts of trade documents and trade intelligence
- 10:54that uh banks are custodyding themselves,
- 10:57right,
- 10:57as part of these major transactions.
- 10:59And so the United States,
- 11:01several years ago,
- 11:02uh,
- 11:03passed a reform to some money laundering,
- 11:05anti-money laundering laws,
- 11:06and it allowed for the Department of
- 11:08Justice and the Treasury Department to actually
- 11:11subpoena foreign banks that have connectivity to the
- 11:14United States when they're doing business in dollars.
- 11:17Um,
- 11:17and to request information from them for any number of types of,
- 11:21uh,
- 11:21financial crimes,
- 11:22uh,
- 11:22or criminal,
- 11:23uh,
- 11:24matters.
- 11:25Um,
- 11:25and so regardless of whether the activity actually
- 11:28relates to their conduct in the United States,
- 11:29the US actually maintains this authority
- 11:31to issue the subpoenas and to threaten them
- 11:34with cutting off their access to the US
- 11:37dollar,
- 11:38uh,
- 11:38banks that they're using to clear up big business in the United States.
- 11:41So there's a real significant approach the United States can
- 11:45use to bring the heavy hand of US law enforcement.
- 11:48to bear
- 11:49against these financial institutions that should
- 11:51be having a significant amount of the
- 11:53trade information that we would want to have a better understanding of.
- 11:56So,
- 11:57this is just part of the conversation that isn't
- 11:58getting a lot of attention right now in Washington,
- 12:00you know,
- 12:00there's kind of like the sexier issues at hand
- 12:02and everyone's talking about the export control reforms,
- 12:05those are necessary,
- 12:06but equally as important is the role that Treasury is going
- 12:08to play in actually policing against this threat in the future.
- 12:12Well,
- 12:13to your knowledge,
- 12:14um,
- 12:15or at least in,
- 12:15in,
- 12:16in,
- 12:16in your experience,
- 12:17um,
- 12:18to what degree has the government used that subpoena power,
- 12:21uh,
- 12:22with overseas financial institutions up to this point?
- 12:26At least in the context of the
- 12:27export controls and trade diversion involving semiconductors,
- 12:30I'm not aware of any instances in which it's actually been utilized.
- 12:35Yeah.
- 12:35And,
- 12:36and,
- 12:36and just before we go to break,
- 12:37um,
- 12:38Max,
- 12:38I know this,
- 12:39we,
- 12:39we're not a,
- 12:39we're not a political show,
- 12:41but you mentioned
- 12:42sort of there's,
- 12:42there's legislation that can be done,
- 12:45um,
- 12:45in,
- 12:46in pursuit of some of these issues we're talking about,
- 12:48uh,
- 12:49with the change
- 12:50following the,
- 12:51the midterm elections beatdown,
- 12:53um,
- 12:53and the change in the House and Senate.
- 12:56Do you see this as a bipartisan issue,
- 13:00or does this land on one side of the aisle or another?
- 13:04I think that that it's,
- 13:06it is quite frankly a bipartisan issue.
- 13:08I think that there are ways in which it could take a partisan turn for the worst.
- 13:12I mean,
- 13:13you know,
- 13:13look,
- 13:13we need to get a better understanding of why some of these delays have happened,
- 13:17right?
- 13:17And so there is some speculation,
- 13:19uh,
- 13:19regarding,
- 13:20uh,
- 13:20uh,
- 13:21potential,
- 13:22um,
- 13:23uh,
- 13:23concerns from within the commerce department
- 13:26as to why the department has been slow rolling these efforts to add.
- 13:30Uh,
- 13:30Megaspeed,
- 13:31which was the firm run by Alice Wong,
- 13:33this alleged Chinese intelligence asset,
- 13:35why there was a delay in adding it to the,
- 13:38uh,
- 13:38uh,
- 13:38Commerce Department's entity list which prohibit exports
- 13:41to that entity.
- 13:43Um,
- 13:43we don't quite know why there was this delay,
- 13:46right?
- 13:46Maybe there was some impropriety,
- 13:47maybe there was just a process issue.
- 13:50Um,
- 13:50I think that there's a potential for it to become
- 13:53partisan if this is going to become just an attack
- 13:56on the Trump administration writ large,
- 13:57when at the end of the day,
- 13:59what it needs to be
- 14:00is,
- 14:00uh,
- 14:01a pursuit to understand transparent transparently
- 14:04why there were certain delays,
- 14:05where the issues were,
- 14:06and then how we actually create the reforms to
- 14:08prevent this from ever happening again in the future.
- 14:11Well,
- 14:12I for one a.m shocked that you,
- 14:13you might have thrown out the idea that there could be impropriety in Washington DC.
- 14:18Come on,
- 14:19Max.
- 14:20That sounds very cynical.
- 14:21Uh,
- 14:22if you'll stay right where you are,
- 14:23don't go anywhere,
- 14:24Max,
- 14:24we have to take a quick break
- 14:26and then we will be back with more from Max Meisli,
- 14:30the deputy director of the Foundation for Defense of Democracy's
- 14:33Center on Economic and Financial Power right here
- 14:36on the PDB Situation Report.
- 14:37So please
- 14:39stick around.
- 14:40Hey,
- 14:40Mike Baker here with a word about personal health and weight loss.
- 14:44Now,
- 14:45everybody's talking about weight loss injections,
- 14:46right,
- 14:47because the results have been so dramatic.
- 14:49They work by lowering blood sugar and reducing appetite.
- 14:52But
- 14:53what if you're looking to lose weight
- 14:54and not interested in painful weekly injections,
- 14:57especially when you hear about some of those side effects?
- 14:59Well,
- 14:59that's why doctors created a weight loss supplement called Lean,
- 15:02L E A N,
- 15:03and the results are remarkable.
- 15:05The studied ingredients in Lean have been shown to lower your blood sugar,
- 15:09burn fat by converting.
- 15:10Converting it into energy and curb your appetite and cravings
- 15:13so you're not as hungry.
- 15:14It's as simple as that.
- 15:15But listen,
- 15:15Lean is not for the casual dieter with only a few pounds to lose.
- 15:19The doctors at Brickhouse Nutrition
- 15:21created Lean for frustrated dieters with 10 or more pounds to lose.
- 15:26Let's get you started with 20% off and free rush shipping so
- 15:28you can add lean to your healthy diet and exercise plan.
- 15:32Visit takelean.com
- 15:34and enter PDB for your discount.
- 15:36That's promo code PDB
- 15:38at takelean.com.
- 15:41Welcome back to the PDB situation Report.
- 15:44Joining us once again is Max Misla.
- 15:46She's the
- 15:46deputy director of the Foundation for Defense of
- 15:49Democracy Center on Economic and Financial Power.
- 15:52We've been discussing the Nvidia situation,
- 15:55scandal,
- 15:56whatever we want to refer to it as.
- 15:58Uh,
- 15:59Max,
- 15:59thank you very much for,
- 16:00for sticking around.
- 16:01Um,
- 16:02and
- 16:03let me ask you this,
- 16:04you brought up
- 16:05at the end of the first segment,
- 16:07you brought up the idea that,
- 16:08uh,
- 16:09there had been some delay.
- 16:10On the part of commerce,
- 16:12Department of Commerce.
- 16:13In,
- 16:14uh,
- 16:15moving against Megaspeed
- 16:17over concern of
- 16:19the fact that it,
- 16:19it may have,
- 16:20uh,
- 16:21been using cutouts,
- 16:22uh,
- 16:22other entities
- 16:24to,
- 16:24uh,
- 16:25transfer,
- 16:26uh,
- 16:26restrictive technology
- 16:27to China
- 16:29from Nvidia.
- 16:30Now,
- 16:30there's been a little bit of reporting that said that the problem there was,
- 16:33uh,
- 16:34Treasury Secretary Scott Besant.
- 16:36Who was pushing back.
- 16:38Oh,
- 16:39no,
- 16:39actually,
- 16:39I take that back and I,
- 16:40with apologies to Besant,
- 16:42it was,
- 16:42uh,
- 16:42actually Howard Lutnick over at Commerce.
- 16:44So,
- 16:45I apologize,
- 16:46uh,
- 16:47to the Treasury Secretary.
- 16:48I,
- 16:48I,
- 16:48he watches this religiously.
- 16:50Uh,
- 16:51so,
- 16:52the idea being that Howard Lutnick,
- 16:54uh,
- 16:54was sort of the roadblock
- 16:57in,
- 16:57in that move.
- 16:58And apparently,
- 17:00according to reporting,
- 17:01uh,
- 17:02it was in part because he was concerned over,
- 17:05Retaliation from China,
- 17:07uh,
- 17:07essentially,
- 17:08um,
- 17:09you know,
- 17:10impacting the relationship with China,
- 17:12such as it is.
- 17:13Mind you,
- 17:14China is at the center of this
- 17:16espionage scandal,
- 17:17so
- 17:18upsetting them,
- 17:19at least in my book,
- 17:20I wouldn't really play a role here.
- 17:22Um,
- 17:23have you heard anything about that
- 17:24and have you heard any,
- 17:25any additional
- 17:27insight into
- 17:29where that stands?
- 17:30Because my understanding again,
- 17:31not to bang on about this before I finish my question,
- 17:34which is rambling.
- 17:35is that the White House has said just get on with it.
- 17:38And yet commerce continues to slow roll this effort.
- 17:42Look,
- 17:43the administration has decidedly different approaches within its own
- 17:48operation as it relates to how to go and
- 17:50and combat China.
- 17:52Um,
- 17:52what we know as a matter of fact from the reporting and then also,
- 17:57uh,
- 17:57on Friday today,
- 17:59uh,
- 18:00Treasury Secretary Besson has said
- 18:03that,
- 18:04uh,
- 18:04the US Trade Representative,
- 18:06Treasury,
- 18:07state,
- 18:08Um,
- 18:08we're all in agreement
- 18:10that Commerce Department should have added,
- 18:12uh,
- 18:13and still should add Megaspeed
- 18:15to the Commerce Department's entity list,
- 18:18which would prohibit exports
- 18:19of these goods to the entity.
- 18:22Uh,
- 18:22Treasury Secretary Bassett made it very
- 18:24plain
- 18:25that the Commerce Secretary,
- 18:27uh,
- 18:28uh,
- 18:28Howard Lutnick,
- 18:29has this responsibility.
- 18:31He has the pen and the decision is his.
- 18:34There's reporting suggesting that President Trump has
- 18:37uh supported this effort,
- 18:38so it's unclear as to why,
- 18:41uh,
- 18:41this is actually moving so slowly.
- 18:43What we know for sure from uh the last year of reporting is that
- 18:48the Commerce Secretary and Jensen Wong have had a close relationship,
- 18:52uh,
- 18:53that of all the people in the administration,
- 18:55Jensen Wong says that he speaks most regularly with the Commerce Secretary.
- 18:59We know that
- 19:00uh Jensen Wong has had this very close
- 19:02and intimate relationship with an individual who is
- 19:05believed by many and alleged to be a Chinese intelligence asset,
- 19:10and so there's concerns about the extent
- 19:12to which Jensen Wong may have been impacting
- 19:14the pace of decision making in the United
- 19:16States that would have had a negative external effect
- 19:19on China's buildout of its AI ecosystem.
- 19:21Um,
- 19:22so all of that is,
- 19:23is ongoing,
- 19:24uh,
- 19:24we need to get to the bottom of it,
- 19:26we need to understand what the delay is,
- 19:28and we need action from the US government,
- 19:29frankly,
- 19:30I think it's high time that President Trump,
- 19:32uh,
- 19:33uh,
- 19:33takes his,
- 19:34uh,
- 19:34uh,
- 19:35position of influence and power within the administration
- 19:37to make an executive decision,
- 19:39uh,
- 19:39that requires the Commerce Department secretary to
- 19:42sign off on this order that would
- 19:44restrict the flow of goods of these export controlled ships to megape.
- 19:49Yeah,
- 19:49a couple of points there,
- 19:50uh,
- 19:51that you raise,
- 19:52Max,
- 19:52I think you're excellent,
- 19:53um,
- 19:55Just uh for general consumption,
- 19:57uh,
- 19:57for those
- 19:58watching,
- 19:58um.
- 19:59From an operational perspective,
- 20:01people are saying,
- 20:01well,
- 20:02well,
- 20:02OK,
- 20:02we get it.
- 20:03Uh,
- 20:03Jensen Huang was,
- 20:04uh,
- 20:04you know,
- 20:04critically important in the AI race,
- 20:06China to the US,
- 20:07you know,
- 20:08so we understand why he was being targeted.
- 20:10Uh,
- 20:11but you're targeting somebody like that for a variety of reasons,
- 20:13not just for,
- 20:15OK,
- 20:15is he going to provide intelligence on
- 20:17the plans and intentions of Nvidia,
- 20:20or is he going to talk about his conversations
- 20:23with the president when he's in the White House.
- 20:25It's also the potential for him to be a,
- 20:27an agent of influence.
- 20:28I,
- 20:28I,
- 20:28again,
- 20:29not saying witting,
- 20:30right?
- 20:30Nobody's,
- 20:31nobody's saying
- 20:32he's a witting asset or he's cooperative contact.
- 20:35He could be perfectly unwitting.
- 20:37The Chinese intel apparatus would be more than happy
- 20:39to use an unwitting contact if they're getting what they want.
- 20:42And in this case,
- 20:43you know,
- 20:44it,
- 20:44it's,
- 20:44uh,
- 20:44very likely that they viewed him as an,
- 20:47essentially,
- 20:48an agent of influence
- 20:49who could help push
- 20:50the policies
- 20:51of the White House in the direction that the Chinese Communist Party wants.
- 20:56Um,
- 20:57a second point,
- 20:58and this may be kind of inside Washington DC
- 21:01baseball,
- 21:02but,
- 21:03um,
- 21:03to your point about
- 21:05Jensen Huang having a
- 21:07close relationship with Howard Lutnick,
- 21:10You know,
- 21:10I'm,
- 21:11for what it's worth,
- 21:12you know,
- 21:12talk around Washington is that,
- 21:14you know,
- 21:14part of the issue with commerce is that
- 21:16everything has to flow through Lutnick and he ends up just basically being
- 21:19the guy who makes decisions.
- 21:21So,
- 21:21anybody who
- 21:22is attempting or companies who are attempting
- 21:24to understand what commerce is doing,
- 21:27basically,
- 21:28you know,
- 21:28you've got to be dealing with Howard Lutnick,
- 21:30which is,
- 21:31uh,
- 21:32perhaps Lutnick's style,
- 21:34but not necessarily perhaps
- 21:36the most effective or efficient way
- 21:38to run the Department of Commerce.
- 21:40So,
- 21:40it's understandable that Jensen Huang
- 21:43and a variety of other CEOs
- 21:46with companies that are concerned about Washington's policies or
- 21:49where commerce is going with tariffs and trade,
- 21:52um,
- 21:53would think,
- 21:54OK,
- 21:54And that's,
- 21:55and,
- 21:55and that's also a very sort of,
- 21:56it's a cultural thing too.
- 21:58I have to develop a personal relationship with that person at the top,
- 22:01right?
- 22:02So,
- 22:02that comment that you made about the relationship between Jensen Huang
- 22:06and Howard Lutnick
- 22:07kind of rings true
- 22:09with sort of the talk on the street about how Lutnick runs commerce.
- 22:13For what it's worth,
- 22:14now I'm gonna
- 22:15scramble down off my soapbox and,
- 22:17and Max,
- 22:18if we could
- 22:19take a,
- 22:19a turn,
- 22:20maybe go up to 30,000 ft from where we,
- 22:22we've been.
- 22:24If you can talk to me about from your assessment.
- 22:28Um,
- 22:30What is
- 22:31the gap
- 22:32in the AI race between China and the US?
- 22:35How do you assess it?
- 22:37Well,
- 22:38look,
- 22:38I'm I'm not an expert on uh AI uh from a from a technical perspective,
- 22:43OK?
- 22:44What I do know is this,
- 22:45is that,
- 22:46uh,
- 22:46the leading chips and the leading labs are based here in the United States.
- 22:52What I know is that,
- 22:53uh,
- 22:53from the open source competitive landscape,
- 22:56uh,
- 22:56some of the the most high-end leading uh labs are based in China.
- 23:01Um,
- 23:02so there is an area of competition here with,
- 23:04uh,
- 23:05China and the United States.
- 23:07What we know is that this industry has high utility for,
- 23:10uh,
- 23:11military applications,
- 23:12uh,
- 23:13for research that relates to sophisticated weaponry and energy systems,
- 23:17um,
- 23:17and then there's all the positive,
- 23:19uh.
- 23:20that this technology can have.
- 23:21And so what the United States needs to do is implement policies that
- 23:25make it so that when there's standard setting and organizations that are creating
- 23:30the rules of the road for this new industry that they're influenced and led by
- 23:34what is going to be in the interests of the United States and its allies and partners.
- 23:38And so this is obviously antithetical to what the
- 23:41Chinese Communist Party is interested in pushing forward.
- 23:43It's why we need to have these tighter controls.
- 23:46And look,
- 23:46I appreciate,
- 23:47uh,
- 23:47you know,
- 23:47this this movement to the 30,000 ft view,
- 23:51but
- 23:51if I can just get a granular for one second,
- 23:54uh,
- 23:54to go back to the commerce side of things,
- 23:57yeah,
- 23:58the,
- 23:58the idea here is that it's not just
- 24:00that there was a significant amount of coordination,
- 24:03uh,
- 24:03and interaction between
- 24:05the Commerce Secretary and Jensen Wong.
- 24:08But there's also been reporting,
- 24:10uh,
- 24:10suggesting that when the Commerce Department was actually interested
- 24:13in putting forward certain changes to its export controls
- 24:18that would have
- 24:18tightened the scope of application vis a vis China and
- 24:22made it more difficult for Nvidia to sell there,
- 24:25that Nvidia's chief general counsel
- 24:28actually had red lines in some of these changes that
- 24:31were being viewed by staff at the Commerce Department.
- 24:34So I just want to highlight the degree to which there's something that's highly,
- 24:37highly unusual,
- 24:38right?
- 24:39It's one thing for the commerce secretary to have a
- 24:41tight relationship with the uh uh senior executive management of,
- 24:45of his agency,
- 24:45right?
- 24:46If he's entrusted by the president to do so,
- 24:48and that's in the president's interest,
- 24:49fine.
- 24:50But what's highly unusual,
- 24:52and what we're going to expect to have more answers,
- 24:54uh,
- 24:54from federal law enforcement and increasingly from Congress,
- 24:57is
- 24:58exactly how did Nvidia influence the decision making of the Commerce Department
- 25:02and to what extent might have that been
- 25:04influenced by whatever was happening between Jensen Wong
- 25:07and Alice Wong?
- 25:08So I want to just highlight that that point there that there is a degree of
- 25:12um
- 25:13quite unusual interaction between
- 25:16uh Nvidia's counsel at the highest level
- 25:20and the senior leadership
- 25:22uh and decision making within the Commerce Department.
- 25:25Yeah,
- 25:26no,
- 25:26I'm glad you,
- 25:26I'm glad you brought that up.
- 25:28Um,
- 25:28I believe it was during the course of
- 25:30the investigation,
- 25:31which is ongoing,
- 25:32that,
- 25:33um,
- 25:34the general counsel from Nvidia
- 25:36reached out,
- 25:37uh,
- 25:37saying that he had been authorized by,
- 25:40might have been the deputy,
- 25:41might have been Kessler,
- 25:42uh,
- 25:42within commerce,
- 25:43I'm not sure,
- 25:44saying,
- 25:45you know,
- 25:45that he'd been authorized to reach out to
- 25:47Commerce to,
- 25:48to inquire about the investigation.
- 25:51And that did cause reportedly some real concern amongst some of the investigators,
- 25:57uh,
- 25:57who were working on this case,
- 25:59thinking,
- 26:00well,
- 26:00that seems like,
- 26:01uh,
- 26:01um,
- 26:02undue or unusual or concerning outside influence,
- 26:06uh,
- 26:06from the company that is actually being investigated.
- 26:09Now,
- 26:09there's a,
- 26:10there is a lot to,
- 26:11uh,
- 26:11look at here.
- 26:12Uh,
- 26:12I think there's a lot of,
- 26:13of rocks that need to be picked up.
- 26:16Um,
- 26:16I'm,
- 26:17Uh,
- 26:18I'm concerned
- 26:20that sometimes these things
- 26:22sort of
- 26:23go to Washington DC to die,
- 26:25and,
- 26:26uh,
- 26:26you rarely see
- 26:27meaningful results from
- 26:29investigations.
- 26:30Uh,
- 26:30but this is,
- 26:31this is,
- 26:32uh,
- 26:33part and parcel of what the Chinese intel apparatus does in terms of
- 26:36reaching out,
- 26:37hoovering up intelligence,
- 26:39economic information,
- 26:40research and development,
- 26:41intellectual property,
- 26:42access to technology,
- 26:44uh,
- 26:45and so I suspect.
- 26:47That the FBI is,
- 26:48is,
- 26:49uh,
- 26:49focused very heavily on this in terms of understanding that aspect of it.
- 26:53You've got the investigation that's internal
- 26:56from Nvidia.
- 26:57That's what you would expect them to do using outside counsel.
- 26:59I
- 27:00don't know that that's going to,
- 27:02um,
- 27:03you know,
- 27:03really impact the situation.
- 27:05And then
- 27:06you've got the other issues,
- 27:07which is,
- 27:07look,
- 27:08what can other companies in this space and in other sensitive spaces,
- 27:12Learn from this
- 27:14and that to me from an operational perspective is also important.
- 27:17They have to understand how critical it is
- 27:20internally within their companies
- 27:22to have a proactive and consistent
- 27:24global security
- 27:26organization that also maintains a counterintelligence element
- 27:29to evaluate and vet and understand every foreign contact,
- 27:33um,
- 27:34that is you would hope that the US government would be.
- 27:37You would also hope that the US government is going to act
- 27:40a little bit more quickly than it has before since the fact that
- 27:43uh the revelations about Megaspeed uh are well over a year old.
- 27:47I mean there was a detailed report from the New York Times in October of 2025 about
- 27:52uh this company and the sanctions,
- 27:54the export control evasion issues at hand.
- 27:57So,
- 27:57none of this is new.
- 27:58Again,
- 27:59it raises these questions about the political will to take action
- 28:01in a way that's going to potentially negatively impact the relationship
- 28:05with China.
- 28:07Yeah,
- 28:08and that's always been,
- 28:09that's always been what I think in part the CCP or the,
- 28:12the Chinese government has relied on was knowing that,
- 28:15you know,
- 28:15whichever administration is
- 28:17never really going to push
- 28:18too hard,
- 28:19um,
- 28:20but I agree with you.
- 28:21It's,
- 28:21it's,
- 28:22uh,
- 28:22but again,
- 28:23as I said,
- 28:24I'm,
- 28:24I'm a cynic.
- 28:25Um,
- 28:26I think,
- 28:26you know,
- 28:27Washington DC is where investigations go to die.
- 28:30So,
- 28:30I'm,
- 28:30I'm hopeful,
- 28:31perhaps the incoming
- 28:33House and Senate will
- 28:35take this up with some speed,
- 28:36um,
- 28:37But
- 28:38I,
- 28:38I'm not sure that I'm that
- 28:40hopeful.
- 28:41Uh,
- 28:41Max,
- 28:41listen,
- 28:42this has been delightful,
- 28:43and I don't use the word delightful very often,
- 28:45um,
- 28:46and,
- 28:46but I do hope that when we call you again that you will agree to come on back because,
- 28:50uh,
- 28:51there's a lot more.
- 28:51I've got another couple of pages of questions here I could throw your way.
- 28:55So,
- 28:55thank you very much for taking the time here on the Situation Report.
- 28:59All right,
- 28:59looking forward to coming back.
- 29:00Thanks.
- 29:01Excellent,
- 29:02thank you.
- 29:04Max Meisli of the Foundation for Defense of Democracies,
- 29:08uh,
- 29:08here on the Situation Report.
- 29:11Well,
- 29:11when we come back.
- 29:14Russia and Ukraine
- 29:15agree to continue peace negotiations.
- 29:17How about that?
- 29:18Following two days of talks in Abu Dhabi.
- 29:21Which is just fun to say,
- 29:22Abu Dhabi,
- 29:23but is either side prepared to make the concessions necessary
- 29:26to end the war?
- 29:27Here's a pro tip.
- 29:29Uh,
- 29:29I don't know that Putin's looking to end the war.
- 29:32We'll ask former US ambassador to Ukraine John Herbst,
- 29:35when we come back.
- 29:36So you know what I'm gonna say.
- 29:37Stay with us.
- 29:39Hey,
- 29:39Mike Baker here.
- 29:40Now,
- 29:41I've been a business owner for many years,
- 29:42and I wanna take just a moment to talk to all you small business operators out there.
- 29:46Look,
- 29:47here's the thing,
- 29:47running any small business,
- 29:49you know this,
- 29:49means dealing with constant unexpected expenses,
- 29:52right?
- 29:52Whether it's upgrading an IT system or repair costs or
- 29:56managing payroll,
- 29:57there is always something,
- 29:59and
- 29:59you cannot afford to let traditional bank red tape slow your momentum.
- 30:04That's why you need Cardiff,
- 30:05America's favorite small.
- 30:06Business lender.
- 30:08Look,
- 30:08with over $12 billion funded to small businesses nationwide,
- 30:12they specialize in high-speed liquidity.
- 30:14Unlike legacy banks,
- 30:16Cardiff's simple application takes only 3 minutes,
- 30:19has absolutely no impact on your personal credit to apply,
- 30:21and
- 30:22offers same day funding up to $500,000.
- 30:26If you've been in business for.
- 30:26For a year or more with at least $20,000 a month in revenue,
- 30:29get the capital you need today.
- 30:32Your business deserves a partner that moves as fast as you do.
- 30:35Approval in minutes,
- 30:36funding same day.
- 30:37Visit Cardiff.co/PDB.
- 30:40That's Cardiff.co/PDB.
- 30:43Real growth,
- 30:44fast funding.
- 30:45Cardiff,
- 30:46borrow better.
- 30:48Welcome back to the PDB Situation Report.
- 30:51For the first time in 9 months,
- 30:53Russian and Ukrainian negotiators have returned to the bargaining table,
- 30:57or negotiating table,
- 30:59or a table anyway,
- 31:00meeting this week in Abu Dhabi for 2 days of US brokered peace talks.
- 31:04The negotiations produced,
- 31:06uh,
- 31:06limited progress,
- 31:08mostly,
- 31:08uh,
- 31:08an agreement in principle on a major prisoner exchange.
- 31:12But on the larger questions there was reportedly
- 31:15very little movement.
- 31:16No ceasefire was reached.
- 31:17Territorial disputes remain unresolved.
- 31:20Both Moscow and Kiev
- 31:22appear unwilling to compromise on their central demands.
- 31:25Still,
- 31:26both sides have agreed to continue talking,
- 31:28raising the question
- 31:29of whether these negotiations.
- 31:30can eventually produce a settlement
- 31:32or simply prolong a diplomatic stalemate while Putin's invasion grinds on.
- 31:38Joining us now to discuss the latest peace negotiations between Russia and Ukraine
- 31:42is Ambassador John Herbst.
- 31:44He served as a US ambassador to Ukraine from 2003
- 31:47to 2006
- 31:49and is currently the senior director of the Atlantic Council's Eurasia Center.
- 31:53Mr.
- 31:53Ambassador,
- 31:53thank you very much for joining us here on the PDB Situation Report.
- 31:57Really appreciate it.
- 31:58My pleasure.
- 31:59Thank you.
- 32:00Absolutely.
- 32:01Let,
- 32:01um,
- 32:02let's start,
- 32:03uh,
- 32:03with a very high-level view.
- 32:05What's your assessment
- 32:07of the
- 32:08two days of talks that have taken place in Abu Dhabi?
- 32:12It achieved
- 32:14a prisoner exchange,
- 32:15and that's a very positive thing,
- 32:18especially since we know
- 32:19how brutally
- 32:20the Russians treat Ukrainian POWs.
- 32:23And Ukrainian civilians
- 32:25in occupied Ukraine.
- 32:27So that's a good thing.
- 32:29Whether it's achieved anything towards actually
- 32:31establishing an end to Russian aggression there
- 32:33is an open question.
- 32:35I,
- 32:36I know,
- 32:36I know this is.
- 32:38You know,
- 32:38this is a bit of a speculative,
- 32:40you know,
- 32:40um,
- 32:42subjective question,
- 32:43but
- 32:45Based on all your experience and from what you've been seeing,
- 32:47um,
- 32:48Is Putin
- 32:50Uh,
- 32:50in a mindset where he's looking to end the war.
- 32:55There is no public indication of that.
- 32:59And I would say
- 33:01either no or very
- 33:03scant
- 33:04private indication of that.
- 33:06Uh,
- 33:07and,
- 33:08and why,
- 33:09I mean,
- 33:09I guess,
- 33:10I,
- 33:10I,
- 33:11I wanna explore this,
- 33:11right,
- 33:12because,
- 33:12you know,
- 33:12there's,
- 33:12there's been a,
- 33:14um,
- 33:14an interesting,
- 33:17Mm,
- 33:18relationship,
- 33:19um,
- 33:19that
- 33:20has.
- 33:22Kind of developed,
- 33:23it seems,
- 33:23between the White House
- 33:25and the Kremlin
- 33:26in the sense of
- 33:28it's,
- 33:29Zelensky's fault.
- 33:31Now,
- 33:32just as a reminder,
- 33:33Putin invaded Ukraine.
- 33:35Just throwing that out there.
- 33:37Um,
- 33:38what,
- 33:38how do you,
- 33:39how do you assess or how do you interpret
- 33:41the current administration,
- 33:42the US administration's,
- 33:45Relationship,
- 33:46maybe that's the wrong word,
- 33:47attitude,
- 33:48uh,
- 33:48dealings with the Kremlin.
- 33:50OK,
- 33:51it's a very good question.
- 33:52Uh,
- 33:53I am.
- 33:55Uh,
- 33:56in a minority
- 33:58amongst many
- 33:59people who watch
- 34:00the Ukraine-Russia war.
- 34:04I do understand in ways that some others do not.
- 34:08That Russia,
- 34:09Russia considers us to be its principal adversary.
- 34:12Which is international relations talk for enemy.
- 34:17And
- 34:18that Russia's pursuing a very aggressive anti-American
- 34:22policy,
- 34:22anti-NATO policy,
- 34:24not to mention its brutal war in Ukraine.
- 34:28And amongst this group,
- 34:31Uh,
- 34:32I think that Trump's policy
- 34:34is,
- 34:35um,
- 34:35inconsistent.
- 34:38Because
- 34:38it's driven by two
- 34:40more or less contradictory.
- 34:42Instincts
- 34:44The positive instinct
- 34:46which we have not seen so much of lately.
- 34:49And,
- 34:50but Trump came into the Oval Office a second time saying this,
- 34:53all the,
- 34:54all the time.
- 34:55is that he wants to see an end
- 34:58to this war.
- 35:00Based upon
- 35:03essentially a deal written around the current lines
- 35:06held by the two
- 35:07militaries,
- 35:08two opposing armies.
- 35:11But a deal that will lead to a stable peace.
- 35:15After which Ukraine would be sovereign.
- 35:18Secure and economically viable.
- 35:21That's,
- 35:21and that instinct has driven
- 35:24part of his policy.
- 35:26I would say the all the good stuff that he's done
- 35:28comes from that instinct.
- 35:30But then there's a second instinct,
- 35:31and this instinct relates to your question.
- 35:35For whatever reason,
- 35:36and there's lots of speculation,
- 35:37but I don't want to deal with speculation here.
- 35:40Trump shows an undue deference
- 35:43to Putin.
- 35:46Again,
- 35:46it can be explained by many different potential factors.
- 35:49And that difference
- 35:51is at the heart of,
- 35:52you know,
- 35:52this very peculiar.
- 35:54A friendly relationship between the two.
- 35:58And the unwillingness to call out Russian aggression.
- 36:01And the need to find someone else responsible for the war
- 36:05and that someone else
- 36:06is Zelensky.
- 36:08And I can tell you,
- 36:09this instinct
- 36:11contradicts the first,
- 36:12so that's why his policy jumps back and forth.
- 36:15And also it's very much.
- 36:17An obstacle
- 36:19to a strong policy that defends the United States though it needs to be defended
- 36:23against the only mere pure
- 36:25superpower that we've got.
- 36:27Who also considers us to be its principal adversary
- 36:31and who works against our interests,
- 36:32whether it's helping Iran
- 36:34target Americans,
- 36:36whether it's sending people to assassinate Americans
- 36:38in the United States.
- 36:41Uh,
- 36:42whether it's directing
- 36:43that be,
- 36:44the Havana syndrome,
- 36:46to,
- 36:47uh,
- 36:47essentially cripple
- 36:48American officials,
- 36:49all these things
- 36:51Putin does,
- 36:52and he's not called on
- 36:53by the President of the United States.
- 36:56Very odd.
- 36:57Yeah,
- 36:58it did.
- 36:58I think it's,
- 36:59it is
- 37:00very confusing,
- 37:01um,
- 37:03during the course of these,
- 37:05Negotiations,
- 37:06um,
- 37:06discussions,
- 37:08um,
- 37:09you know,
- 37:09we've had
- 37:10Steve Witkoff and Jared Kushner
- 37:12out there as part of the US team.
- 37:15Yeah,
- 37:16talking with the delegations from Ukraine and the Kremlin,
- 37:21um,
- 37:22the Europeans don't have a seat at the table,
- 37:24basically because
- 37:25Putin doesn't want them at the table.
- 37:27So,
- 37:27it seems as if they've
- 37:29deferred to,
- 37:30to that,
- 37:31uh,
- 37:32desire.
- 37:34Do you have any,
- 37:35do you have any insight or,
- 37:37or,
- 37:37um,
- 37:38understanding of
- 37:40the position
- 37:41that,
- 37:43Witkoff and Kushner have taken during the course of these latest talks,
- 37:47um,
- 37:49in looking for a compromise.
- 37:51I mean,
- 37:51are they,
- 37:51are they pushing,
- 37:53Equally on both sides,
- 37:55you know,
- 37:56for this idea of,
- 37:56well,
- 37:57you know,
- 37:57are they're willing to compromise?
- 37:58Well,
- 37:59again,
- 37:59you've got an invaded country and you've got Putin.
- 38:02And,
- 38:03and
- 38:03so I just,
- 38:04I'm wondering whether you have any insight into
- 38:07what those conversations are like.
- 38:08I know that's a tough thing,
- 38:09but,
- 38:10you know,
- 38:11do you get the sense that they are,
- 38:13Uh,
- 38:14in fact,
- 38:15pushing both sides,
- 38:16or is this just more of the same saying,
- 38:18well,
- 38:18you know,
- 38:18Ukraine,
- 38:19you got to kind of give this up,
- 38:20give up the territory and
- 38:22give up some of your
- 38:23sovereign abilities,
- 38:25and then we can have peace.
- 38:26OK,
- 38:27um,
- 38:28I would distinguish in answering your question.
- 38:31Between
- 38:33what
- 38:33Witkoff and Kushner have said during the negotiations,
- 38:36that's on the one side.
- 38:38And then on the other,
- 38:40um,
- 38:41decisions taken
- 38:42by the administration
- 38:44that relate to this war.
- 38:45Now,
- 38:45obviously,
- 38:46those two things are related,
- 38:47but they're still distinct.
- 38:49So to answer specifically your question,
- 38:53What we've seen publicly,
- 38:55which is the source of the only
- 38:58information I know I have for sure.
- 39:01Uh,
- 39:02I would not say
- 39:04that
- 39:05the two American negotiators.
- 39:08In the talks in Abu Dhabi
- 39:10and since.
- 39:12have
- 39:12negotiated
- 39:14essentially off of Russian talking points.
- 39:17Or have
- 39:18demanded things from Ukraine while not demanding things from Russia.
- 39:22I think they've tried,
- 39:24having listened to the two parties,
- 39:26to put some things in play.
- 39:28Which
- 39:30in theory,
- 39:31might achieve an agreement
- 39:33if both sides really wanted one.
- 39:35Whereas I think only one side really wants an agreement,
- 39:37meaning the Ukraine side.
- 39:39And so let's say for example,
- 39:42We know
- 39:43that
- 39:44the Europeans
- 39:45were in Abu Dhabi.
- 39:47Not in the negotiations,
- 39:48but in Abu Dhabi.
- 39:50At the initiative
- 39:52of our negotiators.
- 39:54We know too
- 39:56that
- 39:57the two negotiators left Abu Dhabi from Moscow
- 40:00where they were trying to get
- 40:01Putin's OK
- 40:03for them to participate
- 40:04in the next round.
- 40:06So that to me suggests
- 40:08they were hearing both sides and trying to,
- 40:11to get something
- 40:12done.
- 40:13But then there's the steps,
- 40:15steps taken by
- 40:17our country's leadership,
- 40:18meaning President Trump.
- 40:20Over the past 5 weeks
- 40:22which have
- 40:23Without
- 40:25exception.
- 40:26Pleased the Kremlin,
- 40:28made it easier for Moscow to continue this war,
- 40:31and made it harder for Ukraine to defend itself.
- 40:34It all started with the quote unquote diesel deal,
- 40:37right?
- 40:38This is more money going to Moscow despite sanctions
- 40:41which they use to feed their war machine.
- 40:44Then you have
- 40:46the
- 40:48Trump waiving
- 40:49all the sanctions of the Lindsey Graham sanctions bill on Russia,
- 40:53which
- 40:53Trump himself had signed just 3 or 4 weeks ago.
- 40:57Then you have
- 40:58Trump's
- 41:00agreement
- 41:01to the Putin proposal
- 41:03for a trilateral summit
- 41:05of Xi,
- 41:06Putin,
- 41:06and Trump.
- 41:07To
- 41:08quote unquote,
- 41:09figure out a way to end the war
- 41:11in Ukraine.
- 41:12No presence of Ukraine.
- 41:14Now,
- 41:15to his credit,
- 41:16the
- 41:16must say to
- 41:17take a little aback,
- 41:19take back a little bit of that criticism of the decision,
- 41:22Trump said
- 41:23that he wanted to talk about nuclear disarmament
- 41:25with China and Russia,
- 41:26which is,
- 41:27which is a subject
- 41:28makes sense for him to do.
- 41:30But still,
- 41:30the whole sense of this is,
- 41:32it's going to be about ending the war.
- 41:34And this,
- 41:34you know,
- 41:35you,
- 41:35you see stuff in the papers even today and yesterday,
- 41:37where that's the theme.
- 41:39So that's the 3rd step,
- 41:40benefits Russia,
- 41:42hurts Ukraine.
- 41:43The 4th is the worst
- 41:45That was the gameplay
- 41:48with Starlinks and StarShield,
- 41:50right,
- 41:50the satellite system
- 41:51from Elon Musk's company
- 41:53to play with it so that Ukraine was unable to use it.
- 41:57It seems now for 3 separate small periods
- 42:00over the past
- 42:014 or so weeks.
- 42:03Those
- 42:04the intelligence receives from them
- 42:06makes it easier for Ukraine to shoot down
- 42:09Russian drones
- 42:10which are aiming at civilians
- 42:12and energy infrastructure and water facilities in Ukraine.
- 42:15This was a transparent effort by the administration
- 42:19to persuade Ukraine to quote unquote make compromises
- 42:22when
- 42:23Zelitsky
- 42:24has accepted pretty much every proposal
- 42:27Trump has put on the table since March of last year,
- 42:30and Putin has deflected or rejected every single one.
- 42:34So all those things together
- 42:37seem to
- 42:38pressure the victim
- 42:39to agree to additional concessions after they've already said yes
- 42:43to the most important concession,
- 42:44which was Trump's idea
- 42:46of establishing a peace
- 42:48based upon the lines
- 42:49held by the two militaries,
- 42:51which means Russia continues to occupy
- 42:53a substantial part of Ukrainian territory.
- 42:56Ambassador,
- 42:56there's a lot to,
- 42:57uh,
- 42:57a lot to dive into,
- 42:59um,
- 42:59in,
- 43:00in that answer of yours,
- 43:01um,
- 43:02but
- 43:03first,
- 43:03before we dive into that,
- 43:05uh,
- 43:05we have to take that break.
- 43:06So it,
- 43:07yeah,
- 43:08we have to take a quick break,
- 43:09sir.
- 43:09Uh,
- 43:09we'll be back with more from Ambassador Herbst from,
- 43:12uh,
- 43:13the Atlantic Council,
- 43:14former ambassador to Ukraine.
- 43:16So
- 43:17stick around right here on the PDB situation report.
- 43:22Welcome back to the PDB situation Report.
- 43:24Joining us once again is Ambassador John Herbst.
- 43:27He's the former US ambassador to Ukraine
- 43:29and currently the senior director of the Atlantic Council's Eurasia Center.
- 43:34Mr.
- 43:34Ambassador,
- 43:34thank you very much for sticking around.
- 43:37Uh,
- 43:37I,
- 43:37I,
- 43:37here's,
- 43:38here's,
- 43:38this is apropos of nothing,
- 43:40sir,
- 43:40but I'm just gonna raise this because we've
- 43:42been talking about the negotiations and our envoys.
- 43:45I always thought we had a deeper bench of,
- 43:47of envoys and
- 43:49diplomats.
- 43:49It,
- 43:49it does seem as if
- 43:51Steve Woodkoff and Jared Kushner show up for everything,
- 43:54no matter
- 43:55what jurisdiction,
- 43:56what region of the world.
- 43:57Those two show up.
- 43:59Um,
- 43:59it's an interesting
- 44:01style.
- 44:02I assume it's the White House's desire to
- 44:05keep their
- 44:06circle of trusted advisors close.
- 44:09Um,
- 44:10but it is surprising that they,
- 44:12uh,
- 44:13they seem to pop into every
- 44:15overseas crises and,
- 44:17uh,
- 44:17concern.
- 44:19OK,
- 44:20you want me to comment on that?
- 44:24Only if you're willing.
- 44:25Only if you're willing to comment.
- 44:27So,
- 44:28look,
- 44:29um,
- 44:29it's very clear.
- 44:31That Trump has his own
- 44:34strong,
- 44:35particular views.
- 44:37On how
- 44:38he wants to conduct diplomas.
- 44:40So he wants people who he
- 44:42has long trusted.
- 44:44And people who are willing to report directly to him.
- 44:49Um,
- 44:49and
- 44:51Not necessarily people who have
- 44:53a strong background on the subject.
- 44:56or who have
- 44:57a streak of independence.
- 45:00Now,
- 45:01I've annoyed
- 45:02many of my Democratic friends
- 45:05by pointing out
- 45:07that the Trump won
- 45:10national security team
- 45:11was far stronger
- 45:13than the Biden national security team.
- 45:16Uh,
- 45:16but it seems
- 45:18that,
- 45:18you know,
- 45:19once he became used to being president,
- 45:21Trump decided he did not want to have around some
- 45:24authoritative,
- 45:26deeply experienced,
- 45:28deeply knowledgeable
- 45:29national security experts.
- 45:32I think that's a mistake.
- 45:33I think the results of his diploma has,
- 45:35has demonstrated that.
- 45:37But he's the one who won the,
- 45:39you know,
- 45:39the,
- 45:39that,
- 45:40the
- 45:40electoral college and the
- 45:42popular vote
- 45:43in 2024
- 45:44and not me.
- 45:45So he gets to make those choices.
- 45:47But it's a,
- 45:48it's a truly idiosyncratic style.
- 45:50I don't think it serves the interest of the country.
- 45:54And I don't think it's up to the not bad record
- 45:57of Trump won.
- 45:58Yeah,
- 45:59that's very interesting.
- 46:00Thank you for making that
- 46:01those comments,
- 46:01um,
- 46:03Let me ask you this,
- 46:05in all your years of experience,
- 46:08And again,
- 46:08this is,
- 46:09I know this is not a,
- 46:10a real science,
- 46:11uh,
- 46:12here,
- 46:12but
- 46:13Um,
- 46:14from your perspective,
- 46:16What is it that would get Putin
- 46:19to sit down at the negotiating table in a meaningful way?
- 46:23I don't mean sticking to his maximalist demands.
- 46:25I mean
- 46:26actually compromising
- 46:28in a serious effort
- 46:30to wrap up his invasion of Ukraine after all these years.
- 46:33It's,
- 46:34it's really very simple.
- 46:36Putin
- 46:38believes
- 46:39that he can win this war,
- 46:40even though it's been going on,
- 46:42I mean,
- 46:43obviously,
- 46:43it's been going on since 2014.
- 46:45But since the big invasion,
- 46:46it's close to 5 years,
- 46:48right?
- 46:48And the death toll for Russian soldiers,
- 46:50and the Financial Times is now reporting it like 6000 or even 650,000,
- 46:55an extraordinary death toll.
- 46:59And
- 47:00even though he expected to take Kiev in the first few weeks,
- 47:03right,
- 47:03didn't happen.
- 47:04He hasn't even been able to take Donnbass nearly 5 years into the war.
- 47:08He thinks that
- 47:10Western leaders are,
- 47:11leaders are weak,
- 47:12and he's been right about that.
- 47:13I'm sorry to say.
- 47:14And he,
- 47:15his aim is to cut off Western support for Ukraine,
- 47:18starting first and foremost with the United States.
- 47:21And he has been,
- 47:22I won't say completely successful in that,
- 47:25but partly successful.
- 47:26You want this war to stop.
- 47:28You want Trump to achieve his goal of a peace which is stable
- 47:33and leaves Ukraine standing sovereign and economically viable at the end.
- 47:36Well,
- 47:36at the end,
- 47:37Trump doesn't talk about that so much anymore,
- 47:39which is a problem.
- 47:40The way to do it.
- 47:41is to persuade Putin
- 47:43that he'll only suffer more if he continues the war.
- 47:46So what that means,
- 47:47of course,
- 47:47is instead,
- 47:48instead of playing games with Starlinks and Starshoe,
- 47:51we should be enabling.
- 47:53More Ukrainian attacks against the Russian hydrocarbon system,
- 47:57against Russian
- 47:58production,
- 47:59military production plants.
- 48:02Against Russian
- 48:03ballistic missiles,
- 48:05if we had,
- 48:05if we opened up StarShield for Ukraine
- 48:08to target Russian ballistic missiles,
- 48:10they would destroy many of those missiles and the
- 48:13destruction of the Ukrainian residential areas.
- 48:16Uh,
- 48:17energy
- 48:17facilities,
- 48:19water
- 48:20facilities
- 48:21would
- 48:21drop substantially.
- 48:23If we actually
- 48:24impose the sanctions of the Lindsey Graham bill,
- 48:27the pressure on the Russian economy would grow.
- 48:30That's the obvious way
- 48:32to achieve a stable peace.
- 48:34Something which President Trump has done a little bit of when he sanctioned
- 48:38Ross Nefin Lugoyle,
- 48:40um,
- 48:40in October of last year.
- 48:42But because he's uncomfortable
- 48:44putting
- 48:45a 2 by 4 on Putin's forehead
- 48:48right after
- 48:49he did that with the sanctions.
- 48:52We,
- 48:52we submitted the 28 point peace plan to Ukraine.
- 48:55That was the one that Driscoll brought to Kiev in November,
- 48:58which was basically written in Moscow,
- 49:01a very embarrassing one.
- 49:03Yeah,
- 49:04What is
- 49:06What is the reluctance?
- 49:07Is it just a,
- 49:08a hangover from the Cold War,
- 49:10you know,
- 49:10uh,
- 49:10and,
- 49:11and sort of the fear of a cataclysmic
- 49:14conflict?
- 49:14Is,
- 49:14is,
- 49:15is that
- 49:16the,
- 49:17what leads to the reluctance to push Putin?
- 49:19That was Biden's great weakness.
- 49:22Biden let Putin intimidate him
- 49:25in making decisions on arming Ukraine,
- 49:28um,
- 49:28with a nuclear threat.
- 49:30And to his great shame,
- 49:32he bought the,
- 49:33he bought the flimflam.
- 49:35I don't think that's trumps it.
- 49:36I think Trump has this again peculiar,
- 49:39I'm just using a relatively mild word deference here
- 49:42for Putin.
- 49:44Biden
- 49:45kind of understood
- 49:46the threat
- 49:47that
- 49:48Putin's policies raised for the United States.
- 49:51He,
- 49:52he pointed that out 3 times,
- 49:54but only 3 times.
- 49:56Uh,
- 49:57Trump seems to spend more time
- 49:59smacking our allies
- 50:00than smacking our smacking our enemies,
- 50:02whether it's China
- 50:04or Russia.
- 50:05Yes,
- 50:05Iran's our enemy.
- 50:06He's obviously smacked Iran,
- 50:07although not in a particularly skillful way.
- 50:10But against the two big bad boys,
- 50:12um,
- 50:12President Trump has not been a source of,
- 50:14of power and strength.
- 50:16I say that with sadness.
- 50:17During the first term with China,
- 50:19he was terrific.
- 50:20Not so much now.
- 50:21And with Russia,
- 50:22he's never been terrific.
- 50:23Yeah,
- 50:24yeah,
- 50:24we seem to your point on China,
- 50:25we,
- 50:26we seem to have backed off.
- 50:27Um,
- 50:28I was,
- 50:28I was a big fan of highlighting
- 50:31all of their
- 50:31various shenanigans over the decades and getting a focus on
- 50:35what they've done and the cost
- 50:36of their economic espionage and theft of intellectual property,
- 50:40etc.
- 50:41Uh,
- 50:41Trump,
- 50:42Trump deserved credit not just for turning around
- 50:45American policy during his first term.
- 50:47The Democrats basically followed that.
- 50:49So it was,
- 50:50it was truly self-significant development,
- 50:52but it,
- 50:53we don't see it now.
- 50:54It's really quite amazing.
- 50:55Let me,
- 50:56let me ask you this,
- 50:56um,
- 50:58You,
- 50:58you,
- 50:58you referred to
- 51:00sort of,
- 51:00uh,
- 51:01Putin's desire to
- 51:03To outlast the West,
- 51:05but in part to,
- 51:05to drive a wedge between the West and,
- 51:07and Ukraine,
- 51:08uh,
- 51:08in,
- 51:09in terms of their support,
- 51:10uh,
- 51:11do you,
- 51:13uh,
- 51:14View
- 51:16sort of what's been happening in
- 51:17the European Union,
- 51:19um,
- 51:20is,
- 51:21uh,
- 51:21how,
- 51:21however you want to call it,
- 51:22a soft war,
- 51:23sort of sabotage,
- 51:25whatever.
- 51:25Uh,
- 51:26do you attribute a lot of the,
- 51:28the incidents to
- 51:30Russia at this point?
- 51:31Because there's,
- 51:31there's still some question.
- 51:32They,
- 51:32they can,
- 51:33you know,
- 51:33the attribution is difficult at times,
- 51:35uh,
- 51:36but I think the pattern is clear enough.
- 51:38But how impactful do you view what,
- 51:41The Russians are up to in terms of trying to,
- 51:44trying to impact the European Union.
- 51:47I'm glad you raised this.
- 51:48I,
- 51:48I was going to bring it up,
- 51:50had you not.
- 51:51Uh,
- 51:53Putin's aggression,
- 51:55Putin's desires to undermine the United States
- 51:58do not end in Ukraine.
- 52:01It's been going on in Europe for years.
- 52:03It's what some people call a hybrid war,
- 52:05but it's actually more dangerous hybrid war
- 52:08because
- 52:10The Russians have been actually following this policy for many,
- 52:13many years.
- 52:14It predates.
- 52:15Even Trump's first term.
- 52:18Uh,
- 52:18but it's gotten significantly worse
- 52:21starting in the spring of 24.
- 52:24So Biden's last year in office.
- 52:26And what
- 52:28Putin has tried to do
- 52:30is what intimidate
- 52:33Europe so it stops supporting Ukraine.
- 52:35But 2,
- 52:37demonstrating to Europe and to the world
- 52:39that NATO is a paper tiger.
- 52:42That he takes all these steps against
- 52:46NATO countries,
- 52:47not just,
- 52:48but this is the principal,
- 52:49uh,
- 52:50target.
- 52:51What you mentioned
- 52:53sabotage.
- 52:54You mentioned,
- 52:55uh,
- 52:56bombs being put on drones.
- 52:58Uh,
- 52:59actually,
- 52:59you didn't,
- 52:59you didn't mention just drone,
- 53:00drones suddenly appearing over airports to create problems.
- 53:04Um,
- 53:04the assassination or the attempted assassination
- 53:07of,
- 53:07uh,
- 53:08military
- 53:09company's leadership.
- 53:11The,
- 53:12uh,
- 53:14Plans to put
- 53:15a ball on a DHL plane heading to Canada and the United States.
- 53:19All these things.
- 53:21And of course drones flying over NATO
- 53:24countries and even exploding in NATO countries.
- 53:27And there's been very little
- 53:29reaction
- 53:30from NATO.
- 53:30Not none,
- 53:31not none,
- 53:32but very little.
- 53:34And
- 53:35Uh,
- 53:36Trump,
- 53:36like Biden,
- 53:37doesn't want to see this,
- 53:39so
- 53:39he accepts the ambiguity and says that his administration,
- 53:42just as Biden's administration,
- 53:44says,
- 53:44we don't know if the Russians actually did it.
- 53:47Look,
- 53:48I spent 31 years in the State Department.
- 53:50I know that
- 53:52American diplomacy
- 53:53would draw conclusions on evidence
- 53:55that would not satisfy a jury in an American court.
- 53:58You don't have that level
- 54:00of high,
- 54:00high grade level of evidence in most cases
- 54:03in making
- 54:04major national security decisions.
- 54:07So again,
- 54:08Biden before him and Trump now say,
- 54:10well,
- 54:10we don't know if the Russians are really doing this.
- 54:12That means they don't have to answer it.
- 54:14But what's happening is
- 54:16they are telling Europeans,
- 54:18our NATO allies,
- 54:19the US will not defend you,
- 54:21and that's very dangerous
- 54:22because then the provocations will go greater.
- 54:25This is not a peace through strength policy.
- 54:28This is the type of
- 54:30weak policy that normally Republicans make fun of Democrats.
- 54:34And Team Trump suddenly made fun of Biden for it,
- 54:36but we're seeing a repetition
- 54:37of that same type of weakness.
- 54:40And yeah,
- 54:40I'm afraid we're,
- 54:41we're seeing the same thing in,
- 54:43and if Putin wins in Ukraine,
- 54:45for sure all the stuff is gonna go up.
- 54:47All it's gonna be other is we see a lot more of it,
- 54:50and it only stops
- 54:52if we,
- 54:52the United States,
- 54:53as the leadership of the NATO alliance,
- 54:56demonstrates to Russia that they have a price to,
- 54:58there'll be a price to pay.
- 54:59And you know Trump did this in term one.
- 55:02Uh
- 55:04Cyber command
- 55:05during Trump's first term.
- 55:07Uh,
- 55:09did a
- 55:10hack,
- 55:11a notable hack in Russia.
- 55:13Um,
- 55:14this is not public.
- 55:16They told the Russians privately
- 55:18that if he did not like this,
- 55:20You really don't want to interfere with our midterm elections in 2018,
- 55:24and the Russians did.
- 55:26But we,
- 55:26we know,
- 55:26we,
- 55:26we,
- 55:27we,
- 55:27we,
- 55:27we saw nothing similar under Bine.
- 55:29We've seen nothing similar in Trump too.
- 55:32I think it's that I think it's that um
- 55:35That back and forth,
- 55:36that inconsistency,
- 55:38I think that it creates
- 55:40not just confusion but
- 55:42creates,
- 55:42uh,
- 55:42some instability that is definitely not
- 55:45in our,
- 55:46in the US or our allies' best national interests.
- 55:49We're seeing it play out in,
- 55:50in Iran as well,
- 55:52um,
- 55:55and it's outrageous that taken steps against the Russians
- 55:57for giving Iran intelligence to kill American soldiers.
- 56:01Right,
- 56:02and there's been,
- 56:02there's been,
- 56:03there's very credible reporting as well,
- 56:05sir,
- 56:05about,
- 56:06about China
- 56:06doing,
- 56:08uh,
- 56:08the same,
- 56:09yeah.
- 56:11Well,
- 56:12sir,
- 56:12I tell you,
- 56:12I,
- 56:13I've got,
- 56:13uh,
- 56:14a lot of questions left to throw your way,
- 56:16but what I don't have is,
- 56:17is time,
- 56:18um,
- 56:19so I am hopeful that the next time
- 56:21that we give you a call,
- 56:22you'll,
- 56:22you'll agree to come back on because he's been the next conversation.
- 56:27Excellent,
- 56:28excellent.
- 56:28Yes,
- 56:29there is no need for a suit and tie here on the Situation Report.
- 56:32That was Ambassador John Herbs,
- 56:34uh,
- 56:34a great guy,
- 56:35a former ambassador to Ukraine,
- 56:37now senior director of the Atlantic Council's Eurasia Center.
- 56:40Well,
- 56:40that's all the time we have for this week's PDB situation report.
- 56:43I know,
- 56:45I know,
- 56:45but we'll be back next week.
- 56:47If you have any questions or comments,
- 56:48maybe you've got a humorous anecdote,
- 56:50well,
- 56:50just send them our way.
- 56:52Reach out to me at PDB@hefirsttv.com,
- 56:56right?
- 56:56And if you want to watch the show ad-free,
- 56:59you know,
- 56:59you can do that.
- 57:01Yeah,
- 57:02it's very simple actually,
- 57:03just become a premium member
- 57:04of the President's Daily Brief
- 57:06by visiting
- 57:07PDBpremium.com.
- 57:08I told you it was simple.
- 57:10I'm Mike Baker and I'll be back next time,
- 57:13but until then,
- 57:14stay informed,
- 57:15stay safe,
- 57:17stay cool.